8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

1/45

"#$ %# &' () *+,-%#%'.,() /()%,() 0#)-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /#+-6((+7

85 9)%+#71:%,#)

858

* ;( %# 3()7.' B %3(% ,% %# -(>@

%3'> -3#1.7 &' +'-A#)-,2' %# %3'

-%#+'- -3#1.7 #;;'+ ( 2(+,'%> #; &+()7-5 C# () *+,-%#%'.,() #+ F(+$,),() :#):'A%,#) #;

#+6(),- A1+A#+% %# (AA.> B -''

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

2/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 9

I J I

85J

9) :'.;#1 #)7 %3(%@ #+ ,- -5

C3' ;,+-% ,- %3(% 1).'-- %3' #&=':% :#);#+'- ,%-'.;,)%# %3' D,)7 #; #&=':% %3(% ,% ,- &?:#);#+

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

3/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 D

I U I

/()%,() %3'#+> ' () ,

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

4/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 E

I W I

P.(%#),- %3(% () #&=':% ;,%- 1)7'+ ( :'+%(,) :#):'A% #).> %# %3' 'G%')% %3(% ,%

:#);#+ %3(%

%3' #&=':% 6'%- ,%- ,7')%,%> ;+#< ,%- A(+%,:,A(%,#) ,) -# #)' &+()7@ (.%3#163 $'

%3(%@ &1% 7,-(AA#,)%,)6 (-( 6+#:'+> -%#+'5

N['.':%,#)O ,- #)' #; #1+ :+,%'+,( ;#+ 6##7 -%#+'- %3'-' 7(>-5 C3'+'?- ( -,#1 (+')?% %+>,)6 %# #1 (+')?% +'(..>

7(%'7Z 'G(

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

5/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 G

I a I

-3#$6,+.@ $3# $,.. A#A #1% ()7 -,)6 3(AA> &,+%37(> $3') %3' +,63% +##;5 L1% ,) %3(% :(-'@ (- 9 -(,7 &';#+'@ %3'+' ,- ( ., :.'(+ ' ,% !"%@ .(+6' ')#163 %# (::# $#+D- &':(1-' %3' D,)6A,) ,-

'GA':%,)6 ( -3#$6,+.5

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

6/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 J

I ` I

J5J

N0.'()O ()7 N';;,:,')%@O (% .'(-% ,) %3,- :#)%'G%@ (+' 2,+%1' %'+ -1:3 %'+ B %3'> +';'+ %# %3' ;(:% %3(% %3' #&=':% 3(- #%3'+ A+#A'+%,'-@ A'+3(A- #1 () 'G(

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

7/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 O

I e I

9) ;(:% 9 %3,)D $' -3#1.7 ;#..#$ *+,-%#%.' ()7 %(D' %3,- %3#163% ( -%'A ;1+%3'+5

9% ,- )#% =1-% %3(% 2,+%1' %'+- %# (-A':%- #; 6##7 ;1):%,#),)65

*+,-%#%.' &'.,'2'7 ,) %3' 1),%> #; %3' 2,+%1'-@ $3,:3 ,) ';;':% #; %3' -,%1(%,#)5 H) %3,- %3'#+>@ $3(% ( 2,+%1' %'+< +';'+- %#@ -%+,:%.>

-A'(D,)6@ ,- %3' (&-'):' #; ( 2,:'5 C# -(> %3(% -# %# A+#A'+%,'- #; %3' $,..@ %3(%

,-@ %# %3' (6')%?- A+,):,A.'-5a 9) ;(:% %3,- 1-' ,- ( -#1+:' #; A3,.#-#A3,:(. :#);1-,#)@ (-

9 $,.. )#$ -3#$5

a9 (< 1-,)6 %3' $#+7 NA+,):,A.'-O ,) ( $(> %3(% +()6'- %3 #2'+ ,)%')%,#)- ()7 /()%,()

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

8/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 P

I _ I

0#)-,7'+ "15 "1 (:%,#)-@ $' +'6(+7 #).> %3'

- -1AA#-'@ %3(% #)' ,) %3(%

-,%1(%,#) -3#1?7 &' ,);.1'):?7 &> %3' A+#A'+ @ %3(% %3' 2,+%1#1-

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

9/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 Q

I T I

A+,):,A.'fL';#+' $' :() 3(2' -1:3 ( +'6(+7@ %3' (:%,#) P5

"5 M,77,%:35 HG;#+7Q 0.(+')7#) P+'--@ 8Te_5 P(+% U@ L##D 8@ P(+% J@ AA5 WeeIWe_5 0,%'7 ,) %3' %'G% (- C

;#..#$'7 &> #D@ A(+%@ ()7 A(6' )1

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

10/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 ST

I 8S I

(- +'(-#)- #; ( 6,2') $',63%g \,.. ,% )#% &' %3' -(@ :#1+(6'@ ()7 %' +':#6),V'

