+ All Categories
Home > Documents > K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1...

K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1...

Date post: 31-Jul-2020
Category:

Documents
Upload: others
View: 0 times
Download: 0 times
Download Report this document
Share this document with a friend
244
ɇȺɐȱɈɇȺɅɖɇȺ ȺɄȺȾȿɆȱə ɇȺɍɄ ɍɄɊȺȲɇɂ ȱɇɋɌɂɌɍɌ ɋɈɐȱɈɅɈȽȱȲ ɋɍɋɉȱɅɖɇȺ ɌɊȺɇɋɎɈɊɆȺɐȱə : ɄɈɇɐȿɉɌɍȺɅȱɁȺɐȱə , ɌȿɇȾȿɇɐȱȲ , ɍɄɊȺȲɇɋɖɄɂɃ ȾɈɋȼȱȾ Ʉɢʀɜ 2004
Transcript
Page 1: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

:

, ,

2004

Page 2: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

ISBN 966-02-3264-0

ISBN 966-02-3264-0

: , , -/ . , . – .:

, 2004. – 244 .

SOCIAL TRANSFORMATION: CONCEPTUALISATION, TRENDS AND UKRAINIANEXPERIENCE / Ed. by V.Tancher and V.Stepanenko. – .: Institute ofSociology of NAS of Ukraine, 2004. – 244 p.

60.5 90

. 3 27.05 2003 .

60.5

© , 2004

:, , , , , ,

-

XX–XX . --

. --

– , , -

( ), e , -

, .,

, , , , , ,

.

The monography of the scholars of the Institute of Sociology of the Ukrainian Academyof Sciences is one of the first complex research in Ukrainian sociology and social scienceson the reflection and analysis of the social transformations at the edge of the XX–XXIcenturies. Theoretical conceptualisation of the global social transformation is projected byauthors through the prism of a real experience of complex transformation processes whichtaken place in Ukraine today. It is analysed the actual for the Ukraine’s transformationcontemporary theoretical models and strategies of social transformations, that are: postmodernvisions, the concept of civil society and its social-political applications, the theories of newcommunicative paradigms in the mutual relationship of the power and the public (publicrelations), conceptualisation of the role of traditions in social transformations, the issues ofsocial identity and contemporary versions of the theory of conflict.

The authors hope that proposed book can find its readers not only in the circle of socialscientists, researchers, lecturers, students and post-graduate students in humanities, but italso could be useful for politicians and people who are interested in the issues of socialtransformations.

Page 3: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

, ) ............... 5

) .................................................. 13

) ............................................... 27

) ........................................................ 49

V

) ........................... 73

V

: ) ....................................... 99

V

) ........................ 121

V

, ) ......... 172

V

, ) .................... 211

Page 4: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

CONTENT

IntroductionSOCIOLOGICAL THEORY IN THE PERSRECTIVE OF SOCIALTRANSFORMATION (V.Stepanenko, V.Tancher) .................................... 5

Chapter SOCIOLOGICAL CONCEPTUALISATIONOF THE CONTRADICTORY PROCESSOF MODERNISATION (V.Tancher) ....................................................... 13

Chapter SOCIAL TRANSFORMATIONS AND THE CHALLENGESOF SOCIOLOGY OF 21-ST CENTURY (V.Tancher) ............................... 27

ChapterSOCIAL TRANSFORMATION AS THE DESTRUCTIONAND THE CHOICE OF TRADITION (V.Burlachuk) ............................. 49

Chapter VTHE CONCEPT OF CIVIL SOCIETYIN THE REFLECTION ON POST-COMMUNISTSOCIAL TRANSFORMATION (V.Stepanenko) ..................................... 73

Chapter VCIVIL SOCIETY AND CIVIL NATION:THE ISSUES AND PERSPECTIVES OF THEIRFORMATION IN UKRAINE (V.Stepanenko) ......................................... 99

Chapter VTHE SYSTEM OF PUBLIC RELATIONS AS A FACTOROF A CIVIL SOCIETY BUILDING (V.Korolko) ................................... 121

Chapter VSOCIAL IDENTIFICATIONOF UKRAINIAN SOCIETY (V.Tarasenko, O.Ivanenko) ...................... 172

Chapter VTHE CONCEPTUALISATION OF SOCIAL TRANSFORMATIONAS A THEORETICAL-METHODOLOGICAL ANALYSISOF SOCIAL CONFLICTS (O.Ivanenko, V.Kazakov) ........................... 211

Page 5: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

5

. . , ,

, ,,

, . -, , -

, -, (

) , , -

, --

, , -

( , ), .

.

?

? , -

?

XXI , .

, , . -

- XIX–XX . -

Page 6: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

6

. , , , , -

, , , , ,-

.-

, , “ -”, “ ”,“ ”, “ -

” , “ ”, “”, “ ” .

-, -

-. -

, -.

., -

-.

, , -

. ( , , -) – , -

, ,, -

, , . -

, ,, ,

, -, , -

, , .

, ,

Page 7: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

7

, , .

-

. -. ,

(), -

, -. , ,

-, .

---

.,

- – , -

, ( ),

-, ,

. , -

, ,-

.-

, -.

, --

, - [1, .2], -

Page 8: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

8

, -, ,

.-

, ,, -

. --

, , ,

. --

.

“ ”, , -

. --

, , , -

, , . , -

, -,

. -

, -, ,

-. -

, ,

, , -, , , -

. -

.

Page 9: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

9

“ -”, , ,

, -

, ,. -

, , -, ,

. , , , XVIII–

XIX , , -.-

, , --

, , ,,

” .--

. --

: “ -” -

(consociational) ( ), , ( ) -

. -

, .

“” “ -

: ” -

, “” “ ”.

,

Page 10: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

1 0

-. ,

- 1980–1990-

, .

(”) ,

. . -

-. -

, - “ ”, -

. “ ” -

, , ,

, ,.

-, , -

. --

.-

, ,

. -, -

-, . -

“ ” ( -), -

Page 11: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

1 1

, ,-

, -, .

“” -

— --

“ ” (PR).

PR. , - PR

;,

. “ ” ( -

) --

,

( ), , .

“”-.

, ,

--

, . -,

, -.

Page 12: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

1 2

, , -

. , - – -

. ,

, -. : -

-, -, , ,

-, -

. -

. -

, , , , -,

.

1. .: D’Anieri P., Kravchuk R., Kuzio T. Politics and Society in Ukraine. –New York, 1999.

2. . : -. – ., 2000.

Page 13: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

1 3

, 1980- . ,

, .-

, , -, ,

. -, , , , .

, , -

, .

. -.

– -, -

, , ,

.-

, , , , , ,.

---

. , -,

. , , -

Page 14: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

1 4

, .

,

, ” -,

. , .

, ,

. : -

, , , - [1, .5].

, : , ,

, – , , ,

, – , -.

, -, , ,

, -. – -

-, , -

, . , -

, .

. , .

, , , ,

, , , . --

Page 15: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

1 5 ...

, -, , -

, . .

., , “ ”,

[2, .358]. “ : ”

[3, .18]. - “ ”,

” “ ” [4, .364].

,:

-.

, -, , , -

-. -

, [1, .5]. “ -

” , - “ ” (radical imagination),

, -, “ ” (institutional

imaginary) [5].

, “ ” -

-. , ,

, “ ” -, [6].

Page 16: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

1 6

“ ” -

, , -, ,

, ” [7]. -, , , ,

-. -

. , , -, ,

. ,

, . , , . -

: , , , ,

. -. -

, ,.

., -

. -.

, . ( -

), , ( , -

), . ,

, , , . , -

, , -, , -

. -.

Page 17: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

1 7 ...

, .

, -.

-, -

-.

, ,

. “ ”, -

, ,. -

. ,

, , -.

, , ,.

, , -

. , --

. -

, , , -

. , – .,

, , , .

, , -, .

, , – , -

.

Page 18: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

1 8

“ ” “ -” ,

, , , –

, . , , ,

, [8]. “ -

”. - “ ”,

-,

, . -, -

, – , .

, “ ”, “ -”, .

, – “ ”, “

, ”, .

“ -”, .

, , , ,

” [10, .137]. , “”. ,

, .-

, , -, -

. , ,

[9, .17]., -

,

Page 19: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

1 9 ...

, , , “ ”, – .

-, ,

“ ”, – [9, .64].

“” -

. , “ -, ”,

“ , “ ” (spaceof reasons),

, ” [12, .47].

, . -

. -

, “ -, , , -

, , -”. “

”, ( -), ( -

) [12].-

, : -

[11].-

[13]., “ -

”, ,

,

[14].

Page 20: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

2 0

, – ” . -

, “ – ” -. -

. “ ” -

, .

, , -,

. , -, “ ”,

“ ”, “ ” “ ” [15].,

, ,, “ ” ( ),

. -, -

,.

, --

, .--

. ” -

[16]., -

. ., -

, -. -

, , , ,

. “,

”, – .

Page 21: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

2 1 ...

, “ ”, ,

, [16, .238]., -

, -. .

. , , -

. “ , ”. ,

, , -, . -

, . - “ ” ,

. “, .

. : ” ” “” .

” [16, .236]. -, , “ -

”, , ,, -

, . ,-

. -, , -

, . -

, “ -, , -

. , . ,

” [16, .237].-

, “ ”, “ ”,”, “ ” . “ -

: , , , ”. , -

Page 22: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

2 2

, ,, , -

. -.

“ ” ,,

., , , -

, ,

, , -,

.

, . . , ,

, , , -

.

-, , -

, , , . , -

-, , -

“ ” . --

“ ”,, “ -

”, . “ ”

“ ” , -

Page 23: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

2 3 ...

, , “ ”.

. , , -

, .

, , , “ ”

“ ”.-

. . , -, , -

, , -. -

, ,

. -. ,

, , -

, “ ”, , .

, -, -

, .

, ., -

, , -,

, -,

. ,

”, “ ”,. ,

Page 24: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

2 4

– , , -

. ,

” – ., “

, ,

, , , . -

,” [1, .8].

“ ” -,

, -. -

, , “”, . ,

, , ,

.-

, -, , – -

“ ”, , ,

(the Self) (the Other).

, , . -, -

“ ” -. , ,

, , .

, , -. -

, . “ ”.

Page 25: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

2 5 ...

: , -

.

.

. --

. , . -

-

. . -, -

, . , , -

.-

, , -,

. -,

, . “ ”

. , -, “ ”, ,

.-

. --

. -

.

( , , , ) – -. , “ -”, , -

Page 26: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

2 6

, , , .

, , -, , , , , ,

, .

,

.

1. Delanty G. Social Theory in a Changing World. – Cambridge: Polity Press,1999.

2. Arnason J. Social Theory and Japanese Experience: The Dual Civilization. –London: Kegan Paul Intern, 1977.

3. Wagner P. The Sociology of Modernity: Liberty and Discipline. – L.: Sage,1994.

4. Gouldner A.W. The Two Marxisms: Contradictions and Anomalies in theDevelopment Theory. – L.: Polity Press, 1980.

5. Castioriadis C. The Imaginatory Institution of Society. – Cambridge: PolityPress, 1987.

6. Habermas J. Theory of Communicative Action. – L.: Heinemann, 1984.7. Touraine A. Society Turns Back upon Itself // Contemporary Social Theo-

ry / Ed. by A.Elliott. – Oxford: Blackwell Pub, 1999. – P.131–142.8. Touraine A. Critique of Modernity. – Oxford: Blackwell Pub., 1992.9. . . – .: , 2002.10. Beck U. Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity – L.: SASE, 1992.11. Bell D. The Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism. – L.: Heinemann, 1979.12. . . – .: , 2002.13. Barber B. Jihad vs MacWorld. – N.Y.: Palatine, 1996.14. Luhmann N. Observations on Modernity. – Stanford: Stan. Univ. Press,

1998.15. . //

. – 2003. – 12. – .80–93.16. Bauman Z. Modernity and Ambivalence. – Cambridge: Polity Press, 1991.

Page 27: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

2 7

, -. ,

-. ,

. , -

. , -, -

, ,

. -, ,

, , . “ . ”

, ,, , , -

, , -. “ ”, -

,-

– -.

, “ -,

” [1, .2]. , – , , ,

– , -

Page 28: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

2 8

, “ ”, “ ”, “ -”. , . -

, -, .

-. , -, “ ”,

( , “ ”), - ( ) .

, , , ( -

, ). , -, ,

.,

, , -, -

“ ”, , -, ,

, “ ”, ,

, .

, . -, ,

, -,

. , , , -, ,

“ ”, ,, ?

, – -, , -

, -. , -

, , -

, ,

Page 29: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

2 9

-, -

, , -, ,

. , ,

, , , ., “ -

. -, -

” [1, .2]. “”, , .

-: -

, ,

, , , , -

. -,

, , .-

, , -

, . - “ ”,

. -, ,

, , -, , , -

., -

( ) ,, -

, , ,, . -

. , ,

, -.

Page 30: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

3 0

, .

, , ,, -

, -, -

, -.

-, -

.-

, , -, , . “

” (1992), “ ” (1998), “ -, ” (1999)

” (1994), “, ” (1999) , -

-, , , , -

[2].,

, -, -

. , , “

”. , , -

; .

, , -.

-, “ ”

“ ” [3,.140]. “ ” (natural

attitude) “ ” (reflexive attitude). -

-.

Page 31: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

3 1

” , , -

, “ -”, ,

, . ,

-. -, –

, -, .

, – ., -

, ,

, . -

. -, -

. , , : (

), ( ,), ,

, . , -

. . “ ”,

-, , .

-, . -

, -. , -

. , . -

, , -, ,

: , [4].

Page 32: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

3 2

, , -.

[4].-

, . , -

, .. ,

” -, “ ”. -

,, “ ” “ ”, -

. , -.

, -. ( )

.

-, , -

. “ ” “ ”, -

, -

. -, , -

, , - [3].

, - – , -

, , .

, , -.

-. “ -

” ( ). , ,.

Page 33: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

3 3

,, -

: , -, , , , . -

, , , .

, -, . -

, .

, -, , -

, . -, ,

. --

. -.

- ( -

, ). -, , ,

-. -,

.

. ,, -

., ,

, .

, , --

. , -, , ,

. , -. .

