| Date post: | 05-Apr-2018 |
| Category: |
Documents |
| Upload: | nocompromisewtruth |
| View: | 217 times |
| Download: | 0 times |
of 78
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
1/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
813 Lv+ 7% Nkplxxba+ Kb+t 9% 8% 97% 9>%8:% 80% zz+ 988-984% 948-94% 9% 89% 88%8% 9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
10/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8
tg-4941169
9:+Idd|xnkp zxb`|dpt dbkpinkzxnmixne~z|hend xldbx` ik` dbmmlxdniee~iwineihel nkgbxmipnbk ihb|pnk`nwn`|iet ittlmhel` gxbm i eixalk|mhlx bg tb|xdlt+
@NTZ\PL@
XPT ik` BHO% zz+ 8-< %I3 Hlxa @lde+%zz+ 8-4% -7%>13 Lv+ 7% Nkplxxba+ Kb+t 9% 8% 97% 9>%8:% 80% zz+ 988-984% 948-94% 9% 89% 88%8% 9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
11/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8%8:% 80% zz+ 988-984% 948-94% 9% 89% 88%8% 9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
12/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8-99+. Gbx lvimzel% Lvfnhnpt >% 9:% ik` 99 pb pfl Hlxa @ldeixipnbk ixl
zlxtbkie-nkgbxmipnbk xlzbxpt pfip pfl Tikcl~ @lglk`ikpt ieelal`e~ xik bk Enti
Enhlxn ik` flx f|thik` Hxlkp Enhlxn+ &Tll Hlxa @lde+ 9:-94+. Pfbtl xlzbxpt `b kbp
`ltdxnhl pfl wixnb|t tb|xdlt gxbm qfndf pfl z|hend nkgbxmipnbk nt ittlmhel + &Tll
Hlxa @lde+ Lvt+ >-99+. Nk gidp% Zeinkpnggt bqk dbmzeinkp i`mnpt pfip pfl
ElvntKlvnt @lglk`ikpt zxb`|dp% ip ntt|l nk pfnt ditl% dbkpinkt nkgbxmipnbk gxbm i
wixnlp~ bg tb|xdlt% nkde|`nka bhpinkl` gxbm Abwlxkmlkpie% Tpipl ik` bpflx
lkpnpnlt+ &GID 90% 913 Lv+ 7% Nkplxxba+ Kb+t 9% 8% 97% 9>%8:% 80% zz+ 988-984% 948-94% 9% 89% 88%8% 9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
13/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8%
8:% 80% zz+ 988-984% 948-94% 9% 89% 88%8% 9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
14/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8 pb Hlxa @lde+.+.
90+\tlxt dik pflk tleldp i xlp|xkl` kiml
pb xlpxnlwl ipihitl nkgbxmipnbkittbdnipl` qnpf pfip zixpnd|eix xlp|xkl`kiml+
@NTZ\PL@
XPT ik` BHO% zz+ 8-< %I3 Hlxa @lde+%zz+ 8-4% -7%>13 Lv+ 7% Nkplxxba+ Kb+t 9% 8% 97% 9>%8:% 80%zz+ 988-984% 948-94% 9% 89% 88%8% 9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
15/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8 pb Hlxa @lde+.+.
913 Lv+ 7% Nkplxxba+ Kb+t 9% 8% 97% 9>%8:% 80% zz+ 988-984% 948-94% 9% 89% 88%8% 9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
16/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
813 Lv+ 7% Nkplxxba+ Kb+t 9% 8% 97% 9>%8:% 80% zz+ 988-984% 948-94% 9% 89% 88%8% 9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
19/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8+Zixiaxizf 901 bg pfl gnxtp imlk`l`dbmzeinkp ieelalt pfip pfl Xll` + + +@lglk`ikpt bqk% zbttltt ik` minkpink
dbkt|mlx `ipihitlt bg dbkt|mlxn`lkpnp~ ik` dxl`np nkgbxmipnbk gbx|tl nk alklxipnka ik` zxbwn`nka
hidcaxb|k` ik` dxl`np xlzbxpt + +
\K@NTZ\PL@
ElvntKlvnt @lglk`ikpt Xltzbktl? Tnkdl Zeinkpnggt `b kbp `ntz|pl pfl tpipl` gidp%
kb xltzbktl nt kldlttix~+
