Date post: | 05-Apr-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | dr-nancy-malik |
View: | 224 times |
Download: | 0 times |
of 12
7/31/2019 Homeopathic Medicines in 200c Potency Retains Nanograms of Nanoparticles of Original Starting Material 2010
1/12
O^BMBKHI WHWL^
Lzv~lcl joclowhvjbd fbi|vbokt ~lvhbk tvh~vbkmchvl~bhit1 H khkowh~vbd|ihvl wl~twldvbul
W~htjhkv Thvbtj Djb`~hchkl8
) H``bjlnnhi @ T|~ltj8)>
) Ahrltj ^hcltj Nliih~l8)>)! hkf Tjhkvh~hc Moubkf @hkl
8)!
8Flwh~vclkv oe Djlcbdhi Lkmbkll~bkm) Bkfbhk Bktvbv|vl oe Vldjkoiomr *BBV") Nocnhr) Hfb Tjhk`h~hdjh~rh Ch~m) Wo}hb)C|cnhb 677 7=5) Chjh~htjv~h) Bkfbh>Flwh~vclkv oe Nbotdblkdlt hkf Nbolkmbkll~bkm) Bkfbhk Bktvbv|vl oe Vldjkoiomr *BBV") Nocnhr) Hfb Tjhk`h~hdjh~rh Ch~m)
Wo}hb) C|cnhb 677 7=5) Chjh~htjv~h) Bkfbh
Joclowhvjr bt dokv~oul~tbhi nldh|tl clfbdbklt bk jbmj wovlkdblt t|dj ht 47d hkf >77dbkuoiul j|ml fbi|vbok ehdvo~t *8757 hkf 87677 ~ltwldvbulir" }jbdj h~l chkr o~fl~t oechmkbv|fl m~lhvl~ vjhk Huomhf~ot k|cnl~) to vjhv vjlo~lvbdhiir vjl~l tjo|if nl koclht|~hnil ~lckhkvt oe vjl tvh~vbkm chvl~bhit+ Ko jrwovjltbt }jbdj w~lfbdvt vjl~lvlkvbok oe w~owl~vblt oe tvh~vbkm chvl~bhit jht nllk w~owotlf ko~ jht hkr wjrtbdhi lkvbvrnllk tjo}k vo lzbtv bk vjltl jbmj wovlkdr clfbdbklt+ \tbkm ch~`lv thcwilt oe clvhi#fl~bulf clfbdbklt e~oc ~lw|vhnil chk|ehdv|~l~t) }l jhul flcoktv~hvlf eo~ vjl ~tvvbcl nr V~hktcbttbok Lildv~ok Cbd~otdowr *VLC") lildv~ok fbee~hdvbok hkf djlcbdhihkhirtbt nr Bkf|dvbulir Do|wilf Wihtch#Hvocbd Lcbttbok Twldv~otdowr *BDW#HLT") vjlw~ltlkdl oe wjrtbdhi lkvbvblt bk vjltl lzv~lcl fbi|vbokt) bk vjl eo~c oe khkowh~vbdilt oevjl tvh~vbkm clvhit hkf vjlb~ hmm~lmhvlt+ Joclowhvjr*>787" 22) >48l>6>+
@lr}o~ft1 Joclowhvjr0 Khkowh~vbdilt0 Khkod~rtvhiibkl chvl~bhit0 V~hktcbttbokLildv~ok Cbd~otdowr
Bkv~of|dvbok
Joclowhvjr) h cofl oe vjl~hwr) }ht ltvhnibtjlf bk vjl
ihvl 8:vj dlkv|~r nr Ml~chk wjrtbdbhk) Thc|li Jhjkl#
chkk+ Jhjklchkk) f|~bkm jbt lzwl~bclkvt) w~lwh~lf clfb#
dbklt e~oc h }bfl uh~blvr oe khv|~hi w~of|dvt+ Jl fbtdl~klf
vjhv vjl bkkbvl fbi|vbokt oe vjltl t|ntvhkdlt dh~~blf o|v bk
tvlwt hkf hddocwhkblf nr ubmo~o|t tjh`bkm t|dd|ttbok
*vomlvjl~ `ko}k ht wovlkvbqhvbok" hv lhdj fbi|vbok tvlw)
libdbvlf tocl `bkf oe h wovlkv hdvbubvr vo vjltl toi|vbokt+
8)>
Bk twbvl oe vjl uh~bo|t dokv~oul~tblt hkf e~lx|lkv
djhiilkmlt nr vjl tdblkvbd docc|kbvr ~lmh~fbkm bvt
ledhdr) vjbt cofl oe v~lhvclkv jht tvoof vjl vltv oe vbcl)
hkf bt tvbii nlbkm |tlf bk chkr do|kv~blt eo~ v~lhvclkv oe
uh~bo|t dj~okbd dokfbvbokt) }bvj clfbdbklt nlbkm w~lwh~lf
e~oc h uh~blvr oe jl~nhi) hkbchi) clvhi hkf ovjl~ cbkl~hi
to|~dlt+
Jo}lul~) h chao~ ihd|kh jht nllk vjl ihd` oe lubflkdl
oe wjrtbdhi lzbtvlkdl oe vjl tvh~vbkm chvl~bhi+ Vjl chbk fbe#
d|ivr bk h~~bubkm hv h ~hvbokhi lzwihkhvbok tvlct e~oc vjl
ehdv vjhv joclowhvjbd clfbdbklt h~l |tlf bk lzv~lcl fbi|#
vbokt) bkdi|fbkm fbi|vbok ehdvo~t lzdllfbkm Huomhf~ot
k|cnl~ nr tlul~hi o~fl~t oe chmkbv|fl) bk }jbdj okl
}o|if kov lzwldv hkr clht|~hnil ~lckhkv oe vjl tvh~vbkm
chvl~bhi vo nl w~ltlkv+ Bk dibkbdhi w~hdvbdl) joclowhvjbd
wovlkdblt oe 47d hkf >77d jhubkm fbi|vbok ehdvo~t oe 8757
hkf 87677
~ltwldvbulir) eh~ nlrokf Huomhf~ot k|cnl~ oe5+7>4 87>4 coild|ilt bk okl coil) h~l ~o|vbklir |tlf+
Chkr jrwovjltlt jhul nllk wotv|ihvlf vo a|tvber hkf li|#
dbfhvl vjlb~ cldjhkbtct oe hdvbok+ ]jbil tocl jrwovjltlt
