+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming...

Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming...

Date post: 31-Mar-2021
Category:
Upload: others
View: 0 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
232
! "#$ %&'(&' )*#&&+ &, -*&'&./*0 1'( 2&+/3/*1+ )*/$'*$ "#$%&'() &%*+&+(,-. /%0() #+%#1+2 &01,'$01,03+2 &43)'(41',/ 4(5 #%1','$- '( 60,+3 74-, 8%(5%( #$%&'%( )$(*+ , -.*+/+ +01(/--*2 -' -.* 3*4$5-(*6- '7 8'&/'%'9: '7 -.* ;'62'6 8&.''% '7 <&'6'(/&+ 7'5 -.* 2*95** '7 3'&-'5 '7 =./%'+'4.:> ;'62'6> 8*4-*(1*5 ?@!?
Transcript
Page 1: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!"

"

!

!

"#$!%&'(&'!)*#&&+!&,!-*&'&./*0!1'(!2&+/3/*1+!)*/$'*$!"

"

"

"

"

"

!

!

"#$%&'()!&%*+&+(,-.!/%0()!#+%#1+2!&01,'$01,03+2!

&43)'(41',/!4(5!#%1','$-!'(!60,+3!74-,!8%(5%(!!

"

"

"

"

"

#$%&'%(")$(*+""

"

"

"

"

"

"

,"-.*+/+"+01(/--*2"-'"-.*"3*4$5-(*6-"'7"8'&/'%'9:"'7"-.*"

;'62'6" 8&.''%" '7" <&'6'(/&+" 7'5" -.*" 2*95**" '7"3'&-'5" '7"

=./%'+'4.:>";'62'6>"8*4-*(1*5"?@!?"

Page 2: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?"

"

3*&%$5$-/'6"

A"&*5-/7:"-.$-"-.*"-.*+/+"A".$B*"45*+*6-*2"7'5"*C$(/6$-/'6"7'5"-.*"#=./%D=.3"2*95**"'7"-.*"

;'62'6"8&.''%"'7"<&'6'(/&+"$62"='%/-/&$%"8&/*6&*"/+"+'%*%:"(:"'E6"E'5F"'-.*5"-.$6"E.*5*"A"

.$B*"&%*$5%:"/62/&$-*2"-.$-"/-"/+"-.*"E'5F"'7"'-.*5+"G/6"E./&."&$+*"-.*"*C-*6-"'7"$6:"E'5F"&$55/*2"

'0-"H'/6-%:"1:"(*"$62"$6:"'-.*5"4*5+'6"/+"&%*$5%:"/2*6-/7/*2"/6"/-IJ"

"

K.*"&'4:5/9.-"'7"-./+"-.*+/+"5*+-+"E/-."-.*"$0-.'5J"L0'-$-/'6"75'("/-"/+"4*5(/--*2>"45'B/2*2"-.$-"

70%%"$&F6'E%*29*(*6-"/+"($2*J""K./+"-.*+/+"($:"6'-"1*"5*45'20&*2"E/-.'0-"(:"45/'5"E5/--*6"

&'6+*6-J"

"

A"E$55$6-"-.$-"-./+"$0-.'5/+$-/'6"2'*+"6'->"-'"-.*"1*+-"'7"(:"1*%/*7>"/675/69*"-.*"5/9.-+"'7"$6:"

-./52"4$5-:J"

"

A"2*&%$5*"-.$-"(:"-.*+/+"&'6+/+-+"'7"MN>OOP"E'52+J""

"

8-$-*(*6-"'7"0+*"'7"-./52"4$5-:"7'5"*2/-'5/$%".*%4"

A"&$6"&'67/5("-.$-"(:"-.*+/+"E$+"&'4:Q*2/-*2"7'5"&'6B*6-/'6+"'7"%$690$9*>"+4*%%/69"$62"

95$(($5"1:"R'+"845:J"

"

S'6B*6-/'6+"

K.*"E5/-/69"&'6B*6-/'6+"0+*2"/6"-./+"-.*+/+"$5*"1$+*2"'6"-.*"7,9('$!4(5!:4$'41!;,05'+-"-*(4%$-*"

G?@!?IJ"""

Page 3: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

O"

"

,1+-5$&-"

K./+"-.*+/+"/+"$"%'69Q-*5("*-.6'95$4.:"45'20&*2"/6"$62"$5'062"-.5**"T0-*5"<$+-";'62'6":'0-."

&%01+J",225*++/69"-.*"&'6-*(4'5$5:"/6-*5+*&-/'6"1*-E**6"051$6"(0%-/&0%-05*>"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"

$62":'0-."4'%/-/&+>"/-"-*%%+"-.*"+-'5/*+"'7"$1'0-"$".0625*2":'069"4*'4%*"%/B/69"/6"U*E.$("

1*-E**6"?@@V"$62"?@!?J"35$E/69"'6"$"B$5/*-:"'7"*-.6'95$4./&"$62"-*C-0$%"($-*5/$%+>"-.*+*"

-.*(*+"2*B*%'4"-.5'09."7'05"+01+-$6-/B*"$5*$+"'7"&'6&*56J"K.*"7/5+-"&.$%%*69*+"WX'%2*6"<5$Y"

$&&'06-+"'7"<$+-";'62'6"1:"*69$9/69"E/-."-.*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"'7":'069"4*'4%*"$62":'0-."

E'5F*5+"/6"U*E.$(J"A-"$590*+"7'5"$"2**4*5"062*5+-$62/69"'7"-.*"W-5$&*2Y"45'&*++*+"'7"

W1*&'(/69"E./-*Y"$62"$6"$445*&/$-/'6"'7"-.*"4'-*6-/$%"'7"2/$+4'5$"(6*('6/&+J"A6"-.*"&'6-*C-"

'7"W-.*"&0-+Y"/6"401%/&"+4*62/69>"-.*"+*&'62"*C4%'5*+"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"-*55/-'5:"/6"$62"$5'062"

;*:.$("Z'0-."S%01J"[+/69"$"(0%-/Q+&$%$5"$6$%:+/+>"/-"$590*+"-.$-"-.*"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"'7":'069"

4*'4%*Y+"401%/&"+4$&*+>"-.5'09."6*'Q%/1*5$%"$62"6*'Q&'((06/-$5/$6"7'5(+"'7"9'B*56$6&*>"

6**2+"-'"1*"062*5+-''2"$%'69+/2*"-.*"(/&5'Q4'%/-/&+"'7"-*55/-'5:J"K.*"-./52"/6B*+-/9$-*+"-.*"

&%$/("-.$-":'069"4*'4%*Y+"401%/&"45'20&-/'6+"$5*"+'%2Q'0-"$62"6/./%/+-/&J"<69$9/69"E/-."$"5$69*"

'7"(0+/&>"B/2*'"$62"2$6&*"45'H*&-+>"/-"$590*+"-.$-"E./%*":'069"4*'4%*"($2*"0+*"'7"

&'((*5&/$%/+*2"$62"6/./%/+-/&"$*+-.*-/&+>"-.*/5"E'5F"E$+"+-/%%"(*$6/6970%"$62"4'%/-/&$%J"K.5'09."

$"2/+&0++/'6"'7"4*57'5($6&*>"&/-$-/'6"$62"6*E"-*&.6'%'9/*+"'7"2/$%'90*>"-.*"&.$4-*5"705-.*5"

$590*+"7'5"$"5*Q$++*++(*6-"'7"$&$2*(/&"062*5+-$62/69+"'7"&0%-05$%"+:6&5*-/+(J"K.*"7'05-."$5*$"

$225*++*+":'069"4*'4%*Y+"70-05$%"45'H*&-/'6+J"A-"*C4%'5*+".'E"W$+4/5$-/'6$%Y"70-05*+"2*4*62*2"

'6"-.*"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"'7"'-.*5"70-05*+J"K.5'09."$"2/+&0++/'6"'7"./4".'4"B/2*'+>"/-"$%+'"+.'E+"

.'E>"1*:'62"-./+"1/6$5:>":'069"4*'4%*"45'H*&-*2"$%-*56$-/B*"70-05*+J"K.*"-.*+/+"&'6&%02*+"1:"

5*+-$-/69"/-+"&'((/-(*6-"-'"*-.6'95$4.:"$+"$"(*-.'2"-.$-"&$6"$225*++"$62"*69$9*"4'%/-/&$%%:"

E/-."+'&/$%"/6H0+-/&*J"

"

"

Page 4: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

\"

"

,&F6'E%*29*(*6-+"

K./+"=.3"E'0%2"6'-".$B*"1**6"4'++/1%*"E/-.'0-"-.*"+044'5->"/6+4/5$-/'6"$62"75/*62+./4"'7"$"

60(1*5"'7"4*'4%*J"

"

A"E'0%2"4$5-/&0%$5%:"%/F*"-'"-.$6F"S%$/5*",%*C$62*5"7'5".*5"2*-$/%*2"$62"9*6*5'0+"+04*5B/+/'6>"

$62"7'5"1*/69"$"&'6+-$6-"+'05&*"'7"+044'5-"$62"B/+/'6"205/69"(:"-/(*"$-"-.*"3*4$5-(*6-"'7"

8'&/'%'9:>";'62'6"8&.''%"'7"<&'6'(/&+J"A"E'0%2"$%+'"%/F*"-'"-.$6F"S$55/*"]5/*+*"$62"=$0%"X/%5':"

7'5"-.*/5"9*6*5'0+"&'((*6-+"205/69"(:"0495$2*J"A"E'0%2"$%+'"%/F*"-'"*C45*++"$22/-/'6$%"

95$-/-02*"-'"=$0%"7'5"$%E$:+"($F/69"./(+*%7"$B$/%$1%*"-'"2/+&0++"(:"45'H*&-J"

"

TB*5"-.*"&'05+*"'7"-.*"=.3"A".$B*"1**6"7'5-06$-*"-'"E'5F"$%'69+/2*"*6*59*-/&"$62"2*2/&$-*2"

+-02*6-+"$62"$&$2*(/&+J"]5'("-.*"R$&*>"<-.6/&/-:"$62"='+-QS'%'6/$%"8-02/*+"U*-E'5F"-.$6F+"

$62"5*+4*&-"9'"'0-"-'"R/&.$52"^5$(E*%%>",H($%"_0++$/6>"_$66$.")'6*+>"#/&.$*%"`*/-.>"_*%*6"

`/(>"S.5/+-:"`0%a>"8$6H/B";/69:$.>",6+.0($6"#'62$%>")'+.0$"=$0%>"S$5'%/6$"R$(b5*a>"U$$a"

R$+./2"$62"c/&-'5/$"R*2&%/7->"$62"75'("<-.6'95$4./*+"'7"#/95$-/'6"d'5F+.'4+"-'"#$C"^'%-"$62"

<%/a$1*-."]5$6-aJ",%%"45'B/2*2"2/5*&-"/640-"$-"2/77*5*6-"+-$9*+"'7"-.*"=.3J"#:"/6B'%B*(*6-"/6"

UZ;TU".$+"$%+'"1**6"/((*6+*%:"B$%0$1%*"$62"7'5"-.$-"A"E'0%2"%/F*"-'"-.$6F",2$("`$$+$"7'5"./+"

06+-/6-/69"&''52/6$-/'6"$62"$%+'"U/&F"S'0%25:>"<:$%";$B/>"8.$6/"T59$2>"`$-.*5/6*"R'1/6+'6>"c/&"

8*/2%*5"$62"]5$6"K'6F/++"7'5"7**21$&F"'6"25$7-"&.$4-*5+J",-";8<"8'&/'%'9:>"A"E'0%2"$%+'"%/F*"-'"

-.$6F"R'1/6"^055*-->",6-'6/$"3$E*+>"S*&/%/$"3/6$52/>"K/$"<C*%1:>"3*+"]/-a9*5$%2>"]5$6&*+"

_*E+'6>"3$6"`/%1056>"=*-*5"#$66/69>"#$6$%"#$++$%.$>"U$1/%$"#06$E$5>")*++*"='--*5"$62")/%%"

K/((+"7'5"75/*62+./4>"+044'5-"$62"$2B/&*"'6"(:"E'5FJ"A"$("($++/B*%:"95$-*70%"-'"R'+"845:"7'5"

.*5"&'4:"*2/-/69"+F/%%+>"$62"-'"U$$a"R$+./2"7'5"$%%"'7"-.*"$1'B*"/6"$22/-/'6"-'"'05"%06&.-/(*"

&'6B*5+$-/'6+J"

"

#'+-"/(4'5-$6-%:>"A"E'0%2"%/F*"-'"-.$6F"-.*"5*+*$5&."4$5-/&/4$6-+"E/-.'0-"E.'("-./+"-.*+/+"

E'0%2"6'-".$B*"1**6"4'++/1%*J"d./%*"-./+"E'5F"/+"(:"'E6>"-./+"-.*+/+"/+"$%+'"$"45'20&-"'7"-.*/5"

B'/&*+"$62"9*6*5'+/-:J",62"E./%*"A"&$66'-"6$(*"-.*("7'5"$6'6:(/-:"5*$+'6+>"-.*:"F6'E"E.'"

-.*:"$5*"$62".'E"A"95$-*70%"A"$(J"]/6$%%:>"-'"U/&'%*"6'-"'6%:"7'5"1*/69"(:"1*+-"75/*62"10-"7'5"

%/+-*6/69"-'"*62%*++"5$(1%/69+"$62"5*$2/69"/660(*5$1%*"25$7-+>"-./+"-.*+/+"/+"2*2/&$-*2"-'":'0J"

Page 5: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

N"

"

"

K./+"=.3"E'0%2"6'-".$B*"1**6"4'++/1%*"E/-.'0-"-.*"7/6$6&/$%"+044'5-"'7"-.*"<&'6'(/&"$62"

8'&/$%"R*+*$5&."S'06&/%>"$62"%$--*5%:"-.*";'62'6"8&.''%"'7"<&'6'(/&+J"

S'4:5/9.-""

A"E'0%2"%/F*"-'"+/6&*5*%:"-.$6F"#0++$",12$%%$"'E6*5"'7"A&*"]/%(+"<6-*5-$/6(*6-"7'5"4*5(/++/'6"

-'"0+*"-.*"/($9*+"'6"4$9*+"!OMQ!\@>"!\\>"!\e"$62"!Me>"$62"-'"3'6"d$52>"S./*7"<C*&0-/B*"'7"

S'6+-50&-/69"<C&*%%*6&*"7'5"-.*"/($9*"'6"4$9*"!eOJ"

""

Page 6: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

e"

"

K$1%*"'7"&'6-*6-+"

3*&%$5$-/'6"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"?!8-$-*(*6-"'7"0+*"'7"-./52"4$5-:"7'5"*2/-'5/$%".*%4"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"?!S'6B*6-/'6+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"?!,1+-5$&-"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"O!,&F6'E%*29*(*6-+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"\!K$1%*"'7"&'6-*6-+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"e!K$1%*"'7"7/905*+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"V!A6-5'20&-/'6"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!@!

!J! _/+-'5:"$62"+'&/$%"+-$-/+-/&+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!O!;/B/69"'6"-.*"75/69*f"75'("($5+.%$62"-'"(/95$6-"(*-5'4'%/+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!O!3*('95$4./&+"$62"2*45/B$-/'6"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!e!

?J! ;/-*5$-05*"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"?O!#0%-/&0%-05*"$62"E./-*6*++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"?\!#$59/6$%/+$-/'6"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"?M!='%/-/&+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"?P!

OJ! S.$4-*5"'0-%/6*+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"O@!S.$4-*5"T6*"g"<-.6'95$4./&"45'20&-/'6+"'7"-.*"*B*5:2$:"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"O\!

!J! <9'(='()"*-.6'95$4./&$%%:f"75'("5*$%/+("-'"2/$%'90*"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"Oe!?J! R*+*$5&."/6h0/5/*+"$62"/6$445'45/$-*"$6+E*5+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"\!!OJ! 8/-*+"$62"(0%-/Q+/-*+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"\O!

K.*"+/-*+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"\\!#0%-/+/-*+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"\M!

\J! >%'()!*-.6'95$4.:"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"\V!NJ! <-./&+f"&'(4%/&/-:>"G2/+I&'(7'5-"$62"2/$%'90*"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"NO!S'6&%0+/'6"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"NP!

S.$4-*5"KE'"g"d./-*6*++>"%'++"$62"2/$+4'5$"(6*('6/&+f"-.*"&'%%*&-/B*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"'7"

:'069"4*'4%*"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+"/6"U*E.$("JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"e!!=$5-"T6*"g"K.*"$(1/B$%*6&*"$62"$%%05*"'7"E./-*6*++"$62"&%$++"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"e\!

K.*"X'%2*6"<5$"/6"4'40%$5"&0%-05*"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"e\!

Page 7: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

M"

"

_'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!_'E":'069"4*'4%*"5*-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"MO!

=$5-"KE'"g"3/$+4'5$"(6*('6/&+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"MP!K.*"7'59'--*6"(*('5/*+"'7"2/$+4'5$"+4$&*"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"MP!3/$+4'5$"+'%/2$5/-/*+>"%/B/69"7'5"'-.*5+"$62"4'+-Q6$-/'6$%"(6*('6/&+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"VO!

S'6&%0+/'6"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"VM!S.$4-*5"K.5**"g"K.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"-*55/-'5:"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"VP!

!J! ='%/&/69"-.*"+-5**-+"-.5'09."-.*":'0-."&%01"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"P!!?J! S5*$-/69"&'((06/-:"'E6*5+./4"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"PP!

S'6+-50&-/69"&.$'+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!@?!OJ! d/62Q04+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!@e!S'6&%0+/'6"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!!\!

S.$4-*5"]'05"g"8'%2Q'0-"$62"6/./%/+-/&i"<$+-";'62'6"./4".'4"45'20&-/'6+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!!M!?@! 8+/94&!>4($+-"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!?O!?J! Z'0K01*"B/2*'+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!?V!OJ! A'11!411!4!>+&f"6/./%/+-"$*+-.*-/&+"$62"4'%/-/&$%"6*9$-/B/-:"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!O?!S'6&%0+/'6"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!\M!

S.$4-*5"]/B*"g"_'5/a'6+f"$+4/5$-/'6$%>"($59/6$%/+*2"$62"$%-*56$-/B*"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!\P!!J! ,+4/5$-/'6$%".'5/a'6+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!N!!?J! #$59/6$%/+*2"70-05*+"$62"4'B*5-/*+"'7"$+4/5$-/'6"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!eO!OJ! K.*"6*9$-/B*"4'%/-/&+"'7"-.*"70-05*f"<'&+!'-!"#!$62"B%&+!<%C(!D1%3/"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!M!!S'6&%0+/'6"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!V?!

S'6&%0+/'6+"$62"4'%/-/&$%"*626'-*+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!V\!='%/-/&$%"*626'-*+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!P\!

#0%-/&0%-05*"9'6*"(/++/69"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!PN!K.*"/6B/+/1/%/-:"$62"5*B/B$%"'7"E./-*6*++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!Pe!#$59/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"1*/69"401%/&"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!PM!Z'0-."4'%/-/&+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"!PP!

R*7*5*6&*+"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"?@!!"

Page 8: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

V"

"

K$1%*"'7"7/905*+"

E')03+!6(+.!60,1'(+!%F!8%(5%(!G%3%0)9-!HI+C94&!9')91')9,+5J!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!K!E')03+!<C%.!8%(5%(!G%3%0)9!%F!I+C94&!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!K!E')03+!<93++.!L(5+M!%F!N01,'#1+!>+#3'*4,'%(2!I+C94&!:4(='()!OPPQ!H8GI!OP?P52!#@??J!@@@@@@@@@@!OO!E')03+!E%03.!E1'#!$943,!#3%50$+5!4,!,9+!R$3+4,'()!%C(+3-9'#S!,4T1+!503'()!,9+!E3'+(5-!%F!8+/94&!

+*+(,@!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!?P?!E')03+!E'*+.!;,'11!F3%&!RA'11!411!4!>+&S!U!#',T011!$3%--T3++5!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!?VQ!E')03+!;'M.!;,'11!!F3%&!RA'11!411!4!>+&S!U!T4(54(4!4(5!9%%5!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!?VQ!E')03+!;+*+(.!;,'11!!F3%&!RA'11!411!4!>+&S!U!"#$%&'()!N%*+&+(,!C',9!,+33',%3'41!T4(54(4-!@@@@@!?VW!E')03+!7')9,.!;,'11!!F3%&!RA'11!411!4!>+&S!U!3%45!-')(-!&43='()!,9+!,+33',%3/!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!?VW!E')03+!I'(+.!;,'11!!F3%&!RA'11!411!4!>+&S!U!F3%(,!&4(!4(5!T4$='()!)3%0#!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!?VK!E')03+<+(.!;,'11!F3%&!RA'11!411!4!>+&S!U!F3%(,!&4(!4(5!-9%%,'()!)+-,03+-!F3%&!T4$='()!)3%0#!@!?VK!E')03+!71+*+(.!;,'11!!F3%&!RA'11!411!4!>+&S!U!94(5T3+4=!,03(!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!?XP!E')03+!<C+1*+.!;,'11!F3%&!RG+9'(5!,9+!;$+(+-S!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!?XX!E')03+!<9'3,++(.!;,'11!F3%&!RA'11!411!4!>+&S!U!-03*+'114($+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!?XY!E')03+!E%03,++(.!;,'11!F3%&!RA'11!411!4!>+&S!U!-03*+'114($+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!?XY!E')03+!E'F,++(.!Z9%,%-!4(41/-+5!T/!G+-42!7*4!4(5![1&4!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!?\\!E')03+!;'M,++(.!Z9%,%-!4(41/-+5!T/!G+-42!7*4!4(5![1&4!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!?\Y!E')03+!;+*+(,++(.!Z9%,%!4(41/-+5!T/!]+,%(!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!?YP!E')03+!7')9,++(.![3,'-,S-!'&4)+!%F!,9+!F'('-9+5!^+-,F'+15!;9%##'()!_+(,3+2!;,34,F%35!OPPK! !""#"$%

&##'()"'%*#+%,-./*-,0!E')03+!I'(+,++(.![3,'-,S-!'&4)+!%F!,9+!$%&#1+,+5!61/&#'$!5+*+1%#&+(,2!C',9!;,34,F%35!*'-'T1+!'(!

,9+!,%#!1+F,!%F!,9+!#'$,03+!H_%(-,30$,'()!7M$+11+($+!OP?PJ!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!?YV!E')03+!<C+(,/.!;,'11!F3%&!R<'&+!'-!"#S!H"#$%&'()!N%*+&+(,!OP??TJ!U!_4(43/!^943F!4(5!

N'11+(('0&!>%&+!4,!(')9,!F3%&!I+C94&!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!?QY!

Page 9: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

P"

"

"

"

E')03+!6(+.!60,1'(+!%F!8%(5%(!G%3%0)9-!HI+C94&!9')91')9,+5J!

!

"E')03+!<C%.!8%(5%(!G%3%0)9!%F!I+C94&!

Page 10: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!@"

"

A6-5'20&-/'6"

S:&%/69"'B*5"-.*"R/B*5";*$"A"%*7-"1*./62"S$6$5:"d.$57Y+"('60(*6-+"-'"&$4/-$%/+-"E*$%-."$62"

*6-*5*2"$"5*+/2*6-/$%"%$62+&$4*"'6&*"5*4%*-*"E/-."/-+"'E6"+:(1'%+"'7"/620+-5/$%"9%'1$%"4'E*5J"

]'5"'B*5"$".0625*2":*$5+>"-./+"&5'++/69"1*-E**6"K'E*5"_$(%*-+"$62"U*E.$(>"/6"/-+"B$5/'0+"

7'5(+"G^%'&."!PPVI>".$2"+*4$5$-*2"-.*"/66*5"&/-:"75'("-.*"75/69*J"KE/&*"$"E**F>"7'5"-E'":*$5+"A"

($2*"-./+"H'056*:J"K'"-.*"/((*2/$-*"6'5-."E*5*"E$5*.'0+*+"$62"&./(6*:+-$&F+"G-.*"

5*(6$6-+"'7"-.*"/620+-5/$%"3'&F+/2*I"$62"-.*"+-$5-"'7"-.*"T%:(4/&"2*B*%'4(*6-j"-'"-.*"+'0-.>"

-.*"2'&F%$62"<C&*%"&*6-5*"$62"-.*"5*&%$/(*2"($5+.%$62"'7"^*&F-'6j"E./%*"-.*"*$+-"E$+"

2'(/6$-*2"1:"5*+/2*6-/$%"45'4*5-/*+"+($--*5*2"E/-."./9.Q5/+*"1%'&F+J",-"-./+"/6-*5+*&-/'6"$"

&'(4%*C"(0%-/&0%-05*".$+"95'E6"04"-.5'09."!N@":*$5+"'7"&'6+-$6-"4'40%$-/'6>"&0%-05$%"$62"

/675$+-50&-05$%"&.$69*J"K./+"-.*+/+"/+"$"+-'5:"'7"-.*".0625*2"'5"+'":'069"4*'4%*"E.'"%/B*2"$-"

-./+"&5'++/69Q4'/6-"1*-E**6"?@@M"$62"?@!?>"$62"E.'("A"9'-"-'"F6'E"E./%*"E'5F/69"$-"-.5**"

U*E.$(":'0-."&%01+J"

"

U*E.$("'&&04/*+"$"4$5-/&0%$5"4%$&*"/6"4'40%$5"$62"$&$2*(/&"/($9/6$5/*+J"K.5'09."-.*"2'&F+"

$62"-.*"^%/-a>"/-"/+"'7-*6"$++'&/$-*2"$+"-.*".'(*"'7"-.*"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++j"$+"$"7'6-"'7"^5/-/+."

4%0&F>"%0&F"$62"&'05$9*"GX/%5':"?@@\IJ"T6"-.*"1$+/+"'7"/-+"+04*5Q2/B*5+*"2*('95$4./&+"

Gc*5-'B*&"?@@eI"/-"/+"$%+'"+'(*-/(*+"&*%*15$-*2"$+"$6"*C$(4%*"'7"4'+-Q5$&/$%"&'6B/B/$%/-:J"K.*"

:'0-.70%6*++"'7"/-+"4'40%$-/'6"G;^U"?@@e1>"4JOj";^U"?@!@$I"$62"-.*"%'69Q-*5("2*45/B$-/'6"

*C4*5/*6&*2"/6"-.*"$5*$"G;^U"?@!@1>"4J\Nj"U'1%*"*-"$%J"?@@V>"4JVeI"$5*"$"6*B*5Q*62/69"+'05&*"'7"

$--5$&-/'6"7'5"+-5*$(+"'7"5*+*$5&.*5+"7$6-$+/+/69"$1'0-"-.*"/6*B/-$1/%/-:>"'5"+0545/+/69"%$&F>"'7"

051$6"&'67%/&-J"_'E*B*5>"2*+4/-*"-./+>"B*5:"%/--%*"*-.6'95$4./&"E'5F".$+"1**6"401%/+.*2"'6"-.*"

%/B*+"'7":'069"4*'4%*"%/B/69"-.*5*J""

"

#:"'5/9/6$%"&'6-$&-"E/-."U*E.$("&$(*"$+"4$5-"'7"-./+"+-5*$("'7"7*-/+./+-/&"*6h0/5:J"d'5F/69"

7'5"$"h0$69'>!"A"B/+/-*2"U*E.$("$+"4$5-"'7"$"6$-/'6$%"45'95$((*"*B$%0$-/'6J"TB*5"-E'"E**F+"A"

$-*"/6-'"-.*"-/(*"$62"*6*59:"'7"%'&$%":'0-."E'5F"45'7*++/'6$%+"1*7'5*"7/6$%%:"45'20&/69"$"

5*4'5-J"K.*"5*4'5-"E$+"+.$5*2"E/-."-.*"5*%*B$6-"&*6-5$%"9'B*56(*6-"2*4$5-(*6->"$62"$7-*5"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!"L0$69'+"Gh0$+/Q$0-'6'('0+>"6'6Q9'B*56(*6-$%"'59$6/+$-/'6+I"$5*"6'E"F6'E6"$+"U3=^+"G6'6Q

2*4$5-(*6-$%"401%/&"1'2/*+IJ"

Page 11: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!!"

"

/67%0*6&/69"4'%/&:"($F*5+"1:"-*%%/69"-.*("E.$-"-.*:"E$6-*2"-'".*$5>"A"%*7-"-.*"H'1"750+-5$-*2J",-"

-./+"7/5+-"$--*(4->"A".$26Y-"5*$%%:".*$52"E.$-"%/7*"/6"U*E.$("(*$6-"7'5"-.*"4*'4%*"%/B/69"-.*5*J"

8'>".$B/69"+*&05*2"<8RS"7062/69"7'5"(:"=.3>"A"2*&/2*2"-'"5*-056>"7'5"$"+*&'62"%/+-*6J"

"

,55/B/69"1$&F"/6"?@@M>"/-"E$+"-.*"*62"'7"-.*"U*E";$1'05"*5$"$62"-.*"1*9/66/69"'7"-.*"W&0-+Y"/6"

%'&$%"$62"6$-/'6$%"*C4*62/-05*J"8$62E/&.*2"1*-E**6"-.*"80((*5"'7"`6/7*"S5/(*"?@@V>"E./&."

5$6"/6-'"-.*"?@!@"X*6*5$%"<%*&-/'6"&$(4$/96"G^^S"?@@V$j"^^S"?@@V1j"d$--"?@!@I>?"$62"-.*"

R/'-+"/6"?@!!>"/-"1*&$(*"-.*"-/(*"E.*6"-.*"+&'059*"'7"051$6":'0-."7*$-05*2"45'(/6*6-%:"/6"

-.*"6*E+J"K./+"7/*%2E'5F"4*5/'2"E$+"$%+'"&'%'05*2"7'5"(*"$62"'-.*5+"1:"-.*"Kc"+.'E"^5/-$/6Y+"

X'-"K$%*6-"$62"-.*"+0&&*++"'7"-.*"+-5**-2$6&*"95'04+"3/B*5+/-:"$62"]%$E%*++J"S.5/+"^5'E6Y+"

+*%7Q-/-%*2"2*10-"$%10("G?@@N$I".$2"9'6*"2'01%*"4%$-/60("$62"95/(*"$5-/+-"X/99+"E$+"$1'0-"-'"

5*%*$+*"./+"062*595'062"./-"<41='()!,9+!B435+-,"G?@@PIJ",%'69+/2*"&0-1$&F+"$62"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6>"

-.*+*"('(*6-+"-''"4%$:*2"-.5'09.":'069"4*'4%*Y+"%/B*+J"K.5'09."$++'&/$-*2"+-:%*+>"2$6&*+"

$62"(0+/&"-.*:"6$B/9$-*2"-.*/5"%/B*+>"&'((06/&$-*2"401%/&%:"$62"10/%-"4'%/-/&$%"&5/-/h0*+"'7"

-.*/5"($59/6$%/+$-/'6J"

"

_'E*B*5>"('(*6-+"'7"%*++"E/2*+45*$2"$&&%$/("$%+'"5*+'6$-*2"-.5'09."U*E.$(J"A6"?@!@>"

[4&'(/69"#'B*(*6->"$"+($%%"./4".'4D95/(*"95'04"75'(";*:.$(>O"U*E.$(>"5*%*$+*2"$"B/2*'"

7'5"$"-5$&F"&$%%*2"A'11!411!4!>+&J"A-+"6/./%/+-/&"45'&%$($-/'6+"F6/--*2"-'9*-.*5"-.*"9$69+-*5"+-:%*"

'7"X/99+"E/-."-.*"80((*5"'7"`6/7*"S5/(*"$62"-.*"?@!!"R/'-+J"_'E*B*5>"E./%*"/-"+**(*2"-'"

&'67/5("-.*"$4'%/-/&$%"$62"$6-/Q+'&/$%"6$-05*"'7":'0-."&0%-05*>"/-"&'67'062*2"-.*+*"&%$/(+"1:"

25$E/69"$--*6-/'6"-'"($6:"&'6-5$2/&-/'6+"'7"051$6"%/B/69J"A-+"45'('-/'6"'7"-*55/-'5/$%"E$57$5*"

E$+"10/%-"'6"$6"*-./&+"'7"+.$5/69J"A-+"&'((06/&$-/'6"'7"1%$&F"6/./%/+("E$+"($2*"-.5'09."E./-*"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""?"K.*"(*2/$"'0-40-"7'5"-.*"80((*5"'7"`6/7*"S5/(*"('5$%"4$6/&"E$+f"$"S.$66*%"\"2/+4$-&.*+"

2'&0(*6-$5:"Wd.:"`/2+"`/%%Y"GS.$66*%"\"?@@V1I>"B/5$%"$2+"'6"^*1'"G^*1'"?@@P1I>"$"N>@@@>@@@"4'062"

/6&5*(*6-"-'"-.*"K$&F%/69"X$69+",&-/'6"45'95$((*"-'"-$&F%*"F6/7*"$62"906"&5/(*>"-.*"8-5**-"d*$4'6+"

S'((/++/'6".*$2*2"1:"S.*5/*"^''-."%/6F*2"-'"$"+*&'62"./9.Q/(4$&-"S.$66*%"\"2'&0(*6-$5:"&$%%*2"

W3/+$5(/69"^5/-$/6Y"GS.$66*%"\"?@@V$I>"$6'-.*5"^*1'"%$06&."$62"&'(40-*5"9$(*"G^*1'"?@@P$I>"-.*"U*E+"

'7"-.*"d'5%2Y+"W8$B*"'05"8-5**-+Y"R'$2"8.'E"$62"60(*5'0+"$--*(4-+"1:"X'52'6"^5'E6"G-.*6"=5/(*"

#/6/+-*5I"$62"3$B/2"S$(*5'6"G-.*6";*$2*5"'7"-.*"S'6+*5B$-/B*"=$5-:"$62"T77/&/$%"T44'+/-/'6I"-'"'0-2'"

*$&."'-.*5"'6"E.'"E$+"9'/69"-'"1*"-'09.*5"'6"F6/7*"&5/(*"G^^S"?@@V$j"#$/%"'6"8062$:"?@@VIJ"O"K.*"6$(*+"'7"4%$&*+"$62"4*'4%*".$B*"1**6"&.$69*2"G+**"S.$4-*5"T6*IJ"

Page 12: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!?"

"

1'2/*+J"A-+"+044'+*2%:"$4'%/-/&$%"&.$5$&-*5"E$+"$-"'22+"E/-."/-+"5*7%*C/B*"&'6+&/'0+6*++"$62"/-+"

4'%/-/&$%"&.$%%*69*"-'"+'&/$%"/6H0+-/&*J"

"

A6"($6:"E$:+>"[4&'(/69"#'B*(*6-"$62"A'11!411!4!>+&"1*&$(*"(*-$4.'5+"7'5"-./+"-.*+/+>"

45'B/69"-.*"6*&*++/-:"7'5"$"+*&'62"%/+-*6/69J"K./+"-.*+/+>"-.*6>"/+"-.*"+-'5:"'7"-./+"+*&'62"

%/+-*6/69J"^$+*2"'6!$"-E'Q:*$5"*-.6'95$4.:"'7"-.5**"T0-*5"<$+-";'62'6":'0-."&%01+>"/-"-*%%+"-.*"

+-'5:"'7"-.*"%/B*+"'7"$1'0-"$".0625*2":'069"4*'4%*J"A-"064/&F+".'E"U*E.$(Y+"E'5F/69Q&%$++"

4$+-"+.$4*2"-.*/5"2$:Q-'Q2$:"*C/+-*6&*J"A-"/6B*+-/9$-*+".'E"-.*"6*E"%$62+&$4*+"'7"d*+-7/*%2"

8.'44/69"S*6-5*"$62"8-5$-7'52"K'E6"+$-"E/-./6"-.*/5".'5/a'6+J"A-"$225*++*+".'E"-.*:"E*5*"

&5/(/6$%/+*2>"$62".'E"-.*:"6$B/9$-*2>"5*+/+-*2"$62"+01B*5-*2"-.*+*"7'5(+"'7"401%/&"

($59/6$%/+$-/'6J"A-"*C4%'5*+":'069"4*'4%*Y+"4'%/-/&+"-.5'09."-.*/5"5*7%*C/B*"*B$%0$-/'6+"$62"

B/+/'6+"1*:'62"/6H0+-/&*+J"A-"$%+'"&'6+/2*5+".'E":'069"4*'4%*"($2*"50%*+>"75/*62+"$62"

6*9'-/$-*2"4'+-&'2*"1'062$5/*+"$62"6$55$-/B*+"'7"E./-*"$62"$0-'&.-.'6'0+"1*%'69/69J"^0-"

E./%*"/-"*C4%'5*+"-.*"$6-$9'6/+-/&"$62"&'6B/B/$%"&.$5$&-*5"'7"%'&$%"/6-*5$&-/'6+"/-"2'*+"+'"E/-."

&'6+/2*5$-/'6"7'5"$"(0%-/&0%-05*"-.$-".$+"+.$4*2"/-+*%7"$&5'++"!N@":*$5+"'7"(/95$-/'6"$62"

('B*(*6-J"A6"-./+"E$:>"/-"$&F6'E%*29*+"-.*"45*+*6&*"'7"+0545/+/69"$62"&'06-*5/6-0/-/B*"

&'+('4'%/-$6/+(+>"$62"2/$+4'5/&"7'5(+"'7"+.$5/69"$62"&'%%$1'5$-/'6"-.$-".$B*"7%'05/+.*2"/6"

+4/-*"'7"*C&%0+/B*"4$5-/&0%$5/-/*+J"K./+"-.*+/+>"-.*6>"/+"$"+-'5:"$1'0-":'069"4*'4%*>"(0%-/&0%-05*>"

($59/6$%/-:"$62"4'%/-/&+"/6"T0-*5"<$+-";'62'6J"

"

K'"/6-5'20&*"-.*+*"-.*(*+"-./+"/6-5'20&-'5:"&.$4-*5"2*B*%'4+"/6"-.5**"4$5-+J"K.*"7/5+-"4$5-"

45'B/2*+"&'6-*C-0$%"/67'5($-/'6"'6"-.*"./+-'5:"'7"-.*"1'5'09.>"$62"/-+"+'&/$%"$62"*&'6'(/&"

+-$-/+-/&+J"K.*+*"$5*"*++*6-/$%"7'5"062*5+-$62/69"-.*"%'&$-/'6"$-"E./&."-./+"*-.6'95$4.:"E$+"

45'20&*2J"K.*"+*&'62"4$5-"+/-0$-*+"-.*"-.*+/+"E/-./6"$"5$69*"'7"$&$2*(/&"2*1$-*+"'6"

(0%-/&0%-05*>"E./-*6*++>"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"4'%/-/&+J"d/-."5*+4*&-"-'"*$&."'7"-.*+*"$5*$+>"/-"

$225*++*+".'E"-.*"-.*+/+"*69$9*+"E/-."$62"$2B$6&*+"&055*6-"062*5+-$62/69+"'7":'069"4*'4%*"

/6"051$6"^5/-$/6J"K.*"-./52"4$5-"45*+*6-+"-.*"&.$4-*5"'0-%/6*+>"45'B/2/69"$6"/6-5'20&-/'6"-'"-.*"

($/6"$590(*6-+"&'6-$/6*2"/6"*$&."*%*(*6-"'7"-.*"-.*+/+J"

Page 13: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!O"

"

!J _/+-'5:"$62"+'&/$%"+-$-/+-/&+"

;/B/69"'6"-.*"75/69*f"75'("($5+.%$62"-'"(/95$6-"(*-5'4'%/+"

K./+"-.*+/+"/+"+*-"/6"$"4$5-/&0%$5"9*'95$4./&>"2*('95$4./&"$62"./+-'5/&$%"&'6-*C-J"3*+&5/1*2"$+"

-.*"W'0-*5"/66*5"&/-:Y"G#/%%/69-'6"?@!!I"1:"+'(*"$62"-.*"W75/69*Y"1:"'-.*5+"G3/&F*6+"!VNMI>"

$0-.'5+"!N@":*$5+"$4$5-".$B*"E5/--*6"'6"-.*"5*%$-/'6"1*-E**6"U*E.$(Y+"+'&/$%"%/7*"$62"/-+"

%'&$-/'6"G3/&F*6+"!VNMj"_$%%"?@@MI"G+**"]/905*+"T6*"$62"KE'IJ"

"

=5/'5"-'"!V\@>"(0&."'7"-.*"+'0-."$62"E*+-"'7"U*E.$(>"/6"E./&."('+-"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"A"

9'-"-'"F6'E"E*5*"%/B/69>"E$+"064'40%$-*2"($5+.%$62"G='E*%%"!PMOIJ"]5'("-.*"(/2Q6/6*-**6-."

&*6-05:"'6E$52+>"9''2"5/B*5"$62"5$/%"-5$6+4'5-"G;^U"?@@OI"$62"U*E.$(Y+"4'+/-/'6"'6"-.*"

75/69*"'7"-.*"#*-5'4'%/-$6"^0/%2/69",&-"$62"-.*";'62'6"S'06-:"S'06&/%"G_$%%"?@@M"4JVOI"

15'09.-"6'C/'0+"/620+-5:>".'0+/69"$62"(/95$-/'6"-'"-.*"$5*$J"A620+-5:"$62"&.*$4".'0+/69"

$--5$&-*2"$"6*E"4'40%$-/'6>"$62"75'("-.*6"'6E$52+"4*'4%*"&$(*"-'"-.*"1'5'09."75'("$%%"'B*5"

-./+"&'06-5:>"/62**2"-.*"E'5%2>"$+"-.*:"+-/%%"2'"-'2$:J\"=$5/+."5*&'52+"+.'E"-.*"25$($-/&"

/6&5*$+*"/6"-.*"4'40%$-/'6"'7"-.*"$5*$J"A6"!VN!"-.*"%'&$%"4$5/+."&'6-$/6*2"!V>VM@"4*'4%*J"^:"

!VV!"/-".$2"5*$&.*2"!?V>PNO"$62"1:"!P!?"/-"E$+"4'40%$-*2"1:"O@@>Ve@"4*'4%*J"K./+"%*B*%"E'0%2"

1*"+0+-$/6*2"06-/%"-.*"!PO@+"Gc/+/'6"'7"^5/-$/6"U'"2$-*IJ"^:"-.*"+*&'62"2*&$2*"'7"-.*"-E*6-/*-."

&*6-05:"-.*5*"E*5*"OON"($607$&-05/69>"*69/6**5/69"$62"&'6+-50&-/'6"7/5(+"&'66*&-/69"-.*"

R/B*5";*$"-'"-.*";'62'6"2'&F+"G='E*%%"!PMOIJ"K.*"2'&F+"-.*(+*%B*+>"('60(*6-+"-'"c/&-'5/$6"

/(4*5/$%/+("$62"&'%'6/$%"-5$2*"G_$%%"?@@\I>"*(4%':*2"-.'0+$62+"'7"4*'4%*J"U*E.$("E$+"'6*"

'7"-.*"/620+-5/$%"&*6-5*+"'7"-.*"<(4/5*J"K.5'09."/-+"+09$5"5*7/6*5/*+>"95'06260-"-5$2*"$62"=kT"

+./44/69"%/6*+"G^%'&."!PPNI"/-"E$+"$"6*C0+"/6"-.*"&'%'6/$%"E*1"E./&."&'66*&-*2"-.*"S$5/11*$6>"

d*+-",75/&$>",0+-5$%/$>"A62/$"$62"-.*"#/22%*"<$+-"-'"-.*"W#'-.*5";$62YJ"

"

K.5'09."-.*+*"-5$2*+"$62"'-.*5+>"6$-/'6$%"$62"/6-*56$-/'6$%"(/95$6-"E'5F*5+"&$(*>"+-$:*2"$62"

E*6-"$E$:>"45'B/2/69"&.*$4"%$1'05>"$+"-.*:"2'"-'2$:>"7'5"9%'1$%>"/(4*5/$%"&$4/-$%/+(J"A6"!P!!>"

\@"4*5"&*6-"'7"-.*"4'40%$-/'6"'7"-.*"'5/9/6$%"4$5/+."G.$%7"-.*"+/a*"'7"-'2$:Y+"1'5'09.I".$2"&'(*"

75'("'0-+/2*"-.*"$5*$"G_#8T"!P!!IJ"d./%*"('+-"E*5*"75'("505$%"&'06-/*+"-'"-.*"*$+-"$62"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""\"U*E.$("/+"+-/%%"&.$5$&-*5/+*2"1:"&.*$4".'0+/69J"A6"-.*"7/5+-"h0$5-*5"'7"?@!@"-.*"(*2/$6"&'+-"7'5"

.'0+/69"/6"U*E.$("E$+"?!P>@@@"4'062+"6*$5%:"e@>@@@"4'062+"&.*$4*5"-.$6"-.*"(*2/$6"7'5";'62'6J"

K./+"F/62"'7"2/77*5*6&*".$+"1**6"($/6-$/6*2"'B*5"-.*"%$+-"-./5-**6":*$5+"GS;X"$62";$62"R*9/+-5:"?@!@IJ"

Page 14: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!\"

"

+'0-.Q*$+-"G&'6+/2*5$1%*"H'056*:+"7'5"-.*/5"-/(*I>"-.*5*".$2"$%+'"1**6"%$59*"/67%0C*+"'7"8&'-+"

$62"A5/+.>"$62"+($%%*5"-.'09."+/96/7/&$6-"/67%0C*+"'7"W7'5*/96*5+Y"g"$"-*5("0+*2"/6"-.*"&*6+0+"-'"

2*+&5/1*"$"E/2*5"4'40%$-/'6"'7"6'6Q^5/-/+."(/95$6-+J"A6"!P!!>"!"4*5"&*6-"'7"-.*"1'5'09."E$+"

($2*"04"'7"W7'5*/96*5+Y"G_#8T"!P!!IJ"A((/95$6-"E'5F*5+"E*5*"*(4%':*2"/6"%'&$%"/620+-5/*+"

$62"%/B*2"/6"%'&$%".'0+/69J"lA6"!P@!"-.*"&'(4$6:"'7"#''5*"$62"U*--%*7'%2+"m"$%'6*"*(4%':*2"

!N@"/((/95$6-"E'5F*5+"m"^:"-.*"!P?@+"('+-"'7"-.*"+.'4+"'6"-.*"^$5F/69"R'$2"E*5*"'E6*2"1:"

<05'4*$6+n"G;^U"I"$62"S5'E6"8-5**-".$2"1**6"6/&F6$(*2"W35$09.-1'$52",%%*:Y"1*&$0+*"'7"-.*"

(/C"'7"1%$&F"$62"E./-*"4*'4%*"%/B/69"-.*5*"G^%'&."!PPV>"4J!OIJ"

"

^:"!PO!>"e?"4*5"&*6-"'7"-.*"4'40%$-/'6"'7"-.*"1'5'09.".$2"1**6"1'56"-.*5*>"O\"4*5"&*6-"E*5*"

<69%/+."10-"1'56"'0-+/2*"-.*"1'5'09.>"$62"-.*"5*($/6/69"\"4*5"&*6-"/6&%02*2"??@M"8&'-+>"!O?M"

75'("-.*"A5/+."]5**"8-$-*>"\N@"A62/$6+>"OPM"85/";$6F$6+>"!MPO"<05'4*$6+"G/6&%02/69"\\M"='%/+."

$62"?V?"R0++/$6+I>"!eV"S$6$2/$6+>"!@V"S$5/11*$6+>"?@@",0+-5$%/$6+>"!e\",(*5/&$6+"$62"!OM"

,59*6-/6/$6+"G_#8T"!PO!IJ"T7"-.*"?V?"R0++/$6+>"($6:"E*5*")*E+"7%**/69"4*5+*&0-/'6"G^%'&."

?@@?>"4J!OIJ"K.5**")*E/+."&*(*-*5/*+"E*5*"10/%-"/6"U*E.$("1*-E**6"!VNM"$62"!P!P"7'5"-.*"

%$59*")*E/+."4'40%$-/'6"-'"-.*"E*+-"'7"-.*"1'5'09.>"/6"d./-*&.$4*%"$62"84/-$%7/*%2+J"^:"-./+"

4'/6->";*:.$("$%+'".'+-*2"-.*"%$59*+-"1%$&F"&'((06/-:"/6";'62'6"G^%'&."!PPN>"4J\@j"^%'&."

?@@?>"4J!OIJ"

"

]5'("($5+.%$62"-'"/620+-5/$%"$62"&'%'6/$%".01>"d'5%2"d$5"KE'"15'09.-"705-.*5"504-05*"-'"-.*"

1'5'09."$62"-.*"4'40%$&*J",+"$"5*+0%-"'7"/-+"&*6-5$%"/(4'5-$6&*"-'"/620+-5:"$62"-5$2*>"U*E.$("

+077*5*2".*$B:"1'(1/69"G,+-'6"#$6+7/*%2"U'"2$-*>"4J!!IJ"#$6:"'7"-.*"7'5*/96"+*$(*6"E.'"

.$2"1*&'(*"4$5-"'7"-.*"%/7*"'7"-.*"$5*$"E*5*"*B$&0$-*2"$62"2/26Y-"5*-056"G^%'&."?@@?>"4J!\IJ","

h0$5-*5"'7"-.*".'0+*+"G'B*5"!\>@@@I"E*5*"2*+-5':*2"$62"-.5'09."$*5/$%"1'(1$52(*6-"-.*"

%$62+&$4*"E$+"5*('2*%%*2J"^'(1"&5$-*5+"G_'11+"?@@e>"4J!?!I"$62"-*(4'5$5:"U/++*6"_0-"

+.*%-*5+>N"-.$-"1*&$(*"4*5($6*6-".'(*+>"E*5*"7*$-05*+"'7"*B*5:2$:"%/7*"G^%'&."!PPVj"_$55/+"

$62"^%'&."!PPNIJ",7-*5"-.*"E$5"-.*"%$62+&$4*"062*5E*6-"$6'-.*5"-5$6+7'5($-/'6>"$62"V>@@@"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""N"K.*"U/++*6"_0-"E$+"9*6*5$%%:"($2*"'7"&'5509$-*2"/5'6"E/-."$"(*-$%"75$(*>"$"E''2*6"2''5"$62"'/%*2Q

&%'-."E/2'E+"/6+-*$2"'7"9%$++J"A-"E$+"*$+:"-'"-5$6+4'5-"$62"h0/&F"-'"40-"04J"A6B*6-*2"$62"10/%-"$+".'0+/69"

7'5"-.*"-5''4+"/6"d'5%2"d$5"T6*>"/-+"+*(/&/5&0%$5"&'5509$-*2Q/5'6"+.$4*"2*7%*&-*2"+.5$46*%"$62"1'(1"

1%$+-+>"($F/69"/-"$"4*57*&-"E$5-/(*"+.*%-*5"GU/++*6"?@!?IJ"

Page 15: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!N"

"

6*E"4*5($6*6-"2E*%%/69+"E*5*"10/%-"G='E*%%"!PMOJ"4J"\PIe"-'"5*4%$&*"-.*".'0+/69"+-'&F"%'+-"

-.5'09."$*5/$%"$--$&F"$62"-.*"&'6-/60*2"&%*$5$6&*"'7"-.*"W+%0(+YJ"K.*"+%0(+"E*5*"-.*"W4''5"

h0$%/-:Y".'0+*+"'7"-.*"6/6*-**6-."$62"*$5%:"-E*6-/*-."&*6-05/*+"10/%-"7'5"(/95$6-"%$1'05*5+J"K'"

5*4%$&*"-.*"+%0(+>"%$59*"*+-$-*+"E*5*"10/%-"7/5+-"/6"-.*"%'EQ2*6+/-:"W9$52*6"&/-:"4$--*56Y"1*7'5*"

-.*"/6-5'20&-/'6"'7"./9.Q2*6+/-:"1%'&F+"G='E*%%"!PMOJ"4JNeIJ"

"

]05-.*5"&.$69*"&$(*"$1'0-"-.5'09."-.*"2*&%/6*"'7"/620+-5:"$62"5*+0%-/69"06*(4%':(*6-J"

^*-E**6"-.*"*62"'7"d'5%2"d$5"KE'"$62"-.*"*$5%:"!Pe@+"g"-.*"4*5/'2"2011*2"-.*"WX'%2*6"<5$Y"

G3*6&."*-"$%J"?@@e>"4J!VI"g"-.*5*"E$+"6*$5%:"70%%"*(4%':(*6-J"A6"-.*"7'%%'E/69"7'5-:":*$5+>"

/620+-5/$%"*(4%':(*6-"&'6-5$&-*2"1:"-E'Q-./52+"G_$%%"?@@M>"4JVNIJ"^*-E**6"!PeM"$62"!PM\"

*(4%':(*6-"$-"-.*"R':$%"3'&F+"2*&%/6*2"75'("M>!V@"-'"\>@eV"4'+/-/'6+"G_/%%"!PMe>"4J?I"g"-.*"

*h0/B$%*6-"'7"?@"4*5"&*6-"'7"$%%"H'1+"/6"-.*"$5*$J"K.*"&$0+*"E$+"(*&.$6/+$-/'6>"

&'6-$/6*5/+$-/'6>"&.$69/69"-5$6+/-"45$&-/&*+"$62"-.*"10/%2/69"'7"-.*"2**4Q+*$"4'5-"$-"K/%105:"

G_/%%"!PMe>"4JOgNj"_'11+"?@@e>"4J!??j";^U"!PMe>"4J!PIJ"]5'("!Pee"-'"!PMe"-.*5*"E*5*"?\>@@@"

H'1"%'++*+"/6"U*E.$(J"A6"!PMe>"($%*"06*(4%':(*6-"+-''2"$-"!!"4*5"&*6-"$62"e>@@@"4*'4%*"

E*5*"&.$+/69"O@@"B$&$6&/*+"GS$66/69"K'E6"S'((06/-:"3*B*%'4(*6-"=5'H*&-"!PMeIJ"

<(4%':(*6-"/6"-.*"1'5'09.".$+"6*B*5"5*&'B*5*2J"_/9."%*B*%+"'7"06*(4%':(*6-"&'6-/60*2"

-.5'09."-.*"!PV@+"$62"!PP@+"E.*6"-.*"%'&$%"$0-.'5/-:"1*&$(*"-.*"%$59*+-"*(4%':*5"G_$%%"

?@@M>"4JVNIJ"K.*"051$6"7$15/&"'7"-.*"1'5'09."$%+'"&'6-/60*2"-'"1*"5*('2*%%*2J"#$6:"'7"-.*"

./9."5/+*"7%$-+"10/%-"$7-*5"-.*"8*&'62"d'5%2"d$5"E*5*"F6'&F*2"2'E6"$62"5*4%$&*2"GS$66/69"

K'E6"S'((06/-:"3*B*%'4(*6-"=5'H*&-"!PMe>"4JPIJ"U*E"$5*$+"'7"($5+.%$62"E*5*"5*&%$/(*2"

7'5"^*&F-'6Y+"M>N@@"6*E".'(*+"G;^U"!PV@I"$62"-.*"4'+-Q/620+-5/$%"2'&F+/2*".*5/-$9*"

&'6B*5-*2"7'5"45/B$-*"0+*J"K./+"5*&*6-"4.$+*"g"&'66*&-/69"-.*"45/B$-*"45'4*5-:"'7"-.*"<C&*%"

S*6-5*"-'"-.*"8-5$-7'52"<05'+-$5"-*5(/6$%>"d*+-7/*%2"8.'44/69"S*6-5*"$62"-.*"T%:(4/&"+/-*"g"

.$+"1**6"&$%%*2"-.*"W,5&"'7"T44'5-06/-:Y"G;^U"?@!@1>"4J!eg!MI"G+**"S.$4-*5"]/B*"'7"-./+"-.*+/+IJ"

K.*"%/B*+"'7":'069"4*'4%*"/6"U*E.$("-'2$:"6**2"-'"1*"062*5+-''2"/6"-./+"&'6-*C-"'7"

2*('95$4./&"&.$69*>"4'40%$-/'6"('B*(*6-"$62"051$6"5*('2*%%/69J""

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""e"8%0("&%*$5$6&*+"+-$5-*2"/6"-.*"!P?@+"$62"!PO@+"1*7'5*"1*/69"/6-*5504-*2"1:"-.*"8*&'62"d'5%2"d$5"

G='E*%%"!PMO>"4JN>"\PIJ"

Page 16: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!e"

"

3*('95$4./&+"$62"2*45/B$-/'6"

S'6-*(4'5$5:"+-$-/+-/&+"'6"2*('95$4.:"$62"2*45/B$-/'6"45'B/2*"705-.*5"/6+/9.-"/6-'"-./+"75/69*"

&'62/-/'6J"_'E*B*5>"-.*+*"+-$-/+-/&+"6**2"-'"1*"-5*$-*2"E/-."&$5*"$+"-.*"4/&-05*"-.*:"45'B/2*"/+"

$+"(/+%*$2/69"$+"/-"/+"5*B*$%/69J")0+-"$+"-.*:"&$6"1*"0+*2"-'"5*B*$%"U*E.$("$+"$"4%$&*"'7"

45'&*++>"-.*:"&$6"1*"0+*2"-'"2*Q./+-'5/&/+*"-.*"1'5'09."1:"7/C/69"/-"$+"$"+6$4+.'-"/6"-/(*J"K.*"

&$-*9'5/*+"&.'+*6"-'"5*45*+*6-"&'6-*(4'5$5:"+'&/$%"%/7*"/6"T0-*5"<$+-";'62'6"$5*"./9.%:"

4'%/-/&/+*2"G_$&F/69"?@@?IJ"8-$-/+-/&+"'6"/((/95$-/'6"$5*"&'(('6%:"0+*2"-'"*67'5&*"/2*$+"'7"

&0%-05$%"/6B$+/'6>"6$-/'6$%"2*1$+*(*6-"$62"$"%'++"'7"&'6-5'%j"+-$-/+-/&+"'6"./9."45'4'5-/'6+"'7"

:'069"4*'4%*"$5*"'7-*6"&'(1/6*2"E/-."60(1*5+"7'5"2*45/B$-/'6"-'"+099*+-"$"+'&/*-:"'6"-.*"

*29*"'7"$"45*&/4/&*J"K.*+*"/6-*545*-/B*"4/-7$%%+"E*5*"*C4%$/6*2"-'"(*"1:")'6"K5$B/+"/6"-.*"

+0((*5"'7"?@@VJ"8''6"-'"5*-/5*>")'6".$2"E'5F*2"$+"$":'0-."E'5F*5"/6"-.*"1'5'09."7'5"('+-"'7"

./+"45'7*++/'6$%"%/7*>"$62"205/69"-.*"/6-*5B/*E>".*"5*7%*&-*2"'6"E.$-"-.*+*"60(1*5+"(*$6-"-'"

./(J"lA7":'0"%''F"$-"-.*"+-$-/+-/&+n>"A"+$/2"l:'0"&$6"+**"-./+"/+"$"4''5"1'5'09."E/-."$"B*5:"./9."

45'4'5-/'6"'7":'069"4*'4%*>"$62"$"./9."%*B*%"'7"+'&/$%"('1/%/-:"Q"/6"$62"'0-"'7"-.*"1'5'09."$62"

E/-./6"-.*"1'5'09.Jn"l,%%"-.*"2*('95$4./&+"7'5"/6+-$1/%/-:in".*"&.$%%*69*2J"lA+"/-"-50*in"A"

h0*+-/'6*2J"lA"2'6Y-"-./6F"/-"/+n>".*"5*4%/*2"l10-"/7":'0"E*5*"-'"$+F"(*"E.:>"AY("6'-"+05*"A"&'0%2"

+$:Jn")'6"E$+"-*%%/69"(*"-.$-"2*+4/-*"&'(('6"(/+&'6&*4-/'6+>"U*E.$("E$+"6'-"25/B*6"-'"-.*"

*29*"'7"$"&%/77"1:"/-+"2*('95$4./&+j"5$-.*5"-.*+*"7/905*+"+*5B*2"$+"$6"*6-5:"4'/6-"-'"$"('5*"

60$6&*2"*6h0/5:J"A-"/+"E/-."-.*+*"&'6+/2*5$-/'6+"/6"(/62"-.$-"-.*"7'%%'E/69"2$-$"$5*"45*+*6-*2J""

"

,-"-.*"-/(*"A"&'620&-*2"-.*"5*+*$5&."G?@@Mg?@!?I"$5'062"?N@>@@@"4*'4%*"E*5*"%/B/69"/6"

U*E.$("G;^U"?@!@9IM"$62"$1'0-"V@>@@@"GO?"4*5"&*6-I"'7"-.*("E*5*"&./%25*6"$62":'069"

4*'4%*"$9*2"@g!P":*$5+"G;^U"?@@e1>"4JOj";^U"?@!@$IJ",-"V"4*5"&*6-"./9.*5"-.$6"-.*"'B*5$%%"

7/905*"7'5";'62'6>"-./+"7$&-'5"($2*"U*E.$("-.*"%'&$%"$0-.'5/-:"E/-."-.*"./9.*+-"45'4'5-/'6"'7"

:'069"4*'4%*"/6"-.*"[`>"$62"&'6+*h0*6-%:"$"1'5'09."E.*5*"062*5+-$62/69"-.*"*B*5:2$:"%/B*+"

'7":'069"4*'4%*"($--*5+J"

"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""M"3*4*62/69"'6"-.*"45'H*&-/'6+"0+*2J"lK.*"X5*$-*5";'62'6",0-.'5/-:"45'20&*+"$660$%"4'40%$-/'6"

45'H*&-/'6+"7'5";'62'6"1'5'09.+>"0+/69".'0+/69"2*B*%'4(*6-"2$-$"-'"('2*%"(/95$-/'6"7%'E+n"G;^U"

?@!@9IJ"X;,"45'H*&-/'6+"40-"-.*"&055*6-"4'40%$-/'6"$-"$1'0-"?e@>@@@"E./%*"T77/&*"'7"U$-/'6$%"8-$-/+-/&+"

7/905*+"+.'E"-.*"4'40%$-/'6"/+"+-$1%*J"

Page 17: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!M"

"

K.*":'069"4*'4%*"A"E'5F*2"E/-."E*5*"*-.6/&$%%:"2/B*5+*>"6'-"H0+-"/6"-*5(+"'7"($6:"/62/B/20$%"

95'04+>"10-"$%+'"/6"-*5(+"'7"(/C*2"*-.6/&"95'04+J"K./+"2/B*5+/-:"$62"(/C*26*++"E$+"*B/2*6&*"'7"

-.*"./+-'5:"'7"%'69Q-*5("(/95$-/'6"-'"-.*"1'5'09.J"A6"?@@!>"U*E.$(".$2"-.*"%$59*+-"

45'4'5-/'6"'7"6'6QE./-*"*-.6/&"95'04+"/6"-.*"&'06-5:"Ge!"4*5"&*6-I"GTU8"?@@!IV"$62"$('69"

&./%25*6"$62":'069"4*'4%*"G@Q!P":*$5+"'%2I"-./+"*-.6/&"2/B*5+/-:"E$+"('5*"45'6'06&*2J"

8*B*6-:Q+*B*6"4*5"&*6-"'7"&./%25*6"$62":'069"4*'4%*"%/B/69"/6"U*E.$("E*5*"75'("W^%$&F"$62"

#/6'5/-:"<-.6/&Y"95'04+"$62"?O"4*5"&*6-"E*5*"Wd./-*"^5/-/+.Y"G;^U"?@!@$IJ",+"-*+-$(*6-"-'"-.*"

./+-'5:"'7"(/95$-/'6>"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"-.$-"($2*"04"-./+"MM"4*5"&*6-"E*5*"6'-"5*&*6-"$55/B$%+J"

K.*"B$+-"($H'5/-:".$2"1**6"1'56"/6"-.*"[`"GVM"4*5"&*6-I"E/-."'6%:"e"4*5"&*6-"1'56"/6",75/&$"$62"

e"4*5"&*6-"/6",+/$"G;^U"?@@e1>"4JNIJ"K.*"%$59*+-"(/6'5/-:"&$-*9'5/*+"7'5"&./%25*6"$62":'069"

4*'4%*"/6"?@@!"E*5*"W^%$&F",75/&$6Y"G!M"4*5"&*6-I"$62"W^$69%$2*+./Y"G!\"4*5"&*6-I"G;^U"?@@e1>"

4J\IJ"

"

K./+"2/B*5+/-:"E$+"$%+'"6'-"+-$-/&"10-"E$+"&'6-/60$%%:"5*&'67/905*2J"S%'+*5"/6+4*&-/'6"'7"?@@!"

S*6+0+"2$-$"+.'E+"-.$-"E/-./6"-.*"@g!P"$9*"15$&F*-"-.*"+45*$2"'7"*-.6/&"2/B*5+/-:"1:"$9*"E$+"

06*B*6J"]'5"*C$(4%*>"E./%*"-.*5*"E$+"$6"*B*6"+45*$2"'7"Wd./-*Y"$62"W^$69%$2*+./Y":'069"

4*'4%*"$&5'++"-.*"@g!P"$9*"5$69*>"-.*"45'4'5-/'6"'7"W^%$&F",75/&$6o":'069"4*'4%*"E$+"./9.*+-"

/6"-.*"@g\"$9*"15$&F*-"G;^U"?@@e1>"4J\IJ"K./+"5*7%*&-+"('5*"5*&*6-",75/&$6"(/95$-/'6+"-'"-.*"

1'5'09.J"K.*"W(/C*2Y"*-.6/&"4'40%$-/'6"'7"-.*"1'5'09."E$+"$%+'"95'E/69"$62"*C4*&-*2"-'"

2'01%*"/6"45'4'5-/'6"1*-E**6"?@@!"$62"?@!eJ",9$/6>"-.*+*"&.$69*+"E*5*"5*9/+-*5*2"('+-"

+-5'69%:"$('69"-.*":'069J"R*7%*&-/69"5*&*6-"W<$+-*56"<05'4*$6Y"(/95$-/'6>P"-.*"E./-*"

4'40%$-/'6"GE./&."$%5*$2:"/6&%02*2"A5/+.>"8&'-+>"R'($6:"$62"X5**F+I"-''"+.'E*2"/6&5*$+/69"

&'(4%*C/-:"E/-."$6"/6&5*$+*"/6"-.*"WT-.*5"d./-*Y"&$-*9'5:"45'H*&-*2"-'"5/+*"75'("\JN"4*5"&*6-"

/6"?@@!"-'"NJM"4*5"&*6-"/6"?@@M"G;^U"?@!@9IJ"

"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""V"K.*"(/C*2"*-.6/&"4'40%$-/'6"$&&'06-*2"7'5"OJ\"4*5"&*6-"'7"-.*"4'40%$-/'6J"K.*"W,+/$6Y"4'40%$-/'6"

($2*"04"O?JN"4*5"&*6-"$62"-.*"W^%$&F"'5"^%$&F"^5/-/+.Y"?!Je"4*5"&*6-J"d./-*"*-.6/&"95'04+"/6&%02*"W^5/-/+.Y"

GOOJV"4*5"&*6-I>"WA5/+.Y"G!JO"4*5"&*6-I"$62"WT-.*5"d./-*Y"G\JO"4*5"&*6-IJ"P"A6"?@@\"-.*"Sa*&."R*401%/&>"<+-'6/$>"_069$5:>";$-B/$>";/-.0$6/$>"='%$62>"8%'B$F"R*401%/&"$62"8%'B*6/$"

H'/6*2"-.*"<05'4*$6"[6/'6J"#$6:"<$+-*56"<05'4*$6"(/95$6-+"-'"U*E.$("&$(*"75'("-.*"R*401%/&"'7"

;/-.0$6/$J"^*-E**6"?@@N"$62"?@@e>"E'5F/69Q$9*"(/95$6-+"75'("-./+"&'06-5:"2'01%*2":*$5"'6":*$5"G;^U"

?@@MI"5*$&./69"?>M@@"/6"?@@e"G;^U"?@@MIJ"[6'77/&/$%"*+-/($-*+"E*5*"(0&."./9.*5J"

Page 18: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!V"

"

K.*"?@@P"8&.''%"S*6+0+"+044'5-+"-.*+*"7/62/69+J"A-"+.'E+"-.$-"!@"4*5"&*6-"'7"&./%25*6"'6"-.*"

+&.''%"5'%%"E*5*"'7"Wd./-*"^5/-/+.Y"'5/9/6>"E/-."W,+/$6Y"G\O"4*5"&*6-I"$62"W^%$&FY"G?e"4*5"&*6-I"

:'069"4*'4%*"-'9*-.*5"($F/69"04"('5*"-.$6"-E'Q-./52+"'7"-.*"+&.''%"4'40%$-/'6J"K.*+*"

7/905*+"$%+'"+.'E"M"4*5"&*6-"'7"-.*"+&.''%"4'40%$-/'6"$+"Wd./-*"T-.*5Y>"E./&."/6&%02*2"<$+-*56"

<05'4*$6":'069"4*'4%*>"$9$/6"+099*+-/69"$6"/6&5*$+*"/6"%/6*"E/-."4'+-Q?@@\"(/95$-/'6J"8/C"4*5"

&*6-"'7":'069"4*'4%*"/6"-.*"8&.''%"S*6+0+"E*5*"W(/C*2Y"G;^U"?@!@*>"4J!!IJ"]/5+-Q%$690$9*"2$-$"

75'("-.*"8&.''%"S*6+0+"?@@M"G;^U"?@@M1I"+.'E*2"-.*"-*6-."%$59*+-"5*4'5-*2"7/5+-"%$690$9*"/6"

U*E.$(Y+"+&.''%+"E$+";/-.0$6/$6"GMO\"404/%+I"$62"='%/+."E$+"-./5-**6-."G\!N"404/%+IJ"K./+"

&'(4$5*+"-'"!O>MMV"<69%/+."+4*$F*5+>"\>?\\"^*69$%/>"O>PM\"[520>"!>P@M"X0H$5$-/>"!>\PP"8'($%/>"

!>OV@"=06H$1/>"!>O@@"K$(/%>"PPe"Z'501$>"MON"='5-090*+*"$62"O?V",%1$6/$6J"

"

_'E*B*5>"2*('95$4./&"&.$69*+"/6"U*E.$("E*5*"6'-"'6%:"'6"$&&'06-"'7":'069"4*'4%*"$55/B/69"

/6"-.*"1'5'09."$62"+*--%/69"2'E6J","60(1*5"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"A"E'5F*2"E/-."('B*2"

-.5'09."&/5&0%$5"(/95$-/'6"4$--*56+"g"%*$B/69>"&'(/69"1$&F"$62"%*$B/69"$9$/6"$+"7$(/%:"

(*(1*5+"+'09.-"*(4%':(*6-"/6"2/77*5*6-"4$5-+"'7"-.*"E'5%2"G+**"S.$4-*5"KE'IJ"K.*+*"W6*E"

(/95$-/'6+Y"2/2"6'-".$B*"-.*"+$(*"&.$5$&-*5/+-/&+"$+"4'+-QE$5"(/95$-/'6+J"d.*5*$+"S$5/11*$6"

$62",+/$6"/((/95$-/'6"'7"-.*"!PN@+>"!Pe@+>"$62"!PM@+"E$+"&.$5$&-*5/+*2"1:"E'5F*5+"75'("W%*++"

2*B*%'4*2Y"$62"4'+-Q&'%'6/$%"&'06-5/*+"(/95$-/69"-'"$62"+*--%/69"/6"-.*"7$+-Q*C4$62/69"

/620+-5/$%"*&'6'(/*+"'7"d*+-*56"<05'4*>"U'5-.",(*5/&$"$62",0+-5$%/$"GS$+-%*+"$62"#/%%*5"?@@O>"

4JeVQPO"4JeVQPOI>"W6*E"(/95$-/'6Y!@"/+"/2*6-/7/*2"E/-.>"$('69"'-.*5"-./69+>"&/5&0%$5"(/95$-/'6"

4$--*56+J"8'(*"'7"-.*"<$+-*56"<05'4*$6+"E.'"$55/B*2"/6"%$59*"60(1*5+!!"4'+-Q?@@\"&$(*>"%*7-"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!@"S'55*+4'62+"E/-."4'40%$-/'6"('B*(*6-+"5*%$-*2"-'"*B*6-+"$+"15'$2"$+"-.*"&'%%$4+*"'7"-.*"^*5%/6"d$%%"

G`'+*5"$62";0-a"!PPMI>"-.*"15*$FQ04"'7"-.*"7'5(*5"Z09'+%$B/$"$62"-.*"$&&*++/'6"'7"-.*",V"G-.*"Sa*&."

R*401%/&>"<+-'6/$>"_069$5:>";$-B/$>";/-.0$6/$>"='%$62>"8%'B$F"R*401%/&"$62"8%'B*6/$I"$62",?"6$-/'6Q+-$-*+"

G^0%9$5/$"$62"R'($6/$I""-'"-.*"<05'4*$6"[6/'6J"!!"A6"?@@M>"='%$62"'B*5-''F"A62/$"$+"-.*"('+-"&'(('6"6'6Q^5/-/+."&'06-5:"'7"&/-/a*6+./4"7'5"(/95$6-+"

*6-*5/69"-.*"[`"GTU8"?@@M>"&/-*2"/6"S;X"?@@V>"4J!?IJ"_'E*B*5>"-.*+*"4$--*56+"'7"+*--%*(*6-"$62"5*-056"

.$B*"062'01-*2%:"1**6"$77*&-*2"1:"-.*"*&'6'(/&"2'E6-056"-.$-"./-"-.*"[`"*&'6'(:"/6"?@@V"5*+0%-/69"

/6"H'1"+.'5-$9*+J"A6"?@@M>"!!?>@@@"4*'4%*"*6-*5*2"-.*"[`"75'(",V"6$-/'6+"$62"'6%:"?N>@@@"%*7-J"A6"?@@V"

-.*5*"E*5*"$6"*+-/($-*2"VP>@@@"4*'4%*"(/95$-/69"/6-'"-.*"[`"75'("-.*",V"&'06-5/*+"$62"eV>@@@"

(/95$-/69"75'("-.*"[`"-'"-.*",V"&'06-5/*+"G;^U"?@!@&>"4J!\OIJ"

Page 19: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!P"

"

$62"5*-056*2"$9$/6"GR0--*5"*-"$%J"?@@V>"4JVIJ!?"T-.*5":'069"4*'4%*"('B*2"-.5'09."-.*"(/95$6-"

%$1'05"&/5&0/-+"'7"-.*"X0%7"8-$-*+"1*7'5*"5*-056/69"-'"U*E.$(J"S'6+*h0*6-%:>"E./%*"+'(*"

&./%25*6"$62":'069"4*'4%*"&$(*"$62"+*--%*2"/6"U*E.$(>"'-.*5+"%*7-"$62"&$(*"1$&F"$9$/6>"

'7-*6"('5*"-.$6"'6&*J"

"

K.*+*"2*('95$4./&+"E*5*"4%$:*2"'0-"/6"2/77*5*6-"E$:+"$&5'++"-.*"-.5**":'0-."&%01+J"]'5"-.*"

('+-"4$5->"-.*".0625*2"'5"+'":'069"4*'4%*"A"E'5F*2".$2"1**6"1'56"/6"<$+-";'62'6>"-.'09."

+'(*".$2"-.*/5"'5/9/6+"/6";$-/6",(*5/&$>",75/&$>"d*+-*56"<05'4*>"<$+-*56"<05'4*"$62",+/$J"T7"

-.'+*"1'56"/6"<$+-";'62'6>"($6:"E*5*"W(/C*2Y"$62"6*$5%:"$%%".$2"./+-'5/*+"'7"(/95$-/'6"-.$-"

-''F"-.*(>"B/$"-.*/5"4$5*6-+>"95$624$5*6-+"$62"95*$-Q95$624$5*6-+>"'0-+/2*"<$+-";'62'6"-'"-.*"

<69%/+."5*9/'6+>"-'"A5/+."X/4+:"$62"^5/-/+."R'($6:"4'40%$-/'6+>"-'"A5*%$62"$62"8&'-%$62>"-'"

X5**&*>"S'%'(1/$>"-.*"3*('&5$-/&"R*401%/&"'7"S'69'>"U/9*5/$>"8'($%/$>"`*6:$>",%1$6/$>"

R'($6/$>";/-.0$6/$>"='%$62>";$-B/$>"]5$6&*>"84$/6>"='5-09$%>")$($/&$>"^$51$2'+>"^$69%$2*+.>"

=$F/+-$6>",79.$6/+-$6>"$62"-.*"%/+-"E*6-"'6J"8'(*"'7"-.*+*"./+-'5/*+"E*5*"('5*"2/+-$6->"+'(*"

('5*"5*&*6->"10-"('+-"E/-./6"7'05"9*6*5$-/'6+J"8'(*":'069"4*'4%*"4$++*2"-.5'09."U*E.$("

75'("R'($6/$"$62"E*6-"W.'(*Y"$9$/6J"T-.*5":'069"4*'4%*"%*7-"7'5"301$/"$62"8$02/",5$1/$>"'5"

-'"`*6:$"7'%%'E/69"-.*/5"7$(/%:Y+"%$1'05"(/95$-/'6+>"10-"&$(*"1$&F"W.'(*Y"-'"U*E.$(J"T6%:"$"

+($%%"(/6'5/-:"E*5*"06$E$5*"'7"$"7$(/%:"./+-'5:"'0-+/2*"<$+-";'62'6J"

"

K.*"7%0/2/-:"'7"-.*"1'5'09."E$+"$%+'"./9.%/9.-*2"$-"5*9/'6$%"$62"%'&$%"%*B*%+>"$62"-.*+*"%'&$%"

$62"5*9/'6$%"('B*(*6-+"&'6-5/10-*2"-'"-.*"9*6*5$%"W4'40%$-/'6"&.056Y"G#$:.*E"?@@P"&/-*2"/6"

;^U"?@!@1IJ"S*6+0+"2$-$"75'("?@@!"5*B*$%+"-.*"*C-*6-"'7"('B*(*6-"/6"$62"'0-"'7"U*E.$(J"A6"

-.*"-E*%B*"('6-.+"45/'5"-'"-.*"?@@!"S*6+0+>"N"4*5"&*6-"'7"-.*"4'40%$-/'6".$2"('B*2"E/-./6"

-.*"1'5'09."g"-.*"./9.*+-"4*5&*6-$9*"$('69"$%%"-.*";'62'6"1'5'09.+>"e"4*5"&*6-"'7"-.*"

4'40%$-/'6".$2"$55/B*2"75'("'0-+/2*"U*E.$(>"$62"e"4*5"&*6-".$2"%*7-"-.*"1'5'09."G;^U"

?@@e1>"4JNIJ",9$/6>"+0&."('B*(*6-+"E*5*"/6&5*$+/69"$62"1*&'(/69"*+4*&/$%%:"45*B$%*6-"

$('69":'069"4*'4%*>"/6"4$5-/&0%$5"7'5"-.*"$9*"5$69*"@g!N"G;^U"?@@e1>"4JNj"#$:.*E"?@@P>"

&/-*2"/6";^U"?@!@1IJ"#$6:":'069"4*'4%*"A"F6*E".$2"('B*2".'0+*"'5"E*5*"4%$66/69"-'"('B*J","

?@@P"+-02:"7'5"U*E.$("S'06&/%"+099*+-*2"$6"/6&5*$+*"/6"-.*+*"-:4*+"'7"('1/%/-:J"^*-E**6"

?@@M"$62"?@@V>"l!PJN"4*5"&*6-"'7"-.*"4'40%$-/'6"*/-.*5"(/95$-*2"/6-'"'5"'0-"'7"-.*"^'5'09."

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!?"K.*+*"4$--*56+"'7"(/95$-/'6"E*5*"($2*"4'++/1%*"1:"-.*"75**2'("'7"('B*(*6-"7'5",V"6$-/'6$%+"/6"-.*"

<[>"$62"2*+/5$1%*"1*&$0+*"'7"($C/(/+/69"/6&'(*"-.5'09."+*$+'6$%"'5"-*(4'5$%"E'5FJ"

Page 20: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?@"

"

&'(4$5*2"-'"$";'62'6"$B*5$9*"'7"!OJe"4*5"&*6-n"G#$:.*E"?@@P>"&/-*2"/6";^U"?@!@1>"4J!OIJ"A6"

?@@M>"('B*(*6-"-'"-.*"+01051+"G($/6%:"-'"-.*"*$+-"$62"+'0-.Q*$+-I".$2"/6&5*$+*2"1:"?N"4*5"

&*6-"75'("?@@O"G;^U"?@@M>"4JOOIJ"K.*+*"(/95$-/'6+"E*5*"(0%-/Q*-.6/&"5$-.*5"-.$6"WE./-*"7%/9.-Y"

G]/66*:"$62"8/(4+'6"?@@P>"4JP?I"$62"E*5*"7$&/%/-$-*2"1:"$09(*6-*2"+4*62/69"4'E*5>"(/22%*Q

&%$++"$+4/5$-/'6+"$62>"/6"8-5$-7'52"g"$+"$"&'6+*h0*6&*"'7"-.*"T%:(4/&"2*B*%'4(*6-"g"5/+/69"

.'0+*"45/&*+J"

"

,%%"'7"-./+"(*$6-"-.$-"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"A"E'5F*2"E/-."062*5+-''2"-.*"9*'95$4.:"'7"-.*/5"%/B*+"

1*:'62"-.*"%'&$%"&'67/6*+"-.$-"4'+-QE$5"+&.'%$5+"45*+0(*2"-.*("-'"F**4"G=$5F*5"!PM\>"4J?VIJ"

K./+"E$+"/6"6'"+*6+*"$6"/+'%$-*2"E'5F/69Q&%$++"&'((06/-:"GU$:$F"?@@O>"4JV?IJ"#'B/69".'0+*>"

$62"F6'E/69"'-.*5+"E.'".$2"('B*2".'0+*>"(*$6-"-.$-"$-"$"%'&$%"%*B*%"-.*:"F6*E"6'-"'6%:"-.*"

7/B*Q(/60-*"5$2/0+"75'("-.*/5".'(*+>"10-"$%%"'B*5"-.*"1'5'09.>"-'"4$+-".'0+*+"$62"-'"-.*"

.'(*+"'7"75/*62+"$62"7$(/%:J"]5'("/6-*56$-/'6$%"(/95$-/'6+"$62".'%/2$:+"-.*:"F6*E"-.*"+-5**-+"

'7"`$(4$%$"$62"=$5/+>"-.*"_/%%+"'7"+'0-.*56",%1$6/$"$62"-.*"25/B*"-.5'09."X*5($6:"-'"9*-"

-.*5*J"_'E*B*5>"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"-.*/5"9*'95$4./*+"E*5*"&'6-$/6*2"/6"4$5-/&0%$5"E$:+J"8'(*"

2/2"6'-"F6'E".'E"-'"9*-"-'";/B*54''%"8-5**-"8-$-/'6"10-"-.*:"F6*E".'E"-'"-$F*"-.*"+$(*"-5$/6>"

/6"-.*"'-.*5"2/5*&-/'6>"-'"<++*C"g"-'"-.*"+*$+/2*"$62"-'"7$(/%:"(*(1*5+"/6"-.*"*+-0$5:J"K.*:"

F6*E".'E"-'"9*-"-'"8-5$-7'52"10-".$2"6'"/2*$".'E"-'"9*-"-'";*:-'6"H0+-"$"(/%*"705-.*5"04"-.*"

5'$2J"#'+-"E*5*"$%+'"$E$5*"'7"%'&$%"-*55/-'5/$%"5*+-5/&-/'6+>"4'+-&'2*+"$62"-.*"4'-*6-/$%"2$69*5"

'7"9*--/69"W&$09.-"+%/44/69Y"G+**"S.$4-*5"]'05IJ"

"

_'E*B*5>"-./+"(0%-/&0%-05*"&$66'-"1*"062*5+-''2"-.5'09."2*('95$4./&+"$%'6*"G8'%'('+"

!PVeIJ"3*45/B$-/'6>"4'B*5-:>"%'E"*20&$-/'6$%"$--$/6(*6-"$62"06*(4%':(*6-"E*5*"$%+'"

7'5($-/B*"&'62/-/'6+"'7"-.*+*":'069"4*'4%*Y+"%/B*+"GR066:(*2*"K50+-"?@@?>"4JMegVPIJ"d./%*"A"

E$+"E'5F/69"$-"-.*":'0-."&%01+"-.*"5*&*++/'6"E$+"1*9/66/69"-'"1/-*J"U*E.$("E$+"45*4$5/69"-'"

*C4*5/*6&*"-.*"./9.*+-"401%/&"+4*62/69"&0-+"/6";'62'6"G^^S"?@!@I"E./%+-"$%5*$2:"*6205/69"-.*"

./9.*+-"/6&5*$+*+"/6"06*(4%':(*6->"&%$/($6-+"'7")'1"8**F*5+",%%'E$6&*"$62".'0+/69"

5*4'++*++/'6+"/6"-.*"&$4/-$%"G#$&A66*+"*-"$%J"?@!@IJ"A6"?@@M>"-.*":*$5"A"+-$5-*2>"U*E.$("E$+"

-.*"-./52"('+-"2*45/B*2";'62'6"1'5'09."$62"-.*"+/C-."('+-"2*45/B*2"/6"<69%$62"$62"d$%*+J"A-"

5$6F*2"$+".$B/69"-.*"+*&'62"./9.*+-"W*C-*6-"'7"2*45/B$-/'6Y"'7"$6:"2/+-5/&-"/6"-.*"&'06-5:"

GU'1%*"*-"$%J"?@@V>"4JVeIf"e@"4*5"&*6-"'7"U*E.$(Y+"804*5"T0-40-",5*$+"E*5*"/6"-.*"-'4"!@"4*5"

&*6-"('+-"2*45/B*2"/6"<69%$62"$62"d$%*+j"\eJP"4*5"&*6-"'7"&./%25*6"/6"U*E.$("E*5*"%/B/69"/6"

4'B*5-:>"6'-$1%:"./9.*5"-.$6"-.*";'62'6"$B*5$9*"'7"O?JN"4*5"&*6-"G;^U"?@!@1>"4J\NI>"$62"-./+"

Page 21: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?!"

"

4'B*5-:"E$+"2**(*2"4*5+/+-*6-"G^5/-/+."_'0+*.'%2"=$6*%"805B*:"?@@VIJ",B*5$9*"%*B*%+"'7"

/6&'(*"E*5*"%'E"E/-."?V"4*5"&*6-"'7"4*'4%*"/6"-.*"p!@>@@@"gp?@>@@@"/6&'(*"15$&F*-"$62"!e"

4*5"&*6-"/6"-.*"p@gp!@>@@@"15$&F*-"G;^U"?@!@*>"4J!\!IJ"K.*"+'0-."$62"E*+-"'7"-.*"1'5'09.>"

E.*5*"A"E'5F*2"('+-%:>"E$+"$('69"-.*"('+-"2*45/B*2"/6"U*E.$("G+**"]/905*"K.5**IJ"

R*7%*&-/69"-.*+*"7/905*+"-.*"($H'5/-:"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"A"F6*E"&$(*"75'("%'EQ/6&'(*"

7$(/%/*+>"+'(*".$2"*C4*5/*6&*2"/6-*6+*"4'B*5-:>"$62"-.*"($H'5/-:>"-.'09."6'-"$%%>"E'0%2".$B*"

*C4*5/*6&*2"2*45/B$-/'6"$&5'++"+'(*"'5"$%%"'7"-.*"+*B*6"2'($/6+"'7"2*45/B$-/'6f"/6&'(*j"

*(4%':(*6-j".*$%-."$62"2/+$1/%/-:j"*20&$-/'6>"+F/%%+"$62"-5$/6/69"2*45/B$-/'6j"1$55/*5+"-'"

.'0+/69"$62"+*5B/&*+j"%/B/69"*6B/5'6(*6-j"$62"&5/(*"GU'1%*"*-"$%J"?@@V>"4J!OIJ"

"

,9$/6>"$%-.'09."+'(*":'069"4*'4%*"A"F6*E"2/2"$&./*B*"./9.%:>"'B*5$%%"*20&$-/'6$%"$--$/6(*6-"

E$+"%'EJ"]'5"-.*"$&$2*(/&":*$5"?@@VgP>"U*E.$("E$+"-.*"-./52Q%'E*+-Q$&./*B/69"1'5'09."/6"

;'62'6"$-"XS8<"%*B*%f"e\JV"4*5"&*6-"'7":'069"4*'4%*"$&./*B*2"7/B*"4$++*+"$-"95$2*+",qgS"$62"

\MJP"4*5"&*6-"'7":'069"4*'4%*"$&./*B*2"7/B*"4$++*+"$-"95$2*+",qgS"/6&%02/69"<69%/+."$62"($-.+"

G;^U"?@!@7IJ"_'E*B*5>"$+"E/-."2*45/B$-/'6>"*20&$-/'6$%"$&./*B*(*6-"E$+"06*B*6"$&5'++"-.*"

1'5'09.Y+"+&.''%+J"K.*"+&.''%"&%'+*+-"-'";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01>"$--*62*2"1:"+'(*"'7"-.*":'069"

4*'4%*"A"E'5F*2"E/-.>"E$+"$('69"-.*"%'E*+-Q$&./*B/69"/6"-.*"&'06-5:"E/-."?P"4*5"&*6-"'7"

:'069"4*'4%*"$&./*B/69"7/B*"4$++*+"$-"95$2*+",qgS"/6"?@!@J"_'E*B*5>"'-.*5":'069"4*'4%*"A"

F6*E"$--*62*2"$"+&.''%"-.$-"$&./*B*2"V\"4*5"&*6-"$-"-.*"+$(*"%*B*%"G^^S"?@!!IJ"

Page 22: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

??"

"

"

E')03+!<93++.!L(5+M!%F!N01,'#1+!>+#3'*4,'%(2!I+C94&!:4(='()!OPPQ!H8GI!OP?P52!#@??J!

"

T6"%*$B/69"+&.''%>"($6:"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"A"F6*E"E*5*"%''F/69"7'5"E'5F"$62"+'(*"E*5*"

-$F/69"&'%%*9*"&'05+*+J"d'5F"E$+"6'-"*$+:"-'"&'(*"1:J"A6"8*4-*(1*5"?@@P>"NOJP"4*5"&*6-"'7"

:'069"4*'4%*"/6"U*E.$("$9*2"!eQ?\"E*5*"*&'6'(/&$%%:"/6$&-/B*J"K./+"&'(4$5*2"-'"\\J!"4*5"

&*6-"7'5";'62'6"G;^U"?@!@1>"4J\\IJ"K$F/69"&'%%*9*"&'05+*+"E$+"$"4'40%$5"&.'/&*"7'5":'069"

4*'4%*"$62"E$+"*6&'05$9*2"1:"&$5**5+"$2B/+*5+J"A6"?@@N>"MM"4*5"&*6-"'7"+&.''%"%*$B*5+"+-$:*2"

'6"/6"*20&$-/'6"'5"-5$/6/69"E/-."'6%:"!J?"4*5"&*6-"9'/69"'6"-'"*(4%':(*6-"E/-.'0-"-5$/6/69"

G;^U"?@@e1>"4J?MIJ"A6"1*-E**6"-$F/69"&'05+*+"$62"7/62/69"H'1+>":'069"(*6"$62"E'(*6"

5*($/6*2"06*(4%':*2"7'5"%'69"4*5/'2+"'7"-/(*J"8'(*":'069"E'(*6"E'5F*2"+4'5$2/&$%%:"$+"

B'%06-**5+"/6"-.*":'0-."&%01+>"+'"-.*:"&'0%2"9*-"-.*"+F/%%+"$62"$&&5*2/-$-/'6"-.*:"6**2*2"-'"

1*&'(*":'0-."E'5F*5+>"-*$&./69"$++/+-$6-+"$62"605+*5:"605+*+J"T-.*5":'069"4*'4%*".069"

Page 23: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?O"

"

$5'062"/6"-.*"4$5F"'5"$-".'(*J",(/2"6*9$-/B*"(*2/$"$--*6-/'6>"-.*"5*&*++/'6"$62"E/-."4''5"

95$2*+>"7/62/69"E'5F"E$+6Y-"$-"$%%"*$+:J"

"

,+/2*"75'("-.*"5*&*6-"$55/B$%"/6"8-5$-7'52"'7"-.*"l&%*$6+/69"&%$++n"G,(/6"[6401%/+.*2>"4J?!I"g"$"

&'$%/-/'6"'7"-.*"(/22%*Q&%$++>"&'+('4'%/-$6+>"&'6+0(*5+>"10+/6*++*+"$62"9%'1$%"/6B*+-'5+"

15'09.-"-'"-.*"$5*$"1*&$0+*"'7"-.*"T%:(4/&+>"d*+-7/*%2"$62"<05'+-$5"g"-.*"1'5'09."5*($/6*2"

%$59*%:"E'5F/69Q&%$++J"<C&*4-"7'5"'6*"8-$510&F+"/6"8-5$-7'52>"-.*"5*+-"'7"-.*"1'5'09.Y+"./9."

+-5**-+"E*5*"4'40%$-*2"1:"7$+-Q7''2"'0-%*-+>"/62*4*62*6-"&$7*+>"/62*4*62*6-"+-'5*+"$62"-.*"

('5*"($/6+-5*$("./9.Q+-5**-"&.$/6+"%/F*"^''-+"$62")3"84'5-+J"#'+-"4*'4%*"E*5*"*(4%':*2"/6"

%'EQ+F/%%*2"'&&04$-/'6+J"A6"?@!@g!!>"!V"4*5"&*6-"'7"-.*"4'40%$-/'6"E$+"E'5F/69"/6"W*%*(*6-$5:"

'&&04$-/'6+Y"G+/(4%*"$62"5'0-/6*"-$+F+"E./&."($/6%:"5*h0/5*"-.*"0+*"'7".$62Q.*%2"-''%+"$62"

'7-*6"+'(*"4.:+/&$%"*77'5-"rTU8"?@!@sI>"&'(4$5*2"-'"-.*"P"4*5"&*6-";'62'6"$B*5$9*J"

R*7%*&-/69"H'1+"/6"-.*"%'&$%"$0-.'5/-:>"+&.''%+"$62".'+4/-$%+>"W45'7*++/'6$%"'&&04$-/'6+Y"($2*"04"

-.*"+*&'62Q%$59*+-"&$-*9'5:"'7"*(4%':(*6-"$-"!e"4*5"&*6-J"K.*";'62'6"$B*5$9*"'B*5"-.*"+$(*"

4*5/'2"E$+"?N"4*5"&*6-"G;^U"?@!!IJ"

"

A6"+0(($5:>"U*E.$("E$+"$":'0-.70%"1'5'09."E/-."./9."*-.6/&"2/B*5+/-:J"K./+"2/B*5+/-:>"('+-"

*B/2*6-"$('69":'069"4*'4%*>"E$+"/6&5*$+/69"/6"&'(4%*C/-:"g"$+"$"&'6+*h0*6&*"'7"(/95$-/'6"-'"

-.*"1'5'09."10-"$%+'"1*&$0+*"'7".'(*Q95'E6"(/C*26*++J"K.*"&.056"$62"4'40%$-/'6"

('B*(*6-"-'"E./&."-.*+*"2*('95$4./&+"$--*+-*2"4%$:*2"'0-"/6"('B*(*6-+"1'-."E/-./6"-.*"

1'5'09."$62"E/-."6*/9.1'05/69"5*9/'6+J"K.*+*"('B*(*6-+"9$B*":'069"4*'4%*"$&&*++"-'"%'&$%>"

6$-/'6$%"$62"/6-*56$-/'6$%"9*'95$4./*+>"E*%%"1*:'62"-.*"&'67/6*+"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01+J"_'E*B*5>"

(0%-/&0%-05*"$62"-.*"%/B*+"'7":'069"4*'4%*"/6"U*E.$("&'0%2"6'-"1*"062*5+-''2"+'%*%:"-.5'09."

4'40%$-/'6"+-$-/+-/&+J"K.*"4'40%$-/'6"'7"U*E.$("E$+"$%+'"2*45/B*2"$62"%$59*%:"E'5F/69Q&%$++J"

d./%*"+'(*"7'062"E'5F"$62"'-.*5+"E'0%2"9'"'6"-'"2'"+'>"%'E"*20&$-/'6$%"$--$/6(*6->"4'B*5-:"

$62"./9."06*(4%':(*6-"E*5*"5*$%/-/*+"7'5"($6:":'069"4*'4%*"A"E'5F*2"E/-.J"

?J ;/-*5$-05*"

,+"6'-*2>"-.*+*"2*('95$4./&+".$B*"$--5$&-*2"-.*"/6-*5*+-"'7"($6:"5*+*$5&.*5+J"_'E*B*5>"

2*+4/-*"-$%*+"'7".0695:"+'&/$%"+&/*6-/+-+"5'$(/69"U*E.$(Y+"+04*5Q2/B*5+*"%'E%$62+>"-.*5*"/+"

$&-0$%%:"B*5:"%/--%*"*-.6'95$4./&"($-*5/$%"'6":'069"4*'4%*"/6"-.*"1'5'09.J"K.*"-5$2/-/'6"'7"

/620+-5/$%"+'&/'%'9:"$62"&5/(/6'%'9:"-.$-"15'09.-"/%%0(/6$-/69>"/7"'B*5%:"E./-*>"$&&'06-+"'7"

Page 24: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?\"

"

*B*5:2$:"%/7*".$+"E/-.*5*2"$E$:"G3'E6*+"!Peej"_/%%"!PMej"_'11+"!PVVIJ",62"E./%*"'-.*5"

5*&*6-"+-02/*+"G^0-%*5"$62"_$(6*--"?@!!j"#0(7'52"$62"='E*5"?@@OI".$B*"45'B/2*2"

h0$%/-$-/B*"$6$%:+*+"'7"-.*"$5*$>"-.*:".$B*"2'6*"+'"E/-."-.*"F/62"'7"45*Q7'5(0%$-*2"%/+-*6/69"

*(4%':*2"1:"4'%/&:"$62"&'((06/-:"&'.*+/'6"5*+*$5&.*5+>"$62"$+"+0&.".$B*"+/%*6&*2"('5*"

-.$6"-.*:".$B*".*$52J"K.*5*7'5*>"5$-.*5"-.$6"%'&$-*"-./+"-.*+/+"/6"$"1'2:"'7"5*+*$5&."+4*&/7/&"-'"

U*E.$(>"/-"/+"+/-0$-*2"E/-./6"E/2*5"2*1$-*+"'6"(0%-/&0%-05*>"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"4'%/-/&+"

E./&."$225*++>"$%1*/-"/6"'-.*5"-/(*+"$62"4%$&*+>"-.*"-.*(*+"4*5-/6*6-"-'"-./+"+-02:J"

#0%-/&0%-05*"$62"E./-*6*++"

,+"5*9$52+"051$6"(0%-/&0%-05*>"$&&'06-+"75'("-.*"#$5C/$6"$62"&0%-05$%"+-02/*+"-5$2/-/'6+"'7"

^5/-/+."8'&/'%'9:"'77*5"$"+-5'69"7'062$-/'6"-'"-./+"5*+*$5&.J"#$5F*2"1:"-.*/5"$6$%:-/&"&%$5/-:>"

+*6+/-/B/-:>"'4*66*++"$62"$--*6-/'6"-'"-.*"&.$69/69"5$&/$%"$62"&0%-05$%"2/(*6+/'6+"'7"-.*"2$:"

G^$&F"!PP\j"_*E/--"!PVej")'6*+"!PVVI>"-.*:"45'B/2*"$"%$690$9*"-.5'09."E./&."5$&/+-"

*++*6-/$%/+(+".$B*"1**6"2*106F*2"$62"$6-/Q5$&/+("$2B$6&*2J"_'E*B*5>"E./%*"-.*+*"-*C-+"

45'B/2*"$"1*6&.($5F"7'5"-.*"+'&/'%'9:"'7"(0%-/&0%-05*"/6"051$6"^5/-$/6>"-.*"$1+*6&*"'7"+/(/%$5%:"

45'(/6*6-"-*C-+!O"'B*5"-.*"%$+-"-E*6-:":*$5+".$+"%*2"-'"$"B'/2"/6"*-.6'95$4./&"062*5+-$62/69J"

K./+"B'/2".$+"1**6"7/%%*2"1:"6'+-$%9/&"G3*6&."*-"$%J"?@@eI"$62"E./-*"+045*($&/+-"$&&'06-+"'7"

&'6-*(4'5$5:"051$6"%/7*"G8-$5F*:"?@!!IJ"^:"5*-056/69"-'"$62"2*B*%'4/69"-.*"4'%/-/&$%"$62"

+01+-$6-/B*"&'((/-(*6-+"'7"-.*+*"#$5C/$6"$62"&0%-05$%"+-02/*+"E'5F+>"-./+"-.*+/+"$--*(4-+"-'"

7/%%"+'(*"'7"-./+"B'/2>"$62"/6"-.*"45'&*++"&.$%%*69*"-.*"$&&'06-+"-.$-".$B*"$5/+*6"/6"-.*/5"4%$&*J"

"

K'"2'"+'>"/-"5*-$/6+"-.*"0+*"'7"-.*"-*5("W(0%-/&0%-05*Y"G,%*C$62*5"?@@@j",(/6"?@@?j"^$&F"!PP\j"

,(/6"?@@?j"X/%5':"?@@@j"_$%%"?@@@j"_*++*"?@@@IJ"]'5"-.*"+$F*"'7"&%$5/7/&$-/'6>"W(0%-/&0%-05*Y"

+.'0%2"6'-"1*"&'670+*2"E/-."W(0%-/&0%-05$%/+(YJ"^0/%2/69"'6"$"6'-/'6"'7"$6-.5'4'%'9/+*2"

W&0%-05*Y"&'67%$-*2"E/-."*-.6/&/-:>!\"W(0%-/&0%-05$%/+(Y"5*7*5+"-'"$"%$59*%:"6'6Q*C/+-*6-"[`"4'%/&:"

'7"&/-/a*6+./4"1$+*2"'6"*-.6/&"2/77*5*6&*"GX/%5':"?@!?j";*6-/6"$62"K/-%*:"?@!!j"Z'069*"?@!!IJ"

W#0%-/&0%-05*Y>"$+"$44%/*2"/6"-./+"-.*+/+>"/+"6'-"'6%:"&'6&*56*2"E/-."&/-/a*6+./4"$62"*-.6/&/-:"10-"

$%+'"E/-."&0%-05*"G$62"(0%-/&0%-05*I"$+"*B*5:2$:"&5*$-/B/-:"$62"$5-"Gd/%%/$(+"?@@?"r!PNVsIJ"

[6%/F*"/-+"&'0+/6>"-./+"6'-/'6"'7"(0%-/&0%-05*"/+"6'-"7/C*2"-'"6$-/'6$%"1'062$5/*+"$62"5$&/$%/+*2"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""13 Harris’ work on New Ethnicities and Language Use is one exception to this (Harris 2006). !\"8**>"7'5"2/+&0++/'6>",%*C$62*5"?@@Oj"^$5F*5"!PV!j"X$6+"?@!?Ij"8'%'('+"?@@OIj"8'%'('+"$62"^$&F"

!PPeIj"d/%%/+"$62"K5'62($6"?@@?IJ"

Page 25: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?N"

"

F/6+./4"95'04+"10-"$--*62+"$%+'"-'"-.*"9%'1$%"7%'E+"'7"&5*$-/B/-:"-.$-".$B*"&'66*&-*2"-.*"+'&/$%"

%/7*"'7"U*E.$("-'"-.*"5*+-"'7"-.*"E'5%2J"K./+"/+"(0%-/&0%-05*"/6"-.*"&'6-*C-"'7"2/$+4'5$"GX/%5':"

!PPO>"?@!@$j"#'-*6"?@@OI>"$62"/6"-.*"&'6-*C-"'7"(/95$-/'6"$62"('B*(*6-"G^5$."!PPej";*B/--"

$62")$E'5+F:"?@@Mj"c*5-'B*&"?@@O>"?@@\>"?@@MIJ"[62*5+-''2"$+"$"&5*$-/B*"45'&*++>"-./+"B*5+/'6"

'7"(0%-/&0%-05*"$--*62+"-'"4*57'5($6&*"$62"&/-$-/'6"'7"2/$+4'5/&"7%'E+"/6"+4*&/7/&"%'&$-/'6+J"A-"/+"

&'6&*56*2"E/-.".'E":'069"4*'4%*Y+"45'20&-/'6"'7"&0%-05*"-'2$:"/+"2/77*5*6->"10-"5*%$-*2"-'"

E.$-"&$(*"1*7'5*"G,(/6"?@!@j"^0-%*5"!PPO>"!PPMj"X/%5':"!PPOIJ"

"

A6"$6"$--*(4-"-'"$225*++"-.*"*-.6'95$4./&"B'/2"(*6-/'6*2"$1'B*>"-./+"-.*+/+"2*B*%'4+"

45*B/'0+"&'6+/2*5$-/'6+"7'5"&0%-05$%"+:6&5*-/+("G^$&F"!PP\j"^*66*--"!PPPj")'6*+"!PVVIJ"

_'E*B*5>"/-"$%+'"6'-*+".'E"-.*"75$(/69+"'7"1%$&F"$62"E./-*"+:6&5*-/&"&0%-05*".$B*"&.$69*2J"

K.*"%$+-"-E'"2*&$2*+".$+"+**6"./4".'4"1*&'(*"$"9%'1$%"/620+-5:"GX/%5':"?@@@j"`/-E$6$"?@@?j"

=$--'6"?@@PI"E./%*"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"$++'&/$-*2"(0+/&>"7$+./'6"$62"7'5(+"'7"5*+/+-$6&*".$B*"

&'6-/60*2"-'"2*-$&."-.*(+*%B*+"75'("45/'5"5$&/$%"(''5/69+J"K.*"+./7-+"1*-E**6"1%$&F"

5*+/+-$6&*"$9$/6+-"5$&/+("$62"E./-*"5*+/+-$6&*"$9$/6+-"&%$++"'445*++/'6"G^*66*--"!PPPj")'6*+"

!PVVj"U$:$F"?@@OI"g"5*%/$6-"'6"#$5C/$6"4$5$2/9(+"'7"5*+/+-$6&*"$62"'445*++/'6>"$62"5*%$-/B*%:"

+-$1%*"*-.6/&"%'&$-*2"B*5+/'6+"'7"&0%-05*"g"6'"%'69*5".'%2"$+"-.*:"'6&*"2/2J"K.5'09."$6"

*C4%'5$-/'6"'7"&.$69/69"2*('95$4./&"$62"&0%-05$%"4$5$(*-*5+>"-./+"-.*+/+"2'*+"6'-"$590*"-.$-"

W1%$&FY"$62"WE./-*Y"$5*"6'"%'69*5"4'E*570%"1/'4'%/-/&$%"+/96/7/*5+"'5"-.$-"&%$++".$+"&*$+*2"-'"

($--*5j"5$-.*5"-.$-"(0%-/&0%-05$%"B*56$&0%$5+".$B*"+%/44*2"-.*/5"'%2"5$&/$%"$6&.'5+J"

"

K.*"-.*+/+>"-.*6>"*C4%'5*+"-.*"E$:+"-.$-"&0%-05$%"$62"5$&/$%"+/96/7/*5+".$B*"&'6-/60*2"-'"'4*6"

04"$62".'E"-.*:"&'6-/60*"-'"1*"5*Q0+*2"/6"E$:+"-.$-"15*$F"2'E6"45*B/'0+"*++*6-/$%/+(+J"K'"

*69$9*"E/-."-.*+*"+./7-+>"/-"2*B*%'4+"$6$%:+*+"'7"4*57'5($6&*"$62"&/-$-/'6"G^0-%*5"!PPOj"X/%5':"

!PPOI"6'-/69".'E"-.*"&0%-05$%"-5$6+%$-/'6+>"$2'4-/'6+"$62"5*Q$44%/&$-/'6+"'1+*5B*2"/6"+-02/*+"

-E'"2*&$2*+"45*B/'0+"G^$&F"!PP\j"^*66*--"!PPPj")'6*+"!PVVI".$B*"6'-"+-''2"+-/%%J"]'&0+/69"'6"

:'069"4*'4%*"/6"U*E.$(>"/-"*C4%'5*+".'E"&'((06/&$-/'6+"'7"-*55/-'5:>"5$&*"$62"+*C0$%/-:"

E*5*"*%$1'5$-*2"/6"5*%$-/'6"-'"9%'1$%"B*56$&0%$5+"'7"./4".'4"10-"$%+'"/6"5*%$-/'6"-'"%'&$%"4$+-+"

$62"45*+*6-+J"A-"$225*++*+".'E"E./-*":'069"4*'4%*"4*57'5(*2"1%$&F"7'5($-/'6+"'7"6/./%/+("$-"

-.*"+$(*"-/(*"$+"1%$&F"$62",+/$6":'069"4*'4%*"4*57'5(*2"$0-'&.-.'6:"$62"E./-*6*2"6'-/'6+"

'7"1*%'69/69"GX*+&./*5*"?@@Pj"#''5*"?@@Vj"Z0B$%Q3$B/+"?@!?IJ"A-"6'-*+".'E"-.*"&5/*+"'7"

75**2'("&'6-$/6*2"/6"1%$&F"2/$+4'5/&"&0%-05*"G30"^'/+"?@@Mj"<%%/+'6"!PPN>"?@@!j"<+.06"!PPV>"

?@@Oj"]$6'6"!PP!j"X/%5':"!PPO>"?@@@j"#$:*5"?@@@j"#'-*6"?@@Oj"d5/9.-"!Pe\j"Z$+a*F"?@@eI"

Page 26: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?e"

"

E*5*"($2*"/(($6*6-"$62"$B$/%$1%*"$+"$"B*./&%*"7'5"h0*+-/'6/69"%'&$%"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"

/6H0+-/&*J"

"

_'E*B*5>"E./%*"('B/69"$E$:"75'("'%2"$6-$9'6/+(+"$62"$0-.*6-/&/-/*+>"-.*"-.*+/+"2'*+"6'-"

$6-/&/4$-*"-.*"$55/B$%"'7".$44:"&'6B/B/$%/-:>"/55*20&/1%*".:15/2/-:"$62"4'+-Q5$&/$%"*B*5:2$:6*++J"

A-"($/6-$/6+"-.*"/(4'5-$6&*"'7"4'+-Q+-50&-05$%"&5/-/h0*+"'7"*++*6-/$%/+*2"/2*6-/-/*+>"&'5*"-'"

4'%/-/&$%%:"*69$9*2"+'&/'%'9:"G+**",%*C$62*5"?@@@I"10-"2'*+"6'-"0+*"-.*+*"4'E*570%"-''%+"-'"

7%$--*6"-.*"+'&/$%J"]'%%'E/69"-.*"E'5F"'7"^.$1.$"G!PP\I"$62"-.*"('5*"5*&*6-"(/+$44%/&$-/'6+"'7"

X/%5':Y+"E'5F"'6"&'6B/B/$%"&0%-05*"G?@@\I>"-.*(*+"'7".:15/2/-:"$62"&'6B/B/$%/-:>"&*6-5$%"-'"

2/+($6-%/69"2'(/6$6-"6'-/'6+"'7"+$(*6*++"$62"2/77*5*6&*>".$B*"1**6"(/+0+*2"/6"E$:+"-.$-"

.$B*"2*-5$&-*2"75'("-.*"&'6-*+-*2"$62"+'(*-/(*+"B/'%*6-"4'%/-/&+"'7"*B*5:2$:"%/7*J"K.5'09."

