+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Initiating Coverage Valero Energy Corp

Initiating Coverage Valero Energy Corp

Date post: 27-May-2017
Category:
Upload: michael-kollar
View: 228 times
Download: 2 times
Share this document with a friend
13
INITIATING COVERAGE REPORT William C. Dunkelberg Owl Fund March 29, 2014 Michael Kollar: Lead Analyst [email protected] Maxime Berin: Associate Analyst [email protected] Shady Botros: Associate Analyst [email protected] COMPANY OVERVIEW VLO is the world‘s largest independent petroleum refiner and marketer, supplying transportation fuels (Diesel, gasoline, jet fuel, ethanol) and petrochemical products (propane, sulfur, asphalts, etc.), with 16 refineries and 11 ethanol plants. VLO is based in San Antonio, Texas and its geographic portfolio includes the United States (73% of revenue), Canada (7%), United Kingdom (8%) and the Caribbean (12%). VLO‘s revenue is driven by refining (96%) and ethanol production and (3.57%). Its refineries have a collective throughput capacity of 3.1 million barrels per day (mmbdp), while its ethanol plants have a capacity of 1.2 billion gallons a year. VLO also owns and operates a 50 mega-watt wind farm. INVESTMENT THESIS VLO is undervalued as it currently trades at a 16% discount to its implied EV/EBITDA multiple (5.44x vs. 6.31x) relative to its peer group. In the past, Gulf Coast (GC) refiners such as VLO have been at a cost disadvantage due to purchasing expensive Brent crude international feed stock while mid- continent competitors possessed the ability to source cheaper WTI feed stocks. The cost advantage has begun to transition to the GC region as synergies are realized between the GC‘s geographic export capabilities and the low-cost feed stocks abundantly flowing from E&Ps in Canada, the Bakken, and other higher margin crude basins around North America. VLO is the largest independent refiner in the Gulf Coast region and will see margin expansion between its imported feed stocks and exported refined products. Along with margin expansion, VLO has numerous growth investments which will increase volumes, fueling EBITDA growth in FY2014 and FY2015. With margins supported by microenvironment forces such as the US ban on exporting crude and the imminent Keystone XL pipeline completion, efficient logistics systems, and growing international demand for highly refined distillate products, VLO is positioned to capture this value creation more so than any of its peers. We rate the company a strong ―Buy.‖ Energy Oil & Gas Refining & Marketing Valero Energy Corporation Exchange: NYSE Ticker: VLO Target Price: $73.68 Current Price: $52.86 Sector Outperform Recommendation: BUY All prices current at end of previous trading sessions from date of report. Data is sourced from local exchanges via CapIQ, Bloomberg and other vendors. The William C. Dunkelberg Owl Fund does and seeks to do business with companies covered in its research reports. Key Statistics Price Projected $73.68 52 wk Low $33.00 Return 39% 52 wk High 55.96 $ Shares O/S (mm) 533 $ Yield 1.89% Market Cap (mm) 28,159 $ EV (mm) 30,917 $ P/E 12 Beta 2.49 Date EPS Δ NI YOY NI Surp Δ Price 1Q2013 $ 1.18 251% 24.6% -3.8% 2Q2013 $ 0.85 -44% -21.3% -2.1% 3Q2013 $ 0.57 -54% 14.9% 3.0% 4Q2013 $ 2.38 28% 74.5% 2.4% Earnings History $(2.00) $(1.00) $- $1.00 $2.00 $3.00 $4.00 $5.00 $6.00 $7.00 $8.00 2010 2011 2012 2013 E2014 E2015 Diluted EPS & Consensus 1Q 2Q 3Q 4Q Year Period 2010 2011 2012 2013 E2014 E2015 1Q $(0.20) $ 0.17 $(0.78) $ 1.18 $ 1.30 $ 1.55 2Q $ 1.03 $ 1.30 $ 1.50 $ 0.85 $ 1.65 $ 2.29 3Q $ 0.51 $ 2.11 $ 1.21 $ 0.57 $ 1.55 $ 1.76 4Q $(0.77) $ 0.08 $ 1.82 $ 2.38 $ 1.14 $ 1.32 Year $ 0.57 $ 3.69 $ 3.75 $ 4.97 $ 5.64 $ 6.92 Earnings Per Share ( $) for Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
Transcript
Page 1: Initiating Coverage Valero Energy Corp

