Bringing Science to Life
Impact Modeling of Lightweight AutomotiveStructures
Srdan Simunovic and Joseph CarpenterOak Ridge National Laboratory
U.S. Department of Energy
http://www-explorer.ornl.gov
Bringing Science to Life
Outline
• Background• Related Crash Modeling Projects• AIV Project Status• Future Work
Bringing Science to Life
Vehicle Structural Impact
• One of the most complex engineering problems• Current design trends compound complexity
– smaller, lightweight, energy-efficient vehicles– reduction of fuel consumption and pollution– integrated structural design - less structural redundancy
• Computational design optimization requiresaccurate, predictive crash models that incorporatematerial related effects
Bringing Science to Life
Impact Modeling Problems
• Lack of experimental data for dynamic loadingconditions
• Lack of comprehensive studies integratingexperiments, material modeling, and FEMtechnology
• Computational requirements for predictivemodeling can quickly become prohibitive
Bringing Science to Life
Aluminum Vehicle Modeling Objective
• Develop detailed crashworthiness model ofaluminum intensive vehicle using computationalsimulations
• Developed model will be used as a simulationplatform for evaluation and prediction of theeffects of advanced manufacturing and materialsprocessing techniques in automotive impactconditions
Bringing Science to Life
Related Crash Modeling Projects
Bringing Science to Life
Composite Materials Modeling
• Composite materials modeling technology lags behindmodeling of metallic materials
• Only approximate analysis and modeling of compositematerials is practical
• Industry needs tools that will permit design and evaluationof crash-critical polymer composite structures
• Tools should satisfy a wide range of applications including– preliminary design and sizing– detailed final structural design– post-production failure analysis
Bringing Science to Life
Material Modeling of Carbon Fiber Composites
• Random carbon fiber architecture
• New Owens-Corning high-volumeP-4A fabrication process
• Constitutive material model basedon micromechanics
Bringing Science to Life
Successful Crash of Composite Vehicle
• Crash test hassatisfied allNHTSA safetystandards
• Design based oncomputationalmodeling usingdevelopedmaterial models
Bringing Science to Life
Bringing Science to Life
Development of SUV Model
• The U.S. passenger vehicle fleet is substantiallydifferent today than it was 20 years ago
• Among all new passenger vehicle registrations,the proportion of cars significantly declinedcompared to SUVs and pick-up trucks
• Developed SUV model is used for NHTSA U.S.car fleet compatibility study
Bringing Science to Life
Bringing Science to Life
ULSAB Modeling Study• Project Objective
– To further pursue the lightweight steel auto body design– To investigate and document the effects of advanced material processing,
forming and joining techniques on structural performance in high strainrate deformation conditions
• Project Deliverables and Impact on Industry– Advance predictive modeling capabilities to aid in accelerated vehicle
design development– Integrate material processing into structural simulation model– Evaluate influence of forming conditions of high strength steels on vehicle
impact properties– Evaluate compatibility of new vehicle design with the existing U.S. car
fleet
Bringing Science to Life
UltraLight Auto Steel Body
• Developed by AISIand PorscheEngineering
• Utilizes new steelprocessingtechnologies andmaterials
• Employs holisticdesign approach
Bringing Science to Life
ULSAB Components
Front Rails Body Side Outer Spare Tire Tub
Hydroformed Roof Rail Floorpan
Bringing Science to Life
ULSAB Compatibility Study
• Ford Taurus - ULSABfrontal impact
• Speed of both vehiclesis 35 mph
• Simulation showscomparabledeformation andcomponent stackingsequence
Bringing Science to Life
Crashworthiness Study of Lightweight Aluminum Automotive Structures
Bringing Science to Life
Objective
• Develop detailed crashworthiness model ofaluminum intensive vehicle using computationalsimulations
• Developed model will be used as a simulationplatform for evaluation and prediction of theeffects of advanced manufacturing and materialsprocessing techniques in automotive impactconditions
Bringing Science to Life
Project Schedule - Phase 1
1. Select existing representative aluminum intensive vehicle (AIV)2. Procure selected vehicle3. Develop geometric representation of the vehicle4. Scan vehicle geometry using coordinate measurement device5. Develop three-dimensional CAD vehicle model6. Create finite element model of the AIV using the scanned geometry7. Develop a modeling environment that will allow for easy generation of
vehicle models for different loading conditions8. Develop computer environment that will allow for easy design
modifications and material crashworthiness evaluations9. Perform basic model verification
Bringing Science to Life
Project Schedule - Phase 2
10. Perform computational simulations of collisionsof the developed model for the AIV and variousobstacles and vehicles
11. Experimentally test the AIV crash performance12. Verify the accuracy of the model against the
experimental data13. Perform model modifications14. Document the developments and findings
Bringing Science to Life
Project Status
• Developed CAD model for the vehicle• Developed WWW interface for the CAD model• Obtained additional space-frame from Audi for
analysis• FEM meshing is under way
– expected completion date: 9/1/99– FEM model for the vehicle front will be used to
develop impact test for the vehicle space-frame
• Crash test has been scheduled
Bringing Science to Life
Vehicle Disassembly and Scanning
Exterior geometry is usedas reference for internal parts
Internal components arescanned as vehicle isdisassembled
Bringing Science to Life
WWWinterface hasbeendeveloped formanagementof scannedgeometry
Bringing Science to Life
Sub-modelsfor left side,right side, andthe entirevehicle areavailable
Bringing Science to Life
Structuralsubsystemscan bemodified andinvestigatedseparately
Bringing Science to Life
Audi Electronic Service Information System
• Provided by Audi
• Scannedgeometry isreferenced tophysical parts
Bringing Science to Life
Front Lower Rails
• Main energyabsorbers
• Front tube slidesinto tube housing
• Design preventsoscillations inforces duringimpact
Bringing Science to Life
FEM Model of Main Rails
Bringing Science to Life
FEM Model - Energy Absorber Detail 1
• Model usesparametricFEM approach
• Modelcharacteristicscan be quicklymodified
Bringing Science to Life
FEM Model - Energy Absorber Detail 2
Bringing Science to Life
Future Work
• Finalize front FEM model• Simulate impact conditions for crash test• Test space-frame (vehicle)• Develop FEM model for the entire vehicle• Validate the model against the NHTSA crash data• Perform vehicle-to-vehicle crash simulations