MARCELO GALUPPO, MÔNICA SETTE LOPES,
KARINE SALGADO, LUCAS GONTIJO, THOMAS BUSTAMANTEEditors
Human Rights, Rule of Law and the Contemporary Social Challenges in Complex SocietiesProceedings of the XXVI World Congress of Philosophy
of Law and Social Philosophy of the Internationale Vereinigunf für Rechts- und Sozialphilosophie
Belo Horizonte2015
Human Rights, Rule of Law and the Contemporary Social Challenges in Complex Societies: Proceedings of the XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy of
the Internationale Vereinigunf für Rechts- und Sozialphilosophie
Marcelo Galuppo
Mônica Sette Lopes
Lucas de Alvarenga Gontijo
Karine Salgado
Thomas Bustamaente
Editors
1st Edition [E-book]– 2015 – Initia Via
Copyright © [2015] Initia Via Editora Ltda.
Rua dos Timbiras, nº 2250 – sl. 103-104 - Bairro Lourdes
Belo Horizonte, MG, Brasil, 30140-061
www.initiavia.com
Editor-in-Chief: Isolda Lins Ribeiro
Review: Editors and authors
Graphic project: Ana Caroline Azevedo, Agda Torquato,
Olímpia Martins, Tomás Cirino.
Cover design: Eduardo Furbino
Cover image: Tiles at Church of Saint Francis of Assisi,
designed by Oscar Niemeyer, at Pampulha, Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil.
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. This book contains material protected under International Copyright Laws and Treaties. Any unauthorized
reprint or use of this material is prohibited. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means,
electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, without express written permission from the publisher.
Human Rights, Rule of Law and the Contemporary Social Challenges in
Complex Societies: Proceedings of the XXVI World Congress of Philosophy
of Law and Social Philosophy of the Internationale Vereinigunf für Rechts-
und Sozialphilosophie / editors: Marcelo Galuppo, Mônica Sette Lopes, Lucs
Gontijo, Karine Salgado, Thomas Bustamanete. - Belo Horizonte : Initia Via,
2015.
3159 p.
ISBN 978-85-64912-59-5 [E-book]
1. Law - Philosophy. 2. Human Rights. 3. Rule of Law. I. Galuppo,
Marcelo. II. Sette Lopes, Mônica. III. Gontijo, Lucas de Alvarenga. IV.
Salgado, Karine. V. Bustamante, Thomas. VI. Título.
CDU: 34(082)
XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy • 3
Contents
Introduction 27Introdução 28
Hans Kelsen today: Relativism, Democracy and Constitutionalism
Kelsen and Justice 29Hannele Isola-Miettinen
Aristotle and the Philosophy of Law: Justice and Society
Good men aren’t enough: the dialectics between the law and the practical virtue in the Aristotelian thought: the philosophy between normative and critical approaches 44Marcella Furtado de Magalhães Gomes
An historical evaluation of constitutional principles from Aristotle’s Politics for Human Rights 58Lourenço Torres
E-Justice and Governance
E-Citizenship: observations from the theory of communication of Lee Thayer 74Ricardo Menna Barreto
Open source software, access to knowledge and software licensing 100Marcella Furtado de Magalhães GomesRoberto Vasconcelos NovaesMariana Guimarães Becker
Creating legal facts and norms through Interdisciplinary Research
The ontological nature of value on Miguel Reale’s Tridimensional Theory of Law 116Alan Mariano Bezerra de Carvalho
4 • XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy
Property and Human Rights in Globalisation: an engagement
The missing link between property law and labour law 122Martin Dumas
Communicational Theory of Law
Communicational Theory of Law and topology of juridical legitimacy 141Henrique Mello
Legal validity as membership 154Félix Francisco Sánchez Díaz
Communicational Theory of Law and tax computerization 165Guilherme Lopes de Moraes
Legal dogmatic and theory of texts 175Gregorio Robles
The Communicational Theory of Law (CTL) and the language of jurists 185Aurelio de Prada García Intertextuality among legal subsystems: the Brazilian tax experience on “revenue”, “tax” and “inputs” 195Cecilia Priscila de SouzaFernando Gomes Favacho
Give Marxism what it deserves! Law and the Social Analysis: Is Marxism Still an Opportunity?