Page 34: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

3 4

, , -

.-

, , -, -

. , “

, , ”.

. , , .

( , , -) ,

. - ( ), , -

-.

, .-

. ,, -

, , . , -. , -

-,

, . , -

, -. , -

, .

. , -.

-. ,

Page 35: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

3 5

, , , , -

-,

, . -.

, , -, , -

, ” [5]. ,-

. – -,

. ,

...”, – [5].. -

, ,. , -

,, .

“ ” . – , -

. – , ,

. -, “ ” “ ” [6]. , ,

, -, , -

.-

. -, -

, – -.

. - – -

Page 36: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

3 6

– -,

( ) .

, -, -

. – -,

. -,

, .,

“ ”, , -

. , , , , -,

. , -, “ -

” , -, -

[7]., -

, ,

. .

, .,

: , -

.) , -

, , . , -

, . , -, “ ”. -

Page 37: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

3 7

. VIII . ,

, .-

,

, ,. -

, - – -

. -,

, -, , -

, -. -

: “ ”, -

, “ ” -. – “ ” -

., , -

. -,

, -. , ,

., -

,

, , “ ” “

., ,

.

, . -.

Page 38: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

3 8

“ ”, -, . -

– , - “ ”: –

, , , -. ,

-. ,

– , “ -”, .

, . ,

-, , , , -

“ ” (“complexity studies”) “ -” (“cultural studies”), -

. , , “ ” – -

, . . -, ,

, , -, , . – ,

, .

, , ,

, -, , . -

: “ ”.: -

? -, -

. ,

. , -, “ ” -, -

, . ,

[7].

Page 39: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

3 9

“ ”, -, -

, “ ” -, , -

, .

, , “ ”

, , , -

, , -, ,

, , , ,

. –

, -” [7, .190].

, - – -

., ,

. , -,

. -, -

, , . – -

, , -, ,

, , .

, , .

” ., -

, , .

Page 40: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

4 0

, ,,

. “ ”

[7, .191]. , , -

, . ,

, -.

, , (

, -) -

, , :,

. -, “ -

” ( ,,

, – ). ,

, -;

, : ( , -

, .) -, , , ,

( -), -

;-

, , -, , ,

. – , -

, , . – ,

-

Page 41: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

4 1

, , ,

, ., “ -

” -, “ -

” “ ” . , ”, .

– “ ”. - (ISA) V ( -

, 1998 .) , “ ” [8].

? ”, “ ”, “ ” ,

“ ” .,

, .

-, .

, , . , -

“ ”, -. -

“ ”[7, .220]. ,

, . -, -, – , -

, , , . “ ”,

. , : , -

, ( , ,

). – -, , ,

, , -. , -

Page 42: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

4 2

. , – ,. . -

. , -, , -

[7, .222]., , . , -

-, .

, “ ”

(formative thinkers), . ( - – ,

, – -, .)

, , , -

, . -, . ,

. ,

, ,.

“ ” , -

, , . - “ ” ,

. “ ”

, , -, , ,

, -. -

, -

. – -

, ,– -

Page 43: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

4 3

, -. -

., -

, . ,

: ,, , -

. ( -, , , ) . -

, “ ”.

“ ” -.

, , - – , – ,

– .-

, -, , –

( ), ) ( ) ) ,

. “ -...” [7, .229]. “ -

” , , -,

. , .” , ,

. “ ” -, , -

: , , – . -

--

., , -

(the challenges), -

Page 44: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

4 4

. “ -”, – .

-

. -, ,

. ”, -

, .

, ,.

, -, .

“ ” -, ,

. - “ ”, -

, , -, -, ,

. -, .

, , -

. -, .

– , , -. . -

, “ ”, “ ”, “ ”

. -, -

,, ,

.

Page 45: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

4 5

, , , . -

, , -, .

. -,

, . , “ ”,

. , ,

. ”.

, , ., “ -

”, “ ” . -,

. , - “ ”. –

, , -

“ ” : “ ” “ ” ,, ,

, – ., -

, , . -

, ,” “ ”, [10].

, -, -

, , . , – -

– “ -” , , -

, , , . -

, . , -

Page 46: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

4 6

, . “ ” , . -

, . “, ” [9, .68].

, : , , . – -

, , -, , .

, , ., -

, . , -

, – ( -) ( ).

. -, ,

, , . , -

, , , -, ,

, , -, ,

. ,, “ ”. ,

, , . -

, , , . , , -

, - [10, .67].

: , -

, , -, .

, , .

, ,-

Page 47: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

4 7

. . -, , -

. “ ” ”, -

, -, . , -

“ ” , -, -

., , , ,

, -. “ ” -

-, “ , -

”. , .

, , , , -

, -.

-. , –

, -. , – ,

, “ ”, ,

( , , ). -

, , -, -

.-

, .

-

Page 48: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

4 8

, -, .

, , , , -

, , -, .

1. The New Social Theory Reader // Contemporary Debates / Eds by S.Seidman,J.Alexander. – L.; N.Y.: Rutledge, 2001.

2. Contemporary Social Theory / Ed. by A. Elliott. – Oxford: Blackwell Publ.,1999; Lash.S. Another Modernity. A Different Rationality. – Oxford: BlackwellPub, 1994; Delanty. G. Social Theory in a Changing World. – Cambridge: PolityPress, 1999; Beck U., Giddens A., Lash S. Reflexive Modernization. – Cambridge:Polity, 1999; Beck U. Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity. – L.: Sage, 1992;Giddens A. The Third Way. – Cambridge: Polity Press, 1998.

3. . . – : , 2003.4. Luhmann N. Observations on Modernity. – Stanford: Stan. Univ. Press, 1998.5. Delanty. G. Social Theory in a Changing World. – Cambridge: Polity Press,

1999.6. Giddens A. The Consequence of Modernity. – Stanford: Un.Press, 1990.7. Wallerstein I. The End of the World as We Know it. Science for the Twenty-

First Century. – L.: Un of Minnesota Press, 1999.8. Wallerstein I. Presidential ddress. Fourteenth World Congress of Socio-

logy. – Montreal. – 1998. – July 26; Unthinking Social Science: the Limits ofNineteenth-Century Paradigms. – Cambridge: Polity Press, 1991.

9. Macintyre. A. Whose Justice? Which Rationality? – Notre Dame: Unof NotreDame Pr., 1988.

10. Prigogine I. La fin des certitudes – Paris: Odile Jacob, 1996; The End ofCertainty: Time, Chaos, and the New Laws of Nature. – N.Y.: Free Press, 1997.

Page 49: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

4 9

, ,, -

, , -. , , , .

, , ,

, .

, , , -

. –

, . , , , , -

, -, , , .

-.

: , , – .

,: -

., -

XVIII XIX ,

Page 50: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

5 0

, -.

, -, -

, -.

, ,,

, -, .

, ” .

, ., , -

, ., -

, . -

., ,

”, “ ”.-

. -, -

. -, .

, -, -

, . , -, ,

: , , -, . ,

, , . -

, ..

. , ,

Page 51: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

5 1

(“ ”, “ ”, “ ”,”) ,

. , “ ”, , .

, ( ), ,

, . .

, , , -.

. :”, “ ”, “ ”, “ ”, “ ” . -

“ ” , ., , -

“ ” “ ”. , -, ,

. – ,. -

., ,

, -. , -

-, .

, , ,

“ ” [1, .628], -, -

. , , -

. , -.

Page 52: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

5 2

, “ ” -. , –

, , , . “ -, -

. , , -” [2, c.14].

, -, ,

, , .

, , -, , :

, . ,

, , . , , -

, ( -, – -

, )., ,

. , .

-. “ , (

), . , ,

! –” [3, c.213].

-. -

. .

. , “”, . XV

Page 53: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

5 3

-. , -

-. -

. (“ ”) -

, .

, .

. --

. -, .

, , , “ ” .

, -, – . -

, , -, -

.,

,

, .--

. -.

: -. ,

, , , – -, ,

”, “ ”, “ ”, . , , - (600 -

Page 54: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

5 4

). – , -. , , ,

“ -” .

, , , ,, , -

.

., ,

, -,

-. , -

: “ ?” , , .

, , , -, . -

.,

, . . -

, – -, , -

, .

, . “ ” , -

, . , . -

, , , , , , . -

. -. ,

,.

.

Page 55: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

5 5

, ,?

, , -, -

?

, , , . -

, -.

“ -”, .

” , -.

, ” “ ” . “ ” -

(traditur) - “ ” , -

“ ”. , , , ,

. “ ” (“ ” “ -

” ).,

, “ ” ( ), “ ”, “ ”

. , , , . -

, “ ”, “ ”, “ ”., , -

, -. – -

, , , -, .

, , -, -

, , -

Page 56: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

5 6

, ., , -

, , -,

.

, , , , , -

.

, , . “ -

, , ... , ad originem,

, , “ ” , . : ,

, , , , -. -

“ ” “ ”, -,

” [4, c.91].,

: () ( -

). , “ ”. -

, ., , -

, , –, . -

“ ” ” ”, , , , , -

.

, -: ,

, .

Page 57: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

5 7

:,

. : , -

(“ ”); , ; - ( ), .

, ,,

, , ,

.,

, -.

, “ ” “”, .

, , – .

, “ ”. ,

, , , --

., -

, -.

.-

, . ,

. , , , , -

. -. : “ -

, -, “ ”

. - anamnesis’a, -

” [4, c.140].

Page 58: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

5 8

, ,

-, . -

, . , -

, -.

, -.

, .

”, “ ”, “ ”, “ ” “ ” -, . -

, .

, : “ ”, “”, “ -

, ”.. -

, -. ,

, – . , -

, . “ -” , “ ” – ,

“ ” – .

, -, .

, -. -

, , .

, -

Page 59: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

5 9

. , . ,

“ ”., , ,

, , . ,

.

. -,

., -

“ ” “ -” “ ,

”. , , , ,

.-

, , -.

, “ ”, “ ”, “ ” ., ,

, , -

. -, -

, . “” ,

: “ ” -, .

, -, . ,

, .

, – , -, .

.

Page 60: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

6 0

-. -

, ,, . , -

., -

-,

[5, .97]. ,

.,

, , . -

– -.

. ,

. -.

. , -, . ,

.: , -

.,

, . -. -

. , , . ,

, , -. ,

: , , .-

. : -.

Page 61: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

6 1

. , . “

, . ,

, , ..., . ,

, . -

, , . , ,

” [5, .102].,

. ”, . -

, . , , .

-. -

, , . -

., , , . -

, , -. -

, -.

, : “ , ,”.

-. “ – , “ ” -

, ” ” , ” [6].

, -.

-.

. , .

Page 62: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

6 2

, . , ,

. -.

, . -

.

-, . -

, , . – . ,

“ -”. , -

.1922

. – - – , -

.: “ .

: “ -. !”

-. : “ .

. : ”. . -

. “ . . . -

!” -. ,

. – “ -” – “ ”.

. ” [7]. -: -

., , 1921- . ,

, ,

Page 63: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

6 3

, -, .

, , .

, , -. -

, . ,

, .

, , , , – .

. -,

. ,, -

, .-

. , . -

-, .

, , ,

, .

, -.

, , .

. , , . –

. - “ ”: “ ”, “ ”, “ -

”, “ ”. , - “ ”, ,

.

Page 64: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

6 4

, , -. -

, , , “ -”.

, -

: “ ”. -, “ ”, “ ”: “ ”, “ ”. -

“ ” “ ” -, -

.” , -

“ ” , “ ” , , -. , , – -

“ ”. , -

. , ,

, , -. -

, -, , “ ” ,

.-

, , - “ ”,

. ,

, -, , .

, -.

-. , -

, .

. , .

Page 65: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

6 5

, -, .

, . --

. , , , –

, , , . -, , -

.-

, , -. , -

, . -

. , ,

, .

, -, .

, , , ,.

, , , -

, -. “ -

, , -, ,

, , -,

” [8, .127]., , -

, . ,

. ,

, . “ ”,, , -

Page 66: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

6 6

. --

, . , ,

.

, -. , -

, -

. , -

, , . -

. , .

, .

, -, ,

( ). – ,

, ., , -

, . -,

. , , -, -.

, . , -

. , , ( ).

, , , . , ,

, , -: , .

Page 67: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

6 7

, .

. -, , . , ( -

, , ) . -

. , -.

, “ , , ,

, . ,

, , -

” [8, .138]. -, , , -

, , .

, , ,

, -,

. ,

, .-

, , “ ”. -

, , -

. , , , , , -

., -

. -,

. , “ , ,, -

, ” [8, .241].

Page 68: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

6 8

: -

, . -, -

. ” (1874) -

: .

. , , ), , -

, . , ?

, ?, , , -

, -, .

, ” “ ”.

, , .

“ ” “ ” -. “ ” “ ” – ,

. , -,

, -, , .

, , , -.

, - “ ”, “ ”, “ ”.

, , -, , .

, ( -

), ., ,

. ,

Page 69: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

6 9

, -. , , ,

, , , ., (

, -) , -

. , -, Imperfectum. -

, ,,

, .,

, , . , –

, -.

, – , – , -

: , , -

, : -,

. -, , ,

” [9, .162].: , -

, , ,

[9, .163]. -, “ ” “ -

”. -. -

. , , .

, , , .

“ ”.

Page 70: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

7 0

. , , -

, . “ , -” [9, .163].

, .

., -

. , -, , . “ , , ,

– , , ,

, , , , -

, – ” [9, .164].

-. , -

. “ -”, “ , -

”, “ , ”.,

-., -

, . -,

.,

, . , -, ,

, , , – . -

, .?

, -? XIX , ,

, -

Page 71: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

7 1

, . , -,

, ,, , -

, . “ , – , –

” [9, .172]. -, -

. -,

..

.,

, . -, . -

, , .

,. -

,-

. “ , , , -

, -, -

” [9, .174]., -

., , -

, “ ”. -

. , , XIX -, . – -

.

, . -, ,

,

Page 72: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

7 2

, .

, -. -

, “ -”, ,

.-

“ ”. , -

, . , – -

, “ ”, “ -”, -

, .-

, . : , , -

, ?, “ ”,

“ ”, “ ”, “ ?”

1 . // . . – ., 1990.

2. . : . – .,1988.

