Joint Meeting

Report on Standards

8 July 2006

2

Recent Accomplishments

• Systems Modeling Language (SysML) specification accepted for adoption by OMG

• AP233 standard issued as new working draft (WD3)– Committee draft in July 06

– Near-final draft in Mar 07 and publication in 2008

• Liaison established for Enterprise Architecture– TC 184 / SC5 / WG1 (Modeling & Architecture)

– ISO 15704 planned upgrade (Enterprise Reference Architectures and Methodologies)

• EIA G47 endorsed project to develop Enterprise SE Handbook

3

Enterprise

Systems Engineering

System of SystemsEngineering

SystemEngineering

Enterprise &Sub-enterprise

Tens ofSystem of Systems(Mission Strings)

Hundreds of Independent

Systems

…

……

…

Constraints

ConstraintsCapabilities

Functionality

Scales Groupings Patterns

Source: MITRE Joe DeRosa

Enterprise Systems Engineering

4

Enterprise Architecture Framework Example

requirements definition

concept definition

implementation description

design specification

domain operation

decommission definition

domain identification

genericity

ente

rpris

e

mod

ellin

g vi

ew

en

terp

rise

mod

el

ph

ase

org

aniz

ati

on

vie

w

reso

urc

e v

iew

info

rmati

on v

iew

funct

ion

vie

w

partial

level

parti

cula

r lev

el

generic le

vel

Source: ISO FDIS 19439

5

Enterprise Architecture Standards

Standard Title Key Focus Status

15704-2000

Industrial automation systems — Requirements for enterprise-reference architectures and methodologies

Enterprise-reference architectures; provides means of organizing engineering projects. Includes requirements. Based on GERAM

ISO initiate systematic review summer 06, leading to a revision project to commence in late 2006.

19439 Enterprise integration — Framework for enterprise modelling

Ent Arch Models & Modeling Phases (planning), views & genericity.

Published May 06.

19440.2 Enterprise integration — Constructs for enterprise modelling

Computer modeling language and key elements.

Completed and in for balloting. May be final by end of 2006.

14258-2003

Industrial automation systems — Concepts and rules for enterprise models

Provides enterprise level basis for architecture modeling. Business, operational and technical/system metamodel.

15704 will replace 14258 when 15704 new version is approved

Source: ISO TC184/SC5/WG1

6

Upcoming Events

• INCOSE SE Handbook v3 to be submitted for ISO fast-track process to become ISO technical report

• EIA 632 version 2 draft for review in Nov 06

• ISO 24748 draft for review in July 06 (Systems & Software Engineering—Guide for Life Cycle Mgmt)

• ISO 15504 part 6 draft for review in July 06 (SE Process Improvement & Capability Evaluation)

• ISO new WG42 project to be established to fast-track IEEE 1471 standard (Architecture Description)

7

Evaluation Criteria for Standards Activities

Impact Likely impact on SE state of the art or practice

Image Impact on INCOSE image or status in standards community

Influence Potential for significant INCOSE influence

Lack Alternatives

Unavailability of alternative influencing mechanism

Members Importance of the standard and benefits to individual INCOSE members

CAB Importance of the standard and benefits to CAB members

Major Project Key relationship to INCOSE major project (other INCOSE activity)

8

Evaluation for 2006

Evaluation Matrix for INCOSE Standards Activities for FY06 Revised 12 Sept 05

Activity Rank

$ Am

ount

SCORE

Impa

ct

Imag

e

Influ

ence

Lack

Alts

Mem

bers

CABM

ajor

Pro

j

Notes* SC7-WG20 Certification 1 7 29 5 4 3 4 3 5 5 se/sw certification criteria

EIA G-47 2 10 28 5 4 5 4 3 4 3 632, 731, 632 hdbkSC7 Sys/Sw Engrg 3 7 27 5 5 5 5 2 3 2 ambassador, coordinationSC7-WG7 Process 4 7 27 4 5 4 4 3 4 3 15288, 19760, editor teamOMG-UML & SysML 5 11.3 26 4 5 5 3 4 3 2 strong tie to AP233SC7-SWG5 Sys/Sw Harm 6 7 25 4 5 4 2 3 4 3 harmonization of SE/SW stds

* SC7-WG10 Capab Assmt 7 7 22 4 5 4 4 1 3 1 SPICE, 15504AP233 SE data exchg 8 18.5 20 3 4 5 2 2 3 1 CD1 in summer 06AIAA SE Tech Comm 9 3 18 2 4 4 2 2 2 2 G-043 conops std, ABET spt

* TC184 Enterprise Arch 10 5 17 3 4 4 3 2 1 0 arch modeling stds* SC7-WG4 Tools 11 7 17 3 3 2 3 3 3 0 reqts engrg tools criteria* SC7-WG19 Modeling 12 7 16 3 2 2 3 3 2 1 UML and SysML and others

* new in 2005 or beyond 96.8$ 22.7 3.8 4.2 3.9 3.3 2.6 3.1 1.9Averages >>>

Evaluation Criteria1 Impact Likely impact on SE state of the art or practice2 Image Impact on INCOSE image / status in standards community3 Influence Potential for significant INCOSE influence4 Lack Alts Unavailability of alternative influencing mechanisms (eg, INCOSE members with company funding)5 Members Importance of the standard and benefits to members in general6 CAB Importance of the standard and benefits to CAB members7 Major Project Key relationship to INCOSE major project (other INCOSE activity)

9

SC7 Liaison Participation

Enterprise-referenceArchitectures

WG42

– Current participation – Future participation

10

Contact: ISO/TC 184/SC 5 Secretariatgre_winchester@nema.org

ISO/TC 184Industrial Automation Systems & Integration

SC 4Industrial

DataAdvisory

Group

SC 2Robots for

ManufacturingEnvironments

SC 1PhysicalDeviceControl

PT1Revision ofISO 10218

QC - Quality Committee

WG2Part Library

WG3Product Modeling

JWG8**Industrial manufacturingmanagement data

JWG9Electrical & electronicapplications

WG11Express language, implementation methods

WG12Common resources

PPC Policy & planning committee

WG8Distributed installation in industrial applications

WG4NC ProgrammingLanguages

WG7Data modeling forintegration of physicaldevices

WG1Modeling & ArchitectureMT1Communications & Interconnections

WG4Manufacturing Software & Environment

WG5Application Integration Frameworks

WG6Application Service Interface

JWG15Enterprise-Control System Integration

WG7Diagnostics/Maintenance/Control Integration

SG1Vocabulary and terminology

JWG8**Industrial manufacturing management data

SC 5Architecture,

Communications & Integration Frameworks

AP233 Liaison (Dave Oliver)

Enterprise Architecture

Standard