Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
Highly Successful Engineering Design ProjectsAN ACTIONABLE ENGINEERINGDESIGN JOURNALby Walt Maclay
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
Visithttps://www.volersystems.com/blog/project-management/tips-to-successfully-manage-product-development-without-a-technical-background
for more information on project managementof design and sample documents. We can help
you complete your electronic design or firmware project on time and on budget using the project
management techniques in the book.
2
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
Highly Successful EngineeringDesign Projects
Keys to Staying on Budget, on Time, Every Time
Walt Maclay
An Actionable Engineering Design JournalE-mail: [email protected]
20660 Stevens Creek Blvd., Suite 210
Cupertino, CA 95014
3
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
Copyright © 2019, Walt Maclay
All rights reserved. No part of this book shall be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted by any means other than through the AHAthat platform or with the same
attribution shown in AHAthat without written permission from the publisher.
Please go tohttp://aha.pub/EngineeringDesignProjects to read
this AHAbook and to share the individualAHAmessages that resonate with you.
Published by THiNKaha®20660 Stevens Creek Blvd., Suite 210, Cupertino, CA 95014
http://thinkaha.comE-mail: [email protected]
First Printing: July 2019
Hardcover ISBN: 978-1-61699-323-8 1-61699-323-5Paperback ISBN: 978-1-61699-322-1 1-61699-322-7
eBook ISBN: 978-1-61699-321-4 1-61699-321-9Place of Publication: Silicon Valley, California, USA
Paperback Library of Congress Number: 2019907893
TrademarksAll terms mentioned in this book that are known to be trademarks or service marks have been
appropriately capitalized. Neither THiNKaha, nor any of its imprints, can attest to the accuracy of this information. Use of a term in this book should not be regarded as affecting the validity of any
trademark or service mark.
Warning and DisclaimerEvery effort has been made to make this book as complete and as accurate as possible.
The information provided is on an “as is” basis. The author(s), publisher, and their agents assumeno responsibility for errors or omissions. Nor do they assume liability or responsibility to any
person or entity with respect to any loss or damages arising from the use ofinformation contained herein.
4
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
Acknowledgement
John Dring, VP of engineering at Voler Systems, contributed muchof his great knowledge and experience. He consistently completes
projects on time and on budget, and the products are easy tomanufacture. John is well qualified to contribute!
Kimberly Wiefling, founder and president of Wiefling Consulting,edited and contributed a great deal. She is a noted project manager
who advises design teams around the world.
5
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
How to Read a THiNKaha® BookA Note from the Publisher
The AHAthat/THiNKaha series is the CliffsNotes of the 21st century. These books arecontextual in nature. Although the actual words won’t change, their meaning will everytime you read one as your context will change. Be ready, you will experience your own AHAmoments as you read the AHA messagesTM in this book. They are designed to be stand-alone actionable messages that will help you think about a project you’re working on, an event, a sales deal, a personal issue, etc. differently. As you read this book, please think about the following:
1. It should only take 15–20 minutes to read this book the first time out. When you’re reading, write in the underlined area one to three action items that resonate with you.
2. Mark your calendar to re-read this book again in 30 days.
3. Repeat step #1 and mark one to three more AHA messages that resonate. They will most likely be different than the first time. BTW: this is also a great time to reflect on the AHA messages that resonated with you during your last reading.
After reading a THiNKaha book, marking your AHA messages, re-reading it, and marking more AHA messages, you’ll begin to see how these books contextually apply to you. AHAthat/THiNKaha books advocate for continuous, lifelong learning. They will help you transform your AHAs into actionable items with tangible results until you no longer have to say AHA to these moments—they’ll become part of your daily practice as you continue to grow and learn.
Mitchell Levy, The AHA Guy at [email protected]
6
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
Contents
Section ICharacteristics of Highly Successful Engineering Design Projects...................................................9
Section IICritical Steps to Take before Starting a Project................................................................................19
Section IIIMedical Device Requirements............................................................................................................47
Section IVEssential Actions Required during Highly Successful Engineering Design Projects....................61
Section VWarning Signs to Watch for during Highly Successful Design Projects.........................................77
Section VIEnsuring a Successful Transfer to Manufacturing...........................................................................91
Section VIIIntegrating Learning to Get Better with Every Project...................................................................109
About the Author................................................................................................................................116
7
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
Highly successful #EngineeringDesign projectsmake the company successful.
