7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

1/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 1

G.R. No. 168852 September 30, 2008

SHARICA MARI L. GO-TAN,Petitioner,

vs.

SPOS!S P!R"!CTO C. TAN #$% &ANITA L. TAN, Respondents.*

D E C I S I O N

ASTRIA-MARTIN!',J.:

Before the Court is a Petition for Review on Certiorariunder Rule 4 of the Rules

of Court assailin! the Resolution"dated #ar$h %, &'' of the Re!ional (rial Court

)R(C, Bran$h +4, ue-on Cit in Civil Case No. /'/401 and the R(C

Resolution&dated 2ul "", &'' whi$h denied petitioner3s erified #otion for

Re$onsideration.

(he fa$tual 5a$6!round of the $ase7

On 8pril "9, "+++, Shari$a #ari :. ;o/(an )petitioner and Steven :. (an )Steven

were

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

2/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 2

relationship that alle!ations on the $onspira$ of respondents reuire a fa$tual

deter

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

3/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 3

SEC. .Acts of Violence Against omen and !"eir C"ildren. / (he $ri )E

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

4/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 4

G.R. No. 182835 Apr)+ 20, 2010

RSTAN ANG PASCA,Petitioner,

vs.

TH! HONORAL! CORT O" APP!ALS #$% IRISH SAG,Respondents.

D E C I S I O N

AA,J.:

(his $ase $on$erns a $lai< of $ot

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

5/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 5

?&adali lang i'alat yun my c"atrum ang tarlac rayt pede ring send sa la"at ng

c"atter.?4

Irish sou!ht the help of the vi$e

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

6/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 6

&. @hether or not a sin!le a$t of harass

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

7/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 7

offender ual relationship fro< a datin! relationship. Indeed,

Se$tion 0)e a5ove defines ?datin! relationship? while Se$tion 0)f defines

?se>ual relations.? (he latter ?refers to a sin!le se>ual a$t whi$h

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

8/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 8

have to present the $onfis$ated $ellphone and SI# $ards to prove that Rustan

sent those

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

9/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 9

support0fro< alle$era for their supposed $hild. She 5ased her praer on the

latterMs Certifi$ate of :ive Birth whi$h listed alle$era as the $hildMs father. (he

petition also as6ed the R(C to order Philippine 8irlines, alle$eraMs e

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

10/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 10

G.R. No. 190609 M#r/ 6, 2002

R. RICO S. &ACTIN, petitioner,

vs.

P!OPL! O" TH! PHILIPPIN!S, respondent.

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

11/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 11

ITG,J.7

In an a$$usator Infor

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

12/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 12

8 wee6 later, 2uliet told her sister a5out the in$ident. On "1 De$eual favor is

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

13/58

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

14/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 14

(he Sandi!an5aan ri!htl ree$ted the defense of alibiproffered 5 petitioner,

i.e., that he was at a

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

15/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 15

G.R. No. 135:81 $#r 15, 2009

P!OPL! O" TH! PHILIPPIN!S,appellee,vs.MARIIC G!NOSA,appellant.

D E C I S I O N

PANGANIAN,J.;

8d

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

16/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 16

Revised Penal Code as restored 5 Se$. , R8 No. %1+, and after findin!trea$her as a !eneri$ a!!ravatin! $ir$u

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

17/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 17

fro

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

18/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 18

in$ident in #a &&, "++4, earl and his father apparentlrushed to Ben3s aid a!ain and saw 5lood fro< Ben3s forehead and #arivi$holdin! an e

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

19/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 19

a$$ordin! to her a 6nife was stri$6en to her.3 #r. Sara5ia also said thaton$e he saw Ben had 5een inured too. e said he voluntaril testifiedonl that

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

20/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 20

?"'. Dra. Refelina H. Cerillo, a phsi$ian, was the #uni$ipal ealth Offi$erof Isa5el, :ete at the tihuaa

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

21/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 21

Colle!e. She has an 8B in Ps$holo! fro< the Fniversit of thePhilippines, a #aster of 8rts in Clini$al JCounselin!K, Ps$holo! fro< the8teneo, and a PhD fro< the F.P. She was the past president of thePs$holo!i$al 8sso$iation of the Philippines and is a

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

22/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 22

!overn > > > > > >

?8 wo > > >

?Dr. Paarillo testified that he > > > > > > > >

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

23/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 23

?On $ross/e>a > >

?&'. No re5uttal eviden$e or testi

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

24/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 24

T/e Cort>* R+)$

(he appeal is partl assi!ned ite

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

25/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 25

error as to the trial $ourt3s appre$iation of these $ir$u

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

26/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 26

(he illusion of a5solute interdependen$ is well/entren$hed in a 5atteredwo

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

27/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 27

8 Not ne$essaril that he would 5eat

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

28/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 28

8 It was on Nove

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

29/58

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

30/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 30

8 Hes, 9

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

31/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 31

Hou s$rea

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

32/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 32

8 Hes, sir.

Hou said that he dropped the 5lade, for the re$ord will ou pleasedes$ri5e this 5lade a5out 0 in$hes lon!, how does it loo6 li6e

8 (hree )0 in$hes lon! and "A& in$h wide.

