trcsolutions.com |
INTRODUCTION TO PFASNovember 8, 2019
trcsolutions.com2
PFAS in the News https://pfasproject.com
3
• PFAS Naming Conventions
• Physical/Chemical Properties of PFAS
• Sources of PFAS and Potentially-affected Sites
• Replacement PFAS Chemistry
• AFFF
• Toxicology
Today’s Topics
4
PFAS Naming Conventions
trcsolutions.com 5
Acronyms
• PFC = Per-fluorinated chemical
• PFAS = Per- and Poly-fluoroalkyl substances
Perfluoroalkyl Substances• PFAA = Perfluoroalkyl acids
• PFOA = Perfluorooctanoic acid (perfluorooctanoate)
• PFOS = Perfluorooctane sulfonic acid (perfluorooctanesulfonate)
• PFCA = Perfluorocarboxylic acids
• PFSA = Perfluorosulfonic acids
PFCA
PFSA
PFAA
6
PFCs: Do not use this acronym anymore!
• PFCs previously used to describe greenhouse gases
• PFCs do not include polyfluorinated compounds
Perfluorinated Compounds (PFCs)
7
Quick Chemistry Lesson #1• Remember: PFAS are Per and Polyfluoroalkyl substances
C
FFF
F F
CC
F F
F
CC
F
F F
F
CC
F
F F
CSO3H
FF
(PFOS) SO3H = Head
PFAAs
• Perfluoroalkane sulfonates (or sulfonic acids): PFSAs
• Perfluoroalkane carboxylates (or carboxylic acids): PFCAs• Per-fluoroalkyl substances: fully fluorinated alkyl tail
O
OHC
F F
F F
FF
F F
FF
F F
(PFOA)F
FF C
CC
CC
CC
COOH = Head
Alkyl tail, fully fluorinated
8
Quick Chemistry Lesson #2• Remember: PFAS are Per and Polyfluoroalkyl substances
• Poly-fluoroalkyl substances: non-fluorine atom (typically hydrogen or oxygen) attached to at least one carbon atom in the alkane chain
Fluorotelomer Alcohol (8:2 FTOH)
CF
F F
CC
F F
F
CC
F
F F
F
CC
F
F F
C
FF
F F
CC
Non-fluorine atom on one or more carbons.
OH
H H
H H
Polyfluoroalkyl substances may also be degraded to perfluoroalkyl substances (e.g., PFOS or PFOA): PRECURSORS
TRCcompanies.com9
• Remember: PFAS are Per and Polyfluoroalkyl substances
• Per-fluoroalkyl substances: fully fluorinated alkyl tail
• Poly-fluoroalkyl substances: partially fluorinated alkyl tail‒ Fluorotelomers
Nomenclature
Polyfluoroalkyl substances can also be precursors.
Acronym Compound Name Carbon Chain Length
PFOA Perfluorooctanoic acid C8PFOS Perfluorooctanesulfonic acid C8PFBA Perfluorobutanoic acid C4PFBS Perfluorobutane sulfonic acid C4
PFHxA Perfluorohexanoic acid C6PFHxS Perfluorohexane sulfonic acid C6
trcsolutions.com 10
Summary of PFAS Families
PFAS
Non-polymer PolymerPotential Precursors
Perfluorinated PolyfluorinatedPrecursors
PFAAsPFCAsPFSAs
FASAs
FTSAsFTCAsFTOHsFASEs
FASAAs
trcsolutions.com 11
What is a Precursor?
• Polyfluoroalkyl substances transformed to PFAAs
• Transformation
• Precursors are a concern
• 1000s of these
FTSAs: Stable under anoxic conditions Likely degrade to PFCAs in
aerobic surface waters
trcsolutions.com
• FOSE: raw material in ECF process
• FOSAA: degradation intermediate
• Can biotransform into PFCAs and PFSAs
12
PFAS Families
PFCA
PFSA
PFAA
• Directly released to environment
• Produced by precursor degradation
Fluorotelomer-based Substances
FTOH FTSA FTCA
• From telomerization process
• Can biotransform into PFCAs
• FTOH far more volatile
FOSE
FOSAA
ECF-based Substances
13
Polyfluorinated Substances Producing PFAAs
trcsolutions.com 14
PFOS: Linear and Branched Isomers
3M AFFF: Branched and linear isomers (30:70)If exclude branched isomers, concentrations underestimated and biased low.
