of 38
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
1/38
THE RETURN OF
HUMAN/ASIAs Face ?
A Tale of Four FacesCarla June NatanUrban Community
MissionJakarta/Migrant
Forum in AsiaPresented at ASEAN Peoples Forum, Chulalongkorn
University Bangkok, Thailand
22 February 2009
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
2/38
Migrant Forum in Asia MFA is a regional NGOassociation and trade union of migrant workersand individual advocates in Asia.
It has 290 member organizations in the 15countries in Asia.
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
3/38
Global FinancialCrisis
First Face
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
4/38
2008 Global Financial Crisis Chronology
2007
April
New Century Financial Housing credit company
bankrupt
28 August
Sachsen Landes Bankin Germany collapsedbecause of investmentin housing credit
3 Sept
German finance Institutionconfess that they lost1 billion dollars in subprimemortgage investment
17 Feb
Northern Rockwas Nationalistby UK
17 March
Bear stearns collapsed andbought by JP Morgan Chasewith the guarantee ofUS$ 30 billions
2008
10 Oct
Global stack market fellagain
8 Oct
UK preparedbail out find ofUS$ 87 billions
29 Sept
Brandford & Bingley wastook over by UK Govern-ment
25 Sept
Washington mutualcollapsed& bought bySP Morgan
16 Sept
Fed injected Ai6 US$85billions
15 Sept
Lehman brothersbankrupt
5 Sept
Fannie Mae & Freddie MAC wastaken by US Government
6 Oct
Germany injected68 billion dollarsto Hypo Real Estate
3 Oct
US Congressreleased700 billion bailout fund
30 Sept
France, Belgium, Luxemburgsaved Dexia
Source : Tempo Magazine (2008)
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
5/38
What the Difference of1998 Crisis and 2008 Crisis
It happened at 6 countries in Asia Bankruptcy of company and financial
institution. The hittest was : big companies that
played in the global market such asforeign currency, bonds,obligation, off
shore loans; banking, stock marketand property, public sector whom hada foreign loan, importir/businness actorwho depend on the import raw material
Liquidity Crunch,market pessimismand consumption
Investment contraction, economy crisisand increasing of unemployment
For Indonesia, it is social and politicalcrisis
Crisis happened around the world startedfrom subprime mortgage in USA, Europeand Asia Pacific
- Bankrupty of bank/financial institution andcorporations
- Increasing of inflation and unemployment,economy slow down and fell of index instock market
- In Indonesia, stock market and foreigncurrency trading fell to 60%
- Rupiah was weaken from Rp.9076 Rp.13.000
- According to Kwik Kian Gie, EconomyExpert, the rich people in Indonesia are theone who lost much in this crisis for theyplayed in the global stock market. Theirwealth was decreased from Rp.1998 trillion
to 1072 trillion rupiah)- World Bank predicted the global economy
growth will decrease to 0,9% from previousprediction of 3%.
- According to World Economy Expert, Asiaeconomy growth will reach only 2 %.Theaverage growth of Asia country will set backto the year of 1980-2002, around 3.5-4% in2009.
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
6/38
RESPONSES TO THE CRISIS IN ASIA PACIFIC REGION
RESPONSES COUNTRY
Increase bank rates
Decrease bank rates
Indonesia
China, Hong Kong, South Korea,Taiwan, Australia, New Zealand
Took over for recover China
Bail out Japan
Buy Back Indonesia, Thailand
Incentive for Exporter Indonesia, Thailand
Closed stock market Indonesia, Thailand
Increase deposito guarantee Indonesia, Hong Kong, New Zealand,
Australia
Prohibited short Selling Indonesia, Taiwan, Korea.Australia
Different sources
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
7/38
Worker Situation ILO predicted 210 million people will be unemployed around the world in 2009.
This unemployment will happen at the developed countries OECD around 42 million people.The rest, 168 million will come from non OECD countries. OECD predicted the unemployment willraise 8 million in the coming 2 years. This is a serious increasing since the recession in 1980.
The export oriented economies in Asia Pacific such as Hong Kong, South Korea, Japan,Singapore and China will suffer heavily.
South Koreas economy shed more than 100.000 jobs in the year to January. The jobless raterose to 3.6% in January from 3.3% in previous month. The shipment in Korea down 25-30%.
Taiwans industrial production is down to to 30% in December while 15.000 Panasonic workers inJapan has been laid off.
The unemployment in Hong Kong has been increased to 4.5% from November08 January2009. 14.000 people without job.
Singapore expects that there will be about 300.000 job losses in 2010.
The crisis hit Thailands 8.5 million people in tourism and export dependent emplyoment. Since1997 financial crisis, Thai economy has generated more than 2.5 million new jobs in tourism andmanufacture.