#SuccessfulProjects
Share the AHA messages from this book socially by going tohttp://aha.pub/EngineeringDesignProjects
Walt Maclay
8
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
Section I
Characteristics of Highly SuccessfulEngineering Design Projects
9
How do you know if you have a successfulengineering design project or if you have room to
improve? Learn more about what a successfulproject looks like.
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
1Everyone can learn to have highlysuccessful #EngineeringDesign projects.#SuccessfulProjects
2Highly successful #EngineeringDesignprojects are completed on time.#SuccessfulProjects
10
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
3Highly successful #EngineeringDesignprojects are completed on budget.#SuccessfulProjects
4Highly successful #EngineeringDesignprojects result in products that are easy tomanufacture. #SuccessfulProjects
11
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
5Highly successful #EngineeringDesignprojects are adaptable to change.#SuccessfulProjects
12
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
6Scalable #EngineeringDesign projectsdon’t require re-design to adapt and grow.#SuccessfulProjects
7Highly successful #EngineeringDesignprojects result in high-quality products.#SuccessfulProjects
13
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
8Highly successful #EngineeringDesignprojects make team members happy.#SuccessfulProjects
9Highly successful #EngineeringDesignprojects make management happy.#SuccessfulProjects
14
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
10Highly successful #EngineeringDesignprojects make the project leader happy andsuccessful. #SuccessfulProjects
15
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
11Highly successful #EngineeringDesignprojects become the models for otherprojects. #SuccessfulProjects
16
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
12Highly successful #EngineeringDesignprojects make the company successful.#SuccessfulProjects
17
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
18
Ensure that #EngineeringDesign requirementsare complete, and review them several times
with your team #SuccessfulProjects
Share the AHA messages from this book socially by going tohttp://aha.pub/EngineeringDesignProjects
Walt Maclay
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
Section II
Critical Steps to Takebefore Starting a Project
19
There are certain steps to take at the start of yourengineering design project. Without them, it is
difficult to have a successful project. But by doingthese things, you are already halfway there!
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
13Write detailed #EngineeringDesignrequirements. #SuccessfulProjects havedetailed requirements that includethe customer’s POV (inputs) and theengineering department’s POV (outputs).
14Make sure that #EngineeringDesignrequirements are testable. To have#SuccessfulProjects, it must be clear whenrequirements are or are not met.
20
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
15Get agreement from all stakeholders on the#EngineeringDesign requirements beforeproceeding. #SuccessfulProjects
21
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
16Ensure that #EngineeringDesignrequirements are complete, and reviewthem several times with your team.#SuccessfulProjects
22
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
17#EngineeringDesign requirements maychange as customers, competitors, andtechnology change. #SuccessfulProjects
18Describe the appearance of mechanical,electrical, software, and firmware featuresin the #EngineeringDesign requirements.#SuccessfulProjects
23
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
19Specify environmental conditions, suchas temperature, humidity, altitude, shock,and vibration, in the #EngineeringDesignrequirements. #SuccessfulProjects
20Specify serviceability and support inthe #EngineeringDesign requirements.#SuccessfulProjects
24
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
21Specify cleaning and sterilization inthe #EngineeringDesign requirements.#SuccessfulProjects
22Specify compatibility in the#EngineeringDesign requirements, such asworking with other devices and software orbackward compatibility with older products.#SuccessfulProjects
25
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
23Specify the cost target in the#EngineeringDesign requirements.#SuccessfulProjects
24Writing software requirements for#EngineeringDesign projects is hard. Ifyou have not done it before, seek advice.#SuccessfulProjects
26
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
25Include pictures of each screenin the software requirements ofyour #EngineeringDesign project.#SuccessfulProjects
27
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
26Describe what happens when you use eachtool on your screen (e.g., buttons, textentry boxes, drop-down lists, etc.) in the#EngineeringDesign software requirements.#SuccessfulProjects
28
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
27Describe how to move from one screento the next in the #EngineeringDesignsoftware requirements. #SuccessfulProjects
