+ All Categories
Home > Documents > KOLKATA | TUESDAY, 10 SEPTEMBER 2019 Mittal’s funding...

KOLKATA | TUESDAY, 10 SEPTEMBER 2019 Mittal’s funding...

Date post: 21-Apr-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 4 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
1
KOLKATA | TUESDAY, 10 SEPTEMBER 2019 COMPANIES 3 . < DEV CHATTERJEE Mumbai, 9 September D espite ArcelorMittal paying over- dues of ~4,922 crore of Uttam Galva Steels to Indian lenders, the financial metrics of the company had deteriorated in FY19 because of the rising finance cost and provisions made on doubtful advances paid by the firm to its vendors. The company paid interest of ~938 crore in the year ended March 2019, up from ~654 crore reported in FY18. The firm also incurred a loss of ~1,221 crore from operations as against loss of ~881 crore in the previous year. Its loss widened after it made provisions of ~904 crore for doubtful advances made to vendors and capital goods suppliers. Apart from paying secured lenders, ArcelorMittal paid Uttam Galva Steels’ overdue for foreign loans of $172 million. With this, these loans are now assigned to ArcelorMittal India and the remaining outstanding loans are continuing with the existing lenders as ‘surviving debt’. The Bulk of Uttam Galva’s loans are now assigned to ArcelorMittal India. ArcelorMittal had paid the overdues of Uttam Galva in order to become eligi- ble to bid for Essar Steel, which was auc- tioned by the banks after the company failed to repay its debt. Mittal’s payment to banks came after the Supreme Court asked the company to pay overdues of all the defaulting com- panies in which it held stake. As ArcelorMittal held stake in Uttam Galva, which was a bank defaulter, it had to pay the dues of the company following the Supreme Court order. The financial results show that the company’s net worth is completely wiped off by ~2,274 crore while its revenue was ~556 crore in FY19. For FY18, its revenue was ~2,622 crore. The company said its turnover figures for FY19 were not comparable with the previous year mainly because as during the financial year, the company has car- ried out its operations on job-work basis due to lack of working capital and raw materials. In its FY18 annual report, the compa- ny admitted that it was facing continued problem of working capital availability, which has resulted in operating the plant on job-work basis at sub-optimal capaci- ty of 40 per cent. The company warned that the cash flows from existing operations are not suf- ficient to cover the fixed overheads, let alone the principal and interest obliga- tions of the firm. However, to ensure that the debt does not become a non-per- forming asset, the company has consis- tently cleared the dues before 90 days from the due date from the funds bor- rowed from ArcelorMittal India by way of inter-corporate deposits. Thanks to ArcelorMittal’s payment, State Bank of India, which had filed the insolvency petition against the company, withdrew the plea on November 1, 2018. In the first quarter of FY20, the firm’s loss was ~65 crore and made a provision of ~198 crore. Thus taking its total loss to ~263 crore on revenue of ~98 crore. Mittal’s funding fails to lift Uttam Galva fortunes HOW THEY STACK UP Consolidated figures in (~ cr) FY18 FY19 Networth -71 -2,198 Total debt # 6,813 7,482 Revenue ( net) 3,418 757 Finance costs 654 938 PAT -881 -1,241 Ajusted profit -881 -2,146 # Includes other financial liabilities Source: Annual report Compiled by BS Research Bureau KARAN CHOUDHURY Bengaluru, 9 September On an overdrive to ensure a blockbuster festive season, Flipkart on Monday annou- nced onboarding 27,000 kira- nas across 700 cities to its pan- Indian supply chain. The company believes that this would help it reach out to its 160 million users as well as new consumers during its up- coming ‘The Big Billion Days’ sale. At the moment, it is work- ing with over 12,000 kirana stores across the country. The company believes kira- nas would help it massively improve last mile logistics and access to 100 per cent of the pin codes. “The nation-wide kirana onboarding started six months back, keeping in mind the massive scale of the up- coming festive season. This season witnesses heightened demand from customers from across the country and also grows the business of our kirana partners,” the compa- ny said. Flipkart started with