Lectura 6 Acemoglu Et Al 2004 Institutions as the Fundamental Cause of Long-run Growth

8/13/2019 Lectura 6 Acemoglu Et Al 2004 Institutions as the Fundamental Cause of Long-run Growth

1/111

!"#$%$&$%'"# (# $)* +&",(-*"$(. /(* '01'"234&" 56'7$)

!"#$% &'()$*+,!(-"#.)(%. $/ 0'$%$)1'23 456

71)$% 8$9%2$%7+$"% 7'9$$+ $/ 4"%"*()(%.3 456

8")(2 :$;1%2$%!(-"#.)(%.2 $/


2/111

89#$6(:$

6912 -"-(# =(F(+$-2 .9( ()-1#1'"+ "%= .9($#(.1'"+ '"2( .9". =1(#(%'(2 1% ('$%$)1'1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( .9( /,%=")(%."+ '",2( $/ =1(#(%'(2 1% ('$%$)1' =(F(+$-)(%.G H( !#2.=$',)(%. .9( ()-1#1'"+ 1)-$#."%'( $/ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 ;@ /$',21%* $% .I$ JK,"21L%".,#"+ (ML-(#1)(%.2N 1% 912.$#@3 .9( =1F121$% $/ O$#(" 1%.$ .I$ -"#.2 I1.9 F(#@ =1(#(%. ('$%$)1'1%2.1.,.1$%2 "%= .9( '$+$%1P".1$% $/ ),'9 $/ .9( I$#+= ;@ 0,#$-("% -$I(#2 2."#.1%* 1% .9(

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

-$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "%= .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ #(2$,#'(2G


3/111

! "#$%&'()$*

!+! ,-. /(.0$*

69( )$2. .#1.( @(. '#,'1"+ K,(2.1$% 1% .9( !(+= $/ ('$%$)1' *#$I.9 "%= =(F(+$-)(%.

12R H9@ "#( 2$)( '$,%.#1(2 ),'9 -$$#(# .9"% $.9(#2S 6#"=1.1$%"+ %($'+"221'"+ *#$I.9)$=(+23 /$++$I1%* 7$+$I TEBUVW3 X"22 TEBVUW "%= O$$-)"%2 TEBVUW3 (M-+"1% =1(#(%'(2

1% 1%'$)( -(# '"-1." 1% .(#)2 $/ =1(#(%. -".92 $/ /"'.$# "'',),+".1$%G 5% .9(2( )$=(+23

'#$22L'$,%.#@ =1(#(%'(2 1% /"'.$# "'',),+".1$% "#( =,( (1.9(# .$ =1(#(%'(2 1% 2"F1%*

#".(2 T7$+$IW3 -#(/(#(%'(2 TX"22LO$$-)"%2W3 $# $.9(# (M$*(%$,2 -"#")(.(#23 2,'9 "2

.$."+ /"'.$# -#$=,'.1F1.@ *#$I.9G 4$#( #('(%. 1%'"#%".1$%2 $/ *#$I.9 .9($#@3 /$++$I1%*

:$)(# TEBYVW "%= Z,'"2 TEBYYW3 (%=$*(%1P( 2.("=@L2.".( *#$I.9 "%= .('9%1'"+ -#$*#(223;,. .9(1# (M-+"%".1$% /$# 1%'$)( =1(#(%'(2 12 21)1+"# .$ .9". $/ .9( $+=(# .9($#1(2G [$#

1%2."%'(3 1% .9( )$=(+ $/ :$)(# TEBBCW3 " '$,%.#@ )"@ ;( )$#( -#$2-(#$,2 .9"% "%L

$.9(# 1/ 1. "++$'".(2 )$#( #(2$,#'(2 .$ 1%%$F".1$%3 ;,. I9". =(.(#)1%(2 .912 12 (22(%.1"++@

-#(/(#(%'(2 "%= -#$-(#.1(2 $/ .9( .('9%$+$*@ /$# '#(".1%* \1=("2]G!

69$,*9 .912 .9($#(.1'"+ .#"=1.1$% 12 2.1++ F1;#"%. 1% ('$%$)1'2 "%= 9"2 -#$F1=(= )"%@

1%21*9.2 ";$,. .9( )('9"%1'2 $/ ('$%$)1' *#$I.93 1. 9"2 /$# " +$%* .1)( 2(()(= ,%";+( .$

-#$F1=( "&$+!',"+)'-(M-+"%".1$% /$# ('$%$)1' *#$I.9G &2 ^$#.9 "%= 69$)"2 TEB_`3 -G

AW -,. 1.R J.9( /"'.$#2 I( 9"F( +12.(= T1%%$F".1$%3 ('$%$)1(2 $/ 2'"+(3 (=,'".1$%3 '"-1."+


4/111

1%'(%.1F(2 1% 2$'1(.@G H1.9$,. -#$-(#.@ #1*9.23 1%=1F1=,"+2 I1++ %$. 9"F( .9( 1%'(%.1F( .$

1%F(2. 1% -9@21'"+ $# 9,)"% '"-1."+ $# "=$-. )$#( ('1(%. .('9%$+$*1(2G 0'$%$)1' 1%2.1L

.,.1$%2 "#( "+2$ 1)-$#."%. ;('",2( .9(@ 9(+- .$ "++$'".( #(2$,#'(2 .$ .9(1# )$2. ('1(%.

,2(23 .9(@ =(.(#)1%( I9$ *(.2 -#$!.23 #(F(%,(2 "%= #(21=,"+ #1*9.2 $/ '$%.#$+G H9(%

)"#?(.2 "#( )1221%* $# 1*%$#(= T"2 .9(@ I(#( 1% .9( 7$F1(. d%1$%3 /$# (M")-+(W3 *"1%2

/#$) .#"=( *$ ,%(M-+$1.(= "%= #(2$,#'(2 "#( )12"++$'".(=G 7$'1(.1(2 I1.9 ('$%$)1' 1%L

2.1.,.1$%2 .9". /"'1+1.".( "%= (%'$,#"*( /"'.$# "'',),+".1$%3 1%%$F".1$% "%= .9( ('1(%.

"++$'".1$% $/ #(2$,#'(2 I1++ -#$2-(#G

X(%.#"+ .$ .912 '9"-.(# "%= .$ ),'9 $/ -$+1.1'"+ ('$%$)@ #(2("#'9 $% 1%2.1.,.1$%2 12

.9". ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%23 "%= 1%2.1.,.1$%2 )$#( ;#$"=+@3 "#( "+!*2"+*$1a .9(@ "#(3 ".

+("2. 1% -"#.3 =(.(#)1%(= ;@ 2$'1(.@3 $# " 2(*)(%. $/ 1.G X$%2(K,(%.+@3 .9( K,(2.1$% $/

I9@ 2$)( 2$'1(.1(2 "#( ),'9 -$$#(# .9"% $.9(#2 12 '+$2(+@ #(+".(= .$ .9( K,(2.1$% $/ I9@

2$)( 2$'1(.1(2 9"F( ),'9 JI$#2( ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2N .9"% $.9(#2G0F(% .9$,*9 )"%@ 2'9$+"#2 1%'+,=1%* 8$9% Z$'?(3 &=") 7)1.93 8$9% 7.,"#. 41++3

!$,*+"22 ^$#.9 "%= :$;(#. 69$)"2 9"F( ()-9"21P(= .9( 1)-$#."%'( $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1L

.,.1$%23 I( "#( /"# /#$) " ,2(/,+ /#")(I$#? /$# .91%?1%* ";$,. 9$I ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2

"#( =(.(#)1%(= "%= I9@ .9(@ F"#@ "'#$22 '$,%.#1(2G 5% $.9(# I$#=23 I91+( I( 9"F( *$$=

#("2$% .$ ;(+1(F( .9". ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 )"..(# /$# ('$%$)1' *#$I.93 I( +"'? .9( '#,L

'1"+ (*,.'%')03" 1)')0(#(2,+.2 I91'9 I1++ "++$I ,2 .$ (M-+"1% I9@ (K,1+1;#1,) ('$%$)1'1%2.1.,.1$%2 =1(# T"%= -(#9"-2 .912 12 -"#. $/ .9( #("2$% I9@ ),'9 $/ .9( ('$%$)1'2

+1.(#".,#( 9"2 /$',2(= $% .9( -#$M1)".( '",2(2 $/ ('$%$)1' *#$I.9 +"#*(+@ %(*+('.1%*


5/111

.9$,*9 ',+.,#"+ "%= *($*#"-91'"+ /"'.$#2 )"@ "+2$ )"..(# /$# ('$%$)1' -(#/$#)"%'(3

=1(#(%'(2 1% ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( .9( )"Q$# 2$,#'( $/ '#$22L'$,%.#@ =1(#(%'(2 1%

('$%$)1' *#$I.9 "%= -#$2-(#1.@G 0'$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 %$. $%+@ =(.(#)1%( .9( "**#(L

*".( ('$%$)1' *#$I.9 -$.(%.1"+ $/ .9( ('$%$)@3 ;,. "+2$ "% "##"@ $/ ('$%$)1' $,.'$)(23

1%'+,=1%* .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ #(2$,#'(2 1% .9( /,.,#( T1G(G3 .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ I("+.93 $/

-9@21'"+ '"-1."+ $# 9,)"% '"-1."+WG 5% $.9(# I$#=23 .9(@ 1%",(%'( %$. $%+@ .9( 21P( $/

.9( "**#(*".( -1(3 ;,. 9$I .912 -1( 12 =1F1=(= ")$%* =1(#(%. *#$,-2 "%= 1%=1F1=,"+2

1% 2$'1(.@G H( 2,))"#1P( .9(2( 1=("2 2'9()".1'"++@ "2 TI9(#( .9( 2,;2'#1-. #(/(#2 .$

',##(%. -(#1$= "%= e E .$ .9( /,.,#(WR

('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2f

! ('$%$)1' -(#/$#)"%'(=12.#1;,.1$% $/ #(2$,#'(2"!

AG 0'$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( (%=$*(%$,2G 69(@ "#( =(.(#)1%(= "2 '$++('.1F( '9$1'(2$/ .9( 2$'1(.@3 1% +"#*( -"#. /$# .9(1# ('$%$)1' '$%2(K,(%'(2G b$I(F(#3 .9(#( 12 %$

*,"#"%.(( .9". "++ 1%=1F1=,"+2 "%= *#$,-2 I1++ -#(/(# .9( 2")( 2(. $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2

;('",2(3 "2 %$.(= ";$F(3 =1(#(%. ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 +("= .$ =1(#(%. =12.#1;,.1$%2

$/ #(2$,#'(2G X$%2(K,(%.+@3 .9(#( I1++ .@-1'"++@ ;( " (*+!0() *& 0+)"%"1)")$%* F"#1$,2

*#$,-2 "%= 1%=1F1=,"+2 $F(# .9( '9$1'( $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2G 7$ 9$I "#( (K,1+1;#1,)

('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 =(.(#)1%(=S 5/ .9(#( "#(3 /$# (M")-+(3 .I$ *#$,-2 I1.9 $--$21%*

-#(/(#(%'(2 $F(# .9( 2(. $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%23 I91'9 *#$,-]2 -#(/(#(%'(2 I1++ -#(F"1+S

69( "%2I(# =(-(%=2 $% .9( .*-0)0('- .*4"% $/ .9( .I$ *#$,-2G &+.9$,*9 .9( ('1(%'@ $/


6/111

'"%%$. '$))1. %$. .$ ,2( 1. 1% .9(1# ;(2. 1%.(#(2.23 "%= .912 '$))1.)(%. -#$;+() '#(L

".(2 "% 1%2(-"#";1+1.@ ;(.I((% ('1(%'@ "%= =12.#1;,.1$% ;('",2( '#(=1;+( '$)-(%2".1%*

.#"%2/(#2 "%= 21=(L-"@)(%.2 '"%%$. ;( )"=( .$ $2(. .9( =12.#1;,.1$%"+ '$%2(K,(%'(2 $/

"%@ -"#.1',+"# 2(. $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2G

DG 69( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# 1% 2$'1(.@ 12 "+2$ (%=$*(%$,23 9$I(F(#G 5%

$,# /#")(I$#?3 1. 12 ,2(/,+ .$ =12.1%*,129 ;(.I((% .I$ '$)-$%(%.2 $/ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#3

I91'9 I( #(/(# .$ "2 !" #$%" 50+1)0)$)0*+'-6 "%= !" &'()* .*-0)0('- .*4"%G b(#( =( Q,#(

-$+1.1'"+ -$I(# #(/(#2 .$ -$I(# .9". $#1*1%".(2 /#$) .9( .*-0)0('- 0+1)0)$)0*+11% 2$'1(.@G


7/111

-$I(#3 9(%'(R

=12.#1;,.1$% $/ #(2$,#'(2f=( /"'.$ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#

VG 6912 ;#1%*2 ,2 .$ .9( (F$+,.1$% $/ $%( $/ .9( .I$ )"1% 1)')" 3'%0'7-"1 1% $,#

/#")(I$#?3 -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 T.9( $.9(# 2.".( F"#1";+( 12 .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ #(2$,#'(23

1%'+,=1%* =12.#1;,.1$% $/ -9@21'"+ "%= 9,)"% '"-1."+ 2.$'?2 (.'GWG


8/111

/#")(I$#? 12 "2 /$++$I2R

-$+1.1'"+1%2.1.,.1$%2

=12.#1;,.1$%$/ #(2$,#'(2

f

f

=( Q,#(-$+1.1'"+

-$I(#h

=( /"'.$-$+1.1'"+

-$I(#

f

f

('$%$)1'1%2.1.,.1$%2

-$+1.1'"+1%2.1.,.1$%2"!

f

('$%$)1'-(#/$#)"%'(

h=12.#1;,.1$%

$/ #(2$,#'(2"!

69( .I$ 2.".( F"#1";+(2 "#( -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "%= .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ #(2$,#'(23

"%= .9( ?%$I+(=*( $/ .9(2( .I$ F"#1";+(2 ". .1)( 12 2,'1(%. .$ =(.(#)1%( "++ .9( $.9(#

F"#1";+(2 1% .9( 2@2.()G H91+( -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 =(.(#)1%( .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ =( Q,#(

-$+1.1'"+ -$I(# 1% 2$'1(.@3 .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ #(2$,#'(2 1%",(%'(2 .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ =(

/"'.$ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# ". .1)( G 69(2( .I$ 2$,#'(2 $/ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#3 1% .,#%3 "('. .9(

'9$1'( $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "%= 1%",(%'( .9( /,.,#( (F$+,.1$% $/ -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2G

0'$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 =(.(#)1%( ('$%$)1' $,.'$)(23 1%'+,=1%* .9( "**#(*".( *#$I.9

#".( $/ .9( ('$%$)@ "%= .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ #(2$,#'(2 ". .1)( e EG &+.9$,*9 ('$%$)1'

1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( .9( (22(%.1"+ /"'.$# 29"-1%* ('$%$)1' $,.'$)(23 .9(@ "#( .9()2(+F(2

(%=$*(%$,2 "%= =(.(#)1%(= ;@ -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "%= =12.#1;,.1$% $/ #(2$,#'(2 1%

2$'1(.@G

69(#( "#( .I$ 2$,#'(2 $/ -(#212.(%'( 1% .9( ;(9"F1$# $/ .9( 2@2.()R !#2.3 -$+1.1'"+1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( =,#";+(3 "%= .@-1'"++@3 " 2,'1(%.+@ +"#*( '9"%*( 1% .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/


9/111

2,'9 #1*9.2 I(#( +"#*(+@ =('1=(= ;@ .9(2( )$%"#'92G d%/$#.,%".(+@ /$# ('$%$)1' *#$I.93

I91+( )$%"#'92 9"= (F(#@ 1%'(%.1F( .$ -#$.('. .9(1# $I% -#$-(#.@ #1*9.23 .9(@ =1= %$.

*(%(#"++@ (%/$#'( .9( -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2 $/ $.9(#2G c% .9( '$%.#"#@3 )$%"#'92 $/.(% ,2(=

.9(1# -$I(#2 .$ (M-#$-#1".( -#$=,'(#23 1)-$2( "#;1.#"#@ ."M".1$%3 #(%(*( $% .9(1# =(;.23

"%= "++$'".( .9( -#$=,'.1F( #(2$,#'(2 $/ 2$'1(.@ .$ .9(1# "++1(2 1% #(.,#% /$# ('$%$)1'

;(%(!.2 $# -$+1.1'"+ 2,--$#.G X$%2(K,(%.+@3 ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 =,#1%* .9( 41==+(

&*(2 -#$F1=(= +1..+( 1%'(%.1F( .$ 1%F(2. 1% +"%=3 -9@21'"+ $# 9,)"% '"-1."+3 $# .('9%$+L

$*@3 "%= /"1+(= .$ /$2.(# ('$%$)1' *#$I.9G 69(2( ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "+2$ (%2,#(= .9".

.9( )$%"#'92 '$%.#$++(= " +"#*( /#"'.1$% $/ .9( ('$%$)1' #(2$,#'(2 1% 2$'1(.@3 2$+1=1/@1%*

.9(1# -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# "%= (%2,#1%* .9( '$%.1%,".1$% $/ .9( -$+1.1'"+ #(*1)(G

69( 2(F(%.((%.9 '(%.,#@3 9$I(F(#3 I1.%(22(= )"Q$# '9"%*(2 1% .9( ('$%$)1' "%=

-$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 .9". -"F(= .9( I"@ /$# .9( =(F(+$-)(%. $/ -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2 "%=

+1)1.2 $% )$%"#'92] -$I(#3 (2-('1"++@ 1% 0%*+"%= "/.(# .9( X1F1+ H"# $/ EVDA "%= .9(i+$#1$,2 :(F$+,.1$% $/ EVYY3 "%= 1% .9( ^(.9(#+"%=2 "/.(# .9( !,.'9 :(F$+. "*"1%2.

.9( b"-2;,#*2G b$I =1= .9(2( )"Q$# 1%2.1.,.1$%"+ '9"%*(2 ."?( -+"'(S 5% 0%*+"%=3

/$# (M")-+(3 ,%.1+ .9( 21M.((%.9 '(%.,#@ .9( ?1%* "+2$ -$22(22(= " 2,;2."%.1"+ ")$,%.

