6/26/11
Copyright ©2011 by Moshe Matalon. This material is not to be sold, reproduced or distributed without the prior wri@en permission of the owner, M. Matalon. 1
Lecture 11
Diffusion Flames
The candle flame is a classical example of a diffusion flame.
The flame reaches a steady state almost immediately after a match is broughtup close to the wick, and if the air in the room is sufficiently still, it does littleflickering. The flame basically remains constant in shape and size.
The flame has a distinct structure: a yellow luminous zone, which is responsiblefor most of the light provided by the candle, blue regions on the sides of theflame and near the wick, and a dark cone that starts below the curl of the wick.
The wax first melts due to the heat radiated from the flame to the candle. Asa result a pool of melted wax forms at the top of the candle, and liquid wax isdrawn up the wick by capillary action.
The candle flame
6/26/11
Copyright ©2011 by Moshe Matalon. This material is not to be sold, reproduced or distributed without the prior wri@en permission of the owner, M. Matalon. 2
At a critical temperature the wax molecules break into fragments, which freescarbon atoms that agglomerate into soot particles as they enter the yellow tongueof the flame. There the solid carbon particles become incandescent, which pro-duces the yellowish light.
Chemical reaction occurs only when fuel and oxygen molecules mix and if thetemperature is high enough.
The chemical reaction is extremely fast and occurs on a much shorter timescale than diffusion. Diffusion is rate controlling, which is the reason thatnon-premixed combustion is also referred to as “diffusion flames” .
Most of the burning proceeds in the blue reaction zone and upward on thesurface of the flame, which is where the highest temperatures are reached.
The liquid wax on the wick vaporizes by the heat transported to the wick fromthe surrounding reaction zone (primarily by radiation) and the wax vapor dif-fuses outwards and make contact with the oxygen diffusing in from the sur-rounding air.
1g µg
As a result of natural convection, the heat and combustion products flow up-ward and fresh oxygen from the ambient air is carried toward the flame. Thisgives the flame its elongated tear drop shape.
A candle can burn in µ-gravity conditions with the oxygen supplied solely bydiffusion (NASA TM 106858), and the flame shape is nearly a hemisphere.
6/26/11
Copyright ©2011 by Moshe Matalon. This material is not to be sold, reproduced or distributed without the prior wri@en permission of the owner, M. Matalon. 3
Oxidizer
Fuel
Counterflow diffusion flame
L
d Fuel
Jet diffusion flame
Oxidizer
Liquid fuel drop and Burner-generated
spherical diffusion flame
Fuel
Oxidizer
Fuel vapor
Oxidizer
drop
Diffusion flame configurations commonly studied
The steady planar unstrained flame
P. Monkewitz, EPFL
Diffusion flame
Fuel and Oxidizer are supplied from opposite ends where conditions are main-
tained uniform.
Fuel is supplied in the stream flowing from the bottom of the chamber at a con-stant speed, and oxidizer diffuses inwards from the top boundary. The reverseproblem, in which oxidizer is supplied in the stream and fuel diffuses against it,is readily available by exchanging the roles played by the two reactants.
x
xf
Fuel
Oxidizer
0
m̃
Products
Products
6/26/11
Copyright ©2011 by Moshe Matalon. This material is not to be sold, reproduced or distributed without the prior wri@en permission of the owner, M. Matalon. 4
The chemical reaction is described by a one-step irreversible step
νF F + νO O → Products
The planar steady unstrained flame
for simplicity the temperatures are takento be the same on both supply ends
x = −∞ : T = T̃0, YF = YF 0, YO = 0
x = 0 : T = T̃0, YF = 0, YO = YO1
A steady one-dimensional planar flame in the unlimited space (−∞ < x < ∞) isnot possible. The only solution of the reaction-diffusion equation for YO behindthe flame is a constant, so that the oxidizer cannot be consumed at the reactionzone, as required.