28Describe any calculations, data processing,file processing, data transmission, oralarms that happen and what triggers themto happen in the #EngineeringDesignsoftware requirements. #SuccessfulProjects
29
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
29Specify the wording for each alarm inthe #EngineeringDesign requirements.#SuccessfulProjects
30
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
30#EngineeringDesign requirements shouldbe modular and traceable to higher levelrequirements. #SuccessfulProjects
31
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
31When writing requirements, understandboth the user and the purchaser to have asuccessful #EngineeringDesign project.#SuccessfulProjects
32Write a detailed development schedule,with each activity covering one to twoweeks, four weeks being the maximum.#EngineeringDesign #SuccessfulProjects
32
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
33An activity in the #EngineeringDesignschedule should be done by one person soresponsibility is clear. #SuccessfulProjects
33
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
34Build #EngineeringDesign schedulesbottom-up instead of top-down. It’s okay tostart at the top to provide an outline for theteam, then build up the schedule from theteam details. #SuccessfulProjects
35Build #EngineeringDesign schedulesaround a 50% confidence level as opposedto a 99%. If each task has 99% confidence,then the margin will be quite large andproduce a very conservative schedule.#SuccessfulProjects
34
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
36Build margin at the end of the#EngineeringDesign program to improvethe confidence to higher than 50%.#SuccessfulProjects
37A highly successful #EngineeringDesignproject’s end schedule has a date range witha confidence level. #SuccessfulProjects
35
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
38Get your stakeholders to come to anagreement on the #EngineeringDesignschedule, especially those who willhave to contribute to meeting it.#SuccessfulProjects
39#EngineeringDesign stakeholders shouldinclude people from design, marketing,manufacturing, technical support, finance,sales, etc. #SuccessfulProjects
36
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
40Don’t proceed without agreement onthe #EngineeringDesign schedule.#SuccessfulProjects happen when agreementsare in place.
37
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
41Ask for agreement on the#EngineeringDesign schedule, don’tdemand it. Make changes to get willingagreement from those who will work tomeet the schedule. #SuccessfulProjects
38
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
42If stakeholders don’t agree on the#EngineeringDesign schedule, don’tassume they will agree later — they won’t.There is either a flaw in the schedule, or youhave not explained something well enough.#SuccessfulProjects
43A good #EngineeringDesign schedule ischallenging but doable. People enjoy achallenge, as long as it is not too difficult,and they get rewarded for success.#SuccessfulProjects
39
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
44Beware of the person who objects to the#EngineeringDesign schedule but doesnot have a stake in it. Why is this personinvolved? #SuccessfulProjects
40
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
45“It shouldn’t take this long” is an#EngineeringDesign trap. Trust your dataover optimism to have #SuccessfulProjects.
41
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
46Identify #EngineeringDesign risks and planto mitigate them. Allow for extra time in theschedule in proportion to the level of risk.#SuccessfulProjects
47To mitigate large #EngineeringDesignrisks and have #SuccessfulProjects, dopreliminary investigations, prototypes,pilots, or other testing.
42
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
48If you leave large #EngineeringDesignrisks to be resolved during the project,allow time and budget for the predictableand inevitable “unknown” or “unexpected.”#SuccessfulProjects
49#SuccessfulProjects with a detailed#EngineeringDesign plan make it easyto quickly revise the plan when changeshappen during the project.
43
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
50If there is no #EngineeringDesign plan,the project will take far longer to completethan if there is a plan. #SuccessfulProjectshappen when there’s a plan.
44
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
51The budget for #EngineeringDesignprojects should be planned as carefully asthe schedule. #SuccessfulProjects
52The budget for #EngineeringDesignprojects is determined from the scheduleby adding a cost for each person.#SuccessfulProjects
45
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
46
Make sure each medical device requirement is asingle requirement, testable by a single test with a
single outcome. #EngineeringDesign #SuccessfulProjects
Share the AHA messages from this book socially by going tohttp://aha.pub/EngineeringDesignProjects
Walt Maclay
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
Section III
Medical Device Requirements
These requirements are important for medical devicedesign projects, though most are a good idea for just
about any project.
