Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
1/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Lecture 10
Deposition Techniques
2/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Announcements
• Is due now.
• Please email it to me if you have not already done so.
Homework 4/10:
• I will return it one week from today later (November 2nd).
• Is online now.
• I will return it one week later (November 9th).
Homework 5/10:
• Due Monday November 2nd at the start of the lecture
(2:00pm).
• Homework 5 consists of content covered in Lectures 9 and 10.
1
2
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
3/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Lecture 10• Vapor Based Techniques.
• Thermal Evaporation.
• Sputtering.
• Chemical Vapor Deposition.
• Atomic Layer Deposition.
• Solution-Based Techniques.
• Spin Coating.
• Spray Coating.
• Printing.
4/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Large Area Deposition
3
4
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
5/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Large Area Electronics• As we discussed in
Lecture 1, the objective
of thin film electronics is
to have electronics over
large surfaces.IGNIS Innovation
• Eventually, we want this
to be possible at low
temperature, at low
cost, and on flexible
substrates.
6/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Large Area Electronics• This has forced us to rethink how we grow
semiconductors (we can no longer uses Si wafers).
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aWVywhzuHnQ Pi-kem
• So how to we get our semiconductor to form a
uniform film over a large area?
• There is no one answer to this question.
5
6
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
7/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Thermal Evaporation
8/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Thermal Evaporation• One of the crudest methods is to simply vaporize the
semiconductor, and direct the vapor towards the
substrate: Substrate holder
Deposition rate sensor
To vacuum
pump
Source
organic
Substrate
shutter
Substrate and
mask
Thermal
filament
• However for certain
materials the metal
source can be replaced
with a semiconductor.
• E.g. pentacene:
• This is conventionally
used for metals (e.g. Au,
Al) for contacts.
7
8
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
9/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Thermal Evaporation• Normally the material is held in a small “boat” made
of a resistive material.
• A large current is driven between the terminals,
causing the boat to heat up (can be ≫ 1000˚C for
certain materials).
https://angstromengineering.com/tech/resistive-thermal-evaporation/
10/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Thermal Evaporation• Because it is held in
a vacuum, the
material being
heated will vaporize.
• The material will
coat everything
inside the chamber.
• But it can be
partially directed
towards the
substrate. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qIn8vPIKV54
9
10
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
11/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Thermal Evaporation• We have thermal evaporators in the cleanroom in
Owen Hall.
• They are just used for metals, however.
12/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Thermal Evaporation• For organic semiconductors we need much lower
temperature (the materials will often decompose
above ~300 - 400˚C).
• Multiple sources can
be used so complex
structure can be
made, without
having to open the
chamber.
11
12
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
13/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Thermal Evaporation• It happens there are already many commercial
products based on thermally-evaporated organic
semiconductors.
• These all contain organic light-emitting diodes
(OLEDs).
14/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Thermal Evaporation• However at present there are no commercial
products that contain OTFTs. Yet there are plenty of
proof-of-principle demonstrations using OTFTs.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TEey_Yvvc64
13
14
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
15/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Thermal Evaporation• The stacking of small molecules such as pentacene
are highly dependent on growth conditions.
Salzmann et. al. ACSNano. 6 (2012) 10874.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4E9K0W2lTK0
• The alignment of molecules has a strong effect on
electronic properties of TFTs.
16/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Thermal Evaporation• Many factors affect the growth of small organic
molecules on surfaces:
• Deposition Rate.
• Substrate
temperature.
• Chamber pressure.
• Surface energy of
substrate.
• Purity of material.
Oetritz et. al. Org. Electron. 14 (2013) 3070.
15
16
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
17/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Thermal Evaporation• Plastic Logic (Cambridge spin-out) have a huge
facility in Dresden.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OAzE-n6DeFM
18/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Sputtering
17
18
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
19/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Sputtering
Substrate
Gate Metal
• We need uniform deposition over large areas.
https://youtu.be/8mVK5dwyoEY
20/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Sputtering
Substrate
Gate Metal
• We need uniform deposition over large areas.
https://youtu.be/8mVK5dwyoEY
19
20
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
21/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Sputtering
A target material, such as
aluminum, is bombarded with
Argon ions. The displaced atoms of
the target material move across the
Plasma. They are then deposited
on the substrate.