The mass flux m̃ is constant and prescribed.
x
xf
Fuel
Oxidizer
m̃
mdT
dx− d2T
dx2= ω
mdYF
dx− Le−1
F
d2YF
dx2= −ω
mdYO
dx− Le−1
O
d2YO
dx2= −νω
ν = νOWO/νFWF β =E/Rq/cp
Nondimensionalization
The incoming velocity U is used as a unit speed and the Dth/U as a unitlength
The temperature is scaled with respect to Q/cpνFWF , the heat release perunit mass of fuel consumed.
ω = D ρ2YFYOeβ/Ta−β/T
D =(Dth/U2)
[νF (ρ0/WO)B]−1 eE/RT̃a
Here T̃a is the adiabatic temperature (i.e., associated with complete combus-
tion), to be determined, and ˜ denotes dimensional quantities.
6/26/11
Copyright ©2011 by Moshe Matalon. This material is not to be sold, reproduced or distributed without the prior wri@en permission of the owner, M. Matalon. 5
Infinitely-fast chemistry
The Burke-Schumann limit of complete combustion
D → ∞ ⇒ YFYO ∼ 0
D =flow time
reaction time→ ∞
the chemistry is infinitely fast
YFYO ∼ 0 can be satisfied in a diffusion flame if YF vanishes on one side of thereaction sheet, where the oxidizer is being supplied (the oxidizer region) and YO
vanishes on the other side, where the fuel is being supplied (the fuel region).
ω ∼ 0 for x ≶ xf
where xf is the location of the reaction sheet
ω = D ρ2YFYOeβ/Ta−β/T
All variables must be continuous at x = xf , i.e.,
[YF ] = [YO] = [T ] = 0
YF ≡ 0 for x > xf
YO ≡ 0 for x < xf
and in addition
where [ · ] denotes the jump across xf
The jump in the gradients is obtained by adding any two of the equations, inorder to eliminate ω, then integrating across the reaction sheet, from x−
f to x+f .
md
dx(YF − ν−1YO)−
d2
dx2(Le−1
FYF − ν−1Le−1
OYO) = 0
md
dx(T + ν−1YO)−
d2
dx2(T + ν−1Le−1
OYO) = 0
�dT
dx
�= − 1
LeF
�dYF
dx
�= − 1
νLeO
�dYO
dx
�
6/26/11
Copyright ©2011 by Moshe Matalon. This material is not to be sold, reproduced or distributed without the prior wri@en permission of the owner, M. Matalon. 6
�dT
dx
�= − 1
LeF
�dYF
dx
�= − 1
νLeO
�dYO
dx
�[YF ] = [YO] = [T ] = 0Across x = xf :
and
In addition to the BCs, there are 7 conditions at the reaction sheet. Being a6th order system, we have enough conditions for determining the solution andthe reaction sheet location xf .
mdT
dx− d2T
dx2= 0
mdYF
dx− Le−1
F
d2YF
dx2= 0
mdYO
dx− Le−1
O
d2YO
dx2= 0
YF ≡ 0 for x > xf , YO ≡ 0 for x < xf
x = −∞ : T = T0, YF = YF 0, YO = 0
x = 0 : T = T0, YF = 0, YO = YO1
initial mixture strength
It is “like” an equivalence ratio based onthe mass fractions at the BCs.
1
LeF
�dYF
dx
�=
1
νLeO
�dYO
dx
�
φ =YF 0
/νFWF
YO1/νOWO
YF =
YF 0
�1− emLeF (x−xf )
�−∞ < x < xf ,
0 xf < x < 0
YO =
0 −∞ < x < xf ,
YO1
�1− 1− emLeOx
1− emLeOx
�xf < x < 0
xf = − 1
mLeO
ln(1 + φ−1)
Note that the location of the reaction sheet depends on the mixture strengthφ and only on the diffusivity of the oxidizer, which has to diffuse against thestream.
where continuity at xf has been satisfied.
