688 PUBLIC HEALTH SERVICES.
Holland.Dr. H. C. Jennings reports that the work done in
the county laboratory has been of great benefit, butwould be of much wider service if a trained assistantwere appointed. There were 26 cases of small-poxwith no deaths. In 12 of the cases in Spalding infec-tion was traced to a tramp. There were 12 notifica-tions of ophthalmia with one case of impaired visionremoved from hospital against medical advice.There were 52 deaths from pneumonia, and Dr.
Jennings would like to have hospital treatment for allpneumonia cases. Two cases of encephalitis werenotified and both died. The tuberculosis mortalitywas the lowest ever recorded ; 355 new cases werereported and 184 contacts were examined. The30 shelters available in the county were used by46 patients during the year. More local nursingassociations are needed to ensure adequate attentionto mothers in childbirth. As it is, the problem ofthe " handywoman " is an ever-present one. Theamount paid in fees to practitioners called in bymidwives was £ 88 18s., of which 69 5s. was recoveredfrom patients. The public analyst reports a sample ofegg powder as " inferior." It consisted of starchymatter and a small amount of baking powder, and wascoloured with an aniline dye. There is, however, noaccepted definition or standard for egg powder.Under the Tuberculosis Order 86 animals were
slaughtered, four of which were cows in milk withtuberculosis of the udder. Several of the districts inthe south of the county have unsatisfactory water-supplies and are in negotiation with the SpaldingU.D.C., which own bores at Bourne, from which anample supply of pure water is obtained. In anappendix on the isolation hospital accommodation ofHolland Dr. Jennings indicates that the ideal wouldbe to erect one hospital in a central situation to servethe whole county. Unfortunately, the lack of a pipedwater-supply in the greater part of the area verymuch limits the choice of suitable sites.
MENTAL HOSPITAL REPORTS.
THE Devon Mental Hospital issues this year itseighty-third annual report, illustrated by twophotographs, one of the ballroom and the other ofthe female private ward, made gay by a veritableherbaceous border of hand-made floral decorations.There were 1333 patients on the register on Dec. 31st,1928, an increase of 110 during the year, so that onthe female side the hospital is now overcrowded andin urgent need of extension. The increase in theadmission-rate is largely due to the reception ofpatients on contract from Staffordshire, Birmingham,and Plymouth. These were chronic cases, yet therecovery-rate for the year reached 37-82 per cent.The death-rate was 7-6 per cent., and autopsies wereheld in all cases where permission could be obtained-72-34 per cent. The number of cases of pulmonarytuberculosis has been reduced by improved diet, andby ultra-violet ray and sanatorium treatment. Inthe autumn there were three cases of dysentery, butthere has been no typhoid since the routine inocula-tion of all patients with " TAB " was instituted.The laboratory carried out a large number of routineand special examinations ; the dentist visited fort-nightly and examined 636 patients, and the visitingophthalmic surgeon made 76 examinations. Thevisiting surgeon paid 40 visits, saw 107 cases, andperformed 29 major operations. The visiting radio-logist made 59 investigations, and 35 patients weretreated in the light department. During the year13 men and 2 women suffering from general paralysiswere treated by malaria, 7 by mosquitoes, and 8 bydirect inoculation of malarial blood. Three of thepatients were sent home, 4 showed no appreciablechange, and 4 died. In future, arsenical preparationsare to be given as well as malaria, and the resultswill be compared with those following malarial treat-ment alone. Parole within the estate was granted to80 patients ; 46 were allowed outside and 55 were
taken out by friends. As far as possible the open-door system is adopted. Char-a-banc picnics wereenjoyed by 518 patients, and daffodil, primrose, andblackberry-picking parties were organised. The sumof B170 was raised at the annual patients’ sports.The method, devised by the engineer, whereby thewireless can be transmitted through the telephonesystem, continues to work satisfactorily, and thereis a portable set for wards not supplied with a tele--phone. The library has been completely reorganisedin a central room, and the weekly illustrated papersare now circulated in folios made in the bookbindingdepartment of the printers’ shop. Bookbindingoccupies two patients, weaving five, net-making three,and mat-making two. The brush- and basket-makingdepartment, served by eight patients, has turned outexcellent work, and knitting, rug-making, and raffia.occupy some of the women. In all, 271 patients haveuseful employment. At the out-patient clinic therewere 63 attendances, nearly twice as many as in 1927.-A new sterilising room was added to the operating-theatre, and two new cottages were built for themale nursing staff. One nurse passed the finalexamination of the General Nursing Council, and12 nurses and two attendants obtained their R.M.P.A.certificate.