t|dj ht vjl vjlo~r oe }hvl~ clco~r)4l< eo~chvbok oe
dihvj~hvlt)5 hkf lwbvhzr= h~l dokaldv|~hi bk khv|~l) ovjl~t
t|dj ht vjotl nhtlf ok vjl x|hkv|c wjrtbdhi htwldvt oe
vjl toi|vbokt:)2 jhul kov nllk t|edblkvir vltvlf) lbvjl~
f|l vo docwilzbvr bk uhibfhvbkm vjl jrwovjltbt o~ f|l vo
kok#~lw~of|dbnil ~lt|ivt+ Vjl tbibdh jrwovjltbt87 bt vjl
okir cofli vjhv w~owotlt vjl w~ltlkdl oe wjrtbdhi lkvbvblt
t|dj ht tbiozhklt o~ tbibdhvlt ~lt|ivbkm e~oc ilhdjbkm e~oc
vjl mihtt dokvhbkl~t+ Eoiio}bkm h flh~vj oe d~lfbnil hkf vltv#
hnil jrwovjltlt vo bflkvber hkr wjrtbdhi lkvbvr ~ltwoktbnil
eo~ clfbdbkhi hdvbubvr) cotv cofl~k tdblkvbtvt dokvbk|l vo
nliblul vjhv joclowhvjr hv nltv w~oubflt h wihdlno leeldv+
!Do~~ltwokflkdl1 Ahrltj ^hcltj Nliih~l hkf Tjhkvh~hc Mo#ubkf @hkl) Flwh~vclkv oe Djlcbdhi Lkmbkll~bkm) Bkfbhk Bktvbv|vloe Vldjkoiomr *BBV") Nocnhr) Hfb Tjhk`h~hdjh~rh Ch~m) Wo}hb)
C|cnhb 677 7=5) Chjh~htjv~h) Bkfbh+L#chbi1 anGbbvn+hd+bk) tm`hklGmchbi+doc^ldlbulf 5 Koulcnl~ >7720 ~lubtlf >> Hw~bi >7870 hddlwvlf >>Chr >787
Joclowhvjr *>787" 22) >48l>6> >787 Vjl Ehd|ivr oe Joclowhvjr
fob187+8785/a+jocw+>787+7
7/31/2019 Homeopathic Medicines in 200c Potency Retains Nanograms of Nanoparticles of Original Starting Material 2010
2/12
Fltwbvl vjl lzv~lcl fbi|vbokt bk 47d hkf >77d wovlkdblt)
o|~ hww~ohdj jht nllk vo vltv eo~ vjl w~ltlkdl oe vjl tvh~vbkm
chvl~bhit bk vjl eo~c oe khkowh~vbdilt++ Clfbdbklt tlildvlf
}l~l clvhi#nhtlf) hkf }l~l to djotlk vjhv vjl clvhit }o|if
kov h~btl lbvjl~ ht bcw|~bvblt o~ ht dokvhcbkhkvt+ Vjl tbz
clvhit hkf vjlb~ ~ltwldvbul joclowhvjbd clfbdbklt }l~l
moif *H|~|c clvhiibd|c o~ H|~|c clv") dowwl~ *D|w~|cclvhiibd|c o~ D|w~|c clv") vbk *Tvhkk|c clvhiibd|c o~
Tvhkk|c clv") qbkd *Qbkd|c clvhiibd|c o~ Qbkd|c clv")
tbiul~ *H~mlkv|c clvhiibd|c o~H~mlkv|c clv" hkf wihvbk|c
*Wihvbk|c clvhiibd|c o~ Wihvbk|c clv"+ Vj~ll wovlkdblt1
5d) 47d) hkf >77d }l~l tlildvlf+ Vjl fbi|vbok ehdvo~ eo~ 5d
bt 878> }jbdj bt iltt vjhk Huomhf~ot k|cnl~) }jl~lht vjl
fbi|vbok ehdvo~t eo~ 47d hkf >77d h~l }lii hnoul+ Ch~`lv
thcwilt oe vjltl clfbdbklt bk 27,u/u lvjhkoi }l~l
onvhbklf e~oc v}o ~lw|vhnil chk|ehdv|~l~t1 TNI) Bkfbh)
hkf F~+ ]biich~ Tdj}hnl Bkfbh *]TB" W~buhvl Ibcbvlf+
]l lzhcbklf vjl eoiio}bkm wjrtbdo#djlcbdhi htwldvt1
h+ Vjl w~ltlkdl oe vjl wjrtbdhi lkvbvblt bk khkowh~vbdileo~c hkf vjlb~ tbql nr V~hktcbttbok Lildv~ok
Cbd~otdowr *VLC" nr n~bmjv#lif hkf fh~`#lif
bchmbkm+
n+ Vjlb~ bflkvbdhvbok nr chvdjbkm vjl Tlildvlf H~lh
Lildv~ok Fbee~hdvbok *THLF" whvvl~kt hmhbktv ibvl~hv|~l
tvhkfh~ft eo~ vjl do~~ltwokfbkm `ko}k d~rtvhit+
d+ Ltvbchvbok oe vjl ilulit oe tvh~vbkm clvhit nr h 77 cltj dow#
wl~ m~bft dohvlf }bvj dh~nokleo~cuh~+
Clvjoft
Khkowh~vbdil djh~hdvl~bqhvbok nr VLC/THLF1 Vjl VLC
hkhirtlt }l~l wl~eo~clf ok Vldkhb M> 8>7 `U D~ro#VLC
*ELB) Jbiitno~o) \TH"+ Hii thcwilt }l~l ubl}lf hv 8>7 U+
Vjl VLC hkhirtlt }l~l wl~eo~clf eo~ vjl clfbdbklt nr
wihdbkm h f~ow oe vjl o~bmbkhi toi|vbok *}bvjo|v w~l#dokdlk#
v~hvbok" ok vjl dh~nokleo~cuh~ dohvlf dowwl~ VLC m~bft
bk h dilhk lkub~okclkv+ Vjl f~ow oe vjl toi|vbok }ht
vjlk hiio}lf vo f~r docwilvlir hevl~ }jbdj hkovjl~ f~ow
}ht hfflf+ Vjl |t|hi f~rbkm vbcl eo~ lhdj f~ow }ht hw#
w~ozbchvlir 47l57 cbk bk hb~ hv ~ooc vlcwl~hv|~l+ Vjbt
w~odlf|~l }ht ~lwlhvlf < vbclt+ Hevl~ hb~#f~rbkm vjl thc#
wil eo~ e|~vjl~ 47l57 cbk) vjl m~bf }ht `lwv |kfl~ hk B^