Ditl 6?99-dw-::06
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
20/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8
tg-4941169
8:+Pfnt tpiplmlkp nt |kpx|l it pbEKX@MN% ik` nt eixale~ |kpx|l it pbbpflxlkpnpnlt bqkl` `nxldpe~ bxnk`nxldpe~ h~ Xll` Letlwnlx Nkd+
@NTZ\PL@
XPT ik` BHO% zz+ 8-< %I3 Hlxa @lde+%zz+ 8-4% -7%>13 Lv+ 7% Nkplxxba+ Kb+t 9% 8% 97% 9>%8:% 80% zz+ 988-984% 948-94% 9% 89% 88%8% 9% Lv+I% zz+ 99-41
ElvntKlvnt @lglk`ikpt Xltzbktl pb Z|xzbxpl` @ntz|pl Kb+ 8:? Pfnt gidp nt
|k`ntz|pl`+ Pfl miplxnie dnpl` h~ Zeinkpnggt `blt kbp ltpihentf% bx lwlk t|aaltp% pfip
EKX@MN minkpinkt dbkt|mlx `ipihitlt bg dbkt|mlx n`lkpnp~ ik` dxl`np
nkgbxmipnbk gbx |tl nk alklxipnka ik` zxbwn`nka hidcaxb|k` ik` dxl`np xlzbxpt+
Nktpli`% Zeinkpnggt dnpipnbkt xleipl eixale~ pb pflnx `ntdbwlx~-xleipl` dfieelkalt
qfndf dikkbp dxlipl i alk|nkl ntt|l bg miplxnie gidp ik` qnpf qfndf ElvntKlvnt@lglk`ikpt fiwl `liep tlzixiple~ nk pflnx Bzzbtnpnbk pb Mbpnbk pb Tpxncl+ Pfl dnpl`
`ntdbwlx~-xleipl` dfieelkalt `b kbp hlix nk ik~ qi~ bk pfl t|htpikdl bg pfl tpipl`
gidp+ &Tll XPT ik` BHO 8--99+.
Ditl 6?99-dw-::06
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
21/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8+.
89+Kbkl bg pfl lkpnpnlt bqkl` `nxldpe~ bxnk nxldpe~ h~ Xll` Letlwnlx Nkd+
zxlzixl dxl`np xlzbxpt+
@NTZ\PL@
XPT ik` BHO% zz+ 8-< %I3 Hlxa @lde+%zz+ 8-4% -88% 0>-7%>13 Lv+ 7% Nkplxxba+ Kb+t 9% 8% 97% 9>%8:% 80% zz+ 988-984% 948-94% 9% 89% 88%8% 9% 49% 4> ik`Lvt+ 8-4% 7-1% >-9:% 90%ik` 9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
22/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
813 Lv+ 7% Nkplxxba+ Kb+t 9% 8% 97% 9>%8:% 80% zz+ 988-984% 948-94% 9% 89% 88%8% 9% 49% 4>3 Lvt+8-4% 7-1% >-9:% 90% 913 Lv+ 7% Nkplxxba+ Kb+t 9% 8% 97% 9>%8:% 80% zz+ 988-984% 948-94% 9% 89% 88%8% 9% 49% 4>3 Lvt+
8-4% 7-1% >-9:% 90% 9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
23/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
89-8.% tbml dbmziknlt
bqkl` `nxldpe~ bx nk`nxldpe~ h~ Xll` Letlwnlx Nkd+% t|df it ElvntKlvnt Xntc
Tdxllknka Tbe|pnbkt Nkd+ `b zxlzixl lmzeb~mlkp hidcaxb|k` tdxllknka xlzbxpt+
&Tll \kdbkpxbwlxpl` Gidp Kb+ 88 &@bdclp Kb+ 0>9-8+.+. Fbqlwlx% iee xlzbxpt tbe`
h~ dbmziknlt bqkl` `nxldpe~ bx nk`nxldpe~ h~ Xll` Letlwnlx Nkd+ pfip ixl lvzldpl`
bx nkplk`l` pb hl |tl` gbx dxl`np% nkt|xikdl% bx bpflx lenanhnenp~ `lplxmnkipnbkt% ixl
tbe` h~ lkpnpnlt bpflx pfik EKX@MN ik` ixl zxlzixl` |tnka `ipihitlt bpflx pfik pfl
Idd|xnkp `ipihitl+ &Tll \kdbkpxbwlxpl` Gidp Kb+ 84 &@bdclp Kb+ 0>9-8.+.
Pfl miplxnie dnpl` h~ Zeinkpnggt `blt kbp ltpihentf bx lwlk t|aaltp pfip ik
Idd|xnkp `ipihitl nt |tl` pb alklxipl dxl`np xlzbxpt bx pfip pfbtl xlzbxpt ixl tbe` h~
EKX@MN+ Zeinkpnggt dnpipnbkt xleipl eixale~ pb pflnx `ntdbwlx~-xleipl` dfieelkalt
qfndf dikkbp dxlipl i alk|nkl ntt|l bg miplxnie gidp ik` qnpf qfndf ElvntKlvnt
@lglk`ikpt fiwl `liep tlzixiple~ nk pflnx Bzzbtnpnbk pb Mbpnbk pb Tpxncl+ Pfl dnpl`
`ntdbwlx~-xleipl` dfieelkalt `b kbp hlix nk ik~ qi~ bk pfl t|htpikdl bg pfl tpipl`gidp+ &Tll XPT ik` BHO 8--99+.