6/26/11
Copyright ©2011 by Moshe Matalon. This material is not to be sold, reproduced or distributed without the prior wri@en permission of the owner, M. Matalon. 7
�dT
dx
�= − 1
LeF
�dYF
dx
�
stoichiometric temperature
The flame temperature and flame sheet location in dimensional form for LeO = 1
xf = −λ/cpm̃
ln
�1 +
YO1/νOWO
YF 0/νFWF
�
Ta = T0 + YF 0− YF 0
�1 + φ−1
�−1/LeO
For LeO = 1, Ta = T0 +YF 0
1 + φ
T̃a = T̃0 +Q/cp
νFWF /YF 0+ νOWO/YO1
T =
T0 + (Ta − T0)em(x−xf ) −∞ < x < xf ,
T0 + (Ta − T0)1− emx
1− emxfxf < x < 0
where continuity at xf has been applied and the common value denoted Ta.
which peaks at stoichiometry
x
YFYO
T
xf
For the solution to be valid, the discontinuity in slopes must be smoothed outin a thin region near xf , i.e., in the reaction zone. We shall discuss this later.
Hence, for φ < 1, or lean systems, γ < 0 and more heat is conducted to the fuel
side, whereas for φ > 1, or rich systems γ > 0 and more heat is transported to
the oxidizer side.
Note that ∆ = −[dT/dx] = QYF 0/cpνFWF which is the total heat released is
not equally conducted to both sides. The excess conducted to one side is
for LeO = 1γ = − 1
∆
�(dT/dx)x−
f− |dT/dx|x+
f
�=
φ− 1
φ+ 1
6/26/11
Copyright ©2011 by Moshe Matalon. This material is not to be sold, reproduced or distributed without the prior wri@en permission of the owner, M. Matalon. 8
The conditions across the reaction zone can be easily generalized to an arbitrarymulti-dimensional surface
[YF ] = [YO] = [T ] = 0
1
Q
�λ∂T
∂n
�= −
�ρD
F
νFWF
∂YF
∂n
�= −
�ρD
O
νOWO
∂YO
∂n
�
in dimensional form
• The temperature and concentrations are continuous at the reaction sheet
• The fuel and oxidizer are completely consumed at the sheet
• The net fluxes to the reaction sheet are diffusive (diffusive flux overcomethe convective flux) and are in stoichiometric proportions
n
Reaction sheetF(x, t) = 0
Fuel
Oxidizer
with [ · ] denoting the jump across the reaction sheet F (x, t) = 0
YO|n=0 = 0YF |n=0 = 0
The Burke-Schumann Problem Burke & Schumann, Ind. Eng. Chem. 1928
Assumptions:
• The flow is in the axial direction everywhere; the velocity field is thus given by v = u ez
• The total mass flux in the axial direction is constant everywhere; this is practically a constant-density assumption intended to uncouple the hydrodynamic from the transport equations
• Axial diffusion is negligible compared to radial diffusion (this can be justified a-posteriori if the flame height is large compared with b ). This assumption implies that
∇2 =∂2
∂z2+
1
r
∂
∂r
�r∂
∂r
�≈ 1
r
∂
∂r
�r∂
∂r
�
z
u
F O O
r a
b
6/26/11
Copyright ©2011 by Moshe Matalon. This material is not to be sold, reproduced or distributed without the prior wri@en permission of the owner, M. Matalon. 9
z
u
F O O
r a
b
• In studying this problem Burke and Schumann introduced the ingenious limit of infinitely fast chemistry, we have discussed earlier.
• The Lewis numbers were assumed equal to one. This assumption is not essential but leads to significant simplification in the mathematical manipulations.
• Gravity effects have been neglected. Indeed, buoyancy forces may cause distortion of the flame. The controlling parameter is the Froude number
Fr = u2/a g representing the ratio of inertial and buoyant forces. Flame heights are controlled by buoyancy when Fr << 1. • The boundary conditions are:
YF = YF 0, YO = 0 at z = 0, 0 < r < a
YF = 0, YO = YO0at z = 0, a < r < b
∂YO
∂r=
∂YF
∂r= 0 at r = b, for z > 0
We write dimensionless equations using b as a unit of the radial distance, and(u/D)b2 a unit of the axial distance, and normalize both YF and Yo with YF 0
.