ihcw eo~ hww~ozbchvlir >7 cbk vo lkt|~l docwilvl f~rbkm
oe vjl thcwil hkf vjl~lnr w~lulkvbkm vjl wottbnbibvr oetoiulkv coild|ilt e~oc hfjl~bkm vo vjl wh~vbdilt ok vjl
m~bf+ Vjl THLF whvvl~kt oe vjl wh~vbdilt }l~l vh`lk hkf
vjl f#twhdbkmt }l~l dhid|ihvlf |tbkm vjl dhcl~h ilkmvj
*dhibn~hvlf fhbir |tbkm h tvhkfh~f moif doiiobf"+ Vjl
fh~`#lif bchmlt }l~l hito vh`lk nr tlildvbkm vj~ll twovt
e~oc v}o bkkl~ ~bkmt ok vjl THLF whvvl~k+ Vjl f#twhdbkm
uhi|lt e~oc THLF whvvl~kt hkf vjl d~rtvhiibvl tbqlt e~oc
vjl fh~`#lif bchmlt }l~l dhid|ihvlf |tbkm vjl Bchml#A
toev}h~l+
Lilclkvhi docwotbvbok nr BDW#HLT1 Vjl flvl~cbkhvbok
oe vjl tvh~vbkm lilclkvt bk |iv~h#v~hdl dokdlkv~hvbokt }ht
wl~eo~clf ok \ivbch >) *Aonbk Ruok Jo~bnh) Ahwhk"+ Vjlowl~hvbkm wh~hclvl~t eo~ vjl BDW#HLT bktv~|clkv }l~l ht
eoiio}t1 wihtch mht o} ~hvl *H~mok mht"1 8> i/cbk0 h|zbi#
bh~r mht o} ~hvl1 7+> i/cbk0 thcwil |wvh`l1 >+< ci/cbk0
bkvlm~hvbok vbcl1 77d wovlkdblt"
Joclowhvjr
7/31/2019 Homeopathic Medicines in 200c Potency Retains Nanograms of Nanoparticles of Original Starting Material 2010
3/12
vj~o|mj ]jhvchk 67 ivl~ whwl~ vo ~lcoul vjl ~ltbf|hi chv#
vl~ w~bo~ vo hkhirtbt+ Vjl TNI thcwilt }l~l hkhirqlf bk v~bw#
ibdhvl hkf thcwilt e~oc ]TB }l~l hkhirqlf bk f|wibdhvl+ Ht
h klmhvbul dokv~oi) 27,u/u lvjhkoi thcwilt }l~l hito w~l#
wh~lf |tbkm JWID m~hfl lvjhkoi hkf Cbiib#X }hvl~+ Vjltl
lvjhkoibd toi|vbokt }l~l hito dokdlkv~hvlf bk vjl chkkl~
tbcbih~ vo vjhv lcwiorlf eo~ vjl clfbdbklt+Vjl lcbttbok ibklt tlildvlf eo~ clht|~bkm vjl dokdlkv~h#
vbok oe vjl clvhit h~l ht eoiio}t1 Moif1 >6>+=2< kc) Dowwl~1
4>6+=:4+222 kc) Qbkd1 >84+::+75: kc) Wihvbk|c1 >577d }l~l hkhirqlf nr VLC+ Vjl ~lt|ivt h~l mbulk
ht wjovocbd~om~hwjt *Ebm|~l 8*h"l*w"") }jbdj dilh~ir flc#
oktv~hvl vjl w~ltlkdl oe khkowh~vbdilt hkf vjlb~ hmm~lmhvlt+
F|l vo lzv~lcl fbi|vbok oevlk okir h tbkmil khkowh~vbdil o~
h ih~ml hmm~lmhvl bt tllk+ Jl~lhevl~) vjl vl~c wh~vbdilt doi#
ildvbulir ~lel~t vo vjl khkowh~vbdilt hkf vjlb~ hmm~lmhvlt+
]l kovlf h jbmj woirfbtwl~tbvr oe vjl wh~vbdilt bk vjl to#
i|vbokt }bvj ~ltwldv vo vjlb~ tjhwlt hkf tbqlt eo~ uh~bo|t
clfbdbklt hkf wovlkdblt+ H td~|w|io|t lzhcbkhvbok oe
vjl lkvb~l chk|ehdv|~bkm w~odltt oe vjltl clfbdbklt t|m#
mltvlf vjhv v}o `lr w~odlttlt wihrlf h ubvhi ~oil bk bcwh~v#
bkm vjl jbmj woirfbtwl~tbvr+ Vjlr h~l1
8+ Vjl fbi|vbok tvlwt bk vjl toibf wjhtl *vbii 5 wovlkdr" bk#
uoiulf v~bv|~hvbok oe vjl ~h} chvl~bhit }bvj ihdvotl+ T|dj
h doccbk|vbok w~odltt bt lzwldvlf vo mlkl~hvl wh~vbdilt
oe uh~blf tjhwlt hkf tbqlt+ Vjl wjrtbdhi djh~hdvl~btvbdt
oe vjltl wh~vbdilt h~l flwlkflkv ok vjl vrwl oe ~h} chvl#
~bhi hkf vjl tjlh~bkm eo~dl hwwiblf+
>+ F|~bkm ibx|bf fbi|vbokt) vjl t|dd|ttbok w~odltt hv lhdj
wovlkvbqhvbok tvlw wihrlf h ubvhi ~oil+ Vjl t|dd|ttbokt
mbulk vo vjl ibx|bf chtt h~l lzwldvlf vo w~of|dl wh~vbdilt
oe uh~blf tjhwlt hkf tbqlt f|l vo vj~ll ehdvo~t bkdi|fbkm
tjlh~bkm eo~dlt mlkl~hvlf f|~bkm vjl wo|kfbkm oe vjl ibx#
|bf dokvhbkl~ hmhbktv hk lihtvbd tvow) vjl w~owl~vblt oe vjl~h} chvl~bhit bkuoiulf) hkf uh~bhvbokt f|~bkm wo|kfbkm
oe vjl dokvhbkl~) nlv}llk bkfbubf|hit+
Vjl wl~c|vhvbokt hkf docnbkhvbokt oe vjl hnoul#clk#
vboklf ehdvo~t hkf vjl wottbnil t|nvil fbeel~lkdlt bk vjl
chk|ehdv|~bkm w~odlttlt lcwiorlf nr uh~bo|t chk|ehd#
v|~l~t dhk lzwihbk vjl kfbkmt ~lmh~fbkm woirfbtwl~tbvr
nlv}llk fbeel~lkv clfbdbklt hkf chk|ehdv|~l~t+