a customised training pro- gramme to onboard these kirana partners, with soft skills and the know-how to deal with customer queries or requests on the spot. Flipkart already has a large supply chain network, cur- rently delivering over a mil- lion shipments everyday acro- ss 100 per cent of the pin codes in the country. “After digital payments, the next big revolution in kirana is going to be ushered in con- junction with e-commerce. It will reposition and reinvent kirana stores as convenience stores from an e-commerce perspective while offering them a new source of revenue, making it a win-win situation for all,” said Kalyan Krishn- amurthy, CEO of Flipkart Group said. With the 27,000 additional kirana stores, Flipkart will be able to scale up its reach, espe- cially in tier-II and tier-III cities. To seamlessly facilitate the onboarding process and their inclusion in the delivery mod- el, Flipkart is leveraging its in- house tech solution called the ‘Allocation Engine’. This helps automate alloca- tion of shipments to delivery agents and partners, including kiranas. “This has become impor- tant as there is a huge spike in demand during the festive sea- son and deploying tech be- comes essential to provide high-speed deliveries to con- sumers,” the company said. By evenly spreading the ship- ments across various delivery models, the Allocation Engine helps increase efficiency of deliveries, offering a better con- sumer experience. Ahead of festival, Flipkart partners 27K kirana stores Canada Pension Plan Invest- ment Board (CPPIB) has said it is putting $115 million (~8,250 crore) in Delhivery, one of India’s leading third-party logistics providers. Delhivery operates in over 2,000 cities and towns, offering a range of supply chain services. “The contin- ued strong growth of e-com- merce has generated signifi- cant opportunities in India's express logistics space for long-term investors such as CPPIB and we are pleased to partner with a market lead- er,” said Deborah Orida, sen- ior managing director and global head of active equities at CPPIB. The investment was made through CPPIB’s Fundamen- tal Equities Asia Group. The latter’s stated aim is fundame- ntal research and investment in quality companies for the long term in this continent. RANJU SARKAR CPPIB to invest $115 million in Delhivery SHALLY SETH MOHILE Mumbai, 9 September Check into the J W Marriott hotel property at Delhi’s Aero- city, you will no longer find a plastic bottle. On Monday, it banished the last of its poly- ethylene terephthalate (PET) bottles, replacing these with QR-coded glass ones from its Artificial Intelligence (AI)- based bottling unit. This 500-room property, says the management, con- sumes 5,479 bottles a day. The plan is to replicate this model, first at select hotels and to even- tually do away with PET bot- tles at all its properties. Marriott joins Indian Hotels Company (IHCL, the Taj group) in doing so — the latter recent- ly set up bottling units at select hotels in Delhi, Bengaluru, Mal- dives and Colombo, seeking to replace plastic bottles with glass ones. And, a spokes- person at Accor Hotels says most of its properties now use glass in both rooms and at events. Also giving an option to banqueting guests to choose RO water stations in place of PET water bottles. Large chains like the Mar- riott and Taj that are estimated to consume two million plastic bottles a year have taken a con- scious decision to first elimi- nate and then reduce the use of single-use plastic, saying they are all for a sustainably envi- ronment-friendly tomorrow. In his address from the Red Fort on Independence Day, the prime minister had urged peo- ple and shopkeepers to elimi- nate the use of plastic bags. “Can we free India from single- use plastic? The time for implementing such an idea has come. Teams must be mobi- lised to work in this direction. A significant step must come out by October 2 (Mahatma Gandhi’s birth anniversary,” he’d said. Marriott’s elimination of plastic bottles coincides with Amitabh Kant’s tweet, where the NITI Aayog head urged the travel industry to follow the Taj. “Taj informed me that they are establishing a bottling unit plant to eliminate all plastic bottles. They will take the lead in this regard. The entire travel industry should follow this practice,” Kant wrote on the micro blogging site on Monday. For Nitesh Gandhi, general