Date post: | 04-Jun-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | mia-bogdanovic |
View: | 216 times |
Download: | 0 times |
8/13/2019 Incremental Analysis is Used to Find the Impact of Changes in Costs or Revenues
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/incremental-analysis-is-used-to-find-the-impact-of-changes-in-costs-or-revenues 1/19
8/13/2019 Incremental Analysis is Used to Find the Impact of Changes in Costs or Revenues
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/incremental-analysis-is-used-to-find-the-impact-of-changes-in-costs-or-revenues 2/19
many situations requiring incremental analysis, fixed costs remain unchanged,irrespective of the course of action finally taken. Therefore, those fixed costs areirrelevant for the purposes of the decision in question and can be ignored. [This is not tosay that fixed costs are unimportant, or that they don't eventually have to be taken intoaccount. In the long run, fixed costs have to be covered if we are going to make money.]However, incremental analysis is typically used for short run, one-time decisions.
When "one-time decisions" get to be routine, it may be time to reevaluate the situation.For example, suppose a customer wants some sort of special attachment on a product--what on the surface appears to be a "this month only" occurrence. Then perhaps two orthree months later, the same customer calls and says "Remember back in May you dida special job for us? Well, we need another thousand of those. How soon could youhave them?" At some point, management needs to determine whether the "one-timeoccurrence" has suddenly become the "normal circumstances."
Another key element in incremental analysis is the notion of sunk costs. Sunk costs
are costs which were incurred in the past. No future action or inaction can change the
situation. Suppose we spend a million dollars on June 1st for a large machine which will
enhance productivity. On June 2nd, a sales representative offers to sell us a competitive
machine for $500,000; this machine has twice the productivity of the one purchased onJune 1st. In this classic case of "buyer's remorse," it is tempting to we now have a $1.5
million decision. However, the million spent on machine #1 is a sunk cost. We may have
really messed up by not doing our homework and surveying all the options available
before we bought the machine. However, if the second machine really will have the
stated impact on productivity, it would be foolish not to spend the money [if we have, of
course; we may have "shot our wad" on machine #1]. However, no matter what we do,
the million is gone and is irrelevant to the decision about machine #2.
8/13/2019 Incremental Analysis is Used to Find the Impact of Changes in Costs or Revenues
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/incremental-analysis-is-used-to-find-the-impact-of-changes-in-costs-or-revenues 3/19
Introduction to Incremental Analysis
Managerial decisions are choices made based on financial and nonfinancial information.
Typically, financial information serves as the first hurdle in identifying a possible course
of action as an alternative. If the financial hurdle is met, then management must
consider the impact of the alternative on the environment, the company's employees,
its image, the community, its partners or alliances, and so on before making a final
decision.
Incremental analysis, sometimes called marginal or differential analysis, is used to
analyze the financial information needed for decision making. It identifies the relevant
revenues and/or costs of each alternative and the expected impact of the alternative on
future income.
To illustrate the concept, think about the decision to lease or buy a car. Leasing
involves a regular payment and the return of the vehicle at the end of the lease unless
a one-time payment is made. This arrangement means the car does not legally belong
to the person leasing it. To buy a car requires payment of the purchase price. Thepayment may be made in cash or by signing a note payable for the amount owed. If
you were to prepare financial statements under each alternative, they would look very
different. An operating lease for a car with payments of $300 per month would result in
the annual cost of the lease, $3,600, being reported as an expense on the income
statement. The purchase of a car results in an asset — and a liability, if a note was
signed — being recorded on the company's balance sheet.
Another example is the choice between alternatives A and B, given the following
relevant revenues and expenses:
Al ternative A Al ternative B Net I ncome Increase/(Decrease)
Revenues $100,000 $150,000 $50,000
Expenses78,000 105,000 (27,000)
Net Income$ 22,000 $ 45,000 $23,000
This example shows alternative B generates $23,000 more net income than alternative
A. Management must now consider the nonfinancial information to determine whether
alternative B should be accepted.
