Lecture 8: The Death of Stars White Dwarfs, Neutron Stars, and Black
Holes
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! “the time a star is fusing hydrogen into helium in its core”
! stars spend most of their time in this stage ! main-sequence stars in equilibrium
" Gravity vs pressures in balance
Elizabeth Charlton, 2015
Elizabeth Charlton, 2015
! amount of time depends on mass ! more massive stars
! Higher temperature and pressure in core ! Fusion reaction proceeds very rapidly ! Short life span
! low mass stars ! Fusion proceeds very slowly ! Long life span
Elizabeth Charlton, 2015
! Star like our Sun (1 M๏) " ~10 billion years
! Higher mass star (2 M๏) " ~ 1 billion years
! Very high mass star (30 M๏) " ~3 million years
Elizabeth Charlton, 2015
! main-sequence lifetime - " fusing hydrogen into helium in its core
! Eventually runs out of hydrogen in core
"Star types" by Estrellatipos.png: The original uploader was Xenoforme at Spanish Wikipediaderivative work: Begoon - This file was derived from:Estrellatipos.png. Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 via Wikimedia Commons - http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Star_types.svg#mediaviewer/File:Star_types.svg
Elizabeth Charlton, 2015
! Luckily H-He fusion isn’t the only type of fusion ! He -> heavier elements
! Process called “nucleosynthesis”
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! As each element, “runs out” " Radiative pressure drops " Core collapses " Temp and density increases " Next type of fusion becomes possible
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! What type of fusion occurs and how long depends on mass
! During these transitions, star not in equilibrium " Expansion or contraction " Surface cools or heats
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
NASA/CXC/SAO
! Masses less than 0.5M๏" Stars are entirely convective " Core never reaches temperature to required for helium
fusion " Slow collapse into white dwarf
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! We can track the changes in size and luminosity by a changing position on HR diagram
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! masses between 0.5 -10 M๏ " Red Giant Phase
! Star unstable ! H shell burning around contracting core ! Outer layers expand, surface cools ! Core continues to contract and heat until …
HELIUM IGNITION at 100,000,000 K
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! Once helium fusion is exhausted in core (C, O core) " Second red giant phase (asymptotic giant phase)
! Core contracts and heats ! He and H burning shells ignite around core ! Star expands and surface cools ! Temperature for next fusion stage is never reached
! Star ejects outer layers
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! masses more than 10M๏ " Form red supergiants " Massive enough to
continue heavier element fusion
" Fusion continues until Fe-56 ! Now fusion consumes
energy
! Core Collapse "Evolved star fusion shells" by User:Rursus - R. J. Hall. Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 2.5 via Wikimedia Commons - http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Evolved_star_fusion_shells.svg#mediaviewer/File:Evolved_star_fusion_shells.svg
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! Masses above 40M๏ " Mass loss due to stellar winds " Cannot expand to red supergiant " Will remain extremely hot and luminous on HR diagram " Heavier metal fusion continues to Fe-56
! Core Collapse
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
NASA/CXC/SAO
! Eventually the star can not continue fusion " Low mass verses high mass
! Once fusion stops … " Star “dies”
" But what happens to material?
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! The ejected layer of gas from the outside of the low mass star
! Glows due to heat and light of the remaining core
! Shape forms as the gas expands away from star
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
"NGC6543". Licensed under Public domain via Wikimedia Commons - http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:NGC6543.jpg#mediaviewer/File:NGC6543.jpg
"Ngc2392" by NASA, ESA, Andrew Fruchter (STScI), and the ERO team (STScI + ST-ECF) - http://www.spacetelescope.org/images/html/heic9910a.html. Licensed under Public domain via Wikimedia Commons - http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Ngc2392.jpg#mediaviewer/File:Ngc2392.jpg
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! The core of the star remains
! No fusion though, so it isn’t a star " No radiation pressure " Core collapses " Very hot and dense
! Called a “remnant”
! White dwarf - “a dense remnant of a star which shines due to residual heat”
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! remaining core is very dense ! supported against gravity via electron degeneracy
pressure ! mass around 1 M๏! radius around 1 earth radius (1/100 R๏) ! density > 1 million times sun's density
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! “a collapsed star that has cooled to the point where it emits little or no visible radiation”
! all white dwarfs will become black dwarfs after cooling down for enough time
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! White dwarfs aren’t the only type that form
! Type depends on mass
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! (Exact boundaries are uncertain) ! white dwarf – initial star < 8-10 M๏! neutron star – initial star < 15 M๏! black hole – initial star >15 M๏
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! after giant stages, star changing very rapidly " fusion ceases " eventually equilibrium completely breaks down
! first get fast core collapse ! then get a supernova explosion as a reaction
" “bounce”
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! “a very bright explosion marking the end of some star's evolution”
! outer layers thrown off into space ! sends out heavier elements that were generated in
the star and in the explosion
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
"SN1994D" by NASA/ESA, The Hubble Key Project Team and The High-Z Supernova Search Team - http://www.spacetelescope.org/images/html/opo9919i.html. Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 via Wikimedia Commons - http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:SN1994D.jpg#mediaviewer/File:SN1994D.jpg Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! After the supernova explosion…
! Gas is thrown out into space
! Often violent and chaotic
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
"Crab Nebula" by NASA, ESA, J. Hester and A. Loll (Arizona State University) - HubbleSite: gallery, release.. Licensed under Public domain via Wikimedia Commons - http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Crab_Nebula.jpg#mediaviewer/File:Crab_Nebula.jpg Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! Production of heavy elements in supernova explosions
! First advanced by Fred Hoyle in 1954 ! Iron 56 is the last element that causes a net release
of energy by nuclear fusion exothermically ! Core collapse supernova produce heavy elements
through endothermic fusion processes. ! Type II Supernova explosion releases neutrons
" synthesizes heavy elements via neutron-capture method called the r-process
" lasts about 1s inside star as shockwave passes
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! The cores of the some higher mass stars survive the supernova explosion " Depends on mass and metallicity of star " Pair-instability supernovas can entirely destroy the core
! Becomes either a neutron star or black hole
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! “a very dense, compact star composed primarily of neutrons”
! after supernova core mass is still high ! core is compressed even more than white dwarf ! atoms break down and leave only dense neutrons ! supported against gravity via quantum degeneracy
pressure
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! Predicted by theory ! Then observed as
pulsars
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
" So dense that a teaspoon full weighs about 100 million tons
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! the most massive stars will form black holes ! “an object whose gravitational attraction is so strong
that its escape velocity equals the speed of light” ! even light can not escape once it falls in
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! Classical vs. Modern Description " Black holes have “no hair”
! classical description ! can only observe mass, angular momentum, and charge
" Hawking radiation ! quantum mechanical description ! radiate as blackbodies
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
! So dense …
! We don’t really know how compact the material is or what it is like
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
NASA/CXC/SAO
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
By cmglee, NASA Goddard Space Flight Center - File:star_life_cycles_red_dwarf.jpg, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=39174476
! Gravity can pull on light ! Will only be noticed if gravity is very strong
! …Like a black hole…
! Can bend light from stars in the background
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016
Elizabeth Charlton, 2016