Low Power Wide Area Networks: Simple Access Technologies to Create the Big Data
Dr. Juan Nogueira. Cambridge Wireless, December 14h 2017
1
Big Data Sources
Walmart: 1 Mio. customer
transactions / hour.
Facebook: 30+ Petabytes user
generated data.
Tweeter: 230+ Mio. of tweets/day.
Amazon: 258+ Mio sales /
minute
298 Bi. Mails/ Day
Snapchat: 527K+ photos
shared / minute
The Weather Channel: 18 Mi. forecasts requests / minute
??
Speed
Reliable
Mobility
L4
2
Why LPWAN Technologies?
Low costModems < 1.5 - 5$ Fees < 1$/Y, 5ct/month,
of 150 dBs
Long RangeLink budgets in excess
of 150 dBs
Low PowerSimilar to common short
range transceivers.
Low Throughput100bps up to 200Kbps
3
LPWAN Technologies role in The IoT Ecosystem
(SOURCE: RIOT RESEARCH. LPWAN REVENEU FORECAST 2017 - 2023
LPWAN technologies will generate close to $ 3B only in the LPWAN module business by 2023
Three technologies (LoRa, SigFox, NB_IoT) will concentrate 90% LPWAN technologies in the market by 2023.
(SOURCE: ERICSOON, ERICSSON MOBILITY REPORT, JUNE 2016
SOURCE: VODAFONE IoT BAROMETER 2017/18
5
Flex Selected LPWAN technologies
• Sigfox: Technology summary
• Ultra Narrow Band (100Hz) • Less noise comes into the receiver
• achieves high sensitivity (-159dBm) • 156dB Link Budget.
• Rural 30 – 50km • Urban 3 – 10km• Good indoor penetration
• Good coverage• No Roaming problems • Cost:
• Connection prices from ~ 12€ / year / device• HW: Modules for <2$ and ICs for < $ 90ct
• Ultra Narrow Band (100Hz) • Less noise comes into the receiver
• achieves high sensitivity (-159dBm) • 156dB Link Budget.
• Rural 30 – 50km • Urban 3 – 10km• Good indoor penetration
• Good coverage• No Roaming problems • Cost:
• Connection prices from ~ 12€ / year / device• HW: Modules for <2$ and ICs for < $ 90ct
6
Flex Selected LPWAN technologies
• Sigfox: Limitations
• Very low data rate 100bps • Long Time-on-Air
• 12Bytes 2sec Tx time • higher power consumption & collision probability.
• Data communication limitations:• Uplink:
• EU 1% Duty Cycle / hour 72Bytes/hour 140 messages/12Bytes/day
• US 400ms dwell time 288 bits / min • Downlink: max x4 8Bytes/day almost unidirectional
• Weak security (no encryption)• Sigfox is an unique Network Operator
• Very low data rate 100bps • Long Time-on-Air
• 12Bytes 2sec Tx time • higher power consumption & collision probability.
• Data communication limitations:• Uplink:
• EU 1% Duty Cycle / hour 72Bytes/hour 140 messages/12Bytes/day
• US 400ms dwell time 288 bits / min • Downlink: max x4 8Bytes/day almost unidirectional
• Weak security (no encryption)• Sigfox is an unique Network Operator
7
Flex Selected LPWAN technologies
• Sigfox: Architecture
Free FW Licensing
Silicon Vendors
Silicon Vendors
SOURCE: SIGFOX
8
Flex Selected LPWAN technologies
• Sigfox: Coverage
17 countries with national coverage (Sept 2017)
SOURCE: SIGFOX
SOURCE: SIGFOX
10
Flex Selected LPWAN technologies
• Sigfox Admiral Ivory: Ultra low cost Towards disposable IoT
… to transform any short- range wireless device into a long-range IoT, with a hardware component as little as $0.20, and as simple as the one that you find in a garage door remote control.