]l hito chfl hkovjl~ w~ocbklkv ontl~uhvbok ~lmh~fbkm
vjl w~ltlkdl oe t|~ehdl htwl~bvblt ok vjl wh~vbdilt }jbdj
}l~l dilh~ir lubflkv e~oc vjl fbeel~lkdlt bk dokv~htv ok t|~#
ehdlt oe vjltl wh~vbdilt hiokm }bvj h t|ntvhkvbhi fbeel~lkdl
bk vjlb~ tbql nlv}llk fbeel~lkv tvh~vbkm clvhit+ Vj|t) ih~ml~
hmm~lmhvlt }l~l eo|kf bk Qbkd|c clv *Ebm|~l 8*h"l*f""
hkf Tvhkk|c clv *Ebm|~l 8*b"l*i"" ht docwh~lf vo vjotl
ontl~ulf bk H|~|c clv *Ebm|~l 8*l"l*j"" hkf D|w~|c
clv*Ebm|~l 8*c"l*w"" hv vjl thcl wovlkdblt+
Vjl cldjhkbtc oe dhubvhvbok o~ mlkl~hvbok oe uhwo~ n|n#
nilt dh|tlf nr |iv~h#to|kf b~~hfbhvbok *hdo|tvbd dhubvhvbok"
bk vjl lkvb~l ibx|bf chtt f|~bkm chk|ehdv|~bkm chr lzwihbk
vjl ontl~uhvbokt kovlf hnoul+ ]l t|mmltv vjhv vjl w~odltt
oe t|dd|ttbok bt vjl dh|tl oe dhubvhvbok+ Ht tlv o|v bk h ihvl~tldvbok) vjl lzvhkv vjlo~blt oe dhubvhvbok88l86 dhk) bk
w~bkdbwil) w~oubfl hk lzwihkhvbok oe o|~ kfbkmt+
Vjl hmm~lmhvbok nljhubo~ oe vjl wh~vbdilt tllct vo nl fl#
wlkflkv ok vjl wjrtbdhi w~owl~vr oe vjl tvh~vbkm clvhi) twl#
dbdhiir bvt clivbkm wobkv+ ]l ontl~ulf vjhv vjl hmm~lmhvlt
oe qbkd bk Qbkd|c clv hkf vbk bk Tvhkk|c clv }l~l ~lih#
vbulir ih~ml~ ht docwh~lf vo vjl tchiil~ hmm~lmhvlt oe
moif hkf dowwl~ eo|kf bk H|~|c clv hkf D|w~|c clv ~l#
twldvbulir+ Vjl n|i` clivbkm wobkvt oe vbk hkf qbkd h~l
} @ ~ltwldvbulir ht docwh~lf vo vjl
jbmjl~ clivbkm wobkvt oe moif hkf dowwl~ *}844= @ hkf
}
84
7/31/2019 Homeopathic Medicines in 200c Potency Retains Nanograms of Nanoparticles of Original Starting Material 2010
4/12
vjl ~bkm whvvl~kt oe wh~vbdilt ontl~ulf bk H|~|c clv thc#
wilt+ Tbcbih~ir) bk vjl dhtl oe Tvhkk|c clv e~oc TNI) vjl
ontl~ulf whvvl~k bkflzlf vo h#Tk }jl~lht vjhv e~oc ]TB
vo n#Tk+ Bk vjl dhtl oe Qbkd|c clvthcwilt e~oc novj t|w#
wibl~t) }l fbf kov ontl~ul w|~l clvhiibd qbkd) n|v vjl THLF
whvvl~kt bkflzlf vo qbkd jrf~ozbfl }jbdj bt hk lzwldvlf
docwo|kf fl~bulf e~oc qbkd *f#twhdbkm fhvh eo~ qbkd)
vbk hkf dowwl~ jhul nllk mbulk ht T|wwilclkvh~r
bkeo~chvbok l Vhnilt T>lT46
Joclowhvjr
7/31/2019 Homeopathic Medicines in 200c Potency Retains Nanograms of Nanoparticles of Original Starting Material 2010
5/12
t|dj ht 47d hkf >77d }ht htvo|kfbkm) w~oubkm vjhv vjl
tvh~vbkm chvl~bhit }l~l ~lvhbklf lulk }bvj lzv~lclir jbmj
fbi|vbokt+
Vjl f#twhdbkm uhi|lt eo~ vjl wh~vbd|ih~ lilclkvt dok#
eo~clf }lii vo vjl Aobkv Doccbvvll ok Wo}fl~ Fbee~hdvbok
Tvhkfh~ft *ADWFT" fhvh bk ibvl~hv|~l bk vjl ~hkml oe>,+
Jo}lul~) eo~ tocl f#twhdbkmt do~~ltwokfbkm vo h el}
wihklt bk vjl d~rtvhi) vjl uhi|lt fbeel~lf nr hww~ozbchvlir
6,+ Vjl fbeel~lkdlt bk tocl oe vjl f#twhdbkm uhi|lt eo~
lhdj clvhi dhk nl lzwihbklf ok vjl nhtbt oe bkf|dvbok oe cb#
ko~ wihtvbd fleo~chvbokt bk vjl d~rtvhit+ Vjl bkbvbhi v~bv|~h#
vbok w~odltt bkuoiubkm jbmj tjlh~bkm eo~dlt) vomlvjl~ }bvj
vjl t|dd|ttbok w~odltt bkuoiubkm jbmj#uliodbvr doiibtbokt
oe khkowh~vbdilt ~lt|ivbkm bk vjl mlkl~hvbok oe tjod` }hult
dh|tlf nr vjl bcwiofbkm dhubvhvbokt) chr jhul bkf|dlf
cbko~ wihtvbd fleo~chvbokt bk vjl clvhi d~rtvhit+
Bk h el} oe vjl THLF whvvl~kt eo~ vjl clvhit hkhirqlf)
vjl wh~vbdilt hito tjo}lf w~ltlkdl oe fbee|tlf ~bkm
Ebm|~l 8 *dokvbk|lf"+
Khkowh~vbdilt oe tvh~vbkm chvl~bhit bk joclowhvjbd clfbdbkltWT Djb`~hchkl lv hi
>477d+ Bk o~fl~ vo x|hkvber vjl lz#
hdv hco|kvt oe vjltl tvh~vbkm clvhit bk |iv~h#jbmj
wovlkdblt) }l dokf|dvlf vjl BDW#HLT hkhirtlt oe vjltl
clfbdbklt+
