Page 2
8/7/2019 JosetteWierInquiry needed into G20 police actions - thestar.com
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/josettewierinquiry-needed-into-g20-police-actions-thestarcom 2/4
ry needed into G20 police actions - thestar.com
/www.thestar.com/opinion/letters/article/834500--inquiry-needed-into-g20-police-actions[3/22/2011 1:39:18 AM]
crowds, cornering protesters, strip-searching underage girls, making violent threats,
arresting people for no reason or on made-up charges, treating detainees in degrading and
inhumane fashion (caged for hours without phone or toilet access), and more.
Only a full inquiry by a designated independent panel can identify the root causes of G20
police going off track and recommend measures ensuring that these violations of our trust
will never again occur. Only then will there be any chance of healing the wounds inflicted on
police-resident relations by the G20 actions, and restoring our collective confidence in
Toronto's police as a force for good, not ill.
Jessica Wilson, Professor, Department of Philosophy, University of Toronto
I was shocked by the handling of the police at the summit. There is no doubt in my mind
there were many “agents provocateurs,” like in Montebello, from the police and this
succeeded in diverting media coverage away from the real issues that needed to be
discussed and the peaceful protests that took place.
Josette Wier , Smithers, B.C.
Police Chief Bill Blair clearly bungled his G20 responsibilities when he allowed, explicitly or
not, the arbitrary arrest and detention without charge of innocent citizens. He also failed to
prevent vandalism by actual miscreants. If he does not resign, he must be fired.
Carol Damioli, Toronto
Re: Chie f B la i r deserves a vo te o f suppor t , Op in ion J u ly 7
Michael Taube has it wrong when he states, “Blair shouldn't be fired. He should instead be
praised for making the best out of a very bad situation.” Mr. Taube and others advocate that
violations of human and charter rights are acceptable under the guise of public safety. That
is like carpet bombing a village to kill a couple of terrorists.
Brian Stewart, Orleans
I fully support the work that Police Chief Blair and his force did during the G20 summit. We
should move on to the real issue: the spending of over $1 billion on a summit. Stephen
Harper must be very pleased that the focus of accountability has shifted from his massive
spending to civil liberties and the Toronto police. A great diversionary tactic!
Christopher J. Hoover, Toronto
Michael Taube asks “what sensible person would have wanted to be downtown during the
G20, knowing the problems that could potentially occur?” Gee, I don't know, maybe the kind
who believes, perhaps mistakenly, that we live in a democratic society where people have
the right to peaceful protest without fear of being arrested for the “offence” of walking down
the wrong street?
Perhaps a better question is, what sensible person would be so willing to casually dismiss
the democratic freedoms of anyone whose world view is different from his own?
John De Vellis, Toronto
Re: Mayor responds to t w eet fo r he lp , Ju ly 6
Pleasing story about the mayor responding to a tweet from a man stranded during the
blackout.
More cartoons
Edi to r ia l Car toonEdi to r ia l Car toon
by THEO MOUDAKIS/TORONTO STA
Must ReadsMust Reads
Br ide a r res ted a t ow n wedd ing
recep t ion
Keep k ids in booste r sea ts longer :
MDs
Bryan Ad a ms g e ts s ta r i n
Ho l lywood Wa lk o f Fame
How t o ga in con t ro l o f a sp inn ing
c ar
A m o m’s b rai n g ro ws a f te r b ir t h
Fol low The Toronto Star Fol low The Toronto Star
Facebook Twitter RSS NewsAlerts
Mobile Subscribe
Page 3
8/7/2019 JosetteWierInquiry needed into G20 police actions - thestar.com
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/josettewierinquiry-needed-into-g20-police-actions-thestarcom 3/4
ry needed into G20 police actions - thestar.com
/www.thestar.com/opinion/letters/article/834500--inquiry-needed-into-g20-police-actions[3/22/2011 1:39:18 AM]
Such a shame this same mayor didn't have the time or the courage to arrive at the scene of
the June 27 nightmare at Queen and Spadina (see YouTube), walk in and instruct police to
put down their weapons.
Such a shame he has been incapable of joining the thousands of voices on twitter,
Facebook and elsewhere demanding a public inquiry into the events of those horrific days.
Something is rotten in the state of Toronto.
Julia Tait , Toronto
This is an issue of civil liberties and police abusing those liberties with impunity. Who were
the political leaders in charge? Who gave police orders to ignore the Black Bloc rampage?
Was the systematic abuse of protesters ordered by senior police officials? The public needs
answers.
Pam Woolridge , Ottawa
Your live reporting during the G20 summit was incredible, and the photos were
unbelievable. But I'm most impressed with your editorial stance regarding the need for
police accountability, and your coverage of demonstrator viewpoints, specifically those who
were detained. It's a shocking story how these people were treated, and is completely
riveting reading. I have never been more impressed with coverage of any topic in themainstream media.
Rob Broughton, Toronto
Re: Pr ide Parade a joy desp i te c ont rovers ies , Ju ly 4
I take issue with the first sentence: “The last time thousands of people marched on Toronto
streets, a police car was lit on fire.” On Monday, June 28 and Thursday July 1, thousands
marched to demand an inquiry into police actions during the G20 summit. These thousands
marched entirely peacefully.
Vikram Mulligan, Toronto
Re: Grim lessons fo r c iv i l l iber t ies as each s ide upped ante a t G20, Ju ly 3
Thomas Walkom's comment, “the state blatantly abused its powers,” brings to mind that
June 25 — the first day of the summit — was the 107th anniversary of the birth of George
Orwell, author of 1984 and passionate opponent of totalitarianism. As he wrote in Animal
Farm , “All animals are equal but some animals are more equal than others.”
Dennis Kucherawy , Toronto
Top Stor ies:
UN breathes life into‘responsibility to protect’
Allies need a clear strategy
Gwyn: Stakes extend far beyond Libya
Time to track jury duty scofflaws
Extraordinary work
Email Print Republish Add to Favourites Report an errorShare130
