8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 1/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 1
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 2/34
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 3/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 3
John Zink BackgroundJohn Zink Background
•• Privately owned by KIPrivately owned by KI•• 75 years in business75 years in business
•• 1000+ employees1000+ employees
•• Global locationsGlobal locations
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 4/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 4
Quality, Safety, and EnvironmentQuality, Safety, and Environment
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 5/34© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 5
John Zink ProductsJohn Zink ProductsJZ®
• Process Burners•
Flares• Thermal Oxidizers• Vapour Recovery and Combustion• Flare Gas Recovery• Refractory
TODD® Combustion• Industrial and Marine
Boiler Burners
Gordon-PiattTM
• CommercialBoiler Burners
Kaldair ®
• Flares
KEU GmbH• Thermal Oxidizers• Heat Recovery
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 6/34© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 6
John Zink has been for many years theJohn Zink has been for many years theleader in the design and manufacturingleader in the design and manufacturing
of industrial flares and relatedof industrial flares and relatedequipment.equipment.
In addition John Zink has been theIn addition John Zink has been theindustry leader in design and supply ofindustry leader in design and supply ofvapour vapour recovery units.recovery units.
This experience is combined in FGRThis experience is combined in FGRsystems which recover valuable flaresystems which recover valuable flare
gasses to reuse as fuel or feedstock.gasses to reuse as fuel or feedstock.
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 7/34© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 7
Why Flare Gas Recovery (FGR) ?Why Flare Gas Recovery (FGR) ?
FGR provides the benefit ofFGR provides the benefit ofconservation of resources andconservation of resources and
reduction of emissions by recoveringreduction of emissions by recovering
process vent gases, with oftenprocess vent gases, with oftenconsiderable HV, instead of flaring.considerable HV, instead of flaring.
““Environmental control with goodEnvironmental control with goodpaybackpayback ””
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 8/34
Benefits:Benefits:
•• Reduce Combustion EmissionsReduce Combustion Emissionsincluding NOincluding NO XX, CO, and SO, CO, and SO XX
•• Reduce Fuel Gas ConsumptionReduce Fuel Gas Consumption
•• Reduce Flaring Light, Noise, and Odor Reduce Flaring Light, Noise, and Odor •• Reduce Steam ConsumptionReduce Steam Consumption•• Extend Flare Tip LifeExtend Flare Tip Life
•• No impact on existing safety reliefNo impact on existing safety reliefsystemsystem•• Improved PR & company imageImproved PR & company image
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 9/34© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 9
Flare Gas Recovery UnitFlare Gas Recovery Unit
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 10/34© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 10
FG is withdrawn from upstream of liquid seal drum and through LRFG is withdrawn from upstream of liquid seal drum and through LR C dischargedC dischargedinto separator and available as plant gas. Positive P is maintaiinto separator and available as plant gas. Positive P is maintai ned to prevent airned to prevent air
ingress. If FG gas stream exceeds FGR full capacity gas will flingress. If FG gas stream exceeds FGR full capacity gas will fl ow to flare, if FGow to flare, if FGstream is less then system will turndown by staging compressorsstream is less then system will turndown by staging compressors and/or bypass.and/or bypass.
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 11/34
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 12/34© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 12
Liquid SealLiquid SealTo maintain a positive pressure in the flare header andTo maintain a positive pressure in the flare header andprevent undesirable vacuum to pull in air from flare tip.prevent undesirable vacuum to pull in air from flare tip.
•• Existing liquid sealsExisting liquid sealsmay be too shallow tomay be too shallow to
provide hydrostaticprovide hydrostatichead and causehead and causeoperating problems.operating problems.
•• JZ liquid seals warrantJZ liquid seals warrantsteady gas flow to flaresteady gas flow to flaretip which providestip which providesincreased smokelessincreased smokelesscapacity.capacity.
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 13/34
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 14/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 14
Liquid SealsLiquid Seals
•• Typically new liquidTypically new liquidseals are required.seals are required.•• In some applications,In some applications,
new internals can benew internals can beprovided to be installedprovided to be installedin an existing liquidin an existing liquidseal.seal.
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 15/34
Compressor TechnologiesCompressor TechnologiesCompressors
Dynamic Positive Displacement
Reciprocating Rotary
Piston
Diaphragm
Screw
Lobe
Liquid Ring
Sliding Vane
Centrifugal
Axial
Thermal / Jet
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 16/34
Liquid Ring Compressor To compress the flare gas for discharge into seperator.
