Impact of financial literacy in optimising financial
inclusion in rural Southinclusion in rural South AfricaAfrica
Case study of the Eastern Cape Province
Mishi SydenVacu NomfundoChipote PreciousChipote Precious
1African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
IntroductionIntroduction About 37% of South Africa’s adults did not have access to About 37% of South Africa s adults did not have access to
banking services in 2010 and the majority of informal businesses have limited access to
f l fi i (OECD 2012)formal financing, (OECD, 2012).
Definitions: Financial Inclusion is the delivery of banking services at
affordable costs to disadvantaged and low incomegroups including households, enterprises, SMEs and traders;g p g , p , ;Pawar, Kumar, Joshi & Chawla (2011)
CFI defines financial inclusion as a state in which all peopleCFI defines financial inclusion as a state in which all peoplehave access to a full suite of quality financial services,provided at affordable prices, in a convenient manner, andwith dignity for the clients.with dignity for the clients.
African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
2
ContCont….
• Types of financial exclusion include (i) exclusion from payment system(i) exclusion from payment system(ii) exclusion from formal credit
k tmarketsExclusion may be due to: c us o ay be due to• Unbearable costs• Lack of know how
African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
3
ContCont…..
• Gardeva and Rhyne (2011)- CFI expands itsd fi iti t t th t f ll i l i i thdefinition to note that full inclusion requires theclients of these services to be financially literate.
• Financial inclusion definition that have been• Financial inclusion definition that have beenadopted in most cases lack the component offinancial literacyfinancial literacy.
• Financial literacy is thought to enable unlockingof other dimensions of financial inclusion e.g.of other dimensions of financial inclusion e.g.prevention of over indebtedness
African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
4
• Access and use of services needs:– Understanding and independence for g p
consumers
5African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
Strategies employed by financial institutions to enhance financial
inclusion in South Africainclusion in South Africa.• consumer education -social responsibility,
d k ti t t t b k l kand marketing strategy -most banks look back to the unbanked populace for growth and sustainabilityand sustainability. – Financial literacy programs such as:
• Be Financially Smart administered by FNB;Be Financially Smart administered by FNB;• Bubomi governed by ABSA• Teach Children to Save SA
J i A hi t SA• Junior Achievement SA• VISA Fin. Literacy drama.
African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
6
• Innovations to expand access to banking• Innovations to expand access to banking, thus enhancing financial inclusion include:
domestic mone transfer s stemso domestic money transfer systems.o payment via prepaid cards.
using community banking mobile bankingo using community banking mobile banking accountM Pesao M-Pesa
• Increase in infrastructure- ATMs, bank branches
• Financial inclusion may also be thought to involve y gaccess to the financial infrastructure by all the population groups and ages.
African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
7
Figure 6: Financial InfrastructureFigure 6: Financial Infrastructure developmentp
60
70
Financial Infrastructure in South Africa
50
60
Automated teller machines (ATMs) (per 100,000 adults)
30
40
20
Commercial bank branches (per 100,000 adults)
0
10
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
8
ContCont…
• Although there are noticeable efforts forfinancial inclusion in South Africa, the,question still remains: can financialliteracy programmes be utilized inliteracy programmes be utilized inoptimizing financial inclusion?
African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
9
Year and Arguments Conclusions; takeYear and Author
Arguments Conclusions; take home
Leeladhar identified three priority areas for access to banking access Leeladhar (2005)
identified three priority areas for the purpose of financial inclusion
access to banking, access to affordable credit and access to free face-to-face money advice
Sarma and Pais (2008)
Data for 49 countries was used and three basic dimensions of financial inclusion – accessibility,
il bili d f b ki
income inequality, adult literacy and urbanisation- important f i l i i availability and usage of banking
services were utilizedfactors in explaining financial inclusion
Oseifuang (2010)
studied the level of financial lit d it i t th
level of financial literacy th (2010) literacy and its impact on youth
entrepreneurship in South Africa (Vhembe District)
among youth entrepreneurs in Vhembe District is above average
Sarma (2010) while the importance of financial multidimensional index Sarma (2010) while the importance of financial inclusion is widely recognized, the literature lacks a comprehensive measure that can be used to
multidimensional index of financial inclusion (IFI)
measure the extent of financial inclusion across economies 10African Development Finance
Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August 2012
Year and Author
Arguments Conclusions; take homeAuthor take home
Kudva (2012)
financial inclusion initiatives give people
i d
financial inclusion and financial li f
financial literacy programmes need
h d iaccess to organized financial services, the lack of knowledge has resulted in sub-optimal
literacy form two sides of a coin with inclusion activities giving the push
to go hand-in-hand with financial inclusion initiatives to create resulted in sub optimal
impact in using this opportunity and in some cases proven
t d ti ith
giving the push and literacy programmes creating the pull f fi i l
initiatives to create the pull for accessing formal channels of ficounterproductive with
the creation of debt traps.for financial services
finance
Sajeev and Thangavel
impact of Self Helping Groups (SHG) on
study indicates that financial Thangavel
(2012) Groups (SHG) on financial inclusion
that financial education can enhance the link between SHG banking and Financial inclusion11African Development Finance
Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August 2012
Based on literature reviewed, several factors have need identified as central to financial inclusion
12African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
Methodology and Estimation Techniques
• The study employs quantile and OLSregression, influenced by the works ofg , yKoenker and Bassett (1978), Chen (2005);and Sangwan (2008) respectivelyand Sangwan (2008) respectively.