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
8/38
Ban Ki Moon, UN General Secretary predicted 20 million people out of 200 millionforeign workers will lost their job in construction and tourism.
Human rights groups say many of the world's estimated 100 million migrant workersare in dire predicaments as economic woes in the Gulf, Singapore and Taiwan leadto mass layoffs of laborers from countries such as Bangladesh, China, India,
Pakistan, the Philippines and Sri Lanka. MFA data showed that 53 milllion migrant workers from Asia work worldwide mainly
in Gulf countries and Middle East. A high percentage of them are low and middleskilled workers.There are 15-20 million undocumented intra region migrant workers inSoutheast Asia and East Asia.
In Persian Gulf, half of 13 million foreign workers could lose their job in majorconstruction projects in Saudi Arabia, UAE, Kuwait, Bahran, Qatar and Oman. Any
slow down in the construction sector would affect thousands of migrant workers fromBangladesh, India, Myanmar, Thailand and China.
Layoffs of these migrant workers may raise unemployment and poverty in their homecountries as they return without jobs and often with hefty debts. It could also sloweconomic growth in countries such as Indonesia, Bangladesh, Philippines and SriLanka which are deeply reliant on remittances sent home.
10% out of 90 million Filiipino people work overseas. In 2008, they sent 14.4 billionUSD equivalent to 10% of Sautheast Asia nations gross domestic product. 50.000filipino will lost job in USA only at financial sector. There are 2 miilion of them in USA.Remittance of Filipino went to consumption private one reach 70%.
As a result of the economic slowdown, the World Bank said it expects remittances,the lifeblood for millions in the developing world, to moderate significantly over thenext two years and that remittances in 2009 will fall almost 1 percent. Globalremittance flows stood at US$283 billion last year. But as their economic health
declines, the social well-being of migrant workers is also under threat.
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
9/38
MIGRANT WORKERS ARE THE LASTHIRE.......AND......FIRST FIRE
The 1997, Asian financial crisis demonstrated that
migration is not a sustainable economic developmentagenda. By early 1998, the anti migrant sentiment wasalready peaking. Governments throughout Asia wereexpelling migrant workers.Thailand announces a plan
to expel a million migrants while Malaysia indicatedthat hundreds of thousands of migrant workers, ithwork permints and not, would be deported (AMC,
1999). However, governments soon were besieged bycomplaints from business that did not have enoughworkers as locals refused to take those jobs left bymigrants.
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
10/38
The impact of global crisis to migrant workers(IOM Policy Brief Paper 2009)
Job losses, especially in construction, manufacturing, finance, services, retail and
tourism.Possible reductions in wages and poorer conditions in the workplace as companies
and employers seek to make savings, as well as cuts in social services provision,
impacting on migrants quality of life and health.The risk of discrimination and xenophobia as migrants - migrants took local job
particularly in low-skilled.Returning or deportation of migrant to countries of origin. Possibility of increasing
poverty and unemployment - could affect economic and social stability.A decline of remittance. Migrants may also be more reluctant to send money
through formal channels due to a lack of confidence in the stability of banking
systems.More restrictive immigration policies to protect the local labour market and in
response to a demand for fewer foreign workers.A reduction in labour migration flows as potential migrants choose to stay home.An increase in irregular migration and the strengthening of the informal labour
market. An increase in trafficking in human beings is also a possibility.The crisis is expected to impact differently on male and female migrant workers
especially in affected sectors of the economy dominated by one gender (e.g.
construction in which male migrant workers predominate).
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
11/38
CapitalismFace
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
12/38
MaximizeProfit MinimizeCostand
Risk!
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
13/38
China
After China
Return to SEZs condition,
facilitate by FTA?
1980s FDI EPZs
Export promotion Zones
1974s - MFA
Relocation; North/NICs to South
1960- 1970s
Expanding shipped production/ manufacturing
toNICs - Korea, Taiwan, Hong Kong
1995 China
US/EU
Central
America
Africa
SouthAsia
NICS
Taiwan,Hong Kong,
Korea
Southeast
Asia
Mexico
Eastern
EU
India?
Factories relocationfrom North to South.Facilitate by TradeSubsidy/ promotion
and agreement
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
14/38
FLEXIBILITY
Multi skills/less workers
Subcontracting,push pressure toworkers
Using vulnerableworkers, children,immigrant,prisoners
Employment intemporary, part-time,contract system
Target/ piece ratesystem, home baseworkers
In crease speed,
work like robot,no time to eat, topee, to rest.
