Judge blocks BP funds for Gulf State Park Lodge

7/24/2019 Judge blocks BP funds for Gulf State Park Lodge

1/21

!" $%& '"!$&( )$*$&) (!)$+!,$ ,-'+$ .-+ $%&

)-'$%&+" (!)$+!,$ -. */*0*1*

)-'$%&+" (!2!)!-"

"#$% &'()*&+),*- -').*&/0 1

12345675880 1

19: 1 ;,?@@=A=?;B?;

1(+$$C D'.'$$0 (EFGE74GH I8 7JE 1,67EG5IG0 #:(: K'2+&)L'-) *% 1)M' ,-)'&,*&0 K&: /+)M&C- (#$$,=0 U >W:1 +87EG F4GE8S3 FI6O5NEG475I6 I8 7JE 4NP565O7G4759E GEFIGN0 7JE

Case 1:15-cv-00191-CB-C Document 64 Filed 02/16/16 Page 1 of 21


2/21

W

4GRSPE67O I8 FIS6OE30 46N 7JE 4QQ35F4T3E 34V0 7JE ;ISG7 856NO 234567588 5O E67573EN 7I GE35E8 I6

I6E I8 7JE F4SOEO I8 4F75I6 4OOEG7EN 56 7JE (EFI6N +PE6NEN ;IPQ34567 ^(+;1:

!57896:;7 #:(:;: ii e@=?e@]: )JE 64GGIV 5OOSE QGEOE67EN TH 7JE Q3E4N56RO 46N

4NP565O7G4759E GEFIGN 56 7J5O F4OE 5O VJE7JEG 7JE 433IF475I6 I8 h>`:> P5335I6 56 B2 E4G3H

GEO7IG475I6 8S6NO 7I Q4G75433H FI6O7GSF7 4 3INRE 46N FI68EGE6FE FE67EG V4O QGIQEG3H 4GG59EN



3/21

d

47 4QQ3H56R 7JE 4QQ35F4T3E *2+ 46N -'2+ O747S7EO 46N 7JE5G GERS3475I6O0 OS885F5E67 7I

V57JO746N 7JE 64GGIV j4GT57G4GH 46N F4QG5F5ISOj O746N4GN I8 GE95EV S6NEG 7JE +2+:

$=> 3487?

"S38 &EO7IG475I6 -E7VIG[ ^"&-1 a5O 4 6I6?QGI857 PEPTEGOJ5Q FIGQIG475I6

56FIGQIG47EN S6NEG 7JE 34VO I8 7JE (747E I8 $IS5O5464: ^(+; k =>0 KIF: d_:1 "&- aJ4O

6SPEGISO PEPTEGO VJI 359E0 VIG[0 46N 74[E 4N94674RE I8 7JE 7GEPE6NISO IS7NIIG

GEFGE475I6 IQQIG7S6575EO 56 46N 4GIS6N "S38 (747E 24G[:c ^./01 )JE KE8E6N467O 4GE %ENEG43

46N (747E )GSO7EEO NEO5R647EN QSGOS467 7I *2+ 7I FI6NSF7 4 -47SG43 &EOISGFEO K4P4REO

+OOEOOPE67 46N aNE9E3IQ 4 Q346 8IG 7JE GEO7IG475I60 GEJ4T5357475I60 GEQ34FEPE67 IG

4FbS5O575I6 I8 7JE EbS5943E670 I8 647SG43 GEOISGFEO S6NEG 7JE5G 7GSO7EEOJ5Q:c dd #:(:;: i

We@]^F1^=1^;1 U ^F1^W1^;1: (433H DEVE33 5O OSEN 56 JEG I885F543 F4Q4F57H 4O (EFGE74GH I8 7JE

#657EN (747EO KEQ4G7PE67 I8 ,67EG5IG: KG: /47JGH6 (S335946 5O OSEN 56 JEG I885F543 F4Q4F57H 4O

7JE #6NEGOEFGE74GH I8 ;IPPEGFE 8IG *FE46O 46N +7PIOQJEGE 46N +NP565O7G47IG I8

-475I643 *FE465F 46N +7PIOQJEG5F +NP565O7G475I6 ^-*++1: "564 LF;4G7JH 5O OSEN 56 JEG

I885F543 F4Q4F57H 4O +NP565O7G47IG I8 7JE #657EN (747EO '695GI6PE6743 2GI7EF75I6 +RE6FH

^'2+1: )IP


4/21

_

$=> />@4A .84B>C98DE

-3*

)JE *53 2I33S75I6 +F7 I8 =AA@0 dd #:(:;: ii We@= "& 1"200 V4O E64F7EN 56 GEOQI6OE 7I 4

OEG5EO I8 I53 OQ533O0 7JE PIO7 6I7IG5ISO I8 VJ5FJ V4O 7JE =A`A RGIS6N56R I8 7JE 746[EG 344*-

5%6/",56 2G56FE .53354P (IS6N0 +34O[4:W 7-+&"/ 8&%&"1 90 :*;WA #:(: 47 =@=?@W:

K4P4REO 4GE GEFI9EGEN TH 4 7GSO7EE IG 7GSO7EEO 4QQI567EN0 56 7J5O F4OE0 TH 7JE 2GEO5NE67

46N TH 7JE RI9EG6IGO I8 7JE 488EF7EN O747EO: 8"" dd #:(:;: i We@]^41?^T1: )JE 7GSO7EEO 4GE 7I

4OOEOO N4P4REO 7I 647SG43 GEOISGFEO F4SOEN TH 7JE N5OFJ4GRE I8 I53 46N aNE9E3IQ 46N

5PQ3EPE67 4 Q346 8IG 7JE GEO7IG475I60 GEJ4T5357475I60 GEQ34FEPE670 IG 4FbS5O575I6 I8 7JE

EbS5943E670 I8 7JE 647SG43 GEOISGFEO S6NEG 7JE5G 7GSO7EEOJ5Q:c ./0 i We@] ^F1^=1 U ^F1^W1:

)JE QGIFEOO I8 647SG43 GEOISGFE N4P4RE 4OOEOOPE67 ^-&K+1 5O RI9EG6EN TH GERS3475I6O

=-IGP433H0 4 GEF57475I6 I8 84F7O VIS3N QGEFENE 4 N5OFSOO5I6 I8 7JE 4QQ35F4T3E 34V: ,67J5O F4OE0 JIVE9EG0 4 T4O5F [6IV3ENRE I8 *2+0 -'2+ 46N 7JE +2+ 5O 6EFEOO4GH 7I

S6NEGO746N 7JE 84F7O:W +7 7JE 75PE0 7JE 344*- 5%6/",V4O 7JE T5RREO7 I53 OQ533 56 J5O7IGH0 GE3E4O56R PIGE

7J46 == P5335I6 R433I6O I8 FGSNE I53: ./0 ,6 FIPQ4G5OI60 7JE !""#$%&"' )*'+,*- GE3E4OENPIGE 7J46 d:=A P5335I6 =%''"61I8 I530 .- '" >+6 8#+66 =? >+6 @+A B!""#$%&"' )*'+,*- +- &C" DE6F*F LEY5FI0 ee %: (SQQ: dN >@@0 >W> ^':K: $4: W@=>10 VJ5FJ 4FFIGN56R 7I 7JE %ENEG43 )GSO7EEO7G46O347EO 7I =d_ P5335I6 R433I6O:



5/21

>

NE9E3IQEN TH -*++: D"-0 36";0 G*0 90 7080 !"#&0 *F G*HH"';"0 =W` %:dN e]e0 ee@?e= ^%EN: ;5G:

=AAe1l => ;:%:&: i AA@:=@ "& 1"20

,8 7JE 7GSO7EEO NE7EGP56E 7J47 46 I53 N5OFJ4GRE F4SOEN 56\SGH 7I 647SG43 GEOISGFEO

46N 7J47 GEO7IG475I6 5O GEbS5GEN0 7JEH PSO7 a5NE6758fHg 4 mGE4OI64T3E G46REZ I8 GEO7IG475I6

437EG64759EO0 E943S4756R 7JEP 4R456O7 OE9EG43 84F7IGO0 56F3SN56R FIO70 QI7E67543 OSFFEOO0 G5O[

I8 FI3347EG43 56\SGH0 46N QST35F JE437J 46N O48E7H:c D"-0 36";00 =W` %:dN 47 ee@ ^F5756R =>

;:%:&: i AA@:>d?AA@:>_:1 -EY70 7JE 7GSO7EEO NE9E3IQ 4 KG487 &EO7IG475I6 2346 aOE7756R 8IG7J

7JE 56\SGH 4OOEOOPE67 QGIFENSGEO EPQ3IHEN0 7JE 647SGE 46N EY7E67 I8 56\SG5EO GEOS3756R

8GIP 7JE N5OFJ4GRE0 7JE GEO7IG475I6 RI43O0 7JE G46RE I8 GEO7IG475I6 437EG64759EO FI6O5NEGEN0

JIV 7JE 437EG64759EO VEGE E943S47EN0 46N VJ5FJ 437EG64759EO VEGE FJIOE6: ./: +7 ee=

^F5756R => ;:%:&: i AA@:>>^T11: +87EG QST35F 6I75FE 46N FIPPE670 7JE 7GSO7EEO 4NIQ7 4 %5643

&EO7IG475I6 2346: ./0^F5756R => ;:%:&: i AA@:>>^N11: %56433H0 7JE 7GSO7EEO NEP46N Q4HPE67

8GIP 7JE GEOQI6O5T3E Q4G7H IG Q4G75EO: ./0^F5756R => ;:%:&: i AA@:]W^411:

"&3*

)JE -475I643 '695GI6PE6743 2I35FH +F7 I8 =A]A ^-'2+1 aEO74T35OJEO 4 m6475I643

QI35FH f7Ig E6FISG4RE QGINSF759E 46N E6\IH4T3E J4GPI6H TE7VEE6 P46 46N J5O

E695GI6PE670Z 46N V4O 567E6NEN 7I GENSFE IG E35P5647E E695GI6PE6743 N4P4RE 46N 7I

QGIPI7E m7JE S6NEGO746N56R I8 7JE EFI3IR5F43 OHO7EPO 46N 647SG43 GEOISGFEO 5PQIG7467 7IZ

7JE #657EN (747EO:c !"#&0 *F I'%-1#*'&%&+*- 90 JE=6+; G+&+,"-0 >_= #:(: e>W0 e>] ^W@@_1

^bSI756R _W #:(:;: i _dW=1: -'2+ aNIEO 6I7 P46N47E Q4G75FS34G GEOS37Oc TS7 56O7E4N

GEbS5GEO 4RE6F5EO 7I 4643HXE 7JE E695GI6PE6743 5PQ4F7 I8 7JE5G QGIQIOEN 4F75I6O: ./0 )I

7J5O E6N0 -'2+ 5PQIOEO a4F75I6?8IGF56R QGIFENSGEOc I6 %ENEG43 4RE6F5EO: @*="'&1*- 90

K"&C*$ 5%66"? G+&+,"-1 G*E-;+60 _A@ #:(: ddW0 d_` ^=A`A1: )JE aJE4G7c I8 -'2+ 5O 7JE



6/21

]

'695GI6PE6743 ,PQ4F7 (747EPE67 ',(1: ./0 ,8 4 QGIQIOEN P4\IG %ENEG43 4F75I6 VIS3N

O5R6585F4673H 488EF7 7JE bS4357H I8 7JE JSP46 E695GI6PE670 7JE I885F543^O1 GEOQI6O5T3E 8IG 7JE

QGIQIO43 PSO7 QGEQ4GE 46 ',( 7J47 EY4P56EO 7JE 4N9EGOE E695GI6PE6743 5PQ4F7O I8 7JE

4F75I60 437EG64759EO 7I 7JE QGIQIOEN 4F75I60 a7JE GE3475I6OJ5Q TE7VEE6 OJIG7?7EGP SOEO I8

P46ZO E695GI6PE67 46N 7JE P4567E646FE 46N E6J46FEPE67 I8 3I6R?7EGP QGINSF75957H0c 46N

a46H 5GGE9EGO5T3E 46N 5GGE7G5E94T3E FIPP57PE67O I8 GEOISGFEOc 569I39EN 56 7JE QGIQIOEN

4F75I6: _W #:(:;: i _ddW^W1^;1:

%ENEG43 GERS3475I6O 8SG7JEG NE856E 7JE GEbS5GEPE67O 46 ',( PSO7 PEE7: _@ ;:%:&: ii

=>@W:= "& 1"20 )JGEE I8 7JIOE GEbS5GEPE67O 4GE GE3E9467 JEGE: %5GO70 a57 OJIS3N QGEOE67 7JE

E695GI6PE6743 5PQ4F7 I8 7JE QGIQIO43 46N 7JE 437EG64759EO f7I 7J47 QGIQIO43g 56

FIPQ4G4759E 8IGP: : : QGI95N56R 4 F3E4G T4O5O 8IG FJI5FE 4PI6R IQ75I6O TH 7JE NEF5O5I6P4[EG

46N 7JE QST35F:c ./0i =>@W:=_: (EFI6N0 7JE ',( PSO7 TE OSQQIG7EN TH E95NE6FE I8 7JE

E695GI6PE6743 4643HO5O 46N PSO7 5NE6758H PE7JINI3IR5EO 46N OF5E67585F OISGFEO GE35EN SQI6:

./0ii =>@W:=0 =>@W:W_: )J5GN0 57 PSO7 FI6O5NEG 7JE QGI\EF7ZO E88EF70 TI7J N5GEF7 46N 56N5GEF70

4O VE33 4O 57O FSPS34759E 5PQ4F7 I6 7JE E695GI6PE67: ./0ii i =>@W:=] =>@`:e0 =>@`:`:

*3*

)JE +NP565O7G4759E 2GIFENSGEO +F7 ^+2+10 > #:(:;: ii e@=?e@0 QEGP57O 46H QEGOI6

4N9EGOE3H 488EF7EN TH 4 %ENEG43 4RE6FHZO 4F75I6 7I IT7456 \SN5F543 GE95EV I8 7J47 4F75I6 56

%ENEG43 FISG7: ./0ii e@W0 e@d: a)JE +2+ QGI95NEO 8IG \SN5F543 GE95EV I8 m85643 4RE6FH 4F75I6

8IG VJ5FJ 7JEGE 5O 6I I7JEG 4NEbS47E GEPENH 56 4 FISG7:Zc L'%-


7/21

e

4RE6FHZO -'2+ 4F75I6 S6NEG +2+1l O"%- !'"/A+-AM ::G 90 7-+&"/ 8&%&"10 eed %: (SQQ: WN ]d

^K:K:;: W@=_1 ^GE95EV56R 4RE6FHZO *2+ 4F75I6 S6NEG +2+1: +6 4RE6FHZO 4F75I6 P4H TE OE7

4O5NE S6NEG 7JE +2+ 58 57 V4O a4GT57G4GH0 F4QG5F5ISO0 46 4TSOE I8 N5OFGE75I60 IG I7JEGV5OE 6I7

56 4FFIGN46FE V57J 34V:c > #:(:;:( i e@]^W1^+1: )JE a4GT57G4GH 46N F4QG5F5ISOc O746N4GN I8

GE95EV 5O J5RJ3H NE8EGE67543: +O 7JE '3E9E67J ;5GFS57 J4O EYQ3456ENn

+3I6R 7JE O746N4GN I8 GE95EV FI6756SSP0 7JE 4GT57G4GH 46N F4QG5F5ISOO746N4GN R59EO 46 4QQE3347E FISG7 7JE 3E4O7 34757SNE 56 856N56R RGIS6NO 8IGGE9EGO43l mf4gNP565O7G4759E NEF5O5I6O OJIS3N TE OE7 4O5NE 56 7J5O FI67EY7 ::: I63H8IG OSTO7467543 QGIFENSG43 IG OSTO746759E GE4OI6O 4O P46N47EN TH O747S7E0 :::6I7 O5PQ3H TEF4SOE 7JE FISG7 5O S6J4QQH V57J 7JE GEOS37 GE4FJEN:Z )JE 4RE6FHPSO7 SOE 57O TEO7 \SNRPE67 56 T4346F56R 7JE OSTO746759E 5OOSEO: )JE GE95EV56R

