Leveson Report part 3

7/30/2019 Leveson Report part 3

1/491

The

Leveson

Inquiry

culture, practices and

ethics of the press

AN INQUIRY INTO THE CULTURE,

PRACTICES AND ETHICS OF THE

PRESS

REPORT

The Right Honourable Lord Justice Leveson

November 2012

4 volumes not to be sold separately

Volume III


2/491

AN INQUIRY INTO THE CULTURE,

PRACTICES AND ETHICS OF THE PRESS

The Right Honourable Lord Justice Leveson

November 2012

Volume III

Presented to Parliament pursuant to Section 26 of the Inquiries Act 2005

Ordered by the House of Commons to be printed on 29 November 2012

HC 780-III London: The Stationery Office 250.00

4 volumes not to be sold separately


3/491

Crown copyright 2012

You may re-use this information (excluding logos) free of charge in any format or

medium, under the terms of the Open Government Licence. To view this licence,

visit http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/ or

e-mail: [email protected].

Where we have identified any third party copyright information you will need toobtain permission from the copyright holders concerned.

Any enquiries regarding this publication should be sent to us at

[email protected]

This publication is available for download at www.official-documents.gov.uk

ISBN: 9780102981063

Printed in the UK by The Stationery Office Limited

on behalf of the Controller of Her Majestys Stationery Office

ID P002525215 11/12 22930 19585

Printed on paper containing 75% recycled fibre content minimum.


4/491

i

CONTENTS

Volume IPage

PART A: THE INQUIRY 1Chapter 1: The Announcement 3

/

2 Role of the Assessors 6

s

Chapter 2: The approach 10

^

d

K

^

Chapter 3: Further issues of law 38

Z/Z

Z/Z

d

Chapter 4: The Report 49 ^

W

d

PART B: THE PRESS AND THE PUBLIC INTEREST 53

/

Chapter 2: The freedom of the press and democracy 56

h


5/491

ii

The Leveson Inquiry

d

W

W

PART C: THE PRESS 91

Chapter 1: Context 93

/

d

/

E

E> E^D'>

dD

ddD'

d'D'

d/'

d&d

d

D

/

dttt

^

K

W

Chapter 4: Plurality 180

t

dh


6/491

iii

Contents

PART D: STANDARDS 193

d

/

dZW

dZz

dZ

dZ^Y

dZ^Y

dWt

^

/

dW

W&

PART E: CROSSING LEGAL BOUNDARIES:d,Z/D/E>E/s/>>t

d W

KZ

K'

KD

/

dKD

d

WKD WWZ

WK

/

d

d

d

^

W


7/491

The Leveson Inquiry

dEt

:d'

^dEzd

d'

d

W^

W/Ktd

dD^

Volume II

PART F: THE CULTURE, PRACTICES AND ETHICS OF THE PRESS:

THE PRESS AND THE PUBLIC /

K

DKdZ

DK/

dW&Z

'

dh


8/491

Contents

dZ,'DW

,'

^

ZZ

/

>

h

,

/

d

Z

/ &

d

/

W

d

d/

WZd'd,WZ^^Ed,WK>/d,Z>d/KE^,/W

W

/

d

d

d,Z

DW^ K

W

WW

/

d

d

d


9/491

The Leveson Inquiry

d

/W/W

,D/t&&

&DW

WKWK

d

/

d

/

K

>

'

D

Volume III

WZd,d,WZ^^EdWZKdd/KE

/

d/K KD

d

d/K

dW

4 What Price Privacy?d

What Price Privacy?dW

K

d

KD

Chapter 4: The ICO and the press today 1054

/

W

&KD


10/491

Contents

&

W/K

/

d/K

d/K

d

d

/

W/K

^Z

PART I: THE PRESS AND POLITICIANS 1115

/

d

WDd

WDD

E>

d

d

WD

WD

W

d

/

D>K

WD

Z

Chapter 5: Media policy: examples from recent history 1233 Wddd^d

Z^Y

,Z

W

Dd^

/

d


11/491

The Leveson Inquiry

:dZ,sDW

/^

:dZ,:,

D^

EZ,^D^W

&

/

dWDZ,EDW

d>KZ,DDW

d&D^Z,^D^W

dZ,

t

t

Volume IVPART J : ASPECTS OF REGULATION: THE LAW AND THEWZ^^KDW>/Ed^KDD/^^/KE

/

Chapter 2: The criminal law 1480

/

d

d/

W


12/491

Contents

W

W

W

d

d

/

>

d

dW

/

tW

/

d

dW

^W

/

PART K: REGULATORY MODELS FOR THE FUTURE 1581

/

&

/

W

dWW&

/

d

'

^

W

&

d


13/491

The Leveson Inquiry

d/&

/

WW&

/

&

/

W

ZWW&

^

K/

/

&

^

/

^

^

d

Z ^

d

W

W

/

dW/WK

K

ZE

d

/

Z

Z


14/491

Contents

/

K

s

'

^

d

d

d

t

t ,

d

D

Z

/

Z

PART L: SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATIONS 1801

APPENDICES 1819

//d

^

t/

>

W/


15/491

997

PART H

THE PRESS AND DATAPROTECTION

H


16/491

999

H

CHAPTER 1

INTRODUCTION

1. Background

1.1 dZ

/

WW

Z

1.2 dh


17/491

WZd, dWW

H

2Z/K

,

,

1.6

/K

1.7 Z/

WW d

&

&

/KdZ

/KW

/K

W/

Z

1.8 ,dZ

/Z/ 3/

/

/

Z

/d

WZ/

2. The ICO: structure, governance and approach

2.1 d/,DdY

'

,W,

2 W3 /

K

D/

d


18/491

/

H

W>D:

KK

Zd,

t

d

&

2.2 Dd

partly a regulator, partly an ombudsman, partly an

educator and partly a policy adviser

but not limited to

5

d/Kprimarilynotd

d

d

d

WW

W

Dd/K

7

2.3 Dd/K

, W

/K

,

/

,

Zd

d

D,

5Zd ibidZd ibid

DdW

&t^Z

d

7Zd

d

,

tDZYE/Dd

Zd

d

,


19/491

WZd, dWW

H

2.4 &/K

d

d

/K/

d

d/

/K


20/491

1003

H

CHAPTER 2

OPERATION MOTORMAN

d

1.1 d K D 1 and does

tK 2KZ

d

/K/K

1.2 , ^t

s>

/Kt

D

d

1.3 D K &

^

d

&DK

DtD

K

3

t

1 W2 DK/K

/,

W

t^K

3

t^K

pdf


21/491

1004

WZd, dWW

H

/

1.4 DK D d D

d

/

/K

/

/K

1.5 d/KDKD

W

Dt

/

4

,

d

1.6 tKDD

DdKD,

,

1.7 D

/KD

KD

D

D t

/

KDD

6,

4K

d

D,

&

d

D,

6&


22/491

KD

H

d

7

Y / / D

KD/

/

Dd W

^D

d

t/

1.8 d

,

8

/KD

//

/

K//

1.9 D /K ,

9

D

t

D

10

//E

/

/

1.10

D

DDd

&

11D

d

DK 12,

13

7& 8

t^&

9K

d

D,

10&

dD

,

11Zd

d

D,

12

&t^

Zd

13

&t^Z

d/DdW


23/491

1006

WZd, dWW

H

/

KD d

1.11 dDdD

14

,

^/

1.12 ^Dd

/K

d 16

D

^

/ Dt

d

d

1.13 /

Dd

D

//K

17

DW

W,

14 Zd

d

D,

Zd 16 Zd 17

&t^Z

d


24/491

1007

KD

H

d

1.14 Dd 18

d

/

^

Dt

1.15 DdD

W /

//

d

19

1.16 ,&

^

1.17

/// DK

D/

20,/

21

/

Dt

d

/

/

/

/

18 19Zd

d

,

20

K

&

/

Z/

ZKD:

21

dD,


25/491

1008

WZd, dWW

H

1.18 DdD

,

22

/ KD

/K

d

'D

/K

KD

1.19 d

23DdD

24 as did

DK /

26

1.20 /Dd/KD

27

/K W

28dD^^

2003 described it as a 29d

30,/K

d/K

2.1 Dd

/

22

&t^Z

d

23Zd

dD

,

24^tWWE

K

d

,E

26Zd

dD

,

Zd

d,

27Zd 28Zd

29Zd 30Zd


26/491

1009

KD

H

/

D

/

DdD

2.2

D d ,

/ 31 //

32 /

/

33,

/DW^

K'

