1
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
ORLANDO DIVISION
JAMES J. ABOLTIN, et al.,
Plaintiffs.
v.
JEUNESSE, LLC, et al.,
Defendants,
Civil No. 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS
HELEN XIONG’S NOTICE OF APPEAL
Notice is hereby given that Objector Helen Xiong appeals to the Eleventh Circuit
United States Court of Appeals from the Final Judgment of this Court entered on January
8, 2019 (Dkt. 292) and from any and all other judgments, orders, opinions, rulings, and
findings pertinent or ancillary to the foregoing including the Court’s Oral findings made
at the hearing on January 8, 2019. The Final Order being appealed from is attached
hereto as Exhibit 1.
Payment of the required fee of $505, representing the $500 fee for docketing a
case on appeal specified in 28 U.S.C. § 1913, and the $5 fee for filing a notice of appeal
specified in 28 U.S.C. § 1917, is provided with this Notice of Appeal.
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 1 of 50 PageID 2532
2
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED this 9th day of January 2019.
*
p
u
r
/s/ Lawrence J. Gibney, Jr.
Lawrence J. Gibney, Jr. (FL Bar No. 435211)
Law Office of L. Jack Gibney
8777 San Jose Blvd #502
Jacksonville, FL 32217
Telephone: (904) 443-7770
Fax: (904) 443-7769
Email: [email protected]
/s/ Blake J. Lindemann
Blake J. Lindemann
(pro hac vice)
California Bar No. 255747
E-mail: [email protected]
LINDEMANN LAW FIRM, APC
433 N. Camden Drive, 4th Floor
Beverly Hills, CA 90210
Telephone No: 310-279-5269
Facsimile No: 310-300-0267
Counsel For Objector
Helen Xiong
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 2 of 50 PageID 2533
3
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing document
was served upon all counsel of record via the Court’s ECF system on January 9, 2019.
By: /s/ Nataly Grande
Nataly Grande
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 3 of 50 PageID 2534
1
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT MIDDLE DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
ORLANDO DIVISION
James J. Aboltin and Pamela J. Knight, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated, Plaintiffs, v. Jeunesse, LLC aka Jeunesse Global, Inc., a Florida limited liability company, MLM Mafia, Inc., a Nevada Corporation, Online Communications, LLC, a Wyoming limited liability company, Wendy R. Lewis, an individual, Ogale “Randy” Ray, an individual, Scott A. Lewis, an individual, Kim Hui, an individual, Jason Caramanis, an individual, Alex Morton, an individual, Kevin Giguere, an individual, John and Jane Does 1-100, individual natural persons, and ABC Corporations, Companies, and/or Partnerships 1-20, Defendants.
Case No. 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-KRS
ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR FINAL APPROVAL OF CLASS ACTION SETTLEMENT
AND NOW, upon consideration of Plaintiffs’ Motion for Final Approval of Class
Action Settlement and all supporting materials, and the proposed Settlement Agreement
between Plaintiffs James J. Aboltin and Pamela J. Knight (collectively “Plaintiffs”), and
Defendants Jeunesse, LLC (a/k/a Jeunesse Global, Inc.), a Florida limited liability
company (hereafter “Jeunesse”); Wendy R. Lewis; Ogale “Randy” Ray; Scott A. Lewis;
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 292 Filed 01/09/19 Page 1 of 13 PageID 2519Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 4 of 50 PageID 2535
2
Kim Hui; and Kevin Giguere (collectively, “Settling Defendants,” 1 and together with
Plaintiffs, the “Parties”), IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED:
1. Unless defined herein, all capitalized terms in this Order shall have the
same meanings as set forth in the Settlement Agreement.
2. Following a hearing on the Plaintiffs’ Motion for Preliminary Approval of
Class Action Settlement on September 12, 2018, the Court granted the Motion; found that
the terms and conditions of the Settlement Agreement were within the range of
reasonableness for preliminary approval; conditionally certified a settlement class
pursuant to Rule 23(a), (b)(2), and (b)(3) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure; and
directed that notice of the Settlement be issued to potential members of the Settlement
Class in accordance with the Settlement’s notice plan (Dkt. No. 264). The Settlement
notice provided members of the Settlement Class with information about the litigation and
settlement; an opportunity to submit claims; and a manner to exclude themselves from
the Settlement Class or voice objections.
3. On January 8, 2018, the Court held a Final Approval Hearing at the United
States District Court for the Middle District of Florida, allowing the Parties, members of
1 Three named defendants in this matter—Alex Morton, Jason Caramanis, and MLM
Mafia, Inc., a company controlled by Mr. Caramanis—are not parties to the Settlement Agreement. Intentionally, however, the Release provided for in the Settlement Agreement, set forth below in Paragraph 24, extends to all claims that Plaintiffs and the Settlement Class have against all Defendants, including Mr. Morton, Mr. Caramanis, and MLM Mafia, Inc. The term “Defendants,” as used herein, means all Defendants whom Plaintiffs sued in this matter. Because this Order of Final Approval, and the Settlement’s release provision, resolve all claims of Plaintiffs and the Settlement Class against all Defendants, the Court separately will issue an Order terminating this lawsuit with prejudice against all Defendants.
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 292 Filed 01/09/19 Page 2 of 13 PageID 2520Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 5 of 50 PageID 2536
3
the Settlement Class, and other interested parties to be heard on all issues related to the
proposed Settlement.
4. The findings below are based on the Court’s review of the record and
arguments of counsel.
Final Approval of Settlement Agreement
5. The Court approves the terms and conditions set forth in Settlement
Agreement, including all exhibits thereto, finding them to be fair, reasonable, adequate,
and in the best interests of the Settlement Class Members. The Court expressly
incorporates the Settlement Agreement, including all exhibits thereto, into this Final Order
and Judgment. The Settlement Agreement resulted from arm’s-length negotiations
between the parties, including via in-person, Court-ordered mediation overseen by an
experienced mediator. The Court has considered the current posture of this litigation and
the risks and benefits to the Parties involved in both settlement of these claims and
continuation of the litigation. The Court finds that the Settlement represents a reasonable
compromise of disputed legal and factual issues.
6. The Parties are ordered to implement each and every obligation set forth in
the Settlement Agreement in accordance with the terms and conditions of the Agreement
without delay.
Certification of the Settlement Class, Continued Appointment of Class Counsel and Settlement Class Representatives
7. Pursuant to Rule 23(a), (b)(2), and (b)(3) of the Federal Rules of Civil
Procedure, the Court conditionally certifies, for settlement purposes only, the following
Settlement Class:
all Distributors of Jeunesse—persons who executed a contract with Jeunesse providing the opportunity to sell or resell Jeunesse products
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 292 Filed 01/09/19 Page 3 of 13 PageID 2521Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 6 of 50 PageID 2537
4
and/or to sponsor other persons to do so; paying for a “starter kit” of materials to facilitate this business opportunity; directly or indirectly holding a position in the Jeunesse genealogy of Distributors, and/or purchasing Jeunesse products at the discounted prices available only to Jeunesse distributors— between January 1, 2010, and September 12, 2018. Excluded from the Settlement Class are the Defendants, Defendants’ employees, and Defendants’ family members.
8. Based on the facts and the evidence in the record, the Court finds, for
settlement purposes only, that the litigation as to the claims against the Settling
Defendants meet all prerequisites of Rule 23(a), (b)(2), and (b)(3) of the Federal Rules of
Civil Procedure, including that:
a. The Settlement Class is so numerous that joinder of all members is
impracticable;
b. There are questions of law or fact common to the Settlement Class;
c. Plaintiffs’ claims are typical of the claims of the Settlement Class
Members;
d. Plaintiffs and their counsel are capable of fairly and adequately
protecting the interests of the Settlement Class;
e. With respect to the injunctive portions of the Settlement Agreement,
the Court finds that the Settling Defendants allegedly have acted or
refused to act on grounds generally applicable to the Settlement
Class, thereby making appropriate final injunctive relief or
corresponding declaratory relief with respect to the Settlement Class
as a whole;
f. With respect to the non-injunctive portions of the Settlement
Agreement, the Court finds that common questions of law and fact
predominate over questions affecting only individual Settlement
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 292 Filed 01/09/19 Page 4 of 13 PageID 2522Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 7 of 50 PageID 2538
5
Class Members and accordingly, the Settlement Class is sufficiently
cohesive to warrant settlement by representation; and that
certification of the Settlement Class is superior to other available
methods for the fair and efficient resolution of the claims of the
Settlement Class.
9. Class Certification is for settlement purposes only, and is conditioned upon
this Final Order and Judgment becoming Final, the terms of the Settlement Agreement,
and the occurrence of the Effective Date.
10. The Court confirms the appointment of Plaintiffs James J. Aboltin and
Pamela J. Knight as the Settlement Class Representatives. The Court finds that each
has adequately discharged their duties to represent the best interests of the Class.
11. The Court finds that Jonathan S. Batchelor, of Jonathan Batchelor, PLC,
and David Ferrucci and John P. Desmond, of Dickinson Wright, PLLC, have fairly and
adequately represented the interests of the Class, and confirms their appointment as Co-
Lead Class Counsel for the Settlement Class. The Court finds that each has adequately
discharged their duties to represent the best interests of the Class.
Notice to Settlement Class Members Satisfies Due Process
12. The Court previously considered and approved the notice plan set forth in
the Settlement Agreement and the notices appended as exhibits to the Settlement
Agreement, and finds that the method of providing notice fully satisfies the requirements
of due process, the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, and constitutes the best notice
practicable under the circumstances, and shall constitute due and sufficient notice to all
persons entitled thereto.
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 292 Filed 01/09/19 Page 5 of 13 PageID 2523Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 8 of 50 PageID 2539
6
13. The Court finds that the notice specified above was issued by the
Settlement Administrator in accordance with the Court’s Order Granting Plaintiffs’ Motion
for Preliminary Approval of Class Action Settlement (Dkt. No. 264). See Declaration of
Ricky Borges of Epiq Class Action & Claims Solutions, Inc. (Dkt. No. 285-1) (“Borges
Decl.”), ¶¶ 5-8.
14. The Court has reviewed the declaration filed by Mr. Borges and finds that,
to date, the Settlement Administrator has fulfilled its responsibilities as set forth in the
Settlement Agreement. The Settlement Administrator is directed to implement each and
every obligation set forth in the Settlement Agreement in accordance with the terms and
provisions of the Settlement Agreement.
Requests for Exclusion
15. The Settlement Administrator has filed a list of 21 Settlement Class
Members who timely submitted written request to be excluded from the Settlement Class.
See Borges Decl., ¶10, Ex. 3.
16. The Court directs that the above-referenced persons and entities are not
bound by the Settlement Agreement or this Final Order and Judgment, including the
Release.
Objections and Other Opposition to the Settlement
17. One objection to the Settlement was made, by Helen Xiong. See Dkt. No.
284.
18. The Court finds that Ms. Xiong opted out of the Settlement Class by
submitting a request to be excluded, dated November 26, 2018. See Dkt. No. 284-3
(Xiong opt-out form); Borges Decl., ¶10, Ex. 3 (listing Xiong as opt out number 19).
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 292 Filed 01/09/19 Page 6 of 13 PageID 2524Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 9 of 50 PageID 2540
7
19. As such, Ms. Xiong lacks standing to object to the Settlement. A “successful
opt-out” like Ms. Xiong “cannot also file an objection to the Settlement.” Jones v. United
Healthcare Servs., Inc., No., 0:15-cv-61144-RLR, 2016 WL 8738256, at *4 (S.D. Fla.
Sept. 22, 2016). See also, e.g., Zamora v. Lyft, Inc., No. 16-cv-2558-VC, 2018 WL
58119511, at *1 (N.D. Cal. Nov. 6, 2018) (class member “cannot both object and opt out
under the terms of the settlement”). “[I]t is well established that class members may either
object or opt out, but they cannot do both.” Carter v. Forjas Taurus S.A., No. 1:13-CV-
24583-PAS, 2018 WL 3982489, at *13 (S.D. Fla. July 22, 2016), quoting Newberg on
Class Actions § 13.23 (5th ed.) (“Class members who opt out of the class…are no longer
considered class members, and hence Rule 23 does not give them standing to object to
the settlement.”).
20. Although Ms. Xiong lacks standing to object to the Settlement, the Court
has considered Ms. Xiong’s substantive arguments and finds them to lack merit. Among
other things, the Court concludes that it has the ability to approve a release applicable to
Distributors based in California.
21. Truth in Advertising.Org (“TINA”) has also filed an amicus curiae brief
expressing concerns with the Settlement (Dkt. No. 284) similar to Ms. Xiong’s, as well as
other arguments, including that the Settlement would not suffice to pay all claims, and
that the Settlement should not have included a claims process. Based on the Court’s
review of the record, the funds exist to pay claimants without resorting to pro rata
reductions. The Court also concludes that a claims process was necessary to the
Settlement, and that the process was fair, reasonable and adequate under the
circumstances.
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 292 Filed 01/09/19 Page 7 of 13 PageID 2525Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 10 of 50 PageID 2541
8
Dismissal of Claims
22. All Released Claims in the operative Complaint are dismissed with
prejudice.
Release
23. The Court approves the Release set forth in Section 8 of the Settlement
Agreement and repeated, for clarity’s sake, immediately below.
24. As of the Effective Date and in consideration of this Settlement Agreement
and the benefits extended to the Class, the Defendants and all of its and their present
and former, direct and indirect, subsidiaries, parents, affiliates, incorporated or
unincorporated entities, divisions, groups, officers, directors, shareholders, partners,
partnerships, joint ventures, employees, agents, servants, assignees, successors,
insurers, indemnitees, attorneys, transferees, and/or representatives, and all Distributors,
shall be released and forever discharged by the Class Representatives, for themselves
and as the representatives of each Settlement Class Member; each Settlement Class
Member on behalf of himself or herself; and their respective present and former, direct
and indirect, subsidiaries, parents, affiliates, incorporated or unincorporated entities,
divisions, groups, officers, directors, shareholders, partners, partnerships, joint ventures,
employees, agents, servants, assignees, successors, insurers, indemnitees, attorneys,
transferees, and/or representatives (collectively, the “Releasing Parties”) from all claims,
demands, rights, liabilities, suits, or causes of action, known or unknown, as of the
Effective Date, that (1) were or could have been asserted in the complaints filed in this
Action, or (2) are based upon, arise out of, or reasonably relate to, the claims asserted in
the Action. This definition of “Released Claims” specifically extends to any allegation that,
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 292 Filed 01/09/19 Page 8 of 13 PageID 2526Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 11 of 50 PageID 2542
9
during the Class Period, Jeunesse or any Distributor engaged in any acts of unfair
competition; false and/or misleading advertising; or operated any type of illegal, pyramid,
endless chain, or fraudulent scheme.
25. Upon the Effective Date, Settlement Class Members shall be deemed to
have, and by operation of this Final Order and Judgment shall have, fully, finally, and
forever settled and released any and all of the Released Claims, whether known or
unknown, suspected or unsuspected, contingent or non-contingent, which now exist, or
heretofore have existed, upon any theory of law or equity now existing or coming into
existence in the future, for damages, injunctive relief, rescission, disgorgement, or
restitution or any other right, remedy, or relief of every nature and description whatsoever,
whether based on federal, state, local, statutory or common law or any other law, rule, or
regulation, including the law of any jurisdiction outside the United States, that were
brought or could have been brought in the complaints in this Action without regard to the
subsequent discovery or existence of such different or additional facts.
Claims Administration
26. The Court orders the Parties and the Settlement Administrator to perform
their obligations pursuant to the terms of the Settlement Agreement.
27. Consistent with Section 4.15 of the Settlement Agreement, the Court orders
that no disbursements from Available Settlement Funds shall be made prior to this Final
Order and Judgment becoming Final.
Attorneys’ Fees and Costs and Service Awards
28. The Settlement Agreement allowed Class Counsel to apply to the Court for
an award of attorneys’ fees and reimbursement of their expenses and costs from the
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 292 Filed 01/09/19 Page 9 of 13 PageID 2527Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 12 of 50 PageID 2543
10
Settlement Fund as a percentage of the entire value of settlement, including monetary
and the value of the equitable relief, and, as a common fund, in accordance with
applicable law.
29. The Court finds that Class Counsel’s efforts litigating this case and securing
the pool of settlement benefits defined in the Settlement Agreement have benefited the
members of the Settlement Class and that they should be compensated for their time,
effort, risk and expenses advanced.
30. Class counsel have each submitted declarations detailing their time, efforts
and expenses advanced prosecuting this case for the benefit of the Class (Dkt. Nos. 273-
2, 273-3).
31. Based on the foregoing, the Court awards Class Counsel $825,000.00 in
attorneys’ fees and expenses.
32. The Court finds that the amount awarded is fair, adequate and reasonable
pursuant to both the percentage of the benefit and lodestar methods of awarding
attorneys’ fees in class actions.
33. The Settlement Administrator is directed to pay this amount to Class
Counsel from available settlement funds as instructed by Class Counsel and in a manner
and at a time consistent with the Settlement Agreement.
34. Class Counsel has filed a declaration describing each Settlement Class
Representative’s general time and efforts pursuing this litigation for the benefit of the
Settlement Class (Dkt. No. 273-2).
35. The Court finds that the time and effort of the Settlement Class
Representatives benefited the members of the Settlement Class and that Class
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 292 Filed 01/09/19 Page 10 of 13 PageID 2528Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 13 of 50 PageID 2544
11
Representative Service Awards are appropriately awarded to each. A Service Award of
$1,000.00 shall be paid to James J. Aboltin, and a Service Award of $2,500.00 shall be
paid to Pamela J. Knight. The Settlement Administrator is directed to pay these amounts
from available settlement funds in a manner and at a time consistent with the Settlement
Agreement.
Judgment
36. The Court orders that Judgment in the Action be entered on the terms of
the Settlement Agreement as set forth in this Final Order and Judgment and dismisses
all Released Claims and causes of action asserted in the Action, on the merits and with
prejudice, as to the Settlement Class Representatives and all Settlement Class Members.
This dismissal is without cost to any party, except as specifically provided in the
Settlement Agreement.
37. Without affecting the finality of this Final Order and Judgment, the Court
retains jurisdiction in the Action over: (a) implementation and enforcement of the
Settlement Agreement, until such time as the final judgment contemplated hereby has
become effective and each and every act agreed to be performed by the parties hereto
shall have been performed pursuant to the Settlement Agreement, including all payments
set forth thereunder; (b) any other action necessary to conclude this settlement and
implement the Settlement Agreement; and (c) the administration, consummation,
enforcement, and interpretation of the Settlement Agreement, and for any other
necessary purpose.
38. The Court finds that no just reason exists for delay in entering this Judgment
and the Clerk is hereby directed forthwith to enter Judgment in the Action.
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 292 Filed 01/09/19 Page 11 of 13 PageID 2529Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 14 of 50 PageID 2545
12
Remaining Provisions
39. Counsel for the Parties are hereby authorized, without needing further
approval from the Court, to agree to and adopt non-substantive amendments to,
modifications of, and/or expansions of the Settlement Agreement, if such changes are
consistent with this Order and do not limit the rights of any person or Settlement Class
Member entitled to relief under the Settlement Agreement. All substantive amendments,
modifications, and/or expansions shall be submitted to the Court in the form of a joint
motion for approval.
40. No party with standing to do so has objected to the Settlement. Accordingly,
no objector has standing to appeal. Nevertheless, if the Settlement Agreement is
terminated or is not consummated for any reason whatsoever, or if this Final Order does
not become Final, then this Order, including the certification of the Settlement Class and
appointment of Class Representatives and Co-Lead Class Counsel, shall be void and/or
vacated, and this action shall proceed as though the certification and appointments never
occurred, with Plaintiffs and Defendants being deemed to have reserved all their
respective rights to propose or oppose any and all class certification issues.
41. Nothing in this Order shall be construed or used as an admission,
concession, or declaration by or against Defendants for any fault, wrongdoing, breach, or
liability. Nor shall it be construed or used as an admission, concession, or declaration by
or against Plaintiffs or the Members of the Settlement Class that their claims lack merit or
that the relief requested in the operative Complaint in this Action is inappropriate or
improper, or as a waiver by any Party of any claims or defenses he, she, or it may have;
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 292 Filed 01/09/19 Page 12 of 13 PageID 2530Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 15 of 50 PageID 2546
13
nor shall this Order be construed as a finding or conclusion of the Court with respect to
the merit or lack of merit of any claim or defense asserted in the Action.
DONE AND ORDERED in Orlando, Florida on January 9, 2019.
Copies furnished to:
Counsel of Record
Unrepresented Parties
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 292 Filed 01/09/19 Page 13 of 13 PageID 2531Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 16 of 50 PageID 2547
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� ��+)
./0123145678329/0673:;8/3
<=>=?@ABCDAEC?FGHDC?IAJJKL?@ABCDAEC?GM?NKGDAJO?PQDKORJGS
?FTUTV?@QFWXY?NQZ?F[>X?\]?]_aEbac_deafghaYh>
72ijklmn7op7qrsnrttr7;;u7rl7vk
72ttmwnrx7ljy7qsxwr7zvsk7{p7|}~jn7:r�r~~rx7ljy7.vwmtl~vlr7qsxwr73�j�vt7|p78�ml�
70r�vnxy7��6���6���7uvtr7mn7jl�r~7�js~ly72~m�jnv67�y����o������
uvstry7��y����7:v��rlrr~mnw7�:1u4�72�l
70vlr7�mkrxy7����������
7qs~}70r�vnxy7zkvmnlm��75vls~r7j�78smly7���7:v��rlrr~�uj~~s�l
4~wvnm�vlmjn7qs~mtxm�lmjny7�rxr~vk7�srtlmjn
fKOARCAMM
�O�LB?�=?[�GKCAR ~r�~rtrnlrx7i}@ObAJ?gLGMMDL�?hDO�?0m��mntjn7�~mw�l7z;;u7����757urnl~vk72orp678lrp7����7z�jrnm�672�7�����7������������7�v�y7������������7�� ¡¢ ££¤¥¦�§
77@ObAJ?HR©AG?NLDDHEEA?0m��mntjn7�~mw�l7z;;u7����757urnl~vk72orp678lrp7����7z�jrnm�672�7�����7������������7�v�y7������������7/�vmky70�r~~s��mªxm��mntjn«~mw�lp�j�7
7�� ¡¢ ££¤¥¦�§77 ££¤¥¦�§¢£¤¢¬�¢¦¤£®�¡
77�GR?f=?@LB�GRJ?0m��mntjn7�~mw�l67z;;u78smlr7���7���7�rtl7;mir~l}78l7:rnj675°7�����7������������7�v�y7������������7/�vmky7±xrt�jnxªxm��mntjn«~mw�lp�j�7
7�� ¡¢ ££¤¥¦�§77²¥¤¢³ ®¢®�77 ££¤¥¦�§¢£¤¢¬�¢¦¤£®�¡
77�GROCOR?>EGCC?hOCELKGD?qjnvl�vn7|vl��rkj~67z;u7���7�7zj~lkvnx78l67µ���7z�jrnm�672�7�����7������������7�v�y7������������7/�vmky7±jnvl�vnªivl��rkj~�k�p�j�7
7�� ¡¢ ££¤¥¦�§7
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 17 of 50 PageID 2548
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� ��+)
./0123415647883990/:7;1901<71:09647=
88>?@ABCDBEFG?H@ABIJKLMKN8O8PQRSKTTU8VWP8XYZLK8[[\]8\]8_8VT8aNT8bNcR8dL8VYRKSRNKU8dV8 ][efg\f8h\fehh[e\fgi8djk8lffemi]em]]h8_nZNk8oKSNnQpRZqrZQTJQsSZtuLvqJn8
83990/:7;1901<71:09647=88
wxy@zB{Gxy|@}xBIJKLMKN8O8PQRSKTTU8VWP8XYZLK8[[\]8\]8_8VT8aNT8bNcR8dL8VYRKSRNKU8dV8 ][efg\f8_nZNk8c~SZ�~TZpRZqrZQTJQsSZtuLvqJn8
83990/:7;1901<71:09647=
E?@xA�x��
E@HF?@BCDB�Ax���88������������1���1��1������1��1���1������
���������1��������
SKoSKTKQLKR8~��@�x�B�F���GFzB{G@zB�XKK8~JcK8�JS8RRSKTT�8
8�73=13990/:7;88
�@�x�B ¡A¢x�B£FGG¡¤¤xB�XKK8~JcK8�JS8RRSKTT�8
8�73=13990/:7;883990/:7;1901<71:09647=
88C��ABEDB�F}H�A�B�XKK8~JcK8�JS8RRSKTT�8
8�73=13990/:7;88./0123415647883990/:7;1901<71:09647=
88C�A@��@AB¥¤���B{@�¤�F?�GB¦ZqrZQTJQ8§SZtuL8WVV 8XYZLK8[f]]8l\]8©v8KQLSN8PcK8WuJKQZjU8Pª8l\]]fef\ml8m]g«llhe\\m8djk8m]g«mi]em]]h8_nZNk8�JQLuQp~LquKNJSoNqvqJn8
8�73=13990/:7;88./0123415647883990/:7;1901<71:09647=
88>?@ABCDBEFG?H@AB�XKK8~JcK8�JS8RRSKTT�8
83990/:7;1901<71:09647=88
wxy@zB{Gxy|@}xB
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 18 of 50 PageID 2549
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� +�+)
./00123450164712887099:11;<<=>?@AB<=BC@B?=<DE@F
1GH1IJKJLMNLO
PJQLJRRJSTTU11VBWXYZ[\VBX[][_\BX[V[X[aBbY]cVda1
VXeYBfdYgdBVe1h0ij09901kl432l1mjn47o472p08
70o7090jp0813qrstLNSUutROtLNSvJwJuSx0ll0q1y7q01z1{2770j1||}1~�~1}27�1�50H1�0�1�47��1��1~�~��1�~����������1�2��1�~����������1<@>�D?;<@F�B����������1
1�@;FB;<<=>?@A11
�sJLLS�t��O��S�uN�N�Sx0ll0q�1y7q01z1{2770j�1||}1~1h0660794j1�81}279�oo2jq�1�h1���� 1��¡¢��¡���~�1�2��1��¡¢��¡�����1£¤2�l�1¥¥72¦2¤§�0ll0q87q0Hn4¤1
1�@;FB;<<=>?@A11>=B©;EBªDE@11;<<=>?@AB<=BC@B?=<DE@F
11«RNN¬S®SQt°UNuQRS��99¤2j�1±2770pp�1²i7p�1y4j2¦i01z1³n|2�j�}�1~1�1y2l01³237q1²�q1~~p¦1�l712¤o2�1�|1¡¡µ�����µ 1�~¡¢��~�¡~~ 1�2��1�~¡¢��~�¡�¡¡1£¤2�l�1m922nH�i�¶�·27i9§7�99¤2jHn4¤1
1<@>�D?;<@F�B���������11�@;FB;<<=>?@A1
1;<<=>?@AB<=BC@B?=<DE@F11
PJKKuJ�S¹®SPN¬�ºR�LSx0ll0q1y7q01z1{2770j�1||}1~�~1}27�1�501�0�1�47��1��1~�~�����µ�1�~�¢�����~ �1�2��1�~�¢��������1£¤2�l�1»»2n4394j§x0ll0qy7q0Hn4¤1
1�@;FB;<<=>?@A11>=B©;EBªDE@11;<<=>?@AB<=BC@B?=<DE@F
11PJLLtL¼RST®S½QuOS¾S«««S��99¤2j�1±2770pp�1²i7p�1y4j2¦i0�1³n|2�j1z³2j¥2j�1}�1��~1£1}�j01/p�1/i�p01~���1
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 19 of 50 PageID 2550
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� )�+)
./01234567869:;<=6><?@;9AB<=:<6CDE69=>F671DG6><?@;>=BA?:H6CI1J0G6KLMNOPQL/ER/JSSI12PM4I6
6TUVWXYZTU[\]__aa_b66cUZ[]ZTTdVYUe6
6ZTTdVYUe]Td]fU]YdTXgU[66
hijklmnlopijqrsltu1/S426v4O0u6w4Q/u6x6t1SEJS688t6>;F6yP6zu00u/6{3P6|LJEu6><=6w1JE0123567869:?F=6><?@H>?B<<A<671DG6><?@H>?B<<A:6CI1J0G6N}u1/S42R}3I}01~PM4I6
6cUZ[]ZTTdVYUe66ZTTdVYUe]Td]fU]YdTXgU[
66hps�l�l�jr��pk�isl�4}}u/SIJEQ6�/4MNu0I126t8�6:;<<6y6�u2E/106��uP56|EuP6=:<<6tQ4u2JD56��6;F<<>6H<:B::>B<AAA671DG6H<:B::>BH<:<6TUVWXYZTU[\]_ _�a_�6
6cUZ[]ZTTdVYUe66ZTTdVYUe]Td]fU]YdTXgU[
66����ipkl�rq�iql�rr�ij�l{JSSI1256�1//uEE56�L/E56v421QLu56wM81J26xw12�1256t�6:<=6C6tJ2u6|E56|LJEu6=F6./01234567869:;<=6><?@;9AB<=:<671DG6><?@;>=BA?:H6CI1J0G6IJMQ1u0P~4431/3R/JSSI12PM4I6
6TUVWXYZTU[\]__aa_b66cUZ[]ZTTdVYUe6
6ZTTdVYUe]Td]fU]YdTXgU[66
��pkkp�l�rk�isl�4}}u/SIJEQ6�/4MNu0I126t8�6:;<<6y6�u2E/106��uP56|EuP6=:<<6tQ4u2JD56��6;F<<>6H<:B9;=BF>;;671DG6H<:B::>BH<:<6TUVWXYZTU[\]_ _�a_�6
6cUZ[]ZTTdVYUe66ZTTdVYUe]Td]fU]YdTXgU[
�p�ps�is�
�ps��l�nl�p��q66��]������� �¡
/u}/uSu2Eu36KO¢k�sil�j�q��sil�p£pjl¤|uu61K4�u6¥4/6133/uSS¦6
6TUVWXYZTU[\]_� a_�6
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 20 of 50 PageID 2551
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� .�+)
/01231445670899
:;<==>?@ABCDE>:FGDGA>HIJJ9KLMNJ9OMP9KQQPJRRS9
9/01231445670899T653U1V3WXV099144567083453Y03754XV02
99Z[GG\>]>]_@abGF_[>HIJJ9KLMNJ9OMP9KQQPJRRS9
9406cX71402d3efgfhghefi99/0123144567089
9144567083453Y03754XV0299
j<kkF<E>l>jG\Bm[B=>HIJJ9KLMNJ9OMP9KQQPJRRS9
9/01231445670899T653U1V3WXV099144567083453Y03754XV02
99j<==@=n[>o>p_FC>q>ZZZ>HIJJ9KLMNJ9OMP9KQQPJRRS9
9406cX71402d3efgfhghefi99/0123144567089
9144567083453Y03754XV0299
rGF;>s>t<GF[B=>HIJJ9KLMNJ9OMP9KQQPJRRS9
9/01231445670899144567083453Y03754XV02
99r<=C>l>uFB\v<;AG=>HIJJ9KLMNJ9OMP9KQQPJRRS9
9406cX71402d3fegfwghefx99/0123144567089
9144567083453Y03754XV0299
y@\DG<;>bB[AG[>zBB{GF{>HIJJ9KLMNJ9OMP9KQQPJRRS9
9406cX71402d3efgfhghefi99/0123144567089
9144567083453Y03754XV0299
lD<;;<E>?B;AG=>HIJJ9KLMNJ9OMP9KQQPJRRS9
9406cX71402d3fegfwghefx99/0123144567089
9144567083453Y03754XV02
|<k<={G=C
}nG;<>]GE99~����3��35����3�6�~���36���3�~3�~��������
PJ�PJRJ��JQ9L��;@=G>bF@[C@=G>y<�<F>HIJJ9KLMNJ9OMP9KQQPJRRS9
9406cX71402d3efgweghefx99/012314456708
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 21 of 50 PageID 2552
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� *�+)
./01223456789:3/;<9<63=>??.@ABC?.DBE.@FFE?GGH.