FISG7 5O 6I7 4S7JIG5XEN 7I OSTO757S7E 57O \SNRPE67 8IG 7J47 I8 7JE 4RE6FHFI6FEG656R 7JE V5ONIP IG QGSNE6FE I8 7JE QGIQIOEN 4F75I6:

N*'&C OE;


8/21

`

QGI95NE SQ 7I h= T5335I6 7IV4GN E4G3H GEO7IG475I6 QGI\EF7O 7I TER56 4NNGEOO56R 56\SG5EO 7I

647SG43 GEOISGFEO GEOS3756R 8GIP 7JE (Q533: ^+& @@e]==?_>:1 ,6 EYFJ46RE0 B2 VIS3N RE7 4

FGEN57 4R456O7 57O 7I743 354T5357H ^F433EN 46 a-&K I88OE7c1 8IG E4FJ QGI\EF7 8S6NEN S6NEG 7JE

%G4PEVIG[ +RGEEPE67: ^+& @@e]=d?=_:1 )JE 4RGEEPE67 OE7 IS7 7JE QGIFEOO TH VJ5FJ

QGI\EF7O VIS3N TE 8S6NEN: %5GO70 7JE )GSO7EEO VIS3N OE3EF7 QGI\EF7 QGIQIO43O: ^+& @@e]=d:1

-EY70 7JE QGIQIO43 VIS3N TE OSTP577EN 7I B2 46N 7JE Q4G75EO VIS3N 6ERI7547E 7JE -&K

I88OE7: ^./01 *6FE 7JE -&K I88OE7 V4O NE7EGP56EN0 7JE Q4G75EO VIS3N E67EG 4 2GI\EF7

(75QS3475I6 V57J GEOQEF7 7I 7J47 QGI\EF7: ^./01 -I QGI\EF7 FIS3N TE 8S6NEN S6NEG 7JE

%G4PEVIG[ +RGEEPE67 aS63EOO 433 I8 7JE fQg4G75EO 4RGEEfNgSQI6 7JE QGI\EF7 46N 4QQ35F4T3E

-&K *88OE7O 8IG 7J47 QGI\EF7 46N EYEFS7EfNg 4 2GI\EF7 (75QS3475I6:c ^./01 %56433H0 7JE QGI\EF7

VIS3N TE OSTP577EN 8IG QST35F GE95EV 46N FIPPE67: ^+& @=>=Ad:1

'4G3H GEO7IG475I6 QGI\EF7O VEGE Q3466EN 7I 74[E Q34FE 56 7JGEE QJ4OEO: ^+& @=>W>=?

>d:1 2J4OE , 46N 2J4OE ,,0 VJ5FJ 7I743EN he= P5335I60 VEGE 4QQGI9EN 56 +QG53 46N KEFEPTEG

W@=W0 GEOQEF759E3H: )JE QGI\EF7 47 5OOSE JEGE 5O Q4G7 I8 2J4OE ,,,:

3=4?> !!! G 7=> *A4H4B4 I:AJ )747> 348D 389K>;7

)JE 2J4OE ,,, Q3460 856435XEN 56 DS6E W@=_0 5O FIPQIOEN I8 __ QGI\EF7O 56 859E O747EO:

^+& =@>=`>:1 )VI 7HQEO I8 QGI\EF7O VEGE FJIOE6 8IG 8S6N56R 56 7J5O QJ4OEn ^=1 GEO7IG475I6

I8 J4T5747O 46N 35956R FI4O743 46N P4G56E GEOISGFEO 46N ^W1 GEFGE475I643 SOE IQQIG7S6575EO:

^+& @=>=A=:1 )JE 7I743 FIO7 I8 7JEOE QGI\EF7O 5O 4QQGIY5P47E3H h]We P5335I60

4QQGIY5P47E3H I6E?7J5GN I8 VJ5FJ ^hWd@ P5335I61 5O NEN5F47EN 7I GEFGE475I643 SOE: ^+&

@=>=Ad:1 )JE QGI\EF7O 4GE 567E6NEN 7I TE 56NEQE6NE67 I8 E4FJ I7JEG0 OI 7J47 OE3EF75I6 I8

I6E QGI\EF7 NIEO 6I7 488EF7 7JE 954T5357H I8 46H I7JEG QGI\EF7: ^+& @=>=Ad:1



9/21

A

+7 46 EO75P47EN h`>:> P5335I6 7JE "S38 (747E 24G[ '6J46FEPE67 2GI\EF7 5O 7JE PIO7

EYQE6O59E GEFGE475I643 SOE QGI\EF70 TH 84G0 46N 7JE OEFI6N PIO7 EYQE6O59E 2J4OE ,,, QGI\EF7:_

^+& @=>=A>?@=>=Ae:1 *8 7JE 7I743 4PIS67 NEN5F47EN 7I "S38 (747E 24G[0 h>`:> P5335I6 5O 7I

TE OE7 4O5NE 4O Q4G7543 8S6N56R 8IG FI6O7GSF75I6 I8 4 QGIQIOEN 3INRE 46N FI68EGE6FE FE67EG

â7JE 3INREoFI68EGE6FE FE67EGc10 V57J 7JE GEP456NEG RI56R 7I TS53N 46 567EGQGE759E FE67EG0 4

GEOE4GFJ 46N ENSF475I6 FE67EG0 I7JEG 95O57IG E6J46FEPE67O0 ÔSFJ 4O 7G453 5PQGI9EPE67O

46N O5R64RE10 46N NS6E J4T5747 GEO7IG475I6: ^+& @=èdd?d_:1 2SGOS467 7I 7JE %G4PEVIG[

+RGEEPE670 B2 46N 7JE )GSO7EEO E67EGEN 567I 4 2GI\EF7 (75QS3475I6 4QQGI956R 7JE QGI\EF7

46N 4RGEE56R 7I 46 -&K I88OE7 4PIS67: ^+& @=è=>?de:1 ,6 7J5O 56O746FE0 7JE 4RGEEN I88OE7

G475I 5O Wn=: ,6 I7JEG VIGNO0 8IG E9EGH h= OQE67 I6 7JE "S38 (747E 24G[ '6J46FEPE67 2GI\EF7

B2 5O 7I TE R59E6 hW FGEN57: )JSO0 TH OE7756R 4O5NE h>`:> P5335I6 56 8S6N56R 8IG 4 QGIQIOEN

3INRE 46N FI68EGE6FE FE67EG0 7JE )GSO7EEO 46N B2 VIS3N 43OI GEPI9E 46 4NN575I643 h>`:>

P5335I6 8GIP E4G3H GEO7IG475I6 8S6N56R:

+7 7JE 75PE 2J4OE ,,, V4O 4QQGI9EN0 7JE "S38 (747E 24G[ 3INRE 46N FI68EGE6FE FE67EG

V4O 35773E PIGE 7J46 4 FI6FEQ7:> )JE 3INREoFI68EGE6FE FE67EG V4O QGI\EF7EN 7I J49E

4QQGIY5P47E3H d>@ GIIPO 46N PEE756R OQ4FE 8IG SQ 7I =>@@ 477E6NEEO: ^+& @=]d_d:1

)JEGE VEGE 6I 4GFJ57EF7SG43 Q346O Î63H 4 O[E7FJ I8 VJ47 4 3INREoFI68EGE6FE FE67EG H+AC&

3II[ 35[E10 6I OQEF585F FIO7 EO75P47EO0 46N 6I 75PE74T3E 8IG FIPQ3E75I6: ^+& @=]d__?_>l +&

@=]dde:1 )JE )GSO7EEO FI6FENEN 7J47 7JE h>`:> P5335I6 433IF47EN VIS3N 6I7 TE OS885F5E67 7I

_)JE I63H QGI\EF7 PIGE EYQE6O59E 5O 7JE $IS5O5464 *S7EG ;I4O7 &EO7IG475I6 QGI\EF708IG GEO7IG475I6 I8 T4GG5EG 5O346NO 46N TE4FJEO0 47 hd=` P5335I6: ^+& @=>=A>:1