The “syndrome” of legislative reforms in Brazil: criticism of the institutionalization of law in peripheral capitalism 232Carolina Alves Vestena
Redefining relationships between Public Law and Private Law in the Era of Globalization
Sovereignty in a world of tangled legal orders 251Mirlir Cunha
XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy • 5
Political obligation and political legitimacy
The paradox of popular sovereignty 274Saulo Monteiro de Matos
An ontological turn of political obligation 291Hirohide Takikawa
Bioethics, argumentation and human rights
Biomedical Principles: systematic aspects 303Oscar Vergara
AICOL – AI Approaches to the Complexity of Legal Systems
Complexity as a metatheory on relations between Law and sustainable development 311André Folloni
Concepts and Conceptions of Law
Hart’s conception of Law 327Diego Fonseca Mascarenhas
The influence of Ethics in the concept of Law: questions about the actual stage of the “Hart-Dworkin” 338Leonardo Figueiredo Barbosa
Analysis and criticism of Kelsen’s arguments for a necessary relation between law and coercion 349João Vitor Penna e Silva
Compatibility between content-based judicial review and the dynamic principle in Hans Kelsen’s theory 361Gabriel Santos LimaVitor Marcellino Tavares da Silva
The Pure Theory of Law: the transcendental argument and the criticism to reductivism 368Filipe A. O. Rodrigues
6 • XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy
Alexy’s Theory of Law
Fundamental social rights as subjective rights 379Cláudia Toledo
Critical Theory and Law in and after Habermas
Judicial procedure and argumentation: how much discursive is the legal discourse? 389André L. S. Coelho
Law and Music
Law and Music: human rights protection and the song “Dom Quixote” 404Ariane Shermam Morais VieiraRosana Ribeiro Felisberto
Cities as networks of meanings: discursive plurality and the right to the city
The pursuit of recognition of deficient citizens:: the privileged example of the (lack of) urban mobility 411Álvaro Augusto Lauff MachadoAdriano Sant’Ana Pedra
The relation between legal pluralism, lack of human rights and crisis of the social State 432Adriana Goulart de Sena OrsiniNatália de Souza Neves
Popular participation in the Municipal Housing Council of Belo Horizonte, Minas Gerais, Brazil 446Maria Tereza Fonseca Dias
The street carnival of Rio de Janeiro as an exercise of the right to the city 456Gustavo Silveira SiqueiraPedro Henrique Ramos Prado Vasques
The city as a mosaic: Law, otherness and dialectic perspective 478Maria Coeli Simões PiresMila Batista Leite Corrêa da Costa
XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy • 7
Public participation and recognition: an analysis of Vila Viva program 489Aline Rose Barbosa PereiraThaís Lopes Santana Isaías
Reinventing Legal Philosophy in Iberoamerica?
Lusophone jurisprudence in Iberoamerican Legal Philosophy 507Paulo Ferreira da Cunha
Towards a Normative Jurisprudence?