Several concepts are incorporated into incremental analysis and need to be defined
before discussing some specific applications of incremental analysis.
8/13/2019 Incremental Analysis is Used to Find the Impact of Changes in Costs or Revenues
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/incremental-analysis-is-used-to-find-the-impact-of-changes-in-costs-or-revenues 4/19
Relevant cost. Those revenues and costs that differ among alternatives, as
opposed to revenues and costs that stay the same, which are ignored when
analyzing alternatives. Note: Some texts refer to the revenues that change as
relevant benefits.
Sunk cost. A cost that has already been incurred and, therefore, has no impact
on future decisions because the cost will not change or go away in the future. The
book value of a previously purchased and currently owned asset will not change
whether or not a new asset is purchased to replace it. Opportunity cost. A potential benefit that is lost when a company chooses
another alternative.
Examples of Incremental AnalysisIncremental analysis, sometimes called marginal or differential analysis, is used to
analyze the financial information needed for decision making. It identifies the relevant
revenues and/or costs of each alternative and the expected impact of the alternative on
future income.
Here are some examples of incremental analysis:
Accepting additional business.
Making or buying parts or products.
Selling products or processing them further.
Eliminating a segment.
Allocating scarce resources (sales mix).
Accepting additional business
The Party Connection prepares complete party kits for various types of celebrations. It
is currently operating at 75% of its capacity. It costs The Party Connection $4.50 to
make a packet that it sells for $25.00. It currently makes and sells 84,000 packets per
year. Detailed information follows:
Per Uni t Annual Total
Sales $25.00 $2,100,000
Direct Materials 12.00 1,008,000
Direct Labor 6.00 504,000
8/13/2019 Incremental Analysis is Used to Find the Impact of Changes in Costs or Revenues
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/incremental-analysis-is-used-to-find-the-impact-of-changes-in-costs-or-revenues 5/19
Overhead .50 42,000
Selling Expenses 1.75 147,000
Administrative Expenses.25 21,000
Total Costs and Expenses20.50 1,722,000
Operating Income$ 4.50 $378,000
The Party Connection has received a special order request for 15,000 packets at a price
of $20 per packet to be shipped overseas. This transaction would not affect the
company's current business. If 84,000 packets is 75% of capacity, 112,000 packets
would be 100% of capacity. The Party Connection has the capacity to prepare the
15,000 packets requested without changing its existing operations. Should the Party
Connection accept this special order? Using its current cost information, the answer
would be no because accepting the order would generate a $7,500 loss.
Per Uni t Total
Sales$20.00 $300,000
Direct Materials 12.00 180,000
Direct Labor 6.00 90,000
Overhead .50 7,500
Selling Expenses 1.75 26,250
Administrative Expenses.25 3,750
Total Costs and Expenses20.50 307,500
Operating Income$ (.50) $(7,500)
8/13/2019 Incremental Analysis is Used to Find the Impact of Changes in Costs or Revenues
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/incremental-analysis-is-used-to-find-the-impact-of-changes-in-costs-or-revenues 6/19
However, this is not the proper way to analyze the alternative. Incremental analysis,
which identifies only those revenues and costs that change if the order were accepted,
should be used to analyze the alternative. This requires a review of the costs. Suppose
the following information is discovered with further analysis:
Accepting this order would not impact current sales.
To manufacture 15,000 packets would require $12.00 of direct materials and
$6.00 of direct labor.
The per unit overhead cost of $0.50 is 50% variable ($0.25) and 50% fixed
($0.25).
Selling costs (includes commissions and delivery costs) for the 15,000 packets
would be $7,000.
Administrative expenses would not change.