INITIATING COVERAGE REPORT

William C. Dunkelberg Owl Fund March 29, 2014

Michael Kollar: Lead Analyst [email protected] Maxime Berin: Associate Analyst [email protected] Shady Botros: Associate Analyst [email protected]

COMPANY OVERVIEW VLO is the world‘s largest independent petroleum refiner and

marketer, supplying transportation fuels (Diesel, gasoline, jet

fuel, ethanol) and petrochemical products (propane, sulfur,

asphalts, etc.), with 16 refineries and 11 ethanol plants. VLO is

based in San Antonio, Texas and its geographic portfolio

includes the United States (73% of revenue), Canada (7%),

United Kingdom (8%) and the Caribbean (12%). VLO‘s

revenue is driven by refining (96%) and ethanol production

and (3.57%). Its refineries have a collective throughput

capacity of 3.1 million barrels per day (mmbdp), while its

ethanol plants have a capacity of 1.2 billion gallons a year.

VLO also owns and operates a 50 mega-watt wind farm.

INVESTMENT THESIS VLO is undervalued as it currently trades at a 16% discount to

its implied EV/EBITDA multiple (5.44x vs. 6.31x) relative to

its peer group. In the past, Gulf Coast (GC) refiners such as

VLO have been at a cost disadvantage due to purchasing

expensive Brent crude international feed stock while mid-

continent competitors possessed the ability to source cheaper

WTI feed stocks. The cost advantage has begun to transition

to the GC region as synergies are realized between the GC‘s

geographic export capabilities and the low-cost feed stocks

abundantly flowing from E&Ps in Canada, the Bakken, and

other higher margin crude basins around North America. VLO

is the largest independent refiner in the Gulf Coast region and

will see margin expansion between its imported feed stocks

and exported refined products. Along with margin expansion,

VLO has numerous growth investments which will increase

volumes, fueling EBITDA growth in FY2014 and FY2015.

With margins supported by microenvironment forces such as

the US ban on exporting crude and the imminent Keystone

XL pipeline completion, efficient logistics systems, and

growing international demand for highly refined distillate

products, VLO is positioned to capture this value creation

more so than any of its peers. We rate the company a strong

―Buy.‖

E

ne

rgy

Oil

& G

as

Re

fin

ing

& M

ark

eti

ng

Valero Energy Corporation Exchange: NYSE Ticker: VLO Target Price: $73.68 Current Price: $52.86

Sector Outperform Recommendation: BUY

All prices current at end of previous trading sessions from date of report. Data is sourced from local exchanges via CapIQ, Bloomberg and other vendors. The William C. Dunkelberg Owl Fund does and seeks to do business with companies covered in its research reports.

Key Statistics

Price Projected $73.68 52 wk Low $33.00

Return 39% 52 wk High 55.96$

Shares O/S (mm) 533$ Yield 1.89%

Market Cap (mm) 28,159$ EV (mm) 30,917$

P/E 12 Beta 2.49

Date EPS Δ NI YOY NI Surp Δ Price

 1Q2013 $ 1.18 251% 24.6% -3.8%

 2Q2013 $ 0.85 -44% -21.3% -2.1%

 3Q2013 $ 0.57 -54% 14.9% 3.0%

 4Q2013 $ 2.38 28% 74.5% 2.4%

Earnings History

$(2.00)

$(1.00)

$-

$1.00

$2.00

$3.00

$4.00

$5.00

$6.00

$7.00

$8.00

2010 2011 2012 2013 E2014 E2015

Diluted EPS & Consensus

 1Q  2Q  3Q  4Q  Year

Period 2010 2011 2012 2013 E2014 E2015

 1Q $(0.20) $ 0.17 $(0.78) $ 1.18 $ 1.30 $ 1.55

 2Q $ 1.03 $ 1.30 $ 1.50 $ 0.85 $ 1.65 $ 2.29

 3Q $ 0.51 $ 2.11 $ 1.21 $ 0.57 $ 1.55 $ 1.76

 4Q $(0.77) $ 0.08 $ 1.82 $ 2.38 $ 1.14 $ 1.32

 Year $ 0.57 $ 3.69 $ 3.75 $ 4.97 $ 5.64 $ 6.92

Earnings Per Share ( $) for Fiscal Year Ending Dec.

