+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

Date post: 30-Nov-2015
Category:
Upload: social-and-economic-rights-action-center
View: 129 times
Download: 23 times
Share this document with a friend
Description:
A petition to the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) seeking investigation into and adjudication of the actual and threatened violation of thousands of Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront residents’ fundamental and human rights
97
!"#$%& %()$*)"+ ", -./"/"012.3. 4.*%#,#"+* $"556+)*37 89:;8 <6=3 ;>8; "#$%$%&’ $& ()$%&’)* +,-)’ .%/0$1 2&--%11%&’ 3,4-%$$#5 67 3#8$#-4#9 6:;< 3&=%)* )’5 >=&’&-%= .%/0$1 ?=$%&’ 2#’$#9 "*&$ @ABC 20%#D E0&-)1 ?5#4&F# G9%H# I-&*# "0)1# 6C J10#9%C K)/&1 E#*L M6<NO;O@7NO76PP %’D&Q1#9)=O&9/ ?@-AB!BC K)/&1 R)9/%’)*%S#5 2&--,’%$%#1 T&9,- P I’5& 3$9##$ >4,$# R#$$) UV#1$WC K)/&1 E#*L M6<NOB:6O7@AON<@N
Transcript
Page 1: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!"#$%&'%()$*)"+'",'-./"/"012.3.'

4.*%#,#"+*'$"556+)*37'89:;8'<6=3';>8;'!

!

"#$%$%&'!$&!()$%&')*!+,-)'!.%/0$1!2&--%11%&'!

3,4-%$$#5!67!3#8$#-4#9!6:;<!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!!!!

3&=%)*!)'5!>=&'&-%=!.%/0$1!?=$%&'!2#'$#9!

"*&$!@ABC!20%#D!E0&-)1!?5#4&F#!G9%H#!

I-&*#!"0)1#!6C!J10#9%C!K)/&1!

E#*L!M6<NO;O@7NO76PP!

%'D&Q1#9)=O&9/!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

?@-AB!BC'!

K)/&1!R)9/%')*%S#5!2&--,'%$%#1!T&9,-!

P!I'5&!3$9##$!

>4,$#!R#$$)!UV#1$WC!K)/&1!

E#*L!M6<NOB:6O7@AON<@N!!

Page 2: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

;!&D!6<!

3#8$#-4#9!67C!6:;<!

"9&DO!X#-!?'/Y#!

>Z#=,$%H#!3#=9#$)9F!

()$%&')*!+,-)'!.%/0$1!2&--%11%&'!

P!?/,%F%!J9&'1%!3$9##$!

R)%$)-)![!?4,\)C!T#5#9)*!2)8%$)*!E#99%$&9F!

!

G#)9!"9&DO!?'/Y#L!

'

C%D' EFG1G1BH' CFI@CJ1HI' !BCAFJ' FK1AG1BH' B!' -@LBLB014@M@' 4@GFC!CBHG'

AB--NH1GM7'89:;8'<N?M';>8O'

'

V#!Y9%$#!9#/)95%'/!$0#!],*F!;7^6;!6:;<!5#-&*%$%&'!)'5!D&9=#5!#H%=$%&'!&D!$0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!

V)$#9D9&'$! =&--,'%$F! %'! $0#! a)4)! K&=)*! b&H#9'-#'$! ?9#)! &D! K)/&1! 3$)$#O! E0#! 3&=%)*! )'5!

>=&'&-%=! .%/0$1! ?=$%&'! 2#'$#9! U3>.?2W! 1$)'51! )1! 2&,'1#*! &D! 9#=&95! $&! -#-4#91! &D! $0#!

R)_&_&`JY)F)! =&--,'%$FO! E0#! K)/&1! R)9/%')*%S#5! 2&--,'%$%#1! T&9,-! UK?R2ITI.W! %1! )!

-#-4#910%8! &9/)'%S)$%&'! =&-89%1#5! &D! =&--,'%$%#1! *%H%'/! %'! %'D&9-)*! 1#$$*#-#'$1! )=9&11!

K)/&1C! %'=*,5%'/! R)_&_&`JY)F)! Y)$#9D9&'$! =&--,'%$FO! V#! 0)H#! 4##'! %'1$9,=$#5! $&! D%*#! )!

8#$%$%&'! $&! $0#!()$%&')*!+,-)'!.%/0$1!2&--%11%&'! U(+.2W! $&! 1##_!)'! %'H#1$%/)$%&'! %'$&!)'5!

)5\,5%=)$%&'!&D!$0#!)=$,)*!)'5!$09#)$#'#5!H%&*)$%&'!&D!$0&,1)'51!&D!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!

9#1%5#'$1c!D,'5)-#'$)*!)'5!0,-)'!9%/0$1!%'=*,5%'/!$0#!9%/0$!$&!0&,1%'/!&9!10#*$#9C!$0#!9%/0$!$&!

)=d,%9#! )'5!&Y'!89&8#9$FC! $0#! 9%/0$! $&! *%D#C! $0#! 9%/0$! $&!5,#!89&=#11C! $0#! 9%/0$! $&!89%H)$#! )'5!

D)-%*F!*%D#C!$0#!9%/0$!$&!*%H#*%0&&5C!)'5!$0#!9%/0$!$&!#5,=)$%&'O!

!

"*#)1#! D%'5!4#*&Y!)!8#$%$%&'! $0)$!3>.?2!)'5!K?R2ITI.!5#H#*&8#5! %'! =&**)4&9)$%&'!Y%$0! $0#!

R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$! =&--,'%$FO! E0#! 8#$%$%&'! %1! =&-89%1#5! &D! 1#H#9)*! =&-8&'#'$1C! )'!

%'$9&5,=$%&'C! )! 1$)$#-#'$! &D! $0#! D)=$1! &D! $0#! D&9=#5! #H%=$%&'C! $Y&! %11,#1! D&9! 5#$#9-%')$%&'C!

1,4-%11%&'1!&'!#)=0!&D! $0#!=*)%-#5!9%/0$1!H%&*)$%&'1C!)'5!1,88&9$%'/!5&=,-#'$1' E/FG$H$#I'J=?

A=@KL!

!

E0)'_!F&,!D&9!F&,9!,9/#'$!)$$#'$%&'!$&!$0%1!%-8&9$)'$!-)$$#9O!

!

3%'=#9#*FC!!

! ! ! ! ! !?'59#Y!R)_%!! ! ! ! ! R,14),!?/4&5#-,!

3$)DD!?$$&9'#FC!3>.?2! ! ! ! 3#=9#$)9FC!K?R2ITI.!

)'59#YO-Q1#9)=O&9/! ! ! ! 1*,-5Y#**#9O)/4&5#-,Q/-)%*O=&-!

:B;:ON6PO@:7:!U-&4%*#W! ! ! ! :B:6O7@AON<@N!U-&4%*#W!

'

22L! R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!2&--,'%$F!

! 20%5%!I5%'_)*,C!20)%9-)'!(+.2!

! E&'F!I\,_Y,C!G%9#=$&9!&D!"9&$#=$%&'!)'5!J'H#1$%/)$%&'C!(+.2!!

Page 3: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

6!&D!6<!

EFG1G1BH'CFI@CJ1HI'!BCAFJ'FK1AG1BH'B!'-@LBLB014@M@'4@GFC!CBHG'

AB--NH1GM7'89:;8'<N?M';>8O!

'

M;H:$##",'H7N'

3&=%)*!)'5!>=&'&-%=!.%/0$1!?=$%&'!2#'$#9!U3>.?2W!

K)/&1!R)9/%')*%S#5!2&--,'%$%#1!T&9,-!UK?R2ITI.W!

67!3#8$#-4#9!6:;<!

'

'

'

8P>' 1HGCBJNAG1BH'

'

;O;! I'!],*F!;7^6;!6:;<!$0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!b&H#9'-#'$!D&9=%4*F!#H%=$#5!&H#9!NC:<@!9#1%5#'$1!&D!

$0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!=&--,'%$F!%'!$0#!a)4)!K&=)*!b&H#9'-#'$!?9#)!&D!K)/&1!

3$)$#O! E0#! 3&=%)*! )'5! >=&'&-%=! .%/0$1! ?=$%&'! 2#'$#9! U3>.?2W! 1$)'51! )1! 2&,'1#*! &D!

9#=&95! $&! -#-4#91! &D! $0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)! =&--,'%$FO! E0#! K)/&1! R)9/%')*%S#5!

2&--,'%$%#1! T&9,-! UK?R2ITI.W! %1! )! -#-4#910%8! &9/)'%S)$%&'! =&-89%1#5! &D!

=&--,'%$%#1! *%H%'/! %'! %'D&9-)*! 1#$$*#-#'$1! )=9&11! K)/&1C! %'=*,5%'/! R)_&_&`JY)F)!

Y)$#9D9&'$!=&--,'%$FO!V#!0)H#!4##'!%'1$9,=$#5!$&!D%*#!)!8#$%$%&'!$&!$0#!()$%&')*!+,-)'!

.%/0$1!2&--%11%&'!U(+.2W!$&!1##_!)'!%'H#1$%/)$%&'!%'$&!)'5!)5\,5%=)$%&'!&D!$0#!)=$,)*!

)'5! $09#)$#'#5! H%&*)$%&'! &D! $0&,1)'51! &D! R)_&_&`JY)F)! V)$#9D9&'$! 9#1%5#'$1c!

D,'5)-#'$)*! )'5! 0,-)'! 9%/0$1! %'=*,5%'/! $0#! 9%/0$! $&! 0&,1%'/! &9! 10#*$#9C! $0#! 9%/0$! $&!

)=d,%9#!)'5!&Y'!89&8#9$FC!$0#!9%/0$!$&!5,#!89&=#11C!9%/0$!$&!*%D#C!$0#!9%/0$!$&!89%H)$#!)'5!

D)-%*F!*%D#C!$0#!9%/0$!$&!*%H#*%0&&5C!)'5!$0#!9%/0$!$&!#5,=)$%&'O!

'

'

;P>! QN--@CM'B!'!@AGQ'

'

OPQ/N' #%' I;RRB":"&#' #G"' H"B%6' I;::*+7' %1' 1*.#I' $I' !"#$%$&' ()<' *' SD?R*+*)+*RG' J11$,*0$#' $&'

M;RR%+#'I6%+&'#%'H7'JB*IG"'-+*&.$I'J)%7%&'$&'M;$#'O%L'-T94U49M4=VWW4=@'ERB"*I"'&%#"'#G*#'#G$I'

.%;+#'.*I"'G*I'I$&."'H""&'6$#G,+*6&K<'*B%&)'6$#G'%#G"+'I;RR%+#$&)',%.;:"&#I'E!"#$%$&*'()+,)-K'

!

6O;! E0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)! V)$#9D9&'$! =&--,'%$F! %1! -)5#! ,8! &D! )889&Z%-)$#*F! 6::C:::!

8#91&'1C!89%-)9%*F!&D!$0#!>/,'C!J*)\#C!J\)YC!)'5!a&9,4)!$9%4#1!Y0&!=&#Z%1$!)'5!=&&8#9)$#!

%'! $0#%9! 1&=%)*! )'5! #=&'&-%=! )=$%H%$%#1! 5#18%$#! #$0'%=! )'5! 9#*%/%&,1! 5%H#91%$FO! E0#!

=&--,'%$F!Y)1! D&,'5#5! %'! %$1!89#1#'$! *&=)$%&'C! 4,%*$! &'! $0#!Y)$#91! )'5! 10&9#1!&D! $0#!

K)/&1!K)/&&'!Y#**!&H#9!)!=#'$,9F!)/&!)'5!0)H#!Y)$=0#5!$0#!K)/&1!-#$9&8&*%1!/9&Y!,8!

)9&,'5!%$O!J$1!-)%'!#=&'&-%=!)=$%H%$%#1!)9#!D%10%'/C!D%10!1-&_%'/C!)'5!)!Y)$#9D9&'$!$%-4#9!

%'5,1$9FC!1&!$0)$!4&$0!%$1!1,41%1$#'=#!)'5!$0#!$9)5%$%&')*!Y)F!&D!*%D#!5#8#'5!&'!Y)$#9O!!

!

6O6! I'! ],*F! ;<C! 6:;6C! )! (&$%=#! D9&-! $0#! K)/&1! 3$)$#! 2&--%11%&'#9! &D! V)$#9D9&'$!

J'D9)1$9,=$,9#!G#H#*&8-#'$!Y)1!5#*%H#9#5!)$!9)'5&-!$&!)!D#Y!=&--,'%$F!-#-4#91O!E0#!

(&$%=#! Y)1! 5)$#5! ],*F! ;6C! 6:;6! )'5! %'D&9-#5! $0#! eIY'#9`I==,8%#9f! &D! $0#!

R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!&D!$0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!b&H#9'-#'$c1!5#=%1%&'!$&!e=*#)9!)**!%**#/)*!

)'5! ,'),$0&9%S#5! 5#H#*&8-#'$1! &'! %$1! Y)$#9D9&'$! )'5! Y)$#9! 4&5%#1Of! J$! $0#9#D&9#!

8,98&9$#5! $&! /%H#! e'&$%=#g! $&! H)=)$#! )'5! 9#-&H#! )**! %**#/)*! )'5! ,'),$0&9%S#5!

Page 4: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

<!&D!6<!

5#H#*&8-#'$1! )*&'/! $0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!Y%$0%'! @6!+&,91! &D! 9#=#%8$! &D! $0%1!

'&$%=#Of! E0#! '&$%=#! 5%5! '&$! ')-#! 8)9$%=,*)9! 8#91&'1C! )559#11#1! &9! )9#)1! &D! $0#!

R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!'&9!5%5!%$!=%$#!)'F!*)Y!)1!$0#!4)1%1!D&9!$0#!'&$%=#!&9!)==&95%'/!

$&!Y0%=0!&'#!=&,*5!5#$#9-%'#!Y0%=0!e5#H#*&8-#'$1f!Y#9#!e%**#/)*Of!Q%%'FRS)T)*'AO!!

!

6O<! V%$0!'&!D,9$0#9!89&=#11C!$0#!H%&*#'$!5#-&*%$%&'!#Z#9=%1#!=&--#'=#5!&'!$0#!-&9'%'/!&D!

],*F! ;7C! 6:;6C! Y0#'! 9#89#1#'$)$%H#1! &D! $0#! R%'%1$9F! &D! V)$#9D9&'$! J'D9)1$9,=$,9#!

G#H#*&8-#'$C!-#-4#91!&D!$0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!h%=_!?/)%'1$!J'5%1=%8*%'#!Uh?JW!X9%/)5#C!)'5!

0#)H%*F! )9-#5! 8&*%=#-#'! 1$&9-#5! $0#! =&--,'%$F! 4F! 4&)$O! E0#F! ,1#5! =0)%'1)Y1! )'5!

&$0#9!#d,%8-#'$!$&!5#-&*%10!0&-#1C!4,1%'#11!8*)=#1!)'5!=&--,'%$F!1$9,=$,9#1!4,%*$!&D!

1$%*$1!&H#9!$0#!K)/&1!K)/&&'O!.#1%5#'$1C!Y0&!0)5!'&Y0#9#!#*1#!$&!/&C!D#**!%'$&!$0#!Y)$#9!

Y%$0! $0#%9! 8&11#11%&'1! )'5! $0#! 5#49%1! D9&-! $0#%9! 0&,1#1C! 1,DD#9%'/! %'\,9F! )'5! *&11! &D!

89&8#9$FO!E0#!5#-&*%$%&'!=&'$%',#5!,'$%*!],*F!6;C!6:;6C!,*$%-)$#*F!5%18*)=%'/!$0&,1)'51!

&D! 8#&8*#C! %'=*,5%'/! =0%*59#'C! Y&-#'! )'5! #*5#9*FC! Y0&!Y#9#! D&9=#5! $&! *%H#! %'! =)'&#1O!

R)'F!&$0#9!=&--,'%$F!-#-4#91!Y#9#!)DD#=$#5!4F!5%19,8$%&'1!$&!$0#%9! *%H#*%0&&51!)'5!

Y)F! &D! *%D#! )'5! =&'$%',#! $&! D#)9! D,9$0#9! 5#-&*%$%&'1! $0)$! 0)H#! 4##'! $09#)$#'#5O! Q%%'

FRS)T)*U'<8:<8;C!80&$&/9)801!&D!$0#!5#-&*%$%&'C!)'5!%$1!)D$#9-)$0O!

!

6ON! E0#! 5#-&*%$%&'! #Z#9=%1#! Y)1! )==&-8)'%#5! 4F! )=$1! &D! H%&*#'=#! )'5! %'$%-%5)$%&'! 4F!

-#-4#91!&D!$0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!h%=_!?/)%'1$!J'5%1=%8*%'#!Uh?JW!X9%/)5#!)'5!0#)H%*F!)9-#5!

8&*%=#-#'O! 3#H#9)*! -#'! Y#9#! )99#1$#5! )'5! 5#$)%'#5! Y%$0&,$! =0)9/#O! J'! $0#! Y&91$!

%'=%5#'$C!&'! ],*F!6;C!6:;6C!)'!,')9-#5! D%10#9-)'!)'5!=&--,'%$F! *#)5#9C!R9O!E%-&$0F!

?S%'_8&'&! +,'_8&F)'Y)C! Y)1! D)$)**F! 10&$! %'! $0#! 1$&-)=0! 4F! "&*%=#! 2&98&9)*! X&-)!

"#88*#O!Q%%'FRS)T)*U'J8:JOC!80&$&1!&D!R9O!E%-&$0F!?S%'_8&'&!+,'_8&F)'Y)c1!Y&,'51!

)1!Y#**!)1!0%1!=#9$%D%=)$#!&D!5#)$0O!!

!

6OA! G,9%'/! )'5! 1%'=#! $0#! ],*F! ;7^6;C! 6:;6! 5#-&*%$%&'1C! $0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)! V)$#9D9&'$!

=&--,'%$F! *#)5#91! 0)H#! $9%#5! $&! #'/)/#! Y%$0! $0#! b&H#9'-#'$! &D! K)/&1! 3$)$#C! $0#!

b&H#9'&9! &D! K)/&1! 3$)$#C! )'5! $0#! K)/&1! 3$)$#! R%'%1$9F! &D! V)$#9D9&'$! J'D9)1$9,=$,9#!

G#H#*&8-#'$C! )-&'/! &$0#91C! $&! D%'5! )! Y)F! &D! 1)H%'/! $0#%9! =&--,'%$FO! E09&,/0! $0#!

=&,91#! &D! '#/&$%)$%&'1C! $0#! =&--,'%$F! -#-4#91! 0)H#! 9#=#%H#5! -%Z#5! -#11)/#1! $0)$!

*#)H#!$0#-!D#)9D,*! D&9!$0#!D,$,9#O!E0#F!Y#9#!D%91$! $,9'#5!)Y)F!4F!$0#!2&--%11%&'#9!&D!

V)$#9D9&'$! J'D9)1$9,=$,9#! G#H#*&8-#'$! Y0#'! $0#F! =)-#! $&! 0%1! R%'%1$9F! Y0%*#!

5#-&*%$%&'1!Y#9#!&'/&%'/O!3,41#d,#'$*FC!)D$#9!)!=&--,'%$F^*#5!8#)=#D,*!89&$#1$C!-#5%)!

=&H#9)/#C!)'5!0,/#!%'$#9')$%&')*!&,$=9F!&H#9!$0#!5#-&*%$%&'1C!$0#F!9#=#%H#5!)'!)8&*&/F!

D9&-! $0#! b&H#9'&9! &D! K)/&1! 3$)$#! )'5! %'5%=)$%&'1! $0)$! =#9$)%'! -#-4#91! &D! $0#!

b&H#9'-#'$!&D!K)/&1!3$)$#!-%/0$!4#!Y%**%'/!$&!=&**)4&9)$#!Y%$0!$0#-!$&!,'5#9$)_#!$&'I$#;'

5#H#*&8-#'$!%'!$0#%9!=&--,'%$FO!+&Y#H#9C!-#-4#91!&D!$0#!b&H#9'-#'$!&D!K)/&1!3$)$#!

0)H#! 9#D,1#5! $&! *#$! -##$%'/1! 89&=##5! Y0#'! 9#89#1#'$)$%H#1! &D! $0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)!

V)$#9D9&'$!=&--,'%$F!Y#9#!)==&-8)'%#5!4F!*#/)*!9#89#1#'$)$%&'O!'

!

6O7! T,9$0#9C! %'! )'!I=$&4#9!<:C!6:;6!-##$%'/!4#$Y##'!=&--,'%$F! *#)5#91!)'5!K)/&1!3$)$#!

b&H#9'-#'$c1! 9#89#1#'$)$%H#1C! $0#! $09#)$!&D! D,$,9#!5#-&*%$%&'1!Y)1!#Z8*%=%$*F! 9#'#Y#5!

4F!X)F&!3,*#%-)'C!Y0&!%1!)!3,8#9%'$#'5#'$!&D!"&*%=#!)'5!8,98&9$1!$&!4#!$0#!20)%9-)'!&D!

$0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!>'H%9&'-#'$)*!)'5!38#=%)*!IDD#'=#1!U>'D&9=#-#'$W!i'%$!)'5!$0#!K)/&1!

3$)$#! E)1_! T&9=#! &'! >'H%9&'-#'$)*! )'5! 38#=%)*! IDD#'1#1O! +#! %'D&9-#5! $0&1#! )$! $0#!

Page 5: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

N!&D!6<!

-##$%'/! $0)$! $0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!b&H#9'-#'$!0)5!5#=%5#5! $&!89&=##5!Y%$0!5#-&*%$%&'1!&D!

$0#! =&--,'%$FO! .#89#1#'$)$%H#1! &D! $0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)! V)$#9D9&'$! =&--,'%$F! 0)H#!

#H#9F!9#)1&'!$&!D#)9!1,=0!$09#)$1!Y%**!$,9'!$&!5#H)1$)$%'/!)=$%&'!)$!)'F!8&%'$C!#18#=%)**F!

Y0#9#! $0#%9! =&--,'%$F! 0)1! &'! 1#H#9)*! &==)1%&'1! %'! $0#! 8)1$! 1,DD#9#5! 5#-&*%$%&'1!

&95#9#5! )'5`&9! =)99%#5! &,$! 4F! $0#! h%=_! ?/)%'1$! J'5%1=%8*%'#! Uh?JW! X9%/)5#C! $0#! K)/&1!

3$)$#!>'H%9&'-#'$)*!)'5!38#=%)*!IDD#'1#1!U>'D&9=#-#'$W!i'%$C!)'5!$0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!E)1_!

T&9=#!&'!>'H%9&'-#'$)*!)'5!38#=%)*!IDD#'1#1O!!

!

6O@! ?==&95%'/*FC! 9#89#1#'$)$%H#1! &D! $0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)! V)$#9D9&'$! =&--,'%$F! '&Y!

)889&)=0! $0#!()$%&')*!+,-)'!.%/0$1!2&--%11%&'! 1##_%'/!5#$#9-%')$%&'!&D! $0#! %11,#1!

*)%5!&,$!4#*&YC!4)1#5!&'!Y0%=0! $0#F!89)F! D&9! 9#*%#D1! %'=*,5%'/! =#9$)%'!5#=*)9)$%&'1C! )'!

%'\,'=$%&'!)/)%'1$!D,$,9#!,'*)YD,*!5#-&*%$%&'1C!=&-8#'1)$%&'!D&9!-#-4#91!&D!$0#!D)-%*F!

&D! $0#! K)$#!R9O!+,'_8&F)'Y)C! )'5! /#'#9)*! =&-8#'1)$%&'! $&! $0#! =&--,'%$F!-#-4#91!

Y0&!0)H#!4##'!5%18*)=#5!)'5!1,DD#9#5!1&!-)'F!0)9-1!$0)$!)-&,'$!$&!H%&*)$%&'1!&D!$0#%9!

D,'5)-#'$)*!9%/0$1O!!

'

'

OP>' 1QQNF'!BC'JFGFC-1H@G1BH'

!

!

.**/0')1'8G"#G"+'#G"'A;B7'=>?@=',":%B$#$%&'%1'#G"'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'.%::;&$#7'

,%"I' &%#' .%&I#$#;#"' *' 1%+.",' "0$.#$%&<' $&' 0$%B*#$%&' %1' #G"' +$)G#' #%' *,"X;*#"' G%;I$&)' %+'

IG"B#"+' ;&,"+' #G"' 5&#"+&*#$%&*B' 9%0"&*&#' %&' /.%&%:$.<' M%.$*B' *&,' 9;B#;+*B' ($)G#I<' #G"'

5&#"+&*#$%&*B' 9%0"&*&#' %&' 9$0$B' *&,' !%B$#$.*B' ($)G#I<' *&,' #G"' J1+$.*&' 9G*+#"+' %&'T;:*&'

*&,'!"%RB"YI'($)G#IL'

'

.**/0' -1' 8G"#G"+' #G"' 3$BB$&)<' ,"I#+;.#$%&' %1' R+%R"+#7' *&,' %#G"+' *H;I"I' *&,' G*+:I'

.%::$##",' ,;+$&)' #G"' A;B7' =>' #%' @=<' @C=@' ,":%B$#$%&' %1' 2*3%3%456*7*' 8*#"+1+%&#'

.%::;&$#7'*&,'#G"'#G+"*#'%1'1;+#G"+',":%B$#$%&I'H7'Z*7%'M;B"$:*&'EML!LK'$&'*':""#$&)'6$#G'

.%::;&$#7' B"*,"+I' %&'P.#%H"+' DC<' @C=@' ,%' &%#' .%&I#$#;#"' 0$%B*#$%&I' %1' #G"' 1;&,*:"&#*B'

+$)G#I'%1'+"I$,"&#I'%1'#G"'2*3%3%456*7*'.%::;&$#7<'$&.B;,$&)'#G"'+$)G#'#%'B$1"<'#G"'+$)G#'#%'

,$)&$#7'%1'#G"'G;:*&'R"+I%&<'#G"'+$)G#'#%'*.X;$+"'*&,'%6&'R+%R"+#7<'+$)G#'#%',;"'R+%."II<'

#G"'+$)G#'#%'B$H"+#7<'#G"'+$)G#'#%'R+$0*#"'*&,'1*:$B7'B$1"<'+$)G#'#%'B$0"B$G%%,<'*&,'#G"'+$)G#'#%'

",;.*#$%&'*I');*+*&#"",';&,"+' #G"'=SSS'9%&I#$#;#$%&'%1' #G"'-","+*B'("R;HB$.'%1'O$)"+$*'

*&,'#G"'J1+$.*&'9G*+#"+'%1'T;:*&'*&,'!"%RB"IY'($)G#I<'#G"'5&#"+&*#$%&*B'9%0"&*&#'%&'9$0$B'

*&,' !%B$#$.*B' ($)G#I<' *&,' #G"' 5&#"+&*#$%&*B' 9%0"&*&#' %&' /.%&%:$.<' M%.$*B' *&,' 9;B#;+*B'

($)G#IL'

!

VP>' QNW-1QQ1BHQ' BH' 1QQNF' 8D' !BCAFJ' FK1AG1BH' 0' K1B?@G1BH' B!' C1IXG' GB'

@JFYN@GF'XBNQ1HI'BC'QXF?GFC'

!

NO;! V#! 1,4-%$! $0)$! $0#! ],*F! ;7^6;C! 6:;6! 5#-&*%$%&'1! &D! 0&-#1! %'! $0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)!

V)$#9D9&'$!2&--,'%$F!H%&*)$#1!$0#%9!2$3#&'&4'5607/5&0'#4/*$83'42'*#09&02!$0)$!5#9%H#1!

D9&-! ?9$%=*#! ;;O;! &D! $0#! J2>32.C! ?9$%=*#1! ;NC! ;7C! ;B! &D! $0#! ?D9%=)'! 20)9$#9! U)1!

5&-#1$%=)$#5WC!)'5!$0#!;PPP!2&'1$%$,$%&'!&D!(%/#9%)!U)1!)-#'5#5WO!!

!

Page 6: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

A!&D!6<!

NO6! ?9$%=*#!;;O;!&D!$0#!J2>32.!1$)$#1!$0)$!)**!8)9$%#1!$&!$0#!J2>32.!-,1$!e9#=&/'%S#!$0#!9%/0$!

&D! #H#9F&'#! $&! )'! )5#d,)$#! 1$)'5)95! &D! *%H%'/! D&9! 0%-1#*D! )'5! 0%1! D)-%*FC! %'=*,5%'/!

)5#d,)$#! D&&5C! =*&$0%'/! )'5! 0&,1%'/C! )'5! $&! $0#! =&'$%',&,1! %-89&H#-#'$! &D! *%H%'/!

=&'5%$%&'1O!E0#!3$)$#1!")9$%#1!Y%**!$)_#!)889&89%)$#!1$#81!$&!#'1,9#!$0#!9#)*%S)$%&'!&D!$0%1!

9%/0$C! 9#=&/'%S%'/! $&! $0%1! #DD#=$! $0#! #11#'$%)*! %-8&9$)'=#! &D! %'$#9')$%&')*! =&^&8#9)$%&'!

4)1#5!&'!D9##!=&'1#'$Of!

!

NO<! E0#!i(! 2&--%$$##! &'! >=&'&-%=C! 3&=%)*! )'5! 2,*$,9)*! .%/0$1C! $0#! 4&5F! &D! %'5#8#'5#'$!

#Z8#9$1! #1$)4*%10#5! $&! %'$#989#$! $0#! J2>32.!)'5!-&'%$&9! 1$)$#!8)9$%#1! =&-8*%)'=#C!0)1!

D,9$0#9! #*)4&9)$#5! $0#! '&9-)$%H#! =&'$#'$1! &D! $0#! 9%/0$! $&! )5#d,)$#! 0&,1%'/O! E0#!

2&--%$$##!89&H%5#1!),$0&9%$)$%H#!%'$#989#$)$%&'!&D!$0#!=&'$#'$!&D!$0#!9%/0$!$&!)5#d,)$#!

0&,1%'/!)'5! $0#!&4*%/)$%&'1!&D! 1$)$#1! %'!b#'#9)*!2&--#'$!N! U&'! $0#! 9%/0$! $&!)5#d,)$#!

0&,1%'/W!)'5!b#'#9)*!2&--#'$!@!U&'!D&9=#5!#H%=$%&'1WO!?==&95%'/!$&!b#'#9)*!2&--#'$!

N!U;<!G#=#-4#9!;PP;C!8)9)O!@WC!!

!

QG"' +$)G#' #%' G%;I$&)' IG%;B,' &%#' H"' $&#"+R+"#",' $&' *' &*++%6' %+' +"I#+$.#$0"'

I"&I"' 6G$.G' "X;*#"I' $#' 6$#G<' 1%+' "F*:RB"<' #G"' IG"B#"+' R+%0$,",' H7' :"+"B7'

G*0$&)'*' +%%1'%0"+'%&"YI'G"*,'%+'0$"6I' IG"B#"+'"F.B;I$0"B7'*I'*'.%::%,$#7L'

(*#G"+'$#'IG%;B,'H"'I""&'*I'#G"'+$)G#'#%'B$0"'I%:"6G"+"'$&'I".;+$#7<'R"*."'*&,'

,$)&$#7L'

!

NON! J'!:!;(<'=>'?$302$5C!A"556+)$.*)"+'8ZZ0[9C!$0#!?D9%=)'!2&--%11%&'!&'!+,-)'!)'5!

"#&8*#1c! .%/0$1! 9#*%#5! &'! ?9$%=*#1! ;NC! ;7C! )'5! ;BU;W! &D! $0#! ?D9%=)'! 20)9$#9! %'! D%'5%'/!

(%/#9%)'! b&H#9'-#'$! %'! H%&*)$%&'! &D! $0#! 9%/0$! $&! 10#*$#9! &9! 0&,1%'/! &D! $0#! I/&'%!

=&--,'%$FO!E0#1#!)9$%=*#1!&D!$0#!?D9%=)'!20)9$#9!0)H#!4##'!5&-#1$%=)$#5!%'$&!(%/#9%)'!