Flexible labourlaw forinvestment - ATC,Free Trade
Investmentprivilege package,
EPZs
Politicia
n,auth
oritie
sLe
galpro
ceedin
g
Busting
advis
orsManagement,
personnel
Highest profit/cheapest cost
Reducing risks, used less workers, cheapestwages, no liability, no responsibility, no direct
employment, etc.
superv
isors Ma
fia,
gangst
ers
workers are suppressed -- no time to eat [nothing to eat], to rest, to have family life, etc.
Too many OT,no time toparticipate inunion
INCREASEPRODUCTION
CAPITALISTs
Supply ChainManagement
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
15/38
The Curse of Capitalism
Greediness
Spending higher than saving
Material is more important than human
Development emphasize more in physicaldevelopment than human being
Man is an object and production machine
Focus on economy only of human being Wider gap between the have and haves
not
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
16/38
Economy
Law
Politic
Social
Culture
Education
SpiritualBiology
Neoliberalism Vs. Man
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
17/38
Neoliberalism Vs Man
Man is a garden of diversity. He haspolitic, social, legal, cultural, spiritual,economy and spiritual dimension. It
means that a man is a homooeconomicus, but homo oeconomicusnotentirely man. Man is for sure a homopoliticus, but homo politicusnot entirelyhuman being. Decreasing man to be onlyeconomy actor is denial of the thoughtand facts. (B. Herry-Priyono, 2008)
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
18/38
IndonesiaFace!
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
19/38
Based on Industry Department of Indonesia, the fragileindustry hit by global downturn is garment and textile, pulpand paper, plantation especially crude palm oil -CPO, timberindustry, steel and electonic industry, handicraft andfurniture.
The World Bank predicted Indonesia economy grow this yearwill be 4,4% , The Economist : 3,7% from last year of 6,2%
While the Indonesia government optimism to reach 5-5.5%
The unemployment in 2008 is reaching 9,39 million people.According to International Labour Organization (ILO), theunemployment will increase in Indonesia in 2009 will be170.000 to 650.000 people or increase around 9%.
According to Tempo Magazine Jan09, from the insideinformation from government, January-February will be 1,6million people.
ex e an armen n us ry n
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
20/38
ex e an armen n us ry nIndonesia
Textile and garment industry is the largest Industry in Indonesia outsidegas and oil with employee 1,8 million workers.
From that number, 63% worked at the big and medium enterprises and 37%
by small and medium. The center of textile production is in Java (57%),Jakarta (17%) and Central Java (14%).
Indonesia is the seventh world fiber production, produce 1,5 million ton in2004 with the revenue of 672 million US dollar.
Indonesia has a capacity of world fourth largest spinning produce 2.64billion US dollar in 2004.
Lastly, Indonesia has a capacity of third largest woven in the world with theearning of 3,89 billion US $ in 2004.
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
21/38
Indonesia textile industry is one of the major in thecountry macro economies. In 2005, the clothing salesreached 4,27 billion US $, with 71% was from export(3,07 billion US $) and 29% from local market (1,2 billionUS$)
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
22/38
In 2001-2005, the export clothing increased10%, from 2,78% billion US$ in 2001 became
3,07 billion US$ in 2007
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
23/38
The biggest textile and apparel export of Indonesia is to USA(31%), European Union (21%) and ASEAN countries (7%). In
2004, Indonesia is the ninth largest export to the world.
Impact of the Global Crisis to the
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
24/38
Impact of the Global Crisis to theTextile and Garment Industry in
Indonesia
The Indonesia Sport Shoes index fell to 50%, lost 50% exportmarket. The penetration to the global market declined to 5.8percent in 2000 became half of it in 2007 and thus impact to thedecline of competitiveness.
Decreasing of the orders (contract from USA and Europe) 30 40percent, increasing of smuggling of goods especially from China.
Around 100 thousands from 1.2 million textile workers will be lay
off. According to Djimanto, Vice Chair of Indonesia Businessman
Association, in 2009, around 50% workers or around 45,5 millionworkers threaten to lost their job. The Chairman of IndonesianBusiness Association said that they already ended the contractlabor while for the permanent workers will be employed until April2009. The rest will be depend on the situation of global and
national situation. Chairman of Indonesia Textile Association said that, the potential
dismissal in textile sector in 2009 will reach 70.000- 80.000workers. In 2008, they already dismissed 30.000 worker.
Chairman of Indonesia Sportshoes Association stated that,thedismissal on this sector this year will be 40.000 people, while in theend of last year reached 10.000 people. The income in this sector
will decline to 15-20%. NIKE says, it may cut 1,400 jobs to cope with global economy
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
25/38
Indonesian MigrantWorkers
Malaysia will deported 300.000foreign migrant workers 300.000.100.000 of them will be Indonesianmigrant worker will be send backthis year.