:'+%(,) :#)-,7'+(%,#)- Y-1:3 (- %3' ;(:% #; ( A+# ( -'+,'- #; ,)2#.1)%(+>

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

11/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 SS

I 88 I

7#)' $,%3 ( :'+%(,) A+#G,#1 -()7$,:3O 9 3(2' %# (% .'(-% ,)%')7 %#

%+()-#1+-5

L1% #; :#1+-' #)' :() -%,.. 3(2' 7,;;'+')% #1+ 31)6'+@ -'',)6 %3(% (- $#+%3 7#,)6 ;#+ ,%- #$) -(D'5 H+ 9 6,2'

>#1 ( -()7$,:3 &':(1-' 9 &'.,'2' >#1 $,.. A(> #1 ()7 9 (< 3#A,)6 >#1 $,.. :3#D' #) ,%5 H+@ (- "1 %# 6,2' >#1 (

-()7$,:35 L1% %3,- .(-% :(-'@ (% .'(-% (::#+7,)6 %# /()%,()-@ ,- $3'+' "1#1 ( -()7$,:3 -, %# (..'2,(%' >#1+ 31)6'+5

J5 9 6,2' >#1 ( -()7$,:3 %# 6'% %3'

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

12/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 S9

I 8J I

N&')'2#.'):'O #+ N@ %3'+' ,- (

7,;;'+'):' ,) %3' $(> $' %3,)D (% %3' ,7'( #; ( N -A':,;,'7

,)%')%,#)-5 [# ;#+ ,)-%():' $3') 9 -(> %3(% 9 6,2' >#1 ( -()7$,:3 ,) #+7'+ %# (..'2,(%'

>#1+ 31)6'+@ #+ 3#A,)6 >#1 $,.. A(> ( 7'&%@ #+ &':(1-' 9 $()% %#

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

13/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 SD

I 8U I

2,'$@ #; -A':,;>,)6 N %3' N#1 ( -()7$,:3 -, %# (..'2,(%' >#1+ 31)6'+5 YL')'2#.'):'Z

J5 9 6,2' >#1 ( -()7$,:3 %# 6'% %3' #1 ( -()7$,:3 3#A,)6 >#1 $,.. :3#D' #) ,%5 Y4(.,:'Z

W5 9 6,2' >#1 ( -()7$,:3 &':(1-' 9 %3,)D ,% ,- 71%> %# 7# -#5 YF1%>Z

H) %3,- 2,'$@ -%+,:%.> -A'(D,)6@ A'#A.' 7#)?% (:% ;+"= %3,)6- .,D' &')'2#.'):'@ -'.;I

,)%'+'-%@ #+ O ,- ( .,%%.' 7,;;'+')%@ &':(1-' ,) %3' -:3'#1 ( -()7$,:3 &':(1-' 9

%3,)D ,% ,- 71%> %# 7# -#5 C3(% -166'-%- ( :#)%+(-% &'%$'') -##1+ 31)6'+ ()7 -#5 L1% (::#+7,)6 %# /()%@ %3(% 7#'-)?% :#++':%.>

:(A%1+' $3(% ,- 6#,)6 #) $3') -#5 /()% %3,)D- %3(% %3' 71%> ,)

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

14/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 SE

I 8W I

E1'-%,#) ,- %# N6,2' -# ,- )#% =1-% %# A'+;#+< () (:%@ &1% %# (:% $,%3 ( :'+%(,) ;,)(. ,)%')%,#)5

_

C3(% +'E1,+'- %3(% %3'+' &' ( ;1+%3'+ '.'%# 7# %3(% (:% $,%3 %3(% ,)%')%,#)5

9% .##D- (- ,; %3#-' +'A+'-')% %$# 7,;;'+')% $(>- #; &',)6 #1 ( -()7$,:3 -, ,) #+7'+ %# +'.,'2' >#1+31)6'+ &':(1-' %3(% ,- $3(% 9 $()% %# 7#5 Y(:%,)6 ;+#< )(%1+(. &')'2#.')%,):.,)(%,#)Z

W5 9 (7#A% %3' ;,)(. ,)%')%,#) #; 6,2,)6 >#1 ( -()7$,:3 -, ,) #+7'+ %# +'.,'2' >#1+31)6'+ &':(1-' 9 +':#6),V' %3(% ,% ,- 71%> %# 3(2' -1:3 () ,)%')%,#)5 Y(:%,)6 ;+#Z