Kbpihe~% Zeinkpnggt ipplmzp pb mnteli` pfl Db|xp qflk pfl~ tpipl pfip pfl
xlzbxpt% ippidfl` it Lvfnhnpt >% 9:% ik` 99% pb pfl Hlxa @ldeixipnbk dbkpink pfl
dbkt|mlxt g|ee tbdnie tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt+ &Tll% l+a+% Hlxa @lde+ 81% 86% 493tll
Ditl 6?99-dw-::06
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
24/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8+. Zlxzlp|ipnka pfip mnteli`nka tpiplmlkp% Mx+ Hlxa% nk fnt
`ldeixipnbk% kbpl` pfip fl xl`idpl` tbdnie tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt + + + gbx pfnt gnenka ik`
pfip pfl idp|ie `bd|mlkpt xldlnwl` gxbm pfl Tikcl~ @lglk`ikpt qlxl kbp
xl`idpl`+ &Hlxa @lde+ 81 ' k+9+. Nk`ll`% nk pfl ippidfl` xlzbxpt% Zeinkpnggt
heidcl` b|p pfl enkl klvp pb pfl fli`nka Tbdnie Tld|xnp~ K|mhlx t|aaltpnka pfip
pfl |kxl`idpl` wlxtnbkt bg pfltl xlzbxpt `ntdebtl` pfl g|ee tbdnie tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt+
&Tll% l+a+% Hlxa @lde+ Lvt+ 9:% 993tll ietb Enhlxn @lde+ Lvt+ 8% 4+. Nk gidp% pfl
|kxl`idpl` wlxtnbkt bg pfltl xlzbxpt `b kbp dbkpink pfl g|ee tbdnie tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt+
Xipflx% pfl |kxl`idpl` wlxtnbkt `ntdebtl pfl tbdnie tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt nk i px|kdipl`
gbxm h~ dbkpinknka pfl kbpipnbk VVVV it i t|htpnp|pl gbx pfl eitp gb|x Tbdnie
Tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt+ &Tll Mneelx @lde+ Lvt+ N-C+.
Gbx pfl timl xlitbk% Zeinkpnggt dnpipnbk pb wixnb|t dbxxltzbk`lkdl h~ pfl
Tikcl~ @lglk`ikpt pb Hbh \kx|f ik` Bxe~ Pinp ixb|k` Izxne 94% 8::>% nk qfndf
Klne Tikcl~ `ntd|ttl` Enti Enhlxnt zlxtbkie hidcaxb|k` ik` `ntdebtl` flx
z|xzbxpl` g|ee tbdnie tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt% dikkbp dxlipl i alk|nkl ntt|l it pb pfl tpipl`
gidpt+ &Tll Hlxa @lde+ Lvt+ 90% 9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
25/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
80-:+. It
`lmbktpxipl` h~ pfl |kxl`idpl` wlxtnbkt bg pfl xlzbxpt ippidfl` it Lvfnhnpt >
pfxb|af 99 pb pfl Hlxa @ldeixipnbk ik` it lvzeinkl` g|xpflx nk pfl ElvntKlvnt
@lglk`ikpt Bzzbtnpnbk pb Mbpnbk pb Tpxncl% Zeinkpnggt fiwl kbp mb|kpl` ik~
dxl`nhel lwn`lkdl pb dfieelkal Mx+ Tikcl~t @ldeixipnbk+
80+Idd|xnkp xlzbxpt ixl nkplk`l` pb anwl|tlxt qbxcihel eli`t pb flez n`lkpng~
ik` ebdipl izixpnd|eix nk`nwn`|ie% kbppb zxbwn`l `lgnknpnwl nkgbxmipnbk ihb|ppfip nk`nwn`|ie+
@NTZ\PL@
XPT ik` BHO% zz+ 8-< %I3 Hlxa @lde+%zz+ 8-4% -7%>13 Lv+ 7% Nkplxxba+ Kb+t 9% 8% 97% 9>%8:% 80% zz+ 988-984% 948-94% 9% 89% 88%8% 9% 49% 4>3 Lvt+8-4% 7-1% >-9:% 90% 9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