• The key variables in the model aref ffinancial inclusion and financialliteracy.y
African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
13
Methodology and Estimation Techniques Cont.
African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
14
Methodology and Estimation Techniques Cont.
African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
15
Discussion of data and variables
• South African Labour and DevelopmentResearch Unit-2008 National IncomeDynamics Study (NIDS) data is used toexamine access to banks in South Africaexamine access to banks in South Africa.
• For the purposes of this paper, theanalysis is based on adults who have bankaccounts.
African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
16
Discussion of data and variables ContCont.
• Financial Inclusion:• The data was obtained from Eastern CapeThe data was obtained from Eastern Cape
Socio-Economic Consultative Council;NIDS wave 1 2008; individual bankNIDS wave 1 2008; individual bankwebsites; IMF and World Bank databank.
African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
17
bankaccess Freq. Percent Cum.
2 10 601 68 04 100 00 1 4,980 31.96 31.96
2 10,601 68.04 100.00
Total 15,581 100.00
18African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
Discussion of data and variables ContCont.
• Financial Literacy -defined as familiaritywith/understanding of financial marketgproducts, rewards, risks & make informeddecisionsdecisions.
• Ability to grow, monitor, effectively usef ffinancial resources for economic securityof self, family & business.y
African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
19
Discussion of data and variables ContCont.
• Literacy rate: two variables will be usedto measure the literacy rate.y– 1). Ability to manage money by the adult,
2) Ability of the adult to read English– 2). Ability of the adult to read English-Respondent's reading level in English wasused as the second proxy for literacy levelused as the second proxy for literacy level.
African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
20
Trends in financial literacy levels in Eastern cape
70.0%
80.0%
Trends in Literacy levels in Eastern Cape 1996
1997
1998
1999
30.0%
40.0%
50.0%
60.0%
erac
y Le
vels
1999
2000
2001
2002
0.0%
10.0%
20.0%
30.0%
Cacadu Amatole Chris Hani Ukhahlamba O.R.Tambo Alfred Nzo
Lite 2003
2004
2005
2006Eastern Cape Province District Municipalities 2007
2008
2009
20102010
African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
21
Figure 2: Literacy level and access to Banks in South Africato Banks in South Africa
Ability to Manage Money and Bank Access in South Africa
33.04% 26.21%14.02%
1 2 3
66.96% 73.79%85.98%
15.91% 11.32%
4 5
84.09% 88.68%
1 2
Ability to manage money as a proxy for Literacy levelSouth African Household Data: NIDS SURVEY 2008
African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
22
1 2
Ability to Read in English and Bank Access in South Africa
31 03%
1 2
46.53%53.47%
31.03%
68.97%
3 4
22.8% 13.53%
77.2% 86.47%
1 2Ability to read in english as a proxy for Literacy level
23
Ability to read in english as a proxy for Literacy levelSouth African Household Data: NIDS SURVEY 2008
African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
Figure 5: Access to Banks byFigure 5: Access to Banks by Employment status and Population
groupAccess to Bank by Employment status
1 2
38.65%
22.42%
61.35%
77.58%
1 21 2
Graphs by RECODE of w1_a_e1 (e1 - Employment status)Source: South African Household Survey Data: NIDS Wave1 2008
African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
24
25African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
f l l l• Bringing financial services to rural clients is one of the biggest challenges in the quest for broad-gg g qbased financial inclusion.
26African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
Figure 3: Access to banks by locationlocation
Access to Bank by Geographical Location
28.67%17.27%
RURAL FORMAL TRIBAL AUTHORITY AREAS
71.33%82.73%
27 51%
URBAN FORMAL URBAN INFORMAL
47.74%52.26%
27.51%
72.49%
1 2
Graphs by Geo-typep y ypSource: South African Household Survey Data: NIDS Wave1 2008
African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
27
Results and DiscussionResults and DiscussionPercentile 0 0 0 0 0 0
.10 .20 .30 .40 .50 .60 .70 .80 .90 .95
Coef. . . . . . Coef. .
.2349339
.
.4452735
.