_['' -':%,#) #)' #; %3' R+"1)7#"+> "; %3' 4'%(83?-,A- "; 4"+(.-@ ()7 ()(.>-,- #; %3' (+61 j##7 *:%,#)O Y/#+-6((+7@ F3' 0")-%,%1%,") "; *6')A?@ :,%'7

('@ AA5 8eWIJS`@ '-A':,(..> AA5 8e`I8_e5Z ^';'+'):'- %# %3' R+"1)7#"+> $,.. &' ,)-'+%'7 ,)%# %3'

%'G% 1-,)6 j ;#..#$'7 &> %3' A(6' )19 3(2' 1-'7

%3' %+()-.(%,#) &> 4(+> j+'6#+ ,) R+"1)7#"+> "; %3' 4'%(83?-,A- "; 4"+(.- Y0(

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

15/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 SG

I 8a I

*)7 )#$ $' 3(2' (++,2'7 (% %3' A.(:' $3'+' %3' (+61@ %3(% #; 6,2,)6 >#1 ( -()7$,:3 ,) #+7'+ %# +'.,'2' >#1+

31)6'+ B &1% %3(% %3'> (7#A% %3'

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

16/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 SJ

I 8` I

\' 3(2' (.-# (++,2'7 (% ( +'A.> %# "1

:())#% &' %3' N;,+-% 2,+%1#1- %3#163%- (% %3' #%3'+?- )''7@ +(%3'+

%3() %3#163%- (% 71%> YC U5UZ5 C3,+7 A'+-#)(..>@ $' %# $()% 6##7 %3,)6- ;#+ #%3'+

A'#A.'5 NL')'2#.'):'O ,- )#% ( ;#+:' (% $#+D ,) %3' A'+-#)@ &1% ( %3,+7IA'+-#)(.

)( ;1+%3'+ #+ 1.%'+,#+ ,)%')%,#)5 "#$'2'+@ )# 7#1&% %3'+' ,- -# A(:D(6' N&')'2#.'):'O ,; $' .,D'5 L1% %3(% (6(,) ,- 6'-%1+(.5 \3(%

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

17/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 SO

I 8e I

)#% =1-% %(.D (% $3,:3 ;,)(.

,)%')%,#)- $' -3#1.7 3(2'g ]#+ "1'- &',)6

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

18/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 SP

I 8_ I

/()% $3(% %3' :(%'6#+,:(.

, 6'-%1+'- (% ( A'+-#)?- A+,):,A.'-5 C3' , j,&&(+7,-3Z $#+7- 3' 3(- N(::'A%'7 ( :'+%(,) 6+#1A #;

:#)-,7'+(%,#)- (- +'(-#)- ;#+ (:%,#)5O L1% %3') $3> 7#'- -3' $()% %# %(.D (% %3'

2,+%1'-g 9; %# -(> %3(% -#

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

19/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 SQ

I 8T I

$' (:% #) %3''% -3' -(>-@ A1VV.,)6.>Q

f%3' 7'-:+,A%,#) h=1-%?@ (- (AA.,'7 %# ( ,- ( 2,+%1'@ %3,- ,- &':(1-' ,%

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

20/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 9T

I JS I

#; %3' 6')'+(. :3(+(:%'+,-%,:- #; ( -A':,'-@ (- %3#-' $#1.7 &' 7'-:+,&'7 ,) $3(%

4,:3('. C3# (+' )#%

;(.-,;,'7 &> %3' #::(-,#)(. A+# :3(+(:%'+,-%,: #; >#1+ -A':,'-@ (- 7'-:+,&'7 &>

%3'-' :(%'6#+,:(.-@ #+ %# 3(2' %3' A+#A'+%,'- %3(% ')(&.' >#1 %# 7# -#5

4#7'+) :#5 9; %3(% #; 6#,)6 (% %3,)6-@ (- 9 &'.,'2'

*+,-%#%.' 7#'-58S C3' %3+'' D,)7- #; .,;' *+,-%#%.' 7'-:+,&'- ,) 3,- ;(

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

21/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 9S

I J8 I

%3(%

7#'-@ )#% )':'--(+,.> 3#$5 \3(% ,- :3(+(:%'+,-%,: #; 31-5 9) %3' A+(:%,:(. :(-'@ %3(% 3(- ( :'+%(,) A(%%'+) #; :#.#+,)6 B ]##%?- 'G(- )# ;1):%,#)(. +#.' ,) -'.;I