47
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
53Medical device requirements serve as agood model for any good product design.If you’re not doing a medical device, adjustthe level of documentation to suit yourparticular needs. #EngineeringDesign#SuccessfulProjects
54Successful medical #EngineeringDesignprojects require documentation appropriatefor the class of device (I, II, or III for FDA; A,B, or C for CE). Class III or C requires moredocumentation and gets more scrutiny.#SuccessfulProjects
48
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
55Medical device development hasa generally accepted flow: Userrequirements -> Engineering requirements-> Design -> Verification -> Validation.#EngineeringDesign #SuccessfulProjects
56Validation is usually done with animaltesting or human testing (clinical trial).#EngineeringDesign #SuccessfulProjects
49
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
57Medical devices have several different typesof requirements: 1) Product RequirementsDocument (PRD), 2) System Requirements(SysRS), and 3) Software RequirementsSpecification (SRS). #EngineeringDesign#SuccessfulProjects
50
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
58The Product Requirements Document(PRD) has the overall requirements and insimple medical devices, has the completeelectrical and mechanical requirements.#EngineeringDesign #SuccessfulProjects
59A complex medical device has SystemRequirements (SysRS), which are detailedrequirements for electrical, mechanical,and industrial design and user experience.Simple devices usually don’t have SystemRequirements. #EngineeringDesign#SuccessfulProjects
51
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
60The Software Requirements Specification(SRS) has detailed software requirements.#EngineeringDesign #SuccessfulProjects
52
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
61List all the standards that apply tothe medical device in the ProductRequirements Document (PRD).#EngineeringDesign #SuccessfulProjects
53
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
62Provide an overview of the medicaldevice and its uses that is separate fromthe requirements and will not be verified.#EngineeringDesign #SuccessfulProjects
54
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
63For medical devices, each#EngineeringDesign requirement willbe tested during verification. Make sureeach requirement can be tested with ameasurable result. #SuccessfulProjects
55
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
64If you can’t test a medical devicerequirement, it is either badly definedor should not be a requirement. Highlysuccessful #EngineeringDesignprojects have testable requirements.#SuccessfulProjects
56
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
65Make sure each medical device requirementis a single requirement, testable bya single test with a single outcome.#EngineeringDesign #SuccessfulProjects
66Risk analysis will lead to new or changedmedical device requirements. Allow time inthe #EngineeringDesign schedule for this.#SuccessfulProjects
57
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
67Medical device requirements sometimeschange during the project. Always reviewthe risk analysis, schedule, and budget if therequirements change. #EngineeringDesign#SuccessfulProjects
68Making changes in medical devicerequirements after verification testing isexpensive. Ensure #SuccessfulProjects bymaking changes early or in the next version.#EngineeringDesign #SuccessfulProjects
58
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
69Making changes in medical devicerequirements after clinical testing is VERYexpensive. Work hard to achieve successfulclinical testing, and do pre-testing whenpossible to have a #SuccessfulProject.#EngineeringDesign
70For more advice on medical devicerequirements, see: https://volersystems.com/product-design/medical-devices/developing-product-requirementsmedical-devices/. #EngineeringDesign#SuccessfulProjects
59
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
60
Have everyone, including junior people, report on their progress to ensure a highly successful
#EngineeringDesign project. #SuccessfulProjects
Share the AHA messages from this book socially by going tohttp://aha.pub/EngineeringDesignProjects
Walt Maclay
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
Section IV
Essential Actions Requiredduring Highly Successful
Engineering Design Projects
Now that you have started off the design projectright (see Section 2), this is what you need to do to
continue to have a successful project.
61
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
71Hold review meetings morefrequently during crucial phases ofthe #EngineeringDesign project toachieve a highly successful project.#SuccessfulProjects
62
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
72In review meetings, discuss the progress,next steps, risks, schedule, and budgetof the #EngineeringDesign project.#SuccessfulProjects
73During #EngineeringDesign meetings, focuson what’s important. Don’t waste everyone’stime on something that can be betterhandled by an individual or a small group.#SuccessfulProjects
63
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
74Make sure important issues of the#EngineeringDesign project are coveredcompletely in meetings. #SuccessfulProjects
64
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
75For a #SuccessfulProject, makesure everyone contributes in the#EngineeringDesign review meetings.
76Have everyone, including junior people,report on their progress to ensure a highlysuccessful #EngineeringDesign project.#SuccessfulProjects.
65
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
77Hold people accountable for the#EngineeringDesign schedule and budgetto ensure #SuccessfulProjects. They agreedto it beforehand, didn’t they?
