of 28
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
1/28
!"#$%&'()%*++
!"##!"#$%&"'#%!$%()*+,-.%/ $%&%'()*+,-./01'23-,/'45%6%'788%9''
2:;0)?,@)8?'A?
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
2/28#
P>?,;0)*'()*+,-./01'7*C/;/-/?
!"#$%%'()%*)"+,-%%.+/#0%/+%1/%2"3)+4/+56%78"4)$%9,,&0#:)#',6%
;/
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
3/28!Q
NORTHEAST CONSUMERWINTERFORUM
"#$"%&'()*$+,!$-../!$0123)$4)5&6$78$9'#3$':$&6)$;'=5#3$>)#2)*=$5#$;%WNRVNW%QX>LS6%ON%CP!>%WNTYZZ%QX>LS6%
VOO[%.L%WV[YZZM%QC",,H%L"#$%>'H6%\?'/5=65#3$'*$?5#3$#'&5%)=$':$:'*)%>'=1*)$=)8$$0123)$9'#3D=$2)%5=5'#$
5#$!"#"$%&'($)&*+,$-..+'"$/"$01&'23!$E'=8$.F$;GH7$IF,-FI$J479K!$.F$;GH7$IFLMNN$J479K!$
-../$O9$I-/MNN+$J;'=5#3$U*1=&=$:5>)2$?'&5'#=$&'$B5)2$'#$&6)$A:
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
4/28#
P>?,;0)*'()*+,-./01'7*C/;/-/?
:)2$&'$X$'(&
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
5/28!S
NORTHEAST CONSUMERWINTERFORUM
=)%1*5&5WB)2!$5&$5=$6'@)2$(X$&6)$%*)25&'*$=52)$&6>$@*'B52)$25%&2$=)*B)$&'$%>'12$&5&>)$&'$61#2*)2=!$5:$#'&$&6'1=X$
:'*)%>'=)2$6'?)=8$$U65=$5=$#'&$=5?@>X$
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
6/28#
P>?,;0)*'()*+,-./01'7*C/;/-/?
>",),%P#I/8I%C/+'0"0)%D8)?'+/#&?%;)0&,'+"'&/#%!B,'):%Q]CD;!^S
PH
;'*&3)%&*'#5%$a)35=&*
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
7/28U"
NORTHEAST CONSUMERWINTERFORUM
/'()+%'+"#,A)+)),_",,&0#)),%%'()%:/+'0"0)%8/"#%3+/?),,%$/),%#/'%"$I)+,)8B%
&:3"?'%'()%+&0('%'/%A/+)?8/,)%/#%"%:/+'0"0)S
56&7$0"$.89:9&$;:&'$#390/")$;;)$T1*'*H%VOONS
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
8/28#U
P>?,;0)*'()*+,-./01'7*C/;/-/?
U6)$1#2)*>X5#3$'(>53
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
9/28U!
NORTHEAST CONSUMERWINTERFORUM
7>)*S$5=$5?@'=)2$P5&6$&6)$?5#5=&)*5$21&X$':$*)%'*25#3$)*S$?1=&$X!$()%)23)=$5#=&*1?)#&=!$=1%6$
('1#2$(X$&6)$;`aH$?)?()*=65@$%'#&*
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
10/28#U
P>?,;0)*'()*+,-./01'7*C/;/-/?
#'&)=$&'$;`aH '=1*)$(X$'*52'P)*$%'1*&$&6'=1*)$(*'136&$(X$;`aH8$$U6)$>'P)*$%'1*&$)**'#)'1=>X$%'#%>12)2$&6>)%&5'#$5&535=6$>f%WRO%F!6%VOMO%.L%WYRWTRW%
Q@H%`'"(%!)3'H%VO6%VOMOS
R&?-:9 0"$F38+/C73$%&'($*&+,-$R98/+) 1/H%Z@O[UROWZ6%VOMO%.L%WOZTTMV Q78"H%933H%9=0H%T6%
VOMOS
@BD#$0"$%3--6/+96) 1/H%R-O[U>fUYWM%>9!6%VOMO%.L%VYVONOV%QDH@H%C/H%G=8B%M6%VOMOS
#6-0&/$0"$S@.