$/ =( /"'.$ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#3 "%= +("F1%* "21=( '1F1+ I"#2 #(+".(= .$ #$@"+ 2,''(221$%3 %$

$.9(# 2$'1"+ *#$,- '$,+= ")"22 2,'1(%. =( /"'.$ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# .$ '9"++(%*( .9( ?1%*G

>,. '9"%*(2 1% .9( 0%*+129 +"%= )"#?(. T6"I%(@3 EBDEW "%= .9( (M-"%21$% $/ &.+"%.1'

.#"=( 1% .9( 21M.((%.9 "%= 2(F(%.((%.9 '(%.,#1(2 T&'()$*+,3 8$9%2$% "%= :$;1%2$%3

ACCA;W *#"=,"++@ 1%'#("2(= .9( ('$%$)1' /$#.,%(2 "%= '$%2(K,(%.+@ .9( =( /"'.$ -$I(#


10/111

('$%$)1' #(2$,#'(2 /#$) .9". 1% .9( 41==+( &*(2G

5. 12 I$#.9 #(.,#%1%* ". .912 -$1%. .$ .I$ '#1.1'"+ "22,)-.1$%2 1% $,# /#")(I$#?G

[1#2.3 I9@ =$ .9( *#$,-2 I1.9 '$%"1'.1%* 1%.(#(2.2 %$. "*#(( $% .9( 2(. $/ ('$%$)1'

1%2.1.,.1$%2 .9". )"M1)1P( "**#(*".( *#$I.9S 7$ 1% .9( '"2( $/ .9( '$%"1'. ;(.I((% .9(

)$%"#'9@ "%= .9( )(#'9"%.23 I9@ =$(2 .9( )$%"#'9@ %$. 2(. ,- 2(',#( -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2

.$ (%'$,#"*( ('$%$)1' *#$I.9 "%= ."M 2$)( $/ .9( ;(%(!.2S 7('$%=3 I9@ =$ *#$,-2

I1.9 -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# I"%. .$ '9"%*( -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 1% .9(1# /"F$#S [$# 1%2."%'(3 1%

.9( '$%.(M. $/ .9( (M")-+( ";$F(3 I9@ =1= .9( *(%.#@ "%= )(#'9"%.2 ,2( .9(1# =( /"'.$

-$+1.1'"+ -$I(# .$ '9"%*( -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 #".9(# .9"% 21)-+@ 1)-+()(%. .9( -$+1'1(2

.9(@ I"%.(=S 69( "%2I(#2 .$ ;$.9 K,(2.1$%2 #(F$+F( "#$,%= 122,(2 $/(*,,0),"+)"%=

*$ .$ .9( 9("#. $/ $,# /#")(I$#?G

69( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ #(2$,#'(2 1% 2$'1(.@ 12 "% 1%9(#(%.+@ '$%"1'.,"+3 "%= .9(#(/$#(

-$+1.1'"+3 =('121$%G &2 )(%.1$%(= ";$F(3 .912 +("=2 .$ )"Q$# '$))1.)(%. -#$;+()2321%'( *#$,-2 I1.9 -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# '"%%$. '$))1. .$ %$. ,21%* .9(1# -$I(# .$ '9"%*( .9(

=12.#1;,.1$% $/ #(2$,#'(2 1% .9(1# /"F$#G [$# (M")-+(3 ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 .9". 1%'#("2(=

.9( 2(',#1.@ $/ -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2 /$# +"%= "%= '"-1."+ $I%(#2 =,#1%* .9( 41==+( &*(2 I$,+=

%$. 9"F( ;((% '#(=1;+( "2 +$%* "2 .9( )$%"#'9 )$%$-$+1P(= -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#G b( '$,+=

-#$)12( .$ #(2-('. -#$-(#.@ #1*9.23 ;,. .9(% ". 2$)( -$1%.3 #(%(*( $% 912 -#$)12(3 "2

(M()-+1!(= ;@ .9( %,)(#$,2 !%"%'1"+ =(/",+.2 ;@ )(=1(F"+ ?1%*2 T(G*G3 j(1.'93 EBYVWG

X#(=1;+( 2(',#( -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2 %('(221.".(= " #(=,'.1$% 1% .9( -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# $/ .9(

)$%"#'9 &+.9$,*9 .9(2( )$#( 2(',#( -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2 I$,+= /$2.(# ('$%$)1' *#$I.9


11/111

/"'.$ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#3 .912 I$,+= %$. 9"F( ;((% " -#$;+()G b$I(F(#3 =( /"'.$ -$+1.1'"+

-$I(# 12 $/.(% .#"%21(%.3 /$# (M")-+( ;('",2( .9( '$++('.1F( "'.1$% -#$;+()2 .9". "#(

2$+F(= .$ ")"22 .912 -$I(# "#( +1?(+@ .$ #(2,#/"'( 1% .9( /,.,#(3 $# $.9(# *#$,-23 (2-('1"++@

.9$2( '$%.#$++1%* =( Q,#( -$I(#3 '"% ;('$)( 2.#$%*(# 1% .9( /,.,#(G 69(#(/$#(3 "%@ '9"%*(

1% -$+1'1(2 "%= ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 .9". #(+1(2 -,#(+@ $% =( /"'.$ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# 12

+1?(+@ .$ ;( #(F(#2(= 1% .9( /,.,#(G 5% "==1.1$%3 )"%@ #(F$+,.1$%2 "#( /$++$I(= ;@ '$%"1'.

I1.91% .9( #(F$+,.1$%"#1(2G :('$*%1P1%* .9123 .9( 0%*+129 *(%.#@ "%= )(#'9"%.2 2.#$F(

%$. Q,2. .$ '9"%*( ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 1% .9(1# /"F$# /$++$I1%* .9(1# F1'.$#1(2 "*"1%2.

.9( 7.,"#. )$%"#'9@3 ;,. "+2$ .$ "+.(# -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "%= .9( /,.,#( "++$'".1$% $/

=( Q,#( -$I(#G d21%* -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# .$ '9"%*( -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 .9(% ()(#*(2 "2 "

,2(/,+ 2.#".(*@ .$ )"?( *"1%2 )$#( =,#";+(G 69( /#")(I$#? .9". I( -#$-$2(3 .9(#(/$#(3

()-9"21P(2 .9( 1)-$#."%'( $/ -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%23 "%= '9"%*(2 1% -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%23

"2 " I"@ $/ )"%1-,+".1%* /,.,#( -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#3 "%= .9,2 1%=1#('.+@ 29"-1%* /,.,#(3 "2I(++ "2 -#(2(%.3 ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "%= $,.'$)(2G

6912 /#")(I$#?3 .9$,*9 ";2.#"'. "%= 91*9+@ 21)-+(3 (%";+(2 ,2 .$ -#$F1=( 2$)(

-#(+1)1%"#@ "%2I(#2 .$ $,# )"1% K,(2.1$%R I9@ =$ 2$)( 2$'1(.1(2 '9$$2( J*$$= ('$%$)1'

1%2.1.,.1$%2NS &. .912 -$1%.3 I( %((= .$ ;( )$#( 2-('1!' ";$,. I9". *$$= ('$%$)1'

1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#(G & ="%*(# I( I$,+= +1?( .$ "F$1= 12 .9". I( =(!%( *$$= ('$%$)1'

1%2.1.,.1$%2 "2 .9$2( .9". *(%(#".( ('$%$)1' *#$I.93 -$.(%.1"++@ +("=1%* .$ " .",.$+$*@G

6912 ="%*(# "#12(2 ;('",2( " *1F(% 2(. $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 )"@ ;( #(+".1F(+@ *$$=

=,#1%* 2$)( -(#1$=2 "%= ;"= =,#1%* $.9(#2 [$# (M")-+( " 2(. $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2


12/111

-"#".1F( 2.".1'23 "%= .9,2 .$ "% "%2I(# .$ $,# ;"21' K,(2.1$%G [1#2.3 -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2

.9". -+"'( '9('?2 $% .9$2( I9$ 9$+= -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#3 /$# (M")-+(3 ;@ '#(".1%* " ;"+"%'(

$/ -$I(# 1% 2$'1(.@3 "#( ,2(/,+ /$# .9( ()(#*(%'( $/ *$$= ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2G 6912

#(2,+. 12 1%.,1.1F(a I1.9$,. '9('?2 $% -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#3 -$I(# 9$+=(#2 "#( )$#( +1?(+@ .$

$-. /$# " 2(. $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 .9". "#( ;(%(!'1"+ /$# .9()2(+F(2 "%= =(.#1)(%L

."+ /$# .9( #(2. $/ 2$'1(.@3 I91'9 I1++ .@-1'"++@ /"1+ .$ -#$.('. -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2 $/ " ;#$"=

'#$22L2('.1$% $/ -($-+(G 7('$%=3 *$$= ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( )$#( +1?(+@ .$ "#12( I9(%

-$+1.1'"+ -$I(# 12 1% .9( 9"%=2 $/ " #(+".1F(+@ ;#$"= *#$,- I1.9 21*%1!'"%. 1%F(2.)(%.

$--$#.,%1.1(2G 69( #("2$% /$# .912 #(2,+. 12 .9".3 (F(#@.91%* (+2( (K,"+3 1% .912 '"2( -$I(#

9$+=(#2 I1++ .9()2(+F(2 ;(%(!. /#$) 2(',#( -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2G# 691#=3 *$$= ('$%$)1' 1%2.1L

.,.1$%2 "#( )$#( +1?(+@ .$ "#12( "%= -(#212. I9(% .9(#( "#( $%+@ +1)1.(= #(%.2 .9". -$I(#

9$+=(#2 '"% (M.#"'. /#$) .9( #(2. $/ 2$'1(.@3 21%'( 2,'9 #(%.2 I$,+= (%'$,#"*( .9() .$

$-. /$# " 2(. $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 .9". )"?( .9( (M-#$-#1".1$% $/ $.9(#2 -$221;+(G69(2( '$)-"#".1F( 2.".1'2 .9(#(/$#( -+"'( -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 ". .9( '(%.(# $/ .9( 2.$#@3

"2 ()-9"21P(= ;@ $,# .(#) J91(#"#'9@ $/ 1%2.1.,.1$%2N ";$F(G


13/111

.9( )$2. -+",21;+( 12 .9( 1*(0'- (*+!0() 30"4G &''$#=1%* .$ .912 .9($#@3 ;"= 1%2.1.,.1$%2

"#12( ;('",2( .9( *#$,-2 I1.9 -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# ;(%(!. /#$) ;"= 1%2.1.,.1$%2G 69( ()-9"212

$% 2$'1"+ '$%"1'. "#12(2 %".,#"++@ /#$) $,# $;2(#F".1$% ";$F( .9". ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2

1%",(%'( .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ #(2$,#'(2 "2 I(++ "2 ('1(%'@G !1(#(%. *#$,-2 $# 1%=1F1=,"+2

I1++ .9(#(/$#( -#(/(# =1(#(%. 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "%= '$%"1'. I1++ "#12( "2 ("'9 .#1(2 .$ *(. .9(1#

$I% I"@G 7('.1$% V =(+F(2 =((-(# 1%.$ K,(2.1$%2 $/ ('1(%'@ "%= "2?2 I9@ " -$+1.1'"+

F(#21$% $/ .9( X$"2( 69($#() =$(2 %$. 9$+=G H( ()-9"21P( .9( 1=(" .9". '$))1.)(%.

-#$;+()2 "#( 1%.#1%21' .$ .9( (M(#'12( $/ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#G 5% 2('.1$% _ I( "#*,( .9". "

2(#1(2 $/ 912.$#1'"+ (M")-+(2 $/ =1F(#*1%* ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( ;(2. (M-+"1%(= ;@ .9(

2$'1"+ '$%"1'. F1(IG 69(2( (M")-+(2 1++,2.#".( 9$I ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( =(.(#)1%(=

;@ .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#3 "%= 9$I .912 =12.#1;,.1$% 12 1%",(%'(= ;@ -$+1.1'"+

1%2.1.,.1$%2G 7('.1$% Y -,.2 .9(2( 1=("2 .$*(.9(# .$ ;,1+= $,# .9($#@ $/ 1%2.1.,.1$%2G 5%

2('.1$% B I( .9(% '$%21=(# .I$ )$#( (M.(%=(= (M")-+(2 $/ .9( .9($#@ 1% "'.1$%3 .9(#12( $/ '$%2.1.,.1$%"+ #,+( 1% ("#+@ )$=(#% 0,#$-(3 "%= .9( '#(".1$% $/ )"22 =()$'#"'@3

-"#.1',+"#+@ 1% >#1."1%3 1% .9( %1%(.((%.9 "%= .I(%.1(.9 '(%.,#1(2G 7('.1$% EC '$%'+,=(2

I1.9 " =12',221$% $/ I9(#( .912 #(2("#'9 -#$*#") '"% *$ %(M.G

1 8(#'94.#$97 :9(0.0 &; "#)&4.


14/111

:;+1)0)$)0*+1

&. 1.2 '$#(3 .9( 9@-$.9(212 .9". =1(#(%'(2 1% ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( .9( /,%=")(%."+

'",2( $/ =1(#(%. -"..(#%2 $/ ('$%$)1' *#$I.9 12 ;"2(= $% .9( %$.1$% .9". 1. 12 .9( I"@

.9". 9,)"%2 .9()2(+F(2 =('1=( .$ $#*"%1P( .9(1# 2$'1(.1(2 .9". =(.(#)1%(2 I9(.9(# $#

%$. .9(@ -#$2-(#G 7$)( I"@2 $/ $#*"%1P1%* 2$'1(.1(2 (%'$,#"*( -($-+( .$ 1%%$F".(3 .$

."?( #12?23 .$ 2"F( /$# .9( /,.,#(3 .$!

%= ;(..(# I"@2 $/ =$1%* .91%*23 .$ +("#% "%= (=,'".(.9()2(+F(23 2$+F( -#$;+()2 $/ '$++('.1F( "'.1$% "%= -#$F1=( -,;+1' *$$=2G c.9(#2 =$ %$.G

69( 1=(" .9". .9( -#$2-(#1.@ $/ " 2$'1(.@ =(-(%=2 $% 1.2 ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 *$(2

;"'? ". +("2. .$ &=") 7)1.93 /$# (M")-+( 1% 912 =12',221$%2 $/ )(#'"%.1+12) "%= .9( #$+(

$/ )"#?(.23 "%= I"2 -#$)1%(%. 1% .9( I$#? $/ )"%@ %1%(.((%.9 '(%.,#@ 2'9$+"#2 2,'9 "2

8$9% 7.,"#. 41++ T2(( .9( =12',221$% 1% 8$%(23 EBYEWR 2$'1(.1(2 "#( ('$%$)1'"++@ 2,''(22/,+

I9(% .9(@ 9"F( \*$$=] ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "%= 1. 12 .9(2( 1%2.1.,.1$%2 .9". "#( .9(

('$1" $/ -#$2-(#1.@G H( '"% .91%? $/ .9(2( *$$= ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "2 '$%212.1%*

$/ "% 1%.(#L#(+".(= '+,2.(# $/ .91%*2G 69(#( ),2. ;( (%/$#'()(%. $/ -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2

/$# " ;#$"= '#$22L2('.1$% $/ 2$'1(.@ 2$ .9". "++ 1%=1F1=,"+2 9"F( "% 1%'(%.1F( .$ 1%F(2.3

1%%$F".( "%= ."?( -"#. 1% ('$%$)1' "'.1F1.@G 69(#( ),2. "+2$ ;( 2$)( =(*#(( $/ (K,"+1.@

$/ $--$#.,%1.@ 1% 2$'1(.@3 1%'+,=1%* 2,'9 .91%*2 "2 (K,"+1.@ ;(/$#( .9( +"I3 2$ .9". .9$2(

I1.9 *$$= 1%F(2.)(%. $--$#.,%1.1(2 '"% ."?( "=F"%."*( $/ .9()G$

c%( '$,+= .91%? $/ $.9(# .@-(2 $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%23 /$# 1%2."%'( )"#?(.2G 6#"L=1.1$%"+ "''$,%.2 $/ ('$%$)1' *#$I.9 ;@ 912.$#1"%23 /$++$I1%* .9( +("= $/ &=") 7)1.93


15/111

69(2( .9($#1(2 -#$F1=( 1%.(#(2.1%* )$=(+2 $/ 9$I 1%'(%.1F(2 =(-(%= $% (M-('.".1$%2

$/ $.9(#2] ;(9"F1$# $# .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ I("+.9 *1F(% "% ,%=(#+@1%* 2(. $/ )"#?(. 1)L

-(#/('.1$%2G 69(@ ."?( .9( )"#?(. 2.#,'.,#( +"#*(+@ "2 *1F(%3 9$I(F(#G H( ;(+1(F( .9".

.9( 2.#,'.,#( $/ )"#?(.2 12 (%=$*(%$,23 "%= -"#.+@ =(.(#)1%(= ;@ -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2G c%'(

1%=1F1=,"+2 9"F( 2(',#( -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2 "%= .9(#( 12 (K,"+1.@ $/ $--$#.,%1.@3 .9( 1%'(%L

.1F(2 I1++ (M12. .$ '#(".( "%= 1)-#$F( )"#?(.2 T(F(% .9$,*9 "'91(F1%* -(#/('. )"#?(.2

I$,+= ;( .@-1'"++@ 1)-$221;+(WG 69,2 I( (M-('. =1(#(%'(2 1% )"#?(.2 .$ ;( "% $,.L'$)( $/ =1(#1%* 2@2.()2 $/ -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2 "%= -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%23 %$. ,%"+.(#";+(

'9"#"'.(#12.1'2 #(2-$%21;+( /$# '#$22L'$,%.#@ =1(#(%'(2 1% ('$%$)1' -(#/$#)"%'(G 6912

)$.1F".(2 $,# /$',2 $% ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 #(+".(= .$ .9( (%/$#'()(%. $/ .9( -#$-(#.@

#1*9.2 $/ " ;#$"= '#$22L2('.1$% $/ 2$'1(.@G

:;


16/111


17/111

69( )$2. /")$,2 +1%? ;(.I((% ',+.,#( "%= ('$%$)1' =(F(+$-)(%. 12 .9". -#$-$2(= ;@

H(;(# TEB`CW I9$ "#*,(= .9". .9( $#1*1%2 $/ 1%=,2.#1"+1P".1$% 1% I(2.(#% 0,#$-( '$,+=

;( .#"'(= .$ .9(


18/111

9$I 1. '$,+= ;( .#"%2/$#)(= ;@ 9,)"% (%=("F$#3 I91'9 12 "*"1% +1%?(= .$ #(+1*1$,2 =1(#L

(%'(2G &+.9$,*9 >"##$ "%= 4'X+("#@ TACC`W -#$F1=( (F1=(%'( $/ " -$21.1F( '$##(+".1$%

;(.I((% .9( -#(F"+(%'( $/ #(+1*1$,2 ;(+1(/23 %$.";+@ ";$,. 9(++ "%= 9("F(%3 "%= ('$%$)1'

*#$I.93 .912 (F1=(%'( =$(2 %$. 29$I " '",2"+ (('. $/ #(+1*1$% $% ('$%$)1' *#$I.93 21%'(

#(+1*1$,2 ;(+1(/2 "#( (%=$*(%$,2 ;$.9 .$ ('$%$)1' $,.'$)(2 "%= .$ $.9(# /,%=")(%."+