The Roxburgh, Berwick, and Selkir7c District Asylum:had 368 patients, including four voluntary boarders,in residence on May 15th, 1929. The recovery-ratewas 35-2 per cent. and the death-rate 7-9 per cent.Cause of death was verified by autopsy in 17 cases..During the year the hospital was fortunate in admit-ting more recoverable and fewer senile cases thanusual. Apart from a sharp epidemic of influenzathe health was excellent. The dental surgeonsvisited every fortnight. An occupational therapyclass has been started, and a kinematograph apparatushas been installed. Thirteen members of the staffsat for the R.M.P.A. examination, and all but onewere successful.
____
INFECTIOUS DISEASE IN ENGLAND AND
WALES DURING THE WEEK ENDED
SEPT. 14TH, 1929.
N otifications.-The following cases of infectiousdisease were notified during the week :-Small-pox, 96(last week, 150) ; scarlet fever, 2015, diphtheria,1160 ; enteric fever, 113 ; pneumonia, 569 ; puerperalfever, 50 ; puerperal pyrexia, 90 ; cerebro-spinalfever, 13 ; acute poliomyelitis, 12; acute polio-encephalitis, 3 ; encephalitis lethargica, 14 ; continuedfever, 1 ; dysentery, 4 ; ophthalmia neonatorum, 119.No case of cholera, plague or typhus fever was notifiedduring the week.The number of cases in the Infectious Hospitals of the
Metropolitan Asylums Board on Sept. 17th-18th was asfollows :-Small-pox, 121 under treatment, 15 underobservation (last week 156 and 14 respectively) ; scarletfever, 1417 ; diphtheria, 1524 ; enteric fever, 21 ; measles,243 ; whooping-cough, 209 ; puerperal fever, 23 (plus6 babies) ; encephalitis lethargica, 125; poliomyelitis, 3 ;" other diseases," 25. At St. Margaret’s Hospital therewere 22 babies (plus 10 mothers)‘ with ophthalmia neona-torum.
Deaths.-In the aggregate of great towns, includingLondon, there was no death from small-pox, 3 (3).from enteric fever, 9 (2); from measles, 2 (0) fromscarlet fever, 27 (4) from whooping-cough, 24 (2)-from diphtheria, 103 (17) from diarrhoea and enteritisunder two years, and 22 (2) from influenza. Thefigures in parentheses are those for London itself.
Of the deaths from diarrhoea, (which have increased byone-third), 8 were reported from Liverpool, 7 from Gates-head, 6 from South Shields, 5 each from Birmingham, Hull,and Middlesbrough, 4 from Leeds ; while Glasgow, Dublin,and Belfast, reported 7, 5, and 5 respectively. Two deathsfrom measles were reported from Stoke-on-Trent.
The number of stillbirths notified during the week was265 (corresponding to a rate. of 42 per thousand births),including 40 in London.
689RELATION OF THE TONSILS TO RHEUMATIC CONDITIONS.
Correspondence.
THE RELATION OF THE TONSILS TORHEUMATIC CONDITIONS.
"Audi alteram partem."
To the Editor of THE LANCET.
SiR,-The suggestive paper by Dr. Gray Hill inyour issue of Sept. 14th (p. 571) upon the value oftonsillectomy in acute rheumatism, rheumatic carditis,.and chorea raises the important question of the truerelation between the tonsils and rheumatic conditions,and makes us ask ourselves whether we are notpursuing a chimera, and that it is necessary to pause.and reconsider carefully the position. The tabulatedcases upon which Dr. Hill’s contention is based seemclearly to demonstrate that tonsillectomy, even whenefficiently performed, has no influence upon thebehaviour of rheumatism and is no safeguard againstcarditis or chorea, an opinion which supports those ofPoynton, Vining, Hunt, Osman, MacSweeney, Boas,Schwartz, and Wilson as against the too enthusiasticassertions of Schichhold, Robey, Freedman, Kerby,Miller, and Thomson.