Ltvbchvbok oe dokdlkv~hvbok oe vjl tvh~vbkm chvl~bhit nr
BDW#HLT
BDW#HLT bt hk ltvhnibtjlf vldjkbx|l eo~ vjl ltvbchvbok
oe clvhit hkf ovjl~ lilclkvt+ O|~ lx|bwclkv jhf h cbkb#
c|c flvldvhnil ibcbv oe 87 wwn) vjl~lnr kldlttbvhvbkm
Ebm|~l > N~bmjv#lif hkf do~~ltwokfbkm fh~`#lif VLC bchmlt oe khkowh~vbdilt hkf hmm~lmhvlt ontl~ulf bk Qbkd|c clv1 *h" 47d *TNI")*n" >77d *TNI") *d" 47d *]TB") *f" >77d *]TB"+ Bktlvl THLF whvvl~kt oe vjl do~~ltwokfbkm khkowh~vbdil/hmm~lmhvl+
Khkowh~vbdilt oe tvh~vbkm chvl~bhit bk joclowhvjbd clfbdbkltWT Djb`~hchkl lv hi
>45
Joclowhvjr
7/31/2019 Homeopathic Medicines in 200c Potency Retains Nanograms of Nanoparticles of Original Starting Material 2010
7/12
Ebm|~l 4 THLF whvvl~kt oe do~~ltwokfbkm khkowh~vbdilt hkf hmm~lmhvlt *tjo}k bk Ebm|~l 8*h"l*w""+ Qbkd|c clv1 *h" 47d *TNI") *n" >77d
*TNI") *d" 47d *]TB") *f" >77d *]TB"+ H|~|c clv1 *l" 47d *TNI") *e" >77d *TNI") *m" 47d *]TB") *j" >77d *]TB"+ Tvhkk|c clv1 *b" 47d *TNI")*a" >77d *TNI") *`" 47d *]TB") *i" >77d *]TB"+ D|w~|c clv1 *c" 47d *TNI") *k" >77d *TNI") *o" 47d *]TB") *w" >77d *]TB"+
Khkowh~vbdilt oe tvh~vbkm chvl~bhit bk joclowhvjbd clfbdbkltWT Djb`~hchkl lv hi
>4=
Joclowhvjr
7/31/2019 Homeopathic Medicines in 200c Potency Retains Nanograms of Nanoparticles of Original Starting Material 2010
8/12
Ebm|~l 4 *dokvbk|lf"+
Khkowh~vbdilt oe tvh~vbkm chvl~bhit bk joclowhvjbd clfbdbkltWT Djb`~hchkl lv hi
>4:
Joclowhvjr
7/31/2019 Homeopathic Medicines in 200c Potency Retains Nanograms of Nanoparticles of Original Starting Material 2010
9/12
dokdlkv~hvbok oe vjl joclowhvjbd toi|vbokt |tbkm h vldj#
kbx|l bk }jbdj vjl~l bt hntoi|vlir ko wottbnbibvr oe hffbkm
bkhful~vlkvir vjl clvhi vo nl flvldvlf+
Vjl hkhirtlt oe vjl clvhi#nhtlf clfbdbklt) wl~eo~clf
hevl~ vjl dokdlkv~hvbok oe vjl toi|vbokt mhul tvh~vibkm ~l#
t|ivt+ Vjl tvh~vbkm clvhit }l~l flvldvlf eo~ hii wovlkdblt
*5d) 47d) hkf >77d" hv dokdlkv~hvbokt oe vjl o~fl~ oe
wbdom~hc/ci *wm/ci"+ Vjl clht|~lf dokdlkv~hvbokt h~l
w~ltlkvlf bk Vhnil >+ Vjl fhvh w~ltlkvlf bk vjl vhnil h~l
nhd`#dhid|ihvlf dokdlkv~hvbokt oe vjl clvhit bk vjl o~bmb#
khi joclowhvjbd clfbdbklt+ Vjl hkhirtlt oe vjl klmhvbul
dokv~oi oe 27,u/u lvjhkoi fbf kov bkfbdhvl vjl w~ltlkdl oelbvjl~ vjl konil clvhit o~ vbk) hkf eo~ clvhit t|dj ht dow#
wl~ hkf qbkd) bkfbdhvlf eh~ io}l~ dokdlkv~hvbokt vjhk vjotl
bk vjl clfbdbklt+
]l hkhirqlf tlul~hi thcwiltoeH|~|c clv)H~mlkv|c clv)
hkf Wihvbk|c clveo~ vjl w~ltlkdl oe vjlb~ ~ltwldvbul tvh~vbkm
clvhit+ Bk vjl dhtl oeH|~|c clv*TNI") tocl oe vjl thcwilt
vltvlf) bkdi|fbkm jbmjl~ wovlkdblt t|dj ht 47d hkf >77d bkfb#
dhvlf w~ltlkdl oe hww~ozbchvlir 57l877 wm/ci oe moif0 vjl
ilulit nlbkmc|dj jbmjl~ vjhk vjltlktbvbubvr oe vjlbktv~|clkv
}jl~lht bk vjl lvjhkoil}hvl~ klmhvbul dokv~oit vjl~l }ht ko
tbmkhi eo~ vjl w~ltlkdl oe moif+ Jo}lul~) h el} H|~|c clv
*TNI" thcwilt fbf kov tjo} w~ltlkdl oe moif+ O|~ ~lt|ivtwobkv vo}h~ft h doktbfl~hnil nhvdj#vo#nhvdj uh~bhvbok bk vjl
dokdlkv~hvbokt oe vjl tvh~vbkm chvl~bhi+ Vjbt bt dl~vhbkir kov
t|~w~btbkm) doktbfl~bkm vjhv vjl clvjof oe w~lwh~hvbok bk#
uoiulf chk|hi w~odlttlt hiokm }bvj hk hntlkdl oe hkr hv#
vlcwv vo ltvbchvl vjl dokdlkv~hvbokt oe vjl tvh~vbkm
chvl~bhit hv vjl lkf oe vjl chk|ehdv|~bkm w~odltt oe h wh~vbd#
|ih~ nhvdj+ Vjl H|~|c clv*]TB" thcwilt fbf kov tjo} moif
bk flvldvhnil x|hkvbvblt+