Branched Isomers
Linear Isomers
trcsolutions.com 15
PFOS: Linear and Branched Isomers
trcsolutions.com 16
PFOA: Branched and Linear Isomers: Lab Quantitation
Correct integration of PFOA Incorrect integration of PFOA
trcsolutions.com 17
Long Chain Versus Short ChainWhy does it matter?• Short chain:
– PFCAs with seven or fewer carbons– PFSAs with five carbons or less
Perfluorohexanoic acid (PFHxA) is short chain PFCA.
Short-chain PFCAs Long-chain PFCAs
PFBA PFPeA PFHxA PFHpA PFOA PFNA PFDA PFUnA PFDoA
PFBS PFPeS PFHxS PFHpS PFOS PFNS PFDS PFUnS PFDoS
Short-chain PFSAs Long-chain PFSAs
• Long chain: – PFCAs with 8 or more carbons– PFSAs with six or more carbons
Perfluorohexane sulfonic acid (PFHxS) is long chain PFSA.
Source: March 2018 ITRC Factsheet
trcsolutions.com 18
What Are PFAS?• Poly- and per-fluoroalkyl substances
─ Generic family of chemicals─ Manmade and do not occur naturally─ Used since 1940 (Critical for the Manhattan Project)─ Can be branched or linear─ Used to make products that resist heat, oils, grease, stains, and water
• Most prevalent and researched: PFOA and PFOS• PFAS: Acid or anion?PFOS is present in the environment in the anionic form: perfluorooctane sulfonate.
Perfluorobutanoic acid Perfluorobutanoate (+ dissociated proton)
trcsolutions.com 19
CAS Numbers and PFAS State
PFAS State Structure CAS No.
PFOAAnion Perfluorooctanoate C7F15CO2
- 45285-51-6
Acid Perfluorooctanoic acid C7F15COOH 335-67-1
PFOSAnion Perfluorooctane sulfonate C8F17SO3
- 45298-90-6
Acid Perfluorooctane sulfonic acid C8F17SO3H 1763-23-1
Why is this important?
trcsolutions.com 20
Chemical Properties of Perfluoroalkyl Substances
• C-F: Strong bond
• Chemically and thermally stable
• Water soluble and mobile in groundwater
• Surfactant properties
• Recalcitrant in environment
A PFAS Micelle
trcsolutions.com 21
Properties: Acid vs Cation vs Anion Form
PROPERTY• Physical description• Molecular weight• Solubility in water• Vapor Pressure• Henry’s Law constant• Kow• pKa• Half-life• BCF and/or BAF
AVAILABILITY• White powder or waxy substance• Known• Known for acid and cation; N/A for Anion• Known for acid; N/A for anion and cation (*)• Estimated for acid; N/A for anion and cation (*)• Typically see values for acid form• Generally not available (some modeled values available)• Known for anion; N/A for acid & cation
trcsolutions.com 22
Sources of PFAS and Potentially Affected Sites
trcsolutions.com 23
Where Are PFAS Used?