manager at the Aerocity Marri- ott, who spearheaded the proj- ect of setting up a bottling plant, eliminating plastics was a “personal vendetta”. An avid biker, the sight of mounds of plastic in and around the city whenever he would go biking, was disturbing. “We have to admit that hotels of our size consume more than two mil- lion bottles a year. The idea was to eliminate the usage without compromising with our guests’ experience,” says Gandhi. Therefore, a year ago, his col- leagues and he began the exer- cise of indentifying a firm that could help in setting up a (glass) bottling unit. After research which included visits to the bottling units of Pepsi, Coke, Mother Diary and Nestle, the unit became operational on Monday. The AI-based unit gi- ves information about the qual- ity of water and its content on a real-time basis, claims Gandhi. Marriott has invested ~20 lakh in the project, half for water and glass bottles and the rest for buying ergonomically desig- ned trolleys to port the water into rooms and restaurants. The move on plastic bottles by hotels is a continuation of an exercise in eliminating oth- er plastic items, starting a year before. IHCL, which owns the Taj-branded five-star hotel chains, has phased out single- use plastic in rooms. Many Taj hotels have reduced usage of plastic by replacing wrapped dry amenities in rooms such as toothbrushes, shaving kits, etc, with eco-friendly substitutes, said a spokesperson. “Last year, we took a com- mitment to eliminate single- use plastic straws from our hotels and successfully elimi- nated two million of these across IHCL, including at Taj- SATS (in-flight catering),” said the spokesperson. Marriott and Accor, too, say they have replaced such plastics with biodegradable material. After PM push, hotels cut use of PET bottles BAIJU KALESH & P R SANJAI 9 September Reliance Capital has called off a sale of its general insur- ance unit to Hero Fincorp, forcing embattled tycoon Anil Ambani to look for options as he seeks to reduce debt, people familiar with the matter said. The talks for selling Reli- ance General Insurance which were at an advanced stage, ended after the shad- ow financier struggled to raise funds for the acquisi- tion, said the people, asking not to be named as the infor- mation is not public. Ambani’s group is look- ing for alternatives for the insurance asset including reaching out to other poten- tial buyers, the people said. The sale of the fully- owned insurance unit is crucial for Ambani as he steps up efforts to cut his group’s debt that has bal- looned to about ~939 billion ($13 billion) at four of its biggest units. “Reliance Group is committed to meeting all future debt obli- gations,” Ambani said in a rare conference call in June, and becoming “capital light, with bare minimal debt.” A spokesman at Reliance Capital declined to com- ment, while a representative for Hero FinCorp didn't res- pond to an email and phone calls seeking comment. Hero Fincorp was in advanced talks to buy the insurer at a valuation of ab- out ~60 billion ($860 million), The Economic Times reported in May, citing unnamed sources. BLOOMBERG Anil Ambani ends talks with Hero FinCorp on insurer sale Some of the five-star hotels have set up glass bottling units to replace PET bottles MARK GURMAN 9 September Apple and manufacturing part- ner Foxconn violated a Chinese labour rule by using too many temporary staff in the world’s largest iPhone factory, the com- panies confirmed following a report that also alleged harsh working conditions. The claims came from China Labour Watch, which issued the report ahead of an Apple event on Tuesday to announce new iPhones. The non-profit advocacy group investigates conditions in Chinese factories, and says it has uncovered other alleged labor rights violations by Apple partners in the past. For its latest report, CLW said undercover investigators worked in Foxconn’s Zhen- gzhou plant in China, including one who was employed there for four years. One of the main findings: Temporary staff, known as dispatch workers, made up about 50 per cent the workforce in August. Chinese labour law stipulates a maxi- mum of 10 per cent, CLW not- ed. Apple said that, after con- ducting an investigation, it found the “percentage of dis- patch workers exceeded our standards” and that it is “work- ing closely with Foxconn to resolve this issue.” It added that