KD

34D

2.3 /Dd

K

36

D37 &E

h

DDd

KD

,

DK

W

d

38

2.4 d E Dd

/

D 39

,

40

31Zd

d

D,

32 Zd 33 Zd 34 Zd Zd 36

Z:d

37

^t^Zd

38 Zd

dD

,

39 DDd

40

&t^Z

d


27/491

1010

WZd, dWW

H

/ K

/h/

W^

d

/KWd

2.5 d D

d

/K/

2.6 /K

Dd

D

//K

/

d

'

/ decisions to

be taken in considering the D

,

/

2.7 /D

d,

W

/

Dd 41

/d

/

2.8 d

Dd

dD

d

D

&

41 Zd

d

,


28/491

1011

KD

H

2.9 DdD

42

D/KE

/

WD

K//

^

2.10 d

d

/

D/KDd

dW

3.1 Dd W 43

D//D

44

/Zd

W^D/

/ Z d

3.2 W

D

D

/K

Dd

t//

/

3.3 / EDd

W^D 46,

42 Zd

d

D,

43

&t^Z

d

44 &

d

D,

& 46 /

Zd

dD

,


29/491

1012

WZd, dWW

H

47d

&

W

W

/KW

d

W

3.4 /Dd

/K,WD

/K,

,

48 d Dd

W

/K

3.5 Dd ,

49W,

d

Dd

W

/

Dd

3.6 d WD

^^

dDDW

/

Dt

/

47 Zd 48 Zd

d

,

49 Zd

d

D,

Zd

d

,

Zd


30/491

1013

KD

H

3.7 d/KW

/Dd/

W

//K

W

//KDW

W

^D^

W

3.8 /W

/KWDd/

/

,

/

W

3.9 Dd

d

d/K

W

/D

d

W

3.10 DdW

W

dE^'

W>

3.11 DdW/K

,

Zd

d

D,

Zd

Zd

Z:d

Zd

d

,

Zd

Z:d


31/491

1014

WZd, dWW

H

dWd

d

d

/d

3.12 /Dd

/KW/

//

//

tW

z

/

3.13 dDdW

,

^

W^/

^dW

60

3.14 Dd//

61

//

,W 62

/ t W

/

Zd

d

,

Zd

d

D,

60 Zd 61 Zd 62 Zd


32/491

KD

H

3.15 ,W

d

W

d

W/K

d

Dd

D

3.16 &

W

Dd

W

63 His

^

'Dd

/K

d

3.17 ^,

D/K

64

//D:

dW

/

^K

Dd

W/W

W

3.18 ^

WW

/K

^Dd

63 Zd 64 ^D

d

D,:

^D


33/491

1016

WZd, dWW

H

3.19 ^Dd/

W

66dDd

W/K

67

3.20 dW

68

DdWd^

D/KW

69

3.21 dW

/K

WDd

/

W

3.22 D d

70,W

71 and that

d/K

D

W

/K

WDd

WDd

72/

3.23

W

DdW

73/

W

/KDd

66 ^D 67 Zd

d

,

68 Zd 69 ^D

dD,:

70 Zd

d

,

71 Zd

Z:d

72 Zd

d

,

73 Zd


34/491

1017

KD

H

3.24 K^ 74

&,

W

W

KD 76

3.25 /ddW

W

77,

W

W

dW

DdW

t

/ 78

3.26 Dd

79

d / d W

ZdW

W

,Dd

W

80d

/K

W

3.27 d/KtWW81D/K

W

DdD

/

82

d t W W /

/

/ / W

74 Zd

Z:d

Zd

d

,

76 dd

d

D,:

77 dd 78 dd 79 dd 80 dd 81 D82 Zd

Z:d


35/491

1018

WZd, dWW

H

/

Wz

W

3.28 d W

W

/K

83

dZZ

/Zd

d/

Dd

/

W

/ W

W

D

d,

W/

/

/Dd

W

W

3.29 d :

Dd^d/K 84

WtWW

W

^

W

,/K

,W

d/KW

/K

^/K dd

W

3.30 d

W/KW

W

W

83Zd 84Zd

Z:d


36/491

1019

KD

H

W/K

3.31 dDdW

,W

86

t

d

D

t

z

/

3.32 ^ 87

/

&W

/

W

^ 88

//

/ W

/d/Dd

,

/

3.33 / ZW

89 W

/K

D/

/K

3.34 d D d

W

tDd

/K

DE

E

/KW

Zd

d

,

86 Zd 87 ^D

dD,:

88 ^D

d

,:

89 W:


37/491

1020

WZd, dWW

H

3.35

Dd :

^/W

/K

W

back to the issue of guidance90Dd

^

91

3.36 EW

tWW

W/

W

/KD/W

'dDd

/

4. What Price Privacy?d

4.1

/W

/Kd

92

W

93/

the case of the tWW Z

4.2 Zd

/KW94 and do not

/

4.3 d

/K

//K

'

d/

90 Zd

Z:d

91 Zd

d

,

92 /D:93

94


38/491

1021

KD

H

4.4 d ^

zDd/K/

d

4.5 d

E

4.6 /Dd

/ 96

D

/

DtDDdt

//

97

,

/

W

4.7 /

Dt

d t

/K

4.8 d/K

D/

/

96

&t^Z

d

97


39/491

1022

WZd, dWW

H

4.9 t W W d 98

WD/K

99dDd

,

100

d t

>

d

d/

d

KD

4.10 t tWW

/KK

101

d

d/

d

'

tWW

'

Wd

/K

4.11 W

/

102

dKD

K

98 Zd

99

100Zd

101 Zd 102 W:


40/491

1023

KD

H

103 d

/

/

K

4.12 Dd

104

//

d

d

//

/

/

4.13 /t

WW

/

/K

/K

Ddt

d

d

/KdD t

WW

/K

4.14 Dd

d/Kd

103 ,DtKDDDK

104 Zd

d

,

&t^Z

d


41/491

1024

WZd, dWW

H

d

/d

/K

//

4.15 KD

D

Dd

tWW

4.16 //K

106d

oftWW

/D

dW

/K

4.17 dtWW

/KWd

/d

d

d

W/K

4.18 Dd

/ '

W ^ 107

tWWEd 108

K:

109d

tWWE

106 Zd

d

,

107

&t^

Zd

Zd

d,

108 Zd

109


42/491

KD

H

4.19 d

/K

/

110

d

d

t

t'

t

/

5. What Price Privacy?dW

5.1 DdW

/K

5.2 K^Dd/^W

D d

111/Dd

^

Dd

/ D

Dd

5.3 KDdD

/

5.4 //KW

Dd

110Zd

111 Zd

Z:d


43/491

1026

WZd, dWW

H

5.5 K K E/ t

>,^Wd

D,

t

WW 112d

Dd

DdW

5.6 D,

W

E/K

Dd

113

WW

/

W

d

/KW

5.7 /Dd 114

D d

W

D/

D,E

DdD,

E

5.8 /DdW

d

/W

112 Zd

Z:d

113 Zd 114 Zd

Z:d

Zd

Z:d


44/491

1027

KD

H

Dd

5.9 tWWE

/KW/

W

W

116d

dW

//K

d

d /K

d W

/K

5.10 K : DD>

KdD''

KDd 117

/K

/

^

Dd

5.11 d Z

118/

:/ 119

K

DdW

D

120d/K

K

116 Zd

117 Zd

Z:d

118 W/119 '

'

120 Zd

Z:d


45/491

1028

WZd, dWW

H

d/K

d/K

121

5.12 K'

/

d

/K

122

t

/K

/K

5.13 Dd

:/

/ /& /K W '

123D

W 124/Dd'

/K

'

^Z

W

/ D d WD

',

WD/ 126

5.14 /Dd/K

d/K

d

/K

121 Zd

Z:d

122 Zd

Zd:

123 Zd

Zd:

124 Zd

Z:d

Zd

Z:d

126 Zd

Z:d


46/491

1029

KD

H

DdD:

127

/

/t

/W

5.15 ^

K

dDd

>

5.16 dD

d 128

5.17 Dd 129

d /

5.18 ZWDd

d

/ / /

/ 130

d/W

///

/

131

127 Zd

Z:d

128 Zd

d

,

129

&t^Z

d

130 Zd

d

D,

131 Zd

d

,


47/491

1030

WZd, dWW

H

t W

E//

W

/ 132

KtWWE

/W

W/

/

d /K

133

5.19 EDd

WW

134,

/

/WK

5.20 ^ D d

136t

/

Dd

/K

/K

132 Zd 133

&t^Z

d

134 Zd

d

D,

Zd 136

&t^

Zd


48/491

1031

H

CHAPTER 3

OTHER POSSIBLE REGULATORY OPTIONS

1. Criminal proceedings in respect of journalists

1.1 EKD/

/K

d

1.2 dK

D 1

and we were not to speak to, let alone, interview any journalists. Despite our protests

we were told this was the decision of Richard Thomas and that he would deal with thepress involvement by way of the Press Complaints Council. It was at this moment we

EE'/

/hKDt

t

them?

