of 28
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
1/28
WEEK 7 LECTURE 9
Capital Structure Policy
1
Financial Management 1
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
2/28
Capital Restructuring
We are going to loo! at "o# c"anges in capitalstructure a$$ect t"e %alue o$ t"e $irm& all else equal
Capital restructuring in%ol%es c"anging t"e amounto$ le%erage a $irm "as #it"out c"anging t"e $irm's
assets T"e $irm can increase le%erage (y issuing )e(t
an) repurc"asing outstan)ing s"ares
T"e $irm can )ecrease le%erage (y issuing ne#
s"ares an) retiring outstan)ing )e(t
1*+,
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
3/28
C"oosing a Capital Structure
W"at is t"e primary goal o$ $inancial managers-
. Ma/imi0e stoc!"ol)er #ealt"
We #ant to c"oose t"e capital structure t"at #ill
ma/imi0e stoc!"ol)er #ealt" We can ma/imi0e stoc!"ol)er #ealt" (y
ma/imi0ing t"e %alue o$ t"e $irm or minimi0ing t"eWCC
2ptimal 3target4 capital structure . )e(t+to+e5uityratio t"at results in lo#est WCC6
1*+
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
4/28
Capital Structure T"eory
Mo)igliani an) Miller 3M8M4 T"eory o$ CapitalStructure
. Proposition . $irm %alue
. Proposition . WCC
T"e %alue o$ t"e $irm is )etermine) (y t"e cas"$lo#s to t"e $irm an) t"e ris! o$ t"e assets
C"anging $irm %alue )ue to:
. C"ange t"e ris! o$ t"e cas" $lo#s. C"ange t"e cas" $lo#s
1*+;
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
5/28
Capital Structure T"eory Un)erT"ree Special Cases
Case
.
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
6/28
Case . Propositions an)
Proposition . T"e %alue o$ t"e $irm is
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
7/28
Case . Proposition E5uations
WCC @ R1@ 3EAB4RE 3DAB4RD
Rearranging t"e a(o%e gi%es
RE@ R1 3R1. RD43DAE4
. R1is t"e cost o$ t"e $irm's business risk& i6e6&
t"e ris! o$ t"e $irm's assets
. 3R1 . RD43DAE4 is t"e cost o$ t"e $irm's
financial risk& i6e6& t"e a))itional returnre5uire) (y stoc!"ol)ers to compensate $or t"eris! o$ le%erage
1*+7
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
8/28
Figure 1*6
1*+G
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
9/28
Case + E/ample
Data. Re5uire) return on assets @ 1*H? cost o$ )e(t @ 1IH?
percent o$ )e(t @ ;>H
W"at is t"e cost o$ e5uity-
. RE@ 1* 31* + 1I436;>A6>>4 @ ,I691H Suppose instea) t"at t"e cost o$ e5uity is ,>H& #"at
is t"e )e(t+to+e5uity ratio-. ,> @ 1* 31* + 1I43DAE4
. DAE @ 3,> + 1*4 A 31* + 1I4 @ A, @16>
=ase) on t"is in$ormation& #"at is t"e percent o$e5uity in t"e $irm-. EAB @ , A > @ ;IH
1*+9
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
10/28
T"e CPM& t"e SML an)Proposition
Jo# )oes $inancial le%erage a$$ect systematicris!-
CPM: R1@ R$ 13RM. R$4
. W"ere is t"e $irm's asset (eta an) measures t"esystematic ris! o$ t"e $irm's assets
Proposition . RE@ R 3R. RD43DAE4
Replace R#it" t"e CPM a(o%e an) assume t"at t"e)e(t is ris!less 3RD@ R$4 gi%es
RE@ R$ 131DAE43RM. R$4
1*+1I
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
11/28
=usiness Ris! an)Financial Ris!