.IJKLMKNNOPQJR..SPOMTKUMVWUJ..KNNOPQJRMNOMXJMQONWUJL
..YZ<<[3\]3\ 5_a<;Z3=>??.@ABC?.DBE.@FFE?GGH.
.NJPbWQKNJLcMdefegfgdeh..IJKLMKNNOPQJR.
.KNNOPQJRMNOMXJMQONWUJL..
i1jj;1:3k]3i<[7lZ723=>??.@ABC?.DBE.@FFE?GGH.
.IJKLMKNNOPQJR..SPOMTKUMVWUJ..KNNOPQJRMNOMXJMQONWUJL
..i12252mZ3n]3o ;83p3YYY3=>??.@ABC?.DBE.@FFE?GGH.
.NJPbWQKNJLcMdefegfgdeh..IJKLMKNNOPQJR.
.KNNOPQJRMNOMXJMQONWUJL..
q<;03r]3s1<;Z723=>??.@ABC?.DBE.@FFE?GGH.
.IJKLMKNNOPQJR..KNNOPQJRMNOMXJMQONWUJL
..q1283k3t;7[u106<23=>??.@ABC?.DBE.@FFE?GGH.
.NJPbWQKNJLcMedfevfgdew..IJKLMKNNOPQJR.
.KNNOPQJRMNOMXJMQONWUJL..
x5[9<103a7Z6<Z3y77z<;z3=>??.@ABC?.DBE.@FFE?GGH.
.NJPbWQKNJLcMdefegfgdeh..IJKLMKNNOPQJR.
.KNNOPQJRMNOMXJMQONWUJL..
k91001:34706<23=>??.@ABC?.DBE.@FFE?GGH.
.NJPbWQKNJLcMedfevfgdew..IJKLMKNNOPQJR.
.KNNOPQJRMNOMXJMQONWUJL
{1j12z<28
k[7883|3n1}5Z..~�M��������~�
E?�E?G?��?F.A�|052<3a;5Z852<3x1�1;3=>??.@ABC?.DBE.@FFE?GGH.
.NJPbWQKNJLcMdefvdfgdew..IJKLMKNNOPQJR
..
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 22 of 50 PageID 2553
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� '�+)
./011234567892.:;8;52<=>>?@ABC>?DBE?@FFE>GGH?
?IJKLMKNNOPQJR??SPOMTKUMVWUJ??KNNOPQJRMNOMXJMQONWUJL
??YZ;;[2\]2\ 4_a;:Z2<=>>?@ABC>?DBE?@FFE>GGH?
?NJPbWQKNJLcMdefegfgdeh??IJKLMKNNOPQJR?
?KNNOPQJRMNOMXJMQONWUJL??
i0jj:092k]2i;[6lZ612<=>>?@ABC>?DBE?@FFE>GGH?
?IJKLMKNNOPQJR??SPOMTKUMVWUJ??KNNOPQJRMNOMXJMQONWUJL
??i01141mZ2n]2o :72p2YYY2<=>>?@ABC>?DBE?@FFE>GGH?
?NJPbWQKNJLcMdefegfgdeh??IJKLMKNNOPQJR?
?KNNOPQJRMNOMXJMQONWUJL??
q;:/2r]2s0;:Z612<=>>?@ABC>?DBE?@FFE>GGH?
?IJKLMKNNOPQJR??KNNOPQJRMNOMXJMQONWUJL
??q0172k2t:6[u0/5;12<=>>?@ABC>?DBE?@FFE>GGH?
?NJPbWQKNJLcMedfevfgdew??IJKLMKNNOPQJR?
?KNNOPQJRMNOMXJMQONWUJL??
x4[8;0/2a6Z5;Z2y66z;:z2<=>>?@ABC>?DBE?@FFE>GGH?
?NJPbWQKNJLcMdefegfgdeh??IJKLMKNNOPQJR?
?KNNOPQJRMNOMXJMQONWUJL??
k80//09236/5;12<=>>?@ABC>?DBE?@FFE>GGH?
?NJPbWQKNJLcMedfevfgdew??IJKLMKNNOPQJR?
?KNNOPQJRMNOMXJMQONWUJL
{0j01z;17
q452o 4??|}M~}�~�~��|�??NJPbWQKNJLcMdvfdwfgdew
E>�E>G>��>F?A�{;140/2{2x;91;:z2�@��@EF?�EB���?�E���GB�?��EE@�?�?�>��>E���?����?�?�>��E@�?�C>��?=�>�?����?��B>����?��?����� �¡¡�?¢�� �£¤ ����?
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 23 of 50 PageID 2554
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� (�+)
./01234565376898:2;<=>?=@@ABC<D
22EFGHIJKILMFGNOPIQRSS2/TUVS2WUX2/YYXSZZ[2
2;<=>?=@@ABC<D22=@@ABC<D?@A?\<?CA@]<>
_MMPaFPb
cFNOPIdFGFeFPfN22gh?ihjikijlgm
XSnXSZSopSY2TqreFPaFIsONMI_tPPIuqv/opw2xyV/XSzw2{UoSZw2u|ZZU2}2~|qpUow��x�294�2��2�X|Z�2RpXSSpw2R|�pS2:442�/�n/w2.�2773492897�55�6�44�2��/�y12/Y|oo�Xqv/op/yV/XSz��U�2
2;<=>?=@@ABC<D22=@@ABC<D?@A?\<?CA@]<>
22_FPfMHI_I�F�PFGaIQRSS2/TUVS2WUX2/YYXSZZ[2
2;<=>?=@@ABC<D22=@@ABC<D?@A?\<?CA@]<>
22�F�fPI_F�faI�F�F�fPMGIuqv/opw2xyV/XSzw2{UoSZw2u|ZZU2}2~|qpUo�x2R|�pS297425��42R�2�3p�2RpXSSp2~/�oSZV�yySw2.�2753482897�255�6�44�2./012897�55763:��2��/�y12�Y��Xqv/op/yV/XSz��U�2
2@<B�]C=@<>�?����������22;<=>?=@@ABC<D2
2=@@ABC<D?@A?\<?CA@]<>22
d�GfNI MHHeFPI�Syy�/o2}2�/XXSow2���25��992u�Y�S2upS2RpS25442�/�|o/2¡�yyZw2¢x2�53:72���6:8467�7�2./012���6:8467�7�2��/�y12�vSyy�/o�v6vy/v��U�2
2£BA?¤= ?¥]<22=@@ABC<D?@A?\<?CA@]<>
22¦§ObbI KI MHHeFPI�Syy�/o2}2�/XXSow2���25��992u�Y�S2upS2RpS25442�/�|o/2¡�yyZw2¢x2�53:72���6:8467�7�2./012�:�6:8467�782=@@ABC<D?@A?\<?CA@]<>
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 24 of 50 PageID 2555
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� ��+)
./0/12314
56/789:;4:1<<=>?@>A@B@AC=D
EFGEFHFIJFK<LM.3NO28P;O00O4Q8ROS/1S4/O18TUV<WXXYZFH<[X<\U]YK<<_YHFIHJFYI<a<bWb<c[d<efgf<aUEhHLUKi<aj<kfgel<lmlnfopneofm<qUdr<stgnspgnskgp<uvwxyz{uv|}?~��~���~��<
<�v{|?{uu�wzv�<<
�Q3;6/S8��8�3;46/448�ZUEK<�FEEYhh<a�hhYH<�Y��<q�EFI<�YIHL�E�i<j<fgpp<�UYI<�J<�JF<tgg<�UEUH[JUi<qT<pofpsntgkp<koe�pttnlegg<_dJ<eep<qUdr<koe�pttntplo<_�UYhr<ZLUEJhFJJ�YZUEK�FEEYhhbZ[�<
<{uu�wzv�?u�?�v?z�uy�v|
./0/12314
�1�1:�18�3;4O/S<<>=��A?=�?�� >?=>A?�=>�?|���?�¡�~~¢
@>A@B@AC=D?>=£C¤=D?¥�¤��>�¢?=>A?{����¤¥�¤=£@�>�¢?���¥=>@��?=>A��¤¦=¤£>�¤� @¥�?�¡�~
./0/12314
9§98930O38©1ª� EFGEFHFIJFK<LM5«31238¬:S/8.118®�FF<UL[]F<X[E<UKKEFHH<
<�v{|?{uu�wzv�<<{uu�wzv�?u�?�v?z�uy�v|
<<�Q;OS8°/66«318®�FF<UL[]F<X[E<UKKEFHH<
<�v{|?{uu�wzv�<<{uu�wzv�?u�?�v?z�uy�v|
<<P3NO18.3NO2893±3²O1/;8®�FF<UL[]F<X[E<UKKEFHH<
<uvwxyz{uv|}?~���³��~��<<�v{|?{uu�wzv�<
<{uu�wzv�?u�?�v?z�uy�v|<<
ª:448°�8°/66«318µFhh�UI<�<µUEEFIi<TT<fooee<¶YK�F<¶JF<�JF<fgg<TU��IU<·YhhHi<aj<kftmp<koknmlgnpsps<qUdr<kmonmlgnpspl<_�UYhr<HVFhh�UI�VnVhUVbZ[�<
<�v{|?{uu�wzv�<<{uu�wzv�?u�?�v?z�uy�v|
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 25 of 50 PageID 2556
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� ���+)
./0/12314
51671/89:;;<17=347:1>?8@@9
./0/12314
A/B718C7D</E/ FGHFGIGJKGLMNOA3E68PQ8R/3E>:18STGGMUNVWGMXVFMULLFGIIYM
MZ[\]\__ ab[cMM\__ab[c_ d[b _ef[]
g;7=<>
hE<4i8718g2B/E47>71D?8j1=Q FGHFGIGJKGLMNOk368A/;l8@74=i0:E28mUnGFoMpVJGqIVJoMmGUFrUJoMsUqLtGqqMumGFnVtvKwoMxsMTKGMyz{{My{{MTM|FUJ}GM~WGM|FqUJLVoM��M�y�{�M�{���yy���{{M�U��M�{������{�y�M�rUvq�M�qvK��XVFL�NUnGFLVJGqIVJ��VrM
MZ[\]\__ ab[cMM\__ab[c_ d[b _ef[]
M��M5��/=4:E
k/6/18�7:1D FGHFGIGJKGLMNO�63�/8�Q8@712/;3118�vJLGrUJJM�UtM�vFroM~xsM���M��MsUrLGJMpFvWGM�K�M�qVVFMmGWGFqOM�vqqIoMs~Mz{y�{M��{�y�z��y�zM�U��M��{��{{�{y��MZ[\]\__ ab[cM
M�a �\f�ef[MM\__ab[c_ d[b _ef[]
MM@Q8�3=�8C7�1/�8?8�EQ8�UtM|XXv�GMVXM��M�U�nM�vNJGOMT vKGM�{yM����MTUJM�VIGMmqWLM�U�nIVJWvqqGoM��M�yy��Mz{���������{M�U��Mz{���������zM�rUvq�M¡U�n�}vNJGOqUt��VrM
MZ[\]\__ ab[cMM\__ab[c_ d[b _ef[]
.34/8¢76/2 £ .:=�/48h/¤4
{��yz�y{�� �Ms|¥x�~¦�§�M�vqvJ}MXGGMFG�GvWGL�MM�{{�{{oMFG�GvHKMJ rNGFM{z�{���yy���zMXvqGLMNO�UrGIM�M~NVqKvJ�MSI NrvKKGLMNOMpUWvLM�GFF ��vYMS~KKU��rGJKI�M©M�M���vNvKM~oM©MyM���vNvK
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 26 of 50 PageID 2557
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� ���+)
./01020345676809/010:034567680;/010<0345676803/010=096>6?09@>AB0C5AA8D0EFG;D0HGBIJKLABBAMLB@N0IOM0@J0PQR2QSTRUVW0E3J8ABAMX0TUQSPQSTR=D
TUQSPQSTR= S0CYZZ[\C0C]7N688AM070_INAK0_0F7@?86JV0EK]7N688AM070;I>6M0ABB]aa6D0EF88Ia5NAJ8KX10R0C]NN@JK/010S0C]NN@JK/01020C]NN@JK/010:0C]NN@JK/010<0C]NN@JK/010=0C]NN@JKDEFG;D0HGBIJKLABBAM0LB@N0IOM0@J0PQR2QSTRUVW0E3J8ABAMX0TUQSPQSTR=D
TUQSPQSTR= 20 6?6Jb0LAA0cI6M/0BAaA6c80J]N7AB0TPUTdR2SSU:=PV0G56K0aIKA05IK07AAJ0IKK6bJAM08@085Ae@J@BI7?A036?AAJ0C0f6??A88V0F??0L]8]BA0c?AIM6JbK0@B0M@a]NAJ8K0K5@]?M07AIB085A0a@BBAa8aIKA0J]N7ABX09gdR=dTS<U:dheid3CfV0ZIb6K8BI8A03?Aa86@J0L@BN0I88Ia5AMV0EF88Ia5NAJ8KX10R09@JKAJ8D0EFG;D0HGBIJKLABBAM0LB@N0IOM0@J0PQR2QSTRUVW0E3J8ABAMX0TUQSPQSTR=D
TjQTRQSTR= :0CYZZ[\C0C]7N688AM070_INAK0_0F7@?86JV0EF88Ia5NAJ8KX010R0C]NN@JK0C]NN@JKfAJM0kV0lAm6K/010S0C]NN@JK0C]NN@JK0[bI?A0nkIJMn0kI/01020C]NN@JK0C]NN@JKCa@880FV0lAm6K/010:0C]NN@JK0C]NN@JK0o6N0e]6/010<0C]NN@JK0C]NN@JK0_IK@J9IBINIJ6K/010=0C]NN@JK0C]NN@JK0F?A40Z@B8@JDEABB]aa6/0;I>6MD0HGBIJKLABBAM0LB@NIOM0@J0PQR2QSTRUVW0E3J8ABAMX0TjQTRQSTR=D
TjQTSQSTR= <0C]NN@JK0pKK]AM0IK08@0_IK@J09IBINIJ6K/0o6N0e]6/0_A]JAKKA0ll9/0Ca@880F0lAm6K/0fAJMk0lAm6K/0F?A40Z@B8@J/0[bI?A0kIV0EF88Ia5NAJ8KX010R0C]NN@JK/010S0C]NN@JK/0102C]NN@JK/010:0C]NN@JK/010<0C]NN@JK/010=0C][email protected][kGF\GX0f5AJcB6J86Jb085A0K]NN@JK/0KA?Aa80n;@a]NAJ80IJM0K8INcKn0@B0n;@a]NAJ80IJM0a@NNAJ8Kn0L@B85A0KAI?08@0IccAIB0@J085A0M@a]NAJ8V0HGBIJKLABBAM0LB@N0IOM0@J0PQR2QSTRUVW0E3J8ABAMXTjQTSQSTR=D
TjQTjQSTR= =0C3kgp9303i39YG3;0L6?AM070_INAK0_0F7@?86JX0k]?A0:0fI6>AB0@L0CAB>6aA0@L0C]NN@JKVfI6>AB0KAJ80@J0F]b]K80j/0STR=08@0fAJM0kV0lAm6K0V0EF88Ia5NAJ8KX010R0C]NN@JK0fI6>AB@L0CAB>6aA0@L0C]NN@JK0d0fAJM0kV0lAm6KDEABB]aa6/0;I>6MD0HGBIJKLABBAM0LB@N0IOM0@JPQR2QSTRUVW0E3J8ABAMX0TjQTjQSTR=D
TjQTjQSTR= U0C3kgp9303i39YG3;0L6?AM070_INAK0_0F7@?86JX0k]?A0:0fI6>AB0@L0CAB>6aA0@L0C]NN@JKVfI6>AB0KAJ80@J0F]b]K80j/0STR=08@0Ca@880FV0lAm6K0V0EF88Ia5NAJ8KX010R0C]NN@JK0fI6>AB0@LCAB>6aA0@L0C]NN@JK0d0Ca@880FV0lAm6KDEABB]aa6/0;I>6MD0HGBIJKLABBAM0LB@N0IOM0@JPQR2QSTRUVW0E3J8ABAMX0TjQTjQSTR=D
TjQTjQSTR= j0C3kgp9303i39YG3;0L6?AM070_INAK0_0F7@?86JX0k]?A0:0fI6>AB0@L0CAB>6aA0@L0C]NN@JKVfI6>AB0KAJ80@J0F]b]K80j/0STR=08@0[bI?A0nkIJMn0kI0V0EF88Ia5NAJ8KX010R0C]NN@JKfI6>AB0@L0CAB>6aA0@L0C]NN@JK0d0[bI?A0nkIJMn0kIDEABB]aa6/0;I>6MD0HGBIJKLABBAM0LB@NIOM0@J0PQR2QSTRUVW0E3J8ABAMX0TjQTjQSTR=D
TjQTPQSTR= P0C3kgp9303i39YG3;0L6?AM070_INAK0_0F7@?86JX0k]?A0:0fI6>AB0@L0CAB>6aA0@L0C]NN@JKVfI6>AB0KAJ80@J0F]b]K80</0STR=08@0_A]JAKKA0ll90V0EF88Ia5NAJ8KX010R0C]NN@JK0fI6>AB0@LCAB>6aA0@L0C]NN@JK0d0_A]JAKKA0ll9DEABB]aa6/0;I>6MD0HGBIJKLABBAM0LB@N0IOM0@JPQR2QSTRUVW0E3J8ABAMX0TjQTPQSTR=D
TjQR=QSTR= RT0FbBAANAJ808@0ZIb6K8BI8A0_]MbA0_]B6KM6a86@JV0hIB80IbBAAK08@0ZIb6K8BI8A0_]MbA_]B6KM6a86@JV0G56K06K0I0G3iG03\Gkr0[\lrV0G5ABA06K0J@0h; 0M@a]NAJ80IKK@a6I8AM0m685856K0AJ8BV0EZFhD0HGBIJKLABBAM0LB@N0IOM0@J0PQR2QSTRUVW0E3J8ABAMX0TjQR=QSTR=D
TjQS2QSTR= RR0Z[Gp[\0L@B0FMN6KK6@J0hB@0eIa0g6aA0IK08@0I88@BJA0F?6JI09B6K86JI0ZAsAB0@J07A5I?L0@L_A]JAKKA0ll9/0Ca@880F0lAm6K/0fAJM0k0lAm6K/0IJM0[bI?A0kIV0E.FCD0HGBIJKLABBAM0LB@NIOM0@J0PQR2QSTRUVW0E3J8ABAMX0TjQS2QSTR=D
TjQS2QSTR= RS0Z[Gp[\0L@B0FMN6KK6@J0hB@0eIa0g6aA0IK08@0I88@BJA0_ALLBA0C0_Ia@7K@J0@J07A5I?L0@L_A]JAKKA0ll9/0Ca@880F0lAm6K/0fAJM0k0lAm6K/0IJM0[bI?A0kIV0E.FCD0HGBIJKLABBAM0LB@NIOM0@J0PQR2QSTRUVW0E3J8ABAMX0TjQS2QSTR=D
TjQS2QSTR= 0hk[0eF90gp930330hFp;V0t0UT/0BAaA6c80J]N7AB0heiRU<<SP0IK08@0_ALLBA0C0_Ia@7K@J/F?6JI09B6K86JI0ZAsABV0G56K06K0I0G3iG03\Gkr0[\lrV0G5ABA06K0J@0h; 0M@a]NAJ8
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 27 of 50 PageID 2558
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� ���+)
.//012.345672386382/6493:;<6=>?@A6BC:.9/D4::456D:0E6.F56096GHIJHKLIM<N6=O934:45PLQHKJHKLIRA
LQHKJHKLIR IJ6STUOT6VW:/W.936306X494:.Y6S:54:6LGZLQ6[:.9329[6II6\032096D0:6?5E2//2096]:06.1_2146[:.9329[6IK6\032096D0:6?5E2//2096]:06.16_214<6]4:63846a0W:3b/6?5E292/3:.32c4]0Y2124/6.956]:0145W:4/6\.9W.Yd6.VVY21.9368./6D2c46=eA65.;/6296782186306:4[2/34:6./6.6W/4:0D63846OY413:09216f2Y29[6@;/34E<6T4[2/3:.32096306g46.110EVY2/8456c2.6384610W:3b/674g/2346.3777<.F5<W/10W:3/<[0c<6a0W9/4Y62/6.5c2/45638.36384;6.:46Y2E234563063706=KA6.5523209.Y64ZE.2Y6.55:4//4/62963842:6U2/3:21360D6?:2F09.6h/4:6?110W93<6=>?@A6=C82/62/6.6COiC6OjCTkSjlk<6C84:462/690<V5D6501WE4936.//012.345672386382/6493:;<A6BC:.9/D4::456D:0E6.F5609GHIJHKLIM<N6=O934:45P6LQHKJHKLIRA
LQHKmHKLIR Im6jSCnaO60D6?VV4.:.9146g;6o4936@6>:01p4YE.96096g48.YD60D6q4W94//46llad6@10336?l472/d6r495;6T6l472/d6S[.Y46T.;<6=>:01p4YE.9d6o493A6BC:.9/D4::456D:0E6.F5609GHIJHKLIM<N6=O934:45P6LQHKmHKLIRA
LQHKmHKLIR Ie6].:3;6OY413/6?//2[9E49360D6a./46306U2/3:2136qW5[46qW:2/5213209<6C82/62/6.6COiC6OjCTkSjlk<6C84:462/6906]Uf6501WE4936.//012.345672386382/6493:;<6=\?]A6BC:.9/D4::456D:0E.F56096GHIJHKLIM<N6=O934:45P6LQHKeHKLIRA
LQHKeHKLIR IR6\njhCO6STUOTP6]W:/W.936306l01.Y6TWY46J<M=gAd6.6:4sW4/368./6g4496:4142c456D0:6.:.950E6:4.//2[9E49360D6382/61./46306.6U2/3:2136qW5[4<6fhTC OT6STUOTOU6a./4:4.//2[9456g;6:.950E65:.76306qW5[46<6TW//4Y60YY.95<6?YY6DW:384:6VY4.529[/HV.V4://80WY569076Y2/363846D0YY0729[6aS\]lOCO61./469WEg4:P6a_ZIRZKeMmZ] iZT <6C82/62/.6COiC6OjCTk6Sjlk<6C84:462/6906]Uf6501WE4936.//012.345672386382/6493:;<6=\?]ABC:.9/D4::456D:0E6.F56096GHIJHKLIM<N6=O934:45P6LQHKeHKLIRA
LQHKRHKLIR IM6STUOT6Sf6TOah@?l<6STUOTOU6qW5[466TW//4Y60YY.95684:4g;6:41W/4/682E/4YDD:0E6382/6E.334:d6382/61./462/684:4g;6:4.//2[9456g;6:.950E65:.76306qW5[46@34c496]6l0[.9D0:6.YY6DW:384:6V:0144529[/<6?YY6VY4.529[/6/80WY569076Y2/363846D0YY0729[61./469WEg4:P6a_ZIRZKeMmZ] iZ@]l<6@2[9456g;6qW5[466TW//4Y60YY.956096QHKRHIR<6=\?]A6BC:.9/D4::45D:0E6.F56096GHIJHKLIM<N6=O934:45P6LQHKRHKLIRA
LQHKRHKLIR IQ6]TOln\nj?Tk6STUOT638.36E03209/6VW:/W.936306f45<6T<6a2c<6]<6IK=gA6.:4652/10W:.[452D6384654D41361.96g461W:456g;6D2Y29[6.96.E495456VY4.529[<6C846V.:324/6EW/36E4436.95109D4:6V:20:63063846D2Y29[60D6/W186E03209/63065434:E2946784384:62361.96g46.c02545<fhTC OT6STUOTOU638.36]Y.2932DD6/4:c46.610V;60D6382/6S:54:6WV096U4D495.93/6.956D2Y4.690321460D6/4:c214<[email protected]:54:6D0:610EVY4346543.2Y/<6@2[9456g;6qW5[46@34c496]<l0[.96096QHKRHIR<6=al>A6BC:.9/D4::456D:0E6.F56096GHIJHKLIM<N6=O934:45P6LQHKRHKLIRA
LGHIJHKLIR IG6@OT_naO6OiOahCOU6D2Y456g;6q.E4/6q6?g0Y329P6]:00D60D6@4:c2146:4P6@WEE09/6.95aY.//6?132096a0EVY.2936.956U4E.956D0:6qW:;6C:2.Y6WV096?Y4t6\0:3096096?W[W/36KQdKLIR<6=f4::W112d6U.c25A6BC:.9/D4::456D:0E6.F56096GHIJHKLIM<N6=O934:45P6LGHIJHKLIRA
LGHIRHKLIR KL6jSCnaO6:4P6j0321460D6@4:c21460D6]:4Y2E29.:;6S:54:6g;6q.E4/6q6?g0Y3296:4P6IQ6S:54:6:4TWY46IK=gA6\03209/6<6=f4::W112d6U.c25A6BC:.9/D4::456D:0E6.F56096GHIJHKLIM<N6=O934:45PLGHIRHKLIRA
LGHIGHKLIR KI6a09/4936\SCnSj6D0:6Ot349/20960D6C2E46306f2Y46?9/74:6:4P6IG6@4:c2146Ot41W345d6Ia0EVY.2936uvwxyz{v|}~v�~��~�z{w�vw����~��y��|z6g;6?Y4t6\0:309<6=?33.18E493/P6�6I6C4t360D]:0V0/456S:54:6]:0V0/456S:54:6D0:6Ot349/20960D632E46306D2Y46:4/V09/2c46VY4.529[/A=O2/49/3429d6U.c25A6BC:.9/D4::456D:0E6.F56096GHIJHKLIM<N6=O934:45P6LGHIGHKLIRA