66
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
78Work on the high-risk #EngineeringDesigntasks first. #SuccessfulProjects
79Change is inevitable, don’t fear it.Embrace change cautiously, butavoid making frequent changes tothe #EngineeringDesign project.#SuccessfulProjects
67
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
80Before making a change to an#EngineeringDesign project, list all thethings that need to be done when thatchange is made, including the impact to thecost, schedule, and risk. #SuccessfulProjects
68
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
81To avoid last-minute changes, requireall stakeholders to agree that achange is necessary and desirablein the #EngineeringDesign project.#SuccessfulProjects
82Don’t micromanage. Highly successful#EngineeringDesign projects give peoplefreedom to do things their way, but not somuch freedom that failures can be large.#SuccessfulProjects
69
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
83Pay attention to what your people do welland not so well. Offer them specific, direct,and respectful feedback on how to improveon the #EngineeringDesign project.#SuccessfulProjects
70
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
84Expect your #EngineeringDesign staff toimprove. Teach them and reward them, andthey will improve. #SuccessfulProjects
71
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
85Are you rewarding your#EngineeringDesign team? Rewards makepeople feel valued. #SuccessfulProjects
72
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
86Reward your #EngineeringDesign peoplefor taking necessary risks regardless of theoutcome and for learning from mistakes.#SuccessfulProjects
73
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
87#SuccessfulProjects happen when youdeliver specific, selective, and timelyrecognition in person, rather than by justrewarding with money. How do you rewardyour #EngineeringDesign staff?
88Learning how to improve is motivatingand can lead to more successful#EngineeringDesign projects.#SuccessfulProjects
74
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
89Being on a successful #EngineeringDesignteam is motivating. #SuccessfulProjects
75
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
76
Realize that the definition of completion is different for every person. Make sure to come to common ground in the early stages of the #EngineeringDesign project, or
there will be surprises later on. #SuccessfulProjects
Share the AHA messages from this book socially by going tohttp://aha.pub/EngineeringDesignProjects
Walt Maclay
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
Section V
Warning Signs to Watch for duringHighly Successful Design Projects
You are almost done, but don’t forget that without successful manufacturing,the project is not successful. Engineering has a critical role in transferring the
engineering design to manufacturing. Early in my career, it was pointedout to me that a design engineer does not create anything . . .
except documentation that is used by others to create something.If the documentation is not good, the engineer’s job was not well done.
77
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
90Make sure the engineers understandthe entire high-level product and notjust their part of it. #EngineeringDesign#SuccessfulProjects
911 of 16 Warning Signs of#EngineeringDesign Problems: If peopleworking on the project don’t know what isexpected of them. #SuccessfulProjects
78
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
922 of 16 Warning Signs of#EngineeringDesign Problems:If the schedule keeps changing.#SuccessfulProjects
79
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
933 of 16 Warning Signs of #EngineeringDesignProblems: If the requirements keep changing.#SuccessfulProjects
944 of 16 Warning Signs of#EngineeringDesign Problems: If thebudget keeps changing. #SuccessfulProjects
80
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
955 of 16 Warning Signs of#EngineeringDesign Problems: If therequirements are never allowed to change.You must adapt to changes, such ascompetitors or technical discoveries.#SuccessfulProjects
81
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
966 of 16 Warning Signs of#EngineeringDesign Problems: Ifmanufacturing isn’t involved in the design.#SuccessfulProjects
82
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
977 of 16 Warning Signs of#EngineeringDesign Problems: Ifmarketing and sales aren’t involved in thedesign. #SuccessfulProjects
83
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
988 of 16 Warning Signs of#EngineeringDesign Problems: If technicalsupport is not involved in the design.#SuccessfulProjects
999 of 16 Warning Signs of#EngineeringDesign Problems: Ifengineers on the project have differentunderstandings of what the product is.#SuccessfulProjects
84
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
10010 of 16 Warning Signs of#EngineeringDesign Problems: If engineerson the project don’t understand who thecustomers and users are and what theywant. #SuccessfulProjects
10111 of 16 Warning Signs of#EngineeringDesign Problems: If designengineers are not involved in the transfer tomanufacturing. #SuccessfulProjects
85
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
10212 of 16 Warning Signs of#EngineeringDesign Problems: If reviewmeetings usually have arguments.#SuccessfulProjects
10313 of 16 Warning Signs of#EngineeringDesign Problems: Ifthere are few or no review meetings.#SuccessfulProjects
86
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
10414 of 16 Warning Signs of#EngineeringDesign Problems: If onlydesign engineers attend review meetings.#SuccessfulProjects
10515 of 16 Warning Signs of#EngineeringDesign Problems: Ifmanagement doesn’t know the key risks in theproject. #SuccessfulProjects
87
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
10616 of 16 Warning Signs of#EngineeringDesign Problems: Ifmanagement doesn’t review the actualversus planned schedule and budgetregularly. #SuccessfulProjects
88
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
107Realize that the definition of completionis different for every person. Make sureto come to common ground in theearly stages of the #EngineeringDesignproject, or there will be surprises later on.#SuccessfulProjects
89
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
90
Any #EngineeringDesign issue found needs to be included in an updated manufacturing test. Check that the
manufacturing test will identify devices with each issue that is found #SuccessfulProjects
Share the AHA messages from this book socially by going tohttp://aha.pub/EngineeringDesignProjects
Walt Maclay
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
Section VI
Ensuring a Successful Transferto Manufacturing
It’s easy to have problems that go unnoticed,especially when you are still learning to have highly
successful design projects. These are things to watch out for.
