IMPACT ASSESSMENT DIVISION
PRESENTATION
BEFORE HON’BLE MINISTER
Ministry of Environment, Forest
and Climate Change
11.07.2016
1
INTRODUCTION
2
•Impact Assessment Division is entrusted with the work relating to environmental clearance to project(s). • Policies formulation related to environmental clearances. •Regulations for protection and improvement of environment and safeguarding the natural resources in sustainable manner.
BACKGROUND
3
• Stockholm Conference of 1972 – proclaimed protection and improvement of the human environment as a major issue.
• Urged the nation states to preserve the natural resources of the earth including air, water, land, flora and fauna for the benefit of all the people and for their posterity.
• Earth Summit, 1992 was another landmark towards the protection and conservation of environment, where two important principles namely, (i) the concept of sustainable development and (ii) the inter generational equity were declared.
BACKGROUND
4
• The term “environment” was introduced in the Constitution of India for the first time by the 42nd Amendment in 1976.
• Article 48A of the Constitution under Part-IV dealing with Directive Principles of State Policy states as under:
"48A. Protection and improvement of environment and safeguarding of forests and wild life -The State shall endeavour to protect and improve the environment and to safeguard the forests and wild life of the country.“
• Article 51A was introduced as a separate part known as “Fundamental Duties”. Clause(g) of this article states as follows:
“(g) to protect and improve the natural environment including forests, lakes, rivers and wild life, and to have compassion for living creatures”
BACKGROUND
5
• Article 246 divides the subject for legislation in Union, State and Concurrent List.
• Article 248(1) exclusively empowers Parliament to make any law with respect to any
matter not enumerated in the Concurrent List or State List – Residuary Powers • Environment is not included in any of the list (List I, II or III) in distribution of legislative power, any matter not included in the list shall be subject matter of Central government.
• Article 253 empowers Parliament to legislate for giving effect to any international treaty, agreement or convention.
• Entry 14 of Union List which is relevant to this Article provides for “entering to treaties and agreements with foreign countries and implementing of treaties, agreements and conventions with foreign countries”.
• By virtue of these provisions, the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 enacted.
6
In EIA, the term
“impacts” is used
instead of “effects
of activities.”
What is an
impact?
Definition of EIA
Environmental Impact Assessment is A formal process for identifying:
• likely effects of activities or
projects on the
ENVIRONMENT, and on
human health and welfare.
•means and measures to
mitigate & monitor these
impacts
Environment is
broadly interpreted:
physical, biological,
and social.
7
What is an impact?
The impact of an activity is a deviation (a change)
from the baseline situation that is caused by the activity.
To measure an impact, we must know what the baseline situation is.
The baseline situation
is the existing environmental situation or condition in the absence of the activity.
The baseline situation is a key concept in EIA. More…
8
The baseline situation
In characterizing the
baseline situation,
many environmental
components MAY be
of interest
Water Quantity, quality, reliability, accessibility
Soils Erosion, crop productivity,
fallow periods, salinity,
nutrient concentrations
Flora Composition and density of
natural vegetation, productivity, key species
Fauna Populations, habitat
Special Key species
ecosystems
Env Health Disease vectors,
pathogens
The components of interest are those that are likely to be affected by activity—or upon which activity depends for its success
STATUTORY PROVISIONS
9
• EIA in India started as early as 1978 with river valley projects.
• Subsequently EIA extended to large public sector projects requiring PIB clearance. First EIA Notification was issued on 27th January, 1994
• Environmental Impact Assessment Notification, 2006 was issued vide S.O.No.1533(E) dated 14th September, 2006 under Section 3, sub-section(2), clause (v) of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 read with clause (d) of sub-rule(3) of rule 5 of Environment(protection) Rule, 1986.
• Twenty eight Amendments have been made so far.
DIFFERENCE FROM 1994 NOTIFICATION
10
Transparent, decentralized and efficient
regulatory mechanism to:
Incorporate necessary environmental safeguards at
planning stage
Involve stakeholders in the public consultation
process
Identify developmental projects based on impact
potential instead of the investment criteria
DEVELOPMENTAL ACTIVITIES REQUIRING PRIOR
ENVIRONMENTAL CLEARANCE(EC)
11
• All new projects/activities listed in the Schedule;
• Expansion and modernization of existing projects or
activities listed in the Schedule with addition of
capacity beyond the limits specified.