3. . . – ., 1990.4. . / . . – ., 1995.5 . . – ., 2000.6. . . – ., 2000.7. . . – ., 2000.8. . . – ., 2000.9. . // . . :

2- . – ., 1990. – .1.

Page 73: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

7 3

V

-, -

, , , , ,

, , . --

, , C -.

XX “ ” -, -

, “ ” [1]., “ ”, “ ”, “ ”, “

” -

1980–1990- .--

. , – -

, – .

( -) -

, .

,

Page 74: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V7 4

. 1970- , -

. - “ ” -

, . , ,

( -)

., , -

“ -” (remembering the dead)

. , “ ,

” “ ” “ ” , , - “ ” “ ” [2, c.78]. , -

, -: “ 1980- -

, “ ”. 1980–1990-

” [3, c.397]., 1980–1990-

-

. (,

” )

. -, , ( -

)

. “ , –, – -

, , ,

” [4, c.29]. , -, 1980- – 1990-

, .

Page 75: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

7 5 ...

1980-versus ”

. , -

, , ,, -

, -. , -

., -

( , , , ), ( , , ) ( ,

) , , “ ( -

. – .) , -

“ ” [4, c.25]. ,

, -, , -

-.

“ ”, --

, , .

“ -” [5] 1961

, -

.-

.).

-

. -,

Page 76: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V7 6

- ( -

) . -

, -

. -.

, -, ,

“ ” – .,

( , , -) 1 , -

-.

--

, -. ,

, -, – -

. 1980–1990- - ( ) -

, , , , ,

, 1960- . ,

[6, c.102], --

_____________1

, , , , , - “ -

” -.

Page 77: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

7 7 ...

-.

, , -, -

-, , , -

. --

, , -, “

( , , , “ ”, “ ” (statized),

)” [7, c.27–28]. - 1980- -, -

, ” [7, .27]. , -

-, -

,, . -

,-

. , , , -

, “ ” (

).

1980–1990- -.

-,

, -

.

Page 78: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V7 8

--

. , -

-

1980- , . -,

. – ,

– 1980 ( -

) - 1981 . – 1981

1989 – -

1989 . -, -

. --

, -

. , , ,

.

, -, -

-.

1980- -

Page 79: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

7 9 ...

. ,, ,

- [8, c.917]. ,

“ ” .--

, , ,, -

– --

. , -, ,

[9,c.75], 1980- -

, -

.,

1970- – 1980-

? ( )?

1970-, -

( 1975) -

[8, c.919]. , “” ,

, , .

-, , , , -

: “ -, , , ”.

Page 80: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V8 0

, [10], --

, -,

. , -1, , -

, -., ,

, -, . ,

-

, -, (

) [12, .47].

, -, ,

[ ]. --

, -, .

, -

( , , ) - ( , ).

“ ” --

, -

. “ ” --

_____________1 [11],

“ -” , “ ” ,

.

Page 81: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

8 1 ...

, -

. ( -

. , [13], -

, ).

– – ,

, , ( -

), , -. , , -

,, , -

, -,

, . ( -

), -. , “ ” -

1950- , , , .

, “ , -, ” [8,

c.921]., -

, , 1960-, , –

., -

, . -

, , --

. 1976 -

Page 82: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V8 2

, , “ -

” , “ -,

-” [14, c.147],

-.

– 1970-. -

-, ,

-. – -

( R), , , -

– -. , R -

, , ,

, ..

- 1970- -

. --

, -. ,

, “ -” . -

. – , -

(), ,

, -

Page 83: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

8 3 ...

“ ” ( --

), -,

. 1970-. ,

: “ , , -, -

, () , -

, : -, -

” [8, c.923].-

, --

. -, ,

, --

“ ” (), -

., , ,

: -. -

-,

, . ,

, .

-.

, , -

Page 84: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V8 4

, -. 1979

II . , -

, -, -

. - 1979 -

, -, -

, , -

.

, , -

[8, c.924]..

1980 --

. -

. -,

. , -, “ ”

, “ ” [8, c.925].-

. -, -

. --

. -

Page 85: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

8 5 ...

, --

. , -, ,

. , -.

,

-. ,

, -. -

, , , -, ,

. , -

. , ,

1970- ,

– ., -

--

. , -

, -, -

. - [10], ,

1980 , , , , , -

.,

, -

Page 86: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V8 6

, ( , ) --

. . -

, -.

.-

: , -, -

16- - [5].

, , -

1980- , 1989 .

- ( ) -

-,

, ,

1980- .

1970- – 1980- . , , ,

. , -

( ) , ., , -

, -, -

-.

Page 87: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

8 7 ...

“ ” :

1980--

. [15]

“ ”, , -

. – –

, -

. -

. 1980- , , -

, -

. -

. “ ”, , ,

, [ . : 16, .87], -

. -

-1 , , , .

rendszervátlás, [17, c.2].

, , -

, ( ) -. -

_____________1 -

”.

Page 88: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V8 8

- ( ) .

1980- ., ,

, , - “ ”,

. -, “ -

”1 --

. , : --

, , - “ ”. -

( , ,),

-.

, 1980- , -

, -, -

, , – -. ,

, -, .

-, -

( ) _____________1 “ ”

“ ” - ( ) -

.

Page 89: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

8 9 ...

. 1980- , -

[18, c.101], , , . , “ -

, [ -

1980- – 1990- . – .] ” [18, c.101]., , , , -

- 1980- , , -

1970- . ,

-, , -

. , 1 – -

--

. , -

, – ---

1990- ., -

( ) --

, , -,

, . -_____________1 ,

, , , , -

.

Page 90: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V9 0

, 1 . -

, , , .

-. -

“ - (civil), ,

(uncivil) , ?” [19, .2], 1990- ,

. -, , 1970-

, . ( , )

1970- . , , -

, -.

1980- . -,

, : “ - ( ) -

. - ( )

” [20, c.761]., -

, [21], -, “ -

” [20, c.773] 1980- .

_____________1 , “ -

” (civil society), “ ” (civil economy) “ -” (civility) .

Page 91: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

9 1 ...

, – 1980-

, ,, “ ” -

. [22] , ,

. [23, c.120], 1980- 70% -

,

. ,

, (

), , “ ”, , - – . ,

– , ,

– -” [18, .103].

, “ ” , -

1980- – 1990- . -

, ).,

, , -, .

-

1980- .

-.

, -

Page 92: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V9 2

, .

, , ,

-, -

- [23, c.122].

--

.-

1988 . -

, ( 1990 ) –, (FIDESZ),

, ,

(SzDSz), , (MDF),

.--

– , “ ” (agencies).

, -,

.

, . -

-, -

1970- – 1980- [12, c.52]. -

, ,

1980- .

Page 93: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

9 3 ...

, -.

--

( ), -

. , )

1980- . , -

, . -,

, .

, – [12, c.52].

-. “ , – ,

, – -

” . : 12, c.52].,

. -

“ ”, 1987 .

, -, -

, -, -

, , .

, , -

-

Page 94: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V9 4

. , ,

, -, “ -

” . -, -

. , , -

1991 , -.

17 (“ , …”). -, , ,

, [23, c.137].

, , -, -

, --

, 1989 . , -

. --

, , , -.

– 1848 -

1956 . , -

, [18, c.106].

XIX 1956 ( )

, -. -

23 16 , - – 1956 – -

,

Page 95: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

9 5 ...

. 16 1989 , - 1956

-, [18,

c.107]. - 1956 ,

, . , 1980- -

( ) , 1956, ,

[18, c.108]. ,

“ ” ?

. - 1980- – 1990- -

, , :

1) -,

,; ,

, -

;2)

( , , ), ( , -

, , ) ;3)

: a) ,

; ) -, -

– ; ) -

Page 96: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V9 6

1980- ; ) -

; ) - 1848 1956 – -

1956 .

“ ” “ -” -

, --

. ,, -

- 1989 ( )

: -, [21, .72].

. - (

) . , ,

,

“ ” -, , -

( , 1990- ).

. , , -

- “ ”, -

., ( -

“ ” ) . -

Page 97: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

9 7 ...

-.

, ,

( , -) .

, -.

1. Kumar K. Civil Society: an Enquiry into the Usefulness of an HistoricalTerm // The British Journal of Sociology. – 1993. – Vol.44. – P.375–392.

2. . . – ., 2001.3. Bryant C. Social Self-Organisation, Civility and Sociology: a Comment on

Kumar’s ‘Civil Society’ // The British Journal of Sociology. – 1993. – Vol. 44. –P. 397–401.

4. ., . , // . – 1996. – 1. – .25–31.

5. . . – , 2000.6. Nash K. Contemporary Political Sociology. Globalization, Politics and Po-

wer. – London, 2000.7. Bauman Z. After the Patronage State: a Model in Search of Class Interest //

The New Great Transformation? Change and Continuity in East-Central Europe /Ed. by C.Bryant, E.Mokrzycki. – London, 1994. – P.14–36.

8. Matynia E. The Lost Treasure of Solidarity // Social Research. – 2001. –Vol.68. – 4. – P.917–937.

9. Michta A. Democratic Consolidation in Poland after 1989 // The Consolidationof Democracy in East-Central Europe / Ed. by K.Dawisha, B.Parrott. – Cambridge,1997.

10. Spoleczenstwo Polskie Czasu Kryzysu / Ed.by S.Nowak. – Warszawa, 1983.11. . // -

. – 1994. – 1. – .35–52.12. Arato A. Civil Society, Constitution, and Legitimacy. – Lanham, 2000.13. Pérez-Díaz V. Spain at the Crossroads. – Cambridge, 1999.14. Michnik A. New Evolutionism. Letters from Prison. – Berkeley, 1985.15. Dahrendorf R. Reflections on the Revolutions in Europe. – London, 1994.

Page 98: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V9 8

16. Dahrendorf R. After 1989: Morals, Revolutions and Civil Society. –Houndmills, 1997.

17. Bryant G.A., Mokrzycki E. Theorizing the Changes in East-Central Euro-pe // The New Great Transformation? Change and Continuity in East-Central Euro-pe. – London, 1994. – P.1–14.

18. Arato A. Revolution and Restoration: On the Origins of Right-Wing Radi-cal Ideology in Hungary // The New Great Transformation? Change and Conti-nuity in East-Central Europe / Ed. by G.A.Bryant, E.Mokrzycki. – London, 1994. –P. 99–120.

19. Rose R. Towards a Civil Economy? – Glasgow, 1992.20. Frentzel-Zagórska J. Civil Society in Poland and Hungary // Soviet Stu-

dies. – 1990. – Vol. 40 – P.759–777.21. Szelényi I. Socialist Entrepreneurs. – Madison, 1993.22. Burawoy M., Lukács J. The Radiant Past: Ideology and Reality in Hunga-

ry’s Road to Capitalism. – Chicago, 1995.23. Szalai E. The Power Structure in Hungary after Political Transition // The

New Great Transformation? Change and Continuity in East-Central Europe / Ed.by G.A.Bryant, E.Mokrzycki. – London, 1994. – P.120–143.

24. Bryant G.A. Economic Utopianism and Sociological Realism. Strategies forTransformation in East-Central Europe // The New Great Transformation? Changeand Continuity in East-Central Europe / Ed. by G.A.Bryant, E.Mokrzycki. – Lon-don, 1994. – P.58–78.

Page 99: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

9 9

V

:

- ( ) , –

- – ,

. , -, – -

. “ ” -, , , -

, , -

,, , -

--

, -.

“ ” -. -

-, , ,

.

. ,

( ) ,

Page 100: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V100

, , ,. , ,

, , “ -” ( , , “ -

” – nation-state), . ,

, -, “ ” , -

-.

, -

, -.-

XX , -. ,

: 1) -; 2)

3) - [1, . 255–256].

, . ,

-,

. -,

, . -

, -, -

. “ –

” . ,-

, ,

Page 101: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

101: ...

-. “ -

” ), -

( ), , , -

-.

:

, --

. – “?” .

: “ -

?” [2, .1]. , , – -, , ?

, -?

, ,

, “ ” – - “ ” “ ” . -

, , -, -

. -

. -

. (civic

nation) -, .

--

Page 102: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V102

. , -

. , , , , , “ -

” , . . -

“ ” ,

. , -, ,

– , .

-, , , , , -

. --

. , -. ,

– . ( -

, -,

.) ( -

) , , , ,. -

– , , – -

. [3], , .

), -,

-” [4, .24], -

. ( -

Page 103: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

103: ...

), -

( ). , -

- – . “

, -, “ ”- – -

” [5, .89]. ,

, -, .

-, -

-

.

-

[6, .168–173]. -, – , -

– (Volk-centered) .--

, -. -

, , (Volksgemeinschaft). -

“” (jus soli – jus sangunis), – -

(jus sangunis) [6]. ,

, , 1980-

. , ,,-

“ ”

Page 104: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V104

, -

[7, .103].

? ---,

. , [8, .104–105], -

- ( -

). , , , , .

, , -

. , -

-.

, , . ,

( , ), - “ -

” (inclusive) . ,

[9, .136–158]. , -, , -

-. -

, ,

. ,-

Page 105: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

105: ...

- “ ” -

. ( -, , -

,

-.)

( ) --

. –

. XX , : -

-, , -

, - – .

- XVIII . -

“ ” – - ( “ ”)

.,

– -.

, -, -

, “ -” [10, . 74].

, ,

, -. , ,

--

[10, .71]. , -,

, , -

Page 106: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V106

, – , , , .

, , . -

, ,

. -, , , ,

-. , -

-

.

, - “ ”,

,

. “ ” -

. ,

., -

, -.

, --

, ,

, ”.

,

Page 107: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

107: ...

[11, .5] --

, .

-, -

– , - ( , “ -

”) . ,

. -

. , .-

, , - [12, .10] -

, . ( , , )

? ? , ,

-, -

? - “ ” -

.

. --

, -. -

. ,, “

” – “ ”. , 11 -

“ -”. “ ” -

: -

Page 108: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V108

( ),

- “ ” ,

. (

“ ” -).

- ( , ),

-, -

. [13, .141]

-. , ,

-. -

( ), ,

. , , “ -

”. ,

, , ,

, ,-

. , ,

, “” (“the only game in town”) [12, .5]. -

“ ” ?”, – “

?”. , -, -

( ) , -.

[14, .35–50]

Page 109: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

109: ...