Page 2: Initiating Coverage Valero Energy Corp

Spring 2014

T h e W i l l i a m C . D u n k e l b e r g O w l F u n d

Page 2

POSITIVES

Widening WTI-Brent Differential: Currently, the spread

is ~$8.00/barrel. The US Energy Information

Administration forecasts that the differential between WTI

and Brent crude prices and in its latest ―Short Term Energy

Outlook‖ report, the EIA stated, ―The economics of

transporting and processing the growing production of

light sweet crude oil in the U.S. and Canadian refineries‖

will cause the differential to widen to $10/barrel over 2014

and $11/barrel over 2015. This is a key tailwind for VLO

as it can continue to source cheaper, domestic feed stock

and market higher yielding distillates abroad.

Hydrocracking & Capacity Growth: VLO has growth

investments underway at Port Arthur (+60mbpd, +17%)

and Meraux (+20mbpd, +15%) refineries which will

increase distillate yield by 1Q2015. Each of these refineries

are located on the GC which will allow VLO to process

more discounted sweet crude feed stock. Also,

supplementing GC growth is a +25mbpd/+15% capacity

expansion at VLO‘s McKee refinery, located in Texas.

Keystone XL Pipeline Approval: The Keystone XL

pipeline is the final 1,179-mile, 36-inch-diameter leg of the

pipeline that will bisect the US. It will run from Canada to

Nebraska, where it will link with existing pipelines and

extend to the GC. After originally proposed by

Transcanada in 2008, the project has been put on hold for

environmental and political reasons. However, on January

31, 2014, the US State Department approved the

Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) and confirmed the

project is safe to continue. The project must be approved

by the Obama Administration within 90 days of January

31. If approved, the Keystone XL will move 830,000 bpd

of Canadian sour crude with wide margins. VLO has

committed to taking 20% of XL‘s initial capacity.

Rising International Distillate Demand: While

worldwide demand for gasoline is expected to remain

relatively flat, diesel consumption is expected to rise 2%.

World product demand for diesel is expected to grow

especially in Latin America and Europe, where supplies are

low.

Logistics: VLO will spend nearly half of its 2014 growth

investments on its logistics segment, investing over $750

million in new rail cars. VLO had originally purchased

5,320 rail cars for $750 million, 2,000 of which have already

arrived, while the remaining 3,320 are set to arrive by the

second quarter of 2015. The newer rail cars will increase

access to cost advantaged crudes and the capability to

export products and crudes, regardless if the Keystone XL

pipeline is approved.

ECONOMIC MOAT

Summary: VLO has a narrow but stable economic

moat enforced by high barriers to entry.

Location: VLO has refineries located on the Texas

and Louisiana coast line – close enough to large shale

plays such as the Permian and Eagle Ford Basins

affording VLO cheaper transportation costs on crude

feed stock. See ―Location advantage.‖

Scale: VLO benefits from being the largest

independent refinery located on Gulf Coast.

Integration: As a major gasoline producer, VLO is

government mandated to blend ethanol in its

products. VLO has aggressively invested in ethanol

production, vertically integrating its supply chain.

Diversification: VLO markets the ethanol it

produces, supplementing revenue. VLO also

maintains an ownership stake in Valero Energy

Partners (VLP), a MLP that earns revenue by fees and

tariffs for using its transportation & logistics

infrastructure.

RISKS

Commodity Price Volatility: VLO‘s margins are

directly correlated with the prices of its feed stocks

and its refined products.

Economy: VLO is highly correlated with the health

of the US and global economy. Consumption of

refined products decreases in periods of economic

weakness and when raw material prices fluctuate

according to market supply & demand forces.

Environment: VLO‘s refining operations, particularly

in the Gulf, are at risk of disruption due to hurricanes.