trcsolutions.com 24
What Types of Sites Can Be Sources of PFAS?• Fire training facilities• Fire stations• Refineries• DoD sites/Military bases• Commercial and private airports• Landfills (leaching from consumer products)• Biosolids land application • Rail yards• Chemical facilities• Plating facilities• Textile/carpet manufacturers• Residential areas with septic systems
trcsolutions.com 25
Timeline of PFAS
2002
• PFOS manufacturing phased out
2006
• PFOA phased out• EPA PFOA
Stewardship Program
2009
• Stockholm Convention classifies PFOS as POP
2013-2015
• PFOA phase-out complete
• Sampling of public drinking water wells for PFAAs (UCMR3)
2016
• EPA Health Advisory announced for PFOA/PFOS (70 ppt)
1938
• PTFE discovered
1949
• PTFE used inproducts
1956
• Stain-resistant products (PFOS)
1968
• Navy developed AFFF
1978
• Detected in blood of manufacturing workers
trcsolutions.com26
Global Manufacture and Use of PFAS
PFAS Manufactured Globally
PFOA & PFOS No Longer
Produced: US, Europe, Japan
Class B AFFF with PFAS Banned:
South Australia
Prohibits Import, Manufacture,
Use & Sale of PFOS/PFOA: Canada
Banned Sale, Use and Import
of PFOA: European Union
Restrict Manufacture, Import, Export, and Use of
PFOS: JapanIncreased
Production of PFOA:
China, India, RussiaEtFOSA Produced on
Industrial Scale: Brazil
trcsolutions.com 27
Replacement Chemistry• GenX replaces PFOA
• ADONA replaces PFOA
• 6:2 Fluorotelomers replace PFOS in metals plating
• Telomers replace PFOS and PFHxS in AFFF
• Shorter chain PFAAs replace PFOA: PFBA, PFPeA
28
Four New PFAS in Revised EPA 537 Method
Analyte Acronym CAS Number
Hexafluoropropylene oxide dimer acid HFPO-DA 13252-13-6
11-chloroeicosafluoro-3-oxaundecane-1-sulfonic acid 11Cl-PF3OUdS 763051-92-9
9-chlorohexadecafluoro-3-oxanone-1-sulfonic acid * 9Cl-PF3ONS 756426-58-1
4,8-dioxa-3H-perfluorononanoic acid * ADONA 919005-14-4
*F53B compounds
All new compounds have an oxygen molecule in the carbon chain.
29
• Perfluoroether carboxylate surfactant
• Dupont/Chemours
• Is not Gen-X– one component of the Gen-X processing aid technology– is a Gen-X chemical
• Shorter-chain PFAS: 6 carbons; 5 fluorinated
• Replacement for PFOA as a surfactant and polymerization aid in production of PTFE product
Hexafluoropropylene oxide dimer acid (HFPO-DA)
30
ADONA
• Polyfluoroethercarboxylate surfactant
• 3M/Dyneon
• Shorter-chain PFAS (7 carbons; 6 are fluorinated)
• Replacement for PFOA as a polymerization aid in production of PTFE product
ADONA
31
F-53B
9Cl-PF3ONSF-53B: major component
11Cl-PF3OUdSF53B: minor component
• Chlorinated polyfluorinated ether sulfonate• Used in metal plating as alternatives to PFOS for mist suppression• F-53 salts likely derived from fluorotelomer raw material• Used as mist suppressant in chrome plating industry for over 30 years in China• F-53 vs F-53B
trcsolutions.com
Aqueous Film Forming Foam (AFFF)
TRCcompanies.com33
• Highly effective fire-fighting foam• Used for hydrocarbon fuel fires• AFFF acts as:
– An aqueous foam: primary fire extinguishing agent– An aqueous film former: a fuel vapor suppressor
What is AFFF?
TRCcompanies.com 34
• Airports (military/domestic)
• Petrochemical Facilities
• Municipal Fire Dept.
• Industrial Fixed Systems
• Military / Government
• Marine – Off Shore Fire Protection
• Where:– Historical Use (where used to fight a fire)
– Fire Training Areas– Nozzle Testing Areas– Storage Areas
Where is AFFF Used?