Per Un it Totals
Sales$20.00 $300,000
Direct Materials 12.00 180,000
Direct Labor 6.00 90,000
Overhead .25 3,750
Selling Expenses 7,000
Total Costs and Expenses280,750
Operating Income$19,250
Under this scenario, $300,000 of additional revenues would be created with additional
costs of $280,750, so operating income would increase by $19,250 if the order were
accepted. Given the available capacity, this opportunity would not result in additional
costs to expand capacity. If the current capacity were unable to handle the special
request, any new costs for expanding capacity would be included in the analysis. Also, if
current sales were impacted by this order, then the lost contribution margin would be
considered an opportunity cost for this alternative. With additional operating income of
$19,250, this order could be accepted.
8/13/2019 Incremental Analysis is Used to Find the Impact of Changes in Costs or Revenues
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/incremental-analysis-is-used-to-find-the-impact-of-changes-in-costs-or-revenues 7/19
Making or buying component parts or products
The decision to make or buy component parts also uses incremental analysis to
determine the relevant costs. Opportunity costs must also be considered. Toyland
Treasures uses part #56 in several of its products. Toyland Treasures currently
produces 50,000 of part #56 using $0.30 of direct materials, $0.20 of direct labor, and
$0.10 of overhead. The purchase of parts is under review by the company's
management. Purchasing has determined it would cost $0.75 per unit to purchase
50,000 of part #56. Should Toyland Treasures continue to make part #56 or should it
purchase the part?
The total costs to produce part #56 are $30,000, a savings of $7,500 over the purchase
option, and the choice would be for Toyland Treasures to continue to make the part.
Make Buy I ncremental Increase/(Decrease)
Purchase ($0.75) $37,500 $(37,500)
Direct Materials ($.30) $15,000 15,000
Direct Labor ($0.20) 10,000 10,000
Overhead ($0.10)5,000 5,000
Total Relevant Costs$30,000 $37,500 $ (7,500)
If Toyland Treasures can use the part #56 production space for a product that would
generate $20,000 of additional operating income, the make or buy analysis would
generate incremental costs of $12,500 to make the part. In this case, the company
would likely choose to purchase part #56 and produce the other product. The $20,000
additional operating income is considered an opportunity cost and is added to the Make
column of the analysis.
Make Buy I ncremental Increase/(Decrease)
Total Relevant Costs $30,000 $37,500 $(7,500)
Opportunity Cost20,000 20,000
Total Costs$50,000 $37,500 $12,500
8/13/2019 Incremental Analysis is Used to Find the Impact of Changes in Costs or Revenues
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/incremental-analysis-is-used-to-find-the-impact-of-changes-in-costs-or-revenues 8/19
Selling products or processing further
Some companies' product can be sold at different stages in their production cycle. For
example, the DGK Company manufactures children's play gyms. It can sell the gyms
assembled or unassembled. Incremental analysis is used in the decision to sell
unassembled products. A general guideline DGK should consider when deciding how to
sell its units is that if the incremental revenues generated from assembling the gyms
are greater than the incremental assembly costs, DGK should assemble the gyms
(process further). DGK sells an unassembled gym for $1,000. Its costs to manufacture
a gym are $550, which consist of direct materials of $300, direct labor of $150, and
overhead of $100. It is estimated that assembling a gym would take additional labor of
$100 and overhead of $25, and once assembled, the gym could be sold for $1,500.
Sell
(Unassembled) Process Further
(Assembled) Operati ng Income
Increase/(Decrease)
Revenue$1,000 $1,500 $500
Costs 300 300 0
Direct Labor 150 250 (100)
Overhead100 125 (25)
Total Costs550 675 (125)
OperatingIncome
$ 450 $ 825 $375
On a per unit basis, the incremental analysis shows that DGK should process further
and assemble the gyms. Qualitative factors such as loss of business if unassembled
gyms were not offered (an opportunity cost) and customers' willingness to pay the
additional $500 for an assembled gym need to be considered.