*)Y!%'!$0#%9!&Y'!9%/0$!)'5!)*1&!%'D&9-!$0#!%'$#989#$)$%&'!&D!1%-%*)9!9%/0$1!/,)9)'$##5!%'!

$0#!(%/#9%)'!2&'1$%$,$%&'O!?9$%=*#!;NC!5%1=,11#5!)4&H#C!/,)9)'$##1!$0#!9%/0$!$&!89&8#9$FO!

?9$%=*#!;7!/,)9)'$##1!$0#!e9%/0$!$&!#'\&F!$0#!4#1$!)$$)%')4*#!1$)$#!&D!80F1%=)*!)'5!-#'$)*!

0#)*$0Cf!Y0%=0!0)1!4##'!D&,'5!4F!$0#!?D9%=)'!2&--%11%&'!$&!=&'$)%'C!4F!%-8*%=)$%&'1C!$0#!

4)1%=! 1&=%&#=&'&-%=! 9%/0$1! $&! Y)$#9! )'5! D&&5! $0)$! )9#! '#=#11)9F! $&! )=0%#H#! 0#)*$0O!

?9$%=*#!;BU;WC!-#)'Y0%*#C!89&H%5#1!89&$#=$%&'1! D&9! $0#! D)-%*FL! eE0#! D)-%*F! 10)**!4#! $0#!

')$,9)*!,'%$!)'5!4)1%1!&D!1&=%#$FO!J$!10)**!4#!89&$#=$#5!4F!$0#!3$)$#Of!!

!

NOA!! E0#!?D9%=)'!2&--%11%&'!0)1! D&,'5!$0)$! $0#!=&-4%'#5!#DD#=$!&D!?9$%=*#1!;NC!;7C!)'5!;BC!

9#)5! $&/#$0#9C! eD&94%51! $0#! Y)'$&'! 5#1$9,=$%&'! &D! 10#*$#9! 4#=),1#! Y0#'! 0&,1%'/! %1!

5#1$9&F#5C! 89&8#9$FC! 0#)*$0C! )'5! D)-%*F! *%D#! )9#! )5H#91#*F! )DD#=$#5Of! X)1#5! &'! $0%1!

9#)1&'%'/C! $0#!2&--%11%&'! D&,'5! $0#!(%/#9%)'!b&H#9'-#'$c1!5#-&*%$%&'1! %'! $0#!I/&'%!

=&--,'%$F!$&!=&'1$%$,$#!)!H%&*)$%&'!&D!$0#!=&--,'%$Fc1!9%/0$1!$&!10#*$#9!&9!0&,1%'/O!!

!

NO7! E0#!#Z%1$#'=#!&D!)!9%/0$! $&!10#*$#9!&9!0&,1%'/!)*1&! D%'51!)-8*#!1,88&9$! %'! $0#!(%/#9%)'!

2&'1$%$,$%&'O! E0#! (%/#9%)'! 2&'1$%$,$%&'! =&'$)%'1! $0#! 1)-#! D,'5)-#'$)*! 9%/0$1! D9&-!

Y0%=0!$0#!9%/0$!$&!10#*$#9!&9!0&,1%'/!5#9%H#1C!$&!Y%$!$0#!9%/0$1!$&!89&8#9$F!=&'$)%'#5!%'!

3#=$%&'1!N<!)'5!NN!$0#!9%/0$!$&!0&-#!)'5!89%H)$#!*%D#!%'!3#=$%&'!<@O!E0#1#!9%/0$1!=)'!4#!

9#)5! %'! *%/0$! &D! 20)8$#9! JJC! 3#=$%&'! ;NU6WU5W! &D! $0#! 2&'1$%$,$%&'C!Y0%=0! 1$)$#1! $0)$! $0#!

b&H#9'-#'$! 10)**! 5%9#=$! %$1! 8&*%=%#1! $&Y)95! $0#! 89&H%1%&'! &D! 1,%$)4*#! )'5! )5#d,)$#!

10#*$#9O!

Page 7: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

7!&D!6<!

!

NO@! E0#!i(!2&--%$$##!&'!>=&'&-%=C!3&=%)*!)'5!2,*$,9)*!.%/0$1!5#D%'#1!)!@42A06'0=$A&$48!)1!

e$0#!8#9-)'#'$!&9!$#-8&9)9F!9#-&H)*!)/)%'1$!$0#%9!Y%**!&D! %'5%H%5,)*1C! D)-%*%#1!)'5`&9!

=&--,'%$%#1!D9&-!$0#!0&-#1!)'5`&9!*)'5!Y0%=0!$0#F!&==,8FC!Y%$0&,$!$0#!89&H%1%&'!&DC!

)'5!)==#11!$&C!)889&89%)$#!D&9-1!&D!*#/)*!&9!&$0#9!89&$#=$%&'f!Ui(!2&--%$$##!&'!>32.C!

b#'#9)*! 2&--#'$!(&O! @C! 8)9)O! <! U3%Z$##'$0! 1#11%&'C! 6:!R)F!;PP@WC! >`;PPB`66C!?''#Z!

JjWO!

!

NOB! E0#!2&--%$$##!0)1!#-80)1%S#5! $0)$!#H%=$%&'1!-)F!&'*F!4#!=)99%#5!&,$!)1!)! *)1$!9#1&9$!

)'5! &'*F! )D$#9! )**! D#)1%4*#! )*$#9')$%H#1! $&! #H%=$%&'! 0)H#! 4##'! #Z8*&9#5! %'! /#',%'#!

=&'1,*$)$%&'!Y%$0!$0#!)DD#=$#5!8#&8*#O!J$!0)1!=*)9%D%#5!$0)$!#H%=$%&'1!=)'!&'*F!4#!=)99%#5!

&,$!Y0#'!)889&89%)$#!89&=#5,9)*!89&$#=$%&'1!)9#!%'!8*)=#O!E0#1#!%'=*,5#L;!

!

• )'!&88&9$,'%$F!D&9!/#',%'#!=&'1,*$)$%&'!Y%$0!$0&1#!)DD#=$#5k!

• )5#d,)$#!)'5!9#)1&')4*#!'&$%=#!D&9!)DD#=$#5!8#&8*#!89%&9!$&!$0#!#H%=$%&'!

• %'D&9-)$%&'! &'! $0#! 89&8&1#5! #H%=$%&'1! )'5C! Y0#9#! )88*%=)4*#C! &'! $0#!

)*$#9')$%H#!8,98&1#! D&9!Y0%=0! $0#! *)'5!&9!0&,1%'/! %1! $&!4#!,1#5C! $&!4#!-)5#!

)H)%*)4*#!%'!9#)1&')4*#!$%-#!$&!)**!$0&1#!)DD#=$#5k!

• /&H#9'-#'$!&DD%=%)*1!&9!$0#%9!9#89#1#'$)$%H#1!$&!4#!89#1#'$!5,9%'/!)'!#H%=$%&'k!

• #H#9F&'#!%'H&*H#5!%'!=)99F%'/!&,$!$0#!#H%=$%&'!4#!89&8#9*F!%5#'$%D%#5k!

• #H%=$%&'1!'&$!$&!$)_#!8*)=#!%'!8)9$%=,*)9*F!4)5!Y#)$0#9!&9!)$!'%/0$!,'*#11!$0#!

)DD#=$#5!8#&8*#!=&'1#'$!&$0#9Y%1#k!

• 89&H%1%&'!&D!*#/)*!9#-#5%#1k!

• 89&H%1%&'C!Y0#9#!8&11%4*#C!&D!*#/)*!)%5!$&!8#&8*#!Y0&!)9#!%'!'##5!&D!%$!$&!1##_!

9#59#11!D9&-!$0#!=&,9$1k!!

• 89&H%1%&'! &D! )5#d,)$#! )*$#9')$%H#! 0&,1%'/! $&! $0&1#!Y0&! =)''&$! 89&H%5#! D&9!

$0#-1#*H#1k!)'5!!

• =&-8#'1)$%&'!D&9!)**!*&11#1O!

!

NOP! E0#!#H%=$%&'!&D!$0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!2&--,'%$F!$0)$!$&&_!8*)=#!&'!R)9=0!;N^

;7!6:;6!=&'1$%$,$#1!)!D&9=#5!#H%=$%&'!4#=),1#!'&'#!&D!$0#!)4&H#!89&=#5,9)*!89&$#=$%&'1!

Y#9#!%'!8*)=#O!

)O E0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!b&H#9'-#'$!5%5!'&$!=&'1,*$!Y%$0!$0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!

2&--,'%$F!89%&9!$&!)99%H%'/!Y%$0!=0)%'!1)Y1!$&!=&--#'=#!$0#!5#-&*%$%&'!&'!],*F!

;7C!6:;6O!(&!%'D&9-)$%&'!)4&,$!$0#!5#-&*%$%&'!Y)1!-)5#!8,4*%=*F!)H)%*)4*#!$&!$0#!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !;!E0%1!D9)-#Y&9_!%1!$)_#'!D9&-!eJD!a&,!K&H#!a&,9!K%D#C!R&H#!I,$lL!T&9=#5!>H%=$%&'!%'!X)5%)!>)1$C!K)/&1!3$)$#C!

(%/#9%)Cf!?-'#1$F!J'$#9')$%&')*!)'5!3&=%)*!)'5!>=&'&-%=!.%/0$1!?=$%&'!2#'$#9!UihL!?,/,1$C!6:;<WO!!

Page 8: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

@!&D!6<!

=&--,'%$F! )$! *)9/#O! .)$0#9C! &'! ],*F! ;<C! 6:;6C! )! '&$%=#! D9&-! $0#! K)/&1! 3$)$#!

2&--%11%&'#9! &D! V)$#9D9&'$! J'D9)1$9,=$,9#! G#H#*&8-#'$! Y)1! 5#*%H#9#5! )$!

9)'5&-!$&!&'*F!)! D#Y!=&--,'%$F!-#-4#91O!E0#!'&$%=#!5%5!'&$!')-#!8)9$%=,*)9!

8#91&'1C! )559#11#1! &9! )9#)1! &D! $0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)! V)$#9D9&'$! $0)$! 10&,*5! 4#!

=*#)9#5C! '&9! 5%5! %$! =%$#! )'F! *)Y! )1! $0#! 4)1%1! D&9! $0#! b&H#9'-#'$c1! 5#=%1%&'! &9!

)==&95%'/! $&! Y0%=0! &'#! =&,*5! 5#$#9-%'#! Y0%=0! e5#H#*&8-#'$1f! Y#9#! e%**#/)*Of!

Q%%'FRS)T)*'AO!!

!

4O E0#! K)/&1! 3$)$#! b&H#9'-#'$! 89&H%5#5! $0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)! V)$#9D9&'$!

2&--,'%$F! Y%$0! '&! &88&9$,'%$F! $&! 5%1=#9'! $0#! b&H#9'-#'$c1! %'$#'$%&'1C! &9! $&!

,'5#91$)'5! $0#! *#/)*! 4)1%1! D&9! $0#%9! 8#'5%'/! )=$%&'1O! J'5##5C! Y%$0! '&! D,9$0#9!

89&=#11C! $0#!H%&*#'$!5#-&*%$%&'!#Z#9=%1#! =&--#'=#5!&'! $0#!-&9'%'/!&D! ],*F!;7C!

6:;6! [! )! -#9#! <! 5)F1! )D$#9! $0#! '&$%=#! 5&=,-#'$! Y)1! 89&H%5#5! $&! )! D#Y!

=&--,'%$F! -#-4#91! [! Y0#'! 9#89#1#'$)$%H#1! &D! $0#! R%'%1$9F! &D! V)$#9D9&'$!

J'D9)1$9,=$,9#! G#H#*&8-#'$C! -#-4#91! &D! $0#! K)/&1! 3$)$#! h%=_! ?/)%'1$!

J'5%1=%8*%'#!Uh?JW!X9%/)5#!)'5!$0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!E)1_!T&9=#!&'!>'H%9&'-#'$)*!)'5!

38#=%)*!IDD#'=#1C!)'5!0#)H%*F!)9-#5!8&*%=#-#'!1$&9-#5!$0#!=&--,'%$F!4F!4&)$O!!

!

=O E0#! 89&=#11! &D! $0#! #H%=$%&'! %$1#*D! Y)1! D9),/0$! Y%$0! 89&4*#-1O! E0&,1)'51! &D!

)DD#=$#5! 8#91&'1! Y#9#! ,')4*#! $&! 9#1=,#! $0#%9! H)*,)4*#! 4#*&'/%'/1! 4#D&9#! $0#%9!

1$9,=$,9#1! Y#9#! 5#-&*%10#5C! =&**)81%'/! %'$&! $0#! K)/&1! K)/&&'O! .#1%5#'$1C! Y0&!

0)5!'&Y0#9#!#*1#!$&!/&C!D#**!%'$&!$0#!Y)$#9!Y%$0!$0#%9!8&11#11%&'1!)'5!$0#!5#49%1!

D9&-!$0#%9!0&,1#1C! 1,DD#9%'/! %'\,9F!)'5! *&11!&D!89&8#9$FO!?==&95%'/! $&! $0#!K)/&1!

3$)$#! 2&--%11%&'#9! &D! "&*%=#C! -)'F! &D! $0#! 8&*%=#! &DD%=#91! )11%1$%'/! %'! $0#!

5#-&*%$%&'!Y#9#!)=$%'/!%**#/)**F![!4#F&'5!$0#!1=&8#!&D!$0#%9!&DD%=%)*!=)8)=%$%#1C!)1!

0%9#5! )9-#5! 8#91&''#*! )4,1%'/! $0#%9! ),$0&9%$F! UU%%' FRS)T)*' F;WO! E&! 5)$#C! '&!

8&*%=#! &DD%=#91! 0)H#! 4##'! 89&8#9*F! &9! )5#d,)$#*F! 49&,/0$! $&! \,1$%=#! D&9! $0#%9!

)=$%&'1C! ,'5#91=&9%'/! $0#! K)/&1! 3$)$#! b&H#9'-#'$c1! =&'5&'%'/! &D! 1,=0! #Z$9)^

*#/)*!)=$%&'1O!

!

5O E0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!b&H#9'-#'$!89&H%5#5!'&!*#/)*!9#-#5%#1!D&9!$0#!)DD#=$#5!8#91&'1O!

(&! %'D&9-)$%&'! Y)1! &DD%=%)**FC! 8,4*%=*F! 5%11#-%')$#5! $&! $0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)!

V)$#9D9&'$! =&--,'%$F! 4#D&9#! $0#! 5#-&*%$%&'! =&--#'=#5C! &9! )$! )'F! 8&%'$!

$0#9#)D$#9O!(&!&88&9$,'%$%#1!$&!4#!0#)95!&9!$&!=0)**#'/#!$0#!*#/)*%$F!&D!$0#!K)/&1!

3$)$#! b&H#9'-#'$c1! )=$%&'1! Y#9#! )DD&95#5O! V0#'C! )D$#9! $0#! 5#-&*%$%&'!

=&--#'=#5C! $0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)! V)$#9D9&'$! 2&--,'%$F! )$$#-8$#5! $&! =&'H#'#!

-##$%'/1! Y%$0! $0#! K)/&1! 3$)$#! b&H#9'-#'$! Y%$0! $0#%9! *#/)*! 9#89#1#'$)$%H#1C!

3>.?2! U)=$%'/! )1! 2&,'1#*! &D! .#=&95! $&! $0#! =&--,'%$FWC! $0#! K)/&1! 3$)$#!

b&H#9'-#'$! 5%5! '&$! )**&Y! $0#! =&--,'%$Fc1! *#/)*! 9#89#1#'$)$%H#1! $&! #'$#9! $0#!

-##$%'/! [! D,9$0#9! #H%5#'=#! $0#! K)/&1! 3$)$#! b&H#9'-#'$! )=$%H#*F! 89#H#'$#5!

)DD#=$#5!8#91&'1! D9&-!)==#11%'/! *#/)*! )%5! )'5! *#/)*! 9#=&,91#! %'! 9#18&'1#! $&! $0#!

5#-&*%$%&'!&D!$0#%9!=&--,'%$FO!!!

!

#O E&!5)$#C!'&!=&-8#'1)$%&'!0)1!4##'!8)%5!$&!)'F!&D! $0#!)DD#=$#5!8#91&'1C!'&9!0)1!

)'F! )*$#9')$%H#! 0&,1%'/! 4##'! 89&H%5#5! $&! $0&1#!Y0&! *&1$! $0#%9! 0&-#1O! J'1$#)5C!

-)'F! %'5%H%5,)*1! Y0&! *&1$! $0#%9! 0&-#1! 5,9%'/! $0#! 5#-&*%$%&'! Y#9#! 9#'5#9#5!

Page 9: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

B!&D!6<!

0&-#*#11!)1!)!9#1,*$!&D!$0#!)=$%&'1!&D!$0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!b&H#9'-#'$O!R&9#&H#9C!'&!

4,1%'#11! &Y'#91! Y#9#! =&-8#'1)$#5! D&9! $0#! *&11! &D! $0#%9! 1$9,=$,9#1! )'5!

89&8#9$%#1O!

!

NO;:! V#!9#18#=$D,**F!,9/#!$0#!()$%&')*!+,-)'!.%/0$1!2&--%11%&'!$&!D%'5!$0)$!$0#!5#-&*%$%&'!

&D! 0&-#1! )'5! 4,1%'#11#1! &'! R)9=0! ;N^;7C! <:;<! 4F! $0#! K)/&1! 3$)$#! b&H#9'-#'$!

=&'1$%$,$#1! )! D&9=#5! #H%=$%&'C! )1! 5#D%'#5! ,'5#9! %'$#9')$%&')*! *)YC! )'5! =&'1#d,#'$*F! )!

H%&*)$%&'!&D!$0#!9%/0$!$&!0&,1%'/!)'5!10#*$#9O!!

!

!

ZP>' QNW-1QQ1BHQ'BH'1QQNF';D'BGXFC'!NHJ@-FHG@?'C1IXGQ'K1B?@G1BHQ'

!

AO;! ?1!5#$)%*#5!)4&H#C! $0#!],*F!;7^6;C!6:;6!5#-&*%$%&'1!9#1,*$#5! %'!)$! *#)1$!&'#!_%**%'/C! $0#!

59&Y'%'/!&D!)$!*#)1$!&'#!=0%*5!)'5!=&,'$*#11!%'\,9%#1!$&!9#1%5#'$1!&D!$0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!

V)$#9D9&'$! =&--,'%$FO! J'! $0#! =&,91#! &D! $0#! 5#-&*%$%&'1C! )$! *#)1$! '%'#! 8#91&'1! Y#9#!

,'*)YD,**F! )99#1$#5! )'5! 5#$)%'#5! Y%$0&,$! =0)9/#O! T,9$0#9C! $0#F! 9#1,*$#5! %'! $0#!

5#1$9,=$%&'! )'5! *&11! &D! H)*,)4*#! 89&8#9$F! &D! $0&,1)'51! &D! 9#1%5#'$1! Y0&! Y#9#!

1%-,*$)'#&,1*F! 9#'5#9#5! 0&-#*#11! )'5! *#D$! $&! *%H#! %'! &8#'! =)'&#1! &9! &'! $0#! 1$9##$1C!

Y%$0&,$! )'F! 5,#! 89&=#11! &D! *)YO! E0#! I=$&4#9! <;C! 6:;6! $09#)$! &D! D,9$0#9! 5#-&*%$%&'1!

*#)H#! $0#! 9#-)%'5#9! &D! $0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$! =&--,'%$F! [! ',-4#9%'/! ,8! $&!

6::C:::! %'! $&$)*! [! \,1$%D%)4*F! )D9)%5! $0)$! $0#F! Y%**! 1,DD#9! $0#! 1)-#! D)$#! )1! $0#%9!

'#%/04&,91O!R#)'Y0%*#C!8)1$!)'5!D,$,9#!5#-&*%$%&'1!$09#)$#'!$0#!*%H#*%0&&51!)'5!Y)F!&D!

*%D#!&D!$0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!=&--,'%$FO!

!

AO6! V#! 9#18#=$D,**F! 1,4-%$! $0)$! $0#1#! D)=$1! )-&,'$! $&! ',-#9&,1! H%&*)$%&'1! &D! $0#!

R)_&_&`JY)F)! V)$#9D9&'$! =&--,'%$F! 9#1%5#'$1c! D,'5)-#'$)*! )'5! 0,-)'! 9%/0$1!

/,)9)'$##5! ,'5#9! $0#! ;PPP! 2&'1$%$,$%&'C! $0#! ?D9%=)'! 20)9$#9! &D! +,-)'! )'5! "#&8*#1c!

.%/0$1! U)1!5&-#1$%=)$#5WC! $0#! J'$#9')$%&')*!2&H#')'$!&'!>=&'&-%=C! 3&=%)*! )'5!2,*$,9)*!

.%/0$1C!)'5!$0#!J'$#9')$%&')*!2&H#')'$!&'!2%H%*!)'5!"&*%$%=)*!.%/0$1O!

!

AO<! V#! '&Y! )559#11! #)=0! D,'5)-#'$)*! 9%/0$1! H%&*)$%&'! %'! $,9'C! )559#11%'/! 89%-)9%*F! $0#!

H%&*)$%&'1! $0)$! )*9#)5F! &==,99#5! %'! $0#! =&,91#! &D! $0#! ],*F! ;7^6;C! 6:;6! 5#-&*%$%&'1O! J$!

1$)'51! $&! 9#)1&'C! 0&Y#H#9C! $0)$! $0#! $09#)$! &D! D,9$0#9! 5#-&*%$%&'1! %'! $0#! =&--,'%$F!

D&9#10)5&Y#5! 4F! X)F&! 3,*#%-)'! )'5! $0#! ],*F! ;6C! 6:;6! (&$%=#! D9&-! $0#! K)/&1! 3$)$#!

R%'%1$9F! &D! V)$#9D9&'$! J'D9)1$9,=$,9#! G#H#*&8-#'$! )*1&! *#)H#1! $0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)!

V)$#9D9&'$!=&--,'%$F!9#)1&')4*F!D#)9%'/!$0)$!D,9$0#9!D,'5)-#'$)*!9%/0$1!H%&*)$%&'1!%'!

$0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$! =&--,'%$F! =&,*5! 9#1,*$! )$! )'F! $%-#O! E0#F! 9#18#=$D,**F!

)889&)=0!$0#!()$%&')*!+,-)'!.%/0$1!2&--%11%&'!D&9!9#59#11!4F!Y)F!&D!5#=*)9)$&9F!)'5!

#d,%$)4*#!9#*%#D1O!

!

! B$495&$48'4@';$3#&'&4'C$@0'@42'D5E$9F'4@'G2>'H/8IJ4F58K5'

!

AON!! V#! 1,4-%$! $0)$! $0#! ,'\,1$%D%#5! _%**%'/! &D! R9O! E%-&$0F! ?S%'_8&'&! +,'_8&F)'Y)C! )'!

,')9-#5! 9#1%5#'$! &D! $0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)! V)$#9D9&'$! =&--,'%$FC! 4F! )! /,'10&$! $&! $0#!

1$&-)=0!D%9#5!4F!"&*%=#!2&98&9)*!X&-)!"#88*#!%1!)!H%&*)$%&'!&D!$0#!9%/0$!$&!*%D#!#'109%'#5!

%'!3#=$%&'!<<U;W!&D!$0#!;PPP!2&'1$%$,$%&'C!Y0%=0!9#)51L!

Page 10: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

P!&D!6<!

!

/0"+7' R"+I%&' G*I' *' +$)G#' #%' B$1"<' *&,' &%' %&"' IG*BB' H"' ,"R+$0",'

$&#"&#$%&*BB7'%1'G$I'B$1"<'I*0"'$&'"F".;#$%&'%1'#G"'I"&#"&."'%1'*'.%;+#'$&'

+"IR".#'%1'*'.+$:$&*B'%11"&."'*#'6G$.G'G"'G*I'H""&'1%;&,');$B#7LLL'

!

AOA! ?*$0&,/0! 3#=$%&'! <<U6W! *%1$1! )! ',-4#9! &D! #Z=#8$%&'1! $0)$!Y&,*5! \,1$%DF! )'! #Z$9)\,5%=%)*!

_%**%'/! 1&! $0)$! %$!Y&,*5! '&$! =&'1$%$,$#! )! H%&*)$%&'! &D! 3#=$%&'! <<U;WC! $0#! /,'10&$! D%9#5! 4F!

"&*%=#!2&98&9)*!X&-)!"#88*#!D%$1!%'$&!'&'#O!>H%5#'=#!10&Y1!$0)$!0#!D%9#5!)'!,'89&H&_#5!

/,'10&$!)$!)'!,')9-#5!9#1%5#'$!&D!$0#!=&--,'%$F!Y0&!Y)1!&'!)!89&8#9$F!$0)$!0%1!D)-%*F!

,1#5!D&9!$0#%9!D%10%'/!4,1%'#11O!E0%1!/,'10&$!$&!$0#!)45&-#'!*#5!5%9#=$*F!)'5!%'!10&9$!$%-#!

$&!$0#!5#)$0!&D!R9O!+,'_8&F)'Y)O!Q%%'FRS)T)*U'J8:JOP!

!

AO7! T,9$0#9C! $0#!9%/0$! $&! *%D#!0)1!4##'!0#*5! $&! %'=*,5#!)'! %-8*%=%$! 9%/0$! $&! *%H#*%0&&5!U1##! D,**!

)')*F1%1!&D!9%/0$!$&!*%H#*%0&&5!H%&*)$%&'1!4#*&YWO!E0#!_%**%'/!&D!R9O!+,'_8&F)'Y)!5#89%H#5!

0%1!D)-%*F!&D!$0#%9!89%-)9F!49#)5Y%''#9C!$0#9#4F!=&'1$%$,$%'/!)!5%1$%'=$!H%&*)$%&'!&D!$0#%9!

9%/0$!$&!*%H#*%0&&5O!

!

AO@!! E0#!9%/0$!$&!*%D#!%1!49&)5*F!89&$#=$#5!,'5#9!%'$#9')$%&')*!*)YC!%'=*,5%'/!,'5#9!?9$%=*#!N!

&D!$0#!?D9%=)'!20)9$#9C!)'5!?9$%=*#!7!&D!$0#!J22".C!)-&'/!&$0#91O!?9$%=*#!N!&D!$0#!?D9%=)'!

20)9$#9!1$)$#1L!!

!

T;:*&'H"$&)I'*+"'$&0$%B*HB"L'/0"+7'G;:*&'H"$&)'IG*BB'H"'"&#$#B",'#%'+"IR".#'1%+'G$I'

B$1"'*&,'#G"'$&#")+$#7'%1'G$I'R"+I%&L'O%'%&"':*7'H"'*+H$#+*+$B7',"R+$0",'%1'#G$I'+$)G#L'

!

?9$%=*#!7U;W!&D!$0#!J22".!1$)$#1L!!

!

/0"+7'G;:*&'H"$&)'G*I' #G"' $&G"+"&#' +$)G#' #%' B$1"L'QG$I' +$)G#' IG*BB'H"'R+%#".#",'H7'

B*6L'O%'%&"'IG*BB'H"'*+H$#+*+$B7',"R+$0",'%1'G$I'B$1"L'

!

AOBO!! ?==&95%'/*FC!Y#!1,4-%$!$0)$!$0#!_%**%'/!&D!R9O!+,'_8&F)'Y)!H%&*)$#5!$0#!9%/0$!$&!*%D#!)1!

/,)9)'$##5!%'!3#=$%&'!<<!&D!$0#!;PPP!2&'1$%$,$%&'C!?9$%=*#!N!&D!$0#!?D9%=)'!20)9$#9C!)'5!

?9$%=*#! 7U;W! &D! $0#! J22".C! )'5! %1! $0#9#D&9#! )=$%&')4*#! 4F! 0%1! 1,9H%H%'/! D)-%*FO! V#!

9#18#=$D,**F!,9/#!$0#!+,-)'!.%/0$1!2&--%11%&'!$&!1&!0&*5O!!

!

' B$495&$48*'4@';$3#&'&4'L$38$&F'

'

AOP! J'! $0#! =&,91#! &D! $0#! 5#-&*%$%&'! #Z#9=%1#C! -)'F! 9#1%5#'$1! &D! $0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)!

V)$#9D9&'$!=&--,'%$F!Y#9#!0)9)11#5C!-)%-#5C!4#)$#'!4F!$0#!5#-&*%$%&'!1d,)5!Y%$0&,$!

\,1$%D%=)$%&'O!E0#!5#-&*%$%&'!Y)1!=)99%#5!&,$!4F! $0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!R%'%1$9F!&D!Y)$#9D9&'$!

)'5! J'D9)1$9,=$,9)*! G#H#*&8-#'$! )==&-8)'%#5! 4F! )9-#5! 8&*%=#! )'5! K)/&1! 3$)$#!

5#-&*%$%&'! 1d,)5O! E0#F! =)-#! %'! 4&)$1! Y0%*#! $0#! 5#-&*%$%&'! 1d,)5! Y)1! )9-#5! Y%$0!

=0)%'1)Y1!)'5!0)--#91O!!!!!!

!

AO;:! V#!1,4-%$!$0)$!1,=0!)=$1!&D!H%&*#'=#!)'5!%'$%-%5)$%&'!)-&,'$!$&!H%&*)$%&'1!&D!$0#!9%/0$!

$&!5%/'%$F!&D! $0#!8#91&'!#'109%'#5! %'!3#=$%&'!<NU;W!&D! $0#!2&'1$%$,$%&'C!Y0%=0!9#)51! %'!

8#9$%'#'$!8)9$L!

Page 11: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

;:!&D!6<!

!

/0"+7' $&,$0$,;*B' $I' "&#$#B",' #%' +"IR".#' 1%+' #G"' ,$)&$#7' %1' #G"' R"+I%&<' *&,'

*..%+,$&)B7'['E*K'&%'R"+I%&'IG*BB'H"'I;H\".#",'#%'#%+#;+"'%+'#%'$&G;:*&'*&,'

,")+*,$&)'#+"*#:"&#L'

!

?1!Y#**!)1!?9$%=*#!A!&D!$0#!?D9%=)'!20)9$#9C!Y0%=0!1$)$#1L!

!

/0"+7'$&,$0$,;*B'IG*BB'G*0"'#G"'+$)G#'#%'#G"'+"IR".#'%1'#G"',$)&$#7'$&G"+"&#'$&'*'

G;:*&'H"$&)'*&,'#%'#G"'+".%)&$#$%&'%1'G$I'B")*B'I#*#;IL'JBB'1%+:I'%1'"FRB%$#*#$%&'*&,'

,")+*,*#$%&'%1':*&'R*+#$.;B*+B7'IB*0"+7<'IB*0"'#+*,"<'#%+#;+"<'.+;"B<'$&G;:*&'%+'

,")+*,$&)'R;&$IG:"&#'*&,'#+"*#:"&#'IG*BB'H"'R+%G$H$#",L'

!

! ?1!Y#**!)1!?9$%=*#!;:U;W!&D!$0#!J22".C!Y0%=0!1$)$#1L!

'

JBB'R"+I%&I',"R+$0",'%1'#G"$+'B$H"+#7'IG*BB'H"'#+"*#",'6$#G'G;:*&$#7'*&,'6$#G'+"IR".#'

1%+'#G"'$&G"+"&#',$)&$#7'%1'#G"'G;:*&'R"+I%&L'

!

AO;;! J'! $0#! =)1#! &D! (9$F/' .%25#$E' =' M#0' <4EE$**$4802' 4@' N49$A0! m6::@n! 3,%$! (&O!

2?`?`;;A`:AC! %'! Y0%=0! 8&*%=#! #'$#9#5! $0#! ?88*%=)'$c1! 0&,1#! )'5! 59)//#5! 0%-! &,$C!

=),1%'/! 0%-! %'\,9F! )'5! 9%88%'/! 0%1! =*&$01C! $0#! 2&,9$! &D! ?88#)*1! D&,'5! $0#1#! )=$1!

)-&,'$#5!$&!H%&*)$%&'1!&D!$0%1!8&9$%&'!&D!3#=$%&'!<NU;WC!9#)1&'%'/!)1!D&**&Y1L!

!