Power Supply
Gas in Gas out
P
Substrate
Aluminum
Target
Argon ion
bombards the
aluminum surface
Sheath
Aluminum
Bulk
Displaced
aluminum
Atoms
Sheath
Bulk
Silicon Wafer
Aluminum atoms deposit on
the wafer and form a film
Aluminum
atom moving
around
22/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Plasmas• So called “4th State of Matter”.
• An ionized gas of electrons and ions:
• Commonly observed in
“neon” signs.
21
22
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
23/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Ionization• A high speed electron hits an atom hard enough to
knock out an electron.
• This forms an ion and another free electron.
• This is an elastic collision.
e- + Ar Ar+ + e- + e-
Neutral Atom (Ar) Ion (Ar+)
High speed
Electron
24/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Molecules: Dissociation• When a molecule undergoes dissociation we can get
two reactive atoms.
• These atoms are called free radicals.
e- + O2 O + O + e-
High speed
Electron
Stable
Molecule
Reactive
Free Radical
23
24
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
25/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Excitation and Relaxation• An electron hits and excites a neutral atom.
Neutral Atom (Ar) Excited Atom (Ar*)
High speed
Electron
en
erg
y
e-
Relaxed Atom (Ar)
Characteristic Light
hν
e- + Ar e- + Ar* e- + Ar + h𝜈
• Which then relaxes and gives light.
• This is what makes a plasma glow.
26/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Glow Discharge
25
26
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
27/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Sputtering• Sputtering can be used to deposit compounds as
well as elements, But the structure would not
necessarily be preserved.
• Hence it is better suited for fully amorphous systems.
Film
C
CC
C
C
C
CC
C
C
Zn
O
Zn
OZn
OZn
O
Zn
OZn
O
O
Zn
Zn
Zn ZnO
Zn
OZn
O
Zn
O
ZnO
ZnOO
Zn
ZnZn
Target
28/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Sputtering• At OSU we use sputtering to deposit metal oxides.
• In particular, metal oxides such as Indium Gallium
Zinc Oxide (IGZO).
27
28
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
29/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Chemical Vapor Deposition
30/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
• Chemical vapor deposition (CVD) is another
deposition technique.
Chemical Vapor Deposition
• As usual, more details can be found in ECE611.
• In its simplest incarnation, CVD involves flowing a precursor gas or gases into a chamber containing one or more heated objects to be coated.
• Chemical reactions occur on and near the hot surfaces, resulting in the deposition of a thin film on the surface.
• This is accompanied by the production of chemical by-products that are exhausted out of the chamber along with unreacted precursor gases.
29
30
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
31/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
CVD vs PVDChemical Vapor DepositionPhysical Vapor Deposition
• Involves a chemical reaction.
• Source material is physically deposited.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8mVK5dwyoEY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j80jsWFm8Lc
32/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Free radicals transport to the surface and grow a film
Chemical Vapor Deposition
Transport to
surface
Film growth
Reactive species
move on surface
Energy
31
32
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
33/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Sources of Activation Energy
Inlet
Outlet
To vacuum
Reaction
chamber
WaferHeated
wall Inlet
Outlet
To vacuum
Reaction
chamber
Electrode
Plasma
Temperature Plasma
34/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Types of CVDAtmospheric Pressure CVD (APCVD)
• Advantages: High deposition rates, simple, high throughput.
• Disadvantages: Poor uniformity, purity is less than LPCVD
• Used mainly for thick oxides.