∂YF
∂z− 1
r
∂
∂r
�r∂YF
∂r
�= −ω
∂YO
∂z− 1
r
∂
∂r
�r∂YO
∂r
�= −νω
where the reaction term has been properly nondimensionalized, and ν = νOWO/νFWF .
YF = 1, YO = 0 at z = 0, 0 < r < c
YF = 0, YO = YO0/YF 0
at z = 0, c < r < 1
∂YO
∂r=
∂YF
∂r= 0 at r = 1, for z > 0
6/26/11
Copyright ©2011 by Moshe Matalon. This material is not to be sold, reproduced or distributed without the prior wri@en permission of the owner, M. Matalon. 10
We will make use of the “coupling function” ψ = YF − ν−1YO before invokingthe fast chemistry limit.
Clearly∂ψ
∂z− 1
r
∂
∂r
�r∂ψ
∂r
�= 0
is valid everywhere, and being a linear equation can be solved by standardtechniques.
ψ = 1 at z = 0, 0 < r < c
ψ = −φ−1 at z = 0, c < r < 1
∂ψ/∂r = 0 at r = 1, for z > 0
The boundary conditions are
where φ =YF 0
/νFWF
YO0/νOWO
is the initial mixture strength.
The solution, using separation of variables, is expressed as a Bessel-Fourier series
ψ(r, z) = A0 +∞�
n=1
AnJ0(λnr) eλ2nz
A0 = (1 + φ−1)c2 − φ−1
An =2(1 + φ−1)c
λnJ20 (λn)
J1(cλn)
where λn are the roots of J1.
The mass fractions can readily available. On the fuel side, YF = ψ, YO = 0,
and on the oxidizer side YO = −νψ, YF = 0.
In the fast chemistry limit, YF = YO = 0 along the reaction sheet, so that ψ = 0,or
A0 +∞�
n=1
AnJ0(λnr) eλ2nz = 0
determines the reaction sheet surface.
6/26/11
Copyright ©2011 by Moshe Matalon. This material is not to be sold, reproduced or distributed without the prior wri@en permission of the owner, M. Matalon. 11
z
u
F O O
r a
b
overventilated underventilated
F (r, z) ≡ A0 +∞�
n=1
AnJ0(λnr) eλ2nz = 0
H = F (0, z) = 0 for the overventilated case
H = F (1, z) = 0 for the underventilated case
Flame height
For example, if we approximate the infinite sumby taking only one term (n = 1),
A0 +A1J0(λ1r) eλ21z ≈ 0
The flame can either extend to the walls of the duct - the underventilated case(that results for larger values of φ), or converges to the axis - the overventilatedcase (that results for lower values of φ).
H ≈ 1
λ21
ln
�2(1 + φ)c J1(cλ1)
[1− (1 + φ)c2]λ1J0(cλ1)
�
the height of an underventilated flame.
The counterflow diffusion flame
A planar diffusion flame can be established with a reaction-sheet located at adistance x = xf , on one or the other side of the stagnation plane. The flame,however, is strained.
x =xf
YF =YF-!
YO = 0
T=T!
y
YF =0
YO =YO!
T=T!
YF = YF0YF = 0
YO = YO0YO = 0T = T0T = T0
A stream of gas containing fuel with mass fraction YF−∞ impinges against an-other stream of gas containing an oxidizer with mass fraction YO∞ , forming astagnation-point at the origin
6/26/11
Copyright ©2011 by Moshe Matalon. This material is not to be sold, reproduced or distributed without the prior wri@en permission of the owner, M. Matalon. 12
The incoming flow is given by
{u, v} = {−2εx , 2εy}
with ε the strain rate (with units 1/s).
This is the potential flow solution near a stagnation point flow,valid if the velocity of the incoming streams is sufficiently large.
x =xf
YF =YF-!
YO = 0
T=T!
y
YF =0
YO =YO!
T=T!
x
For simplicity, we will assume that the flow remains unperturbed by the presenceof the flame, which is formally obtained by assuming that the density of themixture remains constant.