#; ,%- .'(7,)6 ( &.1' %,%?- )#+ (6')% I ()> (),

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

22/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 99

I JJ I

%3' %3(% ( 315OZ C3' 5O YN* ](..(:> ,) *+,-%#%.'?- (+61 %3(%

&':(1-' 31

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

23/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 9D

I JU I

C31- %# (++,2' (% %3' :#):.1-,#) %3(% =1-%,:' ,- ( 2,+%1'@ ]##% 6,2'- 1- %3' ;#..#$,)6

*+,-%#%'.,() :(%'6#+,:(.Q N"1 31 %3(%

')(&.'- >#1 %# .,2' %3(% $(>@ =1-%,:' ,- ( 2,+%1'5 "'+ (::#1)%- #; %3' #%3'+ 2,+%1'-@ -#

;(+ (- 9 :() -''@ $#1.7 )#% %1+) #1% %# &' 2'+> 7,;;'+')% ;+#< %3' D,)7- #;

,)-%+1 A+#A'+%> ;#+ .,2,)6 $'.. %3' 31@ ()7 -# #)58U

(% $(>- ,) $3,:3 %3'> (+' 6##7 ;#+ 1-Z 7,7)?% 6,2' 3'+ A(1-' #2'+ %3' .,)61,-%,: A#,)% -3' ,- %3',+

:#)%')%@ )#% &> %3',+ ;#+ %3',+ :#)%')%5 C3'+' ,- (

6')'+(. A+#&.'< (% %3' ,7'( #; (:%,)6 ;#+ ( +'(-#)@ $3,:3 :#):'+)- %3' E1'-%,#) 3#$ () (6')% :()

:# 1)(%%+(:%,2'5 C# 1-' %3' 'G(#1+ 31)6'+ ;#+ ,%- #$) -(D'O (- %3' (6')%?- ;,)(. ,)%')%,#)5 9

3(2' (.+'(7> 'GA.(,)'7@ ,) %3' %'G%@ $3(% ,- $+#)6 $,%3 %3(%5 L1% ,%?- (- ,; %3'> %3#163% >#1 :#1.7 (-DQ

N.##D@ ,- 3' 7#,)6 ,% ,) #+7'+ %# +'.,'2' >#1+ 31)6'+@ #+ =1-% &':(1-' 3' %3,)D- ,%- 3,- 71%>gO 9) %3' -(

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

24/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 9E

I JW I

J5e

*- 9 1)7'+-%()7 *+,-%#%.'@ &> :#)%+(-%@ $' :())#% '-%(&.,-3 %3(% ()> A+#A'+%>

,- ( ="+(. 2,+%1' $,%3#1% '-%(&.,-3,)6 %3(% >#1 :())#% +'(-") #'.. $,%3#1% %3,-

A+#A'+%>5 9) *+,-%#%.'?- %3'#+>@ %3,- )':'--(+> ;#+ #1+

:#6),%,2' 6+(-A #; %3' 6##7 B ;#+ A+(:%,:(. $,-7#< B 6,2') %3(% #1+ %3#163%- (%

%3' 6##7 (+' 7'%'+ %# A+(:%,:(. $,-7#< &':(1-' #1+ (&,.,%> %#

-'' $3,:3 +,-D- (+' $#+%3 %(D,)6 ,- -1&=':% %# 7,-%#+%,#) &> %3' ( %3#-' (AA'%,%'- %3'-@ &1%

%3'> 7# )#% 3(2' ="+(.2,+%1'- ()7 2,:'-@ -,):' %3#-' A'+%(,) #).> %# :+'(%1+'- %3(%

>#1 :())#% -3#$ 3#$ %3(% ,- 7#)'@ %3') >#1+ +'(-#)- (+' +'(..> =1-% 7'-,+'- $'(+,)6 %1G'7#-5 9)

N*:%,)6 ;#+ ( ^'(-#)O Y,) F3' 0")-%,%1%,") "; *6')A?Z@ 9 (+61' %3(% /()%?- (::#1)% #; (7#A%,)6 ( 2,(&.' -#.1%,#) %# %3,- A+#&.' 9

%3,)D %3' )#%,#) #; ;#+< ,- '--')%,(. %# 1)7'+-%()7,)6 $3> %3' +'(-#)- $' (+' %(.D,)6 (% (+'

+'(-#)- ;#+ (A%,")5 ]#+ ( -,-,- #; %3' A+#&.'< Y(.%3#163 )#% #)' %3(% ')7#+-'- -#.1%,#)Z@

-'' F#16.(- i(2,)@ NP+#&.'