• Any change in product - mix in an existing
manufacturing unit included in Schedule beyond the
specified range.
CATEGORIZATION OF PROJECTS
12
Developmental activity
Category A
If GC
applicable
Category B
EC by MoEFCC EC by SEIAA
Apply in Form-I for
screening
Stages in Prior Environmental Clearance Process
13
Stage I: Screening
Stage II: Scoping
Stage III: Public Consultation
Stage IV: Appraisal
Screening, Scoping and Appraisal Committees
14
• MoEFCC has constituted EAC at Central level for Scoping and
Appraisal of projects.
• There are 8 EACs for seven sectors.
• MoEFCC has notified SEAC at state level based on proposals
received from State Government.
Contd.
15
• EAC/SEAC may inspect sites (during screening, scoping and
appraisal)
• EAC/SEAC shall not have more than 15 regular members.
• Chairperson may co-opt an expert as a member.
• Time period for Committees -3 years.
• All members will be part-time and expenditure to be borne
by MoEFCC for EACs and by State Government(s) for SEACs.
Expert Appraisal Committees
16
S.No. EAC Chairman Date of constitution
1. Industry-I Dr. Chhavi Nath Pandey, IFS
(Retd.)
2nd November, 2015
2. Industry-II Dr. J.P. Gupta 28th November, 2015
3. Mining (Non-coal) Dr. Ajay Kumar 3rd December, 2015
4. Coal and Thermal Shri Anil Kumar
Former Secretary, GOI
2nd September, 2013
5. River Valley and Hydro Power Shri Alok Perti,
Former Secretary, M/o Coal
5th September, 2013
6. Infrastructure,-I Shri Anil Rajdan, IAS (Retd.) 12th September, 2013
7. Infrastructure-II
Prof. T. Haque 3rd December, 2015
8. Nuclear, Defence and related
proposals
Shri Pradeep Kumar,
Former Chief Vigilance
Commissioner
27th August, 2015
Regional Offices and their jurisdiction
17
S. No. Head Quarter
of Regional
Office
Jurisdiction
1 Bangalore Karnataka, Kerala, Goa and
Lakshadweep
2 Bhopal Dadra & Nagar Haveli, Daman & Diu,
Gujarat and Madhya Pradesh
3 Bhubaneswar Orissa and West Bengal
4 Chennai Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu,
Puducherry and Andaman & Nicobar
Islands
5 Chandigarh Chandigarh, Haryana, Jammu &
Kashmir and Punjab
Regional Offices and their jurisdiction
18
S. No. Head Quarter of
Regional Office
Jurisdiction
6 Dehradun Himachal Pradesh and
Uttarakhand
7 Lucknow Delhi, Rajasthan and Uttar
Pradesh
8 Nagpur Chhattisgarh and
Maharashtra
9 Ranchi Bihar and Jharkhand
10 Shillong Arunachal Pradesh, Assam,
Manipur, Meghalaya,
Mizoram, Nagaland, Sikkim
and Tripura
Post Clearance Monitoring
19
• Six monthly compliance of EC to be filed by
Project proponent with Regional Office.
• SPCB & CPCB monitor the emission & effluent.
• Oversight of Public, NGT and Hon’ble Courts.