'",2(2 $/ 1%'$)( =1(#(%'(2 T-$1%.2 )"=( ;@ 6"I%(@3 EBAV3 "%= b1++3 EBVE;3 1% .9(

'$%.(M. $/ H(;(#]2 .9(212WG5=("2 ";$,. 9$I ',+.,#( )"@ 1%",(%'( *#$I.9 "#( %$. #(2.#1'.(= .$ .9( #$+( $/ #(+1L

*1$%G H1.91% .9( +1.(#".,#( .#@1%* .$ (M-+"1% '$)-"#".1F( =(F(+$-)(%. .9(#( 9"F( ;((%

"#*,)(%.2 .9". .9(#( 12 2$)(.91%* 2-('1"+ ";$,. -"#.1',+"# ',+.,#"+ (%=$I)(%.23 ,2,"++@

+1%?(= .$ -"#.1',+"# %".1$% 2.".(2G [$# 1%2."%'(3 Z".1% &)(#1'" )"@ ;( -$$# ;('",2( $/

1.2 5;(#1"% 9(#1."*(3 I91+( ^$#.9 &)(#1'" 12 -#$2-(#$,2 ;('",2( $/ 1.2 &%*+$L7"M$% 9(#L

1."*( Tjo(+1P3 EBBDWG 5% "==1.1$%3 " +"#*( +1.(#".,#( 1% "%.9#$-$+$*@ "#*,(2 .9". 2$'1(.1(2)"@ ;('$)( \=@2/,%'.1$%"+] $# \)"+"="-.(=] 1% .9( 2(%2( .9". .9(@ "=$-. " 2@2.() $/

;(+1(/2 $# I"@2 $# $-(#".1%* I91'9 =$ %$. -#$)$.( .9( 2,''(22 $# -#$2-(#1.@ $/ .9( 2$'1(.@

T2(( 0=*(#.$%3 EBBA3 /$# " 2,#F(@ $/ .912 +1.(#".,#(WG 69( )$2. /")$,2 F(#21$% $/ 2,'9 "%

"#*,)(%. 12 =,( .$ >"%!(+= TEBUYW I9$ "#*,(= .9". .9( -$F(#.@ $/ 7$,.9(#% 5."+@ I"2

=,( .$ .9( /"'. .9". -($-+( 9"= "=$-.(= " ',+.,#( $/ J")$#"+ /")1+1"#12)N I9(#( .9(@

$%+@ .#,2.(= 1%=1F1=,"+2 $/ .9(1# $I% /")1+1(2 "%= #(/,2(= .$ '$$-(#".( $# .#,2. "%@$%(

(+2(G 6912 "#*,)(%. I"2 #(F1F(= 1% .9( (M.(%21F( ()-1#1'"+ 2.,=@ $/


19/111

TEBBUW "%= 2,;2(K,(%.+@ ;@ b"++ "%= 8$%(2 TEBBBW "%= &'()$*+,3 8$9%2$% "%= :$;1%2$%

TACCE3 ACCA"W "#( 1)-(#/('. "2 " )("2,#( $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%23 ;,. .9( !%=1%*2 "#(

#$;,2. .$ ,21%* $.9(# "F"1+";+( )("2,#(2 $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2G 69( 2'"..(# -+$. 29$I2

.9". '$,%.#1(2 I1.9 )$#( 2(',#( -#$-(#.@ #1*9.23 1G(G3 ;(..(# ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%23 9"F(

91*9(# "F(#"*( 1%'$)(2G

5. 12 .()-.1%* .$ 1%.(#-#(. [1*,#( E "2 =(-1'.1%* " '",2"+ #(+".1$%291- T1G(G3 "2 (2.";L

+1291%* .9". 2(',#( -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2 '",2( -#$2-(#1.@WG ^(F(#.9(+(223 .9(#( "#( I(++ ?%$I%-#$;+()2 I1.9 )"?1%* 2,'9 "% 1%/(#(%'(G [1#2.3 .9(#( '$,+= ;( #(F(#2( '",2".1$% p -(#L

9"-2 $%+@ '$,%.#1(2 .9". "#( 2,'1(%.+@ I("+.9@ '"% "$#= .$ (%/$#'( -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2G

4$#( 1)-$#."%.+@3 .9(#( )1*9. ;( " -#$;+() $/ $)1..(= F"#1";+( ;1"2G 5. '$,+= ;( 2$)(L

.91%* (+2(3 (G*G3 *($*#"-9@3 .9". (M-+"1%2 ;$.9 I9@ '$,%.#1(2 "#( -$$# "%= I9@ .9(@ 9"F(

1%2(',#( -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2G 69,2 1/ $)1..(= /"'.$#2 =(.(#)1%( 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "%= 1%'$)(23

I( I$,+= 2-,#1$,2+@ 1%/(# .9( (M12.(%'( $/ " '",2"+ #(+".1$%291- ;(.I((% ('$%$)1' 1%L2.1.,.1$%2 "%= 1%'$)(2 I9(% 1% /"'. %$ 2,'9 #(+".1$%291- (M12.2G 6#@1%* .$ (2.1)".( .9(

#(+".1$%291- ;(.I((% 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "%= -#$2-(#1.@ ,21%* c#=1%"#@ Z("2. 7K,"#(23 "2 I"2

=$%( ;@ O%"'? "%= O((/(# TEBBUW "%= >"##$ TEBB_W '$,+= .9(#(/$#( #(2,+. 1% ;1"2(=

#(*#(221$% '$('1(%.2G

6$ /,#.9(# 1++,2.#".( .9(2( -$.(%.1"+ 0!"+)0"(')0*+ -#$;+()23 2,--$2( .9". '+1)".(3

$# *($*#"-9@ )$#( *(%(#"++@3 )"..(#2 /$# ('$%$)1' -(#/$#)"%'(G 5% /"'.3 " 21)-+( 2'".L

.(#-+$. 29$I2 " -$21.1F( "22$'1".1$% ;(.I((% +".1.,=( T.9( ";2$+,.( F"+,( $/ =12."%'(

/#$) .9( (K,".$#W "%= 1%'$)( -(# '"-1." 4$%.(2K,1(, 9$I(F(# %$. $%+@ '+"1)(= .9".


20/111

&2 "% (M")-+(3 '$%21=(# !#2. $%( $/ .9( '+("#(2. %".,#"+ (M-(#1)(%.2 /$# 1%2.1.,.1$%2G

5+! ,-. >&%.9# ?@A.%*4.#$

d%.1+ .9( (%= $/ H$#+= H"# 553 O$#(" I"2 ,%=(# 8"-"%(2( $'',-".1$%G O$#("% 1%=(L

-(%=(%'( '")( 29$#.+@ "/.(# .9( 8"-"%(2( 0)-(#$# b1#$91.$ "%%$,%'(= .9( 8"-"%(2(

2,##(%=(# $% &,*,2. EU3 EBDUG &/.(# .912 =".(3 7$F1(. /$#'(2 (%.(#(= 4"%'9,#1" "%=

^$#.9 O$#(" "%= .$$? $F(# .9( '$%.#$+ $/ .9(2( -#$F1%'(2 /#$) .9( 8"-"%(2(G 69( )"Q$#

/("# $/ .9( d%1.(= 7.".(2 =,#1%* .912 .1)( -(#1$= I"2 .9( ."?($F(# $/ .9( (%.1#( O$#("%

-(%1%2,+"# (1.9(# ;@ .9( 7$F1(. d%1$% $# ;@ '$)),%12. /$#'(2 ,%=(# .9( '$%.#$+ $/ .9(

/$#)(# *,(##1++" !*9.(#3 O1) 5+ 7,%*G dG7G ",.9$#1.1(2 .9(#(/$#( 2,--$#.(= .9( 1%",(%.1"+

%".1$%"+12. +("=(# 7@%*)"% :9((3 I9$ I"2 1% /"F$# $/ 2(-"#".1$% #".9(# .9"% " ,%1.(=

'$)),%12. O$#("G 0+('.1$%2 1% .9( 7$,.9 I(#( 9(+= 1% 4"@ EBDY3 ")1=2. " I1=(2-#("=

;$@'$.. ;@ O$#("%2 $--$2(= .$ 2(-"#".1$%G 69( %(I+@ (+('.(= #(-#(2(%.".1F(2 -#$'((=(=.$ =#"/. " %(I '$%2.1.,.1$% "%= (2.";+129(= .9( :(-,;+1' $/ O$#(" .$ .9( 2$,.9 $/ .9(

`Y.9 -"#"++(+G 69( ^$#.9 ;('")( .9( !()$'#".1'


21/111

+("=3 9@=#$-$I(# -$.(%.1"+GN >$.9 '$,%.#1(2 29"#( .9( 2")( *($*#"-91' -$221;1+1.1(2 1%

.(#)2 $/ "''(22 .$ )"#?(.2 "%= .9( '$2. $/ .#"%2-$#.".1$%G

c.9(# )"%L)"=( 1%1.1"+ ('$%$)1' '$%=1.1$%2 I(#( "+2$ 21)1+"#3 "%= 1/ "%@.91%*3 "=L

F"%."*(= .9( ^$#.9G [$# (M")-+(3 .9(#( I"2 21*%1!'"%. 1%=,2.#1"+1P".1$% =,#1%* .9(

'$+$%1"+ -(#1$= I1.9 .9( (M-"%21$% $/ ;$.9 8"-"%(2( "%= 1%=1*(%$,2 !#)2G q(. .912 =(L

F(+$-)(%. I"2 '$%'(%.#".(= )$#( 1% .9( ^$#.9 .9"% .9( 7$,.9G [$# 1%2."%'(3 .9( +"#*(

8"-"%(2( P"1;".2, $/ ^$*,'913 I91'9 "''$,%.(= /$# $%( .91#= $/ 8"-"%(2( 1%F(2.)(%. 1%O$#("3 I"2 '(%.(#(= 1% .9( ^$#.9G 5. ;,1+. +"#*( 9@=#$(+('.#1' -+"%.23 1%'+,=1%* .9( 7,19$

=") $% .9( q"+, #1F(#3 2('$%= 1% .9( I$#+= $%+@ .$ .9( >$,+=(# =") $% .9( X$+$#"=$

#1F(#G 5. "+2$ '#(".(= ^1--$% X9122$3 .9( 2('$%= +"#*(2. '9()1'"+ '$)-+(M 1% .9( I$#+=

.9". I"2 ."?(% $F(# ;@ .9( ^$#.9 O$#("% 2.".(G [1%"++@3 1% X9]$%*Q1% ^$#.9 O$#(" "+2$

9"= .9( +"#*(2. -$#. $% .9( 7(" $/ 8"-"%G &++ 1% "++3 =(2-1.( 2$)( -$.(%.1"+ "=F"%."*(2

/$# .9( ^$#.93%

4"==12$% TACCEW (2.1)".(2 .9". ". .9( .1)( $/ 2(-"#".1$%3 ^$#.9 "%=7$,.9 O$#(" 9"= "--#$M1)".(+@ .9( 2")( 1%'$)( -(# '"-1."G

H( '"% .9(#(/$#( .91%? $/ .9( 2-+1..1%* $% .9( O$#("2 UC @("#2 "*$ "2 " %".,#"+ (ML

-(#1)(%. .9". I( '"% ,2( .$ 1=(%.1/@ .9( '",2"+ 1%",(%'( $/ " -"#.1',+"# =1)(%21$% $/

1%2.1.,.1$%2 $% -#$2-(#1.@G O$#(" I"2 2-+1. 1%.$ .I$3 I1.9 .9( .I$ 9"+F(2 $#*"%1P(= 1%

#"=1'"++@ =1(#(%. I"@23 "%= I1.9 *($*#"-9@3 ',+.,#( "%= )"%@ $.9(# -$.(%.1"+ =(.(#)1L

%"%.2 $/ ('$%$)1' -#$2-(#1.@ 9(+= !M(=G 69,2 "%@ =1(#(%'(2 1% ('$%$)1' -(#/$#)"%'(

'"% -+",21;+@ ;( "..#1;,.(= .$ =1(#(%'(2 1% 1%2.1.,.1$%2G

X$%212.(%. I1.9 .9( 9@-$.9(212 .9". 1. 12 1%2.1.,.1$%"+ =1(#(%'(2 .9". =#1F( '$)L


22/111

5. 12 -$221;+( .9". O1) 5+ 7,%* "%= X$)),%12.


23/111

%(M. 2('.1$%G

B ,-. C.D.%097 &; 8&%$(#.

69( 1)-"'. $/ 0,#$-("% '$+$%1"+12) $% ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 12 -(#9"-2 )$2. =#")".L

1'"++@ '$%F(@(= ;@ " 21%*+( /"'.m912.$#1'"+ (F1=(%'( 29$I2 .9". .9(#( 9"2 ;((% " #(L

)"#?";+( :(F(#2"+ $/ [$#.,%( 1% ('$%$)1' -#$2-(#1.@ I1.91% /$#)(# 0,#$-("% '$+$%1(2G

7$'1(.1(2 +1?( .9( 4,*9"+2 1% 5%=1"3 "%= .9( &P.('2 "%= .9( 5%'"2 1% .9( &)(#1'"2 I(#(

")$%* .9( #1'9(2. '1F1+1P".1$%2 1% EUCC3 @(. .9( %".1$% 2.".(2 .9". %$I '$1%'1=( I1.9

.9( ;$,%="#1(2 $/ .9(2( ()-1#(2 "#( ")$%* .9( -$$#(# 2$'1(.1(2 $/ .$="@G 5% '$%.#"2.3

'$,%.#1(2 $'',-@1%* .9( .(##1.$#1(2 $/ .9( +(22L=(F(+$-(= '1F1+1P".1$%2 1% ^$#.9 &)(#1'"3

^(I g("+"%= "%= &,2.#"+1" "#( %$I ),'9 #1'9(# .9"% .9$2( 1% .9( +"%=2 $/ .9( 4,*9"+23

&P.('2 "%= 5%'"2G

B+! ,-. %.D.%097 94 $-. ;&%4.% )&7*.0

69( :(F(#2"+ $/ [$#.,%( 12 %$. '$%!%(= .$ 2,'9 '$)-"#12$%2G d21%* #("2$%";+( -#$M1(2

/$# -#$2-(#1.@ ;(/$#( )$=(#% .1)(23 I( '"% 29$I .9". 1. 12 " ),'9 )$#( 2@2.()".1'

-9(%$)(%$%G c,# -#$M1(2 /$# 1%'$)( -(# '"-1." 1% -#(L1%=,2.#1"+ 2$'1(.1(2 "#( ,#;"%L

1P".1$% #".(2 "%= -$-,+".1$% =(%21.@G c%+@ 2$'1(.1(2 I1.9 " '(#."1% +(F(+ $/ -#$=,'.1F1.@

1% "*#1',+.,#( "%= " #(+".1F(+@ =(F(+$-(= 2@2.() $/ .#"%2-$#. "%= '$))(#'( '"% 2,2."1%+"#*( ,#;"% '(%.(#2 "%= " =(%2( -$-,+".1$%G [1*,#( D 29$I2 .9( #(+".1$%291- ;(.I((%


24/111


25/111


26/111


27/111

-#$-(#.@ #1*9.2G 69(2( 1%'(%.1F(2 +(= .$ "% 1%2.1.,.1$%"+ #(F(#2"+G

69( 1%2.1.,.1$%"+ #(F(#2"+3 '$);1%(= I1.9 .9( 1%2.1.,.1$%2 9@-$.9(2123 -#(=1'.2 .9(

:(F(#2"+ $/ [$#.,%(R #(+".1F(+@ #1'9 -+"'(2 *$. #(+".1F(+@ I$#2( ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%23

"%= 1/ .9(2( 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( 1)-$#."%.3 I( 29$,+= 2(( .9() ;('$)( #(+".1F(+@ -$$# $F(#

.1)(G 6912 12 (M"'.+@ I9". I( !%= I1.9 .9( :(F(#2"+ $/ [$#.,%(G

4$#($F(#3 .9( 1%2.1.,.1$%2 9@-$.9(212 12 '$%212.(%. I1.9 .9( .1)1%* $/ .9( #(F(#2"+G

:('"++ .9". .9( 1%2.1.,.1$%2 9@-$.9(212 +1%?2 1%'(%.1F(2 .$ 1%F(2. 1% -9@21'"+ "%= 9,)"%'"-1."+ "%= 1% .('9%$+$*@ .$ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%23 "%= "#*,(2 .9". ('$%$)1' -#$2-(#1.@

#(2,+.2 /#$) .9(2( 1%F(2.)(%.2G 69(#(/$#(3 ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 29$,+= ;('$)( )$#(

1)-$#."%. I9(% .9(#( "#( )"Q$# %(I 1%F(2.)(%. $--$#.,%1.1(2G 69( $--$#.,%1.@ .$

1%=,2.#1"+1P( I"2 .9( )"Q$# 1%F(2.)(%. $--$#.,%1.@ $/ .9( %1%(.((%.9 '(%.,#@G X$,%.#1(2

.9". "#( #1'9 .$="@3 ;$.9 ")$%* .9( /$#)(# 0,#$-("% '$+$%1(2 "%= $.9(# '$,%.#1(23 "#(

.9$2( .9". 1%=,2.#1"+1P(= 2,''(22/,++@ =,#1%* .912 '#1.1'"+ -(#1$=G

B+E F#'.%0$9#'*#3 $-. )&7*97 .@A.%*.#).