An alternative way of analyzing this decision is:
Bases, Inc. Manufacturing Overhead Budget 20X1
An alternative way of analyzing this decision is:
Sales Price if Process Further (assembled) $1,500
8/13/2019 Incremental Analysis is Used to Find the Impact of Changes in Costs or Revenues
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/incremental-analysis-is-used-to-find-the-impact-of-changes-in-costs-or-revenues 9/19
Sales Price if Sell (unassembled)1,000
Incremental Revenue 500
Costs to Process Further
Direct Labor $100
Overhead25
Total Costs to Process125
Incremental Operating Income$ 375
Eliminating an unprofitable segment
If a company has several business segments, one of which is unprofitable, management
must decide what to do with the unprofitable segment. In reviewing the quantitative
information, a distinction must be made between those costs that will no longer exist if
the segment ceases to do business and those costs that will continue and need to be
covered by the remaining segments. Costs that go away if the segment no longer
operates are called avoidable costs, and those that remain even if the segment is
discontinued are called unavoidable costs.
Segment data for See Me Binoculars, Inc., shows the economy segment has operating
income of $120,000, the standard segment has operating income of $250,000, and the
deluxe segment is unprofitable by $200,000. The total company has operating income
of $170,000.
See Me Binoculars, Inc. Segment Income Statement 20X0
Economy Standard Deluxe Total
Revenues $1,200,000 $1,500,000 $2,500,000 $5,200,000
Variable Expense900,000 1,000,000 2,200,000 4,100,000
Contribution Margin 300,000 500,000 300,000 1,100,000
8/13/2019 Incremental Analysis is Used to Find the Impact of Changes in Costs or Revenues
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/incremental-analysis-is-used-to-find-the-impact-of-changes-in-costs-or-revenues 10/19
Fixed Expenses180,000 250,000 500,000 930,000
Operating Income$120,000 $250,000 $ (200,000) $170,000a
To prepare the quantitative analysis for its decision whether to eliminate the deluxe
segment, the fixed expenses must be separated into avoidable and unavoidable costs.
It has been determined that unavoidable costs will be allocated 45% to economy and
55% to standard. If all the fixed expenses are unavoidable, the company would
experience an operating loss of $130,000 if the deluxe segment was discontinued, split
as follows:
Economy Standard Total
Revenues $1,200,000 $1,500,000 $2,700,000
Variable Expense
900,000 1,000,000 1,900,000
Contribution Margin 300,000 500,000 800,000
Fixed Expenses405,000 * 525,000 ** 930,000
Operating Loss$ (105,000) $ (25,000) $ (130,000)
If $300,000 of the fixed expenses are avoidable costs and $200,000 are unavoidable
costs, the company's operating income would remain unchanged at $170,000.
Economy Standard Total
Revenues $1,200,000 $1,500,000 $2,700,000
Variable Expense900,000 1,000,000 1,900,000
Contribution Margin 300,000 500,000 800,000
Fixed Expenses270,000 * 360,000 ** 630,000
Operating Loss$ 30,000 $ 140,000 $ 170,000
8/13/2019 Incremental Analysis is Used to Find the Impact of Changes in Costs or Revenues
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/incremental-analysis-is-used-to-find-the-impact-of-changes-in-costs-or-revenues 11/19
The deluxe model has a contribution margin of $300,000, which helps cover some but
not all of the fixed expenses generated by its production and the fixed corporate
expenses that are allocated to it. If the unavoidable expenses (variable and fixed) are
more than the segment's revenues, a decision should be made as to whether to
discontinue the segment. If the avoidable expenses are less than the segment's
revenues, discontinuing the segment could result in a loss to the company. Although a
segment may be unprofitable, it may be contributing to the overall income of the
company. This and other factors should be considered before discontinuing thesegment.
Allocating scarce resources (sales mix)
When a company sells more than one product and has limited capacity for production of
its products, it should optimize its production to produce the highest net income
possible. To maximize profit, a calculation of the contribution margin for each product is
required. In addition, the amount of the limited capacity each product uses must be
determined. For example, if Golfers Paradise produces two different sets of golf clubs, it
is limited by its machine capacity of 4,200 hours per month. The relevant data neededto determine production requirements are contribution margin and machine hours
required to produce the standard and the deluxe set of golf clubs.