when it finds issues, it works with suppliers to “take imme- diate corrective action.” Fox- conn Technology Group also confirmed the dispatch worker violation following an opera- tional review. Apple’s supply chain has faced criticism over poor labor standards for years, and the company has pushed manu- facturing partners to improve factory conditions or risk los- ing business. However, suppli- ers and assemblers are always trying to churn out more hand- sets. Foxconn, officially known as Hon Hai Precision Industry, hires tens of thousands of tem- porary workers to ramp up pro- duction and meet iPhone demand during the key holi- day season each year. “Our recent findings on working conditions at Zheng- zhou Foxconn highlights sev- eral issues which are in viola- tion of Apple’s own code of conduct,” CLW wrote in its report. “Apple has the respon- sibility and capacity to make fundamental improvements to the working conditions along its supply chain, however, Apple is now transferring costs from the trade war through their suppliers to workers and profiting from the exploitation of Chinese workers.” While the report said 55 per cent of factory staff were dis- patch workers in 2018, and abo- ut 50 per cent in August, this included student interns. Beca- use many of these students returned to school at the end of August, that number is now closer to 30 per cent, which is still a violation, according to CLW. “We believe everyone in our supply chain should be treated with dignity and respect,” Apple also said. “To make sure our high standards are being adhered to, we have robust management systems in place beginning with train- ing on workplace rights, on-site worker interviews, anonymous grievance channels and ongo- ing audits.” BLOOMBERG Apple, Foxconn broke a Chinese labour law for iPhone production AVISHEK RAKSHIT Kolkata, 9 September While reassuring sharehold- ers of his commitment to stave off the present financial crisis at McLeod Russel, Aditya Khaitan, chairman, said lending to group entity McNally Bharat Engineering had been a “mistake”. Shareholders at the annual general meeting (AGM) repeat- edly questioned Khaitan on the rationale for issuing inter-cor- porate deposits (ICDs) to Mc- Nally Bharat, whose repayment has since become uncertain. To which, he admitted: “It was a mistake. The firm that was lent to was in serious trou- ble and the mistake we made was to see whether that com- pany could turn around...It (McNally) was in the infra- structure space and we believed India would need infrastructure and we felt it (McNally) could be the next business and growth for the group (Williamson Magor). Unfortunately, the time it took for that company to revive and grow has taken a toll on this company (McLeod Russel) and the group.” Shareholders said McNally's failure to repay the borrowings direly affected Mc- Leod’s financial position, lead- ing to sale of assets and its share price dropping to an all-time low of ~11-12. Promoters pledg- ing had also increased and the lenders had started invoking these pledges. “Did we give our money to McNally? You trans- ferred the cash to McNally. Is this how you reward trust?” an annoyed shareholder asked. Khaitan told them group- level restructuring was on, involving debt recasting, sale of assets and bringing in strate- gic investors. McLeod’s total debt is ~1,700 crore; McNally’s is estimated at ~1,500 crore. Lending to group company a mistake: McLeod Russel head INDIAN INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AHMEDABAD invites Applications for Admission to its Ph.D. PROGRAMME IN MANAGEMENT Ph.D. Programme of IIMA provides an opportunity for those interested in a career that offers lifelong learning and growth. The programme is offered in the following areas of high levels of specialization. Business Policy • Economics Finance & Accounting Food & Agri-business Human Resource Management Information Systems Innovation & Management in Education • Marketing Organizational Behaviour Production & Quantitative Methods Public Systems For eligibility and other details log on to: www.iima.ac.in Last date of submitting on-line Application: January 23, 2020
Transcript
Page 1: KOLKATA | TUESDAY, 10 SEPTEMBER 2019 Mittal’s funding ...vinodkothari.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/B.S-NPRL.pdfAs ArcelorMittal held stake in Uttam Galva, which was a bank defaulter,