Hkhiomo|t ~lt|ivt }l~l onvhbklf eo~ vjl H~mlkv|c clv
*TNI" thcwilt }jl~lbk tbiul~ }ht flvldvlf bk okl 47d
hkf okl >77d thcwil *47+5 wm/ci hkf 885 wm/ci ~ltwld#
vbulir"+ Vjl dokdlkv~hvbokt bk vjl ovjl~ thcwilt }l~l
nlio} vjl flvldvbok ibcbv+ Ib`l}btl) }l fbtdl~klf flvldv#
hnil dokdlkv~hvbok oe wihvbk|c *}67l>>7 wm/ci" bk vjl
Wihvbk|c clv *TNI" thcwilt eo~ hii wovlkdblt+
Vjl dokdlkv~hvbokt oe kok#konil clvhit t|dj ht dowwl~)
vbk hkf qbkd bk vjlb~ ~ltwldvbul joclowhvjbd clfbdbklt ubq+
D|w~|c clv) Tvhkk|c clv) hkf Qbkd|c clv }l~l jbmjl~
*>l47 vbclt vjhv oe konil clvhit" hkf lhtbir flvldvhnil+
Bk vjl D|w~|c clv thcwilt *TNI") }l flvldvlf
}+ Jbmj bkvl~#nhvdj uh~bhvbok bk vjl dokdlkv~hvbok oe vjl
tvh~vbkm chvl~bhit eo~ h mbulk chk|ehdv|~l~ hkf wovlkdr)
hkf nlv}llk chk|ehdv|~l~t+
Vhnil 8 Lildv~ok fbee~hdvbok whvvl~k l docwh~btok oe f#twhdbkm eo~ H|~|c clv47d hkf >77d wovlkdblt
j`i uhi|lt ^lihvbul bkvlktbvr
f#twhdbkmMoif PHS
H|~|c clv47D TNI lEbm|~l 4*l"
H|~|c clv>77D TNI lEbm|~l 4*e"
H|~|c clv47D ]TBlEbm|~l 4*m"
H|~|c clv>77D ]TBlEbm|~l 4*j"
888 877 >+4>77 >+7427 >+7477 >+7424 >+7>84 >+7>>6
>>7 4> 8+66>7 8+64:2 8+66477 8+>777 8+>>> 8> 8+8==6 8+8:72 8+8=4> 8+852 8+78 8+7>88448 >4 7+24> 7+28>7 7+28>7 7+27=26>> >4 7+:4>< 7+:>:5444 l 7+=:87 7+=8=2 7+=825 l 7+5:775>7 l 7+5675>> l 7+58
7/31/2019 Homeopathic Medicines in 200c Potency Retains Nanograms of Nanoparticles of Original Starting Material 2010
10/12
Vj|t) eo~ lhdj clvhi#nhtlf clfbdbkl oe h wh~vbd|ih~ wo#
vlkdr) vjl ltvbchvlf uhi|lt hwwlh~lf vo nl }bvjbk h nhkf oe> o~fl~t oe chmkbv|fl+ Vjltl uh~bhvbokt do|if nl hvv~bn|vlf
vo vjl w~odlttlt lcwiorlf eo~ chk|ehdv|~bkm+ H ubtbv vo
h ~lw|vlf chk|ehdv|~l~ ~lulhilf vjhv vjl bkbvbhi ihdvotl v~bv#
|~hvbokt }l~l wl~eo~clf ok hk h|vochvlf chdjbkl |tbkm
h co~vh~ hkf wltvil+ Hwh~v e~oc vjl dokv~oi oe wh~vbdil tbqlt
oe vjl clvhi wo}fl~t hv 8 wovlkdr *}jl~lbk :7, oe vjl
wh~vbdilt oe vjl tvh~vbkm chvl~bhi tjo|if nl nlio} 87 cc
hkf kokl hnoul 77d) bk
twbvl oe 47d hkf>77d wovlkdblt nlbkm 876: hkf874:: ~ltwld#
vbulir co~l fbi|vl vjhk 5d+ Bv bt bkvl~ltvbkm vo kovl vjhv vjl
wihvlh| eo~ kok#konil clvhit tjo}lf h jbmjl~ clvhi dokvlkv
vjhk eo~ konil clvhit+ O|~ BDW#HLT ~lt|ivt t|mmltvlf vjhv
vjl htrcwvovl leeldv docclkdlt h~o|kf 5d wovlkdr
*Ebm|~l 6"+
O|~ kfbkmt hwwlh~ vo nl hk lzvlktbok oe vjl v~lkft
kovlf hv io}l~ wovlkdblt nr ^ofl~ lv hi+)8: }jo hkhirqlf
vjl dokdlkv~hvbokt oe h el} clvhit bk fldbchi fbi|vbokt
e~oc 5 vo : *do~~ltwokfbkm vo dlkvltbchi wovlkdblt
oe 4d vo 6d"+ Wh~v H bk Ebm|~l 6 lzwibdbvir flwbdvt fl#
d~lhtl bk vjl dokdlkv~hvbokt oe tvh~vbkm chvl~bhit }bvj fb#
i|vbokt+ Okir bk vjl dhtl oe H|4+ bk H|Di4 toi|vbokt) vjl
Vhnil > Ltvbchvlf dokdlkv~hvbok oe tvh~vbkm clvhit bk uh~bo|t wovlkdblt nr BDW#HLT *wm/ci"
Joclowhvjbd fbi|vbok TNI *wm/ci" ]TB *wm/ci"
8 > 4 8 >
27,u/u Lvjhkoi KF KF KF KF KFH|~|c clv 5d :8+6 =5+6 KF Thcwilt kov onvhbklf
H|~|c clv 47d 56+:! KF KF KFH|~|c clv >77d KF 876+5 KF KF KF
27,u/u Lvjhkoi 86677d 6:+> >5:7+>! KF KF
27,u/u Lvjhkoi KF KF KF KF KFTvhkk|c clv5d 8287+> 822+7 >7:+> >87+>Qbkd|c clv 5d 4:7+7 455+7 877>+: 864>+5! 42:2+5Qbkd|c clv 47d 56+7 475:+5! 84==+5Qbkd|c clv >77d 4! >=64+5 >>47+>! >4>>+:
27,u/u LvjhkoiKF KF KF
Thcwilt kov onvhbklfH~mlkv|c clv5d KF KF 47+5H~mlkv|c clv47d KF 885+7 KFH~mlkv|c clv>77d KF KF KF
27,u/u Lvjhkoi KFThcwilt kov onvhbklf Thcwilt kov onvhbklfWihvbk|c clv5d >>7+5!