LGHKLHKLIR KK6STUOT6[:.9329[6KI6\032096D0:6Ot349/20960D6C2E46306?9/74:<6?Y4t6\0:3096.9/74:65W4ILHmHKLIR<6@2[9456g;6qW5[46@34c496]<6l0[.96096GHKLHIR<=al>A6BC:.9/D4::456D:0E6.F5609GHIJHKLIM<N6=O934:45P6LGHKLHKLIRA
ILHLJHKLIR KJ6@410956\SCnSj6D0:6Ot349/20960D6C2E46306f2Y46?9/74:6:4P6KK6S:54:6096\032096D0:
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 28 of 50 PageID 2559
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� �+�+)
./0123452657684916056:23;1<6=>6:?1/6@5<052A6B:00CDE91203F6G6H684916IDE1JK?16L<J1<BM<5M531JN6L<J1<NB.431230142O6PCQ4JN6R8<C2371<<1J67<596CSJ6526TUHVUWXHYAZ6B.201<1JFHXUXVUWXH[N
HXUXVUWXH[ W\6@L8]L 6056_EC216a12K1U8<C2371<6_C316056@4JJ?16P430<4D06576b?5<4JC6=>6c1K213316dd_OID5006:6d1;43O6e12J>6f6d1;43O6LC?16fC>A6B:00CDE91203F6G6H6./E4=406./E4=406HO6G6W681/0576g<5M531J6L<J1<6L<J1<NBh<5Di1?9C2O6j120N6R8<C2371<<1J67<596CSJ6526TUHVUWXHYAZB.201<1JF6HXUXVUWXH[N
HXUXVUWXH[ Wk6_5<M5<C016P43D?53K<16I0C0191206=>6c1K213316dd_A6Bh<5Di1?9C2O6j120N6R8<C2371<<1J67<59CSJ6526TUHVUWXHYAZ6B.201<1JF6HXUXVUWXH[N
HXUX\UWXH[ W[6@L8]L 675<6./0123452657684916056b4?16:23;1<6lmnompqnmqrsntpuqvowtqnmqxyzwon{t|}mp|o~tq��t�uop�6=>6c1K213316dd_O6ID5006:6d1;43O6e12J>6f6d1;43O6LC?16fC>AB:00CDE91203F6G6H681/06576g<5M531J6L<J1<6L<J1<NBh<5Di1?9C2O6j120N6R8<C2371<<1J67<59CSJ6526TUHVUWXHYAZ6B.201<1JF6HXUX\UWXH[N
HXUX[UWXH[ WY6LfP.f60EC060E16304MK?C04526WV6C2J60E16950452675<61/0123452657604916W[6C<16<C201JAP1712JC2036:?1/6@5<052O6c1K21331O6e12J>6fA6d1;43O6LC?1�fC2J>�6fC>O6C2J6ID5006:Ad1;4363EC??6ECQ16WH6JC>36C701<60E1674?4265760E436_5K<0�36L<J1<65260E1695045260560<C2371<Q12K16W\605674?16C26C23;1<60560E16_59M?C42065<650E1<;4316<13M52J6C36M<5Q4J1J6=>6fK?16HW5760E16b1J1<C?6fK?136576_4Q4?6g<5D1JK<1A6I421J6=>6cKJ16I01Q126gA6d5C26526HXUkUH[AB_dhN6R8<C2371<<1J67<596CSJ6526TUHVUWXHYAZ6B.201<1JF6HXUX[UWXH[N
HXUH�UWXH[ W�6I8]g�d:8]L 6<1F6W\6@L8]L 6056_EC216a12K1U8<C2371<6_C316056@4JJ?16P430<4D0657b?5<4JC6vmqrsntpuqvowtqnmq{t|}mpu6=>6cC9136c6:=5?042A6B:00CDE91203F6G6H681/0657g<5M531J6L<J1<6g<5M531J6L<J1<NBb1<<KDD4O6PCQ4JN6R8<C2371<<1J67<596CSJ6526TUHVUWXHYAZB.201<1JF6HXUH�UWXH[N
HXUHTUWXH[ WT6LfP.f6<C20426W�6I04MK?C04526<1F6W\6@5045260568<C2371<6a12K16056@4JJ?16P430<4D0657b?5<4JCA6g?C42047763EC??6ECQ16K204?6HHUHHUWXH[605674?16E436f13M5231A6P1712JC2036c1K21331Odd_O6e12J>6fA6d1;43O6LC?16fC2J>6fC>O6C2J6ID5006:A6d1;4363EC??6ECQ16K204?6HHUVXUWXH[05674?160E14<6f1M?>A6I421J6=>6cKJ16I01Q126g6d5C26526HXUHTUWXH[A6B@@LN6R8<C2371<<1J7<596CSJ6526TUHVUWXHYAZ6B.201<1JF6HXUHTUWXH[N
HHUXVUWXH[ VX6LfP.f60EC065265<6=175<165Q19=1<6HXO6WXH[O6g?C42047769K3063E5;6DCK316;E>P1712JC2036j496�K46C2J6cC3526_C<C9C24363E5K?J62506=16J4394331J675<67C4?K<16056D59M?>;40E6fK?16\B9N65760E16b1J1<C?6fK?136576_4Q4?6g<5D1JK<1A6I421J6=>6cKJ16I01Q126gA6d5C2526HHUVUH[A6B_dhN6R8<C2371<<1J67<596CSJ6526TUHVUWXHYAZ6B.201<1JF6HHUXVUWXH[N
HHUHXUWXH[ VH6@L8]L 675<6./012345265768491657684916056I1<Q16=>6cC9136c6:=5?042A6B:00CDE91203F6G6H./E4=406:O6G6W681/06576g<5M531J6L<J1<NBb1<<KDD4O6PCQ4JN6R8<C2371<<1J67<596CSJ652TUHVUWXHYAZ6B.201<1JF6HHUHXUWXH[N
HHUHHUWXH[ VW6f.IgL I.6426LMM53404526<1F6W\6@L8]L 6056_EC216a12K1U8<C2371<6_C316056@4JJ?1P430<4D06576b?5<4JC674?1J6=>6cC9136c6:=5?042A6B:00CDE91203F6G6H6./E4=406:O6G6W6./E4=406hO6GV6./E4=406_O6G6\6./E4=406PNBb1<<KDD4O6PCQ4JN6R8<C2371<<1J67<596CSJ6526TUHVUWXHYAZB.201<1JF6HHUHHUWXH[N
HHUH\UWXH[ VV6LfP.f6<C20426VH6@50452675<6./012345265768491A6g?C42047763EC??6ECQ16K204?6P1D19=1<W[O6WXH[O6056CDD59M?43E631<Q4D16C2J674?16M<557657631<Q4D16C36056P1712JC2036j496�K46C2JcC3526_C<C9C243A6bC4?K<16056J56356;4??6<13K?064260E16J439433C?65760E16K231<Q1J6P1712JC203AI421J6=>6cKJ16I01Q126gA6d5C26526HHUH\UH[AB_dhN6R8<C2371<<1J67<596CSJ652TUHVUWXHYAZ6B.201<1JF6HHUH\UWXH[N
HHUW�UWXH[ V\6 L8]_.6<1F6504D16576b4?426:912J1J6P1D?C<C04526576f>C26LJ126=>6c1K213316dd_OID5006:6d1;43O6e12J>6f6d1;43O6LC?16fC>6<1F6W\6@L8]L 6056_EC216a12K1U8<C2371<
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 29 of 50 PageID 2560
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� �)�+)
./01234256778129603:6;324<2=84:67/2>2?@33/;AB1C30D2E2F2GHA6I632GHA6I632FJ?K:4;L18B/CMN1C3J2OP:/C0<1::172<:4B2/Q724C2RSFTSUVFW>X2?GC31:17D2FFSUYSUVFZJ
FFSURSUVFZ T[2\P].NG_2I2TY2a25bPb_2342960B6002./012cdefghfijkdllimiejmnfhlfkeopimefhlfqohmekkhjfrelejcsjgfthoghj2I2@81H254:34C>2?G601C0316CM29/u67J25476<61724C2FFSTVSUVFZ?.vKJ>2OP:/C0<1::172<:4B2/Q724C2RSFTSUVFW>X2?GC31:17D2FFSURSUVFZJ
FFSURSUVFZ TZ2w91;8/:/364C24<2\/C7:/254:34C26C2\xyy4:324<D2T[25bPb_2342960B6002./012I2@81H54:34C>2?G601C0316CM29/u67J2w5476<6172342;4::1;321u1C324C2FFSTVSUVFZ2?]GNJ>OP:/C0<1::172<:4B2/Q724C2RSFTSUVFW>X2?GC31:17D2FFSURSUVFZJ
FFSTVSUVFZ TW2]Gzv{2342]10y4C01234254364C2:1D2U|25bPb_2342.A/C}12~1Cx1SP:/C0<1:2./0123456778129603:6;324<2=84:67/2<68172I2�1xC10012vv.M2\;4332@2v1�60M2�1C72]2v1�60M2b}/81]/>2?@33/;AB1C30D2E2F2GHA6I632GHA6I632FJ?K:4;L18B/CM2N1C3JOP:/C0<1::172<:4B2/Q724CRSFTSUVFW>X2?GC31:17D2FFSTVSUVFZJ
FFSTVSUVFZ TY2b]9G]23A/323A1254364C2342960B6002T[260203:6;L1C>2P2\2=�]P�G]2b]9G]G923A/391<1C7/C32@81H254:34C20A/882A/u12xC368291;1BI1:2WM2UVFZ2342<6812/254364C2342960B60026C/;;4:7/C;12�63A23A12.4x:3�02b:71:2FY2>2\6}C172I2�x7}12\31u1C2z>2v4}/C24C2FFSTVSFZ>?.vKJ25476<61724C2FFSTVSUVFZ2?.vKJ>2OP:/C0<1::172<:4B2/Q724C2RSFTSUVFW>X2?GC31:17DFFSTVSUVFZJ
FUSVUSUVFZ TR25bPb_2342960B6002./012�dokdsjgfghf�d�ef��������f����2I2@81H254:34C>?@33/;AB1C30D2E2F2@<<67/u63291;8/:/364C24<2\/C7:/254:34CM2E2U2.1:36<6;/3124<2.4C<1::/8J?G601C0316CM29/u67J2OP:/C0<1::172<:4B2/Q724C2RSFTSUVFW>X2?GC31:17D2FUSVUSUVFZJ
FUSVRSUVFZ |V2w5bPb_2342\3:6L12TW2]1y82342]10y4C01234254364CM2T|2_436;12?b3A1:J2/C7291;8/:/364CGHA6I632342U|254364C2342.A/C}12~1Cx1SP:/C0<1:2./012I2�/B102�2@I4836C>2?@33/;AB1C30DE2F2P1H324<2z:4y40172b:71:J?=1::x;;6M29/u67J2w5476<6172342/772/776364C/8274;xB1C3286CL4C2FUSFUSUVFZ2?]GNJ>2OP:/C0<1::172<:4B2/Q724C2RSFTSUVFW>X2?GC31:17D2FUSVRSUVFZJ
FUSF[SUVFZ |F2]G\zb_\G26C2byy406364C2:1D2|V25bPb_2342\3:6L12TW2]1y82342]10y4C01234254364CM2T|_436;12?b3A1:J2�oielfhlfrelejcsjgkf�edjekke�f����f�ejcnf�e�ik�f�mhggf�e�ik�fsjcf��s�e��sjcn�f�snfijf�qqhkigihjfghf��sijgill�kfthgihjfghf�goi�e2<68172I2�1xC10012vv.M2\;4332@v1�60M2�1C72]2v1�60M2b}/812]/>2?P48B/CM2\A1881J2OP:/C0<1::172<:4B2/Q724CRSFTSUVFW>X2?GC31:17D2FUSF[SUVFZJ
FUSFZSUVFZ |U25bPb_2<4:2v1/u12342=6812_4CaG81;3:4C6;2GHA6I632I2�/B102�2@I4836C>2?@33/;AB1C30D2EF2P1H324<2z:4y40172b:71:J?=1::x;;6M29/u67J2OP:/C0<1::172<:4B2/Q724C2RSFTSUVFW>X?GC31:17D2FUSFZSUVFZJ
FUSFZSUVFZ |T2]G\zb_\G26C2byy406364C2:1D2TR25bPb_2342960B6002./012�dokdsjgfghf�d�ef������������2<68172I2�/B102�2@I4836C>2?@33/;AB1C30D2E2F2GHA6I63M2E2U2GHA6I63J?=1::x;;6M29/u67JOP:/C0<1::172<:4B2/Q724C2RSFTSUVFW>X2?GC31:17D2FUSFZSUVFZJ
FUSFRSUVFZ ||2b]9G]23A/323A1254364C2<4:2v1/u12|U2602}:/C317>2P2\2=�]P�G]2b]9G]G923A/3z8/6C36<<20A/882<68123A12C4Ca181;3:4C6;21HA6I6326C2/;;4:7/C;12�63A23A12y:4;17x:1020132<4:3A26C\1;364C2>_>U24<23A12G81;3:4C6;2./012=686C}2@7B6C603:/36u12z486;6102/C72z:4;17x:105/Cx/8>2\6}C172I2�x7}12\31u1C2z>2v4}/C24C2FUSFRSFZ>?.vKJ2OP:/C0<1::172<:4B2/Q724CRSFTSUVFW>X2?GC31:17D2FUSFRSUVFZJ
FUSFRSUVFZ |[2_bP.G2:1D2_bP.G2b=2=v_�2_b_aGvG.P]b_.2G��KP\2I2�/B102�2@I4836C:1D2||2b:71:24C254364C2<4:2v1/u12342=6812>2?=1::x;;6M29/u67J2OP:/C0<1::172<:4B2/Q724CRSFTSUVFW>X2?GC31:17D2FUSFRSUVFZJ
FUSFRSUVFZ |Z29G.v@]@Pb_24<2�bvv{25>2�bG2_2\�zzb]P2b=2zv@_P==�\2]G\zb_\G2Pb9G=G_9@_P2@vG�25b]Pb_�\25bPb_2Pb29\5 \\2:1D2|T2]10y4C0126Cbyy406364C234254364C2I2z8/6C36<<2�/B102�2@I4836C>2?@33/;AB1C30D2E2F2GHA6I632GHA6I632@J?=1::x;;6M29/u67J2OP:/C0<1::172<:4B2/Q724C2RSFTSUVFW>X2?GC31:17D2FUSFRSUVFZJ
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 30 of 50 PageID 2561
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� �.�+)
/0102102/3 45678494:;<6=6>4?4>@4><A45ABCDED>6@F4@G4H@CCI4J@A4EABA6KAL4DFL47>@EAL46F4><A4M<@AF6;4G6CAE@@NO4P<674674D4P:QP4:RPST4URVTO4P<AEA4674F@4M5?4L@BWNAF>4D77@B6D>AL4X6><4><67AF>EIO4YZ[5\4]PEDF7GAEEAL4GE@N4DL4@F4_1/102/aOb4Y:F>AEALc4/010/102/3\
/010/102/3 da4ePfMgV[PfUR4hijklmnlopqiokihknqrl4=I4sDNA74s4[=@C>6FO4Y[>>DB<NAF>7c4t4/4PA;>@G4ME@u@7AL4UELAE4UELAE\Y?AEEWBB6v45DK6L\4]PEDF7GAEEAL4GE@N4DL4@F4_1/102/aObY:F>AEALc4/010/102/3\
/010/102/3 dw4xUPfUR4G@E4[LN6776@F4ME@4HDB4y6BA4D74>@4D>>@EFAI4Z<E674zACCNDF4@F4=A<DCG4@G4sD7@FZDEDNDF67v4{6N4HW6O4Y{[e\4]PEDF7GAEEAL4GE@N4DL4@F4_1/102/aOb4Y:F>AEALc4/010/102/3\
/010/102/3 d_4xUPfUR4G@E4[LN6776@F4ME@4HDB4y6BA4D74>@4D>>@EFAI4eB@>>4zACCNDF4@F4=A<DCG4@G4sD7@FZDEDNDF67v4{6N4HW6O4Y{[e\4]PEDF7GAEEAL4GE@N4DL4@F4_1/102/aOb4Y:F>AEALc4/010/102/3\
/010/102/3 4MSU4H[Z4yfZ:4?::4M[f5O4|4}v4EABA6u>4FWN=AE4MHQ/w22wa4D74>@4Z<E674zACCNDFOP<674674D4P:QP4:RPST4URVTO4P<AEA4674F@4M5?4L@BWNAF>4D77@B6D>AL4X6><4><674AF>EIOY{[e\4]PEDF7GAEEAL4GE@N4DL4@F4_1/102/aOb4Y:F>AEALc4/010/102/3\
/010/102/3 4MSU4H[Z4yfZ:4?::4M[f5O4|4}v4EABA6u>4FWN=AE4MHQ/22w34D74>@4eB@>>4z4zACCNDFOP<674674D4P:QP4:RPST4URVTO4P<AEA4674F@4M5?4L@BWNAF>4D77@B6D>AL4X6><4><674AF>EIOY{[e\4]PEDF7GAEEAL4GE@N4DL4@F4_1/102/aOb4Y:F>AEALc4/010/102/3\
/010/102/3 }24US5:S4uWE7WDF>4>@4~AFAEDC4UELAE42_92w4�EDF>6F�4dw4x@>6@F4G@E4[LN6776@F4ME@4HDBy6BA�4�EDF>6F�4d_4x@>6@F4G@E4[LN6776@F4ME@4HDB4y6BAO4MAE4><A4Z@WE>�74[LN6F67>ED>6KAM@C6B6A74DFL4ME@BALWEA74xDFWDCv4DuuC6BDF>4<D74G6KA4Y}\4LDI746F4X<6B<4>@4EA�67>AE4D74D4W7AE@G4><A4:CAB>E@F6B4?6C6F�4eI7>ANO4SA�67>ED>6@F4>@4=A4DBB@NuC67<AL4K6D4><A4B@WE>�74XA=76>A4D>XXXODLOW7B@WE>7O�@KO4Z@WF7AC4674DLK67AL4><D>4><AI4DEA4C6N6>AL4>@4>X@4Y0\4DLL6>6@FDC4A9ND6C4DLLEA77A746F4><A6E4567>E6B>4@G4[E6@FD4g7AE4[BB@WF>O4Y{[e\4YP<674674D4P:QP:RPST4URVTO4P<AEA4674F@OuLG4L@BWNAF>4D77@B6D>AL4X6><4><674AF>EIO\4]PEDF7GAEEAL4GE@NDL4@F4_1/102/aOb4Y:F>AEALc4/010/102/3\
/0100102/3 }/4US5:S4�EDF>6F�4da4e>6uWCD>6@Fc4MCD6F>6GG47<DCC4<DKA4WF>6C45ABAN=AE40av402/3v4>@4G6CA4DSAuCI46F4eWuu@E>4@G4d24x@>6@F4>@4e>E68AO4e6�FAL4=I4sWL�A4e>AKAF4M4V@�DF4@F/0100102/3O4YxxU\4]PEDF7GAEEAL4GE@N4DL4@F4_1/102/aOb4Y:F>AEALc4/0100102/3\
/0100102/3 }04�xUPfUR4>@4567N6774ZD7A4��������k��khj��kj���k��������4=I4sD7@F4ZDEDNDF67OY[>>DB<NAF>7c4t4/4:;<6=6>\YxDIFDELv45DF6AC\4�x@L6G6AL4>@4B@EEAB>4G6CAE4@F4/010a102/3YS:{\O4]PEDF7GAEEAL4GE@N4DL4@F4_1/102/aOb4Y:F>AEALc4/0100102/3\
/0100102/3 }4?6E7>4xUPfUR4G@E4:;>AF76@F4@G4P6NA4>@4?6CA4SA7u@F7A1SAuCI4D74>@4d4SA7u@F7A46FUuu@76>6@F4>@4x@>6@F4��k�������4=I4[CA;4x@E>@FO4Y[>>DB<NAF>7c4t4/4PA;>4@G4ME@u@7ALUELAE\Y:67AF7>A6Fv45DK6L\4]PEDF7GAEEAL4GE@N4DL4@F4_1/102/aOb4Y:F>AEALc4/0100102/3\
/010102/3 }d4�RUPfZ:4EAc4RUPfZ:4U?4e:SyfZ:4U?4/w4MS:VfxfR[ST4US5:S4=I4sDNA74s[=@C>6F4O4Y?AEEWBB6v45DK6L\4�x@L6G6AL4>@4DLL4L@BWNAF>4C6F84@F4/010a102/34YS:{\O]PEDF7GAEEAL4GE@N4DL4@F4_1/102/aOb4Y:F>AEALc4/010102/3\
/010102/3 }}4RUPfZ:4@G4:EED>D4EAc4d_4xUPfUR4G@E4[LN6776@F4ME@4HDB4y6BA4D74>@4D>>@EFAI4eB@>>zACCNDFv4}04xUPfUR4>@4567N6774ZD7A4��������k��khj��kj���k��������v4ME@4HDB4y6BA?AA4MD6Lv4}24UELAE4@F4x@>6@F4G@E4[LN6776@F4ME@4HDB4y6BAv4dw4xUPfUR4G@E4[LN6776@FME@4HDB4y6BA4D74>@4D>>@EFAI4Z<E674zACCNDFv4ME@4HDB4y6BA4?AA4MD6L4o�����k��kl�����4=I5AGAFLDF>4sD7@F4ZDEDNDF67OO4YzACCNDFv4eB@>>\4]PEDF7GAEEAL4GE@N4DL4@F4_1/102/aObY:F>AEALc4/010102/3\
/010a102/3 }34US5:S4><D>4><A4e>6uWCD>6@F4}4674�EDF>ALO45AGAFLDF>4[CA;4x@E>@F47<DCC4<DKA4WF>6C5ABAN=AE40wv402/3v4>@4G6CA4D4SAuCI4>@4><A4x@>6@F4>@4567N6774_4O4e6�FAL4=I4sWL�A4e>AKAFMO4V@�DF4@F4/010a1/3OYZV�\4]PEDF7GAEEAL4GE@N4DL4@F4_1/102/aOb4Y:F>AEALc4/010a102/3\
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 31 of 50 PageID 2562
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� �*�+)
./0/10/2.3 4156789:5;<56=>?<@>=5;<5A<;B<@5C=D5EF5AGHIGJ5;<5KB>LB>>5MN>=5OPQRPSTUVUWVXPYZV[\]_]_VaXbO5QZcVOYSdTUdeefRVXZRgWTRZVdTVhggWRdUdWTV]iWjkVlm_VUWViZekVnWQUWTfRVXPYZV[\]_]_nWUdWTVUWVidRodRR5pBq=r5st5uq=v5A<C;<@w5xu;;NyzL=@;>D5{5.5uppBrN|B;5K=yqNCN;B<@5<p5K=pwuq=v5A<C;<@5B@5}~??<C;5<p56=?qt�5{5/5u??=@rBv5�~;z=Ct5|w5�<KNrrtwM<L599M5xKw5uCB�w/2.3�x7B>=@>;=B@�5KN|Br�5�HCN@>p=CC=r5pC<L5N�r5<@5F0.E0/2.1w�5x7@;=C=rD5./0/10/2.3�
./0/10/2.3 4�5AGHIGJ59=N|=5;<5�Bq=5J<@�7q=y;C<@By57vzBsB;5��5|Br=<5�zByz5B>57vzBsB;5u5;<5K=p=@rN@;uq=v5A<C;<@�>5K=yqNCN;B<@5xK<y541�.�5C=D54156=?qt5;<56=>?<@>=5;<5A<;B<@5UWVidRodRRPT�ZQVXPYZV[\]_]_5st5uq=v5A<C;<@w5xu;;NyzL=@;>D5{5.5H=v;5<p58C<?<>=r5GCr=Cw?rp5pBq=<p5?C<?<>=r5GCr=C5�CN@;B@�59=N|=5;<5�Bq=5J<@�=q=y;C<@By57vzBsB;5u�x7B>=@>;=B@�5KN|Br��HCN@>p=CC=r5pC<L5N�r5<@5F0.E0/2.1w�5x7@;=C=rD5./0/10/2.3�
./0/10/2.3 4F5AGHIGJ5p<C57v;=@>B<@5<p5HBL=5;<5}=C|=58C<y=>>5<@5K=p=@rN@;5�BL5�~B5x}=y<@r6=�~=>;�5st5�NL=>5�5us<q;B@w5xu;;NyzL=@;>D5{5.57vzBsB;5u5;zC~57�5{5/5H=v;5<p58C<?<>=rGCr=C�x�CNt�5KN|Br�5�HCN@>p=CC=r5pC<L5N�r5<@5F0.E0/2.1w�5x7@;=C=rD5./0/10/2.3�
./0/10/2.3 325�6789:5;<56=>?<@>=5;<5A<;B<@5dTV�PggWQUVWeVnWUdWTVUWV�UQd�Z5C=D5�25A<;B<@5;<5};CB�=5st8qNB@;Bpp5�NL=>5�5us<q;B@w5x�CNt�5KN|Br�5�A<rBpB=r5;<5y<CC=y;5=|=@;5N@r5Nrr5r<y~L=@;qB@�5<@5./0/�0/2.35x67��w5�HCN@>p=CC=r5pC<L5N�r5<@5F0.E0/2.1w�5x7@;=C=rD5./0/10/2.3�
./0/�0/2.3 3.5G6K765�CN@;B@�54�5A<;B<@5p<C59=N|=w5IH5I}5��6H�765G6K767K5;zN;58qNB@;Bpp5>zNqqpBq=5;z=5@<@�=q=y;C<@By5=vzBsB;5B@5Nyy<CrN@y=5�B;z5;z=5?C<y=r~C=>5>=;5p<C;z5B@5}=y;B<@IIwJw/5<p5;z=57q=y;C<@By5MN>=5�BqB@�5urLB@B>;CN;B|=58<qByB=>5N@r58C<y=r~C=>5AN@~Nqw}B�@=r5st5�~r�=5};=|=@58w59<�N@5<@5./0/�0.3wxM9��5�HCN@>p=CC=r5pC<L5N�r5<@F0.E0/2.1w�5x7@;=C=rD5./0/�0/2.3�
./0/�0/2.3 3/5JGHIM75C=D5<p5�BqB@�5J<@�7q=y;C<@By57vzBsB;5st5uq=v5A<C;<@5C=D53.5GCr=C5<@5A<;B<@5p<CAB>y=qqN@=<~>56=qB=p5�ZS�ZVUWVadYZV�WT��YZjUQWTdjV���ddUw5x7B>=@>;=B@�5KN|Br��HCN@>p=CC=r5pC<L5N�r5<@5F0.E0/2.1w�5x7@;=C=rD5./0/�0/2.3�
./0/�0/2.3 3E5G6K765�CN@;B@�58qNB@;Bpp�>54F5A<;B<@5p<C57v;=@>B<@5<p5HBL=w58qNB@;Bpp5>zNqq5zN|=5~@;Bq�=sC~NCt5E�5/2.1�5;<5Nyy<L?qB>z5>=C|By=5N@r5pBq=5?C<<p5<p5>=C|By=5N>5;<5K=p=@rN@;5�BL�~Bw5�NBq~C=5;<5r<5><5�Bqq5C=>~q;5B@5;z=5rB>LB>>Nq5<p5;z=5~@>=C|=r5K=p=@rN@;w5}B�@=r5st�~r�=5};=|=@58w59<�N@5<@5./0/�0.3w5xM9��5�HCN@>p=CC=r5pC<L5N�r5<@5F0.E0/2.1w�x7@;=C=rD5./0/�0/2.3�
./0/F0/2.3 5KB>�5�57vzBsB;5u5;<5K=p=@rN@;5A<C;<@�>5K=yqNCN;B<@�5K<yw541�.5zN>5s==@5C=y=B|=r5N@r5B>>;<C=r5B@5;z=58z<=@Bv5pBq=5C<<Lw5HzB>5B>5N5H7�H57JH6:5GJ9:w5Hz=C=5B>5@<58K�r<y~L=@;5N>><yBN;=r5�B;z5;zB>5=@;Ctw5xMuK�5�HCN@>p=CC=r5pC<L5N�r5<@5F0.E0/2.1w�x7@;=C=rD52.02�0/2.1�
./0E20/2.3 3�5JGHIM75C=D5M=C;BpByN;B<@5<p5M<@p=CCNq5st5�N><@5MNCNLN@B>5C=D54/5AGHIGJ5;<5KB>LB>>MN>=5OPQRPSTUVUWVaXbOVXPYZV[\]_]\_5bZQUdedjSUdWTVWeVbWTeZQQSYVUWVnWUdWTVUWVidRodRRwxu;;NyzL=@;>D5{5.57vzBsB;5u;;NyzL=@;5;<5M=C;BpByN;B<@5<p5M<@p=CCNq�x�=qqLN@�5}y<;;��HCN@>p=CC=r5pC<L5N�r5<@5F0.E0/2.1w�5x7@;=C=rD5./0E20/2.3�
2.02�0/2.1 345JGHIM75G�5uHHG6J7:�}5M�uJ�75G�5uKK67}}0�I6A5JuA75st5KN|Br5�CBppB;z7B>=@>;=B@w5x7B>=@>;=B@�5KN|Br�5�HCN@>p=CC=r5pC<L5N�r5<@5F0.E0/2.1w�5x7@;=C=rD2.02�0/2.1�
2.0230/2.1 335}HI8�9uHIGJ5ahXV� ¡���¢h�VhaV¡¢n�5st5�NL=>5�5us<q;B@w5xu;;NyzL=@;>D5{5.5H=v;<p58C<?<>=r5GCr=C�x�N;yz=q<C�5�<@N;zN@�5�HCN@>p=CC=r5pC<L5N�r5<@5F0.E0/2.1w�5x7@;=C=rD2.0230/2.1�
2.0230/2.1 315G6K765�CN@;B@�5;z=5?NC;B=>�5335};B?~qN;B<@w58qNB@;Bpp5>zNqq5zN|=5~@;Bq5�N@~NCt5.1�5/2.15;<pBq=5N56=>?<@>=5;<5K=p=@rN@;5�N><@5MNCNLN@B>�5A<;B<@5;<5KB>LB>>54/5w5}B�@=r5st5�~r�=};=|=@58w59<�N@5<@5.030.1w5xM9��5�HCN@>p=CC=r5pC<L5N�r5<@5F0.E0/2.1w�5x7@;=C=rD2.0230/2.1�
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 32 of 50 PageID 2563
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� �'�+)
./0/102./3 456789:;<6=>6<??@A@6?BC64D67=AEFB6=>6;G@HIB6=>6JKK?BLL0ME?N67@NB6OJAA=?HBPQ6RPSB>BHK@HA6JTBU6V=?A=HWW6O<ELBHLABEHX6S@YEKQ6Z9?@HL>B??BK6>?=N6@[K6=H6\0/102./3W]O<HAB?BKC6./0/102./3Q
./0/302./3 4\6 9:_ aJ9:876?BC6D26V89:876A=6SELNELL6;@LB6bcdecfghihjiklmbilcnoipqrstrqt6RPu@NBL6u6JR=TAEHW6OJAA@FGNBHALC6v6/69BUA6=>6_?=w=LBK68?KB?QOx@AFGBT=?X6u=H@AG@HQZ9?@HL>B??BK6>?=N6@[K6=H6\0/102./3W]6O<HAB?BKC6./0/302./3Q
./0/502./3 3.68yS<y6AG@A6AGB6AEwzT@AE=H64\6EL6I?@HABKW6_T@EHAE>>6LG@TT6G@YB6zHAET6u@Hz@?P621X62./36A=>ETB6@6yBLw=HLBW6EIHBK6RP6uzKIB6ABYBH6_W6a=I@H6=H6/0/50/3W6O;axQ6Z9?@HL>B??BK6>?=N@[K6=H6\0/102./3W]6O<HAB?BKC6./0/502./3Q
./0/\02./3 3/6 <y{:;<6<|<; 9<S6>ETBK6RP6u@NBL6u6JR=TAEHC6yzTB6}6~@EYB?6=>6B?YEFB6=>6zNN=HLW~@EYB?6LBHA6=H6u@Hz@?P6/3X62./36A=6�EN6�zE6W6OMB??zFFEX6S@YEKQ6Z9?@HL>B??BK6>?=N6@[K6=H\0/102./3W]6O<HAB?BKC6./0/\02./3Q
./02102./3 326y<_87 <6EH68ww=LEAE=H6?BC6D26V89:876A=6SELNELL6;@LB6bcdecfghihjiklmbilcnopqrstrqt6>ETBK6RP6u@NBL6u6JR=TAEHW6OJAA@FGNBHALC6v6/6<UGEREA6J�xQOx@AFGBT=?X6u=H@AG@HQZ9?@HL>B??BK6>?=N6@[K6=H6\0/102./3W]6O<HAB?BKC6./02102./3Q
./02302./3 316789:;<6?BC6789:;<68M6<y{:;<68M6_y<a:V:7Jy�68yS<y6RP6u@NBL6u6JR=TAEH?BC6/568?KB?6?B6yzTB6/2ORQ6V=AE=HL6W6OMB??zFFEX6S@YEKQ6Z9?@HL>B??BK6>?=N6@[K6=H\0/102./3W]6O<HAB?BKC6./02302./3Q
./01.02./3 3}6�yBwTP6A=6yBLw=HLB6A=6V=AE=H6?BC6D26V89:876A=6SELNELL6;@LB6bcdecfghihjiklmbilcnopqrstrqt6�o�og�fghi�fejgimfdf�fg�e�ilo�n�ihjibnf�gh���i�sjnh�g�eiloe�jgeoi�gi���je�h�jghji�jh�jgihji��e��ee6>ETBK6RP6u@L=H6;@?@N@HELW6O~BTTN@HX6F=AAQ6�V=KE>EBK6A=6F=??BFABYBHA6APwB6=H6/01/02./36O<uJQW6Z9?@HL>B??BK6>?=N6@[K6=H6\0/102./3W]6O<HAB?BKC./01.02./3Q
./01.02./3 3D6�8xu<;9:876A=6<UGEREAL6?BC63}6yBLw=HLB6A=6V=AE=H6�o�og�fghi�fejgimfdf�fg�e��s�o�h�jgeihji����s�hei�hhf��o�ihjibnf�gh���i�sjnh�g�eiloe�jgeoi�gi���je�h�jgihji�jh�jgihj��e��ee6RP6SB>BHK@HA6u@L=H6;@?@N@HELW6O~BTTN@HX6F=AAQ6�V=KE>EBK6A=6F=??BFA6K=FzNBHAHzNRB?6=H6/01/02./36O<uJQW6Z9?@HL>B??BK6>?=N6@[K6=H6\0/102./3W]6O<HAB?BKC6./01.02./3Q
./01.02./3 346789:;<68M6~J:{<y68M6<a<;9y87:;6<y{:;<6RP6JTEH@6;?ELAEH@6VB�B?X6F=zHLBT>=?6SB>BHK@HAL6uBzHBLLB6aa;X6F=AA6J6aB�ELX6~BHKP6y6aB�ELX68I@TB6y@PW6Ox?=F�BTN@HX�BHAQ6Z9?@HL>B??BK6>?=N6@[K6=H6\0/102./3W]6O<HAB?BKC6./01.02./3Q
.20.\02./3 336y<_87 <6?BC63D68R�BFAE=H6b������kk��il��b����i��i��k������m�l�������i����m�����i��i��������6RP6_T@EHAE>>6u@NBL6u6JR=TAEHW6OJAA@FGNBHALCv6/6<UGEREA6J6�6SBFT@?@AE=H6=>6u=H@AG@H6x@AFGBT=?X6v626<UGEREA6/X6v616<UGEREA62X6v6}<UGEREA61QOMB??zFFEX6S@YEKQ6Z9?@HL>B??BK6>?=N6@[K6=H6\0/102./3W]6O<HAB?BKC6.20.\02./3Q
.20/102./3 356ME?LA6V89:876A=6A?E�B6336yBLw=HLB6RP6u@L=H6;@?@N@HELW6O~BTTN@HX6;G?ELQ6Z9?@HL>B??BK>?=N6@[K6=H6\0/102./3W]6O<HAB?BKC6.20/102./3Q
.202302./3 3\6y<_87 <6A=6V=AE=H6?BC6356ME?LA6V89:876A=6A?E�B6336yBLw=HLB6hji�s�o�h�jgihj����s�he6>ETBK6RP6u@NBL6u6JR=TAEHW6Ox@AFGBT=?X6u=H@AG@HQ6Z9?@HL>B??BK6>?=N6@[K6=H\0/102./3W]6O<HAB?BKC6.202302./3Q
.202502./3 5.6789:;<6=>6<??@A@6?BC63\6yBLw=HLB6A=6V=AE=H6RP6_T@EHAE>>6u@NBL6u6JR=TAEHWWOJAA@FGNBHALC6v6/6<UGEREA6<UGEREA6JQOMB??zFFEX6S@YEKQ6Z9?@HL>B??BK6>?=N6@[K6=H\0/102./3W]6O<HAB?BKC6.202502./3Q
.10.102./3 5/6y<_a�6A=6yBLw=HLB6A=6V=AE=H6?BC6356ME?LA6V89:876A=6A?E�B6336yBLw=HLB6>ETBK6RPu@L=H6;@?@N@HELW6O~BTTN@HX6F=AAQ6Z9?@HL>B??BK6>?=N6@[K6=H6\0/102./3W]6O<HAB?BKC.10.102./3Q
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 33 of 50 PageID 2564
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� �(�+)
./0.102.31 4256789:;5<=>56789:;57?578@;A5B989CD89765EF5GHI=J5G5DEKLMNO5P5Q?=<<RSSNT5UHVNWXY8<HOJZ=<<=W5Z<KI5H[W5KO5\03/02.31P]5Q;OM=<=W>5./0.102.31X
./0.102.31 4/56789:;5KZ5H<MF5UNJINJJHL5EF5GHI=J5G5DEKLMNOP5H<MF5_NI5@RN5QHO5NOWNVNWRHLXM=<INOHM=WP5Q?=<<RSSNT5UHVNWX5Y8<HOJZ=<<=W5Z<KI5H[W5KO5\03/02.31P]5Q;OM=<=W>./0.102.31X
.0.302.31 4a56789:;5<=>5BKSHL5ARL=51P2QOX59ObRN<F5EF5GHI=J5G5DEKLMNO5<=>5/15A=cLF5MK5A=JcKOJ=5MKdKMNKOT5/25A=JcKOJ=5NO57ccKJNMNKO5MK5dKMNKOT52a5d789765MK5:eHOf=5g=OR=08<HOJZ=<:HJ=5MK5dNWWL=5UNJM<NSM5KZ5?LK<NWH5P5Q?=<<RSSNT5UHVNWX5Y8<HOJZ=<<=W5Z<KI5H[W5KO\03/02.31P]5Q;OM=<=W>5.0.302.31X
.0.202.31 4h57AU;A5<=fH<WNOf5U=Z=OWHOMJi52a5dKMNKO5MK58<HOJZ=<5g=OR=>58e=5IHMM=<5NJ5ROW=<HWVNJ=I=OM5HOW5H5<RLNOf5jNLL5NJJR=5NO5WR=5SKR<J=P56K5ZR<Me=<5HSMNKO5EF5Me=5cH<MN=J5NJ<=bRN<=W5HM5MeNJ5MNI=P5kNfO=W5EF5GRWf=5kM=V=O55BKfHO5KO50202.31P5Qdd7X5Y8<HOJZ=<<=WZ<KI5H[W5KO5\03/02.31P]5Q;OM=<=W>5.0.202.31X
.\03202.31 457AU;A5l59859k57AU;A;U>53P58eHM5U=Z=OWHOM5dK<MKOiJ5dKMNKO5MK5UNJINJJ5cR<JRHOM5MK?=W=<HL5ARL=5KZ5:NVNL5<KS=WR<=532QEXQhX5QUKSP5/\5X5NJ5f<HOM=W5NO5cH<M5HOW5W=ON=W5NJ5cH<MP8e=5IKMNKO5NJ5f<HOM=W5MK5Me=5=mM=OM5MeHM5J=<VNS=5KO5U=Z=OWHOM5DL=m5dK<MKO5NJ5bRHJe=Wn52P8eHM5LHNOMNZZ5JeHLL5eHV=5235WHFJ5Z<KI5Me=5WHM=5KZ5MeNJ57<W=<5MK5HSSKIcLNJe5J=<VNS=5KOU=Z=OWHOM5DL=m5dK<MKO5HOW5ZNL=5c<KKZ5KZ5J=<VNS=n5/P58eHM5LHNOMNZZiJ5dKMNKO5MK5kM<No=QUKSP5a.5X5NJ5W=ON=Wn5aP58eHM5U=Z=OWHOMJi5dKMNKO5MK5:eHOf=5g=OR=08<HOJZ=<5:HJ=5MKdNWWL=5UNJM<NSM5KZ5?LK<NWH5cR<JRHOM5MK5245pPkP:P5q53a.aQHX5QUKSP52a5X5NJ5f<HOM=Wn5hP58eHMU=Z=OWHOM5:H<HIHONJiJ5dKMNKO5MK5UNJINJJ5cR<JRHOM5MK5?=W=<HL5ARL=5KZ5:NVNL5<KS=WR<=32QEXQ2X5QUKSP5h25X5HOW5dKMNKO5MK5kM<No=5QUKSP5145X5H<=5W=ON=W5HJ5IKKMn5HOW5P58eHM5Me=:L=<o5KZ5:KR<M5JeHLL5M<HOJZ=<5MeNJ5HSMNKO5MK5Me=5dNWWL=5UNJM<NSM5KZ5?LK<NWH5HOW5M=<INOHM=5Me=SHJ=5NO5MeNJ5WNJM<NSMP5Qk==5WKSRI=OM5ZK<5ZR<Me=<5W=MHNLJXP5kNfO=W5EF5GRWf=5kM=V=O55BKfHOKO5\033031P5QBDUX5Y8<HOJZ=<<=W5Z<KI5H[W5KO5\03/02.31P]5Q;OM=<=W>5.\03202.31X
.\03/02.31 415:HJ=5M<HOJZ=<<=W5NO5Z<KI5UNJM<NSM5KZ5D<N[KOHn5:HJ=56RIE=<52>3lSVl.2h1aP5?NL=5<=S=NV=W=L=SM<KONSHLLF5Q;OM=<=W>5.\03/02.31X
.\03/02.31 4456789:;5MK5DBB5SKROJ=L5rUHVNW5C=K<ZZ<=F5s<HFT5UHVNW56RO[NK5?=<<RSSNT5GKOHMeHO5kSKMMsHMSe=LK<T5DLNOH5:<NJMNOH5d=t=<T5G=ZZ<=F5kP5GHSKEJKOT5_=OM5kP5s<KSo=LIHOT5ke=LL=F8KLIHOT5:e<NJ5u=LLIHOT5kSKMM5uP5u=LLIHOT5UHVNW5C<NZZNMe5;NJ=OJM=NOv5KZ5BKSHL5ARL=2P.25QJNfO=W5EF5W=cRMF5SL=<oXP5QdDDX5Q;OM=<=W>5.\03/02.31X
.\03402.31 4\56789:;5KZ5Dcc=H<HOS=5EF5G=OONOfJ5BP5@R<MT59995KO5E=eHLZ5KZ5G=RO=JJ=5BB:T5kSKMM5DB=jNJT5u=OWF5AP5B=jNJT57fHL=5AHF5Q@R<MT5G=OONOfJX5Q;OM=<=W>5.\03402.31X
.\03402.31 \.56789:;5EF5G=RO=JJ=5BB:T5kSKMM5D5B=jNJT5u=OWF5AP5B=jNJT57fHL=5AHF5wxyz{|}~���}w�ywx{��}�y�zz�{||{|5Q@R<MT5G=OONOfJX5Q;OM=<=W>5.\03402.31X
.\02302.31 \35d789765ZK<5G=ZZ<=F5GHSKEJKO5MK5Hcc=H<5c<K5eHS5VNS=5KO5E=eHLZ5KZ5G=RO=JJ=5BB:T5kSKMM5DB=jNJT5u=OWF5AP5B=jNJT57fHL=5AHFP5BKSHL5:KROJ=L>5G=OONOfJ5BP5@R<M5999P56KOlA=JNW=OM:KROJ=L>5G=ZZ<=F5kP5GHSKEJKOP5QDMMHSeI=OMJ>5�535;meNENM5j<NMM=O5W=JNfOHMNKOT5�525;meNENMHMMK<O=F5S=<MNZNSHMNKOXQ@R<MT5G=OONOfJX5dKWNZN=W5KO5\02202.315QAU7XP5Q;OM=<=W>.\02302.31X
.\02302.31 \25d789765ZK<5CL=OO5C<HeHI5MK5Hcc=H<5c<K5eHS5VNS=5EF5G=OONOfJ5BP5@R<MT59995KO5E=eHLZ5KZG=RO=JJ=5BB:T5kSKMM5D5B=jNJT5u=OWF5AP5B=jNJT57fHL=5AHFP5BKSHL5:KROJ=L>5G=OONOfJ5BP@R<M5999P56KOlA=JNW=OM5:KROJ=L>5CL=OO5C<HeHIP5QDMMHSeI=OMJ>5�535;meNENM5j<NMM=OW=JNfOHMNKOT5�525;meNENM5HMMK<O=F5S=<MNZNSHMNKOXQ@R<MT5G=OONOfJX5dKWNZN=W5KO5\02202.31QAU7XP5Q;OM=<=W>5.\02302.31X
.\02202.31 \/5�������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ������������������������������¡�¢������£��¤���¥������¦����
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 34 of 50 PageID 2565
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� ���+)
./01/234256/7189:;2<:2=>??>?@AB42CDEFG2HIJKLMLNOPQRSTTSTQUVW
QRSTTSTQUV RXPYZ[\]IP_PaaLbMbJcLPdePfbghJPibghNPjbkblhJLMPJPdLmbn_P_PobpJP]bMbqbJhpHjbkblhJLMrPfbghJWPHIJKLMLNOPQRSTTSTQUVW
QRSTTSTQUV RsPtIYIuIiPjZ[\ZYP_MPoL__MLePobcdpJPKPbaaLbMPaMPmbcPghcLPJPdLmbn_P_PoLvJLppLww]rPxcKKPPwLyhprPuLJNePtzPwLyhprPZkbnLPtbezPwcbnP]vJpLnOPoLJJhJkpPwzP{vMKP\\\zYJ|tLphNLJKP]vJpLnOPoL__MLePobcdpJzPHKKbcmqLJKpOP}PUPI~mhdhKPyMhKKLJPNLphkJbKhbJNPcJpLJKPKPbcKrP}PTPI~mhdhKPbKKMJLePcLMKh_hcbKhJWH{vMKrPoLJJhJkpWPj Nh_hLNPJRSTsSTQUVPHtiZWzPHIJKLMLNOPQRSTTSTQUVW
QRSTTSTQUV R�PtIYIuIiPjZ[\ZYP_MPfnLJJPfMbmbqPKPbaaLbMPaMPmbcPghcLPJPdLmbn_P_PoLvJLppLww]rPxcKKPPwLyhprPuLJNePtzPwLyhprPZkbnLPtbezPwcbnP]vJpLnOPoLJJhJkpPwzP{vMKP\\\zYJ|tLphNLJKP]vJpLnOPfnLJJPfMbmbqzPHKKbcmqLJKpOP}PUPI~mhdhKPyMhKKLJPNLphkJbKhJbJNPcJpLJKPKPbcKrP}PTPI~mhdhKPbKKMJLePcLMKh_hcbKhJWH{vMKrPoLJJhJkpWPj Nh_hLNPJRSTsSTQUVPHtiZWzPHIJKLMLNOPQRSTTSTQUVW
QRSTsSTQUV RVP�3�D32;0/:�9:;2=�2�<�9<:2�<2/66�/0260<2�/�2�9���2;0/:�9:;2=�2�<�9<:2�<2/66�/060<2�/�2�9��42F���0��2F/�<��<:�2D��42/:82�1�::2�0/�/��2D��4�2�/�2�6��9/11�2/66�/09:2��9�2�/��2/�2�<7:��12�<02����:8/:��2�9��2F�::9:;�2�42�70��2����2D��4�2��0�9:;2/�1<�/12�<7:��14259;:�82��2�/;9��0/��2F78;�2./01/234256/7189:;2<:2=>?�>?@AB42CDEFGHIJKLMLNOPQRSTsSTQUVW
QRSTsSTQUV R�PjZ[\ZYP_MPxcKKPuzPuLnnqbJPKPbaaLbMPaMPmbcPghcLPdePobpJP]bMbqbJhpzPHjbkblhJLMrfbghJWPHIJKLMLNOPQRSTsSTQUVW
QRSTsSTQUV RRPjZ[\ZYP_MP]mMhpPuLnnqbJPKPbaaLbMPaMPmbcPghcLPdePobpJP]bMbqbJhpzPHjbkblhJLMrfbghJWPHIJKLMLNOPQRSTsSTQUVW
QRST�STQUV UQQPYZ[\]IP_PaaLbMbJcLPdePqbJNbPtpLPivJJPJPdLmbn_P_PobpJP]bMbqbJhpPHivJJrqbJNbWPHIJKLMLNOPQRST�STQUVW
QRST�STQUV P����tZP{ ]P�\]IP�IIxPabhNPbJNPxaLchbnPNqhpphJPKKMJLeP]LMKh_hcbKhJP�Mq_hnLNPdePbKKMJLePxcKKPuLnnqbJrPbaaLbMhJkPJPdLmbn_P_PobpJP]bMbqbJhpPH�hnhJkP_LLP�UsQMLcLhaKPJvqdLMPZtwQ�VTQQzWPtLnbKLNPNcvqLJKOPR�PjZ[\ZYP_MPxcKKPuzPuLnnqbJPKbaaLbMPaMPmbcPghcLzPHtiZWPHIJKLMLNOPQRST�STQUVW
QRST�STQUV P����tZP{ ]P�\]IP�IIxPabhNPbJNPxaLchbnPNqhpphJPKKMJLeP]LMKh_hcbKhJP�Mq_hnLNPdePbKKMJLeP]mMhpPuLnnqbJrPbaaLbMhJkPJPdLmbn_P_PobpJP]bMbqbJhpPH�hnhJkP_LL�UsQPMLcLhaKPJvqdLMPZtwQ�VURRzWPtLnbKLNPNcvqLJKOPRRPjZ[\ZYP_MP]mMhpPuLnnqbJKPbaaLbMPaMPmbcPghcLzPHtiZWPHIJKLMLNOPQRST�STQUVW
QRSTVSTQUV UQUP�3�D323D�55������2E�5D42E1�0�29�2890���9:;2�<20�/��9;:2�/��2�<2/:<���0�9��09��2F78;�2�<02/112�70���0260<���89:;�4259;:�82��25�:9<02F78;�2�42.�:8/1125�/06<:2=>?B>?@AB42C�<7:��12�/91�8>��/91�8GC�.FG2HIJKLMLNOPQRSTVSTQUVW
QRSTVSTQUV UQTP]bpLPtLbpphkJLNPKPovNkLP�bvnPfzP eMJzPYLyPcbpLPJvqdLMOP�OUV|cg|U�TX|Ztw|XQ¡txzxLJhMPovNkLPfzP¡LJNbnnPxmbMaPJPnJkLMPbpphkJLNPKPKmLPcbpLzPHo�WPHIJKLMLNOPQRST�STQUVW
QRSTRSTQUV UQ¢P3D��£D�2E�5D2�3�D32���2��£�ED2<�28��9;:/�9<:27:8�02�<�/12371�2¤4@�2¥�0/��2?42£��2�<�9��2<�2¦�:8�:��2<�2����02���9<:�2��/112��2�91�82�9��9:2�<70���:2CA§G8/��2�0<�2���28/��2<�2��9�2�08�04259;:�82��2F78;�2¦/712�42�0<:2<:2=>?=>?@AB4C�� G2�<69��2�/91�8>�¥�/91�8PHIJKLMLNOPQRSTRSTQUVW
QRSTRSTQUV UQXP��£D3D5£D�2¦D35��52�3�D342£��2E�0�9�9�/��2<�2�:��0����82¦�0�<:�2��/112���91�82�9��9:2�<70���:2CA§G28/��2�0<�2���28/��2<�2��9�2�08�04259;:�82��2F78;�2¦/712�4�0<:2<:2=>?=>?@AB42C�� G2�<69��2�/91�8>�¥�/91�8PHIJKLMLNOPQRSTRSTQUVW
