of 49
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
1/49
Long Term Social Impacts andFinancial Costs of Foreclosureon Families and Communities
of Color:A Review of the Literature
W H I T E P A P E R
O C T O B E R 2 0 1 2
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
2/49
!"#$ &'$'(&)" *($ +,-.'. /0 1"' 2--#' 34 5($'0 67,-.(1#7-4 !"' (,1"7&$1"(-8 1"'9 +7& 1"'#& $,::7&1 /,1 ()8-7*;'.
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
3/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> "
!"!#$%&'!)$**+,-
#$%&'$%( )*$ +,% -../% 01 2'3%4 5*6.('+/*.
74 8'9%3 :1 2'$$ '.( ;'+$/. %B4 /9&'=+ *) +,*3%
$%=*99%.('+/*.3 *. =*996./+/%3 *) =*B*$1 ?,/3 3%=*.( &'&%$ @'3 &$%3%.+%( +* $%&$%3%.+'+/D%3 *)
9*$% +,'. JK *$I'./L'+/*.3 D/' ' .'+/*.'B +%B%&,*.% =*.)%$%.=%1 M. +,/3 &'&%$G @% $%D/%@ +,% B/+%$'+6$%
*. +,% B*.IO+%$9 3*=/'B /9&'=+3 '.( )/.'.=/'B =*3+3 *) )*$%=B*36$% *. )'9/B/%3 '.( =*996./+/%3 *) =*B*$1
3S-)$/='. -9%$/='.3 '.( :/3&'./=3ST'+/.*3 +%.( +* &6$36% *.B4 ' )%@ &'+,3G +4&/='BB4 .*+ 74 =,*/=%
76+ $'+,%$ 74 =*.3+$'/.+1 R% &*/.+ *6+ +,'+ 3 (6% +* +,% =*.=%.+$'+/*. *) +,%/$ @%'B+, /. ,*9%*@.%$3,/&1
?,%$%)*$%G 9'.4
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
4/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> a
1+;)(:A&;=(+
b>(' 2$( ;)&2 ,%>( 1()'& 8' &8G 2$( @.%2(/ A2)2(& $)& ,)*(/ &(>(')< (*8.8:%* *'%&(& 2$)2 $)>( )./ +%( >)&2 (,,(*2& 8. 2$( 8;;8'2-.%2%(&G +((.
,-'2$('G 28 ) ').=( 8, DW 28 DV ;('*(.2 %. 2$( ,-2-'( Z@A3 Y()
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
5/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> D
0 $+:
.(DDA+=;=%> (' .(L()
]$%('&%,1 2$(%' )**-:-< 5&&(A+;> E%L: $+: 4%:=$+ 2$LA% (' .$>< 5&&(A+;> B? 6$&%F ,;
6$&%F ,; 8)(9();=(+ "=;< .$>< 5&&(A+;> 4%:=$+ 2$LA% (' .$>< 5&&(A+;> R=' ("+%:S
P=$+
4$))=%:U&((( 0).9%.= &('>%*(&G (&;(*%)
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
6/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> e
#)0 R=' ("+%:S
P9$+=&UJ$;=+(
4$))=%:U&((( 2$( $%=$(&2
:(/%). >);D%+; 6%$L
,>;$;% R=' ("+%:S
P
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
7/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> d
6$&%F ,;
8)(9();=(+ (' 1+N%>;D%+; 6%$L
,>;$;% W"+%)>
4%:=$+ 2$LA% (' 1+N%>;D%+; 6%$L
,>;$;% R=' ("+%:S
3=+*L% D$L% Ck X^3
3=+*L% '%D$L% Ck X^3
5>=$+
4$))=%:U&((=+%>> 5>>%;> R=' ("+%:S
P9$+=&UJ$;=+(
4$))=%:U&(
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
8/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> c
M()&2 /%,,('(.*(& %. 2(':& 8, %.*8:(&
)./ +()=$+> iE"GeWW iVGWWW iVEaGaWW i"WDGDWW
5>=$+ 1+:=$+ "5VV "5"W W5Ca W5cd
.% "5W" "5ae "5"D "5VC
@=L=9=+( "5WD W5eW "5WC W5CC
C$9$+%>% W5CC "5de "5"E "5ED
G()%$+ W5Ed "5WW W5EE W5dE2=%;+$D%>% W5EV W5De W5CW "5Wd