Types of Fluorine-Based AFFF
35
PFOS based (80%) Telomer based (20%) Developed in 1960s Production ended in 2002 Inventory remains in many
locations Contain or breakdown to
PFOS & PFHxS and possibly PFOA
Legacy 1st
Generation AFFF
Sold from 1970s - 2016 Telomers PFOR compounds (R=
cationic and anionic heads) “precursors”
PFOR – transformation to sulfonates and carboxylates
Long-chain fluorotelomers(8:2 FTS) can breakdown to PFOA
2nd Generation Fluorotelomer & Precursors AFFF
Most foam mfrstransitioned to this
No PFOS and no breakdown to PFOS
Short-chain fluorotelomers(6:2 and 4:2 FTS)
May contain trace amts of PFOA and PFOA precursors
Considered lower in toxicity and reduced BAP
Modern Fluorotelomer
AFFF
TRCcompanies.com
Fluorine-Free Foams
• Alternative to AFFF in some applications• Being used at some airports and
industrial facilities in Europe, Australia, and other countries
• Do not contain PFAS or other persistent chemicals
• Contain hydrocarbon surfactants, solvents, and stabilizers
Fluorine-Free Foams available since early 1900s
Fluorine Free Foam - MSDS
trcsolutions.com 37
PFAS Toxicology & Risk Assessment
trcsolutions.com
Ingestion of: contaminated drinking water contaminated food (landfarming, homegrown produce) fish/wildlife (biomagnification concerns)
Contact with other impacted media (air, soil, sediment)
Use of consumer products containing PFAS – generally low ScotchguardTM treated fabrics/carpets GoreTex®
Non-stick cookware AFFF Personal care products – shampoos, dental products
Routes of Human Exposure to PFAS
38
TRCcompanies.com
Human half-life 2-10 years (up to 70 years for complete removal) Have a low affinity for lipids and preferentially bind to proteins Cross the placental barrier and are excreted into breast milk
Toxicokinetics of PFAS
Easily absorbed, slowly metabolized, widely distributed
Stored in liver, blood, kidney, and
muscle
Reabsorbed in kidney /
transported to bileSlowly excreted
in urine and feces
39
Diverse Health Effects
Developmental delays
Liver toxicity
Immune system changes
Increased cholesterol
Pregnancy-induced hypertension
Kidney and testicular cancer
40
Uncertain ToxicityEstimated safe level is low for PFOA/PFOS 20 ng/kg-day, based on 2016 EPA Office of Water evaluation
‒ 10 times more toxic than arsenic
‒ Target is the developing fetus and newborn
‒ Cancer endpoints occur at higher doses than non-cancer endpoints
Safe level is unknown for most PFAS Toxicity studies are continuing, but….
‒ Difficult due to the number and variety of PFAS
‒ Responses differ between animals and humans
‒ No formal IRIS evaluation is scheduled
41
trcsolutions.com
July 2018 – ATSDR reviewed toxicity of 14 PFAS; published Draft Subchronic MRLs for 4 PFAS (PFOA, PFOS, PFHxS, PFNA)
• Awaiting final report
Nov 2018 – EPA released draft toxicity assessments for Gen-X chemicals and PFBS
• Comment period closed Jan 22, 2019• Final values will replace PPRTVs for PFBS
Dec 2018 – EPA announced 5 additional PFAS (PFNA, PFBA, PFHxA, PFHxS, PFDA) will be reviewed for toxicity as part of IRIS Program
• Public Comment Drafts anticipated 2020
Ongoing National Initiatives
42MRL = Minimal Risk Level
trcsolutions.com
Feb 2019 – EPA published PFAS Action Plan outlining concrete steps to address PFAS and protect public health
• Moving forward to develop MCLs for PFOA/PFOS
April 2019 – CDC/ATSDR announced intent to conduct multi-site study on human health affects associate with PFAS exposure
• Soliciting research applications from 6 communities
• Pease Health Study 2018 protocols to be used and all results will be integrated
Ongoing National Initiatives continued
43
trcsolutions.com 44
Plug for ITRC PFAS Team• Includes >350 members: industry, academia, DOD,
regulatory, consulting, analytical labs and vendors
• Seven PFAS Fact Sheets:– AFFF Introduction– History and Use– Naming Conventions and Chemical Properties – Regulations and Guidance– Fate and Transport – Site Characterization, Sampling, Lab Methods– Remediation Technologies and Methods
• 2019 – Technical Guidance Document
Questions?Elizabeth Denly, ASQ CMQ/OEP: (978) 656-3577 | E: [email protected]