,

2

Basically theyd drawn a red line, with the press and the reporters above that line and

1.3 ,

Dtd

/K&,

K

3

,

1

t^

K

2 K

d

,E

3 K

d

D,


49/491

1032

WZd, dWW

H

d

/

/d/

W

1.4 K

,

d

d

t

/

d

1.5 DK

K

Z

dW^/K

Dt

DK/K

Dt

,

D

1.6 KDKD prima

facie

,

7

, Dd

W

1.7 dDDdd

D

,

K ibid

t^

K

K ibid

7 K ibid


50/491

1033

KWZK

H

E

,

8

1.8 Dd

d

9

DK

DdW

10

(c) [if] there was a policy, it was not one which I had any hand in, one which I//

11

(d) as far as Im aware, there was absolutely no such policy and I cant think why

12

///

13

(f) Q: Your evidence is that the policy steer didnt come from you?

W

(h) I dont accept that there was a policy decision. I dont accept that we

1.9 /Dd

17,

,

18

W^ 19

8 &

dD

,

9 Zd

d

D,

10 Zd ibid11 Zd ibid12 Zd ibid13 Zd ibidZd ibidZd ibidZd ibid17 Zd ibid18 Zd ibid19 Zd ibid


51/491

WZd, dWW

H

1.10 d

DK,

tWW

20

d/K

//K/

1.11 DK

21

/

d/

//

tz

/

1.12 /

/

d

1.13 dDd

,/K

d

22

23

20

21 K

d,E

22 Zd

d

D,

&t^Zd

23

^t^Z

d

dt^

Zd


52/491

KWZK

H

DK

W^

more serious

/K

t

journalists 27

This is a

28

1.14 dDd

//K

d

W^d

K

/

/K

/K

ibidZd

d

D,

^t^Zd

dt^Zd

&t^Zd

^t^Z

d

dt^

Zd

27 Zd

d

D,

^t^Zd

dt^Zd

&t^Zd

28 Zd

d

,


53/491

WZd, dWW

H

1.15 Dd

d

/K

d

29

Yt

about that?

/

YE

K/

D d

KD

1.16 dZ:YDd

30

D/'D

d

does it not follow that either there was a policy decision not to pursue that course or,

carry out an elementary step, namely to interview?

1.17 Dd

D:

31

Y^/

t / /

/

///

1.18 dDd

/

/K

29 Zd

d

D,

30 Zd ibid31 Zd ibid


54/491

1037

KWZK

H

1.19 /

/KD:

32

>

d

t

t

d

z

t

1.20 DK

^

33

/

D:

1.21 / / D

t

d/K,,:^Y

Dt

1.22 &

d

Dt

d

d

The vice of the

//

1.23 dDd/K

/K

DK

32 Zd ibid33 K

d

,E

Zd

Z:d

t^

K


55/491

1038

WZd, dWW

H

tt

t

/K

W^DW

1.24 Dd

/

/

/K

W^t

1.25 /

/KW^

1.26 W

DK

DdDK

37

//

/K K

D

d

/Kd

which would carry any form of public interest defence.

d

W

/K

d Dt

/K

could andshould have.

dD

W/

D

D//K

DW

d,

37

t^

K


56/491

1039

KWZK

H

W

WKD

D ^ WZ /K

thad concluded.

1.27 dDd/K

DK

/K

,Z

DK

K

D K

&

/KDK

1.28 /d

D

/K

t

dd

//

1.29

/KD

d

38

problem.KD

/

d/K

1.30 Dd/

W,

38 Zd

d

D,


57/491

WZd, dWW

H

W under way.39

/K

KD

tt

dDd

//K

2. The use of regulatory powers

2.1 KKD

K

/KDd

,

2.2 d

Ddd

Dt

d only

D

2.3 ddD

/

D

2.4 dd

,

d

D

39 Zd ibidZd ibid


58/491

KWZK

H

2.5 dD

d

2.6 /Dd/K

dd

d

2.7 /WZ

/K

d

/K

D

2.8

d/

/K

d/D

prima facie

wasprima facie

tprima facie

/K

d

//K

D

d/K

W

/

/

D

Zd

d

,

d/KD

W

&t

^Zd


59/491

WZd, dWW

H

E

D/K

2.9 /

Ddd

/'d/

/K

D

/K/K

/

2.10 E Z DK ,

D

Its our job to take them or indeed anyone else on, thats what we are paid to do. If

we do not do it, then who does?

d

d W

K/K

/

2.11 E /K should

E

D

d

,

D

/K

3. Engagement with the industry: guidance and

3.1 hW/K

of this Act by data controllers.

t^

K


60/491

KWZK

H

dD

d /K

Dd

d

/KD

3.2 d/

D

/K

/

3.3 Dd

W

W

W

/

WDd

Dd

3.4 /

W tWW

d

Zd

d

,

Zd

d

D,

Zd ibid


61/491

WZd, dWW

H

/

/

W

3.5 DdW

/K

/tWW

/

/

3.6 //D

d/K

d

tWW

/K

^W

/K

d

W

/K/K

3.7 t W W

K

Dd

///

W

//

/

3.8 / /K

Dd

Z

Zd

d

,

Zd ibidZd ibid


62/491

KWZK

H

W&K/

/K

ZW

/K

3.9 & /K

/

/KW

,

W

d

3.10 /KW

WdetailD

^D

dW

/K

d

D

tWW

d/K

W not/K

D

DdD

W

/K

3.11 KDd

/Kt/ I dont think Ive ever had

D

/K

D

4.1 dD/K

d

W

d

d

Zd

d

D,


63/491

WZd, dWW

H

4.2 K

d

D

W

d

4.3 d

'/K

d

t/K

D

d

/K,DZ

/

4.4 ED

/W

DK

/K

4.5 Dd

d

d

4.6 E

D

d/K

d/K

E

dW&ibid'

d

D,:

' ibidZd

d

,


64/491

KWZK

H

4.7 d/

d/K

D

/

/K

d

DK

t

private lists of family and friends sold to the Press and so on./

KD

4.8 dD

/K

d

/KD

4.9 d

/KD

d

d

/t /K

D

D

d

DK

d

4.10 K/

/KD

&

dW

/

D&/

t^

K

Z/ZKD

:


65/491

WZd, dWW

H

Dt

4.11 //

/D'DdW

/D'

/

/

D/

/ /

//

resources to do it.

4.12 D'

D

d

D'

4.13 /Dd

/Zd

zD

K

,/

d/

4.14 D'

d

D:

/

in them is deeply obscure. I said in my witness statement that the individual who made

Z/ZKD

:

'

d

D,:

' ibid' ibid


66/491

KWZK

H

d

/z

D/

/

^

/

:

:^/:^d/

^^

d everyone

D/

4.15 d /K

D

D'

^/

,K

^

d

h

d

4.16 d/K

D

K

/K/K

D

4.17 //K

/K ^/K

d

d

' ibiddWWD

/d

/


67/491

WZd, dWW

H

K

Motorman

5.1 KDprima facie

/

/K

//K

/K

5.2 d/K

/

d/K

D

5.3 &/KD

d /

W

' W D d

d/K

/

5.4 /

/K

D

Zd

d

D,

&t^Zd


68/491

KWZK

H

/K

5.5 /

/KD/

W

D

5.6 /

WD

W

Dd

/K

W

/K

W

5.7 d W

/K /

W/K


69/491

WZd, dWW

H

5.8 DdD'

d

D/

/K

W

/K

5.9 /D

/K

D

/

5.10 /DK/

tWW reports were

/Kd

d

D'/KD we are the

5.11 dW

Z

/

d/K


70/491

KWZK

H

d

/K


71/491

1054

H

CHAPTER 4

THE ICO AND THE PRESS TODAY

/

1.1 d/'Dd

//

'

^

1.2 ,/

,

1

/ KD

quickly.