Standard Set Deluxe Set
Contribution Margin $150 $270
Machine Hours per Set .75 1.5
From the relevant data, the deluxe set appears to have the largest contribution margin.
However, the standard set can be produced in half the time it takes to produce the
deluxe set. To determine which unit should be produced, the contribution margin per
hour (the limited resource) must be determined. It is calculated by dividing the
contribution margin by the machine hours per set. This calculation shows the standard
set has the highest contribution margin when the capacity limitation is considered. The
company should produce the standard set.
Standar d Set Deluxe Set
Contribution Margin $150 $270
Machine Hours per Set .75 1.5
Contribution Margin per Hour $200 $180
8/13/2019 Incremental Analysis is Used to Find the Impact of Changes in Costs or Revenues
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/incremental-analysis-is-used-to-find-the-impact-of-changes-in-costs-or-revenues 12/19
If both sets required the same machine hours, the deluxe set would be produced. If the
market for the standard set is less than 67,200 (the number of standard sets that could
be produced in a year), the deluxe sets should be produced for any excess capacity
remaining after the standard sets are produced.
What Does Incremental An alysis Mean?
A decision-making technique used in business to determine the true cost difference between alternatives.
Incremental analysis ignores sunk costs and costs that are the same between the two alternatives to look
only at the remaining costs. For this reason, it is also called the "relevant cost approach," "marginal
analysis" or "differential analysis."
Investopedia explains Incremental Analys is
If a company is considering replacing its old copy machine, using incremental analysis, the companywould not look at the cost of the existing copy machine because it is a sunk cost (the cost of buying itcannot be reversed). They would look at things like the cost of toner cartridges for each machine, the costof the electricity run each machine, and most importantly, the time saved by having employees use amore efficient model and perhaps the cost savings of being able to prepare documents in-house instead
of outsourcing them.
Chapter 11 Incremental Analysis
This chapter addresses incremental analysis which is a simplified approach to
a number of different short-term decisions that managers must often make. A
number of specific management decisions will be introduced in a later
chapter, however this chapter is devoted to the overall concept of incrementalanalysis that will use as a part of capital budgeting.
Decision Components
Decision-making involves choosing between alternatives. The focus of
incremental analysis is to examine what is different between the alternatives
in terms of three major amounts:
1- Revenue differences (often called benefits) 2- Cost differences 3- Cost savings differences
8/13/2019 Incremental Analysis is Used to Find the Impact of Changes in Costs or Revenues
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/incremental-analysis-is-used-to-find-the-impact-of-changes-in-costs-or-revenues 13/19
Incremental amounts are often called differential or relevant, however thinking
of incremental amounts as 'what is different' will help you identify them more
quickly. Incremental analysisrelies on cost behavior concepts which separates
costs into variable and fixed components so that managers can anticipate how
each cost will behave in the future.
Why Use Incremental Analysis? Managers typically make decisions by selecting between at least twoalternatives. Because there is often a lot data and information available, amanager's time is used more effectively if he or she examines only theamounts that differ between the decisions. These differences are the onlyRELEVANT amounts that are needed to make a decision because no matterwhat decision a manager makes, non-relevant amounts stay the samebecause they do not differ between the alternatives. One option managerssometimes use in decision-making is to create budgeted, side-by-side income
statements that list the total revenues and total costs to be incurred undereach decision outcome. However, because many costs are the sameregardless of which decision is made, it is preferable, and much more efficientfor managers to concentrate on only the relevant amounts. It is fruitless towaste time on irrelevant amounts when incremental analysis identifies thesame decision choice.
Deciding What is Relevant and What is Not Relevant The easist way to think about costs when deciding are they relevant or not is to set up two
column and label each with the respective decision alternative. For example, a manager is
deciding whether to buy a new delivery truck or keep the old truck. The first column could be
labeled as 'Keep Old Truck', and the second column could be labeled as 'Buy New Truck.'