]&.G*BB"&)",' *11$,*0$#' "0$,"&."' #G*#' #G"' *RR"BB*&#' 6*I' G*+*II",' *&,'

$&#$:$,*#",'*&,'1%+."1;BB7',+*))",'%;#'%1'G$I'G%;I"'*+"'*.#I'#G*#'*:%;&#'#%'

$&G;:*&'#+"*#:"&#L'QG"'*RR"BB*&#'6*I'I;H\".#",'#%' $&G;:*&'#+"*#:"&#'*#'

#G"' G*&,I' %1' #G"' +"IR%&,"&#4*)"&#IL' 5#' 6*I' ,")+*,$&)' #+"*#:"&#' .B"*+B7'

.%&#+*+7'#%'#G"'R+%0$I$%&I'%1'M".#$%&'D^E*K'%1'#G"'9%&I#$#;#$%&L'

!

AO;6! V#!1,4-%$!$0)$!$0#!=&,'$*#11!)=$1!&D!0)9)11-#'$!)'5!4#)$%'/1!1,DD#9#5!4F!9#1%5#'$1!&D!

$0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)! V)$#9D9&'$! =&--,'%$F! %'! $0#! =&,91#! &D! $0#! 5#-&*%$%&'! &D! $0#%9!

0&-#1C!4,1%'#11!8*)=#1!)'5!=&--,'%$F!D)=%*%$%#1!)9#!)$!*#)1$!)1!1#H#9#!)1!$0&1#!5#1=9%4#5!

)4&H#O! T,9$0#9C! $0#! 1,DD#9%'/C! 5%18*)=#-#'$! )'5! 0&-#*#11'#11! )11&=%)$#5! Y%$0! D&9=#5!

#H%=$%&'1! 1,=0! )1! $0#1#! %1! %$1#*D! /#'#9)**F! D&,'5! $&! =&'1$%$,$#! =9,#*C! %'0,-)'! )'5!

5#/9)5%'/! $9#)$-#'$! %'! H%&*)$%&'! &D! $0#! 9%/0$! $&! 5%/'%$F! #'109%'#5! %'! $0#! ;PPP!

2&'1$%$,$%&'O!J'5##5C!$0#!20)%9-)'!&D!$0#!()$%&')*!+,-)'!.%/0$1!2&--%11%&'!D&,'5!)1!

-,=0! %'! 0%1! 8,4*%=! 1$)$#-#'$! )4&,$! $0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)! V)$#9D9&'$! 5#-&*%$%&'1! UU%%'

FRS)T)*U'F8:FZWO!!

!

AO;<! ?==&95%'/*FC!Y#!1,4-%$!$0)$!$0#!5#-&*%$%&'!)*&'/!Y%$0!$0#!)$$#'5)'$!=9,#*$F!-#$#5!,8&'!

$0#!9#1%5#'$1!&D!$0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!Y)$#9D9&'$!=&--,'%$F!4F!$0#!5#-&*%$%&'!1d,)5!)'5!

&$0#9!K)/&1!3$)$#!&DD%=%)*1!)-&,'$!$&!H%&*)$%&'1!&D!3#=$%&'!<NU;WU)W!&D!$0#!2&'1$%$,$%&'C!)1!

Y#**!)1!?9$%=*#!A!&D!$0#!?D9%=)'!20)9$#9C!)'5!?9$%=*#!;:!&D!$0#!J22".O!V#!9#18#=$D,**F!,9/#!

$0#!()$%&')*!+,-)'!.%/0$1!2&--%11%&'!$&!1&!0&*5O!!

!

!

!

Page 12: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

;;!&D!6<!

B$495&$48*'4@';$3#&'&4'C$%02&F' '

!

AO;N! I'! ],*F! 6;C! 6:;6C! $0#! D%')*! 5)F! &D! $0#! 5#-&*%$%&'1! %'! $0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)! V)$#9D9&'$!

=&--,'%$FC!)$!*#)1$!'%'#!9#1%5#'$1!Y#9#!)99#1$#5!)'5!5#$)%'#5!Y%$0&,$!)'F!\,1$%D%=)$%&'O!

E0#F!Y#9#!&'*F!9#*#)1#5!D&,9!5)F1!*)$#9C!&'!E,#15)FC!],*F!6NC!6:;6C!Y%$0&,$!#H#9!4#%'/!

=0)9/#5O! E0&1#! ,'*)YD,**F! 5#$)%'#5! %'=*,5#L! ?D&'1#! K)$##DC! V)1%,! G)'0,$&C! 3#'5#!

G)'0,$&C! ])=_*F'! G)'0,$&C! X#',)! ?0&'*&'1,C! >S#_%#*! +,'/#H,C! +,'/#! +)')C! +,'/#!

X)9$0&*&-#Y!)'5!+,'/#!]#9#-FO!!

!

AO;A! V#!1,4-%$!$0)$!$0#1#!,'*)YD,*!)99#1$1!)'5!5#$#'$%&'1!=&'1$%$,$#!H%&*)$%&'1!&D!$0#!9%/0$!

$&!*%4#9$F!#'109%'#5!%'!3#=$%&'!<AU;W!&D!$0#!2&'1$%$,$%&'C!Y0%=0!9#)51L!

!

/0"+7'R"+I%&'IG*BB'H"'"&#$#B",'#%'G$I'R"+I%&*B'B$H"+#7'*&,'&%'R"+I%&'IG*BB'H"'

,"R+$0",'%1'I;.G'B$H"+#7'I*0"'$&'#G"'1%BB%6$&)'.*I"I'*&,'$&'*..%+,*&."'6$#G'*'

R+%.",;+"'R"+:$##",'*#'B*6_'

'

! ?1!Y#**!)1!?9$%=*#!7!&D!$0#!?D9%=)'!20)9$#9C!Y0%=0!1$)$#1L!

!

/0"+7'$&,$0$,;*B'IG*BB'G*0"'#G"'+$)G#'#%'B$H"+#7'*&,'#%'#G"'I".;+$#7'%1'G$I'R"+I%&L'O%'

%&"':*7'H"',"R+$0",'%1'G$I'1+"",%:'"F."R#'1%+'+"*I%&I'*&,'.%&,$#$%&I'R+"0$%;IB7'

B*$,',%6&'H7'B*6L'5&'R*+#$.;B*+<'&%'%&"':*7'H"'*+H$#+*+$B7'*++"I#",'%+',"#*$&",L''

!

?1!Y#**!)1!?9$%=*#!PU;W!&D!$0#!J22".C!Y0%=0!1$)$#1L!

!

/0"+7%&"'G*I'#G"'+$)G#'#%'B$H"+#7'*&,'I".;+$#7'%1'R"+I%&L'O%'%&"'IG*BB'H"'I;H\".#",'#%'

*+H$#+*+7'*++"I#'%+',"#"&#$%&L'O%'%&"'IG*BB'H"',"R+$0",'%1'G$I'B$H"+#7'"F."R#'%&'I;.G'

)+%;&,I'*&,'$&'*..%+,*&."'6$#G'I;.G'R+%.",;+"'*I'*+"'"I#*HB$IG",'H7'B*6L'

!

AO;7! E0#9#! %1! '&! #H%5#'=#! $0)$! $0#! )99#1$1! )'5! 5#$#'$%&'1! =)99%#5! &,$! %'! $0#! =&,91#! &D! $0#!

R)_&_&`JY)F)! V)$#9D9&'$! 5#-&*%$%&'1! Y#9#! %'! )==&95)'=#! Y%$0! )'F! 89&=#5,9#!

8#9-%$$#5!)$!*)Y!)1!#*)4&9)$#5!%'!3#=$%&'!<AU;WU)W^U=W!&D!$0#!2&'1$%$,$%&'C!&9!)'F!&$0#9!

*)Y! %'! D&9=#! %'!(%/#9%)O!R&9#&H#9C! )$! $0#! $%-#! &D! $0#! )99#1$C! '&'#! &D! $0#! )4&H#^')-#5!

%'5%H%5,)*1!Y#9#!89&-8$*F!%'D&9-#5!&D!$0#!9#)1&'!D&9!$0#%9!)99#1$!&9!$0#!=0)9/#1!)/)%'1$!

$0#-C! '&9! Y#9#! $0#9#! 89&-8$*F! 49&,/0$! 4#D&9#! )! \,5/#C! Y0%=0! =&'1$%$,$#1! )! =*#)9!

H%&*)$%&'!&D!?9$%=*#!PU6W^U<W!&D!$0#!J22".O!!

!

AO;@! ?==&95%'/*FC!Y#!9#18#=$D,**F!,9/#! $0#!()$%&')*!+,-)'!.%/0$1!2&--%11%&'! $&!0&*5! $0)$!

$0#F! )-&,'$! $&! )94%$9)9F! )99#1$! )'5! 5#$#'$%&'! )'5! H%&*)$#! $0#! D,'5)-#'$)*! 9%/0$! $&!

*%4#9$F!/,)9)'$##5!%'!3#=$%&'!<AU;W!&D!$0#!2&'1$%$,$%&'C!?9$%=*#!7!&D!$0#!?D9%=)'!20)9$#9C!

)'5!?9$%=*#!PU;W!&D!$0#!J22".O!

'

' B$495&$48*'4@';$3#&'&4'(A7/$20'586'OK8'N24J02&F'

'

AO;B! J'! $0#! =&,91#! &D! $0#! ],*F! ;7^6;C! 6:;6! 5#-&*%$%&'C! $0&,1)'51! &D! 8#91&'1!Y#9#! )DD#=$#5!

$09&,/0!*&11!&D!$0#%9!0&-#1C!4,1%'#11!8*)=#1!)'5!=&--,'%$F!1$9,=$,9#1!-)5#!&D!Y&&51!

)'5!S%'=O!E0#1#!1$9,=$,9#1!Y#9#!5#-&*%10#5!Y%$0!=0)%'!1)Y1!)'5!&$0#9!$&&*1C!9#'5#9%'/!

Page 13: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

;6!&D!6<!

$0#-! *&1$! %'! H)*,#! D&9! $0#%9! &Y'#91O! G,#! $&! $0#! '&'#Z%1$#'$! '&$%=#C! -)'F! )*1&! *&1$!

H)*,)4*#!4#*&'/%'/1!$0)$!Y#9#!%'1%5#!$0#!1$9,=$,9#1O!

!

AO;P! V#!1,4-%$! $0)$! $0#!5#-&*%$%&'!&D!0&-#1C!4,1%'#11!89#-%1#1C! )'5!=&--,'%$F! D)=%*%$%#1C!

=),1%'/! *)9/#^1=)*#! *&11! &D! 89&8#9$F! Y%$0&,$! 5,#! 89&=#11C! )'F! =&-8#'1)$%&'! &9! )!

5#-&'1$9)$#5!8,4*%=!'##5C! %1!)!H%&*)$%&'!&D! $0#!=&'1$%$,$%&')*!9%/0$!$&!)=d,%9#!)'5!&Y'!

4&$0!-&H)4*#!)'5!%--&H)4*#!89&8#9$F!)'5!$0#!89&$#=$%&'1!/,)9)'$##5!,'5#9!3#=$%&'1!

N<!o!NNU;W!U)!o!4W!&D!$0#!2&'1$%$,$%&'!)'5!?9$%=*#1!;N!o!6;!&D!$0#!?D9%=)'!20)9$#9O!

!

AO6:! V#! D,9$0#9! 1,4-%$! $0)$! $0#! D&9=#5! )=d,%1%$%&'! )'5! 5#-&*%$%&'! &D! 0&-#1C! 4,1%'#11!

89#-%1#1C! )'5! =&--,'%$F! D)=%*%$%#1C! =),1%'/! *)9/#^1=)*#! *&11! &D! 89&8#9$F! Y%$0&,$! 5,#!

89&=#11C! )5#d,)$#! =&-8#'1)$%&'! &9! )! 5#-&'1$9)$#5! 8,4*%=! '##5C! %1! )! H%&*)$%&'! &D! $0#!

=&'1$%$,$%&')*! 9%/0$! $&! )=d,%9#! )'5! &Y'! 4&$0! -&H)4*#! )'5! %--&H)4*#! 89&8#9$F!

/,)9)'$##5!,'5#9!3#=$%&'1!N<!o!NNU;W!U)!o!4W!&D!$0#!;PPP!2&'1$%$,$%&'!)'5!$0#!0,-)'!

9%/0$1!/,)9)'$##5!4F!?9$%=*#1!;N!o!6;!&D!$0#!?D9%=)'!20)9$#9C!)-&'/!&$0#9!%'$#9')$%&')*!

%'1$9,-#'$1!$&!Y0%=0!(%/#9%)!%1!8)9$FO!

!

AO6;! E0#! (%/#9%)'! 2&'1$%$,$%&'! /,)9)'$##1! )**! %'5%H%5,)*1! Y%$0&,$! 5%1=9%-%')$%&'! &9!

d,)*%D%=)$%&'C! $0#! 9%/0$! $&! )=d,%9#! )'5! &Y'! 89&8#9$F! )'5! $&! D9##*F! ,1#! )'5! #'\&F! 1,=0!

89&8#9$F! Y%$0&,$! %'$#9D#9#'=#O! 38#=%D%=)**FC! 3#=$%&'1! N<! )'5! NN! &D! $0#! 2&'1$%$,$%&'! &D!

(%/#9%)!89&H%5#!$0)$L!

!

^DL' ' M;H\".#' #%' #G"' R+%0$I$%&I' %1' #G$I' 9%&I#$#;#$%&<' "0"+7' .$#$`"&' %1' O$)"+$*'

IG*BB' G*0"' #G"' +$)G#' #%' *.X;$+"' *&,' %6&' $::%0*HB"' R+%R"+#7' *&76G"+"' $&'

O$)"+$*L'

'

^^L' ' E=K' O%':%0"*HB"' R+%R"+#7' %+' *&7' $&#"+"I#' $&' *&' $::%0*HB"' R+%R"+#7'

IG*BB'H"'#*3"&'R%II"II$%&'%1'.%:R;BI%+$B7'*&,'&%'+$)G#'%0"+'%+'$&#"+"I#'$&'*&7'

I;.G'R+%R"+#7'IG*BB'H"'*.X;$+",'.%:R;BI%+$B7'$&'*&7'R*+#'%1'O$)"+$*'"F."R#'$&'

#G"' :*&&"+' *&,' 1%+' #G"' R;+R%I"' R+"I.+$H",' H7' *' B*6' #G*#<' *:%&)' %#G"+'

#G$&)I'

'

E*K'("X;$+"I'#G"'R+%:R#'R*7:"&#'%1'.%:R"&I*#$%&'#G"+"%1'*&,'

'

EHK'a$0"I'#%'*&7'R"+I%&'.B*$:$&)'I;.G'.%:R"&I*#$%&'*'+$)G#'%1'*.."II'

1%+'#G"',"#"+:$&*#$%&'%1'G$I'$&#"+"I#'$&'#G"'R+%R"+#7'*&,'#G"'*:%;&#'

%1' .%:R"&I*#$%&' #%' *' .%;+#' %1' B*6' %+' #+$H;&*B' %+' H%,7' G*0$&)'

\;+$I,$.#$%&'$&'#G*#'R*+#'%1'O$)"+$*L'

!

AO66! V#!1,4-%$! $0)$! $0#!=&-4%'#5! D&9=#!&D!3#=$%&'1!N<!)'5!NN!&D! $0#!(%/#9%)'!2&'1$%$,$%&'!

#'1,9#! $0#! 1)'=$%$F! &D! )**! 89&8#9$FC! 4&$0! -&H)4*#! )'5! %--&H)4*#C! 4F! 89&0%4%$%'/! $0#!

$)_%'/!&D!1,=0!89&8#9$F!Y%$0&,$!=&H#9!&D!*)YC!=&-8#'1)$%&'C!)'5!)==#11!$&!$0#!=&,9$1O!!XF!

%-8*%=)$%&'C!3#=$%&'!NN!9#)DD%9-1!$0#!9%/0$!$&!&Y'C!8&11#11C!,1#!)'5!#'\&F!4&$0!-&H)4*#!

)'5! %--&H)4*#! 89&8#9$FC! 1%'=#! Y%$0&,$! 1,=0! 9%/0$1! $0#9#! Y&,*5! 4#! '&! '##5! D&9! )!

89&0%4%$%&'! &'! $0#! $)_%'/! &D! 89&8#9$FO! ! E0#1#! 89&$#=$%&'1! )9#! )*1&! =&'1%1$#'$!Y%$0! $0#!

Page 14: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

;<!&D!6<!

=&--&'! *)Y! =&'=#8$%&'! &D! 89&8#9$FC! Y0%=0! 0)1! *&'/! 9#=&/'%S#5! $0)$! $0#! 9%/0$! $&!

89&8#9$F!%'=*,5#1!$0#!9%/0$!$&!,1#!)'5!#'\&F-#'$C!$&!$0#!#Z=*,1%&'!&D!)**!&$0#91O!

!

AO6<! E0#!89&$#=$%&'1!&DD#9#5!4F!3#=$%&'!NN!&D!$0#!2&'1$%$,$%&'!)9#!49&)5C!=&H#9%'/!)**!$F8#1!&D!

89&8#9$F!)'5!)'F! D&9-!&D! %'$#9#1$O! !?1!1,=0C! $0#1#!89&$#=$%&'1!#Z$#'5!'&$!&'*F! $&! *)'5C!

4,$!)*1&!$&!%--&H)4*#!89&8#9$FC!1,=0!)1!4,%*5%'/1!)'5!D%Z#5!1$9,=$,9#1C!)'5!$&!-&H#)4*#!

89&8#9$FC! %'=*,5%'/! 0&,1#0&*5! %$#-1O! 2&'1#d,#'$*FC! D&9=#5! #H%=$%&'1! )'5! 5#-&*%$%&'1!

R+$:*' 1*.$"! H%&*)$#1! $0#! =&'1$%$,$%&')*! 9%/0$! $&! 89&8#9$FC! 9#/)95*#11! &D! Y0#$0#9! $0#!

%'5%H%5,)*!Y0&1#!0&-#!%1!5#-&*%10#5!0)5!$%$*#!$&!$0#!*)'5C!4#=),1#C!)$!)!-%'%-,-C!$0#F!

9#1,*$!%'!$0#!5#1$9,=$%&'!&D!0&,1%'/!-)$#9%)*1!)'5!0&,1#0&*5!/&&51O!

!

AO6N! E0#1#!=&'1$%$,$%&')*!9#d,%9#-#'$1!)9#!4,$$9#11#5!)'5!%'D&9-#5!4F!?9$%=*#1!;N!)'5!;7!&D!

$0#!?D9%=)'!20)9$#9C!Y0%=0!%1!4%'5%'/!*)Y!%'!(%/#9%)!,'5#9!3#=$%&'!;6!&D!$0#!2&'1$%$,$%&'O'

?9$%=*#!;N!&D! $0#!?D9%=)'!20)9$#9!/,)9)'$##1! $0#! 9%/0$! $&!89&8#9$F!)'5!89&H%5#1! $0)$! %$!

e-)F!&'*F!4#!#'=9&)=0#5!,8&'!%'!$0#!%'$#9#1$!&D!8,4*%=!'##5!&9!%'!$0#!/#'#9)*!%'$#9#1$!&D!

$0#!=&--,'%$F!)'5!%'!)==&95)'=#!Y%$0!$0#!89&H%1%&'1!&D!)889&89%)$#!*)Y1Of!?9$%=*#!6;U6W!

)*1&! 89&H%5#1! 9#*%#D! %D! ?9$%=*#! ;N! %1! H%&*)$#5L! eJ'! =)1#! &D! 18&*%)$%&'! $0#! 5%18&11#11#5!

8#&8*#! 10)**! 0)H#! $0#! 9%/0$! $&! $0#! *)YD,*! 9#=&H#9F! &D! %$1! 89&8#9$F! )1! Y#**! )1! $&! )'!

)5#d,)$#! =&-8#'1)$%&'Of! ?1! Y)1! 9#=#'$*F! =&'D%9-#5! 4F! $0#! ?D9%=)'! 2&--%11%&'! &'!

+,-)'! )'5! "#&8*#1c! .%/0$1! U?D9%=)'! 2&--%11%&'W! %'! $0#! <08&20' @42' G$842$&F' ;$3#&*'

L0=094JE08&' PQ08F5R' 586' G$842$&F' ;$3#&*' S24/J' .8&0285&$4859' 48' %0#59@' 4@'

!86424$*'T09@520'<4/8A$9'B*>'Q08F5C!2&--,'%=)$%&'!(&O!6@7!`!6::<L'

!

bQcG"'#"I#'B*$,'%;#'$&'J+#$.B"'=^'%1'#G"'9G*+#"+'$I''.%&\;&.#$0"<'#G*#'$I<'$&'%+,"+'

1%+'*&'"&.+%*.G:"&#'&%#' #%'H"' $&'0$%B*#$%&'%1'J+#$.B"'=^<' $#':;I#'H"'R+%0"&'

#G*#' #G"' "&.+%*.G:"&#' 6*I' $&' #G"' $&#"+"I#' %1' #G"' R;HB$.' &"",4)"&"+*B'

$&#"+"I#' %1' #G"' .%::;&$#7' *&,' 6*I' .*++$",' %;#' $&' *..%+,*&."' 6$#G'

*RR+%R+$*#"'B*6L'

!

AO6A! E0,1C!$0#!?D9%=)'!20)9$#9!9#%$#9)$#1!$0#!9%/0$!$&!=&-8#'1)$%&'!)*9#)5F!/,)9)'$##5!4F!$0#!

(%/#9%)'! 2&'1$%$,$%&'C! )55%'/! $0#! 9#d,%9#-#'$! $0)$! 1,=0! =&-8#'1)$%&'! 4#! '&$! &'*F!

R+%:R#C!4,$!)*1&!*,"X;*#"O!E0#!?D9%=)'!20)9$#9!)*1&!9#%$#9)$#1!$0)$!$0#!$)_%'/!&D!89&8#9$F!

-,1$! 4#! $&' *..%+,*&."' 6$#G' #G"' R+%0$I$%&I' %1' *RR+%R+$*#"' B*6IC! Y0%=0! 9#%'D&9=#1! $0#!

/,)9)'$##!%'!$0#!(%/#9%)'!2&'1$%$,$%&'!$0)$!)!8#91&'!)DD#=$#5!4F!$0#!$)_%'/!&D!89&8#9$F!

-,1$!0)H#!)==#11! $&!)! =&,9$!&D! *)Y! D&9! $0#!5#$#9-%')$%&'!&D! =&-8#'1)$%&'O!V#!1,4-%$!

$0)$! )5#d,)$#! =&-8#'1)$%&'! -,1$! '&$! &'*F! =&-8#'1)$#! $0#! )DD#=$#5! 8#91&'1! D&9! $0#!

H)*,#!&D!$0#!89&8#9$F!$)_#'!&9!5#1$9&F#5C!4,$!)*1&!$0#!&$0#9!0)9-1!$0#F!-)F!1,DD#9!)1!)!

=&'1#d,#'=#!&D!0)H%'/!$0#%9!89&8#9$F!$)_#'`5#1$9&F#5!4F!b&H#9'-#'$O!

!

AO67! T%')**FC!$0#!?D9%=)'!20)9$#9!1,88*#-#'$1!$0#!e&H#99%5%'/!8,4*%=!8,98&1#f!9#d,%9#-#'$!%'!

$0#!K)'5!i1#!?=$C!1$)$%'/!$0)$!$0#!9%/0$!$&!89&8#9$F![!)'F!D&9-!&D!89&8#9$F![!-)F!&'*F!4#!

#'=9&)=0#5!e%'!$0#!%'$#9#1$!&D!R;HB$.'&"",!&9!%'!$0#!/#'#9)*!%'$#9#1$!&D!$0#!=&--,'%$FOf!

V#!1,4-%$!$0)$C!D&9!$0%1!=&,9$!$&!5#$#9-%'#!$0)$!)!$)_%'/!&D!89&8#9$F!%1!\,1$%D%#5!4F!1,=0!*'

R;HB$.'&"",'%+'#G"')"&"+*B'$&#"+"I#'%1'#G"'.%::;&$#7C!$0#!b&H#9'-#'$!-,1$!5#-&'1$9)$#!

$0)$! -#)1,9#5! %'! $0#! 4)*)'=#! &D! #d,%$FC! $0#! ,9/#'=F! &D! $0#! 8,4*%=! '##5! &9! )'5! $0#!

%-8&9$)'=#!&D!$0#!/#'#9)*!%'$#9#1$!&,$Y#%/01!$0#!0)9-!1,DD#9#5!4F!$0#!8#91&'1!Y0&!)9#!

Page 15: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

;N!&D!6<!

5#89%H#5!&D!$0#%9!89&8#9$F!)'5!$0,1!)9#!-&1$!%--#5%)$#*F!)DD#=$#5O!E0%1!=)*=,*)$%&'!-,1$!

$)_#!%'$&!=&'1%5#9)$%&'!$0#!&$0#9!9%/0$1!/,)9)'$##5!4F!$0#!2&'1$%$,$%&'!)'5!$0#!?D9%=)'!

20)9$#9! $0)$!)9#!)*1&!)$! 1$)_#O!R&9#&H#9C! $0#!b&H#9'-#'$c1!89&8&1#5!)=$%&'!10&,*5!4#!

#H)*,)$#5!%'!*%/0$!&D!4&$0!#d,%$F!)'5!$0#!5%9#=$%H#!89%'=%8*#1!#'109%'#5!%'!$0#!20)8$#9!JJ!

&D!$0#!(%/#9%)'!2&'1$%$,$%&'C!%'=*,5%'/!89&H%1%&'!&D!1,%$)4*#!)'5!)5#d,)$#!10#*$#9!,'5#9!

3#=$%&'!;7U6WC!$0#!89&H%1%&'!&D!8,4*%=!)11%1$)'=#!$&!$0&1#!%'!'##5!,'5#9!3#=$%&'!;@U<WU/WC!

$0#! 89&-&$%&'! &D! D)-%*F! *%D#! ,'5#9! 3#=$%&'! ;@U<WU0WC! )'5! )1! )! 89%-)9F! 8,98&1#! &D!

b&H#9'-#'$!,'5#9!3#=$%&'!;NU6WU4WC!$0#!8#&8*#c1!1#=,9%$F!)'5!Y#*D)9#O!

!

AO6@! 3,=0!%'$#989#$)$%&'!&D!?9$%=*#!;N!%1!%'!*%'#!Y%$0!$0#!9#)1&'%'/!&D!$0#!?D9%=)'!2&--%11%&'C!

Y0%=0! %'! $0#!!86424$*'T09@520'<08&02'B*>'Q08F5! U3,89)W!)$!8)9)/9)80!6;NC!0#*5! $0)$!

e)'F!*%-%$)$%&'1!&'!9%/0$1!-,1$!4#!89&8&9$%&')$#!$&!)!*#/%$%-)$#!'##5C!)'5!10&,*5!4#!$0#!

*#)1$!9#1$9%=$%H#!-#)1,9#1!8&11%4*#Of!?88*F%'/!$0#!e8,4*%=!%'$#9#1$!$#1$f!,'5#9!?9$%=*#!;N!

$&! D%'5! $0)$!h#'F)c1!5%18*)=#-#'$!&D! $0#!>'5&9&%1! =&--,'%$F!Y)1!5%189&8&9$%&')$#! $&!

$0#! 8,4*%=! %'$#9#1$! )11#9$#5C! $0#! 2&--%11%&'! *%'_#5! $0%1! $#1$! $&! $0#! #DD#=$! $0#!

5%18*)=#-#'$! 0)5! &'! $0#! =*)%-)'$1c! 9%/0$! $&! *%D#! )'5! *%H#*%0&&5! )'5! $0#! 89%'=%8*#1! &D!

0,-)'!5%/'%$FO!J$!'&$#5C!-&9#&H#9C!$0)$!%D!$0#!b&H#9'-#'$!0)5!5#-&'1$9)$#5!!

!

*' B")$#$:*#"' *$:' b#G*#c' I"+0",' *' R;HB$.' &"",<' $#' .%;B,' G*0"' H""&'

*..%:RB$IG",' H7' *B#"+&*#$0"' :"*&I' R+%R%+#$%&*#"' #%' #G"' &"",L' -+%:' #G"'

"0$,"&."'I;H:$##",'H%#G'%+*BB7'*&,'$&'6+$#$&)<'$#'$I'.B"*+'#G*#'#G"'.%::;&$#7'

6*I' 6$BB$&)' #%' 6%+3' 6$#G' #G"' a%0"+&:"&#' $&' *' 6*7' #G*#' +"IR".#",' #G"$+'

R+%R"+#7'+$)G#I_L'

!

AO6@! E0#!1,--)9F!5#-&*%$%&'!&D!0&-#1C!4,1%'#11!89#-%1#1C! =&--,'%$F! 1$9,=$,9#1C! =),1%'/!

*&11! &D! %--&H)4*#! 89&8#9$F! )'5! -&H)4*#! 89&8#9$F! =&'$)%'#5! $0#9#%'C! Y%$0&,$! 5,#!

89&=#11! &D! *)YC! %1! )! =*#)9! H%&*)$%&'! &D! $0#! 9%/0$! $&! 89&8#9$F! ,'5#9! $0#! (%/#9%)'!

2&'1$%$,$%&'! )'5! $0#! ?D9%=)'! 20)9$#9O! J'! &95#9! $&! $)_#! 89&8#9$FC! Y0#$0#9! $09&,/0!

=&-8,*1&9F!)=d,%1%$%&'C!5#1$9,=$%&'!&9!&$0#9Y%1#C!)'5!'&$!9,'!)D&,*!&D!$0#!2&'1$%$,$%&'!

)'5! %$1! %'$#9')$%&')*! 0,-)'! 9%/0$1! &4*%/)$%&'1C! $0#! K)/&1! 3$)$#! b&H#9'-#'$! -,1$!

89&=##5! &'*F! %'! )==&95)'=#! Y%$0! )889&89%)$#! *)Y! )'5! Y%$0! )H)%*)4*#! 9#=&,91#! $&! $0#!

=&,9$1! &D! *)YC! Y%$0! 8)F-#'$! &D! 89&-8$! )'5! )5#d,)$#! =&-8#'1)$%&'C! )'5! D&9!

5#-&'1$9)$#5!8,4*%=!'##5!)'5!%'!$0#!/#'#9)*!%'$#9#1$!&D!$0#!=&--,'%$FO!!

!

AO6B! V%$0&,$! $)_%'/! 1,=0! 1$#81! %'! $0#! =&,91#! &D! )=d,%1%$%&'C! $0#! K)/&1! 3$)$#! b&H#9'-#'$!

H%&*)$#5!$0#!89&8#9$F!9%/0$1!&D!$0&,1)'51!&D!-#-4#91!&D!$0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!

=&--,'%$FO!V#!9#18#=$D,**F!,9/#!$0#!()$%&')*!+,-)'!.%/0$1!2&--%11%&'!$&!1&!0&*5O!

!

AO6P! T,9$0#9-&9#C!$0#!$09#)$!&D!D,$,9#!5#-&*%$%&'1!4F!X)F&!3,*#%-)'!U3O"OW!-,1$!4#!#H)*,)$#5!

4F! $0#! 1)-#! 1$)'5)951O! J'! $0%1! 9#/)95C! $&! #H)*,)$#! $0#! #Z%1$#'=#! &D! )! 8,4*%=! '##5! &9!

/#'#9)*! %'$#9#1$! 1,=0! )1! $&! \,1$%DF! $)_%'/! R)_&_&`JY)F)! V)$#9D9&'$! =&--,'%$Fc1!

89&8#9$F! $09&,/0! )! D,$,9#! 5#-&*%$%&'! #Z#9=%1#C! $0#! 8,4*%=! 4#'#D%$1! -,1$! 4#! 10&Y'! $&!

&,$Y#%/0! $0#! $09#)$1! $&!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$! =&--,'%$Fc1! 9%/0$1! $&! 10#*$#9! )'5!

0&,1%'/C! *%D#! )'5! *%H#*%0&&5C! D)-%*F! )'5!89%H)$#! *%D#C! $0#%9! =0%*59#'c1! 9%/0$! $&! #5,=)$%&'C!

