8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 1/24

~ U s t o r i o g r a p h y in the

l wentieth

C e ~ r a t u r y

From Scientific Objectivity

t

the

Postmodern hallenge

Georg G Iggers

n /

~ T

~ V

~ w ~

Wesleyan Uníversíty Press

Published

by

Umverslty Press of New England

Hanover and London

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 2/24

C

h

a

p

t

er

 

8

 

L

a

w

r

e

n

c

e

 

S

to

n

e

 a

n

d

 

T

h

e

 

R

e

v

i

v

a

l 

o

 

N

a

r

r

a

t

i

v

e

 

In

  1

9

79

  t

he

re

 a

p

p

ea

re

d

 m

 

as

t a

nd

 F

r

es

em

 

w

h

tc

h

 h

ad

 b

e

en

 s

in

c

e 

tts

  fo

u

n

di

ng

 in

 

19

5

2 t

he

 m

o

s

t 

tm

p

o

rta

n

t 

fo

ru

m

 

m

 G

r

ea

t

B

ri

ta

in

 

f

or

  d

i

sc

us

si

o

ns

 

in

  h

is

to

r

y 

a

nd

 

th

e

  s

o

ct

al

  s

ct

en

c

es

, 

L

a

w

re

nc

e

 

S

to

n

e's

 e

s

sa

y 

"

Th

e

 R

e

v

tv

al

 o

f 

N

ar

ra

 t

iv

e:

R

e

fte

c

tto

n

s 

o

n 

a 

N

ew

 

O

ld

 H

i

st

o

ry

."

t 

In

  t

hi

s 

no

w

 f

am

o

u

s 

pr

e

ce

, S

t

on

e

 n

o

te

s 

th

at

 í

n 

th

e 

1970s 

a baste transformation  took place ín the way  history was 

v

ie

w

e

d 

an

d

 w

r

it

te

n.

 1

)

e

 b

el

ie

f c

e

nt

ra

l

to

 s

o

ci

al

 s

ct

en

c

e 

hí

st

or

y

,

th

a

t 

a

 

c

o

he

re

n

t 

sc

ie

n

t 

nc

e

xp

la

n

at

io

n

 o

fc

h

.á

, 

Íg

ej

rú

h

e 

pa

s

t"2

 

rs

 

p

os

si

b

le

, w

a

s 

w

id

e

ly

  r

ej

ec

fe

d

. 

I r

  .i

ts

 

r

e

,

n

e

w

ed

 

in

te

re

s

t 

in

  t

he

 m

os

t 

\ m

:

t.e

d 

as

p

ec

ts

 o

f

 h

um

an

 e

x

rs

te

nc

e

, 

l)

y"

il

ie

co

ú

vi

é"

ti

on

 

ü

i

c

ti

liu

r

e.

Óf

  t

ft

e 

gr

o

up

,

a

nd

 

ev

e

n 

th

e

 w

il

l 

o

f 

th

e 

in

d

iv

id

u

al

,

ar

e 

p

ot

en

tr

a

lly

 

at

  l

ea

st

  a

s

i

m

p

ór

ta

n

t.

 ca

u

sa

l 

ag

e

nt

s 

o

 f 

ch

an

g

e 

a

s 

th

e 

im

pe

rs

o

na

l 

fo

r

ce

s 

Óf

 

m

a

te

r

ia

l 

ou

t

pu

t

a

nd

 d

e

m

o

gr

ap

h

íc

 g

r

ow

t

h.

  3

 T

h

ís

  r

e

ne

w

e

d 

em

phasis on the expenences of concrete  human beíngs ushered 

in 

a 

re

tu

m

 

to

 n

a

rr

a t

iv

e 

fo

rm

s

 o

f

 h

ts

to

ry

. 

T

h

e 

t

um

 

to

 e

x

pe

r

ie

nc

e

  in

v

o

lv

ed

 a

 

cr

iti

ca

i

re

e

xa

m

m

a

ti

O

n 

o

f 

s

ci

en

ti

fic

 

ra

tío

n

al

it

y.

 S

o

ci

al

 sc

i

en

ce

-

or

ie

n

te

d 

hí

st

or

y

 h

ad

 p

r

es

u

p

po

s

ed

 a

 

po

s

íti

ve

 r

e

la

tio

n

sh

íp

 

to

 a

 m

o

d

e

m

, 

ex

p

an

d

in

g

 in

d

us

tr

ia

l 

w

o

r

ld

  m

 

w

h

ic

h 

sc

te

n

ce

 

an

d

  t

ec

h

no

lo

g

y 

c

on

t

ri

bu

te

d

  t

o 

g

ro

w

th

 

a

nd

 d

e

v

el

op

m

e

nt

. 

B

ut

 th

is

 f

ai

th

 m

 

pr

og

r

es

s 

an

d

 in

t

he

 c

tv

i

líz

a

tío

n

 

of

 

th

e 

m

o

d

em

 

w

o

rl

d 

h

as

 

un

d

er

g

on

e

  a

 

se

rí

ou

s

  t

es

t 

si

n

ce

  t

h

e 

g

6o

s.

  I

n

 th

e

  r

 gs

o

s 

A

m

en

c

a

n 

ht

st

o

na

n

s 

an

d

 s

oc

ta

l 

sc

re

nt

is

ts

 s

til

l 

s

po

k

e 

c

om

p

l

ac

ently   of a  natio nal "consensus"  and  of  a  truly  

9

7

 

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 3/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 4/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 5/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 6/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 7/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 8/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 9/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 10/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 11/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 12/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 13/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 14/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 15/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 16/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 17/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 18/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 19/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 20/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 21/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 22/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 23/24

8/19/2019 Iggers, Georg - Historiography in the Twentieth Century

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iggers-georg-historiography-in-the-twentieth-century 24/24