Regulations: Fines and sanctions from federal, state,

and local environmental laws and regulations

regarding discharge of materials, pollution prevention,

waste management, and greenhouse gas emissions.

Projects: VLO has multiple ongoing and newly

beginning projects. There is potential that these may

turn into drag factors if they fail to meet analyst and

investor expectations as far as timing and returns.

Page 3: Initiating Coverage Valero Energy Corp

Spring 2014

T h e W i l l i a m C . D u n k e l b e r g O w l F u n d

Page 3

INDEPENDENT REFINING INDUSTRY ANALYSIS Overview Refinery revenue is dependent on domestic and international demand for their products, while profits are dependent on

the Crack Spread, or the differential between the cost of crude to a refinery and the price it can charge for refined

products after ―cracking‖ the crude. While major integrated oil companies hedge themselves against market price

movements naturally by controlling their supply chains, independent refiners use the futures markets to lock in future

prices for fuels and other petroleum products depending on their optimal product mix. Futures prices are determined by

the New York Mercantile Exchange (NYMEX) which was founded in 1882. Refineries run many types of crudes at

various differentials, but as a proxy, their feed stocks prices follow West Texas Intermediate crude (WTI) while their

refined products fetch prices closer to, and above Brent crude.

The Year Ahead

We believe that FY2014 will prove to be an excellent year for the refining industry, as robust investments in

infrastructure solidify the Unites States‘ position as a net energy exporter. Crude oil now flows from the mid-Continent

US to refineries on the East, West and Gulf Coasts via interstate pipeline networks, railways, ships and river barges. It

should be noted that there has not been a large refinery (>100,000bpd capacity) built in the US since 1976 (See

Appendices: Newest US Refineries). The lack of new refinery construction insulates Valero from losing market share going

forward.

Location Advantage The Gulf Coast (GC) is the largest refining center on the planet and companies with refineries in the region, such as

VLO, have a large competitive advantage on feed stock costs and export capability compared to those who do not.

Logistics infrastructure has been built out from the GC across the continent which affords refiners in this region with

the lowest feed stock cost, currently $0 to $5 below the price of Brent, versus +$2 on the East Coast and +$1 to -$2 on

the West Coast. VLO has over 50% of total refining

capacity on the GC with a total operating capacity of

14.3 mmbpd, represented on the graph to the right,

second only to XOM, the largest oil company in the

United States. VLO towers above PSX and MPC, the

only other refineries in VLO‘s peer group (other

refiners are major integrated and private LLCs and

LPs). VLO also benefits from being in the US as it

pays about $4/mmbtu for its natural gas it uses for

processing, compared to $16/mmbtu in Europe and

$17/mmbtu in Asia.

US Export Ban on Crude Not Lifting Anytime Soon

A key tailwind to the refining industry and VLO is the US ban on crude exports. The ban will remain over the medium-

term as any change would require an act of Congress and the US Secretary of Energy has stated that those in favor of its

lifting have failed to make a convincing argument. Further, requiring domestic crude to be refined prior to exportation

effectively subsidizes gasoline prices for Americans because E&Ps cannot export their product directly to the

international markets. If E&Ps could sell crude internationally, domestic prices would rise to equilibrium with

international gasoline prices. Although there is immense lobbying done by the major integrated oil companies (such as

XOM), Congress is unlikely to favor any legislation detrimental to American consumers and the overall economy.

Page 4: Initiating Coverage Valero Energy Corp

Spring 2014

T h e W i l l i a m C . D u n k e l b e r g O w l F u n d

Page 4

$131,940

$3,896$5,242

Revenue Segments

Refining: 93.5%

Retail: 2.8%

Ethanol: 3.7%

Effects of Ukraine & Russia Conflict

Europe views the conflict in Ukraine as a potential threat to its economy because it imports 30% of its oil from Russia.

Further, most of Europe‘s natural gas travels through pipelines spanning Ukraine. Geopolitical unrest in the region

creates volatility in the global energy markets, particularly the Brent crude index. While higher Brent prices historically

amount to improved pricing for VLO‘s refined products, violence and war can inflate all crude indices, resulting in

margin compression.