26/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8-99% 90% 9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
27/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
813 Lv+ 7% Nkplxxba+ Kb+t 9% 8% 97%9>% 8:% 80% zz+ 988-984% 948-94% 9% 89%88% 8% 9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
30/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8
tg-4941169
86+EKX@MN tbe` Idd|xnkp xlzbxpt`nxldpe~ pb t|htdxnhlxt qfb fi` lkplxl`nkpb iaxllmlkpt qnpf EKX@MN bx ikiggnenipl` dbmzik~+
@NTZ\PL@
XPT ik` BHO% zz+ 8-< %I3 ik` Hlxa@lde+% zz+ 8-4% -7% >13 Lv+ 7% Nkplxxba+ Kb+t 9% 8%97% 9>% 8:% 80% zz+ 988-984% 948-94% 9%89% 88% 8% 9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
31/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8+Kbkl bg pfl Pinp bx Tikcl~@lglk`ikpt fi` iddb|kpt qnpfEKX@MN pfip aiwl pflm iddltt pbIdd|xnkp xlzbxpt+
@NTZ\PL@
XPT ik` BHO% zz+ 8-< %I3 ik` Hlxa@lde+% zz+ 8-4% -7% >13 Lv+ 7% Nkplxxba+ Kb+t 9% 8%97% 9>% 8:% 80% zz+ 988-984% 948-94% 9%89% 88% 8% 9? Pfl miplxnie dnpl`
h~ Zeinkpnggt `blt kbp xleipl pb% elp iebkl `ntz|pl% pfl tpipl` gidp+ Nktpli`% Zeinkpnggt
dnpipnbkt xleipl eixale~ pb pflnx `ntdbwlx~-xleipl` dfieelkalt qfndf dikkbp dxlipl i
alk|nkl ntt|l bg miplxnie gidp ik` qnpf qfndf ElvntKlvnt @lglk`ikpt fiwl `liep
tlzixiple~ nk pflnx Bzzbtnpnbk pb Mbpnbk pb Tpxncl+ Pfl dnpl` `ntdbwlx~-xleipl`
dfieelkalt `b kbp hlix nk ik~ qi~ bk pfl t|htpikdl bg pfl tpipl` gidp+ &Tll XPT ik`
BHO 8- pb pfl Hlxa
@ldeixipnbk% qfndf nt i Zlbzel Tlixdf xlzbxp pfip pfl Tikcl~ @lglk`ikpt
ieelal`e~ xik bk Enti Enhlxn bk bx ixb|k` Mixdf 97% 8::>% pb klaipl pfl tpipl` gidp
nt g|pnel+ &Hlxa @lde+ 81% Lv+ >+. Tzldngndiee~% Zeinkpnggt ixa|l pfip hldi|tl pflxlzbxp n`lkpngnlt fppzt?""tld|xl+idd|xnkp+dbm"izz"hzt"mink it pfl \XE qlhtnpl
gxbm qfndf np qit z|xzbxpl`e~ xlpxnlwl`% pfl Tikcl~ @lglk`ikpt m|tp fiwl
dbk`|dpl` `nxldpe~ gxbm ik~ bg pfl Xll` @lglk`ikpt+ &Hlxa @lde+ 81+.
Ditl 6?99-dw-::06
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
32/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
83tll ietb
ElvntKlvnt @lglk`ikpt Tpiplmlkp bg \kdbkpxbwlxpl` Gidpt Kb+ 4:+. Zeinkpnggt
ixa|mlkp hitl` bk pfl tpipl` \XE plk`t pb t|zzbxp pfnt \k`ntz|pl` Gidp it np
xleiplt pb xltleelxt tleenka |k`lx pfl Idd|xnkp Hxik`+
Pf|t% pfl gidp pfip pfl xlzbxp nk`ndiplt ik Id|xnkp \XE bke~ t|aaltpt pfip np
qit xlpxnlwl` gxbm ik Idd|xnkp `ipihitl% qfndf nt dbktntplkp qnpf pfl ElvntKlvnt
@lglk`ikpt Tpiplmlkp bg \kdbkpxbwlxpl` Gidpt+ Fbqlwlx% pfip `blt kbpfnka pb