UQSQTSTQUV UQsP�3�D328�:�9:;2�9��<7�260�©789��2=ª2�<�9<:2�<2/66�/0260<2�/�2�9���28�:�9:;
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 35 of 50 PageID 2566
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� ���+)
./012304567839/:74;;4<20/2=4024>557>6456241>:4?/:7@4A/B=794CD4E>B/F06>074G39B7H>6I>4J@4A5>3I9/=B42=4;KL;KLMNO@4PQRGS4TUVWXYXZ[\]_ _ ]ab
]_ _ ]a ]c\defgeh\Wi\XjWXVZ\WklX\Wi\mXYnX\oYipXqq\rVZ\siY\tXrnX\Wi\oXYsiYl\uvWXYVrWknX\mXYnkpXiV\wXsXVZrVW\uvXj\diYWiV\xy\zrlXq\z\uxivWkV{\T|Yk}xrqk~\�k}ryb\diWkiVq\YXsXYYXZ\Widr�kqWYrWX\z�Z�X\�rYvr\�{\m�r�vZkV�{\TUVWXYXZ[\]_ _ ]ab
]_ _ ]a \���o�e\�u�\�g�U\�UUm\�rkZ\rVZ\m�Xpkrv\uZlkqqkiV\uWWiYVXy\�XYWkskprWkiV\�iYlskvXZ\xy\rWWiYVXy\�vXVV\f{\�Yr�rl~\r��XrYkV�\iV\xX�rvs\is\zX�VXqqX\tt�~\mpiWW\u\tX�kq~�XVZy\�{\tX�kq~\e�rvX\�ry\T�kvkV�\sXX\�]�\YXpXk�W\V�lxXY\e�tca�c]{b\�XvrWXZZip�lXVW[\�c\�UhU�Uw\defgeh\siY\�vXVV\�Yr�rl\Wi\r��XrY\�Yi\�rp\nkpX{\T�webTUVWXYXZ[\]_�_ ]ab
]_ _ ]a \���o�e\�u�\�g�U\�UUm\�rkZ\rVZ\m�Xpkrv\uZlkqqkiV\uWWiYVXy\�XYWkskprWkiV\�iYlskvXZ\xy\rWWiYVXy\zXssYXy\m{\zrpixqiV~\r��XrYkV�\iV\xX�rvs\is\zX�VXqqX\tt�~\mpiWW\utX�kq~\�XVZy\�{\tX�kq~\e�rvX\�ry\T�kvkV�\sXX\�]�\YXpXk�W\V�lxXY\e�tca�c{b�XvrWXZ\Zip�lXVW[\��\�UhU�Uw\defgeh\siY\zXssYXy\zrpixqiV\Wi\r��XrY\�Yi\�rp\nkpX{T�web\TUVWXYXZ[\]_�_ ]ab
]_�_ ]a ]a\mfgo�tufgeh\�������������������������� �¡¢£¡¤£¡¥����¦��§������© ª������«��¬��§ ª���xy\zX�VXqqX\tt�~\mpiWW\u\tX�kq~\�XVZy\�{\tX�kq~\e�rvX\�ry{\TuWWrp�lXVWq[\\]\Uj�kxkW�Yi�iqXZ\iYZXYbT��YW~\zXVVkV�qb\diZkskXZ\iV\]_®_ ]a\T�web{\TUVWXYXZ[\]_�_ ]ab
]_®_ ]a ] \°J±QJ4B6>=0/=B4NMO4A0/53I>0/2=4²264Q³07=F/2=42²4/<74024J7F52=94024µI>/=0/²²¶FR2<5I>/=0@417497>9I/=74²264±7²7=9>=0F4G73=7FF74··R4¹7=9D4J@4·7./F4°B>I74J>D>=94A:2004º@4·7./F402467F52=94024µI>/=0/²²¶F4:2<5I>/=04/F47³07=9794354024>=9/=:I39/=B4°:02C764N»4LMNO@4¼2/=B4²26.>69467I/7²4F123I94C7467½37F0794CD4<20/2=6>0176401>=4CD4F0/53I>0/2=@4A/B=794CD4E>B/F06>074G39B74H>6I>4J@4A5>3I9/=B42=NMK¾KLMNO@4PQRGS4TUVWXYXZ[\]_®_ ]ab
]_®_ ]a ]�\�UhU�Uw\defgeh\siY\mpiWW\�{\�XvvlrV\Wi\r��XrY\�Yi\�rp\nkpX\xy\zrqiV\�rYrlrVkq{TuWWrp�lXVWq[\\]\Uj�kxkW\u~\\\Uj�kxkW\|bTdr�r¿kVXY~\�rnkVb\diWkiVq\YXsXYYXZ\Widr�kqWYrWX\z�Z�X\�rYvr\�{\m�r�vZkV�{\diZkskXZ\iV\]_�_ ]a\T�web{\TUVWXYXZ[]_®_ ]ab
]_®_ ]a ]]\�UhU�Uw\defgeh\siY\��Ykq\�XvvlrV\Wi\r��XrY\�Yi\�rp\nkpX\xy\zrqiV\�rYrlrVkq{TuWWrp�lXVWq[\\]\Uj�kxkW\u~\\\Uj�kxkW\|bTdr�r¿kVXY~\�rnkVb\diWkiVq\YXsXYYXZ\Widr�kqWYrWX\z�Z�X\�rYvr\�{\m�r�vZkV�{\diZkskXZ\iV\]_�_ ]a\T�web{\TUVWXYXZ[]_®_ ]ab
]_®_ ]a ]]]\°J±QJ4ºÀ±4±ÁJQR Á°À4°4ÂQ4R·QJH4°Ã4R°ÄJ 4B6>=0/=B4NM;4J7=7.79E20/2=4024º557>64µ624Â>:4Å/:7Æ4B6>=0/=B4NNM4J7=7.794E20/2=4024º557>64µ624Â>:Å/:7@4A:2004¹@4¹7II<>=4QF½@4>=94R16/F4¹7II<>=4QF½@4<>D4F57:/>IID4>557>64/=401/F:>F74>F4:23=F7I4²264±7²7=9>=04G>F2=4R>6><>=/F4./014¼>?/=4±@4E>B>Ç/=764QF½@F76?/=B4>F4I2:>I4:23=F7I@4A/B=794CD4E>B/F06>074G39B74H>6I>4J@4A5>3I9/=B42=NMK¾KLMNO@4PQRGS4TUVWXYXZ[\]_®_ ]ab
]_®_ ]a ]]\�Vi��iqXZ\defgeh\siY\UjWXVqkiV\is\fklX\Wi\�kvX\�Xq�iVqX_�X�vy\rq\Wi\]\�il�vrkVWxy\zrqiV\�rYrlrVkq{\Tdr�r¿kVXY~\�rnkVb\diWkiVq\YXsXYYXZ\Wi\dr�kqWYrWX\z�Z�X\�rYvr\�{m�r�vZkV�{\TUVWXYXZ[\]_®_ ]ab
]_�_ ]a \mXW_YXqXW\ZXrZvkVXq_�XrYkV�q[\siY\zX�VXqqX\tt�~\mpiWW\u\tX�kq~\�XVZy\�{\tX�kq~\e�rvX�ry{\uVq�XY\Z�X\xy\]_]c_ ]a{\T�web\TUVWXYXZ[\]_�_ ]ab
]_�_ ]a ]]�\°J±QJ4B6>=0/=B4NNL4Ä=2552F794E20/2=4²264Q³07=F/2=42²4/<74024J7F52=9402µI>=/0/²²F4R2<5I>/=0@417497>9I/=74²264±7²7=9>=04G>F2=4R>6><>=/F4024>=F.7642620176./F7467F52=940240174:2<5I>/=04/F47³07=9794354024>=94/=:I39/=B4°:02C764N»
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 36 of 50 PageID 2567
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� ���+)
./01234567893:;3<=65>?@=?83AB9683C=@D=3E234F=BD95763G730/HIH./0123JKLAM3NOPQRSRTUVWXWYXZWV[\
VWXW]XZWV[ ^_RQXSRRQTRaTbcPRXdRaScPeUfgShagPiaSajaPcklPmRSTnRopVWXV]XZWV[kNqrs\NOPQRSRTUVWXW]XZWV[\
VWXW]XZWV[ VVt usvwiOgfxRPTRPypgfSRbaQRTyaRxRSzgyabqnbRVkWtNT\SRVW{qRbaQRTiaRsSTRSophagPiaSajaPckqRbaQRTyaRN\UugN|RbbjaP}_ygQQ\~gTcfcRTgPVWXVWXZWV[Nqrs\kNOPQRSRTUVWXW]XZWV[\
VWXW]XZWV[ VVY iOqvw�wilvOgfcPQRSRQRTxRSgPaPTygSxgSaQRTcybgnSRQaQRjRPQSRVWtwPQRSRQRTxRSgPgSTRSophagPiaSajaPckN|RbbjaP}_ygQQ\NOPQRSRTUVWXW]XZWV[\
VWXVWXZWV[ VV] ~svwsuQg_noQcQnQRlQQgSPRp�����������������������������������ophRnPR Rzzi}_ygQQlzRmc}|RPTpqkzRmc}seabRqapkN�nSQ}hRPPcPe\~gQcgPSRfRSSRTQg~aecQSaQRhnTeR�aSbaqk_xanbTcPekNOPQRSRTUVWXVWXZWV[\
VWXVZXZWV[ VV[ hgcPQ~svwsufgSjcyRbbaPRgnSRbcRf}xRycfcyabbpQg_RQ�bRaTcPe_ydRTnbRophajRhlogbQcPkN�Sc�oac}�c�ap\NOPQRSRTUVWXVZXZWV[\
VWXVZXZWV[ VV� usvwiOgflxxRaSaPyRoplbaPhk�RSbjaPgPoRdabfgfhajRhlogbQcPN�RSbjaP}lbaP\NOPQRSRTUVWXVZXZWV[\
VWXV{XZWV[ VV� iOqvw�wilvOgfcPQRSRQRTxRSgPaPTygSxgSaQRTcybgnSRQaQRjRPQSRVWtwPQRSRQRTxRSgPgSTRSophRnPR Rzzi}_ygQQlzRmc}|RPTpqkzRmc}seabRqapkN�nSQ}hRPPcPe\NOPQRSRTUVWXV{XZWV[\
VWXV{XZWV[ VZW usvwiOgfxRPTRPypgfSRbaQRTyaRSRVW{qRbaQRTyaRgSTRSaPTQSay�ZPgQcyRxRSzgyabqnbRVkWtNT\ophRnPR Rzzi}_ygQQlzRmc}|RPTpqkzRmc}seabRqapkqRbaQRTyaRN\UPgN�nSQ}hRPPcPe\NOPQRSRTUVWXV{XZWV[\
VWXV{XZWV[ VZV �E�KE36@=7?576300�3<G?5G73�G@3 8=¡83�G@3¢5?£9@=¤=D3=7934B:>?5?B?5G73G�LGB7>8D23¥??G@78;3C87?3423¦@G§8D©=73=7934£8DD8;3ªGD©=73?8@©57=?89234567893:;<=65>?@=?83AB9683ª£G©=>3¦234©5?£3G730/H0«H./0123JKLAM3NOPQRSRTUVWXV{XZWV[\
VWXZ[XZWV[ VZZ �E�KE36@=7?5763573F=@?3=793987;5763573F=@?30013<G?5G73?G3>8?3�5D576398=9D578>23488G@98@3�G@398?=5D>234567893:;3<=65>?@=?83AB9683C=@D=3E234F=BD95763G730/H.1H./012J4F=BD9576¬3C=@D=M3NOPQRSRTUVWXZ[XZWV[\
VWX{WXZWV[ VZ{ l~OurOris~�zlwuvaeacPQlbb�aSQcRmcQdhnSprRjaPTkfcbRTophajRhklogbQcPkNlQQaydjRPQUVO®dcocQl¯�gbRpqRxgSQ}ZO®dcocQ�¯vwulzRQQRSQg�vi}{O®dcocQi¯hRnPR RsxxgSQnPcQp�baP}tO®dcocQr¯hRnPR R°ajRxbaP}YO®dcocQO¯hRnPR R�gbcypaPT�SgyRTnSR}]O®dcocQ� �ncPR rR±RbgxjRPQleSRRjRPQO®ajxbR\N�Sc�oac}�c�ap\NOPQRSRTUVWX{WXZWV[\
VWX{VXZWV[ VZt �E�KE36@=7?5763573F=@?3=793987;5763573F=@?30/�3<G?5G73�G@3K²?87>5G73G�3ª5©83=79 8=¡83?G3³8@�G@©3¥D?8@7=?5¡8348@¡5§83G73�8�879=7?3¥D8²3<G@?G7234567893:;<=65>?@=?83AB9683C=@D=3E234F=BD95763G730/H«0H./0123JKLAM3NOPQRSRTUVWX{VXZWV[\
VVXWZXZWV[ ^´ �qs�li�wiO�OO_xacTaPT_xRycablTjccgPlQQgSPRpiRSQcfcyaQcgP�gSjfcbRTopaQQgSPRpra±cTuk�RSSnyyc}axxRaScPegPoRdabfgfhajRhklogbQcP}�ajRbahk�PcedQN�cbcPefRRµVYW SRyRcxQPnjoRSsqzW]�Z�Vk\kNqrs\NOPQRSRTUVVXWZXZWV[\
VVXW{XZWV[ VZY �E�KE3�G@3AG7=?£=73¦=?§£8DG@¬3�=¡593¦@=;¬3L£@5>3¢8DD©=7¬3=793�=¡593¶8@@B§§53?G§G©FD;3¤5?£3?£83=9©575>?@=?5¡83F@G§89B@8>3@86=@957638D8§?@G75§3�5D5763¤5?£573?£5@?;J«/M39=;>3�@G©3?£839=?83G�3?£5>3�@98@234567893:;3AB9683³=BD3·23¦;@G73G7300H«H./012J· ¦M3§GF58>3©=5D89H8¹©=5D89NOPQRSRTUVVXW{XZWV[\
VVXW{XZWV[ VZ] �E�KE3�G@3�=¡593K5>87>?8573?G3§G©FD;3¤5?£3?£83=9©575>?@=?5¡83F@G§89B@8>@86=@957638D8§?@G75§3�5D5763¤5?£3?£5@?;3J«/M39=;>3�@G©3?£839=?83G�3?£5>3�@98@23456789
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 37 of 50 PageID 2568
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� ���+)
./0123450672809:0;/<=>0=>0??@A@BC?D:0E9F;G0H=IJ5K0L7J853MNOPQRSRTUMVVWXYWZXV[\
VVWX]WZXV[ M^ _aMbcdMefdOMgOOhMijkTMjPTMhiRlkjmMcTnkookpPMcQQpSPRqMdRSQkrkljQkpPMgpSnrkmRTMsqMjQQpSPRqMtpuPM_vMwRonpPTxMjiiRjSkPyMpPMsRujmrMprMtjnRoMtvMcspmQkPxM_jnRmjMtvzPkyuQMNgkmkPyMrRRM{V|XMSRlRkiQMP}nsRSMa ~X]�Y�Zv\vMNwa\MNOPQRSRTUMVVWX]WZXV[\
VVWX]WZXV[ M^ _aMbcdMefdOMgOOhMijkTMjPTMhiRlkjmMcTnkookpPMcQQpSPRqMdRSQkrkljQkpPMgpSnrkmRTMsqMjQQpSPRqMtpPjQujPMhvM�jQluRmpSxMjiiRjSkPyMpPMsRujmrMprMtjnRoMtvMcspmQkPxM_jnRmjtvMzPkyuQMNgkmkPyMrRRM{V|XMSRlRkiQMP}nsRSMa ~X]�Y�Vv\vMNwa\MNOPQRSRTUMVVWX]WZXV[\
VVWX]WZXV[ VZ[M�a�fa�MrpSMtpuPM_vMwRonpPTMQpMjiiRjSMiSpMujlM�klRMsqMcmmM_mjkPQkrrovMNcQQjlunRPQoUM�VMO�ukskQMcM�MwRlmjSjQkpPMprMtpuPM_vMwRonpPTxM�MZMO�ukskQMO�ukskQM�M�MhiRlkjmMcTnkookpPcQQqMdRSQkrkljQkpPMsqMtpuPM_vMwRonpPT\N�Sk�sjokxMek�jq\M�pQkpPoMSRrRSSRTMQpM�jykoQSjQRt}TyRMzjSmjMvMhij}mTkPyvMNOPQRSRTUMVVWX]WZXV[\
VVWX]WZXV[ VZ�M�a�fa�MrpSMtpPjQujPMhvM�jQluRmpSMQpMjiiRjSMiSpMujlM�klRMsqMcmmM_mjkPQkrrovNcQQjlunRPQoUM�MVMO�ukskQMO�ukskQMcM�MwRlmjSjQkpPMprMtpPjQujPMhvM�jQluRmpSxM�MZMO�ukskQO�ukskQM�M�MhiRlkjmMcTnkookpPMcQQqMdRSQkrkljQkpPMsqMtpPjQujPMhvM�jQluRmpS\N�Sk�sjokxek�jq\M�pQkpPoMSRrRSSRTMQpM�jykoQSjQRMt}TyRMzjSmjMvMhij}mTkPyvMNOPQRSRTUMVVWX]WZXV[\
VVWX]WZXV[ VZ�M�a�fa�MrpSMwj�kTM�vMgRSS}llkMQpMjiiRjSMiSpMujlM�klRMsqMcmmM_mjkPQkrrovMNcQQjlunRPQoUM�VMO�ukskQMO�ukskQMcM�MwRlmjSjQkpPMprMwj�kTM�vMgRSS}llkxM�MZMO�ukskQMO�ukskQM�M�MhiRlkjmcTnkookpPMcQQqMdRSQkrkljQkpPMsqMwj�kTM�vMgRSS}llk\N�Sk�sjokxMek�jq\M�pQkpPoMSRrRSSRTMQp�jykoQSjQRMt}TyRMzjSmjMvMhij}mTkPyvMNOPQRSRTUMVVWX]WZXV[\
VVWX]WZXV[ VYXM�����0�F�0��������F0��0���0�����0��0�����04<7>�J>40?BD0�=�J=>0�=�II57<06<=0�7H0�JH5�04<7>�J>40?B�0�=�J=>0�=0�II57<06<=0�7H0�JH50�04<7>�J>40?B��=�J=>0�=0�II57<06<=0�7H0�JH5:01=�>06:0�5KL=>3�0�K :�01=>7��7>0¡:0;7�H�58=<��K :�07>30�7¢J30F:0�5<<2HHJ�0�K :�0L7/0KI5HJ788/07II57<0J>0��JK0H7K507K0H=2>K580£=<687J>�J££0¤J��0�J¥7/09:0;<J¥.7KJ�0�K :�0K5<¢J>407K08=H780H=2>K58:0¡J4>530./0�74JK�<7�5123450�7<870�:0¡I7283J>40=>0??@¦@BC?D:0E��1G0NOPQRSRTUMVVWX]WZXV[\
VVWV�WZXV[ VYZM�F���¡��0�����0¢7H7�J>40?B¦0�<35<0�=0H=LI8/0¤J��0585H�<=>JH0£J8J>402>�J80K2H��JL507K0�5£5>37>�0�85§0�=<�=>0�7K0.55>0K5<¢530¤J��0��50H=LI87J>�07>30H=2>K580£=<�85§0�=<�=>0�7K0£J85307>07II57<7>H50J>0��JK0H7K5:0¡J4>530./0123450672809:0;/<=>0=>??@?@BC?D:0E9F;G0H=IJ5K0L7J853@5©L7J853MNOPQRSRTUMVVWV�WZXV[\
VVWV�WZXV[ VYYMhª��a�hMkoo}RTMjoMQpMaPmkPRMdpnn}PkljQkpPoxM~~dvMNpSkykPjmMnjkmRTMQpMlp}PoRmMrpSoRS�klR\MNwa\MNOPQRSRTUMVVWV�WZXV[\
VVWV�WZXV[ VY�Mhª��a�hMkoo}RTMjoMQpMcmR�M�pSQpPvMNpSkykPjmMnjkmRTMQpMlp}PoRmMrpSMoRS�klR\MNwa\NOPQRSRTUMVVWV�WZXV[\
VVWV�WZXV[ VY|Mhª��a�hMkoo}RTMjoMQpMzR�kPM«ky}RSRvMNpSkykPjmMnjkmRTMQpMlp}PoRmMrpSMoRS�klR\MNwa\NOPQRSRTUMVVWV�WZXV[\
VVWV�WZXV[ VY]Mhª��a�hMkoo}RTMjoMQpMzknMb}kvMNpSkykPjmMnjkmRTMQpMlp}PoRmMrpSMoRS�klR\MNwa\NOPQRSRTUMVVWV�WZXV[\
VVWZXWZXV[ VY[M�a�fdOMprMciiRjSjPlRMsqM«j�kPMwj�kTM�jyj¬kPRSMpPMsRujmrMprM�~�M�jrkjxMfPlvN�jyj¬kPRSxM«j�kP\MNOPQRSRTUMVVWZXWZXV[\
VVWZXWZXV[ VY�M�a�fdOMprMciiRjSjPlRMsqMcnjPTjMpoRMw}PPMpPMsRujmrMprM�~�M�jrkjxMfPlvMNw}PPxcnjPTj\MNOPQRSRTUMVVWZXWZXV[\
VVWZXWZXV[ VY�McfeO MprMoRS�klRMSRQ}SPRTMR�Rl}QRTMpPMVVWV[WZXV[MsqMtjnRoMtvMcspmQkPxM_jnRmjMtvzPkyuQMjoMQpM�~�M�jrkjxMfPlvvMN�jQluRmpSxMtpPjQujP\MNOPQRSRTUMVVWZXWZXV[\
VVWZXWZXV[ V�XM�a�fa�MrpSMhlpQQMvMRmmnjPMQpMjiiRjSMiSpMujlM�klRMsqM�~�M�jrkjxMfPlvvNcQQjlunRPQoUM�MVMO�ukskQMc\N�jyj¬kPRSxM«j�kP\M�pQkpPoMSRrRSSRTMQpM�jykoQSjQRMt}TyR
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 38 of 50 PageID 2569
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� �+�+)
./01/234256/7189:;42<=:>?0?8@2AABCDBCDAEF
AABCDBCDAE AGA2HIJKIL2MN02OP09Q2R?11S/:2>N2/66?/0260N2P/T2U9T?2VW2HXH2H/M9/Y2K:T442<Z>>/TPS?:>Q@[2A2=\P9V9>2ZF<H/;/]9:?0Y2/U9:F2HN>9N:Q20?M?00?82>N2H/;9Q>0/>?2_78;?2./01/23456/7189:;42<=:>?0?8@2AABCDBCDAEF
AABCDBCDAE AGC2 =OXZ3ZJKIL2NM25TN>>2R42R?11S/:20?2AGD2HIJKIL2MN025TN>>2R42R?11S/:2>N2/66?/060N2P/T2U9T?2VW2HXH2H/M9/Y2K:T442<H/;/]9:?0Y2/U9:F2<=:>?0?8@2AABCDBCDAEF
AABCDBCDAE AGa2 =OXZ3ZJKIL2NM2OP09Q2R?11S/:20?2AGA2HIJKIL2MN02OP09Q2R?11S/:2>N2/66?/0260NP/T2U9T?2VW2HXH2H/M9/Y2K:T442<H/;/]9:?0Y2/U9:F2<=:>?0?8@2AABCDBCDAEF
AABCABCDAE AGG2bcdecfghdfdicejkibhfkbfklefjmecnfbofjbpckfqrstuvtqfwxyfz{uv{tfu{s||}srf|r{f~s�f�v�}�fqrstuvtqfwxwfz{uv{tfu{fs||}srf|r{f~s�f�v�}�f��{uuf��f�}��zst�e����fst�fj~rv�f�}��zst�fe����f�~{f~s�}fs�r}s��f�|}�vs���fs||}sr}�fvtfu~v�f�s�}fs��{�t�}�f�{rfd}�}t�stuf�s�{tfjsrszstv��fzs�fs��{f�|}�vs���fs||}srfvtfu~v�f�s�}fs��{�t�}�f�{rfd}�}t�stuf�m�f�s�vs�fit���f�vu~f�s�vtfd�f�sqs�vt}r�fe���fst�gzst�sfc�fd�tt�fe���f�}r�vtqfs�f�{�s�f�{�t�}��f�vqt}�f��f�sqv�ursu}f���q}fnsr�sc�f�|s���vtqf{tfww��w��yw��f�ej��f<=:>?0?8@2AABCABCDAEF
AABCABCDAE AG�2LIJKO=2NM2���������� �¡ ¢£¤¢£¥�¡�¦2VW2OP09Q2R?11S/:2N:2V?P/1M2NM2HXH2H/M9/Y2K:T4<R?11S/:Y2OP09QF2HN89M9?82N:2AABCCBCDAE2<3 IF42<=:>?0?8@2AABCABCDAEF
AABCABCDAE AG§2LIJKO=2NM2���������� �¡ ¢£¤¢£¥�¡�¦2VW25TN>>2R42R?11S/:2N:2V?P/1M2NM2HXH2H/M9/YK:T42<R?11S/:Y25TN>>F2HN89M9?82N:2AABCCBCDAE2<3 IF42<=:>?0?8@2AABCABCDAEF
AABCCBCDAE AGE2<5J3KO.=L2©2ªA�§2I3 =3F2OZ5=2HZLZ =H=LJ23=«I3J42<¬70>Y2_?::9:;QFHN89M9?82N:2ACB�BCDAE2<3 IF42<=:>?0?8@2AABCCBCDAEF
AABaDBCDAE AG2<5J3KO.=L2©2[A�2=L I35= 2I3 =3F2HIJKIL2>N289QS9QQ2MN021/T®2NM709Q89T>9N:2°¥�¡¥��± ±£ ²¢³° ³¥¦� µ¶·¶µ2VW2_/QN:2O/0/S/:9QY2HXH2H/M9/Y2K:T44<Z>>/TPS?:>Q@2[2A2ZMM98/U9>F<R?11S/:Y25TN>>F2HN89M9?82N:2ACBABCDAE2<3 IF42HN89M9?8N:2ACB�BCDAE2<3 IF42<=:>?0?8@2AABaDBCDAEF
AABaDBCDAE AG¹2<5J3KO.=L2©2[A�2=L I35= 2I3 =3F2HIJKIL2>N289QS9QQ2MN02M/9170?2>N2Q>/>?2/T1/9S2°¥�¡¥��± ±£ ²³¢° ³¥¦� µ¶·¶º2VW2_/QN:2O/0/S/:9QY2HXH2H/M9/Y2K:T44<R?11S/:Y25TN>>F2HN89M9?82N:2ACBABCDAE2<3 IF42HN89M9?82N:2ACB�BCDAE2<3 IF4<=:>?0?8@2AABaDBCDAEF
ACBDABCDAE A�D2HIJKIL2>N29QS9QQ2>P?2ONS61/9:>2VW2_?7:?QQ?2XXOY25TN>>2Z2X?»9QY2R?:8W2342X?»9QYI;/1?23/W42<¬70>Y2_?::9:;QF2<=:>?0?8@2ACBDABCDAEF