69( (M-+"%".1$% /$# .9( #(F(#2"+ .9". ()(#*(2 /#$) $,# =12',221$% 2$ /"# 12 $%( 1% I91'9

.9( ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 1% F"#1$,2 '$+$%1(2 I(#( 29"-(= ;@ 0,#$-("%2 .$ ;(%(!. .9()L

2(+F(2G 4$#($F(#3 ;('",2( '$%=1.1$%2 "%= (%=$I)(%.2 =1(#(= ;(.I((% '$+$%1(23 0,#$L

-("%2 '$%2'1$,2+@ '#(".(= =1

(#(%. ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%23 I91'9 -(#212.(= "%= '$%.1%,(.$ 29"-( ('$%$)1' -(#/$#)"%'(G H9@ =1= 0,#$-("%2 1%.#$=,'( ;(..(# 1%2.1.,.1$%2 1%

1 + = ..+ = .9 1 1 + 1 9 = = + ..+ = S


28/111

0,#$-("%2 .9()2(+F(2 ;('")( .9( )"Q$#1.@ $/ .9( -$-,+".1$%3 1. I"2 1% .9(1# 1%.(#(2.2

.$ 1%.#$=,'( ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 -#$.('.1%* .9(1# $I% -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2G

B+G H.$$7.4.#$0I =&%$97*$J 9#'


29/111

)$#."+1.@ I"2 +"#*(+@ =,( .$ .#$-1'"+ =12("2(2 2,'9 "2 )"+"#1" "%= @(++$I /(F(# "%= ". .9(

.1)( 1. I"2 %$. ,%=(#2.$$= 9$I .9(2( =12("2(2 "#$2( %$# 9$I .9(@ '$,+= ;( -#(F(%.(=

$# ',#(=G

5% &'()$*+,3 8$9%2$% "%= :$;1%2$% TACCEW I( 29$I(=3 ,21%* 0,#$-("% )$#."+1.@

"2 "% 1%2.#,)(%. /$# .9( ',##(%. (%/$#'()(%. $/ -#$-(#.@ #1*9.23 .9". )$2. $/ .9( *"-

;(.I((% #1'9 "%= -$$# '$,%.#1(2 .$="@ 12 =,( .$ =1(#(%'(2 1% ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2G

4$#( -#('12(+@3 I( 29$I(= T-G E`Y_W .9". 1/ $%( .$$? .I$ .@-1'"+m1% .9( 2(%2( .9"..9(@ ;$.9 +1( $% .9( #(*#(221$% +1%(m'$,%.#1(2 I1.9 91*9 "%= +$I (M-#$-#1".1$% #12?3

+1?( ^1*(#1" "%= X91+(3 .9(% "+)$2. .9( (%.1#( =1(#(%'( 1% 1%'$)(2 -(#L'"-1." ;(.I((%

.9() '$,+= ;( (M-+"1%(= ;@ .9( =1(#(%'(2 1% .9( 2(',#1.@ $/ -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2G H( "+2$

-#(2(%.(= #(*#(221$% (F1=(%'( .9". 29$I(= .9". $%'( .9( (('. $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2

$% i!< -(#L'"-1." I"2 -#$-(#+@ '$%.#$++(= /$#3 *($*#"-91'"+ F"#1";+(23 2,'9 "2 +".1.,=(3

I9(.9(# $# %$. " '$,%.#@ 12 +"%=L+$'?(= "%= .9( ',##(%. =12("2( (%F1#$%)(%.3 9"F( %$(M-+"%".$#@ -$I(# /$# ',##(%. -#$2-(#1.@G

69(2( 1=("2 "%= #(2,+.2 -#$F1=( "% 1%.(#-#(.".1$% $/ I9@ .9(#( "#( 2.#$%* '$##(+".1$%2

;(.I((% *($*#"-91'"+ F"#1";+(2 2,'9 "2 +".1.,=( "%= 1%'$)( -(#L'"-1."G >"21'"++@ .912

12 ;('",2( 0,#$-("%2 =1= %$. 9"F( 1)),%1.@ .$ .#$-1'"+ =12("2(2 =,#1%* .9( '$+$%1"+

-(#1$= "%= .9,2 2(..+(# '$+$%1(2 .(%=(=3 $.9(# .91%*2 (K,"+3 .$ ;( '#(".(= 1% .()-(#".(

+".1.,=(2G 69,2 .9( 912.$#1'"+ '#(".1$% $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 I"2 '$##(+".(= I1.9

+".1.,=(G H1.9$,. '$%21=(#1%* .9( #$+( $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 1. 12 ("2@ .$ !%= "

2-,#1$,2 #(+".1$%291- ;(.I((% +".1.,=( "%= 1%'$)( -(#L'"-1." b$I(F(# $%'( ('$%$)1'


30/111


31/111

cF(#"++3 .9( (F1=(%'( 12 %$. '$%212.(%. I1.9 " )"Q$# #$+( $/ *($*#"-9@3 #(+1*1$% $# ',+L

.,#( .#"%2)1..(= ;@ .9( 1=(%.1.@ $/ .9( '$+$%1P(# $# .9( -#(2(%'( $/ 0,#$-("%2G 5%2.("=3

=1(#(%'(2 1% ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "--("# .$ ;( .9( #$;,2. '",2"+ /"'.$# ,%=(#+@1%* .9(

=1(#(%'(2 1% 1%'$)( -(# '"-1." "'#$22 '$,%.#1(2G 5%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( .9(#(/$#( .9( /,%="L

)(%."+ '",2( $/ 1%'$)( =1(#(%'(2 "%= +$%*L#,% *#$I.9G

E K-J


32/111

E+! ,-. ?;;*)*.#$ "#0$*$($* M*.NO,-. P&7*$*)97 :&90. ,-.&%.4

&''$#=1%* .$ .912 F1(I3 2$'1(.1(2 I1++ '9$$2( .9( ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 .9". "#( 2$'1"++@

('1(%.G b$I .912 2,#-+,2 I1++ ;( =12.#1;,.(= ")$%* =1(#(%. *#$,-2 $# "*(%.2 =$(2 %$.

"('. .9( '9$1'( $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2G H( 2.#(22 9(#( .9". .9( '$%'(-. $/ ('1(%'@ 12

2.#$%*(# .9"% 21)-+@ @

=$1%* 2$ .9(@ I1++ 1%'#("2( .9( 21P( $/ .9( .$."+ 2,#-+,2 .9". .9(@ '"% =1F1=( ;(.I((%

.9()2(+F(23 "%= .9(@ '"% .9(% ;"#*"1% $F(# .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ .912 "==1.1$%"+ 2,#-+,2G

4"%@ =1(#(%. F(#21$%2 $/ .9( ('1(%. ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 F1(I 9"F( ;((% -#$L

-$2(=G 5%=((=3 "22,)1%* .9". (M12.1%* ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( ('1(%. 12 " 2."%="#=

)(.9$=$+$*1'"+ "--#$"'9 $/ ('$%$)12.23 1G(G3 $;2(#F1%* "% 1%2.1.,.1$%3 $%( .#1(2 .$ ,%L

=(#2."%= I9". "#( .9( '1#',)2."%'(2 .9". +("= 1. .$ ;( ('1(%.G !()2(.P TEBV_W "#*,(=

.9". -#1F".( -#$-(#.@ ()(#*(= /#$) '$))$% -#$-(#.@ I9(% +"%= ;('")( 2,'1(%.+@2'"#'( "%= F"+,";+( .9". 1. I"2 ('1(%. .$ -#1F".1P( 1.G 4$#( #('(%.+@3 H1++1")2$%]2


33/111

.9( 2(%2( .9". )"%@ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 #(+(F"%. /$# =(F(+$-)(%. "#( '$++('.1F( '9$1'(2

%$. 1%=1F1=,"+ ;"#*"1%2G 69(#( )"@ .9(#(/$#( ;( /#(( #1=1%* -#$;+()2 1%9(#(%. 1% .9(

'#(".1$% $/ ('1(%. ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2G ^(F(#.9(+(223 .9( ,%=(#+@1%* 1=("3 "#.1',+".(=

;@ >('?(# TEBVCW "%= H1..)"% TEBYBW3 12 .9".3 ". +("2. 1% =()$'#"'1(23 '$)-(.1.1$%

")$%* -#(22,#( *#$,-2 "%= -$+1.1'"+ -"#.1(2 I1++ +("= .$ ('1(%. -$+1'1(2 "%= '$++('.1F(

'9$1'(2G 5% .9(1# F1(I3 "% 1%('1(%. ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$% '"%%$. ;( 2.";+( ;('",2( "

-$+1.1'"+ (%.#(-#(%(,# 9"2 "% 1%'(%.1F( .$ -#$-$2( " ;(..(# ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$% "%=I1.9 .9( (M.#" 2,#-+,2 *(%(#".(= I1++ ;( ";+( .$ )"?( 91)2(+/ )$#( "..#"'.1F( .$ F$.(#2G

69( ('1(%. 1%2.1.,.1$%2 F1(I #(*"#=2 .9( 2.#,'.,#( $/ -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 $# -$I(# "2

1##(+(F"%.G 6912 )"@ )"..(# /$# .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ .$."+ 2,#-+,23 ;,. 1. I1++ %$. )"..(#

/$# ('1(%'@ 1.2(+/G 69( \('1(%.] 2(. $/ -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 12 .9(#(/$#( 1%=(.(#)1%".(G

69( %$.1$% .9". " X$"21"% +$*1' "--+1(2 1% -$+1.1'"+ +1/( "2 I(++ "2 1% ('$%$)1'2 12

#(/(##(= .$ ;@ &'()$*+, TACC`"W "2 .9(


34/111

E+1 ,-. "'.&7&3J M*.N

& 2('$%= F1(I 12 .9". ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 =1(# "'#$22 '$,%.#1(2 ;('",2( $/ 1=($+$*1'"+

=1(#(%'(2 p ;('",2( $/ .9( 21)1+"#1.@ ;(.I((% .912 "%= .9( -#(F1$,2 F1(I3 &'()$*+,

TACC`"W '"++2 .912 .9( 4$=1!(=


35/111

%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "%= -$+1'1(2 ;(.I((% .9( ^$#.9 "%= 7$,.9 $/ O$#(" "2 #(2,+.1%* /#$)

=1(#(%'(2 1% ;(+1(/2S [$# (M")-+(3 '$,+= 1. ;( .9( '"2( .9". I91+( :9((3 #1.129 '$+$%12.2 (2.";+129(= =1(#(%. ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 1% F(#@ =1(#(%.

-"#.2 $/ .9( I$#+=R 1% .9( X"#1;;("% .9(@ 2(. ,- -+"%.".1$% 2$'1(.1(2 ;"2(= $% 2+"FL

(#@3 2,--$#.(= ;@ 91*9+@ $--#(221F( ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2G 5% '$%.#"2.3 .9( ('$%$)1'

1%2.1.,.1$%2 .9". =(F(+$-(= 1% "#("2 I9(#( .9( >#1.129 2(..+(=3 "%= I9(#( .9(#( I"2 %$

+"#*( -$-,+".1$% $/ 1%=1*(%$,2 .$ ;( '"-.,#(= "%= -,. .$ I$#?3 "%= I9(#( 2+"F(#@ '$,+=

%$. ;( -#$!.";+@ ,2(= 2,'9 "2 %$#.9("2.(#% d%1.(= 7.".(2 X"%"=" &,2.#"+1" "%= ^(I


36/111

)1%( I91'9 ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 29$,+= -#(F"1+G 0'1(%'@ "#12(2 ;('",2( 1%=1F1=,"+2

,+.1)".(+@ '"+',+".( "''$#=1%* .$ 2$'1"+ '$2.2 "%= ;(%(!.2G 5%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( .9(#(/$#(

'9$1'(2G & =1(#(%. "--#$"'93 -$-,+"# ")$%* )"%@ -$+1.1'"+ 2'1(%.12.2 "%= 2$'1$+$*12.23

;,. "+2$ 2$)( ('$%$)12.23 12 .$ =$I%-+"@ '9$1'(2 "%= .$ .91%? $/ 1%2.1.,.1$%23 ;$.9 ('$L

%$)1' "%= -$+1.1'"+3 "2 .9( ;@L-#$=,'. $# ,%1%.(%=(= '$%2(K,(%'( $/ $.9(# 2$'1"+ 1%.(#L

"'.1$%2 $# 912.$#1'"+ "''1=(%.2G 5% $.9(# I$#=23 912.$#1'"+ "''1=(%.2 ". '#1.1'"+ Q,%'.,#(2

=(.(#)1%( 1%2.1.,.1$%23 "%= .9(2( 1%2.1.,.1$%2 -(#212. /$# " +$%* .1)(3 I1.9 21*%1!'"%.'$%2(K,(%'(2G

b(#(3 I( =12',22 .I$ 2,'9 .9($#1(2G 69( !#2. 12 .9( .9($#@ $/ -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2

=(F(+$-(= ;@ 4$$#( TEBVVW 1% 912 C*(0'- D%020+1 *& E0()')*%180. '+! E",*(%'(93 .9(

2('$%= 12 .9( #('(%. ()-9"212 1% .9( ('$%$)1'2 +1.(#".,#( $% +(*"+ $#1*1%23 /$# (M")-+(

"2 1% .9( I$#? $/ 79+(1/(# "%= 912 '$L",.9$#2 TZ" #1."1%3

i(#)"%@ "%= :,221"G 5% -"#.1',+"#3 9( 1%F(2.1*".(= I9@ >#1."1% (F$+F(= 1%.$ " =()$'L

#"'@3 I91+( i(#)"%@ 2,'',);(= .$ /"2'12) "%= :,221" 9"= " '$)),%12. #(F$+,.1$%G

4$$#( 2.#(22(= .9( (M.(%. $/ '$))(#'1"+1P".1$% $/ "*#1',+.,#( "%= #(2,+.1%* +";$# #(L

+".1$%2 1% .9( '$,%.#@21=(3 .9( 2.#(%*.9 $/ .9( \;$,#*($121(3] "%= .9( %".,#( $/ '+"22

'$"+1.1$%2G 5% 912 .9($#@3 =()$'#"'@ ()(#*(= I9(% .9(#( I"2 " 2.#$%*3 -$+1.1'"++@ "2L

2(#.1F( '$))(#'1"+ )1==+( '+"22 "%= I9(% "*#1',+.,#( 9"= '$))(#'1"+1P(= 2$ .9". .9(#(


37/111

T!Q"%?$F3 Z"


38/111

9(#( 12 .9". .9$,*9 1%2.1.,.1$%2 )"@ 1% 2$)( '1#',)2."%'(2 ;( .9( 1%'1=(%."+ $,.'$)(

$/ 912.$#@3 ". 2$)( -$1%. -($-+( I1++ 2."#. .$ "2? I9@ 2$'1(.@ 9"2 .9( 1%2.1.,.1$%2 .9". 1.

=$(2 "%= .$ '$%21=(# $.9(# "+.(#%".1F(2G &. .912 -$1%. I( "#( ;"'? 1% .9( #("+) $/ '9$1'(G

E+B ,-. H&)*97 :7*)$ M*.N

&''$#=1%* .$ .912 F1(I3 ('$%$)1' T"%= -$+1.1'"+W 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( %$. "+I"@2 '9$2(% ;@

.9( I9$+( 2$'1(.@ T"%= %$. /$# .9( ;(%(!. $/ .9( I9$+( 2$'1(.@W3 ;,. ;@ .9( *#$,-2 .9".

'$%.#$+ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# ". .9( .1)( T-(#9"-2 "2 " #(2,+. $/ '$%"1'. I1.9 $.9(# *#$,-2WG

69(2( *#$,-2 I1++ '9$$2( .9( ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 .9". )"M1)1P( .9(1# $I% #(%.23 "%=

.9( ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 .9". #(2,+. )"@ %$. '$1%'1=( I1.9 .9$2( .9". )"M1)1P( .$."+

2,#-+,23 I("+.9 $# 1%'$)(G [$# (M")-+(3 ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 .9". (%/$#'( -#$-(#.@

#1*9.2 ;@ #(2.#1'.1%* 2.".( -#(=".1$% )"@ %$. ;( 1% .9( 1%.(#(2. $/ " #,+(# I9$ I"%.2

.$ "--#$-#1".( "22(.2 1% .9( /,.,#(G >@ (2.";+1291%* -#$-(#.@ #1*9.23 .912 #,+(# I$,+=;( #(=,'1%* 912 $I% /,.,#( #(%.23 2$ )"@ I(++ -#(/(# ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 $.9(# .9"%

(%/$#'(= -#1F".( -#$-(#.@G 69(#(/$#(3 (K,1+1;#1,) ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 I1++ %$. ;( .9$2(

.9". )"M1)1P( .9( 21P( $/ .9( $F(#"++ -1(3 ;,. .9( 2+1'( $/ .9( -1( ."?(% ;@ .9( -$I(#/,+

*#$,-2G

69( !#2. 2@2.()".1' =(F(+$-)(%. $/ .912 -$1%. $/ F1(I 1% .9( ('$%$)1'2 +1.(#".,#( 12

^$#.9 TEBYEW3 I9$ "#*,(= 1% .9( '9"-.(# $% J& ^($'+"221'"+ 69($#@ $/ .9( 7.".(N .9"."*(%.2 I9$ '$%.#$++(= .9( 2.".( 29$,+= ;( )$=(+(= "2 2(+/L1%.(#(2.(=G b( .9(% "#*,(=

.9 . .9 . / . 1 9. .9 . .9 += 9 / 1 . += ; .9 .9 .


39/111

.9( 1%.(#%".1$%"+ .#"=1%* 2@2.() I"2 =(21*%(= .$ (M.#"'. #(%.2 /#$) =(F(+$-1%* '$,%.#1(2

.$ .9( ;(%(!. $/ =(F(+$-(= '$,%.#1(2G

69( 2$'1"+ '$%"1'. F1(I 1%'+,=(2 21.,".1$%2 I9(#( ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 )"@ 1%1.1"++@

;( ('1(%. /$# " 2(. $/ '1#',)2."%'(2 ;,. "#( %$ +$%*(# ('1(%. $%'( .9( (%F1#$%)(%.

'9"%*(2G [$# (M")-+(3 &'()$*+,3 &*91$% "%= g1+1;$..1 TACCEW 29$I .9". .9$,*9 '(#."1%

2$#.2 $/ $#*"%1P".1$%2 )"@ ;( ,2(/,+ /$# '$,%.#1(2 " +$%* I"@ /#$) .9( .('9%$+$*1'"+

/#$%.1(#3 1. )"@ ;( 2$'1"++@ ('1(%. .$ '9"%*( .9() 2,;2(K,(%.+@G 6912 )"@ %$. 9"--(%9$I(F(# ;('",2( 1. 12 %$. -#1F".(+@ #".1$%"+G &% 1%.(#(2.1%* (M")-+( )"@ ;( .9( +"#*(

;,21%(22 (%.(#-#12(2 T.9((8'"7*-W $/ 7$,.9 O$#("G 5% .9( '$%.(M. $/ -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%23

$%( )1*9. .9(% =(F(+$- " 21)1+"# .9(212G X(#."1% 2(.2 $/ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( ('1(%. /$#

F(#@ -$$# '$,%.#1(2 ;,. .9(@ '$%.1%,( .$ "--+@ (F(% "/.(# .9(@ '("2( .$ ;( .9( ('1(%.