EC and TORs Granted During the Last Three Years
20
Year Number of Environmental
Clearance granted
Number of TOR
granted
2013-14 305 623
2014-15
442 638
2015-16 643 669
Total 1390 1930
Environmental Clearance granted to the projects
from 26.05.2014 to 31.03.2016
21
S. No Sector No of EC Granted Project Cost (Crore)
Employment
Generated
1 Industry 398 231528.39 106696
2 Non Coal Mining 264 19714.74 44249
3 Coal Mining 85 57541.18 13743
4
Infrastructure/CRZ/Bu
ildg. Construction 255
259570.82 47953
5 Nuclear & Defence 3
19560.99 7600
6 Thermal 27 96681.76 37374
7 River Valley 17 54657.61 12710
Total 1049 739255.49 270325
ACTION TAKEN ON PMO’s SUGGESTIONS
22
S.No Sector Number of
Agreed
Reforms
Number on
which action
Completed
Number on
which action
is pending
1 Environment
Clearance
36 31 05
2 Forest Clearance 18 18 0
3 Wildlife Clearance 5 5 0
4 CRZ Clearance 1 1 0
Total 60 55 05
Action has been completed on 55 reforms. In remaining 5 reforms, action is pending, as 2 reforms are related to carrying capacity study of river basins, 2 reforms are related to amendment in laws and one reform pertaining to Green Platform is likely to take some more time.
STREAMLINING THE SYSTEM
23
• Weighted average time taken in grant of EC
reduced from 600 days to 192 days.
• The Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate
Change has taken initiatives from time to time to
streamline and rationalise the Environment
Clearance process:
• Initiatives taken during the last 2 years are as
follows:
STREAMLINING THE SYSTEM
24
1. USE OF ICT:
MoEFCC from 1st July, 2014,
SEIAA from 2nd July, 2015,
DEIAA from 28.06.2016,
Project Proponent can track his application and also has
access to previous Environment Impact Assessment
Reports.
• General Conditions amended reducing 10 km distance from PA, CPA, ESZ to 5
Km – more projects will be appraised at State level.
• TPP [1(d)] up to 15 MW based on biomass or non-hazardous municipal solid
waste using auxiliary fuel such as coal, lignite/ petroleum products upto 15%
exempted from EC and more than 15 MW will be Category ‘B’.
• Non-Molases based industry [5(g)], the threshold limit raised from 30 kld to 60
kld (< 60 kld) to be appraised as Category ‘B’.
• Mineral Beneficiation projects [2(b)] threshold limit for Category ‘B’ raised from
0.1 MTPA to 0.5 MTPA (<0.5 MTPA throughput).
• Irrigation projects [1(c)] of CCA > 2000 ha. to <10000 ha. appraised as
Category ‘B’.
• Delegated power at the district level headed by District Magistrate or District
Collector for mining of minor minerals including sand mining for mine lease area
upto 5 ha. for individual lease and 25 ha. in cluster.
• Constituted DEIAA and DEAC.
DECENTRLIZATION
25
• All highway projects [7(f)] in border States exempted from scoping
requirement.
• All linear projects in border States exempted from the requirement of
public hearing subject to suitable conditions.
• Standardized thirty nine sector specific model Terms of References
(TORs): launched by Hon’ble Prime Minister in April 2015.
• Standard TORs enable the project proponent to commence preparation
of an EIA report after successful online submission and registration of
the application. Additional ToRs, if any has to be prescribed in 30 days
by EACs/SEACs, failing which automatic TORs issued to PP.
• Advisory issued to EACs/SEACs to seek information in one go from the
proponent.
FACILITATING FASTER INFRASTRUCTURE, INDUSTRIAL &
EDUCATIONAL GROWTH
26
• Exemption from PH for expansion of coal mining up to 6 MTPA.
• Cases will be considered for EC even if the data in EIA report is slightly
older than 3 years if EAC has recommended.
• Documents required for evidence of possession of land for
consideration of EC – Govt. initial Notification and consent of land
owners.
• Construction of industrial shed, school, college, hostels for education
institution are exempt from the requirement of EC under EIA
Notification, 2006.
• Clarified that industrial sheds implies building(whether RCC or
otherwise) which is being used for housing plant, machinery of
industrial units and include Godowns and buildings connected with
production related and other associated activities of the unit in the
same premise.
FACILITATING FASTER INFRASTRUCTURE, INDUSTRIAL &
EDUCATIONAL GROWTH
27
• Projects granted CRZ Clearance under 1991 Notification will not
require clearance under Notification of 2011.
• If a Port as a whole has obtained EC, individual berths, dredging
etc. will not require separate EC.
• Validity of ToR raised to 4 years for all projects and 5 years for
HEP.
• Validity of environment clearance increased from 5 years to seven
years without altering the overall validity of ten years.