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

25/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 9G

I Ja I

3(2' ( +(%,#)(. A(+% #; %3' -#1. $3,:3 ,- %3 ,);.1'):'7 &> ()7 ,);.1'):'- %3' )#)I

+(%,#)(. A(+%5

"#$'2'+@ %3'+' (+' %$# 7,;;'+')% $(>- #; 1)7'+-%()7,)6 %3' A#,)%- 9 3(2' =1-%

:()

3(AA,.> %(D' *+,-%#%.'?- (::#1)% #; %3' 2,+%1'- #) (+7@ &1% -3#1.75 C3' #1 %# A+(:%,:' &')';,:'):' $3') >#1 -3#1.7 ,; %3' ;(:% %3(% -##15 *)7 )# 7#1&% >#1 $,.. &' .,(&.' %# (%%(:D- #;

-'.;I7':'A%,#) ,; 3'.A,)6 (.$(>- A+'-')%- ,%-'.; %# >#1 (- ( 7,-(6+''(&.' :3#+'5 *-

/()% 3, ()7 ;#+ %3' [(D' #; %3' M#&.'Q /()% ()7 *+,-%#%.' #) 4#+(..> j##7

*:%,#)O ,) %3' 9)%+#71:%,#) %# F3' 0")-%,%1%,") "; *6')A?@ AA5 8aIJS5

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

26/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 9J

I J` I

-1:3 -'+2,:' ,- )#% .#2'7 &> 3, %3(% -#,)6 %3(% 3'+ A(--,#)- ()7 ' %3(% ,- :#)71:,2' %# %3' 6##7 ;1):%,#),)6

#; 3'+ $,..5 H+ B %# +'%1+) %# '(+.,'+ A#,)% (% %3' 1),%> #; %3' 2,+%1'- B ,% ,- %#

(--'+% %3(% -3' 7#'- )#% 3(2' -#

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

27/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 9O

I Je I

C# A'+:',2'@ %3') ,- .,D' &(+' (--'+%,)6 #+ %3,)D,)6b &1% $3') %3' #&=':%

,- A.'(-()% #+ A(,);1.@ %3' -#1. #; (AA'%,%' ()7

(2#,7():' (+' )#% 7,;;'+')%@ ',%3'+ ;+#< #)' ()#%3'+ #+ ;+#< %3'

;(:1.%> #; -')-'IA'+:'A%,#)b &1% %3',+ &',)6 ,- 7,;;'+')%5

C# %3' %3,)D,)6 -#1. , $'+' :#)%')%- #;

A'+:'A%,#) Y()7 $3') ,% (--'+%- #+ 7'),'- %3'< %# &' 6##7 #+ &(7 ,%

(2#,7- #+ A1+-1'- %3' %3' -#1. )'2'+ %3,)D- $,%3#1% ()

,

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

28/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 9P

I J_ I

J5_

L1%@ -# ;(+ (- %3(% 6#'-@ -# (+' 3'+ 2,:'-5 C# ( )#+ 2,:' (+' )#%

;1..> (:%,#)-@ )#% ;1..> %3' (6')%?- #$)5 C3'+' ,- :'+%(,).>

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

29/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 9Q

I JT I

%3' $#+.7 $3,:3 ,- %3') (% $#+D ,) 3'+ :3#,:'- ()7 -'+2'- (- %3' ( /()%,() (::#1)%Q ,% :() #).> &' :(A%1+'7 ,; (:%,#) ,- 6#2'+)'7 &>

A+,):,A.'- %3(% )#% #).> :#);#+5

9) NC3' M#+ 4()1'. X(+6(- ()7

j,7'#) K(;;'5 YHG;#+7Q HG;#+7 R),2'+-,%> P+'--@ JS8WZ5 9) %3,- A(+% #; %3' A(A'+ 9 7+($ 3'(2,.> #) %3'

A(+(..'. 7,-:1--,#) ,) %3(% A(A'+5

8_C3,- ;#+

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

30/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 DT

I US I

J5 * A'+-#) (:%- $3') 3'+ 7(> .,;'5

C3' ;,+-% (-A':% ,- %3(% %3' (6')%?- (:%,2,%> #+ ';;,A(A? ,- -1AA#-'7 %# &'

, #+ () ,)2#.1)%(+> ,)

-# ,- %3' (6')%?- #$) ';;,:(:>@ $' @ )#% =1-% %3(% #; -# %# &'@ &>

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

31/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 DS

I U8 I

;(,.5 *6'):> :())#% =1-% &' ( A(+%,:1.(+ ;#+< #; :(1-(.,%>@ &':(1-' :(1-'-@ =1-% (- -1:3@

:())#% -1::''7 #+ ;(,.5 9% ,- )#% ,5 C3' +'(-#) ,-

;( ,%-#A'+(%,#) -3#1.7

'-A':,(..> +'A+'-')% %3' (6')%?- #$) -A#)%()'#1- ';;,:(:>@ ()> %3(% -#

%3' ,7'( #; )(%1+(. (6'):>5 \' :() :'+%(,).> (-D $3> 'G(:%.> :(1-(%,#) &> ( :'+%(,)