Wihvbk|c clv47d 68+7!Wihvbk|c clv>77d >84+5
Noif hmhbktv h whb~ oe thcwilt bk h ~o} eo~ mbulk chk|ehdv|~l~ hkf wovlkdr bkfbdhvlt vjlb~ w~lwh~hvbok e~oc thcl chk|ehdv|~bkm nhvdj+ VjlIbcbv oe Flvldvbok *IOF" oe vjl bktv~|clkv }ht 87 km/ci do~~ltwokfbkm vo >7 wm/ci bk vjl o~bmbkhi toi|vbokt+ Hii dokdlkv~hvbokt nlio} vjbt uhi|ljhul nllk ~lwo~vlf ht Kov Flvldvlf o~ KF+! Fhvh bkfbdhvl vjhv vjl novvilt |tlf vo ch`l |w vjl ~lx|b~lf x|hkvbvr *>777 ci" }l~l e~oc vjl thcl chk|ehdv|~bkm nhvdj+
Khkowh~vbdilt oe tvh~vbkm chvl~bhit bk joclowhvjbd clfbdbkltWT Djb`~hchkl lv hi
>67
Joclowhvjr
7/31/2019 Homeopathic Medicines in 200c Potency Retains Nanograms of Nanoparticles of Original Starting Material 2010
11/12
hdv|hi dokdlkv~hvbokt flvl~cbklf }l~l ilttl~ vjhk vjl
lzwldvlf dokdlkv~hvbokt *db~dilt) toibf1 lzwldvlf0 owlk1
ltvbchvlf dokdlkv~hvbokt"+ Ok vjl dokv~h~r) vjl dokdlkv~h#
vbokt oe El4+ vjo|mj tibmjvir io}l~ vjhk lzwldvlf hv vjl
5 wovlkdr) fbf kov fld~lhtl ht lzwldvlf) hkf }l~l bk
ehdv tibmjvir jbmjl~ hv = hkf : wovlkdblt *tvh~t) toibf1
lzwldvlf0 owlk1 flvl~cbklf dokdlkv~hvbokt"+ Ib`l}btl)
vjl dokdlkv~hvbokt oe Jm>+ hkf Qk>+ }l~l hicotv >77,
jbmjl~ vjhk lzwldvlf hv : wovlkdr+ H td~|w|io|t)
dokd|~~lkv hkhirtbt oe vjltl ~lt|ivt t|mmltvlf vjl doc#
clkdlclkv oe hk htrcwvovl eo~chvbok bk vjl ubdbkbvr oe
vjl : *b+l+ 6d" wovlkdr+
]jlk vjl fhvh e~oc Wh~v H oe vjl m~hwj h~l docwh~lf
}bvj o|~ fhvh *Wh~v N") vjl~l hwwlh~t vo nl h wihvlh|bkm
leeldv) ~lhdjlf hv 5d wovlkdr+]jbil h wihvlh| bt ~lhdjlf eo~ lhdj clvhi) vjl dokdlkv~h#
vbok ~hkml uh~blf e~oc okl clvhi vo hkovjl~ hkf nlv}llk
chk|ehdv|~l~t+ Vjl wihvlh| oe Qbkd|c clv *]TB" *toibf
tx|h~lt" }ht hww~ldbhnir jbmjl~ *nlv}llk 8477 hkf
6777 wm/ci" vjhk vjhv eo~ Qbkd|c clv *TNI" *owlk
tx|h~lt") hinlbv }bvj vjl bkjl~lkv uh~bhvbok clkvboklf lh~#
ibl~+ Tbcbih~ v~lkft }l~l hito ontl~ulf eo~ hii vjl ovjl~
clvhit vjhv }l~l hkhirqlf+
Wottbnil `lr cldjhkbtct hv ih~ml fbi|vbokt
Hdo|tvbd dhubvhvbok) h }lii tv|fblf wjlkoclkok88l86
chr lzwihbk o|~ VLC kfbkmt ~lmh~fbkm t|~ehdl
htwl~bvblt hkf wh~vbdil hmm~lmhvbok+ ^ltlh~djl~t jhul
ontl~ulf vjhv vjl uhwo~ n|nnilt mlkl~hvlf f|l vo vjl
jbmj#lkl~mr to|kf }hult jhf vlcwl~hv|~lt lzdllfbkm
h el} vjo|thkf flm~llt *}+) ~bmjv v~bhkmil1 Qk>++ Wh~v N lltvbchvlf nr BDW#HLT bk o|~ }o~` l tx|h~lt1 qbkd dokdlkv~hvbokt) owlk1 Qbkd|c clv *TNI") toibf1 Qbkd|c clv *]TB") owlk v~bhkmilt1moif dokdlkv~hvbokt bk H|~|c clv*TNI" thcwilt+ Vjl fovvlf ibkl hv >7 wm/ci bkfbdhvlt vjl IOF oe vjl bktv~|clkv+
Khkowh~vbdilt oe tvh~vbkm chvl~bhit bk joclowhvjbd clfbdbkltWT Djb`~hchkl lv hi
>68
Joclowhvjr
7/31/2019 Homeopathic Medicines in 200c Potency Retains Nanograms of Nanoparticles of Original Starting Material 2010
12/12
Hkovjl~ x|ltvbok vjhv h~btlt e~oc o|~ ontl~uhvbokt bt
jo} bk twbvl oe t|dj j|ml fbi|vbokt vjl wh~vbdilt oe vjl tvh~v#
bkm chvl~bhit h~l ~lvhbklf lulk hv >77d wovlkdr? Vjl hk#
t}l~ vo vjbt x|ltvbok do|if ibl bk vjl chk|ehdv|~bkm
w~odltt bvtlie+ ]l wl~dlbul vjhv f|~bkm vjl t|dd|ttbok w~o#
dltt) vjl wo|kfbkm oe toi|vbokt hmhbktv h ~|nnl~ tvow mlkl~#
hvlt k|cl~o|t khkon|nnilt82 ht h ~lt|iv oe lkv~hwclkv oehb~ hkf dhubvhvbok f|l vo mlkl~hvbok oe |iv~h#to|kf }hult+
Vjl wh~vbdilt oe vjl tvh~vbkm chvl~bhi bktvhkvhklo|tir mlv
hfto~nlf ok vjl t|~ehdl oe vjltl n|nnilt hkf dhubvhvbokt+
Vjbt wjlkoclkok do|if nl tbcbih~ vo vjl cldjhkbtc oe
eo~chvbok oe Wbd`l~bkm lc|itbokt)>7l>> }jl~lbk vjl
lc|itblf wjhtl ubq+ hb~ n|nnilt o~ ibx|bf f~owilvt h~l
tvhnbibqlf nr h ihrl~ oe wh~vbdilt+
Vjbt khkowh~vbdillkhkon|nnil docwilz ~btlt vo vjl t|~#
ehdl hkf dhk nl }bvjbk h cokoihrl~ okdl vjl vovhi clvhi
dokdlkv~hvbokt h~l }lii nlio} 8 wwc *Vhnil T5 l
T|wwilclkvh~r bkeo~chvbok"+ Bv bt vjbt 8, oe vjl vow ihrl~
oe vjl toi|vbok }jbdj bt doiildvlf hkf hfflf vo vjl klzvulttli) bkvo 22 wh~vt oe e~ltj toiulkv hkf vjl t|dd|ttbok
w~odltt bt ~lwlhvlf+ Vjbt v~hktel~ oe vjl vow 8, ihrl~ bk
lhdj tvlw }bii lkt|~l vjhv okdl }l ~lhdj nlio} h dl~vhbk