WTI – Brent Spread

Crude oil in North America is priced as West Texas Intermediate (WTI) at a central hub in Cushing, Oklahoma. Without

getting into explicit detail, WTI is ―sweeter‖ than internationally benchmarked Brent crude because its lower sulfur

content makes it easier to refine into diesel, gasoline, and other distillates. In theory, WTI would be priced at a premium

to Brent because lower refining cost leads to higher margins, and price should reflect this cost advantage. However,

structural difficulties in getting WTI to international market and rampant supply results in its discount to Brent. These

structural difficulties include the United States ban on crude oil exports and government restrictions on pipeline

development. This disconnect is more evident as the correlation between the benchmarks has also broken down since

US production has increased since 2011. The U.S. Energy Information Association noted in its latest ―Short Term

Energy Outlook‖ report that it expects the spread between WTI and Brent to average $11.46 per barrel through 2014,

and $11.34 per barrel through 2015—higher than the current level of $7.50 per barrel.

Supply

The advent of hydraulic fracturing and

horizontal drilling has made it economically

sound to extract from the tight oil plays

located in the Bakken (North Dakota),

Permian (West Texas), and Eagle Ford (Texas)

Basins. E&P production in North America

has accelerated, and is forecasted to increase

1mmbpd by 2015. Combined with improved

logistics, increasing supply will afford VLO

cheaper feed stocks and facilitate the

continued disconnect between WTI and Brent

crude prices.

FINANCIALS

Revenue VLO has two reporting revenue segments going into FY2014, refining and ethanol. The refining segment (5-Year

CAGR: 16.8%) cracks crude oil into transportation fuels such as: conventional gasoline; reformulated gasoline; ultra-low

sulfur gasoline; clean fuel additives; diesel; commercial, military, and defense standard jet fuel; and methanol. The

remainder of crude is then processed into petrochemicals (See

Appendices: VLO Major Products & Services). The ethanol segment (5-Year

CAGR: 31.5%) continues to generate strong revenue for VLO, $5.2B

in FY2013. VLO acquired 11 ethanol plants which produce over 1.3

billion gallons of ethanol per year, establishing VLO as the first

traditional refiner to enter the production of ethanol, under the

subsidiary VLO Renewables. The Company produces more ethanol

than it can blend, selling the remainder on the market. VLO entered the

ethanol market by purchasing the 7 plants in fire sales in 2Q2009,

acquiring the entire portfolio for 35% of estimated replacement cost,

and earns a 40% cash IRR.

Page 5: Initiating Coverage Valero Energy Corp

Spring 2014

T h e W i l l i a m C . D u n k e l b e r g O w l F u n d

Page 5

The Company reported $138.1B in total revenue for FY2013, down from $139.3B in FY2012, despite seeing refining

revenue grow $99mm (+<1%) and ethanol revenue grow $810mm (+18.3%). This decrease was a result of VLO

spinning off its lower-yielding retail segment (accounting for +$12B revenue in FY2012) as a new publicly-traded

company, CST Brands, Inc (NYSE: CST). After it was spun-off to shareholders on May 1, 2013, VLO held a minority

interest until November. As this segment was discontinued, FY2013 retail segment only accounted for $3.9B in revenue.

Going into FY2014, VLO is expected to see a further drop of 2.8% as there will no longer be retail revenue.

*Bloomberg has expected revenue for FY2014 to be $121.7B, or -12% YoY growth. Upon further investigation, this forecast is the result of

two outlier analyst expectations ($93B and $95B) pulling down the mean revenue estimate of a sample size of only six. These estimates imply

that VLO’s revenue would drop 31% in one year – a highly unlikely scenario. Each analyst is unranked, one is from an undisclosed firm,

and the other still maintains an “Outperform” rating on VLO with a TP of $63.00/share. After conducting our due diligence on VLO, we

believe the only factor attributable to such a large decrease in revenue would be the crude export ban being lifted – which we feel is not feasible

in the near-term. Excluding these two anomalies, the mean estimate reverts to a more realistic $135B in revenue, representing a modest -1.8%

YoY growth, which is in-line with our expectations of flat-to-decreasing oil prices through FY2014 and absent retail revenue.