6$55$-/B*+"'7"/55*20&/1%*"2/77*5*6&*"$62"7$+./'6$1%*"&'+('4'%/-$6/+("-.*+*"'6&*"5$2/&$%"-''%+"

.$B*"G+'(*-/(*+I"1*&'(*".*9*('6/&J"K.5'09."2*B*%'4/69"-.*"W051$6"4$5$2'CY"G^$&F"!PP\I"g"

-.*"h0$%/7/&$-/'6"'7"-.*"l&0%-05$%"2:6$(/&+"'7"-.*"+'062"+:+-*("1:"-.*"45'C/(/-:"-'"-.*"

45$&-/&*+"'7"5$&/$%"-*55'5n"G^$6*5H*$"$62"^$56"!PPe>"4J!PVI"g"-./+"-.*+/+"*C4%'5*+"-.*"B$5/'0+"

E$:+"/6"E./&.":'069"4*'4%*Y+"4*57'5($6&*+"2*&'6+-50&-*2"*++*6-/$%/+("$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"$+"

-.*:"5*Q*6$&-*2"5$&/$%/+*2"*C&%0+/B/-/*+>"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"'445*++/'6J"

"

K.*"051$6"4$5$2'C"/+"-.*"$&F6'E%*29(*6-"'7"-.*"*C/+-*6&*"'7"/6-*6+*"&'6B/B/$%/-:"%/B/69"

$%'69+/2*"&'67%/&-J",62"E./%*"-.*"-.*+/+"*(15$&*+"-./+"75$(*E'5F"7'5"*C4%'5/69"&'6-*(4'5$5:"

051$6"%/7*"/6"U*E.$(>"/-"/+"$%+'"&$5*70%"-'"./9.%/9.-".'E"-.*"7'5(+"'7"051$6"4$5$2'C"-'2$:"($:"

2/77*5"75'("45*B/'0+"($6/7*+-$-/'6+J"]'5"*C$(4%*>"/-"$225*++*+".'E"&'6-*(4'5$5:"051$6"

4$5$2'C*+"($6/7*+-"-.*(+*%B*+"-.5'09."6*E"+/-*+"'7"2/$%'90*"$62"-*&.6'%'9/*+"'7"

&'((06/&$-/'6J"U*9'-/$-/'6+"$62"&'((06/&$-/'6+"-.$-"&'0%2"45*B/'0+%:"1*"062*5+-''2"

-.5'09."-.*";="$62"-.*"+'062"+:+-*("&$6"6'E"1*"$225*++*2"-.5'09."Z'0K01*"$62"('1/%*"

-*&.6'%'9/*+"'7"&'((06/&$-/'6J"A6"&'6-*(4'5$5:"U*E.$(>"('1/%*"4.'6*"+4*$F*5+>"&$(*5$+"

$62"^%0*-''-."&$4$&/-:>"/6"$22/-/'6"-'"-.*"A6-*56*->"4'E*5"$62"45'B/2*"$%-*56$-/B*"+/-*+"'7"

(0%-/&0%-05$%"2/$%'90*J"

"

,+"4$5-"'7"-./+"/6B*+-/9$-/'6"-.*"-.*+/+"*C4%'5*+"7'5($-/'6+"'7"E./-*6*++"/6"T0-*5"<$+-";'62'6J"

3/+&0++/'6+"'7"E./-*6*++"/6"<$+-";'62'6"$5*"'7-*6"$&&'(4$6/*2"1:"%/1*5$%"&'62*(6$-/'6+"'7"

E'5F/69Q&%$++"5$&/+("Gd$5*"?@@VI>"*C.'5-$-/'6+"'7"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"4*'4%*"-'"2*+/+-"75'("

5$&/+("G3*6&."*-"$%J"?@@ej"^*/2*5"?@!!I>"$62"5*+055*&-/'6+"'7"$"&'((06$%"E./-*"4$+-"G3*6&."*-"

Page 27: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?M"

"

$%J"?@@eIJ"K./+"-.*+/+"('B*+"$E$:"75'("-.*+*"B$5/'0+"2/+&'05+*+"-.$-"&'66*&-"/62/9*6'0+"

'E6*5+./4"-'"E./-*"1'2/*+"1:"*C4%'5/69".'E"2/+&'05+*+"'6"E./-*6*++"$5*"4$5-"'7"$"('5*"'4*6"

+:+-*("'7"1*%'69/69"G$0-'&.-.'6:I"GX*+&./*5*"?@@Pj"Z0B$%Q3$B/+"?@!?IJ"K.5'09."*C4%'5/69"-.*"

+-'5/*+"'7":'069"4*'4%*"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+>"/-"/6B*+-/9$-*+".'E"E./-*>"1%$&F"$62"15'E6"1'2/*+"

2*7/6*2"-.*/5"&%$/("-'"-.*"+'/%"$9$/6+-"-.*"/%%*9/-/($&:"'7"-.*"/((/95$6-J",+"4$5-"'7"-./+"$6$%:+/+"

/-"$%+'"$225*++*+"-.*"$--$/6(*6-"'7"E./-*6*++"-.5'09."45'&*++*+"'7"W1*&'(/69"E./-*Y"G3061$5"

!PPMj"U*E/-a"!PPMj"R'*2/9*5"?@@Mj"d5$:"?@@eIJ"A6"[8"%/-*5$-05*>"45'&*++*+"'7"W1*&'(/69"E./-*Y"

$5*"&'(45*.*6+/B*%:"$225*++*2"-.5'09."2/+&0++/'6+"'7"4'+-Q+%$B*5:"+'&/*-:"$62"5$&/$%"04%/7-J"A6"

^5/-/+."%/-*5$-05*"W1*&'(/69"E./-*Y"/+"*C4%'5*2"/6"-.*"&'6-*C-+"'7"U*E&$+-%*"GU$:$F"?@@OI>"<$+-"

,69%/$"GR'9$%:"?@!!j"R'9$%:"$62"K$:%'5"?@@PI>"=%:('0-."$62"^5/+-'%"GX$56*5"?@!@IJ"3*B*%'4/69"

-.*+*"$6$%:+*+>"-.*"-.*+/+"$590*+"-.$-"45'&*++*+"'7"W1*&'(/69"E./-*Y"/6"T0-*5"<$+-";'62'6"

.$B*"./+-'5/&$%"$62"&'6-*(4'5$5:"&'62/-/'6+"-.$-"(*5/-"$--*6-/'6J"K.*"H0C-$4'+/-/'6"$62"

'B*5%$:/69"'7"4'+-QE$5"6$-/'6$%/+(>"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"%'++"$62"(0%-/&0%-05$%"7$/%05*"G^'66*--"

?@@@j"^'--*5'"?@@Pj"X/%%1'56"?@!@j"8B*/6++'6"?@@PI>"$62"-.*"-5$&/69"'7"C*6'4.'1/$"$62"

$0-'&.-.'6:>"45'B/2*"/6+/9.-+"/6-'"-.*"$%%05*"'7"E./-*6*++"/6"&'6-*(4'5$5:"051$6"^5/-$/6"6'-"

$225*++*2"/6"&055*6-"[`"'5"[8"$&&'06-+J"

#$59/6$%/+$-/'6"

A6"$22/-/'6"-'"(0%-/&0%-05*"$62"E./-*6*++>"-.*"-.*+/+"$225*++*+"2*1$-*+"'6"($59/6$%/+$-/'6J"A6"

T0-*5"<$+-";'62'6>"-.*"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"'7"E'5F/69Q&%$++":'069"4*'4%*".$+"1**6"5'0-/6*"$62"

./+-'5/&$%%:"+01+-$6-/$-*2J"K.5'09."&'6&*56+"7'5"-.*"*77*&-+"'7"&'6+0(*5"+'&/*-:>"2/+%'&$-/'6"

75'("4$5*6-"&0%-05*>"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:>"%$E%*++6*++>"/(('5$%/-:"$62"-.*"&'%%$4+*"'7"l1'059*'/+"

B$%0*+n"Gc$%*6-/6*"?@@\j"d/%%('--"!PePI>"E'5F/69Q&%$++":'069"4*'4%*".$B*"%'69"1**6"%$1*%%*2"

$+"&.$'-/&"$62"'0-"'7"'52*5J"K./+"./+-'5:"/+"$%+'"5$&/$%/+*2J"=5*QE*%7$5*"+-$-*"-./+"'&&055*2"

-.5'09."6'-/'6+"'7"W2/5-:"E./-*6*++Y"5*%$-/69"-'"&'%'6/$%"+:+-*(+"'7"4'40%$-/'6"&'6-5'%"G^'66*--"

?@@@j"^''-."!VP@j"#$:.*E"!Ve!j"8/(+"!VVOIJ"A6"4'+-Q&'%'6/$%"-/(*+>"/-".$+"1**6"$44%/*2"

-.5'09."7'5(+"'7"$%/*6"&5/(/6$%/-:"$++'&/$-*2"E/-."1%$&F"$62"15'E6"1'2/*+"G,%*C$62*5"!PPe>"

?@@@j",%*C$62*5"?@@Nj"_$%%"*-"$%J"!PMVIJ"

"

d./%*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"/66*5Q&/-:":'069"4*'4%*".$B*"%'69"1**6"+**6"$+"-.*"*(1'2/(*6-"'7"

/(('5$%/-:"$62"&.$'+>"-.*"-.*+/+"$590*+"-.$-"-.*"-*5(+"'6"E./&."7'5(+"'7"5$&/$%"*C&%0+/'6"$5*"

$44%/*2"$5*"6'-"-.*"+$(*"$+"1*7'5*J"A-"*C4%'5*+".'E"%'69+-$62/69"&'6&*56+"'B*5"1%$&F":'069"

(*6".$B*"7*2"/6-'"E'55/*+"'B*5",+/$6+>",%1$6/$6+>"<$+-*56"<05'4*$6+"$62"-.*"E./-*"E'5F/69Q

Page 28: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?V"

"

&%$++J"A-"$225*++*+".'E"2/+&'05+*+"$++'&/$-*2"E/-."$"E./-*"062*5&%$++".$B*"(*%2*2"E/-."7*$5+"

'B*5"6/./%/+-/&"1%$&F"$62",+/$6":'069"4*'4%*J"K.$-"/+>"E./%*"5$&/+("/+"2/77*5*6-/$%%:"$44%/*2"-'"

2/77*5*6-"1'2/*+>"-.*5*"$5*"$%+'"+/96/7/&$6-"'B*5%$4+"$62"2/+-'5-/'6+"/6"5$&/$%"2/+&'05+*"$62"

45$&-/&*"-.$-".$B*"&'670+*2"-.*"&'%'05Q&'2/69"'7"401%/&"4$6/&J"

"

]05-.*5('5*>"-.*"-.*+/+"$225*++*+".'E"-.*+*"7'5(+"'7"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"6**2"-'"1*"062*5+-''2"

/6"5*%$-/'6"-'"+4*&/7/&"7'5(+"'7"6*'Q%/1*5$%"9'B*56$6&*J"d$&h0$6-".$+"2/+&0++*2"-.*"&055*6-"

4*6$%-/*+"4$/2"1:"-.*"2*-5/-0+"'7"+'&/*-:"+'"-.$-"-.'+*"$-"-.*"-'4"'7"-.*"%$22*5"$5*"$1%*"-'"

+0+-$/6"-.*/5"4'E*5>"45/B/%*9*"$62"E*$%-."G5*9$52%*++"'7".'E"(0&."-.*:"+-*$%I"Gd$&h0$6-"

?@@VIJ"^5*66*5>"=*&F"$62")*++'4".$B*"&'(4%*(*6-*2"-./+"E'5F>"6'-/69".'E"&.$69*+"-'"%'&$%"

4'%/-/&$%"9*'95$4./*+"$62"-.*"&'Q'4-/'6"'7"-.*"-./52"+*&-'5"/6"%'&$%"9'B*56$6&*".$B*"$77*&-*2"

-.*"E$:+"/6"E./&."&.$'+"$62"'52*5"$5*"5*90%$-*2"G^5*66*5"$62"K.*'2'5*"?@@?j")*++'4"?@@?j"

=*&F"$62"K/&F*%%"?@@?IJ"_'E*B*5>"1*:'62"-.*+*"-*C-+"-.*5*".$+"1**6"B*5:"%/--%*"E'5F"-.$-".$+"

&'6+/2*5*2".'E"6*'Q%/1*5$%"9'B*56$6&*"$62"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"$77*&-+":'069"4*'4%*"/6"T0-*5"<$+-"

;'62'6J"K'"$225*++"-./+>"-.*"-.*+/+"/6B*+-/9$-*+"-.*"E$:+"/6"E./&."-*55/-'5/$%"4'%/-/&+"'&&05"'6"

6$-/'6$%>"%'&$%>"/6+-/-0-/'6$%"$62"(/&5'"+&$%*+>"$62".'E"-.*+*"2/77*5*6-"+&$%*+"/6-*54*6*-5$-*"/6"

%'&$%"$44%/&$-/'6+"'7"-*55/-'5/$%"9'B*56$6&*J",+"4$5-"'7"-./+>"/-"*C4%'5*+".'E"&%$++*2"$62"5$&/$%"

&'2/69+"'7":'069"4*'4%*"$5*"4'%/&*2"-.5'09."*B*5"('5*"*%$1'5$-*"-*&.6'%'9/*+"'7"+'&/$%"

&'6-5'%J",+"/2*6-/7/*2"/6"'%2*5"%/-*5$-05*"'6":'0-."&5/(/6$%/-:"$62"2*%/6h0*6&:"G3'E6*+"!Peej"

_0(4.5/*+"!PV!I>"-.*"4'%/&*"+-/%%"4$-5'%"-.*"+-5**-+>"10-"-'2$:"-.*+*"-5$2/-/'6$%"7'5(+"'7"

+05B*/%%$6&*"$62"+'&/$%"&'6-5'%"$5*"$&&'(4$6/*2"1:"6*-E'5F+"'7"SSKc"&$(*5$+"GX5$.$("?@!@j"

#/6-'6"?@@PI"$62"-.*"*B*5"('5*"+'4./+-/&$-*2"$&&'06-/69"45'&*205*+"'7"%'&$%"4$5-6*5+./4+"

G+**"S.$4-*5"K.5**IJ"#'-/B$-*2"'5/9/6$%%:"1:"&'6&*56+"-.$-"B0%6*5$1%*":'069"4*'4%*"(/9.-"+%/4"

-.5'09."-.*"+'&/$%"+*5B/&*+"6*->"-./+"WH'/6*2Q04"-./6F/69Y".$+"%*2"-'"$44$5$-0+"E.*5*"

/67'5($-/'6"'6"-.*"4'-*6-/$%"&5/(/6$%/-:"'7":'069"4*'4%*"/+"+.$5*2"1*-E**6"+*5B/&*"45'B/2*5+J"

"

;$+-%:>"/-"$225*++*+".'E"-.*"401%/&"+4*62/69"&0-+"-.$-"+-$5-*2"/6"U*E.$("/6"?@@V".$B*"$77*&-*2"

-.*+*"7'5(+"'7"9'B*56$6&*"$62"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6J"A-"*C4%'5*+".'E"-.*"&0-+"%*2"-'"$6"/6&5*$+/69"

5*%/$6&*"'6"-.*"4'%/&*"$62"-'"$"2*7*6+/B*"6*'Q&'((06/-$5/$6"4'%/-/&+"G=*&F"?@@?j"=*&F"$62"

K/&F*%%"?@@?j"=05&*%%"?@@Oj"8E:69*2'0E"?@@@I>"1:"(*$6+"'7"E./&."-.*":'0-."&%01"/6&5*$+/69%:"

2*7/6*2"/-+"+*6+*"'7"-*55/-'5/$%"'52*5"-.5'09."-.*"7*$5"'7"E.$-"*C/+-*2"'0-+/2*"/-+"7*6&*"

G,6a$%2t$"?@@Mj"^%$F*%:"$62"86:2*5"!PPPj"^5'E6"?@!@j";'E"?@@Oj"R'+*"$62"#/%%*5"?@@Vj"

8*66*--"!PPOIJ"

Page 29: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?P"

"

='%/-/&+"

K./+"-.*+/+"$%+'"*69$9*+"E/-.":'069"4*'4%*Y+"4'%/-/&$%"$&-/'6+J"]5'("-.*"!Pe@+"'6E$52+>"$"

&'6+/+-*6-"7*$-05*"'7"*-.6'95$4./&"E'5F"'6":'069"4*'4%*".$+"1**6"$6"*69$9*(*6-"E/-."-.*"

4'%/-/&+"'7"*B*5:2$:"%/7*J"35$E/69"'6"#$5C/$6"$62"X5$(+&/$6"75$(/69+>"-.*+*"E'5F+"+'09.-"-'"

./9.%/9.-"-.*"7'5(+"'7"5*+/+-$6&*"-.$-":'069"4*'4%*"'77*5*2"-'"1'059*'/+"+:+-*(+"'7"+'&/$%"$62"

*&'6'(/&"&'6-5'%"G_$%%"*-"$%J"!PMeIJ";$5F/69"$1'0-"Gd/%%/+"!PMMI>"2*7:/69"-.*"4'%/&*"G_0(4.5/*+"

!PV!I"$62"2/+4%$:/69"+01&0%-05$%"2/+'52*5+"'7"+-:%*"$62"%$690$9*"G_*12/9*"!PMPj")'6*+"!PVVI"

E*5*"$%%"4$5-"'7"-./+"$6$%:+/+J"K.*"4'%/-/&+"'7":'069"4*'4%*".$+"$%+'"1**6"B/*E*2"$-"-.*"%*B*%"'7"

-.*"*B*5:2$:"g"-.*"*B*5:2$:"&.$%%*69*+"-'"'6-'%'9/&$%"'52*5"+0+-$/6*2"-.5'09."-.*"

&'(4%/&$-*2>"$(1/90'0+"$62"7%0/2"$&-+"'7"%/B/69"G,%*C$62*5"?@@@IJ"_'E*B*5>"E./%*"1'-."7'5(+"

'7"4'%/-/&+"$5*"/(4'5-$6-"7'5"$6"$6$%:+/+"'7":'069"4*'4%*>"-.*"/67%*C/1/%/-:"'7"#$5C/$6"$62"

X5$(+&/$6"-.*'5:"E.*6"$44%/*2"-'"U*E.$(Y+"(0%-/&0%-05*>"&'(1/6*2"E/-."-.*"

$7'5*(*6-/'6*2"2/77/&0%-:"'7"%/+-*6/69"-'"*B*5:2$:"4'%/-/&+"1*:'62"2*&'6+-50&-/'6>".$+"($2*"/-"

.$52"-'".*$5".'E":'069"4*'4%*Y+"45$&-/&*+"$62"45'20&-/'6+"&.$%%*69*"7'5(+"'7"+'&/$%"$62"

*&'6'(/&"/6H0+-/&*J"A6"/-+"4%$&*"$"6$55$-/B*"'7"&'62*(6$-/'6".$+"-$F*6"5''-J"]'%%'E/69"-.*"?@!!"

R/'-+>"-.*"%*7-"$62"-.*"5/9.->"5$-.*5"-.$6"*C$(/6/69"-.*"4'%/-/&$%"&'6-*6-"'7":'069"4*'4%*Y+"

$&-/'6+>"45*7*55*2"-'"4$-5'6/+*"-.*"45'-$9'6/+-+"1:"6$/%/69"-.*/5"$&-/'6+"-'"($+-+"'7"'B*5Q

&'(('2/7/&$-/'6"$62"6/./%/+("G^$0($6"?@!!j"8-$5F*:"?@!!IJ"

"

R*+4'62/69"-'"-./+"1'--%*6*&F>"-.*"-.*+/+"*C4%'5*+"-.*"4'%/-/&$%"$&-/'6"'7":'069"4*'4%*"-.5'09."

-.*/5"$&-+"'7"5*+/+-$6&*"$62"*B*5:2$:"+01B*5+/'6+>"10-"$%+'"-.5'09."-.*/5"5*7%*&-/B*"

&'6+&/'0+6*++"$62"4'%/-/&$%"&.$%%*69*+"-'"/6H0+-/&*J",&-+"'7"5*+/+-$6&*"2'"'7"&'05+*"+-/%%"*C/+-j"

-.*:"$5*"6*/-.*5"-5/-*"6'5"'0-('2*2"10-"/(4'5-$6-"$+4*&-+"'7":'069"4*'4%*Y+"2$/%:"45'-*+-+"

$9$/6+-"+'&/$%"&'6-5'%J")0+-"$+"5*+/+-$6&*"&'6-/60*+"-'"7%'05/+."+'"-''"2'"*B*5:2$:"$&-+"'7"

+01B*5+/'6"-.$-"('&F"-.*"'52*5+"1*/69"/(4'+*2"'6":'069"4*'4%*Y+"%/B*+J"8'%/2$5/-:>"75/*62+./4"

$62"&'%%*&-/B/-:"E'5F"$9$/6+-"-.*"&'2*+"'7"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"*(4%':*2"$5'062":'0-."&%01+J"3$/%:"

('B*(*6-+"/6>"'0-"$62"1*-E**6"+'&/$%"&$-*9'5/*+>"$62"(/&5'Q+'&/'%'9/&$%"$&-+"-.$-"&'670+*"

5*$2/69+"'7"-.*"2'(/6$6-"'52*5>"+.'E".'E"+'&/$%"&'6-5'%"/+"&'6-*+-*2>"$62"'7-*6"-.*"%*69-.+"-'"

E./&."$0-.'5/-/*+"E/%%"9'"-'"($/6-$/6"'52*5"/6"-.*"7$&*"'7"&.$'+J"d./%*"-.*"-.*+/+"*C4%'5*+"-.*+*"

4'%/-/&$%"$(1/-+>"/-"$%+'"*C-*62+"-.*+*"$6$%:+*+"-'"$6"$5*$"-.$-".$+"5*&*/B*2"%*++"$--*6-/'6"G+**"

S.$4-*5+"]'05"$62"]/B*IJ",9$/6+-"-.*"2/+&'05+*+"-.$-"+/%*6&*":'069"4*'4%*Y+"$&-/'6+"$+"+'%2Q'0-"

$62"6/./%/+-/&>"-.*"-.*+/+"*C4%'5*+"-.*"4'%/-/&$%"$62"(*$6/6970%"0+*"'7"+'%2Q'0-"&0%-05*"$62"

6/./%/+-"$*+-.*-/&+J"A-"6'-*+"-.$-"E./%*":'069"4*'4%*"4*57'5("-.*"$*+-.*-/&+"'7"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:>"

Page 30: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

O@"

"

-.*+*"&'2*+"$%+'"45'B/2*"B*./&%*+"-.5'09."E./&."7'5(+"'7"051$6"($59/6$%/-:"$5*"5*7%*&-*2"

04'6>"062*5+-''2>"$&-*2"$9$/6+->"$62"-.5'09."E./&."6*E".'5/a'6+"$5*"/($9/6*2J"

OJ S.$4-*5"'0-%/6*+"

K'"5*+4'62"-'"-.*+*"2*1$-*+"$62"'-.*5+>"-.*"-.*+/+"&'(45/+*+"7/B*"&.$4-*5+"$62"$"&'6&%0+/'6J"

]'%%'E/69"-.*"(*-.'2'%'9:>"-.*+*"$5*"2/B/2*2"/6-'"-.*($-/&"$5*$+"-.$-"&'6+/2*5"2/77*5*6-"

$+4*&-+"'7":'069"4*'4%*Y+"%/B*+"/6"T0-*5"<$+-";'62'6J"

"

S.$4-*5"T6*"45'B/2*+"$"2/+&0++/'6"'7"-.*"5*+*$5&."(*-.'2'%'9:J";'&$-*2"/6"$"-5$2/-/'6"'7"

4'%/-/&$%"^5/-/+."*-.6'95$4.:"-.$-"*C-*62+"75'("#$5C/$6"$62"X5$(+&/$6"E'5F+"-.5'09."&0%-05$%"

+-02/*+>"/-"2*-$/%+".'E"-.*"5*+*$5&."E$+"&$55/*2"'0-"$62"E.'"4$5-/&/4$-*2"/6"/-+"45'20&-/'6J"K./+"

&.$4-*5"2'*+"6'-"7'%%'E"-.*"-*(4%$-*"'7"W+$(4%/69Y>"W+/-*"+*%*&-/'6Y>"W9$-*F**4*5+Y"$62"

W*+-$1%/+./69"5$44'5-Y"*6&'05$9*2"1:"(*-.'2+"($60$%+>"5$-.*5"/-"'77*5+"$"2*-$/%*2"2/+&0++/'6"'7"

7/*%2E'5F"45$&-/&*+"$62"-.*"&'Q45'20&-/'6"'7"(*$6/69Q($F/69J"A-"$590*+"-.$-"7/*%2E'5F"

45$&-/&*+"5*7%*&-"-.*"(*++:"$62"06&*5-$/6"45'&*++"'7"*-.6'95$4.:"$62"-.$-"-.*:"+.'0%2"1*"

$--*6-/B*"-'"-.*"'4*5$-/'6"'7"4'E*5"/6"-.*"5*+*$5&."45'&*++"$62"$0-.'5/69"'7"-.*"7/6$%"$&&'06-J"

K.*"&.$4-*5"$590*+"-.$-"/6"'52*5"-'"%/+-*6"-'"&'6-*(4'5$5:"%/7*>"*4/+-*('%'9/&$%"7%*C/1/%/-:"/+"

5*h0/5*2J"K'"-./+"*62>"E/-./6"$"2/$%'9/&"75$(/69>"-.*"&.$4-*5"$2B'&$-*+"('B*+"1*-E**6"-.*"

(/&5'"$62"-.*"($&5'j"1*-E**6"-.*"+/690%$5"$62"-.*"(0%-/j"7'5"$6"$445*&/$-/'6"'7"./+-'5/&/-:"

'B*5"-.*"2'(/6$6&*"'7"-.*"45*+*6-j"$62"$"('B*"$E$:"75'("-.*"+01H*&-Q&*6-5*2"1'2:"-'"-.*"

$6$%:+/+"'7"&0%-05$%"'1H*&-+"$62"45'20&-/'6+J"K./+"/+"95'062*2"/6"$"&'((/-(*6-"-'"%/+-*6/69"

G^$&F"?@@MI"$62"-'"(*-.'2'%'9/&$%"($%%*$1/%/-:J";/+-*6/69"-'"-.*"G./22*6I"+-'5/*+"'7":'069"

4*'4%*Y+"%/B*+"$%+'"*6-$/%+"-.*"E/%%/696*++"-'"7'%%'E"-.*+*"B'/&*+"-.5'09."(*-.'2+"$62"

7/*%2E'5F"$445'$&.*+J"K/*2"-'"&'6+/2*5$-/'6"7'5"-.*"&'Q45'20&-/'6"'7"(*$6/69"($F/69>"-.*"

&.$4-*5"$%+'"45'B/2*+"$"2/+&0++/'6"'7"*-./&+>"6'-"$+"$"9*+-05*"-'E$52+"+-$-*(*6-+"'7"*-./&$%"

45$&-/&*"10-"$+"$6"$&F6'E%*29(*6-"'7"-.*"5*+*$5&.Y+"%'&$-/'6"/6"$"7/*%2"'7"&'Q&'6+-/-0-*2"

4*5+'6$%"./+-'5/*+"$62"7%0&-0$-/69"('5$%"'5/*6-$-/'6+J"TB*5$%%>"-.*"&.$4-*5"2*('6+-5$-*+"-.*"

6**2"7'5>"$62"$44%/&$-/'6"'7>"$"(*-.'2'%'9:"-.$-"('B*+"1*:'62"+-$62$52/+$-/'6"$62"-'E$52+"

5*7%*C/B/-:>"($%%*$1/%/-:"$62"%/+-*6/69"-'"-.*"'7-*6"./22*6"-'6*+"'7"*B*5:2$:"%/7*J"

"

]'%%'E/69"-.*"%/-*5$-05*"5*B/*E"$62"(*-.'2'%'9:"&.$4-*5>"-.*"-.*+/+"2*B*%'4+"-.5'09."7'05"

+01+-$6-/B*"&.$4-*5+"g"+-$5-/69"E/-."-.*"4$+-"$62"*62/69"E/-."-.*"70-05*J"

Page 31: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

O!"

"

"

S.$4-*5"KE'>"-.*"7/5+-"+01+-$6-/B*"&.$4-*5>"*69$9*+"E/-."-.*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"'7":'069"

4*'4%*"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+J"K.*"&.$4-*5"&'(4%/&$-*+"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"E./&."7/C"U*E.$("$+"

-.*".'(*"'7"-.*"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++J"K.5'09."$225*++/69"U*E.$(Y+"W95*$-"-/(*Y"G^$F.-/6"

!PVe1I"'7"2/$+4'5$>"(/95$-/'6"$62"('B*(*6-"/-"&.$%%*69*+"6'+-$%9/$+"7'5"-5$2/-/'6$%"<$+-"<62"

%/7*"$62"*C4%'5*+".'E"/-+"%'++"g"$++'&/$-*2"E/-."4'+-Q/620+-5/$%"2*&%/6*"$62"&'6-/60*2"

2*45/B$-/'6"g"&$(*"-'"1*"062*5+-''2"+/(0%-$6*'0+%:"-.5'09."E./-*6*++"$62"-.*"45*+*6&*"'7"

/((/95$6-+J"K.5'09."$6"*C4%'5$-/'6"'7".'E"E./-*6*++"/+"/6B*+-*2"/6"$62"-5$&*2"'B*5"-/(*>"-.*"

&.$4-*5"705-.*5"$225*++*+"-.*"(0-$1/%/-:"'7"/2*$+"'7"1*%'69/69"/6"U*E.$(J"A6"4$5-/&0%$5>"/-"

+.'E+".'E"-.*+*"7'5(+"'7"1*%'69/69"E*5*"('1/%/+*2"1:"E./-*>"1%$&F"$62",+/$6"(/95$6-+"'7"

2/77*5*6-"9*6*5$-/'6+J"R*&$%%/69"-.*"7'5($-/'6"'7"U*E.$("-.5'09."!N@":*$5+"'7"(/95$-/'6>"-.*"

&.$4-*5"*62+"1:"*C4%'5/69"-.*"&'6-*(4'5$5:"*C/+-*6&*"'7"2/$+4'5$"(6*('6/&+"$62"&'6+/2*5+"

.'E"-.*+*"7'5(+"'7"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+>"./22*6"1:"2/+&'05+*+"'6"E./-*6*++>"&.$%%*69*2"$62"

15'F*"2'E6"$0-'&.-.'6'0+"/2*$+"'7"1*%'69/69"$62"%*9/-/($&:J"K.*"'B*5$%%"$590(*6-"'7"

S.$4-*5"KE'"/+"7'5"$"5*70-$-/'6"'7"WX'%2*6"<5$Y"$&&'06-+"'7"<$+-";'62'6>"$"2**4*5"

062*5+-$62/69"'7"-.*"45'&*++*+"'7"W1*&'(/69"E./-*Y>"$62"$6"$445*&/$-/'6"7'5"-.*"*C/+-*6&*>"

$62"4'-*6-/$%"'7>"2/$+4'5$"(6*('6/&+J"

"

S.$4-*5"K.5**"*C4%'5*+"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"-*55/-'5:"/6"$62"$5'062";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01J"K.5'09."

$--*6-/'6"-'"-.*"+-5**-"$62"-.*":'0-."&%01"/-"*C4%'5*+".'E":'069"4*'4%*Y+"401%/&"+4$&*+"E*5*"

4'%/&*2"$62".'E"-.*:"E*5*"&5/(/6$%/+*2"-.5'09."-.*"&0-+"/6"401%/&"+4*62/69>"4$5-6*5+./4"

E'5F/69"$62"-.*"&'Q'4-/'6"'7"-.*"-./52"+*&-'5"/6"%'&$%"9'B*56$6&*J"K.*"&.$4-*5"064/&F+"-.*+*"

45'&*++*+"-.5'09."$"2/+&0++/'6"'7".'E"/6+/2*5+"$62"'0-+/2*5+>"&.$'+"$62"'52*5>"$62"+$7*-:"$62"

2$69*5"E*5*"0+*2"-'"&'6+-50&-"$62"6*9'-/$-*"%'&$%"-*55/-'5/*+"'6"2/77*5*6-"+&$%*+J"A-"/6B*+-/9$-*+"

-.*"4'+/-/'6/69"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01"$+"$"+$7*"+4$&*"7'5":'069"4*'4%*"$62"-.*"/6&5*$+/69"

/6B'%B*(*6-"'7"-.*"4'%/&*"/6"-.*":'0-."&%01"-.5'09."%'&$%"4$5-6*5+./4"/6/-/$-/B*+J"^0/%2/69"'6"

-./+"$6$%:+/+"'7"4'%/&/69"$62"+$7*-:>"/-"$225*++*+"-.*"2*B*%'4(*6-"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01"$+"$"6*'Q

&'((06/-$5/$6"/6+-/-0-/'6"$++'&/$-*2"E/-."/2*$%+"'7"$"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"4$+-"$62"-.*"4$5$%%*%"

7'5($-/'6"'7"5$&/$%/+*2"6'-/'6+"'7"&.$'+"$62"-.5*$-"1*:'62"-.*":'0-."&%01Y+"7*6&*J"_'E*B*5>"

-.*"&.$4-*5"$%+'"2*('6+-5$-*+".'E"-.*+*"4'%/-/&+"6**2"-'"1*"062*5+-''2"$-"-.*"%*B*%"'7"-.*"

(/&5'>"/6"$22/-/'6"-'"-.*"%'&$%>"6$-/'6$%"$62"/6+-/-0-/'6$%J"K'"-./+"*62>"/-"*69$9*+"E/-."-.*"E$:+"

-.$-"-.*+*"-*55/-'5/$%"4'%/-/&+"E*5*"&'Q&'6+-/-0-*2"-.5'09."7'5(+"'7"2/$%'90*>"/6"$62"$5'062"-.*"

:'0-."&%01J"TB*5$%%"-.*"&.$4-*5"$590*+"-.$-"-.5'09."-.*"&0-+"$62"/6&5*$+*2"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"

Page 32: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

O?"

"

:'069"4*'4%*"$5*"%/B/69"6*E"7'5(+"'7"-*55/-'5/$%"0675**2'(+>"-.$-"-*55/-'5/$%"4'%/-/&+"5*h0/5*+"$"

(0%-/Q+&$%*"$6$%:+/+>"$62"-.$-"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"-*55/-'5:"6**2+"-'"7'&0+"'6"-.*"(/&5'"/6"$22/-/'6"-'"

-.*"(*+'"$62"($&5'>"$62"'6"5$&*"$62"9*62*5"/6"$22/-/'6"-'"&%$++J"

"

S.$4-*5"]'05"*C4%'5*+"-.*"&%$/("-.$-":'069"4*'4%*Y+"401%/&"45'20&-/'6+"$5*"+'%2Q'0-"$62"

6/./%/+-/&J"R*7%*&-/69"'6"-.*"2/+&0++/'6"'7"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"1*906"/6"S.$4-*5"

K.5**>"/-"$590*+"-.$-"E./%*"-'"+'(*"*C-*6-"-./+"/+"-50*"g"/6"-.$-":'069"4*'4%*"($F*"0+*"'7"

&'((*5&/$%/+*2"9*65*+"'7"./4".'4"$62"6/./%/+-/&"$*+-.*-/&+"g"-.*"$5-"-.*:"45'20&*"/+"+-/%%"

(*$6/6970%"$62"4'%/-/&$%J"R*%$-/69"1$&F"-'"S.$4-*5"K.5**>"/-"$%+'"+.'E+".'E"-.*+*"45'20&-/'6+"

E*5*"0+*2"1'-."$+"$"+-5$-*9:"7'5"6$B/9$-/69"7'5(+"'7"($59/6$%/-:"$62"7'5"45'B/2/69"$"4'%/-/&$%"

B*./&%*"-.5'09."E./&."-.*"45'-$9'6/+-+"&'0%2"h0*+-/'6"-.*/5"($59/6$%/+$-/'6J"35$E/69"'6"

($-*5/$%"75'("$"+*5/*+"'7"&'%%$1'5$-/B*"(0+/&"B/2*'"$62"2$6&*"45'H*&-+>"/-"705-.*5"&'6+/2*5+"

.'E":'069"4*'4%*Y+"45$&-/&*+"/6B'%B*2"/6-*6+*"7'5(+"'7"%'&$%"$62"2/$+4'5/&"&'%%$1'5$-/'6"

$&5'++"-.*"1'062$5/*+"'7"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:"-.*:"&'((06/&$-*2J"A-"*C4%'5*+".'E"-.*"&%$/(+"-'"

5$&/$%"$0-.*6-/&/-:"$62"/6$0-.*6-/&/-:"&.$5$&-*5/+-/&"'7"-.*"+'%2Q'0-"$62"6/./%/+-/&"

&'62*(6$-/'6+"'7":'0-."&0%-05*"E*5*"15'F*6"2'E6"4*57'5($6&*+"$62"&/-$-/'6+"G^0-%*5"!PPOj"

X/%5':"!PPOIJ"K'"-./+"*62>"-.*"&.$4-*5"*C4%'5*+"-.*"$445'45/$-/'6"$62"&/-$-/'6"'7"9*62*5*2>"

&%$++*2"$62"5$&/$%/+*2"+/96/7/*5+"1*-E**6"-.*"[8"$62"-.*"[`>"$62".'E"-.*+*"E*5*"0+*2"-'"($F*"

+*6+*"'7"T0-*5"<$+-";'62'6J"_'E*B*5>"-.5'09."+.'E/69"-.*"5*7'5($-/'6"'7"-.*+*"&'2*+"$62"

-.*"15*$F2'E6"'7"45/'5"5$&/$%"'52*5+>"/-"2'*+"6'-"$590*"7'5"+/(4%*"&'6B/B/$%/-:>"5$-.*5"/-"

2/+&0++*+".'E"'%2"&'2*+"E*5*"5*&'67/905*2"-'"($F*"+*6+*"'7"%'&$%"5$&/$%/+*2"-*55/-'5/*+"$62"

+*C0$%"('5$%/-/*+J"TB*5$%%>"-.*"&.$4-*5"$590*+"-.$-"/6+-*$2"'7"&'62*(6/69":'069"4*'4%*Y+"

401%/&"45'20&-/'6+"$+"6/./%/+-/&"$62"+'%2Q'0->"/-"/+"('5*"/(4'5-$6-"-'"062*5+-$62".'E"/6"$"-/(*"

'7"&'((*5&/$%/+*2":'0-."&0%-05*"-.*"$*+-.*-/&+"'7"6/./%/+("45'B/2*2"$"B*56$&0%$5"7'5"

&'((06/&$-/'6"$62"4'%/-/&+"-.$-"$5*"(*$6/6970%"$62"4'%/-/&$%J"

"

S.$4-*5"]/B*>"-.*"7/6$%"+01+-$6-/B*"&.$4-*5>"$+F+".'E":'069"4*'4%*"45'H*&-"-.*/5"70-05*+J"

,225*++/69"-.*"$1+*6&*"'7"*-.6'95$4./&"+-02/*+"'7"-.*"70-05*>"-./+"&.$4-*5"/+"1$+*2"'6"($-*5/$%"

75'("4$5-/&/4$6-"'1+*5B$-/'6>"B/2*'"45'H*&-+"$62"/6-*5B/*E+"/6"E./&.":'069"4*'4%*"'7"2/77*5*6-"

(/95$-'5:"-5$H*&-'5/*+>"*-.6/&/-/*+"$62"&%$++"1$&F95'062+"45'H*&-*2"-.*/5"4*5+'6$%"$62"

&'%%*&-/B*".'5/a'6+J"K.*"&.$4-*5"1*9/6+"1:"$225*++/69".'E"+'(*":'069"4*'4%*"+*%7Q4'%/&*2"/6"

$&&'52$6&*"E/-."U*E";$1'05Y+"E./-*6*2">"(/22%*Q&%$++"W4'%/-/&+"'7"$+4/5$-/'6Y"GR$&'"?@@PI"$62"

.'E"-.*:"&'6+*h0*6-%:"45'H*&-*2"-.*/5"%/B*+"-.5'09."-.*"*20&$-/'6g45'7*++/'6$%g&'6+0(*5"

Page 33: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

OO"

"

-5$H*&-'5:J"]'&0+/69"'6"$"95'04"'7"^5/-/+.Q,%1$6/$6":'069"E'(*6>"/-"*C4%'5*+".'E"-.*:"

6$B/9$-*2"-./+"-5$H*&-'5:"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"$+"-.*:"6*9'-/$-*2"7'5(+"'7"^5/-/+.Q,%1$6/$6"

E'($6.''2J"A-"*C4%'5*+"-.*/5"$445'$&."-'"*20&$-/'6>"'&&04$-/'6>"&'6+0(4-/'6"$62"-.*"

$+4/5$-/'6$%"10/%-"*6B/5'6(*6-"'7"6*E"8-5$-7'52"K'E6J"8/-0$-/69"$+4/5$-/'6"$+"$"E./-*"(/22%*Q

&%$++"2/+&'05+*>"/-"$%+'"06&'B*5+"-.*"F/62+"'7"2/+Q/2*6-/7/&$-/'6+"G8F*99+"!PPMI"-.*+*":'069"

E'(*6"($2*>"1'-."5$&/$%/+*2"$62"&%$++*2>"/6"'52*5"-'"6$B/9$-*"-./+"45'H*&-/'6J"K.*"+*&'62"4$5-"

'7"-.*"&.$4-*5"%''F+"$-"-.*"7%/4"+/2*"'7"$+4/5$-/'6$%"2/+&'05+*"$225*++/69".'E"E./-*"(/22%*Q

&%$++"6'-/'6+"'7"$+4/5$-/'6"$5*"($/6-$/6*2"-.5'09."-.*"7'5*&%'+05*"'7"'-.*5":'069"4*'4%*Y+"

70-05*+J"A-"$%+'"*C4%'5*+".'E"E'5F/69Q&%$++"$62"6'-"E./-*"*6'09.":'069"4*'4%*"+*%7Q4'%/&*2"

-.*/5".'5/a'6+"$%'69"-.*"*20&$-/'6g45'7*++/'6$%g&'6+0(*5"-5$H*&-'5:"$62".'E"-.*:"45$&-/+*2"

-.*/5"'E6"7'5(+"'7"2/+Q/2*6-/7/&$-/'6"-'"*C4%$/6"-.*/5"+'&/$%"4'+/-/'6J"K.*"7/6$%"4$5-"'7"-.*"

&.$4-*5"*C4%'5*+"-.*"4'++/1/%/-:"'7".'5/a'6+"-.$-"%''F"1*:'62"-.*"2'(/6$6-"1/6$5:"'7"$+4/5$-/'6"

$62"($59/6$%/+$-/'6J"^0/%2/69"'6"-.*"2/+&0++/'6"$-"-.*"*62"'7"S.$4-*5"]'05>"/-"+.'E+".'E>"

&'6-5$5:"-'"-.*+*+"'6"-.*"2*$-."'7"0-'4/$+"&'6-$/6*2"/6"2/+&0++/'6+"'7"+'%2Q'0-"$62"6/./%/+-/&"

:'0-."&0%-05*>":'069"4*'4%*"45'H*&-*2"$%-*56$-/B*"70-05*+"-.5'09."-.*/5"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+J"

d./%*"-.*"45'20&-/'6+"E*5*"'7-*6"6*9$-/B*"/6"-'6*"$62"+'%2Q'0-"/6"9*65*"-.*:"$%+'"'77*5*2"$"

B*./&%*"7'5"5*7%*C/B*"&'6+&/'0+6*++"-.$-"&.$%%*69*2"+'&/$%"/6H0+-/&*+"$62"/($9/6*2"$%-*56$-/B*"

W-'Q&'(*+YJ"K.*"'B*5$%%"$590(*6-"'7"S.$4-*5"]/B*"/+"-.$-"$+4/5$-/'6$%"70-05*+"2*4*62"'6"-.*"

7'5*&%'+05*"'7"'-.*5"70-05*+>"10-"1*:'62"-./+"/-"/+"4'++/1%*"-'"2/+&*56>"-.5'09."$6"$6$%:+/+"'7"

&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6>".'E":'069"4*'4%*"45'H*&-*2"$%-*56$-/B*+"1*:'62"-./+"7$-$%/+-/&"1/6$5:J"

"

K.*"-.*+/+"&'6&%02*+"1:"5*-056/69"-'"-.*"F*:"2*1$-*+"2/+&0++*2"/6"-.*"/62/B/20$%"&.$4-*5+"$62"

1:"5*+/-0$-/69"-.*+*"2*1$-*+"E/-./6"-.*"5*+*$5&."&'6-*C-J"R*+4'62/69"-'"*6h0/5/*+"'6"-.*"

E/2*5"4'%/-/&$%"(*5/-"'7"-.*"-.*+/+>"/-"*62+"1:"($F/69"+'(*"E/2*5"4'%/-/&$%"4'/6-+"E/-."5*9$52"-'f"

-.*"/(4*5$-/B*"'7"$225*++/69"^5/-$/6Y+"&.$69/69"051$6"(0%-/&0%-05*j"-.*"&'6-/60*2"$%%05*"'7"

E./-*6*++j"-.*"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"'7":'069"4*'4%*j"$62"-.*"5*h0/5*(*6-"-'"

'4*6"'05"*$5+"-'"-.*"4'%/-/&$%"&'6-*6-"'7":'069"4*'4%*Y+"$5-/+-/&"E'5F+J"

"

K.5'09."$6"*69$9*(*6-"E/-."$1'0-"$".0625*2":'069"4*'4%*>"-./+"-.*+/+"-*%%+"$"+-'5:"'7"

($59/6$%/-:>"(0%-/&0%-05*"$62"4'%/-/&+"/6"T0-*5"<$+-";'62'6"$-"-.*"1*9/66/69"'7"-.*"+*&'62"

2*&$2*"'7"-.*"-E*6-:Q7/5+-"&*6-05:J"K./+"+-'5:"1*9/6+>"/6"-.*"6*C-"&.$4-*5>"E/-."$"

(*-.'2'%'9/&$%"2/+&0++/'6"'7"*-.6'95$4./&"45'20&-/'6+"'7"-.*"*B*5:2$:J"

Page 34: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

O\"

"

S.$4-*5"T6*"g"<-.6'95$4./&"45'20&-/'6+"'7"-.*"*B*5:2$:"

#*-.'2'%'9:"&.$4-*5+"$5*"2*+/96*2"-'"&*(*6-"$6"/%%0+/'6"'7"-50-.J"K.*:"$5*"2*+/96*2"-'"

$0-.'5/+*>"-.5'09."7'5(0%$/&"45'&*205*>"-.*"45'&*++"1:"E./&."$6"062*5+-$62/69"'7"5*$%/-:"/+"

*-./&$%%:"$--$/6*2J"8/-*+>"9$-*F**4*5+>"$&&*++>"5$44'5->"5*7%*C/B/-:"$62"*-./&+"$5*"1*$0-/70%%:"%$/2"

'0-"$+"-*+-$(*6-"-'"$0-.'5/-:"'6"$"+01H*&-"'7"&.'/&*J"A6"-./+"&.$4-*5>"-.*"7/*%2"6'-*+>"/6-*5B/*E+>"

4$5-/&/4$6-"-*&.6/h0*+"$62"7/*%2"*6&'06-*5+"2'"6'-"&'67'5("-'"+0&."2*Q.0($6/+/69"6*$-6*++J"

"

R*+4*&-/69"-.*"06/h0*"&'6-*C-"'7"-.*"5*+*$5&."'0-%/6*2"/6"-.*"A6-5'20&-/'6>"-./+"&.$4-*5"

2*+&5/1*+"$"(*-.'2'%'9/&$%"$445'$&."-.$-"+'09.-"-'"%/+-*6>"$62"5*+4'62"-'>"-.*"/55*20&/1/%/-:"'7"

-.*"7/*%2J"A6"+'"2'/69>"/-"&'(4%/&$-*+"-.*"5*$%/+(>"+-$62$52/+$-/'6>"4'+/-/B/+("$62"204%/&/-:"-.$-"

/+"45*B$%*6-"/6",9'(='()!$62"5%'()"*-.6'95$4.:"G,%*C$62*5"?@@OIJ"K.5'09."$"2*-$/%*2"

2/+&0++/'6"'7"7/*%2E'5F"$62"(*$6/69Q($F/69"45$&-/&*+"/-"$590*+"-.$-"*-.6'95$4.:"/+"$"(*++:"

$62"06&*5-$/6"45'&*++"-.$-"$--$/6+"$"45'1%*($-/&"7/C*26*++"-.5'09."-.*"*-.6'95$4.*5Y+"4*6J"

35$E/69"'6"-E'":*$5+Y"*-.6'95$4./&"*6h0/5:"/6"-.5**"<$+-";'62'6":'0-."&%01+>"/-"2/+&0++*+"

&.$69*+"/6"-.*"5*+*$5&."7'&0+"$62"-.*"45'1%*(+"'7"&'6&*/B/69"*B*5:2$:"%/7*"-.5'09."45*Q

&'6&*/B*2"75$(*+J"A-"+.'E+".'E"-.*"*B*5:2$:"%/7*"'7":'069"4*'4%*"/6"U*E.$(>"-.'09."

+-50&-05*2"1:"('6'%'9/&"2/+&'05+*+>"E$+"4%05$%"$62"/55*20&/1%*j".'E":'069"4*'4%*Y+"%/B*+"E*5*"

+'(*-/(*+"1*+-"062*5+-''2"'0-+/2*"'7"-.*"4.*6'(*6'%'9/+-Y+"+01H*&-"&*6-5*2"1'2:j"$62>".'E"

-./+"*-.6'95$4.:"6*&*++/-$-*2"$6"$445*&/$-/'6"'7"(0%-/Q+/-*2"+'&/$%"4.*6'(*6$J"

"

K'"-*%%"-./+"+-'5:>"-.*"&.$4-*5"/+"2/B/2*2"/6-'"7/B*"+*&-/'6+J"K.*"7/5+-"+*&-/'6"'6"W-./6F/69"

*-.6'95$4./&$%%:Y"$225*++*+"-.*"('B*"75'("5*$%/+-"$&&'06-+"'7"(*$6/69"-'"4'+-Q+-50&-05$%"

+-'5/*+>"2/$%'9/&"/($9/6$-/'6+"$62"-.*"$6$%:+/+"'7"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+J"K./+"+*&-/'6"&5/-/h0*+"

.'E"5*45*+*6-$-/'6+"'7"(*$6/69"$62"-*&.6/h0*+"'7"$0-.'5/-:"$5*"+0+-$/6*2>"$62"$2B'&$-*+"$6"

$445'$&."-'"W-./6F/69"*-.6'95$4.:Y"-.$-"/+"5*+4'6+/B*"-'"-.*"4%05$%/-:"'7"*B*5:2$:"%/7*J"K.*"

+*&'62>"-./52"$62"7'05-."+*&-/'6+"10/%2"'6"-.*+*"$590(*6-+"-'"$225*++"-.5**"F*:"

(*-.'2'%'9/&$%"45'1%*(+"*6&'06-*5*2"/6"-./+"-.*+/+f"-.*"5*45*+*6-$-/'6"'7"W5*$%Y"(*$6/69"/6"

-.*"*-.6'95$4./&"-*C-j"-.*"1*%/*7"/6"*(1'2/*2"-50-.+"%'&$-*2"/6"7/C*2"+4$&*+"G$6-.5'4'%'9/&$%"

-50-.+Ij"$62>"-*&.6/h0*+"'7"$0-.'5/-:"0+*2"-'"+0+-$/6"$"1*%/*7"/6"E.$-"/+"W5*$%YJ"

Page 35: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

ON"

"

"

84*&/7/&$%%:>"-.*"+*&'62"+*&-/'6"10/%2+"'6"-.*"7/5+-"-.5'09."$"2/+&0++/'6"'7"*B*5:2$:"%/7*"G2*"

S*5-*$0"!PV\I"$62"-.*"$(1/90/-/*+"'7"-.*"&$56/B$%*+h0*"G^$F.-/6"!PV\IJ"A6-5'20&/69"-.*"

*-.6'95$4.:Y+"*6&'06-*5"E/-."5*+*$5&."h0*+-/'6+>"/-"+.'E+".'E"-.*"5*h0/5*(*6-"-'"4/6"-.*"

45'H*&-"2'E6"-'"45*Q7'5(0%$-*2"%/6*+"'7"*6h0/5:"2/2"6'-"&'55*+4'62"-'"-.*"4%05$%/-:"'7"-.*"

*-.6'95$4./&"*6&'06-*5J";*$B/69"-.*"5*+*$5&."h0*+-/'6+"1*./62>"/-"+-5*++*+"-.*"2/$%'9/&$%"

6$-05*"'7"5*+*$5&."$62"$590*+"7'5"-.*"2*&'6+-50&-/'6"'7"('6'%'9/&"062*5+-$62/69+"'7"-.*"

*B*5:2$:>"E./&."$5*"+'"45*B$%*6-"/6"$&&'06-+"'6":'069"4*'4%*J"K.*"-./52"+*&-/'6"2/+&0++*+"+/-*"

+*%*&-/'6"$62"h0*+-/'6+".'E"W5*$%/-:Y"5*%$-*+"-'"1'062*2"-/(*"$62"+4$&*J"K.5'09."/6-5'20&/69"

-.*"7/*%2E'5F"+/-*+"$62"-.*6"2/+&0++/69"-.*"6*&*++/-:"7'5"$"(0%-/Q+/-*2"*4/+-*('%'9:>"-.*"

+*&-/'6"*69$9*+"E/-."2*1$-*+"'6"+4$-/$%"$62"-*(4'5$%"2*($5&$-/'6+"'7"*-.6'95$4./&"-50-.J"

d/-."5*&'05+*"-'"7/*%2"H'056$%+>"/-"$590*+"-.$-"5$-.*5"-.$6"B/*E"-.*":'0-."&%01"'6%:"/6"5*+-5/&-*2"

+4$-/'Q-*(4'5$%"-*5(+>"-.*":'0-."&%01"+.'0%2"$%+'"1*"+**6"$+"$"B*./&%*"'7"-5$B*%"$62"

2/+4%$&*(*6-"-'"E/2*5"&'6+-*%%$-/'6+"'7"-/(*"$62"+4$&*J"K.*"7'05-."+*&-/'6"'6"W2'/69"

*-.6'95$4.:Y"2/+&0++*+"7/*%2E'5F"45$&-/&*+"1:"('B/69"$E$:"75'("-.*"7'5(0%$/&"-$0-'%'9/*+"'7"

-.*"(*-.'2+"1''F+"G_$((*5+%*:"$62",-F/6+'6"!PPNj"=$--'6"?@@?IJ"R$-.*5"-.$6"$0-.'5/+*"$"

7$&-0$%"$&&'06-"'7"-.*"W5*$%"E'5%2Y>"-./+"+*&-/'6"25$E+"75'("-.*"7/*%2"H'056$%+"-'"+.'E"-.*"($6:"

E$:+"-.$-"-$%*+"75'("-.*"7/*%2"&$6"1*"-'%2"$62"5*$2j"-'"+.'E".'E"*B*6-+"$5*"&'Q45'20&*2"

E/-./6"&*5-$/6"5*&*4-/B*"+4$&*+j".'E"7/*%2"+/-*+"$62"+4$&*+"/6-*54*6*-5$-*j"$62".'E"7/*%2E'5F"

45$&-/&*+"E*5*"7'5(*2"-.5'09."l&'(4%*C"H029*(*6-+"E/-."(:5/$2"&'6-/69*6&/*+n"GR'+$%2'"

!PPO>"4J!!MIJ"K.*"7/6$%"+*&-/'6"/+"$"2/+&0++/'6"'7"-.*"*-./&$%"+4$&*+"/6"E./&."-.*"5*+*$5&."E$+"

45'20&*2"$62"45'20&-/B*J"A-"$590*+"7'5"$"2/$%'9/&$%"$62"(/&5'Q+'&/'%'9/&$%"G^$F.-/6"!PPOj"

^*62*5"!PPVI"$445*&/$-/'6"'7"*-./&+"5$-.*5"-.$6"$"5'0-/6*"$&&'06-"'7"6'5($-/B*"45'7*++/'6$%"

45'&*205*j"$62"7'5"$"5*&'96/-/'6"'7"&'(4%*C"B$5/$-/'6+"'7"&'(4%/&/-:"$62"G2/+I&'(7'5-"/6"-.*"

*-.6'95$4./&"*6&'06-*5J"

"

K.*"&.$4-*5"&'6&%02*+"1:"$590/69"-.$-"*-.6'95$4./&"(*-.'2+"&.$4-*5+"+.'0%2"&5/-/&$%%:"5*7%*&-"

-.*"7/*%2E'5F"$62"$0-.'5/$%"45'&*++"-.5'09."E./&."-.*:"$5*"45'20&*2J"8-$62$52/+$-/'6"

*6&'05$9*2"1:"(*-.'2+"1''F+"2'*+"2/++*5B/&*"-'"-.*"4%05$%"45'&*++*+"'7"+'&/$%"45'20&-/'6J"

K./+"&.$4-*5"*69$9*+"E/-."-.*"6**2"-'"$225*++"-.*"4%05$%/-:"'7"*B*5:2$:"%/7*J"R$-.*5"-.$6"

$2B'&$-*"$"'6*"+/a*"7/-+"$%%"('2*%"'7"+'&/$%"/6h0/5:>"/-"$590*+"7'5"$"2/$%'9/&$%"$445'$&."-'"

(*-.'2+"($%%*$1%*"-'"-.*"+'&/$%"$62"&0%-05$%"&'6-*C-"/6"E./&."-.*"*-.6'95$4.:"/+"*(1*22*2"

$62"$%/B*"-'"-.*"6*9'-/$-/'6"'7"4'E*5"/6.*5*6-"/6"/-+"45'20&-/'6J"

Page 36: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

Oe"

"

!J <9'(='()"*-.6'95$4./&$%%:f"75'("5*$%/+("-'"2/$%'90*"

K./+"7/5+-"+*&-/'6"2/+&0++*+"-.*"2*B*%'4(*6-"'7"*-.6'95$4./&"-./6F/69J"K'"2'"+'"/-"('B*+"75'("

&'%'6/$%"-50-.+"-'"-.*"45/6&/4%*+"'7"2/$%'90*"+044'5-*2"1:"-./+"-.*+/+"/6"E./&."*-.6'95$4.:"/+"

&'6+/2*5*2"$+"$"&'Q45'20&*2"7/&-/'6"$62"$"5*7%*C/B*"-''%"'7"+'&/$%"/6h0/5:J",%'69"-./+"-5$H*&-'5:"/-"

$225*++*+"B$5/'0+"2*1$-*+"'6"*-.6'95$4.:"/6"+'&/'%'9:"$62"$6-.5'4'%'9:"/6&%02/69"&5/-/h0*+"'7"

6$-05$%/+("$62"5*$%/+("$62"*-.6'95$4.:Y+"&'6-5/10-/'6"-'"+'&/$%"H0+-/&*J"A-"*62+"1:"$590/69"7'5"

$6"*-.6'95$4./&"$445'$&."-.$-"6'-"'6%:"-$F*+"'6"1'$52"&'6&*56+"7'5"-.*"&'Q45'20&-/'6"'7"

(*$6/69"$62"-.*"/(4'5-$6&*"'7"+'&/$%"H0+-/&*>"10-"$%+'"7'5"2/$%'90*"1*-E**6"-*C-0$%"$62"

4.*6'(*6'%'9/&$%"$445'$&.*+J"

"

8/6&*"c/&-'5/$6"&'%'6/$%"-/(*+>"<$+-";'62'6"4'40%$-/'6+".$B*"1**6"-.*"+/-*+"'7"$6-.5'4'%'9/&$%"

*6h0/5:J"[51$6"$6-.5'4'%'9/+-+"+0&."$+"^''-."G!VP@I>"8/(+"G!VVOI"$62"#$:.*E"G!Ve!I"

*(4%':*2"-.*"5$&/$%/+*2"$62"&%$++*2"&'2*+"'7"&'%'6/$%"50%*"-'"2'&0(*6-"-.*"2/5-:QE./-*"

4'40%$-/'6+"'7"-.*"<$+-"<62"G^'66*--"?@@@IJ"R*+/2/69"-'"-.*"*$+-"'7"-.*"#*-5'4'%/-$6"3/+-5/&-"'7"

;'62'6>"-.*"4'40%$-/'6+"'7"-.*+*"W06F6'E6Y"$62"W06*C4%'5*2Y"Gd/%%/$(+"!PMO>"4J??!I"-*55$/6+"

E*5*"*h0$-*2"E/-."(*6$&*>"7/%-."$62"*C&5*(*6-"G_0(4.5/*+"!PV!>"4J!!j"U$:$F"?@@O>"44JMeg

MMIj"-*5(*2"W+%0("('6F*:+Y>"W150-$%"+$B$9*+Y"$62"W$4*+Yj"$62"&'(4$5*2"E/-."l45/(/-/B*"

+*C0$%/-:>"-5/1$%"+$B$9*5:>"1*+-/$%/-:"$62"4%$/6"1'B/6*"+-04/2/-:n"G_0(4.5/*+"!PV!>"4J!!IJ",+"E/-."

-.*/5"&'%'6/$%"$6$%'90*+"G#$%/6'E+F/"?@@?I"-.*+*"$&&'06-+"E*5*"45*+*6-*2"$+"6$-05$%"-50-.+"

2*-$&.*2"75'("-.*"45'20&-/B*"4'E*5"'7"-.*"E./-*"1'059*'/+"5*+*$5&.*5J"

"

A6"-.*"!P?@+"$62"!PO@+"-.*+*"4+*02'Q*-.6'95$4./&"$445'$&.*+"-'"051$6";'62'6"E*5*"/670+*2"

E/-."+&/*6-/7/&"2'&-5/6*"-.5'09."R'1*5-"=$5FY+"S./&$9'"8&.''%J"K.*"S./&$9'"+&.''%"+'&/'%'9/+-+"

E*5*"6'-"+**F/69"-'"2/+&'B*5"2/+&5*-*"$6-.5'4'%'9/&$%"&0%-05*+j"5$-.*5>"$+"W6$-/B*+Y"'7"-.*"&/-:"

G3$B/*+"!PPP>"4JM@I"$62"4'+/-/B/+-"5*$%/+-+>"-.*:"+'09.-"-'"+&/*6-/7/&$%%:"'1+*5B*"$62"2'&0(*6-"

-.*/5"+01H*&-+Y"%/7*QE'5%2+J"K.*"S/-:"'7"S./&$9'"E$+"-.*/5"W%$1'5$-'5:Y"$62"-.*"+-50&-05*+"-.*:"

7'062"-.*5*"E*5*"5*$2"$+"+'&/$%"7$&-+J"A6"-.*"[`>"-.*+*"*-.6'95$4./*+"7'062"-.*/5"<$+-";'62'6"

$6$%'90*+"/6"-.*"4'+-QE$5"+'&/$%"+05B*:+"'7"d/%%('--"$62"Z'069"Gd/%%('--"!PeO>"!PePj"Z'069"

$62"d/%%('--"!PNMIJ"

"

305/69"-.*"!Pe@+>"-.*+*"7'5(+"'7"+'&/'%'9/&$%"$62"$6-.5'4'%'9/&$%"*-.6'95$4.:"&$(*"062*5"

/6-*545*-/B/+-"$--$&F"15'09.-"$1'0-"1:"-.*"$44%/&$-/'6"'7"4.*6'(*6'%'9:"$62".*5(*6*0-/&+"-'"

*-.6'95$4.:"G^%0(*5"!PePj"X**5-a"!PMOj"R'&F"!PMPIJ"K.*+*"15$6&.*+"'7"4./%'+'4.:"&.$%%*69*2"

Page 37: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

OM"

"

-.*"6$-05$%/+-"$62"5*$%/+-"$++0(4-/'6+"'7"-.*"*$5%/*5"E'5F"g"-.$-"-.*"+'&/$%"E'5%2"'7"

$6-.5'4'%'9/&$%%:"W45/(/-/B*Y"$62"+'&/'%'9/&$%%:"W+01$%-*56Y"4*'4%*"&'0%2"1*"062*5+-''2"$+"7$&-+"

'5"-.5'09."50%*+J"K.*+*"E'5F+"&'6-*62*2"-.$-"+'&/$%"E'5%2+"E*5*"%/B*2"$62"F6'E6"$+"

+01H*&-/B*"*C4*5/*6&*+"$62"/6-*545*-$-/'6+"'7"5*$%/-:J"K.*:"$590*2"-.$-"-.*"+01H*&-/B*"

/6&'54'5$-*2"-.*"'1H*&-/B*"$62"1*&$(*"$"4*5+'6Y+"5*$%/-:"$62"-./+"/(4%/*2"-.*5*"E$+"6'"

+*4$5$-*"5*$%/-:"$+"/6"*$5%/*5"$&&'06-+J"A6"4$5-/&0%$5>"-.*"$44%/&$-/'6"'7"4./%'+'4./&$%"

.*5(*6*0-/&+"25*E"$--*6-/'6"-'"-.*"/6-*5Q2*4*62*6-"5*%$-/'6+./4+"1*-E**6"-.*"/6-*545*-$-/'6"

'7"-.*"+'&/$%"E'5%2"$62"-.*"*C4*5/*6&*"'7"/-J"A-"($2*"B/+/1%*"l-.*"&5*$-/B*"45'&*++*+"m"1:"E./&."

W&0%-05$%"'1H*&-+"rE*5*s"/6B*6-*2"$62"-5*$-*2"$+"(*$6/6970%n"GS%/77'52"!PVV>"4JOVIJ"K./+"E$+"

&0%-05*"$+"-*C-"G3/%-.*:"!PPej"X**5-a"!PMOIf"l-.*"/6-*545*-$-/'6"'7"-.*"E5/--*6"2'&0(*6-+"'7"

'05"&0%-05*n"GR/&u05"!PMO>"4JP!IJ"

"

K.5'09."-.*"!PM@+"$62"!PV@+>"+'&/'%'9:"$62"$6-.5'4'%'9:"&'6-/60*2"-'"5*$&-"$9$/6+-"-.*"

6$-05$%/+("'7"*$5%/*5"$&&'06-+J"A6"^5/-$/6>"051$6"*-.6'95$4.:"E$+"1*/69"$2B$6&*2"062*5"-.*"

/67%0*6&*"'7"+-50&-05$%"#$5C/+(>"$62"X5$(+&/$6"-.*'5/*+"'7".*9*('6:"$62"&'6+*6-J"K.*+*"

+-02/*+"*C4%'2*2"-.*"5*$%/+-"*-.6'95$4./&"+/-*"1:"15/69/69"/-"/6-'"&'6-$&-"E/-."-.*"($&5'"

+-50&-05*+"'7"9%'1$%"&$4/-$%/+("GS'.*6"!PM?j"S'55/9$6"!PMPj"d/%%/+"!PMMIJ"K.*:"$%+'"2*B*%'4*2"

&'6&*56+"7'5"+'&/$%"H0+-/&*"$+"-.*"/(4%/&$-/'6+"'7"1'059*'/+"4'E*5"$62".*9*('6:>"$-"%'&$%"$62"

9%'1$%"%*B*%+>"E*5*"$225*++*2J!N"]05-.*5"&.$%%*69*+"-'"5*$%/+("$62"6$-05$%/+("/6"*-.6'95$4.:"

&$(*"-.5'09."-.*"&/B/%"5/9.-+"B/&-'5/*+"/6"-.*"[8"$62"-.*"2/++'%0-/'6"'7"*(4/5*+"GS%/77'52"!PVV>"

4J??IJ"K.*'5/+-+"G^$F.-/6>"^$5-.*+>"2*"S*5-*$0>"3*55/2$>"]'0&$0%->"8$/2I"2*&'6+-50&-*2"$62"5*Q

+-50&-05*2"2'(/6$6-"7'5(+"'7"F6'E%*29*>"(*$6/69"$62"4'E*5J"`6'E%*29*"E$+"062*5+-''2"-'"

*C/+-"/6"+4*&/7/&"./+-'5/&$%"5*%$-/'6+"'7"2'(/6$6&*"$62"2/$%'90*"GS%/77'52"!PVV>"4J?OIJ"d.$-"E$+"

W5*$%Y"/6"+'&/$%"5*+*$5&."E$+"$"50+*"'7"4'E*5"-'"'B*5&'(*"$62"&'6-5'%".:15/2/-:"G^.$1.$"!PP\IJ"

S0%-05*"$62"/2*6-/-:"E*5*"7'5(*2"/6"(0%-/4%*"%'&$-/'6+>"$62"&5'++Q&0-"1:"4'E*5"5*%$-/'6+J"A6"

-./+"E$:>"$6-.5'4'%'9/+-+"$62"+'&/'%'9/+-+"$%/F*"E*5*"7'5&*2"-'"*B$%0$-*"-.*"*++*6-/$%/+/69"

2/+4'+/-/'6+"'7"-.*/5"45*2*&*++'5+"$62"&'6+/2*5".'E"-.*/5"E'5F"$%+'"04.*%2".*9*('6/&"4'E*5"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!N"d.*5*$+"+'&/$%"H0+-/&*".$+"$%+'"1**6"$"&'6&*56"'7"[8"+'&/'%'9:>"5*&*6-"E'5F+".$B*"1**6"&.$5$&-*5/+*2"

1:"%/1*5$%"('5$%/+("G,62*5+'6"!PPPj"306*/*5"$62"S$5-*5"?@@!j"306*/*5"$62"^$&F"?@@ej"+**"7'5"$"&5/-/h0*"

d$&h0$6-"?@@?I"$62"5'($6-/&"%'&$%"$6$%:+*+"Gc*6F$-*+."?@@@>"?@@VIJ"^'-."-5$2/-/'6+"$5*"4$5-"'7"E/2*5"

%/1*5$%>"('5$%/+-"$62"5'($6-/&/+-"-5*62+"/6"[8"051$6"+'&/'%'9:"G;/*1'E"!PeMj"8$(4+'6"*-"$%J"!PPMj"8-J"

)*$6"?@@Mj"d.:-*"!P\OI"%$59*%:"2*-$&.*2"75'("$"^5/-/+."#$5C/$6"4*5+4*&-/B*"-.$-"&.$%%*69*+"+-50&-05$%"

'445*++/'6J"

Page 38: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

OV"

"

G,+$2"!PVej"S%/77'52"!PVVj"2*"S*5-*$0"!PV\j"#$5&0+"!PVej"R'+$%2'"!PPOj"8$/2"!PMVIJ"K.*:"

E*5*"$+F*2"-'"h0*+-/'6"6'-"H0+-"-.*"/6-*545*-$-/'6"'7"(*$6/69"10-"$%+'"-.*"E$:"-.*:"E5'-*"

$1'0-"/-"G#$5&0+"$62"S0+.($6"!PV?>"4JNMIJ"

"

_'E>"45*&/+*%:>"/+"$"9$550%'0+>"'B*5"2*-*5(/6*2>"&5'++"&0%-05$%"*6&'06-*5"+.'-"-.5'09."E/-."4'E*5"5*%$-/'6+"$62"4*5+'6$%"&5'++Q4054'+*+"&/5&0(+&5/1*2"$+"$6"$2*h0$-*"B*5+/'6"'7"$"('5*Q'5Q%*++"2/+&5*-*"W'-.*5"E'5%2>Y"&'(4'+*2"1:"$6"/62/B/20$%"$0-.'5i"GS%/77'52"!PVO>"4J!?@I"

"

K.*+*"&'6&*56+"E*5*"705-.*5"5*7%*&-*2"/6"^5/-/+."&0%-05$%"+-02/*+"$+"-.*"&'(4%/&/-:"'7"-.*"

*-.6'95$4.*5Y+"4*6"E/-."5$&/+("$62"*(4/5*"E$+"+&50-/6/+*2"G^$&F"?@@O1j"X/%5':"!PVM>"!PPOj"

;$E5*6&*"!PV?$IJ"

"

3*B*%'4/69"7'5(*5"#$C/$6"$62"X5$(+&/$6"4$5$2/9(+>"_$%%Y+"E'5F"'6"W6*E"*-.6/&/-/*+Y"G_$%%"

!PP?I"&.$%%*69*2"W'%2Y"*-.6/&/-/*+"$62"*++*6-/$%/+*2"B*5+/'6+"'7"4'%/-/&$%"/2*6-/-:"&'((06/-/*+"

G,%*C$62*5"?@@O>"4J!OMIj"-.*(*+"-.$-"E*5*"%$-*5"*C4%'5*2"/6"^$&FY+"&'(4$5$-/B*"*-.6'95$4./&"

$&&'06-"'7"-E'";'62'6":'0-."&%01+"G^$&F"!PP\IJ"K.*+*"^5/-/+."E'5F+"5*&'96/+*2"-.*"

l*C-5$'52/6$5:"2/B*5+/-:"'7"+01H*&-/B*"4'+/-/'6+>"+'&/$%"*C4*5/*6&*+"$62"&0%-05$%"/2*6-/-/*+n"G_$%%"

!PP?>"4J?N\I>"$62"-.*"'B*5%$44/69"-*55/-'5/*+"'7"*-.6/&/-:>"/6&%0+/'6"$62"*C&%0+/'6"G^$&F"!PP\IJ"

A6"$22/-/'6"-'"5*E'5F/69"$5-/&0%$-/'6+"'7"5$&*"$62"&%$++>"-./+"E'5F"E$+"$"2/5*&-"&.$%%*69*"-'"

7'5(+"'7"+'&/'%'9:"-.$-"&'6-/60*2"-'"1*"&'6&*56*2"E/-."$6-.5'4'%'9/&$%"$&&'06-+"'7"^5/-/+."

051$6"%/7*"GS$+.('5*"!PMPj"#'2''2"!PP?j"=5:&*"!PVej"K5':6$"!PMPIJ"

"

=./%'+'4./&$%".*5(*6*0-/&+".$2"$%5*$2:"+./7-*2"-.*"*-.6'95$4./&"*(4.$+/+"75'("*C4*5/*6&*"

$62"/6-*545*-$-/'6"'7"(*$6/69"1:"'-.*5+"-'"/6-*52*4*62*6-"/6-*545*-$-/'6+"1*-E**6"

*-.6'95$4.*5+"$62"'-.*5+J"_'E*B*5>"E.*5*$+"X**5-aY+"/6-*545*-/B/+-"$6-.5'4'%'9:".$2"

$225*++*2"-.*"/6-*545*-$-/'6"'7"-.*"W-*C-Y"'7"&0%-05*+>"$62"/6"-./+"E$:"&5/-/h0*2"-.*"5*$%/+("'7"

*$5%/*5"$&&'06-+>"./+"5*45*+*6-$-/B*"-*C-"+-/%%"1$6/+.*2"-.*"2/$%'9/&$%"$62"+/-0$-/'6$%"$+4*&-+"'7"

*-.6'95$4./&"/6-*545*-$-/'6"G^$F.-/6"!PV!j"S%/77'52"!PVV>"4J\@IJ"35$E/69"'6"^$F.-/6>"S%/77'52"

+./7-*2"-.*"*(4.$+/+"75'("/6-*545*-$-/'6"-'"45'20&-/'6"GS%/77'52"!PVe$>"4J!OI>"$62"/6"4$5-/&0%$5"

-'"-.*"$0-.'5/-:"'7"-.*"*-.6'95$4.*5Y+"4*6"/6"-.*"7/6$%"$&&'06-J"S%/77'52Y+"E'5F"25*E"'6"%/-*5$5:"

-.*'5:"G^$F.-/6"!PV\I"$62"./+-'5/'95$4.:"G2*"S*5-*$0"!PVVj"d./-*"!PMOI"-'"5*4'+/-/'6"-.*"

*-.6'95$4.*5Y+"+-'5:"$+"$6"/6-*52*4*62*6-"/6-*545*-$-/'6>"$"E'5F"'7"7/&-/'6>"&0%-05$%"/6B*6-/'6"

'5"4$5-/$%"-50-."GS%/77'52"!PVe$>"!PVVIJ"A7"(*$6/69"E$+"$%%*9'5/&$%"g"5*45*+*6-$-/'6+"(*$6-"'6*"

-./69"$62"$6'-.*5"g"/6"-.*"45'&*++*+"/6"E./&."-.*:"$5*"/6-*545*-*2"$62"-.*"&'6-*C-+"/6"E./&."

Page 39: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

OP"

"

-.*:"$5*"-'%2"g".'E"E$+"$"6'6Q$%%*9'5/&$%"5*$%/+-"&%$/("4'++/1%*"GS%/77'52"!PVe1>"4J!@@Ii"

K'9*-.*5>"-.*+*"/(4'5-$6-"&'6-5/10-/'6+"('B*2"*-.6'95$4.:"75'("$"&'%'6/$%"-''%"'7"

'445*++/'6>"-'"$"4'%/-/&$%"$62"+*%7Q$E$5*"-*C-j"$62"75'("B/*E/69"-.*"*-.6'95$4.:"$+"$6"

$&&05$-*"5*45*+*6-$-/'6"'7"5*$%/-:>"-'"-.*"'0-&'(*"'7"&'Q45'20&-/'6J"_'E*B*5>"/6"$%%"-.*+*"

&$+*+"*-.6'95$4.:"5*($/6*2"$"+01H*&-Q&*6-5*2"*6&'06-*5J"

"

K.*"+01H*&-Q&*6-5*2"&'62/-/'6"'7"*-.6'95$4.:".$+"1**6"&.$%%*69*2"1:"-*C-0$%"-5$2/-/'6+"'6"

$&&'06-"'7"/-+"&'(4%/&/-:"E/-."&'%'6/$%/+("$62"%/1*5$%"-:5$66:"G8.$5($"*-"$%J"!PPeIJ"_'E*B*5>"

E./%*"*-.6'95$4.*5+".$B*"&'06-*5*2"-.*+*"&%$/(+"1:"$&&0+/69"-*C-0$%"-5$2/-/'6+"'7"6$B*%"9$a/69"

$62"+*%7Q$1+'54-/'6"G#&R'11/*"!PP?I>"-.*"*-.6'95$4./&"$62"*4/+-*('%'9/&$%"1*6*7/-+"'7"

2/$%'90*"1*-E**6"-*C-0$%"$62"4.*6'(*6'%'9/&$%"-5$2/-/'6+".$+"1**6"%/(/-*2J"K.*"45/6&/4%*"'7"

2/$%'90*"$-"-.*"&'5*"'7"-./+"-.*+/+"*C-*62+"-'"$6"*69$9*(*6-"1*-E**6"-.*"-*C-0$%"$62"

4.*6'(*6'%'9/&$%"$+"$"(*$6+"'7"('5*"&%'+*%:"062*5+-$62/69":'069"4*'4%*Y+"%/B*+J"K'"+044'5-"

-./+"$445'$&."/-"25$E+"'6"30"^'/+Y"+*(/6$%"-*C-"<9+!;%01-!%F!G14$=!E%1=!G?@@MI@!A6"-./+"-*C->"30"

^'/+"0+*+"-.*"W+'55'E"+'69+Y"$%'69+/2*"$6"*-.6'95$4./&"$6$%:+/+"'7"1%$&F",(*5/&$"$-"-.*"*62"'7"

-.*"6/6*-**6-."&*6-05:"-'"45'B/2*"/62*4*62*6->"$+"E*%%"$+"/6-*52*4*62*6->"B*./&%*+"-.5'09."

E./&."-.*"&.$69/69"+-$F*+"'7"%/7*"$62"75**2'("&$6"1*"/($9/6*2"$62"&'(45*.*62*2J"A6"-./+"

E$:>"-.*"*-.6'95$4./&"$62"-*C-0$%"1*&'(*"&'(4%*(*6-$5:>"*6$1%/69"$"&%'+*5"%/+-*6/69"-'"-.*"

/(($6*6-"$62"-5$6+&*62*6-"B'/&*+"-.$-"&'(45/+*"./+"$6$%:+/+J!

"

K.5'09."$%%"-.*"+'55'E"'7"-.*"8'55'E"8'69+"-.*5*"15*$-.*+"$".'4*"g"$"7$/-."/6"-.*"0%-/($-*"H0+-/&*"'7"-./69+J"K.*"(/6'5"&$2*6&*+"'7"2*+4$/5"&.$69*"'7-*6"-'"-5/0(4."$62"&$%("&'67/2*6&*J"8'(*-/(*+"/-"/+"7$/-."/6"%/7*>"+'(*-/(*+"$"7$/-."/6"2*$-.>"+'(*-/(*+"$++05$6&*"'7"1'062%*++"H0+-/&*"/6"+'(*"7$/5"E'5%2"1*:'62J"^0-"E./&.*B*5"/-"/+>"-.*"(*$6/69"/+"$%E$:+"&%*$5f"-.$-"+'(*-/(*>"+'(*E.*5*>"(*6"E/%%"H029*"(*6"1:"-.*/5"+'0%+"$62"6'-"1:"-.*/5"+F/6+J"A+"+0&."$".'4*"H0+-/7/*2i"3'"-.*"8'55'E"8'69+"+/69"-50*i"G30"^'/+"?@@M>"4J!MNI"

"

3*+4/-*"-.*+*"/(4'5-$6-"2*B*%'4(*6-+"/6"062*5+-$62/69"-.*"45'20&-/'6"'7"F6'E%*29*>"062*5Q

&'(4%/&$-*2"5*$%/+(+"+-/%%"4*5+/+-"/6"-.*"E/2*5"*-.6'95$4./&"/($9/6$-/'6J"='%/-/&$%"45'4'6*6-+"

'7"4$5$%%*%"%/B*+"$62"&'((06/-:"&'.*+/'6"GS$6-%*"?@@!j"S'((/++/'6"'6"A6-*95$-/'6"$62"

S'.*+/'6"?@@MIj"6*E"6'+-$%9/+-+"7'5"-.*"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"G^^S"?@@V&j"3*6.$("?@@PIj"$62"

Page 40: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

\@"

"

-.'+*"&'6&*56*2"E/-."-.*"('5$%"&'5504-/'6"1:"W&0%-05*+"'7"mY!e"+-/%%"45'7/-"75'("-.*"5*$%/+-"50+*J"

S'(1/6*2"E/-."$"%$&F"'7"2/$%'9/&$%%:"/6B*+-*2"*-.6'95$4./*+"G,%*C$62*5"?@@@j"^$&F"!PP\j"

8&.*4*5Q_09.*+"!PP?j"$5*"*C&*4-/'6+I>"-./+".$+"%*2"-'"$"2*.:25$-/'6"'7"-.*"*B*5:2$:>"$62"-'"

-.*"6'+-$%9/&"5*Q*(4.$+/+"'7"4'+-QE$5"$&&'06-+"GS'.*6"!PM?j"d/%%/+"!PMMIJ"K.*"I+C!74-,!7(5!

G3*6&."*-"$%J"?@@eI2!-.*"5*&*6-"./9.Q45'7/%*"+*h0*%"-'"=*-*5"d/%%('--"$62"#/&.$*%"Z'069Y+"

E4&'1/!4(5!A'(-9'#!'(!74-,!8%(5%("G!PNMI>"/+"*B/2*6&*"'7"45*&/+*%:"-./+"45'1%*("G+**"

A6-5'20&-/'6IJ"

"

d./%*"$&&'06-+"'7"-./+"F/62"($:"1*"E*%&'(*2"$+"$"5/4'+-*"-'"+*%7Q$1+'51*2"4'+-Q+-50&-05$%/+-"

*-.6'95$4./*+"G_'11+"?@@eI>"-.*:"$%+'"5*45*+*6-"-.*"/6$1/%/-:"-'"%/+-*6"-'"&'6-*(4'5$5:"051$6"

%/7*"$62"-.*"2*+/5*"-'"5*4%$&*"/(4'5-$6-"2*1$-*"'6"(0%-/&0%-05*>"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"4'%/-/&+"

E/-."6'+-$%9/&"$&&'06-+"75'("-.*"4'+-QE$5"*5$"G+**"S.$4-*5"KE'IJ"K./+"/+"$"7$/%05*"-'"5*&'96/+*"

-.$-"-.*"E'5%2"'7"&%$++"$62"%'++"G_'11+"?@@e>"44J!?@g!?ej"=$5F*5"!PM\I>"9*62*5"$62"4$5*6-g

&./%2"5*%$-/'6+./4+"GS'.*6"!PM?j"d/%%/+"!PMMI>"-.*"1'062*2"&'((06/-:"G=$5F*5"!PM\I>"$62"-.*"

7*$5"$62"2*+/5*"'7"-.*"(0%-/&0%-05$%"*6&'06-*5"G^*66*--"!PPPj")'6*+"!PVVI".$+"('B*2"'6J"

X%'1$%"&'66*&-/'6+>"2/$+4'5$"+4$&*>"6*E"(/95$-/'6+>"6*E"7'5(+"'7"5$&/+("'B*5%$/2"'6"'%2>"-.*"

1%055/69"'7"(/22%*Q&%$++"$62"E'5F/69Q&%$++"B$%0*+>"6*'Q%/1*5$%"9'B*56$6&*>"-.*"/67%0*6&*"'7"

9%'1$%"&'6+0(*5"&0%-05*>"-.*"6*E"(*2/$-*2"4$5-/&/4$-/'6"/6"401%/&"+4$&*>"$62"&'6-*(4'5$5:"

4'%/-/&+"&$66'-"1*"062*5+-''2"'6"-.*+*"-*5(+J"

"

K./+"*-.6'95$4.:>"-.*6>"2'*+"6'-"45/B/%*9*"-.*"W6$-/B*Y+"B/*EY"$+"2*7/6*2"1:"-.*"051$6"*C4%'5*5>"

6'5"2'*+"/-"5*%:"'6"4*5($6*6-"$62"7/C*2"+-50&-05*+"-'"+0+-$/6"7$(/%/$5"./*5$5&./*+"'7"F6'E%*29*"

$62"4'E*5J"A-"2'*+"6'-"+**F"-'"'4*6"04"$"5'($6-/&>"./22*6"$62"4$5'&./$%"'-.*5"E'5%2"'5"-'"

5*/7:"*-.6/&>"+4$-/$%"$62"+'&/$%"7'5(+J"^0/%2/69"'6"-.*"2/$%'90*"1*-E**6"4'+-Q+-50&-05$%"

&'6+/2*5$-/'6+"G,%*C$62*5"!PPe>"?@@@j"S%/77'52"*-"$%J"!PVej"S%/77'52"!PVVj"#$5&0+"!PPVj"R'+$%2'"

!PPOI>"#$5C/$6"$62"X5$(+&/$6"$6$%:+/+"GR'1/6+"$62"S'.*6"!PMVj"_$%%"*-"$%J"!PMej"d/%%/+"!PMMI"

$62"4.*6'(*6'%'9/&$%"$62"&0%-05$%"+-02/*+"-5$2/-/'6+"G^$&F"!PP\j"30"^'/+"?@@MI>"-./+"-.*+/+"

$590*+"7'5"$"7'5("'7"*-.6'95$4./&"-./6F/69"&$4$1%*"'7"+0+-$/6/69"2/$%'90*"E/-."-.*"&'6-'05+"'7"

&'6-*(4'5$5:"%/7*"$62"15/69/69"-'"%/9.-"-.*"+-'5/*+"-.$-"($--*5"/6"-.*"&'6-*C-"'7"-.'+*"-.*:"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!e"m"B/'%*6&*"GK*%*95$4."?@@VI>"/6-'%*5$6&*"GK.*"K/(*+"?@@PI>"9$69>"906"$62"F6/7*"&5/(*"G^*1'"?@@P1j"

S.$66*%"\"?@@V1j"T77/&*"?@@Vj"K*%*95$4."?@@Vj"K/(*+"?@@VI"H'1%*++6*++"GX0$52/$6"?@@VI"$62"$%/*66*++"

G3$/%:"#$/%"?@@e$>"1>"?@!@IJ"

Page 41: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

\!"

"

($--*5"-'"G^$&F"?@@Mj"d/%%/+"?@@!I>"E./%*"+-/%%"$&F6'E%*29/69"-.$-"/-"/+"$"('6'%'9/&"45'20&-/'6"

'7"$%%"'7"-.*+*J"d/-."-./+"/6"(/62>"-.*"6*C-"+*&-/'6"2/+&0++*+"-.*"45'1%*("'7"5*+*$5&."h0*+-/'6+J"

?J R*+*$5&."/6h0/5/*+"$62"/6$445'45/$-*"$6+E*5+"

,45/%"?@@P>"$":*$5"$7-*5"-.*"7/*%2E'5F"1*9$6>"A"E$+"+-/%%"+-5099%/69"E/-."(:"5*+*$5&."h0*+-/'6"

l_'E"2'"W<$+-*56"<05'4*$6Y":'069"4*'4%*"($F*"-.*/5"%/B*+"/6"W+04*5Q2/B*5+*Y"4%$&*+in"G(:"

5*+*$5&."E$+"'5/9/6$%%:"$1'0-"-.*"*77*&-+"'7"4'+-Q?@@\"<$+-*56"<05'4*$6"(/95$-/'6"'6":'069"

4*'4%*"/6"<$+-";'62'6IJ"K.*"h0*+-/'6"/6B/-*2"$"('6'%'9/&"+-$-*(*6-"$1'0-"$"45*2*-*5(/6*2"

$62"7*-/+./+*2"$%/*6"E'5%2>"$0-.'5/+*2"-.5'09."(:"4'+/-/'6"$+"$6"*C4*5-J"K.*"5*$%"$6+E*5"E$+"

7$5"('5*"$(1/90'0+J"A-"E$+"W-./+"$62"-.$-Yj"/-"E$+"W'6*"-./69"$62"-.*"'-.*5YJ"K./+"+*&'62"+*&-/'6"

45*+*6-+".'E>"'B*5"-/(*>"1*/69"/6$445'45/$-*"$%%'E*2"(*"-'"&'(*"-'"-*5(+"E/-."-.*"4%05$%/-:"

'7"-.*"7/*%2"$62"-.*"45'1%*($-/&"$%%05*"'7"-.*"+/69%*"7/905*"A"E$+"-5:/69"-'"$&&'06-"7'5"G8.$5($"

*-"$%J"!PPeIJ"A-"$%+'"2/+&0++*+".'E>"'B*5"$"(0&."%'69*5"4*5/'2>"A"($6$9*2"-'"%*$B*"(:"/6/-/$%"

5*+*$5&."h0*+-/'6+"1*./62J"

"

A-"/+"-.*"6$-05*"'7"$6"/6-*%%*&-0$%"h0*+-"-'"1*"062*7/6*2J"K'"6$(*"/-"$62"-'"2*7/6*"/-"/+"-'"E5$4"/-"04"$62"-/*"-.*"F6'-J"G8$5-5*"!PeV>"4JCCC///I"

"

<6-*5/69"-.*":'0-."&%01+"/6"?@@M>"(:"/6-*6-/'6"E$+"-'"%*$56"$1'0-"W<$+-*56"<05'4*$6Y":'069"

4*'4%*"/6"U*E.$(J"_'E*B*5>"/-"E$+"+''6"*B/2*6-"-.$-"/7"A"E$+"-'"45$&-/+*"E.$-"A"45*$&.*2>"A"

6**2*2"-'"$%%'E"-.*"5*+*$5&."-'"1*"'4*6"-'"-.*"2/77*5*6-"B'/&*+"-.$-"E*5*"$%+'"($F/69"04"-.*"

*-.6'95$4.:J"T6"5*7%*&-/'6>"-./+"5*$%/+$-/'6"'&&055*2"B*5:"*$5%:"/6"-.*"5*+*$5&."45'&*++J"

_'E*B*5>"/-"-''F"(*"(0&."%'69*5>"$62"$"7$/%*2"0495$2*>"-'"7'5($%%:"$&F6'E%*29*"/-"/6"E5/-/69J"A"

&$6"'6%:"40-"-./+"2'E6"-'"(:"%$&F"'7"&'67/2*6&*"/6"('B/69"'0-+/2*"-.*"&$-*9'5/*+"A"*C4*&-*2"

(:+*%7"-'"0+*J"#$6:"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"A"E'5F*2"E/-."E*5*"6'-"/6"7$&-"<$+-*56"<05'4*$6J",62"

7'5"-.'+*"-.$-"E*5*>"1*/69"W<$+-*56"<05'4*$6Y"/6"$"2/$+4'5$"+4$&*"%/F*"U*E.$("E$+"'6%:"'6*"

$+4*&-"'7"-.*/5"%/B*+J"T6"-.*+*"-E'"+/(4%*"-*5(+>"A"E$+"7'5&*2"-'"$225*++"-.*"1$+/+"'6"E./&."A"

E$+"'B*5Q45/B/%*9/69"<$+-*56"<05'4*$6"/2*6-/-:J"K.*":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"45'B/2/69"(*"E/-."$"

06/h0*"'44'5-06/-:"6'-"-'"&%'+*"2'E6"-.*/5"%/B*+"$+"+'"($6:"'-.*5"4/*&*+"'7"5*+*$5&.".$B*"

2'6*>"10-"-'"*69$9*"E/-."-.*"4%05$%/-:>"./+-'5/&$%"&'(4%*C/-:"$62"$%%*9'5:"-.$-"A"E$+"6'E"$"4$5-"

'7J"

"

Page 42: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

\?"

"

_'E*B*5>"-.*+*"5*$%/+$-/'6+"*6-$/%*2"6'-"'6%:"%''F/69"1*:'62"-.*"7/905*"'7"-.*"<$+-*56"

<05'4*$6"10-"$%+'"'4*6/69"04"-'"$"5$69*"'7"$(1/90'0+"$62"&'06-*5/6-0/-/B*"45$&-/&*+J",+"A"

+-$5-*2"-'"%/+-*6>"A"1*&$(*"$E$5*"'7"&'(4%*C"7'5($-/'6+"'7"E./-*6*++"'B*5%$/2"E/-."2/77*5*6-"

./+-'5/*+"'7"(/95$-/'6>"1*%'69/69>"-*55/-'5:"$62"%'++J"A"1*&$(*"&'6+&/'0+"'7"./9.%:"&5*$-/B*"$62"

B*5+$-/%*"7'5(+"'7"-$06-+>"*6$&-*2"'6"1'2/*+"/6"+4$&*+"-.$-"'4*5$-*2"E/-."$"+F*E*2"%'9/&"-'"-.*"

W5*$%Y"E'5%2>":*-"E*5*"*77'5-%*++%:"7'%%'E*2"$62"&5*$-*2"1:"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"E.'"2*%/B*5*2>"

5*&*/B*2>"%/+-*6*2"$62"2*-*5(/6*2J"A"+-$5-*2"-'"6'-/&*".'E"-.*"45$&-/&*+"'7":'069"4*'4%*"

4$5'2/*2"'77/&/$%"-50-.+"$62"/6B*5-*2"+'&/$%"./*5$5&./*+"G^$F.-/6"!PV\I"-.5'09."%$09.-*5>"

-.5'09."H'F*+"$62"-.5'09."B/'%*6&*J"K.*"1*%%+"'7"-.*"R$1*%$/+/$6"&.05&."G^$F.-/6"!PV\>"

44J?!Og?!\I"E*5*".*$52"/6"-.*"K**6"^0aaJ!M"U'6*"'7"-./+"E$+"$(*6$1%*"-'"(:"'5/9/6$%"5*+*$5&."

h0*+-/'6+J"A"6'-*2".'E"-.*"/62/B/20$%"E$+"-5$6+7'5(*2"-.5'09."-.*"&'%%*&-/B*>"/6"5*+4'6+*"-'"

'77/&/$%"'52*5>"$62".'E"B/'%*6&*"$62"4%$:"E*5*"1'-."+$&5*2"$62"45'7$6*J"K./+"E$+"6'-"+/(4%:"

-.*"+-'5:"'7"$"45*B/'0+%:"062/+&'B*5*2"0-'4/$6"+01B*5+/B*6*++"10-"$6"/6-*5-E/6/69"'7"45$&-/&*+"

-.$-"062/2"$62"2/+4%$&*2>"10-"E*5*"6'6*-.*%*++"$++$0%-*2"1:>"('6'%'9/&"'52*5"G2*"S*5-*$0"

!PV\>"4JP!g!!@IJ"A".*$52"-$06-+"-.$-"&'6-*+-*2"$"+/(4%*"5*$%/+-"5*$2/69"'7"-.*/5"+&5/4-+"10-"-.$-"

E*5*"$%+'"2*-*5(/6*2"1:"-.*"+&5/4-05$%"*&'6'(:"'7"5$&/$%"2/+&'05+*"G2*"S*5-*$0"!PV\IJ"K.*"

-$06-+".$2"./+-'5/*+"$62"&'6-*C-+"-.$-"E*5*"5*(/C*2"75'("2'(/6$6-"C*6'4.'1/$J"A"E$+"

&'675'6-*2"1:"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7":'069"4*'4%*Y+"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+"$62"-.*"E$:+"-.$-"/2*$+"'7"

5$&/$%/+*2"7/C/-:"E*5*"2/+4%$&*2>"$62"5*6*E*2j".'E"7'5(+"'7".'+-/%/-:"$62"+*4$5$-*6*++"&'0%2"

*C/+-"$%'69+/2*"/6-*6+*"&'6B/B/$%/-:"G^$&F"!PP\j"X/%5':"?@@\Ij"$62>".'E"+**(/69%:"6/./%/+-"

5*4*5-'/5*+"'7"1%$&F"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6"&'0%2"1*"5*7%*C/B*"4'%/-/&$%"+-$-*(*6-+"$9$/6+-"/6H0+-/&*"

4*57'5(*2"1:"E./-*"1'2/*+J",9$/6>"-.*"5*$%/+-"75$(/69"'7"(:"'5/9/6$%"5*+*$5&."h0*+-/'6"2/26Y-"

.'%2J"

"

K.*+*"*B*5:2$:"45$&-/&*+"7'5&*2"(*"-'"-./6F"$1'0-"-.*"4%05$%/-:"'7"-.*"*-.6'95$4./&"*6&'06-*5"

$62"-.*"95'062"'6"E./&."A"E$+"4%$66/69"-'"+/%*6&*"/-+"($6:"B'/&*+J"R*-056/69"-'"-.*"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!M"K.*"K**6"^0aa"E$+"$"2'E6%'$2$1%*>"$62"&'6+*h0*6-%:"^%0*-''-.Q$1%*"+'062"7/%*"-.$-"45'20&*2"$"

&'6-/60'0+"./9.Q4/-&.*2"G!N"`_aI"+'062"-.$-"/(/-$-*2"-.*"#'+h0/-'"2*B/&*"GS'(4'062"8*&05/-:"8:+-*(+"

?@!@I"45'('-*2"-'"&%*$5":'069"4*'4%*"$E$:"75'("401%/&"+4$&*+J";/F*"-.*"&.05&."1*%%"G^$F.-/6"!PV\I>"-.*"

5*$%"#'+h0/-'"2*B/&*"-'%2":'069"4*'4%*"E.*5*"G6'-I"-'"1*"$-"&*5-$/6"-/(*+J"K.*"K**6"^0aa"E$+"$"4$5'2:"

'7"-./+"2*B/&*J"=%$:*2"75'("('1/%*"4.'6*+"./22*6"062*5"&.$/5+>"-.*"./9.Q4/-&.*2"+'062"E$+"2/77/&0%-"-'"

%'&$-*"$62"06&'(7'5-$1%*"-'".*$5J"d.*5*$+"-.*"#'+h0/-'"'52*5*2"+4$&*"-.5'09."+'062>"-.*"K**6"^0aa"

2/+'52*5*2"/->"&5*$-/69"6*E"5*9/(*+"'7"+'6/&"$62"-*55/-'5/$%"&'6-5'%"G+**"S.$4-*5"K.5**IJ"

Page 43: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

\O"

"

*4/+-*('%'9/&$%"45'1%*(+"%$/2"'0-"/6"-.*"/6-5'20&-/'6"G_'E"E$+"/-"6'E"4'++/1%*"-'"5*45*+*6-"

W5*$%Y"(*$6/69"/6"-.*"*-.6'95$4./&"-*C-i"_'E"E$+"/-"6'E"4'++/1%*"-'"04.'%2"-.*"&'(('6Q

+*6+*"/2*$"-.$-"5*$%/-:"/+"%/B*2"/6"&*5-$/6"1'062*2"E$:+"/6"7/C*2"4%$&*+i"_'E"E$+"/-"6'E"

4'++/1%*"-'"-5'-"'0-"$"7'5(0%$/&"(*-.'2'%'9:"&.$4-*5"-.$-"$0-.'5/+*2"$+"W5*$%Y"'5"W$0-.*6-/&Y"

+01H*&-/B*"/6-*545*-$-/'6iI>"(:"&'6&%0+/'6"E$+"-.$-"-./+"*-.6'95$4.:"&'0%2"6'-"1*"$6'-.*5"

*6$&-(*6-"'7"2'01%*"204%/&/-:"g"45$&-/+/69"5*$%/+("E./%*"4$:/69"%/4Q+*5B/&*"-'"4'%:B'&$%/-:>"

4'+-Q+-50&-05$%/+("$62"-.*"*B*5:2$:J"K.*"7/6$%"-*C-"6**2*2"E.*5*B*5"4'++/1%*"-'"1*"7$/-.70%"-'"

-.*"*-.6'95$4./&"45'&*++J"R$-.*5"-.$6"+0+-$/6/69"-.*"1*%/*7"/6"*(1'2/*2"-50-.+"%'&$-*2"/6"7/C*2"

+4$&*+>"-.*"*-.6'95$4.:"6**2*2"-'"$225*++"-.*"/6-*5-E/6/69"'7"2/77*5*6-"45$&-/&*+>"./+-'5/*+>"

45'20&-/'6+"$62"4'%/-/&+"-.$-"062/2"$62"2/+4%$&*2"10-"$%+'"+&5/4-*2J"K./+"$E$5*6*++"

/6&5*$+/69%:"1*&$(*"$"&'((/-(*6-"-'"%/+-*6"G^$&F"?@@M>"4J!Ij"-'"062*5+-$62"-.*"%/B*+"'7"-.*"

:'069"4*'4%*"A"E'5F*2"E/-.j"$62"-'"%*$B*"(:"5*+*$5&."h0*+-/'6+"1*./62J"

OJ 8/-*+"$62"(0%-/Q+/-*+"

#:"$445'$&."-'"+/-*"+*%*&-/'6"E$+"+/(/%$5%:"&'6B'%0-*2>"1*9/66/69"-.*"5*+*$5&."/6"?@@M>"A"

+-$5-*2"1:"7'%%'E/69"-.*"(*-.'2+"($60$%+"G=$--'6"?@@?I"$62"+$(4%*2":'0-."&%01+"1$+*2"'6"

-.*"60(1*5"'7"W<$+-*56"<05'4*$6+Y"$--*62/69"+&.''%+"/6"-.*"%'&$%"$5*$J"]5'(".*5*>"A"/($9/6*2"A"

E'0%2"W+*%*&-"+/-*+Y>"W9$/6"$&&*++Y>"W10/%2"5$44'5-Y"$62"W%*$B*"-.*"7/*%2Y"G_$((*5+%*:"$62"

,-F/6+'6"!PPNIJ"_'E*B*5>"-./+"%/6*$5"6$55$-/B*"$%+'"2/26Y-"-5$6+4/5*"$62"-.*"'52*5%:"45'&*++/'6"

'7"*B*6-+"A".$2"/($9/6*2"15'F*"2'E6J"

"

]'%%'E/69"(:"+$(4%/69"75$(*>"A"/6-*5B/*E*2"+*5B/&*"45'B/2*5+>"F*:"E'5F*5+"$62"&*6-5*"

($6$9*5+>".'4/69"-'"%*$56"E.*-.*5"-.*":'0-."&%01+"(*-"-.*"&5/-*5/$"'7"-.*"5*+*$5&."h0*+-/'6+"

g"10-"$%E$:+"%*$B/69"06&*5-$/6"'7"-./+J"A"E$+>".'E*B*5>"9/B*6"$"7/5(*5"/62/&$-/'6"'7"E.*-.*5"

-.*:"E$6-*2"(*"-.*5*J"8'(*"2/26Y-"10-"/(4'5-$6-%:"+'(*"2/2J",62"E/-."7'5($%"$++05$6&*+"

-/&F*2>"E.*-.*5":'0-."E'5F*5+"E$6-*2"(*"-.*5*>"5$-.*5"-.$6"-.*"+$(4%*"A".$2"+*%*&-*2>"

1*&$(*"-.*"2*&/2/69"7$&-'5"'7"E.*5*"A"E'5F*2J"

"

TB*5"-.$-"/6/-/$%"4*5/'2>"A"(*-"U*/%"$62"X$B/6"$-"-.*";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01>"8$1/.$"$-"-.*",7-*5"

8&.''%"S%01"$62"#/5B$"$-"-.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."=5'H*&-J"!V"d*"-$%F*2"$1'0-"E.$-"-.*:"2/2"$62"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!V"K.*"6$(*+"'7"-.*"4*'4%*>"4%$&*+"$62"/6+-/-0-/'6+".$B*"$%%"1**6"&.$69*2J"

Page 44: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

\\"

"

E.$-"A"E$6-*2"-'"2'J"U*05'-/&$%%:"&'62/-/'6*2"1:"*-./&+"($60$%+>"A"E$6-*2"-'"$%%$:"-.*/5"7*$5+"

-.$-"A"E$+"&'(/69"-'"+-*$%"+'0%+>"10-"-.*:"E*5*"('5*"/6-*5*+-*2"/6"E.$-"45$&-/&$%"+044'5-"A"

&'0%2"45'B/2*J"#'+-"6**2*2"B'%06-$5:":'0-."E'5F*5+"-'".*%4"506"-.*/5"45'95$((*+"$62"A".$2"$"

7*E":*$5+Y"*C4*5/*6&*"'7":'0-."$62"&'((06/-:"E'5F"/6";$-/6",(*5/&$J"8$1/.$"6**2*2"+'(*'6*"

-'".*%4"506"-.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01>"U*/%"$62"X$B/6"+$/2"-.*:"&'0%2"0+*"+'(*'6*"E/-."$"1/-"'7"

&'(('6"+*6+*>"$62"#/5B$"E$+"'4*6"-'"6*E"E$:+"E*"(/9.-"1*"$1%*"-'"*69$9*"-.*"95'E/69"

60(1*5+"'7":'069"4*'4%*"/6".*5"'59$6/+$-/'6J"K./+"/+"6'-"-'"+$:"-.$-"-.*"45'&*++"E$+"*6-/5*%:"

5$-/'6$%J"K.*:"E*5*"9*6*5'0+"$62"'4*6>"$62"E*"+**(*2"-'"9*-"$%'69J",7-*5"$"7*E"('6-.+"A"

&'((/--*2"-'"B'%06-**5"$-"-.5**":'0-."45'H*&-+f!P"

"

!J K.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."=5'H*&-"

?J K.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01"$-"3'&F+/+*"

OJ K.*";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01"

"

A"E'5F*2"$-"-.*+*"+/-*+"1*-E**6",45/%"?@@V"$62")06*"?@!@J"305/69"-.$-"4*5/'2>";*:.$("$62"-.*"

,7-*5"8&.''%"S%01"'&&04/*2"5'09.%:"7'05-**6".'05+"*B*5:"E**F>"+4%/-"1*-E**6"-E'"2$:+J"K.*"

+*++/'6+"$-"-.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01"E*5*"1*-E**6"'6*"$62"$".$%7"-'"-E'".'05+"%'69J"K.*";*:.$("

+*++/'6+"E*5*"$%E$:+"%'69*5"-.$6"-.5**".'05+J",+"$"5*+0%-"'7"-.*"-/(*"A"+4*6-"$-";*:.$("$62"

-.*"+%'E*5"-056'B*5"'7":'069"4*'4%*"$62"+-$77"-.*5*>"A"9'-"-'"F6'E"-./+"+/-*"7$5"1*--*5"-.$6"-.*"

'-.*5+J"K./+"/+"5*7%*&-*2"/6"-.*"-.*+/+J"K.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."=5'H*&-"'&&04/*2"E**F*62+"$62"

'&&$+/'6$%"*B*6/69+"$7-*5"+&.''%>"$62"E$+"('5*"45'H*&-Q7'&0+*2J"

K.*"+/-*+"

^*7'5*"*C4%'5/69".'E"-.*":'0-."&%01+"45'B/2*"B*./&%*+"-'"2/77*5*6-"-/(*+"$62"+4$&*+>"/-"/+"7/5+-"

.*%470%"-'"45*+*6-"-.*("$+"2/+&5*-*"+/-*+"E/-."4$5-/&0%$5"&.$5$&-*5/+-/&+J""

"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!P",%-.'09."-.*"'5/*6-$-/'6"'7"-.*"5*+*$5&."E$+"+*-"-'"&.$69*>"-.*":'0-."&*6-5*+"$-"7/5+-"&'(4%*(*6-*2"

2/77*5*6-"$+4*&-+"'7"-.*"/6/-/$%"5*+*$5&."45'H*&-J",%%"E'5F*2"E/-."W<$+-*56"<05'4*$6Y":'069"4*'4%*"$62"

/(4'5-$6-%:"-.*+*":'069"4*'4%*"&'(4%/&$-*2"-.*"6'-/'6"'7"-.*"W<$+-*56"<05'4*$6YJ"K.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."

=5'H*&-"E'5F*2"45/($5/%:"E/-."W,%1$6/$6"+4*$F/69Y":'069"4*'4%*"g"'7-*6"&$-*9'5/+*2"1:"+*5B/&*"2*%/B*5:"

1'2/*+"/6"-.*"$5*$"$+"W<$+-*56"<05'4*$6Y>"10-"E/-."2/+-/6&-"./+-'5/*+"'7"(/95$-/'6J"K.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01"

E$+"$6"'4*6Q$&&*++":'0-."&%01"E./&."/6&%02*2"R'($6/$6>"='%/+."$62";/-.0$6/$6":'069"4*'4%*"g"+'(*"

1'56"/6"-.*"[`"$62"+'(*"6'-J";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01"E'5F*2"E/-."+($%%*5"60(1*5+"'7"='%/+.":'069"4*'4%*J""

Page 45: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

\N"

"

A6"-*5(+"'7"%'&$-/'6"$62"%$:'0->";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01"E$+"%'&$-*2"'6"-.*"*29*"'7"$"%$59*"4$5FJ"

]*6&*2"'77"75'("-.*"5*+-"'7"-.*"4$5F>"/-"&'6+/+-*2"'7"$"./9.Q&*/%/69*2"10/%2/69"-'"-.*"6'5-."*62"

'7"-.*"+/-*"$62"$"%$59*"'0-2''5"$5*$"-'"-.*"+'0-.J"K.*"10/%2/69"E$+"2/B/2*2"/6"-E'f"-.*"%$59*5"

W75'6-"5''(Y"$62"-.*"+($%%*5"W1$&F"%'11:YJ"^'-.".$2"*6-5$6&*+"-'"-.*"'0-2''5"$5*$J"R066/69"

-.5'09."-.*"(/22%*"'7"-.*"10/%2/69>"$62"&'66*&-/69"-.*"75'6-"-'"-.*"1$&F"$5*$>"E$+"$"+($%%"

F/-&.*6"$62"$"&'55/2'5J"K.*"75'6-"5''("E$+"0+*2"7'5"$"B$5/*-:"'7"$&-/B/-/*+>"/6&%02/69f"/62''5"

7''-1$%%>"2'29*1$%%>?@"-$1%*"-*66/+"$62"4''%J"A-"E$+"*h0/44*2"E/-."$"%'02"+-*5*'"+:+-*("2'6$-*2"

1:"'6*"'7"-.*":'0-."E'5F*5Y+"15'-.*5+J"K.*"1$&F"%'11:"E$+".$%7"-.*".*/9.-"'7"-.*"75'6-"5''("'6"

$&&'06-"'7"-.*"(*aa$6/6*"%*B*%"$1'B*J"A-"&'6-$/6*2"$"Kc>"$6"/6-*5(/--*6-%:"706&-/'6$%"

=%$:8-$-/'6"$62"-.5**"B/50+Q5/22*6"&'(40-*5+"E/-."706&-/'6/69"/6-*56*-"&'66*&-/'6+J",-"-.*"7$5"

*62"'7"-.*"10/%2/69>"-.*"1$&F"%'11:"'4*6*2"'6-'"$"E$+.5''("&'6-$/6/69"-.5**"+*4$5$-*"5''(+"

*$&."E/-."$"-'/%*-"g"'6*"7'5"+-$77"$62"-E'"7'5":'069"4*'4%*J"K.*"(*aa$6/6*"/-+*%7"E$+"$B$/%$1%*"

'6%:"7'5"+-$77"0+*>"$62"$&&*++*2"1:"-E'"+-$/5E$:+f"'6*"/6"-.*"75'6-"5''("$62"'6*"/6"-.*"1$&F"

%'11:J"K.*"(*aa$6/6*"&'6-$/6*2"-.*"4$5-/-/'6*2"($6$9*5Y+"'77/&*"$62"2*+F+"7'5"-.*"+-$77J"]5'("

-.*"2*+F"$5*$"/-"E$+"4'++/1%*"-'"%''F"2'E6"/6-'"-.*"75'6-"5''(>"-.*"1$&F"%'11:"$62"&'55/2'5J"

K.*"'0-2''5"$5*$"E$+"($/6%:"95$++>"$62"/6"?@@V"E.*6"A"$55/B*2"/-"E$+"$2'56*2"E/-."&'%'0570%%:"

4$/6-*2"E''2*6"+E/69Q75$(*+>"-.*"5*(6$6-+"'7"-.*"'%2"$2B*6-05*"4%$:95'062J"K'"-.*"+'0-.Q

*$+-"'7"-.*"'0-2''5"$5*$"E$+"$"+*$-/69"$5*$>"$9$/6"4$/6-*2"/6"15/9.-"&'%'05+J"^*:'62"-.*+*"

E*5*"$"7*E"10+.*+"$62"$".*29*5'E"-.$-"5$6"$%'69"-.*"*$+-*56"4*5/(*-*5>"$2H'/6/69"$"%'E"

(*-$%"1$55*2"7*6&*>"$62"5*-056*2"-'"-.*":'0-."&%01"10/%2/69J"305/69"(:"-/(*"-.*5*>"-.*"'5/9/6$%"

+E/69Q75$(*+"E*5*"5*('B*2>"$62"7%'E*51*2+>"$"&'04%*"'7"+($%%"'4*6Q+/2*2"+.*%-*5+>"$6"*/9.-Q

7''-"7*6&*"$62"$"%$59*"E''2*6"$2B*6-05*"4%$:95'062"E*5*"/6+-$%%*2J"

"

K.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01"E$+".'0+*2"'6"-.*"+*&'62"7%''5"'7"$"S'06&/%"W_01Y?!"$62"$&&*++*2"1:"

2*2/&$-*2"+-$/5+"$-"-.*"75'6-"'7"-.*"10/%2/69J"<6-*5/69"-.*"75'6-"2''5>":'069"4*'4%*"4$++*2"-.*"

+4'5-+".$%%"-'"-.*"%*7->"&%/(1*2"+-$/5+>"4$++/69"-.*"-'/%*-+"$62"-.*"%$62/69>"$62"E*6-"/6-'"-.*"

($/6"$5*$J"A6"-.*"(/22%*"'7"-.*"($/6"$5*$"E*5*"-E'"4''%"-$1%*+"$62"-E'"-$1%*Q-*66/+"-$1%*+J"

,5'062"-.*"4*5/(*-*5>"+'7-"+*$-/69"E$+"0+*2"5*+-%*++%:"1:":'069"(*6"$62"E'(*6"E.'"

&.$--*2>"+$->"7%/5-*2"$62"7'09.-J"K'"-.*"5/9.-"E$+"$"+($%%"4'5-$1%*"+-*5*'>"$62"$&5'++"75'("-.*"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""?@"3'29*1$%%"/+"$"9$(*"/6"E./&."4%$:*5+"-5:"-'"./-"(*(1*5+"'7"-.*"'44'+/69"-*$("1:"-.5'E/69"1$%%+"$-"

-.*("E./%+-"-5:/69"-'"$B'/2"1*/69"./-"1:"1$%%+"-.*(+*%B*+J"=%$:*5+"$5*"W'0-Y"E.*6"-.*:"$5*"./-"1:"-.*"1$%%J"

K.*"9$(*"E$+"4'40%$5/+*2"-.5'09."-.*"7/%(">%5)+T411"GK.051*5"?@@\IJ"?!"_01+".'0+/69"B$5/'0+"&'((06/-:"+*5B/&*+J"

Page 46: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

\e"

"

*6-5$6&*"E*5*"-.5**"5''(+J"K.*"-E'"5''(+"-'"-.*"5/9.-"E*5*"'77/&*+"g"'6*"7'5"-.*"9*6*5$%"

($6$9*5"$62"'6*"7'5"-.*":'0-."&%01"($6$9*5J"K.*"5''("-'"-.*"%*7-"E$+"&$%%*2"-.*"S5$7-"R''("

$62"&'6-$/6*2"1'$52Q9$(*+>"4%0+"$5-+"$62"&5$7-+"($-*5/$%+J"K'"-.*"%*7-"'7"-.*"*6-5$6&*>"E$+"-.*"

=%$6*-"R''(J",-"-.*"*6-5$6&*"-'"-.*"=%$6*-"R''("E$+"$"E$%%Q('06-*2"7%$-"+&5**6"Kc"

&'66*&-*2"-'"$"d//"$62"$"=%$:8-$-/'6"?J"K.*"=%$6*-"R''(".$2"'5/9/6$%%:"&'6-$/6*2"$6"$6$%'90*"

(0+/&"+-02/'>"%$--*5%:"-5$6+7'5(*2"/6-'"$6"AK"+0/-*"E./&."&'6+/+-*2"'7"-*6"6*-E'5F*2"

&'(40-*5+"$62"+$-"1*./62"-E'"'6*Q$62Q$Q.$%7"(*-5*"./9."'77/&*"4$5-/-/'6+J",-"-.*"7$5"*62"'7"

-.*"($/6"$5*$"E*5*"-.*"F/-&.*6"$62"-.*"8-$5"R''(J"K.*"F/-&.*6"%''F*2"'0-"'6-'"-.*"($/6"$5*$"

B/$"$"-0&F+.'4"&'06-*5J"K.*"8-$5"R''("g"$"F/62"'7"E/2*"&'55/2'5"g"&'6-$/6*2"+'7-"+*$-/69"$62"

4'+-*5"2/+4%$:+J"K.*"%$:'0-"'7"-.*"5''("(*$6-"-.$-":'069"4*'4%*"&'0%2"+/-"'0-"'7"-.*"2/5*&-"

B/*E"'7"'-.*5":'069"4*'4%*"$62"+-$77J"K.*":'069"E'(*6"/6"4$5-/&0%$5"'7-*6".*%2"&'05-"-.*5*J"

^*:'62"-.*"8-$5"R''("E*5*"-.*"1$&F"2''5>"-.*"5*+-"'7"-.*"_01"$62"-.*"1$&F"+-$/5+J"

"

K.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."X5'04"0+*2"$"60(1*5"'7"+/-*+J"K.*+*"$5*"2/+&0++*2"E.*5*"$62"E.*6"-.*:"

$44*$5"/6"-.*"-.*+/+J""

"

A6"5*+4*&-"'7"-.*"2*('95$4./&+"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"-.$-"$--*62*2"-.*":'0-."&%01+>";*:.$("

.$2"$"%$59*%:"E./-*"$62"(/C*2Q5$&*"4'40%$-/'6>"E/-."$"7*E",+/$6"$62"<$+-*56"<05'4*$6":'069"

4*'4%*J"K.*":'069"4*'4%*"E.'"$--*62*2"-.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01"E*5*"($/6%:"1%$&F",75/&$6"$62"

(/C*2"5$&*J"#$6:"E*5*"7/5+-Q"'5"+*&'62Q9*6*5$-/'6"(/95$6-+"75'("5*709**"1$&F95'062+J"K.*5*"

E*5*"$%+'"$"+($%%*5"60(1*5"'7"1%$&F"S$5/11*$6>",+/$6"G&*6-5$%>"+'0-."$62"+'0-.Q*$+-I>"<$+-*56"

<05'4*$6"$62"E./-*"^5/-/+.":'069"4*'4%*J"K.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."=5'H*&-"E$+"1$+*2"$5'062"$6"

,%1$6/$6Q+4*$F/69"&'((06/-:"95'04J"K.*":'069"4*'4%*"E.'"$--*62*2"-.*"$&-/B/-/*+".$2"1**6"

1'56"/6"`'+'B'>",%1$6/$"$62"-.*"[`J"[6%/F*"-.*"'-.*5"-E'"&*6-5*+>"-.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."X5'04"

E$+"506"1:"-.*"4$5*6-+"'7"-.*"4$5-/&/4$6-+J",-"$%%"-.*"+/-*+>"A"E'5F*2"($/6%:"E/-.":'069"4*'4%*"

'7"+*&'62$5:"+&.''%"$9*"$62"$1'B*>"-.*"'%2*+-"1*/69"6/6*-**6":*$5+"'%2"$62"-.*":'069*+-"-*6J"

#'+-"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"1*-E**6"-./5-**6"$62"+/C-**6J",-"-.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."=5'H*&-"

-.*"9*62*5"+4%/-"E$+"5'09.%:"*h0$%J"d.*6"A"+-$5-*2"$-";*:.$(>"('+-"'7"-.*"4$5-/&/4$6-+"E*5*"

:'069"E'(*6"10-"-'E$52+"-.*"*62"'7"(:"-/(*"-.*":'0-."&%01".$2"1*&'(*"('5*"($%*J"K.*"

,7-*5"8&.''%"S%01".$2"('5*":'069"(*6"-.$6":'069"E'(*6>"-.'09."'&&$+/'6$%%:"%$59*"95'04+"

'7":'069"E'(*6"E'0%2"$--*62J"

"

Page 47: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

\M"

"

Z'0-."&%01+"E*5*"&.'+*6"1*&$0+*"-.*:"'77*5*2"$6"$&&*++/1%*"/6+-/-0-/'6$%"+*--/69"/6"E./&."