On how law is not like chess: Dworkin and the theory of conceptual types 523Ronaldo Porto Macedo Junior
Kant’s Concept of Law
Compatibility of the moral foundation of Law in Kant with the theory of reflective judgment and the Kantian theory of revolution 571Maria Lucia de Paula Oliveira
Citizenship and access to justice in the democratic order
A new rhetoric for a new justice and democratic order 585Marco Antônio Sousa Alves
The myth of constitutional neutrality Adjudication and democracy 592Cássio Corrêa BenjaminTiago Lopes Coelho
Judgment and justice: an Arendtian vision 605Christina Miranda Ribas
Citizenship and cordiality: notes on the relationship between justice and friendship 613Maria Cecília Pedreira de Almeida
Blood for peace: a case of study of law and violence 626Karla Pinhel Ribeiro
8 • XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy
Innovational methodology in the teaching of Law
Using a virtual plataform in the teaching of Law 630Cristiane Silva Kaitel
Autonomy and paternalism: searching for a socially built normativity for the contemporary private law
The acceptable limits of public intervention in private activity 636Luiz Flávio Paína Resende AlvesPaulo Antônio Machado da Silva Filho; Ticiane Moraes FrancoVirgínia Afonso de Oliveira Morais da Rocha
The tax as an inducing instrument of individuals behaviors 649Luiz Flávio Paína Resende AlvesPaulo Antônio Machado da Silva Filho; Ticiane Moraes FrancoVirgínia Afonso de Oliveira Morais da Rocha
The intervenue of public law in private law: Brazilian reality 663Juliana Falci Sousa Rocha Cunha
Liberals, Communitarians, Republicans and the intervention of the State in the private sphere 679Rafael Rodrigues Pereira
The efficacy of the fundamental right to health in private legal relations established between health insurance companies and their customers 692Rodolpho Barreto Sampaio Júnior Thiago Penido Martins
Solidarity in the private relations: a study about the fundamental duties 724Bruna Lyra DuqueAdriano Sant’Ana Pedra
The political activity of judiciary
On the origins of Rule of Law and the meta-physics of institutions 740Bruno Meneses Lorenzetto
The right to justification and the Rule of Law: towards a “justifiable” legal argumentation theory 751Rafael Cascardo Cardoso dos Santos
XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy • 9
Judicial process, jurisdiction and the tension between Constitutionalism and Democracy 774William Soares Pugliese
Legal Philosophical Pluralism
Universal International Law? A challenge and a contribution from the peoples in the South 790Henrique Weil Afonso
The philosophy of the limits to freedom of speech
The freedom of speech in the network society: new forms of controlling information 813Marco Antônio Sousa Alves
Law as Literature: Memory and Oblivion
Featured expressions of the relationship between Law and Literature in Argentina 822Miguel Angel Ciuro Caldani
Considerarions about memory and oblivion in Law from the short story ‘Pai Contra Mãe’, by Machado de Assis 835Leonela Otilia Sauter Soares
The role of Literature in promoting and effecting Human Rights 850Laura Degaspare Monte Mascaro
Schlinks’s “Der Vorleser” and the concept of Truth 862Maria Clara Calheiros
Institutional Philosophy and Institutional Theory
The systemic effects as a legitimate aspect in Institutional Theory 876Maíra AlmeidaHenrique RangelViviane A. da Silva
Institutional analysis and epistemology of values in Law: an outline 898Maciej Pichlak
10 • XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy
Law and Technology: the fusion of Law and Information Technology
From Pontes de Miranda to Mireille Delmas-Marty: a journey to review the theory of sources of Law to accommodate the new rights generated by the nanotechnological revolution 908Wilson Engelmann
Pragmatism and Legal Theory
Inferencialist Pragmatism and Dworkin’s “Law as Integrity” 924Thiago Lopes Decat
Another Pragmatism: the Scandinavian legal thought 941Jean-Baptiste Pointel
Law and literature: experiences from my country
Yugoslav Literature under (Il) Legal Censorship: 1945-1990 957Dijana Zrnić
Incestum: love or a criminal act? 974MirjanaBogunović
Machado de Assis and the struggle for recognition 990Hugo Schayer Sabino
Law and literature: the experience of jus literary discussion introduced in Universidade Federal do Pará, Brasil 995Victor Russo Fróes Rodrigues
Legal Argumentation