KOLKATA | TUESDAY, 10 SEPTEMBER 2019 COMPANIES 3. �

DEV CHATTERJEE

Mumbai, 9 September

Despite ArcelorMittal paying over-dues of ~4,922 crore of UttamGalva Steels to Indian lenders, the

financial metrics of the company haddeteriorated in FY19 because of the risingfinance cost and provisions made ondoubtful advances paid by the firm to itsvendors.

The company paid interest of ~938crore in the year ended March 2019, upfrom ~654 crore reported in FY18. Thefirm also incurred a loss of ~1,221 crorefrom operations as against loss of ~881crore in the previous year. Its loss widenedafter it made provisions of ~904 crore fordoubtful advances made to vendors andcapital goods suppliers.

Apart from paying secured lenders,ArcelorMittal paid Uttam Galva Steels’overdue for foreign loans of $172 million.With this, these loans are now assigned toArcelorMittal India and the remainingoutstanding loans are continuing withthe existing lenders as ‘surviving debt’.The Bulk of Uttam Galva’s loans are nowassigned to ArcelorMittal India.

ArcelorMittal had paid the overduesof Uttam Galva in order to become eligi-ble to bid for Essar Steel, which was auc-tioned by the banks after the companyfailed to repay its debt.

Mittal’s payment to banks came afterthe Supreme Court asked the company topay overdues of all the defaulting com-panies in which it held stake.

As ArcelorMittal held stake in UttamGalva, which was a bank defaulter, it hadto pay the dues of the company following

the Supreme Court order.The financial results show that the

company’s net worth is completely wipedoff by ~2,274 crore while its revenue was~556 crore in FY19.

For FY18, its revenue was ~2,622 crore.The company said its turnover figuresfor FY19 were not comparable with theprevious year mainly because as duringthe financial year, the company has car-ried out its operations on job-work basisdue to lack of working capital and rawmaterials.

In its FY18 annual report, the compa-ny admitted that it was facing continuedproblem of working capital availability,which has resulted in operating the planton job-work basis at sub-optimal capaci-ty of 40 per cent.

The company warned that the cashflows from existing operations are not suf-ficient to cover the fixed overheads, letalone the principal and interest obliga-tions of the firm. However, to ensure thatthe debt does not become a non-per-forming asset, the company has consis-tently cleared the dues before 90 daysfrom the due date from the funds bor-rowed from ArcelorMittal India by wayof inter-corporate deposits.

Thanks to ArcelorMittal’s payment,State Bank of India, which had filed theinsolvency petition against the company,withdrew the plea on November 1, 2018.

In the first quarter of FY20, the firm’sloss was ~65 crore and made a provision of~198 crore. Thus taking its total loss to~263 crore on revenue of ~98 crore.

Mittal’s funding fails tolift Uttam Galva fortunes

HOW THEY STACK UPConsolidated figures in (~ cr)

FY18 FY19Networth -71 -2,198Total debt # 6,813 7,482Revenue ( net) 3,418 757Finance costs 654 938PAT -881 -1,241Ajusted profit -881 -2,146# Includes other financial liabilitiesSource: Annual reportCompiled by BS Research Bureau

KARAN CHOUDHURY

Bengaluru, 9 September

On an overdrive to ensure ablockbuster festive season,Flipkart on Monday annou-nced onboarding 27,000 kira-nas across 700 cities to its pan-Indian supply chain.

The company believes thatthis would help it reach out toits 160 million users as well asnew consumers during its up-coming ‘The Big Billion Days’sale. At the moment, it is work-ing with over 12,000 kiranastores across the country.

The company believes kira-nas would help it massivelyimprove last mile logistics andaccess to 100 per cent of thepin codes. “The nation-widekirana onboarding started sixmonths back, keeping in mindthe massive scale of the up-coming festive season. Thisseason witnesses heighteneddemand from customers from

across the country and alsogrows the business of ourkirana partners,” the compa-ny said. Flipkart started with acustomised training pro-gramme to onboard thesekirana partners, with soft skillsand the know-how to deal withcustomer queries or requestson the spot.

Flipkart already has a largesupply chain network, cur-rently delivering over a mil-lion shipments everyday acro-ss 100 per cent of the pin codesin the country.

