All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 1
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Insight Into Redesigning Your Distribution Network Strategy
Presented by:
Marc Wulfraat
President
MWPVL International
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.com
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 2
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Agenda
Topic
Distribution Network Strategy - Overview
Insight into Redesigning a Distribution Network Strategy
Key Takeaways
Distribution Network Strategy Overview
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 4
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Execution
Suppliers
Planning
Raw Materials Processing
ProductionDistribution, Wholesale,
Retail
Transportation Store Consumer
Distribution strategy defines how we move goods to market.
Regardless of company size or industry, every company
participating in the global supply chain has some form of
distribution strategy.
The question is how effective and flexible is that strategy?
Distribution Strategy Impacts All Supply Chain Participants
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 5
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
For which suppliers should
we manage & integrate inbound
freight?
Which transportation
modes & partners should we use
from each site?
How can we consolidate and
optimize our freight
For a given set of shipments, what
are the best routes?
What strategies can we use to
minimize carbon footprint?
How many distribution
centers do we need? Where
should they be?
What markets should our
facilities serve to optimize service
levels?
What should our stocking strategy
be?
How can we optimize global and domestic
supply chain costs
How do we reduce working
capital in our distribution
infrastructure?
When and why should we use
contract manufacturing?
Which products should be
produced at which plants?
Where should our plants be located
globally and domestically?
Should our plants be in the same locations as our
distribution?
How do we balance
production versus inventory ?
Which countries / suppliers / sites
do we from?
Which distribution
channels should we source through?
How can we lower our net landed cost of
goods?
How much inventory should
we be holding?
What products should we
insource versus outsource?
Supplier Sourcing /
ProcurementManufacturing Distribution Transportation
Distribution Strategy Shapes All Aspects of Supply Chain Behavior
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 6
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Operating Expense &
Working Capital
ServiceLevel
Distribution Network Optimization - The Great Balancing Act
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 7
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Main Drivers of Distribution Network Optimization
Mergers and acquisitions
Business growth or downsizing
Competitive pressure to reduce labor expense through near-shoring or off-shoring
Drive to increase efficiency by reducing logistics operating expenses
Pressure to reduce working capital tied up in inventory assets and/or infrastructure
Changes in customer service level requirements
New market opportunities
Changes in supply or customer base
Increases in fuel / transportation costs
Insight into Redesigning a Distribution Network Strategy
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 9
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Business Assessment & Data Collection
Phase 1
Model Baseline Scenario “As Is”
Strategy FormulationModel Alternative Scenarios
Transition Planning & Implementation
Phase 2 Phase 3 Phase 4
Data Gathering Model Baseline Scenario “As Is”
Model Alternative Scenarios Develop Implementation
Road Map
Project Kick-Off
Define Project Scope.