)'5! $0#!=&--,'%$Fc1!9%/0$! $&! %$1!=,*$,9#!)'5!Y)F!&D! *%D#!)'5! $&!8,91,#! %$1!&Y'!8)$0! $&!

1&=%)*!)'5!#=&'&-%=!5#H#*&8-#'$O!!

Page 16: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

;A!&D!6<!

!

AO<:! ?==&95%'/*FC! Y#! 1,4-%$! $0)$! $0#! $09#)$1! &D! D,9$0#9! 5#-&*%$%&'1! )*1&! H%&*)$#! $0#!

D,'5)-#'$)*! 9%/0$! $&! 89&8#9$F! &D! $0#! 9#-)%'%'/! 9#1%5#'$1! &D! $0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)!

V)$#9D9&'$!=&--,'%$FO!V#!,9/#!$0#!+,-)'!.%/0$1!2&--%11%&'!$&!1&!0&*5O!!

'

B$495&$48*'4@';$3#&'&4'L/0'N24A0**'

!

AO<;! V#! 1,4-%$! $0)$! $0#! 89&=#5,9#1! #-8*&F#5! 4F! $0#! K)/&1! 3$)$#! b&H#9'-#'$! %'! $0#! ],*F!

6:;6! 5#-&*%$%&'! &D! $0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)! V)$#9D9&'$! 5&! '&$! -##$! #H#'! $0#! -%'%-,-!

9#d,%9#-#'$1!&D!6/0'J24A0**!,'5#9!3#=$%&'!<7!&D!$0#!2&'1$%$,$%&'C!)1!)9#!'#=#11)9F!%'!)!

5#-&=9)$%=!1$)$#!$&!*%-%$!$0#!8&Y#9!&D!/&H#9'-#'$!H%1^p^H%1!%$1!8#&8*#O!!

!

AO<6! XF!)! ],*F!;6C!6:;6!(&$%=#C! $0#!R%'%1$9F!&D!V)$#9D9&'$!)'5! J'D9)1$9,=$,9#!G#H#*&8-#'$!

8,98&9$#5!$&!/%H#!$0#!&Y'#91`&==,8%#91!&D!$0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!e'&$%=#!g!$&!

H)=)$#!)'5!9#-&H#!)**!%**#/)*!)'5!,'),$0&9%S#5!5#H#*&8-#'$1!)*&'/!$0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!

V)$#9D9&'$!Y%$0%'!@6!+&,91!&D!9#=#%8$!&D!$0%1!'&$%=#Of!E0#!'&$%=#!5%5!'&$!')-#!8)9$%=,*)9!

8#91&'1C! )559#11#1! &9! )9#)1! &D! $0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$! $0)$!Y&,*5! 4#! )DD#=$#5O!

(&9!5%5!$0#!(&$%=#!=%$#!)'F!*)Y!)1!$0#!4)1%1!D&9!$0#!b&H#9'-#'$c1!5#=%1%&'!&9!)==&95%'/!

$&!Y0%=0!&'#!=&,*5!5#$#9-%'#!Y0%=0!e5#H#*&8-#'$1f!Y#9#!e%**#/)*f!UU%%'FRS)T)*'AWO!

!

AO<<! I'! ],*F! ;<C! 6:;6C! $0%1! (&$%=#! Y)1! 0)'5#5! &,$C! )88)9#'$*F! )$! 9)'5&-C! $&! \,1$! )! D#Y!

9#1%5#'$1O!+&Y#H#9C!$0#!49#)5$0!&D!%$1!*)'/,)/#![!eE0#!IY'#9`I==,8%#9C!R)_&_&`JY)F)!

V)$#9D9&'$f! [! =&,*5! #)1%*F! %'=*,5#! )'! #1$%-)$#5! 6::C:::! 8#&8*#! Y0&! Y&,*5! 0)H#! @6!

0&,91!$&!9#-&H#!$0#-1#*H#1!)'5!)**!$0#%9!4#*&'/%'/1!)'5!5#1$9&F!$0#%9!0&-#1C!4,1%'#11!

8*)=#1!)'5!=&--,'%$F!D)=%*%$%#1!%'!)!8*)=#!Y0#9#!$0#%9!=&--,'%$F!0)1!*%H#5!D&9!Y#**!&H#9!

)!=#'$,9FO!V%$0!'&! D,9$0#9!89&=#11C! $0#!H%&*#'$!5#-&*%$%&'!#Z#9=%1#!=&--#'=#5!&'! $0#!

-&9'%'/! &D! ],*F! ;7C! 6:;6C! ,*$%-)$#*F! 5%18*)=%'/! $0&,1)'51! &D! 8#&8*#! )'5! )DD#=$%'/! D)9!

-&9#O!

!

AO<N! 3%'=#!$0#!(&$%=#!%11,#5!4F!$0#!R%'%1$9F!&D!V)$#9D9&'$!J'D9)1$9,=$,9#!G#H#*&8-#'$!D)%*#5!

$&!=%$#!)'F!*)Y1!,'5#9!Y0%=0!%$!Y)1!89&=##5%'/C!%$!%1!%-8&11%4*#!$&!_'&Y!Y0)$!),$0&9%$F!

%$! Y)1! %'H&_%'/! &9! Y0)$! 89&=#5,9#1! )$! *)Y! %$! %'$#'5#5! $&! 4#! D&**&Y%'/C! %D! )'F! )$! )**O!

+&Y#H#9C! 1#H#9)*! K)/&1! 3$)$#! *)Y1! -)F! 4#! %'1$9,=$%H#! %'! %5#'$%DF%'/! $0#! $F8#1! &D!

89&=#5,9#1!9#d,%9#5!D&9!1%-%*)9`9#*)$#5!-)$$#91O!!

!

)W! E0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!>'H%9&'-#'$)*!3)'%$)$%&'!K)Y!(&O!;!&D!6:::!5#D%'#1!)!',-4#9!&D!

#'H%9&'-#'$)*! 1)'%$)$%&'^9#*)$#5! &DD#'=#1! D&9! Y0%=0! -&'#$)9F! D%'#1! -)F! 4#!

%-8&1#5C!4,$!&'*F!)D$#9! $9%)*!)'5!,8&'!=&'H%=$%&'!4F!$0#!38#=%)*!IDD#'=#1!2&,9$O!

+&Y#H#9C!)1!Y%**!4#!D,9$0#9!5%1=,11#5!4#*&Y!%'!8)9)/9)80!NONO6C!$0%1!*)Y!5&#1!'&$!

89&H%5#! /9&,'51! D&9! D%'5%'/! 0&-#1C! 4,1%'#11! 8*)=#1! )'5! =&--,'%$F! D)=%*%$%#1!

$0#-1#*H#1! $&! 4#! %**#/)*! &9! =&'$#-8*)$#! 5#-&*%$%&'! )-&'/! %$1! ),$0&9%S#5!

8#')*$%#1O!

!

4W! E0#! K)/&1! 3$)$#! V)$#9D9&'$! J'D9)1$9,=$,9#! G#H#*&8-#'$! K)Y! (&O! <! &D! 6::P!

),$0&9%S#1! $0#! 5#-&*%$%&'1! &D! )'F! e1$9,=$,9#! #9#=$#5! )*&'/! $0#! Y)$#9D9&'$1!

Y%$0&,$!&4$)%'%'/!)'!I8#9)$%&'1!"#9-%$Cf! $0#!I8#9)$%&'1!"#9-%$!4#%'/!9#d,%9#5!

Page 17: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

;7!&D!6<!

&'*F!D9&-!$0#! *)Yc1!=&--#'=#-#'$!5)$#!UT#49,)9F!6C!6::PW!D&9Y)95O!+&Y#H#9C!

5#-&*%$%&'! =)'! &'*F! D&**&Y! e1#9H%=#! &D! 1#H#'! 5)F1! G#-&*%$%&'! (&$%=#! &'! $0#!

&==,8%#9!&9!)'F!8#91&'!9#18&'1%4*#!D&9!$0#!%**#/)*!5#H#*&8-#'$Of!R&9#&H#9C!$&!$0#!

#Z$#'$!$0)$!$0#!*)Y!8,98&9$1!$&!),$0&9%S#!$0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!b&H#9'-#'$!$&!#Z#9=%1#!

1,=0! 8&Y#91! &H#9! %'*)'5! Y)$#9Y)F1! &9! %'$#9')*! Y)$#91! &9! &'! $0#! 10&9#1! &D!

&=#)'1C! 1#)1!)'5! *)/&&'1C! )1!)9/,#5!)4&H#C! $0&1#!8&9$%&'1!&D! $0#! *)Y!10&,*5!4#!

5#=*)9#5! ,'=&'1$%$,$%&')*! )'5! H&%5O! T,9$0#9C! )'F! 9#$9&)=$%H#! )88*%=)$%&'! &D! $0#!

89&H%1%&'1! &D! $0%1! *)Y! Y&,*5! H%&*)$#! 3#=$%&'! NUPW! &D! $0#! 2&'1$%$,$%&'! )'5! $0#!

#'$%9#!89&=#5,9#!-)F!Y#**!H%&*)$#!$0#!5,#!89&=#11!9#d,%9#5!,'5#9!3#=$%&'!<7U6W!

&D!$0#!2&'1$%$,$%&'O!

!

=W! E0#! K)/&1! 3$)$#! i94)'! )'5! .#/%&')*! "*)''%'/! )'5! G#H#*&8-#'$! K)Y! &D! 6:;:C!

-#)'Y0%*#C!89&H%5#1!$0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!i94)'!.#'#Y)*!?/#'=F!Y%$0!*%-%$#5!8&Y#91!

$&! 5#-&*%10! %'! $0#! -&1$! #Z$9#-#! =)1#1! D&9! $0#! 8,98&1#! &D! )11%1$%'/! Y%$0! $0#!

%-8*#-#'$)$%&'!&D! )'!)889&H#5!G#H#*&8-#'$!"*)'O!E0#!89&=#5,9#1! 9#d,%9#5! $&!

89&$#=$! $0#! 9%/0$1! &D! $0#! 8#91&'! Y0&1#! 89&8#9$F! %1! $&! 4#! 5#-&*%10#5! )9#!

#Z$#'1%H#O!E0#F!%'=*,5#!U;W!89&H%5%'/!$0#!&Y'#9`&==,8%#9!Y%$0!)!89&8&1#5!&95#9!

)'5!1$)$#-#'$!&D! 9#)1&'1C! %'=*,5%'/!)'!#1$%-)$#!&D!=&-8#'1)$%&'! $&!4#!8)%5! D&9!

$0#!H)*,#!&D!$0#!4,%*5%'/!5#-&*%10#5k!U6W!)DD%Z%'/!$0#!1)-#!&95#9!$&!$0#!4,%*5%'/!

%'! d,#1$%&'k! U<W! 89&H%5%'/! $0#! &Y'#9`&==,8%#9! )'! &88&9$,'%$F! $&! 89#1#'$!

%'D&9-)$%&'!4#D&9#!)!18#=%)**F!D&9-#5!=&--%$$##k!UNW!1#9H%'/!$0#!D%')*!&95#9!)'5!

)! 1$)$#-#'$! &D! 9#)1&'1! &'! $0#! &Y'#9`&==,8%#9! &9! 8#91&'! Y0&! -)5#!

9#89#1#'$)$%&'1! 4#D&9#! $0#! =&--%$$##k! 89&H%5%'/! $0#! &Y'#9`&==,8%#9! Y%$0! $0#!

&88&9$,'%$F! $&! )88#)*k! )'5! UAW! /%H%'/! )! 6B^5)F! 8#9%&5! D9&-! D%')*! '&$%=#! 4#D&9#!

#Z#=,$%&'!&D!$0#!5#-&*%$%&'!&95#9O!!

!

AO<A! V0#9#! $0#! R%'%1$9F! &D! V)$#9D9&'$! J'D9)1$9,=$,9#! G#H#*&8-#'$! 5%5! '&$! 9#D#9#'=#! )'F!

*#/)*! ),$0&9%$F! %'! $0#%9!(&$%=#! $&! $0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$! =&--,'%$F!-#-4#91C!

)'5!'&!K)/&1!3$)$#! *)Y!1##-1! $&!),$0&9%S#! $0#%9!)=$%H%$%#1!&9! $0#!89&=#5,9#1! D&**&Y#5C!

Y#!-)F!$,9'!%--#5%)$#*F!$&!$0#!(%/#9%)'!2&'1$%$,$%&'!$&!#H)*,)$#!$0#!1$)'5)951!&D!5,#!

89&=#11!$0)$!)9#!9#d,%9#5O!!

!

AO<7! 3#=$%&'! <7! &D! $0#! 2&'1$%$,$%&'! #1$)4*%10#1! $0#! 1$)'5)951! &D! 5,#! 89&=#11! 9#d,%9#5! %'!

=9%-%')*! )'5! =%H%*! 89&=##5%'/1! 4#D&9#! =&,9$1! &D! *)Y! &9! 5,*F! =&'1$%$,$#5! $9%4,')*1C! )'5!

)*1&!%'!)5-%'%1$9)$%H#!89&=##5%'/1!4F!$0#!#Z#=,$%H#!49)'=0O!V#!9#18#=$D,**F!1,4-%$!$0)$!

$0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!b&H#9'-#'$c1!89#1#'$!)=$%&'! %1!4#1$!=0)9)=$#9%S#5!)1!X;*I$?.+$:$&*BC! %'!

$0)$! %$! %'H&*H#1! )'! )==,1)$%&'! $0)$! R)_&_&`JY)F)! V)$#9D9&'$! =&--,'%$F! 0)1!

=&'$9)H#'#5! 1&-#! *)Y! 4F! e5#H#*&8%'/! %**#/)*! 1$9,=$,9#1Cf! )'5! %'! $0#! 1)-#! 49#)$0!

%-8&1#1! )! 8#')*$F! %'! $0#! D&9-! &D! 5#1$9,=$%&'! )'5! 9#-&H)*! &D! H)*,)4*#! 89&8#9$FO! G,#!

89&=#11! %'! )! =9%-%')*! 89&=##5%'/! %'=*,5#1! ',-#9&,1! /,)9)'$##1! ,'5#9! 3#=$%&'! <7UNW^

U;;WC!%'=*,5%'/!$0#!9%/0$!$&!)5#d,)$#!)'5!5#$)%*#5!'&$%=#!&D!$0#!')$,9#!&D!$0#!&DD#'=#!)'5!

)5#d,)$#!$%-#!$&!89#8)9#!&'#c1!5#D#'1#C!)!D)%9!)'5!8,4*%=!$9%)*C!9#89#1#'$)$%&'!4F!=&,'1#*!

&D!&'#c1!=0&&1%'/C!)'5!$0#!89#1,-8$%&'!&D!%''&=#'=#O!!

!

AO<@! E0#! R%'%1$9F! &D! V)$#9D9&'$! J'D9)1$9,=$,9#! G#H#*&8-#'$c1! (&$%=#! %11,#5! $&! $0#!

R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!=&--,'%$F!=*#)9*F! D)%*1! $&!-##$! $0#!1$)'5)951!&D! e)5#d,)$#!

Page 18: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

;@!&D!6<!

)'5!5#$)%*#5!'&$%=#f!%'1&D)9!)1!%$!D)%*1!$&!=%$#!)'F!*)Y!)==&95%'/!$&!Y0%=0!)!9#1%5#'$!=&,*5!

5#$#9-%'#!Y0%=0! e5#H#*&8-#'$1f!Y#9#! e%**#/)*Of!(&9!Y)1!'&$%=#! 1#9H#5!&'! #)=0!&D! $0#!

8#91&'1C!D)-%*%#1!&9!4,%*5%'/1!$0)$!Y&,*5!4#!)DD#=$#5!4F!$0#!#'1,%'/!5#-&*%$%&'C!-#)'%'/!

$0)$!-)'F!-)F!0)H#!0)5!'&!'&$%=#!)$!)**!4#D&9#!$0#!8#')*$F!Y)1!%-8&1#5O!?1!$&!$0#!9#1$!

&D! $0#!5,#!89&=#11!9#d,%9#-#'$1! D&9!)!=9%-%')*!&9!d,)1%^=9%-%')*!-)$$#9C! $0#!1,--)9F!

5#-&*%$%&'! #Z#9=%1#! )D$#9! \,1$! @6^0&,91! =*#)9*F! 89#1,-#5! '&! &'#! %''&=#'$! )'5! *#D$! '&!

&88&9$,'%$F!$&!89#8)9#!&9!89#1#'$!)!5#D#'1#O!

!

AO<B! J'! $0#! )*$#9')$%H#C! Y#! 9#18#=$D,**F! 1,4-%$! $0)$! $0#! 89#1#'$! -)$$#9! 10&,*5! 4#!

=0)9)=$#9%S#5! )1! =%H%*! %'!')$,9#C! %'1&D)9! )1! %$! %1! =*#)9*F! %'H&*H#1! )!5#$#9-%')$%&'!&D! $0#!

R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!=&--,'%$Fc1!=%H%*!9%/0$1!4F!)!/&H#9'-#'$!),$0&9%$FO!J'5##5C!

)!=%H%*!89&=##5%'/!%1!$0#!'&9-)*!8)$0!$&!#H%=$%&'C!Y0%=0!%1!&'#!&D!$0#!/9)H#!=&'1#d,#'=#1!

&D! $0#! K)/&1! 3$)$#! b&H#9'-#'$c1! )=$%&'1! %'! $0%1! =)1#O! J'! 8&%'$! &D! D)=$C! $0#9#! )9#!

89&=#5,9#1!,'5#9!H)9%&,1!*)Y1![!1,=0!)1!$0#!.#=&H#9F!&D!"9#-%1#1!?=$!&9!$0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!

E#')'=F!K)YC! 5%1=,11#5! D,9$0#9!4#*&Y![! D&9! &4$)%'%'/! $0#!8#9-)'#'$!5%18*)=#-#'$! &D!

&==,8%#91! &D! *)'5`89#-%1#1! $0)$! 89&H%5#! D&9! )5#d,)$#! '&$%=#C! $0#! &88&9$,'%$F! $&! 4#!

0#)95!)'5!$&!0)H#!)==#11!$&!)!=&,9$!&D!*)YO!3,=0!89&=#5,9#1!%'H&*H%'/!)!=%H%*!89&=##5%'/!

)9#!-&9#!%'!*%'#!Y%$0!$0#!9#d,%9#-#'$1!&D!3#=$%&'!<7U;W!&D!$0#!2&'1$%$,$%&'C!Y0%=0!Y&,*5!

#'$%$*#!$0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!=&--,'%$F!$&!)! D)%9!0#)9%'/!Y%$0%'!)!9#)1&')4*#!

$%-#!4F!)'!%-8)9$%)*!)'5!%'5#8#'5#'$!=&,9$!&D!*)Y!&9!&$0#9!$9%4,')*!#1$)4*%10#5!4F!*)YO!

J'!10&9$C!#H%=$%&'1![!#H#'!4F!/&H#9'-#'$![!10&,*5!9#d,%9#!)!H)*%5!=&,9$!&95#9!$&!89&=##5O!

!

AO<P! >H#'! %D! $0#! 89#1#'$! )=$%&'! %1! =0)9)=$#9%S#5!-#9#*F! )1! )'! )5-%'%1$9)$%H#! )=$%&'C! %O#O! )'!

#Z#=,$%H#! 5#$#9-%')$%&'! &D!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$! =&--,'%$Fc1! =%H%*! 9%/0$1C!Y0%=0!

Y&,*5! %/'&9#! $0#!#'&9-%$F!&D! $0#!8#')*$F!4#%'/! %-8&1#5!4F! $0#!)=$,)*!)'5! $09#)$#'#5!

5#-&*%$%&'1C! $0#! 2&'1$%$,$%&'! )$! 3#=$%&'! <7U6W! 9#d,%9#1! )$! )!-%'%-,-! $0)$! ?88*%=)'$1!

0)H#! U;W! )'! &88&9$,'%$F! $&! 4#! 0#)95! )'5! U6W! $0#! 9%/0$! $&! )88#)*! $0#! )/#'=F!

5#$#9-%')$%&'!4#D&9#!%$!4#=&-#1!D%')*!)'5!-)F!4#!)=$#5!,8&'O!E0#!89&=#5,9#1!*)%5!&,$!%'!

$0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!i94)'!)'5!.#/%&')*!"*)''%'/!)'5!G#H#*&8-#'$!K)YC!5%1=,11#5!)4&H#C!

=*#)9*F! )$$#-8$! $&! =&-8*F! Y%$0! $0#1#! -%'%-,-! 5,#! 89&=#11! 9#d,%9#-#'$1! 4#D&9#!

)**&Y%'/!)'!#Z#=,$%H#!)/#'=F!$&!&95#9!5#-&*%$%&'1!&D!89&8#9$F!%'!$0#!1$)$#O!V0F!10&,*5!

5#-&*%$%&'1! &D! $0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)! V)$#9D9&'$! =&--,'%$%#1! 4#! =)99%#5! &,$! 4F! 1,=0!

/9&11*F!5%DD#9#'$!1$)'5)951q!

!

AON:! T&9! )**! $0#! D&9#/&%'/! 9#)1&'1C! Y#! 1,4-%$! $0)$! $0#! -#$0&51! 4F! Y0%=0! $0#! K)/&1! 3$)$#!

b&H#9'-#'$! %'H)5#5!$0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!)'5!5#-&*%10#5!9#1%5#'$1c!0&-#1C!

4,1%'#11! 89#-%1#1C! )'5! =&--,'%$F! D)=%*%$%#1! 5&! '&$! 1)$%1DF!-%'%-,-!5,#! 89&=#11! )'5!

)9#! $0#9#D&9#!,'=&'1$%$,$%&')*!)'5!,'*)YD,*O!V#!9#18#=$D,**F!,9/#! $0#!()$%&')*!+,-)'!

.%/0$1!2&--%11%&'!$&!1&!0&*5O!!

!

' B$495&$48*'4@';$3#&*'&4'D5E$9F'586'N2$=5&0'C$@0U'C$=09$#446U'586'!6/A5&$48'

'

AON;! J'!)55%$%&'!$&!$0#!)4&H#!=*)%-1!4)1#5!&'!D,'5)-#'$)*!9%/0$1!H%&*)$%&'1C!Y#!1,4-%$!$0)$!

$0#!],*F!;7^6;!5#-&*%$%&'1!&D!$0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!=&--,'%$F!)'5!$0#!D,$,9#!

5#-&*%$%&'1! )''&,'=#5! 4F! X)F&! 3,*#%-)'! U3O"OW! H%&*)$#! )'5! $09#)$#'! $&! H%&*)$#! $0#!

D&**&Y%'/!D,'5)-#'$)*!)'5!0,-)'!9%/0$1C!)-&'/!&$0#91L!!

Page 19: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

;B!&D!6<!

!

U;W $0#! 9%/0$! $&! 89%H)$#! )'5! D)-%*F! *%D#! /,)9)'$##5! ,'5#9! 3#=$%&'! <@! &D! $0#!

2&'1$%$,$%&'k!

U6W $0#!9%/0$!$&!*%H#*%0&&5!$0)$!%1!%-8*%=%$!%'!$0#!9%/0$!$&!*%D#!/,)9)'$##5!4F!3#=$%&'!

<<!&D!$0#!2&'1$%$,$%&'C!?9$%=*#!;A!&D!$0#!?D9%=)'!20)9$#9!U)1!5&-#1$%=)$#5WC!)'5!

?9$%=*#!7!&D!$0#!J2>32.k!!

U<W $0#!9%/0$!$&!#5,=)$%&'!/,)9)'$##5!4F!$0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!20%*5!.%/0$1!K)YC!?9$%=*#!

;@!&D!$0#!?D9%=)'!20)9$#9!U)1!5&-#1$%=)$#5WC!)'5!?9$%=*#!;<!&D!$0#!J2>32.O!!

!

AON6!! 3#=$%&'!<@!&D!$0#!2&'1$%$,$%&'!5#=*)9#1L!eE0#!89%H)=F!&D!=%$%S#'1C!$0#%9!0&-#1g!%1!0#9#4F!

/,)9)'$##5!)'5!89&$#=$#5Of!V#!1,4-%$!$0)$!$0#!1,--)9F!5#-&*%$%&'1!Y%$0&,$!)5#d,)$#!

'&$%=#! &9! 5,#! 89&=#11! &D! *)YC! Y0%=0! 5%18*)=#5! $0&,1)'51! &D! 9#1%5#'$1! )'5! *#D$! $0#-!

0&-#*#11C!*%H%'/!%'!&8#'!=)'&#1!&9!#*1#Y0#9#!Y%$0&,$!10#*$#9C!%1!=*#)9*F!)!H%&*)$%&'!&D!$0#!

2$3#&'&4'J2$=5&0'586'@5E$9F'9$@0'2$3#&'&4'J2$=5&0'586'@5E$9F'9$@0O!R#-4#91!&D!R)_&_&`!

JY)F)!=&--,'%$F!Y0&1#!0&,1#1!Y#9#!5#-&*%10#5!Y#9#!9#'5#9#5!0&-#*#11!)'5!D&9=#5!

$&!$)_#!10#*$#9!%'!&8#'!18)=#1!)'5!1*##8!%'!&8#'!=)'&#1O!R)'F!Y#9#!D&9=#5!$&!)4)'5&'!

$0#%9!*&H#5!&'#1!%'!1#)9=0!&D!10#*$#9O!!20%*59#'!)'5!$0#!)/#5!Y#9#!*#D$!$&!$0#!-#9=F!&D!$0#!

0)910!Y#)$0#9!=&'5%$%&'1O!E0%1!Y#!1,4-%$!%1!)!H%&*)$%&'!&D!$0#%9!5%/'%$F!&D!0,-)'!8#91&'C!

89%H)$#! )'5! D)-%*F! *%D#O! J'! $0#! =)1#! &D!(9$F/' .%25#$E' =' M#0' <4EE$**$4802' 4@' N49$A0C'

\;>>]^' ?EF?C:A@0@088Z0>ZC! $0#! 2&,9$! D&,'5! $0)$! D&9=#D,**F! 59)//%'/! $0#! )88*%=)'$!

&,$!&D!0%1!0&-#!)-&,'$#5!$&!)!H%&*)$%&'!&D!3#=$%&'!<@O!3,9#*F!$0#!#H#'$1!)$!%11,#!0#9#!)9#!

)$!*#)1$!)1!#Z$9#-#O!!

!

AON<! V#! 1,4-%$! $0)$! $0#! 5#-&*%$%&'! #Z#9=%1#! &D! $0#! 4,1%'#11! 89#-%1#1! )'5! =&--,'%$F!

D)=%*%$%#1! %'! $0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$! 0)1! 5#1$9&F#5! $0#! *%H#*%0&&51! &D! $0&,1)'51!

)'5! $0#9#4F! $09#)$#'1! $0#%9!'&'^5#9&/)4*#!9%/0$! $&! *%D#!)1!/,)9)'$##5!4F!3#=$%&'!<N!&D!

$0#!2&'1$%$,$%&'!&D!$0#!T#5#9)*!.#8,4*%=!&D!(%/#9%)!;PPPC!?9$%=*#!N!&D!$0#!?D9%=)'!20)9$#9C!

)'5! ?9$%=*#! 7! &D! $0#! J'$#9')$%&')*! 2&'H#'$%&'! &'! >=&'&-%=C! 3&=%)*! )'5! 2,*$,9)*! 9%/0$1!

UJ2>32.WO! E0#! 2$3#&' &4' 9$=09$#446! %1! )! H%$)*! =&-8&'#'$! &D! $0#! 9%/0$! $&! *%D#! 4#=),1#C!

Y%$0&,$!)!*%H#*%0&&5C!*%H%'/!%$1#*D!4#=&-#1!%-8&11%4*#O!E0#!J'5%)'!3,89#-#!2&,9$!%'!O935'

M099$*'=>'V4E%5F'G/8$A$J59'<42J425&$48!\;>>]^'AXC';V87'.*'_.`%';;7!)!=)1#!5#)*%'/!

Y%$0!$0#!5#-&*%$%&'!&D!1*,-!1$9,=$,9#1!'#)9!$0#!=%$F!&D!X&-4)FC!J'5%)C!0#*5!)1!D&**&Y1L!

!

51' #G"' +$)G#' #%' B$0"B$G%%,' $I' &%#' #+"*#",' *I' *' R*+#' %1' #G"_' +$)G#' #%' B$1"<' #G"'

"*I$"I#'6*7'%1',"R+$0$&)'*'R"+I%&'%1'G$I'+$)G#'#%'B$1"'6%;B,'H"'#%',"R+$0"'G$:'

%1'G$I':"*&I'%1'B$0"B$G%%,'#%'#G"'R%$&#'%1'*H+%)*#$%&L'M;.G',"R+$0*#$%&'6%;B,'

&%#' %&B7' ,"&;,"' #G"' B$1"' %1' $#I' "11".#$0"' .%&#"&#' *&,':"*&$&)1;B&"II' H;#' $#'

6%;B,' :*3"' B$1"' $:R%II$HB"' #%' B$0"_L' d"R+$0"' *' R"+I%&' %1' G$I' +$)G#' #%'

B$0"B$G%%,'*&,'7%;'IG*BB'G*0"',"R+$0",'G$:'%1'G$I'B$1"L'

!

AONN! ?1! %'! $0#!O935'M099$*! =)1#C! $0#! ],*F!;7^6;C!6:;6!5#-&*%$%&'!#Z#9=%1#! =)99%#5!&,$! %'! $0#!

R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!5#1$9&F#5!$0#!4,1%'#11!89#-%1#1!)'5!=&--,'%$F!D)=%*%$%#1!&D!

-)'F! 9#1%5#'$1! )'5! )*1&! 5%18*)=#5! $0&,1)'51! Y0&! 9#*F! &'! $0#! Y)$#9! )1! )! 89%'=%8*#!

1&,9=#!&D!*%H#*%0&&5!D9&-!$0#!Y)$#9D9&'$!=&--,'%$FO!E0#!5#-&*%$%&'!)'5!D&9=#5!#H%=$%&'!

%-8)=$#5! '#/)$%H#*F! &'! $0#! 8#$%$%&'#91O! +)H%'/! *&1$! $0#%9! 0&,1#1C!-&1$! &D! $0#! D)-%*%#1!

)DD#=$#5!0)5!$&!)4)'5&'!$0#%9!4,1%'#11#1!&D! D%10%'/!)'5!1-&_%'/!&D! D%10O!?1!1,=0C! $0#1#!

Page 20: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

;P!&D!6<!

5#-&*%$%&'1!=&'1$%$,$#5!)'!)DD%9-)$%H#!)=$!4F!/&H#9'-#'$!$0)$!5%19,8$#5!$0#!*%H#*%0&&51!

&D!$0&,1)'51C!$0#9#4F!=&'1$%$,$%'/!)!H%&*)$%&'!&D!$0#%9!9%/0$1!$&!*%H#*%0&&5`*%D#O!V#!,9/#!

()$%&')*!+,-)'!.%/0$1!2&--%11%&'!$&!1&!0&*5O!!

!

AONA!! T%')**FC!Y#!1,4-%$!$0)$!$0#!5#-&*%$%&'1!=)99%#5!&,$!%'!R)_&_&`JY)F)!0)H#!)*1&!%'D9%'/#5!

&'!$0#!9%/0$1!&D!$0#!=0%*5C!%'=*,5%'/!$0#!D,'5)-#'$)*!2$3#&'&4'06/A5&$48O!E0#!9%/0$1!&D!$0#!

=0%*5!#'\&F!)!8&1%$%&'!&D!,$-&1$!%-8&9$)'=#!%'!(%/#9%)'!*)YO!?9$%=*#!;@U;W!&D!$0#!?D9%=)'!

20)9$#9C! Y0%=0! 0)1! 4##'! 5&-#1$%=)$#5! %'$&! (%/#9%)'! *)YC! 89&H%5#1! $0)$! em#nH#9F!

%'5%H%5,)*! 0)1! )! 9%/0$! $&! #5,=)$%&'Of! R&9#&H#9C! $0#! 20%*5! .%/0$1! ?=$! (&O! 67! &D! 6::<C!