W;=$+
W5dE W5"e W5ea W5DW
W;=$+ W5Ec W5de W5cE W5dc
E&+98.4 N#$9#3&9' .$ #(5G;(')=( ,8' )(
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
9/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> E
b>(' 2$( ;)&2 ,(+ 1()'&G 2$( >)&2 :)Q8'%21 8, 2).=%0('21 ')2(& &%.*( 2$( 0(=%..%.= 8, 2$( '(*(&&%8. *8:;)'(/
28 82$(' ')*%)< ='8-;&\
O8+(' $())2( &(*28' 2$). 82$(' ')*%)< ='8-;&\ B.*'()&( %. 2$( +()=> $+: ;>=(+ (+ ;
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
10/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> C
0$BL% _M 0)%+:> =+ E(D%("+%)>%F B? 6$&% $+: ,;% dc5CDk dE5Dck dC5D"k dE5Ddk dc5DEk dd5Dek
P%
cD5eek ce5V"k cd5"Ek ce5VVk cD5dck cD5Wak
HL$&I
E(A>%
DE5aVk DE5D"k DC5d"k DC5W"k Dd5CVk DD5eCk
E=>9$+=&UJ$;=+(
E(A>%
De5d"k Dc5eEk DC5Vak DC5a"k Dc5Edk Dd5eCk
5>=$+ E(A>% ea5Dak ed5EDk eC5dWk eC5cCk eE5dE ec5Eak
P
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
11/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> "W
W5dD ;('*(.2)=( ;8%.2& ,'8: VWWC 28 VW""5 3 $D(+* 5>=$+ 5D%)=&$+ $+: 8$&='=& 1>L$+:%) O)(A9>QT
0(;$L 8(9AL$;=(+V```
E(D%("+%)>%S
cdDGDeD eE5WDk "GWecG""D d"5Cdk
.% $L(+% EWaGcDd eE5DVk "G"aeGcVW dV5Vek
@=L=9=+( $L(+% eWcGdeE dW5"Ek cD"GEDW dV5"Ck
ED(+* $L(+% VdGdcV DW5"Ek DdGDCe Dd5c"k
1+:(+%>=$+ $L(+% "aG"ca aE5WEk "CGcW" e"5WWk
C$9$+%>% $L(+% aacGVVd dW5cDk aa"GEaD dD5aek
G()%$+ $L(+% aaEG"Cd DW5cak DC"GcVd Dd5CCk
J$(;=$+ $L(+% aEGcD" ea5DCk e"Gcce eC5dDk
4$L$?>=$+ $L(+% aGeDe Vc5Cak eGaWd Dc5cWk
4(+*(L=$+ $L(+% X^3 X^3 DG"C" V"5Wek
a%9$L%>% $L(+% X^3 X^3 "eG"D" VE5aCk
WI=+$"$+ $L(+% X^3 X^3 "GVae cc5cak
8$I=>;$+= $L(+% DWGecW D"5cck CDG"Ea ee5VCk
3=+*$9()%$+ $L(+% X^3 X^3 "GVWa DC5EEk
3)= J$+I$+ $L(+% dGCac e"5Wak "aGeWe ec5VVk
0$="$+%>% $L(+% aCGVCV de5Edk caGD"c dd5WVk
0
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
12/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> ""
B. )//%2%8.G +$%
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
13/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> "V
,8' '(&)('12$%.= ()'%)0)'%)0
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
14/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> "a
-&( /%,,('(.2 /%&2).*( 0-,,('&5 ]$%2)9(' )./ 7%2?;)2'%*9 ZVW"V[ ,%./ 2$)2 ,8' 2$( *)&( 8, $%=$I;8>('21
.(%=$08'$88/&G 2$( &))*).2 $8:(G "5C ;('*(.2 /-( 28 ) /()*).2
)./ /()*).2 $8:(& %& "5c ;('*(.2 )./
2$( %:;)*2 8, ,8'(*( /(,)-%.2)=(&G ):8.= (
:(2$8/&G M$-22) (2 )
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
15/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> "D
dV ;('*(.2 -./('+)2('g ZM$-22) (2 )('2$())
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
16/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> "e
0$BL% Q`M .%> B? E(A>% 2$LA%
E(A>% 2$LA% .=&h
.