t|zzbxp Zeinkpnggt i``npnbkie nkglxlkdl pfip pfl Tikcl~ @lglk`ikpt tlixdf% qfndf
z|xzbxpl`e~ ~nle`l` pfl xlzbxp% m|tp fiwl hllk dbk`|dpl` `nxldpe~ gxbm ik~ bg pflXll` @lglk`ikpt+ It t|df% Lvfnhnp > pb pfl Hlxa @ldeixipnbk dikkbp dxlipl i
`ntz|pl it pb pfl tpipl` gidp+
Kbx `blt Zeinkpnggt xlenikdl bk pfl Tikcl~ @lglk`ikpt Mbpnbk pb Qnpf`xiq
I`mnttnbkt Z|xt|ikp pb Gl`+ X+ Dnw+ Z+ 47&h. dxlipl i alk|nkl `ntz|pl bg miplxnie
gidp+ &Tll @bdclp Kb+ 0>7-9+. Pfl y|ltpnbk ip ntt|l nk pfnt tpiplmlkp bg |k`ntz|pl`
gidp nt qflpflx pfl Tikcl~ @lglk`ikpt fi` ik iddb|kp `nxldpe~ qnpf EKX@MN+
Kbpfnka dbkpinkl` nk pfl Tikcl~ @lglk`ikpt mbpnbk t|aaltpt pfip pfl~ `b+ Pfl
ElvntKlvnt @lglk`ikpt fiwl pflmtlewlt tpipl` pfip pfl Tikcl~ @lglk`ikpt fi`
iddltt pb Idd|xnkp xlzbxpt pfxb|af pflnx iddb|kp qnpf pfl Idd|xnkp xltleelx NXH+
Ditl 6?99-dw-::06
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
33/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
813 Lv+ 7% Nkplxxba+
Kb+t 9% 8% 97% 9>% 8:% 80% zz+ 988-984%948-94% 9% 89% 88% 8%9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
34/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
813 Lv+ 7% Nkplxxba+
Kb+t 9% 8% 97% 9>% 8:% 80% zz+ 988-984%948-94% 9% 89% 88% 8%9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
38/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8%8:% 80% zz+ 988-984% 948-94% 9% 89% 88%8% 9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
44/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
813 Lv+ 7%Nkplxxba+ Kb+t 9% 8% 97% 9>% 8:% 80% zz+988-984% 948-94% 9% 89% 88% 8% 9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
49/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8%8:% 80% zz+ 988-984% 948-94% 9% 89% 88%
8% 9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
50/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8
tg-4941169
Pb pfl lvplkp pfip pfl dnpl` miplxnie nt kbp xleipl` pb Zeinkpnggt `ntdbwlx~
`ntz|plt% np `blt kbp nk ik~ qi~ `ntz|pl pfl ittlxpl` gidp+ &Tll% l+a+% Hlxa+ @lde+ 86-
8>+. Pfl dnpl` miplxnie xleiplt pb pfl kbk-GDXI z|xzbtlt pfip pfl Tikcl~
@lglk`ikpt n`lkpngnl` nk pflnx Z|hend Xldbx` Zxb`|dpt Izzendipnbk ' Iaxllmlkp
qnpf NXH% kbp qflpflx pfl NXH Izzendipnbk ' Iaxllmlkp dbkpinkl` pfl xlglxlkdl`
|tl xltpxndpnbk+ &Tll Tnmmbkt @lde+ Lv+ I+. Nk gidp% it pfl gidl bg pfl NXH
Izzendipnbk ' Iaxllmlkp miclt delix% np `n` dbkpink pfl xlglxlkdl` |tl xltpxndpnbk
ik` xly|nxl` pfl Tikcl~t pb dlxpng~ pfip pfl~ qb|e` kbp |tl ik~ bg pfl nkgbxmipnbk
Spfl~] xldlnwlS`] pfxb|af NXHtlixdf Tlxwndlt gbx ik~ zlxmnttnhel z|xzbtl |k`lx
pfl GDXI+ &N`+ 0+.
