of 35
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
1/35
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
2/35
Labor Management Relations
Article XIII Sec. 3 of the Philippine Constitution
on Labor-Management Relations, at a Glance:
Full protection to labor, local and overseas,organized and unorganized;
Full employment and equality of employmentopportunities for all;
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
3/35
Right of all workers to:
self-organization, collective bargaining andnegotiations;
engage in peaceful concerted activities, including
the right to strike in accordance with law;
security of tenure, humane conditions of workand a living wage; and
participate in policy and decision makingprocesses affecting their rights and benefits asmay to provided by law;
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
4/35
Promotion of the principle of sharedresponsibility between workers and employers;
Preferential use of voluntary modes in setting
disputes, including conciliation; Recognition of the right of labor to its just share
in fruits of production; and
Right of enterprises to reasonable return ofinvestment and to expansion and growth.
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
5/35
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
6/35
Legal Basis
Sec. 3, Art. XIII, 1987 Constitution &
Art. 3, Declaration of Policy, Labor Code
The State shall assure the RIGHTS OFWORKERS to self-organization, collectivecollective
bargainingbargaining, security of tenure, and just &humane conditions of work.
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
7/35
What is
COLLECTIVE BARGAINING?
it is a process where representatives of the
employer or management and therepresentatives of the labor union of an
organization agree to fix and administerterms and conditions of employment which
must not be below the minimum standards
fixed by law, and set a mechanism forresolving their grievances.
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
8/35
According to the
National Labor Relations Act:
For the purpose of this act to bargain collectively is the
performance of the mutual obligation of the employer and
the representative of the employees to meet at reasonabletimes and confer in good faith with respect to wages, hours
and terms and conditions of employment, or the negotiation
of an agreement, or any question arising there under, and the
execution of a written contract incorporating any agreementreached if requested by either party, but such obligation does
not compel either party to agree to a proposal or require the
making of a concession.
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
9/35
What is Good Faith?
Bargaining in good faith is the cornerstone ofeffective labor management relations.
It means that both parties communicate andnegotiate, that proposals are matched withcounterproposals, and that both parties make everyreasonable effort to arrive at an agreement.
It does not mean that either party is compelled toagree to a proposal. Nor does it require that eitherparty make any specific concessions.
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
10/35
Purposes of collective bargaining:
1. To protect the workers;
2. To empower the workers;
3. To make the right of self-organization usefuland meaningful;
4. To be the preferred mode of settling labor
disputes before resorting to STRIKES;5. To be the preferred mode over that of
compulsory arbitration.
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
11/35
COLLECTIVE BARGAININGAGREEMENT
a negotiated contract between the unionrepresentatives and the employersrepresentatives covering the terms and
conditions of employment includingproposals for adjusting any grievances or
questions under such agreement
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
12/35
What is the advantage of having a CBA?
So that employees can secure better terms and
conditions of employment over that provided by
law.
What is the lifetime of a CBA?
Insofar as the representation aspect, the CBA
lasts for 5 years. However, not later than 3 yearsafter the execution of the CBA, the economicprovisions shall be renegotiated.
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
13/35
Bargaining Items
Labor law sets out categories of items that are subject to bargaining:
MANDATORY BARGAINING ITEMSThere are about 70 basic items over which bargaining is mandatory under the law.
Wages Rates of pay
Hours of Employment
Overtime Pay
Shift Differentials
Holidays
Company housing, meals and discounts
Employee Security
Insurance Benefits
Vacations
Drug Testing of Employees
Union Security
Job Performance
Management-Union Relationship
Christmas Bonuses
Profit Sharing Plans
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
14/35
VOLUNTARY OR PERMISSIBLE BARGAINING ITEMS
Are neither mandatory nor illegal; they become a part of negotiationsonly through the joint agreement of both management and union. Neitherparty can be compelled against its wishes to negotiate over voluntary items.You cannot hold up signing your contract because the other party refuses tobargain on a voluntary item.
Settlement of Unfair Labor ChargesIndemnity Bonds
Continuance of Past ContractIncluding Supervisors in the Contract
Additional parties to the contract such as the international union
Use of Union Label
Employment of Strike Breakers
Pension Benefits of Retired EmployeesScope of the Bargaining Unit
Management Right as to Union Affairs
Prices in Cafeteria
Membership of Bargaining Team
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
15/35
ILLEGAL BARGAINING ITEMS
Examples:
Closed shop
Separation of employees based on race
Disc than teriminatory treatment
are forbidden by law
A clause agreeing to hire union members
exclusively would be illegal in a right-to-work state
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
16/35
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
17/35
MEDIATION
An intervention in which a neutral third partytries to assist the principals in reaching
agreement.