:'069"4*'4%*"&'0%2"1*"*69$9*2J"R*+*$5&."E/-.":'069"4*'4%*"'0-+/2*"'7"$6"/6+-/-0-/'6>"$62"

E/-."(:"%$&F/69"$6:"45/'5"E'5F/69"5*%$-/'6+./4"E/-."-.'+*":'069"4*'4%*>"E'0%2".$B*"$22*2"-''"

(0&."06&*5-$/6-:"-'"-.*"45'H*&-J"A-"$%+'"E'0%2".$B*"%*7-"(*"'4*6"-'"&.$59*+"'7"4$*2'4./%/$>"'5"

$-"%*$+-"$16'5($%"$20%-"($%*"1*.$B/'05J"80&."$5*"-.*"4$6/&+"+055'062/69"E'5F"E/-."&./%25*6"

$62":'069"4*'4%*J"Z'0-."&%01+"$%+'".$2"-.*"$2B$6-$9*>"'B*5"+&.''%+>"'7"/67'5($%/-:J"Z'069"

4*'4%*"E*5*"75**"-'"&'(*"$62"9'>"10-"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"E*5*"+077/&/*6-%:"&'6-$/6*2"-.$-"A"&'0%2"

10/%2"/6-*54*5+'6$%"5*%$-/'6+./4+"E/-."-.*(J"

#0%-/+/-*+"

_$B/69"2*+&5/1*2"-.*/5"%$:'0->"/-"/+"/(4'5-$6-"-'"6'-*"-.$-"-.*+*"/6+-/-0-/'6+"E*5*"7$5"75'("

/6-*95$%>"$62"(*$6/69"($F/69"2/2"6'-"*62"$-"-.*/5"E$%%+J"R$-.*5>"-.*":'0-."&%01+"45'B/2*2"$"

B*./&%*"7'5"*C4%'5/69"E/2*5"-/(*+"$62"+4$&*+J",%-.'09."*B*5:2$:"%/B*+"$5*"'7-*6"4'5-5$:*2"$+"

.$B/69"&*5-$/6"+'&/$%"&.$5$&-*5/+-/&+"7/C*2"/6"1'062*2"9*'95$4./*+>"-.*+*"+4$&*+"E*5*"

(0%-/+/-*2"g"+4$-/$%%:"$62"-*(4'5$%%:"G^$F.-/6"!PV!>"4JV\Q?NVj"_'%h0/+-"!PV!j"#$5&0+"!PPVIJ"

"

#*$6/69"E$+"9/B*6"-'"*C4*5/*6&*+"/6"-.*":'0-."&%01+"-.5'09."-.*"6$55$-/'6"'7"H'056*:+"

1*-E**6"-.*".*5*Q$62Q-.*5*"'7"5*$%/+-"+/-*+"g"+&.''%+>"6*/9.1'05.''2+"$62"G-5$6+6$-/'6$%I"

W.'(*+Y"G;*B/--"$62")$E'5+F:"?@@Mj"`6'E%*+"?@@Pj"+**"S.$4-*5"KE'IJ"3/$+4'5/&"&0%-05*"

&'66*&-*2"-.*":'0-."&%01+"-'"-.*"9%'1$%"75/69*+"$62"4'40%$5"($/6+-5*$(+"G+**"S.$4-*5"K.5**IJ"

c/5-0$%"E'5%2+"$62"-.*/5"&'(4%*C"/6-*54*6*-5$-/'6"E/-."-.*"4.:+/&$%"E'5%2"'77*5*2"705-.*5"

5*70-$-/'6"'7"-.*"1'062*2":'0-."&%01J"]$&*1''F"*C4$62*2"-.*"+4$&*"$62"$--*62$6&*"'7"-.*"

:'0-."&%01"/6-'"4'5-$%+"$5'062"-.*"1'5'09.>"$5'062";'62'6>"$5'062"-.*"[`"$62"$5'062"-.*"

E'5%2J"_'E*B*5>"B/5-0$%"*6(/-/*+"$62"75/*62+./4+"'7-*6"2*4*62*2"'6"7$&*Q-'Q7$&*"&'6-$&-J"

K.5'09."]$&*1''F>"B*62*--$+"$62"4$5-/*+"E*5*"/6/-/$-*2"$62"4*50+*2>"'6%/6*"$62"'6"-.*"+-5**-J"

A($9*+"'7"W.$44:"+%$44/69Y"'5"5*06/'6"E*5*"+.$5*2"1:"-*C-"$62"^%0*-''-.>"$62"04%'$2*2"-'"

+.$(*"'-.*5+"$62"5*(/6/+&*"'B*5>"/6"-.*":'0-."&%01J"

"

K.*"(0%-/Q+/-*2"2/(*6+/'6+"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01"$%+'"6**2"-'"1*"&'6+/2*5*2"-*(4'5$%%:J"K/(*"E$+"

6'-"('6'%'9/&"*/-.*5J"]/9.-+>"5*%$-/'6+./4+"$62"*('-/'6+"2/+-'5-*2"6*'Q%/1*5$%"70-05*+J"K.*"

'77/&/$%"-/(*+"'7"2$:%/9.->"E'5F"%/7*>"+0&&*++>"&.'/&*"$62"$+4/5$-/'6"E*5*"+01B*5-*2"$62"

/6-*5504-*2J"K.*"&'(7'5-"$62"%$E%*++6*++"'7"-.*"6/9.-"E$+"+:(1'%/&$%%:"/6-5'20&*2"-.5'09."

-056/69"-.*"%/9.-+"'77J"K/(*"E$+"&'(45*++*2"$62"*C4$62*2"-.5'09."-.*"0+*"'7"]$&*1''F"-'"

Page 48: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

\V"

"

&'((06/&$-*"$62"5*+4'62"/6"-.*"4.:+/&$%"E'5%2>"$62"-.5'09."-$06-+>"('(*6-$5/%:"-/(*%*++"

1'2/*+"E*5*"&5*$-*2J";/F*E/+*>"(*('5/*+"'7"W.'(*Y"E*5*"-'%2"$+"-$%*+"$1+-5$&-*2"$62"

*(1*%%/+.*2"75'("-.*"%/6*$5"-/(*"/6"E./&."-.*:"'&&055*2J"#'(*6-+"*B'F*2"(*('5/*+"'7"4%$&*+"

-.$-"E*5*"E/%70%%:"/($9/6*2>"$+"(0&."$+".$B/69"$&-0$%%:"'&&055*2J"A"E$+"45*+*6-*2"E/-."E./-*"

E'5F/69Q&%$++"5'($6&*+"'7":*+-*5:*$5>"%'++"$62"(/95$-/'6J"K.*+*"E*5*"+*%*&-/B*"4$+-+"$62"

45*+*6-+"5*+4'62/69"-'"&*5-$/6"5*&*4-/B*"*6B/5'6(*6-+J"K.*+*"$&&'06-+"/96'5*2"&'%'6/$%/+(>"

%'69"./+-'5/*+"'7"7$(/%/$%"$62"%'&$%"(/95$-/'6>"06*(4%':(*6-"$62"4'+-Q/620+-5/$%"2*&%/6*"$-"-.*"

+$(*"-/(*"$+"-.*:"E*5*"($2*"1:"-.*(J"3*+4/-*"1*/69"+01B*5-*2>"('6'%'9/&"-/(*"+-/%%"+&5/4-*2J"

8'(*":'069"4*'4%*"E'5F*2"+-02/'0+%:"-'E$52+"2'(/6$6-"6'-/'6+"'7"(/22%*Q&%$++"+0&&*++J"

K.*:"$+4/5*2"-'"1*"2'&-'5+>"9'"-'"&'%%*9*"$62"06/B*5+/-:J"T-.*5+"E*5*"+-50&-05*2"/6"-.*"/6B*5+*J"

,%+'"-.*"45'20&-+"'7"('6'%'9/&"-/(*>"-.*:".$2"1**6"*C4*%%*2"75'("+&.''%+"-.$-"6**2*2"-'"

($/6-$/6"'52*5"$62"%*$90*Q-$1%*"+&'5*+J"A5'6/&$%%:"7'5"-.*+*":'069"4*'4%*>"1*/69"'0-"25/6F/69"/6"

-.*"4$5F"'6"$"K0*+2$:"6/9.-"+*5B*2"'6%:"-'"/6&5*$+*"-.*"2*($62"7'5"$+4/5$-/'6"$62"&'67/5("-.*"

6**2"-'"9*-"-.*"-*(4'5$%%:"($%Q$2H0+-*2"1$&F"/6-'"*20&$-/'6j"1$&F"/6-'"G-.*"-/(*I"%/6*J"

"

TB*5"-.*"7/*%2E'5F"4*5/'2"A"E$+"/6&5*$+/69%:"&'675'6-*2"1:"-.*"W(0%-/Y"/6"-.*"5*+*$5&.J"=%05$%"

$445*&/$-/'6+"'7"+4$&*"$62"-/(*"/6"*B*5:2$:"%/7*"2*&'6+-50&-*2"-.*".*9*('6/&"-50-.+"

&'6-$/6*2"/6"6*'Q%/1*5$%"$+4/5$-/'6>"-*55/-'5:>"7'05"E$%%+>"1'5'09."1'062$5/*+>"6$-/'6$%"1'52*5+"

$62"*-.6/&"&$-*9'5/*+>"E./%*"$&F6'E%*29/69"-.*/5"45'4*6+/-:"-'"'52*5J"K.*:"./9.%/9.-*2"-.*"

6*&*++/-:"'7"B/*E/69"-.*":'0-."&%01"$+"$"B*./&%*"'7"-5$B*%"$62"2/+4%$&*(*6-"$+"E*%%"$+"$"+/-*"'7"

7/C/-:J"K.*"45$&-/&*+"-.$-".$44*6*2"/6"-.*":'0-."&%01"$62"-.*"(*$6/69"($2*"-.*5*"E*5*"6'-"

&'6-$/6*2"1:"-.*/5"E$%%+J"A"2/2"6'-"7**%"-.$-"-.*":'0-."&%01"6*9$-*2"-.*"6**2"-'"&'620&-"

*-.6'95$4./*+"'7"'-.*5"4.:+/&$%"+4$&*+j"5$-.*5"/-"'77*5*2"$"B*./&%*"-'"2'"H0+-"-.$-J"

\J >%'()!*-.6'95$4.:"

]5'("-.*"'0-+*-"A"/6-*62*2"-'"5%"*-.6'95$4.:J"K./+"E$+"$"4'%/-/&$%"&'((/-(*6-"-'"4$5-/&/4$6-"

'1+*5B$-/'6"$+"-.*"'6%:"(*-.'2"-.$-"&'0%2"%/+-*6"-'"-.*"4%05$%/-:"'7"-.*"5*+*$5&."*C4*5/*6&*"

G^$&F"?@@MI>"(*2/$-*"-.*"062*-*5(/6*2"$62"06F6'E$1%*"&'6+*h0*6&*+"'7"-.*"5*+*$5&."

*6&'06-*5"G,%*C$62*5"?@@O>"4J!\OI>"$62"5*+4'62"-'"-.*"4'E*5"2:6$(/&+"'7"-.*"5*+*$5&."

45'&*++"G,%/"?@@ej"R$($a$6'9%0"$62"_'%%$62"?@@?IJ"_'E*B*5>"$+"-./+"7'05-."+*&-/'6"*C4%'5*+>"

-./+"&'((/-(*6-"E$+"*$+:"-'",9'(="$62".$52*5"-'"5%"G,%*C$62*5"?@@O>"4J!\MIJ"

"

Page 49: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

\P"

"

,+"$"B'%06-$5:":'0-."E'5F*5>"A"2/2"(0&."'7"E.$-"-.*"'-.*5"+*++/'6$%"+-$77"2/2f"A"4'%/&*2"-.*"

10/%2/69"G+**"S.$4-*5"K.5**I>"-''F"4$5-"/6"$&-/B/-/*+>"'59$6/+*2"45'H*&-+>"5$6"E'5F+.'4+"$62"9'-"

6*5B'0+"E.*6"-./69+"E*5*"$1'0-"-'"F/&F"'77J"A"10/%-"5*%$-/'6+./4+"E/-.":'069"4*'4%*J"A"%*$56-"

/62/B/20$%"$62"&'%%*&-/B*"+-'5/*+"$62"-.*:"%*$56-"$1'0-"(*>"-'"-.*"*C-*6-"-.$-"$6:"'7"0+"E*5*"

/6-*5*+-*2"'5"E$6-*2"-'"+.$5*J"K.*"./9."-056'B*5"'7"+-$77"$-"-.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01"(*$6-"-.$-"

$7-*5"$1'0-"$":*$5"A"E$+"-.*"%'69*+-Q+*5B/69"+-$77"(*(1*5J"A"E$+"45'1$1%:>"7'5"+'(*":'069"

4*'4%*>"-.*"('+-"5*90%$5"$20%-"/6"-.*/5"%/7*J"_'E*B*5>"E/-."%/--%*"+&'4*"-'"5*7%*&-"'6"-./+"5*$%Q

-/(*>"A"5*$+'6*2"-.$-"-.*".$52*5"A"E'5F*2"$+"$":'0-."E'5F*5>"-.*"1*--*5"A"E'0%2"1*"$+"$6"

*-.6'95$4.*5"$62"B/&*QB*5+$J"K./+"E$+"&*5-$/6%:"6'-"-.*"7'5(0%$/&"45'&*205*"(*-.'2+"($60$%+"

$2B/+*"G_$((*5+%*:"$62",-F/6+'6"!PPNj"=$--'6"?@@?IJ"

"

,&&'06-/69"7'5"-./+"6'E"+**(+"-'"$22"+-$1/%/-:"-'"E.$-"E*5*"06+-$1%*"*6B/5'6(*6-+J"8-$77"$62"

:'069"4*'4%*"&$(*"$62"E*6-J"K.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01"+'(*-/(*+".$2"$+"($6:"$+"-E*6-:"6*E"

:'069"4*'4%*"7'5"*$&."+*++/'6J"=5'H*&-+"$%+'"&.$69*2J"d/-."-.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."X5'04>"A"E$+"

&'$&./69"7''-1$%%"'6*"E**F"$62"-.*6"'77"-'"4%$6"7'5"$6"$5-"*C./1/-/'6"-.*"6*C-J"K./+"($2*"/-"

2/77/&0%-"-'"E'5F"&%'+*%:"E/-."$6:"4$5-/&0%$5":'069"4*5+'6"'5"7'%%'E"$6:"/62/B/20$%"+-'5:J"A-"E$+"

$"+%'E"$62"06&*5-$/6"45'&*++J"]'5"('+-"'7"-.*"7/5+-":*$5"A"7*%-"/6"-.*"2$5F"/6"-*5(+"'7"(:"

5*+*$5&."$62"'6"-.*"4*5/4.*5:"/6"-*5(+"'7"-.*"/6+-/-0-/'6+J",+"A"&%'&F*2"-/(*"-./+"/(45'B*2>"

$%-.'09."+'(*":'069"4*'4%*"$62"+-$77"$%E$:+"5*($/6*2"2/+-$6-J"A6"5*+4'6+*"-'"-.*"%$&F"'7"

&*5-$/6-:>"A"9'-"/6B'%B*2"/6"$&-/B/-/*+"G4$5-/&/4$-'5:"(*-.'2+I"-.$-"E'0%2"$22"60$6&*"$62"

&'(4%*C/-:"-'"(:"/6-*545*-$-/'6+J"8'(*"A"/6+-/9$-*2"(:+*%7>"$62"+'(*"A"H'/6*2"/6"'6J"K.5'09."

/6B'%B/69"+-$77"$62":'069"4*'4%*"/6"-.*"7'5(0%$-/'6"$62"2*+/96"'7"$&-/B/-/*+>"A".'4*2"-.$-"-.*/5"

B'/&*+"E'0%2"1*&'(*"('5*"45'(/6*6->"-.*"2/$%'90*"2**4*5"$62"-.0+"2*&'6+-50&-"G-'"-.*"

%/(/-*2"*C-*6-"-.$-"-./+"/+"4'++/1%*I"-.*"4'E*5"'7"-.*"5*+*$5&.*5"$62"$20%-"$+"*C4*5-J"A"$%+'"

.'4*2"-.$-"$"95*$-*5"B$5/*-:"'7"$&-/B/-/*+"E'0%2"*69$9*"$"E/2*5"5$69*"'7":'069"4*'4%*J"

"

K.*"(*-.'2+"95*E"'59$6/&$%%:"/6"F**4/69"E/-."-.*"0645*2/&-$1%*"6$-05*"'7":'0-."E'5FJ","

60(1*5"'7"/2*$+"6*B*5"($2*"/-J"8'(*"E*5*"4''5%:"401%/&/+*2"'5"6'-"7'%%'E*2"-.5'09.J"8'(*"

2/2"6'-"&$4-05*"-.*"/6-*5*+-"'7"+-$77"'5":'069"4*'4%*J"T-.*5+"E*5*"'B*5-$F*6"1:"'-.*5"*B*6-+"g"

+'(*-./69"-.$-".$2".$44*6*2"$-"+&.''%>"$"1$2"(''2>"'5"-.*"9*6*5$%"2:6$(/&"'7"-.$-"2$:J"d*"

40-"-'9*-.*5"$"(0+/&"+-02/'"-.$-"9'-"6'"0+*j"A".*%4*2"&'$&."$"7''-1$%%"-*$("E.*5*"$%%"-.*"

4%$:*5+"E*5*"1*--*5"-.$6"(*j"E*"+-$5-*2"$":'0-."&%01"$-"-.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."=5'H*&-"-.$-"E$+"

1$5*%:"$--*62*2j"$62"2*B*%'4*2"$"B/2*'"45'H*&-"-.$-".$2"6'"-$F*Q04J"K.*5*"E$+"$"./9."2*95**"

Page 50: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

N@"

"

'7"06&*5-$/6-:"/6"*B*5:-./69"*C&*4-"-.$-"A"E'0%2"1*"-.*5*"$9$/6"/6"$"&'04%*"'7"2$:+J"A-"($2*"

4%$66/69"2/77/&0%-J"^0-"-.*"('5*"E*"-5/*2>"-.*"('5*"&.$6&*"E*".$2"'7"9*--/69"+'(*-./69"'77"-.*"

95'062j"$62"-.*"('5*"A"'77*5*2"(:"-/(*>"-.*"('5*"A"%*$56->"-.*"1*--*5"A"%/+-*6*2"$62"-.*"%*++"A"

062*5+-''2J"

"

305/69"-.*"+45/69"15*$F"?@@P>"A"'77*5*2"-'"7$&/%/-$-*"$"B/2*'"45'H*&-"$5'062"2$6&*"+*++/'6+"

+-$5-*2"1:"B'%06-**5+"$62":'069"4*'4%*"$-";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01J"A"E$+"WZ'0K01*"#$6Y"$62"-.*"

45'H*&-"E$+"8+/94&!>4($+-!G+**"S.$4-*5"]'05IJ"K.*"B/2*'Q($F/69"45'&*++"E$+"45*2/&-$1%:"

+-'4Q+-$5-Q$62Q5*6*9'-/$-*J"_'E*B*5>"-.*"5*Q+-$5-/69>"-.*"($F/69"$62"-.*"2/+&0++/69"45'B/2*2"

*C&*%%*6-"*-.6'95$4./&"'44'5-06/-/*+"$62"('(*6-+"'7"2/$%'90*J"A"%*$56-"$1'0-"-.*"(*$6/69"'7"

-.*"(0+/&>"1'2/*+"$62"+4$&*+>"401%/&"&'((06/&$-/'6>"4*57'5($6&*>"$62"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"-.*"

2$6&*J"K./+"45'H*&-"/6B'%B*2"$1'0-"-./5-:"&./%25*6"$62":'069"4*'4%*"$9*2"1*-E**6"-*6"$62"

+/C-**6J"</9.-"&./%25*6"$62":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"/6B'%B*2"/6"-.*"/6-*5B/*E"$62"7/%("*2/-/69"

45'&*++J"K./+"E$+"-.*"7/5+-"/6"$"+*5/*+"'7"4$5-/&/4$-'5:"(*-.'2+"g"&'%%*&-/B*%:"&$%%*2"4$5-/&/4$6-"

%$62+&$4*+??"$62"+'062+&$4*+J?O"K./+"$6$%:+/+"'7":'069"4*'4%*Y+"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+"%$--*5%:"

*C-*62*2"/6-'"-.*"*C4%'5$-/'6"'7"'-.*5"./4".'4D95/(*"(0+/&"B/2*'+"$225*++*2"/6"S.$4-*5+"]'05"

$62"]/B*J"

"

,-"-.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."=5'H*&->"A"/6/-/$-*2"4.'-'Q*%/&/-$-/'6"/6-*5B/*E+"$62"$"B/2*'"$62"+'062Q

($44/69"45'H*&-J?\"K.*+*"9$B*"/6+/9.-+"/6-'"-.*":'069"4*'4%*Y+"./+-'5/&/+*2"$62"+4$-/$%"E'5%2+J"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""??"8**"$%+'"^$&F"?@@Nj"W_'(*"$62",E$:Y"*C./1/-/'6"$-"-.*"#0+*0("'7"S./%2.''2j"8$62*5+'6"*-"$%J"?@@Mj"

c*$%*"?@@NJ"?O"8**"$%+'"^$&F"?@@O$j"S'66'5"?@@Oj"X/%5':"?@@Oj"A.2*"?@@Oj"8&.$7*5"!PP\j"K./1$02"?@@Oj"K'6F/++"?@@OJ"?\"=$5-/&/4$-'5:"4.'-'95$4.:>"*+4*&/$%%:"E.*6"$&&'(4$6/*2"1:"-.*"6$55$-/B*"'7"-.*"4.'-'95$4.*5>".$+"

1*&'(*"/6&5*$+/69%:"5*&'96/+*2"/6"*-.6'95$4.:"G^$&F"?@@Nj"S''F"$62"_*++"?@@Mj"=/6F"?@@Mj"K.'(+'6"

?@@Vj"KE/6*"?@@eI"$62"$&-/'6"5*+*$5&."G3*66/+")5"*-"$%J"?@@Pj"`5/*9"$62"R'1*5-+"?@@MI"$+"$"B$%0$1%*"E$:"

'7"9$/6/69"/6+/9.-"/6-'"+'&/$%"E'5%2+J"K.*"0+*"'7"4$5-/&/4$-'5:"4.'-'95$4.:"*69$9*+":'069"4*'4%*"/6"

&$4-05/69"$+4*&-+"'7"-.*/5"+'&/$%"E'5%2"G3*66/+")5"*-"$%J"?@@P>"4J\ePIJ"d.*6":'069"4*'4%*"($F*"2*&/+/'6+"

'6"/($9*"+*%*&-/'6>"/($9*"4%$&*(*6-"$62"45'B/2*"6$55$-/B*>"-.*"-*&.6/h0*":/*%2+"4'E*570%"+-'5/*+"'7"

:'069"%/B*+"/6"%'&$%"+4$&*+J"S'(1/6*2"E/-."4$5-/&/4$-'5:"+'&/$%"($44/69"Gc*$%*"?@@N>"44J?Neg?NPI"$62"

4$5-/&/4$-'5:"&$5-'95$4.:"G-.*"W_'(*"$62",E$:Y"*C./1/-/'6"$-"-.*"#0+*0("'7"S./%2.''2j"8$62*5+'6"*-"

$%J"?@@MI>"4$5-/&/4$-'5:"4.'-'95$4.:"&$6"*6$1%*":'069"4*'4%*"$62"&./%25*6"-'"-./6F"$1'0-"-.*/5"%'&$%"

*C4*5/*6&*+"$62"-.*"(*$6/69"-.*+*".$B*"7'5"-.*(J"

Page 51: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

N!"

"

K.*"4.'-'Q*%/&/-$-/'6"/6-*5B/*E+"E*5*"&'620&-*2"*/-.*5"/6"95'04+"'5"4**5Q-'Q4**5J"]/B*"($%*"

$62"7*($%*":'069"4*'4%*"$9*2"1*-E**6"-./5-**6"$62"+*B*6-**6"-''F"4$5-"G+**"S.$4-*5"]/B*IJ"

K.*"B/2*'"$62"+'062Q($44/69"45'H*&->"062*5"-.*"-/-%*"^9+3+!L!8'*+2!^94,!L!^4(,>"&'6&*6-5$-*2"

'6"-.*"+/9.-+"$62"+'062+"'7"E.*5*"-.*:"%/B*2J"A"E$+"/6-*5*+-*2"/6"-.*"E$:"-.$-":'069"4*'4%*"

-.'09.-"$1'0-"+4$&*"$62".'E"-.*:"45'H*&-*2"-.*/5".'5/a'6+"G+**"S.$4-*5+"KE'"$62"]/B*IJ",+"$"

4/*&*"'7"$&-/'6"5*+*$5&.>"-.*"'59$6/+$-/'6"E$+"/6-*5*+-*2"/6"45'B/2/69"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"E/-."

$2B'&$&:"$62"5*+*$5&."+F/%%+J",7-*5"7/B*"('6-.+>"-.*"45'H*&-"5*+0%-*2"/6"$":'069Q4*5+'6Q&*6-5*2"

+'6/&"$62"B/+0$%"($4>"($2*"04"'7"B/2*'+>"+'062"5*&'52/69+"$62"/6-*5B/*E+"E/-."%'&$%"4*'4%*J"

K.*+*"'0-40-+"E*5*"$6$%:+*2"$62"2*&'2*2"1:"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"$62"*C./1/-*2"$-"TC7'52"K'E6"

_$%%J"

"

^*&$0+*"'7"-.*"4.:+/&$%/-:"'7"4$5-/&/4$-/'6"/6"-.*":'0-."&%01+"$62"(:"&'6&*56+"$1'0-"1*/69"

+**6"$+"+4:>"A"'6%:"*B*5"($2*"(/6/($%"$62"2/+&5**-"7/*%2"6'-*+"/6"-.*"+*++/'6"/-+*%7J"

S'6+*h0*6-%:>"-.*"7/*%2"6'-*+"G/6&%02/69"2*+&5/4-/'6"$62"$6$%:+*+"'7"*B*6-+I"E*5*"%$59*%:"

E5/--*6"'5"5*&'52*2"$7-*5"-.*"+*++/'6+J"#'+-"6'-*+"75'("-.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01"E*5*"E5/--*6"04"

/6"$"&$7*"'6"^$5F/69"R'$2"E./%*"A"E$/-*2"7'5"(:"2/66*5J"K.*";*:.$("+*++/'6+"E*5*"E5/--*6"04"

E.*6"A"9'-"1$&F"$-"-*6"'Y&%'&F"/6"-.*"*B*6/69"'5"5*&'52*2"E./%*"&:&%/69".'(*J"K.*",%1$6/$6"

Z'0-."=5'H*&-"7/*%2"6'-*+"E*5*"$%+'"E5/--*6"E.*6"A"9'-".'(*J"K.*"7'5($-"'7"-.*"6'-*+"$62"

E.*5*"A"E5'-*"-.*("($--*5*2J"84*$F/69"-.*"6'-*+"/6-'"-.*".$62+Q75**"+*-"E./%*"&:&%/69".'(*"

E$+"%*++"5*+-5/&-/B*"-.$6"E5/-/69"-.*(>"$62"+**(*2"-'"'77*5"-.*"75**2'("-'"1*"%*++"+'&/'%'9/&$%"

$62"('5*"6$55$-/B*"/6"(:"$6$%:+/+"'7"*B*6-+J"K.*+*"6'-*+"E*5*"$%+'"('5*"*('-/B*"$62"%*++"

&'6+-5$/6*2J"U'-*+"E5/--*6"04"/6"-.*"&$7*"E*5*"45'1$1%:"./62*5*2"1:"(:"'(*%*--*"$62"&./4+J"

c*51$>"`/69"$62"`*'6*"E'0%2"6'-".$B*"1**6"/(45*++*2"E/-."(:"/6$--*6-/'6"-'"5*%/$1/%/-:"G`/69"

*-"$%J"!PP\IJ"A6"-'-$%"A"&'%%*&-*2".0625*2+"'7"-.'0+$62+"'7"E'52+"'7"7/*%2"6'-*+J""

"

=$5-/&/4$6-"'1+*5B$-/'6"$62"4$5-/&/4$6-"(*-.'2+"E*5*"-.*"45/6&/4$%"(*$6+"'7"45'20&/69"-.*"

+-'5/*+"&'6-$/6*2"/6"-./+"-.*+/+>"10-"+*(/Q+-50&-05*2"/6-*5B/*E+"E*5*"*(4%':*2"-''J"8*(/Q

+-50&-05*2"/6-*5B/*E+"GR01/6"$62"R01/6"?@@NI"E/-.":'069"4*'4%*>"+-$77"(*(1*5+"$62"

B'%06-**5+"E*5*"0+*2"-'"7'&0+"'6"6*E"-.*(*+"$62"/2*$+"-.$-"$5'+*"205/69"-.*"5*+*$5&.J"K./+"

-*&.6/h0*"$%%'E*2"-.*"5*+*$5&."-'"('B*"'0-"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01"$62"/6-'"45*B/'0+%:"./22*6"

4*5+'6$%>"&'%%*&-/B*"$62"./+-'5/&$%"+4$&*+J"8*(/Q+-50&-05*2"/6-*5B/*E+"E*5*"$%+'"*(4%':*2"$-"

-.*"1*9/66/69"'7"-.*"45'H*&-"-'"9$-.*5"-.*"4*5+4*&-/B*+"'7":'0-."+*5B/&*"45'B/2*5+J"A"&'620&-*2"

-E*%B*"/6-*5B/*E+"E/-."+-$77"$62"-E*%B*"E/-.":'069"4*'4%*"$-"-.*"&*6-5*+"E.*5*"A"E'5F*2J"T7"

Page 52: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

N?"

"

-.*+*>".$%7"-.*"5*+4'62*6-+"E*5*"($%*"$62".$%7"7*($%*>"1'-."7'5":'0-."E'5F*5+"$62":'069"

4*'4%*J"#'+-"/6-*5B/*E+"E*5*"'6*Q'6Q'6*"10-"+'(*"E*5*"&'620&-*2"/6"+($%%"95'04+J",%%"-.*"

:'069"4*'4%*"A"/6-*5B/*E*2"E*5*"$9*2"1*-E**6"-./5-**6"$62"6/6*-**6J"#'+-"/6-*5B/*E+"E/-."

:'069"4*'4%*"%$+-*2"$1'0-"-E*6-:"(/60-*+"$%-.'09."+'(*"%$+-*2"7'5"'6*".'05J"A"/6-*5B/*E*2"

-E*6-:Q7'05":'0-."+*5B/&*"45'B/2*5+f"+*B*6-**6"($%*"$62"+*B*6"7*($%*J"A6-*5B/*E+"E/-."+-$77"

$62"+*5B/&*"45'B/2*5+"%$+-*2"1*-E**6"-./5-:"(/60-*+"-'"'6*".'05J"A6"-'-$%"7'5-:Q*/9.-"+*(/Q

+-50&-05*2"/6-*5B/*E+"E*5*"&'620&-*2J"

"

,+"4$5-"'7"-.*"5*+*$5&."2/$%'90*"$62"/67'5(*2"&'6+*6->"A"*69$9*2"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"/6"-.*"

7'5($-/'6"'7"/6-*5B/*E"+&.*20%*+"g"-$F/69"25$7-+"-'":'0-."&%01+"$62"$+F/69"7'5"7**21$&FJ?N"

T&&$+/'6$%%:"-.*:"$+F*2"h0*+-/'6+"'7"&%$5/7/&$-/'6"10-"0+0$%%:"-.*:"4'/6-*2"'0-"+4*%%/69"*55'5+J"

,7-*5"-.*"/6-*5B/*E+".$2"1**6"&'620&-*2>"A"E5'-*"-.*("04"$62"5*-056*2"-.*("-'"-.*"

/6-*5B/*E**+J"A"E$+"/6-*5*+-*2"/6"E.$-"-.*/5"5*+4'6+*+"(/9.-"1*J"8'(*"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"

.$2"($2*"+-5'69"$62"4'-*6-/$%%:"&'6-5'B*5+/$%"+-$-*(*6-+"$62"A"E$6-*2"-'"9/B*"-.*("$"&.$6&*"

-'"5*7%*&-"'6"-.*/5"&'((*6-+J"_'E*B*5>"A"2/26Y-"2/5*&-%:"+'%/&/-"-./+J"3*+4/-*"(:"*6&'05$9*(*6-"

('+-"E*5*"6'-"/6-*5*+-*2"/6"5*$2/69"-.*"-5$6+&5/4-+J"K.'+*"-.$-"E*5*>"4'/6-*2"'0-"('5*"-:4'+"

'5"%$09.*2"$-"-.*"&'6-5'B*5+/$%"-./69+"-.*:".$2"+$/2J"T-.*5":'069"4*'4%*"%*7-"-.*("$5'062"-.*"

:'0-."&%01"7'5"'-.*5+"-'"5*$2J"

"

]'%%'E/69"-.*"&'6&%0+/'6"'7"-.*"7/*%2E'5F>"$%%"5*+*$5&."($-*5/$%+"E*5*"*6-*5*2"/6-'"Uc/B'"

E./&.".$+"-.*"&$4$&/-:"-'"($6$9*"$62"&'2*"-*C->"+'062"7/%*+"$62"B/2*'+J"Uc/B'"E$+"0+*2"

45/($5/%:"$+"$"($6$9*(*6-"-''%"-'"7$&/%/-$-*"-.*"6$B/9$-/'6"$5'062".'05+"'7"B/2*'"$62"+'062"

7/%*+"$62"!@@>@@@+"E'52+"'7"-*C-J"A-"E$+"$%+'"0+*2"-'"&'2*"$62"*+-$1%/+."&'6&*4-0$%"75$(/69+"7'5"

&.$4-*5+J"R$-.*5"-.$6"7'%%'E"$"95'062*2"-.*'5:"('2*%"-.$-"5*%/*+"'6"-.*"1*%/*7"/6"$"5*$%"

+&*6$5/'"75'("E./&."-.*"2$-$"95'E+>"-.*"('2*%"'7"$6$%:+/+"A"$2'4-*2"E$+"('5*"$F/6"-'"d/%%/+Y+"

(*-.'2"7'5"2*B*%'4/69"&'6&*4-+"$62"-*+-/69"-.*'5/*+"Gd/%%/+"?@@!j"d/%%/+"$62"K5'62($6"?@@?IJ"

K'"-.$-"*C-*6->"-.*"$6$%:+/+"E$+"$6"/-*5$-/B*"45'&*++"1*-E**6"-.*"%/-*5$-05*>"7/*%2E'5F"$62"

&'%%*&-*2"*-.6'95$4./&"($-*5/$%+J"

"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""?N"306*/*5"$62"^$&F"45'B/2*"2/+&0++/'6+"'7"-./+"2/$%'9/&"45'&*++"G^$&F"?@@Mj"306*/*5"$62"S$5-*5"?@@!j"

306*/*5"$62"^$&F"?@@eIJ"

Page 53: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

NO"

"

K./+"+*&-/'6".$+"45*+*6-*2"H0+-"+'(*"'7"-.*"7/*%2E'5F"45$&-/&*+"/6B'%B*2"/6"-.*"45$&-/&*"'7"

5%'()"*-.6'95$4.:J"K.*+*"$5*"6'-"2*+/96*2"-'"%*9/-/($-*"-.*"+01+-$6-/B*"&.$4-*5+J"R$-.*5>"

-.*/5"-*%%/69"/62/&$-*+"-.*"45'&*++"$62"2$:Q-'Q2$:"2/$%'90*"/6.*5*6-"/6"-.*"5*+*$5&."*6&'06-*5J"

K.*:"+.'E".'E"7/*%2E'5F"45$&-/&*+"E*5*"6*9'-/$-*2j".'E"2/$%'90*"$62"/62*-*5(/6$&:"E*5*"

&'6-/69*6-"&.$5$&-*5/+-/&+"'7"-.*"*-.6'95$4./&"45'&*++j"$62>".'E"2/77*5*6-"$445'$&.*+"E*5*"

-$F*6"/6"5*+4'6+*"-'"7/*%2"*B*6-+J"K.*:"+4*$F"'7"7$/%05*>"$62"-.*"$9*6&:"'7"+-$77"$62":'069"

4*'4%*J"K.*:"+.'E".'E"-.*"*-.6'95$4.:"067'%2*2"/6"&'66*&-/'6"E/-."'-.*5"4*'4%*"E/-./6"

&*5-$/6"+4$&*+>"$62".'E"7/*%2E'5F"45$&-/&*+"E*5*"7'5(*2"-.5'09."l&'(4%*C"H029*(*6-+"E/-."

(:5/$2"&'6-/69*6&/*+n"GR'+$%2'"!PPO>"4J!!MIJ"

NJ <-./&+f"&'(4%/&/-:>"G2/+I&'(7'5-"$62"2/$%'90*?e"

K.*"45*&*2/69"+*&-/'6+"'0-%/6*"$"&'((/-(*6-"-'",9'(='()"$62"5%'()"*-.6'95$4.:J"K.*:"2/+&0++"

-.*"(0%-/Q+/-*2"6$-05*"'7"-.*"5*+*$5&.>".'E"7/*%2E'5F"45$&-/&*+"E*5*"062*-*5(/6*2"$62"&'Q

2*-*5(/6*2"5$-.*5"-.$6"45*Q2*-*5(/6*2>"$62".'E"(*$6/69"E$+"$%%*9'5/&$%"$62"&'Q45'20&*2"

5$-.*5"-.$6"5*$%"$62"('6'%'9/&$%J"K./+"7/6$%"+*&-/'6"$225*++*+"-.*"*-./&+"'7"-.*"5*+*$5&.>"6'-"$+"

$"2*-$&.*2"$62"204%/&/-'0+"+-$-*(*6-"'7"065*h0/-*2"/6-*6-"10-"$+"$6"*69$9*(*6-"E/-."*-./&+"

$+"2/$%'90*f"45'20&-/B*"$62"45'20&*2j"&'(4%/&/-"$62"G06I&'(7'5-$1%*J"

"

,"h0/&F"7%/&F"-.5'09."$"(*-.'2+"1''F"G_$((*5+%*:"$62",-F/6+'6"!PPNj"=$--'6"?@@?I"'5"$6"

*-./&$%"+-$-*(*6-"G^5/-/+."8'&/'%'9/&$%",++'&/$-/'6"?@@?I"5*(/62+"-.*"5*$2*5"'7"+-$62$52"*-./&$%"

&'6&*56+"$62"45$&-/&*+J"WR$44'5-Y>"W+4'6+'5+Y>"W9$-*F**4*5+Y"$62"W.$5(Y"45'B/2*"&$51'6Q&'4:"

.*$2/69+"7'5"*-./&$%"45$&-/&*J",%-.'09."-.*+*"+-$62$52+"'5/*6-*2"(:"/6/-/$%"$445'$&.>"$+"-.*:"

/6-*5$&-*2"E/-."'-.*5"*-./&$%"&'6+/2*5$-/'6+"-.*:"1*&$(*"/6&5*$+/69%:"1%055*2J"K.*"-.5**":'0-."

&%01+"E*5*"&'(4%/&$-*2>"4*5+'6$%"$62"/6+-/-0-/'6$%>"*-./&$%"+4$&*+"E/-."E./&."-.*"5*+*$5&."

1*&$(*"/6-*5-E/6*2J"A6/-/$%%:>"-.*+*"*-./&+"+**(*2"$-"'22+"E/-."(:"4*5+'6$%"$62"45'7*++/'6$%"

'5/*6-$-/'6J"_'E*B*5>"'B*5"-/(*"-.*"*-./&+"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01"1*&$(*"/6-0/-/B*"$62".$1/-0$%"

G#*5%*$0Q='6-:"?@@?I"$62"(:"'5/9/6$%"'5/*6-$-/'6"'6%:"'6*"'7"($6:"&'(4*-/69"/67%0*6&*+J"

"

A"%*$56-"-.*"*-./&$%"4'+/-/'6"'7"-.*"W:'0-."E'5F*5YJ"K./+"E$+"%$59*%:"-.*"W:'0-."E'5F*5Y"-.$-"

:'069"4*'4%*"$62"+-$77"*C4*&-*2J"d.*6"A"E$+"E'5F/69>"A"*C*5-*2"$0-.'5/-:"$+"$6"$20%->"$"($6>"$"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""?e"S'(4%/&/-:".$+"$%+'"1**6"2/+&0++*2"1:",%*C$62*5"G?@@O>"4J!\?I>"^$&F"G?@@?I>"$62"d$5*"G?@@?IJ"

Page 54: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

N\"

"

E./-*>"$6"W<69%/+.Y>"$62"$"06/B*5+/-:"+-02*6-"G,%*C$62*5"?@@e>"4J\@Nj",%/"?@@ej"^0-%*5"!PPPj"

Z0B$%Q3$B/+"?@@e>"4J?@!IJ"A"$&&*4-*2"+'(*"%'&$-/'6+"$62"5*H*&-*2"'-.*5+J"A"E$+"&$%%*2"04'6"-'"

1*"$0-.'5/-$-/B*"$62"A"2/2"/->"+'(*-/(*+"5*%0&-$6-%:J"A"*+-$1%/+.*2"(:+*%7"/6"&*5-$/6"5015/&+"-.$-"

$77*&-*2"-.*"+4$&*>"4*'4%*Y+"*C4*5/*6&*+"'7"(*"$62"(:"/6-*545*-$-/'6"'7"*B*6-+J"K.5'09."-.*+*"

4*57'5($6&*+>"(:"B$%0*+"E*5*"($2*"*B/2*6->"$62"$2(/--*2%:"-./+"+.'E*2"(*"-'"1*"

06&'(7'5-$1%*"E/-."&*5-$/6"F/62+"'7"4%$:"-.$-"A"45'1$1%:"(/+-''F"7'5"+'(*-./69"('5*"+/6/+-*5J"

A-"$%+'"+.'E*2"-.*"*C-*6-"-'"E./&."A"7/--*2"/6"$62"2/26Y-J"

"

K.*+*"%'&$-/'6+>"F6'E%*29*"$62"&'(4*-*6&/*+"E*5*"&5'++Q&0-"1:"&%$++>"W5$&*Y"$62"9*62*5J"A6"

+'(*"&$+*+>"(:"E./-*6*++"1*&$(*"$44$5*6-"$+"$"7*$-05*"-.$-"+022*6%:"($2*"+*6+*"'7"5$&/$%"

$62"5$&/+-"2:6$(/&+J"A"E$+"'7-*6"06&'(7'5-$1%*"E/-."1$6-*5"A"4*5&*/B*2"-'"1*>"10-"+'(*-/(*+"

E$+6Y->"5$&/+-J"A".$2"1**6"15'09.-"04"%/1*5$%"(/22%*Q&%$++"$62"+01+&5/1/69"-'"-.*"B$%0*+"'7"$6-/Q

5$&/+(>"/5'6/&$%%:"'7-*6"$5-/&0%$-*2"/6"-*5(+"'7"W5$&*YJ",+"+0&.>"5$&/+("E$+"+'(*-./69"A"7*%-"A"

+.'0%2"$B'/2"10-"'B*5"-/(*"/-"1*&$(*"&%*$5"-.$-"A"E$+"4$5-"'7"/-+"45'20&-/'6J"A"E5'-*"/6"(:"7/*%2"

6'-*+".'E"8$5$."$62"`:%/*"E*5*"-5$2/69"/6+0%-+J"`:%/*"+$/2"l:'05"(0("+'%2".*5"-**-."7'5"&5$&FnJ"

8$5$."5*-'5-*2"l:'05"(0("+'%2".*5"E.'%*".'0+*"-'"$";/-.0$6/$6"7'5"&5$&FnJ"^'-."-.*"WE.'%*"

.'0+*Y"$62"-.*"7/905*"'7"-.*"W;/-.0$6/$6Y"E*5*"0+*2"-'"($F*"-.*"H'F*"('5*"*C-5*(*J"A"%$09.*2>"

-.*"*C-5*(/-:"E$+"7066:>"$62"-.*6"7*%-"90/%-:>"&'(4%/&/-J"A"E$+"4$5-"'7"-.*"(*$6/69"($F/69J",+"

$6"$02/*6&*"(*(1*5>"(:"E./-*6*++"$62"&%$++"4'+/-/'6".$2"($2*"-.*"H'F*"4'++/1%*"G_*E/--"

?@@M>"4J!?j"+**"$%+'"S.$4-*5"K.5**"'7"-./+"-.*+/+IJ"#:"2**4"2/+&'(7'5-"E/-."-.*+*"%'&$-/'6+"

'6%:"&'67/5(*2"-.*"E$:"A"E$+"'52*5*2"/6"-.*(J""

"

_'E*B*5>"-.*"E$:"A"%'&$-*2"(:+*%7"/6"-.*+*"5$&/$%"2:6$(/&+"E$+"'7-*6"$-"'22+"E/-."-.*"E$:+"

-.*":'069"4*'4%*"4'+/-/'6*2"(*J",%-.'09."A"-.'09.-"A"E$+"1*/69"5*$2"/6"&*5-$/6"E$:+>"

+'(*-/(*+"A"E$+6Y-J"K.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01"E$+"$--*62*2"1:":'069"4*'4%*"75'("($6:"2/77*5*6-"

(/95$-'5:"1$&F95'062+J",-"-.*"1*9/66/69>"$+"$"6*E"$55/B$%>"A"/($9/6*2"-.$-"A"*C/+-*2"'0-+/2*"'7"

-.*/5"&'+('4'%/-$6"75$(/69"G*C4%'5*2"/6"S.$4-*5"KE'I"$62"/6"-./+"E$:"$++0(*2"-.*"45/B/%*9*"'7"

E./-*"(/22%*Q&%$++"/6B/+/1/%/-:"G3:*5"!PPMIj"-.$-"E$+"06-/%"`$(/%>"'6*"'7"-.*":'069"(*6>"$+F*2"/7"

A"E$+"84$6/+.>"-.*6"]5*6&.>"-.*6",0+-5$%/$6"1*7'5*"2*&/2/69"-.$-"($:1*"A"E$+"l$6"<69%/+.nJ"

"

A"$%+'"%*$56-"-.*"9*62*5*2"*-./&+"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01+J",%%"-.*":'0-."&%01+>"$62"4$5-/&0%$5%:"

;*:.$("$62"-.*",7-*5"8&.''%"&%01>"E*5*"($+&0%/6/+*2"+4$&*+J"T52*5"E$+"%$59*%:"($/6-$/6*2"

-.5'09."-.*"-.5*$-"'7"B/'%*6&*"g"B*51$%"'5"4.:+/&$%"g"$62"$-"-/(*+"A"7*%-"%/F*"$"&%01"1'06&*5"

Page 55: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

NN"

"

+-$62/69"'6"-.*"*29*"'7"-''Q%'02Q-'Q-$%F"(0+/&"$62"2$6&/69"1'2/*+J"^'-."-.*"7*($%*"$62"($%*"

E'5F*5+"-''F"4$5-"/6"-.*+*"7'5(+"'7"&5'E2"&'6-5'%J"_'E*B*5>"/-"E$+"%*7-"-'"-.*"($%*"+-$77"-'"9*-"

4.:+/&$%%:"/6B'%B*2"G+**"S.$4-*5"K.5**IJ""T6"'&&$+/'6+>"-.*:"5$6"'0-"/6-'"-.*"%'&$%"+-5**-+"$7-*5"

$++$/%$6-+>"E*6-"'77"+/-*"-'"15*$F"04"7/9.-+"1*-E**6":'069"4*'4%*>"$62"-'%2"+-'5/*+"'7"4.:+/&$%"

45'-*&-/'6J"A"'7-*6"7*%-"-.$-"A"+.'0%2"5*9$%*"-.*("$%%"E/-."(:"45'E*++"10-"E$+"%$59*%:"

06&'(7'5-$1%*"E/-."-./+"5'%*"GR'1/6+"$62"S'.*6"!PMVIJ"K./+"/+"6'-"-'"+$:"-.$-"A"E$+6Y-"

4'+/-/'6*2"$+"$"($6J"#$+&0%/6*"*-./&+"E*5*"$"+-50&-05$%"7*$-05*"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01+J"K.*5*"E$+"

$"($%*"45*+*6&*"/6"$%%"+*++/'6+"/6"&$+*"$6:-./69"F/&F*2"'77>"E./&."/-"+'(*-/(*+"2/2J";*:.$("

E'0%2"6'-"'4*6"06%*++"-.*5*"E*5*"-E'"($%*"E'5F*5+"'6"+/-*J",%-.'09."A"E$+"'6%:"*B*5"$"

B'%06-**5>"A"E$+"$%+'"+'(*-/(*+"$+F*2"-'"1*"-.*"+*&'62"($%*"45*+*6&*J"K./+"9$B*"(*"$6"

06*$+:"5*+4'6+/1/%/-:"$+"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"$62"+-$77"*C4*&-*2"(*"-'"$&-"$&&'52/69%:>"$62"'6"

('5*"-.$6"'6*"'&&$+/'6"A"E$+"&$%%*2"04'6"-'"W1$6Y"$":'069"4*5+'6"75'("-.*"+/-*"G+**"S.$4-*5"

K.5**IJ"

"

,2'4-/69"-.*+*".$1/-0$%"4'+/-/'6+"$%+'"$77*&-*2"(:"5*%$-/'6+"E/-."7*($%*"$--*62**+J"T6"-.*"

E.'%*"/-"E$+"2**(*2"$445'45/$-*>"1:"+-$77"$62":'069"4*'4%*"$%/F*>"-.$-"-.*"7*($%*"+-$77"

E'5F*2"E/-.":'069"E'(*6"$62"-.*"($%*"+-$77"E/-."-.*":'069"(*6J"S'6+&/'0+"'7"-./+"A"-5/*2"-'"

-5$6+95*++"-.*+*"%/6*+>"10-"7'062"-.$-"-.*+*"&'6+&/'0+"$&-+"'7"-5$6+95*++/'6"E*5*"'0-"'7"+-*4"

E/-."-.*".$1/-0$%"*-./&+"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01"G#*5%*$0Q='6-:"!PVPI>"$62"-.*/5"'1B/'0+6*++"

./62*5*2"-.*"&'6B*5+$-/'6+"A"+'09.-J"

"

_'E*B*5>"-.*"/6*B/-$1%*"*C/+-*6&*"'7"-.*+*"4'E*5"5*%$-/'6+"$62"(:"&'67'5(/-:"-'"-.*("2/2"6'-"

5*+0%-"/6"&:6/&/+(J"A"-5/*2>"10-"'7-*6"7$/%*2>"-'"$2'4-"$"%*$+-Q'445*++/B*"$445'$&."-'"($+&0%/6*"

$0-.'5/-:>"4.:+/&$%"+-5*69-.>"45'H*&-/69"+*C0$%/-:"$62"(/22%*Q&%$++"('5$%/-:>"062*5+-''2"/6"-.*"

+4*&/7/&"&'6-*C-+"/6"E./&."A"E$+"E'5F/69"G=$+&'*"?@@MIJ",62"A"-5/*2"-'"062*5+-$62"-.*"E$:+"-.$-"

$C/+"'7"'445*++/'6"($6/7*+-*2"/-+*%7"/6"2/77*5*6-"+4$&*+>"E/-."2/77*5*6-"4*'4%*"$62"'6"2/77*5*6-"

+&$%*+"G,%/"?@@e>"4J\Mej"R$($a$6'9%0"$62"_'%%$62"?@@?IJ",-"-.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01>"('+-"'7"-.*"

$--*62**+"E*5*":'069"(*6"$62"-.*"$&-/B/-/*+"g"7''-1$%%>"-$1%*"-*66/+>"4''%"$62"&'(40-*5"

9$(*+"g"E*5*"'5/*6-*2"-'E$52+"-.*(J"A6"$6"*77'5-"-'"45'B/2*"+4$&*"7'5"-.*"95'E/69"60(1*5"'7"

7*($%*"$--*62**+>"2/+&0++/'6+"E*5*".*%2"'6".'E"-'"&5*$-*"$"+4$&*"7'5"-.*"7*($%*"(*(1*5+"

-.$-"E$+"6'-"&'62/-/'6*2"1:"-.*"($%*"9$a*"G_$5$E$:"!PVVIJ"^'-.":'069"(*6"$62"E'(*6"

*6H':*2"7%/5-/69"$62"'1H*&-/7:/69"*$&."'-.*5J"_'E*B*5>"E.*6"-.*":'069"(*6"9'-"1'5*2"-.*:"

.$2"-.*"+*&05/-:"'7"-.*"($%*Q&*6-5*2"4''%"-$1%*"'5"7''-1$%%"($-&."-'"5*-5*$-"-'J"K.*":'069"

Page 56: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

Ne"

"

E'(*6".$2"6'"+0&."5*&'05+*J"A6"5*+4'6+*>"E*".*%2"$"&'6+0%-$-/'6"E/-."-.*":'069"E'(*6J"K./+"

%*2"-'"$"7*($%*"2/+&0++/'6"95'04"$62"$"7*($%*"7''-1$%%"$7-*56''6J"K.*"2'01%*"1/62"

GX06$5$-6$("?@@OI"'7"-.*+*"*77'5-+"E$+"-.$-"-.5'09."45'('-/69"+4$&*+"7'5"7*($%*"*C45*++/'6"

E*"E*5*"+4$-/$%%:"*6$&-/69".*-*5'6'5($-/B/-:J"

"

A"E$+"$%+'"&'(4%/&/-"/6"($/6-$/6/69"(:"(/22%*Q&%$++"%'&$-/'6J"A-"E$+"'B*5E.*%(/69%:"&%$++"-.$-"A"

E$+"$E$5*"'7"E.*6"A"+-$5-*2"E'5F/69"/6";*:.$(J"8''6"$7-*5"('B/69"-'"U'5-.";'62'6"75'("

d./-*&.$4*%"A"2*&/2*2"-.$-"-.*"h0/&F*+-"E$:"-'"U*E.$("E$+"1:"1/F*>"&0--/69".$%7"$6".'05"'77"

-.*"H'056*:"1:"401%/&"-5$6+4'5-J"A".$26Y-"45*B/'0+%:"5*9$52*2"(:"1/F*"$+"$"+-$-0+"+:(1'%"10-"

9'/69"-'"E'5F"/6"$"W2*45/B*2Y"4%$&*"+022*6%:"($2*"(*"-./6F"$1'0-"/-"-.$-"E$:J"K.*"1/F*"E$+"$"

1'--'(Q'7Q-.*Q5$69*>"+*B*6Q:*$5Q'%2"84*&/$%/a*2"('06-$/6"1/F*"-.$-"&'+-"$1'0-"O@@"4'062+J"

T6"(:"$55/B$%>"-./+"4*5&*4-/'6"E$+"&'67/5(*2"1:"&'((*6-+"75'("+-$77"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+"E.'"

$+F*2".'E"(0&."/-"E$+"E'5-."$62"E.*5*"A"9'-"/-J"A"2*B*%'4*2"$"+-'5:"-.$-"4%$:*2"2'E6"/-+"

B$%0*"G1:"+$:/69"/-"E$+"$B$/%$1%*"7'5"7/7-:"4'062+"'6"<^$:I"$62"&'6+*h0*6-%:"-.*"$('06-"'7"

('6*:"4*'4%*"-.'09.-"A".$2J"A6"5*-5'+4*&->"-./+"2/+&'(7'5-"(*5*%:"&'67/5(*2"(:"&%$++"

4'+/-/'6J"#:"$&&*6-"$%+'"&.$69*2>"6'-".09*%:"10-"+/96/7/&$6-%:J"A"E$+"15'09.-"04"/6"

_*5-7'52+./5*"$62"+4*$F"/6"$";'62'6"+01051+"25'6*J"A6";*:.$("-./+"E$+"&'6+/2*5*2"4'+.J"

,9$/6>"&'67'5(/69"-'"-.*".$1/-0$%"+4$&*>"A"+-$5-*2"+4*$F/69"('5*"%/F*"-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+J"K./+"

-'6$%"&.$69*"1*&$(*"$44$5*6-"E.*6"A"+-$5-*2"B'/&*"5*&'52/69"(:"7/*%26'-*+J",9$/6>"-.5'09."

-5:/69"-'"7/-"/6>"A".$2"2/+-/690/+.*2"(:"&%$++"4'+/-/'6J"

"

,+"A"1*&$(*"$E$5*"'7"(:"'E6"%'&$-/'6"/6"-*5(+"'7"W5$&*Y>"&%$++"$62"9*62*5>"A"$%+'"1*&$(*"

7$(/%/$5"E/-."-.*"45'7*++/'6$%"$62"4*5+'6$%"*-./&+"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01J"A"E$+"-5$/6*2"/6"

+$7*90$52/69"G&./%2"45'-*&-/'6I>"SR^"GS5/(/6$%"R*&'52+"^05*$0I"&.*&F*2"$62"6*B*5"$%'6*"E/-."

:'069"4*'4%*"1*./62"&%'+*2"2''5+J"d.*6"A"&'620&-*2"/6-*5B/*E+"E/-.":'069"4*'4%*"$-"

;*:.$(>"A"E$+"/6"*:*+.'-"'7"$6'-.*5"(*(1*5"'7"+-$77J"A"6*B*5"E*6-"'77Q+/-*"E/-.":'069"4*'4%*"

06%*++"/-"E$+"7'5"$"+4*&/7/&"'59$6/+*2"*B*6-"'5"$&-/B/-:>"$62"*B*6"-.*6"$"(*(1*5"'7"+-$77"'5"

4$5*6-"E'0%2"$&&'(4$6:"(*J","75/*62"+-02:/69"$6-.5'4'%'9:"'6&*"$+F*2"(*".'E"A"&'0%2"

4'++/1%:"%*$56"$1'0-":'069"4*'4%*"/7"A"2/26Y-"7'%%'E"-.*("-'"-.*/5"45/B$-*"+4$&*+J"A"5*-'5-*2>"lA"

2'6Y-"E$6-"-'"1*"%'&F*2"04nJ"

"

3/+&0++/'6+"'7"5/+F"E*5*"'7-*6"$5-/&0%$-*2"-.5'09."&'62*(6$-/'6+"'7"4$*2'4./%/$>"$62"+-$77"

E*5*"&'6+-$6-%:"&'6&*56*2"E/-."-.*"4'-*6-/$%"7$%%'0-"75'("$6"$&&0+$-/'6"'7"-./+"F/62J"8-$77"

Page 57: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

NM"

"

(*(1*5+"('6/-'5*2"(*"/6"&'%%*&-/69"&'6+*6-"7'5(+"75'("4$5*6-+"1*7'5*"A"&'0%2"+-'5*"$6:"

B/+0$%"7''-$9*"'7":'069"4*'4%*J"T6"-.*"+057$&*"-.*+*"&'6&*56+"7/--*2"4*57*&-%:"E/-."$&$2*(/&"

5*+*$5&."90/2*%/6*+"G^5/-/+."8'&/'%'9/&$%",++'&/$-/'6"?@@?>"4J\I?M"$62"E/-."(:"'E6"6'5($-/B*"

*-./&$%"'5/*6-$-/'6+J"_'E*B*5>"/6"7$&->"-.*"/2*$%+"'7"4$5-/&/4$-/'6"$62"&./%25*6Y+"5/9.-+"

*6+.5/6*2"/6"$&$2*(/&"$62":'0-."E'5F"90/2*%/6*+?V"E*5*"$"%'69"E$:"75'("-.*"&0%-05*"'7"5/+F"

$62"+*%7Q45*+*5B$-/'6"-.$-"2'(/6$-*2"-.*"/++0*"'7"/67'5(*2"&'6+*6-"$-";*:.$(>"$62"

/6&5*$+/69%:"/6"(:"'E6"5*+*$5&.J"

"

^*7'5*"+-$5-/69"A"+/96*2"$"+*5B/&*"%*B*%"$95**(*6-"E/-."$%%"-.*":'0-."&%01+"A"E'5F*2"E/-.J"K./+"

/6&%02*2"$"&'((/-(*6-"-'"F**4"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"/67'5(*2"$1'0-"-.*"5*+*$5&.>"E./&."A"2/2J"A"

5*90%$5%:"40-"04"4'+-*5+"$62".$62*2"'0-"/67'5($-/'6"+.**-+"'6"(:"5*+*$5&.J"T7"&'05+*>"-.*"

4'+-*5+"E*5*"+''6"&'B*5*2"'B*5"'5"5*4%$&*2"E/-."'-.*5"/-*(+>"$62"-.*"/67'5($-/'6"+.**-+"

E*5*"%*7-"'6"-.*"7%''5"7'5"(*"-'"&'%%*&-"$-"-.*"*62"'7"-.*"+*++/'6J",%-.'09."-.*"+-$77"$62":'069"

4*'4%*"F6*E"A"E$+"&'620&-/69"5*+*$5&.>"-.*:"E*5*"6*B*5"/67'5(*2"-'"-.*"*C-*6-"-.$-"(:"'E6"

6*05'+/+"2*+/5*2J"K./+"E$+6Y-"1*&$0+*"-.*:"-50+-*2"(*"-'"-*%%"-.*"+-'5:j"-.*:"+/(4%:".$2"('5*"

/(4'5-$6-"-./69+"-'"-./6F"$1'0-J?P"

"

]'5"-./+"5*$+'6>"-.*"6$(*+"'7":'069"4*'4%*>":'0-."&%01+"$62"/2*6-/7:/69"4%$&*+".$B*"1**6"

$6'6:(/+*2J"_'E*B*5>"-.*"1'5'09."$62"+'(*"F*:"6'6Q/2*6-/7:/69"%'&$-/'6+".$B*"1**6"6$(*2"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""?M"K.*"^5/-/+."8'&/'%'9/&$%",++'&/$-/'6Y+"*-./&$%"90/2*%/6*+"6'-*"-.$-"l5*+*$5&."/6B'%B/69"&./%25*6"5*h0/5*+"

4$5-/&0%$5"&$5*J"K.*"&'6+*6-"'7"-.*"&./%2"+.'0%2"1*"+'09.-"/6"$22/-/'6"-'"-.$-"'7"-.*"4$5*6-J"R*+*$5&.*5+"

+.'0%2"0+*"-.*/5"+F/%%+"-'"45'B/2*"/67'5($-/'6"-.$-"&'0%2"1*"062*5+-''2"1:"-.*"&./%2>"$62"-.*/5"H029(*6-"

-'"2*&/2*"'6"-.*"&./%2Y+"&$4$&/-:"-'"062*5+-$62"E.$-"/+"1*/69"45'4'+*2J"84*&/$%/+-"$2B/&*"$62"*C4*5-/+*"

+.'0%2"1*"+'09.-"E.*5*"5*%*B$6-n"G^5/-/+."8'&/'%'9/&$%",++'&/$-/'6"?@@?>"4J\IJ"?V"A67'5(*2"&'6+*6-"/+"/(4%/*2"/6"-.*"[U"S'6B*6-/'6"'6"-.*"R/9.-+"'7"-.*"S./%2"G[6/-*2"U$-/'6+"!PP@I"

E.*5*"-.*"*(4.$+/+"'6"-.*"4$5-/&/4$-/'6"'7"-.*"&./%2"(*$6-"-.$-"5*+*$5&.*5+"E*5*"6'"%'69*5"5*h0/5*2"-'"

0+*"$20%-+"$+"45'C/*+"7'5"5*+*$5&."E/-.":'069"4*'4%*"G`/5F"?@@M>"4J!?N!IJ"K./+"+./7-"5*+0%-*2"/6"$--*6-/'6"

-'"*-./&$%"5*+*$5&."45$&-/&*+"$62"/67'5(*2"&'6+*6-J"A67'5(*2"&'6+*6-"/+"$%+'"$%%02*2"-'"/6"-.*"_0($6"

R/9.-+",&-"!PPV"G_#"X'B*56(*6-"!PPVIJ"K.*"_0($6"R/9.-+",&-"!PPV"90$5$6-**+"-.*"5/9.-"-'"5*+4*&-"7'5"

45/B$-*"$62"7$(/%:"%/7*"$62"-.0+"+044'5-+"45'B/+/'6"7'5"-.*":'069"4*5+'6+Y"$62"4$5*6-+Y"/67'5(*2"

&'6+*6-"G#$++'6"?@@\>"4J\\IJ"3$-$"'6":'069"4*'4%*"(0+-"'6%:"1*".*%2"E/-."&'6+*6-"G,%2*5+'6"$62"

#'55'E"?@@\>"4JN!IJ"?P"306*/*5"2/+&0++*+"+/(/%$5"+*6-/(*6-+"$-"-.*"*62"'7";'5+C41="G?@@!>"44JO\NgONMIJ"

Page 58: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

NV"

"

-'"45'B/2*"-.*"-.*+/+"E/-."-.*"6*&*++$5:"./+-'5:"$62"+'&/$%"&'6-*C-J"K.*"'6%:"4%$&*+"/6"-.*"

-.*+/+"E.*5*"('5*"+4*&/7/&"2*+&5/4-'5+"$5*"45'B/2*2"$5*"/6"5*%$-/'6"-'"-.*"$6$%:+/+"'7"-.*"B/2*'+"

'7"[4&'(/69"#'B*(*6-J"K.*"95'04".$+"1**6"6$(*2"1*&$0+*"-.*:"2/2"6'-"$--*62"$6:"'7"-.*"

:'0-."&%01+"$62"1*&$0+*"-.*/5"E'5F".$+"$%5*$2:"1**6"401%/+.*2"'6"Z'0K01*J"

"

K.*"*-./&$%"+4$&*"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01"E$+"6'-"2*7/6*2"1:"50%*+"$62"+-$-*(*6-+"10-"E$+"&'%%*&-/B*"

$62".$1/-0$%J"<-./&+"E*5*"$--$/6*2"-.5'09."%$-*6-"/6-*5$&-/'6+"$62"2*7/6*2"/6"+4*&/7/&"('(*6-+"

G^$F.-/6"!PPOj"^*62*5"!PPVIJ"<-./&+"7'5"1*.$B/'05"E*5*"$44%/*2"/6"+4*&/7/&"&'6-*C-+"$62"+4$&*+>"

$62"-.5'09."4*5+'6$%"./+-'5/*+J"<$&.":'0-."E'5F*5"15'09.-"-.*/5"'E6"7%0&-0$-/69"+-$62$52+"-'"

-.*"&%01J"K.*+*"4*5+'6$%"*-./&+"E*5*"'7-*6"*C45*++*2"/6"-.*"($6/7*+-"-50-."'7"45'B*51+>"%/F*f"

l:'069"4*'4%*"6**2"1'062$5/*+nJ"K.*+*"1'062$5/*+"5*%$-*2"-'"+E*$5/69>"5066/69"$62"

/6-*5$&-/69"/6"&*5-$/6"E$:+J",%-.'09."-.*5*"E$+"&*5-$/6%:"$".$1/-0$%"'52*5"G#*5%*$0Q='6-:"

!PVPI"E/-./6"-.*":'0-."&%01>"$"7'5("'7"06E5/--*6"('5$%"&'6+*6+0+"-'"E./&."4*'4%*"&'0%2"1*"

.*%2>"('+-"*-./&$%"1'062$5/*+"2*4*62*2"'6"+0&."-./69+"$+f"-.*"2$:>"E.*-.*5"4*'4%*"E*5*"

-/5*2>"E.$-"-.*"+*++/'6".$2"1**6"%/F*"$62"E.*-.*5"-.*5*"E*5*"45'1%*(+"$-".'(*J"K.*"*6$&-/69"

'7"('5$%"1'062$5/*+"E$+"45*2/&$-*2>"-.*6>"'6"+4*&/7/&>"&'6-*C-0$%"$62"4*5+'6$%"&/5&0(+-$6&*+>"

/6"$22/-/'6"-'"('5*"9*6*5$%"$95**(*6-+J"3*+4/-*"-.*/5"062*5%:/69"%'9/&>"1'062$5/*+"E*5*"6*B*5"

&'6+/+-*6-%:"*6$&-*2"$&5'++"-.*"10/%2/69>"'5"'6"$"2$:Q-'Q2$:"1$+/+J",62":'0-."E'5F*5+"

+'(*-/(*+"*B*6"&5*2/-*2":'069"4*'4%*"E/-."15*$F/69"-.*(J"K*++$"'6&*"-'%2"(*>"$7-*5"3/2/*5"

.$+"H0+-"15'F*6"$"1'062$5:"+.*".$2"+*-"1:"5066/69"-.5'09."-.*"1$&F"%'11:>"-.$-"+.*"%/F*2"F/2+"

E/-."$"l1/-"'7"+406Fn"G-.$-"15'F*"-.*"50%*+IJ"8.*"-.'09.-"-.$-"95'E/69"04"/6";*:.$("/-"(/9.-"1*"

-.*"'6%:"-./69"-.$-"9'-"-.*("+'(*E.*5*J""

"

A-"E$+"'77/&/$%%:"5*&'96/+*2"-.$-"-.*"$20%-+"*+-$1%/+.*2"-.*"*-./&$%"75$(*E'5F"7'5"-.*":'0-."

&%01J"A-"E$+"6'-"+'"5*&'96/+*2"-.$-"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"$%+'"./9.%:"$&-/B*"/6"*+-$1%/+./69"-.*"

*-./&+"'7"-.*"+4$&*J"K.*"E$:+":'069"4*'4%*"/6-*5$&-*2"E/-."-.*"+4$&*"$62"+-$77"E$+"&5/-/&$%"-'"

-.*"*-./&+"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01J"Z'069"4*'4%*"*+-$1%/+.*2"1'062$5/*+"1:"40+./69"E.$-"-.*:"

4*5&*/B*2"-.*"1'062$5/*+"-'"1*J"A6"5*+4'6+*>"+-$77"5*&'96/+*2"-.*:"E*5*"-5:/69"-'"-5$6+95*++"

-.*("$62"*67'5&*2"-.*"50%*J"K.*":'069"4*'4%*"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+"$&-*2"-'9*-.*5"/6"$"9$(*"'7"

+*--/69"$62"-5$6+95*++/69J"Z'069"4*'4%*"-056*2"04"-.*"(0+/&>"-056*2"'77"-.*"%/9.-+>"7'09.-"$62"

-.5*E"7''2"-'"*%/&/-"$"5*+4'6+*J"K.*":'0-."E'5F*5+>"4%$:/69"$-"$0-.'5/-:>"5*+4'62*2"-'"-.*+*"

E/%70%"/675$&-/'6+"1:"7'5($%%:"($5F/69"-.*"1'062$5:"-.5'09."&'((*6-"'5"5*45/($62J"A6"+/(/%$5"

E$:+>"1'062$5/*+"E*5*"($5F*2"-.5'09."-.*"/6-*5$&-/'6+"1*-E**6"'%2*5"$62":'069*5"(*(1*5+"

Page 59: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

NP"

"

'7"-.*"&%01+J"K.*":'069*5"(*(1*5+"+*-"04"1'062$5/*+"1:"&.$%%*69/69"-.*"'%2*5"'6*+J"K.*"'%2*5"

'6*+"$&F6'E%*29*2"-.*"1'062$5:"1:"5*+4'62/69"4.:+/&$%%:"'5"B*51$%%:"G+**"S.$4-*5"K.5**IJ"

"

,+"-.*"7/*%2E'5F"-''F"+.$4*>"-.*"+-$-*(*6-"'7"*-./&$%"45$&-/&*"$62"(:"&'((/-(*6-"-'"$6-/Q

'445*++/B*"5*+*$5&."1*&$(*"'6*"'7"($6:"&'(4*-/69"('5$%"+&.*($+"7'5"-./6F/69"$62"$&-/69"/6"

-.*":'0-."&%01"$+"$6"*-.6'95$4.*5"$62"$+"$":'0-."E'5F*5J"K.*"&.$69/69"*-./&$%"+4$&*"'7"E./&."

A"1*&$(*"$"+($%%"&'6+-/-0*6-"4$5-"E$+"$09(*6-*2"1:"60(*5'0+"4*5+'6$%"./+-'5/*+>"

45'7*++/'6$%"6'5(+"$62"4'%/-/&$%"&'((/-(*6-+"7'5(*2"-.5'09.".$1/-0$%"2/$%'9/&+"G#*5%*$0Q

='6-:"!PVPj"R*:6'%2+"?@@\I"-.$-"2*4*62*2"'6"+.$5*2"062*5+-$62/69+"$62"5*+4'6+*+J"K.*"

*-./&+"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01+"E*5*"$%E$:+"/6"7%0C>"$%-.'09."/-"E$+"$%+'"4'++/1%*"-'"2/+&*56"&*5-$/6"

7*$-05*+"$62"5015/&+"'5"1*.$B/'05J"8'(*"'7"-.*+*"7/--*2"E/-."(:"'5/9/6$%"'5/*6-$-/'6+>"+'(*"

2/26Y-J"K.*"*-./&+"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01+"E*5*"$%+'"'7-*6"&'06-*5/6-0/-/B*J",+"A"&.$%%*69*2"W5$&*Y>"

9*62*5"$62"&%$++"'445*++/'6"A"$%+'"4$5-/&/4$-*2"/6"+0+-$/6/69"-.*(J"A6"'-.*5"&$+*+>"*-./&$%"

75$(*E'5F+"-.$-"+**(*2"+-$1%*"E*5*"+01B*5-*2"$+"1'062$5/*+"E*5*"-5$6+95*++*2"$62"50%*+"

E*5*"($2*"-'"1*"15'F*6J"K.*+*"45'&*++*+"2*($62*2"$"('5*"&'(4%*C"$&&'06-"'7"5*+*$5&."

*-./&+"-.$6"/+"7'5-.&'(/69"/6"+-$-*(*6-+"'7"*-./&$%"45$&-/&*"$62"5*+*$5&."($60$%+J"K.*"

5*+*$5&."*-./&+"E*5*"06/h0*"-'"-.*"45'20&-/B*"45'&*++*+"'7"-.*"7/*%2E'5F"+4$&*J"K.*"

/(4%/&$-/'6+"'7"4'E*5"/6"-.*"5*+*$5&."45'&*++"&'0%2"'6%:"1*"&'6+/2*5*2"/6"-./+"&'6-*C-J"

S'6&%0+/'6""

d/-."$--*6-/'6"-'"*-.6'95$4./&"4%05$%/-:>"-.*"5*+*$5&."%'&$-*+"/-+*%7"$9$/6+-"5*$%/+-"7'5(+"'7"

,9'(='()>!$62"+-$62$52/+*2"7'5(+"'7"5%'()!*-.6'95$4.:"E./%+-"06&'(7'5-$1%:"5*&'96/+/69"/-+"

'E6"5'%*"/6"7%$--*6/69"-.*"+'&/$%"$62"&'(4%:/69"E/-."-.*"2'(/6$6-J"K./+"&.$4-*5".$+"

./9.%/9.-*2"-.*"5*+*$5&.Y+"&'((/-(*6-"-'"2/$%'90*"$62"%/+-*6/69J"K.5'09."*69$9/69"E/-."

*-.6'95$4./&"$62"-*C-0$%"$445'$&.*+"/-".$+"2/+&0++*2"-.*"(*$6+"'7"('B/69"1*:'62"-.*"

+-$62$52"(*-.'2'%'9/*+"0+*2"-'"*C4%'5*":'069"4*'4%*Y+"%/B*+J"A-".$+"+.'E6"-.*"6*&*++/-:"'7"

B/*E/69"-.*":'0-."&%01"$+"$"B*./&%*"'7"-5$B*%"$62"2/+4%$&*(*6-"5$-.*5"-.$6"$"7/C*2"$62"+*%*&-*2"

+/-*J",62"/-".$+"$590*2"-.$-"7/*%2E'5F"45$&-/&*+"+.'0%2"1*"5*&'06-*2"$+"06&*5-$/6"45'&*++*+"

+.$4*2"1:"&'6-*C-+"$62"(/&5'Q+'&/'%'9/&$%"('(*6-+J"K.*"&.$4-*5".$+"$%+'"2/+&0++*2".'E"

5*+*$5&."*-./&+"&$66'-"+'%*%:"1*"$225*++*2"-.'09."2*-$&.*2"45'7*++/'6$%"6'5(+J"R*+*$5&."

*-./&+"$5*"&'(4%*C"7'5($-/'6+"-.$-"/6-*5$&-"E/-."4*5+'6$%"./+-'5/*+>"(''2+>"+4$&*+"$62"

.$1/-0$%"F6'E%*29*"/6"$62"1*:'62"-.*":'0-."&%01J"K.*:"$5*"&5'++Q&0-"1:"$C*+"'7"4'E*5"GW5$&*Y>"

Page 60: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

e@"

"

9*62*5>"&%$++>"$9*"$62"+*C0$%/-:I>"$62"&'67/5(*2"$62"+01B*5-*2"-.5'09."4*5&*4-/'6+"'7"+.$5*2"

('(*6-+J"K.*+*"$5*"1'-."&'(7'5-$1%*"$62"06&'(7'5-$1%*"45'&*++*+j"-.*:"$5*"&'(4%/&/-"$62"

&'6-*+-*2J"]/6$%%:>"-./+"&.$4-*5".$+"%'&$-*2"-./+"+-02:"/6"$"-5$2/-/'6"'7"^5/-/+."+'&/'%'9/&$%"E'5F"

-.$-".'%2+"+'&/$%"H0+-/&*"$62"$6-/Q5$&/+("$-"/-+"&'5*J"

"

TB*5$%%>"-./+"&.$4-*5".$+"$225*++*2"-.*",9'(='()!$62"-.*"5%'()!'7"$"4'%/-/&$%%:"%'&$-*2"

(*-.'2'%'9:J"A-".$+"&*%*15$-*2"-.*"(*++/6*++"'7"-.*"*-.6'95$4.:>"$62"-.*"/(4'5-$6&*"'7"/-+"

($%%*$1/%/-:"-'"-.*"0650%:"6$-05*"'7"*B*5:2$:"%/7*J"3*B*%'4/69"-.*"2/+&0++/'6"'6"5*+*$5&./69"

2/77*5*6-"-/(*+"$62"4%$&*+>"-.*"6*C-"&.$4-*5"*C4%'5*+"-.*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"'7":'069"4*'4%*"

$62":'0-."E'5F*5+"/6"U*E.$(J"

"

Page 61: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

e!"

"

S.$4-*5"KE'"g"d./-*6*++>"%'++"$62"2/$+4'5$"(6*('6/&+f"-.*"&'%%*&-/B*"

(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"'7":'069"4*'4%*"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+"/6"U*E.$("

U*/%"r$"7/5+-"9*6*5$-/'6"S$6$2/$6s>")$:"r$"+*&'62"9*6*5$-/'6"A62/$6s>"K*++$"r$"-./52"9*6*5$-/'6"8&'-s"$62"(*"rd*%+."$62"<69%/+.>"10-"6*E"-'"U*E.$(s"E*5*"/6"-.*"F/-&.*6"($F/69"$"&04"'7"-*$"E.*6"$"&'6B*5+$-/'6"+-$5-*2"$1'0-"-.*"2*&%/6*"'7"<$+-";'62'6"&'((06/-:J"K.*:"2/+&0++*2"-.*"%'++"'7"&'((06/-:"+4/5/-"$62"1%$(*2"/-"'6"4*'4%*"6'-"+4*$F/69"<69%/+."'5"F6'E/69"<69%/+."./+-'5:J"K.*:"1%$(*2"-.*"A62/$6+"$62"=$F/+-$6/+"7'5"-.*"%$690$9*"$62"&/-*2"$"='%/+."E'5F*5"'6"-.*"+*&'62"&.$59*J"_*".$2"$44$5*6-%:"&%$/(*2"-.$-"_*65:"cAAA".$2"F/%%*2"-.*"='4*J"

"

]/*%2"3/$5:>"U'B*(1*5"?@@P""

A"E$+"'0-"E/-."^*+$>"<B$>",%($"$62")*-'6J"d*"/6-*5B/*E*2"$"E'($6"'0-+/2*"U*E.$("($5F*-J"8.*"E$+"75'("-.*"=./%/44/6*+J"d*"$+F*2".*5"E.$-"+.*"%/F*2"$1'0-"-.*"%'&$%"$5*$"$62"+.*"+$/2"-.*"75*+."750/-"$62"(*$-J"8.*"6*B*5"(*6-/'6*2"W.'(*Y"10-"/6"./+"B/2*'"$6$%:+/+"'7"-.*"&'6B*5+$-/'6"^*+/$6"$++0(*2"+.*"$++'&/$-*2"75*+."45'20&-+"E/-."W.'(*YJ"_*"2/2J"]'5"./("-.*:"E*5*"$++'&/$-*2"E/-.",%1$6/$J""]/*%2"3/$5:>"3*&*(1*5"?@@P"

"

K.*:"%$09.*2"$1'0-"$&&/2*6-+"-.*:".$2>"$62"&'(*2/&"+/-0$-/'6+"-.*:".$2"7'062"-.*(+*%B*+"/6f"7$%%/69"2'E6"$"./%%"'5".$B/69"$"&'E"506"$-"-.*(J",-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"$+"1*/69"(*('5/*+"'7",%1$6/$>"-.*:"E*5*"$%+'"H0+-"(*('5/*+"'7"*B*6-+J"A"4$5-/&/4$-*2"/6"-.*+*"(*('5/*+>"6'-"'6"-.*"1$+/+"-.$-"A"E$+",%1$6/$6>"'5".$2"1**6"-'",%1$6/$>"10-"'6"-.*"1$+/+"-.$-"A"-''".$2"+/(/%$5"+-'5/*+"-'"-*%%J"

"

]/*%2"3/$5:>"#$5&."?@@P""

TB*5"-.*"-E'":*$5+"A"E'5F*2"/6"U*E.$("A"%*$56*2"$"%'-"$1'0-"-.*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"'7":'069"

4*'4%*"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+J";/F*"-.*"h0'-*+"$1'B*>"-.*+*"45$&-/&*+"25*E"$--*6-/'6"-'"&'(4*-/69"

6'+-$%9/$+"'7"W.'(*Y"$62"4'+-Q6$-/'6$%"5*&'%%*&-/'6+>"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"$+"-.*:"$225*++*2"-.*"

(0-$1/%/-:"'7"*C&%0+/B*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"-/*2"-'"E./-*6*++"$62"6$-/'6$%"1*%'69/69J"_'E*B*5>"

Page 62: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

e?"

"

E./%*"-.*+*"%'02"$62"+/%*6->"+.$5*2"$62"*C&%0+/B*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"E*5*"4$5->"$62"$%E$:+".$2"

1**6"4$5->"'7"-.*"4%$&*"E.*5*"A"E'5F*2>"<$+-";'62'6Y+"4$+-"/+"('5*"&'(('6%:"5*(*(1*5*2"$+"

-.*".'(*"'7"-.*"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"g"$"6$55$-/B*"E./&."+/%*6&*+"$"('5*"&'(4%*C>"%'69Q-*5("

$62"&'6-*+-*2"./+-'5:"Gd*(:++"?@@V>"?@@PIJ"

"

K./+"&.$4-*5"*C4%'5*+"-.*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"'7":'069"4*'4%*"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+J"A6"+'"2'/69>"/-"

2*B*%'4+"+'(*"'7"-.*"(*-.'2'%'9/&$%"&'6+/2*5$-/'6+"'6"2/$%'90*>"(0%-/Q+/-*26*++>"2/$+4'5$"

$62"-*(4'5$%/-:"2/+&0++*2"/6"-.*"45*B/'0+"&.$4-*5J"84*&/7/&$%%:>"4$5-"'6*"/6B*+-/9$-*+"-.*"

($/6-*6$6&*"'7"(*('5/*+"'7"E./-*6*++"$62"1*%'69/69>"$62".'E"-.*+*"(*('5/*+"E*5*"+.$5*2"

$('69"$"(0%-/Q*-.6/&"4'40%$-/'6J"K.$-"/+>"/-"$225*++*+".'E"5$&/$%"./*5$5&./*+"$5*"5*Q7'5(*2"

-.5'09."(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"$62".'E"-.*"$(1/B$%*6&*"$62"$%%05*"'7"E./-*6*++"$62"&%$++"%'++"&'Q

*C/+-*2"/6"$"W+04*5Q2/B*5+*Y"4%$&*"Gc*5-'B*&"?@@eIJ"=$5-"-E'"$6$%:+*+"7/5+-"E.$-"-.*+*"(*('5:"

45$&-/&*+"7'59'->"1:"2/+&0++/69"-.*"*C/+-*6&*"'7"'-.*5"(*('5/*+"'7".'(*"$62"1*%'69/69"-.$-"

*C/+-*2"$%'69+/2*"/6B*+-(*6-+"/6"E./-*6*++J"8*&'62>"/-"$225*++*+".'E"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"/6"

U*E.$(Y+"2/$+4'5$"+4$&*"&'(4%/&$-*2"6$-/'6$%"$62"*-.6/&"6'-/'6+"'7".'(*J"K.5'09."$6"

*C4%'5$-/'6"'7"+'%/2$5/-:>"-.*"4'++/1/%/-:"'7"%/B/69"'-.*5"4*'4%*Y+"4$+-+>"$62"$"45*+*6-$-/'6"'7"-.*"

E$:+"/6"E./&."6$-/'6$%"$62"*-.6/&"(*('5:"$5*"2*&'6+-50&-*2>"/-"+.'E+".'E"U*E.$(Y+"

(6*('6/&"7'%2+"$77'52*2":'069"4*'4%*"-.*"4'++/1/%/-:"-'"5*(*(1*5"$62"/6-*5$&-"1*:'62"-.*"

&'6+-5$/6-+"'7"6$-/'6"$62"*-.6/&/-:J"

"

;/-*5$-05*"'6"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"/6";'62'6".$+"*C4%'5*2"/6B*+-(*6-+"/6"4$-.'%'9/*+"'7"6$-/'6$%"

%'++"GX/%5':"?@@\I"$62"-.*"5*&'%%*&-/'6"'7"2/$+4'5/&".'(*+"G^5$."!PPeIJ"A-".$+"$225*++*2"-.*"

+/96/7/&$6&*"'7"./22*6"*-.6/&"$62"6$-/'6$%"(*('5/$%/+$-/'6"/6"051$6"+4$&*"G,%*C$62*5"?@!!>"

]'5-.&'(/69j"d*(:++"?@@V>"?@@PI"$62"-.*"75/&-/'6+"$62"&'66*&-/'6+"-.*+*"45'20&*"1*-E**6"

4*'4%*"E.'"+.$5*"%'&$%"./+-'5/*+"G^5$."!PPPIJ"_'E*B*5>"+'"7$5"/-".$+"6'-"45'B/2*2"$6"

*-.6'95$4./&"$&&'06-"'7"2/$+4'5$"(6*('6/&+"/6"<$+-";'62'6J"S'6+*h0*6-%:>"-.*"'B*5%$:/69"

$62"-5$&/69"'7"2/77*5*6-"(*('5/*+"/6"U*E.$(>"$62".'E"-.*:"+0+-$/6>"$62"('B*"1*:'62>"5$&/$%"

$62"6$-/'6$%"'52*5+"$5*"6'-"70%%:"062*5+-''2J"

"

K'"7$&/%/-$-*"-./+"$6$%:+/+"-.*"&.$4-*5"($F*+"0+*"'7"/2*$+"$++'&/$-*2"E/-."W(*('5:"45$&-/&*Y>"

W&'%%*&-/B*"(*('5:Y"$62"W2/$+4'5$"+4$&*YJ"#*('5:"$+"W45$&-/&*Y"$%%'E+"-.*"&.$4-*5"-'"7'&0+"'6"

-.*"%/B*2"45'20&-/'6"'7"(*('5:"$+"&5*$-/B*"$62"4%05$%>"$+"'44'+*2"-'"B/*E/69"(*('5/*+"$+"

7$&-+"'5"*++*6&*+"g"$+"./+-'5:"G^/%%/9"!PPNIJ"c/*E/69"-.*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"'7":'0-."E'5F*5+"$62"

Page 63: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

eO"

"

:'069"4*'4%*"$+"W&'%%*&-/B*Y"45'B/2*+"-.*"(*$6+"7'5"-./6F/69"$1'0-"(*('5:"$+"('5*"-.$6"$6"

/62/B/20$%"$&-"G_$%1E$&.+"!PP?IJ"Z'069"4*'4%*"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+"5*(*(1*5*2"4$+-+"

/62/B/20$%%:>"10-"-.*:"$%+'"5*(*(1*5*2"&'%%*&-/B*%:"GR/&u05"?@@\IJ"K'"('B*"1*:'62"-.*"

6$-/'6$%"&'67/6*+"'7"<$+-";'62'6Y+"4'40%$5"(*('5:>"-.*"6'-/'6"'7"W2/$+4'5$Y"4*5(/-+"$6"

$445*&/$-/'6"'7"-.*"7/*%2"'7"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+":'069"4*'4%*"45$&-/+*2j"$"7/*%2"7'5(*2"-.5'09."

-.*"-5$H*&-'5/*+"$62"/6-*5$&-/'6+"'7"(0%-/4%*"W.'(*+Y"G^5$."!PPeI"$62"&0%-05$%"7%'E+"GX/%5':"

!PPOIJ"

"

K.*"B/*E"'7"&'%%*&-/B*"(*('5:"-$F*6"/6"-./+"&.$4-*5"/+"$%+'"2/$%'9/&"5$-.*5"-.$6"

4.*6'(*6'%'9/&$%"G^$F.-/6"!PVe$IJ"=.*6'(*6'%'9/&$%"$&&'06-+".'%2"+01H*&-/B*"*C4*5/*6&*"$+"

45/($5:"G_$%1E$&.+"!PP?j"R/&u05"?@@\IJ"K./+"'&&%02*+"-.*"4%05$%/-:"'7"-.*"4$+-"/6"7$B'05"'7"-.*"

+01H*&-/B*"45*+*6-"G^$F.-/6"!PV\I"-.0+"%*$2/69"-'"$"-:5$66:"'7"-.*"6'E"g"-.*"45'1%*("'7"W+($%%"

-/(*Y"G^$F.-/6"!PVe1IJ"8'"E./%*"-./+"&.$4-*5"*C4%'5*+"-.*"4$+-"45'H*&-/'6+"'7":'069"4*'4%*"$62"

:'0-."E'5F*5+"/-"2'*+"+'"E/-."$--*6-/'6"-'".'E"-.*+*"45$&-/&*+"'7"-.*"45*+*6-"E*5*"($2*"'B*5"

W95*$-"-/(*Y"G^$F.-/6"!PVe1IJ"K.*"$445'$&."$%%'E+"7'5"$6"$445*&/$-/'6"'7"-.*"W-5$&/69Y"$62"

/6+-$1/%/-:"'7"(*('5:"G^*66*--"?@@Nj"3*55/2$"!PMej"84/B$F"!PMeIJ"c/*E*2"/6"-.*"&'6-*C-"'7"!N@"

:*$5+"'7"(/95$-/'6"75'("[`>"<05'4*"$62"-.*"d'5%2"G$+"2/+&0++*2"/6"-.*"A6-5'20&-/'6I>"-./+"

$445'$&."($F*+"/-"4'++/1%*"-'"B/*E"U*E.$(Y+"4$+-"6'-"$+"$6"*++*6&*"'7"E./-*6*++"10-"$+"$"

W7$6"'7"./+-'5:Y"/6"E./&."2/77*5*6-"(*('5/*+"$5*"7'%2*2"2'E6"'6*"'6"-'4"'7"-.*"'-.*5"/6-'"-.*"

&'%%*&-/B*"(*('5:"+4$&*"G^*6H$(/6"!PMVIJ"A6"-./+"E$:>"U*E.$(Y+"4$+-"/+"'B*5%$/2"'6"'-.*5"

4$+-+>"$6:"'7"E./&."&$6"1*"5*+055*&-*2"/6"-.*"+*5B/&*"'7"-.*"45*+*6-J",+"^$F.-/6"*C4%$/6+f"

"

<B*6"#4-,"(*$6/69+>"-.$-"/+>"-.'+*"1'56"/6"-.*"2/$%'90*"'7"-.*"4$+-"&*6-05/*+>"&$6"6*B*5"1*"+-$1%*"G7/6$%/a*2>"*62*2"'6&*"$62"7'5"$%%I"g"-.*:"E/%%"$%E$:+"&.$69*"G1*"5*6*E*2I"/6"-.*"45'&*++"'7"+01+*h0*6->"70-05*"2*B*%'4(*6-"'7"-.*"2/$%'90*J",-"$6:"('(*6-"/6"-.*"2*B*%'4(*6-"'7"-.*"2/$%'90*"-.*5*"$5*"/((*6+*>"1'062%*++"($++*+"'7"7'59'--*6"&'6-*C-0$%"(*$6/69+>"10-"$-"&*5-$/6"('(*6-+"'7"-.*"2/$%'90*Y+"+01+*h0*6-"2*B*%'4(*6-"$%'69"-.*"E$:"-.*:"$5*"5*&$%%*2"$62"/6B/9'5$-*2"/6"5*6*E*2"7'5("G/6"$"6*E"&'6-*C-IJ"U'-./69"/+"$1+'%0-*%:"2*$2f"*B*5:"(*$6/69"E/%%".$B*"/-+".'(*&'(/69"7*+-/B$%J"K.*"45'1%*("'7")3+4,!,'&*"G!PVe1>"4J!M@IJ""

Page 64: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

e\"

"

=$5-"T6*"g"K.*"$(1/B$%*6&*"$62"$%%05*"'7"E./-*6*++"$62"&%$++"

%'++"

K.*"X'%2*6"<5$"/6"4'40%$5"&0%-05*"

d.*5*$+"95*$-"-/(*"'4*6+"-.*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"'7"U*E.$("-'"-.*"4%05$%/-:"'7"-.*"4$+->"

4'40%$5"7/&-/'6+"'7"U*E.$("5*20&*"/-"-'"$"2/+-'5-*2"+6$4+.'-J"A6"%/-*5$-05*>"7/%(>"$&$2*(/&"

-*C-+"$62"-*%*B/+/'6"2'&0(*6-$5/*+>"<$+-";'62'6"/+"4'5-5$:*2"6'-"$+"$"2/$+4'5$"+4$&*"10-"$+"

-.*"./+-'5/&".'(*"'7"E./-*6*++>"&'((06/-:"$62"'7"E'5F/69Q&%$++"('5$%/-:J"K./+"/+"*B/2*6-"/6"

60(*5'0+"'0-40-+"-.$-"(*%2"-'9*-.*5"^*-.6$%"X5**6"/6"-.*"*$+->"E/-."^$5F/69"$62"3$9*6.$("

/6"-.*"7$5"*$+-J","+019*65*"'7"1''F+"'6"-.*"'%2"<$+-"<62"&'((06/-:"2*2/&$-*+"/-+*%7"-'"-.*"

5*+055*&-/'6"'7"-./+"*++*6-/$%"(*('5:"GX029*"?@@Pj"_*&-'5"?@!@j"#&X5$-."?@@?j"ToU*/%%"!PPPj"

d'51':*+"?@@MIJ"]*$-05*"7/%(+>"A34/-!G#*2$F"!PP@I"$62"8%$=!;,%$=!4(5!<C%!;&%='()!G433+1-"

GR/-&./*"!PPVI>"-*%%"+/(/%$5"-$%*+"'7"$"45/'5/"G&5/(/6$%I"E./-*6*++>"('5$%/-:"$62"&'((06/-:J"

S'6-*(4'5$5:"B*5+/'6+"'7"-./+"+*6-/(*6-"E*5*"$%+'"*C*(4%/7/*2"/6"-.*"-/-%*"+*h0*6&*"-.$-"

$&&'(4$6/*2"-.*"^^SY+"&'6-5'B*5+/$%"d./-*"8*5/*+"G^^S"?@@V&I>"E.*5*"^5/-$/6Y+"4'40%$5"<69%/+."

U$-/'6$%",6-.*(>"W)*50+$%*(Y>"4%$:*2"1*./62"$6"/($9*"-.$-"2*4/&-*2"-.*"1%$&F/69"'0-"'7"$"

E./-*"($6Y+"7$&*"E/-."+&5/4-+"75'("6'6Q<69%/+."%$690$9*+"g"-.*"*5$+05*"'7"$"E./-*"(*('5:"

-.5'09."6'6QE./-*"/((/95$-/'6J"K:/69"-./+"(*++$9*"-'"<$+-";'62'6>"*4/+'2*"+/C"E$+"+*-"/6"

3$9*6.$(J";'&$-*2"/6"-.*"4'+-QE$5"4*5/'2>"-.*+*"E'5F+"$&-/B$-*"-.*"6'+-$%9/&"7/++05*"1*-E**6"

-.*"5'($6&*"'7"-.*"+4/5/-"'7"-.*"^%/-a"$62"2*&%/6*"-.5'09."/((/95$-/'6"g"2*+&5/1*2"$+"-.*"

WX'%2*6"<5$Y"G3*6&."*-"$%J"?@@e>"4J!VI"'5"WS%$++/&"=*5/'2Y"G_'11+"?@@e>"4J!??IJ"A6"-.*+*"

$&&'06-+>"-.*"^%/-a>"$++'&/$-*2"E/-."E./-*"<$+-";'62'6"$62"$"^5/-/+."1%*62"'7"('5$%/-:"g"W4%0&F>"

%0&F"$62"5*+/%/*6&*Y"GX/%5':"?@@\>"4JPeI"g"/+"&'6-5$+-*2"E/-."-.*"/(('5$%/-:"'7"4'+-Q&'%'6/$%"$62"

6'6QE./-*"/((/95$-/'6J"

"

K./+"5$&/$%/+*2"4'40%$5"(*('5:"/+"705-.*5"605-05*2"/6"4'%/-/&$%"2/+&'05+*"$62"/6"$&$2*(/&"-*C-+J"

A6"4'%/-/&$%"2/+&'05+*>"-.*"+**2>"7$('0+%:"+'E6"1:"<6'&."='E*%%"G='E*%%"$62"d''2"!PePI>"E$+"

45'4$9$-*2"1:"<$+-";'62'6";$1'05"#=>"#$59$5*-"_'29*"E.*6"+.*"45'6'06&*2"-.$-"-.*"

./+-'5/&"*6-/-%*(*6-"'7"W/62/9*6'0+Y"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"4*'4%*"/6".*5"<$+-";'62'6"1'5'09.>"

E$+"1*:'62"l-.*"%*9/-/($-*"6**2"2*('6+-5$-*2"1:"-.*"6*E"(/95$6-+n"G_'29*"?@@Mj"8B*/6++'6"

?@@PIJ"#$05/&*"X%$+($6"$62"<$+-";'62'6"#=")'6"S5022$+".$B*"-5'22*6"$"+/(/%$5"%/6*"'6"

Page 65: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

eN"

"

/((/95$-/'6"-.5'09."-.*/5"^%0*";$1'05"/6/-/$-/B*JO@";/F*"-.*"%/-*5$-05*>"7/%(+"$62"Kc"

2'&0(*6-$5/*+"$1'B*>"-.*+*"2/+&'05+*+".$B*"+'09.-"-'"/6+-50(*6-$%/+*"$"6'-/'6"'7"<$+-"<62"

E'5F/69Q&%$++"E./-*6*++"$62"$"45/'5/"1*%'69/69"7'5"4'%/-/&$%"9$/6"1:"&'6-5$+-/69"/-"E/-."-.*"

/%%*9/-/($&:"'7"-.*"/((/95$6-J"K.*+*"2*B*%'4(*6-+"/6"4'%/-/&$%"2/+&'05+*"$5*"4$5-"'7"E/2*5"

-5*62+"/6"-.*"5$&/$%/+$-/'6"'7"-.*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"$+"C9',+"15'09.-"-'"-.*"7'5*"205/69"75*h0*6-"

45'6'06&*(*6-+"'6"-.*"2*$-."'7"(0%-/&0%-05$%/+(O!"GS$(*5'6"?@!!j"=./%%/4+"?@@NI"g"

45'6'06&*(*6-+"1$+*2"'6"-.*"2/+$2B$6-$9*+"+077*5*2"1:"-.*"E./-*"6$-/'6"$62"E./-*"E'5F/69Q

&%$++"4*'4%*>"$-"-.*".$62+"'7"(0%-/&0%-05$%"4'%/&:"$62"/-+"1%$&F"$62"(/6'5/-:"*-.6/&"1*6*7/&/$5/*+"

G3*6.$("?@@PIJ"K.*+*"4'%/-/&$%"2/+&'05+*+".$B*"-.*"20$%"*77*&-"'7"45'('-/69"E./-*6*++>"

./+-'5/&$%"*6-/-%*(*6-"$62"%'++>"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"$+"-.*:"%$(1$+-"1%$&F"$62"(/6'5/-:"*-.6/&"

+'%/2$5/-:"$62"$6-/Q5$&/+-"+-5099%*+"G^'--*5'"?@@Pj"X/%%1'56"?@!@j"8B*/6++'6"?@@PIJ"

"

A6"U*E.$(>"-.*+*"4'%/-/&+"'7"E./-*"./+-'5/&$%"*6-/-%*(*6-"$62"%'++"E*5*"45'('-*2"-.5'09."

2/+&'05+*+"'6"-.*"lU*E"S/-/a*6nJ",+"45*+*6-*2"-'"(*"1:"$"&'06&/%"'77/&/$%"/6":'0-."+*5B/&*+>"-.*"

WU*E"S/-/a*6Y"/+"+'(*'6*"l/6&%0+/B*n"5$-.*5"-.$6"+'(*'6*"-.$-"+044'5-+"l&0%-05$%"

45*+*5B$-/'6nJ"K.*"'77/&/$%Y+"5*H*&-/'6"'7"(0%-/&0%-05$%/+("E$+"$&&'(4$6/*2"1:"-.*"6**2"-'"

7'&0+"('5*"$--*6-/'6"'6"-.*"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++J"]'5"./(>"5$-.*5"-.$6"&'67'062"-.*"4'++/1/%/-:"

'7"E./-*"./+-'5/&"'E6*5+./4>"U*E.$(Y+"./+-'5:"'7"/((/95$-/'6"G$62"5*+0%-/69"+04*5Q2/B*5+*"

2*('95$4./&+I".*/9.-*2"/-+"6*&*++/-:J",+".*"*C4%$/6*2f"

"

A-Y+"$6"/6-*5*+-/69"-./69J"d/-."6*E"(/95$6-"&'((06/-/*+"-.*5*".$B*"1**6"$"60(1*5"'7"-./69+"-.$-".$B*".$44*6*2"'B*5"-.*":*$5+J"A6"U*E.$("E*".$B*"+0&."$"5$4/2%:"+./7-/69"4'40%$-/'6J"d.$-"A".$B*"-'"+$:"/+"-.$-"A"-./6F"-.$-"-.*"*(4.$+/+"/+"7$5"('5*"6'E"m"/+"$5'062"/6&%0+/'6"$62"/+"$5'062"$"+*6+*"'7"-.*"U*E"S/-/a*6"E./&."/+"('5*"/6&%0+/B*J"K.*"2/77*5*6&*"/6"U*E.$("/+"-.$-"U*E.$("E$+"-.*"7/5+-"4'40%$-/'6"/6"$6:"1'5'09."-'".$B*"$"($H'5/-:"'7"$"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""O@"_*$2*2"1:";$1'05"4**5"#$05/&*"X%$+($6"G?@!!I>"^%0*";$1'05"G?@!?I"/+"$6"/67%0*6-/$%"-*62*6&:"E/-./6"

-.*";$1'05"4$5-:J"T-.*5"45'(/6*6-"+044'5-*5+"/6&%02*")$(*+"=056*%%>")'6"S5022$+>"S.0F$"[(066$"$62"

3$B/2";$((:J"^%0*";$1'05"/+"$6"$--*(4-"-'"5*B/B*"$"&'6+*5B$-/B*";$1'05/+("./+-'5/&$%%:"&'(('6"-'"

+'(*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"$5*$+"GT5E*%%"!POMIJ"O!"c$5/'0+"$0-.'5+"&'6+/2*5"-.$-"W(0%-/&0%-05$%/+(Y"g"/6"-.*"+*6+*"'7"$"+-$-*"4'%/&:"'7"(0%-/Q*-.6/&"

9'B*56$6&*"$62"&/-/a*6+./4"g"6*B*5"*C/+-*2"/6"-.*"[`"'0-+/2*"'7"%'&$%"9'B*56(*6-"4'%/&/*+"$62"+'(*"

&*6-5$%"9'B*56(*6-"7062/69"+-5*$(+>"$62"-.*5*7'5*"-.$-"/-+"&'62*(6$-/'6"/6"4'%/-/&$%"5.*-'5/&".$+"'6%:"

1**6"$-"-.*"+*5B/&*"'7"405+0/69"6$-/'6$%/+(>"6*'Q%/1*5$%/+("$62"E./-*6*++"GX/%5':"?@!?j";*6-/6"$62"K/-%*:"

?@!!j"Z'069*"?@!!IJ"

Page 66: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

ee"

"

6'6QE./-*"4'40%$-/'6>"4$5-/&0%$5%:"($5F*2"$('69":'069"4*'4%*J"K.*5*7'5*"E*"7*%-"-.*"6**2"-'"('B*"$E$:"75'("-$59*-*2"+4*&/7/&"45'95$((*+"$/(*2"$-"4$5-/&0%$5"&0%-05$%>"*-.6/&"'5"5*%/9/'0+"95'04+"$62"A"-./6F"-.*"5*$+'6"-.$-"E*YB*"2'6*"-.$-"/+"mK.*5*"/+"'6*"-./69"$1'0-"+044'5-/69"&0%-05$%"45*+*5B$-/'6"E./&."/+"7/6*J"A-Y+"$6'-.*5"-./69"45'B/2/69"95'04+"-.$-"E$6-"-'"($F*"45'B/+/'6"7'5"-.*/5"'E6"&'((06/-:J"K.*"E.'%*"-./69"$1'0-"U*E.$("/+"-.$-"E*".$B*"-'"('B*"7'5E$52J"d*".$B*"-'"10/%2"$6"/6&%0+/B*"$62"/6-*95$-*2"&'((06/-:"$62"/7"E*"2'6Y-"($F*"/-"E'5F".*5*"E*"2'6Y-"($F*"/-"E'5F"$6:E.*5*J"K.*"*(4.$+/+"E/%%"'7-*6"1*"7'5"$%%"45'H*&-+"-'"1*"/6&%0+/B*"$62"*6&'05$9/69":'069"4*'4%*"75'("$%%"1$&F95'062+"-'"1*"/6B'%B*2"$62"-.$-Y+"-.*"&055*6-"$9*62$"/6"U*E.$("$62"/-Y+"1/9"-/(*J"]'5"*C$(4%*"/6"-*5(+"'7"-$59*-*2"*69$9*(*6->"/6"-*5(+"'7"$%%Q'0-"45'H*&-+>"E.*-.*5"/-"1*"U<<K+"r6'-"/6"*20&$-/'6>"*(4%':(*6-"'5"-5$/6/69s>"E.$-*B*5>"'05"1/99*+-"45'1%*("95'04"/+"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"(*6"-.$-"(/9.-"6'-"g"A"F6'E"/-"/+"'6"-.*"401%/&"$9*62$"g"10-"6'-"/6"-.*"E$:"-.$-":'0"9*-"^#<"r1%$&F"$62"(/6'5/-:"*-.6/&s"+-077"(*6-/'6*2"*%+*E.*5*J"A6"U*E.$("-.$-Y+"6'-"-.*"&$+*"E*"6**2"-'"-$59*-"('5*"$5'062"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"($%*+"-.$-"$5*"'05"/++0*"95'04"('5*"-.$6"$6:"'-.*5+"m"A-Y+"&'(4%*C"$62"/-Y+"$1'0->"/6"U*E.$(>"15/69/69"4*'4%*"5'062"-'"-.*+*"/2*$+"-.$-"E*"E$6-"$6"/6&%0+/B*"&'((06/-:"-.$-"4*'4%*"$5*"/6-*95$-*2"$62"$5*"2*B*%'4/69"('5*"&'(('6"062*5+-$62/69"'7"E.$-"/-Y+"%/F*"-'"1*"$"&/-/a*6"$62"A"-./6F"-.$-Y+"E.*5*"E*Y5*"$-J"

"

K./+"5*Q*(4.$+/+"'6"E./-*"./+-'5/&$%"*6-/-%*(*6-"$62"%'++".$+"$%+'"1**6"5*9/+-*5*2"/6"5*&*6-"

+'&/'%'9/&$%"E'5FJ"A6"+'&/'%'9:>"-.*"6'+-$%9/&"7/++05*"'7"-.*"4'+-QE$5"4*5/'2"E$+"7$('0+%:"

&$4-05*2"/6"Z'069"$62"d/%%('--Y+"E4&'1/!4(5!A'(-9'#!'(!74-,!8%(5%(!G!PNMIJ"K./+"-*C-"

2'&0(*6-+"-.*"&%'+*"F/6+./4"6*-E'5F+"'7"^*-.6$%"X5**6"7$(/%/*+>"$62"$+"E/-."E'5F"'6"

U*E.$("G_/%%"!PMej"_'11+"!PVVI>"4'+/-+"E./-*"-*55$/6+"$62"&%'+*QF6/-"&'((06/-/*+>"4$:/69"

%/--%*"$--*6-/'6"-'"-.*"&'6-*+-*2"$62"(0%-/Q*-.6/&"7'5($-/'6"'7"-.*"$5*$"G`*/-."?@@VIJ"K.*"

5*&*6-"5*B/B$%"'7"-./+"6$55$-/B*"&$(*"-.5'09."<9+!I+C!74-,!7(5"G3*6&."*-"$%J"?@@eIJ"<9+!I+C!

74-,!7(5"+F/44*2"-.*"/6-*5B*6/69"7/7-:":*$5+"'7"4'40%$-/'6"$62"&0%-05$%"&.$69*+"/6"<$+-";'62'6"

-'"5*/6B*+-"/6"$++0(4-/'6+"'7"E./-*"4*5($6*6&*J"A6B*+-/69"/6"E./-*"%*9/-/($&:"$62"<$+-"<62"

6'+-$%9/$+>"<9+!I+C!74-,!7(52!&*(*6-*2"/6"+'&/'%'9/&$%"$6$%:+/+"-.*"(:-."'7"-.*"WX'%2*6"<5$Y"

G3*6&."*-"$%J"?@@e>"4J!VI"g"$%+'"45'4'+*2"$+"-.*"WS%$++/&"=*5/'2Y"G_'11+"?@@e>"4J!??IJ"K.*"

X'%2*6"<5$"/+"-.*"4*5/'2"'7"6*$5"70%%"*(4%':(*6-"$7-*5"d'5%2"d$5"KE'J"_'E*B*5>"-.*"X'%2*6"

<5$"/+"'6%:"4'++/1%*"1*&$0+*"'7"-.*"2*&%/6*"-.$-"'&&055*2"$7-*5"/-J"A6"-./+"6$55$-/B*>"-.*".$52+./4+"

15'09.-"-'"-.*"<$+-"<62"-.5'09."2*/620+-5/$%/+$-/'6"$5*"E5/--*6"'B*5"1:"/((/95$-/'6J"

d./-*6*++"1*&'(*+"$++'&/$-*2"E/-."-.*"9'%2*6"4$+-"$62"6'6QE./-*"$62"/((/95$6-"1'2/*+"E/-."

-.*"2*&%/6/69"45*+*6-J"T6"-./+"1$+/+"'7"%*9/-/($&:"$62"%'++>"-.*"-*C-"*C&0%4$-*+"W/62/9*6'0+Y"

<$+-*62*5+Y".'+-/%/-:"-'"W6*E&'(*5+Y"G,%*C$62*5"?@!!j"]$55$5"?@@Vj"`*/-."?@@Vj"#''5*"?@@VIJ"

A6"+'"2'/69>"/-"&'6-5/10-*+"-'"-.*"(*%$6&.'%/&"&'6H06&-05*"2*+&5/*2"$1'B*"E./%+-"/96'5/69"-.*"

Page 67: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

eM"

"

E*%%"2'&0(*6-*2"4.*6'(*6'6"'7"5*&055/69"6'+-$%9/$+"7'5"1*--*5"-/(*+"G=*$5+'6"!PVOj"

d/%%/$(+"!PMOIj"-.*"051$6"$+"$"./+-'5/&$%%:"&'6+-/-0-*2"+4$&*"'7"+-5$69*5+"GK'6F/++"?@@eIj"$62"

E./-*6*++"$+"5$&/$%"+/96/7/*5"-.$-"/+"-5$&*2"$62"6*9'-/$-*2"5$-.*5"-.$6"1*/69"7/C*2"-'"1'2/*+"$62"

-*55/-'5:J"

"

]/6$%%:>"-./+"E./-*6*2"./+-'5:"'7"<$+-";'62'6"/+"$%+'"$++/+-*2"1:"('5*"5*&*6-"E'5F+"-.$-"6'-*"

-.*"W/($9/6*2Y"*C/+-*6&*"'7"-.*"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"&'((06/-:"/6"-.*"$5*$"G]'+-*5"!PPPj"

#0(7'52"$62"='E*5"?@@OIJ"d./%*"-.*+*"-*C-+"4$:"$--*6-/'6"-'"45'H*&-/'6+"'7"E./-*6*++>"5$-.*5"

-.$6"$&&*4-"$+"2*"7$&-'"/-+"./+-'5/&"%*9/-/($&:>"-.*:"6'6*-.*%*++"7$%%"+.'5-"'7"062*5+-$62/69"

E./-*6*++"$+"$"45'&*++"/6"<$+-";'62'6J"R*%:/69"'6",62*5+'6"G!PP!I"-.*:"4'+/-"$6"'5/9/6$5:"

&'((06/-:"75'("E./&."-.*"E/2*5"(:-./&"&'((06/-:"1*&'(*+"/($9/6*2J"A6"-./+"E$:>"-.*:"$%+'"

/96'5*"-.*"%$:*5*2"./+-'5/*+"'7"1*%'69/69"/6"<$+-";'62'6"$62"-.*"E$:+"-.$-"E./-*6*++"/+"-5$&*2"

'B*5"W95*$-"-/(*YJ"K.5'09."5*%:/69"'6"W/($9/6*2"E./-*6*++Y>"&'6-*+-*2"./*5$5&./*+"'7"E./-*6*++"

$62"-.*/5"5*7'5($-/'6"-.5'09."(/95$-/'6"5*($/6"$1+*6->"5*/7:/69"E./-*6*++"$62"%*9/-/(/+/69"$"

45/'5/"1*%'69/69J"

_'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"

=$5*6-+"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+"E.'".$2"95'E6"04"/6"U*E.$("/6"-.*"4'+-QE$5"4*5/'2"$%+'"5*%$:*2"

+-'5/*+"'7"-.*"X'%2*6"<5$J"K.*+*"E*5*"(*('5/*+"'7"70%%"*(4%':(*6->"6$-/'6$%"5*+/%/*6&*"$62"

&'((06$%"%/B/69>"*C./1/-*2"205/69"$62"$7-*5"-.*"8*&'62"d'5%2"d$5J"K.*:"E*5*"(*('5/*+"'7"

-.*"B$5/'0+"&.*(/&$%"$62"5$9"+-5/44/69"7$&-'5/*+O?"-.$-"*C/+-*2>"$62"-.*"4'++/1/%/-:"'7"%*$B/69"

'6*"H'1"$-"%06&.-/(*"$62"9*--/69"$6'-.*5"$-"-.*"*62"'7"-.*"2$:J"K.*:"-'%2"'7"&%'+*QF6/-"7$(/%/*+>"

$62"'7"$06-/*+>"95$624$5*6-+>"&'0+/6+"$62"75/*62+"H0+-"$5'062"-.*"&'56*5J"K.*+*"+&*6*+"'7"

7$(/%:"$62"E'5F"%/7*"E*5*"4$5-"'7"/66'&*6-"&./%2.''2+"4/*&*2"-'9*-.*5"75'("75$9(*6-+"'7"

./+-'5:"/6-'"&'.*5*6-"6$55$-/B*+"-'"($F*"+*6+*"'7"06&*5-$/6"45*+*6-+J"_'%/2$:+"E*5*"/6"

&$5$B$6+"'6"S$6B*:"A+%$62>"&./%25*6"4%$:*2"F6'&F2'E6"9/69*5>".'4+&'-&."$62"-E'"1$%%+"04"-.*"

E$%%>"Kc+"E*5*"H0+-"&'(/69"/6-'"-.*"$5*$>"-.*"2''5+"E*5*"%*7-"'4*6>"&5/(*"E$+".'6*+-"$62"-.*"

%'&$%"('1"E'0%2"9*-":'0"2*$%+"7'5":'05"S.5/+-($+"45*+*6-+"H0+-"$+"%'69"$+":'0"2/26Y-"l+./-"

2'E6"-.*/5"+-5**-n"GK*++$IJ"

"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""O?"]$15/&"5$9+"E*5*"0+*2"/6"-.*"($607$&-05*"'7"4$4*5"45'20&-+J"

Page 68: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

eV"

"

K*++$>"$"7*($%*":'0-."E'5F*5"$-";*:.$(>"1'56"$62"15'09.-"04"$5'062"-.*"R':$%"3'&F+>"E/-."$"

(/95$-'5:"./+-'5:"-.$-"-''F".*5"1$&F"-'"8&'-%$62>"*C4%$/6*2"-'"(*".'E>"$-"-.$-"-/(*>"*B*5:'6*"

W7*%-"+$7*"$62"+*&05*YJ"K.*"+-5**-+>"-.*".'(*>"-.*"E'5F4%$&*"$62"-.*"2'&F+"E*5*"-.*"4.:+/&$%"

+*--/69+"7'5"K*++$Y+"X'%2*6"<5$J"_/9.%/9.-+"/6&%02*2"<69%$62"E/66/69"-.*"!Pee"d'5%2"S04>"d*+-"

_$("E/66/69"-.*"!Pee"],"S04>"4$/6-/69"*B*5:-./69"W&%$5*-"$62"1%0*Y>"-.*"8/%B*5")01/%**"+-5**-"

4$5-:"'7"!PMM>"$62"-.*"W106-/69"$62"7%'E*5+YJ",9$/6>"-.*+*"E*5*"6'-"&.5'6'%'9/&$%%:"$&&05$-*"

10-"E*5*"W+4%/6-*5+"'7"(*++/$6/&"-/(*Y"G^*6H$(/6"!PeVI"4/*&*2"-'9*-.*5"-'"($F*"+*6+*"'7"-.*"

45*+*6-J"

"

K.*+*"6'+-$%9/$+"G^':("?@@!>"4J!OI"E*5*"&'6-5$+-*2"E/-."-.*"%'++"-.$-"'&&055*2"$-"-.*"*62"'7"

-.*"X'%2*6"<5$J"K.*"!Pe@+"'6E$52"+$E"-.*"&'%%$4+*"'7"%'&$%"/620+-5:"GS$66/69"K'E6"

S'((06/-:"3*B*%'4(*6-"=5'H*&-"!PMMj"_$%%"?@@M>"4JVNj"_/%%"!PMej"_'11+"?@@ej";^U"!PMeI"$62"

+'$5/69"06*(4%':(*6-"GS$66/69"K'E6"S'((06/-:"3*B*%'4(*6-"=5'H*&-"!PMeIJ";:66>"$":'0-."