1.3 /

E

'.,

^D^^

'D'

KDd D'

D/K

1.4 ,^

/K

/K D

/KD

W

D

D

/K

1.5 dD

'

1 '

d

D,:


72/491

1055

Chapter 4 | The ICO and the Press today

H

/KD

D'

D,

/K

D

d

1.6 / D' ^

/,

/K

,

t

Wt > ^

sure that journalists understand that this is serious. I saw a copy of the Editors Code

,W

tWWE/

Kd

/

/

t/

1.7 d/

D

/K/Dd

//K

D

&

1.8 E/K

/D'

^WWe do not have any

/

1.9 d /W Z

/K

D

d

Y'


73/491

WZd, dWW

H

/

/K

/K

W

2.1 D ' /

WWhat

WW

d/

/

2.2 D' 4

/ /

^//

/^/

//

Dt

/

^

2.3 d

5

/

much.

2.4 d

D'

/K

4 '

d

D,:

5 ' ibid


74/491

1057


H

/K

/

/KD

/K

2.5 ddtDW

D'/KD

Yt/

/

Yt//

//

why you have not gone back to see whether that has been successful or not or what

,

,

Y/

t

journalists must know; it is a self-regulatory system.

Y^

/

^

were not.

Y/

/

d

2.6 d

DDd

/K

d

YY'


75/491

1058

WZd, dWW

H

&KD

3.1 KD

/K

d/K

tW^d

W

d

DdD

d/K

/Dt

/

/K

3.2 d&

prima facie

Dt^ tW

W

&

Dt

3.3 K

D' /

^d/K

DE

/

/

7

3.4 d

that /

those who may be concerned.8

&

4.1 ^ D'

dDt

Q. But the evidence you have in front of you shows that there was law-breaking on an

industrial scale from the newsrooms of some of the major newspapers in the United

Kingdom.

7 '

d

D,:

8 ' ibidYY


76/491


H

/ /

z

journalist decides should be the agenda for the day when you have got other very big

//

tW

/

4.2 /K

/

/

/

4.3 //K

d

W/K

5.1 The tWWE W

''D 10

KD

/ D

^

&

/

prima facie

5.2 d/K

'D/

D

d

/KD

5.3 /

D 'D

d

DK

11

10 Zd

11 K

d,E

t^K


77/491

WZd, dWW

H

Dt

t

DK/

E',/

D

D

5.4 / /K

/ tWW

E Dd/

/K 'D

completely separate group &D'/

^

/K

,^

14

t//

W'/

/

/

5.5 /D'

/K /K

,

D'

d/K

5.6 D'/K

/,

W/

15&/K

5.7

D'

W

Zd

d

,

'

dD,:

14 Y

15 '

dD,:

' ibid


78/491


H

,/

/K

17/

5.8 /K

W&

d/K

d/

/

d

/K/

//

/K

5.9

/

17 ' ibid


79/491

1062

H

CHAPTER 5

ISSUES ABOUT THE LEGAL FRAMEWORK

1. The current views of the ICO

1.1 dD'/K

1

d /

d

^

^W

/ d

d

//

1.2 d

D'

2

d/

1.3 ,WW

/K

dW

capable of doing in this area.3d

d

/KD'/K

1.4 dD',W

/

.4,/K

d

/K

1

t^

Graham.pdf2 '

d

D,:

3

t^

Graham.pdf4 p14, para 3.21,


80/491


81/491

1064

WZd, dWW

H

1.10 D'W

Y

individuals have

9/K

D'

10

/

d

/

WW

^/

W

K

1.11 D' /K

tD'

/

Z

11

d

,

//

d

d

W

KW'd

d

,Z

d

/

&K/

1.12 d

/

/K

9

10

t^

Graham.pdf11 p25, para 6.8,


82/491

1065

Chapter 5 | Issues About the Legal Framework

H

1.13 /

/K

/K

, /

/

D'/K

1.14 /

/

are capable of improvement.

2.1 d/WY

W 12

DW

W

/

hW13D^

2.2 D

,Zh


83/491

1066

WZd, dWW

H

d

W

d

W

>

2.4 dD

15D

16

/ W

d

d

d d

2.5 D

W

15 W

d

D,:

16

^WY

redacted.pdf


84/491

1067


H

dW/

,>>tD

d'

d >t W

d W

d,Zd

W

d,Z

d^'>&d>t

E

,

/

> > , ,

W

,Z

d

:W

,Zd

D'E>d

d

d

,Z

W

/ , /

W

d


85/491


86/491

1069


H

W

d

'

W

'

,Z

2.6 D 17

dW

dW

dW D

^

,Z

,Z

&W

,Z

dW

,Z

/

,Z

:W

W

17

^WY

pdf


87/491

1070

WZd, dWW

H

2.7 dD

18

2.8 /

,

19

/

2.9 /

W

2.10 D

Wh


88/491

1071


H

d

2.13 D

,Z,

d

2.14 d

2.15 D/

23//

D

Z&

ZD

D

W

2.16

D

&

^

2.17 d

23

^WY


89/491

1072

WZd, dWW

H

/

&

24

d

D

E/D

2.18 E/E//D

25dZ

d

2.19 /E/

26 This relates to the

D'E>

27/

2.20 /

D

W,

K

/W

hd

2.21 /

,Z

/

consider that E/

/

24 Kd: d>^K

^

26 27 Y


90/491

1073


H

d

2.22 /E/

E/

28dD

/ 29d/D

Y

/

Y /

/

d

2.23 d

d

/

D

Z

2.24 dE/30

,Z/

28

E/

W>^

29 W

d

D,:

30

E/W>

^


91/491

1074

WZd, dWW

H

/W

t

2.25 /

E/

,Z

h

,Z/

W

W

2.26 /E/

h


92/491

1075


H

/W

t

/

/

2.29 /

^

2.30 /W

/

d

2.31 /E/

d


93/491

1076

WZd, dWW

H

2.32

tt

t

^

/

2.33 //

/

d

d

d

t

d /

D

/2.34 W

d

/d

/


94/491

1077


H

2.35 dD

33

K

W

t

d

h

K

/

W

2.36 /

/

d

t

2.37 D 34

/

W

/

/

33

^WY

redacted.pdf34 W

d

D,:


95/491

1078

WZd, dWW

H

d

/

:

2.38 /

t

/

^

2.39 >&

/

dW

d

/

t

2.40 D

/

for individuals.

W/

2.41 ,DW

/

^

35

W

35

^WY

pdf


96/491

1079


H

2.42 dW

'

E

^

,

boundaries have to be given some real meaning. Making those boundaries inaccessible, and

strips those boundaries of meaning.

2.43 d

^

/

/

2.44 E

/K /

/K

K

/K

W / /K

2.45 &/K

/

Z

/

d


97/491

1080

WZd, dWW

H

d

W

2.46 /W 36

/

/

t

d

/

spoken.

2.47 /

37 At its root the problem is that

E

d

38

2.48 /

d

d

2.49 K

d

2.50 /

36

37 W

d

D,:

^WY

38 W

d

D,:


98/491

1081


H

39K

W

2.51 D

W

40 To that example might be added the example of the

D

d ^

2.52 d W /

41

2.53 D&/

^

/ 42

2.54 tD

W/

rights.

2.55 D

/K

/

D

39 d

E'E>Et40 W

d

D,:

41

42

^WY

pdf


99/491

1082

WZd, dWW

H

2.56 //

/

/K

/

/K

2.57 /K

enforceable.

2.58 d

/

/

h


100/491

1083


H

2.62 //

/K

/K

/

//K

or

respect.

d

E/

/K/

2.63 t//K

//K

/

/K

2.64 //K

d

/K

D

/

ends.