> )JE QGI\EF7 V4O 7I TE TS537 I6 7JE O57E I8 7JE IG5R5643 "S38 (747E 24G[ 3INRE 46NFI68EGE6FE FE67EG0 VJ5FJ V4O NEO7GIHEN TH MSGG5F46E ,946 56 W@@_:



10/21

=@

8S6N 7JE E675GE QGI\EF70 46N 7JEH N5N 6I7 EYQ3456 VJEGE 7JE GEP45656R PI6EH VIS3N FIPE

8GIP0 VJE6 57 VIS3N TE 494534T3E0 VJE6 7JE QGI\EF7 VIS3N TE FIPQ3E7EN0 IG VJ47 VIS3N

J4QQE6 7I 7JE h>`:> P5335I6 58 7JE QGI\EF7 N5N 6I7 FIPE 7I 8GS575I6: ^+& @=]dd]?de:1

$=> 3=4?> !!! 389@84BB47B>57

)JE )GSO7EEO QGEQ4GEN 46N OSTP577EN 4 2J4OE ,,, 2GIRG4PP475F '695GI6PE6743

,PQ4F7 (747EPE67 ^2',(1 8IG QST35F FIPPE67 46N JE3N QST35F PEE756RO TE8IGE 4NIQ756R 7JE

85643 2',( 56 DS6E W@=_: ^+& @=>=`_? `:1 )JE 2',( 5O TGI4N0 FI9EG56R 433 2J4OE ,,,

QGI\EF7O0 46N SOEO af4g QGIRG4PP475F 4QQGI4FJ 7I 4OO5O7 7JE )GSO7EEO 56 E943S475I6 I8

QGIQIOEN QGI\EF7O:c ^+& @=>=A@:1 %ISG F47ERIG5EO I8 QI7E67543 QGIRG4PO VEGE 5NE67585ENn

^=1 -I 4F75I6 ^5:E:0 6I 4NN575I643 E4G3H GEO7IG475I61l ^W1 &EO7IG475I6 I8 J4T5747 46N 35956R 46N

FI4O743 P4G56E GEOISGFEOl ^d1 '6J46FEN GEFGE475I643 SOE IQQIG7S6575EOl ^_1 4 FIPT56475I6

I8 ^W1 46N ^d1: ^+& @=>=A=:1 )JE )GSO7EEO FJIOE 437EG64759E ^_1p4 FIPT56475I6 I8

GEO7IG475I6 46N GEFGE475I643 SOE: ^./01 '4FJ I8 7JE __ QGI\EF7O 8433O V57J56 I6E I8 7JEOE

TGI4N QGIRG4PP475F F47ERIG5EO0 OIPE75PEO GE8EGGEN 7I 4O a437EG64759EOc: ^+& @=>=A>?

@=>=Ae:1 )JE 2',( EYQ3456EN 7JE QSGQIOE 46N 6EEN 8IG 2J4OE ,,, 4F75I6 4O 8I33IVOn a%IG 7JE

QSGQIOE I8 4FFE3EG4756R PE4656R8S3 GEO7IG475I6 I8 56\SGEN 647SG43 GEOISGFEO 46N 7JE5G

OEG95FEO GEOS3756R 8GIP 7JE (Q5330 7JE )GSO7EEO QGIQIOE 7I FI6756SE 5PQ3EPE67475I6 I8 '4G3H

&EO7IG475I6 56 4FFIGN46FE V57J 7JE *53 2I33S75I6 +F7 ^*2+1 46N SO56R 8S6NO P4NE 494534T3E

56 7JE %G4PEVIG[ +RGEEPE67:c ^+& @=>WdA:1

)JE +34T4P4 "S38 (747E '6J46FEPE67 2GI\EF7 V4O NEO5R647EN 4 GEO7IG475I6 QGI\EF7

NEO5R6EN 7I P4[E SQ 8IG 7JE 3IOO I8 GEFGE475I643 SOE F4SOEN TH 7JE OQ533: +FFIGN56R 7I 7JE

2',(0 7JE 3INREoFI68EGE6FE FE67EG QIG75I6 I8 7JE QGI\EF7 VIS3N P4[E SQ 8IG 3IO7

GEFGE475I643 SOE TH FGE4756R 4QQGIY5P47E3H =W@0@@@ 6EV 95O57IG 65RJ7O QEG HE4G 46N 4



11/21

==

GISRJ3H FIPQ4G4T3E 6SPTEG I8 95O57IG?N4HO 47 7JE Q4G[: )JE 2',( N5N 6I7 EYQ3IGE 46H

QI7E67543 437EG64759E QGI\EF7Ol 56O7E4N0 57 FI6F3SNEN 7J47 7JE I63H 437EG64759E 7I 7JE QGI\EF7

5O a-I +F75I6c0 5:E:0 a7JE )GSO7EEO VIS3N 6I7 QSGOSE 7JE "S38 (747E 24G[ '6J46FEPE67 2GI\EF7

4O Q4G7 I8 2J4OE ,,, '4G3H &EO7IG475I6:c ^+& @=]d]@:1

!??:>? 38>?>57>6

,6 7J5O 4F75I60 "&- FJ433E6REO 7JE 3INREoFI68EGE6FE FE67EG FI67456EN V57J56 7JE

+34T4P4 "S38 (747E 24G[ '6J46FEPE67O 2GI\EF7: "&- 4OOEG7O 7J47 7JE )GSO7EEOZ 4F75I6O

VEGE 4GT57G4GH 46N F4QG5F5ISO ^56 95I3475I6 I8 7JE +2+1 56 7JGEE GEOQEF7O: %5GO70 7JE 2',(

8453EN 7I FI6NSF7 7JE 437EG64759EO 4643HO5O GEbS5GEN TH TI7J -'2+ 46N *2+: (QEF585F433H0

"&- 4GRSEO 7JE 2',( 5O NE85F5E67 TEF4SOE 57 NIEO 6I7 N5OFSOO 437EG64759EO 7I 7JE

3INREoFI68EGE6FE FE67EG I7JEG 7J46 7JE a6I 4F75I6c 437EG64759E: )J5O0 "&- 433EREO0 5O 4

95I3475I6 I8 -'2+ 46N *2+: (EFI6N0 "&- FI67E6NO 7JE 2',( aQGI95NEO 35773E IG 6I N474 7I

OSQQIG7 7JE QG56F5Q43 \SO7585F475I6 8IG : : : 7JE f3INREoFI68EGE6FE FE67EG QGI\EF7gc 46N

7JEGE8IGE 95I347EO -'2+ GERS3475I6O GEbS5G56R EYQ346475I6 I8 PE7JINI3IR5EO SOEN 46N

F57475I6 7I OF5E67585F N474: ^(+; k Ad0 KIF: d_1 )J5GN0 "&- FI67E6NO 7JE 2',( 95I347EO -'2+

TEF4SOE 57 8453O 7I 4643HXE 7JE FSPS34759E 46N 56N5GEF7 5PQ4F7O I8 7JE QGI\EF7: "&- OEE[O

NEF34G47IGH 46N 56\S6F759E GE35E80 56F3SN56R 46 IGNEG E6\I5656R 8SG7JEG 4F75I6 I6 7JE

3INREoFI68EGE6FE FE67EG: ]

BI7J 7JE %ENEG43 )GSO7EEO 46N 7JE (747E )GSO7EE NE6H 7JE5G 4F75I6O VEGE 4GT57G4GH

46N F4QG5F5ISO0 437JISRJ 7JE5G 4GRSPE67O 4GE 6I7 5NE675F43: .57J GEOQEF7 7I 7JE 437EG64759EO

4643HO5O0 7JE (747E )GSO7EE 4GRSEO 7JE QGIRG4P?3E9E3 437EG64759EO 4643HO5O V4O OS885F5E67 7I

] )JE (+; 4F7S433H 4OOEG7O 8ISG F4SOEO I8 4F75I60 TS7 7JE 8ISG7J 5O 4 F345P 8IG56\S6F759E GE35E8 4R456O7 7JE (747E )GSO7EE S6NEG 7JE +33 .G57O +F70 W` #:(:;: i =]>=:



12/21

=W

PEE7 -'2+ 46N *2+ GEbS5GEPE67O: )JE %ENEG43 )GSO7EEO0 I6 7JE I7JEG J46N0 NI 6I7 GE3H I6

7JE QGIRG4P?3E9E3 437EG64759EO 4643HO5O: ,6O7E4N0 7JEH 4GRSE 7JE QGI\EF7?3E9E3 437EG64759EO

4643HO5O ^VJ5FJ N5OFSOOEN I63H 7JE QGIQIOEN QGI\EF7 46N a6I 4F75I6c1 V4O OS885F5E67 S6NEG

7JE F5GFSPO746FEO 7I PEE7 7JE GEbS5GEPE67O I8 -'2+ 46N *2+: BI7J %ENEG43 46N (747E

)GSO7EEO 4GRSE "&-ZO OEFI6N F345P 5O 6I7 4 9435N -'2+ F345P TEF4SOE 7JE 433EREN P5OO56R

N474 NIEO 6I7 GE347E 7I 7JE E695GI6PE6743 E88EF7O I8 7JE QGIQIOEN 4F75I6: $5[EV5OE0 TI7J

FI67E6N 7J47 7JE 2',( 4NEbS47E3H 4NNGEOOEN 7JE FSPS34759E E695GI6PE6743 5PQ4F7O I8 7JE

QGI\EF7:

/>@4A *54AF? 9J *;7


13/21

=d

^41 &5RIGISO3H EYQ3IGE 46N IT\EF759E3H E943S47E 433 GE4OI64T3E 437EG64759EO046N 8IG 437EG64759EO VJ5FJ VEGE E35P5647EN 8GIP NE7453EN O7SNH0 TG5E83HN5OFSOO 7JE GE4OI6O 8IG 7JE5G J4956R TEE6 E35P5647EN:^T1 KE9I7E OSTO7467543 7GE47PE67 7I E4FJ 437EG64759E FI6O5NEGEN 56 NE745356F3SN56R 7JE QGIQIOEN 4F75I6 OI 7J47 GE95EVEGO P4H E943S47E 7JE5G

FIPQ4G4759E PEG57O:^F1 ,6F3SNE GE4OI64T3E 437EG64759EO 6I7 V57J56 7JE \SG5ON5F75I6 I8 7JE 3E4N4RE6FH:^N1 ,6F3SNE 7JE 437EG64759E I8 6I 4F75I6:^E1 ,NE6758H 7JE 4RE6FHqO QGE8EGGEN 437EG64759E IG 437EG64759EO0 58 I6E IG PIGEEY5O7O0 56 7JE NG487 O747EPE67 46N 5NE6758H OSFJ 437EG64759E 56 7JE 85643O747EPE67 S63EOO 46I7JEG 34V QGIJ5T57O 7JE EYQGEOO5I6 I8 OSFJ 4 QGE8EGE6FE:^81 ,6F3SNE 4QQGIQG547E P575R475I6 PE4OSGEO 6I7 43GE4NH 56F3SNEN 56 7JEQGIQIOEN 4F75I6 IG 437EG64759EO:

_@ ;:%:&: i =>@W:=_:

,6575433H0 7JE (747E )GSO7EE 4GRSEO 7J47 7JE#'*A'%HH%&+;437EG64759EO 4643HO5O

O475O85EO 7JE 437EG64759EO GEbS5GEPE67: )J47 4643HO5O FI6O5NEGEN 437EG64759EO 47 7JE TGI4NEG

QGIRG4P 3E9E30 6I7 47 7JE OQEF585F QGI\EF7 3E9E3: ,7 EY4P56EN 7JE 7HQEO I8 QGIRG4P

437EG64759EO 7J47 FIS3N TE 4NIQ7EN 56 2J4OE )JGEE '4G3H &EO7IG475I6n ^=1 -I 4F75I6 ^5:E:0 6I

4NN575I643 E4G3H GEO7IG475I61l ^W1 &EO7IG475I6 I8 J4T5747 46N 35956R 46N FI4O743 P4G56E

GEOISGFEOl ^d1 '6J46FEN GEFGE475I643 SOE IQQIG7S6575EOl ^_1 4 FIPT56475I6 I8 ^W1 46N ^d1:

*8 7JIOE 437EG64759E QGIRG4PO0 7JE )GSO7EEO FJIOE IQ75I6 ^_1: *Q75I6 ^_1 FI6O5O7EN I8 __

N588EGE67 QGI\EF7O 56 859E O747EO: .JE6 46 4RE6FH QGIQIOEO 7I FIPP57 GEOISGFEO 7I 4 OQEF585F

QGI\EF7 4O Q4G7 I8 4 TGI4NEG QGIRG4P0 57 PSO7 QGI95NE 4 OS885F5E673H NE7453EN 437EG64759EO

4643HO5O I8 7JE QGI\EF7: 8"".6+*QE6%*


14/21

=_

EY4P56475I6 I8 QGIRG4PP475F 437EG64759EO 5O 6I7 QGI\EF7 OQEF585F 46N0 7JEGE8IGE0 NIEO 6I7

O475O8H 7JE 437EG64759EO 4643HO5O GEbS5GEPE67:

.57J GEOQEF7 7I 7JE "S38 (747E 24G[ QGI\EF70 7JE 2',( N5OFSOOEN I63H 7VI 437EG64759EOn

^=1 RI 8IGV4GN V57J 7JE QGI\EF7 4O QGIQIOEN IG ^W1 6I 4F75I6: "&- QI567O 7I OE9EG43

GE4OI64T3E 437EG64759EO 7J47 FIS3N J49E TEE6 4NNGEOOENn

2SGFJ4OE QGIQEG7H 8IG QST35F 4FFEOO 46N FI6OEG9475I6:

&EO7IGE VE7346NO 46N OJIGE356E:

BS53N J4T5747:

+33IV QG5947E E6757H 7I 8S6N IG Q4G75433H 8S6N 3INRE FI6O7GSF75I6 46N 4QQ3H 8S6NO 7I

GEO7IG475I6:

BS53N QST35F ENSF475I6 46N 7G453O FIPQI6E67 46N 8IGERI 3INREoFI69E675I6 FE67EG:

)JE )GSO7EEO NI 6I7 N5OQS7E 7J47 7JEOE 4GE0 56 7JEIGH0 GE4OI64T3E 437EG64759EO: )JEH 4GRSE0

JIVE9EG0 7J47 7JEOE 437EG64759EO 4GE S6GE4OI64T3E TEF4SOE 7JEH FIS3N 6I7 J49E TEE6

5PQ3EPE67EN S6NEG 7JE %G4PEVIG[ +RGEEPE67:

)JE )GSO7EEOZ F5GFS34G 3IR5F RIEO OIPE7J56R 35[E 7J5On +33 8S6N56R 8IG E4G3H

GEO7IG475I6 FIPEO 8GIP B2 954 7JE %G4PEVIG[ +RGEEPE67: )JE %G4PEVIG[ +RGEEPE67

QGI95NEO 7J47 I63H QGI\EF7O 4RGEEN 7I TH B2 46N 7JE )GSO7EEO 56 4 2GI\EF7 (75QS3475I6 V533 TE

8S6NEN: -I QGI\EF7 F46 RI 8IGV4GN V57JIS7 8S6N56R: #63EOO B2 46N 7JE )GSO7EEO J49E

4RGEEN 7I 4 QGI\EF70 46H I7JEG QGI\EF7 5O 6I7 4 GE4OI64T3E 437EG64759E TEF4SOE 57 F466I7 TE

8S6NEN: )JEGE8IGE0 OJ %-/ &C" I'E1&""1 /";+/" $C+;C %6&"'-%&+9"1 %'" '"%1*-%=6"=";%E1"

*-6? OJ %-/ &C" I'E1&""1 /";+/" $C+;C #'*U";&1 %'" FE-/"/: (5PQ3H QS70 7JE )GSO7EEO FJIIOE

4 QGI\EF70 74[E 57 7I B20 E67EG 4 2GI\EF7 (75QS3475I60 46N 7JEGE F46 TE 6I 437EG64759E I7JEG

7J46 7JE a6I 4F75I6c 437EG64759E:



15/21

=>

)JE QSGQIOE I8 437EG64759EO 4643HO5O a5O 7I 568IGP TI7J 7JE QST35F 46N 7JE

NEF5O5I6P4[EG0c TH R5956R 7JEP F3E4G3H NE856EN 437EG64759EO: G+&+,"-1 PA%+-1& OE'6+-A&*-M

.-;0 90 OE1"?0 Ad` %:WN =A@0 =A> ^K:;: ;5G: =AA=1: *8 FISGOE0 I63H 437EG64759EO 7J47 4GE

GE4OI64T3E0 IG 8E4O5T3E0 GEbS5GE N5OFSOO5I6: ./0 .JE7JEG 46 437EG64759E 5O GE4OI64T3E

NEQE6NO SQI6 7JE RI43O I8 7JE 4RE6FHZO 4F75I60 TS7 a46 4RE6FH P4H 6I7 NE856E 57O RI43O 56

7EGPO OI S6GE4OI64T3H 64GGIV 7J47 I63H I6E 437EG64759E 8GIP 4PI6R 7JE E695GI6PE67433H

TE65R6 I6EO 56 7JE 4RE6FHZO QIVEG VIS3N 4FFIPQ35OJ 7JE RI430 46N 7JE ',( VIS3N TEFIPE 4

8IGEIGN456EN 8IGP4357H:c ./0 47 =A]: )JE )GSO7EEO QI567 7I 7JE 2',(ZO aQSGQIOE 46N 6EENc

O747EPE67p7I %;;"6"'%&" PE4656R8S3 GEO7IG475I6p46N 4GRSE 7J47 7JEH J49E 8S38533EN 7JE5G

NS7H 7I FI6O5NEG 4 GE4OI64T3E G46RE I8 GEO7IG475I6 437EG64759EO: (56FE 7JEGE FIS3N TE 6I

E4G3H GEO7IG475I6 QGI\EF7 4TOE67 46 4RGEEPE67 V57J ^46N 8S6N56R 8GIP1 B20 6I I7JEG QGI\EF7

FIS3N 4FJ5E9E 7JE O747EN RI43: ME6FE0 7JEGE V4O 6I aGE4OI64T3Ec 437EG64759E I7JEG 7J46 7JE

a6I 4F75I6c 437EG64759E: )J5O 5O 7JE Q4G4N5RP I8 4 OE38?8S3853356R QGIQJEFH: .J53E a6I

P565PSP 6SPTEG I8 437EG64759EOc PSO7 TE FI6O5NEGEN0 G+&+,"-1 F*' 8H%'& D'*$&C 90 8";Q?

!"#&0 *F I'%-1#0M ]]A %:dN =W@d0 =W=W ^==7J;5G: W@=W10 4RE6F5EO PSO7 QGEOE67 4 GE4OI6EN

437EG64759EO 4643HO5O:

+7 TI7J 7JE QGIRG4P 3E9E3 46N 7JE QGI\EF7 3E9E30 7JE )GSO7EEO J49E S6GE4OI64T3H

64GGIVEN 7JE S659EGOE I8 QIOO5T3E 437EG64759EO 7I 7VIn ^=1 RI 8IGV4GN V57J 7JE QGI\EF7 4O

QGIQIOEN IG ^W1 6I 4F75I6: ,6 7JE 2',( QGIRG4PP475F 437EG64759EO 4643HO5O0 7JE )GSO7EEO

FIPT56EN QGI\EF7O 569I3956R GEO7IG475I6 I8 J4T5747 46N P4G56E 358E V57J QGI\EF7O 569I3956R

GEFGE475I643 SOE: BH NI56R OI0 7JEH FGE47EN QGI\EF7O 7J47 FIS3N TE 8S6NEN S6NEG 7JE

%G4PEVIG[ +RGEEPE67: +7 7JE QGI\EF7 3E9E30 7JE )GSO7EEO FI67E6N 7J47 7JE I63H GE4OI64T3E



16/21

=]

437EG64759E 5O 4 QGI\EF7 7J47 F46 TE 8S6NEN: (56FE 8S6N56R GEbS5GEO 4 2GI\EF7 (75QS3475I6

TE7VEE6 7JE )GSO7EEO 46N B20 I63H 7JIOE QGI\EF7O 4GE GE4OI64T3E:

LIGEI9EG0 7JE )GSO7EEO 4GE O5PQ3H VGI6R 56 7JE5G FI6F3SO5I6 7J47 7JE %G4PEVIG[

+RGEEPE67o2GI\EF7 O75QS3475I6 QGEF3SNEO 7JE 8S6N56R I8 437EG64759E QGI\EF7O: )JE )GSO7EEO

4GRSE 7J47 4 8S33 437EG64759EO 4643HO5O V4O 6I7 QIOO5T3E TEF4SOE 7JEGE V4O 6I PE7JIN 8IG

8S6N56R 46H 437EG64759E QGI\EF7: )JE 2GI\EF7 (75QS3475I6 QGI95NEO 7J47 af4g7 46H 75PE 487EG

B2f g J4O P4NE 8S33 Q4HPE67 fI8 2J4OE ,,, 8S6NOg0 7JE )GSO7EEO P4H 8IG RIIN F4SOE E3EF7 6I7

7I 5PQ3EPE67 7JE '4G3H &EO7IG475I6 2GI\EF7:c` ^+& @=è=`:1 )JE )GSO7EEO P4H GE7456

S6OQE67 8S6NO 46N 4QQ3H 7JEP a7I I6E IG PIGE GEQ34FEPE67 QGI\EF7Ô10 VJ5FJ P4H 56F3SNE

4 PIN585EN 9EGO5I6 I8 7JE QGI\EF7 : : : f46Ng OJ433 TE NEO5R6EN 8IG 3IO7 GEFGE475I643 SOE

QGI95NEN TH 647SG43 GEOISGFEO 56\SGEN 56 +34T4P4:c ^+& @=è=A:1 )J5O 346RS4RE 3E6NO

57OE38 7I 6I I7JEG 567EGQGE7475I6 TS7 7J47 7JEGE VEGE 437EG64759EO I7JEG 7J46 7JIOE OE3EF7EN

QGI\EF7O 7J47 FIS3N J49E TEE6 8S6NEN:

)J5O F4OE NEPI6O7G47EO 7JE 5PQIG746FE I8 QGI95N56R 4 F3E4G 46N PE4656R8S3 4643HO5O

I8 437EG64759EO: )JE )GSO7EEO 46N B2 4RGEEN 7I 74[E h>`:> P5335I6 NI334GO ^h==e P5335I6

7I7430 V57J -&K I88OE7O1 IS7 I8 7JE aQI7c I8 8S6NO 494534T3E 8IG E4G3H GEO7IG475I6 V57J 7JE

567E675I6 I8 OE7756R 7JIOE 8S6NO 4O5NE 8IG QIOO5T3E SOE 56 4 QGI\EF7 7J470 47 7JE 75PE0 V4O 35773E

PIGE 7J46 46 5NE4 46N FIS3N 6I7 FIPE 7I 8GS575I6 8IG P46H HE4GO0 58 47 433: ;3E4G3H0 7JE

)GSO7EEO 8453EN 7I E943S47E VJE7JEG 7JEGE VEGE GE4OI64T3E GEO7IG475I6 437EG64759EO 7J47

VIS3N J49E FI68IGPEN 7I 7JE GEbS5GEPE67O I8 *2+ 46N -'2+: )JE5G 8453SGE 7I NI OI V4O

4GT57G4GH 46N F4QG5F5ISO: "&- 5O E67573EN 7I OSPP4GH \SNRPE67 I6 7J5O F4SOE I8 4F75I6:

`BH 7JE 7EGPO I8 7JE 4RGEEPE670 8S6NO VEGE 7I TE 7G46O8EGGEN 7I 7JE (747E )GSO7EEV57J56 =_ N4HO 487EG 7JE 2GI\EF7 (75QS3475I6 V4O 853EN



