1
Legal and Tax Innovations onFrench Financial Markets for
Russian Investors
Legal and Tax Innovations onFrench Financial Markets for
Russian Investors
Moscow, December 9th, 2010
Radisson, Moscow
2
Table of contents
1. Legal innovations in France
2. Tax innovations in France
3
1. Legal innovations1. Legal innovations
4
1. Legal innovations in France1. Legal innovations in France
French Financial markets : an attractive offer
Suitable solutions
NYSE Euronext Paris (focus on Professional compartment)
Alternext
Marché libre
1. Legal innovations in France – Parallels betweenFrance and Russia
1. Legal innovations in France – Parallels betweenFrance and Russia
Main Russian Stock-exchange Structures:
RTS
RTS Classica Market
RTS Standard
Futures & Options on RTS (FORTS)
MICEX (The Moscow Interbank Currency Exchange)
6
1. Legal innovations in France1. Legal innovations in France
French Financial Markets : High level of protection
AMF enforcement powers increased
Short selling under scrutiny
1. Legal innovations in France – Parallels betweenFrance and Russia
1. Legal innovations in France – Parallels betweenFrance and Russia
Regulation of Russian Financial Market
Powers of FSFR
Initiation of laws
Adoption of regulatory acts
Monitoring and supervision
Sanctions
8
1. Legal innovations in France1. Legal innovations in France
Modernisation of French Corporate Law :
No obligation to translate in French and to register Foreigncompanies’ by-laws
Modernized regime of preferred shares
Buy-back programs ; Liquidity agreements ; Redeemable bonds
Transparency on major holdings
1. Legal innovations in France – Parallels betweenFrance and Russia
1. Legal innovations in France – Parallels betweenFrance and Russia
Evolution of Russian Corporate Law
On-going modernization
Project on revision of Russian Civil Code
Restriction on the use of insider information
Liberalization of anti-monopoly regulations on financial markets
Enhancement of transparency obligation
10
2. Tax innovations2. Tax innovations
11Company headquarters, special taxes onfinancial markets, listed REIT…
Company headquarters, special taxes onfinancial markets, listed REIT…
Extension of the special tax regime for company headquarters tofinancial services groups
Elimination of the contribution des institutions financières (special taxon financial institutions) and suppression of the stock-market tax fornon-resident investors
Reforms of the tax regime of listed real-estate companies and of thelevy on non-resident capital gains on immovable properties
12
New impatriate tax regimeNew impatriate tax regime
Main feature of France impatriate tax regime :
- strict conditions to be fulfilled
- limited income tax exemption
New regime applicable from January 1st 2008 much more attractive :
- scope extended to new categories of impatriates
- income tax exemption boosted with a 50 % tax break on foreignsourced passive income
- wealth tax exemption introduced
France impatriates tax regime now one of the most competitive inEurope
13
Russian taxation issuesRussian taxation issues
Low duties on issue of securities
• State duties of issue of securities by Russian issuer – 0,2% of securities nominalvalue, but capped at RUB 200,000 (around EUR 4,800)
• Authorisation for placement of securities on foreign markets – RUB 20,000
Taxation of non-Russian source income
• Income received by a Russian company from foreign sources must be fully declaredas taxable income in Russia. Special rules of the determination of the tax base forsecurities, futures, pension funds…
• Tax paid abroad can be offset when paying tax in Russia
• Offset is available upon presentation by the taxpayer of the certificate issued by aforeign entity which whithheld tax or by foreign tax athorities if tax was paid by thetaxpayer itself
14
Dividends paid to Pension FundsDividends paid to Pension Funds
Conseil d’Etat, 13 February 2009, Stichting Unilever PensioenfondPensioenfonds Progress case : the French administrative supreme courtfound that the principle of free movement of capital bars France from levyinga withholding tax on dividends paid to Dutch pension funds that would beexempt if they were established in France
New provisions introduced in FTC as of January 1, 2010 :• Dividends paid to EU not-for-profit pension funds (and those established in Norway and Iceland) are now subject to
a withholding tax at the rate of 15%, similar to the tax that is now applicable to their French equivalents
• The 15% rate assumes that the foreign entity would be entitled to the same rate if it had its seat in France
• Administrative guidelines of January 15, 2010 allow pension funds to claim back the refund of WHT paid fromJanuary 1st, 2006
Reduction of withholding tax in application of Russian-French Double Taxtreaty of November 26th 1996 :
• The 15% rate can be reduced to 5% if investment not less than EUR 76,225 (FFr 500,000) and if the recipient issubject to profit tax in Russia but enjoys the parent subsidiary favorable tax regime; or to10% if only one of theabove conditions is met
15
Dividends paid to investment fundsDividends paid to investment funds
European Commission, 18 march 2010 : reasoned opinion send torequire that France change its tax rules which discriminate againstforeign pension and investment funds and are therfore considered toinfringe the free movement of capital, as set out in the EU Treaty.
Administrative court of Montreuil, 3 december 2010 : does theprinciple of movement of capital also bars France from applying awithholding tax on dividends paid to non-resident investment funds,whether based in EU on non-EU countries, that would be exempt ifthey were established in France ? Case referred to the Frenchsupreme court. Preeliminary ruling expected by the end of the 2011Q1.
16
Taxation of dividends in RussiaTaxation of dividends in Russia
General regime• Dividends received by a Russian company from a foreign legal entity are taxed at a flat rate of 9%.
• Offset of tax withheld in France
Parent subsidiary regime :• the recipient of dividends owns at least 50% of the payer of dividends’ capital, or owns depository
receipts entitling it to receive at least 50% of the amount of paid dividends;
• the share or depository receipts have been owned for at least 365 days on the day dividends aredeclared;
• the value of the investment is at least RUR 500,000,000 (approx. EUR 12 million). This condition iseliminated as of January 1st 2011.
17
Contact detailsContact details
Maxim BoulbaMaxim Boulba –– Partner, Corporate department, CMS, RussiaPartner, Corporate department, CMS, Russia
DDial: +7 495 786 40 23
Email: [email protected]
Stanislav TourbanovStanislav Tourbanov –– Partner, Tax department, CMS, RussiaPartner, Tax department, CMS, Russia
DDial: +7 495 786 30 74
Email: [email protected]
Stephane AustryStephane Austry –– Partner, Tax department, CMS Bureau Francis LefebvrePartner, Tax department, CMS Bureau Francis Lefebvre
DDial: +33.1.47.38.38.59
Email: [email protected]
Bruno ZabalaBruno Zabala –– Of counsel, Banking & Finance, CMS Bureau Francis LefebvreOf counsel, Banking & Finance, CMS Bureau Francis Lefebvre
DDial: +33.1.47.38. 43.93
Email: [email protected]