WW

2.65 //K

W

44 These

/

/K

44


101/491

1084

WZd, dWW

H

/K

W

/K

/K

/K W

/KW

tWW Z

2.66

K

/K

2.67 K

d

2.68 & /

d

DdW

/K

2.69 /

/

/K


102/491

1085


H

/KW

,///K

2.70 //K

^

h

//K

2.71 //

/K

d

/

/

/

months from the date of this Report.

2.72 //K

d/K

W

>W

2.73 d Dd W

d:/

Act 2008 introduced that amendment, but the changes had not been brought into force. A

W'

2.74

d^^

45 the

/

^

^:

45 W/


103/491

1086

WZd, dWW

H

Z/K

2.75 /K'

commencement of both parts of the changes.46Z:

/K

/

D:,

'

'E

Z

2.76 ^/

Dd

/ 47

dK

d

/

,/ 48

/'

/

/

2.77 d/KD'

d /K

provisions at the end of 200949D

d/K

:

/K

46

47

&t^Z

d

48 Zd

d

,

49 '

'


104/491

1087


H

d

t

/

D' 50

/

/

/

2.78 K /K

d

/

WE& E

/K

/

d

d

d

2.79 ^D: 51 and

D' / /K

&/K

d

D'

52

//^

/E,^

/

d/

50 '

dD,:

51 '

'

52 '

d

D,:


105/491

1088

WZd, dWW

H

2.80 d/K

D'DZ

Y E / d

W

'DD'

53

d /

/

D

/

//

Y/

^

,

z

z

/

d^:

/

/

E/

Yt/D'

'


106/491

1089


H

DZs/^t

/

>KZ:h^d/>s^KE//

/

/

/

/

DZs/^t//D'

^

^

/ s>

/

,,

d

t

/

Yz

/

2.81 DD'

d

Dd

54

DZs/^^D'/

/

Y/

d

Z

/

Y/

^

>KZ:h^d/>s^KE/D

/ > /

/

d/

/

/

/

54 '

dD,:


107/491

1090

WZd, dWW

H

/

2.82 E/

Z//

/

dZ/

dZ

2.83 dDd

/Z

^

/Z

2.84 ^

/

^

/

/

Z

2.85 dW

d

W

d

d

d

D'

2.86 d/

d


108/491

1091


H

2.87 /

/

d

d

/

/Z

form.

2.88 d

d

/

/

t

d

2.89 d

/

2.90 //

E

d

d

2.91 /

D

Wd

t


109/491

1092

WZd, dWW

H

W

2.92 /W

:/Z

/

K/

2.93 ' 55 /

2.94 / /

W/K

2.95 Z

/KK

/Kd

d

Z/W

56

D

57

2.96 d

58/

/K

W^d

d

D

W^

55

56

57

58 d>^K


110/491

1093


H

2.97 d

^ /K

^

of the picture altogether.

2.98 D'/ 59

//

W^

/

/

K

/

/

d

h

d

t

2.99

/KKD

/K/

/K

/K

2.100d/

above,60DW

Ktd

/

59

t^

Graham.pdf60 W


111/491

1094

WZd, dWW

H

2.101 /

E

&

d

2.102 K/K

d/K

/

/

W^

d

2.103 d

/

D

/K

2.104 d

/K/

/KW^/

W^

2.105 d

/Kh

d

/K


112/491

1095


H

d

/

WW

61 d /K

D'

62

/

2.106 ^

/K

W

W^/KW^

2.107 //KDW

Ktd

/K

2.108 d/K

KDd/K

d

d

/

/K

&

focus on the nature of the conduct and its impact on the individual.

2.109

t 63/

^t

for it.

61

dW:

62

t^

Graham.pdf63 W:


113/491

1096

WZd, dWW

H

2.110 d

d

d

2.111 D

Wd

ZD^d

dW

/W

2.112 /

,Zh


114/491


115/491

WZd, dWW

H

/K

D d

Z

/K

Z

1.6 t/K

^

/

/K

/K

D/

/

1.7 /K

W

^ / /

/KKD

/KWW'

d

&

h>Dd

D

Dd

Zd

d

,


116/491

1099

d/K

H

///K

/

,

1.10 dd^d

>> D:d

D t

DtDd

>> again

d:Dt/K

7

^dK>>

1.11 dDdDZYE

/DdE

/KDt

d/KK

d

DDd

Dt

/K>>

t

/Dd>>

1.12 d /

/K

/KDD

d

/K

Dd

/Kdirectly approached a journalist or editor

DDdt

d

DD

/

1.13 d/KDt

dd^d

/K

^t^:

t

7 :t

d

,:

Zd

d

,


117/491

1100

WZd, dWW

H

1.14 dd^dK

>>

d

Dd

W

Dd

9

Newspapers had already been doing this for centuries when he took up his post four

d

zDd

Mr Thomas is complicit in placing another brick in the wall that the state is building

d

Dd

d tWW Dd

1.15 Dd

10D

>,&W

t/

Dt

d^d/K

Dd

11&

DE/Dd

^ddDd

>12

1.16 Dd

D, //

13

E//Kt

Dd/Kd^d

9 Zd

Z:d

10 Zd

d

,

11

^t^:t

12 Zd

d

,

13 Zd ibid


118/491

1101

d/K

H

1.17 d

d^d Z Dd

14tWWE

grave concerns

D

d^dd

clearly defamatoryDD

1.18 Dd& /K

tWWE

d^dZ

&

Dd

W

1.19 d/Kd^d

/ /K

Dd

Dt

d

/

Z

K

/K

/

Dd

/KtDdD

/DK

d^d

14 Zd

Z:d

Zd

Z:d

Zd

d

D,


119/491

1102

WZd, dWW

H

K

1.20 t

/KD

17

,

/

/&

WZ/K^/

fear the media

/

D

1.21 d/Dd

D,

DdD

WZ

/K

1.22 ^

D d

/19d

/

1.23 /Dd tWW

20,

W

21

17 &

d

D,

dt^Zd

19 Zd

d

D,

^

t^Zd

20 Zd ibid21 Zd ibid


120/491

1103

d/K

H

exclusivelyorganising the illegal trade 22

d

d

tWW

23

d

K

1.24 /K

D

Dd/

24

/

K

1.25 d

W^K'

London counsel indicated that the journalists were interviewed and were found to

1.26 W

/KDd

Well, I have to look at it from all points of view, I suppose, but I can see that the

media would not like any of their journalists being prosecuted and I suspect they

would, for example, argue theres a public interest in being able to ensure freedom

E///

1.27 / unreasonable or unfair

t

22 Zd ibid23 Zd

24

&t^Z

d

Zd

d

D,

Zd ibid


121/491

1104

WZd, dWW

H

/KDd

27

d'd

^

/

^,ZttW

W

1.28 d/K

d

/

/K

d/29

/

1.29 d

d

D

' if were talking monkeys, its see no evil, hear

30

d

the power of the press

2.1 Z

d/

d

d/K

d

d

27 Zd ibidZd ibid

29 W&30 '

d

D,:


122/491

d/K

H

2.2 Z

DdD'

Dd

31

t//

/

/

/

to destroy that sort of approach, and therefore I was trying to make us much less

/

^/

K

right

2.3 Dd

tWW

32

/

d/K

//

2.4 d/KDd

D

tWW

33

We were aware from the outset that the media would probably ignore or show

d

d

/

We had worked very hard to secure a good press for the ICO across a veryW&K/

d

d&

Dd

KD

31 Zd

d

,

32

&t^Z

d

33 ibid


123/491

WZd, dWW

H

2.5 /K

d

/Dd

34

I think there was a general feeling that people at the head of newspapers were

/

/

a message that we were challenging something which went to the heart of much of

^

z

that you are actually challenging their whole business model? Maybe thats one

K

2.6 Dd

Whatever was precisely known about the nature and extent of press misconduct

across the industry as a whole, it became increasingly clear that the press were able

/

d/K

^

d

://

recall saying to my colleagues in 2007 and 2008 that, with hindsight, it may have

t

/

3.1 //K

d

,

/K

34 Zd

d

,

&t^Z

d


124/491

1107

d/K

H

W

d

/

dZ/

3.2 /d/K/

d

3.3 /K

/

/K/

/K/K

DK

/

//

we do not do it then who does?