ACBDABCDAE A�A2HIJKIL2>N2TNS6?12/0V9>0/>9N:2VW2_?7:?QQ?2XXOY25TN>>2Z2X?»9QY2R?:8W2342X?»9QYI;/1?23/W42<¬70>Y2_?::9:;QF2<=:>?0?8@2ACBDABCDAEF
ACBDABCDAE A�C2HIJKIL2>N2?:W2O1/QQ2O?0>9M9T/>9N:2VW2_?7:?QQ?2XXOY25TN>>2Z2X?»9QY2R?:8W2342X?»9QYI;/1?23/W42<¬70>Y2_?::9:;QF2HN89M9?82N:2ACBGBCDAE2<3 IF42<=:>?0?8@2ACBDABCDAEF
ACBDABCDAE A�a25=OIL 2=OXZ3ZJKIL2NM23W/:2I;8?:20?2A�C2HIJKIL2>N2O?0>9MW2O1/QQ2¼��½ ¢¦�¡¡¢��±¾¿¾��±¾£�2VW2_?7:?QQ?2XXOY25TN>>2Z2X?»9QY2R?:8W2342X?»9QY2I;/1?23/W42<¬70>Y_?::9:;QF2HN89M9?82N:2ACBGBCDAE2<3 IF42<=:>?0?8@2ACBDABCDAEF
ACBDABCDAE A�G2<J¬K52K52Z2À«XKOZJ=2IÁ2J¬=2=OXZ3ZJKIL2ÁKX= 2ZJ2A�a2F25=OIL=OXZ3ZJKIL2NM23W/:2I;8?:20?2A�A2HIJKIL2>N2TNS6?12/0V9>0/>9N:2VW2_?7:?QQ?XXOY25TN>>2Z2X?»9QY2R?:8W2342X?»9QY2I;/1?23/W42<¬70>Y2_?::9:;QF2HN89M9?82N:ACBGBCDAE2<3 IF42<=:>?0?8@2ACBDABCDAEF
ACBDABCDAE A��2<5J3KO.=L2©2A�§2I3 =3F2OZ5=2HZLZ =H=LJ23=«I3J42<09V/Q9Y2Â9/WFHN89M9?82N:2ACB�BCDAE2<3 IF42<=:>?0?8@2ACBDABCDAEF
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 39 of 50 PageID 2570
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� �)�+)
./0120/1.3 .456789:8;<=;><?@AB;?BC;DEE;FG>B;HGIGJBKBI<;8BL=?<M;DNO;FG>B;HGIGJBKBI<;8BL=?<PQ@JIBR;ST;UVRJB;WGVX;YP;ZT?=I;=I;D[\N\[]DOP;HH_ ;abcdefegh6./0120/1.3i
./0120/1.3 .436789:8C;jkB;LG?<@B>;G?B;9l8:Fj:9;<=;m=InB?;?BJG?R@IJ;RBGRX@IB>;LB?<@IBI<;<=;GK=<@=I;n=?;mXG>>;mB?<@n@mG<@=I;GIR;GRo@>B;<kB;F=V?<;=n;GJ?BBGSXB;RBGRX@IB>;@I;<kB@?mG>B;KGIGJBKBI<;?BL=?<P;jkB;RBGRX@IB>;>k=VXR;@ImXVRB;G;RBGRX@IB;n=?;D;R@>mX=>V?B=n;BpLB?<;?BL=?<>;q;mXG>>;Gm<@=IM;LXG@I<@nn;GIR;RBnBIRGI<r;[;R@>m=oB?T;q;mXG>>;Gm<@=Irs;K=<@=I;n=?;mXG>>;mB?<@n@mG<@=Ir;N;?B>L=I>B;<=;K=<@=I;n=?;mXG>>;mB?<@n@mG<@=Ir;GIRE;?BLXT;<=;K=<@=I;n=?;mXG>>;mB?<@n@mG<@=IP;Q@JIBR;ST;UVRJB;WGVX;YP;ZT?=I;=ID[\N\[]DOP;HH_ ;abcdefegh6./0120/1.3i
./0120/1.3 .4t6:u978Q:9;789:8;><?@A@IJ;DNv;DNw;H=<@=I;<=;9@>K@>>;n=?;xGmA;=n;UV?@>R@m<@=IGIR;H=<@=I;<=;9@>K@>>;n=?;yG@XV?B;<=;Q<G<B;G;FXG@K;n=?;nG@XV?B;<=;m=KLXT;z@<k;x=mGX8VXB;sP]D{G|P;9BnBIRGI<>;UG>=I;FG?GKGI@>;GIR;HxH;HGn@GM;lImP;G?B;R@?Bm<BR;<=;n@XBG;>@IJXB;K=<@=I;<=;R@>K@>>;@I;m=KLX@GImB;z@<k;x=mGX;8VXB>;ST;9BmBKSB?;DDM;[]DOPQ@JIBR;ST;UVRJB;WGVX;YP;ZT?=I;=I;D[\N\[]DOP;Z}~;abcdefegh6./0120/1.3i
./0140/1.3 6�e��f�h6�dd�fce�6����g6�f��6���6����eg6d�6������6��d�6d���6���fd��6�fgef6a����6./4i���e6��ef���6�����e6����6c�6��c�ef6��f��fg6���ef6����e�6��6�c�6����c�6��ge6��6d�e6���fd6d��dd�fce�6�f���6a���i6����e�6����eg0e�����eg6abcdefegh6./0140/1.3i
./0130/1.3 .4�6luj:8:Qj:9;W:8Q7uQ;789:8P;9BnBIRGI<;HxH;HGn@GM;lImP;>kGXX;n@XB;GFB?<@n@mG<B;=n;lI<B?B><BR;WB?>=I>;z@<k@I;n=V?<BBI;DN;RGT>;n?=K;<kB;RG<B;=n;<k@>7?RB?P;Q@JIBR;ST;UVRJB;WGVX;YP;ZT?=I;=I;D[\O\[]DOP;YuZ;m=L@B>;BqKG@XBRabcdefegh6./0130/1.3i
./0130/1.3 .516789:8;j7;Q~7_;F}�Q:;G>;<=;WXG@I<@nn>;UGKB>;UP;}S=X<@I;GIR;WGKBXG;UP;�I@Jk<PWXG@I<@nn>;kGoB;nG@XBR;<=;m=KLXT;z@<k;<kB;F=V?<�>;7?RB?>;D]s;GIR;D]N;P;WXG@I<@nn>;>kGXXQ~7_;F}�Q:;GIR;n@XB;<kB@?;?B>L=I>B;<=;>G@R;7?RB?>;z@<k@I;n=V?<BBI;DN;RGT>n?=K;<kB;RG<B;=n;<k@>;7?RB?P;yG@XV?B;<=;m=KLXT;z@<k;<k@>;7?RB?;KGT;?B>VX<;@IR@>K@>>GX;z@<k=V<;L?B VR@mB;=?;=<kB?;GLL?=L?@G<B;>GIm<@=I>P;Q@JIBR;ST;UVRJB;WGVX;YPZT?=I;=I;D[\O\[]DOP;YuZ;m=L@B>;BqKG@XBR6abcdefegh6./0130/1.3i
./0130/1.3 .5.6:u978Q:9;789:8;R@?Bm<@IJ;<kB;LG?<@B>;<=;n@XB;GI;}KBIRBR;FG>B;HGIGJBKBI<8BL=?<;@I;m=KLX@GImB;z@<k;<kB;F=V?<�>;7?RB?>;G<;DE¡;GIR;DEO;=I;=?;SBn=?B;UGIVG?T[M;[]DvP;Q@JIBR;ST;UVRJB;WGVX;YP;ZT?=I;=I;D[\O\[]DOP;YuZ;m=L@B>;BqKG@XBRabcdefegh6./0130/1.3i
./0130/1.3 .5/6a¢����6b£b��6���b6¤¥b��6������b¦6��6�b§©bi6ª���§6��6�ef���e6��«��e�6«�6����d�c¬6ª��e��6«�6c���d6a§eff����¬6����gi6®�g���eg6�c6./0t0/1.36a���i�abcdefegh6./0130/1.3i
./01t0/1.3 .56�b�©������6��6«���c6��f���c��6�c6¥����fd6��6.536®�d��c6d�6�������6ª�f���cd6d�§��ª6���e6./a�ia/i6��6«���c6��f���c��¬6®©®6®����¬6c���6a¢e����c¬6¥��ddi6®�g���eg�c6./0..0/1.36a���i�6abcdefegh6./01t0/1.3i
./01t0/1.3 .526�b�¤��6��6�ef���e6e°e��deg6�c6�e�e��ef62¬6/1.36��6«��e�6«�6����d�c¬6ª��e��6«�c���d6��6d�6�c��ce6�����c���d��c�¬6©©��6a§eff����¬6����gi6abcdefegh6./01t0/1.3i
./01t0/1.3 .546����b6��6�ecgec��6��6fe��deg6���e�6�ef6©����6���e6.�12agi6fe6.16�e��deg6���e6�fgef��6«��e�6«�6����d�c¬6ª��e��6«�6c���d�6�e��deg6���ea�ih6¦e�6a§eff����¬6����gi6®�g���eg�c6./0..0/1.36a���i�6abcdefegh6./01t0/1.3i
./01t0/1.3 .556�b��§���b6�§6��b�b¥�b�6ªb�¥��¥6�cg6���ª����b6��������fe6¥d�de�ecdfe6.126cdefe�deg6ªef��c�6�fgef6��6«��e�6«�6����d�c¬6ª��e��6«�6c���d�6a§eff����¬6����gi®�g���eg6�c6./0..0/1.36a���i�6abcdefegh6./01t0/1.3i
./01t0/1.3 .536®����6d�6�������6�e�ecg�cd�6«���c6��f���c��6�cg6®©®6®����¬6c��6�f��6d���6��d��c���eg6�c6§��ª6./a�ia/i6�cg6§��ª6./a�ia5i6��6«���c6��f���c��¬6®©®6®����¬6c���
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 40 of 50 PageID 2571
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� �.�+)
/01223456789:;;<7=:>?@?1>7:57ABCAACBDAE7/FGH<I7/J5;1K1>L7ABCDMCBDAE<
ABCAACBDAE ANM7OPHQQH8JG7=HRSHP7;:73:>?@T7=:;?:57;:7=:>?@T7FU217BN/@<7V4W17=454X1315;V:5@1K15917YT7Z4W:57V4K4345?W67=[=7=4@?467S59II7/01223456789:;;<7=:>?@?1>7:5ABCABCBDAE7/FGH<I7/J5;1K1>L7ABCAACBDAE<
ABCAACBDAE AN\7=HRSHP7;:7W;4T7>?W9:]1KT7_ a_bcdedfedgheaibebcjekclf f bdhjmhmf bcj_mefneibo7YT7Z1U51WW17[[V6789:;;7p7[1q?W67015>T7FI7[1q?W67HX421F4TI7/rUK;67Z155?5XW<7=:;?:5W7K1@1KK1>7;:7=4X?W;K4;17ZU>X17s4K247FI78t4U2>?5XI7/J5;1K1>LABCAACBDAE<
ABCAACBDAE AED7FJ8QHP8J7;:7=:;?:57K17ANM7u?KW;7=HRSHP7;:73:>?@T7=:;?:57;:7=:>?@T7FU217BN/@<V4W17=454X1315;7V:5@1K15917vwxyzx{{|}e~|��y|~ez�ej~{~y�wyz|}e_y����|~�em�zx�yez�m��x{�e�v~e���{�elw|~emwyw�~�~yzel�y{~�~y�~7@?21>7YT7Z431W7ZI7pY:2;?567Q431247ZIs5?X�;I7/u1KKU99?67G4]?><7/J5;1K1>L7ABCAACBDAE<
ABCAACBDAE AEA7GJV[pFpRSHP7:@7G1924K4;?:57:@7Z:54;�4578I7�4;9�12:K7?578Utt:K;7:@7AED7F1Wt:5W17;:G1@15>45;W�7O5:tt:W1>7=:;?:57;:7=:>?@T7FU217BN/@<7V4W17=45X1315;7V:5@1K15917K1AED7F1Wt:5W17;:73:;?:57YT7Z431W7ZI7pY:2;?567Q431247ZI7s5?X�;I7/p;;49�315;WL7�7AJ��?Y?;7J��?Y?;7p</u1KKU99?67G4]?><7=:>?@?1>7:57ABCABCBDAE7/FGH<I7/J5;1K1>LABCAACBDAE<
ABCAACBDAE AEB7VJFRSuSVpRJ7:@7?5;1K1W;1>7t1KW:5W745>79:Kt:K4;17>?W92:WUK17W;4;1315;7K17A�\7S5;1K1W;1>t1KW:5W7:K>1K7YT7=[=7=4@?467S59II7/01223456789:;;<7R1�;73:>?@?1>7:57ABCABCBDAE/FGH<I7/J5;1K1>L7ABCAACBDAE<
ABCABCBDAE AE�7���������������������������� �¡������������¢£¤�¥¦��¦���¦�§¦��¡©�ª ���«¦¬� ®�®®�§ ������ �¦��¦��� �«� �§���� § ���«¦� � �« �¦��� « §° ��±¤²±³¢²���¢³µ³³��©§©����� �¶��� ��¦¦§���·�« ����¦�§¡�«¦¬���¦¦§�¹¦¬���¦¦§�º�²�»©¼©¹¦¬��¦¬ ²�½³¢�¾©�¹ ����®�¿®À�©²���®���¦²�ÁªÂ²�¬�® �® ���«¦¬� ®���� ��¦��¦� ��®¦«���¦��¦��������� �¦����� ��®� ����� ������¶���� �²���� �²������® ����¬®���¦�©�Ã�� �� ��«� ²�� �� ��®�� �¦���®����� ·¦����¹� �¥���� § ���� �¦��� §����Ä��¬��¡�±²�±³¢¤©�¼��� ��°¡�¥������� �Ĭ�� �Å��®���©�¼��¬®�����¦�¢±Æ¢±Æ±³¢©�¥ÇÇÂ�/J5;1K1>L7ABCABCBDAE<
ABCA�CBDAE AEÈ78RSQO[pRSHP7K17AE�7HK>1K7:573:;?:57;:73:>?@T7Ée���x{�xy�e���~�ez�e�~��xzev~w����y|~ve{��ezÊ~e�w�zx~|ez�e�~~zexye�~�|�ye{��ezÊ~e�w|~e�wyw�~�~yze��y{~�~y�~e�yË�ÌËÍÌ�ÎËÏewy�eÐw�wz~ezÊ~e�~Ñ�x�~�~yzezÊwzev~w�e���y|~ve�~~ze�yeË�Ì�ÒÌ�ÎËÏÓ7YTZ1U51WW17[[V6789:;;7p7[1q?W67015>T7FI7[1q?W67HX4217F4TI7/Z49:YW:567Z1@@K1T<7/J5;1K1>LABCA�CBDAE<
ABCA�CBDAE AE�7�Ô���¼����������®®¦¶����«¦¬� ®��¦�§ ���¦��� ��� �� �¹� �¥���� § ��� �¦���¦�� « §° ��¢º²�±³¢������ ®� À����� §�¦�� �¦°®�����¦��¦�§ �����¦�����¬��¦ �¦��� « §° ��±¤²�±³¢������®���¦²�Á®¦����©�¼��� ��°¡�¥������� �Ĭ�� Å��®���©�¼��¬®�����¦��¢±Æ¢ºÆ±³¢©�¼��¬®����²�Å��®�Â�/J5;1K1>L7ABCA�CBDAE<
ABCAMCBDAE AEN78RSQO[pRSHP7{��ea�Õ|zxz�zx�ye�{el��y|~v7YT7Z1U51WW17[[V6789:;;7p7[1q?W67015>T7FI[1q?W67HX4217F4TI7/Q14KW:567s4K2<7=:>?@?1>7:57ABCBDCBDAE7/FGH<I7/J5;1K1>LABCAMCBDAE<
ABCA\CBDAE AEE7������� �¡����¶��¦¬���� ·¬��« �¢£�¥¦��¦���¦�¼¬°���¬� �Ç��¦�� ¡©©�¼��� ��°¡¥������� �Ĭ�� �Å��®���©�¼��¬®�����¦��¢±Æ¢ÖÆ¢©����Â�/J5;1K1>L7ABCBDCBDAE<
ABCBACBDAE AEM7OPHQQH8JG7=HRSHP7@:K7J�;15W?:57:@7R?317U5;?27ACANCAM7;:7u?217F1Wt:5W17;:G1@15>45;W�7A�B7=:;?:57F1L7V24WW7V1K;?@?94;?:57YT7Z431W7ZI7pY:2;?567Q431247ZI7s5?X�;I/p;;49�315;WL7�7A7R1�;7:@7QK:t:W1>7HK>1K7QK:t:W1>7HK>1K7F1L7O5:tt:W1>7=:;?:57@:KJ�;15W?:57:@7R?317;:7F1Wt:5>7;:7G1@15>45;W�7=:;?:57F1L7V24WW7V1K;?@?94;?:5</�4;9�12:K6
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 41 of 50 PageID 2572
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� �*�+)
./012310456/27/0859:;:99:<52/561=782912:5.><=:5?19@15AB5CD1>@<70=B56/<7;7:<5/0EFGFFGFHEI5JAKL4B5JM02:9:<N5EFGFEGFHEI4
EFGFEGFHEI EIO5KMPQRARSTLU5/;5./0123105CB5V12W3:@/95705C>DD/925/;5X@17027;;8Y5A:8D/08:52/5EZHL9<:952/583/[5W1>8:5\]5.1:85.B5R\/@270_5X1:@15.B5?07=32B5JV12W3:@/9_5./01231046/<7;7:<5/05EFGFFGFHEI5JAKL4B5JM02:9:<N5EFGFEGFHEI4
EFGFFGFHEI EH5abcdbefghijkifelmneopjkpieqpgedrjsitkpiepqeukvsejpewkxsebstypitsejpelz{oau|a}ejpecsi~e�xhtte�sgjkqk�hjkpi�ebstypitste��se�~el�l��{�ln�e�kfis�e�~ohfktjghjse���fse�hgxheb�e�yh�x�kifepiel{�{{�{�lm�e�bca�eJM02:9:<N5EFGFFGFHEI4
HEGHFGFHE EE5PRCM56RUR�M6MUS5AMXLASB5JV12W3:@/9_5./01231045JM02:9:<N5HEGHFGFHE4
HEGHFGFHE EF5abcdbegselnle�htseohihfsvsijebsypgj�eu�kte�htsektebdwdbbdcejpej�sehttkfis��ikjs�e�jhjsteohfktjghjse���fs�eqpgehxxeq�gj�sgeygp�ss�kiftehi�ej�sesijg~epq���fvsijekieh��pg�hi�se�kj�e{ne������e�e������ehi�ews��b��k����em��e�kj�ehi~hyyshxejpe�sejh�siejpej�se�ikjs�e�jhjste�p�gjepqe�yyshxt�e�kfis�e�~e���fse�h�xe���~gpiepiel�{�{�ln�e�oo��eJM02:9:<N5HEGHFGFHE4
HEGHFGFHE E�5.LTUS5ULSTPM5\]5.:>0:88:5QQP_5CW/225R5Q:[78_5�:0<]5AB5Q:[78_5L=1@:5A1]5/;5M991219:5EE5P18:56101=::025A:D/92B5J.1W/\8/0_5.:;;9:]456/<7;7:<5/05EG�GFHE5JAKL4BJM02:9:<N5HEGHFGFHE4
HEGHFGFHE E�5AMCXLUCM5705LDD/8727/059:5E�H56LSTLU52/5K78788523:5P/ D@17025;7@:<5\]5.1:85.BR\/@270_5X1:@15.B5?07=32B5JV12W3:@/9_5./012310456/<7;7:<5/05EG�GFHE5JAKL4B5JM02:9:<NHEGHFGFHE4
HEGHFGFHE E�5AMCXLUCM5705LDD/8727/059:5E�E56LSTLU52/5W/ D:@519\729127/05;7@:<5\]5.1:85.BR\/@270_5X1:@15.B5?07=32B5JV12W3:@/9_5./012310456/<7;7:<5/05EG�GFHE5JAKL4B5JM02:9:<NHEGHFGFHE4
HEGHFGFHE EZ5AMCXLUCM5705LDD/8727/059:5EZO56LSTLU52/5821]5<78W/ :9]5;7@:<5\]5.1:85.B5R\/@270_X1:@15.B5?07=32B5JV12W3:@/9_5./012310456/<7;7:<5/05EG�GFHE5JAKL4B5JM02:9:<NHEGHFGFHE4
HEGH�GFHE EI5PLUCMUS52/52971@5\]5¡BCB561=782912:5.><=:5\]51@@5D1927:8B5J8::5EE5P18:56101=::02A:D/9245JAKL45JM02:9:<N5HEGH�GFHE4
HEGH�GFHE E 5P18:5A:1887=0:<52/561=782912:5.><=:5?19@15AB5CD1>@<70=5185D9:87<:9B5U:[5W18:50> \:9NZNEI¢W ¢EZF�¢LAQ¢?ACB5JAKL45JM02:9:<N5HEGH�GFHE4
HEGH�GFHE EO5d}cab�dceabcdbe�h�hjkifeln{eag�sgegsqsggkifej�kte�htsejpej�sevhfktjghjs���fs�ekiexkf�jepqej�seyhgjkst£eln�e�pkije}pjk�sepqedgghjhe�kj�ebstys�jejpe�htsohihfsvsijebsypgjeqkxs�e�~e��pjje�e¤s�kt�e�s�isttse¤¤��e�si�~eb�e¤s�kt�eafhxsbh~�e�kfis�e�~e���fse�h�xe��e�~gpiepiel���{�ln�e�oo��eJM02:9:<N5HEGH�GFHE4
HEGH�GFHE EOH56LSTLU52/5K787885¥¦§©ª«¥¬ª®°±²ª³« µ5\]5R@:¶56/92/0B5JV192@:22_5P319@:84JM02:9:<N5HEGH�GFHE4
HEGH�GFHE EOE5abcdbe�si~kifehtevppjel�·eopjkpiejpe�jh~eckt�p�sg~e��gt�hijejpej�se��¤b���kfis�e�~eohfktjghjse���fse�hgxheb�e�yh�x�kifepiel�z�{�ln�e�d���eJM02:9:<NHEGH�GFHE4
HEGH�GFHE EOF56LSTLU5;/95@:1 :52/5;7@:5A:D@]52/5X@17027;;8Y5LDD/8727/052/5E�E56/27/052/5P/ D:@R9\729127/05\]5.:>0:88:5QQP_5CW/225R5Q:[78_5�:0<]5AB5Q:[78_5L=1@:5A1]B5J.1W/\8/0_.:;;9:]456/<7;7:<5/05EGGFHE5JAKL4B5JM02:9:<N5HEGH�GFHE4
HEGH�GFHE EO�56LSTLU52/5C>\8272>2:5R22/90:]5¦¦¹¦º»ª¼½ª¾¥©¿²ªÀ»Á¥¹©²ª¿ªÂ¬5\]5.:>0:88:5QQP_5CW/22R5Q:[78_5�:0<]5AB5Q:[78_5L=1@:5A1]B5JX:198/0_5?19@456/27/0859:;:99:<52/561=782912:.><=:5?19@15AB5CD1>@<70=B5JM02:9:<N5HEGH�GFHE4
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 42 of 50 PageID 2573
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� �'�+)
./0.102./1 /3456789:;875<=5:>>?@<A<?=5BC5/325D:EF:;5G?B5HCIJC5A?5G<HC56C>HK5A?59HI<=A<GG@L:>>?@<A<?=5A?5D?A<?=5A?5M?N>CH5OBP<ABIA<?=5G<HCQ5PK5RINC@5RS5OP?HA<=T59INCHI5RS5U=<VWASXYB<ZPI@<T5[<ZIK\5X7=ACBCQ]5./0.102./1\
./0.102./1 /356789:;875BC5/_5;?A<C5?G5>C=QC=K5?G5BCHIACQ5I@C@5G<HCQ5PK5RCa=C@@C5bbMT58?AA5ObCc<@T5dC=QK56S5bCc<@T5:VIHC56IKS5XRI?P@?=T5RCGGBCK\5D?Q<G<CQ5?=5/0302./15X6e:\SX7=ACBCQ]5./0.102./1\
./0.102./1 /3_5fghijkfhlijhfjlmnopqrpmlstulvwqrwplxwnlyzo{zlqwl|r}zljz~}�l�nrzx�hzxzp�opq��lnz~}�l�nrzxl��o}}lpwqlz��zz�lxr{zl���l~omz�lop�l��o}}l�zlxr}z�lwplwnl�zxwnz�op�on�ls��lu�s��lkrmpz�l��l���mzl�o�}l��l��nwplwpls���u�s��l�����lX7=ACBCQ]./0.102./1\
./0.102./1 /3�5ijhfjlnzlst�lvi��iglqwlk���qrq�qzl�qqwnpz�l������� ¡¢£¡¤¥¦§¡© ª¥�¦�¡�§¡«¬xr}z�l��lk�wqql�lyzr��l�z�pz��zlyy®�lzp��lj�lyzr��limo}zljo��l�qlr�lijhfjfhq�oq�lwplwnl�zxwnzl�op�on�lsu�lu�s��l�qqwnpz��l�zon�wp�l�o�w��wp�lop�l�no�o°��o}}l��~~}z°zpqlq�zl°wqrwplxwnl����qrq�qrwplwxl�w�p�z}lrq�lolnrqqzpl�z�rmpoqrwpop�l�wp�zpq±qw±o�qlq�oql�w°~}rz�lrq�lyw�o}lj�}zlu��u�o��lkrmpz�l��lvomr�qnoqz���mzl²on}olj�lk~o�}�rpmlwpls���u�s��l�f®��lX7=ACBCQ]5./0.102./1\