E'5F*5"E.'".$2"95'E6"04"/6";*:.$(>"$62"E$+"75'("$"R'($6:"7$(/%:>"*C4%$/6*2"-.$-"E./%*"

+'(*"75'("U*E.$(".$2"7'062"H'1+"/6"2/77*5*6-"4$5-+"'7"-.*"&'06-5:>"'5"-.5'09."9'B*56(*6-"

+&.*(*+>"($6:"E*5*"%*7-"06$1%*"-'"7**2"-.*/5"7$(/%/*+J"K./+"2/+%'&$-/'6"E$+"&'(4'062*2"1:"

-.*"*77*&-+"'7"-.*"+%0("&%*$5$6&*"45'95$((*"5*/6+-$-*2"$7-*5"d'5%2"d$5"KE'J";:66"*C4%$/6*2"

.'E"4*'4%*"%*7-".'(*+"-.*:".$2"95'E6"04"/6"$62"('B*2>"'7-*6"$9$/6+-"-.*/5"E/%%>"-'"'-.*5"

4$5-+"'7"-.*"1'5'09."-'"-$F*"$2B$6-$9*"'7"6*E"45'4*5-/*+"E/-."/62''5"-'/%*-+>"1$-.5''(+>".'-"

E$-*5"$62"&*6-5$%".*$-/69J"K.*"5*+0%-"'7"-.*+*"&.$69*+>"+.*"+$/2>"E$+"-.*"*62"'7"&'((06/-:"

+4/5/-JOO"

"

#*('5/*+"'7"%'++"E*5*"($2*"+*6+*"'7"-.5'09."-.*"-*5("W&$66'6"7'22*5YJ"WS$66'6"7'22*5Y"

45'B/2*2"$"&'.*5*6-"6$55$-/B*"7'5"-.*"E$:"-.$-"-.*"<$+-"<62"E'5F/69Q&%$++"l.$r2s"1**6"+./-"

r+.$-s"'6"7'5":*$5+"$62":*$5+"$62":*$5+nJ"A-"E$+"0+*2"1:"K*++$"-'"%/6F"-.*"2*$-.+"'7"<$+-"<62"

4*'4%*"/6"d'5%2"d$5"T6*"g"%/-*5$%%:"W&$66'6"7'22*5Y"g"-'"7$(/%:"(*(1*5+"1*/69"+*6-"'77"-'"

7/9.-"/6"d'5%2"d$5"KE'>"-'"-.*".'5/a'6+"*6B/+$9*2"7'5".*5"7/5+-"+'6"$-"-.*".$62+"'7"-.*"(/22%*Q

&%$++"*20&$-/'6"+:+-*("Gl('5*"&$66'6"7'22*5nI"G+**"S.$4-*5"]/B*I>"$62"-'"-.*"%/7*"&.$6&*+"'7"

:'069"4*'4%*"$-";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01"/6"$"-/(*"'7"$+4/5$-/'6"$62"&'6+0(4-/'6J"A6"-./+"E$:>"K*++$"

*C4%$/6*2"-.*"06&*5-$/6-/*+"$62"2*&%/6*+"-.$-"+.*"+$E"$5'062".*5>"-.5'09."-.*"/2*$"-.$-"<$+-"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""OO"8/(/%$5"'4/6/'6+"$5*"45*+*6-*2"/6"$"60(1*5"'7"-*C-+"'6"<$+-";'62'6"G3*6&."*-"$%J"?@@ej"d/%%('--"!PeOj"

Z'069"$62"d/%%('--"!PNMIJ"

Page 69: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

eP"

"

<62"4*'4%*"E*5*"$%E$:+"2*+-/6*2"-'"2/*"$"+'&/$%"2*$-."$-"-.*".$62+"'7"-.*"4'E*570%J"K.*+*"

E*5*"$"&'%%*&-/'6"'7"E$5"9*6*5$%+>"%'&$%"$0-.'5/-/*+"$62"(/22%*Q&%$++"&'6+0(*5+J",+"K*++$"

*C4%$/6*2"E.*6"-$%F/69"$1'0-"-.*"4$5*6-+"'7":'069"4*'4%*f"

"

,62"r-.*"4$5*6-+s"2'"+-077"E/-."r-.*/5":'069"4*'4%*s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r,6-/"8'&/$%"^*.$B/'05"T52*5s"rmsJ"X/B*"-.*("$6",8^TJ"A"5*$%%:"2'"7**%"E.*6"-.*+*"4*'4%*"9'"'6"$1'0-"5$&/$%".$5$++(*6-J"A"-./6F"&'(*"2'E6"$62"rms"+**".'E"-.*"<$+-"<62"4*'4%*".$B*"1**6"9*--/69"'6J"A"9'-"-'"9'"#$%&'%(>"10-"-.$-Y+".'E"A"7**%J"A"7**%"-.$-"E*".$B*"1**6"+./-"r+.$-s"'6"7'5":*$5+"$62":*$5+"$62":*$5+>"A"5*$%%:"2'J"8'"6'"A"2'6Y-"B'-*J"]0&F"W*(J"K.*:"+.'0%2".$B*"1%'E6"04"-.*".'0+*+"'7"=$5%/$(*6-J"X0:"]$EF*+"+.'0%2".$B*"+0&&**2*2"-.*6J"

"

A6"-./+"6$55$-/B*"K*++$"$%+'"4'+/-/'6+".*5"$6$%:+/+"'7"&%$++"%'++"$9$/6+-"-.*"2*('6/+$-/'6"'7"-.*"

E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"$+"5$&/+-J"_*5"&'((*6-"lA"5*$%%:"2'"7**%"E.*6"-.*+*"4*'4%*"9'"'6"$1'0-"

5$&/$%".$5$++(*6-n"/+"5*H*&-/'6"'7"-.*"%$1*%+"$++'&/$-*2"E/-."062*5&%$++"2/+&'05+*+"G#$&3'6$%2"

$62"#$5+."?@@Nj"#055$:"!PP@>"!PP\I"-.$-".$B*"1**6"$44%/*2"-'"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"

4'40%$-/'6+"%'&$%%:"$62"6$-/'6$%%:"Gd$5*"?@@VI"G+**"S.$4-*5"]/B*I>"$62"$"750+-5$-*2"$&&*4-$6&*"

-.$-"5$&/+("/+"-.*"'0-&'(*"'7"$"./+-'5:"'7"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"($59/6$%/+$-/'6J"

"

,%-.'09."-.*"%'&0+"'7"6'+-$%9/$"7'5"-.*"X'%2*6"<5$"E$+"5*(*(1*5*2"/6"-*5(+"'7"&%$++"$62"

&'((06/-:"%'++>"/-"E$+"$%+'"5*(*(1*5*2"-.5'09."%'++"$++'&/$-*2"E/-."4'+-QE$5"/((/95$-/'6J"

^:"%''F/69"-'"1%$(*"(/95$6-+"7'5"4'+-Q/620+-5/$%"2*&%/6*"$62"-.*"$6C/*-/*+"&$0+*2"1:"+'&/$%"

75$9(*6-$-/'6"062*5"6*'Q%/1*5$%/+("GZ0B$%Q3$B/+"?@!?>"4J!NeI>"/-"7'%%'E*2"$"7$(/%/$5"./+-'5:"'7"

1%$(/69"5$&/$%/+*2"'-.*5+"7'5"E/2*5"+'&/$%"45'1%*(+"G^$6-'6"!PNNj"_0(4.5/*+"!PV!j")'6*+"

!PM!j"R/&.('62"!PN\IJ"A6"-./+"E$:>"/((/95$-/'6"'B*5%$/2"&%$++"%'++"$62"1*&$(*"/-+"'E6"+'05&*"

'7"5*+*6-(*6-J"K.*"/%%*9/-/($&:"'7"(/95$6-+"-.*6"&'6&055*6-%:"*+-$1%/+.*2"-.*"%*9/-/($&:"'7"

-.'+*"1'2/*+"-.$-"&'0%2"%$:"&%$/("-'"-.*"-5$2/-/'6$%"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"&'((06/-:j"-.*"'6*"

-.$-"E$+"/($9/6*2"-'"*C/+-"1*7'5*"-.*"/((/95$6-+"$55/B*2J",-"-.*"-/(*"'7"&'620&-/69"-.*"

5*+*$5&.>"-./+"7'5("'7"(*('5:"45$&-/&*".$2"&'6-/60*2"E/-."5*7*5*6&*"-'"E./-*"<$+-*56"

<05'4*$6"(/95$6-+"E.'"E*5*"/2*6-/7/*2"$+"6'-"1*/69"E./-*"*6'09.J"

"

Page 70: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

M@"

"

K.*"&.$5$&-*5"'7"E./-*6*2"(*('5/*+"'7"1*%'69/69"E$+"W$0-'&.-.'6'0+Y"GX*+&./*5*"?@@PI"g"$"

W(:-."'7"*6-/-%*(*6-Y"G#''5*"?@@V>"4JONeI"$62"$"($H'5/-:"2/+&'05+*"'7"1*%'69/69"GZ0B$%Q3$B/+"

?@!?IJ"_'E*B*5>"/-"E$+"6'-"&'67/6*2"-'"E./-*"1'2/*+J"d./-*6*++"/6"^5/-$/6"$62"<$+-";'62'6"/+"$"

4'40%$5"4.*6'(*6'6"G^'66*--"?@@@IJ"3/77*5*6-"G10-"6'-"+*4$5$-*I"75'("-.*"[8"*C$(4%*+"'7"

5$&/$%"04%/7-"GU*E/-a"!PPMj"R'*2/9*5"?@@Mj"d5$:"?@@eI"$62"c/&-'5/$6"/2*$+"'7"E./-*6*++"$+"

1'059*'/+"'5"*%/-*"G$62"W2/5-:"E./-*Y"$+"+$B$9*I"G^''-."!VP@j"#$:.*E"!Ve!j"8/(+"!VVOI>"

$0-'&.-.'6:"/6"<$+-";'62'6"95*E"'0-"'7"$"./+-'5:"'7"E./-*"4'40%$5/+("-.$-"7'%%'E*2"

/(4*5/$%/+(>"-.*"E*%7$5*"+-$-*>"-.*"8*&'62"d'5%2"d$5"$62"4'+-Q&'%'6/$%"C*6'4.'1/$"G^'66*--"

?@@@IJ"K./+"4'40%$5"&'62/-/'6"'7"$0-'&.-.'6:"(*$6-"-.$-"E./-*6*++"E$+"E/2*%:"2/+-5/10-*2"$62"

/62**2"&'0%2"1*"-5$&*2"1:"4*'4%*"'7"B$5/'0+"*-.6/&/-/*+"$62"(/95$-'5:"-5$H*&-'5/*+J"

"

K./+"/+"6'-"-'"+$:"-.*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"'7"1%$&F"$62",+/$6":'0-."E'5F*5+"E*5*"-.*"+$(*"$+"

-.*/5"E./-*"&'06-*54$5-+J"d./%*"-.*:"('056*2"-.*"%'++"'7"$0-'&.-.'6'0+"&'((06/-:>"$62"-.*"

2*&%/6*"15'09.-"1:"6*E"/((/95$-/'6"G4$5-/&0%$5%:"<$+-*56"<05'4*$6"(/95$-/'6I>"-.*:"2/2"6'-"

('056"-.*"%'++"'7"E./-*"&'((06/-:J"K.*"E./-*"&'((06/-:"/6"U*E.$("E$+"$"./9.%:"

45'1%*($-/&"4%$&*"7'5"($6:"1%$&F"$62",+/$6":'0-."E'5F*5+J"A6"-.*"!Pe@+>"1%$&F"4*'4%*"%/B/69"/6"

-.*"$5*$".$2"-.*/5"E/62'E+"+($+.*2>"06-/%"-.*:"%*7-J"K.*"$5*$".$2"$"U$-/'6$%"]5'6-""45*+*6&*"

G_0+1$62+"!PVVI"$62"-.*"2*+&*62$6-+"'7"-.*"('1"E.'"9$B*"'0-"S.5/+-($+"45*+*6-+"-'"-.'+*"

%0&F:"E./-*"F/2+"E*5*"$%+'"-.*"%'&$%"U$-/'6$%"]5'6-"$&-/B/+-+>"$62"6'-"+'"1*6*7/&*6-"-'":'069"

1%$&F"$62",+/$6"F/2+J"K.5'09."-.*"!PV@+"$62"/6-'"-.*"!PP@+"+*5/'0+"+-5**-Q%*B*%"5$&/+("

&'6-/60*2"$5'062";*:.$(J"^%$&F"$62",+/$6":'0-."E'5F*5+"&'((*6-*2"'6"-.*"$5*$Y+"

5*40-$-/'6"7'5"5$&/+("$62"-.*"2$/%:"/6&/2*6-+"'7"5$&/+-"$10+*"-.*:"*6205*2J"U'-"'6%:"2/2"-.*+*"

:'0-."E'5F*5+"6'-"('056"-.*"%'++"'7"-.*"E./-*"&'((06/-:>"-.*:"$%+'"-.'09.-"/-"$"9''2"-./69"

-.$-"-.*"('+-"$52*6-"5$&/+-+".$2"%*7-"7'5"-.*"./6-*5%$62+"'7"<++*C"$62"`*6-J"

"

R:*6"$62")$:"E*5*"-E'":'0-."E'5F*5+"$-";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01J"R:*6>"/6"./+"*$5%:"-E*6-/*+>"E$+"

1%$&F"$62".$2"95'E6"04"/6"-.*"%'&$%"$5*$J")$:>"*$5%:"-./5-/*+>"E$+",+/$6"$62".$2"1**6"E'5F/69"

$5'062";*:.$("7'5"-.*"%$+-"2*&$2*J"K.*:"*C4%$/6*2"-.*/5"*C4*5/*6&*+f"

"

:/+(f"A"2/2"F6'E"-./+"$5*$"1*7'5*>"1*&$0+*"A"$&-0$%%:"%/B*2"/6";*:.$("7'5"$"1/-"$+"E*%%J"A"%/B*2".*5*"1$&F"/6"-.*"*$5%:"P@+"m"^0-"20*"-'"5$&/+("(:"7$(/%:"('B*2"'0-"'7"-.*"$5*$J"N+f"d.*6"E$+"-.$-i":/+(f"YPO>"WP\"N+f"^*&$0+*"-.*5*"E$+"h0/-*"$"%'-"'7"5$&/+("-.*6i"

Page 71: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

M!"

"

:/+(f"Z*$."-.*5*"E$+J"K./+"$5*$"E$+"($/6%:"E./-*"4*'4%*"/6"-.*"$5*$J"N+f",62"E$+"/-"1$2J":/+(f"Z*$.>"1$2J"K.*5*"E$+"h0/-*"$"%'-"'7"5$&/+(J"N+f"d.$-"F/62"'7"-./69i":/+(f"W3/5-:"&''6Y>"W6/99*5+YJ"N+f")0+-"%/F*"E$%F/69"2'E6"-.*"+-5**-i":/+(f"Z*$.>"H0+-"E$%F/69"2'E6"-.*"+-5**-J"rms"N+f"d.$-"2'":'0"5*&F'6")$:i"]4/f"Z*+>"2*7/6/-*%:J"AYB*"1**6".*5*"7'5"$1'0-"!!":*$5+"$62"E.*6"A"+-$5-*2"-.*5*"E$+"'6*"&0%-05*"$62"/-"E$+"5*$%%:"-'09."7'5"(*J"N+f"3'":'0"(*$6"$"E./-*"$5*$i"]4/f"Z*$.>"$"%'-"'7"E./-*"&./%25*6"$62"+-077"%/F*"-.$-J"A"7'062"/-"5*$%%:".$52"1*&$0+*"A"$("75'("$"2/77*5*6-"1$&F95'062>"1*&$0+*"A"$("A62/$6J"rms"N+f"3/2":'0"0+*2"-'"9*-"5$&/+("+-077"1*7'5*>"$-"-.*"1*9/66/69i"]4/f","%'->"$"%'-J"m"r,s6'-.*5"-./69"-.$-"A"6'-/&*"$1'0-"4*'4%*"-.$-"$5*"5$&/+->"-.*:"2'6Y-"E$6-"-'"1*".*5*J"K.*:"('B*2"$E$:"$62"-.$-Y+"-50*J"K.*:"E$6-"-'"1*"+'(*E.*5*"-.$-"-.*:"7**%"&'(7'5-$1%*J"N+f"K.*:YB*"9'6*"-'"<++*C"'5"`*6-"'5"+-077"%/F*"-.$-i"]4/f"K.$-Y+"/-J"K.$-Y+"+'"-50*J"N+f"8'"2'":'0"-./6F"-.*"$5*$Y+"/(45'B*2"5'062".*5*>"9'-"1*--*5>"9'-"E'5+*i":/+(f"A"-./6F"/6"&*5-$/6"-./69+"/-".$+"9'-"1*--*5>"%/F*"(0%-/&0%-05$%/+("r/6&5*$+*2"*-.6/&"2/B*5+/-:s".$+"/(45'B*2"-.*"$5*$J"

"

U'6*-.*%*++>":'0-."E'5F*5+"$62"4$5*6-+"'7"B$5/'0+"*-.6/&"1$&F95'062+"$62"(/95$-'5:"

-5$H*&-'5/*+"('056*2"-.*"%'++"'7"W&'((06/-:YJ",+"4$5-"'7"-.*"5*&055/69"&'6+-50&-/'6"'7"X'%2*6"

<5$+"G=*$5+'6"!PVOj"d/%%/$(+"!PMOI>"-.*:"-''"-'%2"-$%*+"'7"&./%2.''2>"('5$%/-:"$62"+/(4%*"

4%*$+05*+J"K.*+*"&./%2.''2+".$2"&'(('6"7*$-05*+J"Z'0-."E'5F*5+>"+'(*"'6%:"/6"-.*/5"

-E*6-/*+>"E/-."(/95$-'5:"-5$H*&-'5/*+"-.$-"&'66*&-*2")$($/&$"E/-."A5*%$62>"<69%$62"$62"A62/$>"

-'%2"(*".'E"-.*5*"0+*2"-'"1*"('5*"/66'&*6&*"$62"%*++"&5/(*>"2509+"$62"9$69+J"K.*:"-'%2"(*"

.'E"&./%25*6"4%$:*2"'6"-.*"+-5**-+"$62"2''5+"E*5*"%*7-"E/2*"'4*6J"K.*:"$%+'"$++'&/$-*2"%'++"

E/-."6*E"(/95$6-+"g"4$5-/&0%$5%:"<$+-*56"<05'4*$6+J"K.*:"/2*6-/7/*2"/((/95$-/'6"E/-."&0%-05$%"

2*&$:f"$%&'.'%/+(>"B/'%*6&*>"-.*"45'1%*($-/&"'&&04$-/'6"'7"401%/&"+4$&*"G25/6F/69"/6"-.*"4$5F>"

.$69/69"'0-"'6"+-5**-"&'56*5+I>"1%$&FQ($5F*-"10+/6*++"45$&-/&*+>"9$69+"$62"-.*"%$&F"'7"+-5**-"

+$7*-:J"K.*+*"/2*$+"'7"('5$%"$62"+'&/$%"2*&$:"E*5*"705-.*5"4%$:*2"'0-"-.5'09."2/+&0++/'6+"

$1'0-"E*%7$5*"+.'5-$9*+"$62"$"%$&F"'7"H'1+"7'5":'069"4*'4%*>"$9$/6"$--5/10-*2"-'"/((/95$-/'6J"

T6*":'0-."E'5F*5>"E.'"$55/B*2"/6"-.*"[`"75'("X0:$6$"7'5-:":*$5+"$9'>"-.'09.-"-.$-"6*E"

(/95$6-+".$26Y-"1**6"/6"-.*"&'06-5:"%'69"*6'09."-'"+-$5-"-$F/69".'0+/69>"H'1+>"E*%7$5*"$62"-.*"

l7''2"'0-"'7"-.*"('0-.+n"'7"^5/-/+."4*'4%*J"A6"-./+"E$:>"-.*"/6&'(4$-/1/%/-:"'7"-.*"'%2"6$-/'6"

E/-."6*E"4*'4%*"E$+"5*-5$&*2"$62"($/6-$/6*2"$&5'++"*-.6/&"1'062$5/*+J"A6"-./+"E$:>"-.*"

Page 72: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

M?"

"

*C&%0+/'6+"$62"./+-'5/&"2*Q%*9/-/(/+$-/'6"-.$-".$2"1**6"*6$&-*2"/6"-.*"4$+-"E*5*"5*-5$&*2"$62"

45$&-/+*2"/6"-.*"45*+*6-J"

"

K.*"15*$F2'E6"'7"X'%2*6"<5$"6'-/'6+"'7"&'((06/-:>"5/+/69"&5/(*"$62"+-5**-"B/'%*6&*"E$+"

9*6*5$%%:"B*5/7/*2"1:"-.*"7$&-"-.$-"4*'4%*"WF*4-"-'"-.*/5"'E6Y"'5"W2/26Y-"-$%F"'B*5"-.*"9$52*6"

7*6&*Y"$6:('5*J"Z'0-."E'5F*5+"5*90%$5%:"&'((*6-*2"'6"-.*"%'++"'7"&'((06/-:"$62"$--5/10-*2"

-./+"%'++"-'"-.*"5/+*"'7"&'6+0(*5"&$4/-$%/+("$62"/62/B/20$%/+(J"_'E*B*5>"E./%*"-.*":'0-."

E'5F*5+"2/2"50(/6$-*"'6"-.*+*"+-50&-05$%"/++0*+>"-.*"45'1%*("'7"W4*'4%*QF**4/69Q-'Q-.*/5Q'E6Y"

E$+"$%+'"0+*2"-'"/2*6-/7:"-.*"45'1%*($-/&"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"'7",+/$6"&'((06/-/*+J"=*5&*4-/'6+"

'7"+-5'69"&0%-05$%"(*('5:"$('69",+/$6"&'((06/-/*+"E*5*"E5/--*6"'B*5"+-50&-05$%"06&*5-$/6-:"

$62"&.$69/69"7'5(+"'7"+'&/$%"/6-*5$&-/'6J"K.*+*"&0%-05$%"(*('5/*+"E*5*"7*-/+./+*2"$62"*6B/*2"

7'5".$B/69"($/6-$/6*2"-.*"&%'+*QF6/-"&'((06/-:"-.$-"-.*"<69%/+.".$2"%'+-"$62"&'0%2"6'-"5*9$/6J"

]'5"-.'+*"E.'"/6B*+-*2"/6"8-"X*'59*Y+"3$:"$+"$"&50(1%/69"1$+-/'6"'7"$"405*5"4$+->"-.*"

&*%*15$-/'6"'7"</2"$62"3/E$%/"E*5*"+:(1'%+"'7"-./+J"K.*"%/1*5$%"5*H*&-/'6"'7"8-"X*'59*Y+"3$:"g"

l4'%/-/&$%"&'55*&-6*++"9'6*"($2n"G4*5+J"&'((JI"g"-.*6"7*2"1$&F"/6-'"-./+"5$&/$%/+*2"

(*('5:+&$4*>"($F/69"6'+-$%9/$"7'5"-.*"X'%2*6"<5$"$%%"-.*"('5*"4$/670%J"

"

K.*"2/$%'9/&"7'5($-/'6"'7"/((/95$-/'6"$62"&%$++"%'++>"$62"/-+"(0-$1/%/-:"$&5'++"5$&/$%"

1'062$5/*+>"E$+"B/B/2%:"2*('6+-5$-*2"'6*"*B*6/69"$-";*:.$(J"K.5**":'0-."E'5F*5+f"U*/%>"$"

7/5+-Q9*6*5$-/'6"S$6$2/$6"E.'".$2"%/B*2"/6"-.*"1'5'09."7'5"$1'0-"-E*6-:":*$5+j")$:>"$"+*&'62Q

9*6*5$-/'6"A62/$6"E.'".$+"E'5F*2"/6"-.*"1'5'09."7'5"-.*"%$+-"2*&$2*j"$62"K*++$>"$"-./52Q

9*6*5$-/'6"8&'->"$%+'"1'56"$62"5$/+*2"/6"U*E.$(>"+-''2"E/-."(*"/6"-.*"F/-&.*6"($F/69"$"&04"

'7"-*$J"A"$("E./-*>"E$+"15'09.-"04"/6"_*5-7'52+./5*>"%/B*"/6"U'5-.";'62'6"$62".$B*"$"(/95$-'5:"

./+-'5:"-.$-"&'66*&-+"8'0-."d$%*+"-'"^5/+-'%"$62"+'0-.QE*+-";'62'6J"K.*"-'4/&"'7"&'6B*5+$-/'6"

E$+"-.*"2*&%/6*"'7"<$+-";'62'6"&'((06/-:J"K.*"%'++"'7"&'((06/-:"+4/5/-"E$+"%$(*6-*2"$62"

-.*:"&'6&%02*2"-.$-"/-"E$+"06%/F*%:"-'"5*-056"E./%*"4*'4%*"2/26Y-"+4*$F"<69%/+."'5"F6'E"<69%/+."

./+-'5:J"K.*:"$%%"1%$(*2"-.*"A62/$6+"$62"=$F/+-$6/+"7'5"-.*"%$690$9*"$62"&/-*2"$"='%/+."E'5F*5"

'6"-.*"+*&'62"&.$59*J"_*".$2"$44$5*6-%:"&%$/(*2"-.$-"_*65:"cAAA".$2"F/%%*2"-.*"='4*J"8/7-/69"

1*-E**6"-.*"8*&'62"d'5%2"d$5"$62"d/%%/$("-.*"S'6h0*5'5>"E*"$%%"&%0-&.*2"7'5"75$9(*6-+"'7"

'05"XS8<"'5"TQ%*B*%"'77/&/$%"./+-'5:J",7-*5"$"E./%*>"/-"-056*2"'0-"-.$-"6'6*"'7"0+".$2"$6"$&&05$-*"

$&&'06-"'7"-.'+*"*B*6-+"/6"-.*"!NO@+J",6:E$:>"/-"2/26Y-"($--*5>"$62"$+"-.*:"E*5*"&'6&%02/69"

-.$-"/-"E$+"$"9''2"-./69"-.$-"-.*:"E*5*"$%%"5*$%%:"$&&*4-/69"'7"2/77*5*6&*>"U*/%"+$/2>"W8...v"<2Y+"

(0("/+"&'(/69JY"<2Y+"(0("E$+"1%$&F"$62"*B*5:'6*"E$+"h0/*-J"

Page 73: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

MO"

"

"

K.*"&'6B*5+$-/'6"2*('6+-5$-*2"-.*"4%05$%/-:"$62"&5*$-/B/-:"'7"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"$++'&/$-*2"

E/-."E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"$62"-.*/5"&5*$-/B*"0+*"'7"&0%-05$%"$62"5$&/$%"&'2*+J"K.*"-.5**":'0-."

E'5F*5+"'7"2/77*5*6-"(/95$-'5:"./+-'5/*+"$62"2/77*5*6-"*(1'2/*2"*C4*5/*6&*+"E*5*"$1%*"-'"

&'%%*&-/B*%:"%$(*6-"-.*"2*&%/6*"'7"&'((06/-:"%'&$-*2"/6"-.*"X'%2*6"<5$J"K.*:"2/2"+'"E/-."

5*&'05+*"-'"%'&$%"+-*5*'-:4*+"$1'0-"A62/$6+"$62"=$F/+-$6/+"$62"-.*:"%/6F*2"-./+"*77'5-%*++%:"-'"

-.*"6*E*5"B/'%$-/'6"45*+*6-*2"1:"-.*"7/905*"'7"-.*"='%/+."E'5F*5"g"E.'"E$+"+**6"

+/(0%-$6*'0+%:"$+"$6"/%%*9/-/($-*"45*+*6&*"$62"$"2/5*&-"-.5*$-"-'"^5/-/+."W./+-'5:YJ"d*"E*5*"$%%"

$&&'52*2"$&&*++"-'"-./+"&'6B*5+$-/'6"-.5'09."'05"&'66*&-/'6"-'"U*E.$(Y+"4$+-J",+"$"6*E"

$55/B$%"/6"-.*"1'5'09."(:"E./-*"+F/6"$62"/-+"5*%$-/'6"-'"-.*"(*%$6&.'%/&"6$-/'6"9$B*"(*"-./+"

201/'0+"45/B/%*9*J"U*/%Y+"E./-*"+F/6"$62"-/(*"/6"-.*"$5*$"7$&/%/-$-*2"./+J"K*++$>"E./-*"$62"1'56"

$62"15'09.-"04"/6"-.*"1'5'09.>".$2"6'"&.$59*"-'"$6+E*5J")$:Y+"15'E6"+F/6"E$+"$%+'"6'-"$6"

/6./1/-'5"-'"-./+"2/+&0++/'6J"d./%*".*"2/2"6'-"&*%*15$-*"-.*"+$(*"/2*$"'7"E./-*"&'((06/-:"$+"

-.*"'-.*5"-E'"2/2>".*"E$+"+-/%%"$1%*"-'"$&&*++"$62"0+*"(*('5/*+"'7"E./-*6*++"-'"($F*"./+"'E6"

$0-'&.-.'6'0+"&%$/(+J"

"

^$+*2"'6"-./+"2/+&0++/'6>"U*/%>")$:"$62"K*++$"&'6&%02*2"-.$-"-.*:"E*5*"$%%"5*$%%:"-'%*5$6-"'7"

2/77*5*6&*J"^:"-./+"-.*:"(*$6-"-.$-"2*+4/-*"-.*/5"4*5&*4-/'6"'7"-.*+*"&0%-05$%"45'1%*(+>"-.*:"

E*5*".$44:"-'"9*-"$%'69"E/-."4*'4%*"'7"2/77*5*6-"1$&F95'062+"'6"$"2$:Q-'Q2$:"1$+/+J"K.*"

&'6-*+-*2"./+-'5:"'7"-.*/5"2/+&0++/'6>"$62"-.*"2/77*5*6-"*C&%0+/'6+"/-"*6-$/%*2>"1*&$(*"$44$5*6-"

E/-."-.*"4.:+/&$%"45*+*6&*"'7"<2Y+"('-.*5Y+"1%$&F"1'2:J"<2Y+"('-.*5Y+"1'2:"15'09.-"/6-'"5*%/*7"

-.*"2/77*5*6-"F/62+"'7"./+-'5/&"%*9/-/($&:"*6H':*2"1:"='%/+.>"<69%/+.>"d*%+.>"8&'--/+.>"S$6$2/$6>"

A62/$6"$62"1%$&F"S$5/11*$6"(/95$6-+"/6"-.*"$5*$>"$62"-.*"2/77*5*6-"1$+*+"75'("E./&."-.*/5"

&'%%*&-/B*"$62"6'+-$%9/&"%$(*6-".$2"1**6"4'++/1%*J"d./%*"E*"$%%".$2"$&&*++"-'"E./-*"(*('5/*+>"

-.*"E$:+"-.$-"E*"$&&*++*2"-.*("2*4*62*2"'6"'05"1'2/*+>"'6"-.*"&'%%*&-/B/-:"'7"-.*"%$(*6->"

$62"'6"-.*"45*+*6&*"'7"W'-.*5+YJ"

_'E":'069"4*'4%*"5*-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"

#:"'5/9/6$%"/6-*5*+-"/6"2/$%'9/&"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"$62"-.*/5"&.$%%*69*"-'"-.*"4'40%$5"7/&-/'6+"'7"

-.*"E./-*"<$+-"<62"2/2"6'-"+-$5-"E/-."-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+"10-"E/-."-.*":'069"4*'4%*"$-";*:.$("

Z'0-."S%01J"84*&/7/&$%%:>"-.*"/2*$"7'5"-./+"&.$4-*5"1*9$6"E./%*"A"E$+"'1+*5B/69":'069"4*'4%*Y+"

5/-0$%+"7'5"8-"X*'59*Y+"3$:"$-";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01J",-"-.*"-/(*>"A"$++0(*2"-.$-"1*&$0+*"-.*"$5*$"

E$+"+'"(0%-/Q*-.6/&>"-.*5*"E'0%2"1*"%/--%*>"/7"$6:>"/6-*5*+-"/6"-.*"'&&$+/'6J"A"E$+"(/+-$F*6>"

Page 74: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

M\"

"

.'E*B*5J"A6&5*$+/69%:>"8-"X*'59*Y+"3$:"$62"-.*"8-"X*'59*"S5'++".$B*"1**6"('1/%/+*2"/6"-.*"

+*5B/&*"'7"6$-/'6$%"(*%$6&.'%/$+"GX/%5':"?@@eI>"$62";*:.$("E$+"6'"*C&*4-/'6J"K.*+*"(*('5:"

5/-0$%+>"'5"*B*5:2$:"$&-+"'7"(*('5/$%/+$-/'6"G,%*C$62*5"]'5-.&'(/69I".$2"$"4$5-/&0%$5%:"+-5'69"

5*+'6$6&*"/6"-.*":'0-."&%01J"[6%/F*"+'(*"'7"-.*"'-.*5":'0-."&%01+"-.$-"E'0%2"&*%*15$-*"3/B$%/>"

</2"'5"-.*",75/&$6"S04"'7"U$-/'6+"E/-."*h0$%"/6-*5*+->";*:.$("7'&0+*2"'6"<69%/+."$62"S.5/+-/$6"

7*+-/B$%+J";/F*"S.5/+-($+"$62"<$+-*5>"8-"X*'59*Y+"3$:"E$+"$"($5F*2"'&&$+/'6"$62"-.*":'0-."&%01"

E$+"25*++*2"E/-."$++'&/$-*2"+:(1'%/+(J"

"

A6"-.*"506Q04"-'"8-"X*'59*Y+"3$:>"-.*":'0-."&%01".$2"1**6"2*&'5$-*2"/6"-.*"&'%'05+"'7"-.*"8-"

X*'59*"7%$9J"]/7-:"&./%25*6"$62":'069"4*'4%*"'7"B$5/'0+"6$-/'6$%>"*-.6/&"$62"%/690/+-/&"

-5$H*&-'5/*+"+$-"$5'062"-.*"&5$7-"-$1%*+"($F/69"$"+*%*&-/'6"'7"5*2"$62"E./-*"'1H*&-+J"

=$5-/&/4$-/'6"/6"-.*"5/-0$%+"45'B/2*2"-.*("E/-."$6"'77/&/$%"%$690$9*"-.5'09."E./&."-'"-5$&*"-.*/5"

'E6"B*5+/'6+"'7"E./-*6*++"$62"&%$++"%'++J"K./+"E$+"-.*"$7-*5Q+&.''%"95'04"5$-.*5"-.$6"-.*"

E./-*5":'0-."95'04"A"E'5F*2"E/-.J"K*++$"E$+"($F/69"$"5*2"$62"E./-*".$-"7'5";:66"-'"E*$5"

E.*6"+.*"&$%%*2"-.*"1/69'"$-"$"%'&$%"d'5F/69"#*6Y+"S%01J"`:%/*>"*/9.-**6>"+$-"2'E6"'6"-.*"+'7$"

E/-."(*"-'"E$-&."E.$-"E$+"9'/69"'6"$62"A"$+F*2".*5"E.$-"+.*"-.'09.-J"8.*"-'%2"(*"-.$-"-.*"

5/-0$%+"E*5*"/(4'5-$6-J"lK.*:"r.$B*s"-.*/5"2$:>"+'"E*"$5*"9'/69"-'".$B*"'05+Jn"]'59*--/69"

S.5/+-($+"$62"<$+-*5>"+.*"&'6-/60*2>"ld*"+-/%%"2'6Y-"9*-"$"2$:"'77"+&.''%"-.'09."m"<9+/"2'"7'5"

</2"$62"m"A"&$6Y-"5*(*(1*5"-.*"5*+-"'7"-.*("r5*%/9/'0+".'%/2$:+sJn"

"

]'5"`:%/*>"&*%*15$-/69"8-"X*'59*Y+"3$:"$&-*2"$+"$"7'5("'7"45'-*+-"$9$/6+-"-.*"&0%-05$%"*5$+05*"

+.*"$++'&/$-*2"E/-."(0%-/Q*-.6/&"+'&/*-:>"(0%-/&0%-05$%/+("$62"4'%/-/&$%"&'55*&-6*++J"A62**2>"-.*"

2/+4%$:+"'7"5*2"$62"E./-*"-.$-"&'%'05*2"-.*":'0-."&%01"%*6-"-.*(+*%B*+"-'"-.*"+$(*"&'6&%0+/'6J"

K*++$"$62";:66"E*5*"($F/69"$"+-$-*(*6-"-.$-";*:.$("+-/%%"5*(*(1*5*2"<69%$62J"_'E*B*5>"

-.*"-$1%*"'7":'069"4*'4%*"+**(*2"-'"+099*+-"$"('5*"&'6-*+-*2"./+-'5:J"K.*"$(1/90/-:"$62"

$%%05*"'7"-.*+*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"5*+/2*2"E/-."-E'"E'(*6"'7"R'($6:"$62"8&'--/+.".*5/-$9*"

*6&'05$9/69"-$1%*+"'7"(0%-/Q*-.6/&"&./%25*6"-'"*6-.0+/$+-/&$%%:"9%0*"-'9*-.*5"5*2"$62"E./-*"

7%'E*5+J"

"

_'E*B*5>"E./%*"-./+"*B*6-"4'/6-*2"1$&F"-'"-.*"4'+-QE$5"&'6H06&-05*>"15'09.-"-'"%/9.-"6$-/'6$%"

$62"%'&$%"(:-.'%'9/*+"'7"E./-*6*++>"$62"2*('6+-5$-*2"-.*"-5$&/69"'7"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"/6"$"

+04*5Q2/B*5+*"4%$&*>"/-"$%+'"%*7-"$"%'-"'7"h0*+-/'6+"06$6+E*5*2J"305/69"(:"-E'":*$5+"$-";*:.$("

Z'0-."S%01>"-.*"$(1/90/-:"'7"-.*+*"5/-0$%"45$&-/&*+>"$62"*C$&-%:"E.$-"-.*:"(*$6-"-'":'069"

Page 75: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

MN"

"

4*'4%*>"E$+"7/%%*2"1:"('5*"1$6$%"('(*6-+"G^/%%/9"!PPNIJ"`:%/*>"#'%%:>"3$E6>"8$($6-.$"$62"

)'+/*"E*5*"$9*2"1*-E**6"+/C-**6"$62"*/9.-**6J"K.*:".$2"$%%"1**6"1'56"/6"-.*"1'5'09.>"E*5*"

E./-*"$62".$2"4$5*6-+>"95$624$5*6-+"$62"95*$-Q95$624$5*6-+"E/-."(/95$-'5:"./+-'5/*+"-.$-"

&'66*&-*2"X5**&*"-'"A5*%$62>"$62"^*-.6$%"X5**6"-'"-.*"(/95$-/'6+"'7"-.*"R'($6:"4'40%$-/'6J"

`:%/*"$62"#'%%:"E*5*"75/*62+"$+"E*5*"3$E6>"8$($6-.$"$62")'+/*J"K.*:"E*5*"$%%"E'5F/69Q&%$++J"

3$E6"$62"8$($6-.$".$2"$&./*B*2"+'(*"95$2*"S+"$-"XS8<"$62"-.*"'-.*5+".$2"7$5*2"%*++"E*%%J"

#'%%:>"3$E6"$62")'+/*"E$6-*2"H'1+"10-"$%'69"E/-."NOJP"4*5"&*6-"'7":'069"4*'4%*"/6"-.*"

1'5'09."$9*2"+/C-**6"-'"-E*6-:Q7'05"G;^U"?@!@1>"4J\\I>"-.*:"E*5*"+-5099%/69"-'"7/62"E'5FJ"

,+/2*"75'("`:%/*"$62"#'%%:"$%%"-.*":'069"E'(*6"E*5*"%/B/69"E/-."-.*/5"4$5*6-+"'5"90$52/$6+>"

$%-.'09."-.*:"E$6-*2"-'"('B*"'0-J"A6"$22/-/'6"-'"E'55/*+"$1'0-"*(4%':(*6-"$62"45'1%*(+"

9*--/69".'0+*2"-.*:".$2"&'6&*56+"$1'0-"&5/(*>"$62"4*5&*/B*2"-.*"$5*$"-'"1*"/6"+'&/$%"$62"

*&'6'(/&"2*&%/6*J"

"

,+"/6"-.*"$&&'06-+"45*+*6-*2"$1'B*>"-.*+*":'069"E'(*6"0+*2"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"-'"($F*"

+*6+*"'7"&%$++"%'++"-.5'09."2/+&'05+*+"'6"/((/95$-/'6J"

"

N+f"d.$-"2'":'0"-./6F"$1'0-"(/95$-/'6"/6"-./+"$5*$i"A+"-.*5*"$"%'-i"rms">4C(f";$-*%:"/-Y+"1**6"9*--/69"E'5+*"N+f";/F*"E.$-i"d.$-Y+"E'5+*i"]%-'+f"#'5*"&0%-05*+"$5*"&'(/69"$62"-.*:Y5*"-$F/69"$%%"-.*"H'1+J";4&4(,94f"#'5*"R0++/$6+J"N+f"#'5*"E.$-i""]%-'+f"#'5*"R0++/$6+"$62";/-.0$6/$6+"$62"-.$-j"7'5*/96*5+J"rms"N+f"3/26Y-"/-"0+*2"-'"1*"%/F*"-.$-i">4C(f"U'J"]%-'+f"U'-"$+"1$2J";4&4(,94f"d.*6"(:"2$2"95*E"04"5'062".*5*"/-"E$+6Y-J"A-"0+*2"-'"1*"$%%"'6*J"A"2'6Y-"5*$%%:"(/62"10-"+'(*-/(*+"A"2'J"N+f"^*&$0+*"'7"E.$-i">4C(f"S5/(*".$+"9'6*"04J";4&4(,94f"Z*$.J"]%-'+f"S5/(*".$+"9'6*"04"$"%'-"r4$0+*sJ"K.$-Y+"%/F*"1':+"5'062".*5*"$6:E$:J"";4&4(,94f"U'm"Z*$.>"-.*5*Y+"$"4'%/&*"-./69"'6"1%$&F"&5/(*>"H0+-"'6"1%$&F"&5/(*"'6%:>"+'"/-"(0+-"1*"$77*&-/69J"

"

"

"

"

Page 76: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

Me"

"

#'%%:"$62"`:%/*"45'B/2*2"$"+/(/%$5"$6$%:+/+f""

"

N%11/f",6'-.*5"-./69"-.$-".$+"$66':*2"(*>"5/9.-J",+"A"+$/2>"A"9'-"F/&F*2"'0-"1:"(:"(0("$62"2$2"$62"$+"A"+$/2"A"$("%/B/69"/6"$"^k^J"8'(*'6*"&'(*+"'B*5"75'(";/-.0$6/$>"='%$62"m"A/1'+f"m"-.*:"9*-"$"7%$-"+-5$/9.-"$E$:J"N%11/f"m"$6:E.*5*J"K.*:"&'(*"'B*5"E/-."-.*/5"1%$&F"1$9+"$62"-.*:Y5*"/6"$"7%$-"E/-./6"-E'"E**F+J"d.:".$+"/-"-$F*6"(*"+'"%'69i"^*&$0+*"$%%"'7"-.*"4*'4%*"E.'"&'(*"'B*5"75'("-.*/5"&'06-5/*+"9*-"-.*"7%$-"$62"+-'4+"(*"75'("9*--/69"-.*"7%$-J",62"A"-./6F"-.*:"+.'0%2"45/'5/-/+*J"K.*"4*'4%*"-.$-"%/B*+"/6"-./+"&'06-5:>"-.*"4*'4%*"-.$-"$5*"1'56"/6"-./+"&'06-5:"+.'0%2"1*"45/'5/-/+*2"1*7'5*"-.*"4*'4%*"-.$-"&'(*"'B*5J"

"

K.5'09."-.*+*"$6$%:+*+"-.*":'069"E'(*6"-5$&*2"(*('5/*+"'7"%'++"$62"2*&%/6*>"$62"$+"E/-."

-.*"45*B/'0+"*C$(4%*+"45*+*6-*2"/6"-./+"&.$4-*5>"-.*:"2/2"+'"E/-."5*7*5*6&*"-'"-.*"7/905*"'7"-.*"

/((/95$6-J"8$($6-.$"($F*+"2/5*&-"5*7*5*6&*"-'"-./+"./+-'5/&$%%:"%$:*5*2"45$&-/&*J"K5$&/69"-.*"

(*('5/*+"'7".*5"7$-.*5>"+.*"+$:+f"ld.*6"(:"2$2"95*E"04"5'062".*5*"r&5/(*>"06*(4%':(*6-"

$62"/((/95$-/'6s"E$+6Y-"r+'"1$2sJ"A-"0+*2"-'"1*"$%%"'6*Jn"A6"-./+"E$:>"8$($6-.$"+.'E+".'E".*5"

7$-.*5Y+"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"'7"&%$++"%'++"$62"E./-*6*++"$5*"0+*2"-'"($F*"+*6+*"'7".*5"45*+*6-"

+/-0$-/'6J"

"

K.*":'069"E'(*6"$%+'"$&F6'E%*29*"+./7-/69"4$5$(*-*5+"'7"E./-*6*++J"#'%%:"$62"`:%/*"$5*"

&$5*70%"-'"2/+-/690/+."1*-E**6"-.'+*"-.$-"$5*"W1'56"/6"-./+"&'06-5:Y"$62"W4*'4%*"-.$-"&'(*"

'B*5YJ"A6"-./+"E$:>"-.*:"*C&%02*"-.*"/((/95$6-"E./%*"-.*:"$&F6'E%*29*"-.$-"6'+-$%9/$+"7'5"-.*"

X'%2*6"<5$"$5*"6'-"'6%:"$B$/%$1%*"-'"-.'+*"E/-."E./-*"+F/6J"_'E*B*5>"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"-.$-"-.*"

:'069"E'(*6"$&F6'E%*29*"-.*"(0-$1/%/-:"'7"E./-*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+>"E/-./6"$0-'&.-.'6'0+"

4$5$(*-*5+>"-.*:"$%+'"2*('6+-5$-*".'E"-.*+*"$5*"&'6+-5$/6*2"1:"'%2*5"7'5(+"'7"5$&/+(J"K.*/5"

%$59*%:"C*6'4.'1/&"6$55$-/B*+"&'6-$/6"-5$&*+"'7"'%2*5"5$&/$%"7'5($-/'6+J"K.*"45*B/'0+"+*&-/'6"

2/+&0++*2".'E"-.*"1'2:"'7"<2Y+"('-.*5"25*E"$--*6-/'6"-'"-.*"2/77*5*6-"*(1'2/*2"%'&$-/'6+"

75'("E./&."&%$/(+"-'"E./-*"(*('5:"E*5*"4'++/1%*J"8$($6-.$>"3$E6"$62")'+/*>"$1'B*>"$%+'"*62"

-.*/5"2/+&0++/'6"'7"%'++"$62"/((/95$-/'6"E/-."$"+-$-*(*6-"-.$-"-$F*+"-.*("1$&F"-'"-.*"$%/*6"

7/905*"'7"-.*":'069"1%$&F"($%*"$++'&/$-*2"E/-."4'+-QE$5"('5$%"4$6/&+"$62"+'&/$%"2*&$:"

G,%*C$62*5"!PPej"X/%5':"!PVMj"_$%%"*-"$%J"!PMVj"8'%'('+"!PVVj"$62"+**"S.$4-*5"]'05"'7"-./+"

-.*+/+IJ"

"

K.*+*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"E*5*"6*9'-/$-*2"$%'69+/2*"-.*":'069"E'(*6Y+"'E6"(/95$-'5:"

./+-'5/*+J"K.*:"E*5*"-.*"&./%25*6>"95$62&./%25*6"$62"95*$-Q95$62&./%25*6"'7"(/95$6-+J"A6"-./+"

Page 77: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

MM"

"

E$:>"-.*":'069"E'(*6"E*5*"4$5-"'7"$"2/$%'9/&"./+-'5:"'7"W1*&'(/69"E./-*Y"G^5'2F/6"!PPVj"

3061$5"!PPMj"A96$-/*B"?@@Pj"R'*2/9*5"?@@Mj"d5$:"?@@eIJ"A-"/+"6'-$1%*"-.$-"E./%*"-.*":'069"

E'(*6"E*5*"6*9'-/$-/69"W1*&'(/69"E./-*Y>"45*B/'0+"9*6*5$-/'6+"'7"-.*/5"'E6"7$(/%/*+"($:"6'-"

.$B*"1**6"E./-*"*6'09.J"K./+"+.'E+"-.*"4'E*570%"$%%/$6&*+"$62"$(1/90/-/*+"'7"5$&*"$62"

&0%-05*"/6"%'&$%"&'6+-50&-/'6+"'7"^5/-/+."6$-/'6$%/+("GX/%5':"!PVMIJ"K.*":'069"E'(*6"

$&F6'E%*29*2".'E"+'(*"(*(1*5+"'7"-.*/5"7$(/%/*+".$2"2/77*5*6-"&%$/(+"-.$6"-.*(+*%B*+"-'"

%'&$%"1*%'69/69J"#'%%:"*C4%$/6*2".'E".*5"('-.*5"E$+"X5**F"$62".'E"-.*:".$2"$"X5**F"06&%*"

%/B/69"E/-."-.*("E.'"2/26Y-"+4*$F"(0&."<69%/+.J"8.*"+$/2".*"E$+"l+'"X5**Fn".*"E$+"l1$+/&$%%:"

1%$&FnJ"8.*"(*$6-"-.$-"E./%*"+.*"E$+"E./-*"$62"1*%'69*2j".*5"06&%*"2/26Y-"1*&$0+*".*"E$+"6'-"

E./-*"'5"<69%/+."*6'09.J"A6"-./+"&$+*>"./+"2$5F*5"+F/6"$62"/6$1/%/-:"-'"+4*$F"<69%/+."2*6/*2"./("

$&&*++>"/6".*5"*:*+>"-'"U*E.$(Y+"4$+-J"_'E*B*5>"E./%*".*5"06&%*"($2*"&%*$5".*5"7$(/%:Y+"

&'6-*+-*2"$&&*++"-'"%'&$%"7'5(+"'7"E./-*"1*%'69/69>".*"2/2"6'-"+01B*5-".*5"'E6"&%$/(J"A6"7$&->"/-"

E$+"-.5'09."-.*"45*+*6&*"'7".*5"06&%*"-.$-"+.*"6*9'-/$-*2".*5"'E6"4%$&*"/6"U*E.$(Y+"./+-'5:J"

"

K./+"$5-/&0%$-/'6"'7"E./-*6*++"$%+'"*6$1%*2"#'%%:"-'"1%$(*"-.'+*"E.'"E*5*"6'-"E./-*"*6'09."

7'5"-.*"*&'6'(/&"$62"+'&/$%".$52+./4+"+.*"2*$%-"E/-.J"d./-*6*++"$62"X5**F6*++>"/6"-./+"+*6+*>"

.$2"$"B*5:"2/77*5*6-"(*$6/69"75'("-.*"F/62+"'7"*-.6/&"/2*6-/-:"('1/%/+*2"1:"-.*"(/22%*Q&%$++"

&./%25*6"2/+&0++*2"1:"R*$:"*-"$%J"G?@@MI"E.*6"-.*:"2*+&5/1*".'E"-.*+*"&./%25*6"&$6"0+*"

(/6'5/-:"*-.6/&"/2*6-/-/*+"$+"+'&/$%"&$4/-$%J"_'E*B*5>"X5**F6*++"E$+"6'-"$B$/%$1%*"-'"#'%%:"$+"$"

7'5("'7"(0%-/&0%-05$%"&$4/-$%j"5$-.*5>"/-"E$+"E./-*6*++"-.$-"45'B/2*2".*5"E/-."('1/%/-:J"K./+"E$+"

$"+*%7Q&'6+&/'0+"E./-*6*++"5$-.*5"-.$6"(/22%*Q&%$++"E./-*"1%/626*++J"K.5'09."'B*5%$:/69"

+-50&-05$%"2/+$2B$6-$9*"E/-."/((/95$-/'6>"$62"4.*6'-:4/&$%"5$&/+("E/-."C*6'4.'1/&"*C&%0+/'6>"

-.*":'069"E'(*6"W1*&$(*"E./-*YJ"A6"-./+"E$:>"-.*:"5*(*(1*5*2"4$+-+"6'-"$B$/%$1%*"-'"-.*/5"

4$5*6-+"$62"95$624$5*6-+J"K./+"7'5("'7"(*('5:"45$&-/&*"($2*"+*6+*"'7"1*/69"E'5F/69Q&%$++"/6"

$"+04*5Q2/B*5+*"4%$&*J"A-"$%+'"($2*"+*6+*"1*&$0+*>"6'-"/6"+4/-*"'7>"-.*":'069"E'(*6Y+"(/95$6-"

1$&F95'062+J"

"

Z'069"4*'4%*"$%+'"-5$&*2"./+-'5/*+"'7"E./-*"%*9/-/($&:"-.5'09."-.*"+4$-/$%"45$&-/&*+"'7"

lF**4/69"-'":'05"'E6n>"l/96'5/69"-.*"7'5*/96*5+n"$62"-.5'09."$"7'5("'7"+-5**-"*-/h0*--*"&$%%*2"

W5*+4*&-YJ"T6"-.*"1$+/+"'7"-.*/5"/($9/6*2"./+-'5/&"&'66*&-/'6"-'"-.*"$5*$>"`:%/*"$62"#'%%:"7*%-"

-.$-"-.*:"E*5*"20*"5*+4*&-J"R*+4*&-"&'0%2"1*"95$6-*2"1:"-.*("1*&$0+*"'7"-.*/5"('5*"

%*9/-/($-*"./+-'5/&"&%$/("-'"-.*"-*55/-'5:J"A7"-.*:"E*5*"95$6-*2"5*+4*&->"-.*:"E'0%2"9/B*"5*+4*&-"

1$&FJ"K./+"($+&0%/6/+*2"+4$-/$%"$62"(*('5:"45$&-/&*"G+/(/%$5"45$&-/&*+"$5*"2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"

Page 78: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

MV"

"

K.5**I"*C-*62*2"-'"5*+4*&-"7'5"-.*"&'06-5:J"A6"-./+"E$:>"-.*":'069"E'(*6"&'6+-50&-*2"-.*/5"

-.5*$-*6*2"+*6+*"'7"*6-/-%*(*6->"6'-"1:"+**F/69"-'"*(4$-./+*"E/-."'-.*5"4*'4%*"

2/+*675$6&./+*2"1:"9%'1$%"&$4/-$%/+("10-"1:"&'675'6-/69"-.*/5"4.:+/&$%"45*+*6&*"'6"-.*"+-5**-"

G8*/2%*5"?@@e>"4J!@NIJ"

"

,+"$"($5F"'7"-.*"1$51$5/-:"'7"6*E"/((/95$6-+>"`:%/*"$62"#'%%:"*C4%$/6*2"-'"(*".'E"-.*:"'6&*"

.$2"-'"2*7*62"-E'"'%2"4*'4%*"$9$/6+-";/-.0$6/$6+"E.'"E*5*"1*/69"502*"-'"-.*(J"K./+"$&-"E$+"$"

2*7*6&*"'7"%'&$%"$62"6$-/'6$%"-*55/-'5:"$9$/6+-"$6"$%/*6"/6B$+/'6J"K.*"W'%2"4*'4%*Y"+:(1'%/+*2"

-.*"4*5&*/B*2"B0%6*5$1/%/-:"'7"-.*"$0-'&.-.'6'0+"&'((06/-:"-'"/((/95$6-+J",+"&$4-05*2"/6"-.*"

&.**F"'7";/-.0$6/$6"E'(*6"GE.'"2/2"6'-"*B*6".$B*"-.*"2*7*5*6&*"-'"+4*$F"<69%/+."$5'062"

-.*(I"/-"E$+"$%+'"$"5*H*&-/'6"'7"(0%-/&0%-05$%"4'%/&/*+"-.$-".$2"9/B*6"5/9.-+"-'"/((/95$6-+"'B*5"

6$-/B*+J"

"

A/1'+f"A".$2"$"7/9.-"E/-."-E'";/-.0$6/$6"E'(*6J"K.*:"E$+"1*/69"5*$%%:"$10+/B*"-'"'%2"4*'4%*"E$%F/69"2'E6"-.*"+-5**-J",62"+**"E/-."(*"$62"$%%"(:"($-*+>"E*"2'6Y-"$%%'E"-.$-J"K.$-Y+"2/+5*+4*&-70%"-'"-.*"'%2"4*'4%*J"8'"E*"7'%%'E*2"-.*(>"6'-"+-$5-/69"$6"$590(*6-J"d*"7'%%'E*2J"d*Y5*"%/F*>"W:'0"9'/69"-'"9'"1$&F"$62"+$:"+'55:"-'"-.*("'5"E*Y5*"9'/69"-'"($F*":'0"9'"1$&FYJ"K.*:Y5*"%/F*"W-./+"/+"<69%$62>":'0"+.'0%2"+$:"+'55:"-'"0+YJ"K.*:"%/F*"-$%F/69"$1'0-"0+"/6"-.*/5"%$690$9*J"

"

A6"&'6&%0+/'6>"-.*+*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"+.'E*2".'E"E./-*6*++"E$+"-5$&*2"5$-.*5"-.$6"

4*5($6*6-J"K.*"'4*66*++"'7"-5$&/69"(*$6-"-.$-"E./-*6*++"$62"/-+"$++'&/$-/'6"E/-."6$-/'6$%"

&0%-05*"E$+"('1/%/+*2"1:":'069"4*'4%*"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+"'7"2/77*5*6-"(/95$-'5:"-5$H*&-'5/*+J"

K./+"2/2"6'-"(*$6"-.$-"E./-*>"1%$&F>"X5**F>"R'($6:"$62",+/$6"4*'4%*"45$&-/+*2"(*('5/*+"'7"

1*%'69/69"/6"-.*"+$(*"E$:>"'5"-.$-"C*6'4.'1/$"$62"4.*6'-:4/&$%"*C&%0+/'6"2/+$44*$5*2J"

R$-.*5"/-"+.'E*2".'E"6$-/'6$%>"&0%-05$%"$62"5$&/$%"/2*$+"'7"$0-'&.-.'6:"E*5*"'B*5%$/2"$62"

/6-*54*6*-5$-*2J"^0/%-"$-"6$-/'6$%"$62"%'&$%"%*B*%+>"-.*+*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"5*7*5*6&*2"6$-/'6$%"

2/+&'05+*+"'6"-.*"<$+-"<62>"-.*"2*$-."'7"(0%-/&0%-05$%/+(>"-.*"4%/9.-"'7"-.*"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"

$62"-.*"8-"X*'59*"S5'++>"10-"-.*:"$%+'"$--*62*2"-'"%'&$%"6$55$-/B*+"'7"&%$++"%'++>"/((/95$-/'6>"

2/+%'&$-/'6"$62"4'+-Q/620+-5/$%"2*&%/6*J"

Page 79: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

MP"

"

=$5-"KE'"g"3/$+4'5$"(6*('6/&+"

K.*"7'59'--*6"(*('5/*+"'7"2/$+4'5$"+4$&*"

#*('5:"45$&-/&*+"'7"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"E*5*"'6%:"4$5-"'7"U*E.$(Y+"2/$+4'5$"(6*('6/&+>"

.'E*B*5J"d.*5*$+"4$5-"'6*".$+"*C4%'5*2".'E"E./-*6*++"E$+"-5$&*2"$62"%'++"&'2*2"-.5'09."

/((/95$-/'6>"4$5-"-E'"*C4%'5*+"(*('5/*+"-.$-"$5*"W7'59'--*6Y"GS'66*5-'6"?@@PI"'5"+/%*6&*2"

G^$F.-/6"!PVe1j"U/*-a+&.*"!PVOI"E.*6"T0-*5"<$+-";'62'6"/+"5*(*(1*5*2"$+"E./-*J"A-"2/+&0++*+"

.'E":'069"4*'4%*"+.$5*2"2/$+4'5$"(*('5/*+>".'E"-.*:"6*9'-/$-*2"2/77*5*6-"(*('5/*+"'7"

W.'(*Y"$62"2/+4*5+$%>"$62".'E"-.*:"4$5-/&/4$-*2"/6"$&-+"'7"5*(*(1*5/69"-.$-"*C/+-*2"1*:'62"

*-.6/&"$62"6$-/'6$%"7'5(+"'7"+'%/2$5/-:J"^0/%-"-.5'09."!N@":*$5+"'7"&'6+-$6-"(/95$-/'6"$62"

('B*(*6->"(*('5/*+"'7"E./-*"1*%'69/69"/6"U*E.$("/6-*5$&-*2"E/-."(*('5/*+"'7"60(*5'0+"

'-.*5"9%'1$%"W.'(*+YJ"K./+"7/5+-"+*&-/'6"'7"4$5-"-E'"*C4%'5*+".'E"'-.*5"6$-/'6$%"(*('5/*+"E*5*"

-5$&*2>"6*9'-/$-*2"$62"%$/2"2'E6"$%'69+/2*"-.*"(:-.+"'7"E./-*"4$+-+J"

"

K.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01Y+"+04*5Q2/B*5+*"2*('95$4./&+"45'B/2*2"$"2/77*5*6-"/6+/9.-"/6-'"-.*"

2/$+4'5$"(6*('6/&+"'7"U*E.$(J"d.*5*$+";*:.$(".$2"$"%$59*"E./-*"4'40%$-/'6>"-.*",7-*5"

8&.''%"&%01"E$+"4'40%$-*2"1:":'069"4*'4%*"E/-."<$+-*56"<05'4*$6j",75/&$6j"$62"S*6-5$%>"

8'0-."$62"8'0-.Q<$+-",+/$6"5*709**"$62"(/95$6-"1$&F95'062+>"/6"$22/-/'6"-'"1%$&F>",+/$6"$62"

E./-*":'069"4*'4%*"E/-."%'69*5"7$(/%:"./+-'5/*+"/6"-.*"$5*$J"K.*"'B*5%$:/69"$62"/6-*5+*&-/'6"'7"

(*('5/*+"'7"2/77*5*6-".'(*+"/6"-./+"+4$&*"25*E"$--*6-/'6"-'"-.*"7'5(+"'7"(*('5:"45$&-/&*"

./22*6"1:"6$55$-/B*+"'7"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++J"

"

8*5*6$"E$+"$1'0-"7'05-**6":*$5+"'%2"$62".$2"5*&*6-%:"$55/B*2"/6"-.*"1'5'09."75'("='5-09$%J"A"

E'5F*2"E/-.".*5"/6"-.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01J"8.*"2/26Y-"+4*$F"<69%/+."E*%%"10-"E.$-"+.*"&'0%26Y-"

$5-/&0%$-*"+.*"($2*"04"7'5"E/-."1'2/%:"4*57'5($6&*J"8.*"/6-*5$&-*2"E*%%"E/-."-.*"'-.*5":'069"

4*'4%*>"($6:"'7"E.'(".$2"+/(/%$5"*C4*5/*6&*+"'7"2/+%'&$-/'6>"$62"(0&."'7".*5"-/(*"E$+"+4*6-"

-$06-/69"-.*":'069"(*6"$62"4%$:/69"45$&-/&$%"H'F*+J"_'E*B*5>"+.*"$%+'"($2*"7$/5%:"75*h0*6-"

5*7*5*6&*"-'".*5"(*('5:"'7"='5-09$%J"A6"-./+"E$:>"8*5*6$"15'09.-"$6'-.*5"4.$6-$+("'7"W.'(*Y"

$62"1*%'69/69"/6-'"U*E.$(Y+"2/$+4'5$"(*('5:"+4$&*J"

"

T6*"*B*6/69>"$+"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"%*$B/69"-.*":'0-."&%01>"8*5*6$"2*&/2*2"-'"($F*"$6"

/6-*5B*6-/'6"$62"+.$5*"$"-$+-*"'7"='5-09$%"E/-."-.*"2*4$5-/69"&5'E2J"]5'("-.*"&'(40-*5"

-*5(/6$%"/6"-.*"$2H$&*6-"5''("&'0%2"1*".*$52"-.*"1%$5/69"+'062"'7"='5-090*+*"4'4>"&%'+*%:"

Page 80: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

V@"

"

7'%%'E*2"1:"8*5*6$>"E.'"&$(*"5066/69"-'E$52+"-.*"2*4$5-/69":'069"4*'4%*J"_*5"$/("E$+"-'"

+/(0%-$6*'0+%:"25$E"$--*6-/'6"-'"-.*"(0+/&>"/-+"5*%$-/'6"-'".*5"1'2:"$62"-'"2/+504-"$6"'52*5%:"

*C/-"75'("-.*"&%01J"T6"$%%"&'06-+".*5"+0&&*++"E$+"%/(/-*2J"]/5+->"+.*"E$+"+'"'7-*6"2/+504-/B*"-.$-"

-.*":'069"4*'4%*"/96'5*2".*5"45'B'&$-/'6J"8*&'62>"E./%*"/-"E$+"/(4'5-$6-"7'5".*5>".$B/69"H0+-"

$55/B*2"/6"-.*"$5*$>"-.*"4*57'5($6&*"'7"W.'(*Y"$%+'"2/26Y-"*%/&/-"(0&."/6-*5*+-J";'-+"'7"-.*"

:'069"4*'4%*"$-"-.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01"45$&-/+*2"(*('5/*+"'7"2/77*5*6-"W.'(*+Y"$62"-.*5*7'5*"

-.*"&'6-*6-"'7"8*5*6$Y+"$&-/'6+"E$+"506Q'7Q-.*Q(/%%"5$-.*5"-.$6"+.'&F/69J"A-"+**(*2"-.$-"

8*5*6$".$26Y-"1**6"/6"-.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01"%'69"*6'09."-'"5*$%/+*"-.$-".*5"&%$/("-'"2/77*5*6&*"

E$+"'6*"'7"($6:J",7-*5"-.*"&5'E2".$2"%*7-"A"+4'F*"-'"8*5*6$>"7**%/69"+.*"6**2*2"+'(*"

B$%/2$-/'6"7'5"E.$-"+.*".$2"2'6*J"A"$+F*2"/7"+.*"E$+"='5-090*+*J"8.*"+$/2"-.$-"+.*"E$+>"$62"

-'%2"(*"45'02%:"-.$-"1*&$0+*"+.*"E$+>"+.*"$%E$:+"%/+-*6*2"-'"='5-090*+*"(0+/&J"

"

8*5*6$Y+"(*('5/*+"'7".'(*"E*5*"H0+-"'6*"'7"$"60(1*5"4%$:*2"/6"-.*"1$&F95'062"'7"-.*",7-*5"

8&.''%"S%01J"A4&#414!*'4!G%54!G%54"'77*5*2"+.'-+"'7"-.*"[9$62$6"&$4/-$%"&/-:"75'("$"

('-'51/F*J")'.6"E$-&.*2"/-"/6-*6-%:"'6"Z'0K01*J"A-"E$+"$"&'66*&-/'6"-'"$".'(*".*".$2"%/B*2"

/6>"'5"($:1*"'6*"./+"4$5*6-+".$2"-'%2"./("$1'0-J"d.*5*$+"8*5*6$".$2"0+*2"+'062"$62".*5"

1'2:"-'"15/69".*5".'(*"-'"-.*":'0-."&%01>")'.6"E$+"0+/69"+4$&*"$62"%/9.-"-'"/%%0(/6$-*"$"

&'56*5"'7"-.*"&'(40-*5"5''(J"_/+"75/*62+"'&&$+/'6$%%:"9%$6&*2"'B*5"10-"E*5*"('5*"/6-*5*+-*2"

/6"E'5F/69"'0-"%:5/&+"-'"$6"/6+-50(*6-$%"-.$-".$2"1**6"4%$&*2"'6"X5/(*]'50(Y+"'6%/6*"4'5-$%J"

)'.6"&'6-/60*2"E$-&./69"-.*"+-5**-"+&*6*+"$62"45'B/2/69"$(1/*6-"%/9.-/69"7'5"-.*":'0-."&%01Y+"

2/$+4'5$"(*('5:+&$4*J"

"

A6"-./+"E$:>"(*('5/*+"'7".'(*"$-"-.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01"E*5*"1$6$%"10-"/6"'-.*5"4%$&*+"-.*:"

5*h0/5*2"$"('5*"&'6+&/'0+"6*9'-/$-/'6J"]5*22:"E$+"$1'0-"+*B*6-**6"$62".$2"5*&*6-%:"%*7-"

+&.''%"$62"+-$5-*2"$"&'%%*9*"&'05+*"/6"&'6+-50&-/'6J"_*".$2"1**6"1'56"/6"U*E.$("-'"

S'%'(1/$6"4$5*6-+"$62"$--*62*2";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01J"]5*22:"-$%F*2"-'"(*"$1'0-".'%/2$:+"/6"

S'%'(1/$>"'7"-.*"S'%'(1/$6"7''2".*"$-*"$-".'(*>"$62"'7"-.*"S$-.'%/&"5*%/9/'6".*"45$&-/+*2J"

K.*+*"E*5*"$%%"(*$6+"'7"-5$&/69"%/6F+"1*-E**6"S'%'(1/$"GE.*5*".*".$2"6*B*5"%/B*2I"$62"E.*5*"

.*"E$+"4,@"d*".$2"$"9''2"5*%$-/'6+./4"$62"E./%*".*"2/26Y-"-$%F"$1'0-"-.*+*"+01H*&-+"E/-."./+"

75/*62+>".*"+.$5*2"-.*("E/-."(*J"]5*22:"F6*E"A".$2"%/B*2"/6";$-/6",(*5/&$"$62"+4'F*"84$6/+.>"

10-"($:1*"A"E$+"$%+'"+077/&/*6-%:"+-5$69*"-'";*:.$("-'"+099*+-"'4*66*++"-'"./+"+-'5/*+J"]5*22:"

-'%2"(*"./+"75/*62+"E*5*"l$%%"75'(".*5*n"G.*"(*$6-"E./-*>"<69%/+."$62"75'("U*E.$(I"$62"

06/6-*5*+-*2"/6"./+"+-'5/*+J"_*"E$+"$+"E./-*"+F/66*2"$+"-.*:"E*5*>".*".$2"1**6"1'56"/6"

Page 81: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

V!"

"

U*E.$("%/F*"-.*(>".*"$%+'"+.$5*2"$"./+-'5:"'7"2/+%'&$-/'6>"10-"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*".*"7*%-"

*C&%02*2"75'("-.*/5"('5*"$0-'&.-.'6'0+"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+J"

"

;/F*"]5*22:>"<625/-"$%+'"0+*2"./+"6$-/'6$%"6'+-$%9/$+"-'"5*7%*&-"04'6"./+"4'+/-/'6"/6"U*E.$(Y+"

./*5$5&./*+"'7"1*%'69/69J"<625/-"E$+"!\":*$5+"'%2"$62"A"9'-"-'"F6'E"./("-.5'09."-.*",%1$6/$6"

Z'0-."X5'04J"_*"5*&$%%*2".'E"*B*5:":*$5".*"$62"./+"7$(/%:"25'B*"-'",%1$6/$"7'5"-.*/5"+0((*5"

.'%/2$:+"g"$"7$/5%:"&'(('6"H'056*:"$('69"-.*",%1$6/$6Q+4*$F/69"7$(/%/*+"A"F6*EJ"K.*"H'056*:"

-''F"<625/-"75'("<69%$62>"-.5'09."]5$6&*"$62"/6-'"S*6-5$%"<05'4*J"<625/-"0+*2"-.*"H'056*:"$+"$"

(*$6+"'7"&'((06/&$-/69"./+"'E6"+-'5:"'7"2/+4*5+$%"$62"(/95$-/'6J"d./%*"2*+&5/1/69"-.*"

H'056*:>".*"-'%2"(*"$1'0-"-.*"+(*%%"'7"-.*"&'06-5/*+".*"4$++*2"-.5'09.J"_*"-.'09.-"-.$-"

]5$6&*"+-$6F>"*+4*&/$%%:"=$5/+>"$62".*"-.'09.-"-.$-";'62'6"+(*%%*2"1$2"-''J"_*".*%2"-./+"/6"

&'6-5$+-"-'"-.*"75*+."$/5"$62"405*"E$-*5"'7",%1$6/$J"A6"+.$5/69"./+"(*('5/*+"'7".'(*"$62"/6"

5*-5$&/69"-.*"5'0-*"-.$-".$2"'5/9/6$%%:"15'09.-"./("-'"-.*"[`"$+"$"5*709**>"<625/-"&'6+-50&-*2"

,%1$6/$"$+"$"95**6"$62"405*"4$+-"-.$-"*C/+-*2"/6"&'6-5$+-"-'"-.*"'B*52*B*%'4*2"E*+-*56"

<05'4*$6"(*-5'4'%/+*+J"_'E*B*5>"-./+"E$+"6'-"'6%:"$"B*5/7/&$-/'6"'7"6'+-$%9/&"405/-:>"*++*6&*>"

$62"+01+*h0*6-"2/+4*5+$%"$62"%'++>"10-"$%+'"$"(*$6+"'7"$225*++/69"$"./+-'5:"'7"<05'4*$6"

&/B/%/+$-/'6".*"7*%-"*C&%02*2"75'(J"^:"5*(*(1*5/69",%1$6/$"$+"$"95**6"$62"405*"%$62".*"E$+"

&'675'6-/69"-.*"E/2*%:".*%2"+-*5*'-:4*+"'7",%1$6/$>"$62",%1$6/$6+>"$+"1$&FE$52"G`/69"*-"$%J"

?@@OIJ"^:"5'($6-/&/+/69",%1$6/$6Y+"6$-05*"$62"405/-:>"<625/-"E$+"&'675'6-/69"./+"'E6"

*(1'2/*2"*C/+-*6&*"/6"$"2/+&05+/B*"7/*%2"'7"E*+-*56"45'95*++"$62"*$+-*56"+-$96$-/'6J"<625/-Y+"

+-'5:"'7"./+"H'056*:".'(*>"-.*6>"45'B/2*2"$"B*./&%*"-.5'09."E./&.".*"-5$&*2"$62"6*9'-/$-*2"./+"

'E6"1*%'69/69"/6"U*E.$(J"

"

<B$Y+"45'H*&-/'6"'7"+'&/$%"('1/%/-:"G2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"]/B*I"'4*6*2"04"4'++/1/%/-/*+"7'5"

(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"06$B$/%$1%*"-'"]5*22:"$62"<625/-J"_'E*B*5>"-.*+*"+-/%%"6**2*2"-'"1*"

6*9'-/$-*2"$%'69+/2*"-.*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"'7".*5"('-.*5J"<B$"E$+"7'05-**6":*$5+"'%2"$62"E$+"

1*&'(/69"/62*4*62*6-"75'(".*5"('-.*5J"A"$%+'"E'5F*2"E/-.".*5"'6"4.'-'95$4.:"$62"(*2/$"

45'H*&-+"$-"-.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."=5'H*&-J"_*5"('-.*5"E$+"'6*"'7"-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+>"$62"'B*5"

-/(*"A"9'-"-'"F6'E"1'-."'7"-.*("h0/-*"E*%%J"<B$Y+"/6&5*$+/69"$++*5-/'6+"'7"/62*4*62*6&*".$2"

($2*".*5"('-.*5"E'55:"-.$-"-.*:"E*5*"1*&'(/69"*+-5$69*2J"A6"$6"$--*(4-"-'"&5*$-*"*(4$-.:"

E/-."<B$".*5"('-.*5".$2"$++05*2".*5"-.$-"+.*"5*(*(1*5*2"E.$-"-'"E$+"%/F*"-'"1*"7'05-**6J"

<B$"+*-".*5"+-5$/9.->"-*%%/69".*5"/-"E$+"l$6&/*6-"./+-'5:nJ"_*5"('-.*5Y+"(*('5/*+"'7"-.*"4$+->"

1$+*2"'6"E.$-"<B$"&'6+/2*5*2"-'"1*"$"&'6+*5B$-/B*"0415/69/69"/6"6'5-.*56",%1$6/$>"E*5*"'7"

Page 82: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

V?"

"

%/(/-*2"5*%*B$6&*"-'"<B$Y+"%/7*J"<B$".$2"1**6"1'56"/6"U*E.$("$62"+.$5*2"E/-.".*5"75/*62+"-.*"

2*+/5*"7'5"95*$-*5"/62*4*62*6&*"45'(/+*2"-'"$+4/5$-/'6$%":'069"E'(*6J"<B$Y+"('-.*5"

+'(*-/(*+"$+F*2"(*"7'5"(:"-$F*"'6"-.*"5*%$-/'6+./4"1*-E**6".*5"$62".*5"2$09.-*5J"A"-./6F"

+.*"-.'09.->"$+"+'(*'6*"E.'".$2"95'E6"04"/6"-.*"[`>"A"(/9.-"1*"$1%*"-'"+.*2"+'(*"%/9.-"'6"

<B$Y+"*C4*5/*6&*J"<B$>".'E*B*5>"2*('6+-5$-*2"6'"('5*"$77/6/-:"E/-."(:"&./%2.''2"-.$6"+.*"

2/2"E/-.".*5"('-.*5Y+J"d*"E*5*"$%%"'7"2/77*5*6-"-/(*+"$62"+4$&*+J"<B$"&'0%2"6'-"-$F*"'6".*5"

('-.*5Y+"(*('5/*+"'5"(/6*"1*&$0+*"-.*:"E*5*"($2*"/6"$6'-.*5"-/(*"$62"+4$&*"g"'6*"-.$-"2/2"

6'-"70%%:"($F*"+*6+*"'7"<B$Y+"45*+*6-"'5"70-05*J"

"

_'E*B*5>"E./%*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"'7-*6"5*7*5*6&*2"6$-/'6$%"6'+-$%9/$+"-.*:"$%+'"('B*2"

1*:'62"-.*"6$-/'6$%>"$62"*-.6/&"1'062$5/*+"&*$+*2"-'"1*"2*-*5(/6/69J"^*+/$6"E$+"+*B*6-**6"

:*$5+"'%2"$62"$%+'"E'5F*2"E/-."<B$>".*5"75/*62+"$62"(*"'6"4.'-'95$4.:"$62"(*2/$"45'H*&-+"$-"

-.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."=5'H*&-J"^*+/$6".$2"1**6"1'56"/6",%1$6/$"$62".$2"$55/B*2"$+"$"5*709**"/6"

U*E.$("E.*6".*"E$+"$":'069"&./%2J"_*"$62"./+"('-.*5".$2"1*&'(*"4$5-"'7"-.*",%1$6/$6"

Z'0-."=5'H*&-"$62"/6"-./+"*6B/5'6(*6-".*".$2"1**6"15'09.-"04"E/-."<B$"$62".*5"-E'"1*+-"

75/*62+",%($"$62"^*+$J"K.*:"E*5*"-.5**":*$5+"./+"H06/'5J",+"(*6-/'6*2"/6"S.$4-*5"T6*>"E*"

E'5F*2"'6"$"45'H*&-"&$%%*2"^9+3+!L!8'*+2!^94,!L!^4(,J"]'5"-./+"45'H*&-"<B$>"^*+$"$62",%($"

/6-*5B/*E*2"5*+/2*6-+"/6"-.*"%'&$%"$5*$>"-$F/69"4.'-'+>"B/2*'"7''-$9*"$62"5*&'52/69"+'062+J",-"

-.*"*62"'7"-.*"45'H*&-"^*+/$6"&0-"-.*"7''-$9*"-'9*-.*5"/6-'"$"B/2*'J",+"4$5-"'7"-./+"*2/-/69>".*"

+*%*&-*2"$"+'062-5$&F"-.$-"4%$:*2"205/69"-.*"/6-*5%02*+"1*-E**6"-.*"/6-*5B/*E+J"K.*"-5$&F+"

^*+/$6"4/&F*2"E*5*f"8*$6"=$0%"g";%!E'(+"G?@@PI>"U'/a:"g"69!N/"G?@!@I>"^5/&F"$62";$&*"g"G45!,%!

>'!G%(+"G?@@PI>"$62"X/99+"g"<41='()!,9+!B435+-,"G?@@PIJ"K.*"-5$&F+"E*5*"$"(/C-05*"'7"RY6Y^>"

5*99$*"$62"./4".'4J"8*$6"=$0%"$62"^5/&F"$62";$&*"$5*")$($/&$6"$5-/+-+>"X/99+"/+"$"^5/-/+."$5-/+-"

75'("=*&F.$(>"8'0-.";'62'6J"U'/a:"/+"$6",%1$6/$6"./4".'4"$5-/+-"E.'".$2"%/B*2"/6"d''%E/&.>"

+'0-.Q*$+-";'62'6>"7'5"$"60(1*5"'7":*$5+"1*7'5*"5*-056/69"-'",%1$6/$J"_/+"(0+/&"/+"E*%%"F6'E6"

/6",%1$6/$>"$62"$('69"-.*",%1$6/$6"2/$+4'5$"/6"-.*"[`>"10-"/+"6'-"F6'E6"/6"-.*"[`"

($/6+-5*$(J"^*+/$6".$2"&.'+*6"-.*"-5$&F+"-'"/(45*++"<B$>"^*+$"$62",%($"10-"-.*:"$%+'"

706&-/'6*2"$+"$"7'5("'7"2/$+4'5/&"(*('5:"45$&-/&*"GX/%5':"!PPOI"$62"$"6*9'-/$-/'6"'7"%'&$%"

1*%'69/69J"

"

,+/2*"75'("U'/a:Y+"69!N/>"-.*"-5$&F+"+*%*&-*2"1:"^*+/$6"(/9.-".$B*"1**6"7'062"'6"$6:"

60(1*5"'7":'069"4*'4%*Y+"('1/%*"4.'6*+J"K.*"-*(4-$-/'6"-.*6"/+"-'"7'&0+"'6"U'/a:"$+"^*+/$6Y+"

5*7*5*6-"7'5"$"./+-'5:"'7"2/+4*5+$%"$62"$"(*$6+"-.5'09."E./&.".*"-5$&*+"$"(*('5:"'7".'(*J"

Page 83: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

VO"

"

d.*6".*"45*(/*5*2"-.*"B/2*'>".'E*B*5>"^*+/$6"2/2"6'-"9/B*"45*&*2*6&*"-'"U'/a:J"d./%*"

^*+/$6"5*%$-*2"-'"U'/a:"4$5-%:"1*&$0+*".*"E$+"$%+'"$6",%1$6/$6"$62"%/B*2"/6";'62'6>"./+"

+/96/7/&$-/'6"'7"2/+4*5+$%"E$+"4%$:*2"$%'69+/2*"-.*"'-.*5"-5$&F+>"$%%"E/-."-.*/5"'E6"2/$+4'5$"

./+-'5/*+J"A6"-./+"E$:>"^*+/$6Y+"&'(4/%$-/'6"'7"(*('5/*+"E$+"6'-"E.'%%:"&'6-$/6*2"1:"6$-/'6$%"

6'+-$%9/$+j"5$-.*5"-.*:"E*5*"/6"2/$%'90*"E/-."'-.*5"-5$2/-/'6+"$62"'-.*5"4$+-+"-.$-"*C/+-*2"/6"

U*E.$(Y+"2/$+4'5$"+4$&*"G2/+&0++*2"705-.*5"/6"S.$4-*5"]'05IJ"K.*":'069"E'(*6"*C45*++*2"

-.*/5"$445*&/$-/'6"'7"^*+/$6Y+"(0+/&"&.'/&*"$62>"/6"+'"2'/69>"%*-"/-"1*"F6'E6"-.$-"-./+"&'%%*&-/'6"

'7"2/+4*5+$%+>"-5$2/-/'6+"$62"(*('5/*+"($2*"+*6+*"-'"-.*("-''J"

"

K.*"B/96*--*+"$1'B*"+.'E".'E"(*('5/*+"'7"2/$+4'5/&".'(*+"E*5*"-5$&*2"$62"6*9'-/$-*2"

-.5'09."1'2/*+"$62"+4$&*+"/6"&'%%*&-/B*"*6B/5'6(*6-+J"K.*:".$B*"+.'E6".'E"/6"+'(*"4%$&*+"

2/$+4'5$"(6*('6/&+"E*5*"1$6$%"$62"$(1/*6-"E.*5*$+"/6"'-.*5+"-.*:"6**2*2"-'"1*"6*9'-/$-*2"

$%'69+/2*"&'(4*-/69"./+-'5/*+"$62"4$+-+J"^*+/$6Y+"B/2*'"($F*+"&%*$5".'E"-5$2/-/'6+"'7"2/+4*5+$%"

&$(*"-'9*-.*5"$62"+:6&5*-/+*2"E/-."'-.*5"4$+-+"&'6-$/6*2"/6"2/$+4'5/&"&0%-05$%"7%'E+J"

3/$+4'5$"+'%/2$5/-/*+>"%/B/69"7'5"'-.*5+"$62"4'+-Q6$-/'6$%"(6*('6/&+"

)0+-".$+"-.*"6$-/'6$%"&'6-$/6*5+"7'5"(*('5:"E*5*"15'F*6"2'E6"-.5'09."^*+/$6Y+"4%$:%/+-"-.*:"

E*5*"$%+'"&.$%%*69*2"$62"2*&'6+-50&-*2"-.5'09."7'5(+"'7"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"10/%-"'6"2/$+4'5$"

+'%/2$5/-/*+f"%/B/69"7'5"'-.*5+"$62"4'+-Q6$-/'6$%"(6*('6/&+J"

"

K.*"4'++/1/%/-:"7'5"2/$+4'5$"+'%/2$5/-/*+"7/5+-"1*&$(*"$44$5*6-"-'"(*"E./%*"A"E$+"E'5F/69"$-"

;*:.$("Z'0-."S%01J"`*B/6"E$+"$"-./5-**6Q:*$5Q'%2":'069"4*5+'6"$-";*:.$("E.'".$2"^$51$2/$6"

$62"A5/+."95$624$5*6-+J"_*"%/B*2"&%'+*"-'"-.*":'0-."&%01"$62"$--*62*2"-.*"+*++/'6+"E.*6".*"

2/26Y-".$B*".'(*E'5F"-'"2'J"_*"E$+"F**6"-'".*%4"(*"E/-."(:"5*+*$5&."$62"/6"$6"/6-*5B/*E"A"

$+F*2"./("$1'0-"(/95$-/'6"/6"U*E.$(J"`*B/6Y+"5*+4'6+*"-'"(:"h0*+-/'6"&.$%%*69*2"

$0-'&.-.'6:"'6"-.*"1$+/+"'7"./+"(*('5:"'7"4$+-"('B*(*6-"$62"./+"45'H*&-/'6"'7"70-05*"-5$B*%J"

A+*'(f"Z*$.>"-.*5*"/+"h0/-*"$"%'->";/-.0$6/$6+J"K.*5*"/+"6'-./69"E5'69"E/-."-.$-J"A-Y+"H0+->"A".$-*"/-"E.*6"4*'4%*"+$:"W:'0"(0+-"+4*$F"-.*"%$690$9*"/7":'0"&'(*"/6-'"-./+"&'06-5:YJ"A"-./6F"/-Y+"B*5:"502*J",62"+'(*"4*'4%*"+$:"/6"(:"84$6/+."&%$++>"/6"84$6/+.>"WA"2'6Y-"%/F*"-*55'5/+-+"&'+"-.*:"$5*"-$F/69"04"$%%"-.*"+4$&*"$62"H'1+J"A"-.'09.-"W.'E"&$6":'0"+$:"-.$-Y":'0"2'6Y-"F6'E"E.$-"-.*:".$B*"1**6"-.5'09.J"_'E"2'":'0"F6'E"-.*:"2'6Y-"E$6-"-'"($F*"$"6*E"+-$5-"'7"-.*/5"%/B*+i"_'E"2'":'0"F6'Ei"m"K.*:YB*"45'1$1%:".$2"$"(/+&$55/$9*"'5"E.$-*B*5J"Z'0"&$6Y-"+**"-./69+>":'0"(0+-"F6'E"-./69+"-'"+$:"-./69+J"N+f"8'":'0"-./6F"/-Y+"502*"-.$-"4*'4%*"+$:"-.$-i"

Page 84: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

V\"

"

A+*'(f"c*5:>"1*&$0+*"/7"A"2/26Y-"&'(*"75'("<69%$62"$62"A"%/B*2"/6"A5*%$62"$62"A"E$6-*2"$"6*E"%/7*>"'5"&$(*"75'(",79.$6/+-$6"'5"E.$-*B*5"$62"A"E$6-*2"$"6*E"%/7*>"-.*6"A"E'0%26Y-"%/F*"+'(*'6*"-'"2'"/-"-'"(*J"

"

`*B/6"062*5+-''2"-.$-"C*6'4.'1/$"*C/+-*2"$62"-.$-"/-"E$+"5*%$-*2"-'"/2*$+"'7"1*%'69/69"$62"

%'++J"[+/69"(/+&$55/$9*"$+"$"(*-$4.'5"7'5"$"7'5("'7"-5$0($".*"$++'&/$-*+"E/-."-.*"$6C/*-/*+"'7"

2/+%'&$-/'6"$62"5*+*--%*(*6->O\"5$-.*5"-.$6"$&&*4-"-.*"C*6'4.'1/$"'7"./+"&%$++($-*+".*"

&.$%%*69*2"/-"1:"/($9/6/69".'E"/-"5*%$-*2"-'"./+"'E6"4$+-"$62"70-05*"('B*(*6-+J"

"

`*B/6"E$+"6'-"$%'6*"/6"-./+"E$:"'7"-./6F/69J"]5*22:>"E.'".$+"$%5*$2:"1**6"/6-5'20&*2>"5*&$%%*2"

-.$-"E.*6".*"E$+":'069*5"2/+&5/(/6$-/'6".$2"($2*"/-"2/77/&0%-"7'5"./+"7$-.*5"-'"9*-"E'5FJ";/F*"

`*B/6>"-./+"(*('5:"%*2"]5*22:"GE.'+*"4$5*6-+"E*5*"S'%'(1/$6I"-'"1*"&5/-/&$%"'7"-.*"/2*$"-.$-"

<$+-*56"<05'4*$6"4*'4%*".$2"-$F*6"<69%/+."4*'4%*Y+"H'1+J"

"

E3+55/f"Z*$.>"A"-./6F"-.*5*"/+"$"%'-"'7"5$&/+(J"A"2'6Y-"(*$6"H0+-"/6";'62'6"10-"/6"/((/95$-/'6"$+"$"E.'%*"/6"<69%$62J"K.*:"+$:"-.$-"<$+-*56"<05'4*$6"4*'4%*"-''F"<69%/+."4*'4%*Y+"H'1+"10-"m"A"2'6Y-"5*&F'6J"A"5*&F'6":*$."/-"&'0%2"1*"-'"2'"E/-."-.$-"-.*:"r10/%2/69"&'6-5$&-'5+"$62"'-.*5"*(4%':*5+s"E*5*"9*--/69"&.*$4"%$1'05J"^0-"/7":'0"$5*"$"1*--*5"E'5F*5"-.$6"+'(*'6*"*%+*"-.*6"r-.$-"4*5+'6"/+s"9'/69"-'"9*-"+$&F*2J"A"-./6F"/-"$%+'".$+"-'"2'"E/-."-.$-"-.*:"&$(*"'B*5"-'"7/62"$"H'1"+'"-.*:"E/%%"1*"r45*4$5*2s"-'"E'5F"('5*"$62".$52*5"-.$6"'-.*5"4*'4%*"E.'"-$F*"/-"7'5"95$6-*2"-'".$B*"$"9''2"4$/2"H'1"m","%'-"'7"H'1+".*5*":'0"&$6"+/-"$5'062"$62"6'-"5*$%%:"2'"$"%'-"$62"9*-"9''2"4$:"$62"4*'4%*"-$F*"/-"7'5"95$6-*2J",62"/7"+'(*'6*"*%+*"E$+"-'"&'(*"75'("$6'-.*5"&'06-5:"-.*:"E'0%2"E'5F"7'5"-.*"('6*:"-.$-"-.*:"*$56*2J"8'>"A"-./6F"/-Y+"5*$%%:"/(4'5-$6-J"

"

]5*22:"$62"`*B/6Y+"+'%/2$5/-:"E/-."'-.*5"(/95$6-+"E$+"1$+*2"'6"-.*/5"/($9/6$-/'6"'7"-.*/5"'E6"

4$+-+"$62"70-05*+"/6"-*5(+"'7"'-.*5"4*'4%*Y+"+-5099%*+J"

"

K.*"4'++/1/%/-:"7'5"7'5(+"'7"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"-.$-"15'F*"2'E6"6$-/'6$%"/2*$+"'7"1*%'69/69"E$+"

$44$5*6-"/6"'-.*5"*B*5:2$:"/6-*5$&-/'6+J"T0-+/2*"L0**6Y+"#$5F*-"/6"<$+-"_$(>"$+"4$5-"'7"-.*"

2'&0(*6-$5:"45'H*&-"^9+3+!L!1'*+2!^94,!L!^4(,>"<B$"$62".*5"75/*62+"$-"-.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."

=5'H*&-"&'620&-*2"/6-*5B/*E+"E/-."%'&$%"5*+/2*6-+J"T6*"/6-*5B/*E"E$+"E/-."$"7*($%*"(/95$6-"

75'("-.*"=./%/44/6*+J"8-$62/69"'0-+/2*"-.*"*6-5$6&*"-'"-.*"($5F*-"E/-.".*5"&./%2"+.*"E$+"$+F*2"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""O\",-"-.*"-/(*"A"-.'09.-".*"(/9.-".$B*"/6&%02*2"-./+"&'((*6-"1*&$0+*"'7"./+"*C4*5/*6&*"'7"+'(*'6*"

&%'+*"-'"./(".$B/69".$2"$"(/+&$55/$9*>"10-"A"2/26Y-"$+FJ"

Page 85: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

VN"

"

1:"<B$"E.$-"+.*"%/F*2"$1'0-"-.*"%'&$%"$5*$J"8.*"+$/2"-.*"&.*$4"750/-"$62"75*+."(*$-"-.$-"E$+"'6"

+$%*J"d.*6"^*+/$6"&0-"-.*"($-*5/$%"-'9*-.*5"/6-'"$"7/6$%"7/%(".*"$22*2"-.*"&$4-/'6"lr+.*"%/F*2s"

&.*$4"7''2>"750/-"$62"B*9*-$1%*+"m"10-"('+-"/(4'5-$6-%:"/-"5*(/62*2".*5"'7".'(*nJ";/F*"<625/->"

$1'B*>".*"$++'&/$-*2"/2*$+"'7"405/-:"$62"75*+.6*++"E/-.",%1$6/$>"$62"7'5"./("-.*"E'($6Y+"

&'((*6-+"E*5*"($2*"/6"-.*"+$(*"B*/6J"^0-"E./%*"-.*"E'($6".$2"(*6-/'6*2"-.$-"L0**6Y+"

#$5F*-"E$+"%/F*"-.*"($5F*-+"/6"-.*"=./%/44/6*+"+.*".$2"6'-"4%$&*2"$6:"/(4'5-$6&*"'6"-.*"

5*%$-/'6"1*-E**6"-.*"($5F*-"$62".*5"(*('5:"'7"W.'(*YJ"^*+/$6".$2"+'09.-"$62"7'062"./+"'E6"

6'+-$%9/$"/6".*5J"^*+/$6"$62"-.*"E'(*6"+.$5*2"$"&'%%*&-/B*"(*('5:"-.$-"2/2"6'-"5*h0/5*"-.*("

-'"1*"75'("-.*"+$(*"4%$&*>"$62"-.$-"*C/+-*2"$&5'++"6$-/'6$%"1'062$5/*+J"

"

S./%2.''2"$&&/2*6-+"$62"&'(/&$%"'&&$+/'6+"E*5*"$%+'"+.$5*2"1*:'62"-.*"1'062$5/*+"'7"

6$-/'6$%"6'+-$%9/$J"d.*6"5*%*$+*2"75'("6$-/'6$%"$62"5$&/$%"-/*+"-.*+*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"

'77*5*2"-.*"1$+/+"7'5"*(4$-.:"$62"+.$5/69J"T6"$%-*56$-*"8$-052$:+"A"4%$:*2"7''-1$%%"E/-."$"

95'04"'7",%1$6/$6Q+4*$F/69":'069"(*6>"$9*2"1*-E**6"-E*%B*"$62"+/C-**6>"$62"$%%"1'56"/6"-.*"

[`J"K.*"9$(*+"E*5*".*%2"/6"$"+&.''%".$%%"6*$5"^$5F/69>"./5*2"1:"-.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."=5'H*&-J"

305/69"-.*"9$(*+"-.*:"+.$5*2"+-'5/*+"'7".'%/2$:+"/6",%1$6/$J"K.*:"-$%F*2"$1'0-"9'/69"04"/6-'"

-.*"('06-$/6+"$62".$B/69"7$%%+J"K.*:"-$%F*2"$1'0-"-.*"&'(*2/&"2$69*5"'7".$B/69"$"&'E"506"$-"

-.*(J"K.*+*"E*5*"+-'5/*+"'7"2$69*5"$62"$1+'%0-*"+$7*-:>"-'%2"/6"$".0('5'0+"E$:"$+"/7"6'-./69"

1$2"&'0%2".$44*6J"_'E*B*5>"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"$+"1*/69"(*('5/*+"'7".'(*>"-.*:"E*5*"$%+'"H0+-"

(*('5/*+"'7"*B*6-+J"d./%*"-.*:"E*5*"*C&%0+/B*"-.*:"E*5*"$%+'"'4*6"$62"A"4$5-/&/4$-*2"/6"-.*+*"

(*('5/*+>"6'-"'6"-.*"1$+/+"-.$-"A"E$+",%1$6/$6"10-"'6"-.*"1$+/+"-.$-"A".$2"+/(/%$5"+-'5/*+"-'"-*%%J"

K.5'09."-.*+*"&'6B*5+$-/'6+"E*"+.$5*2"4$+-+"6'-"2*4*62*6-"'6"'05"(/95$-'5:"-5$H*&-'5/*+"10-"

'6"&./%2.''2"*C4*5/*6&*+J"

"

K.*"4'++/1/%/-:"7'5"2/$+4'5$"(6*('(/&+"E$+"7$&/%/-$-*2"1:"-.*"E$:+"/6"E./&."2/$+4'5$"+4$&*"

-.5*E"04"&'6+-$6-"$(1/90/-/*+"E.*6"$+&5/1/69"6$-/'6$%"(*('5/*+"-'"/62/B/20$%"1'2/*+J",-"-.*"

,7-*5"8&.''%"S%01>"-.*"*-.6/&>"6$-/'6$%"$62"%/690/+-/&"2/B*5+/-:"'7"-.*"+4$&*"(*$6-"-.$-"+0&."

$(1/90/-/*+"5*90%$5%:"$5'+*J"K.*"1*+-"75/*62"'7"8*5*6$"G-.*"7'05-**6Q:*$5Q'%2"405B*:'5"'7"

='5-090*+*"4'4"E.'".$+"$%5*$2:"1**6"/6-5'20&*2I"E$+"_*%*6$>"E.'".$2"$55/B*2"75'("R'($6/$"

$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"$+"8*5*6$"&$(*"75'("='5-09$%J"^'-."E*5*"%*$56/69"<69%/+."$62"7/62/69"-.*/5"

7**-J"d.$-"-.*:"+.$5*2>"/6"$22/-/'6"-'"$6"/6-*5*+-"/6"-.*"+$(*"1':+>"E$+"$"7**%/69"'7"1*/69"'0-"

'7"4%$&*"$62"'0-"'7"-/(*J",62"1*&$0+*"-.*:".$2"1'-."$55/B*2"$-"-.*":'0-."&%01"$-"-.*"+$(*"

-/(*>"-.*5*"E$+"'&&$+/'6$%"&'670+/'6"$1'0-"E.'"E$+"E.'J"8*5*6$"4*57'5(*2"1*/69"

Page 86: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

Ve"

"

='5-090*+*"B*5:"%'02%:"$62"1*&$0+*"_*%*6$"E$+"h0/*-*5"+'(*"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"-.'09.-"

+.*"E$+"='5-090*+*"-''J"A6"-./+"E$:>"7'5"$"4*5/'2"'7"-/(*>"_*%*6$"*(1'2/*2"8*5*6$Y+"(*('5/*+"

/6"$22/-/'6"-'"+.$5/69".*5"2/+%'&$-/'6J",%-.'09."-./+"($:"+**("'7"%/--%*"+/96/7/&$6&*>"/-"E$+"

.09*%:"/6+-50&-/B*"$1'0-"-.*"*B*5:2$:"%/B*+"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"/6"-.*":'0-."&%01J"K.*"2/B*5+/-:"

'7"(/95$-/'6+"-'"-.*"1'5'09."(*$6-"-.$-"/6"+'(*"&$+*+"/-"E$+"2/77/&0%-"-'"%'&$-*"(*('5:"/6"

-*5(+"'7"6$-/'6$%>"*-.6/&"'5"%/690/+-/&"1*%'69/69J"S'6+*h0*6-%:>"7'5(+"'7"%/B/69"7'5"-.*"'-.*5+"

1*&$(*"E/2*+45*$2"$62":'069"4*'4%*"1*&$(*"&'(7'5-$1%*"E/-."-.*"$(1/90/-/*+"-.*:"/(4%/*2J"

"

,-"-.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01"-.*"$(1/90/-:"$62"2/B*5+/-:"'7"4$+-"1*%'69/69"$%+'"(*$6-"-.$-"6$-/'6$%"

$62"*-.6/&"2/77*5*6&*"&'0%2"1*"4%$:*2"E/-."/6"E$:+"-.$-"2*-$&.*2"/-"75'("./*5$5&./*+"'7"W5$&*Y"

$62"6$-/'6J"KE'"'7"-.*":'069"(*6"-.$-"&$(*"-'"-.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01".$2"-.*"+$(*"S'69'%*+*"

+056$(*"$62"#*%>"'6*"'7"-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+>"$+F*2"/7"-.*:"E*5*"15'-.*5+J"`$6*"+$/2"l6'n>"-.*:"

E*5*6Y-"$62"/7"-.*:"%''F*2"$%/F*"/-"E$+"1*&$0+*"-.*:"E*5*"75'("-.*"+$(*"-5/1*J"_*"+$/2"-.$-"

-.*5*"E*5*"'6%:"-E'"-5/1*+"/6"-.*"S'69'J"`$6*"E$+"E/62/69"#*%"04>"-.*:"E*5*"/6"7$&-"15'-.*5+J"

K.*"5*7*5*6&*"-'"E.*5*"-.*:".$2"&'(*"75'("E$+"5''-*2"/6"$"&05/'+/-:"'B*5"-.*"+056$(*"$62"

-.*5*7'5*"'7"45'B*6$6&*>"10-"-.*"5*&*4-/B*"*6B/5'6(*6-"'7"-.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01"*6+05*2"-.$-"

-.*"h0*+-/'6"E$+"6'-"5''-*2"/6"$"h0*+-/'6/69"'7"%*9/-/($&:J"`$6*"F6*E"-.$-"1*&$0+*".*"F6*E"

#*%"$62".*"F6*E"-.*"+4$&*"/6"E./&."./+"H'F*"E$+"-'"1*"5*&*/B*2J"_*"+.$5*2"#*%Y+"(*('5:"'7"

('B*(*6-"$62"(0%-/&0%-05$%/+("/6"U*E.$("$62"$++0(*2"-.*5*"E$+"6'"H029*(*6-"'7"

%*9/-/($&:"/6".*5"h0*+-/'6J"K./+"*6$1%*2"./("-'"E/62".*5"04J"

"

K.*+*"+'5-+"'7"&05/'+/-/*+"E*5*"&'(('6"/6"-.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01J"Z'069"4*'4%*"'7"2/77*5*6-"

(/95$-'5:"-5$H*&-'5/*+"g"<05'4*$6"G/6&%02/69"^5/-/+.I>",+/$6>",75/&$6"$62";$-/6",(*5/&$6"g"$+F*2"

*$&."'-.*5"WE.$-"-.*/5"&'06-5:"E$+YJ"d./%*"-./+"$--*62*2"-'"6$-/'6$%"'52*5+>"/-"E$+"B*5:"

2/77*5*6-"75'("-.*"$&&0+$-/'6"WE.*5*"$5*":'0"75'(i"U'>"E.*5*"$5*":'0"3+411/!75'(iY"A-"E$+"$6"

'4*6"&05/'+/-:"+/(/%$5"-'"3*55/2$Y+"$6$%:+/+"'7".'+4/-$%/-:"G?@@@IJ"d./%*"E'5F/69"E/-./6"6$-/'6$%"

'52*5+"'7"1*/69>"-.*+*"7'5(+"'7"+4**&."2/2"6'-"+**F"-'"$&-/'6"$"./*5$5&.:"'7"1*%'69/69"'6"-./+"

1$+/+J"K./+"'4*66*++>"$62"-.*"4$5-/$%"2*-$&.(*6-"'7"(/95$-'5:"-5$H*&-'5/*+"75'("6$-/'6$%"

./*5$5&./*+>"E$+"45*2/&$-*2"'6"$"+.$5*2"2/$+4'5$"&'6+&/'0+6*++"-.$-"$%%'E*2"7'5"(/95$-/'6"-'"

1*&'(*"$"7$&-"'7"*B*5:2$:"/6-*5$&-/'6J"

"

Z'069"4*'4%*"($2*"75/*62+"'6"-.*"1$+/+"'7"7**%/69"'0-"'7"4%$&*>"-.*:"+.$5*2"6'+-$%9/$+"7'5"-.*"

+$(*"F/62+"'7"*B*6-+"/6"2/77*5*6-"-/(*+"$62"+4$&*+>"-.*:"%/B*2"(*('5/*+"7'5"'-.*5+"$62"-.*:"

Page 87: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

VM"

"

45'-*+-*2"7'5(+"'7"$0-'&.-.'6'0+"*C&%0+/'6J"K.*+*"5*&055/69"45$&-/&*+"2/+/6B*+-*2"(*('5:"'7"

/-+"6$-/'6$%/+-"$62"*-.6/&"1$99$9*"$62"4*5(/--*2"$"4%$:70%"$445'$&."-'"1*%'69/69J"K.*+*"

(*('5/*+"'7"'-.*5".'(*+>"$62"6'6*>"E*5*"6'-"/6&%02*2"/6"-.*"./+-'5/*+"'7"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++J"

K.*:"E*5*>".'E*B*5>"-.*"*B*5Q45*+*6-"&'62/-/'6"'7"(/95$-/'6"$62"('B*(*6-"/6"U*E.$(J"

R$-.*5"-.$6"+/96/7:/69"$"%$&F"'7"1*%'69/69>"1*/69"'0-"'7"4%$&*"$62"'0-"'7"-/(*"/670+*2"*B*5:2$:"

%/7*"E/-."$(1/90/-/*+"-.$-"E*5*"45'20&-/B*"5$-.*5"-.$6"2*1/%/-$-/69J"K.*:"&.$%%*69*2"-.*"

5$&/$%/+*2"./*5$5&./*+"-.5'09."E./&."$0-'&.-.'6:"$62"%'++"&'0%2"1*"&%$/(*2J"

S'6&%0+/'6"

;'&$-*2"1*-E**6"-.*"X'%2*6"<5$"$62"-.*"4*5&*/B*2"2*&%/6*"15'09.-"1:"/((/95$-/'6>"4'40%$5"

&0%-05*>"4'%/-/&$%"2/+&'05+*"$62"+'&/'%'9/&$%"$6$%:+/+"4'+/-"$"5*20&*2"9'-,%3/!'7"T0-*5"<$+-"

;'62'6J"^:"7'59*--/69"-.*"2/$%'9/&"&5*$-/B/-:"'7"E./-*6*++"$+"$"4'40%$5"$62"-5$&*2"&$-*9'5:"'7"

1*/69"$62"F6'E%*29*>"-./+"./+-'5:"+*5B*+"6$-/'6$%"(*%$6&.'%/$+"$62"E./-*"/6B/+/1/%/-:J"A-"$%+'"

2'*+"$"2/++*5B/&*"-'"-.*"&'(4%*C/-:"'7"*B*5:2$:"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"/6"U*E.$(J"K.5'09."$6"

*-.6'95$4./&"/6B*+-/9$-/'6"/6-'"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"/6"U*E.$(>"-./+"&.$4-*5".$+"064/&F*2"-.*"

5*/7/*2"9'-,%3'+-"$++'&/$-*2"E/-."-.*"X'%2*6"<5$>"067'%2/69"U*E.$(Y+"7$6"'7"./+-'5:"-'"+.'E"

-.*"2/$%'9/&$%"7'5($-/'6"'7"5$&/$%"./*5$5&.:>"$62"-.*"4'5'+/-:"$62"$%%05*"'7"E./-*6*++"$62"&%$++"

%'++"/6"$"+04*5Q2/B*5+*"4%$&*J"K.*"&.$4-*5".$+"+.'E6"-.$-"E./%*"-.*5*"E$+"6'-./69"E.'%*>"

4*5($6*6-"'5"-/(*%*++"$1'0-"E./-*6*++>"6'6*-.*%*++"/-"706&-/'6*2"-'"&5*$-*"$0-'&.-.'6'0+"

6$55$-/B*+"1$+*2"'6"5$&/$%"$62"6$-/'6$%"./*5$5&./*+"'7"1*%'69/69"-.$-"'B*5%$/2"4.*6'-:4/&$%"

5$&/+("E/-."6*E*5"C*6'4.'1/$+J"K.*"6*&*++/-:"-'"*C&%02*"'6"-.*"1$+/+"'7"$6"$"45/'5/"(:-."'7"

1*%'69/69"7'062"&'(('6"5*+'6$6&*"$('69":'0-."E'5F*5+>"4$5*6-+"$62":'069"4*'4%*"'7"

2/77*5*6-"(/95$-'5:"-5$H*&-'5/*+J"_'E*B*5>"-./+"2/2"6'-"/(4%:"-.$-"$%%"*C&%0+/'6+"E*5*"-.*"+$(*J"

K.*"2/77*5*6-"*(1'2/*2"./+-'5/*+"$62"*C4*5/*6&*+"'7"4*'4%*"+-/%%"$77*&-*2"-.*"E$:"-.*:"

$&&*++*2"-.*"+'/%J"

"

K.*"./+-'5/&$%"$62"+'&/$%"&'6H06&-05*+"/6"E./&."-.*+*"45$&-/&*+"'7"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"'&&055*2"

E*5*"4$5-/&0%$5J"d./%*"-.*:"E*5*"4$5-"'7"$"6$-/'6$%"7'5($-/'6"'7"4'+-QE$5"6'+-$%9/$"-.*:"E*5*"

$%+'"+4*&/7/&"-'"U*E.$(>"$62"-'";*:.$(J"K$F*6"7'5E$52"/6"-.*"7'%%'E/69"&.$4-*5"-.5'09."$"

2/+&0++/'6"'7"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"-*55/-'5:"$62"2*7*6+/B*"&'((06/-:"7'5($-/'6+>"-.*:"25*E"

$--*6-/'6"-'"-.*"./+-'5:"'7"(/95$-/'6"/6"-.*"$5*$"G$62"-.*"5*+0%-/69"+04*5Q2/B*5+/-:I"$-"-.*"+$(*"

-/(*"$+"-.*:"E*5*"45*2/&$-*2"'6"7'59*--/69"-.$-"+$(*"4$+-J",62"-.*:"25*E"$--*6-/'6"-'"-.*"

Page 88: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

VV"

"

%'69"./+-'5:"'7"*&'6'(/&"+-$96$-/'6"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"$+"-.*:"E*5*"45*2/&$-*2"'6"5*4%$&/69"-./+"

6'-/'6"'7"%'++"E/-."-.*"7/905*"'7"-.*"/((/95$6-J"

"

K.*+*"7'5(+"'7"5$&/$%/+*2"%*9/-/($&:"706&-/'6*2"-.5'09."E.$-"-.*:"7'59'-J"^0-"E.$-"E$+"

+/%*6&*2"+-/%%"*C/+-*2"/6"-.*"7$6"'7"./+-'5:"$62"/6"-.*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"'7":'069"4*'4%*J"

U*E.$("E$+"($2*"-.5'09."!N@":*$5+"'7"(/95$-/'6"-.$-"15'09.-"E/-."/-"(*('5/*+"'7"($6:"

2/77*5*6-".'(*+J"8'(*"'7"-.*+*".'(*+"E*5*"6$-/'6$%"*++*6&*+"10-"-.*/5"01/h0/-:"$62"-.*/5"

'4*66*++"-'"$445'45/$-/'6"9$B*"5/+*"-'"7'5(+"'7"$(1/90/-:"-.$-"1*&$(*"*+-5$69*2"75'("-.*/5"

6$-/'6$%"$62"*-.6/&"$6&.'5+J"=*5+'6$%"(*('5/*+"$62"45'H*&-/'6+"'7"(/95$-/'6"E*5*"0+*2"/6"

+'%/2$5/-:"E/-."'-.*5"(/95$6-+"$9$/6+-"-.*"2*.0($6/+/69"&'6+*h0*6&*+"'7"C*6'4.'1/$J"

K.5'09."&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6"2/77*5*6-"(*('/5*+"$62"-5$H*&-'5/*+"E*5*"4%$:*2"-'9*-.*5"/6"

06&'(4%/&$-*2"$%%/$6&*J"A6"+'(*"+4$&*+>"-.*"'4*66*++"-'"2/77*5*6-"4$+-+"$62"-.*"06&*5-$/6-/*+"

/6B'%B*2"/6"2*7/6/69"E.*5*"4*'4%*"E*5*!F3%&"$%%'E*2"7'5"/6-*5$&-/'6+"-.$-"E*5*"-*(4'5$5/%:"

+-5/44*2"'7"5$&/$%"$62"*-.6/&"./*5$5&.:J"Z'069"4*'4%*"E.'+*"6$-/'6$%"'5/9/6+"E*5*"(/+-$F*6"

7'062"-.*(+*%B*+"/6"-.*"4'+/-/'6"'7"%/B/69"(*('5/*+"7'5"-.*/5"75/*62+J"K./+"5*+0%-*2"/6"$"

2/+/6B*+-(*6-"75'("6$-/'6"$62"W5$&*Y"$62"$6"'4*66*++"-'"(6*('6/&"4%$:"-.$-"E'5F*2"$9$/6+-"

-.*"./*5$5&./*+"'7"1*%'69/69"+0+-$/6*2"/6"4'40%$5"&0%-05*"$62"*B*5:2$:"%/7*J"S'6-5$5:"-'"X'%2*6"

<5$"$&&'06-+>"-.*+*"(*('5/*+"E*5*"$%%"4$5-"'7"U*E.$(J"

Page 89: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

VP"

"

S.$4-*5"K.5**"g"K.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"-*55/-'5:"

A6"]*150$5:"?@!@>"-.*"10/%2/69"'7"-.*"6*E"7*6&*"&'((*6&*2J"A-"E$+"-.*"-./52"/6&$56$-/'6"'7"

1'52*5"$5&./-*&-05*"$-";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01J"K.*"7/5+-"/6&$56$-/'6"E$+"$"1'062$5:"/62/&$-'5"g"$"

(*-$%"4/&F*-"7*6&*J",-"7'05"7**-"./9.>"/-"F*4-"+'(*"7''-1$%%+"/6>"10-"$6:"4.:+/&$%"45'-*&-/'6"/-"

'77*5*2"E$+"1$+*2"'6"&'6+*6-"5$-.*5"-.$6"+-5*69-.J"K.*"+*&'62"/6&$56$-/'6"E$+"$"-*(4'5$5:"

10/%2*5Y+"7*6&*J"8-$62/69"*/9.-"7**-"./9.>"/-"5*+-5/&-*2"4.:+/&$%"('B*(*6-"$62"45'-*&-*2"-.*"

6$+&*6-"&'6+-50&-/'6"'7"-.*"6*E"$2B*6-05*"4%$:95'062J"K./+"('5*"$995*++/B*"+-50&-05*"

45'B'F*2"6/9.-%:"$--$&F"$62"7$5"75'("2/+4*%%/69"-.*"%/69*5/69"-.5*$-"+-$77"7*%-"75'("-.*"'0-+/2*>"

/-"&'67/5(*2"/-J"K.*"7/6$%"7*6&*"E$+"*/9.-"7**-"./9.>"($2*"'7"+-**%"1$5+"$62"*6&%'+/69"-.*"

4*5/(*-*5"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01J"S*(*6-*2"/6-'"-.*"95'062>"/-"&'0%2"6'-"1*"'B*5-056*2J"K./+"7*6&*"

$&&'(4$6/*2"/6&5*$+/69"%*B*%+"'7"4'%/&/69"$62"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"$-"-.*":'0-."&%01J",%-.'09."