0% 8:% 80% zz+ 988-984%948-94% 9% 89% 88% 8%9% 49%4>3 Lvt+ 8-4% 7-1% >-9:%90% ik` 9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
51/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8-99 + + + gbx pfnt gnenka ik` pfip pfl
idp|ie `bd|mlkpt xldlnwl` gxbm pfl Tikcl~ @lglk`ikpt qlxl kbp xl`idpl`+ &Hlxa
@lde+ 81 ' k+9+. Nk`ll`% nk pfl ippidfl` xlzbxpt% Zeinkpnggt heidcl` b|p pfl enkl
klvp pb pfl fli`nka Tbdnie Tld|xnp~ K|mhlx t|aaltpnka pfip pfl |kxl`idpl`
wlxtnbkt bg pfltl xlzbxpt `ntdebtl` pfl g|ee tbdnie tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt+ &Tll% l+a+% Hlxa
@lde+ Lvt+ 9:% 993tll ietb Enhlxn @lde+ Lvt+ 8% 4 &`|zendiplt bg Hlxa @lde+ Lvt+ 9:%
99% xltzldpnwle~.+. Nk gidp% dbkpxix~ pb pfl mnteli`nka xl`idpnbkt ik` Zeinkpnggt
tpiplmlkpt ihb|p pfbtl xl`idpnbkt% pfl |kxl`idpl` wlxtnbkt bg pfltl xlzbxpt `b kbp
dbkpink pfl g|ee tbdnie tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt+ Xipflx% pfl |kxl`idpl` wlxtnbkt ntdebtl
pfl tbdnie tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt nk i px|kdipl` gbxm h~ dbkpinknka pfl kbpipnbk VVVV
it i t|htpnp|pl gbx pfl eitp gb|x Tbdnie Tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt+ &Tll Mneelx @lde+ Lvt+ N-C+. Nk bpflx qbx`t% Zeinkpnggt lwn`lkdl t|zzbxpt pfl |k`ntz|pl` gidp% xipflx pfik
dbkpxi`ndpnka np+
G|xpflxmbxl% Zeinkpnggt xlenikdl bk pfl `ldeixipnbkt bg Enti Enhlxn ik` Enti
Btpleei ixl g|pnel it pfl dnpl` miplxnie `blt kbp hlix bk pfl tpipl` gidp nk ik~ qi~+
&Tll Enhlxn @lde+ Lvt+ 7 &i dbz~ bg ElvntKlvnt Xntc Tbe|pnbkt qlhzial%
fppzt?""zlxtbkiexlzbxpt+elvntklvnt+dbm"% micnka kb mlkpnbk bg qflpflx Idd|xnkp
xlzbxpt dbkpink g|ee tbdnie tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt gbx pfl miobxnp~ bg d|tpbmlxt.% 1 &i
dbz~ bg Xly|ltp gbx G|ee Gnel @ntdebt|xl gbxm% micnka kb mlkpnbk bg qflpflx
Idd|xnkp xlzbxpt dbkpink g|ee tbdnie tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt gbx pfl miobxnp~ bg d|tpbmlxt.%
> &i dbz~ bg Kbwlmhlx 8>% 8:9: elpplx gxbm ElvntKlvnt Xntc Tbe|pnbkt H|xli|
EED pb Enti Enhlxn xlaix`nka flx xly|ltp gbx Xntcwnlq Dbkt|mlx @ntdebt|xl
Ditl 6?99-dw-::06
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
55/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8-
99+. Pfltl xlzbxpt tpik`nka iebkl ixl lkb|af pb z|p pfl tpipl` gidpt hl~bk` ntz|pl+
Nk fnt `ldeixipnbk% Mx+ Hlxa kbpl` pfip fl xl`idpl` tbdnie tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt
Sgxbm pfl pfxll xlzbxpt ippidfl` it Lvfnhnpt >-99 + + + gbx pfnt gnenka ik` pfip pfl
idp|ie `bd|mlkpt xldlnwl` gxbm pfl Tikcl~ @lglk`ikpt qlxl kbp xl`idpl`+ &Hlxa
@lde+ 81 ' k+9+. Nk pfl ippidfl` xlzbxpt% Zeinkpnggt heidcl` b|p pfl enkl klvp pb pfl
fli`nka Tbdnie Tld|xnp~ K|mhlx t|aaltpnka pfip pfl |kxl`idpl` wlxtnbkt bg pfltl
xlzbxpt `ntdebtl` pfl g|ee tbdnie tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt+ &Tll% l+a+% Hlxa @lde+ Lvt+ 9:%
993tll ietb Enhlxn @lde+ Lvt+ 8% 4 &`|zendiplt bg Hlxa @lde+ Lvt+ 9:% 99%
xltzldpnwle~.+. Nk gidp% dbkpxix~ pb pfl mnteli`nka xl`idpnbkt ik` Zeinkpnggt
tpiplmlkpt ihb|p pfbtl xl`idpnbkt% pfl |kxl`idpl` wlxtnbkt bg pfltl xlzbxpt `b kbp
dbkpink pfl g|ee tbdnie tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt+ Xipflx% pfl |kxl`idpl` wlxtnbkt ntdebtl
pfl tbdnie tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt nk i px|kdipl` gbxm h~ dbkpinknka pfl kbpipnbk VVVV
it i t|htpnp|pl gbx pfl eitp gb|x Tbdnie Tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt+ &Tll Mneelx @lde+ Lvt+ N-C+. Nk bpflx qbx`t% Zeinkpnggt lwn`lkdl zxbwlt pfl |k`ntz|pl` gidp% xipflx pfik