Under each column label, list the total costs and revenues under each situation. The costs that
are the same under both alternatives are not relevant and can be ignored in the analysis. The
costs that differ are relevant and should be used in the analysis.
Opportunity costs are always relevant because they represent the benefitgiven up as a result of choosing one option over the other. While they are notcash outlays, the represent an increase in profit for one decision over theother.
Sunk costs are never relevant because they have already occurred andcannot be changed no matter which decision option is chosen.
8/13/2019 Incremental Analysis is Used to Find the Impact of Changes in Costs or Revenues
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/incremental-analysis-is-used-to-find-the-impact-of-changes-in-costs-or-revenues 14/19
How to Perform Incremental Analysis The following steps should be performed to create an incremental analysis: Step 1: Compare revenues under both alternatives. Revenues that changeare relevant. Revenues that do not change are not relevant. Eliminate allirrelevant amounts. If possible, list on the differences.
Assume that AT, Inc. plans to produce and sell 80,000 calculators next year to be soldat $7 each. Management is considering raising the selling price to $8 per unit, but thisis likely to cause the sales volume to drop to 76,000 units. Since both units and sellingprice will change, you must consider both changes as part of the incrementalrevenue. The incremental approach determines the difference between old and newrevenue:
Original revenue: 80,000 x $7 $560,000
Adjusted revenue: 76,000 x $8 608,000
Incremental revenue $48,000 Step 2: Compare costs under both alternatives. Costs that do not change are not relevant.
Eliminate all irrelevant amounts, including sunk costs. List only costs that change because they
are the only costs that are relevant. Assume that the variable cost per unit is $4 for AT, Inc. and fixed costs are $100,000. The
relevant variable cost is the difference between the total variable costs in both alternatives.
There will be a cost savings for variable costs because fewer units will be sold. Because fixed
costs remain the same at all levels of activity, there is no change to fixed costs. Step 3: Separate relevant costs into variable and fixed categories and determine the differences
of each. The relevant variable cost is $4 per unit. The number of units will decrease given that 4,000fewer units (80,000 - 76,000) will be sold. Instead of additional costs, there will be a cost
savings:
Variable cost savings: (80,000 - 76,000) x $4 $16,000
Step 4: List and clearly label each incremental revenue, incremental cost, and incremental cost
savings. Include a + sign if the incremental amount increases profit (i.e., a benefit). Show the
amount in ( ) parentheses if profit will decline. Note that a decrease in costs causes an increase
in profits, so the amount should be added to reflect the increase in profit. Total up the amounts.
If the result is positive (incremental revenues exceed the incremental costs), profit increases, sothe decision should be accepted. If the result is negative (incremental revenues are less than
incremental costs), profit decreases, so do not accept.
Original revenue: 80,000 x $7 $560,000
Adjusted revenue: 76,000 x $8 608,000
8/13/2019 Incremental Analysis is Used to Find the Impact of Changes in Costs or Revenues
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/incremental-analysis-is-used-to-find-the-impact-of-changes-in-costs-or-revenues 15/19
Incremental revenue +$48,000 Variable cost savings:
(80,000 - 76,000) x $4 + 16,000 Incremental increase in profit +$64,000 The net effect of the changes is an increase in profit of $64,000. Note that the incremental
analysis did not determine the total profit under either alternative. Only the relevant amounts
were considered.
Qualitative Issues Qualitative effects (nonfinancial amounts) must be considered regardless, but
should not be the sole basis for decision.
Walk-Thru Problem #1 Walker Company sells hammers. During the past year, 4,000 hammers were produced and sold
at $20 each. Variable cost per unit was $9 and total fixed costs were $32,000. Walker would like
to change the selling price per hammer to $19 each, and feels that this will increase sales to
4,600 hammers per year. Which costs are not relevant and why? How much is the incremental
revenue? How much is the incremental profit? Solution: Fixed costs are not relevant since the amount stays the same regardless of whether theselling price stays at $20, or is reduced to $19.