• E.g.:
𝑆𝑖 𝑂𝐶2𝐻5 4 𝐿 + 𝐶𝐻3 3𝑃𝑂3 𝐿 + 𝐶𝐻3𝑂3 3𝐵(𝐿) →
TEOS TMPOAmmonium
chloride
𝑆𝑖𝑂2: 𝐵2𝑂3, 𝑃2𝑂5 𝑆 + gas products
BPSG (Borophosphosilicate
glass)
33
34
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
35/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Types of CVDLow Pressure CVD (LPCVD at ~0.2 to 20 torr)
• Advantages: Excellent uniformity, purity
• Disadvantages: Lower (but reasonable) deposition rates than APCVD
• Used for polysilicon deposition, dielectric layer deposition, and doped dielectric deposition.
• E.g.:
3𝑆𝑖𝐶𝑙2𝐻2 𝐺 + 10𝑁𝐻3 𝐺 → 𝑆𝑖3𝑁4 𝑆 + 6𝑁𝐻4𝐶𝑙 𝐺 + 6𝐻2(𝐺)
Dichloro-silane
(DCS)Ammonia Silicon nitride Ammonium
chlorideHydrogen
36/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Types of CVDPlasma Enhanced CVD
• Plasmas are used to force reactions that would not be possible at low temperature.
• Advantages: Uses low temperatures necessary for back end processing.
• Disadvantages: Plasma damage typically results.
• Used for dielectrics coatings.
35
36
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
37/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
CVD MechanismRequirements for CVD Growth
• Good thickness uniformity.
• High purity and density.
• Controlled composition and stoichiometries.
• High degree of structural perfection.
• Good electrical properties.
• Excellent adhesion.
• Good step-coverage / conformal coverage.
38/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
CVD MechanismMore Detail:
Reactant
molecule
Carrier gas
(to maintain high
pressure & slow
reaction rate)
1). Bulk
transport
2). Transport
across
boundary layer
𝐽1 ∝ 𝐷𝑔∆𝐶
3). Adsorption
4). Surface diffusion
5). Decomposition
6). Reaction with
film
𝐽2 ∝ 𝑘𝑖𝐶𝑖
7). Diffusion of
gaseous by-
product
8). Bulk transport
of by product
37
38
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
39/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Atomic Layer Deposition
40/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
• Sometimes you need to deposit films with monolayer
precision.
Atomic Layer Deposition
• This doesn’t necessarily mean you need a single layer
of a material, but you do need strong control over
the number of layers.
• E.g. you want 10 monolayers, not between 8 and
10.
• Atomic layer deposition (ALD) is a self-limiting
process that enables the user to have monolayer
control over films.
39
40
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
41/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
• The reaction is designed that occurs in two steps.
Atomic Layer Deposition
• A good example is the growth of Al2O3 (an insulator)
using Al(CH3)3 and H2O:
• Cycle 1:
• Cycle 2:
Al-OH* + Al(CH3)3 → Al-O-Al(CH3)2* +CH4
https://beneq.com/en/technology/ald/
Al-CH3* + CH4+H2O →Al-OH*+CH4
Asterisk =
surface species
https://pubs.acs.org/doi/pdf/10.1021/cm0304546
42/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
• The key point with ALD is that because the growth
must take place via two steps, we cannot get more
than a monolayer every two cycles.
Atomic Layer Deposition
• If the half-monolayer is saturated, then the excess
precursor has no sites left to react with, and hence
will be removed when the chamber is purged.
• This allows us to grow materials layer by layer, albeit
at slow rates.
41
42
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
43/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
• This process is best visualized with video:
Atomic Layer Deposition
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HUsOMnV65jk
44/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
• In general, ALD is of interests for conventional CMOS
microelectronics.
Atomic Layer Deposition
• This is because it is highly effective for conformal
coatings.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4G8wXQGEBrA
43
44
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
45/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
• However, deposition over large areas is possible, and
is an active area of research.
Large-Area ALD
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1631070517300567#fg0020
46/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Spin Coating
45
46
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
47/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Solution Deposition• The great thing about some semiconductors (e.g.
organics) is that many are soluble in certain solvents.
• A bit like polystyrene in acetone:
• Often we have to use other organic solvents.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f4-K5p8ZnWA
48/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Spin-Coating
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ea6gykoPrvk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hJZK5b_Uobc
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9TjCTXcU8qU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=53W_ZWwhnTQ
• Because many organic semiconductors are soluble,
one of the most widely-studied deposition
techniques in laboratories is spin-coating.