EBITDA

Due to the sometimes volatile nature of revenue, EBITDA is the best measure of a refiner‘s performance. VLO‘s

EBITDA in FY2013 was $5,185mm, down from $6,180mm in FY2012. This was a result of decreased margins on

gasoline prices and the completion of VLO‘s retail segment spin-off to CST Brands, Inc. Despite this recent decrease,

EBITDA has grown at a 5-Year CAGR of 28.7% from numerous growth investments in hydrocracking/distillate

production and light crude capacity expansion. FY2014 EBITDA estimates are $6,702.3mm, +17.9% YoY. As VLO

eliminated costly retail operating expenses and continues to add light crude capacity, distillate yields should appreciate

further and drive EBITDA to these estimates or higher (See Appendices: Charges & Yields)

Margins As the WTI-Brent spread expands, so too will VLO‘s margins. Also, it is highly likely that the passing of the Keystone

XL pipeline will also boost margins for VLO in the short term. VLO invested more than $1.4B in its logistics projects

and is forecasted to invest another $1.3B by 2015. By moving cost-advantaged WTI more efficiently, margins on this

feed stock will expand. The increase in volume has also been a key driver in VLO‘s margins. They have increased their

Gulf Coast refineries output by 139,000 barrels which now represents 57% of the total output. VLO currently has a

margin of $12.25 per barrel, which is much higher than the previous quarter‘s $7.88 per barrel. VLO has invested in

distillates (Diesel, Kero, jet fuel) in 2013, which yielded a $16 per barrel margin, compared to a $12.25 per barrel margin

for gasoline. Beneficially, global demand for diesel and jet fuels is growing 1.5x faster than the demand for gasoline.

Page 6: Initiating Coverage Valero Energy Corp

Spring 2014

T h e W i l l i a m C . D u n k e l b e r g O w l F u n d

Page 6

Operating Expenses VLO‘s overall operating margin decreased by 7.5% in

2013 after the spin-off of its retail and convenience store,

CST Brands in May 2013. This decreased the VLO retail

segment‘s operating expenses by $267mm, or 67%. The

refining segment‘s operating expenses increased by $36M

mainly due to an increase in natural gas prices. Finally,

there were higher operating expenses in the ethanol

segment, amounting to $55mm, due higher corn

commodity prices driven by droughts in the Mid-Western

US. VLO production rose during this period which

demanded increased chemicals, which also increased

operating expenses.

Earnings VLO reported 4Q2013 EPS of $2.38 v. $1.50 estimates. These earnings were above analyst‘s estimates by 58.35%. This

compared to $1.82 EPS in 4Q2012. This large beat included a nontaxable gain of $0.60 per share from the disposition of

VLO‘s retained interest in its retail segment to CST Brands, Inc. Excluding this unusual item, adjusted EPS was $1.78

which still beat estimates by 13.2%. Although earnings are affected by the seasonality of the business, VLO has beaten

estimates 9 of the last 12 quarters.

A key catalyst for future earnings growth is VLO‘s MLP,

VLP, which currently houses three of VLO‘s logistic

assets (See Appendices: VLP MLP). VLP is a traditional

MLP and generates cash flow from tariffs and fees for

transporting crude and does not source earnings from the

commodity itself. The first drop down to VLP is

expected to be in 3Q2014 and is forecasted to increase

distributions 20% annually for the next three years.

Dividend

VLO‘s board of directors recently announced an 11.1% increase to its quarterly dividend, raising it from $0.22 to $0.25

per common share. This represents 65% dividend growth rate in the last three years, and a dividend yield of 1.89%. In

FY2103 VLO distributed $1.4 billion to shareholders through dividends and share buybacks, doubling that of FY2012.

Valero is strongly committed to shareholder return and consistently increasing the dividend.

Page 7: Initiating Coverage Valero Energy Corp

Spring 2014

T h e W i l l i a m C . D u n k e l b e r g O w l F u n d

Page 7

PEER GROUP IDENTIFICATION

This peer group includes the other members of the S&P 500 Oil

& Gas Refining & Marketing index, as well as other US refiners.