dbkpxi`ndpnka np+
G|xpflxmbxl% Zeinkpnggt xlenikdl bk pfl `ldeixipnbkt bg Enti Enhlxn ik` Enti
Btpleei ixl g|pnel it pfl dnpl` miplxnie `blt kbp hlix bk pfl tpipl` gidp nk ik~ qi~+
&Tll Enhlxn @lde+ Lvt+ 7 &i dbz~ bg ElvntKlvnt Xntc Tbe|pnbkt qlhzial%
fppzt?""zlxtbkiexlzbxpt+elvntklvnt+dbm"% micnka kb mlkpnbk qflpflx pfl tlixdflt
x|k h~ pfl Tikcl~ @lglk`ikpt nkde|`l` bx db|e` fiwl nkde|`l` Zeinkpnggt g|ee tbdnie
tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt.% 1 &i dbz~ bg Xly|ltp gbx G|ee Gnel @ntdebt|xl gbxm% micnka kb
mlkpnbk qflpflx pfl tlixdflt x|k h~ pfl Tikcl~ @lglk`ikpt nkde|`l` bx db|e` fiwl
nkde|`l` Zeinkpnggt g|ee tbdnie tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt.% > &i dbz~ bg Kbwlmhlx 8>% 8:9:
elpplx gxbm ElvntKlvnt Xntc Tbe|pnbkt H|xli| EED pb Enti Enhlxn xlaix`nka flx
Ditl 6?99-dw-::06
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
61/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8-9:% 90% 9 bg pfl Hlxa @ldeixipnbk xleipl pb pfl kbk-GDXI z|xzbtlt pfip pfl Tikcl~
@lglk`ikpt n`lkpngnl` nk pflnx Z|hend Xldbx` Zxb`|dpt Izzendipnbk ' Iaxllmlkp
qnpf NXH+ &Tll Tnmmbkt @lde+ Lv+ I+. Pfl dnpl` miplxnie `blt kbp tfl` ik~ enafp
it pb qfip EKX@MNt xldbx`t xlgeldp ihb|p zitp tlixdflt nk pfl Idd|xnkp `ipihitl+
Kbx `b Lvfnhnpt 8 ik` 4 pb pfl Enhlxn @ldeixipnbk xleipl pb pfl tpipl` gidp+
Pfbtl lvfnhnpt ixl zlxtbkie-nkgbxmipnbk xlzbxpt pfip pfl Tikcl~ @lglk`ikpt
ieelal`e~ xik bk Enti Enhlxn ik` flx f|thik` Hxlkp Enhlxn+ &Tll Enhlxn @lde+ Lvt+ 8%
4+. Dbkpxix~ pb pfl mnteli nka xl`idpnbkt ik` Zeinkpnggt tpiplmlkpt ihb|p pfbtl
xl`idpnbkt% pfl |kxl`idpl` wlxtnbkt bg pfltl xlzbxpt `b kbp dbkpink pfl g|ee tbdnie
tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt+ &Tll Mneelx @lde+ Lvt+ N-C+.
G|xpflxmbxl% Zeinkpnggt xlenikdl bk pfl `ldeixipnbkt bg Enti Enhlxn ik` Enti
Btpleei ixl g|pnel it pfl dnpl` miplxnie `blt kbp hlix bk pfl tpipl` gidp nk ik~ qi~+
&Tll Enhlxn @lde+ Lvt+ 7 &i dbz~ bg ElvntKlvnt Xntc Tbe|pnbkt qlhzial%
fppzt?""zlxtbkiexlzbxpt+elvntklvnt+dbm"% micnka kb mlkpnbk it pb qfip EKX@MNtxldbx`t xlgeldp ihb|p zitp tlixdflt nk pfl Idd|xnkp `ipihitl.% 1 &i dbz~ bg Xly|ltp
gbx G|ee Gnel @ntdebt|xl gbxm% micnka kb mlkpnbk it pb qfip EKX@MNt xldbx`t
xlgeldp ihb|p zitp tlixdflt nk pfl Idd|xnkp `ipihitl.% > &i dbz~ bg Kbwlmhlx 8>%
8:9: elpplx gxbm ElvntKlvnt Xntc Tbe|pnbkt H|xli| EED pb Enti Enhlxn xlaix`nka
flx xly|ltp gbx Xntcwnlq Dbkt|mlx @ntdebt|xl Xlzbxp% micnka kb mlkpnbk it pb
qfip EKX@MNt xldbx`t xlgeldp ihb|p zitp tlixdflt nk pfl Idd|xnkp `ipihitl.% 9: &i
dbz~ bg I T|mmix~ bg ^b|x Xnafpt \k`lx pfl Ginx Dxl`np Xlzbxpnka Idp% micnka
kb mlkpnbk it pb qfip EKX@MNt xldbx`t xlgeldp ihb|p zitp tlixdflt nk pfl
Idd|xnkp `ipihitl.% 90 &i dbz~ bg mixclpnka miplxniet gxbm ElvntKlvnt Xntc
Tbe|pnbkt qlhtnpl% micnka kb mlkpnbk it pb qfip EKX@MNt xldbx`t xlgeldp ihb|p
zitp tlixdflt nk pfl Idd|xnkp `ipihitl.% 9< &i dbz~ bg mixclpnka miplxniet gxbm
Ditl 6?99-dw-::06
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
64/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8+ &Tll Mneelx @lde+
8-
993tll ietb Enhlxn @lde+ 4-0% Lvt+ 8% 4+. It lvzeinkl` ihbwl% dbkpxix~ pb pfl
mnteli`nka xl`idpnbkt izzenl` pb pfl xlzbxpt ippidfl` it Lvfnhnpt >% 9:% ik` 99 pb pfl
Hlxa @ldeixipnbk ik` Mx+ Hlxat tpiplmlkpt ihb|p pfbtl xl`idpnbkt% pfl xlzbxpt `b
kbp `ntdebtl Enhlxnt g|ee tbdnie tld|xnp~ k|mhlxt+ &Tll Mneelx @lde+ Lvt+ N-C+.