H0+-/7/*2"-.5'09."-.*"6**2"-'"45'-*&-"-.*"$2B*6-05*"4%$:95'062>"$6:"4.:+/&$%"45'-*&-/'6"/-"

45'B/2*2"E$+"(/6/($%J"8&$%*2"'6"$"6/9.-%:"1$+/+"/-"$--5$&-*2"('5*"$--*6-/'6"-.$-"/-"2*-*55*2J",+"

d/%%>"'6*"'7"-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+"+$/2>"lU'"7*6&*"E'0%2"1*"('5*"*77*&-/B*nJ"_*"E$+"5/9.-J"^0-"-.*"

5*$%"4054'+*"'7"-.*"7*6&*"E$+"6'-"-'"4.:+/&$%%:"45*B*6-"*6-5$6&*"-'"-.*"+/-*"10-"-'"($F*"$"

+-$-*(*6-"'7"7'5&*>"2*7/6*"$"-.5*$->"$62"%'&$-*"$"('5$%"&'((06/-:"g"$"&'((06/-:"-.$-"

*C-*62*2"75'("-.*":'0-."&%01>"'0-"-.5'09."-.*"/5'6"1$5+"$62"/6-'"-.*"E/2*5"6*/9.1'05.''2JON"

"

K.*"45'&*++/'6"'7"7*6&*"10/%2/69"$-";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01"45'B/2*2"$"0+*70%"$%%*9'5:"7'5"-.*"

2*B*%'4/69"-*55/-'5/$%"4'%/-/&+"/6"-.*"%'&$%"$5*$J"K.*+*"-*55/-'5/$%"4'%/-/&+"25*E"$--*6-/'6"-'"E/2*5"

&'6&*56+"7'5"-.*"06Q75**2'(+"g"W$%/*6$-/'6Y"G;*7*1B5*"!PPeI"g"%/B*2"1:"%'-+"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"

A"E'5F*2"E/-.J"K.*"7*6&*"+:(1'%/+*2"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"*C&%0+/'6"75'("401%/&"+4$&*"G`'7($6"

$62";*1$+"!PPe>"4J"?!j";*7*1B5*"!PPeIJ"A6B*+-*2"E/-."$0-.'5/-:"1:"-.*"4'%/&*>"-.*":'0-."&%01"

$62"-.*"W%'&$%"&'((06/-:Y>"/-"E$+"$"2*($5&$-/'6"'7"'52*5"G$62"2/+'52*5I"-.$-"&'6+-5$/6*2"

:'069"4*'4%*Y+"75**2'("-'"T+!/6>"$62"&'%%*&-/B*%:"45'20&*>"-.*/5"%'&$%"*6B/5'6(*6-"G^*5($6"

!PVej"_$5B*:"?@@Vj"A+/6"?@@@j";*7*1B5*"!PPej"#$5&0+*"?@@Pj"#*55/7/*%2"?@!!j"#/-&.*%%"!PPNj"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""ON"K.*"$*+-.*-/&+"'7"-.*"7*6&*"E*5*"2/+&0++*2"$62"$"(*-$%Q1$5"&'6+-50&-/'6"E$+"2**(*2"$445'45/$-*"1:"

:'0-."E'5F*5+"$62"-.*"%'&$%"$0-.'5/-:"1*&$0+*"/-"E'0%2"$%%'E"B/+0$%"&'66*&-/'6"1*-E**6"-.*":'0-."&%01"

$62"-.*"E/2*5"&'((06/-:J"

Page 90: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

P@"

"

8'H$"?@!@IJ"3*B*%'4/69"&'6+/2*5$-/'6+"75'("-.*"45*B/'0+"&.$4-*5>"-.*+*"6'-/'6+"'7"'52*5"E*5*"

4$5-%:"2*7/6*2"-.5'09."$0-'&.-.'6:J"_'E*B*5>"-.*"7*6&*"$%+'"45'B/2*2"$"(*-$4.'5"-'"*C4%'5*"

-.*"'-.*5"+&$%*+"'6"E./&."'52*5"$62"2/+'52*5"E*5*"2*7/6*2J"K.*"7*6&*"E$+"6'-"-.*"'6%:"+'&/$%"

$62"-*55/-'5/$%"1'062$5:":'069"4*'4%*"*6&'06-*5*2J"T6"-.*"+-5**->"/6"-.*":'0-."&%01>"$62"/6"

(/&5'Q+'&/'%'9/&$%"/6-*5$&-/'6+"1*-E**6":'069"4*'4%*>":'0-."E'5F*5+"$62"-.*"4'%/&*>"'-.*5"

1'062$5/*+"E*5*"&'6+-50&-*2"$62"2/+($6-%*2J"

"

='%/-/&$%"9*'95$4.*5+".$B*"6'-*2"-.*"+:(1'%/&"/(4'5-$6&*"'7"-*55/-'5:"7'5"6*9'-/$-/69"7'5(+"'7"

/6&%0+/'6"$62"*C&%0+/'6"G8(/-."?@@!j"8'H$"?@@NIJ"A6"+'&/'%'9:>"^$&F".$+"2/+&0++*2".'E"-*55$/6+"

$5'062":'0-."&%01+"E*5*"&5*$-*2"$62"&'2*2"-.5'09."7%0/2>"%'&$%"6$-/'6$%/+(+"G!PP\IJ",%*C$62*5"

.$+"*C4%'5*2"-.*":'0-."&%01"$+"4$5-"'7"$"E/2*5"6*C0+"'7"5$&/$%%:"&'2*2"-*55/-'5:"G?@@@IJ"T-.*5"

-*C-+".$B*"2*+&5/1*2"-.*":'0-."&%01Y+"-*55/-'5/$%"45'(/6*6&*"/6":'069"4*'4%*Y+"%'&$%"%$62+&$4*+"

GR'1/6+"!PP?j"d/%%('--"!PePIJ"_'E*B*5>"-.*":'0-."&%01".$+"$%+'"1**6"*C4%'5*2"$+"$"7*$-05*"'7"

-.*"051$6"%$62+&$4*"&'6+-/-0-*2"-.5'09."/-+"5*%$-/'6+./4"E/-."6$-/'6$%>"%'&$%"$62"(/&5'Q4'%/-/&+"

GR'1/6+"$62"S'.*6"!PMVIJ"K./+"E'5F"+.'E+".'E"-.*"-*55/-'5:"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01"/+"+'&/$%%:"

&'6+-50&-*2"$62"6*9'-/$-*2"-.5'09."-.*"/6-*55*%$-/'6"'7"2/77*5*6-"9*'95$4./&$%"+&$%*+"g"

5*7*55*2"-'"$+"-.*"W4'%/-/&+"'7"+&$%*Y"G_$5B*:"!PVP$>"?@@@j")'6$+"!PP\j";*7*1B5*"!PP!j"8'H$"

!PPej"8E:69*2'0E"!PPM>"?@@@j"K.5/7-"!PPMIJ";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01"E$+"&'6+-50&-*2"$62"

6*9'-/$-*2"/6"-./+"E$:J"A-"E$+"6'-"$"7/C*2"+/-*"'7"-*55/-'5:"$62"+'&/$%"(*$6/69J"A6+-*$2"-.*"

-*55/-'5/$%"$0-.'5/-:"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01"E$+"&'6-/60$%%:"5*2*7/6*2"-.5'09."/-+"5*%$-/'6+./4"-'"

6$-/'6$%>"%'&$%"$62"(/&5'"4'%/-/&$%"9*'95$4./*+J"

"

K.5'09."*C4%'5/69"-.*"/6-*5+*&-/'6"'7"-.*+*"2/77*5*6-"-*55/-'5/$%"45$&-/&*+"-.*"&.$4-*5"$590*+"

-.$-"-.*"-*55/-'5/$%"4'%/-/&+"'7";*:.$("&$6"'6%:"1*"062*5+-''2"E.*6"2/77*5*6-"+&$%*+"'7"

-*55/-'5:>"$62"-.*/5"$&&'(4$6:/69"2/+&'05+*+"'7"'52*5"$62"2/+'52*5>Oe"$5*"B/*E*2"$+"(0-0$%%:"

&'6+-/-0-/B*J"K.*"&.$4-*5"45'&**2+"1:"*C4%'5/69"-.*"2/77*5*6-"+&$%*+"'7"-*55/-'5/$%"6*9'-/$-/'6f"

('B/69"75'("'0-+/2*"-.*":'0-."&%01"-'"-.*"/6+/2*>"$62"-.*6"-'"-.*"(/&5'Q4'%/-/&+"'7"2/$%'9/&"

/6-*5$&-/'6+J"K.*"7/5+-"+*&-/'6"'7"-.*"&.$4-*5"2/+&0++*+".'E"-.*"4'%/&/69"'7"-.*"+-5**-+"1*&$(*"

4$5-"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01J"A-"+.'E+".'E"6$-/'6$%"$62"%'&$%"75$(/69+"7'5"2/+'52*5"*C-*62*2"/6-'"$62"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""Oe"3/+&0++/'6+"'7"'52*5"$62"2/+'52*5"$+"$"-*55/-'5/$%"4.*6'(*6'6"$5*"*B/2*6-"/6"8&.(/--"G8&.(/--"?@@Oj"

8&.(/--"?@@VI"E.'"0+*+"-.*"&'6&*4-"'7"-.*"W6'('+Y"-'"2*7/6*"+4$-/$%>"4'%/-/&$%"$62"H05/2/&$%"'52*5"$9$/6+-"

-.*"&.$'+"'7"-.*"+*$J"8&.(/--Y+"/2*$+"$5*"0+*70%%:"2/+&0++*2"$62"&5/-/h0*2"1:",9$(1*6"G,9$(1*6"!PPVj"

,9$(1*6"?@@NIJ"

Page 91: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

P!"

"

&.$69*2"-.*":'0-."&%01Y+"5'%*"/6"%'&$%"-*55/-'5/$%"9'B*56$6&*J"K.*"&'6-*C-"7'5"-./+"2/+&0++/'6"/+"

-.*"401%/&"+4*62/69"&0-+"$62"-.*"('B*"75'("$"-'4Q2'E6"-'"$"%'&$%"4$5-6*5+./4"45'B/+/'6"'7"

+'&/$%"+*5B/&*+J"K.*"+*&'62"+*&-/'6"$225*++*+".'E"-.*":'0-."&%01"2*B*%'4*2"/-+"'E6"5*9/(*+"'7"

-*55/-'5/$%"&'6-5'%J"K./+"/+"*C4%'5*2"/6"-.*"&'6-*C-"'7"-.*"/6&5*$+*2"5'%*"'7"-.*"-./52"+*&-'5"/6"

%'&$%"9'B*56$6&*J"K.*"&.$5$&-*5"'7"-./+"9'B*56$6&*"10/%2+"'6"2/+&0++/'6+"'7"$0-'&.-.'6:"

*%$1'5$-*2"/6"-.*"45*B/'0+"&.$4-*5J"K.*"7/6$%"+*&-/'6>"$225*++*+"-.*"7'5(+"'7"-*55/-'5/$%"

9'B*56$6&*"7'5(*2"$-"-.*"%*B*%"'7"-.*"(/&5'J"K.5'09."$"2/+&0++/'6"'7"1$6-*5"$62"5/2/&0%*"/-"

+.'E+".'E"-*55/-'5/$%"/6&%0+/'6+"$62"*C&%0+/'6+"E*5*"*6$&-*2"-.5'09."7'5(+"'7"2/$%'90*J"K.*"

('B*(*6-"-.5'09."-.*"&.$4-*5>"$62"-.*"/6-*55*%$-/'6"'7"/-+"2/77*5*6-"+*&-/'6+>"5*B*$%+"-.*"

2*B*%'4(*6-"'7"-*55/-'5/$%"9'B*56$6&*"/6"T0-*5"<$+-";'62'6>"$62".'E"-.*"4'%/&*>"-.*":'0-."

&%01>":'0-."E'5F*5+"$62":'069"4*'4%*"45'20&*2"$62"6*9'-/$-*2"/6&%0+/'6$5:"$62"*C&%0+/'6$5:"

-*55$/6+J"

!J ='%/&/69"-.*"+-5**-+"-.5'09."-.*":'0-."&%01"

A6"U*E.$(>"401%/&"+4$&*"E$+"2/B/2*2"1:"-.*"4'%/&*"/6-'"+4$&*+"'7"'52*5"$62"2/+'52*5"g"-.*"

+-5**-"E$+"$"+/-*"'7"2/+'52*5"$62"-.*":'0-."&%01"$"+/-*"'7"'52*5J",+"$"+/-*"'7"2/+'52*5>"-.*"+-5**-"

E$+"$%+'"$"+/-*"'7"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6J"A-+"706&-/'6"/6"-./+"5*9$52"/+"E*%%"2'&0(*6-*2J"U0(*5'0+"

+'&/'%'9/&$%"E'5F+".$B*"*C4%'5*2".'E"E'5F/69Q&%$++":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"&5/(/6$%/+*2"1:"-.*"

4'%/&*J"K.*+*"E'5F+".$B*"$225*++*2".'E":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"&5/(/6$%/+*2"1*&$0+*"'7"-.*/5"

E'5F/69Q&%$++"4'+/-/'6"G_$%%"*-"$%J"!PMej"S'55/9$6"!PMPj"_0(4.5/*+"!PV!j"=*$5+'6"!PVOI>"$62"

1*&$0+*"'7"-.*/5"5$&/$%/+$-/'6"G,%*C$62*5"!PPe>"?@@@j"X/%5':"!PVMj"_$%%"*-"$%J"!PMVj"A+$%"?@@ej"

8'%'('+"!PVVj"d*1+-*5"?@@eIJ"

"

A6"&'6-*(4'5$5:"U*E.$(>"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"A"E'5F*2"E/-."*C4*5/*6&*2"5*90%$5"+-'4Q$62Q

+*$5&."$62"7*%-"-.*:"E*5*"+01H*&-*2"-'"$995*++/B*"$62"2*(*$6/69"-5*$-(*6-"1:"-.*"4'%/&*J"K./+"

/6&%02*2"502*6*++>"B/'%*6&*"$62"-.*"5*4'5-*2"G/%%*9$%I"45$&-/&*"'7"1*/69"+-5/44*2"/6"-.*"1$&F"'7"

-.*"4'%/&*"B$6J"K.*:"E*5*"-$59*-*2"1*&$0+*"'7"-.*"-.5*$-"-.*:"5*45*+*6-*2"-'"401%/&"'52*5J"

T6*"*B*6/69"'0-+/2*";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01"A"+$E"*B*5:"95'04"'7":'069"4*'4%*"-.$-"E$%F*2"4$+-"

1*/69"+-'44*2"$62"h0*+-/'6*2J",-"-.*".$62+"'7"&'((06/-:"+044'5-"'77/&*5+"-.*/5"75**2'("E$+"

705-.*5"&'(45'(/+*2J"S$-*9'5/+*2"$+"2/+'52*5%:"&'695*9$-/'6+"-.*:"E*5*"('B*2"'6"75'("-.*"

+-$/5E*%%+"'7"&'06&/%"7%$-+"$62"+-5**-"&'56*5+J",+"'6*"'7"-.*"%'&$%"&'((06/-:"+044'5-"'77/&*5+"

&'67/5(*2>"-./+"E$+"6'-"1*&$0+*"-.*:"E*5*"&$0+/69"-5'01%*"10-"1*&$0+*"-.*:"E*5*"-./6F/69"

Page 92: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

P?"

"

$1'0-"/-"G;'$2*5"!PPeIJ"K.*/5"45*+*6&*"E$+"+**6"$+"'0-"'7"'52*5>"1*7'5*"-.*:".$2"2'6*"

$6:-./69"E5'69J"

"

8**/69"-.*"+-5**-+"$+"-.*/5"'E6>"$62"$+"$"+/-*"'7"5*%$-/B*"75**2'("&'(4$5*2"-'"-.*".'(*>"

+&.''%"'5":'0-."&%01"Gc$%*6-/6*"?@@\>"4JVOI>"-.*:"'7-*6"45'-*+-*2J"[+/69"-.*"($+&0%/6*"

B*56$&0%$5"'7"+-5**-"&'6-*+->OM":'069"4*'4%*"G($%*"$62"7*($%*I"5*+4'62*2"-'"-.*"4'%/&*Y+"

($+&0%/6*"$995*++/'6"1:"-*$+/69"-.*/5"$0-.'5/-:"-.5'09."+.'E+"'7"15$B$2'"G+E$99*5/69>"F/++/69"

-**-."$62"$995*++/B*"4'+-05/69I"$62"/62/&$-/69"/62/77*5*6&*"$62"5*+/+-$6&*"-'"-.*/5"4'E*5J"

K.5'09."-.*+*"$&-+"'7"E/66/69"1$&F"+4$&*"-.*:"F*4-"-.*"%'69"-5$2/-/'6+"'7"&$-"$62"('0+*"$%/B*J"

_'E*B*5>"E./%*"-.*"4'%/-/&$%"9*'95$4.:"'7"-.*"+-5**-".$+"5*&*/B*2"+01+-$6-/$%"$--*6-/'6"

G_0(4.5/*+"!PV!j"8$(0*%"!PV!j"S'55/9$6"!PMPI>"-.*5*".$+"1**6"%*++"&'6&*56"7'5".'E"-.*"

-*55/-'5/$%"4'%/-/&+"'7"-.*"+-5**-"4%$:"-.5'09."-.*"2*&*6-5$%/+*2"/6+-/-0-/'6+"'7"-.*"6*'Q%/1*5$%"

&/-:"/6-'"-.*":'0-."&%01J"

"

3/77*5*6-"4'%/&*"'77/&*5+".$2"2/77*5*6-"$445'$&.*+"-'":'069"4*'4%*"10-"$%%"-.*"4'%/&*"A"(*-"

062*5+-''2"-.*":'0-."&%01"/6"$"&5/(/6$%"H0+-/&*"&'6-*C-J"K.*":'0-."&%01"E$+"4'+/-/'6*2"$+"$"

-*55$/6"'7"'52*5>"2*7/6*2"$9$/6+-"-.*"+-5**-"g"$"+*$"'7"2/+'52*5J"=S"306&$6")'6*+>"$"%'&$%"'77/&*5"

/6"-.*"$5*$"E/-."$"%/1*5$%"$445'$&."-'":'069"4*'4%*>"2/2"6'-"-./6F"-.$-"95'04+"'7":'069"4*'4%*"

E*5*"W9$69+Y"$62"2/2"-./6F"-.*"1*+-"E$:"-'"E'5F"E/-."-.*("E$+"-.5'09."&'((06/&$-/'6"5$-.*5"

-.$6"$6-$9'6/+(J"U'6*-.*%*++>".*"+$E"-.*":'0-."&%01"$+"$"5*&*4-$&%*"'7"'52*5"$62"-.*"+-5**-+"

$+"$"+/-*"'7"&5/(*J"A6"45$&-/&$%"-*5(+>".*"7*%-"-.$-"E.*6":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"$-"-.*":'0-."&%01>"

%'&$%"5*+/2*6-+"E'0%2"6'-"4.'6*"04"-.*"+-$-/'6"-'"&'(4%$/6"$1'0-"-.*(J"

"

K.*"4*5+4*&-/B*+"'7"-.*"4'%/&*"($--*5*2"1*&$0+*"'B*5"-.*"-/(*"A"E'5F*2"-.*5*>";*:.$("

1*&$(*"/6&5*$+/69%:"&'Q'4-*2"/6-'"-.*"7'5(+"'7"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"-.$-".$2"1**6"45*B/'0+%:"

&'67/6*2"-'"-.*"+-5**-+J"K.*+*"6*9'-/$-/'6+"'7"'52*5"$62"2/+'52*5"*6-*5*2"-.*":'0-."&%01"

-.5'09."4$5-6*5+./4"E'5F/69J"A6"U*E.$(>"$62"$&5'++"<69%$62"$62"d$%*+>"-.*"2*$-."'7"c/&-'5/$"

S%/(1/w"$62"-.*"+01+*h0*6-"$0-.'5/69"'7"7*+3/!_9'15!N4,,+3-"G_#"X'B*56(*6-"?@@OI"%*2"-'"$6"

A6-*95$-*2"Z'0-."8044'5-"8:+-*("2*+/96*2"+'"-.$-"6'"('5*"&./%25*6"E'0%2"7$%%"-.5'09."9$4+"/6"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""OM",0-.'5+".$B*"*C4%'5*2"-.*"($+&0%/6/+*2"2:6$(/&+"'7"401%/&"+4$&*"G#&3'E*%%"!PPPj"=*$5+'6"!PVOj"

R'+*"!PPOj"K'6F/++"?@@eIJ"

Page 93: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

PO"

"

-.*"E*%7$5*"+:+-*(JOV"S'(1/6*2"E/-."-.*"/6&5*$+*2"5*+4'6+/1/%/-:"'7"-./52"+*&-'5"'59$6/+$-/'6+"

-'"45'B/2*"%'&$%"+*5B/&*+"G^5*66*5"$62"K.*'2'5*"?@@?j")*++'4"?@@?j"=*&F"$62"K/&F*%%"?@@?I>"

-.*+*"('B*+"-'"4$5-6*5+./4"E'5F/69"15'09.-":'0-."&%01+"/6-'"-.*"$(1/-"'7"%'&$%"+*5B/&*Q

2*%/B*5:"$%%/$6&*+"$62"45$&-/&*+"'7"+.$5/69"/67'5($-/'6"E/-."-.*"4'%/&*J"

"

,+"$"%'&$%"-./52"+*&-'5"1'2:>";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01Y+"4$5-6*5+./4"E'5F"5*+0%-*2"/6"$"60(1*5"'7"

+.$5*2"*62*$B'05+"E/-."-.*"4'%/&*J"T&&$+/'6$%%:>"'52*5+"*($6$-/69"75'("4'%/&*"%/$/+'6"

(**-/69+"E'0%2"5*$&."-.*":'0-."&%01+"$62"6*E"&'05+*+"7'5"45'B/+/'6"E*5*"+*-"2'E6J",-"

^5''F15/29*"Z'0-."S%01"-.*+*"4$5-6*5+./4"(**-/69+"5*+0%-*2"/6"&.$69*+"-'"-.*"'4*6/69".'05+J"

,1'0-"+/C"('6-.+"$7-*5"A"+-$5-*2"B'%06-**5/69"-.*5*>"45'B/+/'6"-/(*+"+./7-*2"75'("MgP4(>"-'"

MJO@gPJO@4(J"K.*"4'%/&*".$2"/67'5(*2":'0-."+*5B/&*+"-.$-"-5'01%*"E$+"'&&055/69"/6"-.*"%'&$%"

$5*$"$7-*5"6/6*"'Y&%'&F"/6"-.*"*B*6/69J"K./+"$&-0$%%:"$('06-*2"-'"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"-$%F/69"/6"

-.*"&$54$5F"$7-*5"%*$B/69"-.*":'0-."&%01"g"-.*":'0-."&%01"-.*"4'%/&*"/5'6/&$%%:"E$6-*2"-.*("-'"

$--*62J"U'6*-.*%*++>"-.*/5"&'%%*&-/B*"45*+*6&*"E$+"2**(*2"$"W.'-"+4'-Y"$62"-.*"4'%/&*"

/6-*5B*6*2"/6":'0-."&%01"4'%/&:"-'"&.$69*"-.*".'05+J"K.5'09."+/(/%$5"+-5$-*9:"(**-/69+"H'/6-"

E'5F/69"/6/-/$-/B*+"E*5*"$%+'"*+-$1%/+.*2"E.*5*1:":'0-."E'5F*5+"-''F"4$5-"/6"'0-5*$&."E'5F"

E/-."-.*"4'%/&*>"-5$B*%%/69"$5'062"%'&$%"$5*$+"/6"06($5F*2"4'%/&*"&$5+>"'5"'6"7''-"GE/-."%'&$%"

'77/&*5+I"-'"+-'4"$62"h0*+-/'6":'069"4*'4%*J"A6"-./+"E$:>"-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+".*%4*2"+'7-*6"-.*"

/($9*"'7"-.*"4'%/&*>"-.*"4'%/&*"&'%%*&-*2"/6-*%%/9*6&*"-.*:"'-.*5E/+*"E'0%2"6'-".$B*".$2"$&&*++"

-'>"$62"-.*"%/6*+"E*5*"705-.*5"1%055*2"$+"-'"E.*5*"-.*":'0-."&%01"$+"$"+/-*"'7"'52*5"1*9$6>"$62"

-.*"+-5**-"$+"$"+/-*"'7"2/+'52*5"*62*2J"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""OV"K.*"4'%/&/*+"2*-$/%*2"/6"7*+3/!_9'15!N4,,+3-"G_#"X'B*56(*6-"?@@OI"$62"`%0,9!N4,,+3-"G_#"

X'B*56(*6-"?@@N1I"$5*"&*6-5$%"-'"&055*6-":'0-."+*5B/&*"45'B/+/'6J"7*+3/!_9'15!N4,,+3-"E$+"401%/+.*2"1:"

-.*"9'B*56(*6-"7'%%'E/69"-.*"2*$-."'7"c/&-'5/$"S%/(1/wJ"c/&-'5/$"S%/(1/wY+"2*$-."E$+"4$5-%:"1%$(*2"'6"

-.*"+:+-*($-/&"7$/%/69+"'7"&./%25*6"$62":'069"4*'4%*Y+"+*5B/&*+J"7*+3/!_9'15!N4,,+3-!'0-%/6*2"7/B*"F*:"

'0-&'(*+"-.$-"+.'0%2"1*"$&./*B*2"E.*6"E'5F/69"E/-."&./%25*6f"1*/69".*$%-.:>"+-$:/69"+$7*>"*6H':/69"$62"

$&./*B/69>"($F/69"$"4'+/-/B*"&'6-5/10-/'6>"$62"*&'6'(/&"E*%%Q1*/69"G_#"X'B*56(*6-"?@@O>"4J!\IJ"`%0,9!

N4,,+3-"$44%/*2"-.*+*"+$(*"'0-&'(*+"-'"E'5F/69"E/-.":'069"4*'4%*J"A6"U*E.$("-.*"$/(+"$62"

'1H*&-/B*+"'7"7*+3/!_9'15!N4,,+3-!$62"`%0,9!N4,,+3-!.$B*"1**6"-5$6+%$-*2"/6-'"-.*"S./%25*6"$62"Z'069"

=*'4%*Y+"=%$6"G;^U"?@@e$IJ"`%0,9!N4,,+3-".$+"$%+'"45'B/2*2"-.*"1$+/+"7'5"U*E.$(Y+"A6-*95$-*2"Z'0-."

8044'5-"8*5B/&*+f"$"1'5'09.QE/2*"+-5$-*9:"7'5"$%%":'0-."45'B/2*5+"+*-"$5'062"-.*"-5/0(B/5$-*"'7"

/67'5($-/'6"$2B/&*"$62"90/2$6&*>"-$59*-*2":'0-."+044'5->"$62"4'+/-/B*"$&-/B/-/*+"7'5":'069"4*'4%*"

G^5$/%*:"?@@VIJ"

Page 94: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

P\"

"

8/(/%$5%:"('-/B$-*2>"-.*"4'%/&*"$--*62*2":'0-."&%01"+*++/'6+"-'"W/(45'B*"-.*/5"5*%$-/'6+./4+Y"

E/-."-.*"%'&$%":'0-.J"K.*"4'%/&*"E*5*"'B*5E.*%(/69%:"2/+-50+-*2"1:"-.*"F/62+"'7":'069"4*'4%*"

-.*:"E*5*"('+-"/6-*5*+-*2"/6J",62"E./%*"-.*"+-5**-+"&'6-$/6*2"$B*60*+"7'5"*+&$4*>"-.*":'0-."

&%01"45'B/2*2"$"&$4-/B*"$02/*6&*"7'5"-.*/5"$2B$6&*+J"K.*:"$%+'"45'B/2*2"$6"/2*$%"+/-*"7'5"

9$-.*5/69"/6-*%%/9*6&*J"K.*:"&'0%2>"$62"2/2>"$+F":'0-."E'5F*5+"-'"/2*6-/7:"W+0+4/&/'0+Y":'069"

4*'4%*"$62"-.*:"$+F*2"-'"+**"-.*"5*9/+-*5"$62"4*5+'6$%"2*-$/%+"F*4-"'6"7/%*"G-./+"E$+"2*&%/6*2IJ"A"

+$E"4'%/&*"'77/&*5+"25/6F/69"-.*/5"-*$"E./%*"&'620&-/69"+05B*/%%$6&*J"K.*:"+-''2"'0-+/2*"E./%*"

-E*6-:":'069"4*'4%*"4%$:*2"/6"75'6-"'7"-.*(J",+"-.*:"E$-&.*2"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"&%/(1/69"

-.5'09."-.*"+($%%*5"$4*5-05*+"'7"-.*"&%/(1/69"75$(*>"-.*:"'4*6%:"2/+&0++*2"E.'"(/9.-".$B*"

1**6"5*+4'6+/1%*"7'5"$"+4$-*"'7"%'&$%"1059%$5/*+J"T6*":'069"($6".$2"$%5*$2:"1**6"$+F*2"-'"

$44*$5"/6"$"4'%/&*"%/6*Q04J"_*".$26Y-"1**6"&'6B/&-*2":*->"10-"./+"2*C-*5/-:"'6"-.*"&%/(1/69"

75$(*"+**(*2"-'"($F*"/-"/6&5*$+/69%:"%/F*%:J"

_'E*B*5>"-./+"E$+"6'-"-.*"'6%:"E$:"-.$-"-.*"0675**2'(+"'7"-.*"+-5**-"1*&$(*"/6&'54'5$-*2"

/6-'"-.*"7$15/&"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01J"K.5'09."4$5-6*5+./4"E'5F/69>"-.*"4'%/&*"$62"-.*":'0-."

E'5F*5+"+.$5*2"/6-*%%/9*6&*"'6":'069"4*'4%*J"K.*"4'%/&*"/6"U*E.$("($/6-$/6*2"$"%/+-"'7"-.'+*"

('+-"$-"W5/+FY"'7"&'((/--/69"&5/(/6$%"$&-/B/-:J"K.*"%/+-"E$+"+.$5*2"E/-.":'0-."+*5B/&*"45'B/2*5+"

E.'"('6/-'5*2"-.*"5*+4*&-/B*"/62/B/20$%+J"Z'069"4*'4%*"E.'"(/9.-"45*B/'0+%:"6'-".$B*"1**6"

15'09.-"-'"-.*"$--*6-/'6"'7":'0-."E'5F*5+"E*5*"W%$1*%%*2Y"G,%*C$62*5"!PPej"S'.*6"?@@?I"$62"

B/*E*2"$+"4'-*6-/$%%:"&5/(/6$%J"

"

d./%*"+'(*":'0-."E'5F*5+"$445'B*2"'7"-.*+*"/6/-/$-/B*+>"'-.*5+"E*5*"+&*4-/&$%"$62"&'6&*56*2"

-.$-"$".$52QE'6"-50+-"E$+"1*/69"*5'2*2"$+":'069"4*'4%*"+$E":'0-."E'5F*5+"+/2/69"E/-."-.*"

*6*(:J"T6"-./+"1$+/+>"8$1/.$>"-.*"&*6-5*"($6$9*5"$-"^5''F15/29*"Z'0-."S%01>"5*+/+-*2"&'Q

'4*5$-/'6"E/-.".*5"%'&$%"$0-.'5/-:"1'++*+"'B*5":'0-."E'5F*5+Y"4$5-/&/4$-/'6"/6"'0-5*$&."

4$-5'%+J"8.*"+$E"-.*"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"'7":'0-."&%01+"$+"$"45'1%*(>"$+"+.*"2/2"-.*"&'Q'4-/'6"'7"

:'0-."E'5F*5+"/6"4'%/&*"45'H*&-+J"R$/+/69"&'6&*56+".*%2"1:"'-.*5":'0-."E'5F*5+>"+.*"

($/6-$/6*2"-.$-"-.*":'0-."&%01"+.'0%2"1*"$"4%$&*"E.*5*":'069"4*'4%*"7*%-"75**"$62"+$7*J"

=%$:/69"-.5'09."$"7/&-/-/'0+"+&*6$5/'>"+.*"/($9/6*2"1*/69"45*+*6-"'6"$6"'0-5*$&."4$-5'%"$+"$"

:'069"4*5+'6"+.*"F6*E"E$+"$55*+-*2J"K.*"-50+-"+.*".$2"10/%-"04"E'0%2"1*"%'+->"+.*"-'%2"(*>"/7"

-.*":'069"4*'4%*"+$E".*5"$+"$"+4:"7'5"-.*"&'4+J"d/%%>"$-";*:.$(>".$2"2/77*5*6-"5*+*5B$-/'6+J"_*"

F6*E"-.$-"$6:"4*5&*/B*2"75/*62+./4"E/-."-.*"4'%/&*"&$55/*2"-.*"5/+F"'7":'069"4*'4%*"-./6F/69".*"

E$+"$"95$++J"K.*"&'6+*h0*6&*+"'7"-./+"(/9.-"1*"./+"4$5*6-+Y".'(*>"E.*5*".*"$%+'"%/B*2>"9*--/69"

/-+"E/62'E+"+($+.*2J"d./%*"8$1/.$"E$+"&'6&*56*2"-'"($/6-$/6"-.*":'0-."&%01"$+"$6"/6+-/-0-/'6"

Page 95: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

PN"

"

-.$-"4%$&*2"-.*"6**2+"'7":'069"4*'4%*"$-"/-+"&*6-5*>"d/%%Y+"5*+*5B$-/'6+"+.'E*2"-.*"%'69"

./+-'5:"'7"2/+-50+-"$62"$6-/Q4'%/&*"+*6-/(*6-"/6"E'5F/69Q&%$++"T0-*5"<$+-";'62'6J"

"

_'E*B*5>";*:.$(Y+"($6$9*5>"U*/%>"E$+"('5*"*6-.0+/$+-/&J","1*%/*B*5"/6"&'((06/-:"

4$5-/&/4$-/'6"$62"%'&$%"*(4'E*5(*6->".*"+$E"H'/6-"E'5F/69"$+"$"4'+/-/B*"+-*4"/6"2*B*%'4/69"

%'&$%"7'5(+"'7"&/-/a*6+./4"-.$-"&'0%2"5*20&*"&5/(*"$62"1*"('5*"5*+4'6+/B*"-'":'069"4*'4%*f"

"

A"$("$"1*%/*B*5"/6"-.*"E.'%*".$44*6/69>"5/9.-J"[+*"/-"$+"$"E.'%*J"`6/7*"&5/(*"E'6Y-"1*"+-'44*2"1:"a*5'"-'%*5$6&*"75'("4'%/&*>"5/9.->"10-"/-"&$6"1*"+-'44*2"1:"a*5'"-'%*5$6&*"75'("4'%/&*j"/-"&$6"1*"+-'44*2"75'("0+"E'5F/69"'05"-5$2*"$62"E'5F/69"/-"45'4*5%:j"-*$&.*5+"*20&$-/69"g"$"E.'%*"g"$%%"2*4$5-(*6-+"&'(/69"/6"$62"E'5F/69"E/-."/-J"K.*5*"/+"$"4'+/-/B*"*62"-'"/->"/7"-.*:".$B*"4$-/*6&*"$62"/7"-.*"E.'%*"E'5F+J"

"U*/%Y+"*6-.0+/$+("7'5"4$5-6*5+./4"E'5F/69"E$+"/2*'%'9/&$%"10-"$%+'"45$9($-/&J"K./+"E$+"

2*('6+-5$-*2"E.*6".*"40-"-.*"&%01"7'5E$52"$+"$"W&'((06/-:".01YJ"WS'((06/-:".01Y"E$+"-.*"

+-$-0+"9/B*6"-'"-.*"1'5'09.Y+"('+-"/(4'5-$6-"g"0+0$%%:"-.*"%$59*+-"g"&'((06/-:"7$&/%/-/*+J"K.*:"

.'0+*2":'0-."&%01+>"%/15$5/*+"$62"'-.*5"+'&/$%"+*5B/&*+J"

"

]'5"('+-"'7"-.*"-/(*"A"E'5F*2"$-";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01>"/-"E$+"062*5"-.5*$-"'7"&%'+05*J"K.*"&%01"

.$2"45*B/'0+%:"1*%'69*2"-'"-.*"%'&$%"$0-.'5/-:>"E.'"*/9.-":*$5+"*$5%/*5".$2".$62*2"'E6*5+./4"

'7"/-"'B*5"-'"-.*"-./52"+*&-'5"'59$6/+$-/'6"-.$-"6'E"5$6"-.*"+/-*J",+"4$5-"'7"-./+"$55$69*(*6->"

-.*"%'&$%"$0-.'5/-:".$2"$95**2"-'"7062"-.*":'0-."&%01"7'5"-.*"7/5+-"7*E":*$5+"E./%*"-.*"6*E"

'E6*5+"40-"70625$/+/69"+-5$-*9/*+"/6"4%$&*J"K./+"95$&*"4*5/'2".$2"&'(*"-'"$6"*62"$62"E$+"

1*/69"5*6*E*2"'6"$6"$660$%"1$+/+"E./%*"-.*"6*E"'E6*5+"&'6-/60*2"+*$5&./69"7'5"$"5*B*60*"

+-5*$(J"K.*"7**%/69"$('69"-.*"+-$77"E$+"-.$-"-./+"$55$69*(*6-"E'0%2"&'6-/60*>"10-"-./+"2/2"

6'-"-$F*"/6-'"$&&'06-"-.*"401%/&"+4*62/69"&0-+"-.$-"E*5*"$1'0-"-'"./-"-.*"1'5'09.J"A6"?@!@>"

U*E.$("45*4$5*2"-'"062*5-$F*"-.*"./9.*+-"401%/&"+4*62/69"&0-+"/6";'62'6"G^^S"?@!@IJ",+"$"

5*+0%->"-.*"7062/69"E$+"6'-"5*6*E*2"$62"-.*"+-$77"G-.*"7*E"-.$-"E*5*"4*5($6*6->"('+-"E*5*"

+*++/'6$%I"E*5*"40-"'6"5*2062$6&:"6'-/&*J"U*/%Y+"*6-.0+/$+("7'5"-.*":'0-."&%01"1*&'(/69"$"

.01"E$+"4$5-"'7"$6"$--*(4-"-'"($F*"-.*"+/-*"B/$1%*"$9$/6"/6"-.*"*:*+"'7"7062*5+J"

"

K.*"&0-+"$%+'"2/5*&-%:"&'6-5/10-*2"-'"$6"/6&5*$+*"/6"-.*"4'%/&*"45*+*6&*"$-";*:.$(J"^*7'5*"-.*"

&0-+>"-.*":'0-."&%01".$2"($6$9*2"-'"'4*5$-*"E/-."5*%$-/B*"$0-'6'(:"75'("-.*"4'%/&*J"

S''4*5$-/'6".$2"*C/+-*2"$%'69+/2*"$"B/15$6-"$9*62$"'7"9$(*+"$62"$&-/B/-/*+>"5'%%*2"'0-"1:"$6"

*6-.0+/$+-/&"E'5F7'5&*J",+"-.*"&0-+"./->"1'-."*h0/4(*6-"$62"('5$%*"E$+"5*20&*2J"d/-."6'-./69"

Page 96: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

Pe"

"

-'"2'>"$62"6'"'6*"-'"2'"/-"E/-.>"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"+-$5-*2"($F/69"-.*/5"'E6"706"('&F/69"-.*"

:'0-."&%01Y+"$0-.'5/-:J",-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"$--*62$6&*"$-"-.*"*B*6/69"+*++/'6+"5'+*"+.$54%:>"$62"

($6:"6*E"(*(1*5+"$55/B*2>"+'(*"E/-."&.$%%*69/69"1*.$B/'05+J"d.*5*$+"$":*$5"*$5%/*5"-.*:"

E'0%2".$B*"1**6"*$+/%:"/6-*95$-*2>"$"2*('5$%/+*2"E'5F7'5&*"&*2*2"$0-.'5/-:J"K.*5*"E*5*"

5*90%$5"7/9.-+>"$10+*"-'E$52+"+-$77>"10%%:/69>"-.*"15*$F/69"'7":'0-."&%01"45'4*5-:>"$62"(/+0+*"'7"

-.*"+/-*"G9'/69"1*./62"-.*"10/%2/69>"9'/69"04"-'"-.*"(*aa$6/6*"E.*5*":'0-."E'5F*5+".$2"-.*/5"

2*+F"+4$&*+IJ"A6"-./+"*6B/5'6(*6->"+-$77"1*&$(*"&'6&*56*2"7'5"-.*/5"'E6"4.:+/&$%"+$7*-:>"$62"

$%-.'09."+'(*"E*5*"06&'(7'5-$1%*"E/-."-.*"2*&/+/'6>"$"4'%/&*"45*+*6&*"E$+"2**(*2"

/6&5*$+/69%:"6*&*++$5:J"]$&/%/-$-*2"1:"-.*"&'6-$&-+"*+-$1%/+.*2"-.5'09."4$5-6*5+./4"/6/-/$-/B*+>"

-.*"4'%/&*"1*&$(*"/62/+4*6+$1%*"$%%/*+>"$62"E.$-"0+*2"-'"1*"25'4Q/6+"1*&$(*"$%%Q6/9.-"B/+/-+J"

K.*5*"E$+"*B*6"$"50('05"40-"$5'062"-.$-";*:.$("E$+"9'/69"-'"9*-"1056-"2'E6"+'"-.$-"-.*"

4'%/&*"E'0%2"$--*62"('5*"5*90%$5%:J"K.5'09."4$5-6*5+./4"E'5F/69"$62"7062/69"&0-+>"-.*"

&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"-.$-".$2"'&&055*2"'6"-.*"+-5**-+"*6-*5*2"-.*":'0-."&%01J"

"

Z'069"4*'4%*"45'-*+-*2"$9$/6+-"-.*"6*E"4'%/&*"45*+*6&*J"K.*+*"45'-*+-+"E*5*"6'-"062*5-$F*6"

'6"-.*"1$+/+"'7"$1+-5$&-"&'6&*56+"7'5"-.*"W5/9.-"-'"-.*"&/-:Y"G;*7*1B5*"!PPej"#*55/7/*%2"?@!!I"'5"

W+4$-/$%"H0+-/&*Y"G#$5&0+*"?@@Pj"8'H$"?@!@I"10-"5$-.*5"$+"$"5*+4'6+*"-'"-.*"4'%/&*Y+"

*6&5'$&.(*6-"/6-'"E.$-"-.*:"7*%-"G$62".$2"1**6"*6&'05$9*2"-'"1*%/*B*I"E$+"-.*/5"-*55/-'5:J"T6"

-./+"1$+/+>"-.*:"&'6-*+-*2"-.*"4'%/&*"$62"&'((06/-:"+044'5-"'77/&*5Y+"45*+*6&*"/6"-.*":'0-."

&%01J"K.*"&'((06/-:"+044'5-"'77/&*5"E.'"('B*2"-.*("'6"75'("+-5**-"&'56*5+"$62"&'06&/%"7%$-"

+-$/5E*%%+"E$+"5'0-/6*%:"9'$2*2J"Z'069"4*'4%*"&$%%*2"./("$"WE$6F*5Y"1*./62"./+"1$&F"G%'02"

*6'09."7'5"./("-'".*$5I"$62"-5/*2"-'"+-*$%"./+".$-J"K.*:"E$6-*2"./("-'"5*-$%/$-*"+'"-.*:"&'0%2"

&'67/5(".*"2/26Y-".$B*"-.*"4'E*5"-'"$55*+-"-.*(J"d.$-".*"-''F"$E$:"75'("-.*("'6"-.*"+-5**-"

-.*:"+'09.-"-'"E/6"1$&F"/6"-.*"+$7*-:"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01J"K.*"4'%/&*"E*5*"&$%%*2"W'77/&*5Y"

+$5&$+-/&$%%:"g"$"-*5("'7"$10+*"5$-.*5"-.$6"2*7*5*6&*"g"$62"E*5*"&'6-/60$%%:"&.$%%*69*2"-'"

$55*+-"-.*("7'5"$6:"60(1*5"'7"5*$%"'5"/6B*6-*2"&5/(*+J"A6"-./+"E$:>"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"+'09.-"-'"

($F*"$"('&F*5:"'7"-.*"$0-.'5/-:"-.*:"*(1'2/*2J")$&F>"7'05-**6>"E$+"'7-*6"$-"-.*"7'5*75'6-"'7"

-.*+*"*62*$B'05+J";*2"1:")$&F>"$"95'04"'7":'069"(*6"&%/(1*2"'6-'"-.*"5''7"'7"-.*"$2B*6-05*"

4%$:95'062"-'"+.'0-"$62"2/5*&-"4*%B/&"-.50+-+"$-"-.*"7/B*"4'%/&*"'77/&*5+"$++*(1%*2"1*%'EJ"K'"

-.*/5"$(0+*(*6->"-.*"'77/&*5+"&'0%2"2'"6'-./69J"K.*/5"06&'(7'5-$1%*"%''F+"$62"/6+/6&*5*"

+(/%*+"+.'E*2"-.*/5"$0-.'5/-:".$2"1**6"&$%%*2"/6-'"h0*+-/'6J"_'E*B*5>"E./%*"-.*+*"$&-+"'7"

5*+/+-$6&*"E*5*"('5*"95$4./&"-.$6"E.$-"E'0%2".$B*"1**6"4*5(/--*2"1:"-.*"4'%/&*"'6"-.*"

+-5**->"5$-.*5"-.$6"2/+504-"-.*"&5/(/6$%/+*2"2*%/(/-$-/'6+"'7"'52*5"$62"2/+'52*5"/6"-.*"%'&$%"$5*$"

Page 97: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

PM"

"

-.*":'069"4*'4%*"&'67/5(*2"/-J"K.*"5/2/&0%/69"%$59*%:"-''F"$2B$6-$9*"'7"-.*"+$7*-:"'7"-.*":'0-."

&%01"$62"-.*5*7'5*"+-$:*2"E/-./6"-.*"4'%/&*Y+"2*%/(/-$-/'6"'7"401%/&"+4$&*"g"-.*"+-5**-"$+"&.$'+"

$62"-.*":'0-."&%01"$+"'52*5J",+"%'69"$+"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"/6"-.*":'0-."&%01+"$62"6'-"'6"

-.*"+-5**-+>"-.*/5"B/&-'5:"&'0%2"'6%:"1*"4$5-/$%J"

"

,&-+"-.$-"&.$%%*69*2"-.*"4'%/&*Y+"+'&/$%"$62"-*55/-'5/$%"&$-*9'5/*+"'7"&'6-5'%"E*5*"('5*"

+01B*5+/B*J"8'&/$%"$62"-*55/-'5/$%"$++/96$-/'6+"'7"&.$'+"$62"'52*5"E*5*"0+*2"1:"-.*"4'%/&*"$+"

7'5(+"'7"1/'4'%/-/&$%"4'E*5OP"G]'0&$0%-"?@@OI"-'"&'6-$/6"$62"($6$9*"-.*".*-*5'9*6*/-:"$62"

-.*5*7'5*"06&*5-$/6-:"'7"-.*"%'&$%"*6B/5'6(*6-"G^*5($6"!PVej";*7*1B5*"!PPej"8*66*--"!PPOIJ"

K.*"A6-5'20&-/'6"45*+*6-*2"-.*"+04*5Q2/B*5+*"2*('95$4./&+"'7"-.*"1'5'09.J"K.*+*"

2*('95$4./&+"&$0+*2"+4*&/7/&"45'1%*(+"7'5"4'%/&/69"-.*"%'&$%"$5*$"1*&$0+*"($6:"'7"-.*":'069"

4*'4%*"/6"U*E.$("2/2"6'-"7/-"*$+/%:"/6-'"-.*"-./5-:Q:*$5Q'%2"WASY"*-.6/&"&'2*+\@"0+*2"1:"-.*"

#*-5'4'%/-$6"='%/&*"-'"2*+&5/1*"$62"-.*5*1:"&'6-5'%"4'-*6-/$%"&5/(/6$%/-:J";/F*E/+*"-.*"

('B*(*6-"'7":'069"4*'4%*"1*-E**6"75/*62+./4"95'04+"$62"2/77*5*6-"-*55/-'5/$%"$62"

/6+-/-0-/'6$%"$%%*9/$6&*+"(*$6-"-.*"4'%/&*".$2"$".$52"-/(*"$&&'06-/69"7'5":'069"4*'4%*"'6"

-*55/-'5/$%"-*5(+J",+"`*B/6>"'6*"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"$-";*:.$("4'/6-*2"'0->"75/*62+./4"95'04+"

7%0&-0$-*2j":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"75/*62+"'6*"2$:"$62"6'-"-.*"6*C-j"$62>"*B*5:'6*"+**(*2"-'"

F6'E"*B*5:'6*>"*B*6"/7"-.*:"E*5*"6'-"2/5*&-%:"75/*62+"E/-."-.*(J"`:%/*>"'6*"'7"-.*":'069"

4*'4%*"$-";*:.$(>"$%+'"6'-*2"-.*"7%0/2/-:"$62"&'6-5$2/&-'5:"6$-05*"'7"($6:"%'&$%"$%%/$6&*+f"

"

K.*5*Y+"4*'4%*"/6"K.$(*+105:"+&.''%"E.'"%/B*"5'062".*5*"E.'"E/%%"+-/%%".$B*"$"7/9.-"E/-."$";*:.$("4*5+'6J",62"-.*5*"/+"4*'4%*"/6"S*6-5$%"8&.''%"E.'"%/B*"5'062".*5*"E.'"E/%%"+-/%%".$B*"$"7/9.-"E/-."$";*:.$("4*5+'6J"<B*6"-.'09."*B*5:";*:.$("4*5+'6"5'062".*5*"9'*+"-'"-.$-"+&.''%>"%/B*+"/6"-./+"$5*$J"8'"1$+/&$%%:":'0"$5*"7/9.-/69":'05"'E6"75/*62+"1*&$0+*"'7":'05"+&.''%J"

""

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""OP"]'0&$0%-"6'-*+"-.$-"($6$9*(*6-"/+"$-"-.*".*$5-"'7"6*'Q%/1*5$%"9'B*56$6&*J"#*&.$6/+(+>"

-*&.6'%'9/*+>"2/+&'05+*+"$62"45$&-/&*+"E'5F"-'"5*90%$5/a*"-.*"5$62'("*%*(*6-"-.$-"/+".0($6"%/7*"

G]'0&$0%-"?@@OIJ"\@"lK.*"WAS"!QeY"/2*6-/-:"&'2*+".$B*"1**6"0+*2"G$62"$5*"+-/%%"1*/69"0+*2I"$62"5*&'96/+*2"1:"-.*"

#*-5'4'%/-$6"='%/&*"8*5B/&*"7'5"'B*5"-./5-:":*$5+J"K.*+*"&'2*+"$5*"0+*2"1:"'77/&*5+"-'"/2*6-/7:"4*'4%*"

0+/69"15'$2>"*$+/%:"2*7/6*2"$62"5*&'96/+$1%*"95'04+"g"$6"*++*6-/$%"4$5-"'7"5'0-/6*"4'%/&*"E'5FJn"K.*"

&'2*+"$5*f"AS"!"g"d./-*"<05'4*$6j"AS"?"g"3$5F"<05'4*$6j"AS"O"g",75'QS$5/11*$6j"AS"\"g",+/$6j"AS"N"g""

T5/*6-$%j"AS"e"g",5$1"G#*-5'4'%/-$6"='%/&*"?@!@IJ"

Page 98: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

PV"

"

K.*"&'6+*h0*6&*"'7"-*55/-'5/$%"$62"*-.6/&".*-*5'9*6*/-:"7'5"4'%/&/69"-.*"%'&$%"$5*$"1*&$(*"

$44$5*6-"'6*"*B*6/69J",-"6/6*"'Y&%'&F>"#$62:>"'6*"'7"-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+>"E$+".$B/69"$"

&/9$5*--*"E.*6"7/B*":'069"4*'4%*"/6&%02/69",1+"&$(*"'B*5"75'("-.*"4$5FJ",1+"E$+"$"+/C-**6Q

:*$5Q'%2"(/C*2"5$&*>"'5",+/$6"GE*"2/26Y-"F6'EI>":'069"4*5+'6"E.'"+'(*-/(*+"$--*62*2"-.*"

:'0-."&%01J"K.*:"+$/2"$"E'($6".$2"1**6"+.'0-/69"$-"-.*("$62"-.*:".$2"+.'0-*2"1$&FJ"K.*5*"

E$+"$"&'(('-/'6"$62"&'6&*56"7'5"-.*"+$7*-:"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01J"A-"2/*2"2'E6"$62"-.*6"-.*"

4'%/&*"&$(*"'B*5"g"7/5+-"-.*"4'%/&*"5*+4'6+/1%*"7'5"-.*"%'&$%"4$5F"$62"-.*6"-.*"%'&$%"4'%/&*($6J"

,&&'52/69"-'"-.*("$"(*6-$%%:"/%%"E'($6".$2"506"$E$:"75'(".*5"&$5*5>"&$0+*2"$"2/+-051$6&*"

E/-."+'(*"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"/6"-.*"4$5F"G'5"-.*"'-.*5"E$:"5'062I"$62"-.*"4'%/&*".$2"4/&F*2"

.*5"04J",9$/6>"/-"2/*2"2'E6J"K.*6"E*".*$52"$"4'%/&*".*%/&'4-*5J"8''6"7/B*"4'%/&*"&$5+"$62"$"

4'%/&*"B$6"E*5*"'6+/-*J"K.*:"E*5*"$44$5*6-%:"$7-*5",1+>"E.'".$2"1**6"+**6"5066/69"$E$:J"

K.*:"1*%/*B*2",1+"E$+"&$55:/69"+'(*-./69>"($:1*"$"F6/7*>"$62"50('05+"+-$5-*2"&/5&0%$-/69J"

]5'("+6/44*-+".*5*"$62"-.*5*"A>"$62"*B*5:'6*"*%+*>"-5/*2"-'"40-"-'9*-.*5"$"6$55$-/B*"'7"E.$-"

.$2".$44*6*2J"K*C-+"E*5*"+*6-"$62"('1/%*+"5$69J"d./%*"-.*"4'%/&*"F6*E"B*5:"%/--%*"'7"E.$-"

E$+"9'/69"'6>"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"$62"('+-"'7"-.*"+-$77"F6*E"+'(*-./69J"

"

;$-*5"'6>"-.*"4'%/&*"&$(*"'B*5"$9$/6J"K.*:"&'0%26Y-"&$-&.",1+"$62"+$/2".*"E$+"l-$F/69"-.*"

4/++nj"0+/69"/-"$+"$"l1$29*"'7".'6'05nJ"K.*:"+$/2".*"E$+"2*%/1*5$-*%:"7%'0-/69"'52*5"$62"E$6-*2"

-'"40-"$"+-'4"-'"/-"1*7'5*"2/+'52*5"+-$5-*2"-'"+45*$2J"K'"2'"-./+"-.*:"6**2*2"('5*"/67'5($-/'6>"

10-"-.*/5"&$-*9'5/*+"7'5"+'&/$%"&'6-5'%"E*5*"-''"&502*J",1+"E$+"-.*"60(1*5"'6*"+0+4*&-"10-"-.*"

4'%/&*Y+"'6%:"*B/2*6&*"E$+"-.*:".$2"+**6"$6",+/$6"1':"'7"./+"10/%2"7%**/69"/6-'"-.*"2$5FJ"

_'E*B*5>"`$5%**>"'6*"'7",1+Y+"75/*62+>"E$+"$2$($6-"/-".$2"1**6"$"(/C*2"5$&*"1':>"E/-."%/9.-*5"

+F/6J"`$5%**"(/9.-".$B*"1**6"%:/69"-'"45'-*&-",1+"'5"-*%%/69"-.*"-50-.J"</-.*5"E$:>"5$&/$%"45'7/%/69"

E$+6Y-"+-5$/9.-7'5E$52"/6"$"4%$&*"%/F*";*:.$("$62"+.*"F6*E"-.$-J"K.*"4'%/&*"$+F*2"$5'062"10-"

6'1'2:"95$++*2J"`6'E%*29*"'7",1+"E$+"*$+:"-'"2*6:J",6"/675*h0*6-"B/+/-'5>",1+Y+"$(1/90'0+"

%'&$-/'6"1*-E**6"-.*":'0-."&%01"$62"-.*"+-5**-"E$+"-'"./+"$2B$6-$9*J"lK.*:"+$:"-.*:"F6'E"

6'-./69"-'"45'-*&-"-.*(+*%B*+n>"#'%%:"+$/2"$7-*5E$52+J"`**4/69"+/%*6-"E$+"$"+-$-*(*6-"'7"

+'%/2$5/-:"$9$/6+-"-.*"4'%/&*"$62"+'(*-./69"$%%"-.*":'069"4*'4%*".$2"$"B*+-*2"/6-*5*+-"/6J"

"

;$-*5"'6>"A"E$+"+-$62/69"E/-."U*/%>"-.*"&*6-5*"($6$9*5>"E.*6"`:%/*"&$(*"'B*5J"ld.:"$5*"-.*"

4'%/&*"/6"-.*":'0-."&%01"$9$/6in"+.*"&'(4%$/6*2J"A"+:(4$-./+*2J"U*/%"*C4%$/6*2"-.$-"-.*:"

E$6-*2"-'"+**"-.*":'069"4*'4%*Y+"5*9/+-5$-/'6"7'5(+"+'"-.*:"&'0%2"A3",1+J"_*".$2"&'6+*6-*2J"

_*"E$+"5*-056/69"$"7$B'05"g"45'-*&-/'6"7'5"/67'5($-/'6J"^0-".*"$%+'"*C4%$/6*2"-.*"5*&/45'&$-/'6"

Page 99: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

PP"

"

E$+"'6%:"/6"45/6&/4%*J"_*"2/26Y-"F**4"5*9/+-5$-/'6"7'5(+J"A-".$2"$%E$:+"+**(*2"$6"'B*5+/9.-"10-"

-.*"%$&F"'7"&'(4%/$6&*"/6"-./+"-*&.6'%'9:"'7"+05B*/%%$6&*"6'E"+**(*2"6*&*++$5:J"U*/%"*C4%$/6*2"

-.$-"$%-.'09.".*"E$6-*2"-'".*%4>".*"&'0%26Y-J"A-"+**(*2"$+"/7".*".$2"4%$:*2"-./+"9$(*"1*7'5*J"

`**6"'6"4$5-6*5+./4"E'5F/69>"705-.*5"7062/69"$62"45'-*&-/'6>"U*/%"E$6-*2"$"5*%$-/'6+./4"E/-."

-.*"4'%/&*"10-"6'-"$-"-.*"*C4*6+*"'7"95$++/69"'6"-.*":'069"4*'4%*J"

"

,"7*E"('6-.+"%$-*5",1+"&$(*"1$&FJ"A"90*++"/-".$2"1%'E6"'B*5J"A"2/26Y-"$+FJ"_*"H0+-"-'%2"(*".*"

E$6-*2"-'"F**4"./+".*$2"2'E6>"2'"+'(*-./69"4'+/-/B*>"$62"E*"+-$5-*2"4%$:/69"4''%J"

"

K.5'09.'0-"-.*"-/(*"A".$2"E'5F*2"$-";*:.$(>"-.*":'0-."&%01".$2"1**6"2*+/96$-*2"$+"$"+/-*"'7"

'52*5"1:"-.*"4'%/&*"$62"-.*"+-5**-+"$+"$"+/-*"'7"2/+'52*5J"K'"-./+"*C-*6->"-.*":'0-."&%01".$2"

$%E$:+"1**6"/6B'%B*2"/6"($/6-$/6/69"-*55/-'5/$%"9'B*56$6&*J"_'E*B*5>"-.*"/6&/2*6-"E/-.",1+"

2*('6+-5$-*2".'E"6*E"9'B*56$6&*"45$&-/&*+"E*5*"1*/69"$44%/*2J"K.5'09."4$5-6*5+./4"

E'5F/69"$62"-.*"&0-+>"-.*"4'%/&/69"'7"-.*"+-5**-+".$2"*C-*62*2"/6-'"-.*":'0-."&%01J",62"E./%*"

-.*/5"5$-/'6$%*"7'5"/6B'%B*(*6-"E$+"1*6/96>"-.*"5*$%/-:"E$+"-.$-"-.*":'0-."&%01".$2"1*&'(*"

/6&5*$+/69%:"&5/(/6$%/+*2J"K.*"45'-*+-+"75'("-.*":'069"4*'4%*"'B*5"-.*"4'%/&*Y+"45*+*6&*"/6"-.*"

:'0-."&%01"2/2"%/--%*"-'"2/+504-"-.*+*"6*E"'52*5+J"_'E*B*5>",1+Y+"1$6$%"&.$%%*69*"-'"-.*"

-*55/-'5/$%"$62"+'&/$%"&$-*9'5/*+"-.*"4'%/&*"0+*2"E$+"('5*"+01B*5+/B*J"3*('6+-5$-/69"-.*"

75$9/%/-:"'7"-.*/5"4'E*5>"-.*"4'%/&*Y+"5*+4'6+*"E$+"*(4.$-/&J",".*%/&'4-*5>"7/B*"&$5+"$62"$"B$6"

E*5*"+*6-"'0-"-'"+-'4"-.*"2/+'52*5"1*7'5*"/-"+45*$2J"

?J S5*$-/69"&'((06/-:"'E6*5+./4""

A6"&'6H06&-/'6"E/-."-.*"4'%/&*"$62"-.*"6*E"5*9/(*+"'7"'52*5"$62"2/+'52*5>";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01"

45'20&*2"/-+"'E6"7'5("'7"('5$%"&'((06/-:"062*5"-.*".*$2/69"W&'((06/-:"'E6*5+./4YJ";/F*"

%'&$%"4$5-6*5+./4"E'5F/69>"-./+"7'5("'7"9'B*56$6&*"E$+"4$5-"'7"-.*"+./7-"75'("$"&*6-5$%/+*2"

E*%7$5*"+-$-*"$44$5$-0+"-'"-.*"6*'Q%/1*5$%"4'%/-/&+"'7"*6-5*45*6*05+./4"G^5*66*5"?@@!>"?@@\j"

_$5B*:"!PVP1j"#$&;*'2"$62"X'2E/6"!PPPj"=*&F"?@@?j"R0++*%%"?@@Nj"8E:69*2'0E"!PPMIJ"A6"

4$5-/&0%$5>"&'((06/-:"'E6*5+./4"E$+"4$5-"'7"-.*"2/+&0++/'6"'6"&'((06/-:"*(4'E*5(*6->"

5*+4'6+/1/%/-:"$62"%'&$%"&/-/a*6+./4"-.$-"&.$5$&-*5/+*2"U*E";$1'05Y+"W5'%%Q'0-Y"'7"+'&/$%"+*5B/&*+"

-'"-./52"+*&-'5"45'B/2*5+"G^5*66*5"$62"K.*'2'5*"?@@?j"S/B/%"R*6*E$%"[6/-"?@@\j")*++'4"?@@?j"

=*&F"$62"K/&F*%%"?@@?IJ",-";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01>"W&'((06/-:"'E6*5+./4Y"$++0(*2"$"W6*'Q

&'((06/-$5/$6Y"&.$5$&-*5"G=*&F"$62"K/&F*%%"?@@?j"=*&F"?@@?j"=05&*%%"?@@Oj"8E:69*2'0E"?@@@IJ"

Page 100: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!@@"

"

;/F*"-.*"4'%/&*>":'0-."E'5F*5+"$-";*:.$("2*7/6*2"-.*":'0-."&%01"$+"$"+/-*"'7"'52*5J"K.*"/2*$"'7"

'52*5"'6%:"($2*"+*6+*"E.*6"2/+'52*5"E$+"$%+'"*+-$1%/+.*2"$62"$-";*:.$("-./+"'&&055*2"

-.5'09."$"B$5/*-:"'7"6$55$-/B*+"-.$-"2*7/6*2"&.$'-/&":'069"4*'4%*"-.5'09."4'40%$5"(*2/$"$62"

%'&$%"/($9*5:"G+**"S.$4-*5"]'05IJ"^0-"-.*"'52*5"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01"$%+'".$2"$"4'+/-/B*"/2*6-/-:J"

K./+"25*E"'6"-.*"/($9/6$-/'6"'7"$0-'&.-.'6'0+"&'((06/-:"G2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"KE'IJ"K.*"

&'67%0*6&*"'7"-.*+*"2/+&'05+*+"%*2"-'"$"W9$-*2"&'((06/-:Y"(*6-$%/-:"$+"-.*":'0-."&%01"

+/(0%-$6*'0+%:"&'6+-50&-*2"/-+*%7"$62"-.*"-.5*$-"/-"7$&*2"G,6a$%2t$"?@@Mj"^%$F*%:"$62"86:2*5"

!PPPj"^5'E6"?@!@j";'E"?@@Oj"R'+*"$62"#/%%*5"?@@Vj"8*66*--"!PPOIJ"

"

35$E/69"'6"-.*+*"6*'Q&'((06/-$5/$6"6$55$-/B*+>"W&'((06/-:"'E6*5+./4Y"&'(1/6*2"%'&$%"

&/-/a*6+./4>"-.5*$-"$62"$0-'&.-.'6:"/6-'"$"-.*'5:"$62"45$&-/&*"'7"%'&$%"9'B*56$6&*J",+"U*/%"

6'-*2f"

"

A"-./6F"4*'4%*"$5*"B*5:"$4$-.*-/&J"#:"4./%'+'4.:"/+"-.$-"4*'4%*"2'6Y-"-$%F"'B*5"-.*"7*6&*J"d.*6"4*'4%*"0+*2"-'"-$%F"'B*5"-.*"7*6&*"-.*:"0+*2"-'".$B*"-./+"4./%'+'4./&$%"-.'09.-"45'&*++>"E.*-.*5"-.*:"F6*E"/-"'5"6'->"$62"-.$-"-$%F/69"'B*5"-.*"7*6&*"E'0%2"1*"%/F*"-.*"10--*57%/*+"+-$5-/69"-.*".055/&$6*J"A-"E'0%2"+-$5-"-.$-J"Z'0"E'0%2"9*-"-./+"/6+-$6-"-$%F"$%%"'B*5"-.*"&'((06/-:>"-./+"/6+-$6-"$&-/'6"$62"/6-*95$-/'6"$%%"'B*5"-.*"&'((06/-:J"U'E"/-"/+"$"&%'+*2Q2''5"&'((06/-:J"

"

rA"E'0%2"%/F*"-'"+**s"&'(4%*-*"'E6*5+./4"'7"-.*"&%01"1*&$0+*"/7"-.*:".$2"&'(4%*-*"'E6*5+./4>"A"&'0%2"25$E"m"$"95$4."'7"'E6*5+./4J"A"&'0%2"25$E"75/*62%/6*++>"5*+4*&-"'7"95'062"50%*+>"5*+4*&-"'7"*$&."'-.*5>"5/9.-i"A7"-.*:".$2"'E6*5+./4>"5/9.-i"K./+"/+"-.*/5"&%01J"A7":'0"E$6-"-'"&'(*"/6-'"'05"&%01>"2'6Y-"E5*&F"/->":'0"9'"1:"'05"95'062"50%*+J"8'"A"-./6F"'E6*5+./4"g"-.$-"/+"E.$-"A"$("-5:/69"-'"&5*$-*"g"'E6*5+./4"7/5+-"$('69+-"$%%"-./69+J"A"E'0%26Y-"9*-"-.*"B$62$%/+(J"A"E'0%26Y-"9*-"-.*"&.**FJ"W_*:"($6>"-./+"/+"'05"&%01>"2'6Y-"E5*&F"/-JY"AYB*"+**6".'%*+"406&.*2"/6"E$%%+J"A7"-.*5*"E$+"'E6*5+./4>"-.*"4**5+"'7"-.*"&%01"E'0%2"1*"9'/69>"W_*:"-./+"/+"'05+J"3'6Y-"E5*&F"'05+YJ"K./+"/+"'05"%/--%*"4%$&*J"

"

,-"$6"*B*6-"&$%%*2"W]5/*62+"'7";*:.$(Y>"/-"1*&$(*"$44$5*6-"-.$-"-.*+*"/2*$+"E*5*"E/2*%:"

+.$5*2"1:":'069"4*'4%*"$62"+-$77J"W]5/*62+"'7";*:.$(Y"E$+"4$5-"'7"U*/%Y+"B/+/'6"-'"*+-$1%/+."

;*:.$("$+"$".01J"K.*"B/+/'6>"U*/%"+$/2>"E$+"$1'0-"l*B*5:1'2:"&'(/69"-'9*-.*5n":'069"4*'4%*>"

4$5*6-+"$62"5*45*+*6-$-/B*+"75'("%'&$%"+*5B/&*"45'B/2*5+>"/6"-.*"/6-*5*+-"'7"*+-$1%/+./69"$"%'&$%"

7'5("'7"'E6*5+./4J"A6"-.*"45*&*2/69"2$:+>":'069"4*'4%*".$2"1**6"&'6+0%-*2"'6"-.*"(**-/69"

$62".$2"$95**2"-'"$--*62j"+*6/'5"7/905*+"/6";*:.$(Y+"4$5*6-"'59$6/+$-/'6>"-.*"%'&$%"4'%/&*>"

'-.*5"+*5B/&*"45'B/2*5+"$62"4$5*6-+"E*5*"/6B/-*2j"$62"7''2"E$+"%$/2"'6J"T6"-.*"6/9.->"-./5-:"

Page 101: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!@!"

"

%'&$%":'069"4*'4%*"&$(*"-'"2/+&0++"-.*/5"6**2+>"%'&$%"7$&/%/-/*+"$62"-.*"70-05*"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01J"

=$5*6-+"$62"%'&$%"+*5B/&*"45'B/2*5+"2/2"6'-"$44*$5>"$62"-.*"4'%/&*"$55/B*2"$7-*5"/-".$2"$%%"

7/6/+.*2J"K.*"4$5*6-+"E*5*"-.'09.-"-'"1*"-''"+&$5*2"'5"-''"10+:>"-.*"%'&$%"+*5B/&*"45'B/2*5+"

06/6-*5*+-*2>"$62"-.*"4'%/&*Y+"$1+*6&*"E$+"+'(*E.$-"/5'6/&"+**/69"$+"-.*:"&$(*"6*$5%:"*B*5:"

'-.*5"6/9.-J"K.*"%$&F"'7"/6+-/-0-/'6$%"5*45*+*6-$-/'6"(*$6-"-.*"*B*6-".$2"&.$69*2"/-+"6$-05*"-'"

'6*"-.$-"E$+"$225*++/69"$6"$02/*6&*"'7"($/6%:":'069"4*'4%*J","2/+&0++/'6"$1'0-"-.*"6**2+"

$62"2*+/5*+"'7"-.*"%'&$%"&'((06/-:"E$+"$1$62'6*2>"$62"/6+-*$2"-.*"*B*6/69"+-$5-*2"E/-."$"

4%*6$5:"/6"E./&."-.*":'069"4*'4%*"+4'F*"-'"-.*"3/5*&-'5"'7"-.*"-./52"+*&-'5"'59$6/+$-/'6"G-.$-"

'E6*2";*:.$(I"$1'0-"-.*"7$&/%/-/*+"-.*:"E'0%2"%/F*J"K.*"%*B*%"'7"+/6&*5/-:"$62"*6*59:"E/-."

E./&."-.*":'069"4*'4%*"2/+&0++*2"/(45'B*(*6-+"-'"-.*"%'&$%"$5*$"&$(*"$+"$"+.'&F"-'"('+-"'7"

-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+J",7-*5"-.*"4%*6$5:"+*++/'6>":'069"4*'4%*"$62"+-$77>"(:+*%7"/6&%02*2>"15'F*"

/6-'"7'05"5'-$-/69"2/+&0++/'6"95'04+>"*$&."E/-."$"-.*(*"$62"$"7%/4"&.$5-"7'5"6'-/69"2'E6"

45'4'+$%+J"T6*"'7"-.*"95'04+"E$+"&$%%*2"W&5*$-/69"'E6*5+./4Y"$62"-.*"7%/4"&.$5-"45'20&*2"&$6"

1*"+**6"/6"]/905*"]'05J"

"

"E')03+!E%03.!E1'#!$943,!#3%50$+5!4,!,9+!R$3+4,'()!%C(+3-9'#S!,4T1+!503'()!,9+!E3'+(5-!%F!8+/94&!

+*+(,@!

"

Page 102: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!@?"

"

K.*"7%/4"&.$5-"+.'E*2".'E":'069"4*'4%*"$62"+-$77"B/*E*2"&'((06/-:"'E6*5+./4"

45*2'(/6$6-%:"/6"-*5(+"'7"45'-*&-/69"-.*":'0-."&%01"75'("-.5*$-"g"./9.%/9.-/69"+*&05/-:>"SSKc"

&$(*5$+"$62"$"95*$-*5"4'%/&*"45*+*6&*"$5'062"-.*"&*6-5*J"K./+"E$+"/6"+4/-*"'7"-.*"7$&-"($6:"'7"

-.*"+$(*":'069"4*'4%*"7*%-"06&'(7'5-$1%*"$1'0-"-.*"5*90%$5"45*+*6&*"'7"-.*"4'%/&*"$-"-.*"

:'0-."&%01J"_'E*B*5>"-.*"&.$5-"$%+'"&'B*5*2"/2*$+"'7"4$5-6*5+./4"E'5F/69>"-.*"15*$F/69"2'E6"

'7"WH*$%'0+:Y>"10/%2/69"1*--*5"5*%$-/'6+./4+"$62"&'%%*&-/B*"5*+4'6+/1/%/-:"7'5"-.*"&%01J"TB*5$%%>"/-"

2*('6+-5$-*2".'E"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"$%+'"+$E"-.*":'0-."&%01"$+"$"6*'Q&'((06/-$5/$6"*6-/-:J"

K.*:"6'-*2"/-+"&%'+*2"/2*6-/-:".$2"%*2"-'"5/7-+"E/-."'-.*5"WH*$%'0+Y":'069"4*'4%*>"$62"-.$-"-.*+*"

6**2*2"-'"1*"$225*++*2J"_'E*B*5>"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"-.*:"$&F6'E%*29*2"-.$-"-.*"&%01"+.'0%2"

1*"45'-*&-*2"75'("-.*"'0-+/2*"1:"+05B*/%%$6&*"$62"-.*"4'%/&*J"

S'6+-50&-/69"&.$'+"

U*/%"E$+"750+-5$-*2"$-"$"%$&F"'7"'E6*5+./4"$-"-.*":'0-."&%01"10-"-./+"2/2"6'-"(*$6"-.$-"-.*"

:'069"4*'4%*"$62"+-$77"E*5*"6'-"&%'+*QF6/-J"[6%/F*"^5''F15/29*"Z'0-."S%01"G/6-5'20&*2"/6"

S.$4-*5"T6*I>"-.*"&'5*"+-$77".$2"5*($/6*2"-.*"+$(*"7'5":*$5+>"$62"('+-"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"

.$2"95'E6"04"-'9*-.*5"'6"-.*"+$(*"+-5**-+"$62"-.5'09."-.*":'0-."&%01Y+"4%$:"+&.*(*+J"d./%*"

-./+"2/26Y-"(*$6"-.$-"*B*5:'6*"%/F*2"*$&."'-.*5>"/-"2/2"(*$6"7'5"-.*"('+-"4$5-"-.$-"4*'4%*"

-50+-*2"*$&."'-.*5J"=*5+'6$%"1*%'69/69+"E*5*"%*7-"06$--*62*2>"1/F*+"E*5*"%*7-"'0-+/2*"$62"-.*"

2''5+"E*5*"'4*6"7'5"$6:'6*"-'"E$%F"/6j":*-"/-"E$+"5$5*"-.$-"$6:-./69"E*6-"(/++/69>"'5"-.$-"

$6:'6*"&$(*"/6"E.'"E$+"6'-"$%5*$2:"F6'E6J"

"

K.*+*"7'5(+"'7"/6-/($&:>"$62"/6+-/-0-/'6$%%:"*6&'05$9*2"'E6*5+./4>"E*5*"-/*2"-'9*-.*5"E/-."

%'69"./+-'5/*+"'7"%'&$%"-*55/-'5/$%/-:"g"*+-$1%/+.*2"/6"E'5F/69Q&%$++"&0%-05*"-.5'09."%'&$%"401+>"

4'%/-/&+>"+'&/$%>"5*%/9/'0+"$62"&0%-05$%"/6+-/-0-/'6+"GR'1/6+"$62"S'.*6"!PMV>"4JM\IJ"K./+"E$+"

4$5-/&0%$5%:"-.*"&$+*"/6"5*%$-/'6"-'"-.*"4*5&*/B*2"-.5*$-"*(1'2/*2"/6":'069"4*'4%*"-.$-"&$(*"

75'("#/%%7/*%2J"#/%%7/*%2"6*/9.1'05*2";*:.$("$62"1$2"5*%$-/'6+"1*-E**6"-.*"-E'"4'+-&'2*+"

E$+"+$/2"-'"9'"1$&F"-'"-.*"-/(*"'7"4*'4%*Y+"4$5*6-+J"Z'069"4*'4%*"-'%2"'5$%"./+-'5/*+"'7"7/9.-+>"

-/-Q7'5Q-$-"5*-$%/$-/'6+"$62"'&&$+/'6$%"/6&05+/'6+J"#'+-"+$/2"-.*:"E'0%26Y-"E$%F"/6"#/%%7/*%2"

$%'6*J"K./+"5/B$%5:"1*-E**6"-E'"'7"-.*"('+-"2*45/B*2"4$5-+"'7"-.*"1'5'09.".$2"$%+'"1*&'(*"

5$&/$%%:"($5F*2J",+"2/+&0++*2>";*:.$(".$2"$6"$0-'&.-.'6'0+"&'%%*&-/B*"/($9/6$5:>"$62":'069"

4*'4%*"$62"+-$77"-.*5*"$++'&/$-*2"#/%%7/*%2"E/-."('5*"5*&*6-",75/&$6"/((/95$-/'6"-'"-.*"$5*$J"

,+"+0&."-.*"-*55/-'5/$%"5/B$%5:"1*-E**6"-.*"-E'"$5*$+".$2"1*&'(*"5$&/$%/+*2J";$59*"95'04+"'7"

06F6'E6"1%$&F":'069"4*'4%*"'0-+/2*"-.*"+/-*"E*5*"'7-*6"B/*E*2"+&*4-/&$%%:J"K.*+*"7*$5+"E*5*"

Page 103: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!@O"

"

&'67/5(*2"'6"-.*"'&&$+/'6+"-.$-"#/%%7/*%2":'069"4*'4%*"2/2"&'(*"2'E6"E/-."1$-+"$62"2'9+"-'"

+*--%*"+&'5*+J"K.*+*"%'&$%"/2*$+"'7"5$&/$%/+*2"&.$'+"7*2"/6-'"$"E/2*5"4''%"'7"+'&/$%"2/+'52*5"-.$-"

:'0-."E'5F*5+"$62":'069"4*'4%*"$-";*:.$("0+*2"-'"&'6+-50&-"/2*$+"'7"-.5*$-J"K.*+*"/6&%02*2"

(*2/$"/($9*5:"G2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"]'05I"$62"$"+*5/*+"'7"-$%*+"-.$-"&/5&0%$-*2"/6"-.*"%'&$%"$5*$"

$1'0-"$&-+"'7"*C-5*(*"B/'%*6&*"1*-E**6":'069"4*'4%*J"

"

_'E*B*5>"H0+-"$+"2/+'52*5"$62"'52*5"E*5*"&'6+-50&-*2"2/+&05+/B*%:>"-.*:"E*5*"$%+'"&'6+-50&-*2"

-.5'09."+4*&/7/&"45$&-/&*+J",+"-.*"4.:+/&$%"($6/7*+-$-/'6"'7"-.*"2/B/2*"1*-E**6"'52*5"$62"

&.$'+>"'6*"'7"-.*+*"45$&-/&*+"/6B'%B*2"($/6-$/6/69"-.*"4*5/(*-*5"7*6&*J"Z'0-."E'5F*5+"E*5*"

&'6&*56*2"E/-."-.*"*C-*5/'5"1'062$5/*+"'7";*:.$(J"]'5"-.*"('5$%"$62"+4$-/$%"'52*5"-'"1*"F*4-"

/6-$&->"($%*":'0-."E'5F*5+"'&&$+/'6$%%:"4$-5'%%*2"-.*"4*5/(*-*5"7*6&*"%''F/69"'0-"/6-'"-.*"

6/9.-"7'5"+/96+"'7"-5'01%*J"8*++/'6+"5*h0/5*2"-.*"45*+*6&*"'7"$-"%*$+-"'6*"($%*":'0-."E'5F*5"

$62"/6"-./+"E$:"-.*"($%*"1'2:"E$+"/6-*5-E/6*2"E/-."-.*"W$5&./-*&-05*"'7"+'&/$%"&'6-5'%Y"G3$B/+"

!PP@IJ"K.*"'6-'%'9/&$%"&*6-5$%/-:"'7"-.*"7*6&*"$62"($+&0%/6/-:"-'";*:.$(Y+"-*55/-'5/$%"4'%/-/&+"

E$+"('+-"*B/2*6-"E.*6"-.5*$-+"75'("1*:'62"E*5*"B/$1%*f"7'5"*C$(4%*>"/7"-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+"

.$2"5*&*/B*2"/6-*%%/9*6&*"-.$-":'069"4*'4%*"75'("$6'-.*5"$5*$"E*5*"&'(/69"2'E6"7'5"$"7/9.-J"

K.*"7*6&*"E$+"-.*6"/($9*2"$+"-.*"%/(/-"'7":'0-."&%01"+*&05/-:"$62"-.*"%/6*"-.$-"($%*":'0-."

E'5F*5+"E'0%2".$B*"-'"2*7*62"-'"($/6-$/6"-.*"7*$+/1/%/-:"'7"-.*"+/-*J";/F*"-.*"7*6&*>"%/9.-"E$+"

$%+'"&50&/$%"-'"-.*":'0-."&%01Y+"$5&./-*&-05*"'7"+'&/$%"&'6-5'%J"A6"-.*"2$5F6*++":'0-."E'5F*5+"

&'0%2"6'-"*$+/%:"$+&*5-$/6"-.*"/2*6-/-/*+"'5"$&-/'6+"6**2*2"-'"9'B*56"-.*"-*55/-'5:J"A6"E/6-*5"

('6-.+"7%''2%/9.-+"E*5*"0+*2"-'"/%%0(/6$-*"-.*"95'062+"$62"%/9.-/69"-.*":'0-."&%01"E$+"$"

45$&-/&*"-.5'09."E./&."'52*5"$62"2/+'52*5"E*5*"2*7/6*2J"_'E*B*5>"'6&*"-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+"

+.0-"2'E6"-.*"%/9.-+"$62"%*7-"-.*":'0-."&%01"$-".$%7"4$+-"6/6*"-.*"4*5/(*-*5"E$+"2*602*2J",-"

-./+"4'/6->"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"&$(*"1$&F>"&%/(1*2"'B*5"-.*"7*6&*"$62"+4*62"-.*"*B*6/69"

25/6F/69>"&.$--/69"$62"+('F/69"/6+/2*"-.*"4*5/(*-*5J"d*"$%%"F6*E"-./+".$44*6*2>"$62"$+"%'69"

$+"-.*:".$2"-.*"&'05-*+:"-'"E$/-"06-/%"E*".$2"%*7->"6'6*"'7"0+"(/62*2J"

"

A6B*+-(*6-+"/6"-.*"7*6&*"$%+'"7%0&-0$-*2"E/-."7'5(+"'7"45$&-/&*"-.$-"E*5*"2*4%':*2"7'5"+4*&/7/&"

&$%*62$5*2"*B*6-+J"K.*"%$E%*++"6/9.-+"G8$62.0"?@@MI"'7"-.*"E/6-*5"('6-.+"$22*2"$"+*6+*"'7"

06*$+*"6'-"45*+*6-"/6"-.*"+0((*5>"$62"]/5*E'5F+"U/9.-"/6"4$5-/&0%$5"&5*$-*2"$445*.*6+/'6J"

#0&."'7"-.*"E**F"1*7'5*"E$+"2*B'-*2"-'"2/+&0++/'6+"'7"-.5*$-"$62"-.*"6**2"7'5".*/9.-*6*2"

B/9/%$6&*J"Z'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"$6-/&/4$-*2"-'"0+*"-.*"&'B*5"'7"2$5F6*++"-'"%$06&."$"5'&F*-"

$--$&FJ"T6"]/5*E'5F+"U/9.-"?@@P>"U*/%".$2"+-$:*2"'6"-'"45'B/2*"$22/-/'6$%"($%*"+044'5-"$62>"

Page 104: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!@\"

"

-'9*-.*5"E/-."d/%%"$62"(*>"+4*6-"-.*"*B*6/69"-5$&F/69":'069"4*'4%*"$+"-.*:"&/5&%*2"-.*"

4*5/(*-*5J"=**5/69"/6-'"-.*"2$5F6*++"E*"+-5$/6*2"'05"*:*+>"%/+-*6*2"7'5"&5$&F+>"+6/77*2"7'5"

-5$&*+"'7"9064'E2*5>"/($9*2"-.*"&.$'+"-.$-"*C/+-*2"'0-+/2*"$62"-.*"'52*5"-.$-"E*"E*5*"

45'-*&-/69J"K.*".*/9.-*6*2"&'6&*56"'B*5"$"5'&F*-"$--$&F"E$+"1$+*2"'6";*:.$(Y+"./+-'5/&"

5*%$-/'6+./4"E/-."$5+'6J"Z*$5+"$9'"-.*":'0-."&%01Y+"'%2"$2B*6-05*"4%$:95'062".$2"1**6"1056-"

2'E6>"'6"'5"$5'062"]/5*E'5F+"U/9.-J","6*E"'6*".$2"5*&*6-%:"1**6"10/%-"$62"+-$77"E*5*"

&'6&*56*2"-.$-"-.*"+$(*"2*+-50&-/'6"&'0%2".$44*6"$9$/6J"

"

K./+"'5$%"./+-'5:"E$+"&*6-5$%"-'"-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+Y"$62":'069"4*'4%*Y+"&'6+-50&-/'6"'7"'52*5"

$62"2/+'52*5>"('5$%/-:"$62"/(('5$%/-:J"d.*6"A"$55/B*2"$-"-.*":'0-."&%01>"-.*"7$-*"'7"-.*"*$5%/*5"

$2B*6-05*"4%$:95'062"E$+"+099*+-*2"1:"-.*"&.$55*2"10-"&'%'0570%%:"4$/6-*2"+-0(4+"%*7-"

+-$62/69"$5'062"-.*"+/-*J"#'+-"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"6'-"'%2"*6'09."-'"5*(*(1*5"-.*"

'5/9/6$%"+-50&-05*"10-"%/F*"(*"-.*:"*6h0/5*2"$62"E*5*"-'%2"+-'5/*+"1:"+-$77"$62"'%2*5"+/1%/69+"

-.$-"15'09.-"-.*"9%'5:"'7"-.*"7'5(*5"4%$:95'062"-'"%/7*J"K.5'09."-.*+*"-$%*+>"-.*"'%2"$2B*6-05*"

4%$:95'062"E$+"(/++*2>"$62"-.*"$--$&F"-.$-"*62*2"/-+"%/7*"&'62*(6*2J",%-.'09."E*"$%%"F6*E"/-"

.$2"1**6"1056-"2'E6>"6'"'6*"E$+"h0/-*"+05*".'E>"$62"-./+"06&*5-$/6-:"9$B*"5/+*"-'"&'6H*&-05*"

-.$-"E$+"0+*2"-'"($F*"+*6+*"'7"70-05*"$5+'6"-.5*$-+J"A6"-./+"E$:>"-.*"'5/9/6$%"$&-"'7"$5+'6"E$+"

5*&'6+-50&-*2"-'"($F*"+*6+*"'7"&'6-*(4'5$5:"$62"70-05*"&'6&*56+"7'5"'52*5"$62"2/+'52*5J"

8'(*"E'5F*5+"-.'09.-"-.*"'5/9/6$%"$5+'6"E$+"2'6*"'0-"'7"($%/&*"g"$6"$--$&F"$9$/6+-"-.*":'0-."

&%01"$+"$"+:(1'%"'7"'52*5J"T6*":'0-."E'5F*5"-.'09.-"/-"E$+"1'56"'0-"'7"750+-5$-/'6"g"-.*":'069"

4*'4%*"2/2"6'-".$B*"-.*"(*$6+"-'"&'6+0(*"-.*"E$:"5/&.*5"F/2+"2/2>"+'"-.*:"2*+-5':*2"E.$-"

-.*:".$2"G2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"]/B*IJ"A6"$%%"-.*+*"$&&'06-+"-.*"7/&-/-/'0+":'069"4*'4%*"+$/2"-'"

.$B*"&$55/*2"'0-"-.*"$--$&F"E*5*"&'62*(6*2"$62"&'6-*(4'5$5:"2/+'52*5"/($9/6*2"'6"-.*+*"

-*5(+J"^0-"$+"`:%/*>"'6*"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*>"4'/6-*2"'0-f"E$+6Y-"/-"H0+-"$6"$&&/2*6->"$"+.*%-*5"

'6"$"8$-052$:"6/9.->"$62"-.*6"$"7$9>"$62"-.*6"+'(*"1''a*"$62"-.*6"$"%/9.-*5>"$62"-.*6"m"lA-Y+"

H0+-"&'(('6"F6'E%*29*>"$/6Y-"/-in>"+.*"+$/2J"`:%/*"E$+"25$E/69"$--*6-/'6"-'"$"+*5/*+"'7"

$&&/2*6-$%"$&-/'6+"-.5'09."E./&."-.*"1'5*2'("'7"%*/+05*"-/(*".$2"1**6"$%%*B/$-*2"GS'55/9$6"

!PMPj"R'1/6+"$62"S'.*6"!PMVIJ"K./+"E$+"($:1*"$"('5*"$&&05$-*"5*7%*&-/'6"'7"06/6-*62*2"

&'6+*h0*6&*+>"10-"-./+"&'(('6"F6'E%*29*"E$+"E$+.*2"$E$:"/6"$"2*+/5*"7'5"$"('5*"

2*&%$5$-/B*"&'6&%0+/'6J",+"-.*"6*E"$2B*6-05*"4%$:95'062"E$+"10/%->"-.*+*"%/69*5/69"7*$5+"$62"

(:-.'%'9/*+"&'62/-/'6*2"5*%$-/'6+"'7"'52*5"$62"2/+'52*5"$-"-.*":'0-."&%01J",+"-.*"(*-$%"7*6&*"

E*6-"04>"/-"1*&$(*"/6&5*$+/69%:"&%*$5".'E"$62"E.*5*"2/+'52*5"E$+"1*/69"2*7/6*2J"

"

Page 105: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!@N"

"

_'E*B*5>":'0-."E'5F*5+Y"5'%*"/6"($6$9/69"-.*"('5$%"$62"-*55/-'5/$%"'52*5"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01"

E$+"6'-"'6%:"&'6&*56*2"E/-."+*&05/69"-.*"+/-*"75'("*C-*56$%"-.5*$-J"d/-./6"-.*"4*5/(*-*5"'7"

-.*":'0-."&%01>":'0-."E'5F*5+"$%+'"E'5F*2"-'"*6+05*":'069"4*'4%*"5*+4*&-*2"+'&/$%"$62"

-*55/-'5/$%"1'062$5/*+J",-"$"1$6$%"%*B*%>"-.*:"0+*2"$"60(1*5"'7"2/77*5*6-"-*&.6'%'9/*+"-'"&'6-5'%"

-.*"+4$&*J"S%'+/69"-.*"2''5"-'"$6"'4*6"$&&*++"$5*$"&'0%2"7$&/%/-$-*"$6"*6B/5'6(*6-"$(*6$1%*"

-'"+*5/'0+"2/+&0++/'6+"$62"E'5F+.'4+J";/F*E/+*>"/7"-.*"45/B$&:"$77'52*2"1:"$"&%'+*2"2''5"'5"$"

+&5**6"E$+"%*$2/69"-'"$&-+"-.$-"&'0%2"'6%:"'&&05"/6"45/B$-*"g"/6$445'45/$-*"+*C0$%"1*.$B/'05"

1*-E**6":'069"4*'4%*>"7'5"*C$(4%*"g"-.*6"-.*"2''5"&'0%2"1*"'4*6*2J"K.*+*"$&-/B/-/*+"

2*4*62*2"'6"-.*"&''52/6$-/'6"'7"-.*"1'2:"'7":'0-."E'5F*5+>"6'-"H0+-"'6"-.*"/62/B/20$%J"]5'("

-.*"4*5+4*&-/B*"'7"-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+>"+*++/'6+"5$6"E*%%"E.*6"1'062$5/*+"E*5*"'1+*5B*2f"

E.*6"-.*"+-$77"-*$("F6'E"E.$-"*$&."'7"-.*"'-.*5+"E$+"2'/69>"E.*5*"-.*:"$%%"E*5*>"$62"E.$-"

50%*+"-'"$44%:J"

"

='%/&/69"-.*"+4$&*"'6"-.*+*"-*5(+"E$+"9*6*5$%%:"1$%$6&*2"E/-."'-.*5"$+4*&-+"'7":'0-."E'5Ff"

-$%F/69"-'":'069"4*'4%*>"10/%2/69"*+-**(>"-*$&./69>"+'%B/69"45'1%*(+"$62"4$5-/&/4$-/69"/6"

9$(*+"$62"+4'5-+J"_'E*B*5>"E.*6":'0-."&%01+"E*5*"10+:>"'5"E.*6"+-$77/69"E$+"+.'5->"+'7-*5"

+F/%%+"E*5*"40-"-'"'6*"+/2*"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+"&'6&*6-5$-*2"'6"($/6-$/6/69"-*55/-'5/$%"$62"

('5$%"'52*5J"A6"-.*+*"+/-0$-/'6+>"/7"1'062$5/*+"E*5*"-5$6+95*++*2":'0-."E'5F*5+"-''F"$&-/'6"

-.5'09."W1$66/69Y"'5"W1$55/69Y":'069"4*'4%*"75'("$--*62/69"-.*":'0-."&%01J"^$66/69"E$+"5$5*"

E.*6"+-$77"('5$%*"E$+"./9.>"5*+'05&*+"E*5*"4%*6-/70%"$62"-.*"&'%%*&-/B*"1'2:"'7":'069"4*'4%*"

$62":'0-."E'5F*5+"706&-/'6*2"-'E$52+"$".$1/-0$%"*h0/%/15/0("G#*5%*$0Q='6-:"!PVPIJ"_'E*B*5>"

/-"1*&$(*"('5*"&'(('64%$&*"$+"+-$77"$62"7/6$6&/$%"5*+'05&*+"5$6"25:J"A6"-.*+*"+/-0$-/'6+>"

E./%*"+-$77"E*5*"'7-*6"$E$5*"-.$-"1'062$5:"15*$F/69"E$+"5*%$-*2"-'"E/2*5"4*5+'6$%"45'1%*(+>"

/7"6'-"+/(4%:"-.*"%$&F"'7"$&-/B/-/*+>"-.*:"7*%-"7'5&*2"-'"5*B*5-"-'"$"F/62"'7"5'--*6"$44%*+"-.*'5:"g"

$62"5'90*":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"2/+&$52*2"-'"45*+*5B*"-.*"5*+-"'7"-.*"1$55*%J"<(4%':*2"/6"-./+"

E$:>"-.*"1$6"706&-/'6*2"$+"$"%'&$%"7'5("'7"*C&*4-/'6"G,9$(1*6"!PPVI"$62"*67'5&*2"-.*":'0-."

&%01Y+"/2*$"'7"'52*5J"K.*"/6+/2*"E$+"'52*5*2"$62"('5$%"1*&$0+*"-.*"4%$&*"E.*5*"-.*"1$66*2"

:'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"+*6-"G'0-+/2*"-.*"7*6&*I"E$+"2/+'52*5*2"$62"/(('5$%J",+"7062/69"&0-+"$62"

+-$77"+.'5-$9*+"1*&$(*"('5*"$&0-*>"$62"%$59*"60(1*5+"'7"6*E":'069"4*'4%*"$55/B*2>"-.*"1$6"

E$+"/6&5*$+/69%:"*(4%':*2J"

"

d./%*"1'-."($%*"$62"7*($%*"+-$77"*B'F*2"-.*"1$6>"/6"-.*"%$+-"/6+-$6&*"E.$-"%$:"1*./62"-.*"

&'(($62"E$+"-.*"-.5*$-"'7"($+&0%/6*"7'5&*"g"-.*"$1/%/-:"G6'-"6*&*++$5/%:"&$55/*2"'0-I"-'"

Page 106: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!@e"

"

4.:+/&$%%:"5*('B*"$":'069"4*5+'6"75'("-.*"&%01J",9$/6"-./+"&'67/5(*2"-.*"&'66*&-/'6"1*-E**6"

($+&0%/6*"$0-.'5/-:"$62"&'6-5'%"$-";*:.$(J"T&&$+/'6$%%:"$+"$"($%*"E'5F*5"G$%-.'09."A"E$+"

'77/&/$%%:"$"B'%06-**5I"A"+-*44*2"/6-'"-./+"5'%*J"K.*"7/5+-":'069"4*5+'6"A"1$66*2"E$+")$&FJ"

A6-5'20&*2"$1'B*"$+"-.*":'069"4*5+'6"E.'"$/(*2"4*%B/&"-.50+-+"$-"-.*"4'%/&*>")$&F".$2"1**6"

&$0+/69"-5'01%*"7'5")$6*>"$"+*++/'6$%"E'5F*5>"/6"-.*"75'6-"5''(J"_*"F6*E"-.$-"$+"$"E'($6>"10-"

$%+'"1*&$0+*"'7".*5"($66*5>"+.*"2/2"6'-"&$55:"-.*"5*h0/+/-*"-.5*$-"-'"2/+&/4%/6*"./(J",+"A"E$%F*2"

/6-'"-.*"5''(>")$&F"-.5*E"$"+.'*"$-"'6*"'7"-.*"'-.*5":'069"4*'4%*"g"$"&%*$5"B/'%$-/'6"'7"-.*"

50%*+J"A"+.'0-*2"$-"./("$62"-'%2"./("-'"9*-"'0-J"K*+-/69"(*>".*"2/26Y-"('B*"$62"E/-.'0-"

-./6F/69"A"40+.*2"./("'0-"-.*"75'6-"2''5J"_*".$2"&$%%*2"(:"($+&0%/6*"$0-.'5/-:"/6-'"h0*+-/'6"

$62"A".$2"5*+4'62*2J"3/+$44'/6-*2"1:".'E"A".$2"$&-*2>"A"+4'F*"-'")$&F"$62"./+"75/*62+"'0-+/2*J"

K.*:"E*5*"6'-"+.'&F*2>"'5"*B*6"$66':*2J"A6"7$&-"-.*:"*C4*&-*2"/-J")$&F"45'7*++*2"1'5*2'("$+"

-.*"5*$+'6"7'5"-.5'E/69"-.*"+.'*J"A"+:(4$-./+*2J"8-/%%"7**%/69"90/%-:>"A"E$%F*2"1$&F"/6-'"-.*"

5''("$62"$4'%'9/+*2"-'")$6*"7'5"062*5(/6/69".*5J"8.*"E$+"'6%:"2/+$44'/6-*2"A".$26Y-"$&-*2"

+''6*5J"

"

A6"+0(($5:>"&'((06/-:"'E6*5+./4"706&-/'6*2"-.5'09."2*7/6/69"'52*5"$62"2/+'52*5"$-"

2/77*5*6-"+&$%*+J"S'((06/-:"'E6*5+./4"E$+"($2*"4'++/1%*"1*&$0+*"'7"-.*"/6&5*$+/69"$0-.'5/-:"

'7"-.*":'0-."&%01"/6"%'&$%"9'B*56$6&*J"K.*+*"5*+4'6+/1/%/-/*+"E*5*"-$F*6"7'5E$52"-.5'09."

4$5-6*5+./4"E'5F/69"E/-."-.*"4'%/&*J"A6"-./+"E$:>"&'((06/-:"'E6*5+./4"E$+"7'5(0%$-*2"

-.'09."/2*$+"'7"'52*5"$62"2/+'52*5"2*7/6*2"/6"5*%$-/'6"-'"4'%/&/69"$9*62$+J"_'E*B*5>"

&'((06/-:"'E6*5+./4"E$+"$%+'"6*'Q&'((06/-$5/$6"/6"&.$5$&-*5"$62"-.*"/2*$+"'7"'52*5"$62"

2/+'52*5"2*7/6*2"1:"-.*"4'%/&*"E*5*"(/C*2"E/-."%'&$%"/2*$+"'7"-.5*$-J"K.*+*"/2*$+"'7"-.5*$-"

*69$9*2"E/-."%'&$%"-*55/-'5/$%"2/+40-*+"-.$-".$2"1*&'(*"5$&/$%/+*2>"E/-."(*('5/*+"'7"$--$&F"

$62"E/-."4'40%$5"(*2/$"$62"%'&$%"/($9*5/*+"'7":'0-."&5/(/6$%/-:J"K.*+*"/2*$+"'7"-.5*$-"($2*"

+*6+*"$%'69+/2*"$0-'&.-.'6'0+"7'5(+"'7"&'((06/-:"/2*6-/-:>"$62"-.5'09."45$&-/&*+"'7"

+05B*/%%$6&*"$62"($+&0%/6*"B/'%*6&*"-.$-"'&&055*2"$-"-.*"1'52*5"$62"E/-./6"-.*":'0-."&%01J"

OJ d/62Q04+"

K*55/-'5/$%"'52*5"$62"2/+'52*5"/6"$62"$5'062";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01"E$+"6'-"'6%:"6*9'-/$-*2"$-"

-.*+*"%*B*%+>".'E*B*5J";$59*%:"06&'6+/2*5*2"/6"4'%/-/&$%"9*'95$4.:"G^5*66*5"?@@\I>"-*55/-'5:"

E$+"$%+'"6*9'-/$-*2"$-"-.*"%*B*%"'7"-.*"(/&5'>"-.5'09."('(*6-+"'7"2/$%'90*"-.$-"-''F"-.*"7'5("

'7"WE/62Q04+YJ",-";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01>"-.*"E/62Q04"E$+"$"7'5("'7"1$6-*5"$62"45'B'&$-/'6"-.$-"

Page 107: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!@M"

"

706&-/'6*2"-.5'09."-.*"-*+-/69>"+*--/69"$62"-5$6+95*++/69"'7"-*55/-'5/$%"50%*+J"A-"E$+"1$+*2"'6"

h0/&F"E/-"4%$:*2"'0-"-.5'09.".0('05>"/6+0%-"$62"5/2/&0%*J",+"$"01/h0/-'0+"('2*"'7"6*9'-/$-/'6"

/-"&'0%2"'4*5$-*"-'"-.*"5.:-.("'7"$"706&-/'6/69":'0-."&%01"$62"-'"-.*"-06*"'7"2/+'52*5%:"$&-+"g"

/-+"4'-*6-/$%"E$+"1'-."+01B*5+/B*"$62"&'67/5(/69J"

"

=5'7/&/*6&:"/6"-./+"-*55/-'5/$%"(/&5'Q4'%/-/&+"5*h0/5*2"$6"/6-/($-*"F6'E%*29*"'7"/-+"

W&'(4'+/-/'6$%"$62"+-:%/+-/&"7'5(+Y>"$62"-.*"&'6+-$6-%:"&.$69/69"4*5(0-$-/'6+"-.$-"($2*"E/-"

7066:>"$62"/6+0%-"/6H05/'0+"G^$F.-/6"!PVe$>"4JV@IJ"K'"9$/6"45'7/&/*6&:"/6"-./+"9*65*>"4$5-/&/4$6-+"

6**2*2"-'"1*"$2*4-"$-"6$B/9$-/69"-.*"$(1/90/-/*+"-.$-"2*7/6*2"/-J","E/62Q04>"7'5"*C$(4%*>"E$+"

6*B*5"+/(4%:"*C&%0+/'6$5:"'5"$77/5(/69J"A-"15'09.-":'069"4*'4%*"/6-'"1*/69"/6"1'-."4'+/-/B*"$62"

6*9$-/B*"E$:+"G^0-%*5"!PPM>"4JNIJ"^:"(*$6+"'7"$"H'F*>"-*55/-'5:"E$+"E'6"$62"1*%'69/69"

$77/5(*2>"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"$+"95'062"E$+"2*6/*2"$62"$1H*&-/'6"+-$-*2J",+"$"6*E&'(*5"-'"-.*"

$5*$>"$62"-.*":'0-."&%01>"A"E$+"$%E$:+"$"6'B/&*"/6"-.*"+01-%*-/*+"'7"-.*+*"6*9'-/$-/'6+J"A"'7-*6"

7$/%*2"-'"5*&'96/+*"E.*6"$"H'F*"E$+"$"H'F*>"'5"E.*6"/-"E$+"$"('5*"+*5/'0+"&.$%%*69*"-'"(:"

$0-.'5/-:"$+"$":'0-."E'5F*5J"K./+"'7-*6"E'5F*2"-'"(:"$2B$6-$9*J"S'%%*$90*+"$62":'069"4*'4%*"

&'((*6-*2"-.$-"A"E$+"6'-"*$+/%:"7%0+-*5*2>"10-"-.*"5*$%/-:"E$+"A"'7-*6"2/26Y-"062*5+-$62"-.$-"A"

E$+"1*/69"('&F*2J"A-"E$+"$%+'"$"2/+$2B$6-$9*"$+"A"'&&$+/'6$%%:"(/+5*$2"$62"'B*5"5*$&-*2"-'"

E/62Q04+"A"+.'0%2".$B*"-$F*6"$+"H'F*+J"

"

#:"/6-5'20&-/'6"-'"-.*"E/62Q04"$+"$"45$&-/&*"'7"-*55/-'5/$%"6*9'-/$-/'6"&$(*"%/-*5$%%:"W$-"-.*"

.$62"'7"8&'--YJ"A"(*-"8&'--"'6"(:"7/5+-"2$:"$-";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01J"8&'--"E$+"$1'0-"7'05-**6"$62"

.$2"95'E6"04"/6"-.*"$5*$"1*7'5*"$"5*&*6-"('B*"-'"3$9*6.$("g"$"7$/5%:"&'(('6"(/95$-/'6"

$++'&/$-*2"E/-."$"./9.*5"+-$62$52"'7"%/B/69J"_'E*B*5>"E/-."75/*62+"/6"-.*";*:.$("$5*$>".*"

5*90%$5%:"5*-056*2"-'"-.*":'0-."&%01J"T6"(:"7/5+-"2$:>"E.*6"U*/%"E$+"+.'E/69"(*"$5'062>".*"

+$06-*5*2"'B*5"'77*5/69"$"95/6"$62"$".$62"-'"+.$F*J"80545/+*2>"10-"$%+'"4%*$+*2>"A"5*&/45'&$-*2J"

^0-"1*7'5*"'05"4$%(+"(*-".*"E/-.25*EJ"_*"+(/%*2j"U*/%"+(/%*2J"8&'--".$2"+/(0%-$6*'0+%:"

E*%&'(*2"(*"-'>"$62"5*H*&-*2"(*"75'(>"-.*":'0-."&%01J";/F*"(:".$62>"A".$2"1**6"%*7-".$69/69J"

"

,+"A"+*--%*2"/6"$-";*:.$(>"A"-5/*2"-'"%*$56".'E"-.*"50%*+"'7"-.*"+4$&*"E'5F*2J"A"+-$5-*2"E/-."-.*"

'77/&/$%"5*90%$-/'6+"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01"-.$-"$+"$":'0-."E'5F*5"A"E$+"+044'+*2"-'"04.'%2J",+/2*"

75'("-.*"+-02/'0+%:"/96'5*2"WK*6"R0%*+Y"4'+-*2"'6"-.*":'0-."&%01"E$%%>"E./&."/6&%02*2"-./69+"

%/F*"W6'"&:&%/69"/6+/2*Y>"W6'"4%$:/69"7''-1$%%"/6+/2*Y"$62"W6'"7/9.-/69"/6+/2*Y>"-.*5*"E$+"6'"90/2*Q

1''F"'6".'E"-'"2'"-./+"10-"9*6*5$%%:"6'6*"E$+"5*h0/5*2J"^$+/&"5*90%$-/'6+"E*5*"'1-$/6*2"

Page 108: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!@V"

"

.$1/-0$%%:"G#*5%*$0Q='6-:"!PVPj"R*:6'%2+"?@@\IJ"K.5'09."/6-*5$&-/69"E/-."-.*"+-$77>"-.*"

10/%2/69"$62":'069"4*'4%*>"A"4/&F*2"04"E.$-"A"6**2*2"-'"F6'E"$62"$44%/*2"/-J",+"A"2/2"-./+>"

:'069"4*'4%*"+'09.-"-'"$++*++"(:"&'(4*-*6&*"-.5'09."(/6'5"/675$&-/'6+J"U'"7/9.-/69>"&:&%/69"

'5"4%$:/69"7''-1$%%"/6+/2*"($:"+**("06$(1/90'0+"10-"/6"7$&-"-.*+*"+-5$/9.-7'5E$52"45/6&/4%*+"

.$2"($6:"95*:"$5*$+J"3/2"&:&%/69"$"1/F*".$%7E$:"/6-'"-.*"75'6-"5''("15*$F"-.*"50%*+i"3/2"$"4%$:"

7/9.-"&'6+-/-0-*"W7/9.-/69Y"'5"W4%$:Yi"3/2"2'/69"$"&'04%*"'7"F**4Q04+"/6+/2*"*h0$-*"-'"W7''-1$%%Yi"

K.*"$6+E*5+"2*4*62*2"'6"/62/B/20$%"2/+4'+/-/'6+>"'6"-.*"&'%%*&-/B*"F6'E%*29*"'7"-.*"50%*+"$-"

-.*"('(*6->"$62"'6"-.*":'069"4*'4%*Y+"2*+/5*"-'"40+."-.*"1'062$5/*+J"A6"-./+"E$:>"E.*5*$+"/-"

.$2"45*B/'0+%:"+**(*2"-.$-"-.*":'0-."&%01"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+"+*-"5*90%$-/'6+"7'5"1'2/*+"/6"

+4$&*>"/-"+''6"-5$6+4/5*2"-.$-":'069"4*'4%*"4%$:*2"$6"*h0$%"5'%*"/6"6*9'-/$-/69"-.*"95*:"a'6*"

'7"-*55/-'5/$%"'52*5J"

"

]'5"*C$(4%*>":'069"4*'4%*"0+*2"-.*"E/62Q04"-'"&.$%%*69*"5*9/(*+"'7"%/9.->"+'062"$62"1'2/*+"

/6"+4$&*J",+"2/+&0++*2>"%/9.-/69"E$+"$"7*$-05*"'7"/6+-/-0-/'6$%"&'6-5'%"*+4*&/$%%:"/6"-.*"E/6-*5"

('6-.+>"$62"-056/69"-.*"%/9.-+"'77"15'F*"-.*"$1/%/-:"-'"5*90%$-*"1'2/*+"/6"+4$&*J"K.*"

+'062+&$4*"E$+"$%+'"5*90%$-*2J",62"$%-.'09."%'02"$62"h0/*-"2/2"6'-"5*%$-*"-'"-.*"&'6-5'%"'7"

1'2/*+"$+"%/9.-"$62"2$5F"2/2>"/-"+-/%%"'77*5*2"$"+*6+'5/$%"4%$-7'5("-.5'09."E./&."-'"5/2/&0%*"

$0-.'5/-:J"Z'0-."&%01+"$5*"%'02"4%$&*+"10-"-.*"-'%*5$6&*"'7"B'%0(*"2/2"6'-"(*$6"$%%"+'062+"

E*5*"$&&*4-$1%*J",+"/6-5'20&*2"/6"S.$4-*5"T6*>"-.*"K**6"^0aa"E$+"$"2'E6%'$2$1%*>"$62"

&'6+*h0*6-%:"^%0*-''-.Q$1%*>"+'062"7/%*"-.$-"45'20&*2"$"&'6-/60'0+"./9.Q4/-&.*2"G!N"`_aI"

+'062"-.$-"/(/-$-*2"-.*"#'+h0/-'"2*B/&*"GS'(4'062"8*&05/-:"8:+-*(+"?@!@I"45'('-*2"-'"

&%*$5":'069"4*'4%*"75'("401%/&"+4$&*+J";/F*"-.*"&.05&."1*%%>"-.*"5*$%"#'+h0/-'"2*B/&*"E$+"$"

+:(1'%"'7"2*B'%B*2"+-$-*"4'E*5"G^$F.-/6"!PV\I"-*%%/69"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"E.*5*"G6'-I"-'"1*"$-"

&*5-$/6"-/(*+J"K.*"K**6"^0aa"2*B*%'4*2"$+"$"4$5'2:"'7"-.*"'5/9/6$%"2*B/&*"$62"E$+"4%$:*2"75'("

('1/%*"4.'6*+"./22*6"062*5"&.$/5+J"K.*"./9."4/-&.*2"+'062"($2*"/-"2/77/&0%-"-'"%'&$-*"$+"E*%%"

$+"06&'(7'5-$1%*"-'".*$5J"K.*":'069"4*'4%*"$(0+*2"-.*(+*%B*+"$+"+-$77"2*($62*2"-'"F6'E"

E.*5*"-.*"('1/%*"E$+J"

"

K.*"/6-*5$&-/B*"6$-05*"'7"50%*+>"$62"-.*/5"2*4*62*6&*"'6"-.*"(''2+"'7"-.*"4*'4%*"/6B'%B*2>"

(*$6-"-.$-":'0-."E'5F*5+"$62":'069"4*'4%*"+'%/&/-*2"-.*"1'062$5/*+"/6"2/77*5*6-"E$:+J","7/9.-"

$-".'(*"1*7'5*"$"+*++/'6"+-$5-*2>"('6*:"45'1%*(+>"$6"$590(*6-"$-"E'5F"&'0%2"$%%"%*$2":'0-."