Incremental revenue is: Incremental revenue: (4,600 x $19) - (4,000 x $20)
$7,400
Incremental profit is the difference between incremental revenue and incremental costs.Only variable costs are relevant because fixed costs stay the same in total no matterwhat decision is made.
Incremental revenue +$7,400
Incremental cost: (4,600 - 4,000) x $9 (5,400) Incremental increase in profit +$2,000
Walk-Thru Problem #2 Don’s Donuts budgets the following costs for the production of 36,000 boxes of donuts next
year: Rent, $20,000; other fixed costs, $6,000; materials, $54,000, and hourly labor,
8/13/2019 Incremental Analysis is Used to Find the Impact of Changes in Costs or Revenues
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/incremental-analysis-is-used-to-find-the-impact-of-changes-in-costs-or-revenues 16/19
$36,000. The normal selling price is $4.00 per box. A new convenience store has offered to
pay Don’s $3.00 per box to supply them with 10,000 boxes of donuts during the year. Assuming
that Don’s has the capacity to fill this order along with their other production and that accepting
this order will not cause problems with any of their other customers, should Don’s Donuts sell th
10,000 boxes to the cops? Justify your answer with computations. Solution: First determine incremental revenue:
Incremental revenue ($3.00 x 10,000) +
$30,000
If the order is accepted, revenue increases by $30,000 due to the increase of 10,000boxes sold at $3 per box. Incremental cost is based on the only the change in variablecosts since fixed cost remain the same in total no matter how many boxes of donuts aresold. Total variable cost is $54,000 plus $36,000, or $90,000 when 36,000 boxes ofdonuts are produced and sold. The unit variable cost is $90,000 divided by 36,000boxes for a cost of $2.50 per box. The analysis should appear as follows:
Incremental revenue ($3.00 x 10,000) +
$30,000
Incremental cost: $2.50 x 10,000 boxes (25,000)
Incremental increase in profit + $ 5,000
Because costs increase, profit drops. When profit declines, parentheses areplaced around the amount to show the effect on profit.
Yes, Don's Donuts should sell the additional boxes because incremental profits willincrease by $5,000.
Cost Classification for Decision Making (Decision Making Costs):
Learning objective of this article:
Define, explain, and give examples of cost classifications used in making decisions:differential costs, opportunity costs, and sunk costs.
Costs can be classified for decision making. Costs are important feature of many businessdecisions. For the purpose of decision making, costs are usually classified as differentialcost, opportunity cost, and sunk cost. It is essential to have a firm grasp of theconcepts differential cost & differential revenue, opportunity cost, and sunk cost.
Differential Cost and Differential Revenue:
8/13/2019 Incremental Analysis is Used to Find the Impact of Changes in Costs or Revenues
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/incremental-analysis-is-used-to-find-the-impact-of-changes-in-costs-or-revenues 17/19
Definition and Explanation of Differential Cost and Differential Revenue:
Decisions involve choosing between alternatives. In business, each alternative will have
certain costs and benefits that must be compared to the costs and benefits of the other
available alternatives. A difference in cost between any two alternatives is known as
differential cost. A difference in revenue between any two alternatives is known asdifferential revenues. Differential cost includes both cost increase (incremental cost) and
cost decrease (decremental cost). In general the difference (cost and revenue) between
alternatives are relevant in decision making. Those items that are the same under all
alternatives can be ignored.
The accountant's differential cost concept can be compared to the economist's marginal
cost concept. In speaking of changes in cost and revenue, the economists employ the
term marginal cost and marginal revenue. The revenue that can be obtained from
selling one more unit of product is called marginal revenue, and the cost involved inproducing one more unit of a product is called marginal cost. The economists marginal costis basically the same as the accountant's differential concept applied to a single unit of out put.