1%2.1.,.1$%"+ "##"%*()(%.G

5% 2."#? '$%.#"2. .$ .9( (

'1(%. 1%2.1.,.1$%2 F1(I3 -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 -+"@ " '#,'1"+#$+( 1% .9( 2$'1"+ '$%"1'. F1(IG H91'9 ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#12( =(-(%=2 $% I9$

9"2 -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# .$ '#(".( $# ;+$'? =1(#(%. ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2G 71%'( -$+1.1'"+

1%2.1.,.1$%2 -+"@ " '(%.#"+ #$+( 1% .9( "++$'".1$% $/ 2,'9 -$I(# .9(@ I1++ ;( "% 1%.1)".(

-"#. $/ " 2$'1"+ '$%"1'. .9($#@ $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2G

H9". =12.1%*,129(2 .9( 2$'1"+ '$%"1'. F1(I /#$) .9( 1=($+$*1'"+ F1(I 12 .9". 2$'1"+

'$%"1'. '"% +("= .$ '9$1'(2 $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 I91'9 '",2( ,%=(#=(F(+$-)(%. (F(%

I9(% "++ "*(%.2 9"F( '$))$% ?%$I+(=*( .9". .912 12 2$G H9". =12.1%*,129(2 1. /#$)

.9( 1%'1=(%."+ F1(I 12 .9". 1. ()-9"21P(2 .9". 1%2.1.,.1$%"+ '9$1'(2 I91'9 '",2( ,%=(#L


40/111

#".(= /#$) .9( -#$ K,$3 122,(2 $/ '$))1.)(%. I1++ "#12(G 69". .9(2( 122,(2 "#( $/ '#,'1"+

1)-$#."%'( 9"2 ;((% #('$*%1P(= 1% .9( +1.(#".,#(2 $% 1%'$)-+(.( '$%.#"'.2 "%= #(%(*$L

.1".1$% T(G*G3 b"#.3 EBBUWG ^(F(#.9(+(223 1/ .9( +(*"+ 2@2.() /,%'.1$%2 -#$-(#+@3 .9(#(

12 "% "##"@ $/ (%/$#'(";+( '$%.#"'.2 .9". $I%(#2 '"% 21*% I1.9 )"%"*(#23 I$#?(#2 I1.9

()-+$@(#23 ;$##$I(#2 I1.9 +(%=(#2 (.'G 69(2( '$%.#"'.2 '"% ;( (%/$#'(= ;('",2( .9(#( 12

"% ",.9$#1.@3 " .91#= -"#.@3 I1.9 .9( -$I(# .$ (%/$#'( '$%.#"'.2G &+.9$,*9 .9( ",.9$#1.@

.9". 12 =(+(*".(= .$ (%/$#'( '$%.#"'.2 "%= .$ #(2$+F( =12-,.(2 F"#1(2 =(-(%=1%* $% .9((M"'. 21.,".1$%3 "++ 2,'9 -$I(# ,+.1)".(+@ ()"%".(2 /#$) .9( 2.".(3 I91'93 1% )$=(#%

2$'1(.@3 9"2 " %("#L)$%$-$+@ $% .9( ,2( $/ +(*1.1)".( '$(#'1$%G &% $I%(# "%= )"%"*(#

'"% I#1.( " '$%.#"'. ;('",2( .9(@ ;(+1(F( .9". .9( 2.".(3 "%= 1.2 "*(%.2 .9( '$,#.23 I$,+=

;( 1)-"#.1"+ (%/$#'(#2 $/ .9( '$%.#"'.G

5% '$%.#"2.3 1/3 /$# (M")-+(3 " )"%"*(# ;(+1(F(= .9". .9( 2.".( I$,+= ;( "+1*%(= I1.9

.9( 1%.(#(2.2 $/ .9( $I%(# "%= #(/,2( .$ -,%129 .9( $I%(# 1/ "%= I9(% 9( /"1+(= .$ )"?( "-"@)(%. 2.1-,+".(= ;@ .9( '$%.#"'.3 .9(% .9( '$%.#"'. I$,+= 9"F( +1..+( F"+,(G 69(#(/$#(3

.9( -#(2(%'( $/ "% 1)-"#.1"+ (%/$#'(# 12 1)-$#."%. /$# '$%.#"'.1%*G 69( -#$;+() I9(% 1.

'$)(2 .$ 1%2.1.,.1$%"+ '9$1'(2 12 .9". .9(#( 12 %$ 2,'9 1)-"#.1"+ .91#= -"#.@ .9". '"% ;(

.#,2.(= .$ (%/$#'( '$%.#"'.2G 6912 12 .9( $#1*1% $/ .9( '$))1.)(%. -#$;+() 1% -$+1.1'2G

6$ (+";$#".( $% .912 -$1%.3 +(. ,2 '$%21=(# " 21.,".1$% I9(#( 2$'1(.@ '"% ;( *$F(#%(= "2

" =1'.".$#291- $# "2 " =()$'#"'@G 5)"*1%( .9". .9( =1'.".$# =$(2 %$. #(+1%K,129 912 -$I(#3

;,. 1%2.("= 9( -#$)12(2 .9". 9( I1++ $;(@ .9( #,+(2 $/ =()$'#"'@3 2$ .9". 1%=1F1=,"+2

'"% ,%=(#."?( .9( 2")( 1%F(2.)(%.2 "2 .9(@ I$,+= 1% =()$'#"'@ 6912 -#$)12( I$,+=


41/111

-$2.G 69( #("2$% I9@ '$))1.)(%. -#$;+()2 "#( 2(F(#( 1% .9(2( (M")-+(2 12 ;('",2( I(

"#( =("+1%* I1.9 -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#G !1(#(%. 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( "22$'1".(= I1.9 =1(#(%. =12L

.#1;,.1$%2 $/ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#3 "%= .9(#( 12 %$ $,.21=( 1)-"#.1"+ -"#.@ I1.9 .9( I1++ "%= .9(

-$I(# .$ (%/$#'( "*#(()(%.2G 5% 2$)( '"2(23 .9(#( )"@ ;( 2(+/L(%/$#'1%* -#$)12(2 .9".

)"1%."1% "% "*#(()(%.G &'()$*+, TACC`"W =12',22(2 2,'9 -$221;1+1.1(23 ;,. 1% *(%(#"+3

.9(#( "#( +1)1.2 .$ 2,'9 2(+/L(%/$#'1%* "*#(()(%.23 ;('",2( .9(@ #(K,1#( .9( -"#.1'1-"%.2

.$ ;( 2,'1(%.+@ -".1(%.3 "%= I9(% 1. '$)(2 .$ )"..(#2 $/ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#3 .9( /,.,#( 12,%'(#."1% (%$,*9 .9". %$ -"#.@ I$,+= ;(9"F( 1% " 91*9+@ -".1(%. )"%%(#G

>"2(= $% .912 #("2$%1%*3 I( '"% %$I =12',22 .9#(( =1(#(%. '9"%%(+2 F1" I91'9 .9(

-#(2(%'( $/ '$))1.)(%. -#$;+()2 I1++ +("= .$ .9( '9$1'( "%= -(#212.(%'( $/ 1%('1(%.

1%2.1.,.1$%2G

G+! Q&7'(A

5)"*1%( " 21.,".1$% 1% I91'9 "% 1%=1F1=,"+ $# " *#$,- 9$+=2 ,%'$%2.#"1%(= -$+1.1'"+

-$I(#G &+2$ 2,--$2( .9". -#$=,'.1F( 1%F(2.)(%.2 '"% ;( ,%=(#."?(% ;@ " *#$,- $/

'1.1P(%2 $# -#$=,'(#2 .9". "#( =12.1%'. /#$) .9( J-$+1.1'"+ (+1.(2N3 1G(G3 .9( ',##(%. -$I(#

9$+=(#2G 69( -#$=,'(#2 I1++ $%+@ ,%=(#."?( .9( -#$=,'.1F( 1%F(2.)(%.2 1/ .9(@ (M-('.

.$ #('(1F( .9( ;(%(!.2 /#$) .9(1# 1%F(2.)(%.2G 69(#(/$#(3 " 2(. $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2

-#$.('.1%* .9(1# -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2 "#( %('(22"#@ /$# 1%F(2.)(%.G X"% .9( 2$'1(.@ $-. /$# "2(. $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 (%2,#1%* 2,'9 2(',#( -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2S 69( "%2I(# 12 $/.(%

T 1 .9 . J 1 . N . . = W


42/111

-$+1.1'"+ -$I(# (M -$2.3 "%= .912 .#"%2+".(2 =1#('.+@ 1%.$ " 2(. $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2

.9". =$ %$. -#$F1=( 2(',#( -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2 .$ *#$,-2 I1.9$,. -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#G 69( '$%L

2(K,(%'( 12 '+("#R I1.9$,. 2,'9 -#$.('.1$%3 -#$=,'.1F( 1%F(2.)(%.2 "#( %$. ,%=(#."?(%3

"%= $--$#.,%1.1(2 /$# ('$%$)1' *#$I.9 *$ ,%(M-+$1.(=G

69( #("2$% I9@ .9(2( 1%('1(%. ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 -(#212. T$# )"@ ;( .9( (K,1L

+1;#1,) 1%2.1.,.1$%2 $/ .9( 2$'1(.@W 12 #(+".(= .$ '$))1.)(%. -#$;+()2G ,.3 "2 -$1%.(= $,. ";$F(3 .9(#( 12 "%$.9(#3

#(F(#2( '$))1.)(%. -#$;+() 9(#(a .9( ;(%(!'1"#1(2 $/ .9( %(I #(*1)( '"%%$. '$))1.

.$ )"?1%* .9( -#$)12(= -"@)(%.2 .$ .9( -#(F1$,2 -$+1.1'"+ (+1.(2G

4"%@ #("+ I$#+= (M")-+(2 1++,2.#".( .9( '$))1.)(%. -#$;+()2 1%F$+F(= 1% +1)1.1%*

.9( ,2( $/ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#G 5% -#"'.1'(3 "+.9$,*9 ;,@1%* $=1'.".$#2 "%= -(#2,"=1%*

.9() .$ +("F( -$I(# 12 =1',+.3 .9(#( 9"F( ;((% )"%@ "..()-.2 .$ =$ 2$3 ,2,"++@ ;@

.#@1%* .$ *,"#"%.(( .9". .9(@ I1++ %$. ;( -(#2(',.(= 2,;2(K,(%.+@G c%( I"@ $/ =$1%* .912

12 .$ *1F( .9() "2@+,) 1% "%$.9(# '$,%.#@ ^(F(#.9(+(22 2,'9 "..()-.2 #"#(+@ 2,''((=


43/111

/#$) -#$2(',.1$%G 5. I"2 $%+@ I9(% 9( +(/. .9( '$,%.#@ .9". 9( I"2 F,+%(#";+(G

&+.9$,*9


44/111

%$. $%+@ "''$#=1%* .$ 1.2 ('$%$)1' '$%2(K,(%'(23 2,'9 "2 1.2 (('.2 $% ('$%$)1' *#$I.9

"%= 1%'$)( =12.#1;,.1$%3 ;,. "+2$ "''$#=1%* .$ 1.2 -$+1.1'"+ '$%2(K,(%'(2G &%@ ('$%$)1'

'9"%*( .9". I1++ (#$=( .9( (+1.(2] -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# 12 +1?(+@ .$ #(=,'( .9(1# ('$%$)1' #(%.2

1% .9( +$%* #,%G

&2 "% (M")-+(3 1)"*1%( " '9"%*( 1% ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 .9". I1++ 1%'#("2( ('$%$)1'

*#$I.93 ;,. 1% =$1%* 2$3 I1++ "+2$ (%#1'9 *#$,-2 .9". '$,+= -$.(%.1"++@ '$%.(2. -$+1.1'"+

-$I(# 1% .9( /,.,#(G 0F(#@.91%* (+2( (K,"+3 *#(".(# ('$%$)1' *#$I.9 12 *$$= /$# .9$2(9$+=1%* -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#G 5. I1++ '#(".( *#(".(# #(.,#%2 $% .9( "22(.2 .9". .9(@ -$22(223

"%= "+2$ *#(".(# 1%'$)(2 .9". .9(@ '"% ."M $# (M-#$-#1".(G b$I(F(#3 1/ .9(1# -$.(%.1"+

(%()1(2 "#( (%#1'9(=3 .912 "+2$ )("%2 *#(".(# .9#(".2 "*"1%2. .9(1# -$I(# 1% .9( /,.,#(G

[("#1%* .9(2( -$.(%.1"+ .9#(".2 .$ .9(1# -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#3 .9( (+1.(2 )"@ $--$2( '9"%*(2

1% ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 .9". I$,+= 2.1),+".( ('$%$)1' *#$I.9G

69". .9( .9#(". $/ ;('$)1%* " -$+1.1'"+ +$2(# 1)-(=(2 .9( "=$-.1$% $/ ;(..(# 1%2.1.,L.1$%2 12 "*"1% =,( .$ " '$))1.)(%. -#$;+()G 5/ .9$2( I9$ *"1%(= -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# /#$)

1%2.1.,.1$%"+ '9"%*( '$,+= -#$)12( .$ '$)-(%2".( .9$2( I9$ +$2. -$I(# .9(% .9(#( I$,+=

;( %$ 1%'(%.1F( .$ ;+$'? ;(..(# 1%2.1.,.1$%2G

69(#( "#( )"%@ 912.$#1'"+ (M")-+(2 1++,2.#".1%* 9$I .9( /("# $/ +$21%* -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#

9"2 +(= F"#1$,2 *#$,-2 $/ -$+1.1'"+ "%= ('$%$)1' (+1.(2 .$ $--$2( 1%2.1.,.1$%"+ '9"%*( "%=

"+2$ 1%.#$=,'.1$% $/ %(I .('9%$+$*1(2G


45/111

'$%'(%.#".( #(F$+,.1$% )1%=(= I$#?(#2 1% '1.1(23 #"1+I"@2 I$,+= *1F( .9() )$;1+1.@3 "%=

(=,'".1$% I$,+= '#(".( $--$21.1$% .$ .9( )$%"#'9@GN

5. I"2 $%+@ "/.(# .9( =(/(". 1% .9( X#1)("% H"# .9". ^1?$+"1]2 2,''(22$#3 &+(M2"%=#

553 1%1.1".(= " +"#*( 2'"+( -#$Q('. $/ #"1+I"@ ;,1+=1%* "%= "% "..()-. .$ )$=(#%1P( .9(

('$%$)@ ;@ 1%.#$=,'1%* " I(2.(#% +(*"+ 2@2.()3 =('(%.#"+1P1%* *$F(#%)(%.3 "%= (%=1%*

/(,="+12) ;@ /#((1%* .9( 2(#/2G 6912 -(#1$= $/ 1%=,2.#1"+1P".1$% I1.%(22(= 9(1*9.(%(=

-$+1.1'"+ .(%21$%23 '$%212.(%. I1.9 .9( /("#2 $/ .9( (+1.(2 .9". .1)(2 $/ #"-1= '9"%*( I$,+==(2.";1+1P( .9( -$+1.1'"+ 2.".,2 K,$ "%= 2.#(%*.9(% .9(1# $--$21.1$% T4'!"%1(+3 EBYY3

*1F(2 " =(."1+(= "''$,%. $/ .9(2( (F(%.23 2(( "+2$ 4$22(3 EBUYWG

69( '$%2(%2,2 F1(I ")$%*2. 912.$#1"%2 "+2$ "--("#2 .$ ;( .9". .9( )"1% (M-+"%".1$%

/$# .9( 2+$I *#$I.9 $/ &,2.#1"Lb,%*"#@ 1% .9( %1%(.((%.9 '(%.,#@ I"2 +"'? $/ .('9%$+L

$*@ "=$-.1$% "%= 1%2.1.,.1$%"+ '9"%*(3 "*"1% =#1F(% ;@ .9( $--$21.1$% $/ .9( 2.".( .$

('$%$)1' '9"%*(G 6912 F1(I I"2 -#$-$2(= ;@ i(#2'9(%?#$% I9$ "#*,(= .9". .9( 2.".(%$. $%+@ /"1+(= .$ -#$)$.( 1%=,2.#1"+1P".1$%3 ;,. #".9(#3 J('$%$)1' -#$*#(22 ;(*"% .$

;( F1(I(= I1.9 *#(". 2,2-1'1$% "%= .9( #"1+#$"=2 '")( .$ ;( #(*"#=(=3 %$. "2 I(+'$)(

'"##1(#2 $/ *$$=2 "%= -(#2$%23 ;,. "2 '"##1(#2 $/ .9( =#("=(= #(F$+,.1$%G 69(% .9( 2.".(

'+("#+@ ;('")( "% $;2."'+( .$ .9( ('$%$)1' =(F(+$-)(%. $/ .9( '$,%.#@N TEB_C3 -G YBWG

7(( "+2$ i#$22 TEB_`WG

69( "%"+@212 $/ [#,(=(%;(#*(# TEBV_3 --G DBYLDBBW 12 21)1+"#G &2 I1.9 .9( 62"#3

.9( b"-2;,#* ()-(#$#2 $--$2(= .9( ;,1+=1%* $/ #"1+I"@2 "%= 1%/#"2.#,'.,#( "%= .9(#(

I"2 %$ "..()-. .$ =(F(+$- "% (('.1F( (=,'".1$%"+ 2@2.() >+,) TEBD`W -$1%.(= .$ .9(


46/111

G+5 ?)&4*) 7&0.%0

& =12.1%'. ;,. #(+".(= 2$,#'( $/ 1%('1(%'@ 2.()2 /#$) .9( ;"21' 2,--$21.1$% $/ .9(

2$'1"+ '$%"1'. F1(I .9". =1(#(%. ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 1)-+@ =1(#(%. =12.#1;,.1$%2 $/

1%'$)(2G 6912 1)-+1(2 .9". " )$F( /#$) " ;"= .$ " ;(..(# 2(. $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2

I1++ )"?( 2$)( -($-+( $# *#$,-2 I$#2( $T"%= I1++ %$. ;(


47/111

),'9 '9("-(# ,%2?1++(= I$#?(#2G!!

&+.9$,*9 .9( -#$;+() $/ ('$%$)1' +$2(#2 12 "--("+1%* ". !#2. 21*9.3 9"2 #('(1F(= 2$)(

"..(%.1$% 1% .9( ('$%$)1'2 +1.(#".,#(3 "%= !.2 1%.$ $,# /#")(I$#? ;@ ()-9"21P1%* .9(

1)-$#."%'( $/ '$))1.)(%. -#$;+()23 I( F1(I 1. ;$.9 .9($#(.1'"++@ "%= ()-1#1'"++@ +(22

1)-$#."%. .9"% .9( 9$+=,- "%= .9( -$+1.1'"+ +$2(# -#$;+()2G [1#2.3 "2 -$1%.(= $,. 1% &'(L

)$*+, "%= :$;1%2$% TACCC;W3 1% .9($#1(2 ()-9"21P1%* 122,(2 $/ ('$%$)1' +$2(#23 .9(#(

"#( 1)-+1'1. "22,)-.1$%2 ";$,. -$+1.1'23 I91'93 I9(% 2-(++(= $,.3 1)-+@ .9". -$+1.1'"+'$%'(#%2 ),2. ;( 1)-$#."%. I9(%(F(# 122,(2 $/ ('$%$)1' +$2(#2 "#( -#(2(%.G 69( 1=(" $/

('$%$)1' +$2(#2 12 .9". '(#."1% *#$,-23 /("#1%* .9". .9(@ I1++ +$2( .9(1# ('$%$)1' #(%.23

-#(F(%. "=$-.1$% $/ ;(%(!'1"+ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 $# .('9%$+$*1(2G 69( "22,)-.1$% 1%

.912 2'(%"#1$ 12 .9". .9(2( *#$,-2 9"F( .9( -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# .$ ;+$'? 2$'1"++@ ;(%(!'1"+

'9"%*(2G >,. .9(%3 1/ .9(@ 9"F( .9( -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# .$ ;+$'? '9"%*(3 I9@ I$,+=%]. .9(@

"++$I .9( '9"%*( .$ ."?( -+"'( "%= .9(% ,2( .9(1# -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# .$ #(=12.#1;,.( 2$)( $/.9( *"1%2 .$ .9()2(+F(2S 69( 1)-+1'1. "22,)-.1$% ),2. .9(#(/$#( ;( .9". *#$,-2 +$21%*

('$%$)1'"++@ "+2$ (M-(#1(%'( " #(=,'.1$% 1% .9(1# -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#3 )"?1%* 1. 1)-$221;+(

/$# .9() .$ #(=12.#1;,.( .9( *"1%2 .$ .9()2(+F(2 "/.(# .$ '9"%*( ."?(2 -+"'(G 6912 #("L

2$%1%* .9(#(/$#( 2,**(2.2 .9". I9(.9(# '(#."1% *#$,-2 I1++ +$2( ('$%$)1'"++@ $# %$. 12

%$. "2 (22(%.1"+ .$ .9(1# "..1.,=(2 .$I"#=2 '9"%*( "248")8"% )8"0% .*-0)0('- .*4"% 40-- 7"

"%*!"!G


48/111

@ EYUC .912 -#$'(22 $/ (%'+$2,#(2 9"= )"=(

-#"'.1'"++@ "++ $/ >#1."1% -#1F".( -#$-(#.@G0%'+$2,#( I"2 " 9(.(#$*(%$,2 -#$'(22 TcF(#.$% EBBV3 -G ED_W "%= 1. "+2$ .$$? -+"'(

". =1(#(%. .1)(2 1% =1(#(%. -+"'(2G ^(F(#.9(+(223 )$2. $/ 1. I"2 1% .I$ I"F(23 .9( 2$

'"++(= \6,=$# (%'+$2,#(2] ;(.I((% EUUC "%= E_CC "%= .9( \-"#+1")(%."#@ (%'+$2,#(2] 1%

.9( '(%.,#@ "/.(# E_UCG

J[#$) .9( )1=L(1*9.((%.9 '(%.,#@ .9( )$2. ,2,"+ I"@ 1% I91'9 '$))$%

#1*9.2 I(#( #()$F(= I"2 .9#$,*9 " 2-('1!' "'. $/ -"#+1")(%. /$# .9( (%'+$L

2,#( $/ " -"#.1',+"# +$'"+1.@G 7,'9 "'.2 GGG )"=( .9( -#$'(22 ("21(# ;('",2(

(%'+$2,#( '$,+= ;( 2(',#(= -#$F1=(= .9( $I%(#2 $/ " )"Q$#1.@ T/$,#L!/.92W $/

.9( +"%=3 .9( +$#= $/ .9( )"%$#3 "%= .9( $I%(# $/ .9( .1.9( "*#((= 1. 29$,+=

."?( -+"'(G 69,2 .9( +"I $/ -"#+1")(%. T2.".,( +"IW $%+@ .$$? "''$,%. $/

.9( I129(2 $/ .9$2( *4+0+2 +"%= "2 $--$2(= .$ .9( '$))$% +"I I91'9 .$$?