Deliverables, Schedule,
Resources, Team
Develop Data Gathering
Requirements
Facility Tours & Interviews
Assessment of Data Availability
and Accuracy
Build Econometric Financial Model
Construct & Simulate Baseline Scenario
Calibrate Baseline Model to Actual
Spending
Develop Infrastructure
Assumptions & Constraints
Identify Carbon Footprint
Define Main Scenarios to Evaluate
Develop Financial Model by Scenario
Determine Operating Expenses by Scenario
Simulate Inventory Assets by Scenario
Determine Capital Expenditures by
Scenario
Determine Transition Expenses by Scenario
Select Finalist Scenarios to Evaluate
in More Detail
Carbon Footprint
Define and Evaluate Hybrid Scenarios
Select Final Optimized
Distribution Network Address IT, Tax,
Legal, Infrastructure Issues
Risk Analysis and Qualitative Issues
Develop Transition and Implementation
Road Map Plan
Identify Resources, Timeline. Funds,
Structure, Constraints, Partners,
Stakeholders, Communication
Strategy
Distribution Network Redesign & Optimization4-Phased Project Methodology To Be Adapted to Specifics of Each Project
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 10
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Key Activities Deliverables
Project Set-Up
Mobilize Project and Understand Strategic Objectives
Project Kick-Off Site Visits / Facility Tours Interviews With Key Stakeholders Establish Goals & Objectives, Project Deliverables,
Customer Service Requirements, etc. Determine Project Plan, Schedule, Internal & External
Resources, Stakeholders, Communication Strategy
Project Blue-print Preliminary Project Scope
& Objectives
Data Collection
Assess, Cleanse and Validate Available Data
Data Gathering, Data Validation, Data CleansingMerge Financial Data With Operating Data Review and Resolve Data-Related Issues
Project Database Cleansed, Validated and Prepared for Remaining Analytics
Business Profiling
Establish Preliminary Scenarios to Pursue
Formulate Preliminary Direction of the Project Establish Software Modeling Tools and Data
Aggregation Strategy to Use for the Project
Preliminary Project Direction to Be Revised in Subsequent Phases
Capacity ConstraintsDetermine Existing Infrastructure Constraints
Determine the Capacity Constraint of Each Facility to Identify Where and When Existing Infrastructure Requires Capital in the Existing Network
Definition of Existing Network Constraints
Project Approach - Phase 1 Business Assessment and Data Collection
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 11
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Phase 1: Business Assessment
Identifying key business issues up front will shape how the study is conducted
Site visits, interviews and a structured data gathering effort are needed to identify key drivers for the study
What is your company’s business strategy vision?
Where do consolidation /expansion opportunities exist?
What are constraints or barriers to success?
Are changes to customer service requirements expected or permitted?
What essential customer service level requirements must be satisfied by a supply chain strategy?
What is the competitive landscape and how is this anticipated to change?
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 12
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Item/Part Master File
• SKU number, Description, Family, COO
• Unit Movement and Inventory History
• Unit of Measure, Length, Width, Height, Weight
• Material Handling Characteristics
• Cost of Goods
Vendor Master File
• Vendor Location
• SKUS Supplied
• Purchase Order History
• Inbound Freight Charges / Terms
Customer Master File
• Customer Location
• Order / Invoice History & Order Detail
• Service Requirements
• Growth Projections
Transportation File
• Inbound Transportation History
• Outbound Transportation History
• Inter-Facility Transfer History
• Tariff Rates
• Shipment Cost Details
Production / Distribution Facility File• Production & Distribution Center Locations With
Lease/Own Details
• Storage Location Master File
• Capacity Constraints (Storage, Throughput)
• Labor Crewing / Productivity
Financial Accounting Files
• Operating Expenses at GL Level (Budget, Actual)
• Depreciation Rates & Schedule, Tax Rates, Project Accounting Methodology (IRR, ROI, NPV, EVA)
• Hurdle Rates
Phase 1: Data Gathering
Data gathering - accurate operational and financial data are required for a network study
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 13
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
APRIL JUNE JULYMAY AUG, SEP, OCT
Business Requirements
Interviews
Data Gathering / Analysis / Validation