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

32/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 D9

I UJ I

';;,:(:,#1- B %3(% ,-@

,) #.7'+ %'+@ ;+'' B ()7 #1+ (:%,#)- (+' -1AA#-'7 %# +';.':% -# (+' ,)%'+7'A')7')%@ ,) ( .##-' $(> %3'> -''< %# .,)' 1A $,%3

%3' ;,+-% A'+-#) A'+-A':%,2' #) %3' #)' ()7 %3' -':#)7 #+ %3,+7 A'+-#) A'+-A':%,2'

#) %3' #%3'+5 9% ,- (' (.. $3') $' #1+-'.2'- (:% %3(% ,% -''5 9% ,- #&2,#1-.>

$+#)6 %# 3#.7 )#)I31A,)6 %3(% $#1.7 &' ,)2#.2'7 ,) #%3'+@ ()7 3' -(,7 >'-5 ]#+ ;1+%3'+ 7,-:1--,#) -''

NC3' M#+

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

33/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 DD

I UU I

(-D #1+-'.2'- $3(% %3#-' (:%,#)- -(> (% %3',+ ,7')%,%,'-@ (% $3(% -#+% #;

A'#A.' %3'> (+'5 K'% %3'-' (+' (-A':%- #; ( -,)6.' ,7'(@ )#% %$# ,7'(-5 C3' :#):'A%

#; +'-8")-,&,.,%?,- %3' .,):3A,) %3(% 1),%'- %3' %3(% :#):'A% $' )''7 %3

%3' ,7'( %3(% %3' (6')% ,- -A#)%()'#1-.> ';;,:(:,#1- ()7 %3(% 3,- (:%,#) +';.':%-

-#5

9) #)' $(>@ %3'-' %$# (-A':%- #; (6'):> -''< :.#-'.> +'.(%'7 %# '(:3 #%3'+Q

%3 +';.':% $(>- ,) $3,:3 %3' ,7'( #; () (:%,#) ,- -1AA#-'7 %# &' %3' ,7'( #; (

-,:(. -%#+> (% %3' ;+''7#@ ,; >#1+

)#+

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

35/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 DG

I Ua I

:3(+(:%'+-@ ()7 %3'+';#+' ;#+ %3' $(> %3,)6- (AA'(+ %# 1-5 * A'+-#) $3# ,- 7+1)D

7#'-)?% D)#$ $3(% 3' ,- 7#,)6@ &1% $' 3#.7 3,< +'-A#)-,&.' ()>$(>@ &':(1-' 3' 6#%

3, &> %3' -%(%' #; %3',+ :3(+(:%'+-@ &1% $' 3#.7 %3'< +'-A#)-,&.' ()>$(>@

&':(1-' %3'> 6#% %3' (+' %3' %3',+ -.(:D .,2'- +'-A#)-,&.' ;#+ &':# :3'(% #+ -A')7 %3',+ %, 3(2' %# D)#$ %3(% %3' -%(%'- #; 3,-

:3(+(:%'+ (+' A+#71:'7 &> 3,- (:%,#)-@ &1% (.-# %3(% %3' -%(%'- 3' $(- A+#71:,)6

$'+' %3' $+#)6 #)'-5 L1% (- *+,-%#%.' #;%') Y&1% )#% (.$(>-Z '

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

36/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 DJ

I U` I

Y1).,D' (>+(-,(Z N,- 1):#)-:,#1- #; ,%-'.;O YMc e5_ 88aS&UaIU`Z5 C3' 2,:,#1- A'+-#)

%3,)D- %3(% 3' ,- 7#,)6 $3(% 3' #163% %# 7# YMc e5T 88aJ(WB`b -'' (.-# Mc e5_ 88a8(88B

8U@ Mc e5_ 88a8(`BeZ5

U5U

*+,-%#%.'?- ;(,.1+' %# 6,2' () (7'E1(%' (::#1)% #; +'-A#)-,&,.,%> ;#+ :3(+(:%'+ ,-

A+, ( ;(,.1+' %# 'GA.(,) %3' :#))':%,#) &'%$'') (6'):> ()7 $3(% 9 3(2' &'')

:(..,)6 -A#)%()'#1- ';;,:(:>5 \3(% 3' )''7- %# -3#$ ,- %3(% $' #1+-'.2'- (+'

-# #1+ :3(+(:%'+- ,- %3' 7#'- $'.. (% 'GA.(,),)6

%3' ,7')%,%> (-A':% #; (6'):>5 L';#+' 9 ,

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

37/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 DO

I Ue I

9) :(-' -# A.(>- ()

, ,) *+,-%#%.'?- (::#1)% #;

$3(% #; %3,-

A'+:'A%,#) ,- A+#71:'7 $3') %3'> .,2' %#6'%3'+@ -# %3(% ,% ,- )(%1+(.