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
17/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> "d
*8( (f-%21G *8:;)'(/ 28 dV ;('*(.2 .(=)2%>( (f-%21 %. M$-22) (2 )%*( 0-'/(. '(( 28 %.*8:(5
]$%2( ZVW"W[ ;8%.2& 8-2 2$)2 2$( >)&2 :)Q8'%21 8, -./('+)2(' 08''8+('& $)& .82 +)(1 /)2) ;8%.2&5 ]%2$ '(=)'/ 28 :8>(:(.2&8-2 8, $8:(8+.('&$%;G 2$( )-2$8'& ,8-./ 2$)2 2$( ;8>('21 )./ (f-%21 &2)2-&(& :)22(' :8&25 N8'(
&;(*%,%*)(1 +$8 (/ 0((
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
18/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> "c
3(:(.2 %.28 $8:(8+.('&$%;G 2$( )-2$8'& ,8-./G %.2('(&2%.=( :8'( 2$). 2+%*( 2$( ;'80)0%%.= ,'8: '(.2%.= 28 8+.%.= )&
.8.IL%&;).%* l]n$%2(& l+$%(. S8*$$)' (2 )(1& ZVWWe )./ VWWC[5 N8'( '(&()'*$ %. /%,,('(.2 *8::-.%2%(& &$8- (+ 6%L(&$;=(+ (' @$D=L=%> $+: .(DDA+=;=%> (' .(L()
]$%8(
0((. &2-/%(/ (_2(.&%>(( 0((. ),,(*2(/ 01 2$( ,8'(*
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
19/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> "E
#)0( &$8+& 2$)2 ) $%=$(' ;'8;8'2%8. 8, &2-/(.2& %.= %. ;'8;('2%(& (.2('%.= ,8'(*('21G =')/(G )./ 8'%=%.)< &*$88( ;('*(.2 (< +$%( )& 0)&( *)&( %. 2$( '(='(&&%8.\ &(( #)0(
0((. :%_(/ Z)./ 2$(&( '(&-).*(/ %. N)2$
I k #(&2%.= H'8,%*%(.2^3/>).*(/ %. Y()/%.=
X-:0(' 8, A2-/(.2&
eWk
aDk
E"k
"ak
"ak
cDk
eak
"GCCE
Ddk
aek
cck
""k
"Dk
dVk
DEk
"GCed
IDk
"k
IDk
Iakvvv
Wk
I"Vkvvv
Iekvvv
.;=&> (' 3& (' . !"#,+;%)=+* @()%&L(>A)% P).*(/ %. Y()/%.=
X-:0(' 8, A2-/(.2&
aWk
D"kcck
"Ek
"Dk
cck
eck
ECGaCe
a"k
D"kcDk
"ak
"Dk
dek
e"k
ECGVeE
"k
I"kIakvv
Iekvvv
Wk
I"Vkvvv
Iekvvv
E&+98.4 P..' .$ #(7 G;
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
20/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> "C
!"#$%&R.00 $2#' &'. 3.98.'$ &D 0$+B.'$0 6.9. .S8(+B.B D9&* $2. #'#(,0%0 .#82 ,.#9 I.8#+0. $2.,
#$$.'B.B 03.8%#( .B+8#$%&' 082&&(0T U %'B%8#$.0 $2#$ $2. 39&I#I%(%$, $2#$ $2. B%DD.9.'8.0 #9. 9#'B&* %0
(.00 $2#' J 3.98.'$T UU 39&I#I%(%$, (.00 $2#' F 3.98.'$T UUU 39&I#I%(%$, (.00 $2#' 7F 3.98.'$7