dokdlkv~hvbok b+l+ }lii }bvjbk h cokoihrl~) vjl lkvb~l tvh~v#
bkm chvl~bhi dokvbk|lt vo mo e~oc okl fbi|vbok vo vjl klzv)
~lt|ivbkm bk hk htrcwvovl nlrokf 5d+
Dokdi|tbok
\tbkm tvhvl#oe#vjl#h~v vldjkbx|lt *VLC) THLF) hkf
BDW#HLT" }l jhul flcoktv~hvlf vjl w~ltlkdl oe khkowh~#
vbdilt oe vjl tvh~vbkm chvl~bhit hkf vjlb~ hmm~lmhvlt lulk hv
lzv~lclir jbmj fbi|vbokt+ Vjl dok~clf w~ltlkdl oe khko#wh~vbdilt djhiilkmlt d|~~lkv vjbk`bkm hno|v vjl ~oil oe fbi|#
vbok bk joclowhvjbd clfbdbklt+ ]l jhul eo|kf vjhv vjl
dokdlkv~hvbokt ~lhdj h wihvlh| hv vjl 5d wovlkdr hkf nl#
rokf+ E|~vjl~) }l jhul tjo}k vjhv fltwbvl ih~ml fbeel~lkdlt
bk vjl flm~ll oe fbi|vbok e~oc 5d vo >77d *878> vo 87677")
vjl~l }l~l ko chao~ fbeel~lkdlt bk vjl khv|~l oe vjl wh~vb#
dilt *tjhwl hkf tbql" oe vjl tvh~vbkm chvl~bhi hkf vjlb~ hnto#
i|vl dokdlkv~hvbokt *bk wm/ci"+
Jo} vjbt v~hktihvlt bkvo djhkml bk nboiombdhi hdvbubvr
}bvj bkd~lhtbkm wovlkdr kllft e|~vjl~ tv|fr+ Dokd~lvl lub#
flkdl oe vjl w~ltlkdl oe wh~vbdilt ht eo|kf nr |t do|if jliw
vh`l vjl ~ltlh~dj bk joclowhvjr h tvlw eo~}h~f bk |kfl~#
tvhkfbkm vjltl wovlkvbtlf clfbdbklt hkf hito jliw vo wotb#
vbulir djhkml vjl wl~dlwvbok oe vjl tdblkvbd docc|kbvr
vo}h~ft vjbt cofl oe v~lhvclkv+
Dokeibdvoe bkvl~ltv
Vjl~l h~l klbvjl~ hkr khkdbhi ko~ hkr wl~tokhi dokbdvt
oe bkvl~ltv }bvj ~ltwldv vo vjl }o~` dh~~blf o|v eo~ vjbt
h~vbdil+
Hd`ko}ilfmlclkvt
]l vjhk` vjl Flwh~vclkv oe Lh~vj Tdblkdlt hkf vjl
D~ro#VLC dlkv~hi ehdbibvr hv BBV Nocnhr eo~ BDW#HLT
hkf VLC hkhirtlt ~ltwldvbulir+ ]l hito m~hvle|iir
hd`ko}ilfml e|kfbkm nr Tj~bfjh~ Tj|`ih) T M @hkl hkf
Bkf|tv~bhi ^ltlh~dj hkf Dokt|ivhkdr Dlkvl~ *B^DD") BBV
Nocnhr+ ]l hito vjhk` W K Uh~ch eo~ uhi|hnil bktbmjvt+
T|wwilclkvh~rfhvh
T|wwilclkvh~r fhvh httodbhvlf }bvj vjbt h~vbdil dhk nl
eo|kf bk vjl okibkl ul~tbok hv fob187+8785/a+jocw+>787+77750 7l44>+
> @j|fh#N| jtj H^+ Vo}h~ft |kfl~tvhkfbkm coild|ih~ cldjhkbtct
oe hdvbok oe joclowhvjbd f~|mt1 hk oul~ubl}+ Coi Dlii Nbodjlc
>7740 >8l8>:+
= ^ho CI) ^or ^) Nlii B^) Jooul~ ^+ Vjl flkbkm ~oil oe tv~|dv|~l
*bkdi|fbkm lwbvhzr" bk vjl wih|tbnbibvr oe joclowhvjr+ Joclowhvjr
>77=0 251 8=+
: ]hihdj J) Aokht ]N) Bult A) uhk ]ba` ^) ]lbkmh~vkl~ O+ ^ltlh~dj
ok joclowhvjr1 tvhvl oe vjlh~v+A Hivl~k Docwilclkv Clf>772+
2 Fhurfou HT+ Lkl~mr hkf lildv~ok v~hktwo~v bk nboiombdhi trtvlct+
Bk1 Jo C]) Woww EH) ]h~k`l \ *lft"+ Nbolildv~ofrkhcbdt hkfNbodocc|kbdhvbok+ Tbkmhwo~l1 ]o~if Tdblkvbd W|nibtjbkm Do+
Wvl+ Ivf+) 8226+ Djhw 8=) ww 688l647+
87 Hkbd` FA) Bult AH+ Vjl tbibdh jrwovjltbt eo~ joclowhvjr1 wjrtbdhi
djlcbtv~r+ Joclowhvjr >77=0 251 8:2l826=1 875=l8752+
8> T|tibd` @T) Fo`vrdq TA+ Vjl tokodjlcbtv~r oe Qk wo}fl~+ A Hc
Djlc Tod 82:20 8881 >46>l>466+
84 T|tibd` @T) W~bdl MA+ Hwwibdhvbokt oe |iv~hto|kf vo chvl~bhit
djlcbtv~r+ Hkk| ^lu Chvl~ Tdb 82220 >21 >25+
86 T|tibd` @T+ Vjl djlcbdhi leeldvt oe |iv~hto|kf+ Tdb Hc 82:2
*Eln"0:7l:5+
8< Moiftvlbk HK) Ldjl~ DC) Hibubthvot HW+ Clivbkm bk tlcbdokf|dvo~
khkod~rtvhit+ Tdblkdl 822>0 >=+85 Lfbkmvok A]+ Wjbibwt vldjkbdhi ibn~h~r l cokom~hwjt bk w~hdvbdhi
lildv~ok cbd~otdowr bk chvl~bhit tdblkdl > l lildv~ok fbee~hdvbok
bk vjl lildv~ok cbd~otdowl+ Lbkfjoulk1 K+U+ Wjbibwt) 82=77=) ww >=>>l>=67l8>5+
82 ^or ^) Vbiil~ ]H) Nlii B) Jooul~ C + Vjl tv~|dv|~l oe ibx|bf }hvl~1
kouli bktbmjvt e~oc chvl~bhit ~ltlh~dj0 wovlkvbhi ~liluhkdl vo jocl#
owhvjr+ Chvl~ ^lt Bkkou >77778l>7>8+
>8 Nbk`t NW+ Wh~vbdilt ht t|~ehdvhkvt l tbcbih~bvblt hkf fbeel~lkdlt+
D|~~ Owbk Doiiobf Bkvl~ehdl Tdb >77>0 =1 >8l
68+>> Nbk`t NW) I|ctfok TO+ Bk|lkdl oe wh~vbdil }lvvhnbibvr ok vjl vrwl
hkf tvhnbibvr oe t|~ehdvhkv#e~ll lc|itbokt+ Ihkmc|b~ >7770 851
:5>>l:548+
Khkowh~vbdilt oe tvh~vbkm chvl~bhit bk joclowhvjbd clfbdbkltWT Djb`~hchkl lv hi
>6>
Joclowhvjr
http://dx.doi.org/doi:10.1016/j.homp.2010.05.006http://dx.doi.org/doi:10.1016/j.homp.2010.05.006http://dx.doi.org/doi:10.1016/j.homp.2010.05.006http://dx.doi.org/doi:10.1016/j.homp.2010.05.006