%3(% %3'> (,< (% %3,-5 YMc T58J 88e8& UJI88e8&8Z

*)7 %3' :#)-:,#1-)'-- #; >#1+ #$) 'G,-%'):' ,- (' (.. %3' :#):'A% #; >#1+

(:%,#)-Q

9; Y8Z 3(AA,)'-- .,'- ,) .,2,)6 ()7 &',)6 (:%,2'@ ()7 %3' 6##7 ,- 2,+%1#1- ()7 A.'(-()% ,) ,%-'.;@ (- $' 3(2' -(,7 (% %3' #1%-'%@

()7 YJZ ( %3,)6?- &',)6 #)'?- #$) ,- #)' #; %3' (%%+,&1%'- %3(%

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

38/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 DP

I U_ I

(:%,#)- #; ( 6##7 #1+ #$) ';;,:(:>Q

f'2'+> ,% ,; ,% :( 3(2' () 'G:'--,2' .#2' ;#+ %3',+ #$) A#' $'+' :3,.7+')5 C3,- ,- $3(% %3' A#-,%,#) #; &')';(:%#+- ,- .,D'b

;#+ %3(% $3,:3 %3'> 3(2' %+'(%'7 $'.. ,- %3',+ 3()7,$#+D@ ()7 %3'+';#+'

%3'> .#2' %3,- Y,5'5 &> .,2,)6 ()7 (:%,)6Z@ ()7 %3(% %3'

3()7,$#+D ,- ,) ( -')-'@ %3' A+#71:'+ ,) (:%,2,%>b 3' .#2'- 3,-

3()7,$#+D@ %3'+';#+'@ &':(1-' 3' .#2'- 'G,-%'):'5 *)7 %3,- ,- +##%'7 ,)

%3' )(%1+' #; %3,)6-@ ;#+ $3(% 3' ,- ,) A#%')%,(.,%>@ 3,- 3()7,$#+D

3(2' &')';,%%'7 &':(1-' %3'> -'' %3',+ #$)

';;,:(:> '

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

39/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 DQ

I UT I

U5W

"#$ 7#'- %3' ,7'( #; -'.;I:#)-%,%1%,#) 'GA.(,) %3' %$# (-A':%- #; (6'):>g 9%

A1%- %3' ,7'( %3(% >#1 :#)-%,%1%' >#1+ ';;,:(:> ()7 ,7')%,%> &> %3' $(> %3(% >#1 (:% ,)

A.(:' #; %3' ,7'( %3(% () (:%,#) ,- 'GA+'--,2' #; >#1+ #$) -A#)%()'#1- ';;,:(:> ()7

,7')%,%> ,; ,% (+,-'- ;+#< ( :'+%(,) D,)7 #; 5 /()% (+61'- %3(% %# &' ;+'' B

-A#)%()'#1-.> B $' $#1.7 3(2' %# &' (1%#)# %3' A")%')%#; %3'-' %$# /()%,() )#+#1 3(2' %# :#):',2' #;

>#1+-'.; (- () (6')%5 C3(%?- ( :#):'A%,#) #; >#1+-'.; %3(% ,)'2,%(&.> &'.#)6- %# %3'

7'.,&'+(%,2' -%()7A#,)%5 [,):' >#1 3(2' %# :#):',2' #; >#1+-'.; (- () (6')%@ >#1 3(2'

%# :#):',2' >#1+-'.; (- 1)7'+ %3' :(%'6#+,:(. ()7 3>A#%3'%,:(. ,5 M#$ -1AA#-' B #; :#1+-' %3,- ,- :#)%+#2'+-,(. B &1%

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

40/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 ET

I WS I

-1AA#-' %3(% $' :#1.7 $#+D #1% 'G(:%.> #3(% ( -A#)%()'#1-.> ';;,:(:,#1- &',)6

$#1.7 7#5 C3(% ,-@ -1AA#-' $' :#1.7 $#+D #1% #3,A3.($- -1:3 ( &',)6 $#1.7 ;#..#$@

(- /()% -1AA#-'- $' :()5 C3(% ,- %3' 2,'$ %3(% (AA.>,)6 %3' :(%'6#+,:(. ,,'.7- 7'%'+ &1% A+':,-'.> &':(1-' >#1+ :#):'A%,#) #; >#1+-'.; (-