Econometric Modeling : Business Case & Impact
Assessment
Phase 4 - Execution
Phase 2 – Baseline Scenario
•Additional Scenarios
•Implementation Plan
•Develop Road Map
•Operating Model
• “Quick Hits”
• Detailed Facility Design
•Performance Tracking
Model
Scenario Concepts
Alternate Network Modeling
Formulate Optimal Supply Chain Strategy to Support
Business Strategy
Baseline Simulation
Hybrid Scenario
Sensitivities
Phase 1 - Project Kick-Off Post-Strategic Study
Project Activities
Typical Network Strategy Study Project TimelineIllustrative Example
Phase 3 – Alternate Scenario
Transition Planning & Implementation
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 14
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Typical Project Team Structure
Executive Sponsor
Project Leadership
Project Team
Consultants / Internal Resources
Steering Committee
• Finance• Procurement• Customer Service• Information Technology
• Production• Distribution• Transportation• Human Resources• Real Estate
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 15
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Key Activities Deliverables
Set-Up Benchmark Scenario
Develop a Network Model To Simulate Business Operations in the “As Is” Context
Input Key Model Data Requirements to Simulate Existing Network “As Is”
•Transportation•Warehouse•Production• Inventory•Fixed and Variable Operating Expenses•Capacity Constraints
Project Operating Expenses, Capital Requirements and Inventory Assets On An Annual Basis into the Future
Baseline Scenario Supply Chain Network Model
Baseline Scenario Validation
Assess, Cleanse and Validate Baseline Scenario and Data Issues
Compare Baseline Scenario Predictive Results to Actual Financial PerformanceFine-Tune Assumptions and Refine Data Gaps to Obtain Required Level of Confidence (e.g. ± 2.0%)Management Review and Approval of Supply Chain Network Model Validity
Validation of Supply Chain Network ModelSign-Off and Approval of Baseline Validity
Define Alternate Scenarios
Finalize Alternative Scenarios to Study
Team Review of Proposed Scenarios and Hybrid Scenarios to EvaluateConsensus on Project DirectionRefine Scope of Project Based on Established Direction
Sign-Off and Approval of Scenarios to Pursue and Project Direction
Project Approach - Phase 2 Model Baseline Scenario “As Is”
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 16
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Supply chain optimization tools require some form of data
aggregation to reduce large datasets into workable files; e.g.:
Data aggregation is an analytical technique that enables
efficiency at the expense of some accuracy and this trade-off
need to be done so as to minimize uncertainty
SKUs
• 12 Months Daily Shipment History at line level
• Raw Item/Part Data
DC/Plant
• Aggregate Movement History by Plant/DC
Family
• Aggregate Movement History by Product Family
Customers
• 12 Months of Shipment Data at customer level
3-Digit Zip Codes
• Aggregate Demand to 3-Digit Zip Code
MarketArea
• Aggregate Demand to Market Area
Phase 2: Data Aggregation Strategy
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 17
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Phase 2: Product Aggregation Examples
Item Master File
Material Handling Characteristics
• Bulk Floor Pallet Storage
• Full Case Rack Storage
• Split Case Flow Rack/Shelf
• Conveyable
Length, Width, Height, Weight
Material Handling Characteristics
Product Family / Class
Product Velocity Ranking
Cost of Goods
52 Weeks of Sales History
52 Weeks of Inventory History
Sales Channel
Import / Export / Country of Origin
Seasonality Index
Returns Requirements
Freight Class
Hazardous / Control Requirements
Primary Vendor / Source of Supply
Velocity-Based
Stocking Strategy
• Forward Deploy Fast Movers
• Rear Deploy Slow Movers
• Based on order lines, cube, weight
To Model
Distribution Center
Labor Requirements
To Model Different
Stocking Strategies
Transportation Inbound &
Outbound
• Import Versus Domestically
Sourced SKUs
• Export SKUs
• Inbound Freight by Vendor
To Model Different
Transportation
Strategies
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 18
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Phase 2: Software Tools
Depending on the nature of the project and the supply chain vertical there are multiple optimization tool(s) available
Database software may be needed to analyze large datasets:
SQL Server/ SAS/ Microsoft Access
A Few Optimization Tools:
IBM LogicNet Plus XE
i2 Supply Chain Strategist
Infor CAPS Supply Chain Designer
MicroAnalytics OptiSite
Insight SAILS
Barloworld / CAST
SimFlex
LLamasoft, Inc.