E'5F*5+"'5":'069"4*'4%*"-'"5*+4'62"B*5:"2/77*5*6-%:"-'"E/62Q04+J"_'E*B*5>"/-"E$+"6'-"'6%:"

-.*+*"$77*&-/B*"&'62/-/'6+"-.$-"($2*"-.*"E/62Q04"$6"06+-$1%*"+:+-*("'7"-*55/-'5/$%"&'6-5'%J"A-"

Page 109: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!@P"

"

$%+'"2*4*62*2"'6"-.*"5*%$-/'6+./4"1*-E**6":'069"4*'4%*"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+J"K'"-./+"*C-*6-"

-.*"50%*+"'7"-.*"+4$&*"$44%/*2"2/77*5*6-%:"-'"2/77*5*6-"4*'4%*J"K.*+*"&'62/-/'6+"(*$6-"-.$-"/7"

-.*5*"E$+"$"50%*>"-.*5*"E$+"$%E$:+"$6"*C&*4-/'6"-'"/->"$62"-.*"95'062+"'6"E./&."*C&*4-/'6+"

E*5*"($2*"E*5*"'7-*6"$77*&-/B*>"4*5+'6$%"$62"15'09.-"75'("'0-+/2*"-.*":'0-."&%01J"]'5"

*C$(4%*>"E.*6":'069"4*'4%*"$-"-.*":'0-."&%01"5*(/62*2"K*++$"'7".*5"'E6"&./%25*6>".*5"

$44%/&$-/'6"'7"+4$-/$%"5*90%$-/'6"&.$69*2J"8.*"%*-"3/2/*5"506"-.5'09."-.*"1$&F"5''("E.*6"+.*"

.$2"-'%2"./("6'-"-'"1*&$0+*".*"5*(/62*2".*5"'7".*5"+'6"G+**"S.$4-*5"T6*IJ"

"

_'E*B*5>"E/62Q04+"E*5*"0+*2"6'-"'6%:"-'"*+-$1%/+.":'0-."E'5F*5+Y"F6'E%*29*"'7"-.*"50%*+>"10-"

$%+'"-'"6*9'-/$-*"-.*"&'6-5'%"'7"-.*"+4$&*"1*-E**6"2/77*5*6-":'069"4*'4%*J"A-"E$+"&'(('6"7'5"

:'069*5"(*(1*5+"G-E*%B*"'5"-./5-**6":*$5+"'%2I"-'"-*+-"-.*"$0-.'5/-:"'7"'%2*5":'069"4*'4%*J"

T6*"*B*6/69"=$E%"E$+"E/62/69"04"#'J"=$E%"E$+"-.*":'069*5"'7"-.*"-E'"$62".$2"5*&*6-%:"

$55/B*2"/6"-.*"$5*$"75'("='%$62J"#'"E$+"'%2*5"$62".$2"95'E6"04"$5'062"-.*":'0-."&%01J"K./+"

E/62Q04"E$+"$"7'5("'7"($+&0%/6*"H'0+-/69J"K.*"'%2*5"(*(1*5+"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01>"'7-*6"1:"

B/5-0*"'7"1*/69"4.:+/&$%%:"+-5'69*5>".$2"('5*"$0-.'5/-:"-.$6"-.*":'069*5"(*(1*5+"$62"-.*"

:'069*5"(*(1*5+"+'09.-"-'"E/6"+'(*"'7"-.$-"$0-.'5/-:"1$&FJ"K.$-"*B*6/69"=$E%"E$+"40%%/69"

#'Y+"H0(4*5"10-"F**4/69"'0-"'7"$5(Y+"5*$&.J"#'"/96'5*2"./(>"$62"-.*6"5*+4'62*2>"&.$+/69"

./("/6-'"-.*"1$&F"5''(>"$+"=$E%".$2"45*2/&-*2".*"E'0%2J"A62**2".*"6**2*2"./("-'"5*+4'62"-'"

5*&*/B*"-.*"$445'45/$-*"B*5/7/&$-/'6"7'5"./+"$&-/'6J"_'E*B*5>"/-"E$+"6'-"'6%:"=$E%Y+"4**5+"-.$-"

E*5*"45*7/905*2"/6"-./+"$&->"10-"$%+'"-.*"+4$&*"$62"-.*"+:(1'%+"'7"$0-.'5/-:"E/-./6"/-J"=$E%".$2"

506"-'"-.*"1$&F"5''("1*&$0+*"-.*5*"E$+"$6"*C/-"'0-+/2*"+.'0%2".*"6**2"/->"10-".*"+-'44*2"$62"

+-$-/'6*2"./(+*%7"1*./62"(*J"#:"*(1'2/*2"$0-.'5/-:".$2"$%+'"1**6"45*7/905*2"$62"$&&*4-/69"

-./+"#'"E$%F*2"$E$:J"

"

A6"9*6*5$%"/-"E$+"*C4*&-*2"-.$-"45'B'&$-/'6+"E'0%2"1*"5*+4'62*2"-'"/6"F/62J"A7"#'".$2"

5*+4'62*2"-''".$5+.%:"./+"$&-/'6+"E'0%2".$B*"1**6"4*5&*/B*2"$+"06H0+-"$62"4'-*6-/$%%:"%*2"-'"

$6"06E$6-*2"*+&$%$-/'6>"15'09.-"'6"1:"+-$77"'5":'069"4*'4%*J"A6"-./+"E$:>"-.*"E/62Q04"

706&-/'6*2"E/-."-.*"*h0/%/15/0("'7"-.*":'0-."&%01J"K.*"1*+-"5*+4'6+*"-'"-.*"E/62Q04"g"-'"9$/6"

&'6-5'%"'7"-.*"9$(*"g"E$+>"/6"7$&->"-'"5*+4'62"-.5'09."$"('5*".0('5'0+"5*-'5-J"K./+".$2"-.*"

*77*&-"'7"2/+$1%/69"-.*"'5/9/6$%"45'B'&$-/'6"1:"-056/69"-.*"7'5&*"'7"&'%%*&-/B*"%$09.-*5"'6-'"-.*"

/6+-/9$-'5J"K./+"7'5("'7"5*+4'6+*"5*-$/6*2"$0-.'5/-:"E./%+-"6'-"'77*62/69"-.*"4*5+'6"E.'".$2"

/6/-/$-*2"-.*"9$(*J"

"

Page 110: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!!@"

"

d.$-"E$+"4*5&*/B*2"$+"7066:"$62"$&&*4-$1%*"E$+"2*7/6*2"-.5'09."5*%$-/B*%:"+-$1%*"./*5$5&./*+"

'7"4'E*5"$-"-.*":'0-."&%01>"E/-."-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+"$62"+*6/'5":'069"4*'4%*"('+-"%/F*%:"-'"

9*6*5$-*"%$09.-*5"E./%*":'069*5"'5"%*++"2'(/6$6-"(*(1*5+"($F/69"-.*"+$(*"H'F*"(/9.-"1*"

+**6"$+"/55/-$-/69>"'5"9*--/69"$1'B*"-.*/5"+-$-/'6J"A6"'52*5"7'5"-.*("-'"($/6-$/6"-.*/5"/6B*+-*2"

4'+/-/'6"-.*"+-$77"$62":'069"4*'4%*"6**2*2"-'"5*($/6"&'(4*-*6-"$-"-./+"7'5("'7"1$6-*5J"K.*:"

*$&.".$2"-.*/5"'E6"+-:%*+J"8'(*>"%/F*"d/%%>"0+*2"'0-5/9.-"($+&0%/6*"*6*59:"$62".0('5'0+"

2/+4%$:+"g"+.'0-/69>"5066/69"$5'062"$62"4%$:/69"9$(*+"g"-'"*6+05*"-.*:"E*5*"$%E$:+"$.*$2"'7"

-.*"&05B*J"T-.*5+>"+0&."$+"8$5$.>"$"7*($%*":'0-."E'5F*5>"0+*2"+$52'6/&"E/-"'5"'6Q9'/69"

5/2/&0%*J"8'(*"'7"-.*"1*+-"*C$(4%*+"'7"-./+"%$--*5"$445'$&."E*5*"*B/2*6-"/6"-.*"2'a*6+"-.$-"

E*5*"4%$:*2"$-"-.*":'0-."&%01J"K.*"2'a*6+"/+"$"9$(*"'7"B*51$%"*C&.$69*"$--5/10-*2"-'",75/&$6"

,(*5/&$6"B*56$&0%$5J"A6"-.*"2'a*6+>"$"4%$:*5"-5/*+"-'"'0-2'"-.*"'-.*5"E/-."/6+0%-+"$62"E/-"

G;$1'B"!PM?>"44JO@MgO?!j"8(/-.*5($6"?@@MIJ"K.*"9$(*"-.*6"1*&'(*+"$"+/-*"7'5"-.*"

6*9'-/$-/'6"'7"-*55/-'5/$%"$62"+'&/$%"&'6-5'%"$+"*$&."4%$:*5"-5/*+"-'"9$/6"-.*"044*5".$62>"$62"

./9.*5"+-$62/69>"1:"E/66/69"-.*"9$(*"-.5'09."B*51$%"5$-.*5"-.$6"4.:+/&$%"$++$0%-"G8(/-.*5($6"

?@@MIJ"80&&*++"E$+"B*5/7/*2"6'-"1:"-.*"4%$:*5+"10-"1:"-.*"$02/*6&*"+.'E/69"5*+4*&-"-.5'09."

%$09.-*5"'5"'-.*5"+/96+"'7"$445'B$%J"=%$:*2"/6"$"45*2'(/6$6-%:"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++":'0-."&%01"

/6"<$+-";'62'6>"/-+"*C/+-*6&*"25*E"$--*6-/'6"-'"-.*"2/$+4'5/&"7'5($-/'6"'7"%'&$%"-*55/-'5/$%"

6*9'-/$-/'6"G2/+&0++*2"705-.*5"/6"S.$4-*5"]'05IJ"_'E*B*5>"-.*"2'a*6+"/6";*:.$("E$+"6'-"

+/(4%:"$"5*4%/&$-/'6"'7"/-+"[8"&'06-*54$5-J"R$-.*5>"+'(*"&.$5$&-*5/+-/&+".$2"1**6"%'+-"$62"

'-.*5+"5*('2*%%*2J"U'-$1%:>";*:.$(Y+"2'a*6+"2/2"6'-"&'6-$/6"-.*"('5*"*%$1'5$-*"5.:(/69"

B*5+*+"$62"2/2"6'-"45'B/2*"$"&$56/B$%*+h0*"+/-*"/6"E./&."-.*"50%*+"'7"+'&/*-:"E*5*"-*(4'5$5/%:"

+01B*5-*2"G,15$.$(+"!PM?>"4J??@j"^$F.-/6"!PV\IJ"^0-"-.*:"2/2"5*-$/6"-.*"W:'05"($(($Y"

/6B*&-/B*"$62"0+*2"$1+052/-:>"45'7$6/-:>".0('05>"*C$99*5$-/'6"$62"+4'6-$6*/-:"-'"E/6J"

"

,+"E/-."'-.*5"7'5(+"'7"E/62Q04>"-.*"50%*+"-'"-.*"2'a*6+"E*5*"-$09.-"$62"%*$56*2J"#'+-%:"-./+"

.$44*6*2"-.5'09."+%'E"$62"6'6Q+4*&/7/&"/620&-/'6+"/6-'"-.*"+4**&."9*65*"G^$F.-/6"!PVe$I>"10-"

/6"+'(*"&$+*+"-.*"-*$&./69"E$+"('5*"*C4%/&/-J")*5($/6>"$":'0-."E'5F*5"$-"-.*",7-*5"8&.''%"

S%01>"-$09.-"-.*"9$(*J"_*"&$%%*2"/-"-.*"l2/++/69"2$:nJ"K.*"/2*$"E$+"7'5":'069"4*'4%*"-'"1*$-"

./("$-"2/++/69"-.5'09."4%$:/69"-.*"2'a*6+J")*5($/6"*C4%$/6*2"-.*"50%*+f"-.*:"+.'0%2"+$:"

+'(*-./69"'77*6+/B*"-'"./(>"$6:-./69>"$62"+**"/7".*"&'0%26Y-"-056"/-"5'062"E/-."95*$-*5"./%$5/-:"

$62"7'5&*J"K.*6"/-"E$+"-.*/5"-056J"K.*"4'/6-"E$+>"/7":'0"&'0%2"4%$:"-.*"9$(*":'0"2/26Y-"6**2"-'"

-$F*"'77*6&*J"Z'0"&'0%2"5*-$/6"+'&/$%"&'6-5'%"E/-.'0-"5*+'5-/69"-'"4.:+/&$%"7'5&*J",+")*5($/6"

*C4%$/6*2>"/7"+'(*'6*"+$:+"+'(*-./69"-'":'0"$1'0-":'05"(0(>"$+"-.*"'1H*&-"'7".0('05"$62"

Page 111: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!!!"

"

+&$62$%"G,15$.$(+"!PM?>"4J??MI>"5$-.*5"-.$6"9*--/69"04"$62"+-$11/69"-.*(":'0"&'0%2"H0+-"-056"

-.*"/6+0%-"1$&F>"$62"6'-"&$5*J"

"

,-";*:.$("-.*+*"7'5(+"'7".0('05"706&-/'6*2"$+"$"+:+-*("'7"-*55/-'5/$%"6*9'-/$-/'6"/6"-E'"

+*6+*+J"K.5'09.".0('05>"-.*"2'a*6+"45'B/2*2"$"(*$6+"'7"6*9'-/$-/69"+'&/$%"./*5$5&./*+>"10-"

-.*"&$-*9'5/*+"'7"45'7$6/-:"0+*2"$%+'"+.'E*2"E.'"E$+"&'6+/2*5*2"/6+/2*"'5"'0-+/2*"'7"-.*"

('5$%"-*55/-'5/$%"&'((06/-:"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01J"8$5$.>"$":'0-."E'5F*5>"$62"`:%/*>"'6*"'7"-.*"

:'069"4*'4%*>"E*5*"-.*"&%01Y+"('+-"45'7/&/*6-"45$&-/-/'6*5+"$62"5*90%$5%:"-5$2*2"W:'05"

($(($Y"/6+0%-+J",+"/6-5'20&*2"/6"S.$4-*5"T6*>"-.*:"('B*2"75'("l:'05"(0("+*%%+"&5$&Fn"-'"

l:'05"(0("+'%2".*5"-**-."7'5"&5$&Fn"-'"l:'05"(0("+'%2".*5"E.'%*".'0+*"-'"$";/-.0$6/$6"7'5"

&5$&FnJ"K.*"WE.'%*".'0+*Y"E$+"0+*2"-'"$&&*6-0$-*"-.*"/6+0%-j"-.*"7/905*"'7"-.*"W<$+-*56"

<05'4*$6Y"5*45*+*6-*2"5$&/$%/+*2"+&$62$%"$62".0('05j"$62"-.*"/6B'&$-/'6"'7"-.*"('-.*5"

+:(1'%/+*2"2*7/%*(*6-"'7"-.*"+$&5*2"1:"4$-5/$5&.:"G;*9($6"!PMN>"44JM@\gM?MIJ"lZ'05"(0("

+'%2".*5"E.'%*".'0+*"-'"$";/-.0$6/$6"7'5"&5$&Fn>"E'6J"

"

d./%*"-.*"2'a*6+"E$+"0+*2"-'"(0-0$%%:"$77/5("1*%'69/69"/-"$%+'"($/6-$/6*2"$62"6*9'-/$-*2"

$0-'&.-.'6'0+"-*55/-'5/*+"1:"&$+-/69"-.'+*"E.'"2/2"6'-"1*%'69"$+"'1H*&-+"'7"+&$62$%"$62"

5/2/&0%*J"A6"-./+"*C$(4%*>"-.*+*"7'5(+"'7".0('05"E*5*"7*2"1:"-.*"(*2/$"2*4/&-/'6+"'7"<$+-*56"

<05'4*$6"(*6"$+"B/'%*6->"2506F"$62"&5/(/6$%"G3$/%:"#$/%"?@@e$>"1I>"E./&."7'%%'E*2"-.*"

$&&*++/'6"'7"<$+-*56"<05'4*$6"6$-/'6+"/6-'"-.*"<05'4*$6"[6/'6"$62"-.*"+01+*h0*6-"(/95$-/'6"

'7"-.*/5"/6.$1/-$6-+"-'"U*E.$(J"K./+"E$+"4$5-"'7"$"%'&$%"062*5+-$62/69"'7"45'7$6/-:"E./&."$%+'"

*6&'(4$++*2"W='%*+Y>"WR0++/$6+Y>"W;/-.0$6/$6+Y>"W`'+'B$6+Y>"WX:4+/*+Y"$62"W&5$&F".*$2+YJ"d.*6"$"

&.$/5"E*6-"(/++/69>"7'5"*C$(4%*>"`:%/*"H'F*2"l='%*+"&$(*"$62"-''F"/-nJ"K./+"E$+"+:6'6:('0+"

E/-."l=/F*:+"-''F"/-n"'5"lS5$&FQ.*$2+"-''F"/-nJ"

"

K.*+*"7'5(+"'7"45'7$6/-:"E*5*"4$5-"'7"$"E/2*5"2/+&5/(/6$-'5:"5*4*5-'/5*"0+*2"-'"2*7/6*"

1*%'69/69J"d.*6"E*"4%$:*2"7''-1$%%>"K'((:"$62"U/9*%"E'062"=$E%"04"1:"+$:/69"./+"(0("E$+"

WR0++/$6Y"$62"WR'($6/$6Y"*B*6"-.'09."-.*:"F6*E"-.$-"+.*"E$+"='%/+.J"A6+0%-+"2/5*&-*2"$-"./("

E*5*"'7-*6"45*7/C*2"E/-."l:'0"%/--%*"='%/+.mnJ"305/69"-.*"?@!@"d'5%2"S04>"d/%%"/6B/-*2"-.*"

:'069"4*'4%*"-'"+/-"5'062"$62"E$-&."-.*"<69%$62"9$(*"E/-."-.*"E'52+"lE*"+.'0%2"$%%"+/-"5'062"

$62"+044'5-"'05"&'06-5:nJ"_*"2/26Y-"h0/-*"(*$6"/-"$+"/-"+'062*2"10-"U$-.*"+*/a*2"'6"/-"$62"+$/2"

-'"=$E%>"l:'05"-*$("/+"='%$62nJ"A6"-./+"E$:>"=$E%Y+"'-.*56*++"'6";*:.$("-*55/-'5:"E$+"

+0+-$/6*2J"

Page 112: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!!?"

"

"

K.*"E./-*"-*55/-'5:"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01"E$+"$%+'"($/6-$/6*2"-.5'09."5/2/&0%/69"-.*"1%$&F"1'2:J"

T6*"*B*6/69>"`:%/*"$62")'+/*"E*5*"4%$:/69"-.*"2'a*6+"E/-."U/9*5/$6"$&&*6-+"g"$"5*7*5*6&*"-'"

-.*"&.$5$&-*5"X*'59*",92929E69'"/6"E%(+a4$=+3J"A-"E$+6Y-"/((*2/$-*%:"&%*$5"E.*-.*5"-./+"4%$:"

E$+"5$&/+->"*B*5:2$:"'5"*B*6"+01B*5+/B*J"_'E*B*5>"R:$6>"$"1%$&F":'0-."E'5F*5>"5*+4'62*2"$+"/7"

-.*"1$6-*5"E$+"4$5-%:"2/5*&-*2"$-"./(J",E$5*"'7"$"60(1*5"'7"5$&/+-"/6&/2*6-+"/6"-.*":'0-."&%01>"

-./+"5*+4'6+*"E$+6Y-"+0545/+/69J",+"/7"-'"2/+4*%"$6:"5*($/6/69"2'01->"-.*"5'062"'7"2'a*6+"

7/6/+.*2"E.*6"3$E6"+*(/Q+*5/'0+%:"+099*+-*2"-.*:"9'"$62"1*$-"+'(*"4*'4%*"04J"3$4.6*"

+099*+-*2"lS%01",75/h0*"'5"-.*"='%/+.".$/525*++*5n"$+"B*60*+J"

"

K.*"1'2:"E$+"$%E$:+"45*+*6-"/6"-.*"E/62Q04>"*/-.*5"1:"45'B/2/69"$"&'54'5*$%"&'6-$/6*5"7'5"

$1H*&-/'6"'5"*+-**("G+'(*-/(*+"5$&/$%/+*2I"'5"-.5'09."-.*"-.5*$-"'7"($+&0%/6*"B/'%*6&*J";0F*>"

-E*%B*>"$--*62*2";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01"7'5"$"7*E"('6-.+J";0F*"%/B*2"2'E6"-.*"5'$2"75'("-.*"+/-*>"

E$+"(/%2%:"$0-/+-/&>"$62"$+"E/-."$"60(1*5"'7"'-.*5":'069"4*'4%*"E$+"'6",3_3"G,--*6-/'6"

3*7/&/-"_:4*5$&-/B/-:"3/+'52*5I"(*2/&$-/'6J",%-.'09.".*"-5/*2".$52"-'"1*"75/*62+"E/-."-.*"'-.*5"

:'069"4*'4%*"$62"4$5-/&/4$-*"/6"-.*/5"H'F*+>".*"$%E$:+"+%/9.-%:"(/+5*$2"-.*(>"$-"%*$+-"/6"-.*/5"

-*5(+J",+".*"+*--%*2"/6-'"-.*":'0-."&%01>"7$(/%/$5"5'0-/6*+"*(*59*2J"Z'069"4*'4%*"E'0%2"-5:"

$62"6*9'-/$-*"-.*/5"'E6"1*%'69/69"1:"E/62/69"./("04J",+":'069"4*'4%*"($2*"/-"-.5'09."-'"-.*"

6*C-"5'062"'7"d*(1%*:\!"1*/69"4%$:*2"/6"-.*"75'6-"5''(>"-.*:"&$(*"/6-'"-.*"1$&F"5''("-'"

.$5$++"./(J"A-"1*9$6"E/-.")$&F>"$+"/-"'7-*6"2/2J"d$%F/69"'B*5"-'"./(>")$&F"/67'5(*2"./("-.$-".*"

E$+"9'/69"-'"./-"./("$62"-.*6"E./+4*5*2"+'(*-./69"/6"./+"*$5J";0F*"&'(4%$/6*2"-'"(*J"A"E$+"

('6/-'5/69"-.*"&'(40-*5"5''("$62"A"-'%2")$&F"-'"l8.0-"04vn"K.*"10%%:/69"&'6-/60*2"7'5"$"7*E"

(/60-*+J"K.*6"#$62:"&$(*"/6"$62"A"%*7-"7'5"-.*"9$(*J"d.*6"A"&$(*"1$&F"/6-'"-.*"&'(40-*5"

5''(>"$6'-.*5":'069"($6".$2"9'6*"-.5'09.>"E$%F*2"/6-'"-.*"1$&F"5''("$62"E$+"2'/69"-.*"

+$(*J"K.*+*"*6&'06-*5+"7'%%'E*2"-.*"4$--*56"'7"-.*"E/62Q04>"10-"E.$-"($2*"-.*("2/+-/6&-/B*"

E$+"-.*"%/(/-*2"+&'4*";0F*".$2"7'5"E/66/69J"K.*"E$:"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"2*7/6*2";0F*"(*$6-"

-.$-"$E$:"75'("-.*"9$a*"'7":'0-."E'5F*5+>".*"E$+"$%E$:+"$"-$59*->"$62"./+"1'2:"E$+"$-"5/+F"

75'("4.:+/&$%"$--$&FJ"K./+"7'5("'7"-*55/-'5/$%"4'%/-/&+"(*$6-"-.$-"$7-*5"$"7*E"('6-.+".*"%*7-"-.*"

:'0-."&%01J"K.*"+4$&*"E$+"-''"-.5*$-/69"7'5"./(J"

"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""\!"d*(1%*:"/+"$"7''-1$%%"9$(*J",%%"4%$:*5+"&'(4*-*"$9$/6+-"*$&."'-.*5"-'"+&'5*"9'$%+"$9$/6+-"$"+/69%*"

9'$%F**4*5J"=$5-/&/4$6-+"E.'"+&'5*"9'"-.5'09."-'"-.*"6*C-"5'062J"

Page 113: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!!O"

"

K.*"E/62Q04"E$+"$%+'"0+*2"$+"$"+:+-*("7'5"*+-$1%/+./69"-*55/-'5/$%"&'6-5'%"/6"$590(*6-+"

1*-E**6"75/*62+./4"95'04+J"T6*"*B*6/69"$-";*:.$("-.*5*"E$+"$"+-$62'77"1*-E**6"-E'"95'04+J"

,%%"E*5*"%'69+-$62/69"(*(1*5+"$62"E**F+"1*7'5*"$%%".$2"1**6"75/*62+J"K.*"$590(*6-"-.$-"

6/9.-".$2"+-$5-*2"1*&$0+*")'+/*>"E.'"7$6&/*2"U/9*%>".$2"1**6"+45*$2/69"50('05+"$1'0-"./("

$62"$6'-.*5"9/5%"'6"]$&*1''FJ"U/9*%".$2"-'%2")'+/*".*"2/26Y-"%/F*".*5"$6:('5*"$62"-.*"

&'675'6-$-/'6".$2"40+.*2"-.*"'44'+/69"95'04+"'6-'"2/77*5*6-"+/2*+"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01>"$62"/6-'"

2/77*5*6-"'6%/6*"$%%/$6&*+J"K.*"-*55/-'5/$%"7$0%-"%/6*"E$+"(0-0$%%:"$&F6'E%*29*2"$62"'B*5"-.*"

&'05+*"'7"-.*"*B*6/69"/62/B/20$%+"75'("-.*"2/77*5*6-"+/2*+"('B*2"/6-'"-.*"'44'+/69"-*55/-'5:"-'"

45'B'F*"$"5*+4'6+*"'5"+*62"$".'+-/%*"(*++$9*J",-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"-.*:"6$B/9$-*2"$6"'6%/6*"

9$(*"'7"*C&%0+/'6"$62"/6&%0+/'6"-.5'09."401%/&%:".$5$690/69"*$&."'-.*5"'6"]$&*1''F>"7'5"

E./&."1'-."4$5-/*+"5*&*/B*2"042$-*+"'6"-.*/5"('1/%*"4.'6*+J"

"

)'+/*"E$+"%'+/69"+044'5-"5$4/2%:"$62".$%7E$:"-.5'09."-.*"6/9.-".$2"'6%:"'6*"5*$%QE'5%2"W75/*62Y"

5*($/6/69"'6".*5"+/2*"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01J"A"&'0%26Y-"-*%%".'E"+.*"E$+"7$5/69"'6"]$&*1''FJ"K.*"

*C&%0+/'6"+.*"E$+"$1'0-"-'"7$&*"E$+"1*&'(/69"$44$5*6-J"K./+"E$+"$"1/9"2*$%"7'5")'+/*J"8.*"

&$(*"$%('+-"*B*5:"6/9.->"/-"E$+"E.*5*"+.*"+'&/$%/+*2"$62"/-"E$+"E.*5*"+.*"7*%-"+.*"1*%'69*2J"

,+"$"7/6$%"$--*(4-"-'"1'%+-*5".*5"E$6/69"&5*2/1/%/-:"+.*"1*&$(*"('5*"$6/($-*2"-'"

&'((06/&$-*"-'".*5+*%7"$62".*5"5/B$%+"-.$-"+.*"2/26Y-"&$5*J",+"4$5-"'7"-./+"45'&*++"+.*"

*C$99*5$-*2".*5"$%%*9/$6&*+"E/-."-.*"($%*":'0-."E'5F*5+>"&'(/69"'B*5"-'"0+"$62"0+/69".*5"

+*C0$%/-:"-'"9*6*5$-*"&'6B*5+$-/'6J"A6"-./+"E$:>"+.*"+'09.-"-'"$%/96".*5+*%7>"4*5.$4+"$+"$"7'5("

'7"45'-*&-/'6>"E/-."-.*"+:(1'%+"'7"($+&0%/6*"$0-.'5/-:"/6"-.*":'0-."&%01J",-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"+.*"

E$+"+.'E/69"U/9*%"+.*"&'0%2"2'"E/-.'0-"./+"$--*6-/'6J"

"

,+"$"5*+0%-"'7"-.*+*"$&-/'6+"-*6+/'6+"5'+*"$62"1:"-.*"*62"-.*5*"E$+"$"+($%%"9$-.*5/69"'0-+/2*"

E$/-/69"-'"&'675'6-".*5"E.*6"+.*"%*7-J"S''52/6$-/'6"7'5"$"7/9.-"E$+"'6Q9'/69"$62"('1/%*+"E*5*"

4/69/69"$62"5/69/69J"d.*6"3$4.6*"GE.'".$2"$"5*40-$-/'6"$+"$"9''2"7/9.-*5I"-056*2"04>"

4.:+/&$%"B/'%*6&*"E$+"'6"-.*"&$52+J")'+/*"E$+"$2$($6-"+.*"&'0%2"l.$B*".*5nJ",6:-./69"*%+*"

E'0%2".$B*"1**6"&$4/-0%$-/'6J"K.*":'0-."&%01"&%'+*2"$62"-.*"E'5F*5+"%*7-J"A"6*B*5"+$E".'E"

-.$-"6/9.-"7/6/+.*2J"^0-"%$-*5"-.$-"E**F")'+/*"E$+"$"6'-$1%*"$1+*6&*J"A"$+F*2"E.*5*"+.*"E$+"10-"

6'1'2:"E$6-*2"-'"+$:J"K.*:"E*5*6Y-"9'/69"-'"95$++J"K.*6"$"7*E"E**F+"%$-*5"+.*"&$(*"1$&FJ"

d$%F/69"/6"+.*"$66'06&*2"45'02%:"l)'+/*"/+"1$&FnJ"8.*"E$+"25*++*2"/6"$"1$99:"'B*5+/a*"KQ+./5-"

E/-."$"7%'E*5"&%/4"/6".*5".$/5J"A-"E$+"$"1'%2"+-$-*(*6-J"8.*"E$+"5*&%$/(/69".*5"-*55/-'5:J"

Page 114: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!!\"

"

S'6&%0+/'6"

,%%"'7"-.*+*"45$&-/&*+>"1:"$62"%$59*>"($/6-$/6*2"$"E$:"'7"0+/69"-.*":'0-."&%01"+4$&*"-.$-":'069"

4*'4%*>"+-$77"$62"4'%/&*"7'062"$&&*4-$1%*J"d*"$%%"F6*E"5'09.%:"E.*5*"-.*"1'062$5/*+"E*5*"

$62"/-"E$+"5$5*"-.$-"$"45'B'&$-/'6"'5"5*+4'6+*"2/26Y-"(**-"-.*"*C4*&-$-/'6+"'7"-.*"&'%%*&-/B*J"

K./+"/+"6'-"-'"+$:"-.$-"-.*":'0-."&%01"2/2"6'-"&'6-$/6"4*$F+"$62"-5'09.+"'7"&'%%*&-/B*"*('-/'6"

10->"/7"-*6+/'6+"5'+*>"$"-/(*-$1%*2"15*$F>"%/F*"-.*"+&.''%".'%/2$:+>"5*+*-"-.*"1$%$6&*J"K.*+*"

7'5(+"'7"$0-.'5/-:"$62"&'6+*6-"(*$6-"-.*":'0-."&%01"&'6-/60*2"-'"706&-/'6"$+"$"+4$&*"'7"+'&/$%"

$62"-*55/-'5/$%"'52*5J"_'E*B*5>"-.*"*77*&-+"'7"-.*"&0-+>"(*2/$-*2"-.5'09."($+&0%/6*"B/'%*6&*>"

$0-'&.-.'6:"$62"6*'Q&'((06/-$5/$6/+("+-$5-*2"-'"&.$69*"-.*"1$%$6&*"'7"$0-.'5/-:J"K.*"E/62Q

04>"E./&.".$2"45*B/'0+%:"706&-/'6*2"-'E$52+"$"&'%%*&-/B*"*h0/%/15/0(>"+-$5-*2"-'"45'B/2*"$"

B*56$&0%$5"7'5"&.$%%*69/69"-.*"+:+-*(+"'7"2'(/6$6-"'52*5J"

"

,-"-.*"*62"'7"'6*"*B*6/69"-.*5*"E$+"$"&'675'6-$-/'6"1*-E**6"d/%%"$62"R'++J"R'++"E$+".$B/69"$"

2/77/&0%-"-/(*"$-".'(*J",%%'E$6&*+"E*5*"6'5($%%:"($2*"7'5"/62/B/20$%"&/5&0(+-$6&*+"10-"-.*"

&0-+"E*5*"1/-/69"$62"-.*"%$&F"'7"5*+'05&*+"$62"9''2"h0$%/-:"+-$77"E$+"1*/69"F**6%:"7*%-J",-"-.*"

-/(*>"d/%%"$%+'".$2"45'1%*(+"$-".'(*>"$77*&-/69"./+"&$4$&/-:"-'"W-$F*"$"H'F*YJ"8'"5$-.*5"-.$6"

W%$09."R'++"'77Y"E.*6".*"$&-*2"04>"d/%%"+.'0-*2"$-"./(>"$62"5$-.*5"-.$6"$&&*4-"-.*"-*%%/69Q'77>"

R'++"($2*"$"5$+41*55:"$-"d/%%J"d/%%"1$66*2"R'++"7'5"$"E**FJ"U**2/69"-'"2*7*62"./+"($+&0%/6/-:"

/6"75'6-"'7"./+"75/*62+>"R'++"5*70+*2"-'"9'J"_/+"(0("E$+"&$%%*2"$62"/6"-.*"*62"R'++"%*7-"B'E/69"

-'"&'(*"1$&F"-.*"6*C-"2$:J"K.*"2$:"$7-*5>".*"-*$+*2"d/%%Y+"$0-.'5/-:"1:"+&'0-/69"-.*"4*5/(*-*5"

'7";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01"'6"-.*".$62%*1$5+"'7"U$-.*Y+"1/F*J"

"

K./+"*B*6-"2/2"6'-"+/96$%"$"+022*6"2'E6-056"10-"5$-.*5"$"+%'E"+./7-"/6"&'6-5'%"'B*5"-.*"+4$&*J"

T6*"'7"-.*"($H'5"7*$-05*+"'7"-./+"+%'E"+./7-"E$+"-.*"/6&5*$+/69%:"($+&0%/6/+$-/'6"'7":'0-."&%01"

9'B*56$6&*"*(1'2/*2"45/6&/4$%%:"/6"d/%%J"d/%%Y+"E/%%/696*++"-'"($F*"0+*"'7"-./+"4.:+/&$%/-:\?"-'"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""\?"^*7'5*"A"$55/B*2>"$"%'&$%"F/2".$2"1**6"1$2%:"1*$-*6"04"1:"-E'"(*(1*5+"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01>"E.'".$2"

F6'&F*2"&'04%*"'7"./+"-**-."'0->"15'F*6"./+"6'+*"$62".$62J"^*&$0+*"./+"$++$/%$6-+"$--*62*2";*:.$("$-"

-.*"-/(*>"-.*"7$-.*5"'7"-.*"$++$0%-*2":'069"4*5+'6".$2"&'(*"'B*5"-'"+'5-"-.*("'0-J"_*"E$+"l$"1/9"4/*&*"

'7"(*$->"%/F*".*".$2"-.5**"6*&F+n>"d/%%"-'%2"(*J"_*".$2"&'(*"/6-'"-.*":'0-."&%01"$62"d/%%>"$"+*++/'6$%"

E'5F*5"$-"-.*"-/(*>".$2"9'-"04"-'"95**-"./(J"#/+-$F/69"d/%%"7'5"'6*"'7"-.*"$++$/%$6-+>"-.*"90:"+E069"$-"

./("%$62/69"$"406&."'6"./+"&./6J"d/%%"+-0(1%*2"1$&F>"9'-"./(+*%7"-'9*-.*5>"20&F*2"-.*"+*&'62"406&.>"

H0(4*2"'6"-.*"($6"$62"4/66*2"./("-'"-.*"4''%"-$1%*"1:"./+"6*&FJ"d.*6"-.*"($6".$2"&$%(*2"2'E6>"d/%%"

Page 115: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!!N"

"

45*B*6-"-.*":'0-."&%01"75'("&%'+05*"E$+>"7'5"$"-/(*>"+077/&/*6-"-'"($/6-$/6"&'6-5'%"'B*5"-.*"

+4$&*J"_'E*B*5>"-.*"45*++05*"-''F"/-+"-'%%"$62"+$44*2"./+"*6-.0+/$+("7'5"-.*"H'1J"<$&."'7"./+"

/6&5*$+/69"$1+*6&*+"E$+"($5F*2"1:"+*5/'0+"-5$6+95*++/'6+"75'("-.*":'069"4*'4%*>"-'"E./&."

'-.*5"+-$77"&'0%2"6'-"5*+4'62J";'69+-$62/69"+:(1'%/&"1'062$5/*+"E*5*"-.*"7/5+-"-'"1*"15'F*6J"

Z'069"4*'4%*"5$6"$5'062"-.*"1$&F"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01>"E.*5*"10/%2*5+Y"($-*5/$%+"E*5*"F*4->"-.*:"

&%/(1*2"'6"&$5+>"+('F*2"/6"75'6-"'7"-.*"10/%2/69>"5*70+*2"-'"5*9/+-*5"-.*/5"6$(*+"'5"4$:"-.*/5"

+01+>"$62"'6"$"&'04%*"'7"'&&$+/'6+"E*6-"04"/6-'"-.*"+-$77"'77/&*+"-.$-"E*5*"+-5/&-%:"'0-"'7"

1'062+J",09(*6-*2"%*B*%+"'7"B/'%*6&*"$62"$10+*"$&&'(4$6/*2"-.*"&.$69/69"1$%$6&*"'7"4'E*5>"

$62"5$&/+("75'("E./-*":'069"4*'4%*"-'E$52+"1%$&F"$62",+/$6":'069"4*'4%*>"$62":'0-."

E'5F*5+"1*&$(*"/6&5*$+/69%:"B'&$%/+*2J"

"

K./+"1*.$B/'05"7*2"'0-"'6-'"-.*"+-5**-"$62"/6"$"5*%$-*2"/6&/2*6-"d/%%Y+"15'-.*5"E$+"$--$&F*2"$-"

-.*"%'&$%"401J"K.*":'069"(*6"-.$-"E*5*"/6B'%B*2"/6"-.*"$--$&F"&$(*"1$&F"-'"-.*":'0-."&%01"$"

7*E"E**F+"%$-*5"-'"+-*$%"-.*"d//"&'6-5'%%*5"$62"('5*"/(4'5-$6-%:"-'"705-.*5"('&F"d/%%Y+"

$0-.'5/-:J"3$:+"%$-*5"d/%%"E$+"+/--/69"'0-+/2*"E.*6".*"E$+"+.'-"$-"E/-."$"&$-$40%-"$62".$2"$"

%0(4"'7"&'6&5*-*"-.5'E6"$-"./(J"K.$-"E$+"-.*"*62J"d/%%"2*&/2*2"-'"%*$B*"-.*":'0-."&%01J"

=0+.*2"/6-'"-.*"5'%*"'7"1'06&*5".*".$2"1**6"'0-(0+&%*2J"

"

K.*"&'6+-50&-/'6"'7"-.*"7*6&*"$62"-.*"5*+4'6+*"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"2*7/6*2"-.*"2*B*%'4(*6-"

'7"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"-*55/-'5:"$5'062";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01J"d.$-"-.*"7*6&*"5*$%%:"2*('6+-5$-*2"

E*5*"-.*"*C-*6-"-'"E./&."6*'Q&'((06/-$5/$6/+("$62"4'%/&/69".$2"1*&'(*"/695$/6*2"/6"-.*"

%'&$%"$5*$J"#'5*"/(4'5-$6-"-.$6"/-+"45'-*&-/B*"5'%*"E$+"-.*"/%%0+/'6"'7"$"2*7/$6-"&'((06/-:"/-"

45'B/2*2J"A-"+'%/2/7/*2"2*+/5*+"7'5"$0-'&.-.'6'0+"1*%'69/69"$62"6*'Q&'((06/-$5/$6/+("/6"-.*"

7$&*"'7"/6&5*$+/69"06&*5-$/6-:>"&0-+"-'"-.*"E*%7$5*"+-$-*"$62"&'6&*56+"7'5"-.*"/($9/6*2":'0-."

-.5*$-J"K.*+*"/2*'%'9/*+"'7"-.5*$-"E*5*"4$5-"'7"-.*"E/2*5"2/+&'05+*+"'7"&.$'+"$62"'52*5"-.$-"

E*5*"&'5*"-'"%'&$%"$9*62$+"'6"4'%/&/69"$62"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6J"K.5'09."5$/+/69"/-+"4*5/(*-*5>"-.*"

:'0-."&%01"E$+"2*7/6/69"E.*5*"'52*5"$62"2/+'52*5"*C/+-*2>"$62"-.0+"E.*5*":'069"4*'4%*"

+.'0%2>"'5"+.'0%2"6'->"%*9/-/($-*%:"1*J"]'5"$"&%01"25$/6*2"'7"5*+'05&*+>"-.*"7*6&*"+:(1'%/+*2"$"

('B*"75'("45$&-/&*+"'7"&'6+*6-"-'"-.'+*"'7"B/'%*6&*J"

"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

%*-"./("9'>"*C4%$/6/69"-.$-".*"&'0%26Y-"&'(*"-'"-.*":'0-."&%01"%''F/69"7'5"$"7/9.-J"K.*"90:"+.''F"./+".$62"

$62"%*7-J"

Page 116: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!!e"

"

_'E*B*5>"-.*"7*6&*"E$+"$%+'"$6"$%%*9'5:"7'5"'-.*5"-*55/-'5/$%"4'%/-/&+J"K.*"2/77*5*6-"+&$%*+"'7"

-*55/-'5/$%"4'%/-/&+"/6"$62"$5'062"-.*":'0-."&%01"E*5*"/6-/($-*%:"/6-*5%/6F*2J"A-"E$+"6'-"4'++/1%*"

-'"&'6+/2*5"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"-*55/-'5:"/6";*:.$("E/-.'0-"$%+'"&'6+/2*5/69"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"-.*"

+-5**-+>"]$&*1''F>"-.*".'(*"$62"-.*"401J"A-"E$+"$%+'"6'-"4'++/1%*"-'"&'6+/2*5"-.*"&'6+-50&-/'6"

'7"6*'Q&'((06/-$5/$6"&'((06/-:"$-";*:.$("+*4$5$-*%:"75'("-.*"E/2*5"&'((06/-:"'7"E./&."/-"

7*%-"4$5-J"3/+&'05+*+"'7"+*&05/-:"$62"1*%'69/69"E*5*"($2*"+*6+*"'7"-.5'09."-.*"./+-'5:"'7"%'&$%"

5/B$%5/*+"$62"-.*/5"5$&/$%/+$-/'6J"K.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"-*55/-'5:"$%+'"706&-/'6*2"-.'09."-.*"(/&5'Q

4'%/-/&+"'7"2/$%'90*J"K.*+*"(/&5'Q4'%/-/&+"+.'E*2"&'6&5*-*%:".'E":'069"4*'4%*"G6'-"H0+-":'0-."

E'5F*5+>"-.*"4'%/&*"$62"%'&$%"/6+-/-0-/'6+I"E*5*"/6B'%B*2"/6"-.*"6*9'-/$-/'6+"'7"-*55/-'5/*+"/6"

E./&."-.*:"5*+/2*2J"K.*"7'5("'7"(/&5'Q4'%/-/&$%"B*56$&0%$5"GF6'E6"$+"-.*"E/62Q04I"45'B/2*2"$"

(*2/0("7'5"($/6-$/6/69"$".$1/-0$%"*h0/%/15/0(J"K./+"*h0/%/15/0("E$+"2*7/6*2"-.5'09."&'6+*6-"

-'"-.*"&'%%*&-/B*"'52*5"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01J"_'E*B*5>"/-"$%+'"45'B/2*2"&'2*+"-.5'09."E./&."'52*5"

&'0%2"1*"('&F*2>"-5$6+95*++*2"$62"$--$&F*2"E.*6"-.*"7062/69"E$+"5*20&*2J""

"

]/6$%%:>"-./+"&.$4-*5".$+"45*+*6-*2"$6"$6$%:+/+"'7"-.*"/6&5*$+/69"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"0675**2'("

'7":'069"4*'4%*"/6"401%/&"+4$&*J"K.*"W5'%%"'0-Y"'7"-.*"E*%7$5*"+-$-*".$+"%*2"-'"$6"$44$5$-0+"'7"

4'%/&/69"-.$-"*C-*62+"E*%%"/6+/2*"-.*":'0-."&%01>"2*7/6/69"E.$-":'0-."&%01+"2'"$62"/67%0*6&/69"

.'E"-.*:"2*7/6*"-.*/5"-*55/-'5/*+J"K./+"E$+"$"('B*"1*:'62":'0-."&%01+"$+"$"+/-*"'7"'52*5"

G2*7/6*2"$9$/6+-"-.*"+-5**-+"$+"$"+*$"'7"2/+'52*5I"-'":'0-."&%01+"$+"+/-*+"'7"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6J"

Z'069"4*'4%*"5*+/+-*2"-.*+*"6*E"5*9/(*+J"d./%*"$&-+"-.$-"-''F"$2B$6-$9*"'7"-.*"+$7*-:"'7"-.*"

:'0-."&%01"2/2"%/--%*"-'"&.$%%*69*"-.*"4'%/&*Y+"$0-.'5/-:>"('5*"45'7'062"&.$%%*69*+"E*5*"

*B/2*6-"/6"-.*"*B*5:2$:"+'%/2$5/-/*+"$62".*-*5'9*6*/-/*+"'7":'069"4*'4%*"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+J"

"

A6"-.*"7'%%'E/69"&.$4-*5>"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"-*55/-'5:"$5*"15'09.-"/6-'"2/$%'90*"E/-."-.*"2/$+4'5/&"

7%'E+"'7"./4".'4J"K.*"7'%%'E/69"&.$4-*5"*C4%'5*+"-.*"%'&$%"$62"9%'1$%"E$:+"/6"E./&."./4".'4"

&.$'+"G6/./%/+(I"$62"-*55/-'5/$%/-:"E*5*"&'67%$-*2"$62".'E":'069"4*'4%*"0+*2"-.*"$*+-.*-/&+"'7"

6/./%/+("-'"&'((06/&$-*"$62"('B*"1*:'62"4'+-&'2*"B/'%*6&*"$62"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:J"

Page 117: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!!M"

"

S.$4-*5"]'05"g"8'%2Q'0-"$62"6/./%/+-/&i"<$+-";'62'6"./4".'4"45'20&-/'6+"

^*-E**6"+45/69"?@@P"$62"-.*"1*9/66/69"'7"?@!@";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01"('B*2"-'"-.*"5.:-.("'7"

-.5**"(0+/&"$62"2$6&*"45'20&-/'6+J"K.*"7/5+-"'7"-.*+*"E$+"8+/94&!>4($+-J"A6+4/5*2"1:"-.*"

.09*%:"4'40%$5"^5/-$/6Y+"X'-"K$%*6-"GAKc"?@@PI>"8+/94&!>4($+-!E$+"$"&'%%*&-/B*"*77'5-"$-"

W+-5**-2$6&*Y"g"$".:15/2"'7"15*$F"2$6&/69"$62"$-.%*-/&>"95'04"2$6&*"5'0-/6*+"4'40%$5/+*2"

-.5'09."-.*"$%%Q($%*"2$6&*"95'04+"3/B*5+/-:"$62"]%$E%*++J"A(/-$-/69"-.*"8$-052$:"6/9.-"Kc"

7'5($->":'069"(*6"$62"E'(*6"'59$6/+*2"45$&-/&*"+*++/'6+"$62"&.'5*'95$4.*2"5'0-/6*+J",6:"

5*($/6/69"+'&/'%'9/&$%"2'01-"$1'0-"./4".'4Y+"+'%2Q'0-"&$&.*-"GX/%5':"?@@OI"+**(*2"2/+4*%%*2J"

K.*"-./52"45'20&-/'6"-''F"4%$&*"$-"-.*"1*9/66/69"'7"?@!@"/6"-.*"7'5("'7"$"Z'0K01*"4'+-/69"

&$%%*2"A'11!411!4!>+&>"$"./4".'4D95/(*"B/2*'"($2*"1:"$"-5/'"'7"%'&$%":'069"E./-*"(*6"1$&F*2"1:"

:'0-."&%01"(*(1*5+J";/F*"8+/94&!>4($+-2!A'11!411!4!>+&"($2*"0+*"'7"./4".'4Y+"+'%2Q'0-"

$*+-.*-/&+>"10-"$%+'"*69$9*2"E/-."/-+"6/./%/+-/&"5*4*5-'/5*J"_'+-*2"'6"$6"A6-*56*-"4%$-7'5(>"/-"

&'((06/&$-*2"-.*"-.*(*+"'7"($+&0%/6/-:>"B/'%*6&*"$62"-057"E$57$5*"-:4/&$%"'7"($6:"%'&$%"

45'20&-/'6+J",-"7/5+-"9%$6&*"-.*+*"45'20&-/'6+"+**(*2"-'"&'67/5("-E'"45/6&/4$%"&5/-/h0*+"0+*2"

-'"+/%*6&*":'069"4*'4%*Y+"$&-+"'7"401%/&"&'((06/&$-/'6"GS$%.'06"!PP?j"]5$+*5"?@@Mj"X/%5':"

!PPOj"_$1*5($+"!PVPj"U*9-"$62"`%09*"!PPOI"g"-.$-"-.*:"$5*"6/./%/+-/&"$62"+'%2Q'0-J"

"

3/+&'05+*+"'6"6/./%/+(".$B*"2*B*%'4*2"2/77*5*6-%:"/6"-.*"[8"$62"-.*"[`"10-"/6"1'-."&'06-5/*+"

-.*:".$B*"1**6"0+*2"-'"&%'+*"2'E6":'069"4*'4%*Y+"401%/&"45'20&-/'6+"1:"*h0$-/69"-.*("E/-."

/55$-/'6$%"7'5(+"'7"1%$&F"+-5**-"&0%-05*J"A6"-.*"45*B/'0+"&.$4-*5>"7'5(+"'7"2/+'52*5"E*5*"B/*E*2"

-*55/-'5/$%%:J"K./+"&.$4-*5"$2B$6&*+"-.'+*"2/+&0++/'6+"1:"+.'E/69".'E"-*55/-'5/$%"&.$'+"E$+"$%+'"

4$5-"'7"$"-5$6+$-%$6-/&"&'6B*5+$-/'6"&'6&*56*2"E/-."&'((*5&/$%/+*2"1%$&F"&0%-05$%"6/.%/+(J"

"

A6"-.*"&'6-*C-"'7"-./+"&.$4-*5>"W6/./%/+(Y"*6-*5+"-.*"+'&/'%'9/&$%"&$6'6"-.5'09."d*+-Y+"$6$%:+/+"

'7".'4*%*++6*++>"2*+4$/5"$62"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:"/6"4'+-Q+%$B*5:"1%$&F",(*5/&$"Gd*+-"!PP\IJ"

_'E*B*5>"E.*5*$+"d*+-Y+"$6$%:+/+"062*5+-$62+"1%$&F"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:"$+"-.*"'0-&'(*"'7"+'&/$%"

$62"&0%-05$%"45'&*++*+>"2'(/6$6-"2/+&'05+*+"4'+/-/'6"6/./%/+("$+"$6"$0-.*6-/&"$62"4$-.'%'9/&$%"

('2*"'7"%/B/69"7'5"1%$&F"4*'4%*J"A6"-./+"2/+&'05+*>"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+>"+0&."$+"./4".'4>"$62"

4$5-/&0%$5%:"9$69+-$"5$4"G;0&$+"!PPVI>"$5*"5*$2"$+"&'((06/&$-/'6+>"$62"'7-*6"45'('-/'6+>"'7"

Page 118: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!!V"

"

6/./%/+("1*&$0+*"'7"-.*/5"$++'&/$-/'6"E/-."1%$&F"1'2/*+"G^$%2E/6"?@!@j"X/%5':"!PPO>"?@@@IJ"

R$-.*5"-.$6"B/*E"./4".'4"$+"$"B$%/2"/6-*5H*&-/'6"/6-'"401%/&"2*1$-*"$62"2/$%'90*>"/-"/+"2/+&$52*2"

$+"2$69*5'0+"$62"/55$-/'6$%J"A6"-./+"E$:>"2'(/6$6-"2/+&'05+*+"'6"6/./%/+("1*&'(*"4$5-"'7"-.*"

$5('05:"'7"E./-*"+045*($&:"0+*2"-'"5*20&*"-.*"2*('&5$-/&"4$5-/&/4$-/'6"'7"1%$&F"4'40%$-/'6+"

Gd*+-"!PP\IJ"

"

A6"-.*"[`>"2'(/6$6-"2/+&'05+*+"'6"6/./%/+(>"$+"/-"5*%$-*+"-'"1%$&F"&0%-05*>".$B*"$"2/77*5*6-"/7"

5*%$-*2"9*6*+/+J"K./+"9*6*+/+"&'66*&-+"('5$%"4$6/&+"'B*5"5$+-$+"GX/%5':"!PVMI"$62"W(099*5+Y"

G_$%%"*-"$%J"!PMVI"-'"7*$5+"'B*5";'62'6"95/(*"6/9.-+J"]'%%'E/69"-.*"/6-*5B*6-/'6+"'7"

S'6+*5B$-/B*"#="<6'&."='E*%%>"$62"./+"E*%%QF6'E6"WR/B*5+"'7"^%''2Y"+4**&."G='E*%%"$62"d''2"

!PePI>"1%$&F"&0%-05*"/6"-.*"[`"+./7-*2"75'("1*/69"4'5-5$:*2"$+"$"&0%-05*"'7"4'%/-/&$%"5*+/+-$6&*"

-'"$6"$4'%/-/&$%"&0%-05*"'7"B/'%*6&*"$25/7-"75'("($/6+-5*$("E./-*"+'&/*-:"G,%*C$62*5"!PPej"

X/%5':"!PVMj"8'%'('+"!PVVIJ"K.5'09."2/+&'05+*+"'7"1$2"4$5*6-/69"$62"15'F*6"7$(/%/*+"-.$-"

*C-*62"75'("5$&/+-"$++*++(*6-+"'7"+%$B*"&0%-05*"G=$--*5+'6"!PeNI>"-.5'09."2/+&'05+*+"'6"-.*"

1$+-$52"6$-05*"'7"S$5/11*$6"&0%-05*"g"1*-E**6"-.*"('-.*5"%$62"$62"-.*"W2$5F"&'6-/6*6-Y"

GX/%5':"!PVMI>"1%$&F"&0%-05*"E$+"$++'&/$-*2"E/-."2/+%'&$-/'6"$62"2*9*6*5$&:"G_*66*++:"!PVVIJ"

K.*+*"&'62/-/'6+"E*5*"+01+*h0*6-%:"5*$2"-.5'09."-.*"&0%-05$%"+/96/7/*5+"'7"25*$2%'&F+>"

)$($/&$6"2$6&*.$%%"*B*6-+>"+'062"+:+-*(+"GX/%5':"!PVMj"=5:&*"!PVeI"$62"&'675'6-$-/'6+"E/-."

-.*"4'%/&*"G8'%'('+"!PVVIJ"

"

K.*+*"2/+&'05+*+"$%+'"7*2"'77"-.*"./+-'5/&$%"&'62*(6$-/'6"'7"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++":'069"(*6"/6"

^5/-$/6"G_0(4.5/*+"!PV!j"=*$5+'6"!PVOj"d/%%/+"!PMMj"$%+'"2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"K.5**"'7"-./+"

-.*+/+IJ"]*$5+"'B*5"W6/./%/+(Y"$+"$"E'5F/69Q&%$++"+01&0%-05$%"&'62/-/'6"E*5*"*B/2*6-"/6"-.*"('5$%"

4$6/&+"'B*5"-.*"('2+"GS'.*6"?@@?I"$62"'B*5"-.*"+F/6.*$2+Y"7*-/+./+$-/'6"'7"B/'%*6&*"$+"W$995'Y"

/6"-.*"!PM@+"GS%$5F*"*-"$%J"!PMej"R'1/6+"$62"S'.*6"!PMV>"4JVOIJ"K.*+*"7'5(+"'7"B/'%*6&*"E*5*"

062*5+-''2"-.5'09."-.*"&'(('2/7/&$-/'6"'7":'0-."&0%-05*>"$62"-.*"&'6+*h0*6-/$%"2*-$&.(*6-"

'7":'069"4*'4%*"75'("-.*/5"4$5*6-"&0%-05*"$62"$++'&/$-*2"50%*+"'7"&'(4'5-(*6-"GR'1/6+"$62"

S'.*6"!PMVIJ"_'E*B*5>"%/7*+-:%*+"'7":'069"1%$&F"(*6"E*5*"6'-"5*$2"'6%:"$+"E'5F/69Q&%$++"($%*"

&0%-05*+"'7"2*%/6h0*6&:"10-"+4*&/7/&$%%:"$+"T14$="&0%-05*+"'7"6/./%/+("G,%*C$62*5"!PPej";$E5*6&*"

!PV?1IJ"K.*"%*9$&:"'7"-.*+*"2/+&'05+*+"/+"*B/2*6-"-'2$:"/6"('5$%"4$6/&+"'B*5"./4".'4"$62"95/(*"

(0+/&J"R*&055*6-"&'6&*56+"'B*5"./4".'4Y+"45'('-/'6"'7"F6/7*"&0%-05*"G^^S"?@@eI"$62"4'+-&'2*"

Page 119: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!!P"

"

E$5+>"$62"-.*"4'%/&*Y+"0+*"'7"5/+F"$++*++(*6-"7'5("ePe\O"-'"&%'+*"2'E6"W1%$&FY"95/(*"*B*6-+"

G_$6&'C"?@@Pj";'EF*:"?@!?j"=*$5+*"$62"K$:%'5"?@@PI>"/+"-.*"&'67%0*6&*"'7"./+-'5/*+"/6"E./&."

1%$&F"4*'4%*"$62"-.*/5"$5-/+-/&"*C45*++/'6+".$B*"1**6"5*%$-*2"-'"/2*$+"'7"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:>"B/'%*6-"

2/+%'&$-/'6"$62"-.*"W.''2>"$62"/6"E./&."E'5F/69Q&%$++"&0%-05*".$+"1**6"$++'&/$-*2"E/-."B/'%*6-"

2*-$&.(*6-"$62"-057"E$57$5*"GS'.*6"?@@?j"3'E6*+"!Peej"d/%%('--"!PePIJ"

"

_'E*B*5>"E./%*":'069"4*'4%*Y+"401%/&"&'((06/&$-/'6+".$B*"1**6"+/%*6&*2"-.5'09."2/+&'05+*+"

'7"6/./%/+(>"-.*:".$B*"$%+'"1**6"2*%*9/-/(/+*2"-.5'09."-.*/5"$44$5*6-%:"+'%2Q'0-"$62"

&'((*5&/$%"&$&.*-J"K.*"$590(*6-"-.$-":'0-."&0%-05*"/+"+'%2Q'0-"/+"E*%%"2'&0(*6-*2"G`/-E$6$"

?@@?j"=$--'6"?@@PIJ",62"E./%*"-./+"6**2+"-'"1*"&$5*70%%:"+01+-$6-/$-*2"GX/%5':"?@@@I>"

4$5-/&0%$5%:"$+"$"5*+4'6+*"-'"&%$/(+"7'5"./4".'4Y+"$0-.*6-/&"5*B'%0-/'6$5:"&.$5$&-*5"GR'+*"

!PP\I>\\"%*++"5/9'5'0+"&'67%$-/'6+"$5*"'7-*6"($2*J"K.*+*"6'-*"-.*"2*(/+*"'7"051$6":'0-."

&0%-05*"'6"-.*"95'062+"'7"1*/69"6'"('5*"-.$6"-.*"5*4%/&$-/'6"'7"&'((*5&/$%"-5'4*+j"E.$-"

^$0($6>"7'%%'E/69"-.*"?@!!"[`"5/'-+>"2/+&0++*2"$+"W+.'44/69Y"G?@!!IJ"A6"4'40%$5"2/+&'05+*>"-./+"

%*7-QE/69"&5/-/h0*"'7"&'6+0(*5"&0%-05*"&'(1/6*+"E/-.".*9*('6/&>"4'+-Q('2*56/+-"$6$%:+*+"-'"

4'+/-/'6":'069"4*'4%*Y+"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+"$+"/6$0-.*6-/&J"]'%%'E/69")$(*+'6>"-.*+*"

/6-*5B*6-/'6+"-*62"-'"+-$-*"-.$-"1*&$0+*"-.*/5"45'20&-/'6"/+"6'"('5*"-.$6"$"4$+-/&.*"'7"

&'((*5&/$%"/($9*+>"5$-.*5"-.$6"$"('5*"$0-.*6-/&"('2*56"G$62"<05'Q&*6-5/&I"+&5*$(>"-.*:"6'-"

B$%0$1%*"&'6-5/10-/'6+"-'"401%/&"2*1$-*"G)$(*+'6"!PV\>"!PP!IJ\N"K.*"&'67%0*6&*"'7"-.*+*"

$590(*6-+".$+"1**6"*%/2*2"E/-."2'(/6$6-"2/+&'05+*+"'6"6/./%/+("-'"2*6:"$%-*56$-/B*"7'5(+"'7"

4'+/-/B*"401%/&"*C45*++/'6"GX/%5':"!PVMIJ"

"

R*&*6-%:>"-./+"&'6-*(4'5$5:"/6-*5+*&-/'6"'7"+'%2Q'0-"$62"6/./%/+-/&"2/+&'05+*+"'6":'0-."&0%-05*"

.$+"1**6"1*+-"&$4-05*2"1:"='E*%%/-*"$62"S'6+*5B$-/B*"./+-'5/$6"3$B/2"8-$5F*:Y+"$6$%:+/+"'7"-.*"

?@!!"^5/-/+."R/'-+f"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""\O"]'5("ePe"/+"$"5/+F"$++*++(*6-"-.$-"-.*"4'%/&*"5*h0/5*"$"B*60*>"$"45'('-*5"'5"%/&*6+**"-'"45'B/2*"/6"

$2B$6&*"'7"$6"*B*6-J"K.*"7'5("&'6-$/6+"/67'5($-/'6"/6&%02/69"-.*"6$(*+"$62"$225*++*+"'7"3)+"$62"

(0+/&/$6+>"-.*"-:4*"'7"(0+/&"-.$-"E/%%"1*"4%$:*2"$62"-.*"-$59*-"$02/*6&*J",6"*$5%/*5"B*5+/'6"'7"-.*"7'5(>"

+/6&*"5*B'F*2>"$%+'"/6&%02*2"/67'5($-/'6"'6"-.*"*-.6/&/-:"'7"-.*"4*57'5(*5+J"\\X/%5':"&'6-*62+"-.$-"l./4".'4o+"($59/6$%/-:"/+"6'E"$+"'77/&/$%"$62"5'0-/6/+*2"$+"/-+"'B*51%'E6"2*7/$6&*>"

*B*6"/7"-.*"(0+/&"$62"/-+"($-&./69"%/7*Q+-:%*"$5*"+-/%%"1*/69"45*+*6-*2"g"($5F*-*2"g"$+"'0-%$E"7'5(+n"

GX/%5':"?@@@>"4J!V@I"\N"8**"X/%5':"7'5"$"&5/-/h0*"'7")$(*+'6Y+"<05'&*6-5/+("GX/%5':"!PPOIJ"

Page 120: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!?@"

"

"

K.*5*"$5*"-E'"-./69+"$1'0-"-.*+*"5/'-+J"T6"-.*"'6*".$62"-.*:"$5*"&'(4%*-*%:"+04*57/&/$%J"8'(*'6*"15/%%/$6-%:"40-"/-"-.*5*"r/6"-.*"$02/*6&*s"W/-Y+"+.'44/69"E/-."B/'%*6&*Yj"/-Y+"(*5*%:"*C-*62*2"&'((*5&/$%/+("m"K.*"'-.*5"/+"-.$-"-.*5*".$+"1**6"$"45'7'062"&0%-05$%"&.$69*"m"d.$-".$+".$44*6*2"/+"$"+01+-$6-/$%"+*&-/'6"'7"-.*"&.$B+":'0"rTE*6")'6*+s"E5'-*"$1'0-".$B*"1*&'(*"1%$&F>"-.*"E./-*+".$B*"1*&'(*"1%$&Fj"$"4$5-/&0%$5"+'5-"'7"B/'%*6-"2*+-50&-/B*"6/./%/+-/&"9$69+-*5"&0%-05*".$+"1*&'(*"-.*"7$+./'6"$62"1%$&F"$62"E./-*>"1':"$62"9/5%"'4*5$-*"/6"-./+"%$690$9*"-'9*-.*5>"-./+"%$690$9*"-.$-"/+"E.'%%:"7$%+*>"E./&."/+"$")$($/&$6"4$-'/+"-.$-Y+"1**6"/6-502*2"/6"<69%$62J",62"-.$-Y+"E.:"+'"($6:"'7"0+".$B*"-.*"+*6+*"'7"%/-*5$%%:"$"7'5*/96"&'06-5:"G8-$5F*:"?@!!IJ"

"

_*5*"8-$5F*:"0+*+"./+"*+-$1%/+.(*6-"4'+/-/'6"'7"E./-*"^5/-/+."$0-.'5/-:"-'"&%'+*"2'E6"-.*"

401%/&"$62"4'%/-/&$%"&'6-*6-"'7"-.'+*"+0((*5"6/9.-+J"U/./%/+("/+"*h0$-*2"E/-."-.*"(0%-/&0%-05$%"

7'5(+"'7"1%$&F"&0%-05*".*"+**+"$+"&'55'2/69"<69%/+."401%/&"+4/5/-J"K./+"/6"-056"/+"5*%$-*2"-'"

&'((*5&/$%/+(>"7$%+*6*++"$62"B/'%*6&*"-.$-".*"&'6-5$+-+"-'"$"(:-./&"$0-.*6-/&"^5/-$/6J"

8-$5F*:Y+"&5/-/h0*"/+"$"&'6+*5B$-/B*>"(*%$6&.'%/&"$62"E./-*"+045*($&/+-"2*Q%*9/-/(/+$-/'6"'7"

:'069"4*'4%*Y+"(0%-/&0%-05*J"A-"/+"$%+'"$"7'5("'7"4'+-Q('2*56"$6$%:+/+>"/6"E./&."-.*"$-'(/+$-/'6"

'7"$6"/($9/6$5:"^5/-/+."+'0%"/+"('056*2>"$62"-.*"6/./%/+-/&"4$-'/+"$62"&'((*5&/$%/+$-/'6"-.$-"

.$+"5*4%$&*2"/->"&'62*(6*2J""

"

K.*"&'6-*6-/'6"'7"-./+"&.$4-*5"/+"-.$->"5$-.*5"-.$6"&'62*(6"-.*"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+"'7":'069"

4*'4%*"/6"T0-*5"<$+-";'62'6"'6"8-$5F*:Y+"-*5(+>"/-"/+"6*&*++$5:"-'"*C4%'5*".'E"-.*:"$5*"

(*$6/6970%"$62"4'%/-/&$%"/6"-.*"&'6-*C-"'7"-.*"9%'1$%/+$-/'6"'7"./4".'4"$62"6/./%/+-"$*+-.*-/&+J"

8'>"E./%*"8+/94&!>4($+-!25$6F"8/('6"S'E*%%Y+"`''%Q,/2>"/-"$%+'"45'B/2*2"$"(*2/0("-.5'09."

E./&.":'069"4*'4%*"6$B/9$-*2"%'&$%"($59/6$%/+$-/'6J"d./%*"A'11!411!4!>+&!-5$6+%$-*2"./4".'4Y+"

%0&5$-/B*"9%'1$%"%$690$9*"/6-'"$"%'&$%"+-'5:"'7"($+&0%/6*"B/'%*6&*>"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:"$62"-057"E$5>"

/-"$%+'"45'B/2*2"$"(*$6+"-.5'09."E./&.":'069"4*'4%*"1*&$(*"4'%/-/&$%"g"h0*+-/'6/69"$62"

&5/-/h0/69"($59/6$%/+$-/'6>"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:"G8.0+-*5($6"!PP!>"4Je?MIJ"

"

8-$5F*:Y+"$&&'06-"$%+'"./9.%/9.-+"7'5(+"'7"&0%-05$%"+:6&5*-/+("$62"4*57'5($-/B/-:"E/-."E./&."

-./+"&.$4-*5"/+"&'6&*56*2J"K.*"7'5("'7"6/./%/+(".*"/2*6-/7/*+"/+"(0%-/&0%-05$%J"A-"/+6Y-"1%$&F"'5"

E./-*"10-"5$-.*5"$"(0-$1%*"$*+-.*-/&J"A-"/+"&'6-*(4'5$5:"*B/2*6&*"'7"$"%*9$&:"'7"051$6"

&5*$-/B/-:"2/+&0++*2"/6"60(*5'0+"'-.*5"E'5F+"G^$&F"!PP\j"X/%5':"!PVMj"_*E/--"!PVej")'6*+"

!PVVIJ"A6"./+"$&&'06->"6/./%/+("6'"%'69*5"5*-$/6+"7*$%-:"-'"1/'%'9/&$%%:"+4*&/7/&"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:"10-"

5$-.*5"/+"45*+*6-*2"$+"$6"'4*6"+:+-*("'7"&'((*5&/$%"$62"$*+-.*-/&"&'2/69"./9.%/9.-/69"-.*"

Page 121: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!?!"

"

+./7-/69"-*55$/6+"'7"&0%-05*"$62"5$&*"/6"^5/-$/6"GX/%5':"!PVMIJ"3*B*%'4/69"-.*"2/+&0++/'6"'7"-.*"

./+-'5/&"*%/+/'6"'7"1%$&F"$62"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"7'5(+>"-./+"$6$%:+/+"$%%'E+"7'5"W&.$BY"g"$"

5*7*5*6-"-'"-.*"E./-*"062*5&%$++"G2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"]/B*I"g"-'"1*"4%$&*2"$%'69+/2*"7*$5+"'7"

1%$&F"$62",+/$6"E'5F/69Q&%$++"051$6":'069"4*'4%*J"

"

K.*+*"2/(*6+/'6+"'7"&'6-*(4'5$5:"&0%-05*"2*($62"$"5*Q*B$%0$-/'6"'7"2*1$-*+"'6"$0-.*6-/&/-:"

$+"-.*:"5*%$-*"-'"./4".'4J"_/4".'4>"$62"/62**2"/-+"45*&05+'5+"+0&."$+"H$aa>".$+"$%E$:+"1**6"

45$&-/&*2"1:"E./-*"(0+/&/$6+"$62"4*57'5(*5+"G_$55/+'6"?@@Pj"d/%(*5"?@!?I"/6"$22/-/'6"-'"$6"

$55$:"'7"(0%-/&0%-05$%"/6-*5%'&0-'5+J"A6"-./+"&'6-*C->"./4".'4Y+"%'&$-/'6"$+"$6"$0-.*6-/&$%%:"1%$&F"

&0%-05$%"7'5(".$+"$%E$:+"1**6"('5*"&'(4%*CJ"U'6*-.*%*++>"[8"2/+&0++/'6+"'B*5"E.*-.*5"

<(/6*("E$+"/6$0-.*6-/&"1*&$0+*".*"E$+"E./-*"G`/-E$6$"?@@NI>"$62"[`"2/+&0++/'6+"'B*5"

E.*-.*5"^5/-/+."./4".'4"4/'6**5"$62"R$2/'"T6*"3)"K/("d*+-E''2"E$+"7$F/69Q/-"G4$5-/&0%$5%:"

E/-."5*7*5*6&*"-'"./+"S$5/11*$6Q<69%/+."$&&*6-I"GZ'069"?@@NI>".$2"+/96/7/&$6-"-5$&-/'6J"K'2$:>"

.'E*B*5>"'-.*5"-.$6"/6"&'6+*5B$-/B*"$62"E./-*"+045*($&/+-"&'56*5+>"-.*+*"&'6&*56+"'B*5"

$0-.*6-/&/-:".$B*"('B*2"'6J"3*B%/6"$62"=5'7*++'5"X5**6>"-E'"+0&&*++70%"E./-*"95/(*"$5-/+-+>"

.$B*"6'-"1**6"$+F*2"-'"5$&/$%%:"$&&'06-"7'5"-.*(+*%B*+"/6"-.*"+$(*"E$:"$+"-.*/5"45*2*&*++'5+J"

"

,+"2/+&'05+*+"'6"$0-.*6-/&/-:"+./7->"+'"-''"(0+-"$&$2*(/&"$6$%:+*+J"#$5C/$6"$445'$&.*+"-'"

:'0-."&0%-05*"+$E"-.*"2*B*%'4(*6-"'7"&0%-05$%"+:6&5*-/+("-.5'09."$"+./7-"75'("1%$&F"+-5099%*"

$9$/6+-"E./-*"+045*($&:"-'"$"E./-*"+-5099%*"$9$/6+-"&%$++"'445*++/'6"GS.$(1*5+"!PMej")'6*+"

!PVVj"U$:$F"?@@OIJ"R*+4'62/69"-'"-.*"&'6-*C-"/6"E./&."-.*/5"5*+*$5&."E$+"&'620&-*2"-.*+*"

+./7-+"45'4'+*2"5*%$-/B*%:"7/C*2"+-$5-/69"4'/6-+"g"75'("E./&."*C-*62*2"2*1$-*+"'B*5"E.*-.*5"

E./-*":'069"4*'4%*"0+/69"1%$&F"+-:%*+"$62"(0+/&"E*5*"7$F/69Q/-"G)'6*+"!PVVj"U$:$F"?@@OIJ"

"

d./%*"-.*+*"75$(/69+"($2*"+*6+*"'7"-.*"&'6-*C-+"/6"E./&."-.*:"E*5*"45'20&*2>"-.*:"2'"6'-"

.'%2"7'5"&'6-*(4'5$5:"7'5(+"'7"051$6"(0%-/&0%-05*"/6"T0-*5"<$+-";'62'6J",&&'06-*2"7'5"1:"

-E'"2*&$2*+"'7"$22/-/'6$%"&/-$-/'6+"'7"E.$-"&$(*"1*7'5*"G^0-%*5"!PPOj"X/%5':"!PPOI>"-.*"

-*55$/6+"'7"$6$%:+/+".$B*"+./7-*2J"A6"-.*"%$+-"-E*6-:":*$5+>"1$99:"H*$6+>".''2*2"-'4+>"15*$F"

1*$-+"$62"051$6"B*56$&0%$5+".$B*"1*&'(*"($/6+-5*$("$62"*B*6"4$++wJ"K.*"$6$%:+*+"'7"

&0%-05$%"+:6&5*-/+("2*B*%'4*2"-.5'09."+'062Q+:+-*("&0%-05*"G^$&F"!PP\j"X/%5':"!PVMj")'6*+"

!PVVI".$+"6*E"$6$%'90*+"-.$-"&'(4%/&$-*"*$5%/*5"(*$6/69"($F/69"$62"4'%/-/&+J"d./%*"/-"

5*($/6+"-.*"&$+*"-.$-"l&0%-05*"/+"6'-"$"7/C*2"$62"/(4*5(*$1%*"7*$-05*"'7"+'&/$%"5*%$-/'6+n"$62"

-.$-"-.*"l7'5(+"&.$69*>"2*B*%'4>"&'(1/6*"$62"$5*"2/+4*5+*2"/6-'"./+-'5/&$%"45'&*++n"GX/%5':"

Page 122: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!??"

"

!PVM>"4J?P\I"-.*"7'5(+"'7"2*-$&.*2"&0%-05$%"45$&-/&*"$62"&'((06/&$-/'6"*B/2*6-"/6"T0-*5"<$+-"

;'62'6"-'2$:>"$62"-.*"F/62+"'7"4'%/-/&+"-.*:"45'B/2*"B*./&%*+"7'5>"$5*"6'-"-.*"+$(*"$+"-.*:"

E*5*J"U*/-.*5"$5*"-.*"7'5(+"'7"-*&.6'%'9:"-.$-"*6$1%*"-.*(J"=5*B/'0+"+-02/*+"*C4%'5*2"-.*"

&$4$&/-:"'7"-.*"OOQ54("W%'69"4%$:Y"5*&'52+J"K.*+*"5*&'52+"$%%'E*2"7'5"201"-5$&F+\e"-'"1*"4%$&*2"

'6"-.*"^Q+/2*"*6$1%/69"$5-/+-+"-'"75**+-:%*"'B*5"/6+-50(*6-$%+"$62"($F*"6*E"(0+/&"75'("'%2J"

K056-$1%*+"7$&/%/-$-*2"-.*"(/C/69"$62"&0--/69"-'9*-.*5"'7"2/77*5*6-"-5$&F+"/6-'"6*E"4/*&*+"'7"

(0+/&J"K.*"15*$F/69"&/5&%*"45'B/2*2"-.*"4$--*56+"7'5"+.$5/69"$62"2*B*%'4/69"2$6&*"+-*4+"

G^$6*+"?@@\j"X/%5':"!PVMj"_'%($6"?@!@IJ"K'2$:"-.*"A6-*56*-"$62"('1/%*"-*&.6'%'9/*+"45'B/2*"

2/77*5*6-"4'++/1/%/-/*+"7'5"+.$5/69>"$62"2/77*5*6-"+/-*+"7'5"2/$%'90*"$62"&5*$-/B/-:J"

"

K.*+*"7'5(+"'7"&0%-05$%"+:6&5*-/+("$62"+.$5/69"-.5'E"04"6*E"2/(*6+/'6+"'7"-.*"051$6"4$5$2'C"

G^$&F"!PP\I"g"-.*"h0$%/7/&$-/'6"'7"-.*"l&0%-05$%"2:6$(/&+"'7"-.*"+'062"+:+-*("1:"-.*/5"

45'C/(/-:"-'"-.*"45$&-/&*+"'7"5$&/$%"-*55'5n"G^$6*5H*$"$62"^$56"!PPe>"4J!PVIJ"d.*-.*5"/-"E$+"-.*"

%'&$%"4*57'5($6&*"$62"&/-$-/'6"'7"&'((*5&/$%"./4".'4j"E./-*"5$44*5+"0+/69"1%$&F"2/$+4'5/&"

$*+-.*-/&+j"E./-*"5$44*5+"1*/69"45'20&*2"1:",+/$6"$62"1%$&F"4**5+j"-.*"&'((/-(*6-"-'"('1/%*"

-*&.6'%'9/*+"'7"&'((06/&$-/'6"$62"+.$5/69j"'5"-.*"&'%%$1'5$-/B*"*77'5-+"-.$-"E*6-"/6-'"-.*"

45'20&-/'6+>"-.*"E'5F+"*C4%'5*2"/6"-./+"&.$4-*5"45'B/2*"/6+/9.-"/6-'".'E"&'6-*(4'5$5:"

&'%%$1'5$-/'6"$62"&5*$-/B/-:"*C/+-*2"$%'69+/2*"6/./%/+("$62"-*55/-'5/$%"&'67%/&-J"

"

d./%*"-./+"&.$4-*5"*C4%'5*+"-.*"*C-*6-"-'"E./&.":'069"4*'4%*Y+"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+"E*5*>"$62"

E*5*"6'->"+'%2Q'0-"$62"6/./%/+-/&>"/-"/+"$%+'"&'6&*56*2"-'"./9.%/9.-"-.*"(*-.'2'%'9:"-.5'09."

E./&."-./+"$6$%:+/+"/+"4'++/1%*J"K.*"+-'5/*+"45*+*6-*2"1*%'E".$B*"1**6"($2*"4'++/1%*"1:"

.'%2/69"/6"-*6+/'6"-.*"-*C-0$%>"4*57'5($-/B*"$62"4.*6'(*6'%'9/&$%"$+4*&-+"'7"-.*"45'20&-/'6+"

G2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"T6*IJ"K.*"('B*(*6-+"'7"-.*"6$55$-/B*"1*-E**6"-.*+*"-.5**"$6$%:-/&"

$445'$&.*+"'4*6"04"2/77*5*6-"E$:+"'7"5*$2/69"$62"%/+-*6/69"-'"-.*"45'20&-/'6+J"A-"$%%'E+"7'5"

-.*"*C4%'5$-/'6"'7"-.*"-5$6+&*62*6-"$62"-.*"2/$+4'5/&>"$62"7'5"-.*"%'&$-/'6"'7"-.*+*"/6"

*(1'2/*2"*C4*5/*6&*+"$62".'5/a'6+J"A-"$%%'E+"7'5"-.*"/($9*>"+'062"$62"%:5/&+"-'"1*"*B$%0$-*2"

$%'69+/2*"-.*"4*57'5($6&*"$62"-.*"&'6-*C-"/6"E./&."/-"'&&055*2J"

"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""\e"A6+-50(*6-$%"B*5+/'6+"'7"-.*"-5$&F"'6"-.*",Q+/2*"/6"E./&."-.*"B'&$%+".$2"1**6"5*('B*2"$62"-.*"250("

$62"1$++"'7-*6"*6.$6&*2J"

Page 123: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!?O"

"

K.5'09."$"2/+&0++/'6"E./&."('B*+"75'("-.*"+**(/69%:"&'((*5&/$%"$62"-.*"$44$5*6-%:"

6/./%/+-/&>"-./+"&.$4-*5"$225*++*+".'E":'069"4*'4%*"/6"T0-*5"<$+-";'62'6"0+*"6/./%/+-/&"

$*+-.*-/&+"$62"+'%2Q'0-"9*65*+"-'"($F*"+*6+*"'7"-.*/5"%/B*+"$62"45'B/2*"B*./&%*+"7'5"4'%/-/&$%"

5*7%*&-/'6"$62"*B$%0$-/'6J"K.5'09."$--*6-/'6"-'"$*+-.*-/&+>"4*57'5($6&*"$62"*C4*5/*6&*>"/-"

$590*+"-.$-"-.*+*"45'20&-/'6+"25*E"$--*6-/'6"-'"6*E"7'5(+"'7"(0%-/&0%-05$%"+:6&5*-/+("$62"

6*E"E$:+"'7"2'/69"4'%/-/&+J"

?@ 8+/94&!>4($+-!

,-";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01>")'+/*"$62".*5"75/*62+"5*90%$-*2"-.*"5$2/'"2/$%"'6"-.*"+'062"+:+-*(J",-"

-.*/5"1*.*+->"E*"%/+-*6*2"-'"`/++"]#>"_*$5-"$62"#$9/&J"A6")06*"?@@P>"#/&.$*%")$&F+'6"2/*2"$62"

E*"%/+-*6*2"-'"./+"W1*+-"'7Y"&'(4/%$-/'6>"'6"%''4J"T&&$+/'6$%%:"1056-"S3+"E*5*"15'09.-"/6"$62"$"

(/C-05*"'7"1$+.(*6->"201+-*4>"95/(*"$62"RY6Y^>"4%$:*2"$&5'++"-.*"75'6-"5''(J"K./+"$55$:"'7"

(0+/&>"406&-0$-*2"1:"2/77*5*6-"('(*6-+>"*%/&/-*2"B$5/'0+"2$6&*"+-:%*+J"

"

]5'("<$+-*5"?@@P>"-.*+*"+4'6-$6*'0+"45'20&-/'6+"E*5*"&$09.-"/6"-.*"6$-/'6$%"7*B*5"'7"

^5/-$/6Y+"X'-"K$%*6-J",62"7'5"$"7*E"('6-.+"-.*"2$6&*+&$4*"'7";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01"E$+"

-5$6+7'5(*2J!^$+*2"'6"-.*"^5/-$/6Y+"X'-"K$%*6-"7'5($->"8+/94&!>4($+-"+'09.-"-'"5*Q&5*$-*"-.*"

$+4/5$-/'6$%"B$%0*+"'7"8$-052$:"6/9.-"Kc"/6"$6"<$+-";'62'6":'0-."&%01J"K.*"1/9Q-.*$-5*>"

$02/*6&*Q'5/*6-*2"B*5+/'6"'7"./4".'4"*(15$&*2"1:"3/B*5+/-:"$62"]%$E%*++>"-E'"'7"-.*"('+-"

4'40%$5"$&-+"'7"-.*":*$5>"45'B/2*2"&*%*15/-:"&0%-05*"+'%0-/'6+"7'5":'069"4*'4%*Y+"

($59/6$%/+$-/'6"G+**"$%+'"S.$4-*5"]/B*IJ"

"

8+/94&!>4($+-"+-$5-*2"E.*6")'*>"*/9.-**6>"$62"U$-$%/*>"+/C-**6>"$+F*2"/7"-.*:"&'0%2"-*$&."

+-5**-2$6&*"-'"$"95'04"'7"-*6Q"-'"7/7-**6Q:*$5Q'%2":'069"4*'4%*"$-"$".$%7Q-*5("4%$:"+&.*(*J"

U$-$%/*"G/6-5'20&*2"/6"S.$4-*5"T6*I".$2"7'5(*5%:"1**6"$"5*90%$5"$-"-.*":'0-."&%01"10-".$2"

1**6"$1+*6-"+/6&*"+.*"E$+"%05*2"-'"K.$(*+(*$2"$62"1*$-*6"04J")'*>".*5"75/*62>"E$+"$"%'&$%"

:'069"4*5+'6"E.'+*"('-.*5".$2"E'5F*2"'6"-.*"4%$:"+&.*(*":*$5+"*$5%/*5J"A6+4/5*2"1:"-.*"

+0&&*++"'7"3/B*5+/-:"$62"]%$E%*++>"1'-."E*5*"F**6"-'"40-"-'9*-.*5"$"5/B$%"<$+-";'62'6"2$6&*"

-5'04*J"TB*5"-.*"<$+-*5".'%/2$:+"-.*:".*%2"2$/%:"45$&-/&*"+*++/'6+"2*($62/69"&'((/-(*6-"$62"

406&-0$%/-:"75'("-.*/5":'069"4$5-/&/4$6-+J"#$44*2"'0-"'6"$"1%$&F1'$52"1:"U$-$%/*>"-.*"4%$6"

E$+"-'"45$&-/+*"2$/%:>"2'"+'(*"+($%%*5"+.'E+"/6"%'&$%"&'((06/-:".$%%+>"95$20$-*"-'"8-5$-7'52"

S/5&0+"K.*$-5*>"$62"7/6$%%:"-$F*"-.*"T?",5*6$"1:"+-'5(J"^*:'62"-./+>"-.*:"*6B/+$9*2"5*4%/&$-/69"

Page 124: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!?\"

"

-.*"10+/6*++"('2*%"0+*2"1:"3/B*5+/-:"$62"7'062"$"&.$/6"'7"2$6&*"$&$2*(/*+"$&5'++"<$+-"

;'62'6J"K.*/5"75/*62+"E'0%2"-*$&."-.*"&.'5*'95$4.:>"$62"E.*6"-.*:".$2"5$/+*2"*6'09."

('6*:"7'5"$"%$4-'4>"-.*:"E'0%2"&0-"-'9*-.*5"-.*/5"'E6"2$6&*"-5$&F+>"$9$/6"/6"-.*"^5/-$/6Y+"X'-"

K$%*6-"('0%2J"

"

)'*"$62"U$-$%/*"E*5*"+/6&*5*"$1'0-"-.*/5"E'5FJ"K.*:"E*5*"W-.*"&.'5*'95$4.*5+Y"g"-.*"%*$2*5+"

$62"-.*"&5*$-'5+J"K.*:"E*5*"-.*"#$5%'6"W8E''+.Y"d$%%*6G+I"$62"-.*",+.%*:"^$6H'G+I"g"-.*"

&.'5*'95$4.*5+"'7"]%$E%*++"$62"3/B*5+/-:"5*+4*&-/B*%:J",62"-.*:"/($9/6*2"-.*/5"4'-*6-/$%"

+0&&*++"/6"-.*+*"-*5(+J")'*"/6"4$5-/&0%$5"$+4/5*2"-'"d$%%*6Y+"($/6+-5*$("+0&&*++J"_*"$2(/5*2"

./+"l+/&Fn"G/(45*++/B*I"&.'5*'95$4.*2"('B*+"$62"-.*"2*C-*5/-:"E/-."E./&.".*"&0-"-.*"-5$&F+"

-'9*-.*5J"K.*"$2(/5$-/'6"7'5"d$%%*6"$62"^$6H'Y+"-*&.6/&$%"7%$5*"E$+"&'(1/6*2"E/-."*6B:"7'5"

-.*/5"401%/&"$&&%$/("$62"&'((*5&/$%"+0&&*++J"]5'("-.*"^5/-$/6Y+"X'-"K$%*6-"+-02/'"g"E.*5*"

,($62$"_'%2*6"2*+&5/1*2"^$6H'Y+"&.'5*'95$4.:"$+"l+*&'62"-'"6'6*n"g"-'"15*$F7$+-"Kc>"1'-."

d$%%*6"$62"^$6H'".$2"1**6"'4*6%:"&'((*62*2J"K.*:".$2"$%+'"($2*"('6*:J"]%$E%*++"

5*&*/B*2"!@@>@@@"4'062+"7'5"E/66/69"^5/-$/6Y+"X'-"K$%*6-"/6"?@@P"G^5/-$/6o+"X'-"K$%*6-"?@@PIJ"

]'5"$"7*E"('6-.+>"-.*"5$9+"-'"5/&.*+"-5$H*&-'5:"'5>"$+"]%$E%*++"&%$/(*2"'6"-.*/5"E*1+/-*>"

l_''2/*+"-'"_$0-*"S'0-05*n"G]%$E%*++"?@@PI"+**(*2"4'++/1%*J",7-*5"$%%>"3/B*5+/-:"E$+"$6"<$+-"

;'62'6"&5*E>"+'"E.:"+.'0%2"/-"1*"2/77*5*6-"7'5"U$-$%/*"$62")'*i"

"

U$-$%/*"$62")'*Y+"/6B*+-(*6-"/6"-.*"&*%*15/-:"25*$("($2*"+*6+*"'7"-.*/5"($59/6$%/+*2"

1/'95$4./*+J"]'%%'E/69".*5"1*$-/69"/6"K.$(*+(*$2>"U$-$%/*".$2"1*&'(*"2*45*++*2"$62"5$-.*5"

-.$6"+/-".*5"XS8<+".$2"+-$:*2"/6"1*2J"d/-."6'"h0$%/7/&$-/'6+"$62"%/--%*"&.$6&*"'7"9*--/69"$"H'1"

+.*"E$+"-./6F/69"'7"H'/6/69"-.*"$5(:>"1*%/*B/69>"4*5.$4+".'4*70%%:>"-.$-"E'(*6"2/2"6'-"+**"

$&-/B*"+*5B/&*"G+**"S.$4-*5"KE'"7'5"$"2/+&0++/'6"'7"&$66'6"7'22*5IJ",-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*>"+.*".$2"

('B*2"1*:'62"-.*"#&`*6a/*>"U/F*"$62",2/2$+"-5$&F+0/-+"'7".*5":'069*5"4**5+"$62"+4'5-*2".*5"

'E6"B*5+/'6"'7"8.'5*2/-&.".$0-*"&'0-05*f"/5'6/&"!PV@+"7$+./'6>"7%0'5*+&*6-"&'%'05+"$62"

%*9E$5(*5+J"8-5**-2$6&*>"-.*6>"+**(*2"-'"'77*5".*5"$"70-05*"45*7*5$1%*"-'"2*$-."$62"

06*(4%':(*6->"$62"'6*"-.$-"E$+"/6"F**4/69"E/-.".*5"7$+./'6$1%*"7*(/6/6/-:J")'*"E$+"-E'"

:*$5+".*5"*%2*5"$62"./+"1/'95$4.:"E$+"6'-"2/++/(/%$5J"_*"(/C*2"5*-5'"./4".'4"g".$-+>".*$21$62+"

$62"9%$++*+"g"E/-."$"('5*"&'6-*(4'5$5:"[8"051$6"5*4*5-'/5*"g"1$+F*-1$%%"-'4+"$62"'B*5+/a*2"

&'%'05*2"+-5/69"B*+-+J"_*"E$+"$"+F/%%*2"15*$FQ2$6&*5>"$62"-.*"%''+*Q7/--/69"&%'-.*+"$62"'-.*5"

+$5-'5/$%"45'4+"E*5*"$%%"4$5-"'7"-.*"*77*&-J")'*".$2"$%+'"6'-"2'6*"E*%%"$-"+&.''%"$62"$7-*5"

%*$B/69"$-"+/C-**6>".*".$2"9'-"$"H'1"$+"$"-*$&./69"$++/+-$6-"10-"E$+"+$&F*2"E.*6"-.*:"7'062"'0-"

Page 125: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!?N"

"

.*"2/26Y-".$B*"-.*"5*h0/+/-*"h0$%/7/&$-/'6+J"U'E>"$9*2"*/9.-**6>".*".$2"+4*6-"-.*"1*+-"4$5-"'7"

-.*":*$5"06*(4%':*2J"_*"-.'09.-".*"(/9.-"2'"$6"UcL"%*B*%"-E'"/6"-*$&./69>"10-"%/F*"U$-$%/*"

+$E"&.'5*'95$4.:"$+"$"45*7*5$1%*"E$:"'0-J"3*+4/-*"/-+"&'((*5&/$%"&$&.*->"8+/94&!>4($+-"

&'0%2"6'-"1*"2/+(/++*2"$+"+/(4%:"+04*57/&/$%"(/(/&5:J"U$-$%/*"$62")'*Y+"*(15$&/69"'7"-.*"+'%2Q

'0-"7'5($-"E$+"$"W+-5$-*9:"7'5"%/B/69Y"GS.$(1*5+"!PMeIj"/-"E$+"$"-*(4'5$5:"$6$*+-.*-/&"$62"$"

25*$("1*:'62"-.*"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"-.*:"&'675'6-*2J"

"

)'*"$62"U$-$%/*Y+"+4*&/7/&"+-'5/*+"'7"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"70-05/-:"E*5*"$%+'"-'%2"-.5'09."-.*"

(0+/&"-.*:"2$6&*2"-'J"K.*"2$6&*"95'04Y+"('+-"45$&-/+*2"-5$&F+"E*5*"E3++b+"1:"KQ=$/6"7*$-05/69"

S.5/+"^5'E6"G?@@PIj"^411!,%!^411"1:"S.5/+"^5'E6"G?@@M$Ij"$62"`%!H7M$0-+!N+!N'--J"1:"S.5/+"

^5'E6"G?@@N1IJ"A-"+**(*2"$4->"9/B*6"-.*/5"'E6".'4*+"$62"1/'95$4./*+>"-.$-"^5'E6"+.'0%2"1*"

-.*/5"$5-/+-"'7"&.'/&*J",6"$%%*9'5:"'7".''2/*+"-'".$0-*"&'0-05*>"^5'E6".$2"95'E6"04"/6"$"+($%%"

-'E6"/6"c/59/6/$"-'"1*&'(*"$6"*C-5*(*%:"E*$%-.:"2'01%*Q4%$-/60("+*%%/69"$5-/+-"1:"-.*"$9*"'7"

+/C-**6"GRA,,"?@!?IJ"

"

=5$&-/&*+"7'5"8+/94&!>4($+-"/6/-/$%%:"-''F"4%$&*"/6"-.*"75'6-"5''(>"E./&."45'B/2*2"*6'09."

+4$&*"7'5"-*6"-'"-E*6-:"2$6&*5+J";$--*5%:"45$&-/&*+"E*5*".*%2"'6"-.*"1$+F*-1$%%"&'05-J"305/69"

45$&-/&*"+*++/'6+>"-.*:"'59$6/+*2"-.*(+*%B*+"/6"$6"$02/*6&*Q7$&/69>"^5/-$/6Y+"X'-"K$%*6-"

7'5($-/'6"$62"4*57'5(*2"-.*/5"B*5+/'6"'7"^5'E6"$62"KQ=$/6Y+"2$6&*"('B*+>\M"/6-*5+4*5+*2"

E/-."('B*+"75'("-.*"9%'1$%"15*$F/69"B*56$&0%$5J"8%$B*"+.077%*+>"-'"(/6+-5*%"2$6&*+>"-'")$(*+"

^5'E6>"-'"#/&.$*%")$&F+'6j\V"A5/+."H/9+"-'"7%$+.2$6&*j"&%'E6/69"-'"F50(4/69j"$6&/*6-",75/&$"

2$6&*j"=0*5-'"R/&$6"F069"70j"$62"R0++/$6"2$6&*>"$%%"-.*+*"E*5*"-.*"6'6Q'5/9/6$%"&'(4'6*6-+"

'7"-./+"/-*5$-/B*"45'&*++"-.$-".$2"-$F*6"-.*"15*$F/69"&/5&%*"-'"8$-052$:"6/9.-"Kc"G^$6*+"?@@\j"

_'%($6"?@!@IJ"8+/94&!>4($+-!E$+"$6'-.*5"6'2*"/6"-./+"2/$+4'5/&"6*C0+J"K.5'09."%'&$%"

-5$6+%$-/'6>"-.*"'6-'%'9/*+"'7"1%$&F"2/$+4'5/&"2$6&*"E*5*"$9$/6"('2/7/*2J"K.*"7*+-/B*"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""\M"^5'E6"$62"KQ=$/6Y+"2$6&/69"/+"/67%0*6&*2"1:"S%'E6/69"$62"`50(4/69"G`50(4"`/69+"?@@VIJ"K.*"

+-5**-2$6&*"7'5("F6'E6"$+"F50(4/69>"E.'+*"1*+-QF6'E6"45'-$9'6/+-"/+";,"15*$F*5"K/9.-"<:*a>"/+"$"('5*"

$995*++/B*>"$62"*C4%/&/-%:",75/&$6/+-"45'95*++/'6"'7"S%'E6/69J"S%'E6/69"E$+"+-$5-*2"1:"K'((:"-.*"S%'E6"

$+"$"7'5("'7"+4/5/-0$%"'0-%*-"7'%%'E/69"-.*";,"R/'-+"G;$S.$4*%%*"?@@NIJ"^5'E6"$62"KQ=$/6".$B*"-$F*6"-.*+*"

7'5(+"'7"2$6&*"-'"9%'1$%"&'((*5&/$%".*/9.-+J"\V"S.5/+"^5'E6".$+"75*h0*6-%:"45*+*6-*2"./+"B/2*'+"$62"2$6&*"$+"$"-5/10-*"-'"#/&.$*%")$&F+'6J"_/+"B/2*'"

7'5"^411!,%!^411"G?@@M$I"/+"$6"/(/-$-/'6"'7"-.*"7/%("G145+"GU'55/69-'6"!PPVI>"10-"$%+'"$".'($9*"-'"

#/&.$*%")$&F+'6o+"<93'11+3!G!PV?IJ"

Page 126: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!?e"

"

&'(4'6*6-+"'7"15*$F/69"E/-."-.*/5"/610/%-"&.$%%*69*+"-'"4%$6-$-/'6"%/7*"$62"E./-*"+045*($&:"

G`/-E$6$"?@@NI"+./7-*2"-'"$"7'5($-"-.$-"+'09.-"$445'B$%"'7"&'6+0(*5+"$62"&'((*5&/$%"H029*+J"

"

d.*6"2$6&/69"-'"-.*"-5$&F"E3++b+"GKQ=$/6"7*$-05/69"S.5/+"^5'E6"?@@PI>":'069"4*'4%*"&'4/*2"

-.*"%:5/&+"$62"B/2*'"1:"$&-/69"'0-"-.*"E'52"l7%:n>"/6"-.*"%/6*"lZ'0"-./6F"AY("7%:>"2'6Y-":'0in"K'"

2'"+'>"-.*:"+-''2"'6"'6*"7''-"$62"%*$6-"7'5E$52"E/-."$6"$5("'0-+-5*-&.*2J"d.*6"-.*:"E*5*"

$+F*2"-'"W]5**a*vY"-.*:"2/2"H0+-"-.$->".'%2/69"4'+/-/'6"06-/%"-.*"(0+/&"&'6-/60*2J"_'E*B*5>"-./+"

E$+"('5*"-.$6"+'%2Q'0-"/(/-$-/'6"7'5"$6"/($9/6$5:"&'6+0(*5J",+"-.*:"4*57'5(*2"-.*"('B*+"

-.*:"$%-*5*2"-.*"(*$6/69"-'"($F*"+*6+*"'7"-.*/5".$1/-0$%"1'2/*+"/6"-.*":'0-."&%01"*6B/5'6(*6-"

G+**"S.$4-*5"K.5**IJ"K./+"E$+"4$5-/&0%$5%:"6'-$1%*"/6"-.*"E$:+"-.*:"-5$6+%$-*2"-.*"+*C0$%"$62"

5$&/$%/+*2"&'6-*6-"'7"-.*"B/2*'J"W]5**a*Y"/+"$1'0-"KQ=$/6>"E.'"/+"1%$&F>"/6B/-/69"$"1%$&F"E'($6"-'"

2$6&*"%/F*"./("$62"E/-."./(J"A6"-.*"B/2*'>"KQ=$/6"4%$:+"./(+*%7>"+/69+"$62".$+"-.*"&*6-5$%"5'%*J"

K.*"E'($6"4*57'5(+"7'5"./(>"'&&$+/'6$%%:"$+"$"4044*-"'6"$"+-5/69J"K./+"/+"$"+*C0$%/+*2"$62"

4$-5/$5&.$%"4*57'5($6&*"/6"E./&."KQ=$/6"-$F*+"&'6-5'%"'7"-.*"7*($%*"1'2:"$+"4%$:-./69J"KQ=$/6"

$+F+"-.*"E'(*6"lS$6":'0"-/&F>"-/&F>"-/&F>"-/&F"4'4>"%'&F"$62"25'4"/-in"W='4Y"5*7*5+"-'"4'44/69"-.*"

./4"-'"-.*"%*7-"$62"5/9.-j"W%'&FY"-'"('B/69"-.*"./4+"/6"$"%'&F*2"&*6-5$%"4'+/-/'6j"$62"W25'4"/-Y"-'"

1*62/69":'05"F6**+"$62"25'44/69":'05"1'--'("-'"-.*"7%''5"1*7'5*"+45/69/69"1$&F"04J\P"K.*"

('B*(*6->"/67%0*6&*2"1:")$($/&$6"3$6&*.$%%>"/+"/-+*%7"$"2/$+4'5/&"&/-$-/'6"'7"9*62*5"

'445*++/'6J"A6"KQ=$/6Y+"5*62/-/'6>"-.*"('B*"2'*+"6'-"$44*$5"$+"$"+/-*"'7"+*C0$%"75**2'(>"7*($%*"

$9*6&:"$62".*-*5'6'5($-/B*"+01B*5+/'6"G$+"2/+&0++*2"1:"'-.*5"$0-.'5+"/6"5*%$-/'6"-'"

2$6&*.$%%>"5$99$"$62"&$56/B$%"rS''4*5"?@@\j"#/%%*5"!PP!j"U'1%*"?@@@sIJ"]'5"KQ=$/6"-.*"E'($6"

/+"./+"(0+*J"K.*"'6%:"B'/&*"+.*"/+"9/B*6"/+"-.5'09."-.*"+*C0$%/+$-/'6"'7".*5"1'--'(>"B$9/6$"$62"

./4+J"A6"-.*"[8"4'+-Q+%$B*5:"&'6-*C->"-./+"4$-5/$5&.$%"2'(/6$-/'6"$62"+*C0$%/+$-/'6"/+"F*:"-'"

*C4%'5/69"1%$&F"6/./%/+("G.''F+"?@@\IJ"K.*"1%$&F"7*($%*"1'2:>".:4*5Q+*C0$%/+*2"1:"1%$&F"($%*"

4$-5/$5&.:>"/+"$"5*+4'6+*"-'"E./-*",(*5/&$Y+"+*C0$%/+$-/'6"'7"-.*"1%$&F"1'2:J"A6"-./+"E$:>"

-.5'09."./+"2'(/6$-/'6"$62"+01H09$-/'6"'7"-.*"1%$&F"E'($6>"KQ=$/6"E/6+"1$&F"+'(*"'7"-.*"

($6.''2"-$F*6"75'("./("1:"$"E./-*"+045*($&/+-"+'&/*-:J"

"

d./%*"5*h0/5*(*6-+"7'5"1%$&F"+*C0$%/-:"-'"$44*$5"401%/&%:"/6"-./+"E$:"2*('6+-5$-*"-.*"9%'1$%"

&'((*5&/$%"+0&&*++"'7"5$&/$%"+01H09$-/'6+"$62"1%$&F"6/./%/+("G=$--*5+'6"!PPPj"d*+-"!PP\I>"-.*"

./+-'5/&$%"(*$6/69"&'6-$/6*2"/6"-./+"B/2*'"E$+"5*E'5F*2"E.*6"2$6&*2"1:":'069"4*'4%*"$-"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""\P"K.*"('B*"&$6"$%+'"1*"+**6"/6"_0*:Y+"B/2*'"7'5"Z%#2!8%$=!4(5!>3%#!L,"G_0*:"?@@eIJ"

Page 127: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!?M"

"

;*:.$(J"A6"7$/-.70%"5*+4'6+*"-'"KQ=$/6Y+"/6B/-$-/'6>"-.*"E'(*6"/6"8+/94&!>4($+-!4'44*2>"

%'&F*2"$62"25'44*2"/->"E./%*"-.*"($%*"(*(1*5+"&'6-/60*2"/6"+*4$5$-*"5'0-/6*+J"^0-"06%/F*"-.*"

'5/9/6$%"B/2*'"-.*":'069"E'(*6"2/2"6'-"4*57'5("7'5"-.*"($%*"2$6&*5+J"A6+-*$2"-.*:"7$&*2"$6"

/($9/6$5:"$02/*6&*"E./%*"-.*"(*6"4*57'5(*2"+*4$5$-*"15*$F/69"('B*+f".$62+-$62+>"&.*+-"

4'4+"$62"5'1'-/&+J"K./+"E$+"6'-"%/1*5$-/'6"75'("4$-5/$5&.:"'5"+*C0$%/+$-/'6J"R$-.*5>"/-"E$+"

*B/2*6&*"'7"-.*"E$:+"/6"E./&."9%'1$%"$*+-.*-/&+"&'0%2"1*"0+*2"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"$+"-.*/5"

(*$6/69"E$+"5*E'5F*2J"K.5'09."-.*/5"B*5+/'6"'7"4'4>"%'&F"$62"25'4"/->"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"25*E"

$--*6-/'6"-'"-.*/5"5*+4*&-/B*"9*62*5"5'%*+J"d./%*"-.*":'069"E'(*6"4*57'5(*2"-.*"7*(/6/+*2"

5'0-/6*>"-.*":'069"(*6"+.'E*2"'77"-.*/5"($+&0%/6*"+-5*69-."$62"$9/%/-:J"

"

K./+"4*57'5($6&*"$%+'"$%%'E*2"-.*"45'-$9'6/+-+"-'"+-$:"E/-./6"-.*"('5$%>"5$&/$%/+*2"75$(*E'5F"

'7"-.*":'0-."&%01"G2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"K.5**IJ","&%'+*5"5*62/-/'6"'7"KQ=$/6Y+"4'4>"%'&F"$62"

25'4"/-"&'0%2".$B*"1**6"5*$2"$+"$"+*C0$%%:"*C4%/&/-"(/(/&5:"'7"1%$&F"+*C0$%/-:"$62"(/9.-".$B*"

9*6*5$-*2"&'6&*56+"7'5"-.*"'B*5Q+*C0$%/+$-/'6"'7"&./%25*6"$-"-.*"+/-*J"[6%/F*"^5''F15/29*"G-.*"

2*('95$4./&+"'7"^5''F15/29*"$5*"2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"T6*I"E.*5*"2$6&*.$%%"('B*+"E*5*"

5*90%$5%:"45$&-/+*2"E/-."%/--%*"&'6&*56"75'("-.*"+-$77>":'0-."E'5F*5+"$-";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01>"%*++"

7$(/%/$5"E/-."-.*+*"2$6&*+>"($:".$B*"+**6"/(('5$%/-:"E.*5*"'-.*5+"+$E"4'-*6-/$%"75**2'("'5"

+/(4%:"2$:Q-'Q2$:"706J"A6"-./+"E$:>"8+/94&!>4($+-!-5$6+%$-*2"[8"7'5(+"'7"1%$&F"4$-5/$5&.:"-'"

-.*"5$&/$%/+*2"+*C0$%"('5$%/-:"'7";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01J"K./+"$%%"'&&055*2"E/-.'0-"$"2/+&0++/'6"'7"

E.*-.*5"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"W7$F/69Y"1%$&F"&0%-05$%"7'5(+J"K./+"E$+"6'-"1*&$0+*"5$&/$%/+*2"

7'5(+"'7"$0-.*6-/&/-:".$2"&*$+*2"-'"*C/+-j"5$-.*5"1*&$0+*"-.*"-*5(+"'7"5*7*5*6&*".$2"('B*2"

'6J"

"

K.*"/6$44%/&$1/%/-:"'7"7$F/69Q/-"E$+"$%+'"5*%$-*2"-'"-.*"2*('95$4./&+"'7"-.*"2$6&*"95'04J"

8+/94&!>4($+-!E$+"6'-"$6"*6&'06-*5"'7"1%$&F"$62"E./-*>"$+"45*B/'0+%:"2*+&5/1*2"G)'6*+"!PVVI"

10-"$"&/-$-/'6"'7"1%$&F"2/$+4'5/&"&0%-05*"/6"-.*"&'6-*C-"'7"+04*5Q2/B*5+/-:"$62"!N@":*$5+"'7"

(/95$-/'6J"U$-$%/*"$62")'*"E*5*"1'-."(/C*2"5$&*J"K.*:".$2"E./-*"$62"1%$&F"4$5*6-+"$62D'5"

95$624$5*6-+J"K.*"2$6&*5+"E*5*"(/C*2"5$&*>"7/5+-Q"$62"+*&'62Q9*6*5$-/'6"1%$&F",75/&$6>"

<$+-*56"<05'4*$6"$62"E./-*"^5/-/+."G/6"-.*"&'(4%*C"E$:"-.$-"E./-*6*++"/+"2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"

KE'IJ"^*&$0+*"&0%-05$%"$0-.*6-/&/-:"E$+"6'-"*$+/%:"5*$2"-.5'09."-.*/5"1'2/*+"-.*:"E*5*"$1%*"-'"

4$5-/&/4$-*"/6"-.*"2$6&*"E/-.'0-"'%2*5"h0*+-/'6+>"'6"E.*-.*5"-.*/5"4*57'5($6&*+"E*5*"

9*60/6*%:"1%$&F>"$5/+/69J""

"

Page 128: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!?V"

"

A6"+0(($5:>"E.*5*$+"$-"7/5+-"9%$6&*"8+/94&!>4($+-"+**(*2"-'"&'67/5("-.*"-.*+/+"-.$-":'0-."

&0%-05*"E$+"6'"('5*"-.$6"$"+'%2Q'0-"(/(/&F/69"'7"&'((*5&/$%"-5'4*+>"-.*"45'20&-/'6"

2*($62*2"$"(0&."('5*"60$6&*2"5*$2/69J"K.*"./4".'4"$*+-.*-/&+"45*+*6-"/6"-.*"2$6&*"E*5*"

'5/*6-$-*2"-'"-.*"&$4/-$%/+-"&'6+0(*5"10-"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"-.*:"E*5*"0+*2"-'"($F*"+*6+*"'7"

($59/6$%/+*2"%/B*+"$62"45'B/2*"$6>"$%1*/-"$6$*+-.*-/&>"$%-*56$-/B*"-'"-.*/5"7'5*&%'+*2"70-05*+J"

^*:'62"-./+>"-.*"2/$+4'5/&"7'5($-/'6"$62"/-*5$-/'6"'7"-.*"(0+/&"$62"2$6&*"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"

45'20&*2"&'67/5(*2"-.*"&5*$-/B/-:"'7"(0%-/&0%-05*"1*:'62"-.*"6'-/'6+"'7"$0-.*6-/&/-:>"

$++'&/$-*2"E/-."-.*"-.*+/+"'6"6/./%/+("$62"45*+*6-"/6"*$5%/*5"$&$2*(/&"E'5F+"'6"1%$&F"$62"

E./-*":'0-."&0%-05*J"K./+"E$+"4$5-%:"7$&/%/-$-*2"1:"-.*"9%'1$%"+$6/-/+$-/'6"'7"./4".'4"$62"-.*"Kc"

$02/*6&*"7'5($-"'7"-.*"E'5F"10-"/-"E$+"$%+'"($2*"4'++/1%*"1:"-.*"./+-'5:"'7"(0%-/&0%-05*"/6"

U*E.$(J"K.*+*"2:6$(/&+"/(4%/*2"-.$-"$+"5$&/$%/+*2"$62"+*C0$%/+*2"7'5("'7"1*/69"$++'&/$-*2"

E/-."6/./%/+-/&"1%$&F"&0%-05*"E*5*"15'F*6"2'E6>"-.*"2$6&*"E$+"5*Q&'2*2"/6"-.*"('5$%"

75$(*E'5F"'7"-.*":'0-."&%01J"

"

8+/94&!>4($+-!*62*2"E.*6"-.*":'0-."&%01Y+"6*/9.1'05+".$2".$2"*6'09."'7"-.*"%'02"(0+/&>"

$62"-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+"*6'09."'7"U$-$%/*"$62")'*Y+"2*($62+J",-"-./+"4'/6-"-.*"4$5-/&0%$5"

5*62/-/'6"'7"($59/6$%/+$-/'6>"$%-*56$-/B*".'5/a'6+>"$6$*+-.*+/$"$62"2/$+4'5/&"(0%-/&0%-05*"

*62*2J"K.*":'069"4*'4%*"2/2"*B*6-0$%%:"40-"'6"$"+.'E"10-"/-"E$+"6'-"-.*"-.*$-5*"4*57'5($6&*"

-.*:".'4*2"7'5J"A6+-*$2>"-.*:"25*++*2"/6"06/7'5(+"G1%$&F"-5'0+*5+"$62"E./-*"-'4+I>"2/2"-.*/5"

.$/5>"$62"4*57'5(*2"-'"$"95'04"'7"B'%06-**5+>"4$5*6-+"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+"/6"$"%'&$%"&'((06/-:"

.$%%J"

?J Z'0K01*"B/2*'+"

8+/94&!>4($+-!.$2"*62*2"10-"2$6&*"$62"(0+/&"&'6-/60*2J"8-$62/69"1:"-.*"B*62/69"($&./6*+"

/6"-.*"&'56*5"'7"-.*"75'6-"5''(>":'069"4*'4%*"+.'E*2"'77"-.*/5"('B*+J")$&F"G/6-5'20&*2"/6"

S.$4-*5"K.5**I".$2"E'5F*2"'0-".'E"-'"1'2:Q4'4"./+"-'5+'j"]5*22:"G/6-5'20&*2"/6"S.$4-*5+"

KE'"$62"K.5**I"5*+4'62*2"E/-."+/(4%*"7''-E'5FJ"K.*"+4'6-$6*/-:>"45'B'&$-/'6"$62"5*+4'6+*"

E*5*"/6+-$6-%:"5*&'96/+$1%*"$+"$"45'20&-/'6"5*(/6/+&*6-"('5*"'7"-.*"15*$F/69"&/5&%*"-.$6"

8+/94&!>4($+-S!!-.*$-5*"4*57'5($6&*J"d/%%>"'6*"'7"-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+>"E$-&.*2J"<$+-";'62'6"

2$6&*"95'04"`JAJXJY+"B+45!;9%015+3-!A(++-!(!<%+-"G?@@VI"&$(*"'6"$62")$&F>";*E/+"$62"U$-.*"

+-$5-*2"-.*"5'0-/6*"1*7'5*"/6B/-/69"'-.*5+"-'"H'/6J"=%$:/69"-.*"4$-5/$5&.>")$&F"E*6-"'B*5"-'")'+/*"

$62"*%/&/-*2"$"5*+4'6+*"1:"-'0&./69".*5".*$2>"+.'0%2*5>"F6**"$62"-'*+J"l_*$2>"+.'0%2*5+"F6**+"

Page 129: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!?P"

"

$62"-'*+n>"+$69"`JAJXJ>"E/-.")$&F"*&.'/69"-.*"6'E"+*C0$%/+*2"45'B'&$-/'6"75'("-.*"l($62*(n"

G$"95'04"'7"(*6If"l%$2/*+>"%*-"(*"+**":'0"9'"2'E6"%'EnJ"K.*"45'B'&$-/'6"75'("`JAJXJ"$62")$&F"

+.'E*2"-.*"&'((*5&/$%/+$-/'6"'7"2$6&*.$%%"$62"/-+"-5$6+%$-/'6"-'"<$+-";'62'6"1:"$"95'04"'7"

%$59*%:"E./-*":'069"4*'4%*J"K'"-.*"-/(*"'7"-.*"(0+/&>":'069"4*'4%*"+-$5-*2"-E/5%/69"-.*"4''%"

&0*+>"-.5'E/69"-.*"4''%"1$%%+"04"/6"-.*"$/5J"U'*%"$2H0+-*2"-.*"E5/+-1$62"'6"./+"6*E>"+F:Q1%0*"

,2/2$+"-5$&F+0/-"$62>"./9.%:"&'6+&/'0+"'7"./+"1'2:>"+-$5-*2"4%$:/69"-$1%*Q-*66/+"E/-."

&.'5*'95$4./&"45*&/+/'6J"8-$&*:"$62"K'55/"&$(*"'B*5"-'"-.*"-$1%*J"K'55/"+-$5-*2"5011/69".*5"

.$62+"/6"$"&/5&0%$5"('-/'6"'6"-.*"+057$&*"E./%*"R$&.$*%"('B*2"/6"1*./62".*5"$62"&'(4%*-*2"

-.*"+*C0$%/+*2"+*h0*6&*J"

"

TB*5"-.*"6*C-"7*E"('6-.+>"-.*+*"+4'6-$6*'0+"&/-$-/'6+"(0-$-*2"/6-'"$6'-.*5"+*-"'7"

45'20&-/'6+J")$&F>";*E/+"$62"U$-.*>"$9*2"7'05-**6>"E*5*"E./-*":'069"(*6"E.'"%/B*2"&%'+*"-'"

;*:.$("Z'0-."S%01"$62"5*90%$5%:"$--*62*2J"T6*"*B*6/69"-.*:"$+F*2"(*"-'"7/%("-.*/5"2$6&*"

('B*+"+'"-.*:"&'0%2"40-"-.*("04"'6"Z'0K01*J"K.*"2$6&*"+*h0*6&*"-.*:"E$6-*2"(*"-'"

&$4-05*"E$+"4$5-%:"&.'5*'95$4.*2>"$62"/6"-./+"E$:"5*(/6/+&*6-"'7"3/B*5+/-:"$62"]%$E%*++>"10-"/-"

$%+'"/6&%02*2"*%*(*6-+"'7"75**+-:%/69"-$F*6"75'("-.*"15*$F/69"B*56$&0%$5J"d.*5*$+"8+/94&!