“After digital payments, thenext big revolution in kirana isgoing to be ushered in con-junction with e-commerce. Itwill reposition and reinventkirana stores as conveniencestores from an e-commerceperspective while offeringthem a new source of revenue,making it a win-win situationfor all,” said Kalyan Krishn-amurthy, CEO of Flipkart

Group said.With the 27,000 additional

kirana stores, Flipkart will beable to scale up its reach, espe-cially in tier-II and tier-III cities.To seamlessly facilitate theonboarding process and theirinclusion in the delivery mod-el, Flipkart is leveraging its in-house tech solution called the‘Allocation Engine’.

This helps automate alloca-tion of shipments to deliveryagents and partners, includingkiranas.

“This has become impor-tant as there is a huge spike indemand during the festive sea-son and deploying tech be-comes essential to providehigh-speed deliveries to con-sumers,” the company said. Byevenly spreading the ship-ments across various deliverymodels, the Allocation Enginehelps increase efficiency ofdeliveries, offering a better con-sumer experience.

Ahead of festival, Flipkart partners 27K kirana stores

Canada Pension Plan Invest-ment Board (CPPIB) has said itis putting $115 million (~8,250crore) in Delhivery, one ofIndia’s leading third-partylogistics providers.

Delhivery operates inover 2,000 cities and towns,offering a range of supplychain services. “The contin-ued strong growth of e-com-merce has generated signifi-cant opportunities in India'sexpress logistics space forlong-term investors such asCPPIB and we are pleased topartner with a market lead-er,”� said Deborah Orida, sen-ior managing director andglobal head of active equitiesat CPPIB.

The investment was madethrough CPPIB’s Fundamen-tal Equities Asia Group. Thelatter’s stated aim is fundame-ntal research and investmentin quality companies for thelong term in this continent.

RANJU SARKAR

CPPIB to invest$115 million in Delhivery

SHALLY SETH MOHILE

Mumbai, 9 September

Check into the J W Marriotthotel property at Delhi’s Aero-city, you will no longer find aplastic bottle. On Monday, itbanished the last of its poly-ethylene terephthalate (PET)bottles, replacing these withQR-coded glass ones from itsArtificial Intelligence (AI)-based bottling unit.

This 500-room property,says the management, con-sumes 5,479 bottles a day. Theplan is to replicate this model,first at select hotels and to even-tually do away with PET bot-tles at all its properties.

Marriott joins Indian HotelsCompany (IHCL, the Taj group)in doing so — the latter recent-ly set up bottling units at selecthotels in Delhi, Bengaluru, Mal-dives and Colombo, seeking toreplace plastic bottles withglass ones. And, a spokes-person at Accor Hotels saysmost of its properties now useglass in both rooms and atevents. Also giving an optionto banqueting guests to chooseRO water stations in place ofPET water bottles.

Large chains like the Mar-riott and Taj that are estimatedto consume two million plasticbottles a year have taken a con-scious decision to first elimi-nate and then reduce the use ofsingle-use plastic, saying theyare all for a sustainably envi-ronment-friendly tomorrow. Inhis address from the Red Forton Independence Day, theprime minister had urged peo-ple and shopkeepers to elimi-nate the use of plastic bags.“Can we free India from single-use plastic? The time forimplementing such an idea hascome. Teams must be mobi-lised to work in this direction. Asignificant step must come outby October 2 (MahatmaGandhi’s birth anniversary,”he’d said.

Marriott’s elimination ofplastic bottles coincides withAmitabh Kant’s tweet, wherethe NITI Aayog head urged thetravel industry to follow the Taj.“Taj informed me that they areestablishing a bottling unitplant to eliminate all plasticbottles. They will take the leadin this regard. The entire travelindustry should follow thispractice,” Kant wrote on themicro blogging site on Monday.