– , ( ..). ,

. -, -

, , , -, -

[12, .35].

.

, -,

, – – .

, , .

, --

, ( -).

“ ”. -, -

-.

. --

)

Page 110: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V110

-.

, -

“ ”. “ ” , -

“ -” – .

-,

,,

. , “ -

” [12, . 17], --

. -,

. , .

(nation-states)-

, , -.

: “ , -”. , ,

“ ” , [5], .

. --

. , -, -

.

. , -

Page 111: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

111: ...

. , -;

XVIII–XIX [15]. -

[16,. 70]. , -

– , “ -” ( ) , -

. -

-. “ ”

-, . ,

: -, , -

[17, .232]. , -, ,

, -, “ ”, “ -

” (community-oriented) [17, .232], – ., “ ”

, , , “ -” [9, .145].

, , -

. , -

– - -,

. , ,

-, -

,

Page 112: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V112

, ( -, , ). -

, -, “ ” (an ‘etatic identity) [14, .41 ], ,

, ., ,

( ) .,

--

, -

., ,

-

[18]. - [19; 20].

-, -

.,

“ , ” [21, .313], , -

. “ ”.

:

( -)

- “ ” ? -

,-

, . --

.

Page 113: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

113: ...

, - “ -

” ( ), -, -

1

, - [20, .110–116]. ,

, - ( , ,

), . , , 35%

“ ” 2000 ( 47% 1990- -) [19].

, .

, , , - “ ” , – -

() .

, , ,

, [23], XIX .

- ( , ) -

, , .

– , -

, ._____________1

1998 , (90%) -

(10%). : -

(44%) – (26%) [22, .19].

Page 114: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V114

,

, - 1990- ?

, -

.

– , -. ,

, , 1990- ,

“ ”.

– - [19] – -

, , , (

) . -,

1.

-, -

.-

, ,

– -.

--

_____________1 “ ” (activecitizenship) ,

. .

Page 115: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

115: ...

-, .

1992 [20,.113]. , , -

. -

(: “ , ”).

-, -

-. , -

( ) , -

, , . (“ ”),

, ( ),

( ) . , -

- “ ” ( , , -

, ) .

.

( -

), -. ,

, “ ”

[20].:

“ ”, [1, c.262])

Page 116: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V116

-.

. ,

.

(civic natio-nalism), ,

-. -

, , -

. ,

, , “” -

[24]. , , -

[25, .83], , , -

( ) . --

, , “”,

, “ -” [26, .122]. , -

-? [17,

.232; 25, .88; 27, .107], . [24] : -

, -, -

. -,

Page 117: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

117: ...

-.

, , , ,

, , – . -

, -

,

[22, c.26]. , . , , -

, [22, c.18], ,, -

. , --

, , , , , )

. , ,

: “ ( . –.) ,

?” [22, .18]. , -, -

– “” .

– -,

- – -. ,

--

, , , , , ,

. - “ ”, “ -

”, “ ” -, , ( ,

Page 118: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V118

), .

,

, , ( ) , , ,

, -

, [12, . 29]. , , -

, , .

, , - ( ) -

, , .

-

. --

(consociational) [28, .35–36]. -

, .

, ( -

) -

, , . , -

, , ( ,

, - “ ”). -

. , -

Page 119: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

119: ...

, -,

PR-

2002 -. , -

, - [21, .299] – ,

.---

, . , , -

-

. - “ ”, “ ”

, -? .

1. Habermas J. Citizenship and National Identity: Some Reflections on the Fu-ture of Europe // Theorizing Citizenship / Ed. by R.Beiner. – Albany, 1995. –P.252–264.

2. Beiner R. Introduction. Why Citizenship Constitutes a Theoretical Problemin the Last Decade of the Twentieth Century // Theorizing Citizenship / Ed. byR.Beiner. – Albany, 1995. – P.1–14.

3. Kohn H. The Idea of Nationalism. – New York, 1946.4. Kolstø P. Political Construction State. Nation-building in Russia and Post-

Soviet States. – London, 2000.5. . . – ., 1994.6. Brubaker R. Civic and Ethnic Nations in France and Germany // Ethnicity /

Ed. by J.Hutchinson, A.Smith. – Oxford,1996. – P.168–173.7. Fulbrook M. Germany for Germans? Citizenship and Nationality in a Divided

Nation // Citizenship, Nationality and Migration in Europe / Ed. by D.Cesarani,M.Fulbrook. – London; New York, 1996. – P. 88–105.

Page 120: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V120

8. Brubaker R. Nationalism Reframed: Nationhood and the National Questionin the New Europe. – Cambridge, 1996.

9. Bryant C.G.A. Civil Nation, Civil Society, Civil Religion // Civil Society.Theory, History, Comparison / Ed. by J.A.Hall. – Cambridge, 1995. – P. 136–157.

10. Calhoun C. Nationalism. – Buckingham, 1997.11. . :

. – ., 2000.12. Linz J.J., Stepan A. Problems of Democratic Transition and Consolidation.

Southern Europe, South America, and Post-Communist Europe. – Baltimore;London, 1996.

13. . : . – ., 1998.14. Schöpflin G. Nation, Identity, Power. The New Politics of Europe. – London,

2000.15. Gellner E. Nations and Nationalism. – Oxford, 1983.16. Guibernau M. Nationalisms. The Nation-State and Nationalism in the

Twentieth Century. – Cambridge, 1996.17. Schnapper D. Beyond the Opposition: Civic Nation versus Ethnic Nation //

Rethinking Nationalism / Ed. by J.Couture et al. – Calgary, 1998. – P.219–234.18. . -

// . – 1999. – 5. – .91–104.19. . // . – 2001. – 2–8 .20. . : -

// : , , . – 2002. –2. – .102–121.

21. . . – ., 2000.22. Wallace C. Xenophobia in Post-communist Europe. – Glasgow, 1999.23. Weber E. Peasants into Frenchmen: The Modernization of Rural France,

1870–1914. – Stanford, 1976.24. Vos L. Nationalism, Democracy, and the Belgian State // Europe’s New

Nationalism. States and Minorities in Conflict / Ed. by R.Caplan, J.Feffer. – NewYork; Oxford, 1996. – P.85–100.

25. Casanova J. Ethno-linguistic and Religious Pluralism and Democratic Con-struction in Ukraine // Post-Soviet Political Order. Conflict and State Building / Ed.by B.R.Rubin, J.Snyder. – London; New York, 1998. – P.81–103.

26. ., . - // : . – ., 1997. – C.88– 129.

27. Kymlicka W. Minority Nationalism within Liberal Democracies // The Rightsof Nations. Nations and Nationalism in a Changing World / Ed. by D.M.Clarke,C.Jones. – New York, 1999. – . 100–126.

28. . . -. – ., 1997.

Page 121: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

121

V

-,-

“ ” (PR) – , -

-.

, -

, -. ( )

, -

, -, .

, -

, -. -

, , - (

), , , -

. -, -

, .

Page 122: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V122

-.

-, -

. , ,

, -.

-,

.

. , --

, -. -

, , XXI , .

, , , , -

, . , “ -

”, ,, -

, , -

. , -

.

, – -, -

. -, , . , -

, -. , -

, -

Page 123: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

123 ...

, ,

.--

. , --

. ,, -

, . -

, , , -

.

, .-

. , -, -

, , , , -

, -. -

-.

-. -

, , ,

, -

. -

. , , , -

1990- ., -

, , -

Page 124: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V124

( , , ) :

, , , . , -

, – .

. , .

, 1990-, -

, - ( , ) -

.

1992 “ ”, “ -: ,

-; -

, -…” [1].

“ ” -, “

”. - ( ),

. -, -. -

. -,

“ , , ”, , . , -

“-

”, 1997 , “ ” .

“ -, , , ,

, , ” [2].

Page 125: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

125 ...

-, “ ”

“ ,, -

, -” [1, .21]. ,

: , , ,

, -” [1, .21].

( , -), “ ”

., -

, . , -

-, . , -

, -,

( , , ).

. ,,

) ) ( ). -

, - – -

, ,.

, “ ” -

: – , -, -.

-,

Page 126: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V126

. , , -, “ -

” , , “ ” ( ), ,

.-

1996 , , -

. -.

( - 1990- )

,

. (-

, -

.) , .

, ., -

, ( ),

, . , -,

, , ,

( ).,

-. -

, : ,

, , -.

, ,

Page 127: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

127 ...

, --

. - – ,

, -, .

,

, ,

. , , , -

, ( -

), ( ), . , -

, -, -

, -

. , , -

.-

, . -

, , -

( , , ) ,

. , -, -

, -. ,

, – -. -

“ ” ( ) -

Page 128: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V128

, ( “ ”),

.

, ,

.

, - ( -

) . --

, , , -

., -

-, ,

, -, .

, -

, .

, -, -

, -.

, , , -.

, -

, . –

? --

, .

Page 129: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

129 ...

, --

.

-,

, ( , , -

).-

. , -

. , , -,

, . -, ,

-, , “ ”.

“ ”

, -. :

, -, .

, ,

”, 1 2002 [3]. “ ” 2 2002

: “ -... “ ”...

: , -

. , , ,

, , , . . .

: .

Page 130: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V130

, -. , ,

. . -

... [ ]. . , ,

, -. ” [4].

, -. -

,-

, , .

-. -

“ ” “ , ” “ , ”, , -

, , .--

, -, . -

, “ ”, --

. -. -

, , -

. , ,

. , , , -

, -. -

Page 131: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

131 ...

“ -”.

. -, -

( ) ( )

. – , –

. , .

, - “ ”.

-, -

, –

( , , , -) .

– , -

, -, .

PR -, -

. PR -

, .

, – , -

( ) , -, -

.,

.

Page 132: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V132

1. ,

. -,

, , .

2. -, , -

. ( ) , -

. - ( , ,

), , , .

-

( ) . “PR- ” ( PR). -

( , , ) --

.3. ,

. ( , “ PR”), : -

( , ), ( , PR ). , “ PR”,

, - ( PR- , -

), (PR- -, )

(PR- , , PR). PR -

PR- ( -, , ), -

( PR), , ,

.4. , , –

, , -

Page 133: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

133 ...

-. , ,

, - – -

.5.

, :) PR – ( -

), ,

; ) , -,

; ) , -; ) , -

,

.6. PR -

, .7. ( ) ,

PR. , ,

: PR;; -

; -.

, , - PR- .

, -, , -

, .,

, , .

, , -

, ( ) . -

Page 134: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V134

- PR,

“ ”, -

. -, ,

. PR , -

. PR,

, -, , –

, ,

, , , -

, , . PR ( -

) . -, -

. , – -

[5].-

- PR. : ,

PR ;, ,

; , -

., , -

, PR- , .

PR- , XIX ., : “ -

”, “ ” “ ”. :

Page 135: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

135 ...

, ; ( )

( “ ” ); -; -;

” . ( -

) , ., . -

-, , -

( ) .,

, , , - “ ” -

, ). “ -

” PR- -. -

. - “ PR” -

, (). ,

, ( ),

“ ” . PR- “ ”,

: “ -”, “ ”.

”. XX .

.:

; ; -

, . ., “ ” -

:

Page 136: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V136

; PR “ ”,

, , ., ,

( ) , -

. PR- – “ -

”. : -, ,

, . ,

“ ”, PR ,, .

“ ”: ). -

PR- , . PR- ,

“ ”. -: PR- -

; PR- – ( “ ”);

, , -, ,

, ; - PR- -

. PR-

: ;

PR- , , “ ”,

. “ ” , PR

( ,, , “ ”).

PR ( , PR): -

Page 137: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

137 ...

,; ,

PR- -, ; - PR- (

( ), ); PR- .

PR , -

, , -

. 1990- “ ” “ -

” -, “ ”, , .”, ,

”, -, ,

, -.

, “ ”

. “ ” “ ” , -

, , .

, -. ,

, , ,

, – , PR- -

.,

, -, , .

-, , -

-. , , ( -

Page 138: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V138

), -.

1996 --

. --

, “ ” “ ”

, .

“ ” .

. -

– , , , . -

, ,

.,

-. -

, -.

, . -.

,

: -, - ( ) (

) ; , -

, . -

( ), -.

Page 139: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

139 ...

, , -

, , – -.

, -, .

“ -”,

“ ” ( ), , , .

, ,

., , -

, --

. -,

. , -

, . , – -

, .-

, - ( ).

,

( -) .

, -. . -

, . ,

-, .

Page 140: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V140

, , , , ,

( ).

-, -

, ( ).

-, -

. , -

.,

, -

. “ ” , ( )

. ( )

. ()

( -) -

( ). -, PR-

( ).

, -, . , PR- -

-. -

, , -

, , . ,

PR--

Page 141: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

141 ...

. -

, . , PR- -

, - ( , )

. PR -

. -. ,

, -, ,

. “ -”, “ ”, ,

, -, .

-

). , ..

--

, PR- , -.

PR- , .

PR --

. , -, -

. , ,

. , “”

(, 1995 -

022000 – “ ” 40 ).

Page 142: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V142

, -.

, -. ,

, --

, , -. ( , , -

, .)

-, , -

. , PR , , -

? PR -

? , PR

, -? , , - PR-

?-

PR, PR- .

-.

, -, PR.

, , ( -) ,

Page 143: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

143 ...

. -, -

, -.

PR, , , -

. ,

) , .

PR- , -. , PR, -

, , . PR -

, ,-

..

. -,

PR. , – - PR, ,

, , , [6].

, , “PR ,

” [7, . 1701 ] . PR, , PR- “ -

, , “ ”, _____________1 , -

PR, - ( , , ) . -

, -. , ,

(PR) -.

Page 144: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V144

, ..., ... -

, , ..., ” [8]., ,

PR- , . –, -

. , PR- , -

. , PR- -,

, – , . PR-

” --

. , -, ,

, , -.

, – , – ,, “ ” [7, . 170].

. “ ” -

“ ” , . (

( ) ), .

“ -”, . , -

. – , -

, .

PR- . : “, -

PR- , , -.

Page 145: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

145 ...

, -, ” [7, . 178].

, ” (participation frameworks),

PR ., , ,

: , - (principal, author, animator). , -

, -. – -

, ( ) [9].

