Hubble’s Constant, the Hubble’s Constant, the Oosterhoff Dichotomy and Oosterhoff Dichotomy and
Hydrogen Ionization Fronts. Hydrogen Ionization Fronts.
Shashi M. KanburShashi M. Kanbur
University of Florida,University of Florida,
September 2009September 2009
AcknowledgmentsAcknowledgments Chow Choong Ngeow, Douglas Leonard, Lucas Chow Choong Ngeow, Douglas Leonard, Lucas
Macri, Robert Szabo, Robert Buchler, Marcella Macri, Robert Szabo, Robert Buchler, Marcella Marconi.Marconi.
SUNY Oswego undergrads: Dylan Wallace, Dan SUNY Oswego undergrads: Dylan Wallace, Dan Crain, Greg Feiden, Richard Stevens, Robin Crain, Greg Feiden, Richard Stevens, Robin Dienhoffer, Frank Ripple, Sean Scott, Earl Dienhoffer, Frank Ripple, Sean Scott, Earl Bellinger, Lillie Ghobrial, Mike Evans, Martin Bellinger, Lillie Ghobrial, Mike Evans, Martin Berke.Berke.
Isaac Richter, Tim De Haas, Andy Missert, Isaac Richter, Tim De Haas, Andy Missert, Matthew Turner, Alex James, Eamonn Moyer, Matthew Turner, Alex James, Eamonn Moyer, Jillian Neeley.Jillian Neeley.
NSF, AAS, HST.NSF, AAS, HST.
The Cepheid PL RelationThe Cepheid PL Relation
This relation is not linear – at least in the LMC: This relation is not linear – at least in the LMC: change of slope between short (log P < 1) and change of slope between short (log P < 1) and long (log P > 1) period Cepheids.long (log P > 1) period Cepheids.
OGLE II/III data using OGLE determined OGLE II/III data using OGLE determined reddenings and the Zaritsky reddening map.reddenings and the Zaritsky reddening map.
Need detailed statistical tests for this.Need detailed statistical tests for this. It is NOT sufficient just to look at the slopes plus It is NOT sufficient just to look at the slopes plus
or minus some standard deviationsor minus some standard deviations..
Statistical Tests ImportantStatistical Tests Important
Slope is Slope is ββ±±σσ. This means. This means
P(slopeP(slope is in [is in [ββ--σσ,,ββ++σσ]) = 1 ]) = 1 –– αα..
A = [short period slope is wrong], P(A) = A = [short period slope is wrong], P(A) = αα..
B = [long period slope is wrong], P(B) = B = [long period slope is wrong], P(B) = αα..
P(atP(at least one mistake) = P(AUB) = 2least one mistake) = P(AUB) = 2αα--αα22..
1>1>αα>0, 2>0, 2αα--αα22 >>αα..
P(simultaneousP(simultaneous test makes a mistake) is smaller test makes a mistake) is smaller than than P(standardP(standard comparison makes a mistake).comparison makes a mistake).
Multiphase PL/PC relationsMultiphase PL/PC relations
http://www.oswego.edu/~kanbur/IRES200http://www.oswego.edu/~kanbur/IRES2009/Vphase.mov9/Vphase.mov
http://www.oswego.edu/~kanbur/IRES200http://www.oswego.edu/~kanbur/IRES2009/Iphase.mov9/Iphase.mov
http://www.oswego.edu/~kanbur/IRES200http://www.oswego.edu/~kanbur/IRES2009/Cphase.mov9/Cphase.mov
http://www.oswego.edu/~kanbur/IRES200http://www.oswego.edu/~kanbur/IRES2009/Wphase.mov9/Wphase.mov
LMC testsLMC tests
F test.F test. Schwarz Information Criterion.Schwarz Information Criterion. Testimator plus others.Testimator plus others. OGLE II/OGLE III plus long period Cepheids.OGLE II/OGLE III plus long period Cepheids. MACHO, Sebo et al, Perrson et al.MACHO, Sebo et al, Perrson et al. OGLE II reddenings plus Zaritsky reddenings.OGLE II reddenings plus Zaritsky reddenings. BVIJH non-linear.BVIJH non-linear. K marginally nonlinear. OGLE II Wessenheit linear, K marginally nonlinear. OGLE II Wessenheit linear,
OGLE III Wessenheit marginally nonlinear.OGLE III Wessenheit marginally nonlinear. PL/PC cancel each other out – that is the Wessenheit is PL/PC cancel each other out – that is the Wessenheit is
linear.linear.
JHK DataJHK Data
3 years observing campaign using 1.5m 3 years observing campaign using 1.5m NOAO telescope plus CPAPIR and OGLE NOAO telescope plus CPAPIR and OGLE LMC pointings.LMC pointings.
2 years of Sloan filter data again using 2 years of Sloan filter data again using LMC OGLE pointings.LMC OGLE pointings.
Analyzing this data currently.Analyzing this data currently.
M33 DIRECT dataM33 DIRECT data
Cosmological motivationCosmological motivation
KP measured HKP measured H00 to an accuracy of 10%.to an accuracy of 10%. RiessRiess et al (2009) have measured Het al (2009) have measured H00 to an accuracy of to an accuracy of
less than 5%.less than 5%. Strong prospects exist for further reducing this error rate Strong prospects exist for further reducing this error rate
to remove to remove degeneraciesdegeneracies in CMB based parameter in CMB based parameter estimates.estimates.
Need to get better calibrating relations (LMC or NGC Need to get better calibrating relations (LMC or NGC 4285)4285)
Calibrate Calibrate SNIaSNIa Hubble diagram. OGLE II results in a 1Hubble diagram. OGLE II results in a 1--2% change in H2% change in H00 depending on whether a depending on whether a linear/nonlinear PL relation is used.linear/nonlinear PL relation is used.