17/21

=e

)>;956 ,4:?> 9J *;7@W:=0 TEF4SOE 57 NIEO

6I7 a5NE6758H 46H PE7JINI3IR5EO SOENc IG aP4[E EYQ35F57 GE8EGE6FE: : : 7I 7JE OF5E67585F 46N

I7JEG OISGFEO GE35EN SQI6:c _@ ;:%:&: i =>@W:W_: (QEF585F433H0 "&- FI67E6NO 7JE GEFIGN NIEO

6I7 OSQQIG7 7JE )GSO7EEO FI6F3SO5I6 7J47 4 3INRE 46N FI68EGE6FE FE67EG VIS3N P4[E SQ 8IG

3IO7 GEFGE475I643 SOE TH TG56R56R 6EV 95O57IGO 7I 7JE TE4FJ: ,6 OSQQIG7 I8 57O F345P0 "&-

QI567O 7I 7JE 34F[ I8 N474 7I OSQQIG7 7JE 6SPTEG I8 95O57IG 65RJ7O 7JE 3INREoFI68EGE6FE

FE67EG VIS3N TG56R IG 7I OSQQIG7 7JE 6EEN 8IG OJIG7?7EGP 3INR56R 56 7JE 4GE4: MIVE9EG0 4O

7JE )GSO7EEO QI567 IS70 7JEOE 433EREN NE85F5E6F5EO NI 6I7 GE347E 7I 7JE E695GI6PE6743

4643HO5O GEbS5GEN TH -'2+ TS7 7I 7JE 5OOSE I8 3IO7 GEFGE475I643 SOE0 4 F345P 7J47 F46 I63H TE

4OOEG7EN S6NEG *2+: _@ ;:%:&: i =>@W:=: BEF4SOE "&- QI567O 7I 6I NE85F5E6FH 56 7J47 GER4GN0

57 J4O 8453EN 7I PEE7 57O TSGNE6 I8 QGI956R 7J47 7JE )GSO7EEO 4F7EN 4GT57G4G53H 46N

F4QG5F5ISO3H: )JE )GSO7EEO 4GE E67573EN 7I OSPP4GH \SNRPE67 I6 7J5O F4SOE I8 4F75I6:A

$= 9J *;7


18/21

=`

==e_ ^=@7J ;5G: W@@W10H*/+F+"/0 d=A %:dN =W@e ^=@7J ;5G: W@@d1l 1"" %61*_@ ;:%:&: i =>@`:e

^NE85656R FSPS34759E 5PQ4F7O1l _@ ;:%:&: i =>@W:=] ^',( PSO7 56F3SNE N5OFSOO5I6 I8 56N5GEF7

E88EF7O1l _@ ;:%:&: =>@`:` ^NE85656R 56N5GEF7 E88EF7O1l 1"" %61* 8+"''% G6E= 90 K%'1C0 Ae] %:WN

e]d0 ee@ ^=O7;5G: =AAW1 ^N5OFSOO56R N5GEF7 46N 56N5GEF7 E88EF7O GEbS5GEPE671: "&- 4OOEG7O

7JE 2',( 8453EN 7I FI6O5NEG 7JE 8I33IV56R 56N5GEF7 E88EF7O IG FSPS34759E 5PQ4F7On ^=1 7JE

GEFI685RSG475I6 I8 46 567EGOEF75I6 IG V5NE656R (747E &I4N =`W 47 I6E E67G46FE 7I 7JE

QGIQIOEN 3INREoFI68EGE6FE FE67EGl ^W1 7JE FI6O7GSF75I6 I8 4 6EV GI4N 7I 4FFIPPIN47E 4

35[E3H 56FGE4OE 56 7G4885Fl 46N ^d1 7JE 35[E35JIIN 7JE QGI\EF7 V533 3E4N 7I 6EV NE9E3IQPE67:

-I6E I8 7JEOE 4F75I6O 4GE GE4OI64T3H 8IGEOEE4T3E:

)JE )GSO7EEO FI67E6N 7JE 85GO7 4GRSPE670 GER4GN56R GI4N FJ46REO 7I 4FFIPPIN47E

7JE 3INRE E67G46FE0 5O T4OEN I6 4 P5OGE4N56R I8 7JE GEFIGN: )JE F57EN Q4G4RG4QJ 8GIP 7JE

2',( O747EOn

)JE QGIQIOEN QGI\EF7 VIS3N TE 4FFEOOEN 954 7JE EY5O756R 8ISG?V4H0 O5R6435XEN(& =`W 46N =d> 567EGOEF75I6 46N 4 GEFI685RSGEN )?567EGOEF75I6 47 (& =`W 46N7JE I3N f"S38 (747E 24G[g 3INREZO E4O7 4FFEOO: +7 7JE OEFI6N 3IF475I6 0 7JE GE?

EO74T35OJEN 3INRE VIS3N TE 4FFEOOEN 954 (& =`W TH 4 G5RJ7?56 46N G5RJ7?IS7FI685RSG475I6: (& =`W VIS3N 6EEN 7I TE V5NE6EN 7I 4FFIPPIN47E 4 3E87?7SG6346E 8GIP VEO7TIS6N (& =`W0 IG 46 437EG64759E 567EGOEF75I6 FI685RSG475I6VIS3N 6EEN 7I TE 5PQ3EPE67EN &* 1E##*'& +-;'"%1"/ %;;"11 &* &C" 6*/A":

^+& @=]_dW0 EPQJ4O5O 4NNEN:1 )JE VIGN56R FIS3N TE F3E4GEG0 TS7 VJ47 7J5O Q4G4RG4QJ

NEOFG5TEO 5O 7VI E67G46FEO: )JE 85GO7 VIS3N QGI95NE FIPQ3E7E 4FFEOO 56 46N IS7 954 4 7G4885F

35RJ7 47 (& =`W 46N =d>: )JE OEFI6N VIS3N QGI95NE I63H 35P57EN 4FFEOOpE4O7TIS6N

9EJ5F3EO FIS3N 7SG6 G5RJ7 567I 7JE OEFI6N E67G46FE 46N EY5756R 9EJ5F3EO FIS3N I63H 7SG6 G5RJ7

I67I (& =`W: ,8 56FGE4OEN 4FFEOO VEGE NEO5GEN0 5:E:0 7I P4[E 7J5O E67G46FE 4FFEOO5T3E 7I 46N

8GIP TI7J E4O7 46N VEO70 57 VIS3N TE 6EFEOO4GH 7I V5NE6 (& =`W IG GEFI685RSGE 7JE



19/21

=A

567EGOEF75I6: )JEGE8IGE0 FI67G4GH 7I "&-ZO 4GRSPE670 7JE GEFIGN NIEO 6I7 OSQQIG7 7JE

F345P 7J47 4NN575I643 GI4NVIG[ VIS3N TE GE4OI64T3H 8IGEOEE4T3E:

$5[EV5OE0 7JE GEFIGN NIEO 6I7 OSQQIG7 "&-ZO F345P 7J47 FI6O7GSF75I6 I8 4 6EV 6IG7J?

OIS7J GI4N VIS3N 35[E3H TE 6EFEOO4GH 7I OSQQIG7 7JE 56FGE4OE 56 7G4885F GEOS3756R 8GIP 7JE

QGIQIOEN 3INREoFI68EGE6FE FE67EG: )JE )GSO7EEO FI6NSF7EN 4 7G4885F O7SNH0 NE7453EN 56 7JE

2',(0 46N FI6F3SNEN 7JE 5PQ4F7O I8 56FGE4OEN 7G4885F VIS3N TE PINEG47E0 V57J 7JE RGE47EO7

56FGE4OE 56 7G49E3 NE34H TE56R =W:= OEFI6NO NSG56R QE4[ QEG5INO: ^+& @=]_dW?d_:1 B4OEN

I6 7J5O 568IGP475I60 7JE )GSO7EEO FI6F3SNEN 7J47 6EV GI4N FI6O7GSF75I6 V4O 6I7 GE4OI64T3H

8IGEOEE4T3E: ^+& @=`_=W:1 )JE I63H E95NE6FE "&- F57EO 7I 7JE FI67G4GH 5O 4 6EVOQ4QEG

4G75F3E 56 VJ5FJ 7JE P4HIG I8 "S38 (JIGEO EYQGEOOEN J5O OSQQIG7 8IG 7JE 3INREoFI69E675I6

FE67EG TEF4SOE JE TE35E9EN 57 VIS3N 8IGFE 7JE O747E 7I TS53N 4 6IG7J?OIS7J GI4N 7JGISRJ "S38

(747E 24G[: )JE P4HIGZO IQ565I6 NIEO 6I7 FI67G4N5F7 7JE )GSO7EEOZ 7G4885F O7SNH0 6IG NIEO 57

QGI95NE E95NE6FE 7J47 7JE O747E VIS3N TE 35[E3H 7I FI6O7GSF7 4 6EV GI4N 7I 4FFIPPIN47E

3INREoFI68EGE6FE FE67EG 7G4885F:

%56433H0 "&- FG575F5XEO 7JE 2',(ZO FI6F3SO5I6 7J47 7JE QGI\EF7 V533 6I7 GEOS37 56

OSTO7467543 6EV NE9E3IQPE67: "&- NIEO 6I7 4F7S433H QI567 7I 46H E95NE6FE 7J47 OSTO7467543

6EV NE9E3IQPE67 5O 35[E3H 7I IFFSG: ,6O7E4N0 57 PEGE3H QI567O IS7 433EREN 56FI6O5O7E6F5EO 56

7JE )GSO7EEOZ QGI\EF75I6O: (QEF585F433H0 I6E \SO7585F475I6 8IG 7JE QGI\EF7 5O 7JE 34F[ I8 OJIG7?

