Making Healthcare Personal: Driving Better Outcomes, Care and Patient Experience
Mark Wong, Senior Director, Clinical Programs
Chris Lehmuth, Senior Director, Enterprise Data Science
2
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
Presenter’s are employed by Express Scripts
Disclosure will be made when a product is
discussed for an unapproved use.
This continuing education activity is managed
and accredited by AffinityCE in collaboration
with AMSUS. AffinityCE and AMSUS staff as
well as Planners and Reviewers, have no
relevant financial or non-financial interests to
disclose.
Commercial Support was not received for this
activity
Disclosure statement
3
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
Learning Objectives
1. Participants will understand why a performance-based clinical outcomes model
focused on delivering personalized clinical care is needed in the health care
system.
2. Participants will be introduced to innovative approaches around data integration
that support a new clinical management model that delivers guaranteed clinical
outcomes and return on investment.
3. Participants will learn this new clinical management model fosters coordination
of care and creates a better healthcare experience for the patient.
4
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
4
“FALL IN LOVE WITH THE PROBLEM, NOT THE SOLUTION.”
- MARTY CAGAN, INSPIRED
5
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
5
OF TOTAL HEALTHCARE
SPENDING GOES TO
UNNECESSARY,
INEFFECTIVE,
OVERPRICED, AND
WASTEFUL SERVICES*
%
*Lyu H, Xu T, Brotman D, et al. Overtreatment in the United States. PLoS One. 2017;12(9):e0181970. Published 2017 Sep 6. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0181970
6
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
Improving clinical outcomes has stalled
Journal of the American Medical Association Study*
1 in 4
adults with
diabetes
was not
diagnosed
Of those
diagnosed,
nearly 1 in 3
was not
receiving
appropriate
care
Fewer than
1 in 4
achieved
clinical
goals
*Pooyan Kazemian, PhD; Fatma M. Shebl, MD, PhD; et al. Evaluation of the Cascade of Diabetes Care in the United States,
2005-2016. JAMA Intern Med. doi:10.1001/jamainternmed.2019.2396 Published online August 12, 2019.
7
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
7
*2018 Kaiser Family Foundation Employer Health Benefits Survey
OF LARGE EMPLOYERS INVESTED IN HEALTH AND WELLNESS PROGRAMS IN 2018
%
8
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
Reviews are mixed on Health and Wellness Programs
9
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
Personalization impacts engagement
wardrobe
kits
social
media
feed
movie
promptsonline
shopping
music
feed
10
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
MAKING THE DENTIST OFFICE PERSONALIZED
11
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
Using insights to build a better system
BETTER VALUE
BETTER HEALTH
BETTER SERVICE
12
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
“BIG DATA” Defined
THE TYPES
OF DATA
Data is sourced from
over 3,000 external
providers and 400
internal apps
THE CHANGES
WITHIN DATA
Competencies to
integrate and
enhance ever
changing data
THE AMOUNT
OF DATA
20 petabytes;
placed into
17 data domains,
100+ sub-domains
THE SPEED TO
RECEIVE DATA
35MM daily claims are
received and stored
within seconds of
a pharmacy visit
THE QUALITY
OF DATA
Data governance
applied to produce
clean data feeds and
actionable insights
Big data is further defined by the following attributes:
Datasets that are too large, complex or dynamic forconventional tools to capture, store, manage and analyze
VolumeVariabilityVariety VeracityVelocity
13
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
Data Science: From Analytics to Action
Data are just summaries of thousands of stories —
tell a few of those stories to help make the data meaningful.