Optiant
ToolsGroup
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 19
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Baseline Cost Comparison
Cost Element
Actual 2005
Cost
Baseline
Model Cost
Baseline
Variance
Percent
Variance
Transportation
Replenishment (inbound) $583,700 $589,670 $5,970 1.02%
Outbound $2,672,391 $2,887,562 $215,171 8.05%
Total $3,256,091 $3,477,232 $221,141 6.79%
Facility
Fixed $798,339 $798,339 0 0.00%
Variable $913,876 $913,676 (200) -0.02%
Total $1,712,215 $1,712,015 (200) -0.01%
Phase 2: Example of Baseline Scenario Calibration The Model’s Simulation Results are Compared to Actual Financials
Operating data and financial data are combined for a common time period and the network optimization software simulates historical operations until the delta between the model’s simulated results and actual results are deemed acceptable –you should aim for a ± 2.0% delta
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 20
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Key Activities Deliverables
Analyze Alternative Scenarios
Simulate Alternative Distribution Network Scenarios and Hybrid Scenarios
Run Simulations of Each Alternative Scenario toIdentify Operating and Financial Results by Scenario
Develop Econometric Financial Model to Provide the Complete Cash Flow Story by Scenario Including Capital Expenditure Requirements, Inventory Assets, Recurring and One-Time Expenses
Establish Carbon Footprint of Each Scenario
PreliminaryOptimized Supply Chain Network Model
Refine Optimal ScenarioSensitivity Analysis With Hybrid Scenarios
Run Analytics on Key Sensitivity Criteria (e.g. Labor Rates, Fuel Costs, Growth Rates, etc.)
Refine Optimal Scenario Analysis of Hybrid Scenarios
Refined OptimalSupply Chain Network
Real Estate AssessmentMarket Analysis for Labor, Land, Buildings, Taxes...
Identify Key Market Inputs Required to Provide Accurate Scenario Modeling Including: Real Estate and Labor Availability & Costs, Disposal Value of Existing Assets, etc.
Location Assessment
Assessment of Business IssuesRisk Analysis and Assess Qualitative Factors
Perform Assessment of Key Risks and Economic Drivers
Evaluate Qualitative Issues and Constraints Including Legal, Technology, Real Estate, HR, etc.
Final Report and Recommendationsto Senior Management
Project Approach - Phase 3 Strategy Formulation : Modeling of Alternative Scenarios
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 21
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Phase 3: Modeling Alternate Scenarios
Supply chain network optimization studies typically involve an iterative process:
Define a scenario to evaluate based on collective wisdom
Analyze the scenario and obtain first-pass results
Refine the results to assess constrained and unconstrained networks
Refine optimal network to evaluate sensitivities and key economic drivers
Migrate optimal scenario into econometric model
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 22
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Forecast Received on June 6, 2006 with a 40% Inventory Growth Factor
Run Name Baseline 22 18 17
Year 2005 2010 2 DCs - Cleveland & LA 2010 2 DCs - Cleveland & Reno 2010
DC Name(s) Cleveland
Cleveland -
New Cleveland 40' LA 40'/20' Total Cleveland 40' Reno 40'/20' Total
DC
Volume 51,653 117,980 81,389 36,591 117,980 87,252 30,728 117,980
DC Storage
Area (sq. ft.) 45,000 93,320 90,372 44,551 134,922 96,369 38,554 134,922
Adjusted Fixed
Cost $798,339 $1,655,993 $1,603,675 $664,075 $2,267,750 $1,710,092 $328,391 $2,038,483Non-Space
Related
Carrying Cost $487,459 $1,109,660 $1,071,706 $404,728 $1,476,434 $1,148,908 $194,216 $1,343,124
DC Variable
Cost $913,676 $2,095,325 $1,427,563 $701,084 $2,128,647 $1,530,400 $553,411 $2,083,811
DC Cost $2,199,474 $4,860,978 $4,102,944 $1,769,887 $5,872,831 $4,389,400 $1,076,019 $5,465,418
Inbound/
Replen Cost $1,523,247 $4,144,637 $2,400,162 $940,023 $3,340,184 $2,573,061 $923,069 $3,496,131
Outbound Cost $2,672,391 $6,272,830 $3,599,862 $1,665,809 $5,265,671 $4,119,488 $1,247,527 $5,367,015
Trans Cost $4,195,638 $10,417,467 $6,000,024 $2,605,832 $8,605,855 $6,692,549 $2,170,596 $8,863,146
Total Cost $6,395,112 $15,278,445 $10,102,968 $4,375,719 $14,478,686 $11,081,949 $3,246,615 $14,328,564
Cost vs.