M((. (2 ) Q ;W)=*=+ 3& a%=* (' a%=* '"#=+ HA=L:=+*> ,+;%)=+*@()%&L(>A)% P('21I k b+.('Ib**-;%(/ @.%2&X-:0(' 8, A2-/(.2&
aWkaVkVDkVEk
ECGaCe
VEkVCkVVkVCk
ECGVeE
I"kIak
IVkvvvWk
E&+98.4 P..' .$ #(7 G;(G :8>(&G '(=)'/
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
21/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> VW
28 82$(' ='8-;& %& f-%2( $%=$K CW ;('*(.2 %. M)(/ %. M);=+$;=(+ a%=*%.=7'(( 8'Y(/-*(/ H'%*(N()
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
22/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> V"
:-)'%)2( '(='(&&%8.G H(22%2 )./ 68:(1 ZVW"V[ ,%./ 2$)2 g&2-/(.2& %. $8:(& %. ,8'(*(/ 28 .(%=$08'$88/& +%2$ &%=.%,%*).2 %.*'()&(& %. 2$(
Q->(.%W)=*=+M
3;A:%+;> =+@()%&L(>%:
E(D%>
^%>;=+$;=(+M5LL 3;A:%+;>
^%>;=+$;=(+M3;A:%+;> =+@()%&L(>%:
E(D%>
^=''%)%+&%M 5LL3;A:%+;>
^=''%)%+&%M3;A:%+;> =+@()%&L(>%:
E(D%>
H$L;=D()%
kM).*(/ 8. N)2$
eVk eVk eDk edk V5Wk a5Ck
X-:0(' 8, A2-/(.2& "EGeDa acD
P$>%.= 7'(( 8'
Y(/-*(/ H'%*( N()).*(/ 8. N)2$
cck cDk dek dVk I"V5Dk I"V5Wk
X-:0(' 8, A2-/(.2& C"GaCa "GCCE
E&+98.4 N.$$%$ #'B )&*., G;
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
23/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> VV
:()< '(*%;%(.2&G 2$(1 :8>( 28 .(%=$08'$88/& +%2$ ) $%=$(' ;'8;8'2%8. 8, L%&;).%*&^O)2%.8&5 B. 2(':& 8,
)*)/(:%* )*$%(>(:(.2&G ,%./%.=& +('( :%_(/5 B. M)).*(/ %. 082$ '()/%.= )./ :)2$5
B. ])&$%.=28.G T6G &2-/(.2& :8>(/ 28 &*$88('G &2-/(.2& :8>(/ 28 &*$88( ) ( (/-*)2%8. 8-2*8:(&G %.*
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
24/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> Va
Y(=)'/%.= :8'2=)=( /)2)G 2$( VWW" Y(&%/(.2%)< 7%.).*( A-'>(1 ZY7A[G &;8.&8'(/ 01 #$( T(;)'2:(.2 8,
L8-&%.= )./ @'0). T(>(%/( /)2) )08-2 2$( ,%.).*%.= 8, .8.,)':G ;'%>)2((+> '() 0$I=+* (A; $ E(D% ,XA=;? J=+% (' .)%:=; B? 3=+*L%K@$D=L? E(D%("+%)> "=;< $ E(D% ,XA=;?
J=+% (' .)%:=;
Q\\Q V``Q
4$I% $::=;=(+>F =D9)(N%D%+;>F () )%9$=)> ;( ;(L=:$;% :%B;> Vdk V"k
8A)&% $A;( () (;( -&(/ 8.