The Dworkin’s answer to Posner’s Economic Analysis of Law on Bush v. Gore Supreme Court decision 1002Bernardo Gonçalves FernandesRaphaela Borges DavidDaniel Felipe Paiva
XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy • 11
Derrida and Law
Derrida on the Death Penalty 1013Theresa Calvet de Magalhães
Derrida on Friendship and Sovereignty 1030Marcelo Andrade Cattoni de Oliveira
Changing idea of legal personhood: interdisciplinary perspective
The concept of person as an emergent phenomenon 1039Fabio Queiroz PereiraJordhana Mª V. V. C. Costa Gomes
The Idea of Justice from the viewpoints of Legal Philosophy
Nicomachean Ethics and the theory of Justice as the centerpiece of thearistotelian anthropology 1050Marcella Furtado de Magalhães GomesRoberto Vasconcelos Novaes
Soft science, hard puzzle: can we handle John Roemer s Justice algorithm? 1065Nuria López
Aristotle on Justice and Law: Koinonia, Justice and Politeia 1080Giovanni Bombelli
VII Jornada Brasileira de Filosofia do Direito
Pensar o Direito em português 1102Paulo Ferreira da Cunha
A influência de J. C. Salgado na produção científica em Filosofia do Direito na Faculdade de Direito da Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais 1113Laura Souza Lima e Brito
Pode-se prescindir da ideia de contrato social como parâmetro para uma teoria da justiça relevante? Alguns inconvenientes da abordagem comparativa de Amartya Sen 1124Fábio Creder
12 • XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy
Solidariedade e deveres fundamentais da pessoa humana 1133Adriano Sant’Ana Pedra
Por uma retórica construtiva no Direito: esclarecimento e completude 1149Lourenço Torres
The Natural Law Tradition
Natural Law: Classic and Modern? 1181Paulo Ferreira da Cunha
The many identities of Private Law
On the concept of subjectivity in the promissory theory of contracts from the perspective of Paul Ricoeur’s philosophy 1204Marcin PieniążekAndrzej Frycz Modrzewski
Questions of fact and legal reasoning
The use of scientific arguments: thinking like an expert 1213Margarida Lacombe Camargo
Analogical reasoning, deductive reasoning and their relationship with the enquiry of the facts of the case 1221Carlos Magno de Abreu Neiva
Cultural Turn and Philosophy of Law and State
Multicultural character of Brazilian constitutionalism: self-determination of peoples in the 1988 Constitution and the legacy of José Bonifácio 1234Renata Anatólio LoureiroDanyele da Silva Machado
Culturalism and Fundamental Rights 1257Raoni Bielschowsky
Communitarianism and the rescue of Hegel’s conception of freedom 1269Rodrigo Antonio Calixto Mello
XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy • 13
Politics is conflict: Carl Schmitt and our time
Discussion, conflict and exception: Carl Schmitt and the not quite new paradigm of lawmaking 1277Eduardo Carone Costa Júnior
Carl Schmitt: critic of Positivism 1287Fernando José Armando Ribeiro
Justice and the question of violence
Identity, violence, reason and justice: the debate between Amartya Sen and Jonathan Glover 1299Fábio Creder
The potential of testimony in transitional justice: what truth can it bring to light? 1306Laura Degaspare Monte Mascaro
Democracy, Social Justice and Labor
The State in crisis: biopolitics and the state of exception 1320Elsa Cristine Bevian
Working time in Brazil: unconstitutionality direct actions filed in the Federal Supreme Court between 1988 and 2012 1326Eleonora Kira Valdez de Moura
The reduction of the weekly working journey to 40 hours in Brazil: a contemporary debate 1341Roberta Dantas de Mello
Constitutionality control about working matters in Brazil between 1988 and 2012 1356Sayonara Grillo Leonardo Coutinho da SilvaEleonora Kira Valdez de Moura
The question of irregular migrant workers between a rights based international approach and national regulation 1380Daniela Muradas ReisPedro Augusto Gravatá Nicoli
14 • XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy
The equal legal treatment of paternity leave and maternity leave: the path to equality sexist labor market 1399Maria Cecília Máximo TeodoroMiriam Parreiras de Souza
Pre-contractual discrimination towards different types of disabilities: the infra-discrimination on the employer’s choice 1422Maria Rosaria BarbatoFlávia Souza Máximo Pereira
The Pension Fund as an additional labour and pension instrument for promoting social inclusion in the Democratic Rule-of-Law State 1443Érica Fernandes Teixeira