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 17/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 17
Separator To separate compressor seal liquid from flare gasses.To separate condensed hydrocarbons from seal liquid.
To discharge compressed gasses into plant fuel gassystem or feedstock.
Service Liquid CoolersTo remove the heat of compression.
System Control LogicFor fully automated unattended operation.
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 18/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 18
Typical System Project ScopeTypical System Project Scope
Stage 1 - Engineering Study, SiteInvestigation & ProcessEngineering
Stage 2 - Process/Mechanical DesignEquipment SelectionProcurement
Stage 3 - Fabrication & Assembly
Stage 4 - Installation AssistanceStage 5 - Commissioning Support &
Operator TrainingOngoing - Service & Maintenance
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 19/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 19
FGR Engineering StudyFGR Engineering Study
•• Identify Use for Recovered GasIdentify Use for Recovered Gas•• Review of the Existing Flare SystemReview of the Existing Flare System•• Flare Header Flow and Positive PressureFlare Header Flow and Positive Pressure
•• Characterize Flare Gas AvailabilityCharacterize Flare Gas Availability•• Evaluate Flare Gas CompositionEvaluate Flare Gas Composition•• Select Gas Compressor TechnologySelect Gas Compressor Technology
•• FGRU DesignFGRU Design•• System Cost/Benefits AnalysisSystem Cost/Benefits Analysis•• FGRU ProposalFGRU Proposal
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 20/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 20
Process Simulation
• Process simulation aids in refining scope• Stream Properties are calculated
• Determines the Material Balance for System
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 21/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 21
Engineering StudyEngineering Study
•• Determination of flare flow activity is important inDetermination of flare flow activity is important inestablishing recovery system design capacityestablishing recovery system design capacity
•• Determination of the average flare gas flow rate isDetermination of the average flare gas flow rate isimportant step in evaluating the project economicsimportant step in evaluating the project economics
•• Larger projects (higher average flow rates) offer theLarger projects (higher average flow rates) offer thebest returnbest return
•• Uses other than fuel may increase project returnUses other than fuel may increase project return
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 22/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 22
John Zink Capabilities
•• Determination of flare flow activity to establishDetermination of flare flow activity to establishrecovery system design capacity.recovery system design capacity.
•• Determination of the average flare gas flow rate toDetermination of the average flare gas flow rate toevaluating the project economics.evaluating the project economics.
•• Evaluation of flare process and available recoveryEvaluation of flare process and available recoverytechnologiestechnologies
•• Integration with existing flare systemIntegration with existing flare system•• Design of flares and liquid seal vesselsDesign of flares and liquid seal vessels•• Established field service & maintenance networkEstablished field service & maintenance network•• Approx. 30 years experience in flare gas recovery Approx. 30 years experience in flare gas recovery
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 23/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 23
Commissioning, Start-Up,Training and Service
• John Zink engineers andtechnicians are involved inevery start-up
• On-site or in-house training
• Service & Maintenancenetwork
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 24/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 24
#1 Flare Gas Recovery Case Study
Oil Refinery in the Western U.S.Oil Refinery in the Western U.S.•• FGR Design Recovery Flow Rate:FGR Design Recovery Flow Rate: 4,900,000 scfd4,900,000 scfd•• FGR Mean Recovery Flow Rate:FGR Mean Recovery Flow Rate: 2,400,000 scfd2,400,000 scfd
(97% Flare Activity Reduction)(97% Flare Activity Reduction)
•• Year 1 Operating & Maintenance:Year 1 Operating & Maintenance: $182,000$182,000•• Year 1 Value of Recovered Gas:Year 1 Value of Recovered Gas: $3,698,000$3,698,000Flare Emissions ReductionFlare Emissions Reduction•• NONO