>4($+-"/($9/6*2"-.*"&$4/-$%/+-"&'6+0(*5"$+"-.*"$02/*6&*>"-.*/5"E'5F"E$+"'5/*6-*2"-'E$52+"$"

%'&$%"&'6B*5+$-/'6"E/-."$"45'20&*5"&$%%*2"`Q;/6*J"`Q;/6*".$2"+'(*-./69"'7"$"(:-./&"+-$-0+"

$('69"-.*":'069"(*6"$62"-.*:"%''F*2"04"-'"./+"4$5-/&0%$5"15$62"'7"E./-*"($+&0%/6/-:J"K.*:"

$2(/5*2"./+"l+4/--/69n"G5$44/69I"$62"./+"l1%0*"$62"E./-*"+-$77+n"G8-$77'52+./5*"^0%%"K*55/*5+IJ"`Q

;/6*>"*/9.-**6>".$2".*$52"-.*"-5/'"&'0%2"2$6&*"$62"+099*+-*2"-.*:"$44*$5"/6"./+"(0+/&"B/2*'J"

<$9*5"-'"/(45*++>"-./+"E$+"E.$-")$&F>";*E/+"$62"U$-.*"E*5*"E'5F/69"-'E$52+J"

"

,+"E/-."8+/94&!>4($+->"-.*":'069"(*6Y+"1/'95$4./*+"E*5*"/(4'5-$6-"-'"062*5+-$62/69"-.*/5"

/6B*+-(*6-"/6"-.*"45'20&-/'6J"d./%*"U$-.*"$62")$&F"E*5*"/6"/-"7'5"-.*"*6H':(*6->"&$&.*-"$62"

5*&'96/-/'6>";*E/+>"%/F*")'*"$62"U$-$%/*>"+$E"$6"$%-*56$-/B*".'5/a'6J"S$09.-"/6"-.*"^5/-$/6Y+"X'-"

K$%*6-"%/9.-+>".*"E$+"$%+'"&'6+/2*5/69"$"&$5**5"/6"+-5**-2$6&*J"_*"-''F"2$6&/69"('5*"+*5/'0+%:"

-.$6"./+"4$5-6*5+"$62".$2"$%5*$2:"$02/-/'6*2"7'5"3/B*5+/-:Y+"2$6&*"95'04J"_$B/69"7$/%*2>".*".$2"

+/96*2"04"-'"$6'-.*5"%*++"E*%%QF6'E6"%'&$%"-5'04*J"_/+"2$6&/69"+F/%%+".$2"$%+'"E'6"./("6*EQ

7'062"4'40%$5/-:"$('69"./+"4**5+>"+'(*-./69".*".'4*2"-'"&*(*6-"-.5'09."/(45*++/69"`Q;/6*J"

`**6"-'"$++*5-"-.*/5"($+&0%/6/-:>")$&F"$62"U$-.*".$2"5*90%$5%:"10%%/*2";*E/+"45/'5"-'"-./+"

&'%%$1'5$-/'6J"[6&'(7'5-$1%*"E/-."5*-056/69"4.:+/&$%"$995*++/'6>";*E/+"E$+"+**6"$+"$6"*$+:"

-$59*-J"K.5'09."2$6&/69".*".'4*2"-'"*$56"-.*/5"5*+4*&-J"

Page 130: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!O@"

"

"

8+/94&!>4($+-".$2"0+*2"-.*"($/6"+-*5*'"$62"%$59*"$5*$+"'7"7%''5"+4$&*J"_'E*B*5>"2*7/6*2"1:"

-.*"('1/%*"&'((06/&$-/'6"5$-.*5"-.$6"-.*"^5/-$/6Y+"X'-"K$%*6-"-.*$-5*"7'5($->"-.*"-.5**"1':+"

5*h0/5*2"6'"('5*"-.$6"$"+($%%"4/*&*"'7"95$++>"-.*"%'02+4*$F*5"'6"-.*/5"4.'6*+"$62"$"&$(*5$J"

8'6:Y+"d$%F($6"5$69*"'7"4.'6*+"7$&/%/-$-*2"1'-."-.*"/($9*"&$4-05*"$62"$(4%/7/&$-/'6J"K.*:"

.$2"$('69"-.*"%'02*+-"+4*$F*5+"$62"-.*"B'%0(*"%/(/-*5"&'0%2"1*"-$F*6"'77"gW&./44*2Y"g"1:"

7'%%'E/69"$"7*E"+/(4%*"'6%/6*"/6+-50&-/'6+J"T6*":'069"($6"A"E'5F*2"E/-."'77*5*2"-./+"+4*&/$%/+-"

F6'E%*29*"7'5"&$+."/6"-.*"+&.''%"4%$:95'062J"K.*"B/2*'+"&'0%2"$%+'"1*"+.'-"'6"-.*/5"4.'6*+>"

04%'$2*2"'5"+.$5*2"E/-."4**5+"1:"^%0*-''-.J"Z'0K01*"&'6-$/6+"&'06-%*++"B/2*'+"'7":'069"

4*'4%*"5$44/69"$62"15*$F/69"4'E*5*2"1:"+/(/%$5"('1/%*"-*&.6'%'9:J"X/99+Y+"*$5%:"B/2*'"<41='()!

,9+!B435+-,"G?@@PI"/+"*(1%*($-/&"'7"-./+"%'EQ-*&.>"./9.%:"4'5-$1%*"+'062J"

"

]$&/69"-.*"&$(*5$>"$62"-.*5*7'5*"`Q;/6*"G/6"$22/-/'6"-'"-.*"%*++"&'6+/2*5*2"'6%/6*"$02/*6&*I>"

-.*":'069"(*6"2/2"6'-"*69$9*"E/-."-.*"-*C-"'7"-.*"-5$&F+"$+"%/-*5$%%:"$+"8+/94&!>4($+-".$2"

2'6*J"U'6*-.*%*++"-.*/5"5'0-/6*+"-5$&*2"$62"5*($2*"2/$+4'5/&"-5$2/-/'6+J"K.*/5"/6&'54'5$-/'6"

'7".0('05"&'55*+4'62*2"E/-."^5/-/+."+%$4+-/&F>"$62"E/-.",75/&$6"+%$B*"2$6&*+"-.$-"4$5'2/*2"-.*"

('B*+"'7"E./-*"+%$B*"'E6*5+"G^$6*+"?@@\j"_'%($6"?@!@IJ"K.*":'069"(*6"0+*2"-.*"E$B*"5'%%>"

40%%/69"/6"$6"/($9/6$5:"5'4*>"1*/69"+.'-"$62"1*/69"*%*&-5'&0-*2"-'"$22".0('05"-'"-.*/5"$&-J"

K.*"E$%F+"'77"$-"-.*"*62"g".$62"-'"-.*"&$(*5$"g"E*5*"$%+'"5*(/6/+&*6-"'7"-.*"9%'1$%"$*+-.*-/&+"

'7"-.*"15*$F/69"&/5&%*J"

"

d.*5*$+"8+/94&!>4($+-!.$2"*(15$&*2"-.*"+'062+"'7"KQ=$/6"$62"S.5/+"^5'E6>";*E/+>")$&F"$62"

U$-.*"('B*2"-'E$52+".*$B/*5"-5$&F+>"/6&%02/69f"#/++:"<%%/'-Y+"7*$-05/69"S/$5$"8%-+!_%(,3%1"

G?@@NI"$62"$6"06-/-%*2"-5$&F"E'5F"1:"`Q;/6*"./(+*%7"G`Q;/6*"?@!@IJ"^'-."E*5*"1$++:>"($2*"0+*"

'7"-*&.6'"5/77+"$62"E*5*"9''2"-'"2$6&*"-'J",445'45/$-*%:>"-.*"#/++:"<%%/'-"-5$&F"25*E"'6"!PV@+"

15*$F/69"&0%-05*>"($F/69"*C-*6+/B*"0+*"'7"$"B'&$%"+$(4%*2"75'("G%5/!^%3="1:"_'-"8-5*$F"

G!PVOIJ"G%5/!^%3="7*$-05*2"/6"-.*"!PV\"7/%("G3+4='(S"G8/%1*59"!PV\IJ"_'E*B*5>"<%%/'-Y+"B/2*'"/+"

6'-"$1'0-"15*$F"2$6&/69"10-"$".'($9*"-'"-.*"[8",75/&$6Q,(*5/&$6"(0+/&$%"-5$2/-/'6"'7"-.*"

!P?@+"g"-.*"7/5+-"-/(*"1%$&F"4*'4%*"/6"-.*"[8".$2"4'5-5$:*2"-.*(+*%B*+"/6"($/6+-5*$("-.*$-5*>"

7/5+-"-'"$"1%$&F"$62"-.*6"-'"E./-*"$02/*6&*+"GR'1/6+'6"?@@MIJN@"S/$5$>"E.'"7*$-05*+"'6"-.*"

B/2*'>"+/-0$-*+".*5+*%7"/6"-.*"*($6&/4$-'5:"('B*(*6-J"<%%/'-"+-$:+"&*6-5*"+-$9*"7'5"-.*"($H'5/-:"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""N@"K.*"-.*(*"'7"*($6&/4$-/'6"/+"$%+'"45*+*6-"/6"#/++:"<%%/'-Y+"B/2*'"7'5"^%3=!L,"G?@@?IJ"

Page 131: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!O!"

"

'7"-.*"B/2*'>"$62"$+"/+"-.*"&$+*"E/-."($6:"'7".*5"'-.*5"E'5F+>"2'*+"6'-"4*57'5("$+"$6"'1H*&-"'7"

+*C0$%"2*+/5*"7'5"-.*"($%*"9$a*J"_*5"95/62+"$++*5-"7*(/6/6*"4'E*5"$62"75**2'("5$-.*5"-.$6"$"

45*2/+4'+/-/'6"-'"$&&*4-"4$-5/$5&.$%"$0-.'5/-:J"A6"-./+"+*6+*"+.*"5*45'20&*+"$"B*5+/'6"'7"

W+%$&F6*++Y"$%+'"*B/2*6-"/6"5$99$"GU'1%*"?@@@I>"2$6&*.$%%"GS''4*5"?@@\I"$62"&$56/B$%"G#/%%*5"

!PP!IJ"

"

_'E*B*5>"$+"4*57'5(*2"/6";*:.$(>"-.*+*"(*++$9*+"062*5E*6-"$"+01+-$6-/$%"5*B/+/'6J"K./+"E$+"

('+-"$44$5*6-"E.*6"#/++:"<%%/'-"E$+"4*57'5(*2"1$&FQ-'Q1$&F"E/-."`Q;/6*Y+"'E6"5*&'52/69J"

d./%*"`Q;/6*Y+"(0+/&"5*+'6$-*+"-'6$%%:"E/-."#/++:"<%%/'-Y+>"$62"/+"*B/2*6-%:"4$5-"'7"-.*"+$(*"

2/$+4'5/&"6*C0+>"./+"(*++$9*"'7"%'&$%"E./-*"4$-5/$5&.$%"6/./%/+("E$+"2/+-$6-"75'("<%%/'-Y+"

&'((*5&/$%/+*2"*($6&/4$-'5:"7*(/6/+(J"A6"-.*"-5$&F""(,',1+5"G?@!@I>"`Q;/6*"*(4.$+/+*+"./+"

'E6"$1/%/-:"$+"$"5$44*5"$62"+-$-*+"./+"&%$/("-'"-.*"+'/%"g"-.5'09."1*/69"l1'56"$62"15*2n"/6"-.*"

4'+-&'2*"$5*$"g"E./&.".*"*h0$-*+"E/-."E./-*6*++"$62"-.*"lE./-*Q1':"+&*6*n"G+**"S.$4-*5+"

KE'"$62"K.5**IJ"_*"$2B*5-/+*+"./+"+$&5*2>"($+&0%/6*"45'-*&-/'6"'7"-./+"$0-'&.-.'6'0+"a'6*"

E/-."-.*"B/'%*6-"E$56/69f"lAY%%"1$69":'0"'6&*J"AY%%"1$69":'0"-E/&*J"AY%%"1$69":'0"$9$/6"%/F*")*+0+"

S.5/+-Jn"

"

d.*6"75**+-:%/69"/6"-.*"1$&F"5''("'7"-.*":'0-."&%01"./+"4'%/-/&+"E*5*"+/(/%$5J",+".*"5**%*2"'0-"

./+"%:5/&+>".*"9$B*"5*+4*&-"-'";*:.$("$62"./(+*%7J"_*"-.*6"-056*2"-'"./9.%/9.-"./+"'E6"5$&/$%"

1*%'69/69"1:"4'F/69"706"$-"U$-$%/*>"h0/44/69"l:'05"(0(Y+"E./-*>"10-":'05"2$2Y+"1%$&Fn>"1*7'5*"

-056/69"-'"&./2*"$"E./-*":'069"4*5+'6"7'5".$B/69"$"1%$&F"(0("g"$"&'(*2/&"-056"-.$-"45'B/2*2"

./("E/-."+4$&*"-'"$225*++"./+"5*$%"&'6&*56f"-.*"%'++"'7"$0-.*6-/&"E./-*"1*%'69/69"/6"<$+-"

;'62'6J"`Q;/6*"E$+"6'-"$%'6*"/6"./+"0+*"'7"1%$&F"&0%-05$%"7'5(+"-'"405+0*"E./-*"-*55/-'5/$%"

4'%/-/&+J"T-.*5":'069"(*6"0+*2"+/(/%$5"%:5/&+JN!"[6%/F*"-.*"2*B*%'4(*6-"'7"8'0-."<$+-",+/$6"'5"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""N!";:5/&+"75'("$6'-.*5":'0-."&%01"4$5-/&/4$6-f"^/9"04"-'"-.*"E./-*"1':"+&*6*DA-o+"%/F*"CCC>"CCC>"CCC"D^/9"04"

-'"-.*";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01D"CCC>"CCC>"$%%"-.*("&5*EDA-o+"9'-"-.*"B/1*+>"$62"/-o+"%/F*"m"DS'(*"'6"E/%2"E/-."$"

+E/69"$62"$"406&.DK./69"-.$-"A".*$5"/+"$"&5$&F"$62"$"&506&.D8**":'0"9'>"A"-$F*".*5"'0-"7'5"%06&.D,62"9*-"

r.*5s"-'"+0&F"(:"&'&F"%/F*"/-o+"(06&.DS'(*"'6"E/%2"E/-."$"+E/69"$62"$"406&.DK./69"-.$-"A".*$5"/+"$"&5$&F"

$62"$"&506&.D8**":'0"9'>"A"-$F*".*5"'0-"7'5"%06&.D,62"9*-"r.*5s"-'"+0&F"(:"&'&F"%/F*"/-o+"(06&.D8**"

:*$.>"&'+"0"F6'E+"Ao("1$&FD<B*5:'6*"F6'E+"Ao("1$&F"'6"-.*"-5$&FDd*o5*"'0-v"rd$%F+"'77"E/-."./+".$62"

-'"-.*"&$(*5$sJ"

"

"

Page 132: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!O?"

"

_/+4$6/&"./4".'4"+&*6*+"/6"8$6"]5$6&/+&'>"-./+"E$+"6'-"$"&'6+-50&-/'6"'7"&'((06/-:"/2*6-/-:"/6"

-.*"7$&*"'7"/6B/+/1/%/-:"G_$55/+'6"?@@P>"4J!O\I"5$-.*5"G$+"2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5+"KE'"$62"K.5**I"/-"

E$+"$"2*7*6+/B*"$5-/&0%$-/'6"'7"E./-*6*++"1$+*2"'6"(:-.'%'9/*+"'7"%'++>"$62"'6"$"5/9.-"-'"%'&$%"

./+-'5:J"=*57'5(*2"$%'69+/2*"*$&."'-.*5>"-.*+*"-5$&F+"5$/+*2"/(4'5-$6-"h0*+-/'6+"$1'0-"1%$&F"

$62"E./-*"$0-.*6-/&/-:"$62"-.*"E$:+"/6"E./&."1%$&F"&0%-05$%"7'5(+"&'0%2"1*"5*45'20&*2"-'"

+044'5-"E./-*"$0-'&.-.'6'0+"&%$/(+J"

"

A6"+0(($5:>"-.*"Z'0K01*"B/2*'+")$&F>";*E/+"$62"U$-.*"($2*"7'5"`Q;/6*"45'B/2*2"$"2/77*5*6-"

4*5+4*&-/B*"-'"-.*"2*1$-*+"'6"&'((*5&/$%/+$-/'6>"6/./%/+("$62"&0%-05$%"+:6&5*-/+(J",+"E/-."

8+/94&!>4($+-!-.*:"E*5*"6'-"+/(4%:"&'((*5&/$%"5*4%/&$-/'6+J"K.*"$*+-.*-/&+"'7"9%'1$%"./4".'4"

45'B/2*2"-.*":'069"(*6"E/-."+-5$-*9/*+"7'5"%/B/69>"$62"7'5(+"-.5'09."E./&."-.*:"&'0%2"

6*9'-/$-*"-.*/5"($+&0%/6/-:"$62"+*C0$%/-:J"K.*:"E*5*"7'062*2"'6"-*&.6'%'9/*+"'7"&'%%$1'5$-/'6"

E./&."*C-*62*2"75'("-.*"*-./&+"'7"./4".'4"-.5'09."-.*"0+*"'7"('1/%*"-*&.6'%'9/*+J",9$/6>"-.*/5"

+4*&/7/&>"&%$++"%'&$-*2"/-*5$-/'6"E$+"$"&.$%%*69*"-'"*++*6-/$%"6'-/'6+"'7"1%$&F"$62"E./-*J"K.*"

:'069"(*6"2/2"6'-"7**%"-.*:"E*5*"7$F/69Q/-"'5"-5$6+%$-/69"1%$&F"+-5099%*+"-'"&%$++"+-5099%*+J"

K.*/5"4$5-/&/4$-/'6"/6"15*$F/69"$62"-.*/5"1$&FQ-'Q1$&F"0+*"'7"*($6&/4$-/'6"$62"E./-*"

-*55/-'5/$%/-:"/6"6'"E$:"H$55*2J"K.5'09."-.*/5"/6$--*6-/'6"-'"-.*"/2*$+"'7"$0-.*6-/&/-:"/6"./4".'4>"

-.*:"2*('6+-5$-*2"7*$%-:"-'"-.*"1*$-J"_'E*B*5>"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"-.$-"-.*+*"7'5(+"'7"5$&/$%"

7/C/-:"E*5*"15'F*6"2'E6>"'-.*5+"E*5*"5*10/%-j"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"-.$-"-.*:"*C&**2*2"'%2"

2*($5&$-/'6+"'7"5$&*"$62"&0%-05*"-.*:"45'20&*2"6*E"'6*+"1:"5*Q4'%/-/&/+/69"*($6&/4$-/'6"-'"

($F*"+*6+*"'7"*C&%0+/B*"E./-*"-*55/-'5/*+J"

OJ A'11!411!4!>+&f"6/./%/+-"$*+-.*-/&+"$62"4'%/-/&$%"6*9$-/B/-:"

,7-*5"$"7*E"('6-.+>")$&F>";*E/+"$62"U$-.*Y+"*6-.0+/$+("E$6*2>"10-"-.*"(0+/&"$62"2$6&*"

&'6-/60*2J"3'6*$'Y+">+*'1!'(!4!G10+!>3+--"G?@@MI"&$(*"'6"-.*":'0-."&%01"+-*5*'"$62")'+/*"

+-50--*2"$5'062"-.*"4''%"-$1%*"/6"$6",2/2$+"-5$&F+0/-"($F/69"%$59*"*6*59*-/&"+E**4+"E/-.".*5"

$5(+J"8-/&F/69";*E/+Y+"1$+*1$%%"&$4"062*5".*5".''2/*"+.*"20&F*2"2'E6"./2/69".*5"7$&*j"4%$:/69"

'0-"+05B*/%%$6&*"*B$+/'6"$62"6/./%/+("E/-.".*5"E./-*>"+-5**-Q&$('07%$9*2"1'2:J"K.*"2*7$0%-"

$995*++/'6"g"1'11/69"+-50-"$62".'5/a'6-$%"$5("9*+-05*+"g"/62/&$-*2"($+&0%/6*"4*57'5($6&*"

$62"+*C0$%/-:J"3$E6"$62",1/>"-E'"'7".*5"&%'+*"75/*62+>"H'/6*2"/6"1*./62".*5"+E$:/69"%/F*"&.'50+"

9/5%+J"K.*:"E*5*"-.*"4*5/4.*5$%"7*($%*"1'2/*+"-.$-"&'(4%*(*6-*2")'+/*Y+"$995*++/B*"&*6-5*Q

+-$9*"5'0-/6*J"<C$99*5$-*2"10-"6'-"/5'6/&>")'+/*"-''"E$+"-5$6+%$-/69"9%'1$%"./4".'4Y+"$*+-.*-/&+"

Page 133: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!OO"

"

'7"($+&0%/6/-:"$62"6/./%/+("-'"($F*"+*6+*"'7".*5"5*%$-/'6+./4"E/-."-.*":'0-."&%01>"E/-."-.*"

:'069"4*'4%*"$62"E/-."E/2*5"+:+-*(+"'7"+'&/$%"&'6-5'%"G2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"K.5**IJ"

"

T0-"'7"-.*+*"B/15$-/'6+"&$(*"-.*"7/6$%"45'20&-/'6J"A'11!411!4!>+&"E$+"$"(0+/&"B/2*'"4*57'5(*2"

1:"$"-5/'"'7"5$44*5+"&$%%*2"[4&'(/69"#'B*(*6-"$62"45'20&*2"%'&$%%:"1:"_0+-%*5"$62"A&*J"A-"

E$+6Y-"($2*"/6"-.*":'0-."&%01>"$62"[4&'(/69"#'B*(*6-"2/2"6'-"$--*62";*:.$(J"_'E*B*5>"$"

60(1*5"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"A"E'5F*2"E/-."$--*62*2"-.*"7/%(/69"'7"-.*"B/2*'"$62"+01+*h0*6-%:"

2/+-5/10-*2"-.*"7/6$%"E'5F"'B*5"]$&*1''F"$62"Z'0K01*JN?"K.*"B/2*'"0+*2"$"5$69*"'7"6/./%/+-"

/($9*5:"-'"&'((06/&$-*"(*++$9*+"'7"($+&0%/6*"B/'%*6&*>"-057"E$57$5*"$62"2*$-.J"

"

,55/B/69"$-";*:.$("B/$"-.*":'0-."&%01Y+"&'(40-*5"-*5(/6$%+>"-.*"B/2*'"E$+"5*&*/B*2"E/-."$"

(/C-05*"'7"2/+$44'/6-(*6-"$62"&'6&*56"1:"-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+J"K.*:"+$E"/-"$+"$"E'55:/69"

5*7%*&-/'6"'7"-.*"-056"-'"2/+'52*5"$62"$+"$"5/2/&0%'0+"4$55'-/69"'7"&'((*5&/$%/+*2"6/./%/+-"

$*+-.*-/&+J"A6"-./+"+*6+*>"/-"E$+"2*-$&.*2"75'("-.*"'77/&/$%"7'5(+"'7"B/'%*6&*"-.$-"E*5*"

4*5(/--*2"/6"-.*":'0-."&%01"$62"/6"-.*"%'&$%"$5*$"G+**"S.$4-*5"K.5**IJ"A6"$%%"-.*+*"+*6+*+>"/-"E$+"

5'062%:"&'62*(6*2J"

"

K./+"5*$&-/'6"E$+"/62**2"-.*"2*+/5*2"5*+4'6+*J"K.*"/($9*5:>"%:5/&+"$62"+'062"'7"-.*"B/2*'"

E*5*"2*%/1*5$-*%:"2*+/96*2"-'"*B'F*"6/./%/+(J";/F*"=5'7*++'5"X5**6Y+""##+3!_14#,%(!>4($+"

G?@@PI>"8E$:Y+"8',,1+!>+3+="G8E$:"?@@eI"U'";$:Y+""(%3,9%5%M!>40)9,+3"G?@@VI"$62"($6:"

+($%%*5"45'20&-/'6+>"A'11!411!4!>+&"E$+"+-**4*2"/6"-.*";'62'6"4./%'+'4.:"'7"95/--:"G95/(:I"

5*$%/+("G^5$(E*%%"?@!?IJ"A-"E$+"+.'-"/6"1%$&F"$62"E./-*"-'"&$4-05*"-.*"+-$5F"5*$%/-:"'7"+-5**-"

%/7*J"8/(4%*"4'+-Q45'20&-/'6"-*&.6/h0*+"E*5*"0+*2"-'"./9.%/9.-"-.*"&'%'05"'7"-.*"1$62$6$"g"-.*"

+/96"'7"-*55/-'5/$%"$77/%/$-/'6"$62"-.*"&*6-5*"'7"-.*"B/2*'Y+"(*++$9*J"A6"F**4/69"E/-."-.*"/($9*5:>"

-.*"4$&*"'7"-.*"/6+-50(*6-$%"E$+"+%'E>"&5**4/69"$62"'5&.*+-5$%"$62"-.*5*"E$+"$6"$/5"'7"

+0+4*6+*"$62"45*('6/-/'6J"K.*"-5$&F"'4*6*2"E/-."-.5**".$06-/69"6'-*+"4%$:*2"'6"$"

+:6-.*+/+*2"4/$6'f"

"

"

"

"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""N?",6'6:(/-:"/6"5*%$-/'6"-'"-.*+*"45'20&-/'6+"/+"2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"T6*J"

Page 134: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!O\"

"

123#(/*4%5#6-(-*+!4!5/++!1++!1!6$.!789::1;!

"

<$=0$!&'$!AY("]"rms"^$&F"75'("=%$/+-'E"+('F/69"$"+./+.$"rH'/6-s>"^$&F"75'("=%$/+-'E"/6"(*('5/$%"4$5F>""d/-."$"a''-"rH'/6-s"/6"(:".$62"10-"A"$/6Y-"6'"2*$%*5>"X*-"'6"-.*"E5'69"+/2*"'7"(*"'6&*"'5"-E/&*>"rms"95$1"./("04>"95$1"./("04>"=0%%"'0-"-.*"+.$6F"r+-$11/69"E*$4'6s>"+-$1"./("04>"+-$1"./("04>";*$B*"./("7'5"2*$2>"1$9"./("04>"1$9"./("04J""=0-"./("/6"$"B$6>"K$F*"./("-'"<44/69>""]"-.$-"($6"6'E"-$F*"./("#*('5/$%>""_*$2"-'"-.*"S5'++"$/6Y-"6'"-0-'5/$%>"UXx"/-Y+"-*55/-'5/$%>""=/%*"'6"-.*"4'062+>"A"6'"+F/6"$62"1'6*+J"AY("('B/69"h0/&F>"A"6'"`*%%:"_'%(*+"A"2'/69"-.*"&5/(*>"A"$/6Y-"2'/69"-.*"-/(*"X'"WPPPY"4*'4%*"'6"-.*"4.'6*"">#&=?0!K.*("($6"2*5>"F/%%"$%%"$"2*(>"S$-+"/6"-.*"*+-$-*+>"F/%%"$%%"$"2*(>"3'"E.$-"A"9'--$>"2*$%"E/-."/-"45'4*5>"35$E"7'5"+-5$4"r906s"$62"F/%%"$%%"$"2*(>"86/-&."#S+>"F/%%"$%%"$"2*(>"S$-+"/6"-.*"*62a>"F/%%"$%%"$"3*(>"K.*5*Y+"'6%:"'6*"-./6F"-.$-"/+"'6"(:"(/62>"A-Y+"+6$F*+"/6"-.*"95$++"$62"A"F/%%"$%%"$"2*(J""<$=0$!3@&!#$6'5"1%$&F*2"'0-"/6"-.*"6/9.-"-/(*>"Z'0Y%%"9*-"+.$6F*2"r+-$11*2s"/6"-.*"7$&*"$-"-.*"5/9.-"-/(*>"3'6Y-"5*$%%:"&$5*"6'6*>"+4/-"r5$4s"'6"-.*".$%7"5.:(*>""S'(*"-.5'09."+.''-/69"E/-."$"1/9"1%$&F"+-$5"P"r906s>"#*6"$5*"'6"-.*"5'$2"-'"SK>"^$&F"-'"d*+-"_$(>"rms"/+"*$+:>""S5/(*"4$:+"+'"A"9'--$"2'"/-"4$5-"-/(*>"#$F*"$".0+-%*"$"E'62*5"%/F*"8-*B/*J"";/--%*"5$-+"F**4"E$%F/69"-.*"B*5(/6>"",--*6-/'6"+**F/69>":'0Y5*"+-/%%"6'-"%*$56/69>"K$%F/69"$1'0-"($F/69"/-"TY+"r'5/9/6$%s"$62"XY+"r9$6+-$s>""Z'0"$/6Y-"+('F/6Y"-.*"E**2>":'0"+-/%%"+('F/6Y"-.*"8-*5%/69>"=0(4"$"7*E"E*/9.-+>":'0"+-$5-"-./6F/69":'05"X/99+"r=*&F$("5$44*5"7$(*2"7'5"9$69+-*5"+-:%*s>"U'-"10%%*-"45''7"E.*6"-.*"%*$2"+-$5-+"1056/69>"

Page 135: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!ON"

"

R/6+*"r+.''-s"$"E.'%*"&%/4>".*$2+"+-$5-"-056/69>""^5/69":'0"E.'%*"&5*E>"AY("6'-"rms"'7":'0"45/&F+J"">#&=?0!K.*("($6"2*5>"F/%%"$%%"$"2*(>"S$-+"/6"-.*"*+-$-*+>"F/%%"$%%"$"2*(>"3'"E.$-"A"9'--$>"2*$%"E/-."/-"45'4*5>"35$E"7'5"+-5$4"$62"F/%%"$%%"$"2*(>"86/-&."#S+>"F/%%"$%%"$"2*(>"S$-+"/6"-.*"*62a>"F/%%"$%%"$"2*(>"K.*5*Y+"'6%:"'6*"-./6F"-.$-"/+"'6"(:"(/62>"A-Y+"+6$F*+"/6"-.*"95$++"$62"A"F/%%"$%%"$"2*(J""<$=0$!3#=$$!X*-"502*>"A"%*$B*"1'2/*+"/6"-.*"&*(*-*5:>""R/B*5"1'$-"7%'E/69>"%/F*"2'E6"/6"-.*"(*%'2:>"K.*("($6"-.*5*>"A"E/%%"%*$B*"-.*("1*./62>""S'+"-50+-"(*"7$(Y"-.*:"E/%%"6*B*5"1*"$.*$2"'7"(*>"K*55/-'5:Y+".:4*"15/69/69"-.*"*6*59:>"X5*:"1$62$6$+"($5F/69"-.*"-*55/-'5:""K.*("($6>"E/-."-.*".:4*"'6"]$&*1''F"K50+-"(*"7$(Y>"-.*:"&$6"6*B*5"1*75/*62"(*""8**"(*"E/-."-.*"($62*("r($%*"75/*62+s"+('F/69"-.*"30-&."r+4%/7s"S.**+*"$62"-.*"%*('6"r&$66$1/+"-:4*+s>"%/9.-/69"$"R/a%$"Z'0Y%%"($62*("E./%+-"+&5*E/6Y"$-"0+>"S'+"(:"($6"$/6Y-".$52"-'".*$5>"S'+"(:"1$5+"-.*:"'4*6"*$5+>"X'"7'5"-.*"&$4+"r10%%*-+s>"E.'Y+"5'%%/6Y".*5*>"A7"A"&$-&.":'05"($62*("+%/44/6Y>"-.*:Y%%"9*-"1*$-"2'E6"+'"+*B*5*J"">#&=?0!!K.*("($6"2*5>"F/%%"$%%"$"2*(>"S$-+"/6"-.*"*+-$-*+>"F/%%"$%%"$"2*(>"3'"E.$-"A"9'--$>"2*$%"E/-."/-"45'4*5>"35$E"7'5"+-5$4"$62"F/%%"$%%"$"2*(>"86/-&."#S+>"F/%%"$%%"$"2*(>"S$-+"/6"-.*"*62a>"F/%%"$%%"$"2*(>"K.*5*Y+"'6%:"'6*"-./6F"-.$-"/+"'6"(:"(/62>"A-Y+"+6$F*+"/6"-.*"95$++"$62"A"F/%%"$%%"$"2*(J"

"

K.*"%:5/&+"&'(4%*(*6-*2"-.*"-.*(*+"'7"6/./%/+("$62"-057"E$5"&'((06/&$-*2"-.5'09."-.*"

/($9*5:"$62"+'062+J"K.*:"4%$:"-.5'09."-.*"+&*6*"'7"+-$11/69"+'(*'6*"75'("$"5/B$%"$5*$>"

1$99/69"./("04"$62"-$F/69"./("-'"<44/69"]'5*+-"g"5*+-/69Q4%$&*"'7"06($5F*2"95$B*+J"c*5+*"

$7-*5"B*5+*>"-.*"-5$&F"/($9/6*+"+&*6$5/'+"'7"*C-5*(*"4.:+/&$%"B/'%*6&*>"+-$11/69>"+.''-/69"$62"

2*$-.J"K.*"1$6$%/-:"'7"-.*"B/'%*6&*"$&&*6-0$-*+"-.*"(*++$9*J"K.*"&'((*6-$5:"/+"706&-/'6$%>"

Page 136: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!Oe"

"

E/-.'0-"*('-/'6JNO"K.*"B/'%*6&*"$44*$5+"+*6+*%*++J",6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:"/+"7'&0+*2"'6"'-.*5"

E'5F/69Q&%$++":'069"4*'4%*"g"-.*"W&$-+"/6"-.*"*62aY"5$-.*5"-.$6"('5*"%*9/-/($-*"-$59*-+J"K.*"

5*$%/+("'7"-.*"25$($"&'(4%*(*6-+"-.*"7%'EJ",+"E/-."X/99+Y"-5$&F"<41='()!,9+!B435+-,"G?@@PI>"

&.'5*'95$4./&"$--*6-/'6"/+"4$/2"-'"-.*"-.*$-5*"'7"&'67%/&-"g"-.*"906"/+"25$E6>".*$2+"-056"$62"

-.*"'44'+/-/'6"&'675'6-*2J",62"$%%"'7"-./+"/+"H0+-/7/*2"-.5'09."-.*"2*7*6&*"'7"-*55/-'5:J"K*55/-'5:"

/+"2*($5&$-*2"-.5'09."5*7*5*6&*+"-'"%'&$%"%$62($5F+J"c/'%*6&*"/+"-.*"6*&*++$5:"5*+4'6+*"7'5"

E.'*B*5"-5$6+95*++*+"-.*+*"1'062$5/*+J"^*"/-"-.5'09."1:"95$++/69"'5"+%/44/69"G-5$6+95*++/69"

-*55/-'5/$%"1'062$5/*+I>"-.*"&'6+*h0*6&*+"$5*"+*B*5*J"<B*5:"B*5+*"&'(*+"1$&F"-'"-.*"&.'50+"WF/%%"

$%%"$"2*(YJ"

"

K.*"7/%("'4*6+"G+**"]/905*+"]/B*"-'"<%*B*6I"E/-."$"+.'-"'7"$695:Q%''F/69":'069"E./-*"(*6"

1*7'5*"&0--/69"-'"$"7$&*"&'B*5*2"E/-."$"-*55/-'5/$%"1$62$6$>"5*7*5*6&/69"051$6"E$57$5*"$62"

+05B*/%%$6&*"*B$+/'6J"A6"-.*"6*C-"/($9*>"-.*"7'5(*5"(*++$9*"/+"$6-.5'4'('54./+*2"/6"$6"$%*5-"

4/-10%%J"K.*+*"+.'-+"$5*"/6-*5+4*5+*2"E/-.".$6215$F*"-056+>"E.**%/*+"'6"('-'51/F*+>"$62"$"+'%'"

4*57'5($6&*"75'("d/+F/6"/6"E./&.".*"($F*+"+.''-/69"9*+-05*+J"d'(*6"4%$:"'6%:"$"

1$&F95'062"5'%*"$44*$5/69"$-"-.*"*29*+"'7"95'04"+.'-+J"#'+-"'7"-.*"B/2*'"/+"-$F*6"04"E/-."

+.'-+"'7"-.*"-.5**"75'6-Q(*6"5$44/69"/6"75'6-"'7"'-.*5":'069"(*6"E.'"5$4"$%'69"-'"-.*"E'52+"

'7"-.*"-5$&FJ"A6"-./+"E$:>"-.*"1$&F/69"95'04"+.'E+"$95**(*6-"E/-."-.*"%:5/&+"$62"E/-."-.*"

&'%%*&-/B*"&$0+*"7'5"E./&."-.*:"B'%06-**5"-.*/5"1'2/*+"g"($+&0%/6*"-*55/-'5/$%/-:"G2/+&0++*2"/6"

S.$4-*5"K.5**IJ"

"

[62*5%:/69"-.*"$*+-.*-/&+"'7"-.*"B/2*'"E*5*"6*9'-/$-/'6+"G+-5$-*9/*+"'7"%/B/69"GS.$(1*5+"!PMeII"

$62"4*57'5($6&*+"'7"+*C0$%/-:>"($+&0%/6/-:>"%$1'05"$62"-*55/-'5/$%"1*%'69/69J"K.*"B/2*'"25$E+"

$--*6-/'6"-'"-.*"+/(0%-$6*'0+%:".$52*6*2"($%*"1'2/*+"'7"9%'1$%"./4".'4"$62"E'5F/69Q&%$++"

&0%-05*J"[`"$62"[8"$5-/+-+>"N@"S*6->")$:Qx"$62";/%Y"d$:6*"$62"X/99+"$5*"$%%"/6-*5%'&0-'5+J"K.*"

1'2:"4'+-05*+"$62"+.''-/69"9*+-05*+"$5*"E$:+"'7"45*+*6-/69"-.*"2/+&'66*&-*2"W1$2"1':Y"-.*"

"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""NO"X/%5':"6'-*+"-.$-"7*$5"/+"&%'+*%:"/6-*5-E/6*2"E/-.":'069"4*'4%*Y+".*2'6/+-/&"*6H':(*6-"'7"2$6&*"$62"

(0+/&"g".'E".*2'6/+("$62"2$69*5"$5*"&%'+*%:"/6-*5%/6F*2"GX/%5':"!PVM>"4J!?VI"g"10-"A'11![11!4!>+&"

&'((06/&$-*+"7*$5"6'-"-.5'09."*6H':(*6-"10-"-.5'09."706&-/'6$%/-:J"

Page 137: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!OM"

"

"

E')03+!E'*+.!;,'11!F3%&!RA'11!411!4!>+&S!U!#',T011!$3%--T3++5!HL$+!E'1&-!7(,+3,4'(&+(,!+,!41@!OP??4J!

!

"E')03+!;'M.!;,'11!!F3%&!RA'11!411!4!>+&S!U!T4(54(4!4(5!9%%5!HL$+!E'1&-!7(,+3,4'(&+(,!+,!41@!OP??4J!

Page 138: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!OV"

"

"

E')03+!;+*+(.!;,'11!!F3%&!RA'11!411!4!>+&S!U!"#$%&'()!N%*+&+(,!C',9!,+33',%3'41!T4(54(4-!HL$+!

E'1&-!7(,+3,4'(&+(,!+,!41@!OP??4J!

"

"

E')03+!7')9,.!;,'11!!F3%&!RA'11!411!4!>+&S!U!3%45!-')(-!&43='()!,9+!,+33',%3/!HL$+!E'1&-!

7(,+3,4'(&+(,!+,!41@!OP??4J!

!

Page 139: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!OP"

"

"

E')03+!I'(+.!;,'11!!F3%&!RA'11!411!4!>+&S!U!F3%(,!&4(!4(5!T4$='()!)3%0#!HL$+!E'1&-!7(,+3,4'(&+(,!

+,!41@!OP??4J!

"

"

E')03+<+(.!;,'11!F3%&!RA'11!411!4!>+&S!U!F3%(,!&4(!4(5!-9%%,'()!)+-,03+-!F3%&!T4$='()!)3%0#!HL$+!

E'1&-!7(,+3,4'(&+(,!+,!41@!OP??4J!

"

Page 140: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!\@"

"

"

E')03+!71+*+(.!;,'11!!F3%&!RA'11!411!4!>+&S!U!94(5T3+4=!,03(!HL$+!E'1&-!7(,+3,4'(&+(,!+,!41@!OP??4J!

"

:'069"(*6"7**%"/+"+*C0$%%:"$--5$&-/B*"G8*/2%*5"?@@eIJ"d/+F/6Y+"5*7*5*6&*"-'"X/99+>"&$+0$%"&5/(*>"

*$+:"('6*:"$62"+('F/69"E**2"-/*"-.*+*"(*++$9*+"-'"./4".'4"/2*$+"'7"%$1'05"$62"%*/+05*"g"

*$+:"E'5F>"h0/&F"5*E$52"$62"5*%$C$-/'6"g"'5"W9*--/69"4$/2Y"GX/%5':"?@@@IJ"R:$6>"'6*"'7":'0-."

E'5F*5+"$-";*:.$("*C4%$/6*2f"

"

:/4(."A"-./6F"-.*:"$5*"%''F/69"$-"5$44*5+J"K.*5*"/+"6'"4'+/-/B*"5'%*"('2*%+"6'"('5*J"K.*"+$2"-./69"/+"/-"/+"$"%'-"'7":'069"1%$&F"F/2+"-.$-"$5*"9*--/69"/6B'%B*2"/6"-.$-"m""N."A-"$77*&-+"-.*"E./-*"F/2+"$+"E*%%i"":/4(."Z*$."/-"2'*+"$77*&-"-.*"E./-*"F/2+"$+"E*%%J"Z*$.>"-'"1*"1$2>"9/5%+"%'B*"$"1$2"1':J"d.*6":'0"$5*"'6"Kc"9/5%+"$5*"%/F*"E'E"%''F"$-"-./+"90:J"_*Y+"9'-"&.$/6+>".*Y+"9'-"('6*:"$62"-.*":'069"1':+"$5*"E$-&./69"$62"-./6F/69"'F$:"-.*"9/5%+"(0+-"%/F*"-./+J"A7"A"1*"%/F*"-./+>":'0"F6'Ei"K.$-Y+"E.$-"A"1*%/*B*"5*$%%:J"T6&*":'0"+-$5-"($F/69"('6*:"$62"'6&*":'0"+-$5-"1*/69"9''2>":'0".$B*"4*'4%*"E.'"E$6-"-'"+-$5-"%''F/69"9''2"-''"$62"-.*6":'0".$B*"&'(4*-/-/'6J"Z'0".$B*"-'"&.$69*":'05"/($9*>"$&-/69"04J""

,+"$"4*57'5($6&*>"l.*Y+"9'-"-.*"&.$/6+>".*Y+"9'-"-.*"('6*:n"&/-*+"<5/&"^"$62"R$F/(Y+"W=$/2"/6"

]0%%Y"G!PVMI"g"$"5*7*5*6&*"4'/6-"7'5"($H'5"[8"&/-/*+"/6"-.*"!PV@+"E.*6"$"2*+/5*"7'5"04E$52"

('1/%/-:"E$+"1*/69"5*&'96/+*2"$62"1%$&F"$02/*6&*+"$62"$5-/+-+"E*5*"95$44%/69"E/-."E.$-"/-"

(*$6-"-'"1*"1%$&F"$62"4$/2"G^$%2E/6"?@!@>"4J!e?IJ"K./+"&'6H06&-05*"/+"5*&'67/905*2"-.5'09."A'11!

Page 141: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!\!"

"

411!4!>+&"$+"-.*:"($F*"-.*/5"'E6"*6h0/5:"/6-'"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"('6*:J"K./+"/+"6'-"+/(4%:"

$6"'5/*6-$-/'6"'7";*:.$("-'"-.*",(*5/&$6"35*$(>"10-"5$-.*5"-.*"5*7'5(0%$-/'6"'7"$"B*56$&0%$5"

-.$-"($F*+"+*6+*"'7>"$62"&'((06/&$-*+>"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"'6"$6'-.*5"75/69*J"d/+F/6Y+"l.0+-%*n"

&'66*&-+"$"%'&$%"./+-'5:"'7"/67'5($%"*$56/69"$62"%'EQ%*B*%"&5/(/6$%/-:"G3'E6*+"!Pee>"_'11+"

!PVVI"-'"-.*"5/+*"'7"-.*"&'6+0(*5"/6"-.*"[8"$62"[`"G+**"S.$4-*5"]/B*IJ"

"

K*55/-'5/$%"$++*5-/'6+"$5*"$%+'"($2*"-.5'09."%/--*5/69"-.*"B/2*'"E/-."%'&$%"%$62($5F+J"K.*+*"

($9/&"+:(1'%+"GR'1/6+"$62"S'.*6"!PMVI"&'6-5'%"-.*"($-*5/$%"*6B/5'6(*6-"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"

%/B*"/6J"K.*:"/6&%02*"-.*"0+*"'7"4'+-&'2*"&'%'05+>"%'&$%"-01*"+-$-/'6+>"-.*"%'&$%"4$5F>"5'$2"$62"

4*2*+-5/$6"+/964'+-+>"-.*"7%:'B*5>"$62"-.*"2/+0+*2"$62"95$77/-/*2"5$/%E$:"%/6*J"K.*:"$%+'"/6&%02*"

-.*"45*+*6&*"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"-.*(+*%B*+>"E.'"$5*"*(1'2/*2"$62"('1/%*"($5F*5+"'7"-.*"

4'+-&'2*J"X5/(*>"$+"x01*5/".$+"6'-*2>"/+"2'(/6$-*2"1:"%'&$%"-*55/-'5/$%"$++*5-/'6+>"-057"E$5+"$62"

4'+-&'2*"5/B$%5/*+"1*-E**6"&5*E+"Gx01*5/"?@!@>"44J!V\>"!VeIJ"K.5'09."-.*"0+*"'7"1$62$6$+"

$62"&'%'05+>"-.*+*"6'-/'6+"'7"-*55/-'5/$%/-:"&/-*"-.*"[8"./4".'4"W.''2"G]'5($6"?@@?>"?@!@j"

X/%5':"?@!@1IJ"<B/2*6&*"'7"-./+"/+"+-$5F%:"45'B/2*2"/6"-.*"6'5-."'7"U*E.$("E.*5*"'6*"4'+-&'2*"

$5*$"/+"6/&F6$(*2"-.*"W^%''2+Y"$62"$6'-.*5"-.*"WS5/4+YJ"^'-."0+*"-.*"&'%'05+"'7"-.*/5";,"

&'06-*54$5-+J"A6"A'11!411!4!>+&"-./+"7'5("'7"-*55/-'5/$%"+:(1'%/+("/+"($2*"-.5'09."-.*"0+*"'7"-.*"

95*:"1$62$6$"g"l95*:"1$62$6$+"($5F/69"-.*"-*55/-'5:nJ"K.*"95*:"1$62$6$"G&.$69*2"-'"'5$69*"

/6"-.*"B/2*'"-'"7$&/%/-$-*"4'+-Q45'20&-/'6"*77*&-+I"/+"$"%'&$%"-*55/-'5/$%"+:(1'%J"K.*"B/2*'"+.'E+"

:'069"4*'4%*"E*$5/69"-.*"1$62$6$>"&'B*5/69"-.*/5"7$&*+"E/-."/->"$62"E*$5/69"/-"5'062"-.*/5"

E5/+-+J"_'E*B*5>"-.*+*"5*45*+*6-$-/'6+"'7"-*55/-'5:"E*5*"1'-."'%2"$62"6*EJ"d./%*"-.*"1$62$6$"

E$+"$"5*%$-/B*%:"6*E"$55/B$%"-'"-.*"$5*$>"-*55/-'5/$%"5/B$%5/*+"1*-E**6"2/77*5*6-"6*/9.1'05.''2+"

E*5*"%'69"*+-$1%/+.*2J"3'E6*+>"/6"./+"!Pee"+-02:"<9+!>+1'(c0+(,!;%10,'%(2"h0'-*2"$6"

/67'5($6-"E.'"2/+&0++*2"-.*"1$6$%/-:"'7"-057"E$5+"/6"-.*"%'&$%"$5*$"G3'E6*+"!Pee>"4J?@!I>N\"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""N\"_'E*B*5>"-.*"-5$6+%$-/'6+"'7"[8"./4".'4"$*+-.*-/&+"-'"%'&$%"-057"2/+40-*+"2/2"6'->"/6"&'6-5$2/&-/'6"'7"

+'(*"5*&*6-"$&&'06-+"G=/--+"?@@MI>"/(4%:"-.*"-$F*Q04"'7"[8"9$69"7'5($-/'6+"G&.$5$&-*5/+*2"1:"

./*5$5&./*+"'7"%*$2*5+./4"$62"/6/-/$-/'6"5/-*+"G,%*C$62*5"?@@Vj"3'E6*+"!PeeIJ"]5*22:>"'6*"'7"-.*":'069"

4*'4%*"$-";*:.$(>"6'-*2".'E"/-"E$+"6*B*5"$"W9$69Y"5/B$%5:"10-"$"4'+-&'2*"5/B$%5:J"K./+"/+"./+-'5/&$%%:"

+044'5-*2"1:"d/%%('--Y+"2/+&0++/'6"'7":'069"(*6"/6"^*-.6$%"X5**6>"<$+-";'62'6J"K.*+*":'069"(*6"

+-$-*2"-.*:"E*5*"%*$2*5%*++"$62"-.*5*7'5*"6'-"$"9$69"/6"-.*"[8"('0%2j"5$-.*5"-.*:"E*5*"H0+-":'069"

4*'4%*"E.'"$++'&/$-*2"/6"4**5"95'04+"Gd/%%('--"!PeP>"4JO\IJ"U'6*-.*%*++"-.*:"($/6-$/6*2"-*55/-'5/$%"

5/B$%5/*+"E/-."%'&$%"$5*$+"6'-/69"-.$-"-.*"&%'+*5"$5*$+".$2"-.*"7/*5&*+-"&'(4*-/-/'6+"Gd/%%('--"!PeP>"

44J!N@QN!IJ"

Page 142: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!\?"

"

$9$/6"+.'E/69".'E"&'6-*(4'5$5:"9%'1$%"B*56$&0%$5+"E*5*"$44%/*2"-'"($F*"+*6+*"'7"%'69Q

+-$62/69"-*55/-'5/$%"4'%/-/&+J"

"

K.*"+-5$-*9/*+"7'5"%/B/69"$62"-.*"&/-$-/'6+"2/+&*56/1%*"-.5'09."-.*"B/2*'Y+"&'((06/&$-/'6"'7"

+*C0$%/-:>"($+&0%/6/-:"$62"-*55/-'5/$%"1*%'69/69"E*5*"&'((06/&$-*2"$-"2/77*5*6-"+/-*+"'7"401%/&"

2/$%'90*J"K.*"6/./%/+-/&"(*++$9*"'7"A'11!411!4!>+&>"-.*"9*65*"/6"E./&."/-"+4'F*"$62"-.*"4'%/-/&+"-'"

E./&."/-"5*7*55*2"E*5*"$%%"/6-/($-*%:"062*5+-''2"1:"-.*"B/2*'Y+"%'&$%"/6-*5%'&0-'5+J"K.*+*"

/6-*5%'&0-'5+"$%+'"062*5+-''2>"%/F*"[4&'(/69"#'B*(*6->"-.$-"-.*+*"7'5(+"'7"-*55/-'5/$%"

&'((06/&$-/'6"E*5*"6'-"'6%:"7'5"-.*"+$F*"'7"$5-"10-"$%+'".$2"5*$%"&'6+*h0*6&*+J"A6"A'11!411!4!

>+&2![4&'(/69"#'B*(*6-Y+"401%/&"&%$/("-'"2*7*62"-.*";*:.$("4'+-&'2*"/+"&$4-05*2"/6"/-+"

E$56/69"-'"'0-+/2*5+"6'-"-'"-5$6+95*++"-.*/5"1'062$5/*+J"K.*"$&-"'7"-5$6+95*++/'6"E$+"F6'E6"$+"

W+%/44/69YJ"]5'6-"($6"`*(4:"&%$/(+"l/7"A"&$-&.":'05"($62*("+%/44/6Y>"-.*:"E/%%"9*-"1*$-"2'E6"2'"

+*B*5*nJ",%-.'09."-*55/-'5/$%"5/B$%5/*+"E*5*"5*$+'6$1%:"7%0/2>"4'+-&'2*"-5$6+95*++/'6+"2/2"5*+0%-"

/6"B/'%*6&*>"$62"E.*6"[4&'(/69"#'B*(*6-Y+"(*++$9*"E$+"5*%*$+*2"'6"Z'0K01*>"/-"1*&$(*"

+/(0%-$6*'0+%:"4$5-"'7"$6"'6%/6*"2/$%'90*"G2*7/6*2"-.5'09."-.*"4*57'5($6&*"'7"6/./%/+(I"$62"

4$5-"'7"$"5*$%Q%/7*"+&*6$5/'"/6"E./&."-.*"4*57'5($6&*"'7"6/./%/+("(/9.-"('B*"1*:'62"5.*-'5/&"-'"

$&-0$%"B/'%*6&*J",+"45*(/+*2"1:"[4&'(/69"#'B*(*6-Y+"&'((/-(*6-"-'"-./+"2/$%'90*>"E.*6"

-.*"B/2*'"E$+"04%'$2*2"'6"Z'0K01*"%'&$%"$B$-$5+"5*+4'62*2"$62"-.*"&'((*6-+"+*&-/'6"

+-$5-*2"-'"7/%%"04"E/-."/6-*5%'&0-'5+"E.'"E$6-*2"-'"-*+-"-.*"95'04Y+"&'((/-(*6-"-'"B/'%*6&*J"

='+-+"/6&%02*2f"

!

>&..$'3!&'$!l%'%"($6"-$%F/6"1'E-"+.$6F/6"r+-$11/69s"1'E-"+.$6F/6J"6*B$"+.$6F*2"+'(*'6*"10-"1**6"+.$6F*2>"26-"7/6F"0"F6'E"E$-"/-+"%/F*"F/2>"$62"2*+4/-*"($6"+-/&F/6"1%$2*"/6"(*".*"%''F*2".'55'57/*2"$%%"0"7$66/*+"5"40++/*+"($-*J"E.*5*"0"75'("0"9'$-+>"%''F"%/F*"7$99'-+>"e@":'069*6+"E/2"+'(*"7$-"$++"45/&F"9/(4Jn""">&..$'3!3@&"G4'+-*2"1:"$"2/77*5*6-"95'04"'7";*:.$(":'069"(*6I!lE$-"2'"0"F6'"9$69+-*5+"&0("?"2$"1%'&+"$6"9*-"2044/*2NN"r1*$-*6"04s"+6"0"7$-"+./-Jn""">&..$'3!3#=$$!lK./+"/+"$E70%J"/"E'0%2"2044:"$%%"O"'7":'0"E.'"H0(4*2"'6"-./+"-5$&FJ"'6"!"5/22/("r5.:-.(sn"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""NN")$($/&$6"B*56$&0%$5"(*$6/69"W9.'+-Y"'5"W+4/5/-YJ"

Page 143: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!\O"

"

A6"$22/-/'6"-'"2*('6+-5$-/69"-.*"B$5/'0+"+/-*+"$-"E./&."6/./%/+("E$+"6*9'-/$-*2"$62"4*57'5(*2>"

-.*+*"/6-*5$&-/'6+"h0*+-/'6*2"[4&'(/69"#'B*(*6-Y+"&'((/-(*6-"-'"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:"$62"

B/'%*6&*"$+"$"E$:"'7"%/7*J"[4&'(/69"#'B*(*6-Y+"*6-5$6&*"/6-'"2/$%'90*"E.*5*"+4*&-5*+"'7"

B/'%*6&*"&'0%2"1*&'(*"5*$%/-:"45'B/2*+"+4$&*"7'5"-./6F/69"$1'0-"-.*"2/++'6$6&*"1*-E**6"

6/./%/+("$+"4*57'5($6&*"$62"6/./%/+("$+"$"E$:"'7"%/7*J"K./+"705-.*5"&.$%%*69*+"-.*"2'(/6$6-"

2/+&'05+*+"'6":'0-."&0%-05*"$+"6/./%/+-/&J"K./+"2/++'6$6&*"1*&$(*"&%*$5*5"E.*6"[4&'(/69"

#'B*(*6-"5*%*$+*2"$"G+9'(5!,9+!;$+(+-!B/2*'"7'5"A'11!411!4!>+&!GA&*"]/%(+"<6-*5-$/6(*6-"*-"$%J"

?@!!1IJ"K.*"B/2*'"+.'E*2"-.*"W($F/69"'7Y"E.$-"1*&'(*+"-.*"6/./%/+-/&"4*57'5($6&*J"8.'-"/6"

&'%'05>"/-"E$+"$"2*4$5-05*"75'("-.*"95/--:"1%$&F"$62"E./-*"'7"A'11!411!4!>+&!+.'E/69"-.*"

*B*5:2$:".0($6/-:"'7"-.*"45'-$9'6/+-+"1*./62"-.*"$0+-*5*"7$y$2*J"A-"+.'E+"-.*"75'6-(*6"

9*--/69"-.*"B*5+*+"E5'69>":'069"4*'4%*"+(/%/69"$-"*$&."'-.*5>"$62"E/62/69"*$&."'-.*5"04J"A6"$%%"

-.*+*"E$:+>"/-"+099*+-+"-.$-"5$-.*5"-.$6"%/B/69"/6"$"4*5($6*6-"$62"7/C*2"+-$-*"'7"B/'%*6-"

-*55/-'5/$%/-:"$62"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:"-.*":'069"4*'4%*".$2"-'"5*.*$5+*"/-+"&'6-'05+"-'"$&./*B*"$"

&'6B/6&/69"+-:%*"'7"&'((06/&$-/'6J"

"

G+9'(5!,9+!;$+(+-!GA&*"]/%(+"<6-*5-$/6(*6-"*-"$%J"?@!!1I"$%+'".*%4+"('B*"$E$:"75'("-.*"/2*$"

-.$-"A'11!411!4!>+&!E$+"$"4*57'5($6&*"'7"E./-*"-*55/-'5/$%/-:J"S'6+/2*5*2"/6"-.*"&'6-*C-"'7"

$0-'&.-.'6:"$62"-*55/-'5/$%/-:"G2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"K.5**I>"$62"1$+*2"/6"-.*"+F/6"&'%'05"'7"-.*"

-.5**"75'6-"(*6>"-./+"(/9.-"1*"$6"*$+:"&'6&%0+/'6"-'"25$EJ"_'E*B*5>"E./%*"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"

/6"-.*"B/2*'"E*5*"45*2'(/6$6-%:"E./-*>"-.*"45'20&*5+"E*5*"5*B*$%*2"-'"1*"1%$&F"$62",+/$6J"

K./+"+099*+-+"'6"-.*"'6*".$62"-.$-"%':$%-:"-'"-.*"45'20&-/'6"&$(*"1*7'5*"*-.6/&"7*$%-:"GX/%5':"

!PP\>"4JN?I>"$62"'6"-.*"'-.*5"-.$-"E./-*"-*55/-'5/$%/-:"&$6"1*"45'20&*2"1:"1%$&F"$62",+/$6"

:'069"4*'4%*"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"-.$-"E./-*":'069"4*'4%*"4*57'5("1%$&F"6/./%/+(J"

"

K.*"*C-*6-"'7"-.*+*"(0%-/&0%-05$%"4$5$2'C*+"G^$&F"!PP\I"&$66'-"1*"062*5+-''2"$+/2*"75'("-.*"

9*6*+/+"'7"-.*"-5$&F"/-+*%7>"$62"-.*"*-./&+"'7"+.$5/69"$-"-.*".*$5-"'7"-.*"E'5FJ"A6"$22/-/'6"-'"

1*/69"$"45'6'06&*(*6-"'7"6/./%/+("$62"-057"E$5>"-.*"45'20&-/'6"5*%/*2"'6"1'55'E/69"$62"

5*(/C/69"$&5'++"-*55/-'5/$%"1'062$5/*+"GX/%5':"?@@@>"4J!PPIJ"K.*"B/2*'"+.'E+":'069"4*'4%*"

75**+-:%/69"'B*5"U'&-056$%Y+"5*(/C"G?@@PI"'7"3c,Y+"$F$"8&5$-&.$"GR/6+*"]#"$62"<$+-";'62'6"

$5-/+-I"/6+-50(*6-$%"$%+'"&$%%*2"A'11![11![9!>+&\Y!G?@!@IJ"K.*"/6+-50(*6-$%"/+"6'-"06/h0*"$62"/-"/+""

"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""Ne"3/77*5*6-"B*5+/'6+"'7"-.*"-5$&F".$B*"2/77*5*6-"+4*%%/69+J""

Page 144: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!\\"

"

"

"

E')03+!<C+1*+.!;,'11!F3%&!RG+9'(5!,9+!;$+(+-S"GA&*"]/%(+"<6-*5-$/6(*6-"*-"$%J"?@!!1I"

"

-'6$%%:"+/(/%$5"-'"d/%*:Y+"<9+!N4,3'M!L(-,30&+(,41!G?@!@"r?@@!Q?@@esIJ"A6"-./+"E$:>"[4&'(/69"

#'B*(*6-Y+"A'11!411!4!>+&"*C/+-+"/6"$"6*C0+"'7"$445'45/$-/'6"$62"5*0+*J"K./+"/+"7$5"75'(""

4%$9/$5/+(J",+"E/-."d/%*:Y+"<9+!N4,3'M!L(-,30&+(,41>!8&5$-&.$Y+"B*5+/'6"'7"A'11![11![9!>+&"E$+"

($2*"-'"1*"+.$5*2"$62"5*(/C*2>"$62".$+"1**6"&'B*5*2"1:"60(*5'0+"$5-/+-+"/6&%02/69"3'%%$5"2$"

30+-($6"G?@!!I"$62"K/6/*"K*(4$."G?@!@IJ"S'%%$1'5$-/'6"/+"705-.*5"*B/2*6-"/6"-.*"0+*"'7"

-*&.6'%'9:"$62"%$690$9*J"K.*"&$(*5$"+.'-+"$5*"7$&*".*/9.-"$62>"/6"$%%"10-"+'062"$62"/($9*"

h0$%/-:>"7$/-.70%"-'"-.*"45*B/'0+%:"2/+&0++*2"9*65*"'7"95/(*"B/2*'+"-.$-"$5*"&$4-05*2"'6"('1/%*"

4.'6*+"$62"04%'$2*2"-'"Z'0K01*J"K.*"%$690$9*"'7"A'11!411!4!>+&"(/C*+")$($/&$6>";'62'6>"[8"

$62",5$1/&"B*56$&0%$5+"-'"2'&0(*6-"-.*"%*/+05*"-/(*"405+0/-+"'7"+('F/69"&$66$1/+J"A6"'-.*5"

B*5+*+"d*+-"S'$+-"5$4"-*5(+"GUXx"$62"TXI"$5*"(/C*2"E/-."[`"45/+'6"B*56$&0%$5+"G+.$6FIJ"

"

_'E*B*5>"1*:'62"-./+>"A'11!411!4!>+&!E$+"$6"/(4'5-$6-"6*9$-/B*"4'%/-/&$%"&'((*6-$5:J"K.*"

95/(:"$6-/Q+'&/$%"5*$%/+("'7"-.*"7/%("2/2"('5*"-.$6"5*4%/&$-*"$"&'((*5&/$%/+*2"9*65*"$62"

&'((06/&$-*"(*++$9*+"'7"(*$6/69%*++"B/'%*6&*J"A-"$%+'"h0*+-/'6*2"-.*"4.:+/&$%"$62"

*C45*++/B*"%/(/-$-/'6+"'6":'069"4*'4%*Y+"%/B*+J","15/*7"9%$6&*"$&5'++"[`"95/(*"$62"./4".'4"

5*B*$%+"$6"$55$:"'7"$5-/+-+"E/-."+/(/%$5"45'H*&-/'6+J"U'";$:>"3/aa**"R$+&$%>"R''-+"#$60B$>"d/%*:>"

8F/66:($6>"3*B%/6>"^5$/6-$C>"K$+F"]'5&*>",75/&$6"^':>";$2:"S.$66>";/'6*++>";'EF*:>",F$%$>"8E$:"

Page 145: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!\N"

"

$62"8'E*--'"`/6+&.".$B*"$%%"1**6"4'%/-/&$%%:"('-/B$-*2J"K.5'09."$695:>"95/(:>"6/./%/+-/&>"

+'(*-/(*+".0('5'0+>"+'&/$%"5*$%/+-"$*+-.*-/&+>"-.*:".$B*"*69$9*2"E/-."-.*"/6H0+-/&*+"'7"

/((/95$-/'6>"06*(4%':(*6->"1'52*5"+*&05/-:>"6$-/'6$%/+(>"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:>"1$6F*5+Y"1'60+*+>"

4$-5/$5&.:>"(/+'9:6:>"4'B*5-:>"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6>"-.*"4*6$%"+-$-*>"+05B*/%%$6&*"$62"/(4*5/$%/+(J"A6"

-./+"E$:"-''"-.*:".$B*"'4*6*2"04"-.*"4'++/1/%/-:"'7"&'675'6-/69"-.*+*"7'5(+"'7"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"

$62"&'6+/2*5/69"E$:+"'7"%/7*"1*:'62"-.*("G+**"S.$4-*5"]/B*IJ"

"

A'11!411!4!>+&"/+"4$5-"'7"-./+"-5$2/-/'6J"A-"($F*+"2*-$/%*2"&'((*6-$5:"'6"-.*"&05-$/%(*6-"'7"

:'069"4*'4%*Y+"75**2'(>"4$5-/&0%$5%:"E/-."5*9$52+"-'"-.*"4'%/&*"$62"-'"4'%/&*"+05B*/%%$6&*"G$%+'"

2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"K.5**IJ"d./%*"-./+"45*+*6-$-/'6"'7"&'67%/&-"E/-."-.*"4'%/&*"$62"+05B*/%%$6&*"

/+"4$5-"'7"-.*"4*57'5($6&*"'7"6/./%/+(>"/-"/+"$%+'"$"(*$6+"1:"E./&."-.*":'069"4*'4%*"4'%/-/&$%%:"

5*7%*&-"'6"-.*/5"($59/6$%/+$-/'6J"U*$5%:"$%%"'7"-.*"B/2*'"E$+"+.'-"/6"401%/&%:"'E6*2"+4$&*"g"-.*"

4$5F>"062*5"-.*"7%:'B*5>"-.*"2/+0+*2"5$/%E$:"%/6*"g"10-"-.*5*"/+"$"&'6+-$6-"$&F6'E%*29*(*6-"

-.$-"-.*"+-$-*"/+"E$-&./69j"-.$-"-.*/5"45*+*6&*"/6"-./+"+4$&*"/+"4'-*6-/$%%:"&5/(/6$%J"84*&/7/&$%%:>"

-.*"%:5/&+"+-$-*"lAY("2'/69"-.*"&5/(*>"A"$/6Y-"2'/69"-.*"-/(*J"PPP"4*'4%*"'6"-.*"4.'6*+Jn"8-*B'Y+"

/6-*6-/'6"-'"+-$1"./+"4'+-&'2*"5/B$%+"-$F*+"/6-'"$&&'06-"$"5*+4'6+*"75'("-.*"4'%/&*>"E.'".*"

$++0(*+"E/%%"F6'E"E.$-".*"2/2>"*B*6"/7"-.*:"&$66'-"&$-&."./(J",+"/+"-.*"&$+*"E/-."'-.*5"B/2*'+"

/6"-.*"9*65*"+0&."$+"3/aa**"R$+&$%Y+"W8/5*6+Y"G?@@MI>"-.*"*:*"'7"-.*"+-$-*"/+"45*+*6-J"K.*"+.'-+"'7"

SSKc"&$(*5$+"$-"-.*"1*9/66/69"'7"A'11!411!4!>+&"$44*$5"$9$/6"$+"-.*"B/2*'"&'6-/60*+J"='%/&*"

'77/&*5+"($F*"$6"$44*$5$6&*"-.5'09."$6"*69$9*(*6-"E/-."$"95'04"'7":'069"(*6"$62"E'(*6"

+/--/69"'6"-.*"2/+0+*2"5$/%E$:"4%$-7'5(J"K.*"25$($-/&"&%$/("-'"F/%%"4'+-&'2*"5/B$%+"$%+'"'4*6+"

-.*"E$:"7'5"h0*+-/'6/69"$"+:+-*("'7"401%/&"($+&0%/6/-:"-.$-"%*$2+"+'(*":'069"4*'4%*"-'"($F*"

+*6+*"'7"-.*/5"%/B*+"-.5'09."4*57'5($6&*+"$62"5*$%/-/*+"'7"B/'%*6&*"$62"$6-/Q+'&/$%"1*.$B/'05J"

,+"2/+&0++*2"705-.*5"/6"S.$4-*5"]/B*>"-./+"4'%/-/&+"/+"6*9$-/B*%:"4'%/-/&$%"G_$%1*5+-$("?@@VI"

1*&$0+*"E./%*"/-"2'*+"6'-"45'B/2*"$"4'+/-/B*"+'%0-/'6"/-"2'*+"h0*+-/'6"-.*"/6H0+-/&*+":'069"

4*'4%*"&'675'6->"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"$+"/-"45'B/2*+"$"-''%"7'5"2*B*%'4/69"&5/-/&$%"5*7%*&-/'6"$62"

4'%/-/&$%"&'6+&/'0+6*++J"

"

"

Page 146: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!\e"

"

"

E')03+!<9'3,++(.!;,'11!F3%&!RA'11!411!4!>+&S!U!-03*+'114($+"HL$+!E'1&-!7(,+3,4'(&+(,!+,!41@!OP??4J"

"

"E')03+!E%03,++(.!;,'11!F3%&!RA'11!411!4!>+&S!U!-03*+'114($+!HL$+!E'1&-!7(,+3,4'(&+(,!+,!41@!OP??4J!

"

A6"+0(($5:>"A'11!411!4!>+&"E'5F*2"'6"2/77*5*6-"%*B*%+"E/-."2/77*5*6-"$02/*6&*+J"d./%+-"1*/69"$"

%'&$%"45'20&-/'6"1$+*2"'6"-*55/-'5:>"($+&0%/6/+*2"B/'%*6&*"$62"+05B*/%%$6&*"/-"E$+"$%+'"4$5-"'7"$"

Page 147: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!\M"

"

./9.%:"&'((*5&/$%/+*2"9*65*"-.$-"4'40%$5/+*2"6/./%/+(J"K.*":'069"4*'4%*"&/-*2"-./+"2/$+4'5/&"

$*+-.*-/&"7'5"-.*"4054'+*"'7"6*9'-/$-/69"%'&$%"$62"9%'1$%"7'5(+"'7"($+&0%/6/-:>"+*C0$%/-:"$62"

-*55/-'5/$%"1*%'69/69J"K.*"4*57'5($6&*"*6+05*2"-.$-"1%$&F"$62"E./-*"$0-.*6-/&/-/*+"$++'&/$-*2"

E/-."-*55/-'5/$%/-:>"($+&0%/6/-:"$62"+*C0$%/-:"E*5*"15'F*6"2'E6"$62"5*Q($2*J",+"E./-*":'069"

4*'4%*"4*57'5(*2"1%$&F"6/./%/+(>",+/$6"$62"1%$&F"45'20&*5+"E'5F*2"E/-."E./-*"$0-'&.-.'6:J"

,-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"-.*:"*6+05*2"-.$-"*-.6/&"7*$%-:"E$+"2/+5*9$52*2"/6"405+0/-"'7"$"&'%%*&-/B*"

45'H*&-J"

"

K*55/-'5/$%/-:"$62"($+&0%/6/-:"E*5*"&'((06/&$-*2>"5*B*$%*2"$62"6*9'-/$-*2"$-"2/77*5*6-"5*$%"

$62"B/5-0$%"%*B*%+J"K.*+*"B$5/'0+"+/-*+"'7"2/$%'90*"*C4'+*2"2/77*5*6-"2/(*6+/'6+"'7"-.*"

4*57'5($6&*>"$62"-.*"E$:+"/6"E./&."-.*":'069"(*6"*69$9*2"E/-."$62"&'((06/&$-*2"6/./%/+(J"

K.*:"./9.%/9.-*2"-.$-"7$5"75'("1*/69"$"E$:"'7"%/7*>"6/./%/+("E$+"$6"$*+-.*-/&"+:+-*("-.$-"

[4&'(/69"#'B*(*6-".$2"5*.*$5+*2"W1*./62"-.*"+&*6*+YJ"K.*+*"+/-*+"'7"2/$%'90*"$%+'"($2*"

+-$5F"-.*"&'6-*(4'5$5:"4$5$2'C*+"'7"051$6"(0%-/&0%-05*"G^$&F"!PP\IJ"d./%*"A'11!411!4!>+&"

&'((06/&$-*2"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:"$62"*C&%0+/'6$5:"-*55/-'5/$%/-:>"-.*/5"E'5F"*C/+-*2"'6%:"1*&$0+*"

'7"/6-*6+*"&'%%$1'5$-/'6"$&5'++"-.*+*"1'062$5/*+J"K.*"B/5-0$%"+/-*+"$-"E./&."4.:+/&$%"B/'%*6&*"

1*&$(*"5*$%"E*5*"$%+'"-.*"+4$&*+"/6"E./&.":'069"4*'4%*"+.$5*2"-.*"(0+/&"-.$-"($2*"-.*"

45'20&-/'6"4'++/1%*J"A6"-./+"E$:>"-.*"*-./&+"'7"2/$%'90*"5$-.*5"-.$6"2*-$&.(*6-"E$+"$-"-.*"&'5*"

'7"-.*"B/2*'J"]/6$%%:>"&'06-*5/69"-.*"$++0(4-/'6"-.$-":'0-."&0%-05*"/+"+'%2Q'0-"$62"$4'%/-/&$%>"

A'11!411!4!>+&"E$+"4$5-"'7"$"-5$2/-/'6"'7"4'%/-/&$%"E'5F"-.$-"$%%'E*2":'069"4*'4%*"-'"*B$%0$-*"

-.*"/6H0+-/&*+"-.*:"*6&'06-*5*2J"

S'6&%0+/'6"

Z'069"4*'4%*Y+"&5*$-/B*"$62"4'%/-/&$%"E'5F"/+"'7-*6"*C&%02*2"75'("401%/&"$62"2*('&5$-/&"

2*1$-*"'6"-.*"1$+/+"-.$-"/-"/+"+'%2Q'0-"$62"6/./%/+-/&J"K$F/69"-./+"$+"$"+-$5-/69"4'/6->"-.*"&.$4-*5"

.$+"$590*2"-.$-"E./%*":'069"4*'4%*Y+"45'20&-/'6+"0+*2"6/./%/+-"$*+-.*-/&+"$62"&'((*5&/$%"

-5'4*+"-.*:"E*5*"$%+'"(*$6/6970%"$62"4'%/-/&$%J"U'6*"'7"-.*"45'20&-/'6+"45*+*6-*2"/6"-./+"

&.$4-*5"E*5*"(/62%*++"4$55'-/69+"'7"&'((*5&/$%"9*65*+J"Z'069"4*'4%*"0+*2"6/./%/+("7'5"

5*7%*&-/69"4'%/-/&$%%:"'6"7'5(+"'7"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"-.*:"$%+'"0+*2"+'%2Q'0-"9*65*+"-'"45'B/2*"

+-5$-*9/*+"7'5"%/B/69J"K.*+*"/6&%02*2"6*9'-/$-/'6+"'7"+*C0$%/-:>"($+&0%/6/-:>"7*(/6/6/-:"$62"

1*%'69/69J"K.5'09."2/+&0++/'6+"'7"&/-$-/'6"$62"2/$+4'5$"-.*"&.$4-*5".$+"+.'E6".'E"-.*"&%$/(+"

-'"5$&/$%/+*2"$0-.*6-/&/-:>"+*C0$%/-:"$62"($+&0%/6/-:>"/6.*5*6-"/6"-.*"-.*+/+"'7"6/./%/+(>"E*5*"

Page 148: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!\V"

"

15'F*6"2'E6J",225*++/69"$&$2*(/&"2*1$-*+"'6"&0%-05$%"+:6&5*-/+("/-".$+"2*('6+-5$-*2"-.$-"

E./%*"$++'&/$-/'6+"E/-."-.*"&0%-05$%"&$-*9'5/*+"'7"1%$&F"$62"E./-*"E*5*"15'F*6"2'E6>"6*E"

7'5(+"'7"$0-.*6-/&/-:"$5'+*J"A6"-.*"&'6-*C-"'7";*:.$(>"($+&0%/6/-:"$62"+*C0$%/-:"E*5*"5*7'5(*2"

-'"($F*"+*6+*"'7"%'&$%"6'-/'6+"'7"-*55/-'5:"$62"+*C0$%"('5$%/-:J"#0+/&"$++'&/$-*2"E/-."

2$69*5'0+"1%$&F"1'2/*+"E$+"5*Q0+*2"-'"+044'5-"E./-*"-*55/-'5/$%"&%$/(+>"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"$+"

1%$&F"$62",+/$6":'069"4*'4%*"45'20&*2"E./-*"-*55/-'5/*+J"K.*+*"+**(/69%:"&'06-*5/6-0/-/B*"

/2*$+"*C/+-*2"/6"06&'(4%/&$-*2"$%%/$6&*J"K.*"&.$4-*5".$+"&'6+/2*5*2".'E"-.*"+./7-/69"+$62+"'7"

&0%-05$%"+:6&5*-/+("E*5*"-*+-$(*6-"-'"-.*"&'%%$1'5$-/'6"-.$-"*C/+-*2"1*:'62"$++0(*2"*-.6/&"

$62"-*55/-'5/$%"1'062$5/*+J"K.*"2$6&*"('B*+"$62"(0+/&":'069"4*'4%*"5*45'20&*2"E*5*"($2*"

75'("9%'1$%%:"2/+-5/10-*2"$62"75**%:"$B$/%$1%*"($-*5/$%+J"K.*"-*&.6'%'9/*+"-.$-"7$&/%/-$-*2"-./+"

2/$%'90*"E*5*"&.'+*6"-'"($C/(/+*"*$+*"'7"&'%%$1'5$-/'6"$62"&5*$-/B*"*C&.$69*J"TB*5$%%>"-.*"

&.$4-*5".$+"$590*2"7'5"$"5*Q*B$%0$-/'6"'7"%*7-Q"$62"5/9.-"E/69"4'+/-/'6+"-.$-"&'62*(6":'069"

4*'4%*Y+"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+"$+"(/62%*++"(/(/&5:"$62"$4'%/-/&$%"6/./%/+(J"K.*"&.$4-*5".$+"

2*('6+-5$-*2"-.$-":'069"4*'4%*Y+"45'20&-/'6+"'7"9%'1$%/+*2"$*+-.*-/&+"E*5*"(*$6/6970%"$62"

4'%/-/&$%J"K.*:"$%%'E*2"-.*("-'"6*9'-/$-*"-.*/5"%/B*+>"45'B/2*2"$"B*56$&0%$5"7'5"401%/&"

&'((06/&$-/'6>"5*45'20&*2"$6"*-./&+"'7"&'%%$1'5$-/'6+>"$62"'4*5$-*2"$+"$"(*2/0("-.5'09."

E./&."-.*:"&'0%2"*B$%0$-*"/6H0+-/&*+J"

"

S.$4-*5"]/B*>"'6"-.*".'5/a'6+"'7":'069"4*'4%*"/6"U*E.$(>"*C-*62+"-./+"2/+&0++/'6"-'"5*B*$%"

705-.*5"2/(*6+/'6+"'7"-.*/5"4'%/-/&$%"&'6+&/'0+6*++>"6*9$-/B*"4'%/-/&+"$62"-.*"45'H*&-/'6"'7"

$%-*56$-/B*"70-05*+J"

Page 149: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!\P"

"

S.$4-*5"]/B*"g"_'5/a'6+f"$+4/5$-/'6$%>"($59/6$%/+*2"$62"$%-*56$-/B*"

Z'069"4*'4%*"$5*"$"%/9.-6/69"5'2"7'5"-.*"70-05*J"WS0%-05$%"-5$6+%$-'5+Y>"10+/6*++"+-5$-*9/+-+>"

&'6+0(*5"4+:&.'%'9/+-+>"($5F*-/69"*C4*5-+>"9%'1$%"(0%-/6$-/'6$%+"$62"&'6+0%-$6&/*+"$%%"-5:"-'"

06%'&F"-.*"/(4*62/69"2*+/5*+"'7"-.*"+'Q&$%%*2"X*6*5$-/'6"ZNM""g"-.*"&'.'5-"'7"&./%25*6"1'56"

1*-E**6"!PMP"$62"?@@@"G_'77($6"?@@Mj";$6&$+-*5"$62"8-/%%($6"?@!@>";$a$5*B/&"$62"=*-5'B/&Q

;$a$5*B/&"?@@Mj"ToU*/%%"?@@Pj"?@!?j"L0/66"?@@N>"K$4+&'--"?@@P>"Z$55'E"$62"To3'66*%%"

?@@PIJK.*+*"*20&$-*2>"(/22%*Q&%$++>"E*$%-.:":'069"(*6"$62"E'(*6"$5*"&'05-*2"$+"-.*"70-05*"

4/'6**5+>"6$B/9$-'5+"$62"&'6+0(*5+"'7"-*&.6'%'9/&$%>"/62/B/20$%/+*2"$62"9%'1$%/+*2"$2B$6&*+"

G_$55/+"?@@\>"4J!NIJ"T6"-.*"7%/4"+/2*"$5*"-.'+*"-.$-"%$&F"$+4/5$-/'6+J"K.*+*":'069"4*'4%*"$5*"

'7-*6"E'5F/69Q&%$++J"K.*:"5*45*+*6-"-.*"06&*5-$/6-/*+"$62"2:+-'4/$+"'7"-.*"E'5%2"-'"&'(*J"

K.5'09."-.*+*":'069"4*'4%*"-.*"6*9$-/B*"/(4%/&$-/'6+"'7"/62/B/20$%/+$-/'6"$62"9%'1$%/+$-/'6"g"

-.*"15*$F2'E6"'7"&'((06/-:"$62"-.*"/6&5*$+/69"4'%$5/+$-/'6"1*-E**6"-.*"5/&."$62"-.*"4''5"g"

$5*"B/*E*2"G_$55/+"?@@\>"44J\QNIJ"K.*+*":'069"4*'4%*".$06-"$20%-"+'&/*-:"l1*&$0+*"r-.*:s"

5*7*5*6&*"'05"6**2"-'"1*"$--*6-/B*"-'"$"70-05*"-.$-"'-.*5+"E/%%"/6.*5/-n"GX/5'0C"!PPe>"4J!@IJ"

"

X/B*6"-.*"&*6-5$%/-:"'7"&./%25*6"$62":'069"4*'4%*"/6"$&&'06-+"'7"-.*"70-05*>"-.*"$%('+-"-'-$%"

$1+*6&*"'7"*-.6'95$4./&"*6h0/5:"'6"-.*"+01H*&-"/+"+0545/+/69J"d./%*"+'&/$%"+&/*6-/+-+".$B*"1**6"

&'Q'4-*2"/6-'"60(*5'0+"$6$%:+*+"'7"70-05*"W5/+FY"G^*++$6-"*-"$%J"?@@Oj"S$/56+"$62"S$/56+"!PP\j"

`5'6/&F"!PPMj"U*E1056"*-"$%J"!PPPj"R/&.($6"$62"]5$+*5"?@@!I"-.*:".$B*"/96'5*2"$-"$6"

*B*5:2$:"%*B*%".'E":'069"4*'4%*"45'20&*"$62"*C4*5/*6&*"-.*/5"70-05*+J"8'&/'%'9/+-+".$B*"

45'20&*2"E'5F"'6"W:'0-."-5$6+/-/'6+Y"g"%'69/-02/6$%"$6$%:+*+"'7"%$1'05"($5F*-+"$62"7$(/%:"/6"

%$-*"('2*56/-:"g"10-".$B*"%$59*%:"%*7-"-'"'6*"+/2*":'069"4*'4%*Y+"'E6"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6"'7"

-.*/5".'5/a'6+"G_*62*5+'6"?@@Mj"K.'(+'6"?@@PIJ"<-.6'95$4.*5+".$B*"E'5F*2"2/%/9*6-%:"'6"

&'%%*&-/B*"(*('5:>"./+-'5:"$62"&'6-*C-"10-".$B*"/96'5*2"-.*"/(4'5-$6&*"'7"-.*"-'Q&'(*"

($6/7*+-*2"/6"$%%"*B*5:2$:"+&*6$5/'+"G,44$205$/"?@@\>"4Je@IJ"K./+"&.$4-*5"/+"+'(*E.$-"

2/77*5*6-J"A-"/6B/-*+"$6"062*5+-$62/69"'7"2/77*5*6-"70-05*+"75'("-.*"4*5+4*&-/B*+"'7":'069"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""NM",%+'"5*7*55*2"-'"$+"-.*"W#/%%*66/0("X*6*5$-/'6YJ""

"

Page 150: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!N@"

"

4*'4%*"$62"-.5'09."-.*/5"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+J"A-"&'6+/2*5+"7/5+->".'E":'069"4*'4%*"45'H*&-*2"

$+4/5$-/'6j"+*&'62>".'E":'069"4*'4%*"45'H*&-*2"70-05*+"($59/6$%/+*2"75'("-./+"B/+/'6j"$62"

-./52>".'E":'069"4*'4%*Y+"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+"*6B/+/'6*2"$%-*56$-/B*".'5/a'6+J"K.*"-./52"

+*&-/'6"'7"-./+"&.$4-*5"10/%2+"2/5*&-%:"'6"-.*"$6$%:+/+"&'6-$/6*2"/6"S.$4-*5"]'05>"E./&."*62*2"

1:"$590/69"-.$-"A'11!411!4!>+&"E$+"4'%/-/&$%J"K./+"&.$4-*5"-$F*+"-.$-"$590(*6-"7'5E$52>"+.'E/69"

.'E"/-+"5*7%*C/B*"4'%/-/&+"$62"*69$9*(*6-"E/-."/6H0+-/&*"($6/7*+-*2"-.*(+*%B*+"/6"$%-*56$-/B*"

B/+/'6+"'7"-.*"70-05*J"

"

K'"+'(*"*C-*6-"-.*"-.*+/+".$+"$%5*$2:"$225*++*2"-.*"70-05*J"A-".$+"2/+&0++*2".'E"-.*"$&-/'6+"

'7":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"&'62/-/'6*2"1:"$"&'%%*&-/B*"F6'E%*29*"'7".'E"-.*:"E'0%2"1*"5*&*/B*2J"

K.*"E/62Q04+"G2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"K.5**I"706&-/'6*2"/6"45*&/+*%:"-./+"E$:J"_'E*B*5>"E./%*"

-.*"/((*2/$-*"70-05*".$+"1**6"&'6+/2*5*2>"-./+"&.$4-*5"/+"&'6&*56*2"E/-."705-.*5"-.5'E6"

45'H*&-/'6+"4$5-/$%%:"2*B*%'4*2"/6"S.$4-*5"]'05Y+"2/+&0++/'6"'7"8+/94&!>4($+-"GU$-$%/*"$62"

)'*Y+"$--*(4-"-'"&5*$-*"$"70-05*"7'5"-.*(+*%B*+"$+"&.'5*'95$4.*5+IJ"K.*"-''%+"7'5"-./+"$6$%:+/+"

$5*"7'062"/6"4.*6'(*6'%'9:>".*5(*6*0-/&+"$62"&0%-05$%"-.*'5:J"A6"4.*6'(*6'%'9:"$62"

.*5(*6*0-/&+"-.*"&'6&*4-"'7"-.*"W.'5/a'6Y"5*7*5+"-'"$"B/+/'6"-.$-"$6:":'069"4*5+'6".$+"75'("$"

+-$624'/6-"/6"-.*/5"%/7*J",+"X$2$(*5"6'-*+>"lK.*".'5/a'6"/+"-.*"5$69*"'7"B/+/'6"-.$-"/6&%02*+"

*B*5:-./69"-.$-"&$6"1*"+**6"75'("$"4$5-/&0%$5"B$6-$9*"4'/6-n"G!PVP>"4JO@?IJ",+":'069"4*'4%*"

('B*"-'E$52"-.*".'5/a'6"G-'E$52+"-.*/5"70-05*I>"/-"*C4$62+"/6"75'6-"'7"-.*("+'"-.$-"/-"/+"6*B*5"

-50%:"&%'+*2"GX$2$(*5"!PVP>"4JO@\IJ",62"$+"E*".$B*"+**6"E/-."(*('5:"GS.$4-*5"KE'I>"-/(*"/+"

$6"/62/B/20$%"$62"&'%%*&-/B*"45$&-/&*"G_*/2*99*5"!Pe?>"4JOM\IJ"Z'069"4*'4%*"*C/+-"/6"-.*"E'5%2"

E/-."'-.*5+>"$62"&'6+*h0*6-%:"-.*/5".'5/a'6+"$5*"70+*2"-'9*-.*5"GX$2$(*5"!PVP>"4JO@Oj"

R/&u05"!PV\j"4J??@IJ"K.5'09."-.*+*"/6-*5$&-/'6+"/62/B/20$%"$62"&'%%*&-/B*"062*5+-$62/69+"'7"

-.*"70-05*"$5*"h0$%/7/*2"$62"-5$6+7'5(*2"G,%&'77"?@@e>"4J\Nj"X$2$(*5"!PVPj"_*/2*99*5"!Pe?>"

44J\ONg\OeIJ",%-.'09."6'-"$445*&/$-*2"/6"-.*"%/6*$5"45'H*&-/'6+"&'(('6"-'"%'69/-02/6$%"E'5F>"

-./+"($F*+"-.*"70-05*"06+-$1%*"$62"&5*$-/B*"G,%&'77"?@@e>"4J\\IJ"

"

,+"E/-."(*('5:"45$&-/&*+>"-.*".'5/a'6"/+"45'20&*2"-'"($F*"+*6+*"'7"-.*"45*+*6-J"A-"/+"

45'20&*2"/6"E.$-"R/&u05"&$%%+"$"l+4$&*"'7"*C4*5/*6&*n"GR/&u05"!PV\j"4J?@VIJ"A6"-./+"+4$&*>"-.*"

70-05*>"%/F*"-.*"4$+->"/+"*C4*5/*6&*2"-.5'09."-.*"1'2:"$62"-.5'09."-.*"7$15/&"'7"-.*"4.:+/&$%"

E'5%2"GR/&u05"!PV\j"44J?O@g?O!j"#*5%*$0Q='6-:"!PVPIJ"_'E*B*5>"/6"'52*5"-'"70%%:"$445*&/$-*"

.'E"70-05*+"$5*"+/-0$-*2"/6"W95*$-"-/(*Y"G^$F.-/6"!PVe1I"G2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"KE'I"-.*:"$%+'"

6**2"-'"1*"062*5+-''2"1*:'62"-.*"4.*6'(*6'%'9/+-Y+"+01H*&-Q&*6-5*2"1'2:"$62"-.5'09."-.*"

Page 151: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!N!"

"

.'5/a'6+"'7"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6J",+"60(*5'0+"$0-.'5+".$B*"&'((*6-$-*2>"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+"

G+'062>"B/2*'"2$6&*"$62"%:5/&+I"&$55:"E/-."-.*("-5$6+&*62*6-$%"4$+-+"$62"-.*"70-05*+"G30"^'/+"

?@@M>"<+.06"!PPV>"?@@Oj"]$6'6"!PP!>"X/%5':"?@!@$>"#'-*6"?@@OI"-.$-"$5*"-5$6+%$-*2""$62"

($2*"/(($6*6-"-.5'09."+4*&/7/&"9*'95$4./*+"$62"1'2/*+J"

A6"$%%"-.*+*"&$+*+>"-.*"($6:"70-05*+"*C4%'5*2"1*%'E"&$66'-"1*"+*4$5$-*2"75'("-.*/5"($6:"

4$+-+J",62"&'6+*h0*6-%:"-./+"&.$4-*5"&$66'-"1*"5*$2"$4$5-"75'("-.*"7/5+-"&.$4-*5>"'5"-.'+*"-.$-"

.$B*"&'(*"/6"1*-E**6J"A6".*5(*6*0-/&"-*5(+>"/7"-.*".'5/a'6"+-5*-&.*+"/6"75'6-"'7":'0>"E.*6"

:'0"-056"$5'062>"/-"$%+'"*C-*62+"1*./62":'0"G,%&'77"?@@e>"4J\Oj"_*/2*99*5"!Pe?>"4JOM\IJ"

!J ,+4/5$-/'6$%".'5/a'6+"

"

Z'069"4*'4%*o+"$+4/5$-/'6+"($--*5"-''J"K.*"95*$-"7$/%05*"/+"6'-"-.*"&./%2"E.'"2'*+6o-"5*$&."-.*"+-$5+>"10-"-.*"&./%2"E.'".$+"6'"+-$5+"-'"5*$&."7'5J""

X'52'6"^5'E6"?@@M1""

S.$4-*5"K.5**".$+"$%5*$2:"*C4%'5*2".'E"7'5(+"'7"2*&*6-5$%/+$-/'6"$62"-./52"+*&-'5"

*6-5*45*6*05+./4>"&.$5$&-*5/+-/&"'7"-.*"5'%%Q'0-"'7"-.*"E*%7$5*"+-$-*>"$77*&-*2"-.*"-*55/-'5/$%"

9'B*56$6&*"'7"051$6"+4$&*J"='+-Q?@@@>"$6'-.*5"2*7/6/69"7*$-05*"'7"U*E";$1'05"E$+"$"+./7-"

75'("E*%7$5/+-"('2*%+"'7"+-$-*"+044'5-"-'"$"4'%/-/&+"'7"$+4/5$-/'6J"K.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"$+4/5$-/'6"

($5F*2"$"-5$6+/-/'6"75'("*$5%/*5"4'+-QE$5"&'6&*4-0$%/+$-/'6+"'7"-.*"70-05*>"2*7/6*2"-.5'09."$"

4'%/-/&+"'7"*C4*&-$-/'6"g"-.$-"2*45/B*2"4'40%$-/'6+"E'0%2"*C4*&-"70-05*"+-$-*"+044'5-"/6"

2/77/&0%-"-/(*+"GR$&'"?@@P>"4J\OMIJ"='+-Q?@@@"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"*C4*&-$-/'6"E$+"5*4%$&*2"E/-."-.*"

%$690$9*"'7"4*5+'6$%"5*+4'6+/1/%/-:J"S'6-/60/69"*$5%/*5"S'6+*5B$-/B*"-.*(*+"'6"-.*"062*5&%$++"

g"&'6&*56*2"E/-."&'62*(6/69"-.*"2*45/B*2"4'40%$-/'6+Y"E/%70%>"+-$-*Q2*4*62*6-"$62"7*&F%*++"

/(('5$%/-:"G#055$:"!PP@>"!PP\j"+**"$%+'"#$&3'6$%2"$62"#$5+."?@@N"7'5"$"&5/-/h0*I>"U*E"

;$1'05"$590*2"-.$-"/-"E$+"45*&/+*%:"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"70-05*"*C4*&-$-/'6"-.$-".$2"9*6*5$-*2"

/695$/6*2"('2*+"'7"2*4*62*6&:"G,5&.*5"$62"]5$6&/+"?@@Mj"^5'E6"?@!!j"#&3'6$%2"*-"$%J"?@!!j"

R$&'"?@@Pj"8/6&%$/5"*-"$%J"?@!@IJ"Z'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"$+F*2"6'-"-'"5*%:"'6"-.*"+-$-*"$62"/6+-*$2"

-'"-$F*"&'6-5'%"'7"-.*/5"'E6"2*+-/6/*+J"K./+"E$+"4$5-/&0%$5%:"*B/2*6-"/6"*20&$-/'6>"$62"%$--*5%:"/6"

-./52"+*&-'5"45'B/+/'6>"/6&%02/69":'0-."+*5B/&*+J"

"

Page 152: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!N?"

"

K.*"?@@N"E./-*"4$4*5"B')9+3!;,4(5435-!G+,,+3!;$9%%1-!F%3![11"G_#"X'B*56(*6-"?@@N$I"E$+"

2*+&5/1*2"$+"l('5*"-.$6"$6:-./69"m"$"d./-*"=$4*5"$1'0-"$+4/5$-/'6n"G`*%%:"?@@NIJ",62"+'>"./9."

$+4/5$-/'6"$+"$"&'96/-/B*"+-$-*"G8-5$62"$62"d/6+-'6"?@@V>"4JOI"g"l-.*"9'$%+"-.*:"+*-"7'5"-.*"

70-05*>"-.*/5"/6+4/5$-/'6"$62"-.*/5"('-/B$-/'6"-'"E'5F"-'E$52+"-.*+*"9'$%+n"G8'&/$%"<C&%0+/'6"

K$+F"]'5&*"?@@V>"4JNI"g"1*&$(*"&*6-5$%"-'"*20&$-/'6$%"4*57'5($6&*"$62"70-05*"$--$/6(*6-J"A-"

E$+"*B*6"4'+/-*2"$+"$6"/66$-*"('5$%"9''2>"45*+*6-"/6"$6:"E'5-.E./%*"&/-/a*6"G3$%*"*-"$%J"?@@?IJ"

,+"-.*"7'5(*5"8*&5*-$5:"'7"8-$-*"7'5"^0+/6*++>")'.6"_0--'6>"+-$-*2f"l$+4/5$-/'6"$62"$(1/-/'6"

$5*"6$-05$%".0($6"*('-/'6+n"G&/-*2"/6"R$&'"?@@P>"4J\OPIJ"]5'("?@@\"'6E$52+>"$+4/5$-/'6"/6"

*20&$-/'6"E$+"40+.*2"-.5'09."-.*"['&9')9+3!45'95$((*"G_<]S<"?@!?IJ"K.*"4*5&*/B*2"

+0&&*++*+"'7"-./+"45'95$((*"7'5"2*%/B*5/69>"*6B/+/'6/69"$62"($6$9/69":'069"4*'4%*Y+"70-05*+"

%*2"-'"/-+"/6-5'20&-/'6>"/6"?@@M>"-'":'0-."+*5B/&*+"-.5'09."['&'()!B')9!F%3!`%0()!Z+%#1+.![!<+(!

`+43!;,34,+)/!F%3!Z%-','*+![$,'*','+-!G_#"K5*$+05:"$62"3S8]"?@@M>"44JOg\IJ"K.5'09."-.*+*"

/6/-/$-/B*+"U*E";$1'05"/6+-$%%*2"$6"/2*$%"7/905*"'6":'069"4*'4%*Y+".'5/a'6+J"K./+"/2*$%"7/905*"

E$+"$"(/22%*Q&%$++>"*20&$-*2>"/62/B/20$%"&'6+0(*5"$62"70-05*"&/-/a*6"GR$&'"?@@P>"4J\OPIJ"A6"

U*E.$(>"-.*+*"2/+&'05+*+"4%$:*2"'0-"-.5'09."-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"-.*"WU*E"S/-/a*6Y"2/+&0++*2"/6"

S.$4-*5"KE'JNV"

"

T6"-.*"7%/4"+/2*"'7"-./+"&'/6"E$+"2*7/6*2"-.*"&'96/-/B*%:"2*7/&/*6->"066$-05$%":'069"4*5+'6"

&'((*6+05$-*"E/-."$"W4'B*5-:"'7"$+4/5$-/'6Y"G8/6&%$/5"*-"$%J"?@!@>"4JOIJ"U'-"1*/69"$+4/5$-/'6$%"

1*&$(*"-.*"&'6-*(4'5$5:"*h0/B$%*6-"'7"_*9*%Y+"70-05*%*++"70-05*"G^*6H$(/6"!PeV>"44J?NPg

?e@j"U/*-a+&.*"!PVO>"4J!@\IJ"K./+"6$-05$%"7$/%05*"-.*6"45'B/2*2"U*E";$1'05"E/-."$"&$-&.Q$%%"

*C4%$6$-/'6"7'5"$6:"60(1*5"'7"+-50&-05$%"45'1%*(+"G;/((*5"?@@VIJ"_'E*B*5>"2/+&'05+*+"'6"-.*"

4'B*5-:"'7"$+4/5$-/'6"g"-.*"E$:+"/6"E./&.":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"($59/6$%/+*2"75'("-.*"5/9.-"-'"

/($9/6*"$62"45'20&*"-.*"70-05*"'6"-.*/5"'E6"-*5(+"G;*7*1B5*"!PPeI"g"E*5*"6'-"*B*6%:"$44%/*2J"

K.'+*"2**(*2"-'".$B*"$"W4'B*5-:"'7"$+4/5$-/'6Y"E*5*"'B*5E.*%(/69%:"E'5F/69Q&%$++"G,5&.*5"

$62"]5$6&/+"?@@M>"4J!!Vj"_$55/+"?@@\>"4J?NIJ",62"7'%%'E/69"7$(/%/$5"4'+-QE$5"2/+&'05+*>"-./+"

&$-*9'5:"E$+"+012/B/2*2"/6"*-.6/&"$62"4+*02'Q*-.6/&"&$-*9'5/*+J"=$5-/&0%$5"$--*6-/'6"E$+"4$/2"

-'"*20&$-/'6$%%:"W7$/%/69Y":'069"1%$&F"$62"#0+%/("(*6>"$62"-.*"W062*5Q$&./*B/69Y"E./-*"

E'5F/69Q&%$++"G_$:%*--"?@@!j"=5*+-'6"?@@Pj"R*$:"*-"$%J"?@@Mj"8B*/6++'6"?@@Pj"$62"+**"S.$4-*5"

KE'"7'5"$"2/+&0++/'6"'7"WE./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++YIJ"8'"E./%*"U*E";$1'05"*C4$62*2"(/22%*Q&%$++"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""NV"A6"-./+"E$:>"-.*"45'('-/'6"'7"/62/B/20$%"+0&&*++"E$+"5*%$-*2"-'"$"45'('-/'6"'7"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"

%'++>"$62"-.*"5*H*&-/'6"'7"(0%-/&0%-05$%/+("/6"-.*"&'6-*C-"'7"$"+04*5Q2/B*5+*"$62"2*45/B*2"1'5'09.J"

Page 153: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!NO"

"

&'6+0(*5/+-"$62"*20&$-/'6$%"B$%0*+"-'"$"E/2*5"G45*2'(/6$6-%:"(/22%*Q&%$++I"($5F*-"

G_*62*5+'6"?@@M>"4JOVI>"-.*:"2/2"+'"/6"E$:+"-.$-"5*45*+*6-*2"$"&'6-/60$-/'6"'7"*$5%/*5"7'5(+"'7"

5$&/$%/+*2"&'62*(6$-/'6"'7"-.*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"G_0(4.5/*+"!PV!j"R*$:"?@@Pj"d/%%/+"!PMMj"+**"

$%+'"S.$4-*5"K.5**"'7"-./+"-.*+/+IJ"

"

A6"U*E.$(>"-.*+*"2/+&'05+*+"E*5*"4$5-/&0%$5%:"4'/6-*2J"_/9."%*B*%+"'7"2*45/B$-/'6"$62"4'B*5-:>"

-.$-"&'0%2"45*B/'0+%:".$B*"1**6"062*5+-''2"$+"+-50&-05$%"$62"$+"-.*"5*+4'6+/1%:"'7"-.*"%'&$%"

$0-.'5/-:>"1*&$(*"*h0$-*2"E/-."4'B*5-/*+"'7"$+4/5$-/'6J"

"

A6"$5*$+"%/F*"U*E.$("-.*:"$%E$:+"+$:"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"$5*6Y-"9'/69"-'"$&./*B*>"-.*:Y5*"6'-"9'/69"-'"$&&*2*"r$--$/6s"g"-.*"(*2/$"$62"*B*5:'6*"*%+*j"h0/-*"'7-*6"-.*"4$5*6-+J"d*Y5*"$1'0-"&5*$-/69"./9."$+4/5$-/'6J""

U*E.$("+*5B/&*"45'B/2*5""A6"U*E.$("-.*5*"/+"$"4'B*5-:"'7"$+4/5$-/'6"$+"-'"E.$-"r:'069"4*'4%*s"E$6-"-'"+0&&**2"-'J"A-Y+"$"(/C-05*"'7"5*$%"4'B*5-:"E.*5*":'0"$5*"+.'5-"'7"&$+."$62"$&&*++"-'"'44'5-06/-/*+J"A-"&$6"$77*&-"E.$-"-.*:"2'"E/-."-.*/5"+'&/$%"-/(*>"r-.*/5s"*20&$-/'6"m"8'"-.*5*"/+"-.$-"+/2*"'7"4'B*5-:"$62"-.*5*"/+"$%+'"-./+"4'B*5-:"'7"$+4/5$-/'6J"

U*E.$("+*5B/&*"45'B/2*5""

Z'069"4*'4%*"A"E'5F*2"E/-."6$B/9$-*2"$62"4$5-/&/4$-*2"/6"-.*+*"2/+&'05+*+J",-"+&.''%>"/6"-.*"

:'0-."&%01>"$-".'(*"$62"E/-."*$&."'-.*5>":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"&'675'6-*2"E/-."-.*"%$690$9*"'7"

$+4/5$-/'6>"E./&."-.*:"-5$6+%$-*2"'6"-.*/5"'E6"-*5(+J"^*+$>"<B$"$62",%($>"$%%"-./5-**6>".$2"

1**6"1'56"$62"15'09.-"04"/6"U*E.$(J"A"E'5F*2"E/-."-.*6"$-"-.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."X5'04J"K.*/5"

7$(/%/*+"E*5*"6'-"4$5-/&0%$5%:"E*$%-.:J"K.*/5"7$-.*5+"E'5F*2"/6"-5$2*+"$62"-.*/5"('-.*5+"

E'5F*2"/6"7$(/%:"5'%*+>"+($%%"10+/6*++*+>"$62"$+"&''52/6$-'5+"7'5"-.*"X5'04J"K.5'09."-.*/5"

/6B'%B*(*6-"/6"-.*"X5'04>"$62"062*5"-.*"/67%0*6&*"'7"-.*/5"4$5*6-+>"-.*":'069"E'(*6".$2"

1**6"15'09.-"04"/6"$6"$+4/5$-/'6$%"*6B/5'6(*6-J"K.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."X5'04>"506"1:"-.*/5"

('-.*5+>"*(15$&*2"-.*"$+4/5$-/'6$%"-./52"+*&-'5"$9*62$J"A-"5$6"-.*"['&'()!B')9!45'95$((*"

G/6-5'20&*2"$1'B*I"$62"-.5'09."$"5$69*"'7":'0-."$62"&'((06/-:"$&-/B/-/*+"^*+$>"<B$"$62",%($"

-''F"4$5->"(*-"E/-."5'%*"('2*%+"$62"E*5*"*6&'05$9*2"-'"-$F*"04"(*6-'5+J"K.*/5"75**"-/(*"E$+"

7/%%*2"E/-."&055/&0%$5"$62"*C-5$Q&055/&0%$5"$&-/B/-/*+J"A6"$%%"'7"-.*+*"$"4'+/-/B*"$445'$&."-'"

4*5+'6$%"70-05*"+0&&*++"E$+"/(45*++*2"04'6"-.*(>"'7-*6"2*7/6*2"$9$/6+-"-.*"%'&$%/+*2"5/+F"'7"

7$%%/69"/6-'"&5/(*>"+-5**-"%/7*"'5"062*5$&./*B*(*6-J"

"

Page 154: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!N\"

"

K./+"$+4/5$-/'6$%"*6B/5'6(*6-"E$+"9*62*5*2"/6"E$:+"/67'5(*2"1:"-.*"/6-*5+*&-/'6"'7"6*'Q

%/1*5$%"4'+-Q7*(/6/+("G#&R'11/*"?@@PI"$62"$6"<$+-";'62'6"B*5+/'6"'7",%1$6/$6"7$(/%:"B$%0*+J"

K.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."X5'04"-.*"-.5**":'069"E'(*6"1*%'69*2"-'"%$59*%:"&'(45/+*2"(/95$6-+"

75'("-.*"6'5-."'7",%1$6/$>"E.'".$2"('B*2"-'"-.*"+'0-."'7"-.*"&'06-5:"-'"*+&$4*"4'B*5-:j"$62"

-.*6"&'(*"-'"-.*"[`"B/$"'-.*5"<05'4*$6"&'06-5/*+J"K./+"(/95$-/'6"%$59*%:"'&&055*2"$7-*5"-.*"

W4:5$(/2"&5/+/+Y"g"-.*"&'%%$4+*"'7"$"45/B$-*"+$B/69+"+&.*(*"g"/6"!PPM"Gc0%%6*-$5/"?@@MIJ",+"

6'5-.*56",%1$6/$6+>"-.*/5"4$5*6-+".$2"('5*"&'6+*5B$-/B*"'0-%''F+"-.$6"-.*/5"+'0-.*56"

&'06-*54$5-+"$62"%''F*2"-'"($/6-$/6"-.*/5"B*5+/'6"'7"-5$2/-/'6$%",%1$6/$6"9*62*5"5'%*+"/6"

;'62'6J"K.*"E'(*6>"$+"-.*"l&$55/*5+n"'7"&0%-05*"$62"*20&$-/'6"G=.'*6/C"$62"d''%%*--"!PP!j"

Z0B$%Q3$B/+"*-"$%J"!PVPI>"5$6"-.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."X5'04"G`/69"*-"$%J"?@@e>"4J\!Pj"`'+-'B/&'B$"

$62"=5*+-5*+./"?@!@IJ",+"45*4$5$-/'6"7'5"-.*/5"-5$6+/-/'6"-'"-.*+*"5'%*+>"-.*":'069"E'(*6"E*5*"

45'-*&-*2"$62"4'%/&*2"/6"E$:+"-.$-"-.*":'069"(*6"E*5*6Y-"G`/69"*-"$%J"?@@O>"4JNVIJ"<B$>"7'5"

*C$(4%*>"E$+"4/&F*2"04"75'("+&.''%J"_'E*B*5>"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"-.$-"<B$Y+"('-.*5"E$+"

&'6&*56*2"-'"15/69".*5"2$09.-*5"04"/6"$&&'52$6&*"E/-."$"9''2",%1$6/$6"E$:"'7"%/B/69>"+.*"$%+'"

E$6-*2".*5"-'"+0&&**2"/6"-.*"$+4/5$-/'6$%"('0%2>"2'"E*%%"*20&$-/'6$%%:"$62"$--*62"-.*"1*+-"

06/B*5+/-/*+"GX/%%/*+"?@@M>"4JMIJ"K./+"/(4%/*2"/62*4*62*6&*"$62"*&'6'(/&"75**2'(J"

"

K.*":'069"E'(*6"$%+'"6$B/9$-*2"-./+"/6-*5+*&-/'6J"K.*:"$+4/5*2"-'"2'"E*%%"$-"+&.''%"$62"9*-"

E*%%Q4$/2"H'1+>"$62"-.*:"+4*6-"&'6+/2*5$1%*"-/(*"-$%F/69"$1'0-"-.*"F/62"'7"7$+./'6"'1H*&-+"-.*:"

+.'0%2"&'6+0(*"-'"45'H*&-"-./+"-5$H*&-'5:J"K.*:"E*5*"45'02"-'"1*"$-"-.*"1'5'09.Y+"1*+-"

+&.''%+>"45*+*6-*2"-.*(+*%B*+"$+"&'((/--*2"+-02*6-+"$62".$2"-.*/5"+/9.-+"+*-"'6"9'/69"-'"

TC7'52"'5"S$(15/29*"[6/B*5+/-:>"$62"'6"*B*6-0$%%:"1*&'(/69"2'&-'5+J"T7"-.*"-.5**>"^*+$"E$+"

%*++"+05*"'7".*5"70-05*"/6"-.*+*"+4*&/7/&"-*5(+>"10-"6'6*-.*%*++"-.*"-.5**":'069"E'(*6"+.$5*2"

$"15'$2"$+4/5$-/'6$%".'5/a'6J"d./%*"-.*:"(/9.-".$B*"1**6"&'6+/2*5*2"%'E*5"(/22%*Q&%$++"/6"

+'&/$%"$62"*&'6'(/&"-*5(+>"%/F*"'-.*5"(/95$6-"95'04+"1*7'5*"-.*("GS'66'5"*-"$%J"?@@\j"3$%*"*-"

$%J"?@@?j"35/6FE$-*5"$62";*+%/*"!PPVj"#/22%*-'6"*-"$%J"?@@Nj"#'2''2"!PPMj"d$F*%/69"?@@PI"

-.*:".$2"B*5:"(/22%*Q&%$++"$+4/5$-/'6+>"7'(*6-*2"/6"-.*/5"7$(/%/*+"$62"/6"-.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."

X5'04J"K.*:"E*5*"B*5+/'6+"'7"-.*"l&$6Q2'"9/5%n"G_$55/+"?@@\>"44J!eg?NI"g":'069"E'(*6"E/-."

/62*4*62*6-"70-05*+"E.'"B*5/7/*2"-.*/5"&/-/a*6+./4"$62"*6-/-%*(*6-"-.5'09."*20&$-/'6"$62"

E$9*Q*$56/69"&$4$&/-/*+"G#&R'11/*"?@@P>"4J?IJ"

"

K.*":'069"E'(*6Y+"B*5+/'6"'7"$+4/5$-/'6"E$+"6*9'-/$-*2"$9$/6+-"-.*/5"062*5+-$62/69"'7"%'E"

$+4/5$-/'6J"K./+"2/+-/6&-/'6"+-$5-*2"-'"1*"5*B*$%*2"-.5'09."-.*/5"$6$%:+*+"'7"$"4.'-'95$4.:"

Page 155: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!NN"

"

45'H*&-"-.*:".$2"-$F*6"4$5-"/6J"K.*"45'H*&-"E$+"&$%%*2"N/!d'+C!%F!8%(5%("$62".$2"/6B'%B*2"

-.*("-5$B*%%/69"-'"`*6+/69-'6"$62"8-5$-7'52"Gd*+-"$62"<$+-";'62'6>"5*+4*&-/B*%:I>"

4.'-'95$4./69"/($9*+"'7"4'B*5-:"$62"E*$%-.J"K.*"3/5*&-'5"'7"-.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."X5'04"G<B$Y+"

('-.*5I"*C4%$/6*2".'E"-.*"45'H*&-".$2"/(4$&-*2"45'7'062%:"'6"-.*":'069"E'(*6>"7'5&/69"

-.*("-'"-./6F"$1'0-"-.*"2/+4$5/-/*+"'7"4'B*5-:"$62"E*$%-."/6"$"9%'1$%"&/-:J"A6"$"+*5/*+"'7"4**5Q-'Q

4**5"4.'-'"*%/&/-$-/'6"/6-*5B/*E+"G2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"T6*I"-.*:"$6$%:+*2"-.*"4.'-'+"-.*:".$2"

-$F*6j"E.:"-.*:".$2"-$F*6"-.*(j".'E"-.*:"7*%-"$1'0-"/-j"$62>"E.$-"-.*:".$2"%*$56-"75'("-.*"

45'&*++J"

"

"E')03+!E'F,++(.!Z9%,%-!4(41/-+5!T/!G+-42!7*4!4(5![1&4!

"

Page 156: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!Ne"

"

!E')03+!;'M,++(.!Z9%,%-!4(41/-+5!T/!G+-42!7*4!4(5![1&4!