For Nitesh Gandhi, generalmanager at the Aerocity Marri-ott, who spearheaded the proj-ect of setting up a bottling

plant, eliminating plastics wasa “personal vendetta”. An avidbiker, the sight of mounds ofplastic in and around the citywhenever he would go biking,was disturbing. “We have toadmit that hotels of our sizeconsume more than two mil-lion bottles a year. The idea wasto eliminate the usage withoutcompromising with our guests’experience,” says Gandhi.Therefore, a year ago, his col-leagues and he began the exer-cise of indentifying a firm thatcould help in setting up a (glass)bottling unit. After researchwhich included visits to thebottling units of Pepsi, Coke,Mother Diary and Nestle, theunit became operational onMonday. The AI-based unit gi-ves information about the qual-ity of water and its content on areal-time basis, claims Gandhi.Marriott has invested ~20 lakhin the project, half for water andglass bottles and the rest forbuying ergonomically desig-ned trolleys to port the waterinto rooms and restaurants.

The move on plastic bottlesby hotels is a continuation ofan exercise in eliminating oth-er plastic items, starting a yearbefore. IHCL, which owns theTaj-branded five-star hotelchains, has phased out single-use plastic in rooms. Many Tajhotels have reduced usage ofplastic by replacing wrappeddry amenities in rooms such astoothbrushes, shaving kits, etc,with eco-friendly substitutes,said a spokesperson.

“Last year, we took a com-mitment to eliminate single-use plastic straws from ourhotels and successfully elimi-nated two million of theseacross IHCL, including at Taj-SATS (in-flight catering),” saidthe spokesperson. Marriottand Accor, too, say they havereplaced such plastics withbiodegradable material.

After PM push,hotels cut useof PET bottles

BAIJU KALESH & P R SANJAI

9 September

Reliance Capital has calledoff a sale of its general insur-ance unit to Hero Fincorp,forcing embattled tycoonAnil Ambani to look foroptions as he seeks to reducedebt, people familiar withthe matter said.

The talks for selling Reli-ance General Insurancewhich were at an advancedstage, ended after the shad-ow financier struggled toraise funds for the acquisi-tion, said the people, askingnot to be named as the infor-mation is not public.

Ambani’s group is look-ing for alternatives for theinsurance asset includingreaching out to other poten-tial buyers, the people said.

The sale of the fully-owned insurance unit iscrucial for Ambani as hesteps up efforts to cut hisgroup’s debt that has bal-looned to about ~939 billion($13 billion) at four of itsbiggest units. “RelianceGroup is committed tomeeting all future debt obli-gations,” Ambani said in arare conference call in June,and becoming “capital light,with bare minimal debt.”

A spokesman at RelianceCapital declined to com-ment, while a representativefor Hero FinCorp didn't res-pond to an email and phonecalls seeking comment.

Hero Fincorp was inadvanced talks to buy theinsurer at a valuation of ab-out ~60 billion ($860 million),The Economic Times reportedin May, citing unnamedsources. BLOOMBERG

Anil Ambaniends talks withHero FinCorp on insurer sale

Some of the five-star hotelshave set up glass bottlingunits to replace PET bottles

MARK GURMAN

9 September

Apple and manufacturing part-ner Foxconn violated a Chineselabour rule by using too manytemporary staff in the world’slargest iPhone factory, the com-panies confirmed following areport that also alleged harshworking conditions.

The claims came fromChina Labour Watch, whichissued the report ahead of anApple event on Tuesday toannounce new iPhones. Thenon-profit advocacy groupinvestigates conditions inChinese factories, and says ithas uncovered other allegedlabor rights violations by Applepartners in the past.

For its latest report, CLWsaid undercover investigatorsworked in Foxconn’s Zhen-gzhou plant in China, includingone who was employed therefor four years. One of the mainfindings: Temporary staff,known as dispatch workers,made up about 50 per cent theworkforce in August. Chineselabour law stipulates a maxi-mum of 10 per cent, CLW not-ed. Apple said that, after con-ducting an investigation, itfound the “percentage of dis-patch workers exceeded ourstandards” and that it is “work-ing closely with Foxconn toresolve this issue.” It added thatwhen it finds issues, it workswith suppliers to “take imme-diate corrective action.” Fox-conn Technology Group alsoconfirmed the dispatch workerviolation following an opera-tional review.