Example:
Differential cost can be either variable or fixed. To illustrate assume that a company isthinking about changing its marketing method from distribution through retailers to
distribution by door to door direct sale. Present cost and revenues are compared toprojected costs and revenues in the following table.
Description Retailer Distribution(Present)
Direct SaleDistribution(Proposed)
Differential Costsand Revenues
Revenue (variable) $700,000 $800,000 $100,000
--------- --------- --------- Cost of goods sold (V) 350,000 400,000 50,000 Advertising (V) 80,000 45,000 (35000) Commissions (F)* -0- 40,000 40,000 Warehouse depreciation (V)** 50,000 80,000 30,000 Other Expenses (F) 60,000 60,000 -0-
---------- ---------- ---------- Total 540,000 625,000 85,000
---------- ---------- ---------- Net Operating Income $160,000 $175,000 $15,000
======= ======= ======= *F = Fixed **V = Variable According to the above analysis, the differential revenue is $100,000 and the differential
cost is $85,000,leaving a positive differential net operating income of $15,000 under theproposed marketing plan. The net operating income under the present distribution is$160,000, whereas the net operating income under door to door direct selling is estimated
to be $175,000. Therefore the door to door direct distribution method is preferred, since it
8/13/2019 Incremental Analysis is Used to Find the Impact of Changes in Costs or Revenues
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/incremental-analysis-is-used-to-find-the-impact-of-changes-in-costs-or-revenues 18/19
would result in $15,000 higher net operating income. Note that we would have arrive atexactly the same conclusion by simply focusing on the differential revenue, differential cost,
and differential net operating income, which also shows a net operating advantage of$15,000 for the direct selling method. The company can ignore other expenses of $60,000.
Because it has no effect on the decision. If it were removed from the calculation, the door todoor selling method would still be preferred by $15,000. This is anextremely important principle in management accounting.
Opportunity Cost:
Definition:
Opportunity cost is the potential benefit that is given up when one alternative is selected
over another. To illustrate this important concept, consider the following examples:
Example 1:
Vicki has a part-time job that pays her $200 per week while attending college. She would
like to spend a week at the beach during spring break, and her employer has agreed to give
her the time off, but without pay. The $200 in lost wages would be an opportunity cost of
taking week off to be at the beach. Example 2:
Suppose that Neiman Marcus is considering investing a large sum of money in land thatmay be a site for future store. Rather than invest the funds in land, the company could
invest the funds in high-grade securities. If the land is acquired, the opportunity cost will be
the investment income that could have been realized if the securities had been purchasedinstead.
Example 3:
You are employed in a company that pays you $30,000 per year. You are thinking aboutleaving the company and returning to school. Since returning to school would require that
you give up $30,000 salary. The forgone salary would be an opportunity cost of seekingfurther education.
Opportunity cost is not usually entered in the accounting records of an organization, but it is
a cost that must be explicitly considered in every decision a manager makes. Virtually everyalternative has some opportunity cost attached to it.
Sunk Cost:
Definition:
A sunk cost is a cost that has already been incurred and that cannot be changed by anydecision made now or in future.
8/13/2019 Incremental Analysis is Used to Find the Impact of Changes in Costs or Revenues
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/incremental-analysis-is-used-to-find-the-impact-of-changes-in-costs-or-revenues 19/19
Example:
Sunk costs cannot be changed by any decision. These are not differential costs and should
be ignored in decision making. To illustrate a sunk cost , assume that a company paid
$50,000 several years ago for a special purpose machine. The machine was used to make a
product that is now obsolete and is no longer being sold. Even though in hindsight thepurchase of the machine may have been unwise, no amount of regret can undo that
decision. And it would be folly to continue making the obsolete product to recover the
original cost of the machine. In short, the $50,000 originally paid for the machine has
already been incurred and cannot be differential cost in any future decision. For this reason,such costs are said to be sunk costs and should be ignored in decision making.