( ) – -, . – ,

. [10] – “ ”,

, , -. – -

, , –, -

. “ ”

“ ”. ( , -, PR- )

, , . , , “ ”,

, ,, -

, ., PR- , ,

, , -, PR- . ,

, , , -, PR- , -

. , , ,

“ ” – ,. PR-

, , . -

Page 146: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V146

- “ ”

.. -

, .

, [11], : . -

, , – , -

. , , -,

, -, .

, , , ,

PR- – , -, .

, , , , ,

, PR- - [19].

, PR-), ,

, -. ( -

), . -,

, – ,

., -

, -. , -

. PR ,

, , PR- -

. , --

.

Page 147: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

147 ...

. , PR- -,

. ,

, [13], , -

. PR- -,

. , , PR-

. PR- --

, -.

,

PR. , , ,

[14].,

-.

. PR -: ,

, ,.

. PR -, , ,

, PR. , , , -

, , -. , -

, [15]. PR -

, . -, PR- -

: -; ;

; -.

Page 148: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V148

. ,, -

. -

, PR-.

, , -. ,

“” [16]. -

. PR -, , -

, , ,. , , , PR, -

, , “ ” , “ -” “ ”. PR- , ,

, , . “

” ( ) , “ , PR- ” [17].

, -; PR- -

.

, .

, -.

– , .

-.

, .

, -.

,.

, -.

Page 149: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

149 ...

, --

. , ,, -

-. ,

, ,

. PR ,

, -,

. , , -

., PR -

, , : 1) ;

2) ; 3) , -

; 4) PR- -, -

; 5) .

, , “ ”.

-.

, “ ”, “ ”,”, “ ”.

., , , , -

. --

, ., -

, -, . -

Page 150: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V150

, , , ,

, -. , -

.-

, , -, . -

, , “ -, ,

“ ” ( ) -, ,

. , , , ( -

) ” [18]., -

, , , -

. ,, [19] -

( , -), , (

) .

, --

. , , -

. - ( ) , , -

, ,

[20, . 236]. , , , –. -

– -.

, -. :

Page 151: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

151 ...

) -, , “

( ) ” [20,. 239]. ,

, -. , , ,

“ ”, , , , -

. , -

. , ,

, , .

-, .

, , -,

. , (

) . , , -

., -

. – -, ,

. -,

– , , , , . --

, .

, , -

. , -; -

, ;

-

Page 152: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V152

, , ., ,

, -, .

, .

, , . , -

. , , – , -, , , – -

, , . -

, “, ” [21, . 134]. -

, , , , .

, - PR – -

, , ,

, – ), -

-.

-, [22, . 35–37]1.

_____________1 PR -

, – , . -

– , --

. , ,

“ ” “ ”.

Page 153: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

153 ...

1. PR- -. “ -

” , “”. ,

. -, PR- , -, PR-

, . , PR- ,

. 2. PR- -

, . “ ”

, , PR- - PR- . , -

, PR- , -, . -

, PR-, PR- , ,

. PR- .

3. PR- . -,

. -, ,

, .

, ,

” [23]. , ,-

, . 4. PR-

., -

, , , . -. ,

. , --

Page 154: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V154

, ( ) .

5. PR- -.

PR , -. , PR- -

, -. , ,

. 6. PR- .

, , -, , .

, , , , -

, [24]. , PR-

, .

7. PR-, . -

PR- -: , -

. , . PR-

, . 8. PR- -

. “ ” -, ,

. , PR- -. -

. , -

( ) -. , PR-

., , ,

, . , ,

PR, -, .

Page 155: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

155 ...

,, -

, 1.-

. -, -

, , -. , , ,

, . “

, – , – -”.

, -, [25]. , -

--

PR- ., , -

. “ ” “

”. ( -

), ( , , -), -

. , -, [15],

“, -

” [22]. , , , : 1) -

_____________1 “ ” ,

“ ”, - (IABC). -

PR- -. -

“ ”. ( PR

), .

Page 156: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V156

, 2) , 3) 4) .

PR-

. “”, [20]. ,

, , -, – -

, . ,, ( )

, . , ,

, , -, .

, -, PR

, :1) ;2) ;3) ;4) ;5) ;6) ;7) ;8) .

, - PR- -

-, PR-

. -, ,

, , , PR- -. , ,

, “ ”. -

.

Page 157: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

157 ...

, , -

PR ., PR -

, ,. -

, : PR, , , -

- [26].

PR, , , -

., -

.

, - PR ,

-,

PR , -. , PR – -

, “ ”, - ( PR- ) .

PR, . PR -

- PR, , -

, -.,

“ PR”, , -

Page 158: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V158

PR. - PR, PR- - ( ,

, ) , ( )

(“ ”) , , .

, , .

, , , , ,

, ., PR

. , , PR

, -

. - PR

, ,

, , , .

, , PR ,

, , “ -” [27]. PR

, , PR “ -”, “ ,

, , , -

” [28]. , , PR “ ” [29]. -

- PR , “

”, , PR - [30].

, PR, -

Page 159: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

159 ...

( ), -.

-. -

, “ ”, “ ” “ PR”, -

, , “ ” [31].

, , “ -

”, .

, , PR. -

, , , -, .

, --

. , PR , -

, -.

, , .

, , , ,, ,

PR- , , -

[32]. ,

, [33].

, , , - PR

, - ( ,

– ). , , , , , PR

, -

Page 160: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V160

. -, -

.

, -, , PR,

.

, , PR, ”. -

PR -,

PR, -, -

[34]. - PR,

. , PR, -

-, -

, .

, , -. -

, , -.

, PR -, -

, PR -

, -.

, . -

. PR – . ,

, PR- , , -, , , -

. -

Page 161: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

161 ...

, “ ” -

-.

, “ ” -. ,

, -, -

. , -

, .

PR. -,

, -.

, , . -, -

PR, .

PR . ,

.O , PR , -

[35]. , -, PR -

[36]. -, , ,

- [37].

PR . , [38],

[39] PR, -, , “ ”

[40] , , “ ” - (

, , , ) [41]. -, PR -

. ,

Page 162: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V162

, , PR-,

.

- PR -

(“ ”). , “ PR”,

, , [42]. -

, , PR- -

, - PR.

, . , , -

PR, , ---

.

PR. , - PR -

PR. , PR – , , -, , . ,

PR- , , , 1989 , -

: “PR – , , , ... ,,

PR?” [43]. , PR- , -, , -

, , .

. PR, “ PR- ”,

, - PR- “ ” [44].

PR - “ ”, -

Page 163: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

163 ...

PR- Hill & Knowlton - [45], PR

, PR [46]. PR

-, -

PR IX – . “ ” ,

PR- -. , PR- -

, – , – [47].

, PR,, , -

, , ,

.

PR

. ,

. , , -

. -.

, --

, , , -

.PR -

, , -, -

. PR ( “ -”, ),

()

. , -, -

Page 164: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V164

, , PR . -

, , -.

:, -;

, -

, ;,

.

, , , , -

, PR

.

, PR ” “ -

” “ ”) , , -. ” ” -

, . “

” PR , ,

PR . PR -

. “ ” ? ,

, “ ” “ ”?. , ,

: . ( , .), ,

, . , ,

, , -.

Page 165: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

165 ...

, -, -

. -, , .

, “... -

. , , ”[48, .20]. ,

, . , , ,

[48, . 21].

“” “ ”. . , , ,

PR- , ,

. -, , ,

, , , . -

PR, [49].

, PR , -

, . -, PR- ,

, . , , ?

PR

, , , , –

. ,, “... , ,

, . ,

” [50]., PR

, -

Page 166: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V166

, -. -

, , , , . -

, -, -

, ., , -

, -, .

“ -” “ ” . -

, .To “ ” PR.

, – , – -,

” [51, .6]. .To -, -

:. -

.. -

.. , -

. , “, , ”.

.. “ , ,

” [51, .12–14]., PR

[52]. -. , , -

“ ”, , , [40].

, ., -: – , -

. , . “ , -

Page 167: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

167 ...

, , ... , ” [52, . 235].

“ , , , -, ”. “ -

” [52, .236].

– “ , ,”. , -, -

, “ ” [52, . 237]. “ , , , -

, , ”. , , -

. , , , “ -

” . , - [52, . 237].

, ( ), -, -

, , . ,

-. , -

“ ”, , , , .

, “ -”: , ,

[52, . 315]., -

. , , “ , -

”. -: , “

” “ ” -, [52, . 239].

, -, . ( -

), ,

Page 168: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V168

( , ) -, , .

. , -, , “

” , , “” [53].

: “ -,

, , , ” [54].

, - (“ ”) ,

. -, ,

, -. -

, , -.

, - ( ), -

, [52, .244]., -

“ ” PR., PR:

: PR , ,

, , , . PR

, ,.

:1)

, -.

2) -, . , -

, , -

[52, .377].

Page 169: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

169 ...

, PR

-. , -

-.

PR ,

, . ,” , , -

, -. , -

, -, .

1. “ ” 2657- 2 1992 . –. 10 // . – ., 2003.2.

-” 539/97- 23 1997 . – . 6 //

: 1 2001 / .; . . – .: , 2001.

3. “ -” 1 2002 .

4. . // . – 2002. – 138. –2 .

5. Grunig J. What Kind of Public Relations do you Practice? New Theory ofPublic Relations Present Four Models // Pr Reporter: Purview. – 1984. – April 9. –Vol. 27. – P.1.

6. Grunig J.E.,Hunt T. Managing Public Relations. – New York, 1984. – P.6.7. Cheney G. The Corporate Person (Re)Presents Itself // Rhetorical and Critical

Approaches to Public Relations / Ed. by E. L. Toth, R. L. Heath. – S.l., 1992.8. Heath R.L. A Theoretical Approach to Zones of Meaning and Organizational

Prerogatives // Public Relations Review. – 1993. – 19. – P.141.9. Goffman E. Forms of Talk. – Philadelphia, 1981. – P.144.10. Schiffrin D. The Management of Co-operative Self During Argument: The

Role of Opinions and Stories // Conflict Talk: Sociolinguistic Investigations ofArguments and Conversation / Ed. by A. Grimshaw. – Cambridge, 1990. – P. 242.

11. Clegg S.R. Frameworks of Power. – London, 1989.

Page 170: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V170

12. Creedon P.J. Acknowledging the Infrasystem: A Critical Feminist Analysesof System Theory // Public Relations Review. – 1993. – 19. – P.157–166.

13. Grunig J.E. Organizations, Environments, and Models of Public Relations //Public Relations Research and Education. –1984. – 1. – P.6–29.

14. Spicer C. Organizational Public Relations: A Political Perspective. – S.l.,1997. – P.22.

15. Collier M.J., Thomas M. Cultural Identity: An Interpretive Perspective //Theories in International Communication / Ed. by Y.Y.Kim, W.B.Gudykunst. – S.l.,1988.

16. Carbaugh D. (ed.) Cultural Communication and Intercultural Contact. –S.l., 1990. – P.7.

17. Heath R.L. Critical Perspectives on Public Relations // Rhetorical and CriticalApproaches to Public Relations / Ed. by E.L. Toth, R.L. Heath. – S.l., 1992. – P.42.

18. Kim Y.Y., Gudykunst W.B. (Eds.) Theories in Intercultural Communicati-on. – Newbury Park, 1988. – P.16.

19. Banks S.P. Multicultural Public Relations: A Social-Interpretive Ap-proach. – Ames, 2000.

20. Penman R. Good Theory and Good Practice: An Argument in Progress //Communication Theory. – 1992. – 2.

21. Leeds-Hurwitz W. Forum Introduction: Social Approach to InterpersonalCommunication. // Communication Theory. – 1992. – 2.

22. Banks S.P. Multicultural Public Relations: A Social-Interpretive Approach.– Ames, 2000.

23. Ting-Toomey S. Communicative Resourcefulness: An Identity NegotiationPerspective // International Communication Competence / Ed. by R.L. Wiseman, J.Koester. – Bewerly Hills, 1993.

24. Fisher W. Human Communication as Narration: Toward a Philosophy ofReason, Value, and Action. – Columbia, 1987. – P.73.

25. Gudykunst W.B. Bridging Difference: Effective Intergroup Communicati-on. – Newbury Park, 1991. – P.101.

26. Grunig J. What Kind of Public Relations do you Practice? New Theory ofPublic Relations Present Four Models // Pr Reporter: Purview. – 1984. – April 9. –Vol.27. – P.10.

27. Tedlow R. S. Keeping the Corporate Image: Public Relations and Business1900–1950. – Greenwich, 1979.

28. Pimlott J.A.R. Public Relations and American Democracy. – Princeton, 1951.29. Sussman L.A. The Personnel and Ideology of Public Relations // Public

Opinion Quarterly. – 1949. – 12. – . 697–708.30. Lesly P. Overcoming Opposition. – Englewood Cliffs, 1984.31. .: Pielle Public Relations Consultancy Newsletter (1988, January). –

London, 1988.32. Goldhaber G.M., Dennis H.S., Richetto G.M., Wiio 0.A. Information

Strategies: New Pathways to Corporate Power. – Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 1979.33. Hofstede G. Angola Coffee – Or the Confrontation of an Organization with

Changing Values in its Environment // Organization Studies. – 1980. – 1. – .21–40.

Page 171: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

171 ...

34. Excellence in Public Relations and Communication Management / Ed. byJames E.Grunig, David M.Doier. – N.J., 1992.

35. Olasky M.N. Corporate Public Relations: A New Historical Perspective. –N.J., 1987; Olasky M.N. The Aborted Debate within Public Relations: An throughKuhn’s Paradigm Approach / Ed by Grunig J.E., Grunig L.A. Public RelationsResearch Annual. – Vol.1. – N.J., 1989.

36. Candy 0.H., Jr. Beyond Agenda Selling: Information Subsidies and PublicPolicy. – Norwood, 1982.

37. Rakow L.F. From the Feminization of Public Relations to the Promise ofFeminism // Beyond the Velvet Ghetto / Ed by E.L.Toth, C.0.Cline. – San Francisco,1989.

38. Smilowitz M., Pearson R. Traditional, Enlightened, and InterpretivePerspectives on Corporate Annual Giving // Public Relations Theory / Ed. by –C.H.Botan, V.T.Hazleton, Jr. Hillsdale, NJ, 1989. – .83–98.