.4475134
.
.6321857 .400192
.
.4615741 .4221021 .7533334 1.314768
1.49052
p vale 0 0 0 0 0 0p-vale 0
.229
0
.023
0
.054
0
.010 .208
0
.092 .337 .229 .000
0
.000
The values of ᶐ1 are positive and increased as the percentile increase. there is significant positive effect of literacy percentage on the 90ththere is significant positive effect of literacy percentage on the 90and 95th percentiles of the conditional distribution of access to bank through bank accounts per 100 people given the literacy rate.
28African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
• If the different areas are ranked with similar literacy
percentage, in increasing order of the number of accounts per
100 people, then:
– if a district is among the top 10 percent in that list, an increase ing p p ,
literacy percentage can help further improve the financial inclusion in that
district (local municipality).
– Deductively, increase in literacy percentage does not necessarily imply
significant improvement in financial inclusion in every district, especially if
not part of the top 10 percent districts in terms of access to finance (i.e.
financial inclusion).
29African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
Model Dependent Constant Income Literacy1 Literacy2 Education R2 Model Dependent
Variable
Constant Income Literacy1 Literacy2 Education R2
1. Bank Account 2.027 -.143 .052 - -.000 0.18
(0.000) (0.000) (0.000) (0.313)
2. Bank Account 1.901
(0.000)
-.127
(0.000)
- .078
(0.000)
-.003
(0.000)
0.21
(0.000) (0.000) (0.000) (0.000)
3. Bank Account 1.869
(0.000)
-.112
(0.000)
.043
(0.000)
.107
(0.000)
-.001
(0.001)
0.23
Literacy1, being the ability of one to manage money, and thus abetter measure for financial literacy will increase access to banksby 5% per unit increase in the measure of the literacy levels. Theby 5% per unit increase in the measure of the literacy levels. Thesecond measure for literacy,literacy2- the ability to read in English, which can be associatedwith better education has a higher impact or about 8%
30
with better education, has a higher impact or about 8%.African Development Finance
Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August 2012
• Contrary to literature, per capita
income and level of education has a
ti ff t t b k Thnegative effect on access to bank. The
results further indicate that bothresults further indicate that, both
literacy measures explain access toy p
banks better, 23 %.31African Development Finance
Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August 2012
Part 2: Proposed SurveyPart 2: Proposed Survey
• Peddie• IdutywaIdutywa• Stutterheim • Cholumna
32African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
Preliminary Survey results: Qualitative analysis
• 93 percent said they have opened accounts after receiving some form of financial literacy training. “ if you don’t have someone to talk to you about … if you don t have someone to talk to you about these things, how do you know what to do … banks and schools are helping us understand better”, p g ,female respondent from Peddie.
• knowledge transfer from school children to parents have been rated highly
• about 62% cited the distance to the nearest bank as a discouragement. The cost for taxi fare, the danger for thieves and time waiting in a queue,
33African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
b 30% i di h h h h h d • about 30% indicate that even though they have managed to open bank accounts, managing and sustaining them is a great challenge- bank fees
• “The banks in South Africa have become a luxury and a thing for the well off…” unemployed youth (Male) respondent in Idutywa communityIdutywa community.
• about 70% indicated that they do not trust banks can handle their accounts well without them getting banks statements f h b k ( h i bil b ki d i from the bank (they are against mobile banking, despite acknowledging its usefulness)
• there is a belief that services like e-wallet have enabled many yto use banking services without having the hustles of opening accounts with a bank. Such individuals are financially included but it may be technical impossible to account for included, but it may be technical impossible to account for such financial inclusion.
34African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
Measurement issuesMeasurement issues
• Dormant accounts- how to account for theses
• E-wallet- can we include this• …
African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012
35
Policy Recommendations and Conclusion
’ i h li l l l d i• paper’s aim was to assess how literacy levels relate and impact on access to banks in South Africa, focusing on Eastern Cape Province
– level of literacy is significantly positively related to access to bank by individuals– Africans lag behind with regard to access to banks in South Africa.
• this points to a rich niche market for banks in South Africa in the form of the many unbanked rural populace
– the measure for financial inclusion has its weakness exposed here; -– the measure for financial inclusion has its weakness exposed here; -actually there is more measurement exclusion rather than financial exclusion in South Africa
– However, the inclusiveness that is available does not warranty access to loans, , y ,for start-up capital (for example).
– The reported results should however be interpreted with great care, as bank dormancy was not catered for in our analysis. Also it is imperative to note that it is now five years since the NIDS survey was conducted (second wave recently released may present a platform for comparisons over time) and thus there could be variations with the current status quo, given some stepped up efforts by banks to educate the unbanked populationto educate the unbanked population.
36African Development Finance Workshop, USB,RSA, 7-8 August
2012