I think that many practitioners of experience willendorse me when I say that, apart from a certaingeneral improvement that must necessarily accruefrom the removal of a definitely septic focus, tonsillec-tomy has no influence upon the incidence or course ofany rheumatic condition, either acute or chronic.This being so, it behoves us to look further afield, andto search for a more likely reason for the undoubtedlyfrequent concurrence of septic tonsils in rheumaticcases, and one which will also give us more certainindications for treatment. The first suggestion thatoccurs is that the rheumatic condition is not depen-dent upon the tonsil sepsis, but that both are in factthe result of a source of infection situated elsewhere.
I personally believe that the most frequent sourceof rheumatism, septic tonsils and septic teeth, lies inthe chronic toxaemia which results from chronic intes-tinal intoxication. Research should lie in the directionof establishing a possible connexion between rheumaticconditions, or septic tonsils, or both, and the variouspathogenic organisms occurring in intestinal toxaemia.Such a connexion would tend to give indications forprophylaxis and rational treatment. II am, Sir, yours faithfully, ,
MACLEOD YEARSLEY.
DISPLACEMENT OF THE MANDIBULARCARTILAGE.
To the Editor of THE LANCET.
SIR,-I have long been interested in the subjectof the displacement of the mandibular cartilagediscussed by Mr. Wakeley in your columns on
Sept. 14th. I had to do with two patients ofthe late Prof. Annandale who was the first surgeonto treat recurring displacement of this meniscusby operation, as he was the first to operatefor " displaced semilunar cartilage " of the knee-joint. A more intimate reason for my interest inthis unusual accident was my personal experienceof the extreme discomfort it can cause. I found amethod by which I could reduce the displacementby manipulation. Ten years ago I contributed tothe British Journal of Surgery (1919, vi., 385) anarticle designed (1) to make clear that the descrip-tion of the meniscus in our anatomical text-bookswas not a correct one ; (2) to indicate by originaldiagrams what I believed to be the characteristicshape and appearance of this structure ; (3) to describethe sensations and symptoms which result from arecent displacement and how I conceived them tobe brought about, as well as to describe my methodof reduction by manipulation ; (4) to record a case
of constantly recurring displacement which I treatedin 1911 by excising the meniscus. Mr. Wakeley’saccount of the condition does not appear to differ inany particular respect from my own, and it is gratify-ing to observe that the method which he describesas being " the best method of reduction" is thatrecommended by me. It is unusual to find one’sstatements on a subject in surgery so completelycorroborated in every detail as mine have been byMr. Wakeley without a reference to the originaldescriptions, especially when an accident is uncom-mon and has received scanty attention in theliterature. However, since THE LANCET is exten-sively read by practitioners who may not see themore specialised journals regularly, it is all to thegood that attention should be called to the conditionin your columns.-I am, Sir, yours faithfully,
J. HOGARTH PRINGLE.
RADIOGRAPHIC EXAMINATION OF THELUNGS.
To the Editor of THE LANCET.SIR,-On X ray examination of the lungs the bases
are obscured by the domes of the diaphragm andabdominal contents. In cases of left-sided diseasewe give some sodium bicarbonate before the examina-
Radiogram showing left basal bronchiectasis.
tion, in order that there may be gas in the stomach torender the bases of the lung more visible. The radio-gram here reproduced shows a patient with leftbasal bronchiectasis and lipiodol in the dilatedbronchi. It will be seen how clearly the conditionshows up against the air bubble in the stomach.
We are, Sir, yours faithfully,L. S. T. BURRELL,STANLEY MELVILLE.
THE AGE OF MARRIAGE AND OF CONSENT.To the Editor of THE LANCET.
SiR,-In your leading article last week (p. 618)reference is made to the Hindu custom of earlymarriage. Therein is quoted a statement by Dr.Margaret Balfour and Dr. Ruth Young to theeffectthat this custom amongst the Hindus is foundedon the principle that early marriage is likely to leadto chastity in the youth of both sexes. This state-ment appears to be of the nature of an argumentum a