0($)
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
25/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> VD
0$BL% QZM 6%>9(+>%> ;( cA%>;=(+ j^=: ?(A A>% 9%)>(+$L L($+> g')(Dh $ B$+I ;( '=+$+&% ;(LA;% aADB%)R8)(9();=(+S
6%>9(+>%M 7%> 6%>9(+>%M a( 0(;$L aADB%) ('6%>9(+>%>
V``[ EWc
Z"d5edk[
DGWdc
ZEa5DDk[
DGEcD
Z"WWk[
V``Y e"e
Z"a5edk[
aGDdD
ZEc5Wdk[
aGCcC
Z"WWk[
V``_ D"CZ"V5a"k[
VGCEdZEc5dCk[
aGDWeZ"WWk[
V``Z VCd
Z"W5"Vk[
VGdVC
ZEC5EEk[
VGCVe
Z"WWk[
V``b VdW
ZC5Cek[
VGaeD
ZCW5Wek[
VGd"D
Z"WWk[
E&+98.4 W#+DD*#' A&+'B#$%&' G'7B7HL 8#(8+(#$%&'0 &D $&$#(0 #'B 39&3&9$%&'0 +'B.9$#X.' I, #+$2&90
]$%( ,%.).*%)< %.&2%2-2%8.& 8' 82$(' ;(8;(/ 2$( ,%'&2 8-2&%/( ,-./%.= ,'8: ,%.).*%)< %.&2%2-2%8.& 8' 82$(' ;(8;
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
26/49
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
27/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> Vd
.;=& 6%>=:%+;=$L HA>=+%>> 1+N%>;D%+; 5LL 6%$L ,>;$;%
V``b
V``\
V`Q`
V`QQ
0(;$L W"+%: 4();*$*% 0(;$L W"+%: 4();*$*% 0(;$L W"+%: 4();*$*% 0(;$L W"+%: 4()
/9>=:%K^("+ Ek
Ck
dk
"Dk
Ck
"Wk
ck
"dk
"ak
"ek
"Wk
VVk
"k
ak
"k
Vk
Dk
Vk
Dk
""k
dk
dk
dk
"ck
ak
ak
ak
Dk
dk
dk
Ek
""k
"Vk
"Vk
"ek
"ek
""k
"ak
Ek
"Ek
""k
"Dk
Ck
VWk
"D
"C
"V
Vd
4();*$*%:'() HA>=+%>>
8A)9(>%>
"Ek"dk
"ek
"Dk
"Ck"ck
"dk
"dk
VdkVek
VDk
VVk
ekdk
Vk
ek
Ck"dk
Ck
VVk
VWkVWk
VWk
aek
Vkek
Vk
ak
dkdk
ek
"Wk
""k""k
Ck
"Ek
VakV"k
"ck
"Ck
VDkVVk
"Ek
V"k
aWVC
V
Vd
/>%: $>
.(LL$;%)$L
Ck
dk
ck
""k
"Wk
ck
ck
"Vk
"ak
"Wk
""k
"ck
ck
Dk
Dk
ek
"Ck
""k
"Ck
VDk
aWk
aWk
aWk
aEk
Vk
ak
Vk
Vk
ek
ek
dk
ek
"Wk
"Wk
"Vk
Ck
"dk
""k
""k
"ek
"ck
"Dk
""k
"dk
V
"d
"d
V
a dCW
dae
caD
cac
deD
d"E
dCa
dcV
Dc"
D"d
Dec
DcE
dCW
dae
caD
cac
aVD
VDE
aVD
VaC
"CE
"ae
"CE
"ec
dCW
dae
caD
cac
a"D
VcE
a"W
VEd
"eE
"dE
"dd
"eE
dCW
dae
caD
caD
ddE
dWC
cWE
dEE
e
D
e
e
E&+98.4 Y.''%0 G;
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
28/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> Vc
0$BL% Q\M 3ADD$)? (' 1D9L=&$;=(+> (' ; ;( 6%N=>% ;%>i 3;)A&;A)%>6%%>;$BL=>< $>O(N%)+D%+;K39(+>()%:,+;%)9)=>%> RO3,>S
,>;$BL=>< O(N%)+D%+;.()9()$;=(+ () 5*%+&?