Tesoro Corporation (NYSE:TSO)

Marathon Petroleum Corporation (NYSE:MPC)

Phillips 66 (NYSE:PSX)

Delek US holdings (NYSE: DK)

Holly Frontier Corporation (NYSE: HFC)

Relative Valuation

TARGET PRICE

The target price was calculated using an implied

EV/EBITDA multiple. Once VLO‘s catalysts are

realized, the company will trade more in-line with its peer

group, represented by a target multiple, of 6.31X.

Peer Analysis Target Price = $73.68

Target Multiple EV/EBITDA = 6.31x

NTM Consensus EBITDA = $6,659

Projected Return: 39%

Debt Total Debt: $6.56 Billion Debt to Equity: 32.9% Interest Coverage Ratio: 12.0

After $1.2 billion in debt was issued between FY2008 and FY2010 to fund aggressive capital expenditures to expand

refining capacity, VLO has been reducing its leverage. Debt has been decreased each year since by an average of 6%.

VLO‘s debt to capital ratio at the end of 2013 was 24.8%, compared to 28% in FY2012 and 32% in FY2011. Currently,

VLO holds total outstanding debt of $6.56 billion. Despite this burden, VLO is more than capable of meeting its short

term obligations, with an interest coverage ratio of 12.0, as well as a current ratio of 1.50. VLO is solvent as evidenced

by a debt-to-equity ratio of 32.9%. VLO is scheduled to pay off $200 million notes in April 2014 and maintains an

‗investment grade‘ debt rating by S&P.

Free Cash Flow VLO FCF has a 5-year CAGR of 26.9% with $3.44B reported in FY2013 and $2.04B in FY2012. Management has given FY2014 CAPEX guidance of ~$3.0B. They anticipate 50% of this to fund growth projects while 50% will be allocated to maintenance. Refineries are operational 24/7/365 and due to the intense pressure, heat, and mechanisms involved in the refining process, regular maintenance is crucial to ensure continued operations without outages. VALUATION

Page 8: Initiating Coverage Valero Energy Corp

Spring 2014

T h e W i l l i a m C . D u n k e l b e r g O w l F u n d

Page 8

Valero Energy Corporation (VLO) Comparable Analysis($ in millions except per share)

Stock Equity Enterprise Current Interest Debt/ Debt/ Dividend

Price Market Market Gross EBITDA Net ROE ROA ROC Ratio Coverage Equity Capital Yield

Value Value Ratio

Company Current LTM NFY LTM NFY LTM LTM LTM NTM NTM NTM LTM LTM MRQ LTM LTM

MPC $87.67 $25,675 $27,191 12.92 8.17 5.97 4.17 5.3 4.8 2.2 19.2 7.6 14.9 1.30 16.09 31.1 23.1 1.76

HFC (MLP) $47.45 $9,441 $9,385 12.65 10.11 6.06 4.75 6.8 7.7 3.6 12.6 7.2 10.4 2.33 18.31 16.7 13.1 6.74

PSX $76.65 $43,476 $44,673 13.74 9.72 12.78 5.74 5.3 2.3 2.4 16.2 7.6 13.9 1.49 9.27 28.0 21.6 1.73

DK $28.43 $1,712 $1,908 14.60 10.05 5.83 4.18 4.0 3.7 1.3 12.8 4.3 10.8 1.31 6.31 43.9 26.8 3.34

TSO $50.50 $6,616 $9,390 17.58 7.81 7.40 4.15 8.0 3.3 1.1 9.3 3.4 7.5 1.56 5.16 65.8 34.0 1.78

Median 13.74 9.72 6.06 4.18 5.3 3.7 2.2 12.8 7.2 10.8 1.49 9.27 31.1 23.1 1.78

Mean 14.30 9.17 7.61 4.60 5.9 4.4 2.1 14.0 6.0 11.5 1.60 11.03 37.1 23.7 3.07

VLO $52.86 $28,159 $30,917 11.76 8.35 5.44 4.37 3.6 4.1 2.0 13.1 5.9 11.5 1.47 10.86 33.7 24.8 1.61

Capitalization

P/E Multiple EV/EBITDA

LeverageLiquidityProfitabilityMarginsValuation Multiples

Relative Valuation

Undervaluation On a 3-year EV/EBITDA basis, VLO has deviated below where it normally trades, relative to its peer group. With industry tailwinds of decreasing oil prices, increasing distillate international demand, and continued discounted crude feed stocks, we believe VLO is currently undervalued at its current multiple of 5.44X. Given our bullish outlook for VLO over the next twelve months, we expect 16% multiple expansion from 5.44X to the implied multiple of 6.31X.