FACILITATING FASTER INFRASTRUCTURE, INDUSTRIAL &
EDUCATIONAL GROWTH
28
FACILITATING FASTER INFRASTRUCTURE, INDUSTRIAL &
EDUCATIONAL GROWTH
• Public hearing exemption provided for the existing pellet plants.
• Transfer of environment clearance of cancelled coal block to legal
person to whom such block is subsequently allocated without
referring to EAC/SEAC.
• Preparation and presentation of Environment Impact Assessment
(EIA) report and Environment Management Plan by the accredited
Consultants.
29
Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change
Vide its OM No. 22-15/2014-1A.III dated 29th August,
2014 has constituted High Level Committee to
undertake a retrospection exercise in the functioning of
forests, wildlife and environment related statues.
HIGH LEVEL COMMITTEE REPORT
30
• Environment (Protection) act, 1986 (EP act)
• Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 (FC Act)
• Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972 (WLP Act)
• The Water (Prevention & Control of Pollution) Act,
1974 (Water Act)
• The Air (Prevention & Control of Pollution) Act, 1974
(Air Act)
• The Indian Forests Act, 1927 (IF Act) (Added on 18th
September 2014)
Acts
31
• The High Level Committee (TSR Subramanian Committee) submitted its
report in November, 2014.
• The main recommendations are :
(a) Enacting a new umbrella Environment Law-
Environment Law (Management) Act (ELMA).
(b) The above Act to provide for setting up of National
Environment Management Authority(NEMA) and
State Environment Management Authority(SEMA).
(c) These Authorities will have sector-wise experts for
appraisal of projects.
(d) Setting up of a National level institute on Environment.
32
Main recommendation of HLC
(e) NEMA/SEMA will make recommendations to the Ministry on
environment clearances.
(f) NEMA/SEMA will develop systems for effective monitoring of
compliances.
(g) A national level electronic database to be prepared for
environment and forest parameters.
(h) Integration of various clearances
(i) Integration of provisions of Water and Air act in the new law and
subsequent sub-subsumation of CPCB and SPCB by NEMA and
SEMA.
(j) In total 55 recommendations have been made by HLC.
33
Main recommendation of HLC
Consortium of Ernst & Young LLP and
Shardul Amarchand Mangaldas & Co
appointed as Technical consultant by the
Ministry to examine the Recommendations
of HLC
The Technical Consultant has submitted
inception report, Gap Assessment report
and Best Practices report.
HIGH LEVEL COMMITTEE REPORT
• Amendment in Environment (Protection) Act. Incorporation of civil
penalty provisions in EP Act. A Cabinet Note is under finalisation
after receipt of Ministries comments.
•Notification for integrating of environmental conditions with the
building permission up to 150000 sq. mts.
•To establish Green Platform – to create an authentic, dynamic data
base on 111 environmental parameters for the country.
•To organise country wide workshops on sand mining notifications
for its effective implementation.
WORK IN PROGRESS: TARGETS
35
•Strengthening monitoring mechanism for environmental compliance:
Environmental Audit.
• Setting up of Environment Regulator.: Hon’ble Supreme Court’s Orders.
•Review of projects to be covered under EIA: NGT orders on Bridges,
Metro etc.
• Notification to deal with cases of “Violations”.
• Strengthening of SEIAA/SEAC.
• De-linking EC and Stage-I FC of the linked coal mine with the EC of TPPs on the line of Ultra Mega Power Plants (UMPPs).
• Considering e-auction coal under the domain of firm coal linkage.
WORK IN PROGRESS….
36
Carrying capacity Study for Orissa and Jharkhand mining :
The ICFRE has done study for Jharkhand and submitted its draft final report on 28/03/2016 .
NEERI has done study for Orissa.
River basin Study:
Carrying capacity study and cumulative impact assessment of River Basins
WORK IN PROGRESS….
37
1. Questions on environmental clearance granted in
different sectors/ states.
2. Pending Cabinet Note and Draft bill on introducing
civil penalty.
3. Notification on Construction and Violation.
4. Questions on HLC Report.
ISSUES LIKELY TO BE RAISED IN PARLIAMENT
38