Y0%=0!/%H#1!5&-#1$%=!)DD#=$! $&!(%/#9%)c1! 9)$%D%=)$%&'!&D! $0#!2&'H#'$%&'!&'! $0#!.%/0$1!&D!

$0#!20%*5C! %'=*,5#1!',-#9&,1!89&H%1%&'1!&'!$0#!9%/0$1!&D!$0#!=0%*5C! %'=*,5%'/!$0#!=0%*5c1!

9%/0$!$&!89&$#=$%&'!)'5!=)9#!)1!'#=#11)9F!D&9!$0#!Y#**^4#%'/!&D!$0#!=0%*5!,'5#9!3#=$%&'!6C!

9%/0$!$&!1,9H%H)*!)'5!5#H#*&8-#'$!,'5#9!3#=$%&'!NC!)'5!$0#!9%/0$!$&!$0#!e4#1$!)$$)%')4*#!

1$)$#! &D! 80F1%=)*C! -#'$)*! )'5! 18%9%$,)*! 0#)*$0f! ,'5#9! 3#=$%&'! ;<C! )'5! $0#! 9%/0$! $&!

#5,=)$%&'! ,'5#9! 3#=$%&'! ;AO! E0#1#! 9%/0$1! )9#! ,'5#9/%95#5! 4F! $0#! 5%9#=$%H#! 89%'=%8*#!

=&'$)%'#5!%'!?9$%=*#!;B!&D!$0#!2&'1$%$,$%&'O!K)1$*FC!?9$%=*#!;<!&D!$0#!J2>32.!89&$#=$1!e$0#!

9%/0$!&D!#H#9F&'#!$&!#5,=)$%&'Of!!

!

AON7! .#*F%'/!&'!1,=0!),$0&9%$%#1C!$0#!2&--,'%$F!2&,9$!&D!],1$%=#!&D!$0#!>=&'&-%=!2&--,'%$F!

&D! V#1$! ?D9%=)'! 3$)$#1! %'! $0#! =)1#! &D! :!;(N' B*>' D060259' ;0J/%9$A' 4@' ?$302$5' 586'

W8$=02*59'V5*$A'!6/A5&$48'<4EE$**$487'>2V`22]`?""`:B`:BC!9#=&/'%S#5!$0%1!9%/0$!$&!

#5,=)$%&'! )1! #'D&9=#)4*#! %'! (%/#9%)O! XF! H%9$,#! &D! $0#! >2IV?3! E9#)$FC! $0%1! 5#=%1%&'! %1!

4%'5%'/!*)Y!%'!(%/#9%)O!!

!

AON@! XF! 5%19,8$%'/! *%H#*%0&&51! )'5! 5%18*)=%'/! $0&,1)'51! D9&-! $0#%9! 0&-#1C!Y#! 1,4-%$! $0)$!

$0#! ],*F!;7^6;C!6:;6!5#-&*%$%&'1!0)H#!)*1&! \#&8)95%S#5!$0#!)4%*%$F!&D!-)'F!=0%*59#'!$&!

)$$#'5!1=0&&*O!J'5##5C!1#H#9)*!=0%*59#'!0)H#!4##'!Y%$059)Y'!D9&-!$0#!1=0&&*!)1!)!9#1,*$!

&D! $0#! 5#-&*%$%&'O! V#! 1,4-%$C! $0#9#D&9#C! $0)$! $0#! ],*F! ;7^6;C! 6:;6! 5#-&*%$%&'1! 0)H#!

H%&*)$#5!$0#!9%/0$!$&!#5,=)$%&'!&D!=0%*59#'!%'!$0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!=&--,'%$F!

)'5!9#18#=$D,**F!,9/#!$0#!()$%&')*!+,-)'!.%/0$1!2&--%11%&'!$&!1&!0&*5O!!

!

!

9P>' EC@MFCQ'!BC'CF?1F!'

'

7O;! ?! G>2K?.?EJI(! $0)$! $0#! #H%=$%&'! &D! $0#! R)_&_&`JY)F)! V)$#9D9&'$! 2&--,'%$F! )'5!

5#-&*%$%&'! &D! $0#%9! 0&-#1C! 4,1%'#11! 8*)=#1! )'5! =&--,'%$F! D)=%*%$%#1! &'! ],*F! ;7! ^! 6;C!

6:;6!=&'1$%$,$#1!)!,"#$%&'%()$*)"+')'5C!$0#9#4FC!H%&*)$#1!$0#!9%/0$!$&!)5#d,)$#!0&,1%'/!

/,)9)'$##5! ,'5#9! $0#! J'$#9')$%&')*! 2&H#')'$! &'!>=&'&-%=C! 3&=%)*! )'5!2,*$,9)*! .%/0$1!

)'5!$0#!9%/0$!$&!0&,1%'/`10#*$#9! %-8*%=%$! %'!$0#!?D9%=)'!20)9$#9!&D!+,-)'!)'5!"#&8*#1c!

.%/0$1!)'5!$0#!;PPP!2&'1$%$,$%&'!&D!$0#!T#5#9)*!.#8,4*%=!&D!(%/#9%)O!

!

7O6! ?!G>2K?.?EJI(! $0)$! $0#!_%**%'/C!5#1$9,=$%&'!&D!89&8#9$F!)'5!&$0#9!)4,1#1!)'5!0)9-1!

=&--%$$#5! 5,9%'/! $0#! ],*F! ;7! $&! 6;C! 6:;6! 5#-&*%$%&'! &D! R)_&_&`JY)F)! V)$#9D9&'$!

=&--,'%$F!)'5!$0#!$09#)$!&D! D,9$0#9!5#-&*%$%&'1!4F!X)F&!3,*#%-)'!U3O"OW! %'!)!-##$%'/!

Y%$0! =&--,'%$F! *#)5#91! &'! I=$&4#9! <:C! 6:;6! =&'1$%$,$#! H%&*)$%&'1`$09#)$#'#5!

H%&*)$%&'1!&D!$0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!9#1%5#'$1c!D,'5)-#'$)*!9%/0$1!$&!*%D#C!5%/'%$FC!

Page 21: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

6:!&D!6<!

*%4#9$FC! 89&8#9$FC! 5,#! 89&=#11C! 89%H)=F! %'! $0#! 0&-#C! *%H#*%0&&5C! )'5! #5,=)$%&'! )1!

/,)9)'$##5! ,'5#9! $0#! ;PPP! 2&'1$%$,$%&'! &D! $0#! T#5#9)*! .#8,4*%=! &D! (%/#9%)C! $0#!

J'$#9')$%&')*! 2&H#')'$! &'! >=&'&-%=C! 3&=%)*! )'5! 2,*$,9)*! .%/0$1C! $0#! J'$#9')$%&')*!

2&H#')'$!&'!2%H%*!)'5!"&*%$%=)*!.%/0$1C!)'5! $0#!?D9%=)'!20)9$#9!&'!+,-)'!)'5!"#&8*#1!

.%/0$1C!)-&'/!&$0#9!%'1$9,-#'$1!$&!Y0%=0!(%/#9%)!%1!8)9$FO!

!

7O<! ?'! I.G>.! &D! R?(G?EI.a! J(]i(2EJI(! &95#9%'/! $0#! K)/&1! 3$)$#! b&H#9'-#'$! $&!

%--#5%)$#*F! 8)F! )5#d,)$#! =&-8#'1)$%&'! D&9! )**! $0#! 9%/0$1! H%&*)$%&'1! 1,DD#9#5! 4F! )**!

)DD#=$#5!8#91&'1C!%'=*,5%'/!$#')'$1!)'5!1$9,=$,9#!&Y'#91!)*%_#C!)'5!9#1#$$*#!)'F!)DD#=$#5!

8#91&'1!Y0&!)9#!,')4*#!$&!9#1#$$*#!$0#-1#*H#1O!

!

7ON! ?'!I.G>.!&D!R?(G?EI.a!J(]i(2EJI(!&95#9%'/!$0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!b&H#9'-#'$!$&!9#D9)%'!

D9&-! =)99F%'/! &,$! )'5! $)_#! %--#5%)$#! 1$#81! $&! 89#H#'$! D&9=#5! #H%=$%&'1! %'! $0#! 1$)$#C!

%'=*,5%'/!5&-#1$%=)$%'/!$0#!89&0%4%$%&'!&'!D&9=#5!#H%=$%&'1!%'$&!K)/&1!3$)$#!*)YO!!!

!

7OA! ?'!I.G>.!D&9!$0#!8)F-#'$!&D!E09##!X%**%&'!()%9)!U(<!4%**%&'W!%'!/#'#9)*!5)-)/#1!$&!$0#!

)DD#=$#5!8#91&'1!Y%$0%'!$0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!2&--,'%$FO!!

!

!

3,4-%$$#5!&'!67!3#8$#-4#9!6:;<O!

!

!

!

!rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr!

!

?'59#Y!R)_%!

3$)DD!?$$&9'#F!

3&=%)*!)'5!>=&'&-%=!.%/0$1!?=$%&'!2#'$#9!

"*&$!@ABC!20%#D!E0&-)1!?5#4&F#!G9%H#!

I-&*#!"0)1#!6C!J10#9%C!K)/&1!

!

M6<NOB;:ON6PO@:7:!U-&4%*#W!

M6<NO;O@7NO76PP!U&DD%=#W!

)'59#YO-Q1#9)=O&9/!`!%'D&Q1#9)=O&9/!

Page 22: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

6;!&D!6<!

'

EFG1G1BH'CFI@CJ1HI'!BCAFJ'FK1AG1BH'B!'-@LBLB014@M@'4@GFC!CBHG'

AB--NH1GM7'89:;8'<N?M';>8O'

'

M;H:$##",'H7N'

3&=%)*!)'5!>=&'&-%=!.%/0$1!?=$%&'!2#'$#9!U3>.?2W!

K)/&1!R)9/%')*%S#5!2&--,'%$%#1!T&9,-!UK?R2ITI.W!

67!3#8$#-4#9!6:;<!

!

!

!

'

'

@GG@AXFJ'FaX1W1GQ'

!

FRS)T)*'@8!^!! ?DD%5)H%$!%'!3,88&9$!&D!I9%/%')$%'/!3,--&'1C!3,%$!(&O!T+2`K`23`;A@@`;6C!1Y&9'!

$&!4F!?*)10#!T9)'=%1!iO!?/&F&'!&'!6;!G#=#-4#9!6:;6!U(XL!$0%1!-)$$#9!Y)1!

Y%$059)Y'!D9&-!$0#!T#5#9)*!+%/0!2&,9$!%'!],'#!6:;<W!

!

FRS)T)*'@;![!!.#/%1$#9!&D!0#)51!&D!0&,1#0&*51!5%9#=$*F!)DD#=$#5!4F!$0#!],*F!;7^6;!6:;6!

5#-&*%$%&'!&D!$0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!2&--,'%$FC!=&-8%*#5!4F!

=&--,'%$F!*#)5#91!%'!=&\,'=$%&'!Y%$0!$0#!3&=%)*!)'5!>=&'&-%=!.%/0$1!?=$%&'!

2#'$#9C!$&$)**F%'/!@@:!0&,1#0&*51C!Y%$0!NC:<N!8#91&'1!

!

FRS)T)*'W!^! R)8!&D!$0#!R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!

!

FRS)T)*'A![!! e(&$%=#!$&!j)=)$#!)'5!.#-&H#!30)'$%#1!`!J**#/)*!G#H#*&8-#'$!?*&'/!$0#!

V)$#9D9&'$Cf!D9&-!$0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!R%'%1$9F!&D!V)$#9D9&'$!J'D9)1$9,=$,9#!

G#H#*&8-#'$C!5)$#5!],*F!;6C!6:;6!

!

FRS)T)*'J8':' "0&$&!;!&D!E%-&$0F!+,'_8&F)'Y)C!Y%$0!4,**#$!Y&,'51!%'!)45&-#'!

!

FRS)T)*'J;':' "0&$&!6!&D!E%-&$0F!+,'_8&F)'Y)C!Y%$0!4,**#$!Y&,'51!%'!)45&-#'!

!

FRS)T)*'JO':' G#)$0!=#9$%D%=)$#!D&9!E%-&$0F!+,'_8&F)'Y)C!D9&-!K)/&1!3$)$#!i'%H#91%$F!

E#)=0%'/!+&18%$)*C!5)$#5!],*F!<:C!6:;6!

!

FRS)T)*'F8'!^!! eG)F!6L!R)_&_&!G#-&*%$%&'![!6::!.#'5#9#5!+&-#*#11!)1!>H)=,##1!j&Y!$&!

.#-)%'!&'!V)$#9Cf!e*&);*+,'O"6IC!],*F!;BC!6:;6!

!

FRS)T)*'F;!^!! e"&*%=#-#'!)$!R)_&_&!G#-&*%$%&'!Y#9#!&'!J**#/)*!G,$F![!2&--%11%&'#9!&D!

"&*%=#Cf!e*&);*+,'O"6IC!],*F!6NC!6:;6!

!

FRS)T)*'FO!^!! e(%/#9%)!D&9=#1!$0&,1)'51!D9&-!D*&)$%'/!1*,-Cf!JB'A*`""+*!>'/*%10C!],*F!6:C!6:;6!

!

FRS)T)*'FV!^!! e"&*%=#!h%**!K)/&1!2&--,'%$F!K#)5#9Cf!],*F!66C!6:;6!

Page 23: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

66!&D!6<!

!

FRS)T)*'FZ!^!! e+,-)'!.%/0$1!2&--%11%&'!$&!J'H#1$%/)$#!G#-&*%$%&'1Cf!QG$I'd*7'U$0"C!?,/,1$!@C!

6:;6!

!

FRS)T)*'!8!^!! K#$$#9!D9&-!K)/&1!3$)$#!R%'%1$9F!&D!V)$#9D9&'$!J'D9)1$9,=$,9)*!G#H#*&8-#'$!$&!

20%#D!R#11,!?49)0)-C!$%$*#5!eG#H#*&8-#'$1!)*&'/!$0#!Y)$#9D9&'$!)'5!10&9#*%'#!

)$!R)_&_&Cf!5)$#5!],*F!6AC!6:;6!

!

FRS)T)*'!;!^!! K#$$#9!D9&-!R)_&_&!V)$#9D9&'$!G#H#*&8-#'$!2&--%$$##!$&!$0#!2&--%11%&'#9!

D&9!V)$#9D9&'$!J'D9)1$9,=$,9)*!G#H#*&8-#'$C!$%$*#5!e.>L!G#H#*&8-#'$1!)*&'/!$0#!

Y)$#9D9&'$!)'5!10&9#*%'#!)$!R)_&_&Cf!5)$#5!],*F!<:C!6:;6!

!

FRS)T)*'I!^!! K#$$#9!D9&-!R)_&_&!2&--,'%$F!K#)5#91!$&!b&H#9'&9!X)4)$,'5#!T)10&*)C!$%$*#5!

eK#$$#9!&D!J'$#'$!$&!i'5#9$)_#!2&--,'%$F^*#5!.#/#'#9)$%&'!&D!$0#!

R)_&_&`JY)F)!V)$#9D9&'$!2&--,'%$FCf!5)$#5!?,/,1$!66C!6:;6!

!

FRS)T)*'X8!^!! K#$$#9!D9&-!K)/&1!3$)$#!R%'%1$9F!&D!V)$#9D9&'$!J'D9)1$9,=$,9)*!G#H#*&8-#'$!$&!

20%#D!?49)0)-!R#11,C!$%$*#5!e.>L!G#H#*&8-#'$1!)*&'/!$0#!Y)$#9D9&'$!)'5!

10&9#*%'#!)$!R)_&_&Cf!5)$#5!I=$&4#9!;PC!6:;6!

!

FRS)T)*'X;!^!! K#$$#9!D9&-!R)_&_&!V)$#9D9&'$!2&--,'%$F!K#)5#91!$&!$0#!2&--%11%&'#9!D&9!

V)$#9D9&'$!J'D9)1$9,=$,9)*!G#H#*&8-#'$C!$%$*#5!e.>L!G#H#*&8-#'$1!)*&'/!$0#!

Y)$#9D9&'$!)'5!10&9#*%'#!)$!R)_&_&Cf!5)$#5!I=$&4#9!66C!6:;6!

!

FRS)T)*'XO!^!! K#$$#9!D9&-!K)/&1!3$)$#!R%'%1$9F!&D!V)$#9D9&'$!J'D9)1$9,=$,9)*!G#H#*&8-#'$!$&!

20%#D!?49)0)-!R#11,C!$%$*#5!e.>L!G#H#*&8-#'$1!)*&'/!$0#!Y)$#9D9&'$!)'5!

10&9#*%'#!)$!R)_&_&Cf!5)$#5!I=$&4#9!6NC!6:;6!

!

FRS)T)*'1!^!! 3?R"K>!e)4)$#-#'$!&D!',%1)'=#f!'&$%=#!%11,#5!4F!$0#!K)/&1!3$)$#!>'H%9&'-#'$)*!

)'5!38#=%)*!IDD#'=#1!U>'D&9=#-#'$W!i'%$!

!

FRS)T)*'<8!^!! "0&$&/9)80!&D!5#1$9&F#5!1$9,=$,9#C!$)_#'!],*F!6:C!6:;6!

!

FRS)T)*'<;!^!! "0&$&/9)80!&D!89&H%1%&')*!1$9,=$,9#1!)'5!#-8$F!8*)$D&9-1C!$)_#'!],*F!6:C!6:;6!

!

FRS)T)*'<O!^!! "0&$&/9)80!&D!9#-')'$1!&D!5#1$9&F#5!1$9,=$,9#1!)'5!1)*H)/#5!4#*&'/%'/1C!$)_#'!

],*F!6:C!6:;6!

!

FRS)T)*'<V!^!! "0&$&/9)80!&D!5#-&*%10#5!0&,1#!1%'_%'/!%'$&!Y)$#9C!$)_#'!],*F!6:C!6:;6!

!

FRS)T)*'<Z!^!! "0&$&/9)80!&D!8*)$D&9-!&'!Y0%=0!0&,1#1!&'=#!1$&&5C!$)_#'!],*F!6:C!6:;6!

!

FRS)T)*'<9!^!! "0&$&/9)80!&D!89&$#1$!-)9=0!$&!$0#!b&H#9'&9c1!&DD%=#C!K)/&1C!$)_#'!],*F!6<C!6:;6!

'

FRS)T)*'<]!^!! "0&$&/9)80!&D!89&$#1$!-)9=0!$&!$0#!b&H#9'&9c1!&DD%=#C!K)/&1C!$)_#'!],*F!6<C!6:;6!

'

Page 24: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$#$%&'(")*+,$&)'-%+.",'/0$.#$%&'%1'2*3%3%456*7*'8*#"+1+%&#'9%::;&$#7<'=>?@='A;B7'@C=D' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' ' '

6<!&D!6<!

FRS)T)*'<b!^!! "0&$&/9)80!&D!9#1=,#5!4#*&'/%'/1C!$)_#'!],*F!6:C!6:;6!

'

FRS)T)*'<[!^!! "0&$&/9)80!&D!5#-&*%10#5!0&,1#C!$)_#'!],*F!6:C!6:;6!

'

FRS)T)*'<8>!^!!"0&$&/9)80!&D!9,44*#!D9&-!5#-&*%10#5!0&,1#1C!$)_#'!],*F!6:C!6:;6!

'

FRS)T)*'<88!^!!"0&$&/9)80!&D!9,44*#!D9&-!5#-&*%10#5!0&,1#1C!$)_#'!],*F!6:C!6:;6!

'

FRS)T)*'<8;!^!!"0&$&/9)80!&D!8*)%'=*&$0#1!K)/&1!b&H#9'-#'$!8#91&''#*!=0&88%'/!4,%*5%'/1!Y%$0!

=0)%'1)Y1C!$)_#'!],*F!6:C!6:;6!

'

!

Page 25: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 26: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!

! 8

1. That I am a resident of the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community and the Alashe of the

Eguns in Makoko.

2. That by virtue of my position, I am conversant with the facts deposed herein.

3. That I have the consent and authority of the Plaintiffs to depose to this affidavit.

4. That the Plaintiffs are all leaders of the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community and/or

persons affected by the July 16-21, 2012 demolition and related events.

5. That the 1st Defendant is the Government of Lagos State.

6. That the 2nd

Defendant is the Governor and Chief Executive Officer of Lagos State.

7. That the 3rd

Defendant is the Commissioner of Waterfront and Infrastructure

Development for Lagos State, the chief officer of the Ministry of Waterfront and

Infrastructure Development within the 1st Defendant, appointed by the 2

nd Defendant.

8. That the 4th

Defendant is the Inspector General of Police, the first in command of the

Nigerian Police Force.

9. That the 5th

Defendant is a body known as the Kick Against Indiscipline (KAI) Brigade,

allegedly a parastatal under the control/management of the Lagos State Government, that

purports to have authority to execute the Lagos State Environmental Sanitation Law and

other laws of Lagos State.

10. That the 6th

Defendant is Bayo Suleiman, a Superintendent of Police and the purported

Chairman of the 7th

and 8th

Defendants.

11. That the 7th

Defendant is a body known as the Lagos State Environmental and Special

Offences (Enforcement) Unit, allegedly a parastatal under the control/management of the

Lagos State Government, that purports to have authority to execute the Lagos State

Environmental Sanitation Law and other laws of Lagos State.

12. That the 8th

Defendant is a body known as the Lagos State Task Force on Environmental

and Special Offences (known popularly by a variety of similar names), allegedly a

parastatal under the control/management of the Lagos State Government, that purports to

have authority to execute the Lagos State Environmental Sanitation Law and other laws

of Lagos State.

13. That the 9th

Defendant is the Environmental Sanitation Enforcement Agency, a statutory

body with certain enumerated powers relating to environmental sanitation.

Personal Circumstances

14. That I am an Egun man and a fisherman by trade.

Page 27: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!

! 9

15. That I was born in Makoko in the year 1955 and have lived in Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront

community ever since.

16. That I presently have two wives and 18 children, all residents of the Makoko/Iwaya

Waterfront community.

17. That my family and I do not have any other home but the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront

community.

Personal Circumstances of the Other Named Plaintiffs !

18. That Baale Sodiq Yusufu Segla Hungbeme is an Egun man, a resident of the

Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront Community and a Baale of the Sogunro area. On November

21, 2012, at about 3:30pm, at the office of our legal representative, the Social and

Economic Rights Action Center (SERAC), he told me and I verily believe the following

information to be true:

a. That he was born in 1948 in Makoko-Akoka and has lived all his life in the

Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community.

b. That he is a carpenter by trade and does his work in Makoko.

c. That he has three wives and 12 children

d. That his wives used to work in the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community doing

fish smoking, but their livelihood was severely affected by the destruction of

fishing and fish smoking facilities during the demolition.

e. That, as a consequence, his children have had to leave the school they were

attending because the family cannot afford the school fees.

19. That Mr. Emmanuel Hagbe J.P. is an Egun man, a resident of the Makoko/Iwaya

Waterfront community. On November 21, 2012, at about 3:30pm, at the office of our

legal representative, SERAC, he told me and I verily believe the following information to

be true:

a. That he was born on October 12, 1975 in Makoko.

b. That he has two wives and five children.

c. That he is presently the Youth Leader and the President of the Gbenokpo Society

of Fishermen and Fish Sellers in the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community.

d. That he was formerly a CDA Chairman in the community.

Page 28: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!

! 10

20. That Mr. Ayeseminikan Bawo is an Egun man, a resident of the Makoko/Iwaya

Waterfront community. On November 21, 2012, at about 3:30pm, at the SERAC office,

he told me and I verily believe the following information to be true:

a. That he is 53 years old and resides in the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community.

b. That he has one wife and eight children, also residents of the community.

c. That he is the proprietor of the Kennedy Group of Schools, a nursery, primary and

secondary school serving approximately 350 children from the Makoko/Iwaya

Waterfront and neighboring communities.

d. That the school was started in 1990 and has been operating ever since, with

international recognition for its service to the Makoko community.

e. That as a result of the July 16-21 demolitions, at least 10 children have been

withdrawn from his school due to loss of their homes in the community or the

livelihoods that enabled their families to pay school fees.

f. That he is also the secretary of the Ilaje community in Makoko.

21. That Mr. Ewajane Osowo is an Ilaje man, a resident of the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront

community. On November 21, 2012, at the SERAC office, at about 3:30pm, he told me

and I verily believe the following information to be true:

a. That he was born on June 6, 1979.

b. That he is married and has one child.

c. That is presently the Secretary of the Ilaje Crayfish and Fishermen Association of

Nigeria in the Makoko branch.

d. That he was formerly the Youth Representative in the Baale Council.

22. That Mr. Prosper Aivoji is an Egun man, a resident of the Oko-Agbon area of the

Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community. On November 21, 2012, at about 3:30pm, at the

SERAC office, he told me and I verily believe the following information to be true:

a. That he was born in Makoko and is now 42 years old.

b. That he is a businessman by trade.

c. That he has two wives and two children.

Page 29: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!

! 11

d. That he is the secretary to the Baale of the Oko-Agbon area of the Makoko/Iwaya

Waterfront community, comprised of at least 100 families, and also the Chairman

of the Oko-Agbon Community Development Association.

23. That Mr. Staycool Sofiyegha is an Ijaw man, of 13 Apollo Street, Waterfront, and the

secretary to the Ijaw Atorhu (Chief) of the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community. On

November 22, 2012, at about 9:30am, at the SERAC office, he told me and I verily

believe the following information to be true:

a. That he was born on October 10, 1960 in Arogbo in Ese Odo LGA in Ondo State.

b. That he came to live in the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community, where his

sister was already living, on December 7, 1985.

c. That he has lived in the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community ever since.

d. That he works as a timber contractor in the Okubaba waterfront sawmill industry.

e. That he has two wives and seven children and all are residing with him in the

Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community.

f. That one of his wives works in the timber industry and the second is a trader at

the Owaya waterfront.

g. That all his children are schooling in Makoko and depend on his and his wives’

incomes for their school fees and other needs.

h. That his family’s home and livelihood would be gravely affected if the threatened

demolition of the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community were to proceed.

24. That Mrs. Abosede Hunkpoyanwa is an Egun woman, of No. 18 Raimi Street, Makoko

House of Lagoon, in the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community, and a widow of the late

Mr. Timothy Azinkpono Hunkpoyanwa. On November 23, 2012, at about 11:30am, at

my palace in the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community, she told me and I verily believe

the following information to be true:

a. That she was born in about 1962 in Badagry and is now 50 years old.

b. That she came to the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community in about 1982 on

business and then married her late husband and has lived there ever since.

c. That she and her husband stayed together for about thirty years until his death on

July 21, 2012 at the hands of the police.

d. That they have four children, who are about 29, 27, 24 and 15 years old.

Page 30: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!

! 12

e. That the youngest of their children still stays with her and schools in the

Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community.

f. That she was the first of her husband’s three wives and together they have 14

surviving children, most remaining in the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community.

g. That her late husband was a fisherman working the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront

and the main breadwinner of the family.

h. That she works selling fresh fish, while her co-wives sell smoked fish, so that all

their incomes are tied to the economy of the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront.

i. That her husband’s death at the hands of the police in July 2012 (circumstances

described further below) has devastated her life, the lives of her co-wives, and the

lives of all of their children. Besides their grief, they are now unable to pay their

children’s school fees or go to the hospital or buy medicines when they fall ill.

j. That besides losing their breadwinner in the demolition, her family lost the

building they maintained for fishing business at the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront.

k. That she prays that justice will be done for her husband’s death and her family

will be properly compensated for their tremendous loss so they can survive and

care for themselves and their children.

Community Circumstances

25. That the Makoko/Iwaya community is home to over 200,000 (two hundred thousand)

people. The Plaintiffs stand as representatives of this community, including the 4,034

persons named and described in Exhibit A who are among those who lost property and

were displaced in the course of the demolition of their homes and business premises.

26. That Makoko/Iwaya waterfront community is situated partially on land and partially on

water, namely on the Lagos Lagoon between the shore and the Third Mainland Bridge.

Both the water and land communities are open to public thoroughfare by land or water

and do not prevent any public waterfront access or interfere with any current waterway

navigation. Shown to me and marked Exhibit B is a copy of a survey map depicting the

general area referred to as Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront communities.

27. That the residents of the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community are predominately Eguns,

Ilajes, Ijaws and Yorubas.

28. That the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community is well documented and globally

recognized as an ancestral fishing settlement that has flourished since the 1800s when our

ancestors settled in the community.

Page 31: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!

! 13

29. That the residents of the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community have coexisted peacefully

ever since, despite ethnic and religious diversity.

30. That the lifestyles, occupation, cultures and identity of majority of the residents are

intricately connected to access and use of open water for fishing and other fishing related

activities as well as the timber industry that involves moving logs by water.

31. That the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community boasts of highly developed structures of

organization that ensure the security and overall cohesiveness of the community.

32. That the local economy of the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront Community is equally vibrant

as over 40% of all smoked fish consumed in Lagos is processed in the community and the

residents of Makoko engage in the timber industry, carpentry, trading and other business.

33. That most of the residents of the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront Community, like me, were

born in the community and they do not have or know any other home but the community.

34. That the oldest man in the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community Mr. Shemede Oke

Moses is 115 years old.

35. That Mr. Shemede Oke Moses told me on July 22, 2012 at about 4:30pm at his residence

in the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community and I verily believe that he was 15 years old

when his father brought him to the Makoko/Iwaya Community from Vawe in Ogun State. !

36. That, to the extent that the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community suffers from poor

public infrastructure, this is the result of the sustained failure of the Lagos State

Government and its local councils to extend social services such as potable water, roads,

hospitals, solid waste disposal facilities, schools and other infrastructure.

37. That, by contrast, the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community itself is engaged in

productive livelihood activities that are integral to the broader economy and food security

of Lagos State and, through its community organizations, is working to upgrade the

community’s environment and harness its economic potential with or without the

participation of the Lagos State Government, with which it has tried to engage.

July 2012 Demolition Activities and Related Events

38. That on July 13, 2012, a notice dated July 12, 2012 issued by the Lagos State Ministry of

Waterfront Infrastructure Development was sent to the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront

Community and was randomly handed out to some residents of the community.

39. That, in the Notice, the Ministry informed the “Owner/Occupier” of Makoko/Iwaya

Waterfront of the Lagos State Government’s decision to clear all “illegal structures”

along the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront and implicitly accused the residents of developing

illegal shanties on the waterfront and impeding economic and gainful utilization of the

waterfront for navigation, entertainment, and recreation.

Page 32: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!

! 14

40. That the Notice ordered all owners and occupiers of the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront to

vacate and remove all structures within 72 hours of receipt of the notice.

41. That a photocopy of the said Notice issued by the Lagos State Ministry for Waterfront

Infrastructure Development is hereby exhibited and marked Exhibit C.

42. That at about 10:30am on Monday July 16, 2012, officials of the Lagos State Ministry of

Waterfront Infrastructure Development accompanied by heavily armed Policemen,

officials of Kick Against Indiscipline (KAI) Brigade and the Environmental and Task

Force on Special Offences stormed the community in boats.

43. That as soon as they entered the community, they began demolishing homes and other

structures with chainsaws as residents of the community scrambled to salvage their

belongings from the falling structures.

44. That many residents, including children, fell into the water as the demolition squad

brought their homes down while they were still inside.

45. That the demolition continued from Monday July 16, 2012 to Saturday July 21, 2012.

46. That the demolition exercise left many persons in the community homeless and without

any option but to sleep in open canoes.

47. That on the night of Wednesday, July 18, 2012, three children were reported missing

after the open canoe in which they slept capsized.

48. That a search party organized to find the children discovered one of them dead while the

remaining two have not been found till date and as such are presumed dead.

49. That on Friday, July 21, 2012 leaders of the community paid a visit to the Ministry of

Waterfront Infrastructure Development to meet with the Commissioner Mr. Olusegun

Oniru and discuss the demolition exercise being carried out by his Ministry.

50. That the Commissioner refused to give us audience and instructed his security personnel

to walk us out of the premises.