Page 9: Initiating Coverage Valero Energy Corp

Spring 2014

T h e W i l l i a m C . D u n k e l b e r g O w l F u n d

Page 9

APPENDICES

VLO Capacity Dominance

VLO is the dominant independent refinery in its peer group, as well as in the GC region

Charges & Yields (2013, 2012, 2011)

VLO has been increasing the amount of sweet crude it has processed in the last 3 years by almost 10%. This has

resulting in higher yields. Our focus is on VLO‘s refineries in the GC, as they have reduced sour charges since 2011 and

doubled the amount of sweet crude charges, improving yields in both gasoline and distillates as a result.

Page 10: Initiating Coverage Valero Energy Corp

Spring 2014

T h e W i l l i a m C . D u n k e l b e r g O w l F u n d

Page 10

WTI – BRENT Historical Spread over 10 year period

VLO EV/EBITDA to S&P 500 Oil Refiner Index EV/EBITDA over 10 year period

Page 11: Initiating Coverage Valero Energy Corp

Spring 2014

T h e W i l l i a m C . D u n k e l b e r g O w l F u n d

Page 11

VLO Major Products & Services

Reformulated gasoline blend stock for oxygenate blending (RBOB)

Conventional gasoline

Premium grades of reformulated and conventional gasoline

California Air Resources Board (CARB) Phase III gasoline

Customized clean-burning gasoline blends

Clean-burning oxygenates

Low-sulfur gasoline

Low-sulfur diesel

Jet fuel Aviation gasoline

Kerosene

Home heating oil and stove oil

Asphalt Lube oils

Crude mineral spirits

Bunker oils

Propane

Octane

Alkylate

Naphtha

Raffinate

Reformate

Anhydrous ammonia

Ammonium thiosulfate

Benzene

Iso-octanes

Mixed xylene

Methyl tertiary butyl ether (MTBE)

Petroleum coke

Petroleum coke gasifier slag

Spent metal catalyst

Spent sulfidic caustic

Spent sulfuric acid

Sulfur

Toluene

Ethanol

VLO 3-Year Historical EV/EBITDA Benchmarked to S&P 500 Oil&Gas Refiner Index

VLO 5-Year Historical EV/EBITDA

Page 12: Initiating Coverage Valero Energy Corp

Spring 2014

T h e W i l l i a m C . D u n k e l b e r g O w l F u n d

Page 12

VLP

NEWEST UNITED STATES REFINERIES

Page 13: Initiating Coverage Valero Energy Corp

Spring 2014

T h e W i l l i a m C . D u n k e l b e r g O w l F u n d

Page 13

DISCLAIMER

This report is prepared strictly for educational purposes and should not be used as an actual investment guide.

The forward looking statements contained within are simply the author‘s opinions. The writer does not own any

Valero Energy Corporation stock.

TUIA STATEMENT

Established in honor of Professor William C. Dunkelberg, former Dean of the Fox School of Business, for his

tireless dedication to educating students in ―real-world‖ principles of economics and business, the William C.

Dunkelberg (WCD) Owl Fund will ensure that future generations of students have exposure to a challenging,

practical learning experience. Managed by Fox School of Business graduate and undergraduate students with

oversight from its Board of Directors, the WCD Owl Fund‘s goals are threefold:

Provide students with hands-on investment management experience

Enable students to work in a team-based setting in consultation with investment professionals.

Connect student participants with nationally recognized money managers and financial institutions

Earnings from the fund will be reinvested net of fund expenses, which are primarily trading and auditing costs

and partial scholarships for student participants.


Recommended