"''$,%. $/ "++ .9$2( I9$ 9"= ;$.9 $I%(#291- #1*9.2 "%= $1"#1*9.2 .$ +"%=G4$#($F(# GGG 1% 2$)( -"#129(2 .9( GGG )"Q$#1.@ '$,+= ;( 9(+= ;@ " 21%*+(


49/111

69( (%'+$2,#( $/ '$))$% +"%= .9,2 +(= .$ " 9,*( 1%'#("2( 1% 1%(K,"+1.@ 1% ("#+@

)$=(#% 0%*+"%=G 4"%@ -("2"%.2 "%= #,#"+ =I(++(#2 9"= .9(1# .#"=1.1$%"+ -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2

(M-#$-#1".(=G 5% -#$.(2.3 *#$,-2 $/ '1.1P(%2 =12-$22(22(= ;@ (%'+$2,#( "..()-.(= .$

$--$2( 1. .9#$,*9 '$++('.1F( "'.1$% "%= #1$.2m"..()-.1%* .$ 1%",(%'( .9( (M(#'12( $/

-$+1.1'"+ -$I(#G 69(2( *#$,-2 I(#( %$ )".'9 /$# .9( >#1.129 2.".(3 9$I(F(#G O(..]2

#(;(++1$% $/ EUDB3 .9( cM/$#=291#( #(;(++1$% $/ EUBV3 .9( 41=+"%= :(F$+. $/ EVC_3 "%=

$.9(#2 ,- .$ .9( 7I1%* :1$.2 $/ EY`CLEY`E I(#( "++ =(/(".(= T2(( X9"#+(2I$#.93 EBY`WG69( -#(2(%'( $/ ('$%$)1' +$2(#2 =1= %$. -#(F(%. .912 9,*( '9"%*( 1% ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2

"%= 1%'$)( =12.#1;,.1$%G

G+B ,-. "#0.A9%9R*7*$J &; ?;;*)*.#)J 9#'


50/111

-"@)(%.23 .9$2( I9$2( 1%'$)(2 /"++ I9(% ;(..(# ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( 1%.#$=,'(=

9"F( "% 1%'(%.1F( .$ ;+$'? 2,'9 1%2.1.,.1$%2G

>('",2( '$))1.)(%. -#$;+()2 2(() 2$ (%=()1' 1% '$++('.1F( '9$1'( "%= -$+1.1'23 1.

2(()2 %".,#"+ .$ ;(+1(F( .9". 1%2.1.,.1$%"+ '9"%*( 9"2 21*%1!'"%. =12.#1;,.1$%"+ '$%2(L

K,(%'(2 "%= "2 " #(2,+. .9(#( I1++ ;( '$%"1'. $F(# .9( 2(. $/ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 1% 2$'1(.@G

G+E :&4A9%9$*D. H$9$*)0

c,# "%"+@212 2$ /"# 9"2 )"=( 2$)( -#$*#(22 .$I"#=2 $,# .9($#@ $/ =1(#(%'(2 1% ('$%$)1'

1%2.1.,.1$%2G &+.9$,*9 $,# /,++ .9($#@ 12 @(. .$ ;( =(F(+$-(= 1% .9( +".(# 2('.1$%23 .9(

=1(#(%. )('9"%12)2 =12',22(= 1% .912 2('.1$% "+#("=@ -$1%. $,. .9( )"Q$# '$)-"#".1F(

2.".1' 1)-+1'".1$%2 $/ $,# "--#$"'9 #(*"#=1%* I9(% ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 -#$.('.1%* .9(

-#$-(#.@ #1*9.2 $/ " ;#$"= '#$22L2('.1$% $/ 2$'1(.@ "#( +1?(+@ .$ ;( "=$-.(=3 "%= I9(%

.9(@ "#( +1?(+@ .$ ;( $--$2(= "%= ;+$'?(=G H( %$I ;#1("@ =12',22 .9(2( '$)-"#".1F(2.".1'2G

b$+=L,-3 -$+1.1'"+ +$2(# "%= ('$%$)1' +$2(# '$%21=(#".1$%2 +("= .$ 2$)( 1%.(#(2.1%*

'$)-"#".1F( 2.".1' #(2,+.2 I91'9 '"% ;( =(#1F(= ;@ '$%21=(#1%* .9( -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2

.9". +1( ;(91%= .9(2( -9(%$)(%"G

EG [1#2.3 .9( -(#2-('.1F( $/ 9$+=L,-2 1))(=1".(+@ 2,**(2.2 .9". 21.,".1$%2 1% I91'9

.9(#( "#( '$%2.#"1%.2 $% .9( ,2( $/ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#3 /$# (M")-+(3 ;('",2( .9(#( 12

" ;"+"%'( $/ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# 1% 2$'1(.@ $# " /$#) $/ 2(-"#".1$% $/ -$I(#2 ;(.I((%


51/111

`G 691#=3 *$$= ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( )$#( +1?(+@ .$ "#12( "%= -(#212. I9(% .9(#(

"#( $%+@ +1)1.(= #(%.2 .9". -$I(# 9$+=(#2 '"% (M.#"'. /#$) .9( #(2. $/ 2$'1(.@3 21%'(

2,'9 #(%.2 I$,+= (%'$,#"*( .9() .$ $-. /$# " 2(. $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 .9".

)"?( .9( (M-#$-#1".1$% $/ $.9(#2 -$221;+(G

DG [1%"++@3 '$%21=(#".1$%2 #(+".(= .$ 122,(2 $/ -$+1.1'"+ +$2(#2 2,**(2. .9". 1%2.1.,.1$%"+

#(/$#)2 .9". =$ %$. .9#(".(% .9( -$I(# $/ 1%',);(%.2 "#( )$#( +1?(+@ .$ 2,''((=G

69(#(/$#(3 1%2.1.,.1$%"+ '9"%*(2 .9". =$ %$. 2.#(%*.9(% 2.#$%* $--$21.1$% *#$,-2

$# =(2.";1+1P( .9( -$+1.1'"+ 21.,".1$% "#( )$#( +1?(+@ .$ ;( "=$-.(=G

G+G ,-. :&7*97 ?@A.%*.#). *# S*3-$ &; $-. :&4A9%9$*D. H$9$*)0

H( %$I ;#1("@ #(.,#% .$ .9( '$+$%1"+ (M-(#1(%'(3 "%= =12',22 9$I .9( '$)-"#".1F( 2.".1'2

=12',22(= 9(#( 29(= +1*9. $% .9( =1(#(%'(2 1% ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "'#$22 .9( /$#)(#

'$+$%1(2 "%= .9( 1%2.1.,.1$%"+ #(F(#2"+G

69( 2('$%= '$)-"#".1F( 2.".1' #(2,+. ";$F( 2,**(2.2 " #("2$% I9@ ;(..(# ('$%$)1'

1%2.1.,.1$%2 =(F(+$-(= 1% -+"'(2 I9(#( 0,#$-("%2 2(..+(=G 5% .9(2( 2$'1(.1(23 " #(+".1F(+@

;#$"=L;"2(= *#$,- $/ 0,#$-("%2 '")( .$ =$)1%".( -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#3 "%= .9(@ $-.(= /$# "

2(. $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 -#$.('.1%* .9(1# $I% -#$-(#.@ #1*9.2G 5% '$%.#"2.3 1% -+"'(2

I9(#( 0,#$-("%2 =1= %$. 2(..+(3 (2-('1"++@ I9(#( .9(@ I(#( " 2)"++ )1%$#1.@ #(+".1F( .$ "

+"#*( 1%=1*(%$,2 -$-,+".1$%3 .9(@ =1= %$. 9"F( .9( 1%'(%.1F(2 .$ =(F(+$- *$$= ('$%$)1'1%2.1.,.1$%2 ;('",2( 2,'9 1%2.1.,.1$%2 I$,+= 9"F( )"=( 1. '$%21=(#";+@ )$#( =1',+. /$#


52/111

('$%$)1' (+1.(2G 5% .9( /$#)(# 2(. $/ '$+$%1(23 .9(#( I(#( '$%2.#"1%.2 $% .9( =(F(+$-)(%.

$/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 .9". I$,+= /"F$# " /(I ". .9( (M-(%2( $/ .9( )"Q$#1.@G 7,'9

'$%2.#"1%.2 I(#( (%.1#(+@ ";2(%. 1% .9( +"..(# 2(. $/ '$+$%1(2G

[1%"++@3 .9( /$,#.9 '$)-"#".1F( 2.".1' 12 ,2(/,+ 1% .91%?1%* ";$,. I9@ )"%@ '$+$%1(2

=1= %$. "..()-. .$ '9"%*( .9(1# ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 =,#1%* .9( %1%(.((%.9 '(%.,#@

I9(% %(I ('$%$)1' $--$#.,%1.1(2 )"=( .9(1# -#(F1$,2 2@2.() ;"2(= $% /$#'(= +";$#3

2+"F(#@3 $# .#1;,.(L."?1%* ),'9 +(22 ;(%(!'1"+ #(+".1F( .$ $%( (%'$,#"*1%* 1%F(2.)(%. 1%1%=,2.#@ "%= '$))(#'(G


53/111

F1(I "%= .$ ;(*1% .$ 1++,2.#".( 1% '$%'#(.( 2(..1%*2 9$I -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# I$#?2G

T ,-. H&)*97 :7*)$ M*.N *# 2)$*

H( %$I =12',22 .9#(( 1)-$#."%. (M")-+(2 .$ ;#1%* $,. .9( /"'. .9". '$%"1'. $F(# ('$L

%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 12 '#1.1'"+ .$ .9( /,%'.1$%1%* $/ .9( ('$%$)@ "%= .9". .912 '$%"1'.

2.()23 %$. /#$) =1(#(%'(2 1% ;(+1(/23 1=($+$*@ $# 912.$#1'"+ "''1=(%.23 ;,. /#$) .9( 1)L

-"'. $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 $% =12.#1;,.1$%G 69( (M")-+(2 "+2$ 29$I .9". .9$2( I1.9

-$+1.1'"+ -$I(# 9"F( " =12-#$-$#.1$%".( (('. $% ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "%= .9(@ 29$I

9$I .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# 12 1%",(%'(= ;@ =1(#(%. /"'.$#2G 69(2( /"'.$#2

1%'+,=( .9( "++$'".1$% $/ =( Q,#( -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# .9#$,*9 .9( 2.#,'.,#( $/ -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1L

.,.1$%2 "%= .9( ";1+1.@ $/ *#$,-2 .$ 2$+F( .9( '$++('.1F( "'.1$% -#$;+()3 $# (M(#'12( I9".

I( '"++(= =( /"'.$ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#G H1.9 .9(2( (M")-+(2 1% )1%= 1% 2('.1$% Y I( )$F(

.$ =12',22 1% )$#( =(."1+ .9( %".,#( "%= 2$,#'(2 $/ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#G

T+! S9R&% =9%U.$0

& )"#?(.m"% $--$#.,%1.@ /$# 1%=1F1=,"+2 .$ (M'9"%*( " '$))$=1.@ $# 2(#F1'(m12 $;L

F1$,2+@ " /,%=")(%."+ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$% #(+(F"%. /$# =(F(+$-)(%.G &2 &=") 7)1.9

TE__VW "#*,(=3 )"#?(.2 "++$I 1%=1F1=,"+2 .$ ."?( "=F"%."*( $/ .9( ;(%(!.2 $/ 2-('1"+L

1P".1$% "%= .9( =1F121$% $/ +";$#3 "%= 2'9$+"#2 2,'9 "2


54/111

#".1$ "2 "--#$M1)".(+@ DCt $/ .9( -$-,+".1$% $/ 0,#$-( =1(= T(G*G3 X"%.$#3 ACCEW3 .9(>+"'? !(".9 *#(".+@ 1%'#("2(= .9( ;"#*"1%1%* -$I(# $/ -("2"%.2 "%= "++$I(= .9() .$

%(*$.1".( " /#(( 2.".,2 (%=1%* /(,="+ $;+1*".1$%23 -"#.1',+"#+@ I1.9 #(2-('. .$ +";$#G

69(#(/$#(3 #(%%(# TEB_VW3 .9( =()$*#"-91' .9(L

$#@ $/ .9( =('+1%( /(,="+12) 12 %$. '$%212.(%. I1.9 .9( '$)-"#".1F( (F1=(%'(G &+.9$,*9

=()$*#"-91' .#(%=2 I(#( 21)1+"# "++ $F(# 0,#$-( "%=

J1. 12 .#,( .9". GGG 1% )$2. $/ H(2.(#% 0,#$-( 2(#/=$) I"2 =("= ;@ .9(

("#+@ 21M.((%.9 '(%.,#@G c% .9( $.9(# 9"%=3 1% 0"2.(#% 0,#$-(3 1% -"#.1',+"#

#"%=(%;,#*3 0"2. #(%%(#3 EB_V3 -G DEWG


55/111

J)$#( $/ " .(%=(%'@ .$ 1%=1F1=,"+12.1' /"#)1%*a +(22 =(F(+$-(= $#*"%1P".1$% $/ '$++";$L#".1F( "*#1',+.,#"+ -#"'.1'(2 ". .9( +(F(+ $/ .9( F1++"*( $# ;(.I((% F1++"*(2a "%= +1..+( $/

.9( .#"=1.1$% $/ .9( \2.#,**+( /$# '$))$%2 #1*9.2] "*"1%2. .9( +$#=2 I91'9 I"2 2$ '9"#"'L

.(#12.1' $/ I(2.(#% =(F(+$-)(%.N T-G U_WG 6912 =1(#(%.1"+ $#*"%1P".1$% I"2 =,( .$ .9(

-#$'(22 $/ 1%1.1"+ $'',-".1$% $/ .9(2( 0"2.(#% +"%=2G

&+.9$,*9 )"%@ -"#.2 $/ >#(%%(#]2 "%"+@212 #()"1% '$%.#$F(#21"+3 .9(#( 12 *(%(#"+

"*#(()(%. .9". .9( =('+1%( $/ /(,="+12) "%= .9( .#"%2/$#)".1$% $/ 0,#$-("% +";$# )"#L?(.2 I(#( 1%.1)".(+@ #(+".(= .$ .9( -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# $/ .9( ?(@ *#$,-2 I1.9 $--$21%*

1%.(#(2.23 .9( -("2"%.2 "%= .9( +$#=2 T2((3 /$# (M")-+(3 &2.$% "%=


56/111

J4(M1'$ 9"= " 2(#1(2 $/ 2(*)(%.(= )$%$-$+1(2 .9". I(#( "I"#=(= .$ " *#$,- $/ 1%21=(#2G69( $,.'$)(3 '1#'" EBEC '$,+= %$. 9"F( ;((% )$#( =1(#(%.R .9( d%1.(= 7.".(2 9"=

#$,*9+@ AU3CCC ;"%?2 "%= " 91*9+@ '$)-(.1.1F( )"#?(. 2.#,'.,#(a 4(M1'$ 9"= DA ;"%?23

.I$ $/ I91'9 '$%.#$++(= VC -(#'(%. $/ .$."+ ;"%?1%* "22(.23 "%= F1#.,"++@ %$%( $/ I91'9

"'.,"++@ '$)-(.(= I1.9 "%$.9(# ;"%?GN

69( (M-+"%".1$% /$# .912 9,*( =1(#(%'( 12 %$. $;F1$,2G 69( #(+(F"%. .('9%$+$*@ I"2

'(#."1%+@ #("=1+@ "F"1+";+( (F(#@I9(#( "%= 1. 12 =1',+. .$ 2(( I9@ .9( F"#1$,2 .@-(2 $/)$#"+ 9"P"#=2 $# "=F(#2( 2(+('.1$% 122,(2 '$%%('.(= I1.9 !%"%'1"+ 1%.(#)(=1".1$% 29$,+=

9"F( +1)1.(= .9( (M-"%21$% $/ ;"%?2 1% 4(M1'$ ;,. %$. .9( d%1.(= 7.".(2G b";(# .9(%

29$I2 .9". T-G BW3 J". .9( .1)( .9". .9( dG7G X$%2.1.,.1$% I"2 -,. 1%.$ (('. 1% E_YB3 GGG

kdG7G ;"%?1%*l I"2 '9"#"'.(#1P(= ;@ " 2(#1(2 $/ 2(*)(%.(= )$%$-$+1(2 .9". 29"#(= #(%.2

I1.9 2.".( *$F(#%)(%.2 F1" ."M(2 $# 2.".( $I%(#291- $/ ;"%? 2.$'?G 5% 2$)( '"2(23 ;"%?2

"+2$ 29"#(= #(%.2 =1#('.+@ I1.9 .9( +(*12+".$#2 I9$ #(*,+".(= .9()GN

6912 2.#,'.,#(3 I91'9 +$$?(= #()"#?";+@ +1?( .9". I91'9 "#$2( 2,;2(K,(%.+@ 1% 4(ML

1'$3 ()(#*(= ;('",2( 2.".( *$F(#%)(%.2 9"= ;((% 2.#1--(= $/ #(F(%,(2 ;@ .9( X$%2.1L

.,.1$%G 5% #(2-$%2(3 2.".(2 2."#.(= ;"%?2 "2 " I"@ .$ *(%(#".( ."M #(F(%,(2G 7.".(

*$F(#%)(%.2 #(2.#1'.(= (%.#@ J1% $#=(# .$ )"M1)1P( .9( ")$,%. $/ #(%. ("#%(= ;@ ;"%?23

#(%. I91'9 I$,+= .9(% ;( 29"#(= I1.9 .9( 2.".( *$F(#%)(%. 1% .9( /$#) $/ =1F1=(%=23

2.$'? =12.#1;,.1$%23 $# ."M(2 $/ F"#1$,2 .@-(2GN

69,2 1% .9( ("#+@ %1%(.((%.9 '(%.,#@3 dG7G ;"%?2 (F$+F(= "2 )$%$-$+1(2 I1.9 #(*,+"L

.1$%2 "1)(= ". )"M1)1P1%* #(F(%,(2 /$# .9( 2.".( *$F(#%)(%.2 q(. .912 2@2.() =1= %$.