39. Cheney G., Dionisopoulos G.N. Public Relations? No, Relations with Publics:A Rhetorical-organizational Approach to Contemporary Corporate Communicati-on // Public Relations Theory / Ed by C.H.Botan, V.Hazleton, Jr.– Hillsdale, NJ,1989. – .135–158.

40. Habermas J. The Theory of Communicative Action. – Vol.I. – Boston, 1984.41. Gusfield J.R. Kenneth Burke on Symbols and Society. – Chicago, 1989.42. Excellence in Public Relations and Communication Management / Ed. by

J.E.Grunig, D.M.Doier. – N.J., 1992.43. The Ragan Report. – 1989. – March 20.44. Wood R. J., Gunther M. Confessions of a PR man. – New York, 1988.45. Dilenschneider R.L. Power and Influence. – New York, 1990.46. Bernays E.L. [Review of Robert L. Dilenschneider’s Power and Influence]. –

Public Relations Review. – 1990. – 16(2). – .82–83.47. Kotler P., Andreasen A.R. Strategic Marketing for Nonprofit Organizations

(3rd ed.). – Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 1987.48.Tuleja T. Beyond the Bottom Line. – New York, 1985.49. Grunig J.E., Hunt T. Managing Public Relations. – New York; Winston,

1984.50. Booth W.C. Mere Rhetoric, Rhetoric & the Search for Common Lear-

ning // Common Learning: A Carnegie Colloquium on General Education / Ed. byE.I.Boye.r – Washington, 1981.

51. Cheney G., Tompkins P.K. Toward an Ethic of Identification // Paper Presentedat the Burke Conference. – Philadelphia, 1984. – March. – .6.

52. Pearson R. A Theory of Public Relations Ethics. – Unpublished DoctoralDissertation. – Athens, 1989.

53. Ackerman B.A. Social Justice in the Liberal State. – New Haven, 1980.54. Pearson R. Beyond Ethical Relativism in Public Relations // Coorientation,

Rules, and the Idea of Communication Symmetry / Ed by J.E. Grunig, L.A.Grunig.Public Relations Research Annual. – N.J., 1989. – Vol. 1. – .72.

Page 172: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

172

V

, , . -

[1, c.71]., , -

, : , -

. , , , .

: ( ), - ( ),

( , -), ( ) [2]. ,

?,

. , -

, , , , -, . -

-. , , , -

, , . ,

- ( )

, .

. , -

Page 173: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

173

, . ,

, -

. -, -

. , - ( ),

: ) ) -. -

, , ( ). -

, -, .

, , , .

, . , , -, : 1) -

-, 2)

: , , ,, 3) ,

., ,

, -, , -

. -. , -

( ), ( ), – -

, . , --

. , -

, ( “ ”

, ) [3, c.9], -

Page 174: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V174

, . , “ ”, “ ”, “ -

”, . – . -

, ,. -

, : - ( ). , -

, -,

– . -, ,

. ,

: – . – – , -

, , ( -

), , .

.

, -.

, “ ” ., -

, -,

.--

– , , -. ,

– , ,

. , -

, , , . –

,

Page 175: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

175

. - – -

, , -,

.

, . , -

, ,

--

. -,

. ,,

, . , -

, , . , -

, , . -

, .

. , ,

. - “ ” -

. -:

? ? ? ?

: , -. ,

,, .

, -,

-

Page 176: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V176

. , -.

, , ,,

. -, -

.

, -:

. , .

-, , ,

, , , ,, .

. -, -

, , ,

. , , -

-

-. -

, . –

, , -, -

: -, ,

. () “ ” .

., -

-, “ -

Page 177: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

177

”. , . -

, .

-. -

, ( , -,

), -, .

.-

, , ( -

), ( ), , – -

, , -. , , ,

, 70–80 --

; -, ( )

--

, ; , , ,

, , -.

– -, -

, “ ”, ,

, , , , .

,,

, “ ”

( ), ,

Page 178: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V178

-. , -

, . -

, , - “ ”, , 1990

.--

, ”.

: , , -, , ,

.,

, , ,

. , , (“ -

”): 1) ( , -, , , ,

); 2) , -; 3) -

. , , , , -

, . -

, , .

, – -; , – -

; 4) “ ” , “ , ”.

, , -

, -, , ( ) -

“ ” . -

Page 179: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

179

, – . (

) , –

” , -, , .

:;

; ., -

,

, , , . -

, -, . ( ), ,

, , – , -

. , --

, , ( ) ,

., “ ”, ( )

-. ,

, ,

., , -

, . , , ?

, , -, -

? ,, , -

, , .

Page 180: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V180

. , , ,, ( -

) – ? , ,

, ? ,

, , -.

:, , -

( , , -, ), – “ ”,

, ( , , -), , , . -

, -

, . -

, -

, – .

– -. , , -

. , , , -

. - – , –

, “ ” ( ) - [4, c.9].

. , . -

, – , – - “ - – ,

” [5]. “ ” -

. “... – , – ) . – – -

Page 181: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

181

, , -. –

, , ” [6]. “ ”.

, -.

, . ,

. , -.

, -.

, , -: 1) ,

; 2) ( , , -

). .. -

( , , ), –

( ), ( , ) ( , , , ,

). “ ” (“ -”) “ ” “ ” (“ ”, “ -”). .

, “ ” – -, “

“ ”; , , ” [7,

c.240]. , “ ” -. ( ), -

. , ,

., -

, , ,

Page 182: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V182

. ,,

. , - – “ , ,

” [8, c.205], ( , , ).

-, , ,

. , , -

, , -, .

-,

, “” [9, c.24–40].

.1. , ,

, -, , -

, -,

. , . ,

“ ” – -, .

2. -. -

: -, -

, “ ” ,. -

.3. ,

“ ” -. -

, , , -

.

Page 183: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

183

4. , -, . , ,

( ) -,

, ., -

-,

, --

, , - [9, c.41–43].

: - ” ( ) ” -

? , ?,

. -. , -

, : , , .

. , , , , -

( - – , , ), , -

, .

-, -

. , , : “

, , , , -

, . -;

, . , , ,

. , ”, “ ”, ” [9, c.8].

Page 184: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V184

, ( ) . -

, , .,

.,

, , . ,

-, ,

,

. , -, , ,

. ,

-

. ,

.-

: .

, . -

, , ,

. , . -

., -

, , , -

. “, – , – -

, , -. -

Page 185: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

185

,,

,. -, “ -

” , -

“ ”, , , ” [10, c.15].,

, , --

, ,

.. -

, ( , ),

”, -. , -

., – -

, - ( ), -

( , ) . ?

, – , ,

. , -

, -

, , , -, , ).

, , -

.

Page 186: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V186

, .

-, ( , -

).

, (),

. ( , -

; ; ; -

) [11, c.4] -, , , ,

.,

– -. -

“ ”, -, ,

. , -

, -, , .

“ -” – ,

, , , -, – -

, -. , -

, .

.

, [12].

Page 187: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

187

, .

“ - ( )” [13], ,

., , -

- – – . -

, – ( ) [14].

, .,

, -.

, -.

. , ,

, . - “ ”

. , -, , –

.?

, ,, -

, -, .

, “” , -, , , , , -

. -.

, .169, .

, , -

Page 188: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V188

. , , ,

. “ ”-

. --

.-

, “ ”, -

, , , , , , . , -

, “ -”

, - ( .) -

, . , “ ” “ ” (

) “ ” ( , ) “ -” “ ”. , “ ” -

, ... ? ? “ ” , !

– .: –

, , --

, , , , -. -

, .

5 1998 -: “

. . .

. ? – , , -

” [15].,

. ,

Page 189: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

189

- [16], ,

“ ” . -

31 1999 , -. “ ”,

, . -

, -, – “ -

” , .

, “ ”. –

, -, , -

“ ” , -

, , , , . -

. “ ”

, , , -

, , -, . -

“ ” , , , .

, ,

, -. ,

, 1996 , -

., -

, --

. ,

Page 190: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V190

. -.

, -. -

, . ,

, -. – , , -

. , .

-. -

. ,, – -. -

, , , –, – .

-, -

, , , .

,. -

, -, , -

. , -

“ ” .,

, -. , -

, , , , -

. , -

, .

Page 191: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

191

,.

, , . ,

, : -, ?

, , , . -

, , -

. , -, -

, , .

-, – ,

. “ , – , – --

. , , , , -

, –

. – , -

, , - ” [17, c.61].

. -,

. “ ” -

. .,

, ,

: “ -

Page 192: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V192

” – “ ”, “ – “ ”, “ – ” -. , -

, -, . ,

– , , , , , , ?

, “ ” “ ” . -

“ ” , . .

(“ ”) “ -” “ ?” . ,

, , -, , -

, . “ , – , –

” [18, c.352].

( , , , , -, ) “ ” “ ” .

“ ” : “ -, “ ” -

– . , , , “ ” – . ! -

– . “ -”? -

“Bysiness Week” [19]. , -, .

, “ ” “ ” -. ,

, -. -

, , : 1) -

; 2) -, -

-

Page 193: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

193

; 3) , ,,

; 4) ,

[20, c.46]., , , -

, , “ ”, ,

. “ ” , -

, “ ” “ ” ., , , - – .

, , “ -

” “ ”, , [21].

“ ” .: -

( ). – -. ,

, . , , - – (“ ”), (“ ”),

(“ ”, “ ”) . “ ,, – , –

“ ”, -

” [22, c.162].

. , – , , , -

, ... – , “ ” [23, c.245]. , -

, ” , -

. ,

Page 194: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V194

“ – -” , ,

, “ ” “ ”. -

, – , . , , ,

, , , , -

, , ., –

, – , - “ ” “ ”

. , ,, -

. , ,. -

“ ” “ ” , , -

” [21, c.43]., “ ” ? -

, , , .

, ( -) -

, , “ – ”.

– - – , .

? , -

. – , , . ,

– , , , , , , -

Page 195: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

195

, , . , , , ( ). –

, -,

, – ., -

.,

, .

. , -

, , -, .

: , , -

, , , -, -

. . -

, , , , -

, .

.

-,

, , , ”, ,

, . , -

“ -?”, “ ?”, -. -

.,

-

Page 196: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V196

, -, , -

. . – . , -

, , , -, , – -

. -, ,

-, ,

.

, , -, – , -

. , -: -

. , – . , , -

1994 – 2000 [24], , -: , –

(“ , ”), ,

( . .1). , -, , ,

[25, c.44]. (1994 )

(29,6%) ,

, 2000 22,5%, - 2001 21%.

: 21,4% 1994 28% 2000 ( 29% – 2001).

, . -

10% -, 1997–1999 (38–39%), 30%

2000 33% 2001 .,

, -

Page 197: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

197

, ( - – ) , .

– , ,, ,

, ( -

) ( ), . , ,

, . ,

( ). , “ ”

, , , “ ”,

, “ ” .: “ ” ,

, , .

, -, ,

, . “ ”

“ ”, -

1 (%)

1994

1199

5

1996

1997

1998

1999

2000

29,6 27,8 23,9 20,0 20,0 20,7 22,5

21,4 19,0 23,6 24,1 23,8 23,0 28,3

, 30,9 34,8 33,8 38,0 39,0 38,5 30,4

2,5 2,5 2,4 2,7 3,6 2,8 2,815,1 15,9 16,5 14,9 13,3 14,6 15,5

Page 198: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V198

. , -

, -, , , -

. -,

. “

” ( ) “ -” ( ). -

, , -

-.

: 32% -, , , 44% , -

, 5,5% ,

1., ,

, , -, . -

. -. , , -

, , ,

. , -, , .

, -, -

, -, -

: , ,_____________1 2 6 , -

-. “ -

( )” 2000 . – 1206 .

Page 199: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

199

, , , , , , , -

, , , , ,

, .

. ,, ( ) -, ,

. , -. -

, , . ,

( ) , , -

. --

, “ ” ( )-

, . -, ,

( . . 2). 2

(%))

………………………………………………….…....59,5 ( )..…….…58,0

…………………………………. …………………… …………54,2 ……………… ………….52,8

…………………………………… ……………..44,6……………………………... .34,4

…………………………………..39,0……………………………………………….….26,0

…………..22,2……………………….......10,0

……………………………………….....8,0

, , , , -,

Page 200: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V200

), ,, , – -

. , , , ,

, , --

, ( ), , .

, ( , ,

, ). , , 40% 60% .

“ ” ,.

”, “ -” – -

, . , ,

, , ( ) . -

“ – ”, (

) , “ ” “ ” “ ” -

“ ”. -,

- ( . . 3).

3 (

?”) [27]

, … ..………. 32,0, ……………………………………… .5,5

………………………………………………. 43,6…………………………………………………………. 17,7

“ ”: 44%,

Page 201: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

201

. , , ., – -

, , ,

. ” ( . . 4).

4

“?”) [27]

................18,1...................59,0

, ...............................3,6...................................... 4,7

................... 8,9............................................................................................5,5

, -

. , 77% , , 18%

, -, – 37% , -

, 51% , , ( . . 5).

5, % [27]

…………………………………….. ..36,7, … ….50,8

, …….…..…... 2,2………………………………………...…...1,6

……..…….....6,8

, -, -

, -,

,

Page 202: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V202

, , -. , 90,3% ,

. , -

, , . , 66,8% ,

23,7% , . 26,6% , , 12,2%

, , , 15,9% -. 14,5%

, , , (18,6%). .- , “ -

, , , , , -, . –

: -, , ” [26, c.96].

,

, “ ” -. , -

41,2% 65,5% –. ,

, , 39,0% .

(, ,

), ,

. : ,

. , , -

. :, .

, -. , .

- – -

( . . 6).

Page 203: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

203

6, %

“ …”)

, 74% , , -

.

, , , -

, , . -

. -,

, , .,-

( 58,7%)., -

-, ,

. . – . , – ,

, – ,, ,

, . 52%

, 38,8% ,

( )

, 6,8 92,5

13,4 85,9

12,0 87,44,9 94,8

14,4 85,25,9 93,7

Page 204: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V204

, , 44,9% , -

[27]. - – , -

, .

, -,

(). , 57%

, – , -, , 20%

.,

, -,

. -

: , ,, – -

, , . – ,

, . ,, ,

, 20% ( -!) , , 26% -, [27]. -

( 1998 ) ( 2001), – , –

, , . ,

, , (60%), -

(57%), (64%), (63%).

