Inclusive Semileptonic B Decays at BABAR
IntroductionThe BABAR DetectorDetermination of |Vcb|Determination of |Vub|Conclusion and Outlook
IntroductionThe BABAR DetectorDetermination of |Vcb|Determination of |Vub|Conclusion and Outlook
19th International Workshop on Weak Interactions and Neutrinos
Thorsten Brandt (TU Dresden)
for the BABAR Collaboration
2 Thorsten Brandt (TU Dresden)
Introduction Semileptonic B decays provide
pure method for determination of |Vcb| and |Vub| theoretical framework : OPE / HQE
Analysis of final states yields additional information : b quark mass „“ nonperturbative QCD parameters
(-) kinetic energy squared of b-quark in B-meson „“ consistency checks of OPE / HQE
Inclusive precision measurements small statistical and systematic errors high sensitivity to theoretical uncertainties
3 Thorsten Brandt (TU Dresden)
Qualitative Overview
,1shape
)( lXBBr c
|| cbV
)( lXBBr u
uc ,
,e
,eW
...,,,,,, (*)*** DDDDB
K
|Vcb|2, |Vub|2
Rate for Mx < 1.5
|| ubV
Shape
Shap
e
Rate
Inclusive El spectrum
Inclusive Mx spectrum
Semileptonic B decay
2|| cbV
2|| ubV
2|| cbV
HXbq
El[GeV]
4 Thorsten Brandt (TU Dresden)
Inclusive Spectra & HQE Heavy Quark Expansion relates s.l. decay rate and
|Vcb| :
related to b-quark mass 1 : (-) kinetic energy squared of b-quark in B-meson
2 : chromo-magnetic coupling of b-quark spin to gluon
field
Similar expressions for shapes of Mx and El spectra for different threshold momenta of the lepton first moment of invariant mass-squared of hadronic
system
)1
(02.018.395.087.0165.154.11192
||369.0
)(
322
21
2
2
3
522
BBBB
s
B
sBFcb
c
mO
mmmmmGV
eXB
)1
(02.018.395.087.0165.154.11192
||369.0
)(
322
21
2
2
3
522
BBBB
s
B
sBFcb
c
mO
mmmmmGV
eXB
,...),,( 212
minmin
EEEx fM
l
Combined fit to measurements of Mx2 for different Emin
and to measurement of (BX l)
5 Thorsten Brandt (TU Dresden)
The BABAR Detector
BBSYee )4( BBSYee )4(
6 Thorsten Brandt (TU Dresden)
)2,2,5( 4321 nnnn
Problem 1: Two B mesons decaying in the detector which tracks belong to the semileptonically decayed B ?
Use events with fully reconstructed hadronic B decay: look for decay modes
using
Momentum and flavor of both B mesons determined
Identification of S.L. Decays
040321
(*) nKnKnnDB sreco
2,
42 s
EEps
Mrecoreco BBES
2,
42 s
EEps
Mrecoreco BBES
K
recoB
HX
,e
,e
(*)D
Y(4S)K
SLB
7 Thorsten Brandt (TU Dresden)
4000 fully reconstructed B decays/fb-1
purity 65% if lepton is present
Does the lepton originate from a semileptonic B decay ? exclude s.l. D decays :
Is the XH - system complete, i.e. has no particle been missed ? check missing 4-momentum
Pmiss must be compatible with neutrino hypothesis :
0)( lBb QQSL
0|| missP
tracks alle
iSYmis PPP )4(
5.20 5.22 5.24 5.26 5.28 5.30
mES [GeV/c2]
2200200018001600140012001000800400200
0
Eve
nts
/ (2
.5 M
eV/c
2 )
x 102 All Events
Identification of S.L. B decays
5.20 5.22 5.24 5.26 5.28 5.30
mES [GeV/c2]
12000
10000
8000
6000
4000
2000
0
Eve
nts
/ (2
.5 M
eV/c
2 )
1 lepton, pl > 1 GeV/c
8 Thorsten Brandt (TU Dresden)
Mx2 Analysis : Event
Selection 1 lepton with p*>0.9 GeV/c Mx
2 determined by 2C kinematic fit energy conservation, p2
miss = 0, mB
1Hreco XlBtot QQQQ
GeVEmiss 5.0 cGeVpmiss /5.0||,
GeVpcE missmiss 5.0||
HX
,e
,e
(*)D
Y(4S)
K
2/350)( cMeVMx
signalbackground
K
(p* >0.9 GeV/c)
(p >0.5 GeV/c E>0.5 GeV) 5.22 5.23 5.24 5.25 5.26 5.27 5.28 5.29
mES[GeV/c2]
225020001750150012501000750500250
0
Eve
nts
/ 1.8
MeV
/c2
high mass final states
Mx2[GeV2/c4]
B
BBABAR
9 Thorsten Brandt (TU Dresden)
Determination of Mx2
Measured Mx2 differs from true Mx
2
For each interval in Mx2, full detector
simulation delivers Mx2 and Mx
2 calibration curve which is applied to
data event-by-event weak dependence on decay model validated on data with decays function of multiplicity and
Event selection efficiency depends on decay mode
influence on Mx2 determined with MC,