Freedom from poverty and a decent standard of living from a social justice and Human Rights perspective
Reflections on the concept of poverty and social change in Brazil:an analysis of the “Bolsa Família” program 1460Tainah Simões Sales
Truth and objectivity: in Law and morals
Truth, hermeneutics and judicial decision 1474Fernando José Armando Ribeiro
Discrimination: Philosophical and Jurisprudential Issues
Philosophical and Jurisprudential Issues on Domestic Violence and Gender Discrimination 1489Marcia Nina Bernardes
Legal Reasoning
Precedent as a typological term upon the Court of Justice of the European Union Decisions 1503Bartosz Greczner
The right to justification and the Rule of Law: towards a “justifiable” legal argumentation theory 1510Rafael Cascardo Cardoso dos Santos
XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy • 15
Law and science in public hearings: between the legislator’s discretion and scientific (un)certainty of the Brazilian Federal Supreme Court 1533Margarida Lacombe Camargo
To whom it serves to conciliate? Reflections on the access to justice in neoliberal times 1539Gabriela Maia RebouçasMariana de Faro Felizola
Law and Democracy
Regnum legis hic et nunc 1550Daniel Nunes Pereira
From autonomy to democracy 1562Mou Chengwen
The hardships faced in the path of democratisation: democratisation against conservatism and Turkish experience 1570Zeynep Üskül Engin
Democracy in the presence of liberalism and its enemies: the history of a concept 1596Laurenio Sombra
Between agreement and disagreement: a search for the best conception of democratic jurisprudence 1618Ana Luisa de Navarro Moreira
Interpreting Law: democracy and decision procedures 1631André Almeida Villani
Transitional justice and Brazilian amnesty law: a study on their democratic legitimacy 1649Ronaldo Louzada Bernardo SegundoAdriano Sant’Ana Pedra
State power legitimacy in Brazilian democracy 1661Luciana Cristina de Souza
16 • XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy
Human Rights
Technique, Dehumanization and Human Rights 1684Eduardo C. B. Bittar
Human dignity in the moral discourse of social justice for people with severe or extreme mental disabilities 1712Ana Paula Barbosa-Fohrmann
Human Rights: pragmatic utility, theoretical approach and complex societies 1733Giovanni Bombelli
Human rights: has the present economic crisis proven Bentham was right? 1758Maria Clara da Cunha Calheiros de Carvalho
Fundamental social rights and existenzminimum 1774Cláudia Toledo
Rethoric
The rhetoric of resignification: the hidden face of spiritualist scientism in Pontes de Miranda and the effect of opacity 1786André Lucas Fernandes
Preserved sophistic rhetoric as part of Aristotle legacy to the history of legal persuasion 1794Lourenço Torres
International Law
Universal International Law? a challenge and a contribution from the peoples in the South 1801Henrique Weil Afonso
Sovereignty in a world of tangled legal orders 1824Mirlir Cunha
Judicial Decision Making
Subjectivity and judicial decision: a philosophical approach 1847André Martins Brandão
XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy • 17
The role of procedural dialogue in the democratic system and the risks of judgment standardization in Brazilian Law 1857Flávia Almeira Pita
The judicial activism as an evidence of the fragility of fundamental rights towards the Weberian political-administrative system 1886Sérgio Luiz Barbosa Neves
For a judicial decision theory between ontological hermeneutic and epistemological hermeneutic 1899João Víctor Nascimento Martins
Bioethics and Biopolitics
Law, mental health care and the public health system: achievements and vulnerabilities of the Brazilian model 1920Márcia Araújo Sabino de Freitas
Posthumanism and equality 1942Denis Franco Silva
Hermeneutics
A paradigm for Law 1955Nuria López
On fallacies and fundamentals of legal argumentation 1973André Ferreira Leite de Paula
Semantic constructions and Law 1985Lourenço Torres
Restrictions on fundamental rights: an interpretation in the light of Friedrich Müller´s structural theory of law 1992Débora Dossiatti de LimaNestor Castilho Gomes
Constitutional interpretation in Philosophy of Law beyond interpretivism and non-interpretivism 2002Bernardo Gonçalves Fernandes
18 • XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy
Changes in Constitutional interpretation about fundamental rights: conditions And Limits 2015Adriano Sant’Ana Pedra