91
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
108Highly successful #EngineeringDesignprojects have complete requirements toensure a successful transfer to manufacturing.#SuccessfulProjects
109In a highly successful #EngineeringDesignproject, it is easy to buy the parts, build it,test it, ship it, and support it in the volumesrequired and to the quality specifications.#SuccessfulProjects
92
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
110Manufacturing needs tightly controlled#EngineeringDesign documentation thatis uniform and easy to follow and repeatwithout a lot of training. #SuccessfulProjects
1111 of 2 disconnects between engineering andmanufacturing that need solving to havesuccessful #EngineeringDesign Projects:Engineers usually don’t understand why thetransfer to manufacturing should take somuch of their time. #SuccessfulProjects
93
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
1122 of 2 disconnects between engineering andmanufacturing that need solving to havesuccessful #EngineeringDesign Projects:Manufacturing people usually don’tunderstand why engineers are so sloppyand hard to deal with. #SuccessfulProjects
94
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
113Manufacturing needs these standard#EngineeringDesign documents: Bill ofMaterials, Gerber files, executable softwarefiles, dimensioned drawings, assemblyinstructions, and test instructions to ensure#SuccessfulProjects.
95
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
114Manufacturing needs manufacturable#EngineeringDesigns in addition to thestandard documents. #SuccessfulProjects
115Manufacturable #EngineeringDesignsstart with good requirements.#SuccessfulProjects
96
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
116Manufacturable #EngineeringDesignshave manufacturing in mind from the start.#SuccessfulProjects
97
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
117Manufacturable #EngineeringDesigns areeasy to assemble. #SuccessfulProjects
98
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
118Manufacturable #EngineeringDesigns havecareful part selections that are affordableand procurable. #SuccessfulProjects
99
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
119Manufacturable #EngineeringDesignsrequire careful design to be able to meetspecifications, despite part variations, toensure #SuccessfulProjects.
120Manufacturable #EngineeringDesigns areeasy to test. #SuccessfulProjects
100
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
121Manufacturable #EngineeringDesignshave test points in the printed circuitboard (PCB) layout to facilitate testing.#SuccessfulProjects
101
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
122Manufacturable #EngineeringDesignsconsider testing during the design.#SuccessfulProjects
123Manufacturable #EngineeringDesignsget input from manufacturing, so they aresuited to the manufacturing process of themanufacturer. #SuccessfulProjects
102
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
124Manufacturable #EngineeringDesigns allowfor parts to be easily removed from moldsby having draft. #SuccessfulProjects
125Manufacturable #EngineeringDesignsdo not get last-minute changes in therequirements. #SuccessfulProjects
103
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
126Expect that the transfer to manufacturingwill have a few issues. Plan this intoyour schedule. Remember that building#EngineeringDesign prototypes is quitedifferent from building goods ready to sell.#SuccessfulProjects
127A 10x increase in manufacturing volumebrings out a new set of #EngineeringDesignissues to be addressed. Plan on timeto find and address these issues.#SuccessfulProjects
104
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
128When product issues are found, there needsto be revised drawings, work instructions,etc. There needs to be an outcome forany issue found, or it is being ignored.#SuccessfulProjects
129Any #EngineeringDesign issue found needsto be included in an updated manufacturingtest. Check that the manufacturing testwill identify devices with each issue that isfound. #SuccessfulProjects
105
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
130Use bad parts in the manufacturing testto ensure that the test procedure finds allissues. #SuccessfulProjects
106
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
131Part availability needs to be monitoredduring the life of the product. End-of-lifeparts can be a large #EngineeringDesignissue. Stay on top of this to mitigatea potential line-down situation.#SuccessfulProjects
107
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
108
If you don’t do anything different with your#EngineeringDesign projects, you won’t get
different results. #SuccessfulProjects
Share the AHA messages from this book socially by going tohttp://aha.pub/EngineeringDesignProjects
Walt Maclay
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
Section VII
Integrating Learning to Get Betterwith Every Project
No matter what level of success you just had, learnhow to improve. With these steps, a good team
can become great.