-- , “ -

” -. “ -

Page 205: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

205

”, , -, ,

).-

. ,

. – “ ”,

, , , , “ ”. -

, -,

– . , -.

, , , ,

, , -,

, -, , [28].

, , , -. , -

2000 , ,

, 69% . 54% , , , .

( 70% 55%)., ,

, , -,

. (, .) ,

, , ? 16%

( 1995 4%). (22%) , -

(1995 17%). , 31% -

, ( 1995 ),

Page 206: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V206

16% , 1995

12% [27]. .

* * *, -

, .

. .

, : – -

, -, – ;

, , “ -

”, , , -. , , ,

, -, “ ” ,

, , , – ,

) . , , , “ ”,

” (“ ”) ., -

, , - “ –

” , , ” (,

, , ). , –

– , -,

, , ( ) -, , “ ”.

, , -

Page 207: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

207

, , . “ ” – , -

. -,

. , – ,.

, , ,-

: , “ ”, “ -”, ” ”, “

”, “” .

, -,

.,

, -.

, -: -

.

, -. ,

“ – ”.,

. – -, , -

,, , , (

”). , , -, ,

, , -. – .

-, ,

. – -,

Page 208: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V208

, , -

, – , - “ ” .

.,

-, ,

, . , -, , ,

. ,

. , , -,

(18,4%), (6,3%). ,,

(47,1%), (2,4%).

, -. -

. , , -

.

. -

, ,

, -.

, .

, -.

, , , -, – :

, “

Page 209: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

209

”, .

, “ ”,, , , -

.,

“ ” – . , , , -

, -. ,

, -,

., -

. ,

. --

. -,

, .,

.

1. . . – ., 2000.2. .: ., ., . -

. – ., 1996.3. .: . //

. – 1969. – 1.4. .: .

: . . ... . . – ., 1997.5. . -

// , 2001. – 24. –14 .6.. . // . – 1999. – 28. –

30 .7. . : 3- . – ., 1977. –

.3. – .

Page 210: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V210

8. . . – ., 1990.9. .: . . -

/ . . – , 1999.10. . . – ., 2001.11. . : // . –

1992. – 6 ( ).12. .: . , . -

. – ., 1997.; ., . (1994–1998 ).

, , ). – ., 1999; : --2000 . . – ., 2000.

13. .: . ( -). – , 1997.14. .: / . . –.1, 2. – ., 1993, 1994; ., . -

// . – 1995. – 6;., ., .

. – .,1996; . // . – 1994. – 10. – .112–123.

15. . // . –1998. – 24 ( ).

16. .

20 1999 //. – 1999. – 95. – 25 .

17. . - // . – 1989. – 6. – .60–63.

18. . ? – ., 1998.19. “ ”? // . – 1994. – 12. – 29 .20. . . – . 1993.21. ., . “ ” “ ” //

. – 1991. – 15. – .43 – 49.22. . “ ” // . – 1991. – 11.23. . // . –

1992. – 5.24. : –2000 .

– ., 2000.25. .

// : –2000 . -. – ., 2000. – .42–47.

26. .: .- . . – ., 1994.27. .: : 1994–2001. -

. – ., 2001.28. .: Uncaptive Minds. – 1993. – Vol. 6. – 2.

Page 211: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

211

V

-

-

. , , . , -

: “ – , – , , -

. ,

, , , “ ”,

” [1, .376–377]., , -

, ,

., ,

, , -, .

, , , . “

-, .

, , , -

. , ” [2, .31].

, -. , -

Page 212: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V212

: ,,

. , .

, -, -

, -,

-,

. “ ” ,

. , ,

, ,, -

, , -, , , -

.,

, .. -

. , . -

, , -, , .

( ) ,, , , ,

– “ ”, “ -”, “ ” .

60- . -

, “ , , ,

” [3, .98–99], , , ,

. -, -

Page 213: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

213 ...

, , , “ , ”, “

” [3, .167]. , , , ” [4,

.70]. -, , ,

, ,, , -

, ., “ -

” [3, .43], ,

, ,,

(). , ,

, , , ,

, , [3, .329]. “ ” -

., ,

– XVIII–XX -

, , . , ( ,, ) -

, -, .

– , , - – ( ),

, -, -

( ), -. -

, “ ”., , -

: , , ,

. ( , ,

Page 214: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V214

, ) ( , , ).

, , [2, .47]. , “ -

”, . , -

, -.

, . -

. -, “ ” “ ”, ,

, -. “ , -

, , -

” [2, .101], , ., , -

., -

. “ -

. “ ”, ,, -

– , -, .

” . , -

. ,, ” [2, .263].

, ; ,-

, , ., :

– , -, ( ) , -

. , -

Page 215: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

215 ...

, , , -, .

, ,-

, , -.

, “ ”, “ ”, , -

, [2, .103]. , “ -

, ” [5, . 214], “ ” , “ ” [2, .288],

, [6, .253], .

, , : , , –

. , – -, . , , -

, , , . . -

, , - – .

, . -

. , , -, : , -

, “”, .

, , , -, , , , -

. , , , , , , “ ”.

,

,

.,

, “ ”,

Page 216: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V216

“ ” [2, .102], , .

“ ”, “ ” -

” [2, .444]. , -, , , -

. , - “ ”: “

, ,

, ” [2, .444]. - “ ” , -

,, , , , [2, .444–445], ,

-; ,

,, , , -

, . , , , ,

. “ -

, , ,, -

” [6, .264]. -, [6,

.270], , [7, .284]., , “ -

, , , ” [7, .285].

,, ,

-, , , .

, -, -

, -, , , -

,

Page 217: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

217 ...

, , -. : ) -

, , , -, ; )

, ; ) , ,

. , -

, , -, ,

, , -, -

.,

– . “ ” “ -

” [2, .292], “ ” - [5, .46]. , “ ”, -

– “ , ” [5, .687], -, (

) ( ), – “ ” “ ”.

-,

, , -.

: , ( ), , -

, . ,: , , ( , , -

). , , : “ -, -

, , ” [8, .152]., -

, , , -, ,

( , , , ,) ,

Page 218: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V218

( , ), , -

, , .:

, , , -. -

, -,

, . -, -

, , .: “ ,

, -.…

. , -,

. , -” [9, .41].

, , , -

, -,

, .

“ ”: “ , -. -

– , ”, – [8, .153].

-, .

.: ,

. “ , -” [8, .154], , , ,

, . , -

( XIX–XX ), ,

Page 219: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

219 ...

, , – . , .

, -,.

, , : “ , ,

, , -. , ,

-, . ,

, ” [8, .155]. , ,

. “ ,,

” [8, .156]., , , ,

, .

, , - –

: : -, “ ” “ ”, -

[8, .46]. , , .

-. , , -

“ ”, – “”, “ ”. ,

, .-

, “”, , , ,

. ,,

., -

, -

Page 220: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V220

, , “ ”. -

, , , , “ -”, -

, , ”. -

, “ ” ,

, .

2. , ,

, , -, , . -

., -

, . ,,

. , -, , – . “ – -

, – ”, – [10, .41]. “ -

”, “ “”, -

: , , , -, ” [11, .142].

, , , , , ,

. , , “ ”

, , , “ , , -

, , , -” [10, .14].

, “ ” “ ”,

, -. -

.

Page 221: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

221 ...

.: “ ”, “ -

”, “ ”, - “ ” ,

., –

, -. , -

– “” [10, .149]. XIX–XX

: -

( ). , “ – ” [10, .102].

, – , . :

, , ,

.: -

, , , , . :

-, , , “ -

, ”,

[10, .57–58]. ,

“ ”, -.

-. ,

1889 -, -

, .

, -. :

Page 222: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V222

, – , -

. “ ”, , -

; .,

, “”, , -

, , ,.

. , , , “ -

”, , , , ( ) , . “” , -

, , -

, -. , ,

, .-

, -. -

, 30- - “ ,

, ” [10, .104]. -,

,.

“ ” –; , “

” ( , , -), –

.-

() ,

Page 223: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

223 ...

. . -

, , -, [10,

.150]. -, , -

, . – , - – , .

. -, “ -

, . ... , -

, -” [10, .143–144].

. : , , -

, , , . , , – -

. , - ( ,

), , .1943

“ ”. -, 1959 , .

-. “ -

”. , -, , -

. , , -

. , , , -

- [12, .187].

, , , ,

,

Page 224: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V224

. , , – ” [10, .68]. , -

“ ” – -. “ ,

, -” [10, .68].

, “ -” [10, .69], -

. – , “ -

” [10, .69].-.

, ,

“ ”,

, , , , .

. , ,

( ) . -

. , -. “ , -

-” [10, .209–210] – ,

. ,, , “ ”. “ -

” [10, .210].

., “ , -

, , , ?

? , ,, , -

?” [10, .210]. ,

.

Page 225: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

225 ...

, -, ,

, , -. -

, , ,

, . “ -, -

, ” [10, .212]. -, .

, , , , . “

”. , . ,

, , . -. ,

, , .

” [10, .213], . ,

. – . ,, –

. “ -

, ”, – [10, .213]. – , . -

: , , -. ,

. -, -

. , , .

“ , -

” [10, .216]., , -

, ,

Page 226: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V226

, , . ,

, , , , -

., -

, , , – .

, -, “ -

, ” [10,.217], .

, ( ), , -

.. , -

, , , -, : -

? ? -

? ( -, -

), -, ,

.

. , “ , -

” [10, .30]. , ,

. , , , -

. -. “ – ”, – -

[10, .56]. -

, “

Page 227: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

227 ...

1989 -”, – [10, .140].

, -, , “

, ,, , ,

” [10, .141]. , -,

, . , -

, .” – , -

“ ” – -. ,

, , ( ,

). , “ -,

(“ ”)” [10, .99]., ( ,

” ), . -, , -

, -. , “ ” -

, ,, .

-,

“ ”, .-

, “,

. , , – -, – ; -

, . , : ” [10, .227]. -

,, -

, .

Page 228: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V228

, “ ” , ,.

, , , .

– , . – -

, , ,

. - – . “ -, , ;

” [10, .229]. : -. -

. , “ ”, -

, .:

, ,

, -.

“ ” – : , ,

. - “ –

, , … ” [10, .236].,

, , . -, “ – !” -

, – . - “ -

” . -

., -

-. -

. ,, .

Page 229: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

229 ...

, -

, . “ ”,

, .,

( , , ),, .

, -, , , -

, , , -.

, , , -

, -, “ ”, “ ”.

, , , -, ,

”, – -. ,

. , -, , -

, --

. -,

, , -

, , . -, -

, -, . ,

, -

, -. , , , , -

, “ -” .

Page 230: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V230

, -, ,

.

, [ .: 15; 16; 17; 18,], -

, “ --

, - –

” [15, .9]. , ( ,

, )

, “ , -”.

, , , - [15, .15; 19, .174; 20, .84].

-, , , , -

, , , “ -

”, “ ” [ .: 21; 23; 24; 25]. ,” , -

, : “ ?”, -

-, -

[15; 16; 20; 26; 27; 28; 29; 30; 31]. - “ ” [15, .7], “

” [32, .395]. , ,

, , , -, -

( , , -, ) [16; 33; 34; 35; 36; 37].

( ) ,. , -

Page 231: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

231 ...

, -, -

. -, , -

, ,, .

-, -

, “ -”, “ ”, -

, ., ,

. “ , ,

, , , -

, “ ” , -

” [25, .60]. , , , , , ,

, “ -, -

“ ” .

[25, .26]. ” [38, .98–99], –

, “ -”, “ -

” [39, .16–17]. “ ”,

. “” – ,

. “ “

”, , , -

Page 232: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V232

, -” [25, .27].

, – . “ ”

“ ” - “ ” . -

-,

. -, -

, , , -, . -, ,

, . ( ) : , ( , -)

, . –

, ,-

( ) : - “ ” [35, .287–288;

36, .273–277; 40, .365–392], – . -, , -

, , , . -

.

, -

, , –, , , . , -, ,

, -, ,

; -, ,

Page 233: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

233 ...

, , , , -

, “ -”, .

“ ”, . , “ ”.

( , , ), , ( ),

, – , , ( ) ,

( ). -

, - “ ”. ,

“ ” .

( , -, , ). -

, : , -

,. ,

, , -. -

( , , , -), -

“ ”, . , ,

, -,

.

, -,

. -

, , “ ”) “ ” ( , )

Page 234: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V234

, , , -, , “ ” -

, , , . -

-, -

, , , , , .

-, (

, , , ),

, ( - ). -

, , “ ” [41; 42; 43; 44], -

, , -, , -, ,

, .-

, , ,

. , , , ,

, [45, .37]. “ ” . -

– , -,

, . “ ” -

, , ,

. , ( -), , , -

. –

-.

Page 235: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

235 ...

, , ,, – “ -

, ”, – “ , ”. -

, “ -, , -. , , –

” [24, .239–240]. , -, “

, , , -

” [24, .256]. “ ”, ,

, , , -, , ,

( ) , . , , -

“ ”: “ -

. -, , -

, -. -

, , , -

, , ” [ . : 46, .133].

-, -

1994 “ -” “ ”, 41%

45% , ); 33%

41% , . , -

, , [47, .611, 609].

, – , ,

Page 236: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V236

. -; -

, -, , -

“ ”, .

, ,

, ; -; , ,

, . -.-

, , , , [52, .101–104]. ,

1994–2003 )., , – -

( ) , , ,

, -, -

, – -,

, – - “ ”.

,. -

, )

- [47; 48; 49].

, , : ,

” ( )2001 , “ -

, (

Page 237: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

237 ...

4 ), 63%” [51, .10]. ,

“ ”.

, ., 33% 41% ,

, , 5% 9% , [47, .609].

41% 45% , -, 5% 6% [47, .611]. -

, , -, (

, ), -, ,

, , , , .

, “N – )–”. - [49, .25–26], -

, . 61% 77% [49, .29], 60% 77%

, [47, .597]. “ ”,

, 18% 30% “ -”, 9%–12% -

[49, .17]. 23% 40% ,-

[49, .19]. 36% 61% -, [49, .19] .