Gadamer‘s dialectics and its basis on Hegel‘s theory 2028Danilo Ribeiro PeixotoNathália Lipovetsky e SilvaRicardo Henrique Carvalho Salgado
Law and State
Decentralization: new values and new rights 2043Juan Alberto del Real Alcalá
Is there a Marxist presence in the 1988 Brazilian Constitution? 2058Rodrigo Augusto Suzuki Dias CintraDaniel Francisco Nagao Menezes
Legitimate power: Law and the theory of sovereignty 2071Rodrigo Augusto Suzuki Dias CintraDaniel Francisco Nagao Menezes
Corporate governance and the financial crisis: the new paradigm of the rule of law after the collapse 2078Dawid Bunikowski
On demarcation problem between libertarianism and neoliberalism 2098Hashimoto Tsutomu
Law under Fascim: Fascism anarchy of the monopolistic bourgeois power 2109Marcus Vinícius Giraldes Silva
Personhood and Private Law
Humor and damages: civil liability for offensive jokes in Brazil 2118João Paulo Capelotti
Abuse of dominant position: function versus structure in outwardly equal contractual relationships 2127Ana Letícia Salomão e Ribeiro
XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy • 19
On the concept of subjectivity in the promissory theory of contracts from the perspective of Paul Ricoeur’s philosophy 2133Marcin Pieniążek
The supremacy of the consumer and the redefinition of the notion of citizenship in supercapitalism 2142Felipe Meira Marques
Searching the validity fundament of Civil Law in a post-national order 2165Daniella Bernucci PaulinoRodolpho Barreto Sampaio JúniorThiago Penido Martins
The naturalization of the legal entity in the Brazilian legal system 2175Sergio Marcos Carvalho de Ávila Negri
Society, Culture and Law
Equality and justice in children’s rights 2185Patrícia Pereira CavaErnani Santos Schmidt
Global logic and surrender: how to think about the antipodes 2200Kory González-Luis, PhD
From Art to Politics: challenging representation 2211Lucas de Oliveira GelapeThiago Álvares Feital
The “authoritarian culture” in a historical perspective: a comparative study between the mafiosi police in Rio de Janeiro and Buenos Aires 2233Luciana Araújo de Paula
The recognition of new social actors and the checkmate of statutory law 2241Maria Fernanda Salcedo Repolês
Labour Law and its essential nature within the capitalist scene of the 21st Century 2256Érica Fernandes Teixeira
20 • XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy
Public Policies, Politics and Law
Accessory tax obligations from the perspective of the fundamental duties theory 2281Henrique da Cunha Tavares*
Adriano Sant’Ana Pedra**
Between two worlds: human rights and public policies 2291Eric Santos Lima
Neoliberal hegemony versus social justice 2295Natalia Pais Álvarez
Semiotic analysis of tributary incidence matrix-rule 2311Piera Paula Schnaider do Nascimento
A hermeneutical review of the principle of legality in tax law 2341Sarah Amarante de Mendonça Cohen
History of Law
Jurisprudential Ghetto of Zionism 2354Luís Homem
Fundo Clamor: Memories of stories of human rights violations during military dictatorships in Brazil and in the Southern Cone 2366Anna Flávia Arruda Lanna Barreto
Critics of Human Rights from a historical perspective 2383Birden Güngören Bulgan
Unconditional legitimacy of Law: collaboration with the Nazism 2397Álvaro Ricardo de Souza CruzBernardo Augusto Ferreira Duarte
Philosophy of Law: important issues
The freedom as subjective right in the William of Ockham’s thought 2424Gabriel Lima Marques
Consilience and Macrophilosophy: contributions to a post-disciplinary Philosophy of Law 2443Renato César Cardoso
XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy • 21
Communitarianist perspective of fundamental rights: issues about the objective dimension 2456Raoni Macedo BielschowskyRodrigo Antonio Calixto de Pina Gomes Mello
Theory of Law
General Law versus Specific Law 2467Rodrigo Augusto Suzuki Dias CintraDaniel Francisco Nagao Menezes
From Pontes de Miranda to Mireille Delmas-Marty: a journey to review the theory of sources of law to accommodate the new rights generated by nanotechnological revolution 2479Wilson Engelmann
Norms, Semantics and Ontology 2495Wagner de Campos Sanz
Questions of fact and questions of law: distinction and consequences 2507Gabriel CabralLuiz Felipe Teves de P. Sousa
Law and the Communication Processes
Lights, camera, jurisdiction: communication technology and the myth of transparent justice in Brazil 2520Joana Machado de Souza*