./0.102./1 /3156789:;875<=5:>>?@<A<?=5BC5/_�5D:EF:;5A?5e<@N<@@5eCGC=QI=A@5RI@?=5MIBINI=<@5I=QDbD5DIG<IT5F=S5GB?N5AW<@5IA<?=5PI@CQ5?=5³6M95/2XP\X2\5I=Q5³6M95/2XP\X_\5G<HCQ5PKRINC@5RS5OP?HA<=T59INCHI5RS5U=<VWAS5XYIAWCH?BT5R?=IAWI=\5D?Q<G<CQ5?=5/0302./15X6e:\SX7=ACBCQ]5./0.102./1\
./0//02./1 /335dB<AAC=5QC@<V=IA<?=5I=Q5?=@C=A5A?5IA5PK5HC==5E<N?AWK5BIWIN5?=5PCWIHG5?G5RCa=C@@CbbMT58?AA5O5bCc<@T5dC=QK56S5bCc<@T5:VIHC56IKS5b?IH5M?a=@CH]5UIBH57S59CIB@?=T57@µSS;?=¶6C@<QC=A5M?a=@CH]5HC==5ES5BIWINT57@µSS5XBIWINT5HC==\5X7=ACBCQ]5./0//02./1\
./0//02./1 2..5dB<AAC=5QC@<V=IA<?=5I=Q5?=@C=A5A?5IA5PK5RCGGBCK58S5RI?P@?=5?=5PCWIHG5?G5RCa=C@@C5bbMT8?AA5O5bCc<@T5dC=QK56S5bCc<@T5:VIHC56IKS5b?IH5M?a=@CH]5UIBH57S59CIB@?=T57@µSS5;?=¶6C@<QC=A5M?a=@CH]5RCGGBCK58S5RI?P@?=T57@µSS5XRI?P@?=T5RCGGBCK\5X7=ACBCQ]5./0//02./1\
./0//02./1 2./5dB<AAC=5QC@<V=IA<?=5I=Q5?=@C=A5A?5IA5PK5UIBH57S59CIB@?=5?=5PCWIHG5?G5RCa=C@@C5bbMT8?AA5O5bCc<@T5dC=QK56S5bCc<@T5:VIHC56IKS5b?IH5M?a=@CH]5UIBH57S59CIB@?=S5;?=¶6C@<QC=A5M?a=@CH]5RCGGBCK58S5RI?P@?=S5X9CIB@?=T5UIBH\5X7=ACBCQ]5./0//02./1\
./0//02./1 2.25D:EF:;5G?B5HCIJC5A?5G<HC5·¹º»¼½¾¿À¼·Á¾ÁÃÃÄÅÆÇÈÉ»»¿ÄÁ¾Á¿Â¾¿ÊºÃºÂ˷¾ÄÅÌ¿¾Á¿Â¾¿ÊÁÄÍÁÄĻιÄη¾¾¿ÏÐÊÑÒÑÓÔÕÑÀÑÆÖ×ØÙ×ÖÙ·ÂËÆÖ×ØÙ×ÚÙ5PK5RI@?=5MIBINI=<@T5DbDDIG<IT5F=SS5XdCHHNI=T5MWB<@\5D?Q<G<CQ5?=5/0/202./15X6e:\S5X7=ACBCQ]5./0//02./1\
./0//02./1 2.Û5e7MbO6OEF:;5?G5MWB<@5dCHHNI=5<=58a>>?BA5?G52.25D:EF:;5G?B5HCIJC5A?5G<HC5I5BC>HKA?59HI<=A<GG@L5:>>?@<A<?=5A?5eCGC=QI=A@L5D?A<?=5A?5e<@N<@@5>aB@aI=A5A?5³7eS56S5MF[S59S/2XP\X2\5I=Q5/2XP\X_\5PK5RI@?=5MIBINI=<@T5DbD5DIG<IT5F=SS5XOAAIWNC=A@]5Ü5/57ÝW<P<A\XdCHHNI=T5MWB<@\5D?Q<G<CQ5?=5/0/202./15X6e:\S5X7=ACBCQ]5./0//02./1\
./0/202./1 2.45ijhfjlmnopqrpmlst�ljzpzz�lkqr~�}oqz�lvwqrwplxwnlk���qrq�qrwplwxl®w�p�z}lxwnq�zl�z�pz��zlhzxzp�opq��l�qqwnpz�lvr��oz}l®w�°o�lww�on�Þl�zpprpm�ly�l��nq�l���op�l��oo�lj�lj�rß±®on��lqzn°rpoqz��lkrmpz�l��lvomr�qnoqzl���mzl²on}olj�k~o�}�rpmlwpls�su�u�s��l�f®��lX7=ACBCQ]5./0/202./1\
./0/02./1 2.5D:EF:;5G?B5IJ<=5eS5DIVIà<=CB5A?5c<AWQBIc5I@5IAA?B=CK5PK5RI@?=5MIBINI=<@T5DbDDIG<IT5F=SS5XDIVIà<=CBT5IJ<=\5D?A<?=@5BCGCBBCQ5A?5DIV<@ABIAC5RaQVC5UIBHI56S8>IaHQ<=VS5D?Q<G<CQ5?=5/0/_02./15X6e:\S5X7=ACBCQ]5./0/02./1\
./0/_02./1 2._5fghijkfhlijhfjlmnopqrpmlu��lvwqrwplqwlrq��nolo�l�qqwnpz��l�qqwnpz��o{rplho{r�lvomoßrpznlrq��no�lo�l�w�p�z}lxwnlvyvlvoxro�l�p��lop�l�o�wp®ono°opr��l��z�zl�zxzp�opq�lnz°orplnz~nz�zpqz�l��lwq�znl�w�p�z}lwxlnz�wn��lkrmpz�
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 43 of 50 PageID 2574
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� �(�+)
./0123456726809:;380<27=20>?0@A2:=;4B30CB0DEDFEGHDI?0J@A2:=;4B3K0<27=2L0MNOPQRQSTUVWVXWYUVZ[
UVWVXWYUVZ YU\] N_a]b cNd]eO]fghhiRP]ij]VkV]lmncmo]Pi]piqhQr]sRtePRsPeiO]jerQS]tu]vQgOQffQ] wxypiPP]z]Q{efx]|QOSu]}]Q{efx]m~srQ]su}]MvspitfiOx]vQjjRQu[]liSejeQS]iO]VWV\WYUVZM�m[}]MNOPQRQST]UVWVXWYUVZ[
UVWVXWYUVZ YUZ] Ny_moyN]eO]mhhifePeiO]RQ]YUY]deRfP]lmncmo]jiR]rQs�Q]Pi]jerQ]s]RQhru]Pi]_rseOPejjf�mhhifePeiO]Pi]�QjQOSsOPf�]liPeiO]Pi]�efqeff]hgRfgsOP]Pi]dN�}]}]wc�}]_}]VYMt[MY[]sOSVYMt[MX[]jerQS]tu]vsqQf]v}]ztirPeOx]_sqQrs]v}]�Oe~�P}]MbsPp�QriRx]viOsP�sO[]liSejeQS]iOVWV\WYUVZ]M�m[}]MNOPQRQST]UVWVXWYUVZ[
UVWVXWYUVZ YU�] Ny_moyN]eO]mhhifePeiO]RQ]VkY]lmncmo]Pi]�QOu]wrsff]wQRPejepsPeiO]jerQS]tu]vsqQf]v}ztirPeOx]_sqQrs]v}]�Oe~�P}]MbsPp�QriRx]viOsP�sO[]liSejeQS]iO]VWV\WYUVZ]M�m[}MNOPQRQST]UVWVXWYUVZ[
UVWV�WYUVZ YVU]��@�01�����1���0���0@���������0�>��>?0@43B8;0./09:;380�2:=0�?�/7CB0CB0DED�EGHDI?0J11�L0MNOPQRQST]UVWV�WYUVZ[
UVWYYWYUVZ ]yQPWRQfQP]fp�QSgreO~]iRSQR]SQsSreOQfT]zqQOSQS]_rQsSeO~f]SgQ]tu]�WVXWYUVZx]�efpi�QRuSgQ]tu]VYW�WYUVZx]�efhifePe�Q]qiPeiOf]SgQ]tu]VWYWYUV�x]_RQPResr]fPsPQqQOP]SgQ]tu�WV�WYUV�x]zrr]iP�QR]qiPeiOf]SgQ]tu]�WYXWYUV�x]deOsr]_RQPResr]wiOjQRQOpQ]fQP]jiR�WVXWYUV�]sP]U�TUU]_l]eO]mRrsOSi]wigRPRiiq]�]b]tQjiRQ]vgS~Q]_sgr]�}]buRiOx]vgRu]nResrfQP]jiR]PResr]PQRq]tQ~eOOeO~]iO]kWXWYUV�]sP]U�TUU]zl]eO]mRrsOSi]wigRPRiiq]�]b]tQjiRQvgS~Q]_sgr]�}]buRiO}x]wiOSgpP]qQSesPeiO]�QsReO~]tu]�W�UWYUVZ}]QsS]pigOfQr]PipiiRSeOsPQ]SsPQf}x]�QjQOSsOP]SefprifgRQ]ij]Q�hQRP]RQhiRP]SgQ]tu]XWVkWYUVZx]_rseOPejjSefprifgRQ]ij]Q�hQRP]RQhiRP]SgQ]tu]XWVWYUVZ]M�m[]MNOPQRQST]UVWYYWYUVZ[
UVWYYWYUVZ YVV]wzyN]NdN N�]Pi]lQSesPeiO}]oi]qQSesPiR]fQrQpPQS]sP]P�ef]PeqQ}]M�m[]MNOPQRQSTUVWYYWYUVZ[
UVWYYWYUVZ YVY]M| mo�]wm�N}]NdcN�]zn]YVk][]_mmd]ij]fQR�epQ]tu]vsqQf]v}]ztirPeOx]_sqQrs]v}�Oe~�P]MbsPp�QriRx]viOsP�sO[]liSejeQS]iO]VWY�WYUVZ]M�m[}]MNOPQRQST]UVWYYWYUVZ[
UVWYYWYUVZ YV�]M| mo�]wm�N}]NdcN�]zn]YVX][]_mmd]ij]fQR�epQ]tu]vsqQf]v}]ztirPeOx]_sqQrs]v}�Oe~�P]MbsPp�QriRx]viOsP�sO[]liSejeQS]iO]VWY�WYUVZ]M�m[}]MNOPQRQST]UVWYYWYUVZ[
UVWYYWYUVZ YV�] Ny_moyN]Pi]liPeiO]RQ]V�U]lmncmo]Pi]�efqeff]������ �¡��¢£¤¥¦§� ©ª]jerQS]tuvsqQf]v}]ztirPeOx]_sqQrs]v}]�Oe~�P}]MbsPp�QriRx]viOsP�sO[]MNOPQRQST]UVWYYWYUVZ[
UVWY�WYUVZ YVk] Nn« o]ij]fQR�epQ]Q�QpgPQS]iO]�QpQqtQR]VZx]YUV\]tu]vsqQf]v}]ztirPeOx]_sqQrs]v}�Oe~�P]sf]Pi]�eq]¬ge}]MbsPp�QriRx]viOsP�sO[]MNOPQRQST]UVWY�WYUVZ[
UVWY�WYUVZ YVX] Nn« o]ij]fQR�epQ]Q�QpgPQS]iO]vsOgsRu]V�x]YUVZ]tu]vsqQf]v}]ztirPeOx]_sqQrs]v}]�Oe~�Psf]Pi]�Q�eO]�e~gQRQ}]MbsPp�QriRx]viOsP�sO[]MNOPQRQST]UVWY�WYUVZ[
UVWYXWYUVZ YV\]lmncmo]jiR]rQs�Q]Pi]jerQ]Qhru]Pi]YV�]QfhiOfQ]eO]mhhifePeiO]Pi]liPeiO]Pi]�efqeff]tuzrQ�]liRPiO}]MbsRPrQPPx]w�sRrQf[]liSejeQS]iO]VWY�WYUVZ]M�m[}]MNOPQRQST]UVWYXWYUVZ[
UVWY�WYUVZ YVZ]����>@��0�>��>0;8B/4B30GD01C64CB0®C70�82806C0°4=80>8A=/0�748®?0�±80�C:76²4==0;478³606±80A27648506C05:AA=8 8B60.748®4B304®0B8³85527/?0@43B8;0./09:;380�2:=0�?�/7CB0CB0DEG�EGHDI?0J���L0MNOPQRQST]UVWY�WYUVZ[
UYWUVWYUVZ YV�]omncwN]ij]zhhQsRsOpQ]tu]�sRr]N}]_QsRfiO]iO]tQ�srj]ij]�eq]¬ge]M_QsRfiOx]�sRr[MNOPQRQST]UYWUVWYUVZ[
UYWUVWYUVZ YYU]omncwN]ij]zhhQsRsOpQ]tu]�sRr]N}]_QsRfiO]iO]tQ�srj]ij]�Q�eO]�e~gQRQ]M_QsRfiOx]�sRr[MNOPQRQST]UYWUVWYUVZ[
UYWUVWYUVZ YYV]omncwN]ij]fghhrQqQOPsr]sgP�iRePu]RQ]VkV]lmncmo]Pi]piqhQr]sRtePRsPeiO]tu]vQgOQffQ
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 44 of 50 PageID 2575
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� ���+)
../0123455161.789:01;7<=>[email protected]:01ABCD71?C>@1E655C3FG7<5:H1I1J1KLF9M951541N4593714O2PQQD7G7<5CD16P5F4R95>SET7CR:4<01UCRDS1EK<57R7=H1VWXVJXWVJYS
VWXVJXWVJY WWW1Z<4QQ4:7=1[A\]AN15417O7R1\9G71541_9D71?7:Q4<:971TD7C=9<B1541/4GQDC9<51M>1U9GaP901U79<1b9BP7R7@1ET7CR:4<01UCRDS1[4594<:1R7O7RR7=1541[CB9:5RC571cP=B71UCRDC1?@2QCPD=9<B@1[4=9O97=14<1WXWXWVJY1E? AS@1EK<57R7=H1VWXVJXWVJYS
VWXVWXWVJY WWd1efghijegkhigeiklmnopqolkqokrnmpknoskstouqolkqokrnmpkvvvkwxpqxokyxmezpto{qxokxyk|q}tkpxk~o{�tmkxmkmt{rxoskpxk�v�k~}tostsk�x}r�nqop�k|�tk�x�mp�nooxpktyyq�qtop�uk}xoqpxmkp�tkrmxlmt{{kxyk�qpqlnpqxokqykstns�qot{knmtk�xopqoltopkxom��qol{kxok}xpqxo{�k~��xmsqol�kp�tkstns�qotkyxmkgtytosnop{k�ql�tmtknosk��qkpxno{�tmkxmkmt{rxo{tkpxkp�tkn}tostsk�x}r�nqopkq{ktzptostskpxkwnm��k��kv����kjqlots�ukwnlq{pmnptk��sltk�nm�nki�kjrn��sqolkxokv�v�v����k�jrn��sqol�k�nm�n�kEK<57R7=HVWXVWXWVJYS
VWXVWXWVJY WW�1ZNATTA2K 1[A\]AN15417L57<=159G71541N459O>15F71/4PR514O15F71TCR597:�127D73594<14O[7=9C54R1C<=1C571M>1cCG7:1c@16M4D59<01TCG7DC1c@1U<9BF5@1E�C53F7D4R01c4<C5FC<S1[4594<:R7O7RR7=1541[CB9:5RC571cP=B71UCRDC1?@12QCPD=9<B@1[4=9O97=14<1WX�XWVJY1E? AS@1EK<57R7=HVWXVWXWVJYS
VWXV�XWVJY 1275XR7:751=7C=D9<7:XF7CR9<B:H1O4R1U9G1aP901U79<1b9BP7R7@16<:87R1=P71M>1dXJXWVJY@E? AS1EK<57R7=H1VWXV�XWVJYS
VWXV�XWVJY WW�1higeiklmnopqolkvv�kwxpqxokyxmkezpto{qxokxyk|q}tkpxkfxpqyukp�tk�x�mpkxykp�t�nmpqt{�kjt�t�pqxokxykwtsqnpxmknoskgnpt�k|�tkstns�qotkyxmkp�tkrnmpqt{kpxkyq�tknkoxpq�tqoyxm}qolkp�tk�x�mpkxykp�tqmknlmtts��rxok}tsqnpxmknoskp�tksnptkxykp�tk}tsqnpqxokq{tzptostsk�rkpxknoskqo���sqolk�t�m�nmuk��kv����kjqlotsk�ukwnlq{pmnptk��sltk�nm�ni�kjrn��sqolkxokv���v����k�e���kEK<57R7=H1VWXV�XWVJYS
VWXVYXWVJY WW�1higeik|hkj�h�k�~ jekn{kpxk��nqopqyy{k�n}t{k��k~�x�pqo�k�n}t�nk��k�oql�p���nqopqyy{k{�n��k{�x�k�n�{tk�qp�qokyx�mpttok����ksnu{kymx}kp�tksnptkxykp�q{khmstmk��up�tk�x}r�nqopknlnqo{pkp�tkgtytosnopkho�qotk�x}}�oq�npqxo{�k¡¡�k{�x��skoxpk�tsq{}q{{tskyxmkynq��mtkpxkrmx{t��ptkr�m{�nopkpxk¡x�n�ki��tk�����n��kw�g�k��n�k�nq��mtpxkmt{rxoskpxkp�q{kxmstmk}nukmt{��pkqoksq{}q{{n�kxykho�qotk�x}}�oq�npqxo{�k¡¡��qp�x�pkrmt¢�sq�t�kjqlotsk�uk��sltk�n��k��k£umxokxokv���v����k��f£�k�xrqt{kt�}nq�ts1EK<57R7=H1VWXVYXWVJYS
VWXVYXWVJY WW¤1¥f|eiej|egk�eijhfjkhigei�kgtytosnop{k~�tzkwxmpxoknosk�t¦qok�ql�tmt{�n��kyq�tknk�tmpqyq�nptkxyk¥optmt{ptsk�tm{xo{k�qp�qokyx�mpttok����ksnu{kymx}kp�tksnptxykp�q{khmstm�kjqlotsk�uk��sltk�n��k��k£umxokxokv���v����k��f£�k�xrqt{kt�}nq�tsEK<57R7=H1VWXVYXWVJYS
VWXV§XWVJY WWY1NA\]/K1A_12K.K/\]AN14O1.9M75F1aC::701K:©@1C:1G7=9C54R1M>1c7P<7::71../012345516.789:01;7<=>[email protected]:01ABCD71?C>@EcC34M:4<01c7OOR7>S1EK<57R7=H1VWXV§XWVJYS
VWXWVXWVJY WW§1Z<4QQ4:7=1[A\]AN1O4R1KL57<:94<14O1\9G71541_9D716<:87R1ª«¬«®°±²³ª1M>1U9G1aP90U79<1b9BP7R7@1ET7CR:4<01UCRDS1[4594<:1R7O7RR7=1541[CB9:5RC571cP=B71UCRDC1?@12QCPD=9<B@EK<57R7=H1VWXWVXWVJYS
VWXWJXWVJY WdV1higeiklmnopqolkvv�k oxrrx{tskwxpqxokpxkezptosk|q}tkpxk�q�tkit{rxo{q¦t��tnsqol{kpxkp�tk�x}r�nqop�k|�tkstns�qotkyxmkgtytosnop{k�t¦qok�ql�tmtknosk�q}��qkpxkno{�tmkxmkxp�tm�q{tkmt{rxoskpxkp�tk�qm{pk~}tostsk�x}r�nqopk�gx��kfx�k�v��q{ktzptostsk�rkpxknoskqo���sqolk~rmq�k���kv����kjqlotsk�ukwnlq{pmnptk��sltk�nm�nki�jrn��sqolkxokv�v��v����k�e���kEK<57R7=H1VWXWJXWVJYS
VWXWJXWVJY WdJ1/K?\]_]/6\K14O19<57R7:57=1Q7R:4<:1C<=134RQ4RC571=9:3D4:PR71:5C57G7<51R71WW¤1]<57R7:57=Q7R:4<:14R=7R1M>1U9G1aP901U79<1b9BP7R7@1ET7CR:4<01UCRDS1EK<57R7=H1VWXWJXWVJYS
VWXWWXWVJY WdW1/K?\]_]/6\K14O19<57R7:57=1Q7R:4<:1C<=134RQ4RC571=9:3D4:PR71:5C57G7<51R71WW¤1]<57R7:57=
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 45 of 50 PageID 2576
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� +��+)
./012314205/0467489/:4;20<23=4>?@0<9/<<A4BC@09/1D4>E3</0/5F4GHIHHIHGJKD
GHIHHIHGJK HLL4;MNOMP4Q2045/Q@R9<48..9ST@<S234Q204E3<0742Q4U/Q@R9<4@V@S31<4M39S3/4B2WWR3ST@<S231674X@W/14X=48629<S3A4Y@W/9@4X=4Z3SVC<=4>8<<@TCW/3<1F4[4J4E:CS6S<4E:CS6S<48D>?@<TC/920AX23@<C@3D4;2<S23140/Q/00/54<24;@VS1<0@</4XR5V/4Z@09@4\=4].@R95S3V=4>E3</0/5FGHIHHIHGJKD
GHIHHIHGJK HL4\E]YMP]E4NM4M\UE\4NM4]_M 4B8a]E40/4HHb4M05/04<241C2c4T@R1/4QS9/54674X@W/1X=48629<S3A4Y@W/9@4X=4Z3SVC<=4>?@<TC/920A4X23@<C@3D4>E3</0/5F4GHIHHIHGJKD
GHIHLIHGJK HLd4B9/0ef14EPN\g4Mh4UEh8aiN4@14<24M39S3/4B2WWR3ST@<S231A4iiB4>\UMD4>E3</0/5FGHIHLIHGJKD
GHIHLIHGJK HLb4jklmnojlpmnljnpqrstuvwxryxpzz{pmwq|wp}~pou~�p�v�s|�porxy|qp��p��qx|p�v����p��w~yp~ypz�z��z����p�����p>E3</0/5F4GHIHLIHGJKD
GHIHKIHGJK HL�4>]N\OBZEP4?g4HG4M\UE\D4PMNOBE42Q4T2W.9S@3T/40/4HJG4B@1/4W@3@V/W/3<4@351TC/5R9S3V4205/04��������������� ¡¢�£¡�¤�¡�¥£�¢£�¦¡��4674ZSW4_RSA4X/R3/11/4iiBA4Z/§S3SVR/0/A4]T2<<484i/cS1A4/3574\=4i/cS1A4MV@9/4\@74>Y/@0123A4Z@09D4;25SQS/5423LIdIHGJK4>\UMD=4>E3</0/5F4GHIHKIHGJKD
GHIHKIHGJK HLK4>]N\OBZEP4?g4HG4M\UE\D4PMNOBE42Q4T2W.9S@3T/40/4HJG4B@1/4;@3@V/W/3<4@35]TC/5R9S3V4M05/04674X@1234B@0@W@3S1A4;i;4;@QS@A4O3T=4>/99W@3A4BC0S1D4;25SQS/5423LIJIHGJK4>\UMD=4;25SQS/54234LIdIHGJK4>\UMD=4>E3</0/5F4GHIHKIHGJKD
GHIHKIHGJK HL©4>]N\OBZEP4?g4HG4M\UE\D4PMNOBE42Q4T2W.9S@3T/40/4HJG4B@1/4;@3@V/W/3<4@35]TC/5R9S3V4M05/04674X@W/14X=48629<S3A4Y@W/9@4X=4Z3SVC<4>?@<TC/920A4X23@<C@3D4;25SQS/5234LIJIHGJK4>\UMD=4;25SQS/54234LIdIHGJK4>\UMD=4>E3</0/5F4GHIHKIHGJKD
GLIGHIHGJK HG4mnljnp}~ps}wrª|pw|«pz��p�~¬�rvyt|py~}rt|p®r�|qp��p�vs~yp�vwv¬vyrsp�°�p�v®rv±yt�pz�²p�~¬�rvyt|py~}rt|p®r�|qp��p�v¬|sp��p³�~�}ryp�v¬|�vp��pyrxu}pz�µ�~¬�rvyt|py~}rt|p®r�|qp��pot~}}p³p°|�rspr¬p¶�rp�|�y|ss|p°°�p�|yq�pn�p°|�rsmxv�|pnv�p|·ryp�rx�|w|�porxy|qp��p�vxrs}wv}|p��qx|pvw�vpn�pov��qryxp~y��z�z����p�j���p>E3</0/5F4GLIGHIHGJKD
GLILGIHGJK HJ4X2S3<4;MNOMP4<24B23<S3R/4�¹ �¥ £¦4674X@W/14X=48629<S3A4Y@W/9@4X=4Z3SVC<=>8<<@TCW/3<1F4[4J4N/:<42Q4Y02.21/54M05/04Y02.21/54M05/04\/F4X2S3<4;2<S234<24B23<S3R/;/5S@<S23D>?@<TC/920A4X23@<C@3D4>E3</0/5F4GLILGIHGJKD
GIGLIHGJK HH4mnljnpxwvy}ryxpzº�p�~ry}p�~}r~yp}~p�~y}ry�|p�|qrv}r~ypl|vq�ry|�p»u|pq|vq�ry|®~wp}u|pvw}r|sp}~pt~¬�|}|p¬|qrv}r~yprsp|¼}|yq|qp�p}~pvyqpryt��qryxp�v�p²pz����orxy|qp��p�vxrs}wv}|p��qx|pvw�vpn�pov��qryxp~ypº�z�z����p�j���p>E3</0/5FGIGLIHGJKD
GIGIHGJK 4]/<I0/1/<41TC/5R9S3V4205/045/@59S3/1F4B235RT<4W/5S@<S234C/@0S3V4674dI©IHGJK=4i/@5T2R31/94<24T2205S3@</45@</1=4>\UMD4>E3</0/5F4GIGIHGJKD
GIGdIHGJK HL4a32..21/54;MNOMP4Q204E:</31S2342Q4NSW/4<24hS9/4\/1.231/I\/.974@14<24JHL48W/35/5B2W.9@S3<4A4;MNOMP4Q204E:</31S2342Q4NSW/4<24hS9/4831c/04¥£�½ ¤¡¥�¾¿�¦¹�¹�À£¿Á�� ¦¥674ZSW4_RSA4Z/§S34SVR/0/=4>Y/@0123A4Z@09D4;2<S23140/Q/00/54<24;@VS1<0@</4XR5V/4Z@09@\=4].@R95S3V=4>E3</0/5F4GIGdIHGJKD
GIGdIHGJK H 4mnljnpq|y�ryxpzº�pÂy~~s|qp�~}r~yp}~pj¼}|yqp»r¬|p}~pÃr�|pn|s~ysr·|��|vqryxp}~p}u|p�~¬�vry}�porxy|qp��p�vxrs}wv}|p��qx|pvw�vpn�pov��qryxp~yº�Ä�z����p�j���p>E3</0/5F4GIGdIHGJKD
GIJ�IHGJK Hd4;MNOMP4<245S1WS114Q204Q@S9R0/4<241<@</4@4T9@SW4674ZSW4_RSA4Z/§S34SVR/0/=4>Y/@0123AZ@09D4>E3</0/5F4GIJ�IHGJKD
GdIGLIHGJK Hb4a32..21/54;MNOMP4Q204E:</31S2342Q4NSW/4R3<S94dIJdIJK4<24hS9/4\/1.231/4<2
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 46 of 50 PageID 2577