SOURCE: SIGFOX
11
Flex Selected LPWAN technologies
• LoRa : Technology summary
• Spread Spectrum Technology• Tx below noise floor Intrinsic security
• Three device classes• A,B,C for different use case requirements
• Deep indoor penetration• IEEE 802.15.4 Security layer and encryption E2E • Standardized & open MAC protocol LoRaWAN• Public & private networks• LoRa Alliance Ecosystem (>450 members)• Cost:
• LoRa module (100K units) $7.5, • Flex LoRa modem BOM $4.25
• Spread Spectrum Technology• Tx below noise floor Intrinsic security
• Three device classes• A,B,C for different use case requirements
• Deep indoor penetration• IEEE 802.15.4 Security layer and encryption E2E • Standardized & open MAC protocol LoRaWAN• Public & private networks• LoRa Alliance Ecosystem (>450 members)• Cost:
• LoRa module (100K units) $7.5, • Flex LoRa modem BOM $4.25
12
Flex Selected LPWAN technologies
• LoRa : Technology summary
• Multiple spreading factors • Adaptive data rate 300 bps – 30 Kbps
• Multiple spreading factors • Adaptive data rate 300 bps – 30 Kbps
SOURCE: SEMTECH
13
Flex Selected LPWAN technologies
• LoRa: Limitations
• Roaming needs to be solved• Scalability, multiple providers, spectrum / network congestion • Data communication limitations:
• Uplink: • EU 1% Duty Cycle / hour
• It depends on SF12 x3 SigFox, SF7 x55 SigFox• US 400ms Dwell time
• SF12 & SF11 not allowed. • Range compensated with higher Tx Power
• Downlink: Every message is Acknowledged. bidirectional
• Roaming needs to be solved• Scalability, multiple providers, spectrum / network congestion • Data communication limitations:
• Uplink: • EU 1% Duty Cycle / hour
• It depends on SF12 x3 SigFox, SF7 x55 SigFox• US 400ms Dwell time
• SF12 & SF11 not allowed. • Range compensated with higher Tx Power
• Downlink: Every message is Acknowledged. bidirectional
14
Flex Selected LPWAN technologies
• LoRa: Ecosystem
End Node IP Core Licensing
Silicon Vendors
Unique GW Chips Provider
Open SW - Promotion
GW Providers
Eco System
15
Flex Selected LPWAN technologies
• LoRa: Ecosystem
Silicon/Modules GatewaysDevices Network Server Application Server
LoRa RF LoRaWAN
TCP/IP SSLLoRaWAN
TCP/IP SSLSecure Payload
AES Encrypted Secured Payload Application Data
17
Flex Selected LPWAN technologies
• LoRa: Coverage • 50 Announced Public Network Operators• 45 Alliance Member Operators• 350+ on-going trials & city deployments• 500+ members in the Alliance
Legend:
Country with Publicly Announced Network
Other LoRaWAN deployment
September 2017SOURCE: LoRa Alliance
18
Flex Selected LPWAN technologies
• LTE Cat-M/NB_IoT: 3GPP Targets
• Optimized for low cost < $5 and low power• 10 years feasible in many scenarios with very low duty
cycle• Extended coverage:
• 20 dB better than existing cellular • Deep indoor penetration
• Narrowband (180 kHz channels)• Huge numbers of terminals per cell (10s of 1000s)
• Reuses existing cellular infrastructure • Licensed Spectrum No interferences• End2End Security
• Optimized for low cost < $5 and low power• 10 years feasible in many scenarios with very low duty
cycle• Extended coverage:
• 20 dB better than existing cellular • Deep indoor penetration
• Narrowband (180 kHz channels)• Huge numbers of terminals per cell (10s of 1000s)
• Reuses existing cellular infrastructure • Licensed Spectrum No interferences• End2End Security
19
LPWAN Technologies: 3GPP answer to LPWAN NB_IoT
• 3GPP Release 13 Cellular IoT Evolution CIoT GERAN Clean sheet proposals