Is it a fle>i5le 5lade

8 It3s a $utter.

ow do ou des$ri5e the 5lade, is it sharp 5oth ed!es

8 Hes, 5e$ause he on$e used it to

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

33/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 33

Did she infor< ou in what hotel in Or

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

34/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 34

(o understand the sndro

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

35/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 35

Did she ever feel that she provo6ed the violent in$idents 5etween her and herspouse Did she 5elieve that she was the onl hope for Ben to refor

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

36/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 36

ro< several ps$holo!i$al tests she had adplained that the effe$tof ?repetitious pain ta6in!, repetitious 5atterin!, JandK repetitious

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

37/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 37

In addition, we also find in favor of appellant the e>tenuatin! $ir$u

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

38/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 38

8 Hes, sir.

@hat is there in the drawer

8 I was aware that it was a !un.

COFR( IN(ERPRE(ER

)8t this un$ture the witness started $rin!

8((H. (8BFC8NON7

@ere ou a$tuall 5rou!ht to the drawer

8 Hes, sir.

@hat happened when ou were 5rou!ht to that drawer

8 e dra!!ed

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

39/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 39

8 Considerin! all the phsi$al sufferin!s that I3ve 5een throu!h with hi

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

40/58

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

41/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 41

private respondent adopted 2essie 8nthone 2. ;ar$ia, 1 ears old and 2osephEduard 2. ;ar$ia, 0 ears old.9

Private respondent des$ri5ed herself as a dutiful and faithful wife, whose liferevolved around her hus5and. On the other hand, petitioner, who is of ilipino/Chinese des$ent, is do

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

42/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 42

8fter the Respondent leaves or is re

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

43/58

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

44/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 44

2esus Chua ;ar$ia onl and those in whi$h the $onu!al partnership of!ains of the Petitioner Rosalie 2. ;ar$ia and respondent have an interestin, espe$iall the $onu!al ho

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

45/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 45

.

(E COFR( O 8PPE8:S SERIOFS:H ERRED IN NO( DEC:8RIN; R.8. No. +&1&8S IN8:ID 8ND FNCONS(I(F(ION8: BEC8FSE I( 8::O@S 8N FNDFEDE:E;8(ION O 2FDICI8: PO@ER (O (E B8R8N;8H OICI8:S.09

(he Rulin! of the Court

Before delvin! into the ar!u

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

46/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 46

@e $annot su5s$ri5e to the theor espoused 5 petitioner that, sin$e a$ounter$lai

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

47/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 47

ar5iter of $onstitutional issues, and with

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

48/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 48

instan$e,

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

49/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 49

(he President Pro (e

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

50/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 50

naturall inferior 5oth phsi$all and intelle$tuall. In an$ient @estern so$ieties,wo

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

51/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 51

has ratified the CED8@ as well as the Convention on the Ri!hts of the Child andits two proto$ols. (o $ap it all, Con!ress, on #ar$h 9, &''4, ena$ted Rep. 8$t No.+&1&, entitled ?8n 8$t Definin! iolen$e 8!ainst @o

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

52/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 52

HR | FEB 23 2016 53

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

53/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 53

$ts of as$iviousnes

9' 01 09& 09 44 49 %4

hsi$alnuries

0,0

&,00

",9+&

",'

",0'%

",4+9

&,'"9

e>ualarassation

+' ' + + 90 %'0 "90

otal1,&%"

,0%4

4,99"

,%&+

1,+'

+,49

","'4

*&'"" report $overs onl fro< 2anuar to 8u!ust

Sour$e7 Philippine National Poli$e L @o

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

54/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 54

Our own Senator :oi Estrada la

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

55/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 55

pu5li$ations and inde$ent shows or for$in! the wo

7/24/2019 HR FEB 23

56/58

HR | FEB 23, 2016 56

?(he s$ope of reliefs in prote$tion orders is 5roadened to ensure that the vi$ti