47
48
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
49/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Spin-Coating1). Organic semiconductor (in
solvent) is deposited in
center of the substrate.
Substrate is held in place
with vacuum chuck.
2). Substrate is rotated slowly
(200 rpm) to distribute
material.
3). Accelerate the substrate to
final speed (~5000 rpm).
Spin the substrate at
constant speed for 30 -
60s. Forms a uniform film
and evaporates solvent.
50/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Film Thickness• It can be shown (we won’t) that the final film thickness
depends on the spinning speed via:
𝑡 ∝1
𝜔Film
thickness
Angular
velocity
• Actual thickness will also
depend on:
• Concentration.
• Solvent evaporation
rate
• Viscosity.
• Local temperature.
• Local humidity.
49
50
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
51/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Surface Wetting• Surface energy (Jm-2) is very important in growth.
• Energy required to create one unit of surface area.
• Surface energy exists because bonds are broken
to create/increase the surface.
• Surface stress: bonds are elastically strained.
https://www.nature.com/articles/srep44213#f3
52/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Spray Coating
51
52
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
53/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Spray Coating• Spin coating is fine for laboratory testing, but is
clearly not suited for large-area deposition.
• Researchers are interested in developing scalable
techniques such as spray-coating.
Sonotec
• This is still an emerging area of research.
54/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Spray Coating• The motivation is that spray-coating is already
industrially-established.
• Therefore it is potentially easy to scale up for other
applications
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K3rusvc_c7E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wJnJxZfSfKM
53
54
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
55/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Metal Oxide Deposition• As with organics, many metal
oxide semiconductors are
solution-processable.
• One challenge is conversion.
• Most metal oxide solutions are
actually formed of precursors.
• After deposition, they
typically need treatment
(normally thermal) to convert
from a precursor to a
semiconductor.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=crAugJXG3QA
56/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Spray Coating• Currently surface roughness is a lot higher for spray-
coated vs spin-coated films.
Faber et. al., ACS Appl. Mater. & Int. 7 (2015) 782. Labram et. al., Adv. Funct. Mater. 26 (2016) 1656.
Spray Cast In2O3 Spin Cast In2O3
55
56
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
57/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Printing
58/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Printing• Spin-coating is a very simple technique for use in the
laboratory.
• But the goal of thin-film electronics is to one day be
highly-scalable and incredibly cheap.
• For a lot of us, the end goal is printed electronics.
• This is a difficult engineering challenge to solve.
• There are a few different printing technologies:
• Gravure printing.
• Inkjet printing.
• Roll-to-roll printing.
57
58
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
59/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
• Gravure printing is a
simple, physical
deposition method.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wsX6uaKNZ2k
• There are indentations
in a roll, which define
the material pattern.
• Clearly for such an approach the definition of
features is going to be limited by physical features on
the gravure roll.
• The deposition can be
pretty inhomogeneous.Thiburce et. al. Adv. Electon. Mater. (2017) 1600421.
Gravure Printing
60/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Gravure Printing• As can the
performance:
59
60
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
61/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Inkjet Printing• Traditional inkjet printing should be familiar.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5iiJMv-jh7U
62/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Inkjet Printing• Inkjet printing for organic electronics has the same
goals: desktop-printable flexible electronics.
• The research is in early
stages.
• The “coffee-ring” effect
is a notable issue:
Teichler et. al. JMCC. 1 (2013) 1910.
Teichler et. al. JMCC. 1 (2013) 1910.
61
62
Lecture 10 – Monday October 26th 2020
ECE 617 – Fall 2020
63/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Roll-to-Roll Printing• But one of the ultimate goals of printed organic
electronics is to be able to create products using roll-
to-roll printing methods.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zPhDUN5IBZ8
• This remains a long way off commercialization.
64/64
ECE 617 – Thin Film Electronics
Fall 2020 - John Labram
Next Time…• Gate Dielectrics:
63
64