8)=N$;=m% () 0%)D=+$;%
5B=L=;? ;( 9)(N=:% L=XA=:=;?$+: >A99(); ;( D();*$*%D$)I%;>
Y(*8.&2%2-2%.= 2$((.2(';'%&(& )& UA4& :)1;'8>%/( ('G)& ,8'I;'8,%2 (.2%2%(&G 2$(%'*);)*%21 28 &-;;8'2$8-&%.= ,%.).*( /-'%.=&2'(&&,-< (*8.8:%* ;('%8/&%& 8;(. 28 f-(&2%8.5
3 =8>('.:(.2 (.2%21G +%2$)**(&& 28 #'()&-'1I%&&-(//(02G :)1 0( ;8&%2%8.(/28 ;'8>%/( :8'2=)=(
78'I;'8,%2 &2)2-& )./(('.:(.2 &;8.&8'&$%;5
N)1 :%2%=)2( '%&9 /-( 28
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
29/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> VE
B. T(*(:0(' VW"WG #$( 68.='(&&%8.)< M-/=(2 b,,%*( Z6Mb[ &-0&(f-(.2(. 2$( *8&2 28 2)_;)1('& 8, 2$(
=8>('.:(.2 2)9(8>(' 8, 2$( UA4& )./ =%>(. 2$( &2'-*2-')< +()9.(&&(& 2$)2 *8.2'%0-2(/ 28 2$( ,%.).*%)%&A)=;=m%)>
@./(' g;-0>A%)> (' 9)=N$;%KL$B%L 4H3>
A('>( 08''8+('& +$8&(:8'2=)=(& /8 .82 f-)( 08''8+('& +$8&(:8'2=)=(& /8 .82 f-)
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
30/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> VC
0$BL% VQM G%? @$&;()> '() 5>>%>>=+* 5L;%)+$;=N%> '() ;( '%&92)9%.=5 O%:%2%.= =8>('.:(.2=-)').2((& )./ *$)'=%.='%&9I0)&(/ ;'%*(& ,8' 2$(:+8-)2( %.2(':(/%)'%(&+8-( ). %.*(.2%>( 28&(2 '%&9I0)&(/ ;'%*(& )./:8.%28' '%&9 2)9%.=5
L)>%.= 2$( =8>('.:(.2)0&8'0 )( '%&92)9%.= 01 8'%=%.)28'&5 #$(=8>('.:(.2 *8-( 28 :).)=('%&9G 0-2 %2 +8-
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
31/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> aW
E?B)=: 8ABL=&U8)=N$;%4(:%L
@ALL? @%:%)$L 5*%+&? @ALL? 8)=N$;% 4$)I%;
W;=:%)$;=(+> T(;(./%.= 8. 2$( :8/((' 2$( &(*8./)'1:8'2=)=( :)'9(2 *8-
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
32/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> a"
A-0&(f-(.2(&2:(.2 28&-;;8'2 ,-2-'( 0-&%.(&&5 #$( f-(&2%8. %& +$(2$(' 28 %:;'8>( 2$( *-''(.2 %.,')&2'-*2-'( 8' 28
*8.&%/(' 2$%& ). 8;;8'2-.%21 28 0-%)28'&$%;& )./ /(,%.( ) ;)2$ ,8' $8-&%.= ,%.).*(5 O(=%&( ;'8;8&)( 0(=-. 28
(:('=(G 0-2 (.)*2:(.2 &88. );;()'& -.(LA;% 5D(A+; $+: 8)(9();=(+> (' /#3# 6%>=:%+;=$L 4();*$*% W)=*=+$;=(+>F Q\\` ;( V`Q`
E&+98.4 \%((0$.%' G;
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
33/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> aV
@=*A)% VM 8)(9();=(+ (' 6%>=:%+;=$L 4();*$*% W)=*=+$;=(+> 3%&A)=;=m%:F V``Q ;( V`QQ
E&+98.4 \%((0$.%' G;(' 2$( ;)&2 ,(+ 1()'&G *8::('*%)< 0).9& $)>( '(2'(.*$(/ ,'8: $8-&%.= ,%.).*(G )& &$8+. %. 7%=-'(& a
)./ D 0(;$;% J($+> E%L: B? .(DD%)&=$L H$+I>F V``b ;( V`QQ
E&+98.4 \%((0$.%' G;
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
34/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> aa
@=*A)% [M 5D(A+; (' 8)=N$;%KJ$B%L 4();*$*% H$&I%: 3%&A)=;=%> 1>>A%:F V``` ;( V`Q`