• NB-M2M (Neul-Huawei, u-blox, Ericsson, Samsung)• NB-OFDMA (Qualcomm)• C-UNB (derivative of SIGFOX)• NB-CSS (Semtech, derivative of LoRa)• NB-CIoT (NB-M2M + NB-OFDMA) (Qualcomm, Neul-Huawei, u-blox)
GSM Evolution proposals• NB-GSM• EC-GSM (Ericsson)
TR 45.820 GERAN selection process
Move forward• LTE-M 1.4MHz• EC-GSM
Clean sheet for further refinement• NB-CIoT• NB-LTE RP-151621
RAN #70 selection process December 2015
Output for R13• EC-GSM• LTE-M 1.4MHz Cat M1• NB_CIoT + NB-LTE NB_IoT = CatM2 = CatNB1
NB_CIoTEC-GSM
TR 36.88RAN #69 selection process September 2015
CIoT RAN Clean sheet proposal• NB-LTE (Ericsson, Nokia, MTK, AT&T, Sprint)
LTE Evolution proposal• LTE-M 1.4MHz BW
R13 specification June 2016
6PRB reserved for
control
Cat M2 in-guard band20
180kHz from 12x15kHz subcarriers (OFDMA downlink)
LTE 180kHz PRB(Physical Resource Block)
LTE Cat M2200KHz from 1 x 180kHz + 20kHz guard bands
Typical 5MHz LTE 5MHz with 25 x 180kHz + 500kHz guard bands
LTE Cat M11.4MHz with 6 x 180kHz + 320kHz guard bands
Cat M2 in-band
Cat M2 in 200kHz GSM no guard Cat M2 in 200kHz GSM with guard
Cat M1 in-band
Flex Selected LPWAN technologies
• LTE Cat-M/NB_IoT
21
LPWAN Technologies: 3GPP answer to LPWAN NB_IoT
• 3GPP Release 13 Cellular IoT Evolution
LTE-MTC (Cat-0) EC-GSM NB-CIoT NB-LTE
3GPP Release 3GPP Rel 12 3GPP Rel 13 3GPP Rel 13 Candidate 3GPP Rel 13 Candidate 3GPP Rel 13 Candidate
Technology Based on LTE Based on LTE GERAN Clean-slate Clean-slate
DL peak data rate 1 Mbps 200 kbps DL 360kbs, UL 48kbps DL 128kbs, UL 64kbps DL peak data rate
Bandwidth 20 MHz 1.4 MHz 200 kHz180kHz DL (48 x 3.75kHz)UL (36 x 5kHz)
180kHz DL (12 x 15kHz) UL (72 x 2.5kHz)
Multiple Access DL OFDMA OFDMA TDMA OFDMA OFDMA
Multiple Access UL SC-FDMA SC-FDMA TDMA FDMA SC-FDMA
Modulation DL QPSK, 16QAM, 64QAM
QPSK, 16QAM, 64QAM GMSK BPSK, QPSK, optional
16QAMBPSK, QPSK, optional 16QAM
Modulation UL QPSK, 16QAM QPSK, 16QAM GMSK GMSK, optional BPSK, QPSK,8PSK
BPSK, QPSK, optional 16QAM
Target Link Budget
15-20 dB coverage enhancement vs. Rel 12
20 dB better coverage vs. LTE
+20 dB better coverage vs. LTE
+20 dB better coverage vs. LTE
+20 dB better coverage vs. LTE
Merged as LTE-CatM2 (NB_IoT)Merged as LTE-CatM2 (NB_IoT)Go ThroughGo ThroughMerged in LTE-Cat M1Merged in LTE-Cat M1
22
Flex Selected LPWAN technologies
• LTE Cat-M/NB_IoTLTE – Cat M NB_IoT EC - GSM
3GPP Release 3GPP Rel 13 3GPP Rel 13 3GPP Rel 13
Peak data rates 1 Mbps (FDD)375 kbps (HD-FDD)
DL up to 250kbps UL single tone up to 20 to 64kbps, UL multi-tone up to 250kbps
10 kbps to 240kbps
Bandwidth DL 1.4 MHz 180kHz (12 x 15kHz) 200 kHz
Bandwidth UL 1.4 MHzSingle-tone 180kHz by 3.75kHz or 15kHz) or multi-tone (180kHz by 15kHz)
200 kHz
Multiple Access DL OFDMA OFDMA TDMA
Multiple Access UL SC-FDMA Single-tone FDMA or multi-tone SC-FDMA TDMA
Modulation DL QPSK, 16QAM, 64QAM BPSK, QPSK, optional 16QAM GMSK, optional 8PSK
Modulation UL QPSK, 16QAM TBC π/4-QPSK, rotated π/2-BPSK, 8PSK optional 16QAM GMSK, optional 8PSK
Target Link Budget ~156 dB ~164 dB ~164 dBMobility Full Nomadic FullMax Tx Power +20 dBm or 23 dBm +23 dBm +23 dBm or 33 dBmVoLTE support Yes No YesDuplex Mode Half or Full Half Half
28
Disclaimer
• All information in this presentation is collected from public available sources.• Flex does not claim any relation with any of the companies mentioned in this
presentation.• This presentation does not reveal any information regarding future plans of any
company mentioned, including Flex its customers and its subsidiaries • Neither the author nor Flex is getting paid, and neither the author nor Flex endorse
any company mentioned