Gbx pfl timl xlitbk% Zeinkpnggt dnpipnbk pb wixnb|t dbxxltzbk`lkdl h~ pfl
Tikcl~ @lglk`ikpt pb Hbh \kx|f ik` Bxe~ Pinp ixb|k` Izxne 94% 8::>% nk qfndf
Ditl 6?99-dw-::06
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
73/78
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
74/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8% 8:% 80% zz+988-984% 948-94% 9% 89% 88% 8% 9
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
75/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
80
8 pb pfl Hlxa @ldeixipnbk dikkbp dxlipl i
`ntz|pl it pb pfl tpipl` gidp+
Kbpl ietb pfip \k`ntz|pl` Gidp Kb+ 4: xli`t it gbeebqt? Nk i``npnbk%
EKX@MN lkplxl` nkpb iaxllmlkpt qnpf bpflx nkgbxmipnbk zxbwn`lxt &xltleelxt.
|k`lxqfndf t|df zxbwn`lxt db|e` x|k tlixdflt iainktp pfl Idd|xnkp `ipihitl pb
zxlzixl xlzbxpt pfip pfl xltleelxt tbe` pb pflnx bqk d|tpbmlxt |k`lx lnpflx pflnx bqk
hxik` bxpfl Idd|xnkp hxik`+ Zeinkpnggt ixa|mlkp hitl` bk pfl tpipl` \XE plk`t
pb t|zzbxp pfnt \k`ntz|pl` Gidp it np xleiplt pb xltleelxt tleenka |k`lx pflIdd|xnkp Hxik`+
Kbx `blt Zeinkpnggt xlenikdl bk pfl Tikcl~ @lglk`ikpt Mbpnbk pb Qnpf`xiq
I`mnttnbkt Z|xt|ikp pb GXDZ 47&h. dxlipl i alk|nkl `ntz|pl bg miplxnie gidp+ &Tll
@bdclp Kb+ 0>7-9+. Pfl y|ltpnbk ip ntt|l nk pfnt tpiplmlkp bg |k`ntz|pl` gidp nt
qflpflx pfl Tikcl~ @lglk`ikpt fi` ik iddb|kp nxldpe~ qnpf EKX@MN+ Kbpfnka
dbkpinkl` nk pfl Tikcl~ @lglk`ikpt mbpnbk t|aaltpt pfip pfl~ `b+ Pfl ElvntKlvnt
@lglk`ikpt fiwl pflmtlewlt tpipl` pfip pfl Tikcl~ @lglk`ikpt fi` iddltt pb
Idd|xnkp Xlzbxpt pfxb|af pflnx iddb|kp qnpf pfl Idd|xnkp xltleelx NXH+
Ditl 6?99-dw-::06
7/31/2019 Lexisnexis Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs Disputed Facts Doc 516
78/78
9
8
4
0
9:
99
98
94
90
9
8:
89
88
84
@ipl`? Mi~ 1% 8:98 OIMLT G+ MdDIHLMBXXNTBK ' GBLXTPLXEEZ
H~? "t Oimlt G+ MdDihl
Oimlt G+ MdDihl
Ippbxkl~t gbx Xll` Letlwnlx Nkd+%ElvntKlvnt Xntc ik` NkgbxmipnbkIkie~pndt Axb|z Nkd+% ElvntKlvnt%Nkd+% ElvntKlvnt Xntc Tbe|pnbkt% Nkd+%ElvntKlvnt DfbndlZbnkp% Nkd+%ElvntKlvnt Tlntnkp% Nkd+% `"h"iIdd|xnkp% ik` ElvntKlvnt Axb|z Nkd+
Ditl 6?99-dw-::06