E&+98.4 \%((0$.%' G;)%(' 2$( ;)&2 &(>(')< 1()'&G .-:('8-& ;'8;8&)
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
35/49
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
36/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> ae
#$( 2+8 :)%. (('.:(.25 #$( NM3 &-==(&2& 2$)2 2$( N6U4&
g&$8-%/(%.>(&28'& )&&-').*( 2$)2 2$(%' ;'%.*%;)< )./ %.2('(&2 +%%.=& /(;8&%2& 2$'8-=$ 2$(
7(/(')< T(;8&%2 B.&-').*( 68';8')2%8. Z7TB6[h X)2%8.)< 3&&8*%)2%8. 8, L8:( M-%
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
37/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> ad
N%%/( ). (_;)2( *);%2)< H'%>)2( :8'2=)=( %.&-'('& )./ &(*-'%2%?('& :-&2 0( )/(f-)2(('.:(.2 0)%)2( NMA %.&-'('& ,8' &),(21G &8-./.(&&G )./
*);%2)< )/(f-)*15 #$( 7NB6 +8-
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
38/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> ac
@.(')'*$%.= ;'%.*%;('1 /)1 )./ %. (>('1
*8::-.%21G 2$'8-=$
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
39/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> aE
@=*A)% ZM .(D9$)=>(+ (' 8)=D$)? @A+&;=(+$L 6%>9(+>=B=L=;=%> =+ O(N%)+D%+;KH$&I%: 3%&A)=;=m$;=(+
E&+98.4 \&9$:#:. A%'#'8. ]&9X%': Q9&+3 G;)2( (.2%2%(& %.&2()/ 8, 7)..%( N)( )./ 7'(//%( N)*G +8-)2( %.>(&28'& 8, :8'2=)=(I0)*9(/ &(*-'%2%(&G +$%*$ +8-
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
40/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> aC
#$( N8'2=)=( 7%.).*( ]8'9%.= U'8-; ZVW""[ (&2%:)2(& 2$)2 2$( *8&2 8, ) aWI1()' ,%_(/ ')2( :8'2=)=(
+8-('.:(.2 &-;;8'2 +%)'/
@.%>('&%21G VW"V[ &-'>(1(/ "GWWW '(=%&2('(/ g('1 %:;8'2).2G ,8' (%=$2 ;('*(.2 %2 +)& &8:(+$)2 %:;8'2).2G )./ ,8'
&%_ ;('*(.2 %2 +)& .82 %:;8'2).2 )2 )( 1()'& )=85 #$%'21I2$'(( ;('*(.2 &2)2(/ 2$)2 $8:(8+.('&$%; +)& :8'( %:;8'2).2G ,%,21I8.( ;('*(.2
).&+('(/ 2$)2 %2 +)& Q-&2 )& %:;8'2).2G )./ "V ;('*(.2 2$)2 %2 +)& )*1G
)./ "V ;('*(.2 ;8%.2(/ 8-2 82$(' '()&8.&5
]$%(' 2$( +()
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
41/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> DW
)2 2$( ;()9 8, 2$( $8-&( ;'%*( 0-00
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
42/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> D"
6%'%)%+&%>
3.)*9('G S)2'%. M5 VW"V5 #$( 4,,(*2 8, A-0;'%:( )./ 3(5=)85=8>^2V;0)2D^"eWcVD5;/,
M8*%).G T(00%( U'-(.&2(%.G O%G ](%G Y(%/G 6)'8
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
43/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> DV
6(.2(' ,8' Y(&;8.&%0( 4f-%215 A).2) 3.)G 63K 68'(O8=%*5 $22;K^^+++5*8'((I(f-%215)&;_
68+(.G A;(.*(' )./ M-%2')=8G S)2%(5 VW"V5 E$9+::(%': $& E$#, ZD($4 ".:#$%/. ab+%$, %' )&**+'%$%.0 &D )&(&9 %' $2.