Cleveland New - - - - ($799,759) - - ($949,881)
A combination of graphical and analytical outputs are generated by supply chain
optimization tools
Phase 3: Sample Scenario Outputs
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 23
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Phase 3: Econometric Financial Modeling
Distribution network optimization should always include detailed financial modeling otherwise the results may be challenged
Accurate portrayal of the timing of all cash flow requirements for each scenario including:
Logistics & production operating expenses
Capital investment requirements into infrastructure, depreciation & tax shield
Inventory assets & cost of capital
One-time transition expenses, tax breaks, etc.
Configurable sensitivity analysis that rolls up to an executive summary for your preferred accounting measurements (IRR, NPV, ROI, EVA)
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 24
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
1st Half 2009 2009-2010 2010-2011 2011-2012 2012-2013 2013-2014
0 1 2 3 4 5
Incremental Revenue / Reduced COGS -$ 137,214$ 139,591$ 141,644$ 144,444$ 148,553$
Ongoing Expense Savings -$ 869,385$ 882,112$ 895,822$ 916,309$ 944,776$
Depreciation -$ (22,675)$ (22,675)$ (22,675)$ (22,675)$ (22,675)$
Amortization -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ -$
Asset write-off (140,635)$ -$ -$ -$ -$ -$
Initial one-time expense (852,132)$ (75,000)$ -$ -$ -$ -$
EBIT Impact (992,767)$ 908,924$ 999,028$ 1,014,791$ 1,038,079$ 1,070,654$
EBIT Impact (992,767)$ 908,924$ 999,028$ 1,014,791$ 1,038,079$ 1,070,654$
Adjust for Non-Cash Items
Depreciation -$ 22,675$ 22,675$ 22,675$ 22,675$ 22,675$
Amortization -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ -$
Asset Write-off 140,635$ -$ -$ -$ -$ -$
Total Non-Cash Items 140,635$ 22,675$ 22,675$ 22,675$ 22,675$ 22,675$
Income Tax 386,186$ (353,571)$ (388,622)$ (394,754)$ (403,813)$ (416,484)$
Net Cash Flow Impact (465,946)$ 578,027$ 633,081$ 642,712$ 656,941$ 676,844$
Inventory Reduction -$ 103,776$
Capital Investment (226,750)$
Total Cash Flow Impact (692,696)$ 681,804$ 633,081$ 642,712$ 656,941$ 676,844$
5-Year 10-Year
Net Present Value (@ 13%) 1,435,554 2,689,627
NPV of EVA (@ 13%) 1,271,406 2,443,070
Total EVA Impact (Gross) 2,304,386 5,811,240
Internal Rate of Return (%) 42.1% 31.9%
Cash Flow Summary
Scenario 1A-3 : Consolidate Richmond Into Washington
Cash Flow Impact by Year
Financial Summary
Phase 3: Example: Financial Modeling Rollup
Build up financials at the GL level of detail to enable easy accounting audit & flexible sensitivity analysis
Avoid black box cost savings numbers!