– Chip & Dan Heath, authors of “Made to Stick: Why Some Ideas Survive and Others Die”
“ ”
USEFUL
ESI TURNS DATA INTO INSIGHTS BY MAKING IT …
Timely Relevant Accurate Complete Actionable
14
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
ESI Enterprise Data Science Competencies
gradient
solid color
AI (research)Deep
LearningMachineLearning
TextMining / NLP
AnomalyDetection
Optimization GISDesign of
Experiments
Enterprise Data Science Services/Enablement
15
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
PROSPECTIVE / REAL-TIME
Identify risk before the first fill and throughout treatment, then proactively engage
Track changes in patient-level risk
over time
Adjust intensity of engagement as a
patient’s risk changes
Identify the type of interventions most
likely to elicit a positive response
Effectively target patients based on their
behavior profile
Appling data science to healthcare
16
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
Interventions are often happening too late
TIME
RIS
K EARLY INTERVENTION= healthier & safer patients
while reducing waste
CURRENT
intervention timeframe
RECOMMENDED
intervention timeframe
17
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
COMPREHENSIVE HEALTH RISK MANAGEMENT
Building the right insights to drive change
Gap In care Predictive Insights
Therapy Specific Engagement
Channel Engagement models
18
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
L IVE CALL CHANNEL ENGAGEMENT
State or Province
19
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
L IVE CALL CHANNEL ENGAGEMENT
Prescriber AMA School Location Code
20
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
A New Model
Integrated Hub Personalized Interventions
STEP 1 :
Multi-source data
integration
STEP 3 :
Recommendation
Engine
STEP 4 :
Outcomes-focused
Personalization
STEP 2 :
Insights
Engine
21
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
Dynamic Personalization
Diabetes and Hypertension Remote
Monitoring
Provider detailer
Quality Pharmacy Networks
Physician EMR Communications
Personalized Member Communications
TRC
Pharmacist
Care Coordination
Health eating
support
Proactively selecting the right set of evolving engagements for each person’s individual needs…
recalculating as we go for the greatest outcomes.
22
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
Holistic population insights + personal touch
Clinical performance viewed on demand for total
and sub-populations through Care Insights Hub
• Access to all clinical measures and opportunities
• Recommended action plan to meet clinical goals
• Visibility to interventions and clinical/financial
outcomes
• Action plans can be generated based on member
priority and desired clinical focus
Screenshot of Care Insights Hub
Complementing our machine learning recommendations with a personal touch. Our Population Health
Managers are clinicians trained on data analysis—providing daily monitoring and evaluation based on your
goals, using the Care Insights Hub’s rich information at both patient and population levels.
23
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
Diabetes Health Risk, Avoided INTERVENTIONCASE
STUDY
59 y/o female
Has history of diabetes, with high A1c levels (11.3 vs. goal <7.0), nonadherence to metformin and missing
a recommended statin — left untreated, at significant risk for eye, kidney and nerve complications.
BLOOD SUGAR
CONTROL
Elevated A1c levels
11.3
Drastically reduced A1c
levels
6.2
• Statin not prescribed, omission gap
• Interested in lifestyle changes, but not sure
where to start
• Statin prescribed, gap closed
• Dietitian referral to assist with
lifestyle changes
MEDICATION
ADHERENCE
• Doesn’t want to take insulin• Nonadherentto metformin
73%
• Discussed ways to remember to take meds
with TRC pharmacist• Adherent to metformin
99%
PHYSICIAN
VISIBILITY
Several electronic messaging attempts; no change in therapy
• Connected and coordinated
• Academic Detailer discussed statin
omission with provider
CARE
COORDINATION
Information not shared across
medical/pharmacy care team
Provider, case manager, TRC Pharmacist,
Academic detailer and PHM engaged
High risk of complications
• A1c level controlled with ADA diet and exercise• Insulin discontinued
• Adherent to recommended statin
• Significant reduction in diabetes complications
$7.5Kcost savings
BLOOD SUGAR
CONTROL
GAPS IN
CAREMEDICATION
ADHERENCE
PHYSICIAN
VISIBILITY
CARE
COORDINATION
OVERALL
HEALTHSAVINGS
2018
2019
24
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
Final Takeaways
1. Leverage personalized strategies – using actionable data
2. Maximize your clinical outcomes through comprehensive care
coordination
3. Hold health care service organizations (including digital vendors)
accountable for delivering clinical and financial value
25
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.
How to Earn CE
If you would like to earn continuing education credit for this activity, please visit:
http://amsus.cds.pesgce.com.
Hurry, CE Certificates will only be available for 30 Days after this event!
26
© 2019 Express Scripts. All Rights Reserved.