)2%8#:& E%S )&+'$, -.:%&'5 6$%*)=8G BOK ]88/&28*9 B.&2%2-2(5 $22;K^^+++5+88/&28*9%.&258'=^0
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
44/49
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
45/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> DD
O%.G x$(.=-8G Y8&(.0(
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
46/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> De
H(22%2G S)2$'1. O5 A5 )./ 68:(1G F(..%,('5 VW"V5 @2. A&9.8(&0+9. )9%0%0 #'B )2%(B9.'4 Z @29..=)%$, E$+B,5
])&$%.=28.G T6K #$( @'0). B.&2%2-2(5 $22;K^^+++5-'0).58'=^@;^.(+&(>(.2&^&;((*$ ')&9%.VW"VW"Wc)5$2:
Y()%.(G 63K Y()%/(.*(G YBK @AVW"W H'8Q(*25
$22;K^^+++5&D50'8+.5(/-^@AVW"W^T)2)^Y(;8'2^'(;8'2WaV"VW"V5;/,
Y8&(.='(.G 4'%* A5 VW"W5 Y(:)'9& )2 2$( 7(/(')< Y(&('>( 68.,('(.*( 8. Y4b )./ P)*).2 H'8;('21 A2')2(=%(& ,8'
X(%=$08'$88/ A2)0%('.:(.2 A;(./%.=G
68::%22(( 8. b>('&%=$2 )./ U8>('.:(.2 Y(,8':G L8-&( 8, Y(;'(&(.2)2%>(&5 ])&$%.=28.G T6K @5A5 U8>('.:(.2
3**8-.2)0%^.(+5%2(:&^/"VaD5;/,
A$);%'8G #$8:)& N5 VWWD5 @2. _%BB.' )&0$ &D P.%': ZD9%8#' Z*.9%8#'4 _&6 ].#($2 N.93.$+#$.0 C'.b+#(%$,5 b_,8'/K
b_,8'/ @.%>('&%21 H'(&&5
A$%
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
47/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> Dd
8+.)%*(&^7A`N8'=).A2).^$$(&^+++^',&^/VCWW5;/,
@5A5 M-'()- 8, 2$( 6(.&-&5 VWWW5 @5A5 6(.&-& VWWW5 $22;K^^,)*2,%./('V5*(.&-&5=8>
@5A5 T(;)'2:(.2 8, 2$( #'()&-'1 )./ @5A5 T(;)'2:(.2 8, L8-&%.= )./ @'0). T(>((^%.%2%)2%>(&^/8*-:(.2&^'(,8':%.=kVW):('%*)|&kVW$8-&%.=kVW,%.).*(kVW:)'9(25;/,
@5A5 U8>('.:(.2 3**8-.2)0%(&5 L()'%.= 8. gUA4 Y(,8':K B::(/%)2(
A2(;& 28 H'82(*2 #)_;)1('& )./ 4./ 2$( M)%
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
48/49
"#$%&'#( )&**+'%$, -.%'/.0$*.'$ )(%$%&' 1 2$$34556667'8987&9:1 ;;?=??>> Dc
]$%2)9('G A2(;$). )./ 7%2?;)2'%*9 BPG #$8:)& F5 VW"V5 @2. C*3#8$ &D c#8#'$L @#S=Y.(%'b+.'$ #'B A&9.8(&0.B
N9&3.9$, &' E#(.0 N9%8.0 &D ".%:2I&9%': _&*.05 6(( M).9 8, 6(
8/13/2019 Long-Term Social Impacts and Financial Costs of Foreclosure on Families and Communities of Color
49/49
727 15th Street, NW, Suite 900Washington, DC 20005202.628.8866 | www.ncrc.org