51. That on Saturday, July 21, 2012, the demolition took on a more violent dimension as a

policeman attached to the demolition squad known as Police Corporal Boma Pepple shot

dead Mr. Timothy Azinkpono Hunkpoyanwa, a resident of the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront

community, without justification.

52. That the police bullets gruesomely ripped through his stomach discharging his intestines

and other internal organs.

Page 33: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!

! 15

53. That following the shooting, Mr. Hunkpoyanwa was rushed to hospital and Mr.

Emmanuel Hagbe J.P. went to inform the bereaved family, who were unable to see their

loved one and say goodbye before he died.

54. That attached herein and marked Exhibit D1-D3 are pictures of the late Mr. Timothy

Azinkpono Hunkpoyanwa taken immediately after he was shot as well as an autopsy

report stating that Mr. Hunkpoyanwa died on July 21, 2012 at 3:20pm and the cause of

death was blood loss and related issues due to a gunshot injury to the abdomen.

55. That, during the demolition exercise, many residents of the community were harassed,

maimed, beaten, arrested and detained without any justification by officials of the

demolition squad.

56. That among those who were arrested on Saturday, July 21, 2012 and held in detention for

four days were: Afonse Lateef, Wasiu Danhuto, Sende Danhuto, Jacklyn Danhuto, Benua

Ahonlonsu, Ezekiel Hungevu, Hunge Hana, Hunge Bartholomew, Hunge Jeremy.

57. That those detained were released on Tuesday, July 24, 2012 on orders of the

Commissioner of Police for Lagos State without any charges ever filed against them.

58. That on Monday, July 23, 2012, thousands of residents of the community were led by the

Social and Economic Rights Action Center (SERAC) in a peaceful protest to the office of

the Lagos State Governor over the demolition of the community and the shooting of late

Mr. Timothy Azinkpono Hunkpoyanwa.

59. That the Lagos State Governor, Mr. Babatunde Raji Fashola received the protesters at his

office and apologized to them for the murder of Mr. Timothy Azinkpono Hunkpoyanwa

while assuring the people that the demolition will not continue and that the government

will work together with the community to provide essential social services and

infrastructure, improve living conditions and harness the community’s tourism potential

by turning it into the ‘Venice of Africa’.

60. That the demolition exercise and protest were widely covered by both local and

international news media.

61. That the National Human Rights Commission also came out publicly to condemn the

demolition exercise and vowed to conduct an investigation into what appeared to be

serious violations of fundamental human rights of the displaced residents.

62. That attached herein and marked Exhibits E1-E5 are photocopies of some newspaper

and online news articles covering the demolition exercise, protest march, and statements

from the Chairman of the National Human Rights Commission, Dr. Chidi Odinkalu.

63. That following the protest of July 23, 2012, the representatives and leaders of the

Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community were invited to meet with the Commissioner of

Waterfront Infrastructure Development by letters addressed to them and dated.

Page 34: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!

! 16

64. That attached and marked as Exhibit F1- F2 are copies of the correspondence between

the government and the community in respect of the meeting, which ultimately took place

on July 31, 2012.

65. That the representatives and leaders of Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community attended

the July 31, 2012 meeting together with our legal representatives from the Social and

Economic Rights Action Center (SERAC).

66. That representing the government at the meeting was Prince Adesegun Oniru, the

Commissioner for Waterfront Infrastructure Development, Mr. Aderemi Ibirogba, the

Commissioner for Information & Strategy and Mr. Bayo Suleiman, the purported

Chairman of the Lagos State Environmental and Special Offences (Enforcement) Unit

and/or the Lagos State Task Force on Environmental and Special Offences.

67. That, upon arrival at the meeting, the Commissioner for Waterfront Infrastructure

Development, Prince Adesegun Oniru, asked the lawyers from SERAC to leave because

the meeting was meant only for residents of the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront community.

68. That the Commissioner pointed out that the aim of the meeting was simply for

Government to engage in discussions with its people and, as such, there was no need for

any legal representation.

69. That, the community’s leaders and representatives explained to the Commissioner that

they specifically invited SERAC to be a part of the meeting in its capacity as the

community’s legal representative and also made clear that SERAC’s presence was crucial

to the furtherance of the meeting.

70. That the team of lawyers from SERAC reminded the Commissioner that the community

has the constitutional freedom to be represented by lawyers of their own choosing in

matters of legal or administrative nature and, as such, SERAC should be welcome to stay

regardless of the nature of the meeting.

71. That, upon the Commissioner’s further insistence that the meeting is for the community’s

leaders and representatives alone, the team of lawyers from SERAC withdrew.

72. That, many of the community’s leaders and representatives left the meeting in protest

after SERAC’s withdrawal and this led to the disruption of the meeting.

73. That, by a letter dated August 22, 2012, the Makoko/Iwaya Community informed the

Lagos State Governor of their intent to undertake a community-led regeneration of the

community in line with the Governor’s commitment to provide essential social services

and infrastructure, improve living conditions and harness the community’s tourism

potential by turning it into the ‘Venice of Africa’.

Page 35: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!

! 17

74. That, in the letter the community members expressed their commitment to collaborate

with the government to design and implement a plan for the redevelopment of the

Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront Community for the utmost benefit of the people. Attached and

marked as Exhibit G is the said letter to the Governor.

75. That the representatives and leaders of the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront Community were

once again invited to a meeting by the Ministry of Waterfront Infrastructure Development

on October 30, 2012.

76. That attached and marked as Exhibit H1- H3 are copies of the correspondence between

the government and the community with respect to the meeting.

77. That the community leaders and representatives were present at the meeting together with

lawyers from SERAC.

78. That, at the meeting, the Lagos State Government was represented by Mr. Bayo

Suleiman, in his purported capacity as the Chairman of the Environmental and Special

Offences (Enforcement) Unit (a.k.a. Task Force), two officers of the Kick Against

Indiscipline (KAI) Brigade and the Personal Assistant to Commissioner of Waterfront

Infrastructure Development Prince Adesegun Oniru.

79. That, at the meeting, Mr. Bayo Suleiman informed the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront

community leaders and representatives of the Lagos State Government’s decision to

continue the demolition of the Makoko/Iwaya Waterfront Community.

80. That, accordingly, the Lagos State Government seems bent on annihilating an entire

community in pursuit of “mega-city status,” which judging by the government’s actions

and threats, can only mean a city that caters only to the needs and desires of the wealthy

and leaves evicted residents without shelter or livelihood opportunities.

81. That the July 2012 Notice from Ministry of Waterfront and Infrastructure Development

follows on several occasions on which the 7th

and 8th

Defendants have issued “abatement

of nuisance notices” and demolished houses and structures in the Makoko community,

for the purported purpose of enforcing “the provision of the Environmental Management

Laws of Lagos State”.

82. That, for instance, by a Notice dated 9th

December 2010, the 7th

Defendant, the Lagos

State Environmental and Special Offences (Enforcement) Unit, ordered “The Owner of

Shanties by Adekunle Bridge” (an area of the Makoko community built on land) to abate

environmental nuisance including “illegal occupation of land and erection of shanties”

within three days. Attached and marked Exhibit I is a copy of the said notice.

83. That the ensuing December 2010 demolition exercise was brutally carried out in the

community by the 8th

Defendant, the body that purports to be the Task Force on

Environment and Special Offences, causing one death and many injuries.

Page 36: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!

! 18

84. That the December 2010 demolition is presently the subject of Suit No. M/198/2012 at the Lagos High Court. That an April 2010 demolition in Makoko is the subject of Suit No. M/757/2011 at the Lagos High Court, while an April 2005 demolition in Makoko is the subject of Suit No. CA/L/637M/2009 pending at the Lagos State Court of Appeals.

85. That there is proliferation of bodies or persons that have threatened or been involved in

demolitions of the Makoko/Iwaya communities, including the Commissioner for

Waterfront Infrastructure Development, Kick Against Indiscipline (KAI) Brigade, Mr.

Bayo Suleiman (S.P.), the Lagos State Environmental and Special Offences

(Enforcement Unit), and the Lagos State Task Force on the Environment, the 5th, 6th, 7th

and 8th Defendants respectively, so we do not know where the next threat will come from.

!

86. That, even while the Government repeatedly threatens us with demolitions, it makes public promises to improve our community for the benefit of current residents.

87. That, for instance, Makoko and Iwaya are two of the nine host communities for “urban upgrade” activities under the Lagos Metropolitan Development and Governance Project (LMDGP), a US$200 million World Bank-funded project.

88. That I have been informed by Felix Morka, Esq. our legal representative, at the SERAC

office at about 12noon on 23 July 2012 and I verily believe the following to be true:

a. That, for the purposes of the Project, the Lagos State Government and the World Bank agreed to a Resettlement Policy Framework that would apply to Bank-funded activities or any activities necessary to the completion of the Project.

b. That under this Resettlement Policy Framework, the Lagos State Government is mandated to “avoid [involuntary resettlement] and minimize the social impacts of the project” and, where resettlement is unavoidable, “to provide offsetting mitigation measures that give the persons displaced by the project meaningful opportunity to share in the project benefit . . . [and that] assist [them] to improve livelihoods and standards of living or at least to restore them to levels equivalent to those prior to the project.”

c. That the Lagos State Government is further mandated to observe World Bank

Safeguard Policies that mandate prior consultation, adequate notice, grievance procedures for Project-affected communities, as well as compensation, resettlement and other remedies for those who are involuntarily displaced.

89. That we do not see how the demolitions that have taken place and threatened in our

communities can be in line with these policies or how they can be consistent with the spirit and purpose of such “urban upgrade” projects when the very communities that are meant to benefit would no longer exist if/when the projects are ever completed.

Conclusion

Page 37: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 38: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 39: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

HUGBEJI SIMON

30. AGOSU MARY FIFAME AGOSU CASMIR, DIEDONE, TOPE 5

31. MIFOPO JOMES MARY MIFOPO PAUL, SOLOMON, MAUMA,

FEBI

6

32. HUGBEJI

MARCELAIN

HUNGBEJI KLEME TOPE, NOLINU, SUNDAY 5

33. KOTVE

METONEMEYI

KOTOE TAIWO DAMILE, JOSEPH, VITOR,

MAUTIN

6

34. GUJO LUCIEN GUJO ROSALIN ISAAC, JOSHUA 4

35. LOKOSU FEMI LOKOSU

ALBERTINE

JOEL, ANGELA, JEAN, MAIC 6

36. GOCLONU BATHO

NOEL

GODONU DOVOME FUNWANTON, ISAAAC 4

37. MIFOKPO ASAGBO CECILE LOKOSU ZITA, LEONI, BRUNO 5

38. AGO LOKOSU ODETTE LOKOSU ZITA, LEONI, BRUNO 5

39. ZOSU LOUIS EPIPHANIE ZOSU BENOIT, SERAPHINNE 4

40. ADEKUNLE

BAMUGBEJE

NAOMI

BAMUGBEJE

REBECCAH, MAUTIN,

JESUTIN

5

41. ZANNU ADEBAYO KPOJIGAN ZANNU JANETH, OLA 4

42. THOGBE

HUNKPATIN

AHISI HUNKPATIN EUGENIE, JUSTIN,

OLORUAWA

5

43. BAUKOLE FEMI ALICE BAUKOLE INUMIDUN, BOLA 4

44. MATHIAS KUNNU SOSI KUNNU APPOLINAIRE, BERNADETTE,

DOSU

5

45. SOLOMON WAWHE EUGENIE WAWHE MAHUYON, UNSCENMT,

THEODORE

5

46. OCHLAN PAUL EMILIENNE

OCHLAN

JANETH, OLIVIER 4

47. WAHABI MOJUSI ELIZABETH

MOJUSI

SETEVEN, LEONIE 4

48. OCHLAN ISMAILA FELICIA OCHLAN JOEL, COGI, BOSE 5

49. HUGBEJI

MARCELLE

REBECCAH

HUNGBEJI

NOELLINE, ISAAC, MADECU 5

50. THOGBE ELIJA XAVINE ELIJAH BOBO, SEGRE, ANIGUSTIN 5

51. SAMIEL

HUNNUKON

ELIZABETH

HUNNUKON

PEGO, TINU, VERONICA 5

52. JONAS ZANNU CHRISTINE ZANNU SAMIEL, MONDAY, TOBI 5

53. JOHANU

HUKANRIN

CECIL HUNKANRIN VINSECENT, FLORENCE, LEA 5

54. DOROTHEE

HUNGBJI

MICHELLINE

HUNGBEJI

DANIL, XAVIER, DEBORA 5

55. PIERRE AHISU WARYINNA AHISU SEBA, ANTOINETTE, JOSEPH 5

56. EWUNTIN AHISU ANAGO AHISU ZINSU, DOSU, ANDO 5

57. AHOTON MATHIEU MIDIYINDI

AHOTON

DEBORA, ANDREW 4

58. AGUNCHEDE ZOSU GUNEHEDE KPOSI KEKE, MANE, EMMANUEL 5

59. FOSUKPE LUCIEN LUCIENNE

FOSUKPE

SINPLICE, SAMDRINE 4

60. SESIKINDE

TOUSAINT

OVONODE

SESIKINDE

JEAN, LUCIEME, LUCIE 5

Page 40: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

61. FELIX HAJAGUN SANDRA AHLEUN DUBE, JONAS 4

62. JEAN AHLEUN PAULINE AHLEUN JEREMI, PASCALINE, FRIGON,

EZEKIEL

6

63. MATTEW

ATUNGBE

ALICE ATUNGBE BENOIT, BENEDERT,

FELICIENNE

5

64. MARCELIW

HUNKANRIN

COLETTE

HUNKANRIN

FIRMAINE, ISIDORE 4

65. CYRIL AWHI KOUN AWHI ROSE, ROLAND, AMED 5

66. LUC AHOUANSU MAURICEENNE EBENISELLE, LERICIA,

PRINCE, GENIVREVE

6

67. ROSE AHOUANSU JUDITH

AHOUANSU

ROSETTE 3

68. SAMUEL HUNGBO GOSI HUNGBO JAWU, SEBA, OLIVIER 5

69. ROBERT HUGBO VERONICA

HUNGBO

EMILE, MONDAY, SUNDAY 5

70. ISAI HUNGA VERONICA HUNGA ANTOINETT, SUNNY 4

71. MATHIAS KPETOSI AYIGBETISI MARITTE, SOPHIE 4

72. JOHANU KPETOSI MARLE KPETOSI ZITA LANDRY 3

73. KPOSU GONUEVE ZANSI GONUVE ZITA LANDRY 3

74. CHRIKOPHER

ZUNKPON

ANTOINETTE

ZUNKPON

HONISE, DIDRE, KPEGO 5

75. SANFIL AZANKPO TOT RANTI

AZAKPO

DIEU, IMOLE, RONILE 5

76. CLEMENT

TOYINGANDE

AGATH

TOYINGANDE

MAHUKRO, SENAKPON 4

77. SALMON WHESU CELESTINE WHESU AMOS, MARCELLE,

HENRIETTE

5

78. ZANNU EDEWTIN CHUSTIANA

EDEEHIN

KATE, ALBESTINE 4

79. MATHEW

KPOSUKPE

EDITH KPOSUKPE SERAPHIN, MONICA, DOSU,

HASI

6

80. GUJO ESA MEDESE ESE HASI 3

81. EDOND AVLESI BERBDETTE

AVLESI

EZEKIEL NOLLINE 4

82. ZANNU WUSA MARIA ZANNU CHEKPEMI, AGNES 4

83. CASIMIR ZANNU LOUISE ZANNU DAVID, CHRISTINE 4

84. ATEJI ADOGUN KURI ATIYI APPOLINAINE, NAVMI,

JOSUA

5

85. ADOGUN GIGI CELESTINU

ADOGUN

FELIX, SOMINAKPON 4

86. BAKARE HONFO MARIAMA HONFO SIIKIRU, SUKURAT, LASIRA 5

87. MEDENU

THEEPHILUS

JANET MEDENU NATANIEL, REINE, EUGENIE 5

88. SEBASTIEN

YONLONFUN

ALICE

YONLONFUN

SUNDAY, JEHOVANI 4

89. BARTHOLOMEO

ZANNU

ANASTHASU

ZANNU

FAITH, ROMES, JOEL 5

90. MARTIN ZANNU EPIPHANIE ZANNU KEVINE, AGNES 4

91. BRUNO

AVOCETIEN

COLETTE MIFOKPO INES, SUPINT, JEAN 5

Page 41: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

92. DOSU MATIU HENRIETTE DOSU JENNET, FIFAME, OSIA 5

93. AVLESI NONORE JODEPHINE AVLESI MARK, NENRIE, FABRICE,

PRUDENCE, MAWUJLO

7

94. HUVESU ROBERT MERIE HUVESU JOEL, GODONU, PELAGIE 5

95. GANSUVUN

ZANNU

YAICNA

GANSUVUN

ANDREW, JOHN, ELISABETH 5

96. TANMASE

APPOLINAIRE

MARIA TANMASE 2

97. NUDEMAMON

MENRIE

RACHEL

NUDEMAMON

JACOB, ROMAIN, SRAEL 5

98. ADOGUN ANDREW JULIENNE

ADOGUN

FRANCIS, BRIGITE, ROSINE 5

99. KPAGO ZAVIE ROSALINE KPAGO JOHN, ERIC, NRUNO 5

100. ALPHONSE ANASU CHRISTENA

ANASU

DANIEL, ELISE, VICTOR,

CLAUDINE

6

101. HOSEA SOSU ESITH SOSU MEDAND, TOSIN, VERONICA,

EDWIGE

6

102. MARCELLIN

HUKPATIN

JANETH KUNNU HONNETE, DIEUAIME 4

103. ISAAC MEHINTO PIERRETTE

MEHINTO

DINA, CLEMENTINE, DAVID,

VIVIANNE

6

104. MULENI AWHI SERAPHINU

BAMIGBOCHE

FIRMAIN, DEBORA,

CLEMENT, PETER

6

105. ANDRE

BAMIGOOCHE

PHILOMENE JACOB, PETER, ADEBAYO,

JEREMI, MARTHA

7

106. FRANCIS HUNKPE SURU HUNKPE PASCA, SHETH, DORCAS 5

107. ANDRE KIKOGBLE THAHUTIN

KIKOGBE

JUSTINE, CLEMENTINE

MICHELLINE, JACOB

6

108. JALIUS

CHAGOLOLA

CHRISHANA

CHANGOLOLA

FERDINARD, NESTOR 4

109. PAUT HUNKONNU LEA AKOTESU SEGUN, ALBERT, MARIA,

JEAN, MANIE

7

110. SAMUEL GBEFA KPOMIDE GBEFA MARTHA, MARIA, PHILO 5

111. JEAN GBEFA JOANIS GBEFA SAMUEL, SAMSON, DAVID 5

112. ZINSU HUNVI VICTORNE HUNVI PARTRICE, EDMOND 4

113. MICHEL TOSECH CHRISTINE TOSEH ROSINE, MARTINE, GIDEON 5

114. EMMANUEL

TOSEH

LAYO TOSEH ESTHER, JOSIAS 4

115. FRANCOIS ATIKPO ALFONSINE

ATIKPO JOSUA,

SERAPHINE

2

116. ANTHONY

KUCHOEKPON

HONORINE

KUCHOKPON

FARNCOIS, BERNADETTE,

REGINA

5

117. SEGI MAWUKLO EMILIENNE SEGI RUTH, IDA, OPE, YEMI 6

118. LOWATO DANIEL ENGENIE LOWATO JOSIA, FRIDAY, BIENVENIE 5

119. HUNNUKON

KAIAH

EDITE HUNNUKON BEATRICE, ODILE, SAMSEND 5

120. VODA NICOLAS VODA

EMMILIENNE

JOSNUA, SYLVESE, SIDONIE 5

121. ESHEDA ABDUD LATIFAT ESHEDA NONIE, FAUSAT, NASIRU,

MOYNAT, AYMIDET,

9

Page 42: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

MARIAM, AMUDAT

122. KPOSE GUJO MEDESE KPOSE HASI, RELANIE ELISABETH 4

123. SALAKO ROBERT PRERRETTE

SALAKO

ANDERW, SHEUN, DEBORA 5

124. ASOKLE FRANCOIS LEONIE ASOKLE AYOMIDE, FRIDAY, 4

125. AJONUMAKPE

LEONARD

VICTORINE

AJONUMAKPE

ANDEL, ALBERT, PIERRETTE,

RAZAK

6

126. AJONUMAKPE

SOTONDJI

TALABI

AJONUMAKPE

AMINU, EDUARD, HUME. 5

127. AMITIN ZANNU ZANSI AMITIN APPOLINAIRE, YLONFUN,

MICHEAL

5

128. AJONUMAKPE

SUMAILA

EMMILIENNE

AJONUMAKP

OTRE, SEBATIEN, IDOWU,

EMINE,

6

129. AJONUMAKPE

HUNKONNU

SNEYISON

AJONUMAKPE

ZANNU, KPEDETIN, AGOSU 5

130. MISOAYI

GBENUKPO

SOSI MISOAYI PHILIP, JONAS, GBETOGO 5

131. TOSE DANIEL CLEMATINE TOSE BOSE, SUNDAY, BRIGIT 5

132. HUNNUKON

SATINGO

FINA HUNNUKON JESUGO, VICTOR,

NATHANAEL, NESTOR.

6

133. AHISU CELESTIN SERAFINE AHISU JOSEPH, BERNADET, ABIGEL 5

134. HAJAGUN DANIEL EDITU HAJAGUN LUCIENNE, CAZMIE,

VICTOIRE, OLIVIE, GISELE,

7

135. TDONU DANSU YEVOSI TODONU PAUL, GLARICE, FLORENCE 5

136. YEWHENU

BARNABE

GELESTINE

YEWHENU

VERONIKE, NAOMI,

ROSALINE, SALMOND,

CELESTIN, JANET, EXTER.

9

137. WHEIN PETER SERAFINF WHEKIN AYUBA, GERARD,

CLEMATINE

5

138. AFFA VINCENT KPOSI AFFA ADEBAYO, AGOSI,

OLORUNTOBI, PIERRETE

6

139. ACHUE SIMON ENGENIE OGHUE PASCALINE, DANIEL, DIANE,

JENNET, ODILON

7

140. HUSU

GANMADIGO

JULIENNE HUSU ERIC, GERARD, FLORA 5

141. AVLESI JOACHIN MERIE AVLESI JOHN, JERAFINE, 4

142. JEUNGBO

YOLONFUN

AYELE JEUNGBO ETIENE, SHALIE, RENE 5

143. LOWATO DEGO CHRISTIAN

LOWATO

JAWU 3

144. WHEHUMI

RAYMOND

PIERRETTE

WHEHUMI

MODUPE, TOSU, OWOLABI,

MODEKAI,

6

145. ZOSU PTER IYABO ZOSU FLORENCE, WILIAM 4

146. LOWATO ETINNE NAOMI LOWATO JANE, JAKELINE, JANET,

IDOWU, ALABA

7

147. ZOSU AKPITI LUK ALICICE ZOSU FRANCIS, MICHAEL,

JANUARY, BEATRICE,

ZANMENU

7

148. JOSHUA ZANNU

MARTINS

PASCALINE

MARTINS

CHERIANT, JOSCALAN. 4

149. ASOKLE NENRIETTE MODUKPE, TADAGBE 4

Page 43: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

LETIMOND ASOKLE

150. AGOSU SOFIN AGES AGOSU OWHE, PASCAL, 4

151. AGUE ANUGBIN YAICHA AGUE GBESE, SANDINE,

YONLONFUN, ZANSI, AJIMON

7

152. ZUNDO HNSU PIERRETTE ZUNDO MERIE, FIFAME, KUVI 5

153. KUKU AGLIN HUNSI KUKU HUNME, OWNE, 4

154. ZANNU DANKOLE MAWUTIN ZANNU JULIENNE, ABEL, MONDAY,

NIGHAEL

6

155. ZANNU OLIVIER RAIMENT ZANNU OJU 3

156. AGOSU PETER PELAGIE AGISU EMANUEL, MAWUTIN,

FRIDAY

5

157. AJIYON DIDIER AMILIENNE

AJIYON

GERARD, HONTONYON 4

158. AGUNSELE JEMESI DOWE AGUNSELE MANAS, MICHAEL, JUTINS 5

159. GODONU MUNSA HUNMENU HUNSA TADAGBE, RENE, NOAR 5

160. AHOWEKUN

ADRIEN

HENRIETTE

AHOWEKUN

CLAUD, JAWU, 4

161. SUNNUVUN MOSES SEBATIENNE

SUNNUVUN

EMINE, AUGUSTIN,

CHRISTINE

5

162. HUNGBO PAUL EMILIENNE

NUNGBO

IMOLE, ANU, DANIEL 5

163. KPOTON

CHRISTOPHE

PIERRETTE

KPOTON

GABRIEL, PELAGIE,

DAMIENE

5

164. ASAGBO PHILIP ZANSI ASAGBO NADINE, TANIE, 4

165. ZANNU FRANCOIS MAWUMON

ZANNU

GISLAIN, MEDA, JAWU 5

166. YONLONFUN

DEKPE

MADELEINE

YONLONFUN

MOSES, GBENGA, KPOSI 5

167. HUSU JELEMIA KOLETINE HUSU BARNABE, PAUL, CAZMIE 5

168. ATIKPO FRANCOIS ALFONSINE

ATIKPO

JOSHUA, SERAFINE,

RICHARD

5

169. KILAUNKO

ATIGABO

MARIA KILAUNKO WHESU, ZUSU, TETE,

MAGERITE

6

170. EHUNTIN PETER ALFONSINE

EHUNTIN

ANTOINETTE, ELEINE,

FIDELE

5

171. AGUE BERNARD MAGERITE AGUE DIDIER, LEA, CHRISTINE 5

172. AYAYON ZACME PIERRETTE

AYAYON

PROSPER, JELEMIE, ZOSI 5

173. DOSA MARK ROSINE DOSA SAMUEL, GABRIEL,

FLORENCE

5

174. ZANNU MICHAEL ROSALINE ZANNU BASIE, TEREZE, STEVEN,

LORENSIA

6

175. WHETO DANSO ALBERTINE

WHETO

SURU, NUBERT, ELIJA 5

176. HUNGA

EMMANUEL

TEREZA HUNGA ZAVIE, TEOPHIL, LEA 5

177. AHOUWEKUN

MOSES

OKE AHOWEKUN JILE, JOHN, HENRIETTE 5

178. HUNGBEJI MOSES AGESSI HUNGBEJI DONNE 3

179. WHESU SAMUEL ANTOINETTE YACENT, VICTORIA 4

Page 44: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

180. ZANNU FETELIKI ALISI ZUNNU BRIGETI, WINYANJI 4

181. GBEYON

APPOLINEAR

GBEYON PELAGI ROZA, MAWUWAME, 4

182. PETOSI ETTINNE PETOSI SEWANU GODWIN, VICTOR 4

183. YEWENU GILBERT YEWENU SELESTIN STEFANI, GLADY, PHILIP 5

184. WHEAU EDEWEN WHESU VERONICA DINA, ELIJAH, HANNAH 5

185. ASOKLE ETIENNI ASOKLE ODETI JACOB, VIANU 4

186. EZINSU TEWUDO EZINSU

ALUBETINU

JULIENU, ALPHOSINU, DIDIA,

MIKOLU, ZACHEAUS.

7

187. FOSUPE ANTOANI FOSUPE ASIBA SENA, KLITINU, TULU, MARY 4

188. ZANNU OGOSU ZANNU REBECCA JOJO, BENEDICT 4

189. HUNKPE KLANSU HUNKPE ALIETI DOKASI, BENEDICT, 4

190. FOSUPE JONAS FOSUPE LUSIENU FELI, PLEDEJI, OBETI 5

191. AZANKPO WUNSU AZANKPO KLISINU FRANCIS, ABEL 4

192. MIYANWANDE

MESES

MIYANWANDE

ANAGO

FEREMIAH BOOSI 3

193. WEZE GODONU WEZE ZANSI BOLE, DISELI, 4

194. ASOKLE BATHEMI ASOKLE MATILI KLISINU, JOSHUA, EZEKIEL,

ABRAHAM

6

195. EUNTIN AGEMO EUNTIN

MIMOSULU

WILIAMU, TOPE 4

196. ZANNU FINNAYON ZANNU SITOLINU SANDRANU 3

197. HUNKONU

VICTONE

HUNKONNU

BEYATRICE

VERONICA, RONA 4

198. HUNKPE JOHU HUNKPE DETI MARIA, JULIANU, SUNDAY 5

199. TOSAME HWENU TOSAME HANNAH IDOWU, KLUME, DAVID 5

200. YONFUN EZINSU EZINSU ALIETI BREZE, THOMAS, MILIENU 5

201. ZANNU MICHELI ZANNU DELFIN ANDREW, BOSE 4

202. MEDENU ALUBERT MEDENU

ELIZABETH

MONDAY, SENNE, LORAN 5

203. TAPINU SOSU NOWEYON

TANPINU

DELE, MINASIN 4

204. YATIN LAMARMU ALIMATU LUWI, FATIMA 4

205. SAMUEL EKPODE ALISE EKPODE TOSHUA, JEKOLIA 4

206. KUNKENH

MACELINE

IFETI KUNKENH SAMUEL, LYDIA, NUBIYON 5

207. HUNKPE RAFIU MADELEUN SABINU, IDOWU, SAVILAR 5

208. KUNKENH LUWIS MAGRETH

KUNKENH

EMMANUE, JEREMIAH,

MECHAK

5

209. AVLESSI CORNEIL OSE AVLESI LUWIZE, ISDROLA 4

210. HANWADE PETER CLEMATINU

HANWADE

FELISEYENU, ROZET,

MARLAKI

5

211. HEWENSU DANIEL PIPI HEWENSU SANSAN, LAZARUS,

BERNADITH

5

212. YONFUN

BERNUDITH

AYIGBE YONFUN LYDIA, SEGUN, 4

213. MOJLO HOSIA MECHELIN MOJLO MAWUTIN, SELAFINU, MARY 5

214. MIFOKPO

YUBERTH

VOWEL MIFOKPO JOHN, SHADE, ELIZAH 5

215. SONAYON OKE SELATION GILBERT, AGATH, ROZERT 5

Page 45: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

216. ATEJI MATIYE FELISEYENU DAVID, BERNVENI, MARY 5

217. ATEJI BOTON CATELIUN ATEJI BOGAR, DOMINIC, DARGBO 5

218. HUNNUKON

EZEKIEL

ALIETI

HUNNUKON

JEWESI, EMMANUEL, JOSEPH 5

219. HAJOGI JUNIYEN MAGRETH HAJOGI PETER, BERNADITH,

SEBASTIN.

5

220. KENSU MOSES KENSU DIDIA SURU, ODETH, APPOLINEAR 5

221. AGBEKE FELIX AGBEKE FRONASI MAWUTIN, TEMIDIRE,

DODAGBE.