Judging online hate speech: challenges brought by the perspective of recognition 2530Anna Clara Lehmann Martins
Law Epistemology
Methodology in comparative legal studies 2544Leonardo Machado Pontes
Legal Research: empirical analysis, philosophical work and the “non research” kind of studies 2571Alexandre VeroneseRoberto Fragale Filho
22 • XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy
Kelsen and Law Theory
Kelsen’s legal theory, indetermination and completeness in law 2604J. Alberto del Real Alcalá
From ought-to-be to ought-to-do: semantic investigation in Kelsen and Castañeda 2623Gustavo Vieira Vilar Garcia
Theories of Justice
The countermajoritarian theory: a philosophical perspective on rawlsean public reason 2635Carlos BolonhaGabriella Costa; Igor de LazariMarina Rezende
Police-Community Partnership Forum (FKPM) as a means of implementing Restorative Justice: study Case in Lasem, Rembang, Central Java, Indonesia 2649Ferry Fathurokhman
Laïcité and the affaires des foulard: an analysis based on the work of John Rawls 2664Camila Sombra Muiños de Andrade
Can one dispense with the idea of social contract as parameter for a relevant theory of justice? Some disadvantages of Amartya Sen’s Comparative Approach 2685Fábio Creder
Law, Art and Narrativeness
The voice under arrest in The Queen of the Prisons of Greece, by Osman Lins: an analysis of Paul Ricoeur´s concepts of subject of right and of narrative identity 2694Hilda Helena Soares Bentes
Law & Literature: justice and vengeance on Shakespeare and Aeschylus tragedies 2708Fernanda Borges da Costa
XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy • 23
Law and Ethics
Universality, ethical community, and human rights in Lima Vaz 2723Laura Souza Lima e Brito
Ethical pluralism as a lesson in humility for lawyers 2732Beata Polanowska-Sygulska
Cities and their issues
Cultural heritage and urban protection legislation 2738Marina Salgado
The social function of urban property 2744Marina Salgado
The rule of law on a plural society under the perspective of realist culturalism: considerations on a Brazilian urban development case 2748Alan Mariano Bezerra de Carvalho
Right to the city as a condition to the effectiveness of social rights: the possibility of judicial activism and public space 2757Alessandro Bruce Lied PadilhaGiuliana Redin
Dworkin’s perspectives on the knowlege of law
Influence of ethics in the concept of law: questions about the actual stage of the “Hart-Dworkin” debate 2764Leonardo Figueiredo Barbosa
Hobbes and his thinking
The presence of Hobbes and Machiavelli in authoritarian thinking in Brazil and Germany in the Decade 30 2775Rodrigo Augusto Suzuki Dias CintraDaniel Francisco Nagao Menezes
From Leviathan State to Leviathan Executive: an institutional perspective of Brazilian powers behavior 2784Henrique RangelCarlos BolonhaViviane Almeida
24 • XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy
Justice and Public Policies
Neoliberal hegemony versus social Justice 2811Natalia Pais Álvarez
Law and Education
Is it possible to have an egological model of legal education? 2827Diego Luna
Tax education as an instrument of social change 2839Ana Cecília Bezerra de Aguiar ; Fernanda Castelo Branco Araujo
Teaching law in basic education: research method 2864Anaína Clara de Melo
War and International Law
Terrorism, state of exception and human rights: a look towards the perverted economic face of the ‘declared war’ 2886Rosa Maria Zaia Borges
Deconstructing Terrorism: trauma, perversions and auto-immunities 2903Augusto Jobim do Amaral
Targeted killings: legal and ethical justifications 2909Tomasz Żuradzki
The paradigm of Post-War: the construction of a myth 2924Lara Freire Bezerra de Sant’Anna
Criminal Law issues
Criminal law and cultural diversity: a philosophical approach (from a European Standpoint) 2942Stefano Biancu
Multiculturalism and Human Rights
Humans rights and national minority rights in the European community plan 2953Carla Ribeiro Volpini SilvaAna Marina de Castro
XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy • 25
Alexy’s theory
Some Critics to Robert Alexy’s “Claim to Correctness” 2962Edna Felício Torres Câmara, MSc, Phd CandidateMelanie Merlin de Andrade, MSc
The role of precedent in the rational control of judicial decision from the perspective of the Theory of Legal Argumentation by Robert Alexy 2974Maira Portes