() (6')%Z1-% ,-( :#):'A%,#) #; >#1+-'.; (- )7 &> %3#-' .($-5 C3') >#1 $#1.7 &'

-A#)%()'#1-.> ';;,:(:,#1-5 C# A1% ,% +(%3'+ &.1)%.>@ ,; >#1 :() &' #1 (+' () (6')% ()7 -# )7 &> %3' .($- #; (6'):> %# (:% ,) 'G(:%.>

%3' $(> ( -A#)%()'#1-.> ';;,:(:,#1- &',)6 $#1.7@ %3') >#1 (+' -A#)%()'#1-.>

';;,:(:,#1-5 M# 7#1&% %3'+' ,- -# (% 3#$ $' :(#1 %(>':#)%+#. #2'+ >#1+ #$) (-A':% #; (6'):>5 C3' :(%'6#+,:(. ()7 3>A#%3'%,:(.

, 6,2' #1+ (:%,#)- %3' ;"+=#;

-A#)%()'#1- ';;,:(:>@ $3,:3 ,- %3' ;#+< #; (6'):>5 L1% %3' A+,):,A.'- ,) (::#+7():'

JJ C3' :#):'A%,#) #; (6'):> %3(% 9 (< 7'-:+,&,)6 3'+' 7#'- )#% -1AA#+% (- N7''AO ( :#):'A%,#) #;

() #

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

41/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 ES

I W8 I

$,%3 $3,:3 $' (:%1(..> :3##-' B #1+ #) A+,):,A.'- 7'+,2'7 ;+#< %3#-' +#.'-5

\,%3 %3,- ,7'( ,) A.(:'@ *+,-%#%.' %1+)- #1% %# &' +,63% (;%'+ (..Q $'

';;,:(:,#1-@ ,; 9 A1% ,% %3(% $(>@ (+' %3' A#--'--#+- #; %3#-' 2'+> A+(:%,:(.

,7')%,%,'-@ #+ ,; >#1 A+';'+ %3' *+,-%#%'.,() -%#+>@ #; %3#-' :3(+(:%'+-5 C3(% ,- $3> #1+

(:%,#)- (+' %3' (AA+#A+,(%' 6+#1)7- #; %3' D,)7- #; )#+5

[# %3' ,7'( ,- %3(% &> :3##-,)6 #1+ (:%,#)- ,) (::#+7():' $,%3 :'+%(,) )#+#1

&+,)6 ,)%# 'G,-%'):' %3+#163 >#1+ #$) -A#)%()'#1- (:%,2,%>5

9; %3'-' (+61#1+

-A#)%()'#1- ';;,:(:> ()7 (% %3' -(

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

42/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 E9

I WJ I

&> %3' ,7'( #; -'.;I:#)-%,%1%,#)5 \' ;#..#$,)6 )#+@ ()7 $' - (% 2,+%1'5

*::#+7,)6 %# %3' ;,+-%@ %3' 2,+%1'- (+' ;'(%1+'- #; #)'?- A(--,2' #+ +':'A%,2' :(A(:,%,'-

%3(% -'+2' (- (,7- %# %3' $,..5 C3,-@ 9 -(,7 ( /()%,() %3(% (

/()%,() :#1.7 (.-# %(D' #) (+7 -# #; )#+

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

43/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 ED

I WU I

&':# %3' A#--,&,.,%> #; (+%,:1.(%,)6 ,)6 %3'< #):' $'?2' 1-'7 %3' :(%'6#+,:(. ,,)6 %3'< (+' %3 )''7'7@ $' @ ;#+

A+(:%,:(. +'(-#)5 9) ;(:% A+'-1 %3' %3' (:%,#) ,- +,63%5 *;%'+ (..@ %3' 7,;;'+'):' &'%$'')

)(%1+(. 2,+%1' ()7 ;1..> M#+

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

44/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 EE

I WW I

()7 A+(:%,:(. $,-7#< ,- +,63% +'(-#) (% -1:3 () (:% #; )"1-@ ,) ( $(> %3(% A(+(..'.- #1+

(&,.,%> %# 'G%+(:% %3' ;#+

8/12/2019 How How to be an Aristotelian Kantian Constitutivist

45/45

!"# %" &' () *+,-%"%'.,() /()%,() 0")-%,%1%,2,-%

03+,-%,)' 45 /"+-6((+7

85 EG

A+(:%,:' ()7 3(&,%1(%,#) 7#@ #+ ()>$(> :()@ .'(7 %# 6##7 =176 %3(% :# #; A+,):,A.' $,%3 () *+,-%#%'.,()

(::#1)% #; =176 A+#2'7 A#--,&.'@ %3'