57/111

5% b";(#]2 "#*,)(%. -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 1% .9( d%1.(= 7.".(2 "++$'".(= -$+1.1'"+-$I(# .$ -($-+( I9$ I"%.(= "''(22 .$ '#(=1. "%= +$"%2G &2 " #(2,+. .9(@ /$#'(= 2.".(

*$F(#%)(%.2 .$ "++$I /#(( '$)-(.1.1F( (%.#@ 1%.$ ;"%?1%*G 5% 4(M1'$ -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2

I(#( F(#@ =1(#(%.G 69(#( I(#( %$ '$)-(.1%* /(=(#"+ 2.".(2 "%= .9( 2,#"*( I"2 91*9+@

#(2.#1'.1F(G &2 " #(2,+. .9( '(%.#"+ *$F(#%)(%. *#"%.(= )$%$-$+@ #1*9.2 .$ ;"%?2 I9$

#(2.#1'.(= '#(=1. .$ )"M1)1P( -#$!.2G 69( *#"%.1%* $/ )$%$-$+1(2 .,#%(= $,. .$ ;(

" #".1$%"+ I"@ /$# .9( *$F(#%)(%. .$ #"12( #(F(%,( "%= #(=12.#1;,.( #(%.2 .$ -$+1.1'"+2,--$#.(#2 T2(( ^$#.93 EBYE3 X9"-.(# `WG

& -#1$#13 1. 12 -$221;+( .9". .9( 2$#. $/ )"#?(. #(*,+".1$% b";(# /$,%= 1% 4(M1'$ )1*9.

9"F( ;((% 2$'1"++@ =(21#";+(G 4"#?(.2 %(F(# /,%'.1$% 1% " F"',,)3 ;,. #".9(# I1.91% 2(.2

$/ #,+(2 "%= #(*,+".1$%2 I91'9 9(+- .9() .$ /,%'.1$%G q(. 1. 12 9"#= .$ ;(+1(F( .9".

.912 "#*,)(%. "--+1(2 .$ 4(M1'$ T2(( "+2$ 4",#(#3 ACCAWG b";(# TACCEW =$',)(%.2 .9".

)"#?(. #(*,+".1$% I"2 "1)(= %$. ". 2$+F1%* )"#?(. /"1+,#(2 "%= 1. 12 -#('12(+@ =,#1%*

.912 -(#1$= .9". .9( 9,*( ('$%$)1' *"- ;(.I((% .9( d%1.(= 7.".(2 "%= 4(M1'$ $-(%(=

,- T$% I91'9 2(( X$".2I$#.93 EBB`3 0%*(#)"% "%= 7$?$+$3 EBB_WG 5%=((=3 b";(# "%=

4",#(# TACCDW (M")1%(= 1% =(."1+ 9$I .9( 2.#,'.,#( $/ ;"%?1%* 1%",(%'(= .9( 4(M1'"%

.(M.1+( 1%=,2.#@ ;(.I((% EYYC "%= EBE`G 69(@ 29$I(= .9". $%+@ !#)2 I1.9 -(#2$%"+

'$%."'.2 I1.9 ;"%?2 I(#( ";+( .$ *(. +$"%2G 69(@ '$%'+,=( T-G UWR

Jc,# "%"+@212 =()$%2.#".(2 .9". .(M.1+( )1++2 .9". I(#( #(+".(= .$ ;"%?2I(#( +(22 -#$!.";+( "%= +(22 .('9%1'"++@ ('1(%. .9"% .9(1# '$)-(.1.$#2G ^(FL


58/111

J4$2. &/#1'"% 2.".(2 -$22(22 -,;+1'+@ 2"%'.1$%(= )$%$-2$%1(2 /$# .9( -,#L'9"2( "%= (M-$#. $/ "*#1',+.,#"+ *$$=2 GGG 69(2( "*(%'1(23 ;(K,(".9(= .$ .9(

*$F(#%)(%.2 $/ .9( 1%=(-(%=(%. 2.".(2 ;@ .9(1# '$+$%1"+ -#(=('(22$#23 -,#L

'9"2( '"29 '#$-2 /$# (M-$#. ". "=)1%12.#".1F(+@ =(.(#)1%(= =$)(2.1' -#1'(23

"%= .9(% 2(++ .9() ". .9( -#(F"1+1%* I$#+= )"#?(. -#1'(2G >@ ,21%* .9(1#

)"#?(. -$I(# .$ ?((- .9( -#1'( -"1= .$ .9( /"#)(# ;(+$I .9( -#1'( 2(. ;@

.9( I$#+= )"#?(.3 .9(@ "'',),+".( /,%=2 /#$) .9( "*#1',+.,#"+ 2('.$#N >".(2TEBYE3 -G EAWG

69( )"#?(.1%* ;$"#=2 )"=( 2,#-+,2(2 I91'9 I(#( *1F(% .$ .9( *$F(#%)(%. "2 " /$#)

$/ ."M".1$%G >".(2 TEBYE3 -G EUW %$.(2

J& )"Q$# .(2. $/ .9( 1%.(%.1$%2 $/ .9( %(I+@ 1%=(-(%=(%. *$F(#%)(%.2

$'',##(= GGG kI9(%l ;(.I((% EBUBLEBVC "%= EBVELVA3 .9( I$#+= -#1'( $/ '$'$"/(++ "--#$M1)".(+@ !UC " .$%G 5/ .9( #(2$,#'(2 *(%(#".(= ;@ .9( )"#?(.1%*

"*(%'1(2 I(#( .$ ;( ,2(= .$ 2.";1+1P( -#1'(23 .9(% 2,#(+@ .912 I"2 .9( .1)( .$

,2( .9( /,%=2 /$# .9". -,#-$2(G 5%2.("= GGG .9( *$F(#%)(%.2 $/ ;$.9 i9"%"

"%= ^1*(#1" -"22(= $% .9( /,++ ;,#=(% $/ .9( =#$- 1% -#1'( .$ .9( -#$=,'(#2GN

>".(2 '$%.1%,(2 Jd21%* .9( -#1'( 2(..1%* -$I(# $/ .9( )$%$-2$%12.1' )"#?(.1%* "*(%L

'1(23 .9( 2.".(2 9"F( .9(#(/$#( )"=( .9( -#$=,'(#2 $/ '"29 '#$-2 " 21*%1!'"%. -"#. $/ .9(1#

. ; = 9 . ? / .9 1.9 . .1 1 .9 / / 1


59/111

-$+1'@ .9,2 ;('$)(2 " ;@L-#$=,'. $/ -$+1.1'"+ #(+".1$%2 ;(.I((% *$F(#%)(%.2"%= ,#;"% '$%2.1.,(%.2N TEBYE3 -G ``W

5% '$%.#"2. .$ .9( 21.,".1$% 1% i9"%"3 g");1" "%= ^1*(#1"3 >".(2 TEBYE3 EBYB3 EBB_W

29$I(= .9". "*#1',+.,#"+ -$+1'@ 1% O(%@" "%= X$+$);1" $F(# .912 -(#1$= I"2 ),'9 )$#(

-#$L/"#)(#G 69( =1(#(%'( I"2 =,( .$ I9$ '$%.#$++(= .9( )"#?(.1%* ;$"#=G 5% O(%@"3

/"#)(#2 I(#( %$. 2)"++9$+=(#23 "2 .9(@ I(#( 1% i9"%"3 ^1*(#1" "%= g");1"3 "%= '$%L

'(%.#".(= +"%=$I%(#291- )"=( 1. ),'9 ("21(# .$ 2$+F( .9( '$++('.1F( "'.1$% -#$;+()G

4$#($F(#3 /"#)1%* I"2 1)-$#."%. 1% .9( O1?,@, "#("23 "% (.9%1' *#$,- '+$2(+@ #(+".(=

.$ .9( #,+1%* -$+1.1'"+ -"#.@3 O&^d3 ,%=(# 8$)$ O(%@".." T>".(23 EBYE3 -G EAAWG ["#)L

(#2 1% O(%@" .9(#(/$#( /$#)(= " -$I(#/,+ +$;;@ "%= I(#( ";+( .$ *,"#"%.(( .9()2(+F(2

91*9 -#1'(2G 0F(% .9$,*9 .9( *$F(#%)(%. $/ O(%@" (%*"*(= 1% +"%= #(/$#) "/.(# 1%=(L

-(%=(%'(

JYCt $/ .9( /$#)(# I91.( 91*9+"%=2 I(#( +(/. 1%."'. "%= GGG .9( *$F(#%)(%.

.$$? (+";$#".( )("2,#(2 .$ -#(2(#F( .9( 1%.(*#1.@ $/ .9( +"#*(L2'"+( /"#)2

GGG kI91'9l #("=1+@ '$);1%( 1% =(/(%2( $/ .9(1# 1%.(#(2.2G c%( $/ .9( )$2.

1)-$#."%. '$++('.1F( ($#.2 12 .9( O(%@" ^".1$%"+ ["#)(#]2 d%1$% TO^[dW

GGG 69( $#*"%1P".1$% GGG 12 =$)1%".(= ;@ .9( +"#*(L2'"+( /"#)(#2 GG k;,.l 1. '"%

;( "#*,(= .9". .9( O^[d 9(+-2 .$ '#(".( " /#")(I$#? $/ -,;+1' -$+1'1(2 .9".-#$F1=(2 "% ('$%$)1' (%F1#$%)(%. /"F$#";+( .$ "++ /"#)(#2N >".(2 TEBYE3 --G


60/111

I9$ ". ?(@ )$)(%.2 .9()2(+F(2 ;$#( .9( '$2.2 $/ '$++('.1F( "'.1$%3 -#$F121$%L1%* .9( '$(( 2('.$# I1.9 ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "%= =(+(*".1%* -,;+1' -$I(#

.$ '$(( 1%.(#(2.2GN

b$I '$,+= .9( '$(( *#$I(#2 *"1% 2,'9 +(F(#"*( $F(# %".1$%"+ -$+1'@S

J& )"Q$# #("2$% .9(@ '$,+= =$ 2$ GGG 12 ;('",2( .9( 2.#,'.,#( $/ -$+1.1'"+

1%2.1.,.1$%23 "%= 1% -"#.1',+"# .9( 2.#,'.,#( $/ -"#.@ '$)-(.1.1$%3 #(%=(#(=

.9() -1F$."+3 *1F1%* .9() .9( -$I(# $F(# .9( -$+1.1'"+ /$#.,%(2 $/ .9$2(

I1.9 ");1.1$% /$# $'( "%= (%";+1%* .9() .$ )"?( $# ;#("? *$F(#%)(%.2G

69(@ .9(#(;@ *"1%(= .9( -$I(# .$ =(/(". *$F(#%)(%. $'1"+2 I9$ 2$,*9. .$

$#'9(2.#".( $# '$%2.#"1% .9(1# ;(9"F1$#GN >".(2 TEBB_3 -GUE3 UDW

& .(++1%* -1('( $/ (F1=(%'( 1% /"F$# $/ .912 .9(212 12 .9". =,#1%* .9( EBUC]2 I9(% " '1F1+I"# ;#$?( $,. ;(.I((% .9( .I$ -"#.1(23 .9(#( I"2 !F( @("#2 $/ )1+1."#@ #,+( "%= -$+1'@

.,#%(= =('121F(+@ "*"1% .9( '$(( *#$I(#23 $%+@ .$ 2I1.'9 ;"'? "*"1% I1.9 .9( -("'(/,+

#(2,)-.1$% $/ =()$'#"'@ 1% EBUYG

T+B P&7*$*)97 P&N.% 9#' ?)&4*) "#0$*$($*

69(2( .9#(( (M")-+(2 $/ .9( '#(".1$% $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 9"F( '(#."1% /(".,#(2 1%'$))$%G &++ .9(2( 1%2.1.,.1$%23 +";$# )"#?(. #(*,+".1$%u/(,="+12)3 .9( #,+(2 *$F(#%1%*


61/111

69( =#1F1%* /$#'( ;(91%= "++ .9#(( (M")-+(2 12 .9". ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( '9$2(%/$# .9(1# =12.#1;,.1$%"+ '$%2(K,(%'(2G H91'9 2-('1!' ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 ()(#*( =(L

-(%=2 $% I9$ 12 ";+( .$ *(. .9(1# I"@mI9$ 9"2 -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#G 5% 0%*+"%=3 -("2"%.

'$)),%1.1(2 9"= =(F(+$-(= #(+".1F(+@ 2.#$%* +$'"+ -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "%= I(#( ";+(

.$ '$%2$+1=".( $% .9( 29$'? $/ .9( >+"'? !(".9 .$ -,. "% (%= .$ /(,="+ #(*,+".1$%2G 5%

0"2.(#% 0,#$-( 1. I"2 .9( +$#=2 I9$ 9"= #(+".1F(+@ )$#( -$I(# "%= .9(@ I(#( ";+( .$

1%.(%21/@ /(,="+12) 1% .9( /"'( $/ .9( 2")( =()$*#"-91' 29$'? T"2 !$)"#3 EB_C3 -$1%.(=$,.3 .9( >+"'? !(".9 "'.,"++@ )"=( 2(#/=$) )$#( "..#"'.1F( .$ .9( +$#=2 (F(% 1/ ". .9(

2")( .1)( 1. 1%'#("2(= .9( ;"#*"1%1%* -$I(# $/ .9( -("2"%.2WG 5% .9( '"2( $/ ;"%?L

1%* 1% .9( %1%(.((%.9 '(%.,#@3 b";(#]2 #(2("#'9 29$I2 I91+( .9( ",.9$#1."#1"% #(*1)(

1% 4(M1'$ 9"= .9( -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# .$ /#((+@ '#(".( )$%$-$+1(2 "%= '#(".( #(%.2 1% .9(

;"%?1%* 1%=,2.#@3 .9( d%1.(= 7.".(2 I"2 =1(#(%. ;('",2( 1. I"2 /(=(#"+ "%= ),'9 )$#(

=()$'#".1'G 69( -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 $/ .9( d%1.(= 7.".(2 -#(F(%.(= -$+1.1'1"%2 /#$)

"--#$-#1".1%* .9( #(%.2 .9". '$,+= "$I /#$) .9( '#(".1$% $/ )$%$-$+1(2G [1%"++@3 1%

>".(2]2 "%"+@2123 =12.$#.1$%"#@ -#1'( #(*,+".1$%2 "#$2( 1% i9"%" "%= g");1"3 ;,. %$. 1%

O(%@" "%= X$+$);1"3 ;('",2( 1% .9( +"..(# '$,%.#1(2 "*#1',+.,#"+ -#$=,'(#2 9"= )$#(

-$+1.1'"+ -$I(# "%= 2$ '$,+= -#(F(%. .9( =12.$#.1$%"#@ -$+1'1(2 .9". I$,+= 9"#) .9(1#

1%.(#(2.2G

5. 12 "+2$ ,2(/,+ .$ '$%21=(# 1% .9( '$%.(M. $/ .9(2( (M")-+(2 .9( )('9"%12)2 I( =12L

',22(= 1% 2('.1$% V I91'9 ,%=(#+1( .9( "=$-.1$% $/ 1%('1(%. ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2G H9@'$,+=%]. .9( -("2"%.2 "%= +$#=2 $/ /(,="+ 0,#$-( %(*$.1".( "%= "++$I .9( 1%.#$=,'.1$%


62/111

5% .9( '"2( $/ "*#1',+.,#"+ -#1'( #(*,+".1$%3 21)1+"# "#*,)(%.2 "#( -+",21;+(G X$'$"/"#)(#2 1% i9"%" I$,+= %$. 9"F( ;(+1(F(= -#$)12(2 ;@ *$F(#%)(%.2 .9". .9(@ I$,+= %$.

(M-#$-#1".( .9( /#,1.2 $/ 91*9(# 1%F(2.)(%.3 "%= .9( *$F(#%)(%.2 .9()2(+F(2 I$,+= %$.

9"F( ;(+1(F(= -#$)12(2 ;@ .9( /"#)(#2 .$ '$)-(%2".( .9() 1/ .9(@ +(/. $'(G 4$#($F(#3

('1(%. 2(.2 $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 1% i9"%" $# ^1*(#1" I$,+= 9"F( 2.#(%*.9(%(= .9(

('$%$)1' ;"2( $/ .9( #,#"+ 2('.$# ". .9( (M-(%2( $/ .9( -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# $/ .9( .9(%

=$)1%"%. ,#;"% 2('.$#G 5%=((=3 /$# i9"%" 1% .9( EBVC]23 I( 9"F( =1#('. (F1=(%'( /#$).9( ,#;"% ('$%$)@ .9". .9( .9#(". $/ ;(1%* " -$+1.1'"+ +$2(# +(= .$ 1%('1(%. ('$%$)1'

1%2.1.,.1$%2G 6912 ()(#*(2 1% .9( "%"+@212 $/ O1++1'? TEB_Y3 -G `_W $/ .9( "..()-. ;@ .9(

*$F(#%)(%. $/ OI")( ^?#,)"9 .$ -#$)$.( 1%=,2.#1"+1P".1$%G O1++1'? %$.(2R

J0F(% 9"= .9(#( ;((% .9( -$221;1+1.@ k$/ '#(".1%* "% 1%=1*(%$,2 (%.#(-#(L

%(,#1"+ '+"22l 1. 12 =$,;./,+ .9". ^?#,)"9 I$,+= 9"F( I"%.(= .$ '#(".( 2,'9 "

'+"223 /$# #("2$%2 $/ 1=($+$*@ "%= -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#G b( I"2 F(#@ (M-+1'1. ";$,.

.912 2"@1%* \I( I$,+= ;( 9")-(#1%* $,# "=F"%'( .$ 2$'1"+12) 1/ I( I(#( .$

(%'$,#"*( .9( *#$I.9 $/ i9"%1"% -#1F".( '"-1."+12) 1% $,# )1=2.G] 69(#(

12 (F1=(%'( .9". 9( "+2$ /("#(= .9( .9#(". .9". " I("+.9@ '+"22 $/ i9"%"1"%

;,21%(22)(% )1*9. -$2( .$ 912 $I% -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#GN

[,#.9(# (F1=(%'( $% .9( 1)-$#."%'( $/ -$+1.1'"+ +$2(# '$%21=(#".1$%2 '$)(2 /#$) 0G&@(9LO,)1 $%( $/ ^?#,)"9]2 )"1% ('$%$)1' "=F12(#2 I9$ %$.(= "/.(# .9( '$,- .9".