Density variations can be taken into accountwithout much difficulty by introducing adensity-weighted axial coordinate,
x̂ =
� x
0ρdx
Viscous effect may also be taken into consideration
by replacing u = −2εx with u = −2εf(x),a function obtained numerically as the solution of
a nonlinear ODE.
To write dimensionless equations, we chose (Dth/ε)1/2 as a unit of length, and
normalize the temperature with respect to the heat release (per unit mass offuel consumed) Q/cpνFWF .
2xdYF
dx+ Le−1
F
d2YF
dx2= ω
2xdYO
dx+ Le−1
O
d2YO
dx2= νω
2xdT
dx+
d2T
dx2= −ω,
YF = YF0, YO = 0, T = T0 as x → −∞
YF = 0, YO = YO0, T = T0 as x → ∞.
ω = DYFYOeβ/Ta−β/T
ν = νOWO/νFWF β =E/Rq/cp
D =ε−1eE/RT̃a
[νF (ρ0/WO)B]−1
6/26/11
Copyright ©2011 by Moshe Matalon. This material is not to be sold, reproduced or distributed without the prior wri@en permission of the owner, M. Matalon. 13
Frozen limit, D → 0
2xdYF
dx+ Le−1
F
d2YF
dx2= 0
2xdYO
dx+ Le−1
O
d2YO
dx2= 0
2xdT
dx+
d2T
dx2= 0
YF = YF0, YO = 0, T = T0 as x → −∞
YF = 0, YO = YO0, T = T0 as x → ∞.
The solution illustrates pure mixing between the two streams
computed for equal Lewis numbers
x
T = T∞
YO = 12YO0
�1 + erf(
�Le
Ox)�
YF = 12YF 0
�1− erf(
�LeF x)
�
Infinitely fast chemistry, D → ∞
YF =
YF 0
�1−
1 + erf(�LeF x)
1 + erf(�
LeF xf )
�(x < xf )
0 (x > xf )
YO =
0 (x < xf )
YO0
�1−
erf(�Le
Ox)− 1
erf(�Le
Oxf )− 1
�(x > xf )
1 + erf(�Le
Fxf )
1− erf(�
LeOxf )
− φ
�Le
O
LeF
e(LeO−Le
F)x2
f = 0
where φ =YF 0
/νFWF
YO0/νOWO
is the initial mixture strength.
the location of the reaction sheet is determined from
solving the equations and using the jump conditions across xf yields
6/26/11
Copyright ©2011 by Moshe Matalon. This material is not to be sold, reproduced or distributed without the prior wri@en permission of the owner, M. Matalon. 14
If we assume that LeF= Le
O= Le; i.e., retaining differential diffusion between
heat and mass while ignoring preferential diffusion between species, an explicitexpression results for xf
erf(√Lexf ) =
φ− 1
φ+ 1
0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1 1.25 1.5 1.75 2 2.25 2.5 2.75 3
-1
-0.5
0.5
1
xf
the variations caused bychanging Le are relatively small
If fuel and oxidizer are supplied in stoichiometric proportions, φ = 1 the reactionsheet will locate along the stagnation surface, i.e., xf = 0. It will be located onthe fuel side (xf < 0) for a “lean” system and on the oxidizer side (xf > 0) fora “rich” system.
Le = 1 ν = 4
0.3
0.6
0.8
6/26/11
Copyright ©2011 by Moshe Matalon. This material is not to be sold, reproduced or distributed without the prior wri@en permission of the owner, M. Matalon. 15
We can also solve for the temperature
T =
T0 + (Tf − T0)1 + erf(x)
1 + erf(xf )(x < xf )
T0 + (Tf − T0)1− erf(x)
1− erf(xf )(x > xf )
and with the remaining jump condition of the temperature gradients, determinethe flame temperature Tf . The expression is cumbersome, but for Le = 1simplifies to
Tf = To +YF 0
1 + φ
referred to, earlier, as the adiabatic temperature.
Flam
e Te
mpe
ratu
re
Damköhler number D
Tf
Dext
BS limit Ta
Dign
T0
Recall that D ∼ ε−1, so that increasing the strain rate results in decreasing D.
Frozen limit