Malaysia still employed foreignmigrant workers at the sector ofplantation and construction andnot any longer factory workers.
Ministry of Manpower and Transmigration announced that250.000 Indonesian migrantworkers has returned home lastyear.
South Korea will not receive
Indonesian migrant workers inFebruary 2009. South Koreaseconomy shed more than 100.000
jobs in the year to January. Taiwan has dismissed several
thousands foreign migrantworkers.
Several migrant workers have
been trafficked to the conflictareas such as Palestina and Israel.
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
26/38
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
27/38
1. Indonesian migrant workers are the biggestcontributor to the country revenue outsidetax. In 2006-2008, the remittance countryreceived was 11,49 billion USD. In 2009, it istargeted USD 21 billion.
2. The irony of remittances of migrant workersis :
Not necessary increasing the economywelfare in their village.
Not reduce the poverty in the community.
There is no government plan to improve orstrengthening the migrant workerseconomy back home. Migration is only aforce to escape from poverty and not fromthe plan to reduce poverty.
There is no or difficult to access togovernment fund to improve their economy
D. Hero of Remittances orCommodity ?
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
28/38
Will Human/Asia FaceReturns?
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
29/38
I d i G t
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
30/38
Indonesia GovernmentResponses
1. Law enforcement and investment guarantee;
2. Monetary stabilization through policies
3. Strengthening Real Sector including TextileProduct,Sportshoes and Electronic.
4. Sustainability of small and medium enterprises : credit facility
5. Social Safety Net Program. The government targeted toreduce poor people 12-14% in 2009 by providing 17 trillionrupiah through free health care, free school, rice subsidy,
cash money (BLT), Housing subsidy, National PeopleStrengthening program, credit for the people
6. For the workers, social insurance office, provide credits forenterprises after dismissal, cash money of 350.000 fordismissal workers.
7 E P i it A d
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
31/38
7 Economy Priority Agendaof 2009
Limited unemployment
Manage inflation at the certain level
Policies to ensure the real sector must be
move including fiscal incentive Maintain people power buying
Protect the poor by given direct assistance,
etc. Maintain enough food and energy
Maintain the development growth above 4,5%
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
32/38
What the workers can befighting for
1. For the worker who still work:
- Retraining:sewing, stitching, embroider, English andComputer Course,etc
- Increase the capacity of negotiation, lobby,communication (internet)
- Information information information on whathappen in the factories and companies
- Consolidation and Network
S lid it !
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
33/38
Solidarity !Dignity
Returns
Factory from, byand for the worker.
Sub Contractwith decent wage
EthicEnforcement
InternationalLaw, Procedure
and mechanism
Decent Wage
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
34/38
Workers
Living wage
Bonus
Pension
Subsidy
Food allowance
Transportation, etc.
Leaves- holiday, annual
Familybenefit
Sick leaves
Maternitybenefit
Activities leaves
Learning/Education
Union office/facilities
Political Rights
Union is a tool to good lifeand Security
Legal Rights
Workers party
Compensation,
Provident fund
OS&H --Safe andHealthy work
Democratic laws
SocialWelfare
UnemploymentSecurity
Economic Rights
CBA
Strike
Organizing
Social Rights
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
35/38
Global Supply Chain!
The impact to workers
Freedom
Of
Association
Western TUS/NGOs
pressuring brand
names and retailers
Asian TUs/
ATNC monitoring groups
pressuring manufacturers
workers trying
to organise
against exploitation
AMRC& TLC
proposal
Tri-angular
Solidarity tosupport
workers
rights to
Freedom of
Association
Freedom
Of
Association
Western TUS/NGOs
pressuring brand
names and retailers
Asian TUs/
ATNC monitoring groups
pressuring manufacturers
workers trying
to organise
against exploitation
Freedom
Of
Association
Western TUS/NGOs
pressuring brand
names and retailers
Asian TUs/
ATNC monitoring groups
pressuring manufacturers
workers trying
to organise
against exploitation
AMRC& TLC
proposal
Tri-angular
Solidarity tosupport
workers
rights to
Freedom of
Association
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
36/38
For the potential dismissal
worker and migrant workers
Compensation and severance payment
Reintegration program: Training/upgradingskill :salon, machine, sewing, cake,recycle,
shop, farming Planning, implementing and market access
Access to the governments fund
Return to the village = provincial autonomy Coalition with other sectors :farmer,
fishermen, women, etc.
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
37/38
Kisah Perjuangan
8/14/2019 Human Face Returns
38/38
Asia can indeed turn this challenge into anopportunity to rebalance the sources ofgrowth by revitalizing domestic investmentand consumption and maintaining steadyeconomic growth at this difficult time,thereby contributing significantly to theglobal recovery