, -

, ( ) ( ) –. 88% ,

[49,.18]. , ,

.? -

,

Page 238: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V238

, ,, ,

. , : “, ,

?”, 63,9% 2001 [47, .637].

56,3% [47, .637]. , 2003 64,4% - “ ”, “ ” “ -

”; 20,7% , “ -, ”

”., , ,

( ). -. -

, , 37% 2002 -

, [48, .580]. , -,

,.

-, , “ –

”, ( , -, ) . , , -

, , , – -, , ,

. -,

, – , ., ( -

) , , .

. ( ), -, , “ ”:

, , , -

,

Page 239: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

239 ...

[25, .11], ( , – ).

, “, ” [25, c.28].

, . , .

, ,

. , .

, , -, ( -

, ); “ ” -.

: “ ” , , , “ ”.

, : -

. : “ -. -

– , , -” [52].

, , ” “ ” -

, “ ”. ,, , ,

, , ,,

;, -

, , , , ( ),

, . -

, , , - – , , “ ”, -

( ), , “ ”,, , , , -

Page 240: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V240

( ) . ,, “ ”, “ -

” ( ), , , “ ”

, , , .

, -, “ ”,

(), , , -

, . , ( ) .

. , , , .

, “ ”, , -

.

, , “ -”. , ,

“ ” .

. , ,. -

, -, .

1. . . – ., 2002.2. . . – ., 2001.3. . . . – ., 1967.4. . . . – ., 1976.5. . . – ., 2002.6. . // . –

., 1986. – .250–275.7. . , //

. – ., 1986. – .276–288.

Page 241: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

241 ...

8. . . . – .,1998.

9. . , , // . – 1991. – 14. – .32–43.

10. . . -. – ., 2002.

11. . - // . – 1994. – 5. – .141–142.

12. . . – ., 2000.13. . :

// : . – ., 1991. –.43–50.

14. . : - // . – 1990. – 9. – .61–75.

15. . : - // . -

. – ., 2001. – .6–17.16. : . “ -

” // : . – ., 1998. –.20–72.

17. . . -. – ., 1994.

18. . // : , , . – 1998. – 4–5. – .41–55.

19 ., .: , , , // -

. . – ., 2001. – .161–175.

20. . // . -

. – ., 2001. – .71–85.21. -

1917 // . – 1991. – 13 .22. . // . – 1994. – 1. –

.58–67.23. ., ., ., . , -

... ? –92 //. – 1993. – 8.

24. ., . . . 1991–1995. – ., 1996.

25. . , . . – ., 1997.

Page 242: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

V242

26. . : , // -

. -. – ., 2001. – .373–394.

27. . : -, //

. . –., 2001. – .315–329.

28. ., . : , // : -

( ). –., 2001. – .180–200.

29. ., . // : -

. – ., 1998. – .7–19.30. : -

. – ., 2001.31. ., . :

, , // . . –

., 2001. – .192–196.32. . //

. . – ., 2001. – .395-401.

33. ., . -: , , . – ., 1997.

4. . - // -

. . – ., 2001. – .115–128.

35. . // . -

. – ., 2001. – .278–288.36. .

// . . – ., 2001. –

.273–277.37. . : -

. – ., 1995.38. ., ., . -

. . – ., 1992.

Page 243: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

243 ...

39. ., . - // :

, , . – 2001. – 4. – .5–22.40. ., . :

// : -. – ., 1998. – .365–392.

41. . : , ? – ., 2001.

42. ., ., . . – ., 1996.

43. . // : , , . – 2002. – 1. – .5–20.

44. . – – : - // : , , . –

2002. – 2. – .102–121.45. . ? // . – 1994. – 1. –

.33–48.46. . . – ., 1992.47. : ( -

). – ., 2001.48. – 2002. . – ., 2002.49. : 1994–2003. – ., 2003.50. . ( ). –

., 1996.51. . //

. – 2001. – 28. – .10.52. .

// . – 1999. – 10 .

Page 244: K M K I 1 E V G : L J : G K N H J F : P 1 Y D H G P ? I L M : E 1 A : P ... · K V D B C > H K < 1 >/ A Z j _ ^. < < L Z g q _ j Z, < I K l _ i Z g _ g d Z. –

: ,,

, )

, . 01021, –21, . , 12

26.04.2004 . 60 84/16. . 1.. .- . 15. . . 300.

“ ”04070, –70, ., 7

( 150 16.08.2000 .)

“ “ ”.04176, –76, , , 26.

( 149 16.08.2000 .)

: :

::


Recommended
e g g є j k h g Z e q Z k h j ] Z g a Z p · 2018-07-31 · 7 1. K m l g k lь k l _ f b i l Z p _ j k h g Z e m Z f k l m q Z k g b o m f h \ Z o

e g g є j k h g Z e q Z k h j ] Z g a Z p · 2018-07-31 · 7 1. K m l g k lь k l _ f b i l Z p _ j k h g Z e m Z f k l m q Z k g b o m f h \ Z o

Documents

K E M @ ; ? G B = E : K G B D O PREKRSAJIMA... · 2014. 7. 28. · 903 G Z h k g h \ m : f Z g ^ f Z g Z XL l Z q d Z 2. g Z M k l Z \ J _ i m [ e b- d _ K j i k d _ (“ K e m `

K E M @ ; ? G B = E : K G B D O PREKRSAJIMA... · 2014. 7. 28. · 903 G Z h k g h \ m : f Z g ^ f Z g Z XL l Z q d Z 2. g Z M k l Z \ J _ i m [ e b- d _ K j i k d _ (“ K e m `

Documents

Шаблон РП дисциплины€¦ · F b g b k l _ j k l a h \ Z g b g Z m d b h k k b c k d h c ^ _ j Z p b b N _ ^ _ j Z e v g h _ m ^ Z j k l \ _ g g h _ ^ ` _ l g h

Шаблон РП дисциплины€¦ · F b g b k l _ j k l a h \ Z g b g Z m d b h k k b c k d h c ^ _ j Z p b b N _ ^ _ j Z e v g h _ m ^ Z j k l \ _ g g h _ ^ ` _ l g h

Documents

Z g g Z y k b k l f Z f g ^ ` f g l Z · K _ f b g Z j u \ Z \ l h f h [ b e v g h c h l j Z k e b 1. H [ a h j g m j k l j _ [ h \ Z g b IATF 16949:2016 ^ e y k i _ p b Z e b k l

Z g g Z y k b k l f Z f g ^ ` f g l Z · K _ f b g Z j u \ Z \ l h f h [ b e v g h c h l j Z k e b 1. H [ a h j g m j k l j _ [ h \ Z g b IATF 16949:2016 ^ e y k i _ p b Z e b k l

Documents

F B G B K L ? J K L < H H ; J : A H < : G B Y B G : M D B ...география. > B K K ? J L : P B Y g Z k h b k d Z g b _ m q _ g h c k l _ i _ g b d Z g ^ b ^ Z l Z ]

F B G B K L ? J K L < H H ; J : A H < : G B Y B G : M D B ...география. > B K K ? J L : P B Y g Z k h b k d Z g b _ m q _ g h c k l _ i _ g b d Z g ^ b ^ Z l Z ]

Documents

realty.yandex.ru · 113 e _ k l g b q g Z y e _ l d Z f _ k l Z s _ g b y A ^ Z g b _ №2, -1 ` 8.8 114 e _ k l g b q g Z y e _ l d Z f _ k l Z s _ g b y A ^ Z g b _ №2, 9 ` 14.8

realty.yandex.ru · 113 e _ k l g b q g Z y e _ l d Z f _ k l Z s _ g b y A ^ Z g b _ №2, -1 ` 8.8 114 e _ k l g b q g Z y e _ l d Z f _ k l Z s _ g b y A ^ Z g b _ №2, 9 ` 14.8

Documents

P g l j « F h [ b a g k»€¦ · 3 I. Общие положения 1.1. G Z k l h y s j _ ] e Z f _ g l h d Z a Z g b y m k e m ] P _ g l j Z « [ b a g _ k» j Z a j Z [ h l Z

P g l j « F h [ b a g k»€¦ · 3 I. Общие положения 1.1. G Z k l h y s j _ ] e Z f _ g l h d Z a Z g b y m k e m ] P _ g l j Z « [ b a g _ k» j Z a j Z [ h l Z

Documents

Z l e v q j ` ^ g « d b k Z ^ « G Z k l g v d Z» H K G H ...детские-сады.абакан.рф/assets... · В соответствии с Федеральным государственным

Z l e v q j ` ^ g « d b k Z ^ « G Z k l g v d Z» H K G H ...детские-сады.абакан.рф/assets... · В соответствии с Федеральным государственным

Documents

G ? K L : G > : J L G D D M J K ? « H E»4 1. L _ f Z l b q _ k d h e Z g b j h \ Z g b _ Таблица 1 :. L _ f Z l b q _ k d h e Z g b j h \ Z g b h e Z « k g h \ g u Z d h

G ? K L : G > : J L G D D M J K ? « H E»4 1. L _ f Z l b q _ k d h e Z g b j h \ Z g b _ Таблица 1 :. L _ f Z l b q _ k d h e Z g b j h \ Z g b h e Z « k g h \ g u Z d h

Documents

n Z a Z II k Z Q Z l b g Z g Z k g h ] j ] m e Z p b ] g j Z e g i e Z g Z G Z p j l · 2018-10-15 · ] j Z g b p Z h [ m o \ Z l Z I e Z g Z d Z l Z k l Z j k d Z i h ^ e h ] Z

n Z a Z II k Z Q Z l b g Z g Z k g h ] j ] m e Z p b ] g j Z e g i e Z g Z G Z p j l · 2018-10-15 · ] j Z g b p Z h [ m o \ Z l Z I e Z g Z d Z l Z k l Z j k d Z i h ^ e h ] Z

Documents

H ; H ; S ? G B K L B Q ? K D : ; E B P B A : C G H K L L ... · 14. I j h e h ` _ g b _ № 14 – = j Z n b d Z a Z ^ _ c k l \ b l _ e g Z g Z l h \ Z j _ g h k g Z k t ^ b b \

H ; H ; S ? G B K L B Q ? K D : ; E B P B A : C G H K L L ... · 14. I j h e h ` _ g b _ № 14 – = j Z n b d Z a Z ^ _ c k l \ b l _ e g Z g Z l h \ Z j _ g h k g Z k t ^ b b \

Documents

F B G B K L ? J K L < H H ; J : A H < : G B G : J H K K B ...€¦ · ^ h p _ g) O Z k Z g h \ Z F b e y m r Z K Z o j _ l ^ b g h \ g Z 24.06.2016 14:34 27.06.2016 09:10 J _ d h

F B G B K L ? J K L < H H ; J : A H < : G B G : J H K K B ...€¦ · ^ h p _ g) O Z k Z g h \ Z F b e y m r Z K Z o j _ l ^ b g h \ g Z 24.06.2016 14:34 27.06.2016 09:10 J _ d h

Documents

I h y k g b l e v g Z i b k d Z ; Z e d Z j k d b c u d 5 ... · I h y k g b l _ e v g Z i b k d Z ; Z e d Z j k d b c u d 5 e Z k k. Рабочая программа учебного

I h y k g b l e v g Z i b k d Z ; Z e d Z j k d b c u d 5 ... · I h y k g b l _ e v g Z i b k d Z ; Z e d Z j k d b c u d 5 e Z k k. Рабочая программа учебного

Documents

 · 2019-09-23 · N _ ^ _ j Z e v g h _ m ^ Z j k l \ _ g g h _ \ l h g h f g h _ [ j Z a h \ Z l _ e v g h _ m q j _ ` ^ _ g \ u k r _ ] h [ j Z a h \ Z g « J h k k b c k d b c

 · 2019-09-23 · N _ ^ _ j Z e v g h _ m ^ Z j k l \ _ g g h _ \ l h g h f g h _ [ j Z a h \ Z l _ e v g h _ m q j _ ` ^ _ g \ u k r _ ] h [ j Z a h \ Z g « J h k k b c k d b c

Documents

D Z j e b b» стр. 1 · W e _ d l j h g g u m q g h- i j Z d l b q _ k d b c @ m j g Z e « F m ^ j Z y D g b ] Z G Z k l Z \ g b d h \. K h ] e Z k b _ \ K _ f v _ - K h ] e Z

D Z j e b b» стр. 1 · W e _ d l j h g g u m q g h- i j Z d l b q _ k d b c @ m j g Z e « F m ^ j Z y D g b ] Z G Z k l Z \ g b d h \. K h ] e Z k b _ \ K _ f v _ - K h ] e Z

Documents

k l j k v d Z ^ b i e h f g Z j h [ h l Z - СумДУ€¦ · 2.3.5. K b k l _ f Z h p g x \ Z g g y e x ^ k v d b o j _ k m j k \ g Z i ^ i j b } f k l \ < : L „ P _ g l j h e

k l j k v d Z ^ b i e h f g Z j h [ h l Z - СумДУ€¦ · 2.3.5. K b k l _ f Z h p g x \ Z g g y e x ^ k v d b o j _ k m j k \ g Z i ^ i j b } f k l \ < : L „ P _ g l j h e

Documents

I h y k g b l e v g Z y - uCozdiveevo-school.ucoz.ru/pdf_2/urovni/osnovnoe/istorija_po_fgos_5-6_klass.pdf2 I h y k g b l _ e v g Z y a Z i b k d Z G h j f Z l b \ g g g Z i b k Z g

I h y k g b l e v g Z y - uCozdiveevo-school.ucoz.ru/pdf_2/urovni/osnovnoe/istorija_po_fgos_5-6_klass.pdf2 I h y k g b l _ e v g Z y a Z i b k d Z G h j f Z l b \ g g g Z i b k Z g

Documents

Z l e v g Z j h ] j Z f f Z · 2014. 6. 13. · \ u ^ _ e y l v g u _ , m k d Z _ i _ g g u _; m k l Z g Z \ e b \ Z l v q _ k d m x h k e _ ^ h \ Z l _ e v g h k l v g h \ g u o

Z l e v g Z j h ] j Z f f Z · 2014. 6. 13. · \ u ^ _ e y l v g u _ , m k d Z _ i _ g g u _; m k l Z g Z \ e b \ Z l v q _ k d m x h k e _ ^ h \ Z l _ e v g h k l v g h \ g u o

Documents