systematic error estimated by variationof individual exclusive decay modes
missmiss pE
)()( 22xx MM highlow
lDB *
0.9 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 pmin[GeV/c]
4.5
4.4
4.3
4.2
4.1
4.0
Mx2
[G
eV2 /
c4 ]~
calibration (D,D*, D**,D(*) mix)
verification withexcl. modes
D
*D
.Resnon
**D
3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Mx
2 [GeV2/c4]
1211109876543
Mx2
[G
eV2 /
c4 ]
~
~
10 Thorsten Brandt (TU Dresden)
Mx2 - Fits to BABAR
Moments Extract OPE parameters from
fit to Mx2 vs. pl - curve
include correlations based on work of Falk
and Luke
Comparison with CLEO and DELPHI : All hadronic moments consistent
:,)5.0(,0,128.0
2233
21
1
22
fixedFor
GeVGeV iT
2exp1
exp
09.036.0
09.053.0
GeV
GeVMS
MS
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8][GeVMS
-0.1
-0.2
-0.3
-0.4
-0.5
1M
S [G
eV]
11 Thorsten Brandt (TU Dresden)
Include measurement of inclusive semileptonic branching fraction into the fit SL = (4.37 0.18) x 10-11 MeV
Good agreement with hadronicmoments from CLEO, DELPHI
Moments of lepton spectrum agreement on the 1 level when
using CLEO/DELPHI lepton momentsinstead of BABAR hadron moments
- expect higher precision after inclusion of BABAR measurements -
Combined Fit to Mx2
and SL
3
/1dimexp
2/1dimexp
11
2/1dimexp
1
1050.052.004.110.42||
04.004.006.026.0
/07.006.009.064.4
3
3
3
B
B
B
mBLMcb
mBLMS
mBLMS
b
V
GeV
cGeVm
4.4 4.6 4.8 5.0
44
43
42
41
40
39
38
|Vcb
|[10-3
]
mb1S [GeV/c2]
12 Thorsten Brandt (TU Dresden)
Measurement of Br(BXu l )
Use Mx spectrum of XH
good b c l rejection large acceptance (50- 80%)
Problems : leading order dependence on
shape function of Mx
low statistics of Breco sample
Additional event selection : lepton with p* > 1 GeV/c veto on K+, K0
s anddecays
m2miss < 0.5 GeV2/c4 , Qtot = 0
lDB *0
2/55.1 cGeVMx
13 Thorsten Brandt (TU Dresden)
cut momentum lepton through biasfor correction
sample through biasGeV/c1.55Mwithfractionsignalf
efficiencysignal2
xu
:/:/
::
)/()(
)(
)(
ue
SLe
recout
SLt
usel
ut
ul
SLt
SLl
sl
uuselbgdatau
B
N
fNN
eXBBreXBBr
Br(BXu l ) : Signal Extraction
Extract number of signal events by fitting sum of 3 shapes to Mx distribution : signal, b c l background, other sources (<1%,
misidentified leptons, and secondary charm decays)
S / B comparable to excl. analyses : B0 : S/B 3.6 , B+ : S/B 1.2
14 Thorsten Brandt (TU Dresden)
B Xu l : Results Branching fraction :
Extraction of |Vub| : formula from CKM 2002 workshop , B=(1.608
0.016) ps:
3
2
10)39.026.027.024.2()(
10)36.023.025.006.2()(
)(
theosyststatu
theosyststatu
lXBBr
xlXBBrlXBBr
:)%3.018.087.10()( sysstatlXBBr oftmeasuremenBABAR using
)052.0020.00.1(55.1
002.0
)(00445.0|| 3/1
2/1
bmpertB
uub
lXBBrV
ps
310)26.040.027.028.062.4(|| theosyststatubV
error due to extrapolation and efficiencyerror of transition (BXu l ) |Vub| (Uraltsev, Hoang)
15 Thorsten Brandt (TU Dresden)
Conclusions & Outlook Precise measurements of and decays :
New model-independent determination of moments of hadronic mass distribution in semileptonic B decays fully consistent with measurements from DELPHI and CLEO
BABAR measurement of moments of lepton energy spectrum in progress measurements for different values of Emin, starting at 0.6
GeV tighter constraints on OPE parameters and |Vcb|
lcb lub
3
3/1
2/1
1
10)26.040.027.028.062.4(||
10)50.052.004.110.42(||
/)07.006.009.064.4(
3
3
theosyststat
BLMdimexp
BLMdimexp
ub
mcb
mS
b
V
V
cGeVm
b
b
16 Thorsten Brandt (TU Dresden)
Backup Slides
17 Thorsten Brandt (TU Dresden)
Systematic studies on <Mx
2> Cross-check on data :
sample ofdecays identified by reconstruction of slowpion from
analysis on this sampleyields D* - mass
Consistent measurements inindependent data sets electrons / muons , years, B0 / B+
variation of cut on variation of Breco purity
• add / remove decay channels
eDB *0
sDD 0*
|| missmiss pE
18 Thorsten Brandt (TU Dresden)
Fit to Moments