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
11/28UV
NORTHEAST CONSUMERWINTERFORUM
D3?':/: 0"$K&8-$I6'&'C6&-)$;;6%VOO[%.L%WNWWV[N%Q1H@H%>"8H%1/IH%MT6%
VOO[S
I&9&7&'6$0"$"8H%C"B%N6%
VOO[S
U&4V834$0"$.89:9&$;:&'$#3906C3/) 1/H%V-ONU?IUOMNOOU;>GU;GG6%VOO[%.L%MOYTNOY%Q@H%1)IH%
93+H%VO6%VOO[S
R93'+$0"$@BD#) VNN%7)$H%933gh%ZYM%QMM'(
>&+H%VOONS
1'$93$#E6+7) WTT%bH;H%MR[%Qb"#5+H%@H%>/8/H%VOOYSi
@BD#$0"$U3'+89&) >fOZROOWMTN!6%VOOT%.L%MVWOVTZ%Q>/##H%!=3)+H%93+H%VO6%VOOTS
PPPH @)?&,&/#, '("'%F"5)%P,,=)%4&'(%CD;!
;&'>E&9($*&+6:'&-$%&'($0"$53/-39
G#$
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
12/28#U
P>?,;0)*'()*+,-./01'7*C/;/-/?
T>='!$H'B)*)53#$252$#'&$*)35=&)*$)35=>
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
13/28UQ
NORTHEAST CONSUMERWINTERFORUM
?'B)2$:'*$*)>5):!$)$&'$;`aH8$$;`aH$5=$#'&$&6)$()#):5%5
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
14/28#U
P>?,;0)*'()*+,-./01'7*C/;/-/?
!'"#$%%C/+'0"0)U;)8"')$%b"#5+=3'?B%>",),%%C",,"?(=,)'',%
;5%6$fS$Q#5B)*=5&X$9!$R'=&'#!$;
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
15/28US
NORTHEAST CONSUMERWINTERFORUM
U6)=)$ ?
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
16/28#U
P>?,;0)*'()*+,-./01'7*C/;/-/?
W" #+&'>6'A$+:$I6-3$&$K9::H$:H$)$':$R$3)#)*>X$()$
)Z)%1&)2$(X$&6)$%*)25&'*8$$ T$%*)25&'*$5=$2):5#)2$5#$&6)$RX$
:5>)2$ P65%6$ 5#%>12)=$ &6)$ )B52)#%)$ *)\15*)2$ (X$ a1>)$ I..+$ 5=$ @*5?X$ ()$ *)(1&&)2$ P5&6$ A=1(=&
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
17/28V"
NORTHEAST CONSUMERWINTERFORUM
?'&5'#$:'*$*)>5):$:*'?$=&)28$$0'$92$?&8.&,!$IMF$R8a8$
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
18/28#V
P>?,;0)*'()*+,-./01'7*C/;/-/?
;
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
19/28V!
NORTHEAST CONSUMERWINTERFORUM
X" F3E:'/+9&+6'A$JQ'39/76G$:H$&$@:9+A&A3$
H5?5>X!$X$*)%'*2)2$?'*&3
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
20/28#V
P>?,;0)*'()*+,-./01'7*C/;/-/?
'#$&6)$G()
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
21/28VV
NORTHEAST CONSUMERWINTERFORUM
>H ;)?)#'%C",,"?(=,)'',%b"#5+=3'?B%>/=+'%>",),%
W" 1'$93$N8AA6'/)$YZ[$%"D"$W\]$O%&'(9"$F"$@&//"$X]]^P$
;`aH$='136&$*)>5):$:*'?$&6)$)2$ )#2)*!$ P=$V5#3$5):$5):$:*'?$=&
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
22/28#V
P>?,;0)*'()*+,-./01'7*C/;/-/?
*)B)$&62$&6$2)*$5#$
B5'>)$/.++!$P65%6$5#25%)23)$(
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
23/28VQ
NORTHEAST CONSUMERWINTERFORUM
Z" 1'$93$N&?3/)$Y_Y$%"D"$XZ_$O%&'(9"$F"$@&//"$X]]\P$
_5#3$ '!$5&$252$#'&$)=&5=6$&612)$&6)$5&X$&'$2$
&6
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
24/28#V
P>?,;0)*'()*+,-./01'7*C/;/-/?
^" 1'$93$L:'3/)$*:"$][TWZ^^XTL*I)$X]]\$=;$`ZY_`\^$O%&'(9"$F"$@&//"$JC+"$Y)$
X]]\P
7
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
25/28VS
NORTHEAST CONSUMERWINTERFORUM
&62$()$)=&5=6)2$&'$=6'P$7
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
26/28#V
P>?,;0)*'()*+,-./01'7*C/;/-/?
!'"#$%%C/+'0"0)U;)8"')$%b"#5+=3'?B%>",),%%C",,"?(=,)'',%
;5%6$fS$Q#5B)*=5&X$9!$R'=&'#!$;
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
27/28O"
NORTHEAST CONSUMERWINTERFORUM
:'*)%>'=5#3$@2)*$':$&6)$?'*&3
8/7/2019 Litigation Symposium - Sand in the Gears
28/28
P>?,;0)*'()*+,-./01'7*C/;/-/?
R