3.4 d/K

/

/

,

/K

37

3.5 d Z

/K

d

dZ/K

/

D:/K

t^

K

37 d>^K


125/491

WZd, dWW

H

W/K

4.1 d/K

/d

4.2 / Z

/

/K

4.3 d

d

d

/D' /K

d

/K/K

/

/K

4.4 /K

/

/

/K

//K

4.5 d

d

d'&d

d'

'D

tK'

K

D

K


126/491


127/491

1110

WZd, dWW

H

/

/

/K


128/491

1111

H

CHAPTER 7

SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATIONS

1.1 I am conscious of both the length and complexity of this Part of the Report. For ease of

/

of this Part rather than to follow the approach I have pursued elsewhere.

/D:

dW

1

dW

2

W//^

d

/

W

3

1 Part H, Chapter 5, para 2.602 Part H, Chapter 5, para 2.603 Part H, Chapter 5, para 2.62


129/491

1112

WZd, dWW

H

dW

4

/

W

/ K

5

^

/

K

6

d

W:

/

7

d /

8

/KW^

9

dW

/K /

10

4 Part H, Chapter 5, para 2.465 Part H, Chapter 5, para 2.576 Part H, Chapter 5, para 2.647 Part H, Chapter 5, paras 2.94-2.958 Part H, Chapter 5, para 2.1079 Part H, Chapter 5, para 1.10710 Part H, Chapter 6, para 4.9


130/491

1113

^

H

//K

d/K

11

/

/ K

d

Z

12

d / K

13

//K

14

d/KZW

15

d/K'

W

WW^

16

d/K

DW

K

Ktd 17

d/K

18

d /K

19

11 Part H, Chapter 5, para 2.6412 Part H, Chapter 5, para 2.7213 Part H, Chapter 5, para 2.7314 Part H, Chapter 5, para 2.6515 Part H, Chapter 5, para 2.7316 Part H, Chapter 5, para 2.10717 Part H, Chapter 5, para 2.10818 Part H, Chapter 6, para 4.319 Part H, Chapter 6, para 4.4


131/491

PART I

THE PRESS AND

POLITICIANS

I


132/491

1117

I

CHAPTER 1

INTRODUCTION

1.1 / d Z /

d/

/

/

1.2 /dZ

d

/

,

d

1.3 dZD

dWD

:

D

,z

z

^

z

>

1.4 d

/

/

/

1.5 W

/

/


133/491


134/491

/

I

1.11 &

d

d

1.12

/

t

E

d

1.13 d

d

/

1.14 dDDE

ddd^d

^ds

E

E

E^

/

/

1.15 K

,

Z,

^^Y

d

Z

d

W

'

,


135/491

WZd/ dWW

I

1.16 dWW

,

/Z

t

Wt

WD

1.17 d/

d /

W /

,

1.18 d W Z

WD

W

W

WDdW

1.19 d/D

//

t

dZ

//

/

1.20 d W D

1.21 d Z W d

/

d

d/

WW,


136/491

1121

I

CHAPTER 2

THE CONSERVATIVE YEARS

1. Prime Minister Thatcher: 1979-1990

1.1 D d

WD

1

Margaret Thatcher never read a newspaper from one week to the next.

t

/>

D 2

Dd

and editors.

1.2 d

ZD great admirer3 of

d 4

1.3 d / DD d ^

/d Dd

5

D D 6

D Y ZD

for Mrs Thatcher 7^:Dd

8

DW

/

/

Ed^dd

DD ideological soul mates 9^:

Baroness Thatcher and these proprietors with their common commitment to trade union1D

3ZD

d

D,

4ZD ibid5d

dD

,D

6ZD

d

D,

7

t^D

8^:D

d

D,:

9

tE


137/491

1122

WZd/ dWW

I

reform, to shared views about business (and buccaneering businessmen) and the European

hd&t

1.4 d

DD

11DE

d 12


138/491

1123

dz

I

1.9 DDd

DD 19

D^

/

D

,, ^ /

,K

1.10 d'

E/

^ K

^dDE>,d 21

1.11 D

d 22

Dd

1.12 >D

23

^

d / /

seemed so calm to her on all occasions ...

1.13 >' 24

controller of BBC One when in the days of then Mrs Thatchers government when the

t

a Nolan process ...

1.14 /

D

25

d&

ddDd^

>

> Throughout the

19

t^D

tE

21ZD

d

D,

22

t^

23>D

d

D,D

24>'

d

,:

25

t^D


139/491

1124

WZd/ dWW

I

dDD

dDD

^

D K

disheartening for press rivals(emphasis added)

1.15 d

Kdd>

KD&EWD

26

What we do know is that the press [Michael Foot and Neil Kinnock] received was

DdWD

&

Z^^donkey jacket. But that was but part of a long campaign during which in several

D &^

W^&

>

D

dD

page with a disputed claim that Nissan would scrap plans for a 50m car plant

>&

/>

D>d

dK^d

among them Neil Kinnock and Robin Cook.

1.16 >D 27

//

/

/>W/>W

DW

E/

>Wt

>W

26

^t^

27>D

d

,D


140/491

1125

dz

I

'

/>

W/

/DD

D

>^

1.19 Dt>W

D 31

1.20 >WdsD

/>W

32

/dsD

dd>Wd

dsD

>W

28WK

dD

,D

29

^t^

'

d

D,:

31

d

,D

32

d

,D


141/491

1126

WZd/ dWW

I

2. Prime Minister Major: 1990-1997

2.1 /E^:D

33,

/

W^

2.2 ^:d

^ : >

2.3 dD/

^:'

^Y 34D^:D

2.4 WD^:

,

/ 35

WD/

/

d

D

E

/Dd

E/

EWK

W/

2.5 ^: /

/

/

^:/D

36

2.6 /^:,DD

>

>^,

33^:D

d

D,:

34W/35

t^^:D

36 ibid


142/491

1127

dz

I

ZDDDE

37

^DD

^ds

38,

W^

39,

h

41

2.7 dD

42

z/Dd/

newspapers were given a sense of power. The numbers that received the peerages

/

:D//

/

2.8 > K ^ :W^

^

D>K'

d

^/'

d//>K 43

t/Z

D/^

/

/W^

'/

'/

^WD

37

t^^:D

^:D

^:D

38

t^^:D^

:D

^:D

^:D

dD,

:

39

t^^:D

p16, ibid^:D

^:D

41

t^^:D

^:D

42

d

,D

43>K

d

D,D


143/491

1128

WZd/ dWW

I

2.9 d^:

'

^

44

d

/

phenomenally over the years.

^

page headline and commentary columns within. There was an absolute belief that

reported the stories.

/

^^

/

^/

2.10 Wtdd

^:

^

45K^:

46

d

>K

2.11 DD

^:

>KWD

47>K^:

DD

/^:

48

zd

d

d

>

DW

Wsd

44^D

d,:

45Wt

d

D,:

46^:D

d

D,:

47^:D

^:D

48^:D

d

D,:

^:D

^:D


144/491

1129

dz

I

/DW

2.12 WZD' 49

Dt

t/

//E^:

DD 51

Y ^ ^ d W

:D

K

t

2.14


145/491

WZd/ dWW

I

54

2.17 , 55

^

d

servants and public services were held. The press undermined this campaign from the

led by journalists

(emphasis

added).

2.18 ^:

d

W

ED

no right to

any privacy 56

57

Department of a hospital. The caller explained that my sons then girlfriend had been

,

&

58

/

D

E/

D

,

Zh

/Et

the equipment was a telephoto lens. The motorcyclist had been instructed to follow my

and

59

&'/&

/

d

54

t^^:D

55

t^^:D

56

t^^:D

57 ibid58 ibid59 p26, ibid


146/491

1131

dz

I

2.19 dWDDEt

z/&/

while to try and track down the woman who took John Majors virginity. This was a

while ago. We found her but we couldnt get a picture of her with her new boyfriend.

^:DWD&

//

/ZE

WE

t

Well put it in the paper. Which is what we did.

2.20 ^: 61

Y z

t

^:

about you by the press?