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 25
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Inventory Value Comparisonby Product Family
F2004 Actual vs. Optimized
Prod Family 01-HandGuns 02-LongGuns 03-Ammunition 04-Optics 05-Reloading 06-Blk Powder 07-Gun Acc
Inv Value ($M) $6.2 $16.3 $5.9 $2.1 $0.6 $1.5 $0.7
% of Total 18% 46% 17% 6% 2% 4% 2%
Future Value $4.1 $6.0 $2.5 $1.2 $0.4 $0.7 $0.4
% Change 34% 63% 57% 46% 37% 49% 47%
On Hand Units 35,315 41,562 550,285 82,104 52,247 54,813 53,686
% of Total 3% 4% 53% 8% 5% 5% 5%
Future Units 12,235 14,902 221,560 28,579 32,640 18,540 29,095
% Change 65% 64% 60% 65% 38% 66% 46%
Turns 7.84 3.40 3.83 5.83 6.31 3.55 6.12
Future Turns 11.87 9.22 8.97 10.73 9.95 7.01 11.46
% Change 34% 63% 57% 46% 37% 49% 47%
Days Supply 88 87 86 73 62 67 53
Future Supply 31 31 35 26 39 23 28
% Change 65% 64% 60% 65% 38% 66% 46%
$6.2
$16.3
$5.9
$2.1$0.6
$1.5$0.7
$7.1
$10.4
$3.0$1.8
$0.4$1.2
$0.5
$4.1
$6.0
$2.5$1.2
$0.4 $0.7 $0.4
$0
$2
$4
$6
$8
$10
$12
$14
$16
$18
F2004 - Actual Forced SL Future - 'Premium'
Total: $35.2M Total: $16.4MTotal: $20.5MInventory Value ($M)
Inventory Turns Comparisonby Warehouse
F2004 Actual vs Optimized
Scenario F2004 - Actual Forced SL Optimal SL Future - 'Premium'Inv Value ($) $35,166,812 $25,630,162 $20,498,920 $16,421,476
% of F2004 100% 73% 58% 47%
On Hand Units 1,044,239 535,881 508,603 455,192
% of F2004 100% 51% 49% 44%
Turns 4.59 6.29 7.87 9.82
% of F2004 100% 137% 171% 214%
Days Supply 76 39 37 33
% of F2004 100% 51% 49% 43%
4.86
7.00
8.90
10.12
6.36
5.22
7.03
4.12
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
BE 02Inventory Turns
Phase 3: Inventory Optimization
A key deliverable within a supply chain network study is the understanding of how to optimize the cost of inventory assets versus required service levels and total operating expenses
You can use inventory simulation tools or other modeling techniques to obtain accurate inventory optimization projections
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 26
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Phase 3: Carbon Footprint AssessmentCap & Trade Compliance
US Production-
Optimal
US Production-
Opt with Cap (35K)
US Production-
Opt with Cap &
Trade
Production Cost $19,163,011 $19,163,011 $19,163,011
Inbound Shipping Cost (Rail) $4,804,922 $4,995,311 $4,916,713
Outbound Shipping Cost (Truck) $17,458,372 $15,624,919 $17,464,900
Warehouse Fixed Costs $11,750,000 $13,850,000 $11,750,000
Total Supply Chain Cost $53,176,305 $53,633,241 $53,294,624
Net Carbon Penalty ($50/ metric ton) $0 $0 $111,038
Total Cost $53,176,305 $53,633,241 $53,405,662
Total CO2 Emissions (metric tons) 39,737 34,917 37,220
Baseline CO2 Reduce 25%
Companies are increasingly making decisions based on the carbon footprint associated with different supply chain network options
CO2 Reduce 10%
Optimal CostAdding 2 DCs reduced costs 2% and
distance to customer by 46%
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 27
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Phase 3 – Real Estate Assessment
Community Characteristics
Civilian Labor Force (2007) 78,912
Blue Collar Labor Force (2007) 22,894
Projected Growth (2012) (%) 3.19%
Unemployment Rate (2007) 4.25%
Projected Growth (2012) (%) 0.36%
Access to Union Pacific Yes
Access to BNSF Yes
Access to Shortline Railroad No
Available Greenfield Sites Yes
Available Brownfield Sites No
Other Railroad Shops in the Area Yes
Supplier Proximity High
Tax Environment / Incentives
Corporate Income Tax Rate 7.81%Effective Sales/Use Tax Rate 5.00%
Incentives
Job Training YesInfrastructure Assistance Available Yes
Low/No Cost Loans Available (Y/N) Yes
Compensation Credits Yes
Investment Tax Credits Yes
Sales Tax Rebate Yes
Grand Island, NE
Highlights:
• Highest ranked location in
screening model
• Site has access to both Union
Pacific and BNSF
Median Wages:
Laborer: $11.80
Driver: $14.43
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 28
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Key Activities Deliverables
Implementation Plan
Develop High-LevelRollout Strategy to Implement Strategic Supply Chain Network Optimization
Identify Key Stakeholders for Implementation Phase GAP Analysis – IT, Process, People Develop Management Consensus on Pilot Site and
Phased Rollout Strategy and Communication Strategy Detailed Location Screening, Site Selection and Real