RE@ R$ 31DAE43RM. R$4
CPM: RE@ R$ E3RM. R$4
E= A(1 + D/E)
T"ere$ore& t"e systematic ris! o$ t"e stoc!)epen)s on:
. Systematic ris! o$ t"e assets& 3(usiness ris!4. Le%el o$ le%erage& DAE 3$inancial ris!4
RE increases #"en $inancial le%erage increases
#"ile t"e (usiness ris! Rremain unc"ange)6
1*+11
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
12/28
Case . Cas" Flo#
nterest is ta/ )e)ucti(le
T"ere$ore& #"en a $irm a))s )e(t& it re)ucesta/es& all else e5ual
T"e re)uction in ta/es increases t"e cas" $lo# o$t"e $irm . a))e) (ene$it o$ )e(t $inancing6
Jo# s"oul) an increase in cas" $lo#s a$$ect t"e%alue o$ t"e $irm-
1*+1,
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
13/28
Case + E/ample
Unlevered Firm Levered Firm
EBIT 1&III 1&III
Ineres I GITa!ableInc"me
1&III 9,I
Ta!es (#$%) II ,7*
&e Inc"me 7II *;;
'as Fl"Fr"m Asses
7II 7,;
1*+1
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
14/28
nterest Ta/ S"iel)
nnual interest ta/ s"iel). Ta/ rate times interest payment
. 1&III in GH )e(t @ GI in interest e/pense
.nnual ta/ s"iel) @ 6I3GI4 @ ,;
Present %alue o$ annual interest ta/ s"iel)
.ssume perpetual )e(t $or simplicity
. PB @ ,; A 6IG @ II
. PB @ D3RD43TC4 A RD@ DTC@ 1&III36I4 @ II
1*+1;
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
15/28
Case . Proposition
T"e %alue o$ t"e $irm increases (y t"e present%alue o$ t"e annual interest ta/ s"iel)
. Balue o$ a le%ere) $irm @ %alue o$ an unle%ere)$irm PB o$ interest ta/ s"iel)
. Balue o$ e5uity @ Balue o$ t"e le%ere) $irm .Balue o$ )e(t
ssuming perpetual cas" $lo#s
. BU@ E=T31+T4 A RU
. BL@ BU DTC
1*+1>
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
16/28
E/ample: Case . Proposition
Data
. E=T @ 1&III? Ta/ rate @ IH? De(t @ 1&III?Cost o$ )e(t @ GH? Unle%ere) cost o$ capital @1IH
BU@ 1&III31+6I4 A 61I @ 7&III
BL@ BUDTC@ 7&III 3I6I / 1&III4 @
7&II E @ 7&II + 1&III @ *&II
1*+1*
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
17/28
Figure 1*6;
1*+17
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
18/28
Case . Proposition
T"e WCC )ecreases as DAE increases (ecause o$t"e go%ernment su(si)y on interest payments
. R1@ 3EAB4RE 3DAB43RD431 . TC4
. RE@ RU 3RU. RD43DAE431 . TC4
E/ample. RE@ 1I 31I+G431&IIIA*&II431 .6I4 @ 1$*%
E is ta!en $rom t"e %alue o$ e5uity un)erproposition
. R1@ 3*&IIA7&II431I6,,4 31&IIIA7&II43G431 . 6I4
R1@ ,*-%
WAo )e(t& WCC @ 1IH? WA )e(t& WCC @ 96*H1*+1G
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
19/28
E/ample: Case .Proposition
Suppose t"at t"e $irm c"anges its capital structure sot"at t"e )e(t+to+e5uity ratio (ecomes 16
W"at #ill "appen to t"e cost o$ e5uity un)er t"e ne#capital structure-
. RE@ RU 3RU. RD43DAE431 . TC4
. RE@ 1I 31I . G431431 . 6I4 @ 11*.%
W"at #ill "appen to t"e #eig"te) a%erage cost o$capital-
. R@ 3EAB4RE 3DAB43RD431 . TC4
. R@ 6>3116;4 6>3G431 . 6I4 @ *0%
T"e amount o$ le%erage in t"e $irm increase)& so t"ecost o$ e5uity increase)6 =ut& t"e o%erall cost o$ capital
)ecrease)6 1*+19
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
20/28
Figure 1*6>
1*+,I
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
21/28
Case
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
22/28
=an!ruptcy Costs
Direct costs. Legal an) a)ministrati%e costs
. Ultimately cause (on)"ol)ers to incur a))itionallosses
. Disincenti%e to )e(t $inancing Financial )istress
. Signi$icant pro(lems in meeting )e(t o(ligations
. Firms t"at e/perience $inancial )istress )o not
necessarily $ile $or (an!ruptcy. Cost o$ a%oi)ing $ile $or (an!ruptcy : in)irect
(an!ruptcy cost A $inancial )istress cost
1*+,,
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
23/28
More =an!ruptcy Costs
n)irect (an!ruptcy costs
. Larger t"an )irect costs& (ut more )i$$icult tomeasure an) estimate
. Stoc!"ol)ers #ant to a%oi) a $ormal (an!ruptcy $iling
. =on)"ol)ers #ant to !eep e/isting assets intact so
t"ey can at least recei%e t"at money.ssets lose %alue as management spen)s time
#orrying a(out a%oi)ing (an!ruptcy instea) o$running t"e (usiness
. T"e $irm may also lose sales& e/perience interrupte)operations an) lose %alua(le employees
1*+,
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
24/28
Figure 1*6*
1*+,;
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
25/28
Figure 1*67
1*+,>
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
26/28
Conclusions
Case . no ta/es or (an!ruptcy costs.
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
27/28
Figure 1*6G
1*+,7
8/9/2019 Lecture_9_-_BA205.pptx
28/28
Step"en 6R& Ran)olp" W6W& =ra)$or) D6N6&
Lim& N6 an) Tan& R6 3,I1,46 Fun)amentals o$Corporate Finance& McOra# Jill6
1*+,G