Apple’s supply chain hasfaced criticism over poor laborstandards for years, and the

company has pushed manu-facturing partners to improvefactory conditions or risk los-ing business. However, suppli-ers and assemblers are alwaystrying to churn out more hand-sets. Foxconn, officially knownas Hon Hai Precision Industry,hires tens of thousands of tem-porary workers to ramp up pro-duction and meet iPhonedemand during the key holi-day season each year.

“Our recent findings onworking conditions at Zheng-zhou Foxconn highlights sev-eral issues which are in viola-tion of Apple’s own code ofconduct,” CLW wrote in itsreport. “Apple has the respon-sibility and capacity to makefundamental improvements tothe working conditions alongits supply chain, however,Apple is now transferring costsfrom the trade war throughtheir suppliers to workers andprofiting from the exploitationof Chinese workers.”

While the report said 55 percent of factory staff were dis-patch workers in 2018, and abo-ut 50 per cent in August, thisincluded student interns. Beca-use many of these studentsreturned to school at the endof August, that number is nowcloser to 30 per cent, which isstill a violation, according toCLW. “We believe everyone inour supply chain should betreated with dignity andrespect,” Apple also said. “Tomake sure our high standardsare being adhered to, we haverobust management systemsin place beginning with train-ing on workplace rights, on-siteworker interviews, anonymousgrievance channels and ongo-ing audits.” BLOOMBERG

Apple, Foxconn brokea Chinese labour lawfor iPhone production

AVISHEK RAKSHIT

Kolkata, 9 September

While reassuring sharehold-ers of his commitment tostave off the present financialcrisis at McLeod Russel,Aditya Khaitan, chairman,said lending to group entityMcNally Bharat Engineeringhad been a “mistake”.

Shareholders at the annualgeneral meeting (AGM) repeat-edly questioned Khaitan on therationale for issuing inter-cor-porate deposits (ICDs) to Mc-Nally Bharat, whose repaymenthas since become uncertain.

To which, he admitted: “Itwas a mistake. The firm thatwas lent to was in serious trou-ble and the mistake we madewas to see whether that com-pany could turn around...It(McNally) was in the infra-structure space and webelieved India would needinfrastructure and we felt it

(McNally) could be the nextbusiness and growth for thegroup (Williamson Magor).Unfortunately, the time it tookfor that company to revive andgrow has taken a toll on thiscompany (McLeod Russel) andthe group.” Shareholders saidMcNally's failure to repay theborrowings direly affected Mc-Leod’s financial position, lead-ing to sale of assets and its shareprice dropping to an all-timelow of ~11-12. Promoters pledg-ing had also increased and thelenders had started invokingthese pledges. “Did we give ourmoney to McNally? You trans-ferred the cash to McNally. Isthis how you reward trust?” anannoyed shareholder asked.

Khaitan told them group-level restructuring was on,involving debt recasting, saleof assets and bringing in strate-gic investors. McLeod’s totaldebt is ~1,700 crore; McNally’s isestimated at ~1,500 crore.

Lending to group company amistake: McLeod Russel head

INDIAN INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AHMEDABAD

invites Applications for Admission to itsPh.D. PROGRAMME IN MANAGEMENT

Ph.D. Programme of IIMA provides an opportunity for those interested in a career that offers lifelong learning and growth. The programme is offered in the following areas of high levels of specialization.• Business Policy• Economics• Finance & Accounting• Food & Agri-business• Human Resource Management• Information Systems

• Innovation & Management in Education

• Marketing• Organizational Behaviour• Production & Quantitative Methods• Public Systems

For eligibility and other details log on to: www.iima.ac.inLast date of submitting on-line Application:

January 23, 2020

Recommended