Consensual weighting by arbitration and the Alexy’s theory of argumentation 2982L’Inti Ali Miranda FaiadLossian Barbosa Bacelar Miranda
Democracy, Participation and Representation
Fair voting in the electronic age 2994Wade L. Robison
The Presidency and the Executive Branch: a philosophical approach to the parameters for interpretation and decision-making authority 3012Carlos BolonhaIgor de Lazari; Bernardo ZettelCamila Marques
Personified Executive Power and Discredited Legislative Power:prospects of a failure democratic model 3023Bernardo Supranzetti de MoraesJacqueline Ferreira Torres
Classical Natural Law
O caráter complementar entre retórica, filosofia e direito em Cícero: a concepção de uma totalidade física, ética e política na relação entre a retórica e outros saberes 3030Fernando Joaquim Ferreira Maia
26 • XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy
After World War II Philosophy of Law
De-constructing the modernity in epistemology: critical analysis of postmodernism 3054Alex Feitosa de OliveiraFelipe Meira Marques
Post-positivist Philosophy of Law and a Theory of Judgment of Justice:Kant, Arendt and the contemporary debate 3076Maria Lucia de Paula Oliveira
Human Rights between tolerance and hospitality:an essay from the though of Jacques Derrida 3090Gustavo Oliveira de Lima Pereira
Law and Democracy
Democracy and deliberation 3097Rubens Becak
Law and democracy between political paradigms in conflict 3116José Alcebíades de Oliveira Junior
Law, democracy and public reason: an analysis of constitutional justice from the thought of John Rawls. 3131Bruno Camilloto ArantesVanessa Nunes Kaut
Media and democracy: challenges and dilemmas of media regulation 3150Gustavo Ferreira Santos
***
XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy • 27
Introduction
We are proud to present the Proceedings of the XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy.
The conference was organized by the Internationale Vereini-gung für Rechts- und Sozialphilosophie (International Association for the Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy) – IVR and by a Associação Brasileira de Filosofia do Direito e de Sociologia do Direito (Brazilian As-sociation for Philosophy of Law and Sociology of Law) – ABRAFI and took place in Belo Horizonte, Brazil, at Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais’ Campus, from July 21 through July 27, 2015.
The papers published in the Proceedings were present-ed during the Conference in many Working Groups and Special Workshops, which represent the significant diversity of themes and subjects discussed by the participants from all over the world. They express the high leveled research and the creative endeavor of each author, and help us to understand the broad and distinct perspec-tives in order to understand Law from the standpoint of the main theme of this Conference: Human Rights, Rule of Law and the Con-temporary Social Challenges in Complex Societies.
Marcelo GaluppoMônica Sette Lopes
Lucas de Alvarenga GontijoKarine Salgado
Thomas Bustamante
Belo Horizonte, June 2015.
28 • XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy
Introdução
É com grande alegria que apresentamos os anais do XXVI World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy.
O congressso, organizado pela Internationale Vereinigung für Rechts- und Sozialphilosophie (International Association for the Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy - IVR) e pela Asso-ciação Brasileira de Filosofia do Direito e de Sociologia do Direito (ABRAFI), foi realizado entre 21 a 27 de julho de 2013, em Belo Horizonte, Brasil, no Centro de Atividades Didáticas 1 (CAD1), no Campus da Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais.
Nos anais, que ora se publicam, estão trabalhos apresenta-dos nos diversos Working Grupos e Special Workshops, que acol-heram a significativa diversidade dos temas trazidos à discussão pelos congressistas vindos de várias partes do Brasil e do mundo.
Percorrer os textos, fruto do trabalho de pesquisa e do uso da energia criativa por parte de seus autores, permite sentir a di-mensão das demandas que se abrem para a compreensão do direito na perspectiva do tema central daquele congresso - Human Rights, Rule of Law and the Contemporary Social Challenges in Complex Societies.
Marcelo GaluppoMônica Sette Lopes
Lucas de Alvarenga GontijoKarine Salgado
Thomas Bustamante
Belo Horizonte, Junnho de 2015.