109
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
132Get better on every #EngineeringDesignproject by improving processes, systems,tools, and practices based on what youlearned. #SuccessfulProjects
133Focus on what is required beyond the#EngineeringDesign shipment phase.#SuccessfulProjects
110
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
134Highly successful #EngineeringDesignprojects design for supportability.#SuccessfulProjects
111
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
135Highly successful #EngineeringDesignprojects design for repairability.#SuccessfulProjects
136Review the #EngineeringDesign projectwith your customer(s), and look forconstructive feedback. #SuccessfulProjects
112
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
137Highly successful #EngineeringDesignprojects encourage criticism by suggestingpossible things you could have done better.This also encourages praise where it is due.#SuccessfulProjects
138Review the #EngineeringDesign projectwith the team. Include the extendedteam and all the parties involved in theproject. Present feedback from customers.#SuccessfulProjects
113
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
139Solicit constructive criticism from theteam. Make sure all members are heard.#EngineeringDesign #SuccessfulProjects
114
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
140Update #EngineeringDesign proceduresand practices from what is learned byreviewing the project. #SuccessfulProjects
115
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
About the Author
Voler is particularly experienced in designing wearable and IoT devices, using its skillwith sensors and wireless technology. Mr. Maclay has been active in several consultantorganizations and is a senior life member of the Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers (IEEE). He is a reviewer for NSF SBIR grants and has mentored dozens of startup companies. Voler Systems is a member of a technology consortium, the Product Realization Group, whichprovides all the services to design and introduce new hardware products. Mr. Maclay holdsa BSEE degree in electrical engineering from Syracuse University.
Contributors:John Dring, VP of Engineering at Voler Systems, contributed his great knowledge andexperience.
Kimberly Wiefling, founder and president of Wiefling Consulting, edited and contributeda great deal.
116
Walt Maclay is the president and founder of Voler Systems in 1979, now one of the top electronic design firms in Silicon Valley, and iscommitted to delivering quality electronic products that are easy to manufacture on time and on budget. Voler Systems provides design, development, risk assessment, and verification of new devices for medical, consumer, and industrial applications.
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
117
THiNKaha has created AHAthat for you to share content from this book.
Share each AHA message socially:http://aha.pub/EngineeringDesignProjects
Share additional content: https://AHAthat.com
Info on authoring: https://AHAthat.com/Author
Copyright ©2021 www.volersystems.com
1021 S. Wolfe Rd, Suite 285, Sunnyvale, CA [email protected]
118
Everyone can learn to have highly successful #EngineeringDesign projects.#SuccessfulProjects
Highly successful #EngineeringDesign projects have Complete requirements toensure a successful transfer to manufacturing. #SuccessfulProjects
Build margin at the end of the #EngineeringDesign program to improve theconfidence to higher than 50%. #SuccessfulProjects
Before making a change to an #EngineeringDesign project, list all the things that need to be done when that change is made, including the impact to the cost,schedule, and risk. #Successfulprojects
Learning how to improve is motivating and can lead to More successful#EngineeringDesign projects. #SuccessfulProjects
Walt Maclay, President and Founder of Voler Systems in 1979, now one of the top electronic design firms in Silicon Valley, is committed to delivering quality electronic products on time and on budget that are easy to manufacture. He is active in consultant organizations, does SBIR grant reviews for the NSF, and mentors startup CEOs.
https://AHAthat.com