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� +��+)
./0/12314567896:;4<;164;6.<5=<556>?6@3=/56@A6B>;C4<1D6E3=/C36@A6F1<GH4A6IB443JH=/145KL6M6N/O46;06EP;Q;5/26RP2/P6EP;Q;5/26RP2/PSIT34JH/C;PD6@;134H31S6:;4<;156P/0/PP/264;:3G<54P34/6@U2G/6F3PC36VA6WQ3UC2<1GA6:;2<0</26;169X8X7YMZ6IV.RSA6I[14/P/2KY9XY\X7YMZS
Y9XY8X7YMZ 78]6 _ a_bcdefghfcbijkblmghmfbnmdbaogpfqhmfbmnbrhspbgmbthupb_pqvmfqpw_pvuxbdpbijyl rz{bgmb|hqshqqbnmdbnehu}dpbgmbqgegpbeb~uehsb_pqvmfqpqb|}pb�xbyw�ywi����b�hcfp|�xblechqgdegpb�}|cpb�edueb_�b�ve}u|hfcbmfbywjwi����b�_ �bI[14/P/2K6Y9XY8X7YMZS
Y9XMMX7YMZ 78Z6�RN��[6R�6W�EE�[:[�NB�6B�N�RV�N�6P/6M9M6:RN�R�64;6J;=Q/C63P><4P34<;1>?6F<=6�U<D6@/U1/55/6���D6F/�<16�<GU/P/D6WJ;446B6�/�<5D6�/12?6VA6�/�<5D6RG3C/6V3?AIB443JH=/145K6L6M6[OH<><4SIE/3P5;1D6F3PCS6:;2<0</26;169XM8X7YMZ6IV.RSA6I[14/P/2KY9XMMX7YMZS
Y9XM9X7YMZ 78�6:[.�BN�R�6P/Q;P46�/3P<1G6H/C26;16Y9XY�X7YMZA6�/3P<1G6;U4J;=/K6�=Q355/AA6IE/3P5;1DF3PCS6I[14/P/2K6Y9XM9X7YMZS
Y9XM9X7YMZ 79Y6V[WER�W[6<16RQQ;5<4<;16P/67896:RN�R�64;62<5=<5560;P603<CUP/64;65434/636JC3<=60<C/26>?@3=/56@A6B>;C4<1D6E3=/C36@A6F1<GH4A6IT34JH/C;PD6@;134H31S6:;2<0</26;169XM�X7YMZ6IB��SAI[14/P/2K6Y9XM9X7YMZS
Y9X\YX7YMZ 79M6�RN��[6;065UQQC/=/143C63U4H;P<4?6P/6M9M6:RN�R�64;6J;=Q/C63P><4P34<;16>?6@/U1/55/���D6WJ;446B6�/�<5D6�/12?6VA6�/�<5D6RG3C/6V3?A6IB443JH=/145K6L6M6[OH<><464;6�;4<J/6;0WUQQC/=/143C6BU4H;P<4?SIE/3P5;1D6F3PCS6I[14/P/2K6Y9X\YX7YMZS
Y�X7�X7YMZ 7976@;<146:RN�R�64;6543?6������������ �¡���6>?6BCC6EC3<14<005A6IT34JH/C;PD6@;134H31SI[14/P/2K6Y�X7�X7YMZS
Y]XY7X7YMZ 79\6a{ _�a b_ a_bcdefghfcbiyib�mhfgblmghmfbgmb�gexb¢pf|hfcb�pggupspfg�br£hq~eqpbhqb�r¤¥a bvpf|hfcbebsmghmfbnmdbvdpuhshfedxbevvdm¦eubmnbeb~ueqqbe~ghmfqpggupspfgb§£h~£bq£euub�pbnhup|bmfbmdb�pnmdpb¤}c}qgb�bi����br£pb©updªbhqz_a©ra bgmbpfgpdbebqgex�b�hcfp|b�xb�}|cpb¢e}ub«�b¬xdmfbmfbwiwi����b�ll®�I[14/P/2K6Y]XY7X7YMZS
Y]XY7X7YMZ 6�35/6W43?/2A6IB��S6I[14/P/2K6Y]XY\X7YMZS
Y]X\MX7YMZ 7986WN�E��BN[.6:RN�R�60;P6[O4/15<;16;06N<=/64;6�<C/6:;4<;16�;P6EP/C<=<13P?6BQQP;�3C;06�C3556BJ4<;16W/44C/=/146>?6BCC6EC3<14<005A6IT34JH/C;PD6@;134H31S6:;2<0</26;16ZXMX7YMZIV.RSA6I[14/P/2K6Y]X\MX7YMZS
YZXYMX7YMZ 7996a{ _�a b_ a_bcdefghfcbiyjblmghmfbnmdbaogpfqhmfbmnbrhspbgmbthup�br£psmghmfbnmdbvdpuhshfedxbevvdm¦eubmnbeb~ueqqbe~ghmfbqpggupspfgbq£euub�pbnhup|bmfbmd�pnmdpb¤}c}qgb� bi����b�hcfp|b�xb�}|cpb¢e}ub«�b¬xdmfbmfb�w�wi����b�ll®�I[14/P/2K6YZXYMX7YMZS
YZXMYX7YMZ 79�6WN�E��BN[.6:RN�R�60;P6[O4/15<;16;06N<=/64;6�<C/6:;4<;16�;P6EP/C<=<13P?6BQQP;�3C;06�C3556BJ4<;16W/44C/=/146>?6BCC6EC3<14<005A6IT34JH/C;PD6@;134H31S6:;2<0</26;1ZXM\X7YMZ6IV.RSA6I[14/P/2K6YZXMYX7YMZS
YZXM\X7YMZ 79]6 _ a_bcdefghfcbiykblmghmfbnmdbaogpfqhmfbmnbrhspbgmbthup�br£pbvedghpqbq£euub£e¦p}fghubef|bhf~u}|hfcb¤}c}qgb�bi���bgmbnhupbebsmghmfbnmdbvdpuhshfedxbqpggupspfgevvdm¦eu�b�hcfp|b�xb�}|cpb¢e}ub«�b¬xdmfbmfb�w�wi����b�¤°��bI[14/P/2K6YZXM\X7YMZS
YZXM]X7YMZ 79Z6WN�E��BN�R�6±²��³ µ³¶³·6>?6@3=/56@A6B>;C4<1D6E3=/C36@A6F1<GH4A6IB443JH=/145KL6M6[OH<><46BD6L676[OH<><46TD6L6\6[OH<><46�D6L686[OH<><46.D6L696[OH<><46[D6L6�6N/O46;0EP;Q;5/26RP2/P6�P314<1G6EC3<14<0056:;4<;160;P6EP/C<=<13P?6BQQP;�3C6;06�C3556BJ4<;1W/44C/=/14SIT34JH/C;PD6@;134H31S6I[14/P/2K6YZXM]X7YMZS
YZXM]X7YMZ 79�6:RN�R�60;P6EP/C<=<13P?6BQQP;�3C6;06�C3556BJ4<;16W/44C/=/146>?6@3=/56@A6B>;C4<1D
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 47 of 50 PageID 2578
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� +��+)
./012/34536789:;53<=;;/>:017;?@3A3B3CD:8E8;3BF3A3G3H/873IJ>K017;3H10JL/7MK0387NKOOJL;3JP3HJ;8J73PJL3.L128087/LQ3=OOLJR/23JP3S2/??3=>;8J73N1;;21017;F3A3T3U1D;3JP.LJOJ?1M3VLM1L3WL/7;8793.2/87;8PP?X3HJ;8J73PJL3.L128087/LQ3=OOLJR/23JP3S2/??3=>;8J7N1;;21017;Y<Z/;>:12JLF34J7/;:/7Y3U1D;30JM8P81M3J73[\G]\G]B[3<IVY53<C7;1L1M@][\B_\G]B[Y
][\G\G]B[ Ga]3bVUcSC3JP3:1/L8793J730J;8J73L13Gde3HVUcVb3PJL3.L128087/LQ3=OOLJR/23JP3S2/??=>;8J73N1;;21017;53HJ;8J73f1/L8793?1;3PJL3e\BG\G]B[3/;3B]@T]3=H3873VL2/7MJ3SJKL;LJJ0Z3E1PJL134KM913./K23W53ZQLJ7F3g5N53I8?;L8>;3SJKL;F3]B3h1?;3S17;L/23Z2RMF3VL2/7MJFi2JL8M/53U:13SJKL;3:/?3?1;3/?8M13J713<BY3:JKL3PJL3;:8?3:1/L87953<WbZY3>JO81?31j0/821M<C7;1L1M@3][\G\G]B[Y
][\TB\G]B[ GaB3gbV..VNCI3HVUcVb3;J3CD>K?13k1/M3SJK7?12X?3=E?17>13/;3;:13f1/L8793J73HJ;8J7PJL3.L128087/LQ3=OOLJR/23JP3S2/??3=>;8J73N1;;21017;3/7M3=22Jl3kJ>/23SJK7?123;J3=OO1/LEQ34/?J73S/L/0/78?F3HkH3H/P8/F3c7>553<=;;/>:017;?@3A3B3=PP8M/R8;Y<h1220/7F3S:L8?YHJM8P81M3J73e\\G]B[3<IVY53<C7;1L1M@3][\TB\G]B[Y
]e\]d\G]B[ GaG3mnopqrmospqomqstuvwxywtsz{|so}~}w�vwx��s��xy�wsx�sm����}s�}v�s���w�}��rytw}�s��s���t}s�v��s��s��u�ws�ws����z�|��s�r���s<C7;1L1M@3]e\]d\G]B[Y
]e\BG\G]B[ GaT3H87K;13C7;LQ53.LJ>11M879?3:12M3E1PJL134KM913./K23W53ZQLJ7@3HVUcVb3fC= cbW3:12MJ73e\BG\G]B[3L13Gde3HVUcVb3PJL3.L128087/LQ3=OOLJR/23JP3S2/??3=>;8J73N1;;21017;3P821MEQ34/01?3453=EJ2;87F3./012/34536789:;53SJKL;31OJL;1L@36JL1;;/3N;/7PJLM3<WbZY3>JO81?31j0/821M3<C7;1L1M@3]e\BG\G]B[Y
]e\BT\G]B[ Ga3pqomqstuvwxywtsz��s��vywxy~~��s��xy�ws~�us�u}�y�ywvu�s���u��v�s�~s��v��s��xy�wr}xx�}�}wx�srytw}�s��s���t}s�v��s��s��u�ws�ws��|��z�|��s�r���s<C7;1L1M@]e\BT\G]B[Y
]e\BT\G]B[ Gad3bVUcSC3JP3f1/L879@3i87/23i/8L71??3f1/L8793?1;3PJL3B\[\G]Be3/;3T@]]3.H3873VL2/7MJSJKL;LJJ03Z3E1PJL134KM913./K23W53ZQLJ753<WbZY3>JO81?31j0/821M3<C7;1L1M@]e\BT\G]B[Y
BB\Ba\G]B[ Gaa3mnopqrmospqomqs�}w�ywtsv�s���xs|��s��xy�wsx�s�y��y���s�}w�ywtsv�s���xs|�|��xy�wsx�s����}�s�u�yxuvxy�w�s�}w�ywtsv�s���xs|�zs��xy�wsx�s�}uxy~�s��v����}w�ywtsv�s���xsz��s��xy�wsx�soy��y���s� }s��xy�w�svu}su}w�}u}�s���xs��sx }pu�}usz{�stuvwxywts��vywxy~~��s��xy�ws~�us�u}�y�ywvu�s���u��v�s�~s��v��s��xy�wr}xx�}�}wx�srytw}�s��s���t}s�v��s��s��u�ws�ws||�|{�z�|��s�r���s<C7;1L1M@BB\Ba\G]B[Y
BB\Ba\G]B[ Ga_3mnopqrmospqomqs�yu}�xywts��vywxy~~�svw�sx }sw�w¡�}xx�ywtso}~}w�vwx�¢s�v��w�vuv�vwy�¢s��}�s��ux�w¢svw�s���s�v~yv¢s£w��¢sx�s¤�ywx��sv��y�}sx }s���uxs¥ �x y�s�vxx}us� ����sw�xs�}su}��}w}��s� }s�vuxy}�s� v��s~y�}svs¤�ywxs�xvx}�}wxs��¦uy�v�¢sn��}��}us��¢sz�|��srytw}�s��s���t}s�v��s��s��u�ws�ws||�|{�z�|��s�r���<C7;1L1M@3BB\Ba\G]B[Y
BB\Be\G]B[ Ga[3HVUcVb3PJL3CD;17?8J73JP3U8013;J3i8213HJ;8J73PJL3=OOLJR/23JP3=;;JL71Q?3i11?3/7MSJ?;?3EQ34/01?3453=EJ2;87F3./012/34536789:;53<=;;/>:017;?@3A3B3U1D;3JP3.LJOJ?1M3VLM1L.LJOJ?1M3VLM1L3HJ;8J73;J3CD;17M3=;;JL71Q?3i11?3I1/M2871Y<i1LLK>>8F3I/R8MY3<C7;1L1M@BB\Be\G]B[Y
BB\G]\G]B[ Gae3pqomqstuvwxywtsyws�vuxsvw�s�}w�ywtsyws�vuxsz{�s��xy�ws~�usm�x}w�y�ws�~s�y�}sx�¦y�}s��xy�ws~�us�xx�uw}���s¦}}��s� }s�}v��yw}sx�s~y�}sx }s��xy�wsy�s}�x}w�}�sx�n��}��}usz|¢sz�|�s�ws�us�}~�u}sw��wsmv�x}uwsrxvw�vu�s�y�}�sn�xy�}s�~sx y�s��xy�w���xs�}s�u��y�}�sx�s��x}wxyv�sr}xx�}�}wxs��v��s�}��}u�sywsx }s�vww}usvw�s��sx }�vx}�svw�sxy�}�s��}�y~y}�sywsx }���~s�u�}u�s� }���~s�u�}usv���s}�x}w��sx }s�}v��yw}~�us��x}wxyv�sr}xx�}�}wxs��v��s�}��}u�sx�s��¤}�xsx�sx }s�}xx�}�}wxsx�so}�}��}us§¢z�|�¢s��s��¤}�xy�w�s���x�vu}�s��sx vxs�vx}�sr}}���~s�u�}us~�us�x }usu}©�yu}�}wx���
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 48 of 50 PageID 2579
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� ++�+)
./01234564780/9:;8:24<=3024>8;[email protected]=?3/104C14DDEFGEFGDHA4I.B8=?3/10J4>8;?8KLMNOPQRSTUVWXOYQOZ[WL\T]YR_WabcabcdZ
`abcabcd becWfghigjWklYWQOmW]lWkSQWnopqrstusvwpxyuszyoptqs{|s}~~�up�p�|s��s�o�~�uq�s�q���qwq|���WhYP]�WSTW�RmY]S�STUVWiT�[[WL�]]O���T]�_W�WW\��S�S]WW�W�YSkVW�WbW\��S�S]WbW�Wjl]S�ZL�S]��klYRVW�OQZWL\T]YR_WabcabcdZ
`abcabcd beW�\�hi�i��h\WlkWST]Y�]RWNY�lT�WOTRW�lYNlYO]WRS��Ql�PYW�]O]�T]WYWc�WiT]Y�]RNY�lT�WlYRYW��WhYP]�WSTW�RmY]S�STUVWiT�[[WL�S]��klYRVW�OQZWL\T]YR_WabcabcdZ
`abcabcd bebW�SY�]WfghigjWklYW�QOYSkS�O]SlTWYWb��WgYRYW��W�QQW�QOST]Skk�[WL�]]O���T]�_W�WW\��S�S]V�WbW\��S�S]ZL�O]��QlYVW�lTO]�OTZWflRSkSRWlTWababcdWL��gZ[WL\T]YR_WabcabcdZ
`ababcd be�W�SY�]WfghigjWklYW�]]lYT�W� �W��W�QQW�QOST]Skk�[WL�]]O���T]�_W�WWfOSTW�l�P�T]f �lYOTRP�WlkW�O�VW�WbW\��S�S]W��QOYO]SlTWlkW�lTO]�OTWMW�O]��QlYVW�W�W\��S�S]��QOYO]SlTWlkW�OmSRWjW�YYP��SVW�W�Wh�]WlkW�YlNl�RWgYRYW�YlNl�RWgYRYZL�O]��QlYV�lTO]�OTZWfl]SlT�WYkYYRW]lWfOUS�]YO]W�PRUWXOYQOW�[WMNOPQRSTU[WL\T]YR_`ababcdZ
`ababcd be�W�\M�gjM\W]lWfl]SlTWYWbebW�SY�]WfghigjWklYW�QOYSkS�O]SlTWkSQRW��WXS�W�PSVW�PT�����VWXmSTW�SUPYVWM�l]]W�W��S�VW� TR�W�[W��S�VWgUOQW�O�[WL�OY�lTVWXOYQZL\T]YR_WababcdZ
`ababcd be�W @¡¢@4C£4@2¤=98?A4780/9:;8:24<=3024>8;[email protected]=?3/104;2¤=923A4¥¦24§?2;4C£§C=;:4/94¡©@¢§¥¢¡4:C4;2899/014:¦/94¤8924:C481C:¦2;4ª80/9:;8:24«=302A4./0123456780/9:;8:24<=3024>8;[email protected]=?3/104C14DDEFGEFGDHA4I¢§<K4L\T]YR_WababcdZ
`ababcd be�W�g��\�h\�W�\M�gjM\W]lWbebW�SY�]WfghigjWklYW�QOYSkS�O]SlTWz�ooqx�q�WkSQRW��XS�W�PSVW�PT��W���VWXmSTW�SUPYVWM�l]]W�W��S�VW� TR�W�[W��S�VWgUOQW�O�[L�OY�lTVWXOYQZWflRSkSRWlTWab�abcdWL��gZ[WL\T]YR_WababcdZ
`ab�abcd beeWjghi�\WlkW�l�NQSOT�WYWb��WgYRYW��W�O��W�[W��lQ]STWL�O]��QlYVW�lTO]�OTZWflRSkSRlTWab�abcdWL��gZ[WL\T]YR_Wab�abcdZ
`ab�abcd bedW�O�W�O��SUTRW]lWfOUS�]YO]W�PRUWh�l�O�W�[WM�S]�[Wj�W�O�WTP��Y_W�_e��m��b��gYQ��ch�M[Wfl]SlTWbe�W�SY�]WfghigjWklYW�]]lYT�W� �WYkYYRW]lWfOUS�]YO]�PRUWh�l�O�W�[WM�S]�[WLf��ZWL\T]YR_Wab�abcdZ
`ab�abcd be�W @¡¢@40;81:/104/14B8;:481343216/104/14B8;:4F¬F47C:/C14£C;4¤?8;/£/¤8:/C1A4./0123564780/9:;8:24<=3024¥¦Cª894A4.ª/:¦4C14DDEF®EFGDHA4I¢§K4L\T]YR_Wab�abcdZ
`a�cabcd bdcW�gijhWjghi�\W��W�O��W�[W��lQ]STVW�O�QOW�[WXTSU�]W�UOYRSTUWjlT�MSUTO]lY��kTROT]�WL�O]��QlYVW�lTO]�OTZWflRSkSRWlTWba�abcdWL��gZ[WL\T]YR_Wa�cabcdZ
bac�abcd bdW�\M�gjM\W]lWbecWfghigjWklYWQOmW]lWkSQWnopqrstusvwpxyuszyoptqs{|s}~~�up�p�|s���o�~�uq�s�q���qwq|�WkSQRW��WXS�W�PSVW�PT��W���VWXmSTW�SUPYVWM�l]]W�W��S�V� TR�W�[W��S�VWgUOQW�O�[WL�OY�lTVWXOYQZWflRSkSRWlTWba�abcdWL��gZ[WL\T]YR_bac�abcdZ
bac�abcd bdbW¢ ¡ @.¢¡4 @¡¢@40;81:/104/14B8;:481343216/104/14B8;:4F¬G4¥;=:¦4/1°3±2;:/9/10J4©1¤A²947C:/C14£C;4³28±24:C4/?24;/2£4894°ª/¤=94§=;/82A4¥¦24ªC:/C14/90;81:234:C4:¦242µ:21:4/:4;2¶=29:94?28±24:C4£/?24845;/2£4/14CBBC9/:/C14:C4:¦24B;CBC92392::?2ª21:A4¥C4:¦242µ:21:4¥;=:¦4©14°3±2;:/9/10J4©1¤A492294:C48BB28;452£C;24:¦24§C=;:8:4:¦24/18?48/;12994·28;/10J4:¦24ªC:/C14/94321/23A4./01234564<=30248=?4¹A46;C1C14DFEºEFGDHA4I.§7K4L\T]YR_Wbac�abcdZ
baceabcd bd�W�fi�»MW�»�i�\W��i\�WSTWgNNl�S]SlTW]lW]�W�YlNl�RWM]]Q�T]W�UY �T]WYWbdbgYRYWlTWfl]SlTWklYW�OmW]lW�SQW��WhYP]�WSTW�RmY]S�STUVWiT�[[WL�S]��klYRVW�OQZflRSkSRWlTWbacabcdWL��gZ[WL\T]YR_WbaceabcdZ
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 49 of 50 PageID 2580
�������� ������ �������� � ����������� � ��������� ������ � �������� ��
��� ��������!�����������"��� �# ���$%����&'(���))(''(�*)+�,-�-��� +)�+)
./0.10/1.2 /234567894:;4<==<>:?:<;4@A4/BC4DEF7EG4H<@4I@AJ:K:;L@M4N==@<OLJ4<H4PJL>>4NQ?:<;RA??JAKA;?4H:JAS4TM4UAJA;4V:<;WX4YN??LQZKA;?>[4\4.4R?L?AKA;?4<H4UAJA;4V:<;W]4\4/8Z:T:?4.]4\4_48Z:T:?4/Y6aE4Y8;?A@AS[4./0..0/1.2
./0.30/1.2 /2B4P86F797PNF84<H4Q<K=J:L;QA4TM4bLKA>4bX4NT<J?:;X4YN??LQZKA;?>[4\4.48Z:T:?4NaAQJL@L?:<;4<H46:QcM45<@WA>Y5L?QZAJ<@]4b<;L?ZL;4D<S:H:AS4<;4./0.d0/1.24Y6aEXY8;?A@AS[4./0.30/1.2
./0.d0/1.2 /2e4DEF7EG4H<@45JLcA4f:;SAKL;;4?<4L==AL@4=@<4ZLQ4O:QA4TM4UAJA;4V:<;WX4YN??LQZKA;?>[4\.4NHH:SLO:?4aAQJL@L?:<;]4\4/48Z:T:?4g<<S4R?L;S:;WYg:T;AM]4fX4D<?:<;>4@AHA@@AS4?<DLW:>?@L?A4bhSWA4FZ<KL>45X4RK:?ZX4Y8;?A@AS[4./0.d0/1.2
./0.d0/1.2 /2d4ijkljmnopqrsqnmtuvmwxrsxqmyxomz{p|}m~�m�sq�}wpqqmrxmp��}pom�oxm�p�m�s�}myxo�}{}qm�sxqn�m�snq}�m��m�pns�ropr}m~��n}m��xwp�mz�m�wsr�mxqm�t����t��u�m��wsr����xwp��mY8;?A@AS[4./0.d0/1.2
./0.20/1.2 /224l�kij�lkmijkljm�}q�sqnmp�mwxxrm�v�m�xrsxqmrxmks�ws���m�}q�sqnmp�mwxxrm����xrsxqmrxm�s�ws���m�}q�sqnmp�mwxxrmt�tm�xrsxqmyxom�}p�}mrxm�s{}�m��}mwxrsxq�mpo}o}q�}o}�mwxxrm��mr�}mio�}omtv�mnopqrsqnm�{psqrsyy��m�xrsxqmyxom�o}{swsqpo����ox�p{mxym�{p��m��rsxqm�}rr{}w}qr�m�snq}�m��m~��n}m�p�{m��mz�oxqmxqm�t��u�t��u������mY8;?A@AS[4./0.20/1.2
./0/30/1.2 /2C4a898GaNGF R4567894:;4>h==<@?4<H4/e34E@SA@4<;4D<?:<;4H<@4RA??JAKA;?4H:JAS4TM4¡:KUh:]4bAh;A>>A4ffP]4¡AO:;4g:WhA@A]4RQ<??4N4fA¢:>]4£A;SM46X4fA¢:>]4EWLJA46LMXYIAL@><;]4¡L@J4D<S:H:AS4<;4./0/e0/1.24YfDDX4Y8;?A@AS[4./0/30/1.2
./0/30/1.2 /C14DEF7EG4H<@4H:;LJ4L==@<OLJ4<H4QJL>>4LQ?:<;4RA??JAKA;?4TM4NJJ4IJL:;?:HH>X4YN??LQZKA;?>[4\.48Z:T:?4.4aAQJL@L?:<;4<H4b<;L?ZL;4R45L?QZAJ<@]4\4/48Z:T:?4N48=:¤4£AAcJM46A=<@?Y5L?QZAJ<@]4b<;L?ZL;4D<S:H:AS4<;4./0/e0/1.24YfDDX4Y8;?A@AS[4./0/30/1.2
1.0120/1.C /C.4D:;h?A48;?@MX4I@<QAAS:;W>4ZAJS4TAH<@A4bhSWA4ILhJ4gX45M@<;[497GNf49N76G8RRU8N67Gg4ZAJS4<;4.020/1.CX4P<h@?46A=<@?A@[4¡<@A??L4R?L;H<@S4YgG54Q<=:A>4A¥KL:JASY8;?A@AS[41.0120/1.C
1.01C0/1.C /C/4ijkljmnopqrsqnmt��m�xrsxqmyxom�sqp{m���ox�p{mxym�{p��m��rsxqm�}rr{}w}qr�m�snq}���m~��n}m�p�{m��mz�oxqmxqm����t����m�����mY8;?A@AS[41.01C0/1.C
���ljm�}o�s�}m�}qr}o
�opq�p�rsxqmj}�}s�r
1.01C0/1.C4./[32[_3
���lj�xnsq¦
TJLcA/1_C[__B/2/2[1�{s}qrm�x�}¦
k}��os�rsxq¦a<QcA?46A=<@?�}po���osr}osp¦
e[.d¥QO¥1.e/3¥Ig5¥F5R
zs{{p�{}�pn}�¦
/C �x�r¦ /XC1
Case 6:17-cv-01624-PGB-TBS Document 293 Filed 01/09/19 Page 50 of 50 PageID 2581