/

/

/

/

'

////

/////

//

^/

z/

t

z

/

/

2.21 d DD ^ :

^:DD

^:

62

/

&

/

'^/

DD/

/

DDW

2.22 ^:

63

/

/

W

WDD

d

,E

61^:D

d

D,:

62

t^^:D

63^:D

d

D,:


147/491

1132

WZd/ dWW

I

/

2.23 t/DD

'^:

64

Y^dWd

t//

K

/

/

//^//

would have preferred to have less of the editorial support and more of the equitable

news coverage.

2.24 , 65

W

/

2.25 D

WDDZ

66

Z:Dd'

WD

/

2.26 Dt

67

Y zDZ

:Dd

'

list?

z/

/

:D

64 p34, ibid65 p35, ibid66

t^WZ

67Wt

d

D,:


148/491

1133

dz

I

2.27 / :

/

d

D&>


149/491

1134

I

CHAPTER 3

NEW LABOUR

d

1.1 d > W

E

/ E/ /

Z

DD 1

1.2 d>W

>>

/

/

t

1.3 d^

>


150/491

1135

Chapter 3 | New Labour

I

^/

1.5 >

1.7 dZ,,,DW d>W

ZDt

' 9

/

D

1.8 D^ &'

^d

11 /

/

12

1.9 ^ :D >W

/

/

/

'/

1.10 t

^t^

9

t^,,YDW

,,

d

,:

11:^

t^:^

DW

12:^

d

D,D

13^:D

d

D,:


151/491

1136

WZd/ dWW

I

dZ,d

14

Y /

/

DW

/

z//

/

1.11 D > W

D 15 ,ZD

16

1.12 D^

17

D

/

d/

1.13 D,/

Y D /

D/

t/d

1.14 D 19

>,

>WD

D

14d

d

,D

15

d

,D

16 17:^

dD

,D

,,

d

,:

19

t^d


152/491

1137


I

^

D

/

D

1.15 D>WD

E>

D

,/DD

D

1.16 ,

21

///>W

/

1.17 dD

22

D/Z

//

/

d

z/

/

///

//

WD

/

1.18 ^D /

/

//

23

1.19 '>W 24

d

dD

,D

21d 22d 23d 24'

d

D,:


153/491

WZd/ dWW

I

d>E

d

/

1.20 >W

D

tE

>

25

z//

/d>E W >WE/t

/

^

'

1.22 > D

>E/d

^

DD

1.23 /

> W

,

/

1.24 W

E>>

W

^:D'

>


154/491

1139


I

d

2.1 K:D>>W

>W 26D/

27

/>W

t/

/

/

/

tE>

2.2 ,

Mr

ZD

^

29 Although Mr Murdoch

&D

>Wd

h 31

2.3 dt

>W>ZD

32DD

33

2.4 K : 34DD d E/

35 D

> W 36,WDW^D:

^E

2.5 D

D>D

d,D

27d

dD,D

d 29d ZD

dD,

31d

dD

,D

32D tW33ZD

d

D,

34 s35

^t^

36


155/491

WZd/ dWW

I

d

37,

/>t

>W

WD

Dd>t

W

>

2.6 D>DDW,>W

>D 39

E>W

2.7 K:DDDE

,///D

/ /

D

>W

d

/>WE>d

D'>

'/

2.8 ,

41

/d

E/

d//

/

K//

d>W

/

/

/

37 39>D

d

,D

t^d

41d

dD

,D


156/491

1141


I

//

/ /

2.9 DD 42

/D,/,

>W/

D

D

2.10 ,D

43

/d/

2.11 d

/DD/

D

44

,DD

45

2.12 dDD

46

D 47

>

Wz

2.13 ^,/:

d^D

DD

42

t^


157/491

1142

WZd/ dWW

I

D

2.14 ^Dd^>

W/W

on 17 March 1997

and D>W

D

d^D

DD

>W49

2.15 DD /

d^/

>W^ D

d^

51/d

52

2.16 dE>^:D

W

d

DD

53D 54

/

/^

2.17 DD

DD^

55

Y /

,D

/

49

^t^

d

dD

,D

51

^t^

d

dD,D

52>D

d

,D

53ZD

d

D,

54

^t^

55d

d

D,DDDDE

dD


158/491

1143


I

/

dDD

D

E

/

DD

/

/ /

//

//ZD/W

K 57

/

//

/

//

3.2 D

3.3 D/

'DWD

59d

WD

DW

56 /^57>K

d

D,D

t^d

59

t^


159/491


160/491

1145


I

>D

64

d

D

K

3.8 D ' D

65

d

3.9 >D 66

/D>/

/t

3.10 dD

Z

D,

67

d

d

/^

t

/

64

t^>D

65

t^

66>D

d

D,D

67d

dD

,D

E>D

d/

t^


161/491


162/491

1147


I

K/DD

,Dhd

/ds

DD

>

3.16D

'DD

3.17 d /D

DDddD/

WDZW/'DD

D//D

DD/

hD

/h

d

3.18 DDWDD

DDWD

,DW

/DD

79

ZW /

D

,/ / /

/

3.19 /DE

d W /

WZ

DWDWD

/

/

WD

/

3.20 tDDWDD

/

DD

79d

dD

,D

d

,D


163/491

WZd/ dWW

I

DD

WD

3.21 d/D^

D/DD

D

/W//

/

/

h^

/^,

//ZD/

//

,D'

//

/D

/

3.22D/D/t

,

>//

/

/

///

/Kd/

'^//

E/

/h^

/

3.23 D

DD

h^/D

D

3.24 //D

WD

K:

D W>Z/

/DDDdWD

ddd^dW

d

,&

t^d

d

dD

,D

d


164/491

1149


I

:

3.25 ,

d &

E

^

/

/

d

/

&

3.26 ,

,K

3.27 ddd

: >&^

D

3.28 DK dD^D

/

D

WD

/

>D 91

3.29 ' : Z ^ t W 92 It

d

93

dd:

^':

dD

91 92 d':

93


165/491

WZd/ dWW

I

/^

d

3.30 D

94/': 95 Lord

D

WD

4.1 dZ,'DWWD:D

DE>

96

D

>E,^

t

//

/

4.2 DZD

97,

d^

D

4.3 D

',

'

4.4 D

>D

99

D/

/

4.5 D

t/

///

94

d

,D

95

96'

d

D,:

97 ' ' 99>D

d

D,D

'

d

D,:


166/491

1151


I

/

K

d

t

WdW

/

/

/

/

/

d/

W

h

4.6 /D

h

>

d

^E

^

4.7 /:DDD

,^

d^>D

Y z D

D

z

d

z

Y ,

/Zt

'd^

/

'd

t^

>D

d

,D


167/491

1152

WZd/ dWW

I

DD

&Z

>

>

4.8 >DD

E/

E/t

E/

/ :D ZD

///

D//

/

DDDdE/

4.9 /DDD

/',^

W,

D

/

DD/

W

/>W/D

d^

/

4.10 D

Y DD

/

z///

//

/

//

Y t d^

dW

'

dD

,:

t^


168/491


169/491

1154

WZd/ dWW

I

/

d

WD WD

/

4.14 Dd

^

DDD

E

111

4.15 D

DW

112

/D

D

//

,ZD

/

/DdD

>W/

>Z/W/>

D

/

Y ^ D D

/

>

D

/

D

dDW

D/

/

4.16 />D 113

'

'

'

'

111

't^

'DW

112'

d

D,:

113>D

d

,D


170/491

1155


I

Y D

, D

/

D / D

/

'W/W

DD

'WD

D

D^ >

D/

Y D

/D

Y D

DD

WD

/

/ /

d

4.17 D

tD

D

114

4.18 Dd>

KDt

DD

D 115

W

d

116

114 '

d

D,:

115D

d

,:

116 dZ,dKW dZW>


171/491


172/491

1157


I

/

/

///

/

dE>

5.7 : D D

>D 121/

DD

122

123

E

^/

5.8 D 124

/

/

d

/

/

D

/

K

/

//

/>

Wt

d

^//

/

/

121 sK

WW

122d d: 123

d

,D

124d

dD

,D


173/491

WZd/ dWW

I

5.9 >D

,

125

/

/

d>W

^/

>

Y

/ /

/

//

5.10 D

126

/

/ /

Z

^

zW

K:ZD

^

&

E>

E

5.11 D>D 127

Y >D

d

d

E

//

/

d

125>D

d

D,D

126

d

,D

127


174/491

1159


I

5.12 / D

5.13 D,

K',D

D

129

/D/

//

//

z

&

/

/ D ^

t

//

//

/

//

DD/

/

Y /

>D

DD

E

/

z/

//

/

>W

>W

/

/

/

5.14 dD

D

129d

d

,D

d


175/491


176/491

1161


I

5.16 D E >

132

zt

/

^t

/

5.17 &

'