5

222. DOKA SELESTINE DOKA SOSAHANA JAVIER, MAWUKPEGO,

NATANIEL

5

223. GODONU PIERE GODONU MARIA CHANTALL, ACHILLE,

VICTONE

5

224. MEDENU ANTONI MEDENU LUCY ROMA, ROZALINE, DOKPE 5

225. AGUCHELE

NICOLA

AGUCHELE

SONATYON

JUNIOR, PAUL 4

226. HUNSA AJIMO HUNSA BOSE BENUWA, CHIMENU 4

227. ATEJI MARCELEN DEGOFO AJIKILI, DAMILOLA 4

228. WHESU

NICODEMUS

SELAFIUN NOWELL, NESTOR, JEREMIEB 5

229. KIKLOGBE DAVID AYONSHE ERIC, FRANCIS, NOLE 5

230. FRACIS DELE SESI ROZELIN, SERAH, MARK 5

231. ALIKPO AIGO MARY LONA, SEGUN, SUTUDAY 5

232. OWHE KLISTOFU DIDIA LAZARUS, SEYI 4

233. WHESU OLIVER DORKASI STELLAR, TITILAYO,

ADEWALE

5

234. AYEFUNJI

KLISTOFU

AYISE ELIJAH, TANYI, LUWE 5

235. AGIYA FRANCIS VICTORIA DANIEL, NOAH 4

236. HUNGBEJI PETER ADIJATU SEYI, ELIBETH, MESIME 5

237. ZANNU SULU LUSEYENU AGBETE, FIFAMEN 4

238. GATEJI MATIYE SUZANU BOSE, HOSIA, JELUME, 5

239. HUSU SLUMO SHEPEMI BERNA, PASI 4

240. KOGBE DANIEL BERNEDITH FRANCIS, DIDIA, BERNA 5

241. HUSU OJO BOSE SOSI, REBECCA, JOHN 5

242. AKE HUMENU COMFORT

HUMENU

JACK, MARK, MALI, MATA 6

243. WHEHUNE

HUMENU

ALICE HUMENU JUSTIN, MAGRET, MILIEN,

MOISE, ISLAMIYAT

7

244. GIDI GANYON

ALEX

CHATI GIDI YLONFOU, SEVEREN,

JOHANU, OWHE, GBOYE

7

245. HUSOU FELISIEN

EMALA

HUSOU ELA

EMALASI

MATINS, JEAN, PRIDENS,

ELISE, EGITH, PRIERRET,

EPKOYEMI, GBENU, ELISE,

MAGERET, TAIBATU, ISIAH

14

246. HUNKPE MOGBE HONKPE VITUA EPKOYASI, GBENU, ELISE,

MAGERET, TAIBATU, ISIAH

8

247. EJADU .O. SIMON EJADU CLEMATIN MAIUZI, PIER, BIEVENUE 5

248. HUNKPE TOSIN HUNKPE NUKANUI TOBI, FIDELI, ISIAH, KOLO 6

249. KUASI HOVESOU HUNKPE JAWO, MAUNA, MAUTIN, 7

Page 46: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

ANASOUKILO JANET, MICHELINE

250. ANDBU ISAAC ADOSU IFETI SIMIONU, JOSIA, JOHANU,

LUSIEN, JAWU.

7

251. GANDONU MATIE AJOSOU NATASI DONACIEN, LEYA, DOMINICK

VITUA, SELLAH

7

252. GANDONU FELISE OKLEN TINU JIJEYON, JEVENIE 4

253. ZAZU PETER MEHENTO SELE LIONA, BATEN, WHENUME 5

254. YLONFO PIERRE YLONFO MALI JULI, SEVEREN, FILOMENU,

JEREMI, MESIME, VERONICA.

8

255. AGBOZE DOROTE AGBOZE JUSTINE SOLOMON, SELAH, BENUWA,

SELAPHIN, JELAH, ZATHE

8

256. LOKOSOU

NATANIEN

AKPANJE DORCAS DESIRE, JEROME, MICHEAL,

MAWODOAGOOAN

6

257. TANDE DAVID TANDE JUILI PASCAL, LEYON, PAUL, TOBI,

JAWU, MAWUWE

8

258. SEMONJI SAMUEL SEMONJI

MADELENU

IVANU, JOEL,

DURODEOLUWA

5

259. AKODEVO MATIE AKODEVO

SILIVIANU

EGUSTINE, BALANB, JEAN,

ANE, MARIET, DAVID

8

260. KUYONU ROCHE WHEGBO LENI JERO NADETH, APORINE 5

261. AKODEVO MATE AKODEVO

SILIVIANU

EGUSTIN, BALANBE, JEAN,

AVE, MARIET, DAVID.

8

262. AKODEVO NOWELI AKODEVO

FINAYON

IZAVETH, MIHODE 4

263. HUNAYOU REMON KPOSI SENDE

EGBENONU

SONAYOU, SELINU,

FRANSOUA, ELENU

6

264. HUNSA FRANTAI KPAKE SALIMON AJALA, SIKIRU, RODIA,

RAZACK

6

265. HOCHEME

TITILAYO

HOCHEME

SELESTINE

LEYA, JULIET, IYNSI 5

266. KPATINVO REMON KPATINVO

JULIENU

JEAN, EME, SEFANI,

JELADINE

6

267. AGBONJI GOSSOU DOWHIN ALIET HUNSI, DOSSOU, NOVIYOU 5

268. BATAH HUNSA KUKPO AJIMON SEGUN, GUSTIN, PAUL,

ANDEL, CLEMENT

7

269. AGOSSOU

ALUFONSI

AGOSSOU JULIET EMINE, DLUNASIEN, JAHU,

MAHUME

6

270. AVINWKE HOSSOU WHEKEHU ALIET MAHUNA, ABRAHAM, BETI,

SEBASTIN,

6

271. ZIKIELI GODONOU AVAGBO ALISE DELE, MAUSI, PETER, CLEMA,

JAIL, JAKE

8

272. SOKONI

SELGAPHIN

SOKONI FLORENSI VIJINI, MOSES, MAWUMATO 5

273. MESE ISIAH MESE BENA YISEYON, JUNIOR, BATLEMI. 5

274. GBEMASOU MAUSI

GANJA

GBEMASOU ZANSI ANE, SELESTIN, DEFINE,

MAHUKLO

6

275. SHEMEDE RAMON NUDEWAGBE

RUTH

RODINE 3

276. AKISIRE ISAAC AKISOE JULIANU JONAS, FIDELI, TOBI, SATIME,

RENU, JANET

8

277. DOSA SELESTIN DOSA FINAN ROZALINE, FREEMAN 4

Page 47: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

278. ANASOU

KITMARTINS

ANASOUKILO

RACHEEL

JOSIASI, STEPHANI, FEBI,

AMOSI

6

279. SLAFOU KILIHUN

MAGA

KILIHUN BAITO LIONA, DEFONE, CLEMENT,

MAHUNMESSI

6

280. MESE RICOBERT MESE CRISTINE ESTHER, JOZE, CRISTIAN 5

281. HONTONYON

KISEGBESI

VIDEYON

ROZALINE

SELAN, AMOSOU, HUMENU,

SITEPHANI

6

282. ADANMADO LUWI GODONU MATIE ISREAL, REBECCA, JOSHUA 5

283. HUNGBEYATO

BATLEMI

HUNGBEYATO

ALIET

SIMOTE, JILBERT, ROBERT,

SETONYON

6

284. LOKOSSOU

KOSOUHENTO

LOKOSSOU HANAH PASCAL, EJEN, ANDREW 5

285. WHEEZE ALAJI

KWAYINKUHOME

SHEZE YONSINHO AMU, BELLE, KOLO 5

286. NUDEWAGBE

HUNSA

SHEZE YONSINHO PASCAL, EJEN, ANDREW 5

287. HEDUTO LEYON HEDUTO

ALBETINE

DAVID 3

288. AWHASOU

JELMAIN

MIMOVOU

JULIENU

TEOPHIL, JAHU, YISEYON,

ADOLPHE

6

289. WHEEZE

SOLOMON

EWLEN ALIET JAKE, DAVID, RACHEAL,

DORCAS, LITA, BOSE

8

290. ZOLA NOAH KOKOSSOU

CHALLOT

FORENSIC, SANDLIN, JEAN,

MOSES, IMOLE

7

291. ATUNGBE

MAWUTIN

WHEEZE JALI MAWUWALU, ANIET 4

292. ANTOINE GBEYON GBEYON

SELESTINE

ZOME, ISAAC, PAUL, ABEL 6

293. YHLONFO

TODOWUDE

GBETOME YAICHA JOHANNU, PIERRE, OLIVIE,

ZABIE, SEKINAH

7

294. AWHADI EZINSOU RAJEDO DEKOBO JEAN, AYOMIDE, AJIMON,

JELADINE, JOSUA

7

295. HUNGBO JOHN HUNGBO ENJENI JOHANU, CRISTIN, PASCAL,

GIOMU, JOHN

7

296. KPADONU DOSA DOSA NIMED BOSE, MASAYO, VIVIEN 5

297. ANAGONU MOISE AYIMETON ALISE EMANUEL, CONSAN,

APOLINE, DELFIN

6

298. KUMAYON

NICOLAR

ZOMAHUN SIEDE JOMON, ENES 4

299. MESE OWOLABI MESE PHRRET ANAH, GLORIA, MAWUSEDE 5

300. HUNHO NIKOLA AGBODOME

BLAIME

ETIEN, NATASI, BENA, ROSE 6

301. TOSE JEREMY TOSE KORRET DONA, BETI, FLORENS,

IRENU, ODINE, SISAN

8

302. TODJE DESIRE TODJE FELISITE ALFONS, SAMMUEL 4

303. HLONFO JOSEPHIN AHLONSOU JUSTIN JESUTIN, BENARD, LIOIVA,

JESUYON

6

304. TODJE ISIAH TODJE ALIET AUGUTINE, ED 4

305. ASOKLE BENADEN ASOKLE

PHILOMENU

MATAEL, MALI, SHANTAL 5

306. MEHUNU HOSEA MEHUNU POLINU MIYISE, SERAPHINU 4

Page 48: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

307. AGBOKPANSI

MATIE

AGBOPKANSI IFETI VERONIKA, SUNDAY 4

308. AHISSOU ATOUKU AHISSOU ARIET SAMUEL, MOSES, JOSEPHIN 5

309. GANKPANU

NAOMU

GANKPANU

LUSIENU

JANI, JACOB, TEMI, LAYO 6

310. WLEHUMI PAUL WLEHUMI MARIA EMAWAETON 3

311. HUNKANNIN

PERRE

HUNKANNI

VIGUNE

HUNKANNI LAZA 3

312. AGONTOZEEZ AGONTO FLOANCE JIJI, EMINE, JUTIN 5

313. HUNKPE ANTONI HUNKPE FLOANCE KONFO, JONRTHAN,

BLESSING

5

314. AGBOHUGBE

SOSSU

AGBOHUGBE

MIDOHOME

DELFIN, DONASIEN,

ROMANIC

5

315. GODONU TEMENU GODONU KPOSI MAHUTONJI, KOASI,

SEGBEYON, AGESI

6

316. ATIA DOTUR DAVID, JULIEN, MELITO 5

317. DINJO BENUA DINJO TETE GABRIEL, BENJAMEN, JONAS,

JENIAH

6

318. HUNU FELIX HUNU LOUIS COUSTAUTIN, CREPIN, LUKA 5

319. HWELANU

OLIVIER

HWELANU

BERNADETH

MOUIQUE, DEBULU,

MAHOUSI, PELAJI

6

320. HUNU FLORENT HUNU YAO THIERYI, VERONICA 4

321. HWELANU

NICOLAS

HWELANU ANRIET KPENAYI, SEYON, TIFENAM 5

322. KPOKPENADE

JILBERT

KPOKPENADE

FILOMENE

EDOUARD, IVET, DEBORA 5

323. KPOKPENADE

EDOUARD

KPOKPENADE

EUGENIE

JONAS, ZIPOLA, 4

324. HLONFO VINCENT HLONFO AGATH JULIENE, LEOTINE, JAHU 5

325. WAHWE HODEWU WAHWE HOULINE OLIVIER, SEOUN, ZOSI, 5

326. DOSA HONORE DOSA

ANODREWGA

GLORIA 3

327. EMEKPE JRACHIN EMEKPE JUSTINE FEBI, HOBADIAH, FLORA 5

328. KPOKPENADE

SALAKO

KPOKPENADE

TOPE

MONDAY, JULIEU, CLARIS 5

329. MAJLO PETER MAJLO AGNES YACINTH, ESTER, BIDENI 5

330. AHISU PETER AHISU NATHA ABEL, AKEEM, GREGOUARD 5

331. GODONU

MAHUKLO

GODONU NATHA LOUIS, MAIAU, WILIAM 5

332. GANDE BERNADIN GANDONU

JOSEPHIN

PASCAL, SIDONY, SESE, LILI 4

333. GANDE NRACHE GANDE RAYMOUD ARNAULD, COLETHE, CHELI 5

334. GANDE ASOGBA GANDE DOGONU GODONU, WUNE, TANTI 5

335. HWENU JACOB HWENU ANDEL ALIU, ISE, OLUWA, ELIJAH 6

HWENU HONUINE CHRITNEY, KEMY LEONARD 5

HWENU EGURY DOGBE, DASUN, CLENENTIN 5

336. HUNSA JUSTIN ISALEFINU HUNSA FUNMLLAY, JOSHUA, SEUN,

TOPE

6

337. HUNGBO PETER HUNGBO COLETTE VIRGINY, JOSHUA, SEUN,

TOPE

6

Page 49: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

338. NUNGBO PETER HUNGBO COLETE VIRGINY, ENOCK,

MAHUBAYI

5

339. DOSA MOSES DOSA ANRIET ROLAND, BATHELENUY

GISLAIR

5

340. LOKOSU

GBE MICHEL

LOKOSU DUKPE MATHIER, BOSE, FIRMAIN 5

341. AGBOJOGBE

MICHEL

AGBIJOBE AGNES JEACQUES, DOGBE, MARIEY,

CLEAR

6

342. AGBOJOGBE

MICHEL

AGBOJOGBE TINU TSAHIA, IMOLE, JUSTIN 5

343. DEGBO JOHN DEGBO ROSALINE HERVES, CHUDRAC; SEDE 5

344. KUJLAHYIN

GBOUESO

KUJLANJIN CELINE ROSENE; MOHUGBEGO;

LEON

5

345. JISUKUMO DAVID SAUAYINA

JISUHUNA

BLESSING, KASIMI, SEGUN,

FREEMA, SERAH

7

346. LOKOSU TATA ELIBERT LOHOSU MATIEZI, AUGUNTINE,

HUBAT

5

347. GANPO

JLIECLEMENT

ALICE GANPOJTE VICTORIA ROYER, RIGIEL

JOHN

5

348. SUNUVES WESU PILETI SUNUVES JAMES, RICHARD, DESTON,

CALAME

6

349. CLEMENT

BALOGUN

ESTHER CLEMENT FRACIS, BAVEIN, ABRAM,

DEBORAH

6

350. KOKPE HAROKO BOSE KOKPE GADISI, OLUWASEUN 4

351. KOKPE POPO ALETI KOKPE AGATI, JOJIH ANUBER. 4

352. GBEYETON LEOYO IUWIZI GBEYETEN PROMISE PARISH 3

353. GBEYETON

ROBOTI

MATA GBEYETO DEBORAH, SUNDAY, KEMI 5

354. ADIYETON

TANKPINU

SERAFINU

ADIYETO

ROMES, DIANU, KEMATINU,

SEDE, BIODU, JOHN

8

355. NATANEL AUESI AVESI NATASI, HWENUME,

TOVIYON YIFETI, SEBA

7

356. KWLAYIN AYESI KUJLAYIN ROSINU SELAFINU, MALI, JOHN,

MAWUGLO

6

357. AYONUDE DANIEL IUWIZI, AYONUDE RONATIDIO, SEVIUN

KEHINDE, TAYE, IDOWU

7

358. AMUSU MATHEW EMIENU AMUSU DEBORAH, TEMITPOE, MATA,

SOLOMON

6

359. NOBERT AZANKPO BICHET AZAKPO TOPE, KEMI, DUPE 5

360. GANDE JOHN MARY GANDE MAHUKLO MAHUSI ESTHER 3

361. SUNUVU KODMAN LILI SNNUVU JUSTINE RONADO 3

362. HLOFO ZOSU MADINA HLOFO GERDI, MAHUKLO, SOGOSI 5

363. SOMEHWE PETER FIFAME SODJI DANEL MAZELINU GODDAY,

HAPPINESS, ANU

5

364. AWLES AGOSI GBEGA AULESI TOBI, TOPE 4

365. SODEJI JUTEN FIFAME SODJI MATA DOCASI 3

366. WUSA ADRAW KEMI WUSA DAMI, TOBI, REBECCA

SAMUEL

6

367. ZONSU MACHIEL MARIA ZONSU HOSEA, ERIC, MIDOKPE 5

368. AGUNKPE MOJUBU HANNAH

AGUNKPE

ELI, SEPEYE, ISRAEL,

DONASIYE

6

Page 50: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

369. EHUNTIN ZAANU ANUFUSINU

EHUNT

ANOHNG ERENU, FTDELI,

ROMOABE

5

370. HUNGE

YUNSEGEYO

EWESU HUNGEVUS FRACIS, MAUNA JULIENU 4

371. AYINSU

QMOPETER

IFETI AYISU JELERA, REBECCA, DOTISH 5

372. AHWUNU JOSHUA ROSINE AHWANU GOOD LUKY, FUNMILAYO 4

373. AHWUNU JEJENU SERAH AHUWANU MONDEST, APO RICHARD,

LUCIYE, ABEL,

6

374. HUNGBO BENJAME BANADET

HUNGBO

DANUNIQUE ISAAC,

AGUSTIN CARTINE,

ZACARIA, SIMEM DELFINE,

JOHN, BENUA

8

375. HUNGA SAMONELI HUNGA BANADETI WIBE, MONGISI, GAERI,

FRIDAY

6

376. SOKE PETER MARIA SOKE JONASI, ESTHER, BEJAME,

AZARIA REMI

6

377. LOKOSU

HUNGBERE

LOJAKERINU

LOKOSU

AJIMOH, LOKOSI, JEKOPU.

DANIEL

6

378. AGOSU MARIA AGOSU MAWU

KPEGO

MAWUTI, EMIRIENU,

JEREMIYA MICHRNU

MAWUPO

6

379. VIDEGARA

EZUNSU

MARIA VIDEGARA JOHN, KATE, BETI, AGATI 6

380. MLFOKPO JONASI MIFOKPO BOSE EKORU, AKARICI, DENTI

MATISI

6

381. ESENU SARAMI ESENU ARUBETI TAOFIKI WAKINI

ARIMATARAHI

3

382. AGOSU ANADU AGO SUPIPI SEYONGBEBEDI, KAYODE,

KPOSI, BOSEDE, OLUSEGUN,

MATIYUN, AYOUI, OWORABI

10

383. LOKOSU AMUSI LOKO SUMAGERTI DEBORA AYENSI, JAKERINU,

JOHN AMIRI RLEN JURIENU

EMANUELI, MAWUOANU

7

384. WESU WUWE WAWE JOHN JNIFINA NOU MINAYOM

MADUPE.