XX: 34.6 ton/yr : 34.6 ton/yr CO: 188 ton/yr CO: 188 ton/yr
•• HC: 71.4 ton/yr HC: 71.4 ton/yr SOSO XX: 74.8 ton/yr : 74.8 ton/yr
Payback inPayback in ~~ 14 months14 months
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 25/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 25
#2 Flare Gas Recovery Case StudyLarge refinery process flareLarge refinery process flareObjective is toObjective is to maximisemaximise economic nuisance flaring reductioneconomic nuisance flaring reduction•• Gas processing design rate: 12,000Gas processing design rate: 12,000 scfmscfm (17.3(17.3 MMscfdMMscfd ))•• Gas processing average rate: 10,400Gas processing average rate: 10,400 scfmscfm (15(15 MMscfdMMscfd ))•• Recovered gas HV: 688 Btu/Recovered gas HV: 688 Btu/ scf scf •• Recovered gas utilized as fuel gasRecovered gas utilized as fuel gas
Results:Results:•• First year recovery: $11.3 MMFirst year recovery: $11.3 MM•• Payback: 20 monthsPayback: 20 months
•• Flaring reduction: 82%Flaring reduction: 82%Basis of EconomicsBasis of Economics•• Fuel value: $3.00/MMBtuFuel value: $3.00/MMBtu
•• Cost of Electrical power: $0.062/kWhCost of Electrical power: $0.062/kWh
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 26/34
Flare Gas Recovery Design
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 27/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 27
Flare Gas Recovery Unit
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 28/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 28
Flare Gas Recovery UnitFlare Gas Recovery Unit
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 29/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 29
Flare Gas Recovery UnitFlare Gas Recovery Unit
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 30/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 30
UUss
eer r
ss
LLiiss
Location Compressor Type Pressure YearOlin Chemicals-Brandenburg, KY 100 psig 1978Dow Chemical-Beaux Bridge, LA 250 psig 1980Flint Hills Refining-Minneapolis, MN ane 80 psig 1981Texaco Refining-Lawrenceville, IL 100 psig 1983Pennzoil Refining-Shreveport, LA 85 psig 1984Sohio-Toledo, OH ing 75 psig 1985Flint Hills Refining-Corpus Christi, TX ing 60 psig 1985Texaco Refining-Port Arthur, TX ing 65 psig 1986Engineers-Madras, India L ing 75 psig 1987Unocal Refining-Nederland, TX ing 80 psig 1988Environmental-Perth, Australia L ing 100 psig 1989Fina O&C Refining-Nederland, TX ing 80 psig 1989Koch Hydrocarbon-Hutchison, TX 300 psig 1994
Fina O&C Refining-Big Spring, TX ing 120 psig 1995HAR-Athens Greece ing 65 psig 1996Shell Products-Buenos Aires, Argentina L ing 100 psig 1999Lion Oil-El Dorado, AR ing 90 psig 2000ConocoPhillips-Ponca City, OK ing 85 psig 2002
ConocoPhillips-Ponca City, OK ing 105 psig 2003
Sliding VaneReciprocatingSliding VReciprocatingReciprocatingLiquid R Liquid R Liquid R
iquid R Liquid R
iquid R Liquid R Rotary Screw
Liquid R Liquid R iquid R
Liquid R Liquid R
Liquid R
John Zink Users List
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 31/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 31
John Zink Users ListJohn Zink Users ListHunt Refining Tuscaloosa, AL Liquid Ring 120 psig 2004
NCRA Coffeeville, KS Liquid Ring 30 psig 2004Frontier Refining Cheyenne, WY Liquid Ring 85 psig 2005Repsol YPF La Plata, Argentina Liquid Ring 80 psig 2005ConocoPhillips Ponca City, OK Liquid Ring 110 psig 2005Calcasieu Refining Lake Charles, LA Liquid Ring 45 psig 2005Ergon WV Newell, WV Liquid Ring 120 psig 2005Valero St Charles Norco, LA Liquid Ring 120 psig 2006Suncor Sarnia, ON Canada Liquid Ring 112 psig 2006
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 32/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 32
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 33/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 33
Thank you !Thank you !
8/11/2019 John Zink_Flare Gas Recovery
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-zinkflare-gas-recovery 34/34
© 2006 John Zink International Luxembourg Sarl 34
No WarrantyNo Warranty
This technical documentation and the information contained therein is beingdelivered to the user AS-IS and John Zink Company makes no warranty as to itsaccuracy or use. Any use of this technical documentation or the informationcontained therein is at the risk of the user. Documentation may include technical
or other inaccuracies or typographical errors. John Zink Company reserves theright to make changes without prior notice.
COPYRIGHT NOTICE• Copyright © 2006 John Zink Company, LLC, All Rights Reserved.