ARBITRATION
The most definitive type of third partyintervention, in which the arbitrator usually
has the power to determine and dictate thesettlement terms.
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
18/35
STRIKES
Economic strike - a strike that results from a failureto agree on the terms of a contract that involveswages, benefits and other conditions of
employment. Unfair labor practice strike - a strike aimed at
protesting illegal conduct by the employer
Wildcat strike - an unauthorized strike occurrence
during the term of a contract
Sympathy strike - a strike that takes place when oneunion strikes in support of the strike of another.
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
19/35
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
20/35
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
21/35
Labor Management Contracts differ in their
bargaining structures but the actual contractagreement may be 20 or 30 pages long orlonger. It may contain just general declarations
of policy or a detailed specification of rules andprocedures.
The tendency today is toward the longer,
more detailed contract. This is largely a result ofthe increased number of items the agreements
have been covering.
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
22/35
(1) Management rights,
(2) union security and automatic payroll dues deduction,
(3) grievance procedures,
(4) arbitration of grievances,(5) disciplinary procedures,
(6) compensation rates,
(7) hours of work and overtime,
(8) benefits: vacations, holidays, insurance, pensions,(9) health and safety provisions,
(10)employee security seniority provisions, and
(11)contract expiration date.
The main sections of a typical contract cover
subjects such as these:
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
23/35
Negotiation
Is a process of building a common interest and
reducing differences in order to arrive an
agreement which is at least minimally
acceptable to all parties concerned.
Is the process that occurs when two or more
parties, each of whom is seen as controllingsome resource which the other desires, confer
to reach an agreement on mutual exchange of
the resources.
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
24/35
The Negotiation Process could be broken
into four subprocesses:1) Distributive Bargaining focuses on dividing a fixed
economic pie between the two sides
2) Integrative Bargaining has a win win focus; it seekssolutions that are beneficial to both sides
3) Attitudinal Structuring refers to the relationship andtrust between labor and management negotiators
4) Intraorganizational Bargaining reminds us that labor
management negotiations involve more than just twoparties
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
25/35
Managements Preparation for
Negotiations can be divided into seven areas,most of which have counterparts
on the union side:
1. Establishing interdepartmental contractobjectives
2. Reviewing the old contract
3. Preparing and analyzing data
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
26/35
4. Anticipating union demands
5. Establishing the cost of possible contract
provisions
6. Preparing for a strike
7. Determining strategy and logistics
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
27/35
Negotiation Stages andTactics
1. Early Stages: more people are present; unionnegotiators often raise an extensive list of
proposals
2. Middle Stage: each side makes a series of decisions
3. Final Stage: pressure for an agreement
increases as the deadline for a strike
approaches; negotiators from each side mayhave oneonone meetings or small groupmeetings where a neutral third party may
become involved; impasse may occur
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
28/35
ow to Avoid Impasses
1. Separate the people from the problem
2. Focus on Interests, not positions
3. Generate a variety of possibilities before
deciding what to do
4. Insist that the results be based on some
objective standard
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
29/35
Managements Willingness toT
ake a Strikecomes down to two questions:
1. Can the company remain profitable over thelong run if it agrees to the unions demands?
2. Can the company continue to operate in the
short run despite a strike?
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
30/35
Factors to consider / that gets affected when
there is a strike:1) Product Demand
2) Product Perishability
3) Technology
4) Availability of replacement workers
5) Multiple production sites and staggered
contracts6) Integrated facilities
7) Lack of substitutes for the product
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
31/35
Alternatives to Strike:
Bargaining outcomes also depend on the
nature of the bargaining process andrelationships which include the type of tacticsused and the history of labor relations.
1) Mediation
2) Fact Finding3) Arbitration
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
32/35
ContractAdministration
Hammering out a labor agreement is not the
last step in collective bargaining; in some respects,
it is just the beginning.
The contract negotiation process typicallyoccurs only about every 3 years while contract
administration goes on day after day, year afteryear.
Vague or incomplete contract language
developed in the negotiat ion process can make
administration of the contract difficult.
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
33/35
Grievance Procedure
Key influence in successful contract
administration
Procedure for resolving labor-management
disputes over the interpretation andexecution of the contract
From the employees perspective, it is the key
to fair treatment in the workplace
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
34/35
New Labor-Management Strategies
Employee involvement in decision-making,
Self-managing employee teams,
Broadly defined jobs, and
Sharing of financial gains and businessinformation with employees
8/2/2019 Labor Relations, Collective Bargaining, Contract Negotiating and Health & Safety - FINAL
35/35