3

385. HONFO JEREMIAH HONFO LUSIENU BENEDICT, REBECCA,

OLAMIDE ILUMIDUN

5

386. AYIMETON

ANDREW

AYIMETON

FELICIA

SEGUN, NESGA, ALPHONSUS 5

387. AVAGBO KPEJLE AVAGBO DORCAS JULIET, MARY, MONDAY

KORODINE

6

388. KUWHENU CHOFE KUWHENU

JOSEPHINE

BENA, RACHARD,

MAWUWANU, LUSIENU

6

389. ZINSSOU KEKERE ZINSSOU ANGELI JERLADINU, PASCAL

MAWUMESSI, SATILE

6

390. HUNGEVUN

RICHARD

HUNGEVUN

FUNKE

REMI, OLIVIA, ROMEO 5

391. GBEDEGAO, COMI GBEDEGAO ALICE LUSIEN, ODRE, 4

392. SEKI MATINS SEKI LAMALAN ALELUYAH, SIEDE, TOMAS

NESTOL

6

Page 51: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

393. SEKI PHILIPS SEKI MARIA MAUTIN, WHENUME,

SIMOTE, ABBEY

6

394. BANKOLE MASENE BANKOLE

ALBERTINE

MAGARET, MAWUME, ZOZA,

ODINE

6

395. ZOGBE MICHEAL ZOGBE ANTOINET JOHN, MASELINE, DAVID,

NOELINE,

6

396. HUNGEVUN OFLE

KPODUFUNDJI

HUNGEVUN JULIET AUGUSTINE, OLIVER,

MADELINE, JANET,

MATTHEW

7

397. KIKI POPO KIKI SERAH ZAKARIA, KPEDETIN,

SEMAKO, DEYON

6

398. AGBOGLO

HUNSEEKEN AGESI

AGBOGLO AGESI ZANU, TRENO 4

399. HUNKPE MEDEJO HUNKPE NONINU CATE, ELODINE, DONACIEN

ELIZABETH, MAWUKPEGO

7

400. AGOSSOU BOTON

HUSA

AGOSSOU BOTON

JULIANNAH

GLORIA, LUCIEN, JOHN,

LEYA

6

401. AYLONSOU

DOROTE

AYLONSOU

MAWUYLO

GERRAD 3

402. IDOWU MATHEW IDOWU SERAFINU JANET, OTTANCE, GEORGE,

OPE

6

403. ATUKO AHUMENU ATUKO

CHRISTIANAH

JOEL, AYENSI, SEGBEYON,

FRANCISCA

6

404. ATUNGBE

SEGBEYON

ATUNGBE ZANSI JOHN, STEPHEN, SESSI,

JAHOU

6

405. GREGUWA LOTI GREGUWA ZOME LOTI 3

406. ASOKLE BERMBE ASOKLE FELICIA PAUL, SERAFINU, 4

407. DINDIN AWE DINDIN SOSSI JOHN, JACK, AYOMIDE, JAHU,

FELICIA, FELIX

8

408. LOKOSU JOHN LOKOSU

MAGARETH

CLEMACI, LUCI, KASONI,

MADERENU, OLIVER

7

409. AWANJINU SEKPE AWANJINU VITUA MAWUKLO 3

410. HUNYEME ISAAC HUNYEME

PIERETTI

KLITI, MATHA, KATE, EKO 6

411. AWANJINU SHESI AWANJINU MARIA DIANA, CHRISTY 4

412. VODUNNU

GERRAD

VODUNNU

ALBERTINA

SIEDE, ISITOR, DONA,

AYENSI

6

413. HUNFO YEKINI HONFO AMUDA ALIMOT, LAMANU, SHAKIRA 5

414. AJAKPA HUSA AJAKPA TANTI ROME, APOLINUS, MIYISE 5

415. KINNON

AGBOYIDE

KINNI MARI DOSSI, EGUSTIN, FENISI 5

416. MEDEMOKU

MODESI

MEDEMOKU DOSSI DENIZI, FLINSO 4

417. MEDESUKU

MATHIAS

MEDESUKU

RECCAH

LEON, ALICE, SATIDE, PAUL,

PIERRE, JESUYON, MAHUTIN,

9

418. ADOVO EDWARD ADOVA FLORENCE PASCALINE, MICHEAL 4

419. ZOGBE HOUSUGBO ZOGBE KOLETINU EZEKIEL, SERAH, BLESSING 5

420. AWANSU JOACHIM AWANSU BERNA VIVI, MARI, MAHULE 5

421. HUNGBE PETER HUNGBE

VERONICA

WANYINNA, ROBERT

RODINU

5

422. SOMONTIN SOMONTIN SERAH AMBROSE 3

Page 52: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

BERNAD

423. KUZUZONZIN

WASIU

KUZONZIN

ADELINU

MAHUJLO, SEYINU, JOSE,

SEUN

6

424. ZANNOU

DOMINIQW

ZANNOU

LUCIENNOU

MATTHEW ANTONIA,

HANNAH

5

425. OKE KLONODINU ALADJEDO

CHAYON

ODLE, SABINOU, DOVIS 5

426. ALADJEDO

BANABAS

GBENONNOU LUCI TOBI, FLORENCE, MOSES 5

427. AWHADI AGRIN NADOUKILO

HANNAH

BONI, STEPHEN, JANET 5

428. ZANNOU

MATTHEW

MEHENTON

SONADJI

THEO, MITLIMAHU, FUNMI 5

429. SUNUVU

SEWANOU

SUNUVU

ROSALINE

ADJIMON, PETER, FLONA 5

430. HUNSU JAVIER HUNSU DOCAS BENADETIN, BENAT,

NAUDREM

5

431. HUNGE NOEL HUNGE LYDIA PAULINE, JILOU, MODES 5

432. ZOLA AKODENU

SELI

ZOLA MADELENU MAWUSEDE, NAOMI

FRANCIES

5

433. AVAGBO GILBERT AGBETE ALICE ANTOINE, JENEVIE, ALIDA 5

434. ADOSU FELIX ADOSU JULIANAH PAUL, MARTINA, JOHN 5

435. TOTINRENE

TONASE

TONASE

VERONICA

RODRIC, MARIA, AJELO 5

436. ZOGBE

MIKPONMAHU

DEGBO PELAJI KPEGO, AMOS 4

437. SERIKI LOKOSU KUNUME YEYINU SAMUEL, ZACHARIAH, EDITH 5

438. LOKOSSOU SERIKI

AUGUSTINU

BAKOLE

JOSEPHINU

VIANE, ANGEL 4

439. AKODEVO

ABRAHAM

WHESOU

MADELENU

ALEX, NEHEMIAH, ABIGAEL 5

440. ZOUDJE JOSHUA HUNGBO ANTOINA JOHN, MARY CAMEINOU 4

441. KUKPO SIMON JIGBE HUME NESTOR, RONDIN, CYTHIA 5

442. DOSUGAN

SAMADU

DOSUGAN

SEKIRATH

RUKAYATH, SALIMOTH,

YUFATH

5

443. HUNBION MOSES LOKOSSOU MARIA APOLINUS 3

444. MENHETO

ADJAWIN

MENHETO

REBECCA

BIOLA, TAOFEEK, BUMI,

SEUN

6

445. HUDEWAGBE

HUNSA

KUNKPA SESI PETER, BRIGETH, RENAI,

RENES

6

446. HUNGE ALBERT HUNGA ALIET REBECCA, SAMUEL,

WHAYINA

3

447. WHESU YEKE JIDONU SEVAH THONA, PENAYI, FILO 5

448. HUNOKAN

MATTHEW

HUNOKAN

CHRISTIANAH

SERAFEN, MAWUNA,

MONDAY

5

449. KPOFON PETER PROFON ASIVU FRANCIS, STEPHEN, 4

450. AGBOGLO ISACC AGBOGLO SARAH MARTINS, TOBI, SERAH,

NAOMI

6

451. HONFON SAMUEL HONFON ANGEL AUGUSTINE, CASMI, SIMON

JOKE

6

452. HUNMINU HUNMINU ENDMOND, MOSES, MILIITUS 5

Page 53: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

ANTONY COMFORT

453. AYIDEU

EMMANUEL

AYIDEOU

REBECCA

OLIVER, AYENSI, GLORIA,

ELIAS

6

454. HOUSOU ISACC HOUSOU PIERRETH ISRAEL, LEA, DORCAS 5

455. JIGBE SOLOMON JIGBE MARTHA JEREMIAH, EZEKIEL,

PASCALINE

5

456. ZUJE GABRIEL ZUJE DOCAS WIBE, VALE, PELAJI 5

457. DOSSA VODUNNO HLONFO SENUMEN TINU, MAHUESI, MACENE 5

458. DJAFAN PHILIP DOWHIN AVIYETI CHILELVEN. 3

459. HUNGA

CHRISTOPHER

HUNGA JESUGO

&

WHESU

ALUBETINA

KLITIAN, ROSE,

HALLELUYAH

&

JUJI, BOSE, EMILY

9

460. ZOGBE AJIMOU HUNGA BONADI GILICAL, MAUTIN, LUSIENU 5

461. NASAOUKILO

HUSUBAKOU

NASUKILA

JULANNU

JOHN, CASMIR, ROSE 5

462. ZOGBE HUSUTAYE ZOGBE BENORTIN FRANCIS, VICTOR

FRANCISCA

5

463. HUNGA DANIEL HUNGA JULIET NOWELINE, JOHN, YAYIBA 5

464. SOMOTIN MANEYA SOMOTIN

AMINATH

GEORGE, JUTIN, HENRY 5

465. AGBAUNDE FELIX NIYEJON PELAJI ROSE, FERDNAND

MAWUUMESI

5

466. DOSSU MEKEN MEKEN POSSI MICHEAL, ROSELINE, MASE 5

467. AGBAHOUNDE

ZAMMENOU

AGBAHOUNDE

NAOMI

PAULINE, TIANU, ISAAC 5

468. ANASOUKILO

TTIENNE

ANASOUILO JANET PROSPER, LUMUIZI, LUSIEN 5

469. GBEZE JOACHIM GBEZE BOSE VICTORINE, JULI, MAWUYON 4

470. ADEKPO KESIYE NOUKPO

ELIZABETH

TEBI, DONA, SAMUEL 5

471. JEMAYIHODE

ASHEPO

ASHEPO TMIELINU HOSEA, MADIN, DAVID 5

472. GBEZE CHESI GBEZE DASOYIN KLISTIAN IMADINOU,

SEFANINE

5

473. GBEMASU RENES GBEMASU

TMILINU

STEPHEN, EMMANUEL,

CHETH

5

474. KINI OKE JAWULA AGBOKON BOSE SEBENOU, MAWUWA, BINDA 5

475. DOSSA ROBERT DOSSA ALICE OLAMIDE MIDOPE, TOBI 5

476. JIGBE MOSES MEDEDJITEN JIGBE THEOPHILUS, RAFAEL, LEA 5

477. ATUNGBE DADDY KIKI ESTHER IMOLE, JOSIAH, OLURUNI 5

478. ZOGBE ZANNU GIDI ESTHER OLIVIER, MAHULE, LEO 5

479. HUNGEVUN

EZEKIEL

HUNGEVUN

CHRISTINU

PETER, NAVELI, NESTON 5

480. KINI MOSES AWHASOU WAYIN MARK, DUPE, MOJUBA 5

481. BAODE KINI BAODE JOJO I BIOBA, AGUNGBE, JOSHUA 5

482. PETER YENDE 1

483. WHESOU SERAFEN WHESOU ZINWHE MATTHEW, JUNIOR, CALEB 5

484. HUNGA PAUL HUNGA TOYIN RAMOS, ELISABETH,

CHARLES

5

Page 54: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

485. SAGBO PAUL KEPLA ELIZABETH MAWUDO, JOHN 4

486. HUNGA SOLOMON ZOGBE ELIZABETH ALEX, TUNSE, FEDRICK 5

487. ATUNGBE

SENEAKENNOU

ATUNGBE OWEHE CHRISTIANA, PETER,

MATTHIAS

5

488. GOSSOUBA

SONNOU

GBENNONOU

ADJIMON

SEFELINOU, ROSE, CALEB 5

489. SAGBO ZANNOU

KONDA

AGBAUNDE

REBECCA

MISEMAUEU, ROSELINE. 4

490. WECHENU DAVIDI WECHENU HUNSA MIDO, MAHUVE, MAHUWA,

DONA, DOTU

7

491. JIMAHO ILE JIMAHO

JACKELINU

INNOCENT, KLISTIAN,

OLIVER, ZANNU, GILBERT,

RODETTI, KLISTIN

9

492. HUNSU MICHEAL NUJANDE LEKIA EZEKIEL, DANIEL, RABBI 5

493. MINUS AGATE HUNSU MICHEAL ANDO, IRENE, ELA 5

494. JIGBE TUSIN AKODEVO POLINU

NATONJI

MAGERITTE

SEGUN, FLANKO, REGINA,

MAHUTOFI

6

495. ATIDEKUN

ALBERT

JOSIA ESTER PETER, JACOB, TANWA 5

496. DOSSA REMI JIGBE VIGINI KONSAN, NOWELI 4

497. KUCHEGBE JACOB KUCHEGBE

COMFORT

POYININ, JOSE, ZINSU,

EZINWE, PHINA, SERAH,

DOSSI

9

498. HUNTONJI BENIOR HUNTONJI

CHRISTY

DANIEL, OSIAH, MANASE,

NOWELINU, REBECCAH,

ESTER, DINA

9

499. HUNTONJI CHETTE HUNTONJI

MAHUKPEGO

YISEYON, MAUTIN, SEKANDE 5

500. HUNGA JELUMIN HUNGA JOSEPHINE BENARD, ABELI, ODINU,

PASCALINU

6

501. WECHENU

SEGBEYON

WECHENU KPOSI EVU, SEYINDI, KPOMILE

ROSA

6

502. AWANSUHA

ALPHONSUS

AWANSUHA

FILOMENU

ROSEMON, BLINDO, FIDELIX,

EMILY

6

503. AWANSUHA

NATANIEL

AWANSUHA SESSI MATHEW, LEO, FEGO 5

504. KABA SIMON KABA CHOYINKIN ELIZA, JELADINU 4

505. HUNTONJI

CELESTIN

HUNTONJI ZANSI ILE, MAHUWA, YEMANIN,

OSE, MININ, DENIS, EMILY

9

506. YLONFUN ZOGBE HUNGA

HERRIENTA

MEDA, MAHUNA, DIANU,

FINAYON

6

507. HUNGA ADUGBO KUKPO

MAGDALINE

EDMOND, STVERE, VICTO,

TOBI

6

508. HUNGA ALUFONSI HUNGA MANMA KLOTINU 3

509. SEZONNI LEYON SEZONNI LUSI OLIVER, ANSLEM, FRANCIS,

SENTIYA, ESTHER, ROLALD,

ELIZABETH

9

510. ZANNU DANSU ZANNU

ALUBETINU

PATRIC GOSSU, VINCENT,

RENE, RONA

6

511. ATOKUN VESATIN TOVON KPOSI ADEBAYO, BENA 4

Page 55: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

512. AHISSOU

TLIKINAGO

AGBOKUNOU

MARIA

EDUWA, WHESU, EZISSOU 5

513. ZOUSSOU ISAAC ZOUSSU

CHRISTANA

MOSES, DOCAS, GIDEON 5

514. BAYAHON

ABRAHAM

CHEDA JOSEPHINE REBECCA, SEDE, VEGGINNA 5

515. LOKOSSOU

GERMON

LOKOSSOU

ALIYETI

FIDELIS, TOPE, DELPHINE,

SEGUN

6

516. AWHADJINOU

PETER

AWHADJINNU

MARIA

FRANCIS, PRICISCA, DONA 5

517. EGBETE SIMON EGBETE MAYRITH MANUUTIN, SHATOTH, PAUL 5

518. SEZOLIN MATHIAN AGBOTOMAKUN

SEZALIN

ERIC, MOSES, VARELINE 5

519. ZOSSOU BENJAMIN LOKO DOSSI DORIS, JACK, JACKILINE, 5

520. KINI ELIJAH KINI VICTORIA ELIZABETH, JOB, KPEGO,

FLONA

6

521. MEHENTO ISSAC GODONNAS

ALIYETI

TINU, EMILE 4

522. SEZONLIN SIMON SEZONLIN

JOHNIKEN

JELADINU, MESINE, ANICE 5

523. OLOYA MOSES OLOYA SOSIYANA ISRAEL, JESUGO, NOELINU 5

524. AJOGUN LAMIDI AJOGUN SOYATH HALIYAT, MUTIU, KAFILAT 5

525. HUNMMOU HOUSA AGBAUNDE TOYIN PETER, ALIE, WHEKO 5

526. HUNGEVUN

SATURDAY

HUNGEVUN

JULIETH

TACHEYON, ROCHE 4

527. HUNGA JACOB YLONFUN SERAH ISAAC, JAMES, ALBERT 5

528. EKPEAZIDJI

JACKEY

ATUNGBE

CHRISTINU

ADREW, EMINU, LEA,

MAVUNESI

6

529. ACHA JOELI ACHA SIAVI LINUS, FIFAME, CHRISTIANU, 5

530. HUNTONJI

CHEUNBA

HUNTONJI

ROSALINU

PETER, TOPE, ADEFUN 5

531. KINI MOSES KINI CHRISTANA MARK, TADAGBE, BLESSING

VISION

6

532. YEDE PETER YEDE MARY SILI, SENAMI MOJUBA, TELLE 5

533. KINI ABAODE KINI JOJO ABIOBA, GIGOYON, KPEPO 5

534. KEYETON DUSIYE KEYETON TATI BARTIN, DAPE, PASCAL 5

535. SUNUVUN

PRESIDA

SUNNUVUN

BINIBIRENU

RANADI, BLESSING, DIANA 5

536. HUNSANA

FRANCIS

HUNSANNA

FILANONU

ALICE, SEPLISI, RANCO,

DANTIN

6

537. AYIMENTOR

ROBERT

AYINENTOR

SOYINAH

SONTONS, JONATHAN,

EFLUM

5

538. ZANNU SOSU

AZIADARE

ZANNU ANAYISI JESUYON, ISAAC, DELE. 5

539. ZANNU YINLE

GANNAVO

ZANNU JAKE INNOCENT, CHRISTIAN 4

540. PADO PESU MARY PESU ZINWHE, SENA 4

541. YONFUN ZOSOUVI ZOSOU JAKELINE ZANSI, SONAYON 4

542. GODONU GILBERT GODONU MIDOPE GANDONU, ELIJA 4

543. ZANNU ZOSOU OWE ZOSOU TANTIVI, JELENI 4

Page 56: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

544. APAHUNGE JELEMI AGHILIBO

APAHUNGE

FELIX, APAHUN, GABRIEL,

JANET, RUTH

7

545. HOUNGA ANTONI HOUNGA VICHINI TOSIN, RICHARD 4

546. GANSE CHINEKE GANSE MARIA TITI, ADE, TOPE 5

547. KOULIO MATHIEU JAOULIO VILO KOULIO SELAPHIN 3

548. ZOSOU TOGBE ZOSOU SEDE ZOSOU MAWAUWANU 3

549. SHEMEDE JESUGO SHEMEDE JUWANA CHEMEDE MOSES 3

550. GBESESALUMON GBESE ELIZABETH GBESE JAWU, PASCAL 4

551. SOKONI STEPHEN SOKONI MENLANI SENA, ROBERT 4

552. SOKONI ANTONI SOKONI JULIET ELIJA MAUSI 3

553. ADJAJIKOUNON

PHILIPH

AJAJIKOUNON

FAITH

MARK, JUNIOR, ELI 5

554. LOKO EDWARD LOKO KLOTINWE GERRALD 3

555. KPEH LOKO KPEH GUSI TITO, ENAGBO, LOUIS 5

556. SONU YONFUN SONU MIGERINNE SONU FELISIN 3

557. AGBOHOUN GBO

FOLU

AGBOHOUNGBO

KOLETT

JAWU, NUTIN, AFEFE 5

558. AKPE ROME AKPE RIBECA GAPE 3

559. GOUDJEMEJI LOUI GOUDJEMEJI

PAULINA

SYLVESTER, HANNAH,

SYSTIVIN

5

560. TOKIN

OVLONLIGAN

TOKIN ELIZABETH JEWAKUNNU, YEMISA 4

561. GBENONNU

MATINS

GBEMONNU

AYINSI

GBENONNU ABEL FILO 3

562. MESE ETHIENA MESE AGATHI MEDESE, JOJUWA, 4

563. ZOGBE

HOUNWAME

ZOGBE YIDA MEYON, MODRES 4

564. RONFO MOSES RONFO REBECA ANTONIA, ANTONY 4

565. LOKOUSOU

SEWAGBE

LOKOUSOU

ALUBETHIEN

MEDAVI, SEWEDO, SESI 5

566. SETON JACOB SETON SEGODO MASEE, ALBERT 4

567. VODUNNNE PAUL VODUNNNE

ELIZABETH

MARK, VINAYON 4

568. LOKO FANSOUWA LOKO DROCAS AMANU, EVIVI 4

569. ADANDOGBESI

BATENSONI

ADADOGBESI

MAKELITHI

PHILIPH, JAKELINNE 4

570. ADANDOGBESI

ADJIPE

ADANDOGBESI

OKE

ADANDOGBESI AGATHI 3

571. HLENUGOUDO

WSA

HLENUGOUDO

GIFT

OKOUSIN 3

572. TITAI JUTIN TITAI DRONI TITI ALUBET, MERCY 4

573. ZOSOU

BATHELEMI

ZOSOU FANSOUZI BLADINU, SOTIN 4

574. ZISOU BENA ZISOU MARRIA AHLUTIN, YONMI 4

575. KPADONU PETER KPADONU

SILESIME

JOUAJON, VICTORIA 4

576. AWANSOV SIPIGIN AWANSU SEYINA LITA, YEMISI 4

577. ZOUNZE OBE ZUNZE ALINE ROBERT, RUTH 4

578. LOKO ELI LOKO FLORENCE DOKASI, MAUYON 4

579. NUTAWADE NUTAWADE EWAJO, OWORE, LATI 5

Page 57: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

ELUKO VIDEWUN

580. TOHO KPOHE KPOHE REGINA EHI, JON, DONA, MAHUWA, 6

581. ILENAKLUWA

FELIS

ILENAKLUWA

YONMI

JEAN, WIZIKI, DEMOS,

HUMENU

6

582. SAVI ALIM SAVI RAFIATU AMIDU, BEYA MARIAMA,

AYISHATA

5

583. PROFISU FRANCIS PROFISU EDITH BANOWA, REBECCA, DIANU,

KOLETI

6

584. SAMUEL HONFOR MALUDO HONFOR LESSIN, PROSPER, ALBERT,

HEAJUAMO

6

585. ALUPEGO HONFOR MADELINE

HONFOR

INNOCENT, CHRISTINE,

GABRIEL

5

586. BARTHOLOMY

KUKAYI

CELESTINE

KUKAYI

XAVI, JOSIAN, NOCHINE,

JEHINE,

6

587. VALENTINE

AWADID

NAOLINE AWANDI KOLETI, EDIMO, ROGERS,

BERNARD

6

588. FONNI BANAWA BLENDINU KINNI,

FONNI

MARVAM, OBEYIDINU, FABI,

AMBROSE

6

589. ANULUKE SAMUEL AMULUKE KIEYI MOJIFU, MIDOPE, CHRISTINA 5

590. AWAMJINU

VICTOR

AWANJINU SASI JANON, LOUIS, MOSEWA,

JOSELINA

6

591. ADEPO PETER ADEPO KATE MOSES, JENA, KUFI,

MATHEW

6

592. DOSSUGAN,

GERMAIN

NAWNAH

DOSSUGAN

PASERI, HONABLE, MARITI 5

593. HUNGE GAB LAYE HUNGE RAFU, LAMBE, SATURDAY 5

594. HONSUN ZACHEUS HOUSU MADELIU WILLIAM, EDMOND, JEAN,

CHARIA

6

595. HUNG JOHNNY HUNGA ALIATU SEGRO, WEYENA, MARIAN,

NOELINE

6

596. ZANU KUWUNU ZANU EWUZU WAZIZU, POZI, HEVITHI,

SENADI

6

597. SAMUEL BOZISU ELIZEBETH BOSISU MICHEAL, TOPE, HANNAH,

TAMALI

6

598. JEGBE MALUTINE JEGBE MADELINE EGERINU, PALAGI,

MENALINE, FLORENCE

6

599. OKE ZANU OKE WANDAMO ELIZABETH, JUDE 4

600. OWATA AGBETA OWATA ESISU SONDERO, RENE, XAVIVA,

HIGA

6

601. LOKOSOU

NATHANIEL

LOKOSOU DORAS DESELE, HENRY,

MAUDOGBO.

5

602. KUKOYI

BATHOLOMY

KUKOYI SASSAN CHRISTI, ZAGALI, SESEYON. 5

603. DOSA ROBRT DOSA ALICE JONATHAN, ABEL, OLAMIDE,

SAMUEL

6

604. ZOGBE YONFUN ZOGBE VEKISI ZANNU, DONE, NESTO,

SONAYON, EMILIEN, MAUSI,

VEVE

9

605. ZOGBE JEAN ZOGBE JANET YLONFUN, MASEL, ELIJAH,

SONAYON, FIFAMEN,

SUNDAY, EMMANUEL, PETER

10

Page 58: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

606. DOSSOU MEKEN MEKEN POSSI MICHEAL, ROSELINE,

ROMENU, JULIET, NOEL,

AJAGUN

8

607. HUNGE SOJI HUNGE HANNAH FRIDAY, OLUWATOBI,

ALBERTINE

5

608. JOGAN CELMENT JOGAN KALINE FLESIENU, BIEMIENIN,

PAPETI, FINESIU

6

609. HUNDEWA

AWONSOU

ADINPO

MADELINE

ZACHIUS, KPOSI, ALIETI,

FILOMENU, AGUNJA,

SLANDE

8

610. HUSOU

PANSONTON

HUSOU ALIETI WANYINA, MAINA,

HONOURABLE, MADINE

6

611. AGBANDE

MATHEW

AGBANDE

CELESTINE

DUPE, AWHIANDJI 4

612. WHEDUTO

SAMUEL

WHEDUTO ZANSI ROLAND, LOTI, 4

613. AWHANJINU

SIKIRU

AWHANJINU

FATIMA

SIKIRA, GANIU, RASHIDI,

SHERI, AMUDA, AFIS,

ASHIMU, FATAI

10

614. HUNGA HUNSU HUNGA

WHENYINDI

BANABE, DOPE, VICTOR

EMILY, SEMENU, DEDE,

MAGDALINE

9

615. SESONLIU

ZACHEUS

SESONLIU

CEESTINE

JOSIAH, JUSTIN, NATHANIEL,

SEUN

6

616. ZEGE EZEKIEL ZEGE JULIENU MAUKLO, TONTON,

YONNUDOSU, TCHEKO,

6

617. SUZE AGADE SUZE SEINA LUCCI, LEOLINE, KPENAYIN 5

618. OKE SAKO OKE MATA ABEL, MATTHEW, KLEPEN,

SEBASTIAN, CYNTIA, ELVE,

FELIX, TINU, ROSELINE

11

619. HUNSA BERNADIN HUNSA DORCAS PEDETIN, JOEL,

IYAANUOLUWA

5

620. WHLENGBE

AGBAJUMO

WHENGBE JULIET TOJANU, JELA, PELUMI,

PONMILE, SIEDE, KRISTITIN,

MEDESE

9

621. AIVE TITILAYO AVIVE MALI MAUMESI, SEYIDE 4

622. AKOWANU OKE AKOWANU KPOSI MIDOMITON, SATURDAY

OKLE, FLINSO

4

623. GIDI JELUME GIDI JOSEPHINE SIBA, BONIBAS, ELIZABETH 5

624. BATHLEMY

AKOWANU

AKOWANU

MADERENE

SEBASTIN, ROSELINE, FEBI,

JOE.

6

625. AWANJINU JACOB AWANJINU

RACHEL

BORIZE, RENE, MELANI,

MANMAN

6

626. ZANNU FATAI ZANNU SAVITIU SALAMI, FAUSA, LATI 5

627. VISU SUNDAY VISU MURI DONIN, ROMARIC,

MAGENTTE, ABIDEMI

6

628. TOWENU

RICOBERT

TOWENU

MADERENU

MARY, ELIZEBETH, JESUTON 5

629. KPOSUKPE

ENAYON

KPOSUKPE

EZINWE

SAMUEL, CLEMENTINE,

MATHIAS, WANYINNA

6

630. AGBOGRO HUSA AGBOGRO TANTI ROMIN, POYININ, YISE 7

Page 59: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

KENRAYIN, SILIFIN

631. HUNGA TIMOTHY HUNGA MATA DISININ, JULIETH, MOSES,

SESSI, APPOLINUS

7

632. SEZONNI

ZACHEAUS

SEZONNI AYISI JOSEA, JUTIN, NATHANIEL 5

633. HUNMENU HUSA HUNMENU TOYIN ARIETTE, ZAGARI, PICER 5

634. WANSHEYON

MATHEW

WANSHEYON

ALICE

JESUGO, JOHN, TOPE,

MAHUWANU, JACOB, PETER

8

635. AGBOGRO ISAAC AGBOGRO

SERAFIN

MARTINS, TOBI, KOLE 5

636. VIDEYON AJIMON VIDEYON

SEDEKUNNUN

LUCIENNE, PELAGIE, KASINI,

MOSES.

6

637. ZUNZE AUGUSTIN ZUNZE JAKELINE JANETT, JOSIAH, FELIX,

PAULINA, LEOTINE, LUCIEN,

8

638. GBENMNU

MANINJER

GBENMNU OHE ABEL, DESIRE, THOMAS,

SENA, BOBO, SAMUEL

8

639. GBEYI RENE GBEYI ODETH SILIFIN, LEAH, BRIDGET,

ANGEL.

6

640. BOJLENU LUWI BOJLENU

FLORENCE

SAGBOJILE, FELISETE,

AYOMIDE

5

641. EKE OME EKE SERAPHINE ADELI, RORA 4

642. EKE TACHEYM EKE MAHUME FEBI, JOSUA, 4

643. JEOFU TITU , JEOFU JOSEPHINE LUCY, BOLADE, PELAGIE,

MOSES

6

644. GUMAVO

ADEBAYO

GUMAVO ALICE RENES, JESUGO, OSEUN,

YISEYON

6

645. ATADE DANIEL CHRISTAN ATAND AGEALI STATURDAY, ELIS,

BERT, SHATO, JETEMI

7

646. POSU CLMESI POSU JEME, MELANI, FRANCIS 5

647. AVESSE SELENE AVESSE SOFIA, APETO, JULENT 5

648. AVESSE SALAFINE AVESSE CHRINE, AYA, MONKI 5

649. AGBEDITE ZANSIGBEDITE RENE, EMESU, JAKE 5

650. ZANNU JOEL ZANNU LUCEYENU FETINA, KAMI, BANDER 5

651. AHEHE ESUMUEL VICTORIA AHEHE HANDE, MOSISI, FIANK 5

652. AZANK\PO ELIJAH LUCIYENU

AZANPO

VICTORIA, JISENE, SENACH,

MAHUYO

6

653. GODONUSAMEL SALA GODONU NONUBE, AYEJE, JILIBERT,

MAHUYO

6

654. AZANPO RODIKI HANNAH AZANPO GODUANL, PETER, KEMI, 5

655. KOKPE, SIMIYO KOKPE JANET ANUBERT, BICHITI, REMI,

RUKI, ESTHER

7

656. MEHAWANUDE

RANA

MEHAWANUDE

BIAKA

THANKGOD, ESTHER 4

657. GHBELO THOMAS FRANATINE

GBEHLO

CLODU, AGINESI, JOHN,

EYEFIWOLE

5

658. HUNHLO ISALAH GADISI HOUNHLO LOVE, SURU, FRETESL 5

659. HUNKPE, BAFERM ESTHER HUNKPE MESEH, SLIVER, ERIC 5

660. GBEHLO SIVER MONIKIGBEHLO GODWINI, RICHARD, WIBE,

PETER

6

661. AHLOSU MARIA AHLOSU FREEMA, ABIJA, PASIKALI, 6

Page 60: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

WEDUGBE

662. AUESSI ISREAL NOLMU AUESSI FRACISICA, JOY, PELAGE,

MULUKU

6

663. HUNKPONU

SALEFE

YEKUME

HUNKPONU

SELE, LOTI, ELIJAH, MARIA,

ESAHU

7

664. ASSOCLE MATI LUCIYENU

ASSOCLE

BOSE, KATE, MEKE, TAIWO,

KEHINDE, ALABA

8

665. AGIGBA HALAJI DOVOME AGIGBA TOPE HEKOLU KEMI 3

666. HUNSA ELIZABERT HUNSA WIBE, PASIKALINE, FRANKO

SEGUN, SUNI

7

667. HLOFOGA WIBO HEJENI HLOFOGA MAHULI, KEMI, ELBIES 5

668. MEDEKUSU

SUMAHE

ANTHONY

MEDEKUSU

IDOWU, DOWE, JOSHUA 5

669. HAFA BATEMI YINADE HAFA OJO, KORETI 4

670. HAFA OJO YAWO HAFA JELE, RASA, APO 5

671. BATEMI

HUNGBEYATO

ALISI

HUNGBEYATO

JULI, IVAYI 4

672. SONNU VEJEW SAMICHEHINU

SONNU

PAUL, DANIEL, MORIYA 5

673. HUNSA ZANNU FRORASI HUNSA VIVI, TAISA 4

674. KOKPE EDUWA VICTORIA KOKPE EKUDAYO, BIDO, PHILIP 5

675. JISUKUNON AFASU ZANSI JISUKUNON KOFFI GATOVI FILASI,

YAWUDU TOLUWUNI

5

676. DOSSA JOB ESTHER DOSSA JESUGO, MANUELI, ELIJAH,

SUNE

6

677. DEGBO JEJE DEMIS DEGBO FLORESI, MEDOKPO, ABELI,

GETLE CHALU

6

678. JISUKLONON KIWK JISUKUNON THEO, SHOU, YONLEJI 5

679. KPKPA MATHEW CESIKOKOPE AMOSI, ASAUL, RUTH, RONA

SERAH,

7

680. GODONU ENLU GODONU

JULILANA

ODIMI, ALIDA 4

681. GAUSE PETER GAUSE CHARTH MALANI, JOSHUA, SUNDAY,

MONDAY, FRIDAY

7

682. SUNNUVUN EMMA ZOSI SUNNUVUN CATHERLINE, PETER,

THAMAS

5

683. GHEUNDU

ASOGBA

GHEUNDU KOSIBA HANNAH, SENA, NEGITO,

SHEKO

6

684. GBE DITE SELTIN FIHONLONSI

GBEDITE

CESH, VENNATON, SELAFINE,

PACOME

6

685. GBEDITTE

SELESTINE

CHRISTAN

GBEDITE

HOSEA, SHAYELI, SUME, 5

686. AGBAN TIMOTHY ASIBA AGBAN FEBI, 3

687. AMUSU ROZAHUN AMUSU FEMI, TIFENA, MAWU, PEGO 6

688. CANKPO NAWEL CANKPON

MADLERE

MATIN, LUCIYE, PITA,

STEVEN

6

689. MAJO MATHEW MUBERT MAJO DAWENO, PHILIP 2

690. EDIYETON VAUO FOLOMENU

EDIYETON

LUCIYE, 3

691. AHWASU JOHN SEYINA AHWUSU ROSINE, PERETTI, JOHN 5

Page 61: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

692. AHWASU SAJONU SELISINU AHWASU EZEKIEL, TOBI, SEGUN, ZOYE 6

693. TANDE PASIHA FITINU FEMIDE IDOWU, DOSSA, VERONICOY,

MONDEST

6

694. MEHUNU ZINSU ELIBERT MEHUNU FLORESI, ELIJAH, SUNDAY 5

695. SOSU DANKOLE MAHUTIN

DANKOLE

TEJE, MADINA, QROBA,

DACASI, KEMI, MAHUMESI

8

696. DANKOL SOSU SOSI DANKELE CASIME, OLIVER, JOZE,

MONDAY

6

697. AGONDO NASSIS FLORESI AGONDO CLASIME, MICHEAL, OZE,

EMINU, JISIHE, PASIKA,

ODINU

9

698. AHWOZE SOSU MEDOHOME

ALWOZE

IDONASI, NOMAREKI,

DENUFE, DI BITIRI, MATA,

ALEADJI, ANOTHOY

9

699. HLOFAYE HOSIYA HLOFOYE

MESHELNU

ANUFESI, PAPE, BENIN,

ZINZE EVAIYO THEO,

MONDAY

7

700. HLOFOYE HOSY HLOEMILIRENU

HLOFOYE

DIANU, MATINE, ALESI,

TAYE, SENA, JIMEDO, SILIFE

ABEL

10

701. AMOSU SEFERE ZOME AMOSU JESUYO, TOPE, DEBE, JOHN 6

702. WEDEKUTIN

SAMEL

EJENI WEDE THOMASELENI ANUFUSI,

MATISIZI

4

703. KOKPE AHLOSU HUNSI KOKPE 2

704. KOKP AHLOSU JOSEFINU KOKPE 2

705. JISUKUNON WOEL MAGNAT

JISUKUNON

2

706. DOSSA TALA DOSSA MAHOUTIN ELELE, AYESSI, AYEJE 5

707. DOSSA JAVIEL DOSSA PATSIALIE EMMANUEL, FELIX, LUME 5

708. AJAGBE

BANTHLEMI

AJAGBE EFENSINE PAUL TACHIEGNON, BAZIL,

EMMANUEL

6

709. GBEDITE BACHIPE GBEDITE TP;A JEMESSI MAHAUME 3

710. DOSSA EKLO MALAK DOSSA

MADELENU

EMMAUEL, SINMON,

CLEMETINE

5

711. HOUNNOU

SAMUEL

HOUNNON ANDEL JAHOU, EDINON, COUES,

MATHEW

6

712. GANTON PITA GANTON LITA MUHOUTIN, ATHOU 4

713. AMOUSSOU

CELESITIN

AMOUSSOU

MELANE

SILIVIANE DIANE, JELEMI 4

714. ACHOU BENOLT ACHOU

BILONIENE

MADELENE SUVE, DEBORA,

BELI HELIMA

5

715. AMOUSSOU KOSSI AMOSSOU

JANETTE

LIGNON, KPESSO HEME 4

716. KOKPE EDMON KOKPE JANETTE JANETTE, SELATINE,

AMADINE

5

717. DOSSA

AHANTONOU

DOSSA PALAGLE MAZIETTE SILINI RICHARD 3

718. AZON GBON

AFILONOU

AZONGBON

CHOTISITINE

SITEFARI, VICTORIA, ALIETE,

EMILLEME

6

719. AMOUSSOU SONNI AMOUSSOU MEWA KELINE DABIEL, TOBBI,

ONNE

6

Page 62: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

720. HOUNNOU

ANTOINE

HOUNNOU QUME CHEYE LELOMENE,

DOKASSIMICHIEL

4

721. DOSSA

MISSEKEDO

DOSSA TAYE JEGAUN 3

722. KINDE JEAN KINDE ANWETTE HOMINTA, TOEKEE,

CELESTINE, DONACE, ONNE,

OSSA, JEEL

9

723. MEDESUKE AGINESI

MEDESUKU

ESTHER, NOWER, JANET 5

724. DOSSA DOSSA YABO YENAYO, MAHUMESI 4

725. DOSSA BIDE DOSSA MONDAY, SAMUEL 4

726. HUNDEGA RAFIFAT

HUNDEGA

KABIRU, SAYIDI, HUMARU,

SURAJU

6

727. AVESSE MAYLBAT AVESSE LUCEYE, MAGENT, ADISHAT,

BLESSINGING, FATAGI

7

728. WAWE VIYO WAWE TOLUWANI, DANIEL 4

729. GBEDOSI GBE DOSI HOSILA, MOLILI, SEDIQ,

KOYUMU

6

730. MAJO SALEFUNMAJO LEONA, MASEL, HODUN 5

731. ASHAFI ASANA ASHAFT AGELI, TOPE, SENAMI,

JERADI, FELIX

7

732. AGBADOGBE JUELI AGBADOGBE FEEMA, POLINU, FAGI

SAMUEL

6

733. AGBADOGBE JUELI AGBADOGBE JUWO, TOPE, GLORY 5

734. HUNCAN ALELL HUNCUN SLAFINU, PAUEL, JOHN,

JELEMAYA

6

735. HLOFO KISINU HLOFO SENA, JACK, JOHNSON 5

736. HLOFOYE HLOFOYE SEGUN, JAUIEL, ABELUJI,

BOSE, CLEMENT

7

737. VODA FIFANI VODA MALI, JESO, 4

738. KAPO PELINU KAKPO PHILI, MADINA

739. HUNUHLO

MISTALE

MADINA

HUNUHLO

OWOLABI, JANET, MAHUTI 5

740. KOKPE KOKPE ANTHONY, KATE, KUYEU,

MODUPE, ESTHER

7

741. AMOSU SHEYI AMOUSU ENOKU, SUNNAYO TIFENA 4

742. MAJO ANUBET MAJO MELANI, FELISI, YENU,

AUNTI SERAH

6

743. ATANDE MIRENU ATANDE FRANK, AJOMI, PAUL,

MONDAY

6

744. HUNSUA ALETI HUNUA DEFUNU, FUNMLAYO,

ROMEO, ANTHONY, JESE

7

745. AJIDA MACELINE AJIDA JOEL, SILIFE, MOSES, RONA 6

746. JEWA SERAH JEWA ESTHER, JULET, JULINU,

OBADIA

6

747. KETOGADE DEKIA KETOGADE EZEKIEL, DANIEL, RABI,

WIBE, JUJINA

7

748. HUNSU AGATI HUNSU HANDO, YIDENE, YELE LOTI 5

749. HUNYE ANUBERT HUNYE EVE, MAHUJO, 4

750. GAWOJI ELIZEBETH

GAWOJI

JOHNSON, SSALECINU,

EGUSTE ODERT FETINA

8

Page 63: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

STEUEN

751. GODONU MARE GODONU JOHNSON, FETINA

HANUBERT ETITI ALETI

7

752. TANTE ETILE TANTE JUEL OLULE AHGEW REBECA 6

753. CANDA ROLA CANDA AGATI, PAUL, LEAYO, TOBI,

JANET

7

754. YEDIYETON YEDIYETON, LUGEVA, JEWJOKE BID 4

755. SEWA JANET SEWA WESEL FRACIS, JAUEL 5

756. ASSOCLE SAUNU ASSOCLE BIDDO, LASA TOPE 4

757. KOKP EMILIYENE KOKPE JELA JULI, LEONA FEENA 4

758. KOKPE BAMADET LOLPE CHIEF MATTE YENO, ISAAC 4

759. KOKPE JAKELINE KOKPE EFIEYE BORO 3

760. HUNTON VITORIA HUNKON ANOTHY, ROSE MIKPA,

SERAH, MALI

6

761. SOSU HUNTO TUT SOSU HUTON SAUIE, JUEL, DIVE, JELE, LILI 7

762. HUNTO IDOWN ANUBERT HUNTO SEBU, FROSIS, NONA,

POLINUHUNA

6

763. WANU MAENT WONU MELIKI, SEDE, TOPE, JOSHUA, 6

764. GBE HUNMI AYSI GBEHUNMI DEFINIY REMI MACHAKI,

CHSTI, BONADI

5

765. AGBOGA ENDIYETO PSEJO PITA, MAHUTI CHEVE 4

766. OKO LUMANLAYO OKE PHILIP, KEMI, TOYI, DANIEL

ANUBERT

7

767. AZE SESI AZE IDUJESELI, CHESENE, LAZE,

MERECHE

6

768. ZOSU OPALOBA ELEMU ZOSU VICTOR, SENA, FRANCIS,

JULIANAH, WHETO, MARK,

LIN, MONDAY

10

769. ZOSU YONRONFON JACKLAIN ZOSU WASIU, SONAYON,

OWOLABI, JANIYAN,

NORICHE, WUSU, DARVE,

GBO, SINA

11

770. ISMAILA

HOUSSAIN

AWAHU-IS FARIDAT, TAHI, WARIS,

KAMILU- RAUDAT

6

TOTAL PERSONS AFFECTED 4034

Page 64: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 65: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 66: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 67: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 68: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 69: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 70: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 71: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 72: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 73: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 74: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 75: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 76: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 77: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 78: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 79: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 80: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 81: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 82: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 83: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 84: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 85: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition
Page 86: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$%$&'()'*+,-&./0,+'-&.12&1.,3'

'

!

Page 87: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$%$&'()'*+,-.$/$-012'/#32&3,/'104'35+&6'+21&7-,5/8'

'

!

Page 88: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$%$&'()'*+,-./.&0'12'3,0&+14,3'0&+56&5+,07'0/89/:,3'%,81.:$.:0;'

'

!

Page 89: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$%$&'()'*+,-./$0#,+'#.10,2'0$34$35'$3&.'67&,89'

'

!

Page 90: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$%$&'()'*+,-&./012'/3'4#$5#'#/6272'/357'2&//89'

'

!

Page 91: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$%$&'()'*+,-&./&'01,2#'&-'&#.'3-4.,5-,6/'-77$2.8'913-/:'

'

!

Page 92: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$%$&'()'*+,-&./&'01,2#'&-'&#.'3-4.,5-,6/'-77$2.8'913-/:'

'

!

Page 93: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$%$&'()'*+,-./$01'%,2301$01-4'

'

!

Page 94: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$%$&'()'*+,-./$0#,+'#.10,2'

'

!

Page 95: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$%$&'()*'+,-%%./'0,12'3/21.$4#/3'#1-4/45'

'

!

Page 96: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$%$&'())'*+,%%-.'/+01'2.10-$3#.2'#0,3.34'

'

!

Page 97: Makoko Demolition (2012) - NHRC Petition

!"#$%$&'()*'+,-.$/0-1&#23'4.513'61728/92/&',2831//2-'0#1,,$/5'%:$-;$/53'<$&#'0#.$/3.<3='

'

!


Recommended