7EGP 3INR56R0 TS7 7JE 7G4885F O7SNH 4OOSPEN e>r I8 7JE FI68EGE6FE 477E6NEEO VIS3N O74H

I88O57E: )JE 7G4885F O7SNH 8IFSOEN I6 QE4[ 83IVO 46N 4OOSPEN 7JE FI68EGE6FE FE67EG V4O 56

8S33 SOE: ^+& @=]_dW:1 ,6 I7JEG VIGNO0 57 V4O 6I7 QGEN5F756R 7JE 6SPTEG I8 95O57IGO0 I63H

VJ47 VIS3N J4QQE6 7I 7G4885F 58 7JE FI68EGE6FE FE67EG V4O 47 P4Y5PSP F4Q4F57H: "&-ZO

I63H I7JEG 4GRSPE67 5O 4 FI6F3SOIGH 4OOEG75I6 7J47 7JE QGI\EF7EN 6SPTEG I8 466S43 95O57IGO



20/21

W@

V533 a56EYIG4T3Hc 3E4N 7I 6EV NE9E3IQPE67: +O 7JE )GSO7EEO QI567 IS70 7JE QGI\EF7EN

6SPTEG??W=@0@@@ 95O57IGO QEG HE4GpEbS47EO 7I 4QQGIY5P47E3H d=@ 95O57IGO QEG N4H:

-I7J56R 56 7JE GEFIGN 56N5F47EO 7I 7JE ;ISG7 7J47 46 56FGE4OE I8 7J5O O5XE VIS3N P4[E 6EV

NE9E3IQPE67 GE4OI64T3H 8IGEOEE4T3E:

,6 OSP0 7JE )GSO7EEO N5N 6I7 4F7 4GT57G4G53H IG F4QG5F5ISO3H 56 845356R 7I FI6O5NEG

56N5GEF7 E88EF7O IG FSPS34759E 5PQ4F7O 7J47 VEGE 6I7 GE4OI64T3H 8IGEOEE4T3E: )JEGE8IGE0

7JEH 4GE E67573EN 7I OSPP4GH \SNRPE67 I6 7J5O F4SOE I8 4F75I6:

.9:87= ,4:?> 9J *;7AJ +>P:>?7>6

"&- OEE[O 7JE 8I33IV56R GE35E8 n ^=1 4 NEF34G475I6 7J47 7JE %ENEG43 )GSO7EEO 95I347EN

-'2+ 46N *2+ TH 4QQGI956R 7JE 3INREoFI68EGE6FE FE67EGl ^W1 aKEF34GE S634V8S3 46N OE7

4O5NE 7JE &EFIGN I8 KEF5O5I6 4O 57 GE347EO 7I 7JE f3INREoFI68EGE6FE FE67EGglc ^d1 aKEF34GE

S634V8S3 46N OE7 4O5NE 7JE 2GI\EF7 (75QS3475I60 4O 57 GE347EO 7I 4QQGI956R 7JE

f3INREoFI68EGE6FE FE67EGglc ^_1 *GNEG 7JE %ENEG43 )GSO7EEO 7I V57JNG4V 7JE5G 4QQGI943 I8

7JE a3INREoFI68EGE6FE FE67EGglc ^>1 a'6\I56 7JE %ENEG43 )GSO7EEO 46N ;IPP5OO5I6EG "SH

8GIP 74[56R 46H 4F75I6 56 8SG7JEG46FE I8 7JE f3INREoFI68EGE6FE FE67EGg S6753 7JE %ENEG43

)GSO7EEO FIPQ3H V57J 7JE 34Vlc 46N ^]1 4V4GN 477IG6EH 8EEO 46N FIO7O: ,6 4 OEQ4G47E F4SOE

I8 4F75I60 "&- 4OOEG7O 57O G5RJ7 7I QGIOQEF759E 56\S6F759E GE35E8 4R456O7 ;IPP5OO5I6EG "S67EG

"SH0 7JE NEO5R647EN ,PQ3EPE6756R )GSO7EE:

"&- J4O QGE9453EN I6 7JE5G F345P 7J47 7JE )GSO7EEO 8453EN 7I FI6NSF7 4 -'2+o*2+

437EG64759EO 4643HO5O V57J GEOQEF7 7I 7JE 433IF475I6 I8 h>`:> P5335I6 56 B2 E4G3H GEO7IG475I6

8S6NO 7I Q4G75433H 8S6N 7JE 3INREoFI68EGE6FE FE67EG: )JE ;ISG7 F460 46N V5330 E6\I56 7JE SOE



21/21

I8 7JIOE 8S6NO QE6N56R 8SG7JEG GE95EV TH 7JE )GSO7EEO:=@ MIVE9EG0 T4OEN I6 7JE

4NP565O7G4759E GEFIGN TE8IGE 570 46N 7JE 64GGIV 5OOSE QGEOE67EN TH 7JE Q3E4N56RO0 7JE ;ISG7

F466I7 E6\I56 7JE ;IPP5OO5I6EG IG 7JE (747E 8GIP TS53N56R 7JE 3INREoFI68EGE6FE FE67EG

V57J 8S6NO I7JEG 7J46 E4G3H GEO7IG475I6 8S6NO:

)JE ;ISG7 V533 V57JJI3N GS356R I6 "&-ZO GEbSEO7 8IG 477IG6EHZO 8EEO 46N FIO7O

QE6N56R 8SG7JEG TG5E856R: .57J56 7J5G7H N4HO I8 7JE N47E I8 7J5O IGNEG0 "&- P4H 853E 4

QGIQEG3H OSQQIG7EN PI75I60 56F3SN56R F57475I6 7I 4S7JIG57H QEGP57756R 7JE 4V4GN I8 8EEO 46N

FIO7O 4O VE33 4O NIFSPE67475I6 OSQQIG756R 7JE JISGO EYQE6NEN 46N 7JE JISG3H G47E

FJ4GREN: + TG5E856R OFJENS3E V533 TE E67EGEN 487EG 7JE PI75I6 5O 853EN:

,95;A:?6 56 849IG I8 "&- 4O 7I 7JE *2+o-'2+ F345P0 4OOEG7EN

56 7JE %5GO7 ;4SOE I8 +F75I60 7J47 7JE )GSO7EEO 4F7EN 4GT57G4G53H 46N F4QG5F5ISO3H TH 845356R 7I

FI6NSF7 4 QGIQEG 437EG64759EO 4643HO5O: (SPP4GH \SNRPE67 5O @8457>6 56 849IG I8 7JE

)GSO7EEO I6 7JE GEP45656R F4SOEO I8 4F75I6: DSNRPE67 V533 TE E67EGEN TH OEQ4G47E IGNEG:

(-"& 46N -+(&+&(7J5O 7JE =]7JN4H I8 %ETGS4GH0 W@=]:

OoGC%'6"1 @0 OE&6"'M W'0)>5

Date post:	24-Feb-2018
Category:	Documents
Upload:	dennis-pillion
View:	215 times
Download:	0 times

Judge blocks BP funds for Gulf State Park Lodge

Documents