63/111

=$(2 -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# '$)( /#$) "%= I9$ 9"2 -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#S 5% "==#(221%* .9(2( K,(2L.1$%2 I( I1++ =(F(+$- $,# .9($#@ $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2G 5% " .9($#@ ;"2(= $% 2$'1"+

'$%"1'. I9(#( ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( (%=$*(%$,23 1. I1++ ;( .$ =1(#(%'(2 1% -$+1.1'"+

1%2.1.,.1$%2 "%= .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# .9". I( ),2. +$$? .$ (M-+"1% F"#1".1$%

1% ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2G

V 2 ,-.&%J &; "#0$*$($*V+! H&(%).0 &; P&7*$*)97 P&N.%

H9$ 9"2 -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# "%= I9(#( =$(2 1. '$)( /#$)S &2 I( %$.(= 1% .9( 5%.#$=,'.1$%

T2('.1$% EGA3 -$1%. DW3 -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# '$)(2 /#$) .I$ 2$,#'(2G [1#2.3 "% 1%=1F1=,"+ $#

*#$,- '"% ;( "++$'".(=!" #$%"-$I(# ;@.*-0)0('- 0+1)0)$)0*+1G >,. 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( %$. .9(

$%+@ 2$,#'( $/ -$I(#G & 2('$%= .@-( $/ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# "''#,(2 .$ 1%=1F1=,"+2 $# *#$,-2

1/ .9(@ '"% 2$+F( .9( '$++('.1F( "'.1$% -#$;+()3 '#(".( #1$.23 #(F$+.23 $# =()$%2.#".1$%23$I% *,%23 (.'GG H( '"++ .912 .@-( $/ -$I(#!" &'()* -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# T2(( &'()$*+, "%=

:$;1%2$%3 ACC`3 '9"-.(# UWG

&'.,"+ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# 12 .9( '$)-$21.1$%3 .9( Q$1%. $,.'$)(3 $/ =( Q,#( "%= =( /"'.$

-$I(#G 6$ 2(( 9$I .912 I$#?2 $,. 1% -#"'.1'(3 '$%21=(# .9( 21.,".1$% 1% X91+( 1% .9( ("#+@

EB_C]2G 7"+F"=$# &++(%=( I"2 (+('.(=


64/111

#,+(2 I91'9 I$,+= *,"#"%.(( 1.G >,. I9(#( =1= .9(2( =1(#(%'(2 1% -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2'$)( /#$)S 69(2( =1(#(%'(2 I(#( -"#.+@ " #(2,+. $/ -$+1.1'"+ (F(%.2 1% .9( %1%(.((%.9

'(%.,#@3 "%= -"#.1"++@ " #(2,+. $/ =1(#(%. '$+$%1"+ -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2G 5% .9( d%1.(=

7.".(23 =,#1%* .9( 1%1.1"+ -9"2( $/ '$+$%1P".1$% 1% .9( ("#+@ 2(F(%.((%.9 '(%.,#@G j(#@ +$I

-$-,+".1$% =(%21.@ "%= +"'? $/ ("21+@ (M-+$1.";+( #(2$,#'(2 /$#'(= '$+$%1P1%* '$)-"%1(2

"%= .9( >#1.129 2.".( .$ )"?( ;$.9 ('$%$)1' "%= -$+1.1'"+ '$%'(221$%2a .9(@ *#"%.(=

.9( 2(..+(#2 "''(22 .$ +"%= "%= "''(-.(= .9( /$#)".1$% $/ #(-#(2(%.".1F( =()$'#".1' 1%L2.1.,.1$%2 T4$#*"%3 EB_UWG X$%2(K,(%.+@3 (F(% ". 1%=(-(%=(%'( .9( d%1.(= 7.".(2 9"=

#(+".1F(+@ =()$'#".1' -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 TO(@22"#3 ACCCWG 4$#($F(#3 .9( 1%1.1"+ (*"+1L

."#1"% =12.#1;,.1$% $/ "22(.2 "%= .9( 91*9 =(*#(( $/ 2$'1"+ )$;1+1.@ )"=( /$# " 21.,".1$%

I9(#(3 ". +("2. 1% .9( %$#.9(#% 2.".(23 .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ ('$%$)1' #(2$,#'(23 "%= .9,2

=( /"'.$ -$I(#3 I"2 #(+".1F(+@ (K,"+G 69( #(+".1F(+@ #(-#(2(%.".1F( -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2

.9(#(/$#( -(#212.(= "%= I(#( 2,--$#.(= ;@ .9( ;"+"%'( $/ =( /"'.$ -$I(# 1% 2$'1(.@G

5% 4(M1'$ .9(#( I(#( F(#@ =1(#(%. 1%1.1"+ '$%=1.1$%2 =,#1%* .9( '$+$%1"+ -(#1$= I1.9

" +"#*( 1%=1*(%$,2 -$-,+".1$% "%= #1'9 21+F(# )1%(2 .$ (M-+$1.G 6912 +(= .$ " ),'9 )$#(

91(#"#'91'"+ "%= ",.9$#1."#1"% ;"+"%'( $/ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# "%= F(#@ =1(#(%. '$+$%1"+ ('$L

%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 T2(( 0%*(#)"% "%= 7$?$+$3 EBB_3 &'()$*+,3 8$9%2$% "%= :$;1%2$%3

ACCDWG 69(2( '$%=1.1$%2 /(= 1%.$ .9( =1(#(%. 1%2.1.,.1$%"+ 2.#,'.,#(2 ". 1%=(-(%=(%'(3

.9( d%1.(= 7.".(2 I1.9 1.2 '$%2.1.,.1$%3 '9('?2 "%= ;"+"%'(2 "%= /(=(#"+12)3 4(M1'$ I1.9

1.2 ),'9 )$#( '(%.#"+1P(=3 ,%'9('?(=3 ,%;"+"%'(= "%= ";2$+,.12. 2.".(G 69(2( =1(#(%.-$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 .9(% +(= .$ F(#@ =1(#(%. ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "%= ('$%$)1' $,.L


65/111

1%2.1.,.1$%2 "%= ('$%$)1' -(#/$#)"%'(G 5. "+2$ 1%",(%'(2 .9( /,.,#( (F$+,.1$% $/ -$+1.1L'"+ -$I(# "%= -#$2-(#1.@G 0'$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 =(.(#)1%( .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ #(2$,#'(2

". .9". -$1%.3 I91'93 1% .,#%3 1%",(%'(2 .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ =( /"'.$ -$I(# 1% .9( /,.,#(G

71)1+"#+@3 .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ -$I(# ". "%@ -$1%. =(.(#)1%(2 %$. Q,2. .9( ('$%$)1' 1%2.1L

.,.1$%2 .9(%3 ;,. "+2$ .9( /,.,#( -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2G 69,2 .9( "++$'".1$% $/ -$+1.1'"+

-$I(# ". $%( =".(3 ;('",2( $/ .9( I"@ 1. 1%",(%'(2 .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ #(2$,#'(2 "%=

/,.,#( -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%23 9"2 " '#,'1"+ (('. $% .9( /,.,#( "++$'".1$% $/ ;$.9 =( /"'.$"%= =( Q,#( -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#G

>$.9 .9( '$)-"#12$% b";(# )"=( ;(.I((% 4(M1'$ "%= .9( d%1.(= 7.".(23 "%= .9".

I91'9 >".(2 )"=( ;(.I((% i9"%"3 g");1"3 O(%@" "%= X$+$);1" 1++,2.#".( .912 =1"*#")

1% "'.1$%G 69(@ 29$I 9$I -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "%= =( /"'.$ -$I(# '$);1%( .$ *(%(#".(

=1(#(%. 2(. $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%23 9$I .9(2( 1%2.1.,.1$%2 =(.(#)1%( ;$.9 .9( =12.#1;L

,.1$% $/ #(2$,#'(2 "%= .9( *#$I.9 #".( $/ .9( ('$%$)@3 "%= 9$I -$I(# "%= 1%2.1.,.1$%2

(F$+F( $F(# .1)(3 $/.(% 1% I"@2 .9". .(%= .$ #(1%/$#'( -"#.1',+"# 1%1.1"+ '$%=1.1$%2G

V+1 P&7*$*)97 P&N.% 9#' P&7*$*)97 "#0$*$($*

69( (M")-+(2 I( =12',22(= ";$F( 29$I(= 9$I -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# =(-(%=2 $% -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1L

.,.1$%2 "%= =( /"'.$ -$I(#3 "%= 9$I .912 =(.(#)1%(2 ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2G 4$#($F(#3

I( 2"I .9". ". "%@ .1)( .9( -#(L(M12.1%* ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 I1++ ;( "% 1)-$#."%.

=(.(#)1%"%. $/ .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ =( /"'.$ -$I(#G 69( !%"+ (+()(%. .$ ()-9"21P( 12

9 +1.1 + 1 .1. .1 + .1 = 9 .9 1 " .9 =1 . 1; .1 /


66/111

.9( '$%2.1.,.1$% '"% ;( $F(#.9#$I%3 I9@ ;$.9(# .$ #(LI#1.( 1.S 69( 2('#(. .$ .912 +1(21% .9( 1%.#1%21'"++@ .#"%21.$#@ %".,#( $/ =( /"'.$ -$I(#G!# q(23 .9( )1+1."#@ I(#( ";+(

.$ $#*"%1P( " '$,- 1% EB_` ;,. .912 I"2 $%+@ ;('",2( .1)(2 I(#( ,%1K,(+@ -#$-1.1$,2G

69(#( I"2 " I$#+=LI1=( ('$%$)1' '#12123 "%= /"'.1$%2 $/ .9( )1+1."#@ .9". $--$2(= .9(

'$,- '$,+= ;( )"#*1%"+1P(=G 4$#($F(#3 .9( d%1.(= 7.".(2 *$F(#%)(%. ". .9( .1)( I"2

9"--@ .$ (%'$,#"*( "%= (%=$#2( .9( $F(#.9#$I $/ " 2$'1"+12. *$F(#%)(%.3 (F(% 1/ 1. 9"=

;((% =()$'#".1'"++@ (+('.(=G 69( '$)1%* .$*(.9(# $/ 2,'9 '1#',)2."%'(2 '$,+= %$. ;((M-('.(= .$ 9"--(% '$%.1%,"++@3 9(%'( $%'( X91+("% 2$'1(.@ #(L=()$'#".1P(=3 "2 1. =1=

"/.(# EBBC3 .9( )1+1."#@ I$,+= %$. ;( ";+( .$ '$%.1%,"++@ .9#(".(% " '$,-G 5% #(2-$%2( .$

.912


67/111

;@ .9( 2.".(G 71%'( .9(#( 12 %$ .91#= -"#.@ .$ (%/$#'( .9( =('121$%2 $/ .9( 2.".(3 -#$;+()2$/ '$))1.)(%. "#( -"#.1',+"#+@ 2(F(#( 1% .9( -$+1.1'"+ #("+)G

[$,#.93 .9( (K,1+1;#1,) 2.#,'.,#( $/ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 I1++ .9(#(/$#( ;( =(.(#L

)1%(= ;@ I9$ 9"2 .9( -$I(# .$ *(. .9(1# I"@3 1G(G3 I9$ '"% '#(".( "%= 2,2."1% ('$%$)1'

1%2.1.,.1$%2 .9". ;(%(!. .9()2(+F(2G 69( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# .9,2 =(.(#)1%(2

('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%23 .9( "++$'".1$% $/ #(2$,#'(2 "%= .9( #".( $/ ('$%$)1' *#$I.9G

[1/.93 -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# 9"2 .I$ /$#)2R =( Q,#( -$I(# =(.(#)1%(= ;@ .9( -$+1.1'"+1%2.1.,.1$%23 2,'9 "2 .9( '$%2.1.,.1$% "%= .9( (+('.$#"+ #,+(23 "%= =( /"'.$ -$I(#3 I91'9

2.()2 /#$) .9( ";1+1.@ .$ 2$+F( .9( '$++('.1F( "'.1$% -#$;+()3 )$;1+1P( I("-$%2 (.'GG !(

/"'.$ -$I(# '"% 1%",(%'( -$+1.1'"+ $,.'$)(2 1%=(-(%=(%.+@ $/ .9( -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%23

"%= 1.2 =12.#1;,.1$% $/.(% '#1.1'"++@ =(.(#)1%(2 9$I " *1F(% 2(. $/ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 I$#?2 1%

-#"'.1'( "%= I9(.9(# $# %$. .9(@ "#( "'.,"++@ $;(@(=G

71M.93 .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ =( /"'.$ -$+1.1'"+ -$I(# ". "%@ =".( 12 1%",(%'(= .$ " +"#*(

=(*#(( ;@ .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/ #(2$,#'(2 1% 2$'1(.@3 21%'( .9$2( I1.9 *#(".(# #(2$,#'(2 '"%

'$))"%= )$#( -$I(# ;$.9 .9#$,*9 +(*1.1)".( "%= 1%.1)".( )("%23 "%= -(#9"-2 '"%

"+2$ 2$+F( .9( '$++('.1F( "'.1$% -#$;+() )$#( ('1(%.+@G ^".,#"++@3 .9( =12.#1;,.1$% $/

#(2$,#'(2 ". .912 -$1%. 12 1%",(%'(= ;@ ('$%$)1' 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "%= ('$%$)1' $,.'$)(2 1%

.9( -"2.G

[1%"++@3 -$+1.1'"+ 1%2.1.,.1$%2 "#( "+2$ (%=$*(%$,2a .9( ',##(%. ;"+"%'( $/ -$+1.1'"+

-$I(#3 1%'$#-$#".1%* ;$.9 =( Q,#( "%= =( /"'.$ (+()(%.23 "+2$ =(.(#)1%(2 /,.,#( -$+1.1'"+1%2.1.,.1$%2


68/111

=12.#1;,.1$% $/ =( Q,#( -$+1.1'"+ -$I(#G

W+! C*0. &; :$*$($*a =%)-J 9#' ?)&4*) X%&N$- *# ?9%7J =&'.%#

?(%&A.

c,#!#2. (M")-+( 12 .9( #12( $/ '$%2.1.,.1$%"+ )$%"#'9@ 1% 0,#$-(G 5% .9( )(=1(F"+ -(#1$=

)$2. 0,#$-("% %".1$%2 I(#( *$F(#%(= ;@ 9(#(=1."#@ )$%"#'91(2G b$I(F(#3 "2 .9( /(,="+

I$#+= '9"%*(=3 F"#1$,2 *#$,-2 2.#,**+(= .$ *"1% -$+1.1'"+ #1*9.2 "%= #(=,'( .9( ",.$'#".1'-$I(#2 $/ )$%"#'91(2G 5% 0%*+"%=3 .912 -#$'(22 ;(*"% "2 ("#+@ "2 EAEU I9(% O1%* 8$9%

I"2 /$#'(= ;@ 912 ;"#$%2 .$ 21*% .9( 4"*%" X"#."3 " =$',)(%. I91'9 1%'#("2(= .9(

-$I(#2 $/ .9( ;"#$%23 1%.#$=,'(= .9( '$%'(-. $/ (K,"+1.@ ;(/$#( .9( +"I3 "%= /$#'(=

2,;2(K,(%. ?1%*2 .$ '$%2,+. I1.9 .9()G 4"%@ $.9(# 0,#$-("% %".1$%2 "+2$ =(F(+$-(=

\-"#+1")(%.2] I91'9 ?1%*2 '$,+= 2,))$% .$ =12',22 ."M".1$% $# I"#/"#( T2(( i#"F(23 ACCE3

0#.)"%3 EBB_WG ^(F(#.9(+(223 .9( )$F()(%. .$I"#=2 +1)1.(=3 '$%2.1.,.1$%"+ )$%"#'9@

I"2 %$. +1%("# $# 21)-+(G 5%=((=3 1% [#"%'(3 '(#."1%+@ /#$) .9( ;(*1%%1%* $/ Z$,12 v5j]2

#(1*% 1% EV`Y3 " )$#( -$I(#/,+ ";2$+,.12. )$%"#'9@ "--("#(= I1.9 F(#@ /(I '$%.#$+2G

5%=((= .9( /(,="+ [#(%'9 -"#+1")(%.23 .9( 02.".(2 i(%(#"+3 I(#( %$. 2,))$%(= ;(.I((%

EVED "%= E_YY3 Q,2. ;(/$#( .9( :(F$+,.1$%G

5% 0%*+"%=3 .9( 6,=$# )$%"#'923 -"#.1',+"#+@ b(%#@ j555 "%= .9(% 0+1P";(.9 53

/$++$I(= ;@ .9( !#2. 7.,"#. ?1%*23 8")(2 5 "%= X9"#+(2 53 "+2$ "..()-.(= .$ ;,1+= "%

";2$+,.12. )$%"#'9@G 69(@ /"1+(=3 9$I(F(#3 )$2.+@ ;('",2( $/


69/111

#(2(%.)(%. 1% EU_A +(= .$ " 2(#1(2 $/ ,-#121%*2 "*"1%2. .9( b"-2;,#*23 )$2.+@ $#'9(2.#".(=;@ '$))(#'1"+ 1%.(#(2.2G 69(2( ',+)1%".(= 1% .9( H"# $/ 5%=(-(%=(%'( I91'9 I"2!%"++@

I$% 1% EVDYG

H91+( 0%*+"%= "%= .9( ^(.9(#+"%=2 I(#( =(F(+$-1%* +1)1.(= '$%2.1.,.1$%"+ *$F(#%L

)(%.23 7-"1% "%=


70/111

$/ X"2.1++(3 I91'9 .9(@ =(+(*".(= .$ .9(A'1' !" A*+)%')'(0F*+Tb$,2( $/ 6#"=(W 1% 7(F1++(G6912 )(#'9"%.2 *,1+= I"2 '+$2(+@ )$%1.$#(= ;@ .9( *$F(#%)(%. T$,#;$% #(/$#)2 $/ .9( )1= (1*9.((%.9 '(%.,#@3 %$.91%*'$,+= ;( (M-$#.(= =1#('.+@ /#$) >,(%$2 &1#(23 "%= 1/ 2$)(;$=@ -#$=,'(= "%@.91%* /$#

(M-$#. $% .9(


71/111

(M-"%=(= -#('12(+@ .9$2( *#$,-2 I1.91% !,.'9 2$'1(.@ )$2. $--$2(= .$ b"-2;,#* #,+(G52#"(+ TEBBU3 --G ADELADAW I#1.(2R J[#$) EUBC3 .9(#( I"2 " =#")".1' 1)-#$F()(%. 1%

.9( :(-,;+1']2 ('$%$)1'

Date post:	04-Jun-2018
Category:	Documents
Upload:	gabriel-amer
View:	220 times
Download:	0 times

Lectura 6 Acemoglu Et Al 2004 Institutions as the Fundamental Cause of Long-run Growth

Documents