With OGLE III, a 5% change.With OGLE III, a 5% change.
Impact on H0Impact on H0
Calibrate SNIa diagram with Cepheids.Calibrate SNIa diagram with Cepheids. μμ00 = = μμVV – 2.45( – 2.45(μμVV – – μμII).). W = V – 2.45(V-I).W = V – 2.45(V-I). There is a difference when used with There is a difference when used with
OGLE III with these data.OGLE III with these data. W is less sensitive to possible changes of W is less sensitive to possible changes of
slope in V and I.slope in V and I. http://www.oswego.edu/~kanbur/IRES200http://www.oswego.edu/~kanbur/IRES200
9/H0impact.pdf9/H0impact.pdf
Mid-InfraRed PL relationsMid-InfraRed PL relations
PhysicsPhysics PL/PC relation connected through the PLC relation.PL/PC relation connected through the PLC relation. PC relation affected through the interaction of the stellar PC relation affected through the interaction of the stellar
photosphere and hydrogen ionization front (HIF).photosphere and hydrogen ionization front (HIF). Engaged: Color of star which is related to the Engaged: Color of star which is related to the
Temperature of photosphere = temperature of HIF.Temperature of photosphere = temperature of HIF. Engaged at low densities: Color of Star is related to Engaged at low densities: Color of Star is related to
temperature of photosphere which is less dependent on temperature of photosphere which is less dependent on period.period.
Engaged at high densities: more sensitive to period.Engaged at high densities: more sensitive to period. Sudden: - either engaged or not.Sudden: - either engaged or not. ML relation affects phase/period of interaction.ML relation affects phase/period of interaction. Flat PC relation at maximum light for Galactic Cepheids, Flat PC relation at maximum light for Galactic Cepheids,
and for logP > 1 for LMC Cepheids.and for logP > 1 for LMC Cepheids.
PC/AC RelationsPC/AC Relations
LLmax max ~ R~ R22maxmax T T44
maxmax, L, Lminmin ~ R ~ R22minmin T T44
minmin
Amplitude ~ 4log(TAmplitude ~ 4log(Tmaxmax – T – Tminmin).).
PC relation flat at maximum light – AC PC relation flat at maximum light – AC relation at minimum light and vice versa.relation at minimum light and vice versa.
See this in LMC OGLE II/III Cepheids.See this in LMC OGLE II/III Cepheids. http://www.astro.umass.edu/~shashi/paperhttp://www.astro.umass.edu/~shashi/paper
s/paper1.pdfs/paper1.pdf
RR LyraesRR Lyraes
PC relation at minimum light is flat.PC relation at minimum light is flat. Higher amplitude RR Lyraes are driven to hotter/bluer Higher amplitude RR Lyraes are driven to hotter/bluer
temperatures/colors at maximum light.temperatures/colors at maximum light. PC relation is flat at minimum light because the HIF is PC relation is flat at minimum light because the HIF is
further out in the mass distribution.further out in the mass distribution. HIF always engaged with stellar photosphere for RR HIF always engaged with stellar photosphere for RR
Lyraes.Lyraes. But density changes as pulsation proceeds from But density changes as pulsation proceeds from
minimum light.minimum light. http://www.astro.umass.edu/~shashi/papers/paper9.pdfhttp://www.astro.umass.edu/~shashi/papers/paper9.pdf
The Oosterhoff DichotomyThe Oosterhoff Dichotomy OoI: <P> ~ 0.65 days, Z = 0.001OoI: <P> ~ 0.65 days, Z = 0.001 OoII: <P> ~ 0.55 days, Z = 0.0001OoII: <P> ~ 0.55 days, Z = 0.0001 Period-Amplitude (PA) relation different in the Period-Amplitude (PA) relation different in the
two groups.two groups. Evolved RRab stars in OoI clusters follow a Evolved RRab stars in OoI clusters follow a
similar PA relation to that in OoII clusterssimilar PA relation to that in OoII clusters M3: OoI, M15: OoII.M3: OoI, M15: OoII. V = a + blog PV = a + blog P V = a + c(B-V) – c(B-V) + blogPV = a + c(B-V) – c(B-V) + blogP Related to PC/AC relations as a function of Related to PC/AC relations as a function of
phasephase
M3/M15 analysisM3/M15 analysis
M3 data from Benko et al (2007)M3 data from Benko et al (2007) M15 data from Corwin et al (2008)M15 data from Corwin et al (2008) Fourier decomposition to smooth out observed Fourier decomposition to smooth out observed
data.data. Use decomposition to estimate max/min.Use decomposition to estimate max/min. BVI light curves.BVI light curves. Concentrate on RRab stars.Concentrate on RRab stars. Possible evidence of a difference in PC/AC Possible evidence of a difference in PC/AC
relations as a function of phase.relations as a function of phase.
PC/AC relations in RR LyraesPC/AC relations in RR Lyraes
Sloan RR Lyraes and M31 data usign HST.Sloan RR Lyraes and M31 data usign HST. Theoretical models computed by Robert Szabo.Theoretical models computed by Robert Szabo. M,L,T,X,Z. Two values of Z=0.001, Z=0.0001M,L,T,X,Z. Two values of Z=0.001, Z=0.0001 Range of M/L. Strong possibilities to constrain Range of M/L. Strong possibilities to constrain
models and estimate reddening.models and estimate reddening. Kurucz atmosphere parametrized by effective Kurucz atmosphere parametrized by effective
gravity and photospheric temperature.gravity and photospheric temperature. Comparing models with observations and Comparing models with observations and
understanding possible implications.understanding possible implications.
Model ResultsModel Results