Estate Support Services Traffic Studies Facility Design Services, Material Handling Systems Supply Chain Technology Systems Transportation Execution Optimization
High-Level Implementation Plan
Strategic Market Assessment
Project Road Map
Develop Detailed Plan for Transition to Optimal Network
Establish Organization Structure and Project Resource Requirements
Identify Detailed Project Schedule for Transition Planning
Develop Prioritization to Capture Quick Wins
Detailed Project Road Map
Pilot ProjectImplementation and Execution
Manage, Assist and/or Participate in Key Activities Identified Within Project Road Map
Execution of Network Optimization Recommendations
Project Approach - Phase 4Transition Planning & Implementation
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 29
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Phase 4 - Real Estate - Detailed Location Screening
Locations need to be investigated based on:
Locations of suppliers
Transportation considerations – e.g. Direct access to rail networks and highway networks
RFI Responses from Economic Development Agencies
Workforce demographics
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 30
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Phase 4 - Real Estate - e.g., Detailed Location Screening
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 31
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Phase 4 – Site Selection
Site Selection Suitability Analysis – GEO Mapping
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 32
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Phase 4 – Implementation ServicesTransit Feasibility Assessment – Population Growth Forecasts
Key Takeaways
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 34
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Key Takeaways: Success Factors For the Project
Supply chain strategy can only be optimized if there exists a well-defined business strategy that precedes the study
Logistics is a support function and it cannot be optimized unless a business strategy has already been defined as a guiding light.
Otherwise we head directly into the storm with no beacon to guide us.
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 35
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Key Takeaways: Success Factors For the Project
Everyone thinks they have great data until they get into a logistics study and find out otherwise...
Data Quality is Critical:
The ability to obtain clean, accurate data drives costs and timeframes for any study.
It is common to make data assumptions.
Establish a level of precision and a time period for data gathering that is appropriate to the study because perfect data will never be available
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 36
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Key Takeaways: Success Factors For the Project
Establish a cross-functional team:
Reports into Project Leadership & Committee
To support the project by providing an overall understanding of the business
To make decisions throughout the project
To participate in regular scheduled updates and watershed meetings
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 37
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Key Takeaways: Success Factors For the Project
Don’t try to determine all scenarios upfront.
The optimization process will actually invoke new “what-if” scenarios that will challenge pre-conceived strategies.
Management will want to explore “hybrid” scenarios as the results begin to be understood.
Expect the unexpected because the direction will take on new direction as the project unfolds
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 38
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Key Takeaways: Success Factors For the Project
Optimization of operating expenses is only one dimension of a supply chain albeit an important one.
It is important to address all shareholder concerns:
Customer service impacts
Minimizing risks - business, political, currency, tax, legal, labor, etc.
Tax implications
Liabilities associated with real estate holdings
Information technology constraints
Fuel cost sensitivity
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 39
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
Time to Ask Questions...
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.comPage 40
MWPVL International
Supply Chain | Experience
For More Information:
Speaker: Marc Wulfraat
Home Page: www.mwpvl.com
All Rights Reserved, MWPVL International Inc., 2010
www.mwpvl.com