&

&

E

/

^

^

5.18 /E>

K

K

d

5.19 D Dd

133

d

E>

d

D

d

132' 133D Dd

^,:


177/491


178/491


179/491

1164

I

CHAPTER 4

THE CONSERVATIVE REVIVAL AND THE COALITION1

/

1.1 /Z,DW

,

WZ^

E>dD,,

K

>


180/491

1165

dZ

I

D'K ,

/Dd

1.4 dZD

>K

WD/K

D

d^'^

t

d

D

D

d

D

/&D

D>

K

2.1 D>W

> K ,

K

'

KK

11

D

/ K

/

K&

^K

/:

> K

2.2 d

K/

D K

D

'K

d

,:

t^

DW

11


181/491

1166

WZd/ dWW

I

d

d

14

/D

15

2.3 dD

/

D

ZDZ

E

16

/

D

D, d

DDD

DD

Zd

DD

DE>d

DWD

D

D

d /

dD

DD

2.4 'DWW^

DKEDE

D

t/ /

d

D,:

t^

DW

14 15 16

t

E

d

D,:


182/491


183/491

WZd/ dWW

I

dD'D

d

2.10 t D

,

>W

W

2.11 d

//

/

2.12 d

W

/'//

/

2.13 ^

/

zD

D

,/K',

/ d

d

d

2.14 /DKD

DK

Et EdtD

DK dKWdKZzK


184/491


185/491

WZd/ dWW

I

/D

2.19 , EdtD

&

W

/

2.20 DKDE/

Y E/

d//

d

/

E//D

D^^/

E/

>KZ:h^d/>s^KE

d//

DZ

E//

t

2.21 DD

E/,

E/Edt

Y /E/

E

/

E/

Etd

'K

d

,:

'K

d

D,:


186/491


187/491

WZd/ dWW

I

2.26 E

2.27 t

DE^

DD

46

,DD K^,D

D W

W,WZ,&

DDW^>D

2.28 dDD

, &D

DD

DW:

2.29 D

,

DK

, 51D

DK D

D

DDDD>

/&D

>d /

E

t''D

,

d

46

d

D,:

t^

DW

t^

51

t^'

KDW

d

D,:

t^

DW


188/491

dZ

I

2.30 ^D

D

D,

54

D/

d

/

//

/

D

55

dD/

/

/

t//>/

2.31 d D

,D

D

DD> D

56

& D >

/

/ /

,/

&D>

/

/

W,

2.32 D D

D ,'

2.33 d

/tD

54

d

D,:

55 56

t^

DW

t^


189/491


190/491

dZ

I

/D'

D

2.37 dZW//

D

D

EdtKDD

WE/

2.38 DKD

/DD/

61,

D

D

D

t

W/E/

D/

d

2.39 DDKD

DK

64

Y t

/

Et

2.40 D

DEdt,

65

Y t

t/

KEt

^

^//

61

t^'

KDW

'K

d

,:

d

D,:

64 'K

d

,:

65

d

D,:


191/491

WZd/ dWW

I

d

z

/

2.41 d

DDKD

DDK

66

t / /D

/

//d

d

/

t

/

/E/

d

/

2.42 DDD

//

//

//

/

2.43 DZD

,

2.44 W

DE

>DKD

DDD

66 'K

d

,:

d

D,:

ZD

d

,

t^


192/491

dZ

I

Y d

E

/

/

2.45 DK

>KZ:h^d/>s^KEt

E>D

/ d

W

^/DD

/

/

//

2.46 ,WD

,^

' , D

,

d

D,

DW

2.47 dDE

/ W D

E'E >

D

,

D

d

ED

W,

'K

d

,:

t^


193/491

WZd/ dWW

I

E

W

2.48 /D

W

E/

dE/W

2.49 ,D

D/:DD

^^D/

/

d

D

d^ //

/

D

:

^

2.50 D

t

t

d

2.51 t

D K D D

/DK

,

Y

/ d /

WD^

d

,D

d

t^

DW

d

D,:

'K

d

,:


194/491


195/491

WZd/ dWW

I

/

/

^/

^

/

/

/

2.55 D

,

d

D

WDd

D

d

Dddd

d

2.56 D

t

2.57 D

D

/

/ ^

d

//

'/

,

t^

d

D,:

t^


196/491

dZ

I

2.58 ED

D

Y dWD:t

E/

zD

z

Y /:

/:

E/

2.59 ED

Y D

tE/K

t

E

2.60 D

/ &

/WD

D

t/

^/

/

>W

d

dd

/

//

2.61 dD

D

d

,D

Z

d

D,D

t^


197/491

WZd/ dWW

I

K

2.62 /

K/

WZ

2.63 DW

DK

Y D^

t/

z

2.64 D D

,

/'//

D^D/

/

dd

^

2.65 t

D

/

^ /

/

z

t

2.66 Z

D

'K

d

,:

d

,D


198/491

dZ

I

D

ZdD'

2.67 DdD'K

dW

DZ

d:

D

Zd&D

EDD

EdZD

2.68

d

'

Z

2.69 /D

Dd

D

t

/WD

/

Y ^WD

/

Y WD

z

2.70 DD'

WD'

t^

d

,

d

D,:


199/491

WZd/ dWW

I

/

/ W

d'//

d

/

2.71 dDd

DdD

Dd

dDKW

DD

D>dD'&/

&DD>

/

WDt

^

2.72 dDD

DD>ddW

dD'

ZEE/2.73 DE/

E>

E

E/

tW

E/

W

Rupert Murdoch

2.74 ZDDD

D,

d

,

t^

DW

t^

DW

D^>


200/491

dZ

I

D

ZD d

d ^

tK

2.75 d

D>K

d d

2.76 dE

DD

Zt:^

DKD

Z:


201/491

WZd/ dWW

I

d^DD ,

D

/&//

//

/

/D

K

D /D

/

2.79 DDd^E/

^>>K^^

,D:ZD/

Dd^

2.80 DDD

^:DDD

W

2.81 KDD

DK,K

>KZ:h^d/>s^KE/

D:

^

>

d

E

/

/

ZD

d

,

ZD

d

,

d

D,:

ZD

d

,


202/491

dZ

I

>KZ:h^d/>s^KE

/

/ /

K/

/

/

2.82 DD

W,

111

E D :

dW

/

/d

/ / /

///dW

2.83 ,

2.84 & D

WE/,

114

/

&

WE/z

/

//

K/

//

W//

z/

/

2.85 K

D

'^

115d

111 ZD ZD ZD 114

d

D,:

115 ZD

d

,


203/491

WZd/ dWW

I

D&

DD 116D

ZD

DD

DD&&//'

Zt^/D&

ZD

D/>/

2.86 d^DD&&D

DD

tZ D K /

/

2.87 &DD,

,D

DD

t//

/

d/

// /

d

d

d:

116

d

D,:

t^

DWZDD

dD,:

d

D,:

ZD

t

^


204/491

dZ

I

D^/

///dW

>W

2.88 DD

^

DDD

t>/

James Murdoch

2.89 D:DZDKd

d

D:D

E/

/

/

2.90 d :D

2.91 K/K

^KD

/ / :

D,/

/W

///

2.92 dE/

d^DDt

Z

dD,D

Z ED

K

d

D,:

:

D

:Z:D

d

D,:

:D

d

D,

d

D,:


205/491

WZd/ dWW

I

:DD

d^

Rebekah Brooks

2.93 /Ztd^D>K

^^

E/

2.94 d/DD

D>

KD

D

^D

/

E

^

/

dZd

2.95 :Dt

E/Z

DD D

^

Y DD

D>&/

/

/ /^

t


206/491

dZ

I

2.97 DD:

d^EdtK

>,d^

D

DD D

DD

2.98 D

>D

///

//'

/WD/

D/

/

/

2.99 /DDtd

::K

Date post:	04-Apr-2018
Category:	Documents
Upload:	anamaco
View:	221 times
Download:	0 times

Leveson Report part 3

Documents