"

K.*"/6-*5B/*E"-5$6+&5/4-+"$62"4.'-'"1'$52+"2*('6+-5$-*2>"$+"-.*"3/5*&-'5".$2"+099*+-*2>".'E"

&'6-5$+-+"'7"4'B*5-:"$62"E*$%-."/6"`*6+/69-'6"$62"8-5$-7'52".$2"/(4$&-*2"'6"-.*(J"_'E*B*5>"

/6"$22/-/'6"-'"2*('6+-5$-/69"$"&'6&*56"7'5"+'&/$%"/6*h0$%/-:>"-.*"4.'-'+".$2"/6B/-*2"$"('5*"

4*5+'6$%"$6$%:+/+"-.5'09."E./&."-.*":'069"E'(*6"45'H*&-*2"-.*/5"'E6"0-'4/$+"$62"2:+-'4/$+J"

K./+"/+"$"-5$6+&5/4-"75'("'6*"'7"-.*"/6-*5B/*E+f"

"

[1&4."3*+&5/1*"*$&."4.'-'"/6"$+"(0&."2*-$/%"$+":'0"&$6J"7*4."A6"-.*"7/5+-"4/&-05*"E*"+$E"$"E'($6"E.'".$2"15'09.-"&'77**"75'("$"+.'4J"8.*".$2"5*$%%:"*C4*6+/B*"5/69+"'6J"8.*".$2"9'-".*5"6$/%+"2'6*"$62".*5".$62+"E*5*"5*$%%:"&%*$6"$62"+(''-.J"A6"-.*"+*&'62"4/&-05*"E*"+$E"$".'(*%*++"4*5+'6"E.'".$2"45'1$1%:"1**6"9/B*6"-./+"&04"1:"+'(*'6*J""[1&4."d.:"2/2":'0"2*&/2*"-'"-$F*"-.*+*"4.'-'+i"7*4."A"2*&/2*2"-'"-$F*"-.*+*"4.'-'+"1*&$0+*"-.*:"&%*$5%:"+.'E"-.*"2/77*5*6&*"1*-E**6"5/&."$62"4''5"$62".'E"2/77*5*6-"-.*:"$5*"/6"-.*"+$(*"$5*$J"[1&4."_'E"2'":'0"7**%"E.*6":'0"E*5*"-$F/69"-.*"4.'-'+i"7*4."d.*6"E*"E*5*"-$F/69"-.*"4.'-'+"'7"-.*".'(*%*++"4*5+'6>"E*"7*%-"h0/-*"+$2"7'5"./("1*&$0+*"E*".$B*"9'-".'(*+"$62"E*".$B*"6*B*5"*C4*5/*6&*2"E.$-"/-"7*%-"%/F*"-'"1*".'(*%*++J"A-"7*%-"$"1/-"+$2J"d.*6"E*"-''F"-.*"'6*"r4/&-05*s"'7"-.*"5/&."4*5+'6"A"7*%-"WA"E$6-"-'"1*"%/F*"-.$-"E.*6"A"95'E"04YJ"A"2'6Y-"E$6-"-'"1*".'(*%*++J"

Page 157: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!NM"

"

[1&4."d.$-"2/2":'0"%*$56"75'("-$F/69"-.*"4/&-05*+"-.$-":'0"2/26Y-"F6'E"1*7'5*i"7*4."A"%*$56".'E"2/77*5*6-"%/B*+"&$6"1*"2*4*62/69"'6"-.*"E$:+":'0"&.''+*"/-J"A7":'0"&$55:"'6"E/-.":'05"*20&$-/'6":'0"&$6"1*"5*$%%:"5/&."$62"E*$%-.:"$62".$B*"$"9''2"H'1"/6"%/7*"10-"/7":'0"+F/4"+&.''%"$62"%*++'6+":'0"E/%%"*62"04".'(*%*++"$62":'0"$5*"9'/69"-'"1*"1*99/69"7'5":'05"7''2J""

"

A6"$22/-/'6"-'"$225*++/69"/++0*+"'7"+'&/$%"/6H0+-/&*>"<B$"5*$2"-.*"/($9*+"-.5'09.".*5"'E6"

$+4/5$-/'6$%".'5/a'6"$62"-.*"5/+F+"+.*"$++'&/$-*2"E/-."%'E"$+4/5$-/'6J"8.*"*h0$-*2"-.*"1*$0-:"

$62"($-*5/$%"E*$%-."'7"-.*"W5/&.Y"E'(*6"E/-.".*5"'E6"/2*$%"70-05*"$62"1*%/*B*2"-.$-"$--$/6/69"

-./+"E$+"$"($--*5"'7"/62/B/20$%"&.'/&*J"K.*"5/&."E'(*6Y+"H*E*%%*5:"$62"+F/6"E$+"$6"/($9*"+.*"

2*+/5*2J"K./+"E$+"$"B*5+/'6"'7"7*(/6/6/-:"/6"E./&."&'67'5(/-:"-'"4$-5/$5&.$%"&'2*+"'7"1*$0-:"

E$+"+:(1'%/&"'7"+0&&*++"G#&R'11/*"?@@P>"4JNIJ"d./%*"<B$>"^*+$"$62",%($"2/2"6'-".$B*"-.*"

('6*:"-'"25*++"$+"-.*"W5/&.Y"E'(*6"2/2>"-.*/5"&%'-.*+"E*5*"&$5*70%%:"&.'+*6>"2/+&0++*2"$62"

B$%/2$-*2"1*-E**6"-.*(J"K.*:"*(0%$-*2>"-'"-.*"*C-*6-"-.$-"/-"E$+"7/6$6&/$%%:"4'++/1%*>"-.*"

/($9*"'7"044*5"(/22%*Q&%$++"&./&J"8&$5B*+>"H$&F*-+>".$/5+-:%*+"$62"%*99/69+"E*5*"$%%"&$5*70%%:"

&''52/6$-*2J"_'E*B*5>"<B$"2/2"6'-"45'H*&-".*5".'5/a'6+"75'("-.*"%'7-:"4'+/-/'6"'7"+'(*'6*"

E.'"&'0%2"6'-"-$69/1%:"&'6&*/B*"'7"4'B*5-:j"$+"+-$-*2>"+.*"E$+"+055'062*2"1:"+-'5/*+>"$62"

5*$%/-/*+>"'7"%'E"$&./*B*(*6-J"

"

K.*":'069"E'(*6"$%+'"45'H*&-*2"-.*/5"$+4/5$-/'6+"-.5'09."4$5'2/*+"'7",%1$6/$6Q6*++J"K.*+*"

E*5*"7'5(+"'7"2/+Q/2*6-/7/&$-/'6"G8F*99+"!PPMI"g"E$:+"/6"E./&."-.*":'069"E'(*6"2/+-$6&*2"

-.*(+*%B*+"75'("%'E*5Q&%$++>"%*++"E./-*"+'&/$%"4'+/-/'6+"-.*:"E*5*"4$/670%%:"&%'+*"-'J";'&$%%:"

,%1$6/$6+"E*5*"+'(*-/(*+"+-*5*'-:4*2"7'5"1*/69"5'09.>"&5/(/6$%"$62"%/B/69"'6"&5'E2*2"

*+-$-*+>"$62"$6-/Q,%1$6/$6"5$&/+("706&-/'6*2"$%'69"-.*+*"%/6*+"G`/69"*-"$%J"?@@O>"4JN?IJ",E$5*"

'7"-./+>"^*+$>"<B$"$62",%($"+'09.-"-'"2/+-$6&*"-.*(+*%B*+"75'("-.*+*"4'+/-/'6+J"^*+$Y+"

5*+/2*6&*"'6"'6*"'7"^$5F/69Y+"W,%1$6/$6"*+-$-*+Y"2/2"6'-"*C&%02*".*5"75'("-./+"&'6B*5+$-/'6J"

K./+"6*9'-/$-/'6"'7"$"E./-*6*2",%1$6/$6"+01H*&-/B/-:"$%%'E*2"-.*("-'"&'67'5("-'"-.*"E./-*"

/2*$%"'7"$+4/5$-/'6"2/+&0++*2"/6"-.*"/6-5'20&-/'6"-'"-./+"&.$4-*5j"/-"$%%'E*2"-.*("-'"/($9/6*"

-.*/5"*6-5$6&*"-'"-.*"1$+-/'6+"'7"-.*"E./-*"044*5"(/22%*Q&%$++"*+-$1%/+.(*6-"g"TC7'52"$62"

S$(15/29*"[6/B*5+/-:"g"E.*5*"W*-.6/&"./*5$5&./*+Y".$B*"1**6"&'6+/+-*6-%:"6'-*2"G#'2''2"

?@@?>"4J?@?j"+**"$%+'"#'2''2"!PPO>"!PPVIJ"K./+"E$+"6'-"$"2/+$B'E$%"'7"1*/69",%1$6/$6J"K.*:"

E*5*"/6B'%B*2"/6"-.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."X5'04"GE/-."-.*"E'5F/69Q&%$++",%1$6/$6+"-.*:"2/+Q

Page 158: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!NV"

"

/2*6-/7/*2"-.*(+*%B*+"75'(I>NP"-.*:"+4'F*",%1$6/$6"-'9*-.*5"$62"4$5-/&/4$-*2"/6"$"E/2*"5$69*"

'7",%1$6/$6"7'%F"$&-/B/-/*+"g"2$6&*+>"4%$:+"$62"`'+'B'"A62*4*62*6&*"3$:J"R$-.*5>"/-"E$+"$"

2/+-/6&-/'6"-.*:"($2*"1*-E**6"-.*(+*%B*+"$+"&$6Q2'Q9/5%+"$62"'-.*5"%*++"E./-*",%1$6/$6+"E/-."

%'E"$+4/5$-/'6+J"

"

K.*+*"2/+Q/2*6-/7/&$-/'6+"E*5*"705-.*5"./9.%/9.-*2"-.5'09."$"2$:Y+"B/2*'/69"-.$-"E*"062*5-''F"

/6"R*215/29*J"A".$2"1'55'E*2"-E'"&$(&'52*5+>"$62"$+"4$5-"'7"$"7/%("45'H*&-"E*"2*&/2*2"-'"

+4*62"$"7*E".'05+"45$&-/+/69"'05"7/%(/69"$62"$&-/69J"K.*"-.*(*"7'5"-.*"45'H*&-"E$+"Wd.*5*"A"

%/B*>"d.$-"A"E$6-Y"$62"/-"E$+"(*$6-"-'"&5/-/&$%%:"2'&0(*6-"-.*"+/9.-+>"+'062+"$62"+(*%%+"'7"-.*"

%'&$%"$5*$J"^*+/$6>"$6"*/9.-**6Q:*$5Q'%2":'069"($6"-.*":'069"E'(*6".$2"95'E6"04"E/-."$%+'"

4$5-/&/4$-*2J"]/%%/69"-.*"+%'E"+-5**-+"'7"R*215/29*"E/-."(099/69+>"W.''2"5$-+Y"$62"W&.$B+Y"'B*5"

$6"$7-*56''6>"-.*"7'05"'7"-.*("$&-*2"'0->"$62"7/%(*2>"4$5'2/*+"'7"051$6"E'5F/69Q&%$++"$62"

(0%-/Q*-.6/&"^5/-/+.6*++"$62"E'5F/69Q&%$++",%1$6/$6Q6*++J"

"

^*7'5*"9'/69"'0-"'6-'"-.*"+-5**-+>"^*+/$6"15'F*"'77"$"45*Q7/%("2/+&0++/'6"-'"*$-"./+"^;K"

+$62E/&.J"=%$:/69"-'"-.*"&$(*5$>"^*+/$6"+$/2"l1$&'6>"%*--0&*>"-'($-'n"/(/-$-/69".'E"-.*/5"

7$-.*5+"'5"'-.*5"%*++"<69%/+."G%*++"E./-*I",%1$6/$6+"(/9.-"(/+45'6'06&*"-.*"E'52"W1$&'6YJ"K.*"

-.5**":'069"E'(*6"15'F*"/6-'".:+-*5/&$%"%$09.-*5>"5*&'96/+/69"-.*/5"7$-.*5+Y"$&&*6-+>"$62"-.*6"

45'&**2*2"-'"+$:"'-.*5"E'52+"-.*/5"7$-.*5+"(/+45'6'06&*2J")'F/69"$1'0-"1$2",%1$6/$6"<69%/+.>"

-.*:"$77/5(*2"-.*(+*%B*+"$+"./9.*5"+-$-0+"1'-."/6"&%$++"$62"&0%-05$%"-*5(+J"]5'(".*5*"-.*"

:'069"4*'4%*"('B*2"'0-"'6-'"-.*"+-5**-"$62"E.$-"7'%%'E+"/+"$"-5$6+&5/4-"40-"-'9*-.*5"75'("-.*"

B/2*'"7''-$9*"-.*:"5*&'52*2J"

"

<9+!/%0()!#+%#1+!-,43,!C41='()!5%C(!4!c0'+,!-0T03T4(!3%452!1'(+5!C',9!$43-!4(5!-&411!T1%$=-!%F!?KQP-!,+334$+5!9%0-'()@!"z#'B*"'0-"-.*"E$:":'0"+-5**-"5$-n>"^*+$"+$:+"-'",%($"$+"+.*"-5/*+"-'"%/6*"04"-.*"7/5+-"+.'-"'7"^*+/$6"*$-/69"./+"^;K"+$62E/&.J"l=*'4%*"*$-/69"'6"-.*"5'$2"%/F*"6'5($%j"-.5'E/69"%/--*5"'6"-.*"95'062j"B*5:>"B*5:"10+:"5'$2+n>"+.*"&'6-/60*+J"lA6"3$9*6.$("/-Y+"h0/-*"&%*$6"-.'09.J"K.*5*Y+"H0+-"$"7*E"*C&*4-/'6+>"%/F*"-.*":'069"4*'4%*Jn""lS.$B+n>"^*+/$6"&'55*&-+J""

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""NP"K.*":'069"E'(*6"E*5*"6'-"4*57'5(/69",%1$6/$6"/2*6-/-:"$+"$"(*$6+"-.5'09."E./&."-.*:"$--$/6*2"

+'&/$%"&$4/-$%"'B*5"W%*++"&0%-05*2Y",%1$6/$6+"G+**"R*$:"*-"$%J"?@@M"7'5"-.*"'44'+/-*"$590(*6-IJ"

Page 159: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!NP"

"

,%($"&$55/*+"'6>"lK./+"/+"-.*"6*/9.1'05.''2"/6"X''2($:*+J"A-Y+"h0/-*"h0/*-J"A-Y+"B*5:"&%*$6J"K.*5*Y+"0+0$%%:"9$69+"$5'062J"K.*:"2'6Y-"&$0+*"(0&."-5'01%*"7'5"-.*"4*'4%*"%/B/69".*5*"-.'09."m"$+"-.*:"+$/2"-'"0+Jn",+"+.*"6$55$-*+"-./+"+.*"-056+"-'"+.''-"-.*"7'05"'7"0+"E$%F/69"-'E$52+"-.*"&$(*5$>"/6+/60$-/69"-.$-"E*"$5*"-.*"9$69J"lK.*5*Y+"0+0$%%:"'%2"&'04%*+"$5'062"E$%F/69"-.*/5"2'9+n>"+.*"$22+J"^*+/$6"1*&'(*+"$6"'%2"4*5+'6"+-''4/69"7'5E$52"$62",%($"&'670+*+"./("E/-."$"W&.$BYJ"lK.*".''2"5$-+n>"+.*"+$:+"&'55*&-/69".*5+*%7J"^*+/$6"40-+"./+".''2"04"$62"-.*"9/5%+"%$09.J""lZ*$.>"AY("$"&.$B>"A"%/B*"/6"X''2($:*+J"K.*5*Y+"$6"*C$(4%*"'7"$6'-.*5"&.$BnJ"^*+/$6"4'/6-+"$-",%($J"l#:":$52"150Bn>".*"+$:+J"A(/-$-/69"E.$-".*"-./6F+"/+"&.$B"-$%F>".*"4'/6-+"-'"-.*".'0+*"'B*5"-.*"5'$2J"l,%-.'09."A"$/6Y-"9'-"-.*"F*:+J"Z'0"9*-"(*in"_*"%''F+"$-"-.*"&$5"6*C-"-'"0+"$62"-.*"&$(*5$"7'%%'E+"./(J"lK.$-Y+"(:"5/2*"-.*5*J"c$0C.$%%"`<"m"`'+'B'"A6H*&-/'6J"S0->"&0->"&0-Jn""A"15/*7%:"-$F*"&'6-5'%"'7"-.*"&$(*5$"E/-."/6+-50&-/'6+"75'(",%($J"lA-Y+"B*5:"+$7*"-'"&5'++"-.*"5'$2n>"A"+$:J"T6"&0*"^*+/$6"506+"$&5'++"-.*"5'$2"$7-*5",%($"E/-."./+".''2"04J"_*"/+"4%$:/69"-.*"&.$BQ(099*5J"_*"95$1+",%($"$62"25$9+".*5"2'E6"-.*"4$-.E$:"1*+/2*"$".'0+*J""^*+$>"+-$62/69"1*./62"(*>"+.'0-+"l#09".*5>"(09".*5vn"$62"%$09.+J"l8*C0$%".$5$++(*6-vn>"15/*7%:"+%/44/69"'0-"'7"-.*"4$5'2:"$62"$&F6'E%*29/69"E.$-"-.*"4%$:"/+"$%+'"($F/69"$&&*4-$1%*"g"15/69/69"1'2/*+"/6-'"&'6-$&-J"R*-056/69"-'"-.*"+F/->"+.*"+$:+>"lAY2"%'B*"/-"/7"-.*"4'%/&*"&'(*J"T."(:"2$:+vn""S'6-/60/69"-.*"+.''-"E*"('B*"2'E6"/6-'"$"h0/*-*5"5*+/2*6-/$%"&0%Q2*Q+$&"'7"5*2"15/&F>"-.5**Q1*25''(>"+*(/Q2*-$&.*2".'0+*+J"^*+/$6"-$F*+"&'6-5'%"'7"-.*"&$(*5$>"lZ*$."3$9*6.$(>"&.$B+"E$%F/69"$1'0->"%/F*"-.*+*"-.5**Jn",%($>"^*+$"$62"<B$"$5*"705-.*5"2'E6"-.*"+-5**-J",%($"506+"$&5'++"-.*"5'$2"(*%'25$($-/&$%%:"+&5*$(/69J"_*"&'6-/60*+>"l;''F"$-"-./+"'6*"-.*5*J"8.*Y+"($2Jn"=0--/69"'6".*5"B*5+/'6"'7"$"&.$B"B'/&*"$62"2*(*$6'05>",%($"+-$5-+"+.'0-/69"$62"E$B/69".*5"$5(+"04"$62"2'E6J"lZ'0"9'-"$"45'1%*(in"+.*"2*($62+"'7"^*+$J"lK$%F"-'"(*"-.*6>".*:vn",-"-./+"+.*"506+"$-"^*+$"$62"-.*"-E'"+-$5-"4%$:"7/9.-/69"'6"-.*"95'062J"lA".$-*":'0vn",%($"+.'0-+J""^*+/$6"&'6-/60*+>"lZ*$."3$9*6.$(n"1*7'5*"$+F/69"(*"-'".'%2"-.*"&$(*5$J"lAY("9'/69"/6n>".*"+$:+>"+**/69"$6"'44'5-06/-:"-'"/6-*5$&-"E/-."-.*"9/5%+J"_*".*%4+"^*+$"04"'77"-.*"7%''5"$62"5*-056/69"-'"./+"5'%*"'7"W.''2"5$-"5'11*5Y"2*($62+"lE.$-":'0"9'-"7'5"(*in""^*+$"%$09.+"$62"$%+'"-$F/69"'6"^*+/$6Y+"&.$5$&-*5>"+.*"('&F+>"lZ'0"9'-"4"r('6*:s"7'5"(*"1%''2i"Z'0"9'-"4"7'5"(*"1%''2in";$09./69>"+.*"*C4%$/6+"lK.$-Y+"E.$-"*B*5:'6*"+$:+"$-"+&.''%"-'"(*>"W:'0"9'-"4"7'5"(*"1%''2Yin"",%($"*&.'*+"-.*"E'52"l1%''2n"$62"*B*5:'6*"%$09.+J""

Page 160: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!e@"

"

,%($>"^*+$>"<B$"$62"^*+/$6"0+*2"-.*"4$5'2:"'7"-.*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"-'"2*7/6*"E.'"-.*:"E$6-"-'"

1*"B/+Q$QB/+"E.'"-.*:"$5*"6'-J"K.*"4$5'2:"&*6-5*2"'6"-.*"($5$02/69"45*+*6&*"'7"/%%Q($66*5*2"

&.$B+"$62"-.*/5"7$-.*5Y+"/6$1/%/-:"-'"+4*$F"<69%/+."$+"-.*:"2/2J"S'69%'(*5$-/'6+"'7"(0%-/Q*-.6/&"

E'5F/69Q&%$++"+-5**-"&0%-05*"GW&.$B+Y"$62"W.''2"5$-+YI"$62"B*56$&0%$5"GW150BY"$62"W1%''2YI"

45'B/2*2"$6"$%%*9'5:"7'5"-.*/5"7$-.*5Y+"E'5F/69Q&%$++"+-$-0+"$62",%1$6/$6Q<69%/+."$&&*6-J"K.*"

7'5(+"'7"4'%%0-/'6"*B/2*6-"/6"%/--*5/69"$62"-.*".''2"34,S-"$6-.5'4'('54./+$-/'6>"4%$:*2"/6-'"

-.*"`'+'B'"A6H*&-/'6"&$5J"K.*":'069"4*'4%*"0+*2".0('05>"*C$99*5$-/'6>"B0%9$5/-:>"/(('5$%/-:"

$62"2*1$+*2".0($6/-:"-'"B/%/7:"-.5'09.".0('05"GA5B/6*"!PPOj";*$&."?@@@j";*9($6"!PMNj"U*0"

?@@MIJ"A6"-./+"E$:>"-.*:"2/+Q/2*6-/7/*2"-.*(+*%B*+"75'("5$&/$%/+*2"$62"E'5F/69Q&%$++"7'5(+"'7"

/2*6-/-:"-.*:"E*5*"06&'(7'5-$1%:"&%'+*"-'J"

"

K.*"7/905*+"-.*:"&5*$-*2"/6"-./+"+F*-&.".$2"5*$%"%/7*"&'5'%%$5/*+J")*-'6>"$"%*++"5*90%$5"4$5-/&/4$6-"

$-"-.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."X5'04"GE.'".$2"$%+'"1**6"/6B'%B*2"/6"-.*"45'H*&-"N/!d'+C!%F!8%(5%(I>"

E$+"'6*"+0&.":'069"4*5+'6J"R$-.*5"-.$6"4.'-'95$4."-.*"5/&."$62"4''5"/6"`*6+/69-'6"$62"

8-5$-7'52>".*".$2"2*&/2*2"-'"-$F*"4.'-'+"'7>"$('69"'-.*5"-./69+>"E.$-"%/7*"E$+"%/F*"/6"./+"

&'56*5"'7"U*E.$(J")*-'6"*C4%$/6*2"-'"(*"-.$-"./+"4.'-'"+.'E*2"l-.*"&'62/-/'6+"E*Y5*"%/B/69"

/6"/6"U*E.$(nJ"lA-Y+"%/F*"$"9.*--'J"A-Y+"&'5504-"r/6s"+'(*"4%$&*+n>".*"+$/2J"

"

"

E')03+!;+*+(,++(.!Z9%,%!4(41/-+5!T/!]+,%(!

!

Page 161: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!e!"

"

]'5")*-'6"*B*5:2$:"%/7*"E$+"$1'0-"-.*"l+-5099%*n>"10-"7'5"-.*":'069"E'(*6"-./+"F/62"'7"$--/-02*"

E$+"*B/2*6&*"'7"%'E"$+4/5$-/'6J"8'"-''"E$+")*-'6Y+"2*(*$6'05"$62"25*++J"_*"$&-*2"-'09."$62"

06/6-*5*+-*2j".*"E'5*"2$5F"%''+*"H*$6+>"-5$/6*5+>"$"2$5F"H0(4*5"$62"1%$&F"=077$"1'2:"E$5(*5>"

+'(*-/(*+"$09(*6-*2"1:"$"95*:"1*$6/*Je@"K.*"$*+-.*-/&+"'7"-./+"+-:%*"$62"/-+"5*%$-/'6"-'"

($+&0%/6*"+-5$-*9/*+"'7"%/B/69".$B*"1**6"*C4%'5*2"/6"S.$4-*5"]'05J")*-'6Y+"+-:%*"E$+"+/(/%$5"-'"

($6:"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"A"E'5F*2"E/-.J"_'E*B*5>".*"E$+"h0/-*"2/+-/6&-"75'("-.*":'069"

E'(*6J"K.*:"+$/2".*"E$+"l&.$BB:nJ"_/+"25*++>"$62"$--/-02*"-'"%/7*>"E$+"+:(1'%/&"'7"1*/69"/6"-.*"

E5'69"&5'E2j"-.$-".*"E$+"$"-5'01%*Q($F*5"5$-.*5"-.$6"$6"*20&$-/'6$%"$&./*B*5J"K'"($/6-$/6"

-./+"2/+-/6&-/'6>"$62"-.*5*1:"($/6-$/6"-.*/5"'E6"70-05*"-5$H*&-'5/*+>"-.*":'069"E'(*6"

($6u0B5*2"-.*/5"1'2/*+"-'"F**4")*-'6"'0-+/2*"-.*/5"+'&/$%"&/5&%*J"K.*:"E*5*"5*%0&-$6-"-'"+/-"

6*C-"-'"./(>"'5"E'5F"E/-."./("'6"45'H*&-+J"A6"$22/-/'6>"E.*6".*"$--*(4-*2"-'"/6-*5$&->"-.5'09."

7%/5-/69>"-5:/69"-'"($F*"-.*("%$09."'5"/6/-/$-/69"&'6B*5+$-/'6>"-.*:"+.'E*2"6'"/6-*5*+-J"A-"E$+"

6'-"*6'09."-'"1*"502*>"10-"&*5-$/6%:"*6'09."-'"%*-"./("F6'E"-.$-"./+"$2B$6&*+"E*5*"6'-"

5*&/45'&$-*2J"_*"E$+"-.*5*1:"40-"/6"-.*"'22"4'+/-/'6"'7"1*/69"'%2*5>"7**%/69".*"+.'0%2"1*"

%''F*2"04"-'>"-.$-".*"+.'0%2"1*"+*C0$%%:"$--5$&-/B*>"10-"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"5*($/6/69"'6"-.*"

'0-+/2*"'7"-.*":'069*5"E'(*6Y+"&/5&%*"g"$"&/5&%*"-.$-"+'09.-"-'"($/6-$/6"-.*/5".'5/a'6+J"]'5"-.*"

:'069"E'(*6>")*-'6"E$+"-.*"E5'69"F/62"'7",%1$6/$6J"_/+"4*5&*/B*2"&%$++"%'&$-/'6"$62"./+"

1*/69"6'-QE./-*Q*6'09."E$+"E.$-"-.*:"+'09.-"-'"$B'/2J"

K.*+*"7'5(+"'7"5$&/$%/+*2"$62"&%$++"2/+-/6&-/'6+>"$62"-.*/5"5*%$-/'6"-'"$+4/5$-/'6$%"70-05*+>"E*5*"

6'-"'6%:"062*5+-''2"-.5'09.")*-'6"10-"$%+'"-.5'09."-.*/5"$++'&/$-/'6"E/-."-.*"10/%-"

*6B/5'6(*6-"$62"E/-."-.*"5*&*6-"$62"&'6-/60/69"2*B*%'4(*6-"'7"8-5$-7'52"K'E6J"K.*"7'5(+"'7"

$+4/5$-/'6"-.$-"$5*"*B/2*6-"/6"*20&$-/'6>":'0-."+*5B/&*"45'B/+/'6"$62"/6"-.*":'069"E'(*6Y+"

+*%7Q4'%/&/69"$5*"$%+'"*B/2*6-"/6"-.*"5*2*B*%'4(*6-"'7"8-5$-7'52Y+"/620+-5/$%".*5/-$9*J",-"-.*"

-/(*"A"E$+"E'5F/69"E/-."-.*(>"-.*"T%:(4/&"=$5F"E$+"062*5"&'6+-50&-/'6"$62"&5$6*+"E*5*"

25'44/69"-.*"7/6$%"4/*&*+"'7"-.*"d*+-7/*%2"+.'44/69"&*6-5*"/6-'"4%$&*J"lK.*"&/-:"'7"&'6+0(4-/'6"

/+"$6"$+4/5$-/'6$%"&/-:n"G#/%*+"?@!@>"4JNI>"$62"d*+-7/*%2"G'6*"'7"<05'4*Y+"%$59*+-"+.'44/69"

&*6-5*+I"$62"-.*"T%:(4/&"3*B*%'4(*6-"G?@!?Y+"9%'1$%"&'6+0(4-/'6"*4/&*6-5*I"'4-/(/+*2"-./+"

(*++$9*J"K.*+*"./9.%:"+*&05/-/+*2"2*B*%'4(*6-+".$B*"1**6"2*+/96*2"$+"/6E$52Q%''F/69"

-*(4%*+"'7"&'6+0(4-/'6J"^5/69/69"&.*(/&$%"./9.+"-'"4'+-Q/620+-5/$%"2*45/B$-/'6>"-.*:"E*5*"

10/%-"7'5"-.*"$+4/5$-/'6$%"&%$++*+J",-"d*+-7/*%2"-./+"E$+"%$-*5"B*5/7/*2"1:"-.*"45/&*+"'7"-.*"/-*(+"

'6"+$%*"$62"-.*"'B*5a*$%'0+"+*&05/-:"90$52+"-056/69"$E$:"+4'5-+Q&%'-.*2"-**6+"$-"-.*"2''5"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""e@","W1*$6/*Y"/+"$"5'062"F6/--*2"'5"E'B*6"&%'+*Q7/--/69".$-J"

Page 162: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!e?"

"

G45$&-/&*+"'7"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"$5*"2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5+"K.5**"$62"]'05IJ"_'E*B*5>"7'5"-.*":'069"

E'(*6>"-.*+*"$+4/5$-/'6$%"+-50&-05*+"$62"/2*$%+"'7"401%/&"%/7*"E*5*"4$5-"'7"-.*"E./-*6*2"4'+-Q

7*(/6/+-"70-05*"-.*:".$2"+/96*2"04"-'J"K.*+*"+4$&*+"'7"&'6+0(4-/'6".$2"/6"($6:"+*6+*+"1**6"

10/%-"7'5"-.*(J""

"

d*"B/+/-*2"8-5$-7'52"H0+-"1*7'5*"S.5/+-($+"?@@P"$+"4$5-"'7"-.*"45'H*&-"^9+3+!L!8'*+2!^94,!L!

^4(,@!A-"E$+"-.*"%$+-"+-'4"7'5"-.*"2$:Y+"7/%(/69J"_$B/69"45*B/'0+%:"&'620&-*2"+'(*"/6-*5B/*E+"

$-"L0**6"8-5**-"#$5F*->"U*E.$(>"E*"2*&/2*2"-'"E5$4"04"E/-."$"7*E"&'6&%02/69"5*($5F+"

'0-+/2*"-.*"6*E"*6-5$6&*"-'"-.*"-5$/6"+-$-/'6J"A"+099*+-*2"-.$-"<B$>"^*+$"$62",%($"+.''-"+'(*"

7''-$9*"'7"-.*"+F:%/6*"$62"($F*"+'(*"7/6$%"&'((*6-+J"K.*:"$95**2J"_$B/69"7/%(*2"-.*"&5$6*+>"

-.*"$5-/+-Y+"/($9*"'7"-.*"&'(4%*-*2"d*+-7/*%2"G]/905*"</9.-**6I>"$62"-.*"6*E"-5$/6"+-$-/'6"

*6-5$6&*>"-.*/5"&'6&%0+/'6"E$+"-.$-"-.*"2*B*%'4(*6-"'7"8-5$-7'52"E$+"$"9''2"-./69"$62"-.$-"

-.*"$5*$"E$+"&.$69/69"7'5"-.*"1*--*5J"A6"-.*/5"(/62+>"6'-"(0&."*%+*"6**2*2"-'"1*"2'6*J"K./+"

+*6-/(*6-"E$+"*&.'*2"E.*6"^*+/$6"&0-"-.*"7/%("-'9*-.*5"7'5"$"7/6$%"*2/-J"A6"1*-E**6"+.'-+"'7"

-.*"+F:%/6*".*"$22*2"$"&$4-/'6"-.$-"5*$2"lU'E".*5*"/+"$"9'B*56(*6-$%"4%$6"'7"-.*"70-05*"/6"

45'95*++n>"lT05"$5*$"/+"$%5*$2:"/(45'B/69nJ"

"

S'67/5($-/'6"'7"-.*/5"5*%$-/'6"-'"-.*"$+4/5$-/'6$%"&/-:"E$+"$9$/6"45'B/2*2"1:"$"&'06-*54'/6-"g"$"

7/905*"'7"%'E"$+4/5$-/'6"*6&'06-*5*2"'0-+/2*"-.*"'%2"8-5$-7'52"8.'44/69"S*6-5*J"d/-."

S.5/+-($+"$445'$&./69>"$"($6"E*$5/69"$"8$6-$"&'+-0(*"E$+"&'%%*&-/69"('6*:"$-"-.*"2''5"7'5"

&.$5/-:J"K.*":'069"E'(*6"2*&/2*2"-'"/6-*5B/*E"./(J"A6/-/$-/69"-.*"/6-*5B/*E>"<B$"$+F*2"E.$-"

"

"

"

"

"

K./+"/($9*"WE')03+!7')9,++(.![3,'-,S-!'&4)+!%F!,9+!F'('-9+5!^+-,F'+15!;9%##'()!_+(,3+2!;,34,F%35!

OPPKS".$+"1**6"5*('B*2>"$+"-.*"&'4:5/9.-"/+"'E6*2"1:"$6'-.*5"'59$6/+$-/'6J!

"

"

"

"

Page 163: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!eO"

"

"

E')03+!I'(+,++(.![3,'-,S-!'&4)+!%F!,9+!$%&#1+,+5!61/&#'$!5+*+1%#&+(,2!C',9!;,34,F%35!*'-'T1+!'(!

,9+!,%#!1+F,!%F!,9+!#'$,03+!H_%(-,30$,'()!7M$+11+($+!OP?PJ!

"

.*"%/F*2"$1'0-"-.*"$5*$J"_*"E$+"2506F>"$62"+$/2"-.$-".*"0+*2"-'"%/F*"-.*"$5*$"10-".*"2/26Y-"

$6:('5*>"6'-"+/6&*"./+"75/*62"2/*2J"]'5"(*>"./+"+-'5:"5*+'6$-*2"E/-."-.*"(*('5/*+"'7"%'++"

*C4%'5*2"/6"S.$4-*5"KE'>"10-"-.*":'069"E'(*6"2/26Y-"4/&F"04"'6"-./+"$62"45*++*2"'6>"$+F/69"

E.$-".*"5'5(S,"%/F*"$1'0-"-.*"$5*$J"_*"9'-"-.*"h0*+-/'6"-.*"E5'69"E$:"5'062"$62"+$/2"-.*"6*E"

+.'4+"E*5*"9''2>".*"+044'+*2J"_*"2/26Y-"5*$%%:"+**("-'"1*%/*B*"/-J"#$:1*".*"E$+"+$:/69"E.$-"

.*"-.'09.-"-.*:"E$6-*2"-'".*$5J"<B$"5*&/45'&$-*2"1:"/62/&$-/69"-.$-"+.*"5'5"-./6F"-.*"

2*B*%'4(*6-"'7"-.*"$5*$"E$+"$"4'+/-/B*"-./69J",+"E*"E$%F*2"$E$:"75'("8$6-$>"<B$"$62".*5"

75/*62+>"*(1$55$++*2>"%$09.*2"$-"./(J"_*"E$+"2506F"$62"&'670+*2"10-"('5*"-.$6"-.$-".*"E$+"

'7"$"2/77*5*6-"-/(*"-'"-.*(J"_*"45'B/2*2"-.*"4'+-Q/620+-5/$%"&'6-5$+-"-'"-.*"$+4/5/69"

$5&./-*&-05*"'7"-.*"6*E"8-5$-7'52"K'E6J""

?J #$59/6$%/+*2"70-05*+"$62"4'B*5-/*+"'7"$+4/5$-/'6"

W='B*5-:"'7"$+4/5$-/'6Y"E$+"$"E*%%Q0+*2"4.5$+*"$-";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01J",62"E./%*"/-".$2"

*B/2*6-%:"1**6"/(4'5-*2"75'("-.*"U*E";$1'05"($6-5$>"/-"E$+"6'-"&'6-$/6*2"1:"/-J",-";*:.$("

Z'0-."S%01>"W4'B*5-:"'7"$+4/5$-/'6Y"E$+"0+*2"-'"$225*++"-.*"/62/B/20$%"+.'5-&'(/69+"'7":'069"

4*'4%*"$62"7$(/%/*+"+**(/69%:"06$1%*"'5"06E/%%/69"-'"45'H*&-"$6"$+4/5$-/'6$%"70-05*J"_'E*B*5>"

$%'69"E/-."4.5$+*+"+0&."$+"W&$66'6"7'22*5Y"$62"W-.*:"2'6Y-"+**"6'"70-05*Y"/-"E$+"$%+'"0+*2"-'"

Page 164: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!e\"

"

$225*++"$"E/2*5"5$69*"'7"E'5F/69Q&%$++"/62/&-(*6-+"'7"(/22%*Q&%$++".*9*('6:"GX/%%/*+"?@@Mj"

R*$:"?@@Pj"8F*99+"!PPM>"?@@\IJ"

"

W='B*5-:"'7"$+4/5$-/'6Y"E$+"/6-5'20&*2"-'"(*"/6"?@@V"1:"-.*"S.$/5"'7"-.*"'59$6/+$-/'6"-.$-"

($6$9*2";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01J"801+*h0*6-%:>"E./%*"E'5F/69"-.*5*>"A".*$52"-.*"4.5$+*>"'5"

B$5/$-/'6+"'7"/->"'6"60(*5'0+"'&&$+/'6+"$62"'7-*6"E.*6":'0-."E'5F*5+"E*5*"-5:/69"-'"E'5F"'0-"

E.:":'069"4*'4%*"$&-*2"E/-."$44$5*6-"2/+5*9$52"7'5"$"+0&&*++70%"70-05*J"d.:"2'6Y-"-.*:"9'"-'"

+&.''%i"d.:"2'6Y-"-.*:"$+4/5*"-'"H'1+"'0-+/2*"'7"-.*"%'&$%"$5*$i"d.:"2'"-.*:"5*($/6"

06*(4%':*2"'5"'6%:"E'5F"7'5"%'E"4$:i"Z'0-."E'5F*5+"*C4%$/6*2".'E"-.*:".$2"($2*"*77'5-+"-'"

-5$/6":'069"4*'4%*"/6":'0-."E'5F>"'5".$2".*%4*2"-.*("$44%:"7'5"H'1+>"'6%:"-'"E$-&."-.*("25'4"

'0-"'5"6'-"-056"04"-'"/6-*5B/*E+J"U$55$-/B*+"'7"-.*+*"F/62+"E*5*"4$5-%:"%'&$-*2"/6"-.*"

$+4/5$-/'6$%"4'%/-/&+"'7"-.*":'0-."+*5B/&*"$62"4$5-%:"/6"-.*"('5*"&'6+*5B$-/B*"$62"E'5F/69Q&%$++"

6'-/'6"'7".$52"E'5F"$62"+*%7Q5*+4*&-"-.$-"+'(*"'7"-.*"+-$77"*62'5+*2J"

"

_'E*B*5>"W4'B*5-:"'7"$+4/5$-/'6Y"E$+"6'-"-.*"'6%:"%$690$9*"0+*2"-'"-./6F"$1'0-":'069"4*'4%*Y+"

5*20&*2".'5/a'6+J"WS$66'6"7'22*5Y"$62"W-.*:"2'6Y-"+**"6'"70-05*Y"E*5*"-E'"$++'&/$-*2"('2*+"

'7"$6$%:+/+"-.$-"1%$(*2"-.*"+-50&-05$%"7'5*&%'+05*"'7":'069"4*'4%*Y+".'5/a'6+"'6"(/22%*Q&%$++"

B/+/'6+"'7"+0&&*++J""

"

WS$66'6"7'22*5Y"/($9/6*2"$"70-05*"+'&/$%"2*$-."$-"-.*".$62+"'7"&'6+0(*5"&$4/-$%/+("$62"

*20&$-/'6J"84*$F/69"75'("-.*"4*5+4*&-/B*"'7"$"E'5F/69Q&%$++"('-.*5"E/-."-.5**"70%%:"95'E6"

&./%25*6>"K*++$>"'6*"'7"-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+>"*C4%$/6*2".'E"E'5F/69Q&%$++":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"

7$/%*2"$-"+&.''%>"$62"-.*6"40+.*2"/6-'"$6-/Q+'&/$%"1*.$B/'05"'5"4'B*5-:"-.5'09."-.*"45*++05*+"

'7"(/22%*Q&%$++"&'6+0(4-/'6J"A6"-*5(+"'7"*20&$-/'6>"+.*"5*%$-*2"-.*"+-'5:"'7".*5"'E6"+'6"E.'"

.$2"1**6"+-/9($-/+*2J"_*"E$+"/6-*%%/9*6->"+.*"+$/2>"10-".$2"*62*2"04"&'67'5(/69"-'"-.*"

+-*5*'-:4*+"-.*"-*$&.*5+".$2"'7"./(J"_*"E$+"E5'69%:"$&&0+*2"'7"./--/69"$"1':"$62"E$+"

+0+4*62*2J"_/+"5*-$%/$-/'6"-'"-./+"/6H0+-/&*"E$+"-'"7/62"-.*"1':"$62"70%7/%"-.*"$&&0+$-/'6"1:"

./--/69"-.*"1':"7'5"5*$%"/6"75'6-"'7"-.*"+-$77J",7-*5"1*/69"*C4*%%*2"75'("+&.''%>".*".$2"*62*2"04"

/6"H$/%"$62"6'E"E'5F*2"$+"$"1'06&*5J"d'5F/69"E/-."./+"7/+-+"E$+"-.*"'6%:"-./69".*".$2"*B*5"

1**6"5*$%%:"9''2"$->"K*++$"+$/2J"K*++$"E$+"4$/6*2"1:"-.*"'0-&'(*"10->"$&&*4-/69"$"#$5C/$6"

$6$%:+/+>"E$+"5*+/96*2"-.$-"/6"-.*"*62"E'5F/69Q&%$++":'069"(*6"E*5*"2*+-/6*2"-'"0+*"-.*/5"7/+-+"

-'"&'(4*-*"/6"$"(/22%*Q&%$++"+'&/*-:"GR*$:"?@@P>"4J?MIJ"_'E*B*5>".*5"$6$%:+/+"'7"(/22%*Q&%$++"

.*9*('6:"2/2"6'-"*62"E/-."*20&$-/'6"10-"*C-*62*2"('5*"E/2*%:"/6-'"$6"$6$%:+/+"'7"6*'Q%/1*5$%"

Page 165: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!eN"

"

&$4/-$%/+("$62"/6"4$5-/&0%$5"U*E";$1'05Y+"$+4/5$-/'6$%"45'95$((*+"7'5"&5*$-/69"&'6+0(*5+J"

8.*"*C4%$/6*2".'E"E'5F/69Q&%$++"&./%25*6"E*5*"%*7-"$%'6*"$-".'(*"E./%*"4$5*6-+"E'5F*2"

2'01%*"+./7-+"H0+-"-'"1*"$1%*"-'"$77'52"-.*"%$-*+-"4.'6*+"$62"-5$&F+0/-+J"8.*"-$%F*2"$1'0-"-.*"

+4/5$%%/69"2*1-+"'7"7$(/%/*+"E.'"E$6-*2"-'"-$F*"-.*/5"&./%25*6"'6"7$+./'6$1%*"4$&F$9*".'%/2$:+J"

_*5"&'6&%0+/'6"E$+"-.$-"$"+'&/*-:"+-50&-05*2"-.5'09."(/22%*Q&%$++"*20&$-/'6"$62"&'6+0(4-/'6"

E$+"7'5*&%'+/69"E'5F/69Q&%$++".'5/a'6+J"8.*"$&F6'E%*29*2".'E"$+4/5$-/'6"$62"&'6+0(*5/+("

.$2"1*&'(*"($/6+-5*$("2/+&'05+*+"'7"+0&&*++>"10-"6'-*2"-.$-"-.*+*".'5/a'6+"E*5*"'4*6"'6%:"

-'"-.'+*"E/-."('6*:"$62"+'&/$%"&$4/-$%J"

"

d.*5*$+"W&$66'6"7'22*5Y"45*2/&-*2"$"+-50&-05$%"2*$-."$-"-.*".$62+"'7"-.*"&'6+0(*5>"W-.*:"

2'6Y-"+**"6'"70-05*Y"25*E"$--*6-/'6"-'"-.*"7'5*&%'+05*"'7":'069"4*'4%*Y+".'5/a'6+J"A-"7'&0+*2"

'6".'E"4''5"*20&$-/'6>"%$&F"'7"H'1+"$62"4'+-Q/620+-5/$%"2*&%/6*"+.0-"2'E6":'069"4*'4%*Y+"

4'-*6-/$%J";:66>"'6*"'7"-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+"$-";*:.$(>"*C4%$/6*2f"

"

K.*:YB*"9'-"-'".$B*"+'(*"+'5-"'7"70-05*"$62"$-"-.*"('(*6-"-.*:"2'6Y-"+**"6'"70-05*J"d.$-"E'0%2":'0"+**i"Z'0"E'0%26Y-"+**"6'-./69"E'0%2":'0i"d.*5*"$("A"9'/69"-'"%/B*i"d.*5*"$("A"9'/69"-'"E'5Fi"

"

A6"-*5(+"'7"*(4%':(*6->"-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+"5*&'96/+*2"-.*5*"E$+"9''2"5*$+'6"7'5"-.*":'069"

4*'4%*"-'"1*"4*++/(/+-/&J"K.*"%'&$%"H'1"($5F*-".$2"6*B*5"5*$%%:"5*&'B*5*2"75'("2*Q

/620+-5/$%/+$-/'6J"K.*"4*5&*4-/'6"E$+"-.$-"+($%%"10+/6*++*+"E*5*"+-/%%"&%'+/69"2'E6>"$62"1/9"

:'0-."*(4%':*5+"%/F*"+04*5($5F*-+"E*5*"201/'0+"$1'0-"*(4%':/69"%'&$%":'069"4*'4%*J"T-.*5"

:'0-."E'5F*5+"1%$(*2"4'%/-/&/$6+"7'5"+0&&*++/B*"7$/%05*+"-'"&5*$-*"*(4%':(*6-"/6"-.*"%'&$%"

$5*$J"K.*"T%:(4/&"?@!?"+/-*"E$+"062*5"&'6+-50&-/'6"10->"2*+4/-*"45'(/+*+>"$445*6-/&*+./4+"

.$2"6'-"1**6"7'5-.&'(/69J"d*+-7/*%2>"'6*"'7"<05'4*Y+"%$59*+-"+.'44/69"&*6-5*+>".$2"$%+'"1**6"

&'6+-50&-*2>"$62"$9$/6"6'"$445*6-/&*+./4+J"K./+"7*2"/6-'"$"./+-'5:"'7"%'+-"'44'5-06/-/*+J"]'5"

-.5**"9*6*5$-/'6+>"-.*"70-05*+"'7":'069"4*'4%*".$2"1**6"-$F*6"$E$:"$62"6'-./69".$2"5*4%$&*2"

-.*(J"lK.*5*"E$+"$"-5$2*"(*6-$%/-:"/6"-./+"$5*$>n"U*/%"-'%2"(*J"lA-Y+"$"E'5F/69Q&%$++"$5*$"E/-."

-.*"2'&F+"$62"-./69+"%/F*"-.$-J"8'"-.*5*"E'0%2"1*"-5$2*"$+4/5$-/'6"r.*5*sn>".*"&'6-/60*2J"lZ'0"

E'6Y-"7/62"($6:"4*'4%*"9'/69"-'"06/B*5+/-:J"Z'0"F6'E>"6'-"'0-"'7"'05"%/--%*"&5*EJn"

"

Z'069"4*'4%*"2/2"6'-"2/+&0++"-.*/5"70-05*+"/6"-*5(+"'7"W$+4/5$-/'6Y"$62"W4'B*5-:"'7"$+4/5$-/'6Y"

10-"-./+"2/2"6'-"(*$6"-.$-"-.*:"2/26Y-"062*5+-$62"'5"+*%7Q4'%/&*"-.5'09."-.*+*"2/+&'05+*+J"

A62**2>"-.*:"E*5*"'7-*6"5*h0/5*2"-'"$&&'06-"7'5"-.*(+*%B*+"/6"-./+"E$:"$62"067'5-06$-*%:"/-"

Page 166: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!ee"

"

E$+"'&&$+/'6$%%:"(:"(/22%*Q&%$++"%'&$-/'6"-.$-"($2*"-./+"6*&*++$5:J"T6*"*B*6/69")'+/*"$62"A"

E*5*"&.$--/69"/6"-.*"1$&F"5''("$62"A"0+*2"-.*"E'52"W2/++YJ"A"E$+"-5:/69"-'"*C4%$/6"-.*"&'6-*6-"

'7"-.*"Z'0K01*"4'+-/69"1:"^$+.:"&$%%*2"W]0&F"d/%*:Y"/6"E./&."^$+.:"W2/++*+Y"d/%*:J")'+/*"

%$09.*2J"lZ'0Y5*"+'"7066:>"#$%&'%(>n"+.*"+$/2J"8.*".$26Y-".*$52"-.*"E'52"W2/++Y"7'5"$"%'69"

-/(*J"A"$+F*2"E.$-"/-"+.'0%2"1*>"$62"+.*"+$/2"W&0++*2Y>"W.'--*2Y"'5"W(05F*2YJ"#:"%$690$9*"

+.'E*2"04"(:"%/(/-*2"'B*5%$4"E/-.")'+/*Y+"+4**&."9*65*"G^$F.-/6"!PVe$IJ"_'E*B*5>"/-"E$+6Y-"

H0+-"E'524%$:J";$-*5"-.$-"*B*6/69"E*"&'6-/60*2"&.$--/69J"A-"E$+"$"5$(1%/69>".0('5'0+"

&'6B*5+$-/'6"/6"-.*"1$&F"5''(J",+"+-'5/*+"4%$:*2"'0->":'069"4*'4%*"$62"+-$77"($2*"H'F*+"$62"

E'062"*$&."'-.*5"04"G+**"S.$4-*5"K.5**"7'5"$"2*-$/%*2"2/+&0++/'6"'7"E/62Q04+IJ"]**%/69"4$5-"'7"

-.*"('(*6->"A"&./44*2"/6J"K.*"E/62Q04"E$+"$/(*2"$-")'+/*"$62"&'6-/60*2"'05"*$5%/*5"1$6-*5J"

K.*"&'6B*5+$-/'6".$2"('B*2"'6"-'"-$%F"'7"9*--/69"$"H'1"$62"E.*6"+.*"+$/2"-.*5*"E*5*6Y-"($6:"

'44'5-06/-/*+"/6"-.*"%'&$%"$5*$>"A"+$/2"-.$-"+.*"E$+"+-$-/69"-.*"'1B/'0+J"A"+$/2"/-"+$5&$+-/&$%%:J"

,%-.'09."/-"2'*+6Y-"+'062"7066:"6'E>"A"*C4*&-*2".*5"-'"%$09.>"5*-'5-"$62"&'6-/60*"-.*"9$(*J"

^0-"/-"7*%%"7%$-"$62"+.*"5*+4'62*2"+*5/'0+%:"1:"-*%%/69"(*"A"E$+"l-./&FnJ"U'-"E$6-/69"-'"9/B*"04>"

$62"7$/%/69"-'"5*&'96/+*"E.$-"A".$2"H0+-"2'6*>"A"5*-'5-*2"-.$-"1*/69"-./&F"E$+"E.$-"-.*:"-$09.-"

:'0"$-"06/B*5+/-:J"8.*"2/26Y-"7/62"-.$-"7066:"*/-.*5J""

"

8.*"2/26Y-"7/62"/-"7066:"1*&$0+*"A".$2"$++*5-*2"(:"&%$++"45/B/%*9*J"A".$2"('&F*2".*5"

06E/%%/696*++"-'"%''F"7'5"$"H'1"'0-+/2*"-.*"$5*$J",62"/6"-./+"E$:"A".$2"7%*C*2"(:"%$1'05"($5F*-"

('1/%/-:>"6'-"-'"(*6-/'6"(:"$9*"45/B/%*9*>"'6-'"E.$-"+.*"E$+"7/62/69"$"B*5:"%/(/-*2".'5/a'6"'7"

'44'5-06/-:J"#:"+*&'62"H'F*"$1'0-"W06/B*5+/-:"($F/69":'0"('5*"+-04/2Y"E$+"/6-*62*2"$+"$"E5:"

'1+*5B$-/'6"'6"W-.*"('5*":'0"%*$56"-.*"%*++":'0"F6'EYJ"_'E*B*5>"+.*"-''F"/-"$+"+$5&$+("$62"

-.'09.-"A"E$+"$++*5-/69"(:"*20&$-/'6$%"+04*5/'5/-:"'B*5".*5>"E./&."E$+"$%+'"$"+-$-*(*6-"'7".*5"

7$/%05*J"A6"'52*5"7'5"(/22%*Q&%$++"&./%25*6"-'"+0&&**2>"E'5F/69Q&%$++"&./%25*6".$B*"-'"7$/%"GX/%%/*+"

?@@M>"4JMMIJ"T7"&'05+*"-.*"H'F*"E$+"$%+'"./9.%:"*%/-/+-J"A-"E$+"45*2/&$-*2"'6".$B/69"$&&*++>"'5"

1*/69"$1%*"-'"45'H*&-"$&&*++>"-'"-.*"./9.*5"*20&$-/'6"*C4*5/*6&*J"8.*>"$62"-.*"B$+-"($H'5/-:"'7"

.*5"75/*62+>"E*5*"6'-"&'6+/2*5/69",Q%*B*%+"%*-"$%'6*"./9.*5"*20&$-/'6J"8.*"E$+"$%%"-''"7$(/%/$5"

E/-."-.*"1'C"A"E$+"06/6-*6-/'6$%%:"40--/69".*5"/6J"8.*"'7-*6"-'%2"(*"+.*"E$+"-./&F>"6'-"1*&$0+*"

+.*"E$+>"10-".*5"&'6-$&-"E/-."-.*"*20&$-/'6"+:+-*(".$2"%*2".*5"-'"1*%/*B*"/-J",%'69"E/-.".*5"

75/*62+"E.'"E*5*"+/(/%$5%:"4'+/-/'6*2>"+.*"E$+"-.*":'069"4*5+'6"/6"-.*"&'55/2'5"E.*6"+.*"

+.'0%2".$B*"1**6"/6"&%$++J",%%"/6"$%%>"-./+"&'670+*2"*C&.$69*"2*('6+-5$-*2".'E"A"/6*+&$4$1%:"

*C/+-*2"$+"$"(/22%*Q&%$++"$62"$+4/5$-/'6$%"7/905*"/6"-.*":'0-."&%01J",62"/-"$%+'"+.'E*2".'E"-./+"

&'/6&/2*2"E/-.")'+/*"+*%7Q4'%/&/69".*5"'E6"7'5*&%'+*2".'5/a'6J"

Page 167: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!eM"

"

"

3/+&'05+*+"'6"$+4/5$-/'6"4%$&*2"$6"'60+"'6"*20&$-/'6>"45'7*++/'6$%/+$-/'6"$62"&'6+0(4-/'6J"

,62"-.'+*"6'-"$1%*"-'"/($9/6*"-.*/5"70-05*"'6"-.'+*"-*5(+"E*5*"2011*2"$+".$B/69"$"W4'B*5-:"'7"

$+4/5$-/'6YJ"_'E*B*5>"E./%*":'069"4*'4%*"A"E'5F*2"E/-."%/B*2"-.*+*"2/+&'05+*+"/6"W1$2"7$/-.Y"

G8$5-5*"!PePI>"-.*:"6'6*-.*%*++"*C4%$/6*2"-.*/5"7'5*&%'+*2"70-05*+"-.5'09."+-'5/*+"'7"*20&$-/'6"

$62"*(4%':(*6-J",('69"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"$-";*:.$("-.*5*"E$+6Y-"$"95*$-"2*$%"'7"'60+"4%$&*2"

'6"*20&$-/'6J";'-+"'7"-.*("+F/44*2"+&.''%>"&.''+/69"/6+-*$2"-'"+4*62"7/6*"2$:+"/6"-.*"4$5FJ","

7*E".$2"$%+'"1**6"*C&%02*2J"#/&F*:>"$":'069"E'($6"$9*2"7'05-**6>".$2"1**6"F/&F*2"'0-"7'5"

$%%*9*2",^_"G,&-0$%"^'2/%:"_$5(I"'6"$"9/5%"-E'":*$5+"'%2*5"-.$6".*5J"8.*"E$+"5*$2(/--*2"+/C"

('6-.+"%$-*5J"A6"-.*"/6-*5B*6/69"4*5/'2"+.*"-'%2"(*"E/-."$6"06&*5-$/6"45/2*"G6'-"+05*".'E"A"

E'0%2"5*+4'62I".'E"+.*".$2"+4*6-".*5"75**"-/(*"25/6F/69>"+%**4/69"$62"+('F/69J",6'-.*5"

:'069"E'($6".$2"1**6"*C&%02*2"7'5"$++$0%-/69".*5"-*$&.*5J"T7"-.'+*"E.'"+-$:*2"/6"+&.''%"

06-/%"$9*"+/C-**6>"-.*"($H'5/-:>"%/F*")'+/*>"2/26Y-"+**"-.*(+*%B*+"$+"*20&$-/'6$%%:"$2*4-J"8&'5/69"

$"S"$-"XS8<"E$+"+'(*-./69"'7"$"5$5/-:>"$62"$"(/C-05*"'7"+0545/+*>"45/2*>"+.'&F"$62"5*+4*&-"

$&&'(4$6/*2"-.*"5*B*%$-/'6J"K./+"E$+6Y->"'7"&'05+*>"1*&$0+*"-.*5*"E$+"$"&'6&*6-5$-/'6"'7"

+-04/2/-:"$5'062";*:.$(>"10-"5$-.*5>"$+"*$5%/*5"+-02/*+"'6"*20&$-/'6".$B*"+.'E6"G_0(4.5/*+"

!PV!j"d/%%/+"!PMMI>"-.*"E'5F/69Q&%$++":'069"4*'4%*"$-"-.*":'0-."&%01".$2"1**6"2*+/96*2"'0-"'7"

-.*"+:+-*(J"

"

K.*"5*$+'6"7'5"-./+"$445'$&."-'"*20&$-/'6"E$+"&'(4%/&$-*2J"A6"+'(*"&$+*+>"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"

.$2"2/77/&0%-"7$(/%:"%/B*+>"B/'%*6-".'(*+>"%/B*2"/6"4'B*5-:>"$62"E*5*"+-/9($-/+*2"$-"+&.''%J"8'(*"

.$2"%*$56/69"2/77/&0%-/*+"-.$-"E*5*"6'-"1*/69"$2*h0$-*%:"$225*++*2J"8'(*"E$6-*2"-'"+044'5-"

-.*/5"7$(/%/*+"7/6$6&/$%%:"1:"+-$5-/69"-'"E'5F>"/6+-*$2"'7"9'/69"-'"06/B*5+/-:J"T-.*5+"&'0%26Y-"

&'6-*(4%$-*"9*--/69"/6-'"-.*"F/62+"'7"2*1-"-.$-"$6"062*595$20$-*"2*95**"*6-$/%+"GS'66'5"*-"$%J"

?@@\j"d''25'E"*-"$%J"?@@?IJ"A6"$22/-/'6"-'"-./+>"+'(*":'069"4*'4%*"2/26Y-"'4-"7'5"*20&$-/'6$%"

$--$/6(*6-"1*&$0+*"-.*:"5*$%/+*2"-.*:"&'0%2"1*--*5"9$/6"5*&'96/-/'6"75'("-.*/5"4**5+"1:"

45'-*+-/69"$9$/6+-"-.*"+:+-*("-.$-"'445*++*2"-.*("g"-.5'09."15*$F/69"50%*+"$62"4*57'5(/69"

2/+'52*5"GK.'(+'6"?@!@>"4J?Mj"+**"$%+'"S.$4-*5+"K.5**"$62"]'05IJ"K.*+*"7$&-'5+"%*2"-'"

W&.$%%*69/69"1*.$B/'05+Y"-.$-"2/2"6'-"7/-"E/-."-.*"*20&$-/'6$%"*-.'+J",+"*C4%$/6*2"-'"(*"1:"

R:$6>"'6*"'7"-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+>"l-.*"-*$&.*5+"$5*"'6%:"/6-*5*+-*2"/6"-.'+*"E.'"E$6-"-'"%*$56J"

K.'+*"E.'"2'6Y-"$5*"%*7-"-'"/-Jn"A6"$6"*20&$-/'6"+:+-*("E/-."%/(/-*2"5*+'05&*+"$62"'5/*6-$-*2"

-'"(/22%*Q&%$++"+0&&*++"-.*:"E*5*"E5/--*6"'77J"

"

Page 168: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!eV"

"

8'(*"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"A"E'5F*2"E/-."$-";*:.$("E*5*"4'+-Q+/C-**6"$62".$2"%*7-"*20&$-/'6J"

T6%:"8$($6-.$"E$+"-./6F/69"$1'0-"06/B*5+/-:J",+"+044'5-*2"1:"'-.*5"5*+*$5&."'6":'069"4*'4%*"

6'-"/6"70%%Q-/(*"'5"4$5-Q-/(*"*20&$-/'6"G#/22%*-'6"*-"$%J"?@@N>"4J?OI>"('+-"E$6-*2"4$/2"

*(4%':(*6-"10-"'6%:"$"(/6'5/-:".$2"'1-$/6*2"/-J"T6*":'069"($6"E$+"E'5F/69"$+"$"10/%2*5Y+"

%$1'05*5>"'6*"E'5F*2"/6"$"+04*5($5F*->"$62"'6*"E$+"-5$/6/69"-'"1*"$"7/5*($6J",%'69"E/-."NOJP"

4*5"&*6-"'7":'069"4*'4%*"/6"-.*"1'5'09."$9*2"!eg?\"G;^U"?@!@1>"4J\\I>"('+-"E*5*"+-5099%/69"

-'"7/62"*(4%':(*6-J"`:%/*".$2"1**6"'6*"'7"-.'+*":'069"4*'4%*"g"*C4*%%*2"75'("-.*"%'&$%"

+&.''%>"+*6-"-'"$"=04/%"R*7*55$%"[6/-"$62".$B/69"6'-"-$F*6".*5"XS8<+J"d/-.'0-"XS8<+"+.*".$2"

+-5099%*2"-'"9*-"$"H'1>"*B*6"$-"#&3'6$%2Y+J",7-*5":*$5+"'7"06*(4%':(*6-"+.*".$2"7/6$%%:"9'-"

E'5F"E/-."-.*"%'&$%"S'06&/%"/6"5*&:&%/69J";/F*".*5"4**5+>"`:%/*"25*$(-"'7"$"($/6+-5*$("70-05*>"

6'-"'6*"-.$-"E$+"6/./%/+-/&"'5"&5/(/6$%J"8.*"E$6-*2"-'"%*$B*"-.*"1$2"(*('5/*+"'7";*:.$("

1*./62"$62"('B*"-'"_$5%'E"lE.*5*"-.*5*"$5*"95**6"7/*%2+>n"+.*"+$/2J"8.*"E$6-*2"-'"5*-$F*".*5"

XS8<+"$62"1*&'(*"$"+'&/$%"E'5F*5>"10-"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"+.*"5*&'96/+*2"-.*"2*&F".$2"1**6"

+-$&F*2"$9$/6+-".*5J"

"

K.*"5*($/62*5"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"1'06&*2"1*-E**6"06*(4%':(*6-"$62"B$5/'0+>"'7-*6"

065*%$-*2>"&'%%*9*"&'05+*+Je!"A6"1*-E**6>"-.*:".069"'0-"$-".'(*>"E$/-/69"-'"(**-"04"E/-."-.*/5"

75/*62+"/6"-.*"*B*6/69J"K.*:"2/2"-.*"&'05+*+"1*&$0+*"-.*5*"E*5*"6'"H'1+J"#'+-"+$/2"-.*:"

E$6-*2"H'1+>"-'"9*-"+'(*"('6*:"$62"10:"$".'0+*"'5"&$5>"$62"+'(*"E$6-*2"-'"('B*"l04"-'E6n"

$62"1*"&%'+*5"-'"-.*"&'6+0(*5"6/9.-%/7*"-.*:"*6H':*2J"K.*/5".'5/a'6+"E*5*"&'67/905*2"-.5'09."

/2*$+"'7"/62*4*62*6&*"$62"&'6+0(4-/'6"10-"-.*:"2/2"6'-"/($9/6*"$"%'69Q-*5("$62"45'+4*5'0+"

70-05*J"K.*/5"-'Q&'(*"E$+"(0&."('5*"45*&$5/'0+"GX/%%/*+"?@@M>"4J!\eIJ"K.*5*"E$+"$%E$:+"$"

+/96/7/&$6-"2'+*"'7"06&*5-$/6-:"E.*6"2/+&0++/69"-.*"E'5F"-.*:"(/9.-"%/F*"-'"-$F*"'6J"='40%$5"

'4-/'6+"E*5*"605+*5:"605+*+>":'0-."E'5F*5+>"-*$&./69"$++/+-$6-+>"10/%2*5+Y"%$1'05*5+"'5"'77/&*"

$2(/6/+-5$-'5+J"8'(*"E$6-*2"-'"7'%%'E"$"&$5**5"-.*:"*6H':*2"10-"E*5*"%/(/-*2"1:"7/6$6&/$%"

5*$%/-:J"3$B*>"E.'"($2*"0+*"'7"7$(/%:"6*-E'5F+"-'"7/62"E'5F"$+"$"10/%2*5Y+"%$1'05*5>"+$/2"-.$-"

.*"E'0%2"5*$%%:"%/F*"-'"2'"+'(*-./69"/6"+4'5->"%/F*"&'$&./69"'5"4.:+/'-.*5$4:J"_*"+$/2"-.$-".*"

.$2"+-$5-*2"$"&'05+*"10-"/-"4$/2"H0+-"-E*6-:"4'062+"$"E**FJ"_*"&'0%2"9*-"$".0625*2"4'062+"$"

E**F"7'5"%$1'05/69J"K.*"('6*:"'77*5*2"./("$"2*95**"'7"/62*4*62*6&*>"$62"($:1*"-.*"&.$6&*"

-'"10:"$"&$5J"_'E*B*5>"'B*5"$"7*E"('6-.+"-.*"6'B*%-:"E'5*"'77"$62".*"5*(/6/+&*2"E/-."./+"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""61 The 2008 borough figures for young people aged 16–18 not in education, employment or training was

7.7 per cent (LBN 2008).

Page 169: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!eP"

"

75/*62+"$1'0-"-.*"706"-.*:".$2".$2"$-"+&.''%"9*--/69"/6-'"-5'01%*"/6"-.*"2*+/96"-*&.6'%'9:"

&%$++J"A"$+F*2"E.*-.*5".*"(/9.-"%/F*"-'"9'"1$&F"-'"+4'5-+"+&/*6&*J"_*"+$/2".*"2'01-*2"/-J"_*"

.$-*2"+/--/69"/6"$"&%$++5''(J"lA"9*-"$9/-$-*2>n".*"+$/2J"

"

)0+-"$+"-.*"$+4/5$-/'6$%",%1$6/$6":'069"E'(*6"+*-"04"&%$++*2"$62"5$&/$%/+*2"7'/%+"-'"45'B/2*"

-.*(+*%B*+"E/-."('1/%/-:>"-.*"E'5F/69Q&%$++":'069"4*'4%*"$-";*:.$("$%+'"*C4%$/6*2"-.*/5"

*C4*5/*6&*+"'7"%$1'05"($5F*-"($59/6$%/-:"-.5'09."5$&/$%/+*2"$62"&%$++*2"2/+-/6&-/'6+"-.$-"9$B*"

-.*("$"E$:"'7"5$-/'6$%/+/69"-.*/5"+'&/$%"4'+/-/'6+J",0-'&.-.'6:"G*C4%'5*2"/6"S.$4-*5"KE'I"

1*&$(*"$"(*$6+"'7"*C4%$/6/69".'E"-.*:"E*5*"2/+*675$6&./+*2"$62".'E"-.*/5"E'5F/69Q&%$++"

E'5F"*-.6/&".$2"1**6"2*B$%0*2J"d./%*"$"&%$++"$6$%:+/+"E'0%2".$B*"45'B/2*2"$6"/6+/9.-"/6-'"

-.*/5"*20&$-/'6$%"$62"*&'6'(/&"2/+*675$6&./+*(*6->"+/(/%$5"-'"-.*"*C4*5/*6&*"'7"($6:"5*&*6-"

(/95$6-+"-'"-.*"$5*$>"-.*:"/6+-*$2"*h0$-*2"-.*/5"45*&$5/'0+6*++"E/-."/((/95$-/'6"$62"-.*"

/%%*9/-/($-*"9$/6+"'7"6*E&'(*5+J"3$B*>"$"7*E"('6-.+"/6-'"./+"%$1'05/69"H'1>".$2"9'-"'B*5"-.*"

6'B*%-:"'7"9*--/69"4$/2"$62"E$+"6'E"$&h0$/6-*2"E/-."-.*"-/5/69>"4.:+/&$%"5*$%/-:"'7"10/%2/69"

E'5FJ"_*"*C4%$/6*2f"

"

N+."d.$-"H'1+"2/2":'05"X5$624$5*6-+"2'i"3'":'0"5*(*(1*5i">4*+."#:"3$2Y+"3$2"2/2"E.$-"(:"3$2"2'*+>"2/2"2'"1*7'5*".*".$2"./+"$&&/2*6-"g"10/%2/69"$62"-.$->"$6:"H'1>"%$1'05/69"$62"-.$-J"A"-./6F"(:"'-.*5"X5$622$2"E$+"/6"-.*"$5(:"$62"(:"U$6"0+*2"-'"2'"&%*$6/69"$62"-.$-J"N+."3'":'0"-./6F"-.*5*"/+"$"%'-"'7"(/95$-/'6"$5'062".*5*>"$"%'-"'7"(/95$-/'6"/6"-.*"$5*$i">4*+."Z*$."N+."A+"-.$-"('5*"'5"%*++"+/6&*":'0"E*5*"%/--%*i"T5"-.*"+$(*i">4*+."A-Y+"9'-"E'5+*J"=*'4%*"75'("2/77*5*6-"&'06-5/*+"$62"-.$-J"N+."Z*$.i">4*+."A-Y+"9'-"E'5+*J"N+."A6"E.$-"E$:i">4*+.","%'-"'7"-.*"='%/+."$62";/-.0$6/$6+".$B*"&'(*"'B*5"$62"%/F*"'E6"('+-"'7"-.*"+.'4+"'6"-.*"^$5F/69"R'$2"6'E"$62"-.*5*"/+"$%E$:+"-5'01%*J"K.*:"$%E$:+"&'(*"'0-"7/9.-/69J","($6"&'(*"'0-"'7"-.*"401>"2/26Y-"2'"6'"E5'69"$62"-.*:"1*$-"./("$62"-.*:"15'F*"./+"%*9+"$62"H$E"$62"40-"./("/6"$"1$2"E$:J"A-Y+"$%%"2/77*5*6-"4*'4%*"/6"-.*/5"2/77*5*6-"95'04+"$62"4*'4%*"+**"-.*("$+"-.5*$-+"5*$%%:J"N+."8'"E.$-"$5*"-.*"6*E"($/6"95'04+i"Z'0"+$/2";/-.0$6/$6+>"='%*+J",5*"-.*:"-.*"($/6"'6*+i">4*+."Z'0"9*-"8'($%/$6+>":'0"9*-"+'(*"S./6*+*"'6*+J"Z'0"9*-"$%%"2/77*5*6-J"K.*"('5*"A"-./6F"-.*"R0++/$6>"='%/+."m"K.*:"&'(*"'B*5J"N+."3'":'0"-./6F"/-Y+"9''2>"/-Y+"1$2>"'5":'0"2'6Y-"&$5*i">4*+."A"2'6Y-"-./6F"/-Y+"5*$%%:"9''2"-.$-"-.*:"&'(*"'B*5"$62"-.*:"9*-"*B*5:-./69"9/B*6"-'"-.*("$62"4*'4%*".*5*"$5*"+-5099%/69"$62"-.$->"$62"-.*:"&$6Y-"9*-"70&F"$%%"'77"$6:'6*J",62"-.*:"&'(*"'B*5"$62"9*-"*B*5:-./69J"3'E6"

Page 170: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!M@"

"

-.$-"5'$2"-.*5*Y+"[F5$/6/$6+"E.'Y+"%/B*2".*5*"7'5"+/C":*$5+"6'EJ"K.*:"'E6"+.'4+>"1/9"{N")**4+"$62"A"-./6F"/-Y+"$%%"9/B*6"-'"-.*("5*$%%:J"8'(*"2'"E'5F".$52"7'5"-.*/5"('6*:"10-"+'(*>"-.*:"$5*"/6-'"2/5-:"10+/6*++J"N+.",62"/7"-.*:"E'5F".$52"7'5"-.*"('6*:"-.$-Y+"9''2i">4*+."A7"-.*:"$5*"E'5F/69".$52"7'5"-.*"('6*:"r-.$-Y+"7$/5"*6'09.sJ"N+."A+"/-"-.$-"$"%'-"'7"4*'4%*".$B*"$".$52"%/7*"$5'062".*5*"+'"E.*6"-.*:"+**"4*'4%*"25/B/69"-.*+*"1/9")**4+"m">4*+."U'-"+'"(0&.J"=*'4%*"$5*"6'-"+-5099%/69"%/F*J"K.*:".$B*"-'"E'5F".$52"7'5"-.*/5"('6*:>"*B*5:"2$:"E'5F/69".$52>"-'"*$56"-.*"('6*:J"K.*:"r/((/95$6-+s"&'(*"'B*5".*5*>"9*-"*B*5:-./69"4$/2"7'5"$62"-.$-J"A-"$66':+"4*'4%*"$62"E/62+"-.*("04J"

"

A6"$22/-/'6"-'"2/+&0++/'6+"'7"*20&$-/'6"$62"*(4%':(*6-":'069"4*'4%*"$%+'"($2*"+*6+*"'7"-.*/5"

70-05*+"-.5'09."7'5(+"'7"&'6+0(4-/'6"$62"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6J")0+-"$+"-.*"$+4/5$-/'6$%":'069"

E'(*6"062*5+-''2"-.*/5"70-05*+"-.5'09."-.*"$1/%/-:"-'"2*+/5*"'1H*&-+"$62"1'2:"/($9*+>"

($59/6$%/+*2":'069"4*'4%*"$5-/&0%$-*2"-.*/5"70-05*+"-.5'09."$--$/6/69"9''2+J"_'E*B*5>"

E.*5*$+"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"$+4/5$-/'6"2**(+"-.*":'069"E'(*6Y+"&'6+0(4-/'6"4$--*56+"6'5($%>"

($59/6$%/+*2":'069"4*'4%*Y+"&.'/&*+"$5*"'7-*6"&'6+/2*5*2"l2/+'52*5*2n"GX5/77/6"!PPM>"4J!eIJ"

"

`5/+-*6"E$+"$1'0-"7'05-**6":*$5+"'%2"$62".$2"H0+-"+-$5-*2"+*&'62$5:"+&.''%J"8.*"%/B*2"/6"$"

+($%%"45'4*5-:"6*$5"-.*":'0-."&%01"E/-.".*5"('-.*5"$62"7/B*"15'-.*5+J"K.*".'(*"E$+"h0/-*"

B/'%*6-"$62".*5"('-.*5"+-5099%*2"7/6$6&/$%%:"-'"45'B/2*"7'5"-.*(J"`5/+-*6".$2"2/77/&0%-/*+"

&'((06/&$-/69"E/-."4*'4%*J"8.*"E$+"'7-*6"E/-.25$E6"$62"E'0%2"'&&$+/'6$%%:"2*($62"

$--*6-/'6"-.5'09."+4'5$2/&"'0-105+-+J"A".$2"9'-"-'"F6'E".*5"-.5'09."($F/69"-.*"B/2*'"7'5"

8+/94&!>4($+-"G+**"S.$4-*5"]'05IJ"`5/+-*6"2/26Y-"-50+-"4*'4%*"B*5:"*$+/%:"10-"-.5'09."-.*"

7/%(/69"45'&*++"E*"+-$5-*2"-'".$B*"'&&$+/'6$%"&'6B*5+$-/'6+>"E.*6"/-"+0/-*2".*5J")0+-"$7-*5"

S.5/+-($+"?@@V"+.*"&$(*"'B*5"-'"-$%F"-'"(*J"A"$+F*2".'E".*5"S.5/+-($+"E$+J"8.*"2/26Y-"+$:"

E.*-.*5"+.*"*6H':*2"/->"10-"5**%*2"'77"$"%/+-"'7"45*+*6-+"+.*".$2"1**6"9/B*6f"+'(*"-5$&F+0/-+"g"

'6*",2/2$+"'6*"-.$-"E$+"-''"1/9"$62"$"#&`*6a/*"'6*"-.$-"+.*"E$+"E*$5/69"10-".$2"W+&077*2"

04YJ"8.*".$2"9'-"/-"(022:"4%$:/69"'6"-.*"$2B*6-05*"4%$:95'062J"_*5"7$(/%:"4$/2"$--*6-/'6"-'"

&'6+0(*5"9''2+"$-"S.5/+-($+"$62"1/5-.2$:+"1*:'62"-.*/5"7/6$6&/$%"(*$6+J"K.*"#&`*6a/*"

-5$&F+0/-".$2"$".''2"$62"$"a/4"-.$-"E*6-"$%%"-.*"E$:"75'("-.*"E$/+-1$62"-'"-.*"-'4"'7"-.*"

.''2J"d.*6"a/44*2"04"70%%:"/-"&'(4%*-*%:"&'B*5*2".*5"7$&*J"A"$+F*2>"H'F/69%:>"/7"A"&'0%2"a/4"/-"04J"

8.*"%''F*2"$-"(*"-'"9$09*"(:"/6-*6-/'6+"$62"+$/2"A"&'0%2>"/7"A"45'(/+*2"-'"062'"/-J"K./+"E$+"$"

-*+-"'7"-50+-J"^0-"+.*"2/26Y-"&'(4%*-*%:"-50+-"(*J"8.*"2*&/2*2"-'"a/4"/-"04".*5+*%7"10-"6'-"$%%"-.*"

E$:>"%*$B/69"H0+-"*6'09."+4$&*"7'5".*5"*:*+"-'"4**F"'0-J",62"-.*6"+.*"$&-*2"'0-"$"+-5**-"

5'11*5:J"S.$69/69"/6-'"E.$-"+.*"-.'09.-"E$+"$"-.5*$-*6/69"4'+-05*"+.*"2*($62*2"A"9/B*".*5"

Page 171: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!M!"

"

(:"('6*:J"A"06a/44*2".*5"7$&*"$62"-.*"4*57'5($6&*"*62*2J"8.*"-'%2"(*"E/-."15$B$2'>"10-"6'"

/5'6:>"-.$-"+.*"E$+"9'/69"-'"1*"$"+-5**-"5'11*5"E.*6"+.*"95*E"04J"K.*6"+.*"E$%F*2"'77J"

"

`5/+-*6Y+"$&-"E$+"*B/2*6-%:"$"4*57'5($6&*"'7"6/./%/+-"$*+-.*-/&+"G+**"S.$4-*5"]'05I>"10-"$"

60(1*5"'7"-./69+"+-50&F"(*"$1'0-".*5"$&-/'6+J"`5/+-*6Y+"-5$&F+0/-"+.'E*2".'E":'069"4*'4%*"

75'("4''5"7$(/%/*+"E*5*"'1%/9*2"-'"4$5-/&/4$-*"/6"7'5(+"'7"&'6+0(4-/'6"-.*:"&'0%2"/%%"$77'52>"

H0+-"-'"F**4"04J"S.5/+-($+"7'5"`5/+-*6>"$+"7'5"($6:"'-.*5"4*'4%*>"/(45*++*2"'6".*5"-.*"6**2"7'5"

('6*:J"A6"-./+"E$:>"`5/+-*6Y+".'5/a'6+"E*5*"1*/69"7'5(*2"-.'09.".*5"*C4*5/*6&*"'7"

($59/6$%/+$-/'6"75'("-.*"&'6+0(*5"25*$(J"_'E*B*5>".*5"4*57'5($6&*"'7"$"&5/(/6$%"70-05*"E$+"

6'-"$6"/62/&$-/'6"'7"$"70-05*"B'&$-/'6"10-"$"(*$6+"'7"($F/69"+*6+*"'7".*5"750+-5$-/'6+"G$+"$"

+-5$-*9:"7'5"%/B/69I"/6"$"E/2*5"+'&/*-:"/6"E./&."$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:"$62"('6*:"E*5*"B$%0*2"G+**"

S.$4-*5"]'05IJ"_'E*B*5>"-./+"E$+"$%+'"$"B*5:"4*5+'6$%"$&-"'7"+01-*5709*J",-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"+.*"

E$+"4*57'5(/69"6/./%/+("+.*"E$+"*+&$4/69".*5"'E6"+.:6*++J"_/22*6"/6".*5".''2>"-.*"$&-"

'77*5*2"5*%/*7J"

OJ K.*"6*9$-/B*"4'%/-/&+"'7"-.*"70-05*f"<'&+!'-!"#!$62"B%&+!<%C(!

D1%3/!

K./+"&.$4-*5".$+"*C4%'5*2"6*9'-/$-/'6+"'7"$+4/5$-/'6$%"$62"($59/6$%/+*2"70-05*+J"A-".$+"

*C4%$/6*2".'E"$+4/5$-/'6$%"$62"($59/6$%/+*2":'069"4*'4%*"45'H*&-*2"-.*/5"70-05*+"-.5'09."

7'5(+"'7"2/+Q/2*6-/7/&$-/'6"$62"-.5'09."-.*/5"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"75'("-.*"2'(/6$6-"*20&$-/'6g

*(4%':(*6-g&'6+0(4-/'6"-5$H*&-'5:J"_'E*B*5>"/-".$+"6'-"*69$9*2"E/-.".'E":'069"4*'4%*"

*6B/+$9*2".'5/a'6+"$%-*56$-/B*"-'"-.*+*"+&*6$5/'+J",%-*56$-/B*".'5/a'6+".$B*"1**6"%$59*%:"

$1+*6-"/6"*-.6'95$4.:"1*&$0+*"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6"$+"$"B*./&%*"7'5"70-05*"$6$%:+/+".$+"1**6"

062*5B$%0*2J",+"2/+&0++*2"/6"-.*"/6-5'20&-/'6"-'"-./+"&.$4-*5>"*-.6'95$4.:".$+"-*62*2"-'"7'&0+"

'6"-.*"4$+-+"'5"45*+*6-+"062*5+-''2"75'("+01H*&-/B*"$62"/6-*545*-/B*"+-$624'/6-+J"A6"-.*"7/5+-"

-E'"+*&-/'6+"'7"-.*"&.$4-*5>"-.*+*"F/62+"'7"$6$%:+*+".$B*"1**6"*(4%':*2"-'"45'B/2*"/6+/9.-"

/6-'":'069"4*'4%*Y+"45'H*&-/'6+"'7"$+4/5$-/'6$%"$62"($59/6$%/+*2"70-05*+J"_'E*B*5>"-'"('B*"

1*:'62"-.*+*"1/6$5:"4'+/-/'6+"/-"/+"6*&*++$5:"-'"5*%*$+*"-.*"$6$%:+/+"75'("-.*"&'6+-5$/6-+"'7"

*C4*5/*6&*"$62"/6-*545*-$-/'6"$62"'4*6"/-"04"-'"-5$6+&*62*6-$%"70-05*+"-.$-"-5$B*%"1*:'62"-.*"

4.*6'(*6'%'9/+-Y+"+01H*&-Q&*6-5*2"1'2:J"

"

Page 172: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!M?"

"

d.*5*$+"$445'$&.*+"'7"-./+"F/62"$5*"6'-"&'(('6"-'"*-.6'95$4.:>"/6"E'5F"+4$66/69"'B*5"$"

&*6-05:>"($6:"$0-.'5+"$62"$5-/+-+"/6"-.*"$75'Q70-05/+-"-5$2/-/'6".$B*"1**6"/6B'%B*2"45*&/+*%:"/6"

-./+"F/62"'7"*62*$B'05J"84*&/7/&$%%:>"-.*:".$B*"+'09.-"-'"45'H*&-"$"B/+/'6"'7"-.*"70-05*"75**"75'("

5$&*"$62"-.*5*7'5*"75**"75'("-.*"G5$&/$%/+*2I"1'2:J",-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"-.*:".$B*"*C4$62*2"-.*"

(*-.'2'%'9/&$%"4'++/1/%/-/*+"7'5"062*5+-$62/69"-.*"70-05*"1:"4%$&/69"-.*"*(4.$+/+"'7"$6$%:+/+"

6'-"'6"-.*"&'6+-5$/6-+"'7"+01H*&-/B*"$62"/6-*545*-/B*"*C4*5/*6&*"GS.$4-*5"T6*"&'6+/2*5+".'E"

4.*6'(*6'%'9:"/+"&'6+/2*5*2"-'"1*"*4/+-*('%'9/&$%%:"&'(4%/&/-"/6"($/6-$/6/69"5$&/+(I>"10-"'6"

-.*"4'++/1/%/-/*+"'7"-5$6+&*62*6-$%"('B*(*6-+J"K.5'09."-.*"$6$%:+/+"'7"(0+/&"$62"+&5*$(+>"

-.*:".$B*"*69$9*2"E/-."-.*"-5$6+&*62*6-$%"&5:"7'5"75**2'("$+"$"B*./&%*"'7"&0%-05$%"$6$%:+/+"/6"

E./&."$"B/+/'6"'7"$6'-.*5"4'++/1%*"E'5%2"/+"&$55/*2"G30"^'/+"?@@M>"44JVgPj"<%%/+'6"!PPN>"?@@!j"

<+.06"!PPV>"?@@Oj"]$6'6"!PP!j"X/%5':"!PPO>"4J\Mj"X/%5':"?@@@>"44JO\!gO\Oj"#$:*5"?@@@j"

#'-*6"?@@Oj"d5/9.-"!Pe\j"Z$+a*F"?@@eIJ"_'E*B*5>"/6"('5*"5*&*6-"-/(*+>"$0-.'5+"E'5F/69"/6"

-./+"7/*%2".$B*"$%+'"$590*2"-.$-"-./+"0-'4/$6"-5$2/-/'6"/6"1%$&F"4'%/-/&+".$+"1**6"/6"2*&%/6*J"

K.5'09."-.*"5/+*"/6"&'(('2/7/&$-/'6"$62"$6"$&&'(4$6:/69"5*-056"-'"-.*"5$&/$%/+*2"1'2:"

G*C4%'5*2"-.5'09."2/+&0++/'6+"'7"6/./%/+("/6"S.$4-*5"]'05I>"$"+./7-"75'("-.*"-5$6+&*62*6-$%"-'"

-.*"/(($6*6-".$+"1**6"'1+*5B*2"GX/%5':"?@@@j"X/%5':"?@!@$IJ"d./%*"-.*:"2'"6'-"$590*"7'5"-.*"

*62"'7"5$2/&$%"$62"$6-/Q5$&/+-"7'5(+"'7".0($6/-:"GX/%5':"?@@\I>"-.*:"6'6*-.*%*++"5*7%*&-"('5*"

4'40%$5"6$55$-/B*+"&'6&*56/69"-.*"2*(/+*"'7"0-'4/$+"$62"-.*"&'6&055*6-"7'5*&%'+05*"'7":'069"

4*'4%*Y+".'5/a'6+J",-";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01>"R:$6>"'6*"'7"-.*":'0-."E'5F*5+>"6'-*2"-./+"

+*6-/(*6-f"

"

A"-./6F"-.*:"r:'069"1%$&F"(*6s"$5*"%''F/69"$-"5$44*5+J"K.*5*"r$5*s"6'"4'+/-/B*"5'%*"('2*%+"6'"('5*J"K.*"+$2"-./69"/+>"/-"/+"$"%'-"'7":'069"1%$&F"F/2+"-.$-"$5*"9*--/69"/6B'%B*2"/6"-.$-J"^$&F"/6"-.*"2$:"E*"r1%$&F"4*'4%*s".$2"4*'4%*"E*"%''F*2"04"-'"%/F*"#$5-/6";0-.*5"`/69"$62"#$%&'%("{>"$62"*B*6"2'E6"-'"-.*"^%$&F"=$6-.*5+"$62"^%''2"$62"S5/4+J",62"*B*6"^%''2"$62"S5/4+"E.*6"-.*:"7/5+-"+-$5-*2"-.*:"E$+"$&-0$%%:"$"('B*(*6-"06-/%"m"K.*:"-.'09.-"E*".$B*"9'-"75**2'("/6",(*5/&$"6'E"E.$-"&$6"E*"2'J"K.*5*"r$5*s"6'"4'+/-/B*"5'%*"('2*%+J"K.*"5'%*"('2*%+"-.*:"%''F"$-"$5*"5$44*5+J"K.*:"2'6Y-"%''F"$-"4'%/-/&/$6+J"K.*:"%''F"$-"5$44*5+J"K.*5*"$5*"1%$&F"4'%/-/&/$6+"10-"-.*:"2'6Y-"%''F"$-"1%$&F"4'%/-/&/$6+>"-.*:"%''F"$-"1%$&F"5$44*5+"-$%F/69"$1'0-"906+"$62"E.$-*B*5"$62"-.*:"E$6-"-'"1*"%/F*"-.$-J"

"

K./+"+*&-/'6>".'E*B*5>"$590*+"-.$-"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"$%-*56$-/B*"70-05*+".$B*"6'-"*62*2J"d./%*"G$+"

*C4%'5*2"/6"S.$4-*5"]'05I":'069"4*'4%*Y+"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+"0+*2"6/./%/+-/&"$*+-.*-/&+"

&*6-5*2"'6"-.*"1'2:>"$62"E./%*"-.*:"5*%/*2"'6"&'((*5&/$%"-5'4*+"7'5"&'((06/&$-/'6>"-.*/5"

45'20&-/'6+"+-/%%"&$55/*2"$%-*56$-/B*".'5/a'6+J"

Page 173: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!MO"

"

"

K'"($F*"-./+"$590(*6->"-.*"+*&-/'6"2*B*%'4+"-.*"$6$%:+/+"'7"A'11!411!4!>+&!&'6-$/6*2"/6"S.$4-*5"

]'05J"S.$4-*5"]'05"$590*2"-.$-"A'11!411!4!>+&2!$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"$+"1*/69"$"4*57'5($6&*"'7"

6/./%/+-"$*+-.*-/&+>"E$+"$"B*./&%*"-.5'09."E./&.":'069"4*'4%*"5*7%*&-*2"'6"-.*/5"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"

$62"&'6+/2*5*2"-.*"/6H0+-/&*+"-.*:"&'675'6-*2J"A-"*C4%'5*2".'E"-.*"B/2*'"($2*"$"&'6+-$6-"

*6h0/5:"/6-'"-*&.6'%'9/*+"'7"+05B*/%%$6&*"$62"4'%/&/69"$62".'E"/-"$225*++*2"-.*"/6H0+-/&*+"'7"

&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"$6-/Q+'&/$%"5*%$-/'6+J"A-"$590*2"-.$-"5$-.*5"-.$6"1*"B/*E*2"$+"$4'%/-/&$%"

6/./%/+(>"[4&'(/69"#'B*(*6-Y+"E'5F"+.'0%2"1*"B/*E*2"$+"4'%/-/&$%%:"6*9$-/B*"G_$%1*5+-$("

?@@VI"g"1*&$0+*"'7"-.*/5"0+*"'7"6/./%/+-"$*+-.*-/&+>"10-"$%+'"1*&$0+*"-.*:"&5/-/h0*2"'445*++/'6"

5$-.*5"-.$6"45'B/2/69"$B*60*+"7'5"*($6&/4$-/'6J"d.*5*$+"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"A'11!411!4!>+&!$5*"

+'(*E.$-"'4$h0*>"-./+"+*&-/'6"2*('6+-5$-*+".'E>"E.*6"&'6+/2*5*2"/6"2/$%'90*"E/-."

[4&'(/69"#'B*(*6-Y+"-E'"+01+*h0*6-"E'5F+"g"<'&+!'-!"#!$62"B%&+!<%C(!D1%3/!g"-.*:"

1*&'(*"*C4%/&/-J"A6"2/$%'90*"E/-."-.*+*"E'5F+>"A'11!411!4!>+&"1*&'(*+"6'-"'6%:"$"5*7%*C/B*"

*69$9*(*6-"E/-."($59/6$%/+$-/'6"10-"$%+'"4$5-"'7"$"-5$H*&-'5:"'7"E'5F"-.$-"6*9$-/B*%:"*C4%'5*+"

$%-*56$-/B*"70-05*+"1*:'62"($59/6$%/+*2".'5/a'6+J"K.*"5*($/62*5"'7"-./+"&.$4-*5"*C4%'5*+"

-.*+*"$%-*56$-/B*"$62"4'%/-/&$%%:"6*9$-/B*"70-05*+J"A-"2*('6+-5$-*+".'E"-.5'09."$6"$445*&/$-/'6"

'7"-.*+*"/-"/+"4'++/1%*"-'"062*5+-$62".'E"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+"&'675'6-"$62"%''F"1*:'62"-.*"

&'6-5$2/&-/'6+"'7"&$4/-$%/+-"+'&/*-:"G%'6*%/6*++>"*C&%0+/'6+"$62"/6H0+-/&*+I"G;/4+/-a"!PP\>"4J?NI>"

&5*$-/69"$%-*56$-/B*"+&*6$5/'+"7'5"-.*"-'Q&'(*J"

!

<'&+!'-!"#!$62"B%&+!<%C(!D1%3/"7'%%'E*2"-.*"5*%*$+*"'7"A'11!411!4!>+&J",+"E/-."-.*"7'5(*5"

45'20&-/'6>"-.*:"E*5*".'+-*2"'6"-.*"95'04Y+"Z'0K01*"&.$66*%"E./&."1:"#$5&."?@!?".$2"

-E*6-:"+01+&5/1*5+"$62"!?>@@@"B/*E+J"<'&+!'-!"#!/+"$"-.5**Q$62Q$Q.$%7"(/60-*>"&'%'05"B/2*'"-.$-"

E$+"04%'$2*2"-'"-.*"+/-*"/6"3*&*(1*5"?@!!J"A-"$5-/&0%$-*+"$6"$%-*56$-/B*".'5/a'6"1:"2/5*&-%:"

$&F6'E%*29/69"-.*"($59/6$%/+*2"70-05*+"$9$/6+-"E./&."[4&'(/69"#'B*(*6-"E'5FJ"K.*"70%%"

%:5/&+"'7"-.*"-5$&F"$5*"$+"7'%%'E+f"

"

7/(-%/8%12!A!BC*&./'D!E&F$.$'3!789::*;!!L(,3%.!Z'4(%!4(5!-/(,9!"<$=0$!&'$!A"%/*2"-.'09.>"A"1**6".'-"E/-."$"^/5'>"K.*:"+$:"AY("1%/62>"A"9'"/6"E/-."(:"*:*+"&%'+*2>"A"$/6Y-"+$:/69"AY("-.*"1*+-"10-"6'-./69"%/F*"-.*"5*+->"

Page 174: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!M\"

"

^0-"AY("&'6+/+-*6->"+'":'0"F6'E"-.$-"A"-5:"15'YJ""8'"($6:".$-*5+"E$66$"+**"(*"7$%%"'77>"^0-"AY("6'-"$-"-.*"-'4":*-"+'"A"&$55:"'6"&%/(1/69>"A"6*B*5"+-'44*2"(:"E'5F"5$-*>"Z'0Y%%"$%E$:+"+**"(*"E5/-/69>"8F$-*1'$52*5"%/7*>"AY("'6"-.*"&051"$62"AY("95/62/69J""A"2'6Y-"E/+."6'"2*$-."04'6"$".$-*5>"A"E$66$"('B*"-'"m"+'"$%%"A"+**"/+"4$4*5"r('6*:s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d.*6"A"1'56"/-"E$+"-.*"'6%:"-/(*":'0"*B*5"+**"$"+.''-*5>",62"6'E$2$:+"/-Y+"%/F*"*B*5:1'2:Y+"+-5$44*2"04"r$5(*2s>",62"A"E$+"F/62$"5'%%/69"5'062"$62"-./6F/69"-.$-"A"+.'0%2Y$J""^0-"7'5"6'E"AY($"&$55:"'6"95/62/69>"[6-/%"(:"-/(*Y+"04"$62"-.*"%/9.-Y%%"1*"1%/62/69>"AY%%"6*B*5"9*-"/-"1$&F>"A-Y+"%/F*"AY("%*7-"/6"-.*"2$5F>"A"E$66$"($F*"7$&*"+'"AY%%"&$55:"'6"-5:/69J""K.5'09."-.*"5$/6>"75'("-.*"%/9.-6/69>"E.$-*B*5"-.*"E*$-.*5>"AY("F**4"1$55/69"r5$44/69s>"&'+"1$55/69"/+"(:"4%*$+05*>"=*'4%*"&5/-/&/+*"10-"A"($F*"/-"&'6+-50&-/B*>"S'+"&'6+-50&-/B*"&5/-/&/+("'6%:"($F*+":'0"1*--*5J""A-"%*-+":'0"F6'E":'05"2'E6"+/2*+>"

Page 175: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!MN"

"

^0-"F**4":'05"&./6"04"&'+"-.*5*Y+"$"4%0+"-'"*B*5:"2'E6+/2*>"U*9$-/B*"/($9*+"'7"&'670+*2"/62/B/20$%+>"K.$-"$%E$:+"E$6-"-'"+E/69"10-"-.*:"6*B*5"%*-"/-"+%/2*J""U*B*5""[6-/%"(:"-/(*"/+"04"[6-/%"(:"-/(*"/+"04"[6-/%"(:"-/(*"/+"04"">#&=?0!#:".$-*5+"E$6-"-'"15/69"(*"2'E6>"K.*:"$%%"E$6-"-'"+**"(*"7$/%>"^0-"AY($"&$55:"'6"95/62/69"W-/%"(:"-/(*"/+"04>"[6-/%"(:"-/(*"/+"04>"[6-/%"(:"-/(*"/+"04>"[6-/%"(:"-/(*"/+"04J""#:".$-*5+"E$6-"-'"15/69"(*"2'E6>"K.*:"$%%"E$6-"-'"+**"(*"7$/%>"^0-"AY($"&$55:"'6"95/62/69"W-/%"(:"-/(*"/+"04>"[6-/%"(:"-/(*"/+"04>"[6-/%"(:"-/(*"/+"04>"[6-/%"(:"-/(*"/+"04J"

"

<'&+!'-!"#!*C-*62+"-.*"$6$%:+/+"&'6-$/6*2"/6"A'11!411!4!>+&"-'"$"('5*"2/5*&-"*69$9*(*6-"E/-."

7'5*&%'+*2".'5/a'6+J"K.*"2/+&0++/'6"'7"9*--/69"/6B'%B*2"/6"906"&5/(*>"$62"-.*"2*&/+/'6"-'"%''F"

1*:'62"/-"-'"$6'-.*5"7'5("'7"%/7*"g"W95/62/69Y"g"5*45*+*6-+"$6"*B$%0$-/'6"'7>"$62"2*4$5-05*"

75'(>"-.*"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:"'7"A'11!411!4!>+&J"A-"2*('6+-5$-*+".'E"4'%/-/&$%"&'6+&/'0+6*++"E$+"

7'5(*2"-.5'09."-.*"95'04Y+"*69$9*(*6-"E/-."-.*"$*+-.*-/&+"'7"6/./%/+("$62"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:J"

<'&+!'-!"#2!$+"-.*"-/-%*"+099*+-+>"/+"$"E'5F"/($9/6*2"$9$/6+-"-.*"%/(/-+"'7"%/7*J"K.*"45'20&-/'6"

+-$5-+"E/-."$"(*%$6&.'%/&>"+%'E"4/$6'"/6-5'20&-/'6"5*(/6/+&*6-"'7"$"+%'E*2Q2'E6".$44:"

.$52&'5*"(*%'2:J"K./+"/+"$&&'(4$6/*2"1:"+.'-+"'7"-.*"6/9.-Y+"+F:%/6*f"S$6$5:"d.$57"$62"-.*"

#/%%*66/0("3'(*"75'("-.*"6'5-."1$6F"'7"-.*"K.$(*+J"K.*"-5$&F"-*%%+"-.*"+-'5:"'7"$"&'6-/60$%"

&'675'6-$-/'6"E/-.".$52+./4+>"$62"-.*"6*&*++/-:"'7"95/62/69"'0-"-/(*"06-/%"2*$-."&'(*+J"3*$-.>"

6'-"%/7*>"/+"0+*2"$+"-.*"%/(/-"'7"-.*"$5-/+-+Y".'5/a'6+J"lAY("9'66$"F**4"95/62/69>"06-/%"(:"-/(*"/+"

04n>"`*(4:"+-$-*+J"K./+"(*2/-$-/'6"%*$2+"-.*"$5-/+-+"-'"15/69"/6"5*7*5*6&*+"-'"X'2"E.'"4%$:+"

-.*"5'%*"'7"$"95*$-*5"E/+2'(>"$"H029*>"$62"$"45'-*&-'5"'7"75/*62+"$62"7$(/%:>"'6&*"-.*":'069"

(*6"$5*"2*$2J"_'E*B*5>"X'2"2'*+"6'-"45'B/2*"+$%B$-/'6"$62".'4*>"5$-.*5"$":$52+-/&F"-.5'09."

E./&."-.*:"062*5+-$62"-.*"95/62J"

"

Page 176: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!Me"

"

K.*"95/62"/+"45*+*6-*2"1:"-.*"$5-/+-+"$+"$6"$%-*56$-/B*"-'"/6B'%B*(*6-"E/-."906"&5/(*"$62"-.*"

2$5F*5"+/2*+"'7"U*E.$("%/7*J"K./+"/+"$"('B*(*6-"$E$:"75'("-.*"&*%*15$-/'6"'7"&5/(*"-.$-"$5*"

&'6-$/6*2"/6"-.*"6/./%/+-"$*+-.*-/&+"'7"A'11!411!4!>+&J"A-"/+"$%+'"$"($5F*2"&.$69*"75'("-.*"-.5**"

$+4/5$-/'6$%":'069"E'(*6Y+"B/+/'6"'7"*20&$-/'6>"45'7*++/'6$%/+$-/'6"$62"&'6+0(4-/'6J"]'5"

`*(4:"$62"8-*B'"-.*5*"$5*"6'"+0&."4'++/1/%/-/*+J"K.*/5+"/+"$"l8F$-*1'$52*5"%/7*>"AY("'6"-.*"&051"

$62"AY("95/62/69Jn"=%*$+05*"-.*6"&'(*+"-'"-.*("6'-"-.'09."-.*"*C4*&-$-/'6"'7"&'6+0(4-/'6"

10-"-.5'09."-.*".$52"E'5F"$62"5*E$52"15'09.-"1:"%*/+05*f"l1$55/69"r5$44/69s>"&'+"1$55/69"/+"(:"

4%*$+05*Jn"K.*":'069"(*6"45'7*++"-'"7/62"+'%$&*"75'("($59/6$%/+$-/'6"/6"-.*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"

($+&0%/6*"*62*$B'05"'7"95/62/69"'0-"$"%/7*"$62"E5/-/69"./4".'4J"_'E*B*5>"-./+"/+"6'-"+/(4%:"

&'67'5(/-:"-'"'445*++/'6>"5$-.*5"$"45'&*++"-.5'09."E./&."-.*":'069"(*6"&5/-/&$%%:"*B$%0$-*"

-.*/5"%'->"$62"45'B/2*"+-5$-*9/*+"7'5"6*9'-/$-/69"-.*/5"70-05*+J"

"

K./+"/+"$"4$5-/&0%$5%:"E'5F/69Q&%$++>"($+&0%/6*"062*5+-$62/69"'7"-.*"70-05*J"_$52"E'5F>"+E*$-"

$62"%$1'05"$5*"B$%0*2"1:"[4&'(/69"#'B*(*6-"$+"E'5-.E./%*"$62"('5$%"/6"-.*"%$62+&$4*"'7"

%/(/-*2"'44'5-06/-/*+J"_'E*B*5>"-.*/5"($+&0%/6/-:"$%+'"/67'5(+"-.*/5"B/+/'6"'7"-.*"70-05*J",+".$+"

1**6"2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"K.5**>"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"2/+&'05+*+"'7"7$/%05*"$5*"'7-*6"$/(*2"$-""

"

"

E')03+!<C+(,/.!;,'11!F3%&!R<'&+!'-!"#S!U!_4(43/!^943F!4(5!N'11+(('0&!>%&+!4,!(')9,!F3%&!

I+C94&!HL$+!E'1&-!7(,+3,4'(&+(,!+,!41@!OP??$J!

"

Page 177: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!MM"

"

E'5F/69Q&%$++":'069"(*6J"K.*/5"E/2*5"45'H*&-/'6"'7"06&*5-$/6-:"$62"7'5*&%'+05*"&$6>"-.*6>"1*"

+**6"$+"+:(4-'($-/&"'7"$"9*62*5*2"$+4/5$-/'6$%"4'%/-/&+"75'("E./&."-.*:".$B*"1**6"*C&%02*2J"

"

K./+"6*9$-/B*"4'+/-/'6/69"/+"45*+*6-"/6"-.*"B/2*'Y+"/($9*5:J"K.*"B/2*'"E$+"+.'-"$9$/6+-"-.*"

6/9.-Y+"+F:%/6*"g"-.*"#/%%*66/0("3'(*"$62"-.*"S$6$5:"d.$57"G]/905*"KE*6-:IJ"K.*+*"10/%2/69+"

2'"6'-"$44*$5"$+"4$5-"'7"$"E*$%-.:"$+4/5$-/'6$%"70-05*>"'5"$+"-.*:"2'"/6"8.:+-/*Y+"B/2*'"7'5"L&4!

G%--"G?@!!I"$+"$"6/./%/+-/&"&*%*15$-/'6"'7"('6*:"G$%+'"'6*"'7"-.*"-.*(*+"'7"A'11!411!4!>+&I>"10-"$+"

$6"06'1-$/6$1%*"(/5$9*J"<'&+!'-!"#>"-.*6>!'77*5+"-.*"/($9*"'7"$"70-05*"&'62/-/'6*2"1:"

($59/6$%/-:J"

!

K.*"+*&'62"B/2*'>"B%&+!<%C(!D1%3/!-$F*+"-./+"$6$%:+/+"$"+-*4"705-.*5J"A-"7/%%+"'0-"-.*"*B*5:2$:"

*C4*5/*6&*"'7"-.*"95/62>"$62"/-+"5*%$-/'6"-'"2*$-.>"E/-."$"2*-$/%*2"2/+&0++/'6"'7"+'&/$%"/6H0+-/&*+J"

B%&+!<%C(!D1%3/!2*('6+-5$-*+".'E"-.*"95'04Y+"*6h0/5:"/6-'"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"401%/&"+4$&*"G/6"

A'11!411!4!>+&I!$62"-.*"70-05*"G/6"<'&+!'-!"#I!%*2"-'"$"4'%/-/&$%"$6$%:+/+"'7"-.*"&05-$/%(*6-"'7"

:'069"4*'4%*Y+".'5/a'6+J",+"$"7'5("'7"6*9$-/B*"70-05/-:>"-./+"45'B/2*+"705-.*5"*B/2*6&*"'7"

-./6F/69"1*:'62"($59/6$%/+*2".'5/a'6+"-.5'09."-.*"5*7%*C/B*"&5/-/h0/69"'7"&$4/-$%/+-"

&'6-5$2/&-/'6+J",9$/6>"E./%*"-.*"95'04"2'*+6Y-"45'H*&-"$"0-'4/$>"$62"/6"-./+"+*6+*"5*-$/6+"-.*"

6*9$-/B*"4'%/-/&+"-.$-"&.$5$&-*5/+*+"-.*/5"E'5F>"-.*:"h0*+-/'6"-.*"%*9/-/($&:"'7"-.*".'5/a'6+"'6"

'77*5J"

"

B%&+!<%C(!D1%3/!/+"$"7/B*Q$62Q$Q.$%7"(/60-*"&'%'05"B/2*'"04%'$2*2"-'"Z'0K01*"/6")$60$5:"

?@!?J",9$/6"-.*"/6-5'20&-/'6"/+"$"(*%$6&.'%:"$62"5*7%*&-/B*"4/$6'"5/77>"/6-*5+4*5+*2"E/-."$"

.$44:".$52&'5*"+-:%*"'7"B'&$%+"g"5*(/6/+&*6-"'7"^$1:%'6"x''Y+";#4$+&4(!G!PPNIJ"K.*"5/77"/+"

$&&'(4$6/*2"1:"+.'-+"'7"-.*"%'&$%"9*'95$4.:"%'&$-/69"-.*"45'20&-/'6"/6"U*E.$(J",9$/6>"

S$6$5:"d.$57"'&&$+/'6$%%:"45'B/2*+"$"1$&F25'4J""

"

"

"

"

"

Page 178: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!MV"

"

9#(-%7#:*%;<#"=!A!BC>&./'D!E&F$.$'3!789:8;G8!"Z'4(%!4(5!*%$41!'(,3%!"<$=0$!&'$!;*-"(*"-*%%":'0"F6'E"AY("7**%/69"6'E>"8-$5/69"$-"-.*"&%'02+"9'-"(*"7**%/69"2'E6>"<B*5"+**":$"90:"-056"+6$F*"r95$++s"7'5"+'(*"+F5/%%$"r('6*:s>"Z'0"501":$"*:*+"$62"($F*"+05*"-.$-":'0"$/6Y-"25*$(/69>"7$(Y"r7$(/%:sJ""<B/%"150-$%/-:>"('6*:"/+"-.*"5''-"'7"/->"U'E"-$F*"$E$:"10-"90:+"$5*"'6"-.*"+-5/4"('B/69"-.5'09."-./+"+./->"^$&F"-.*6"-.$-"E$+"(:"E$:"-'"9*-"+'(*"45'7/->"^0-"A"&.$69*2"(:"E$:>";/7*Y+"$"1/-&.>"/-"70&F+":'0"/7":'0Y5*"502*"-'"/-J""X'B*56(*6-"E$6-":'0-.+"'6"-.*"E$575'6->"8'"-.*"&'06-5:"&$6"9*-"+'(*"1*--*5"/6&'(*>"d.:"7/9.-"7'5"-.*"&'06-5:"-.$-"2'6Y-"E$6-"0+>"K*%%"(*"E.$-Y+":$"rms>""A6"-./+"F/692'("4/9+"r4'%/&*s"E$6-"-'"%'&F":'0"04"$62"-.5'E"$E$:"-.*"F*:>"K.$-"%/--%*"1/-"'7"4"r&$+.D*$56/69+s>"d*"4$:"-$C"-'"-.*"L0**6>"X'-"&$09.-"/6"-.*"&*%%"&'+"A"E$+"-5:/69"-'"('B*"+'(*"E**2>"A-Y+"E.$-"-.*"9'B*56(*6-"2'*+"-.$-"($F*+"0+"%/B*"-.*"%/7*"E*"%*$2J"T6*J"">#&=?0!701.C+$(;!"<$=0$!3@&!;/7*"&'(*"*$+:"E.*6"A"E$+"H0+-"$"F/2>"U'E"AY("+/--/69"1$&F"-./6F/69"E.:Y+"/-"9'6*"+./->"A"6*B*5"1**6"-.*"-:4*"'7"90:"-'"50%*"-.*"5'$2>"A"6*B*5"-'%2"'6*"4*5+'6"l&'(*"(:"4'+-&'2*n>""A7"-.*"1**7"r-5'01%*s"9*-+"(*++:"6'E$2$:+>"=*'4%*"-./6F"/-Y+"5/9.-"10-"-.*:"&$6Y-"*B*6"7/+-"7/9.->",62"-.*:"-./6F"/-Y+"6/&*>"+0&F":$"(0-.$"-E/&*>"K.*6":$"(0-.$"%/*+"$62"-*%%+":'0"/-Y+"9'66$"1*"$%5/9.-J""d.*6"E*"$%%"F6'E"7'5"$"7$&-"-.$-"/-"E'6Y->"#$6'5"/6":$"6'5-."5$-$-$-"E/-."6'"4.'6*>"`/2+"+6'5-/69"+6'E"r&'&$/6*s"E.*6"rms>"<B*5:1'2:Y+"'0-"7'5"-.*"2'*"r('6*:s>"6'"H'F*J""

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""e?"B%&+!<%C(!D1%3/"+.$5*+"+'(*"5.:-.(/&"$62"+01H*&-"($--*5"+/(/%$5/-/*+"E/-.";'EF*:Y+"+*&'62"$%10("

;%0(5,34$=!,%!,9+!;,30))1+!G?@!!IJ"

Page 179: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!MP"

"

K.*6"E*"+/-"1$&F"$62"&'-&."r5*%$Cs>"d$-&./69"-.*"F/2+"E/-."-.*"+-/&F+"/6"-.*/5"+'&F+>"d.$-"&$6"A"+$:i""K.*"E'5%2Y+"H0+-"&.$69*2>"AYB*"%'+-"$%%"(:"($-*+>"d*"E*6-"+*4$5$-*"E$:+J"">#&=?0!701.C+$(;!"<$=0$!3#=$$!8**"A"9'-"9%'5:"7'5"(:".'(*"-'E6>"^$&F"/6"-.*"*62a"r6*/9.1'05.''2s"A"E$+"5/44/69"95*:"r4'+-&'2*"&'%'05+s"7'5"UQK'E6>"^0-"AY("$1'0-"(:"(0+/&"$62"(:"4"r&$+FD*$56/69+s"6'E>"U'"-057"E$5+>"5/9.-"4$-.>"AY("+-**5/69"&%*$5"6'EJ""S'+"/7":'0"%/B*"1:"-.*"5'$2+>"-.*6":'0Y%%"2/*"1:"-.*"5'$2+>"^5$/6"($+.*2J"X*--/69"-$F*6"'B*5"1:"8$-$6>"U'"1'2:"/6"-.*"&*(*-*5:>"K.*5*"%*7-"'6"-.*"4$B*(*6->"8'0%"/6"-.*"+F:>"+.$F/69".$62+"E/-."-.*"4$9$6+"r+6$F*+D95$++*+D-.'+*"E/-."6'"('5$%"1*%'69/69sJ""8'"-*%%"(*".'E":'0"&$6"40-"-.*"WX5*$-Y"/6"^5/-$/6>"K.*"9'B*56(*6-"-''F"-.*"WX5*$-Y"$62"-.*"W7$F*Y"/6-'"^5/-$/6>"K.*:"+.'0%2"4$:"$--*6-/'6"-'"-.*"E'52+"-.$-"AYB*"E5/--*6>"8.'0%2"+**"-.*"4$/6"/6"-.*"%/7*"-.$-"E*Y5*"%/B/69J""S'+"/-Y+".$52"E.*6":'0"+**"$"('-.*5"&5:>"U'"('6*:"/6".*5"4'&F*-"$62"+**".*5"+-5099%*"1:>"8'":'0"-056"-'"-.*"5'$2+"-'"40-"7''2"'6"-.*"-$1%*>"Z'0"&$6"+**"E.:"-.*"&5/(*"/+"./9.>"K.*5*"$/6Y-"6'"4'/6-"/6"$+F/69"E.:J"">#&=?0!701.C+$(;!

"

K.*"-5$&F"($5F+"-.*"&'%%*&-/B*"H'056*:"'7"[4&'(/69"#'B*(*6-"+/6&*"-.*"5*%*$+*"'7"A'11!411!4!

>+&J"K.*:"6'-*"$"&'6+&/'0+"2*4$5-05*"75'("-.*"45'('-/'6"'7"-057"E$57$5*>"lS'+"/7":'0"%/B*"1:"

-.*"5'$2+>"-.*6":'0Y%%"2/*"1:"-.*"5'$2+nJ"T6*"'7"-.*"45'-$9'6/+-+"$&F6'E%*29*+"-.$-".*".$+"

6*B*5"1**6"&'(7'5-$1%*"E/-."-.$-"E$:"'7"%/7*"$6:E$:J"A6"-./+"E$:>"-.5'09."-.*/5"/6B*+-/9$-/'6"

'7".0($6"2*-$&.(*6-"-.*:".$B*"2*&/2*2"-'"%/B*"-.*/5"%/B*+"1*:'62"-./+"7'5("'7"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:J"

B%&+!<%C(!D1%3/!1$+*+"/-+"$6$%:+/+"'6"-.*".'5/a'6+"$B$/%$1%*"-'"-.*":'069"4*'4%*J";/F*"<'&+!'-!

"#>"-.*"$5-/+-+"$%%02*"-'"-.*"*C/+-*6&*"'7"+'(*"./9.*5"$0-.'5/-:"-.$-"9'B*56+"-.*"50%*+"$62"

*h0/%/15/0("'7"%/7*"$62"2*$-."g"-.$-"2*7/6*"-.*"70-05*J"K.*"%:5/&+"+-$-*"l+-$5/69"$-"-.*"&%'02+"9'-"

Page 180: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!V@"

"

(*"7**%/69"2'E6n"$62"l;/7*Y+"$"1/-&.>"/-"70&F+":'0"/7":'0Y5*"502*"-'"/-Jn"[6%/F*"-.*"$+4/5$-/'6$%"

:'069"E'(*6>"-.*"70-05*"/+"6'-"/6"-.*/5".$62+J"

"

A-"$%+'"2/77*5+"75'("-.*"B*5+/'6"'7"-.*"70-05*"40-"7'5E$52"/6"A'11!411!4!>+&@!A'11!411!4!>+&!7'&0+*+"

'6"$"-5$6+/-/'6"-'"$20%-.''2"g"$"+&.''%/69"'7"-.*"W:'069*5+Y"/6"-.*"E$:"'7"9$69+-*5"%/7*>"-.*"

*624'/6-"'7"E./&."/+"4$5-Q-/(*".0+-%*"$62"4$5-Q-/(*"%*/+05*J"B%&+!<%C(!D1%3/!('B*+"E*%%"

1*:'62"-./+"-'"7'&0+"'6"-.*"/6H0+-/&*+"'7"6*'Q%/1*5$%"&$4/-$%/+(>"E$5"$62"-.*"4'%/-/&$%"&%$++J"A-"

2*7/6*+"-.*"+-50&-05*+"$62"$&-'5+"-.$-"7'5*&%'+*"-.*/5".'5/a'6+J"A6"4$5-/&0%$5>"/-"/2*6-/7/*+"-.*"

45'1%*("'7"-.*"/62/B/20$%"405+0/-"'7"('6*:"/6"4%$&*+"%/F*"U*E.$("E.*5*"-.*5*"/+"6'-"*6'09."

E*$%-."-'"9'"$5'062J"K.*:"6'-*".'E"($(('6"2*+-5':+"-50+-"$62"75/*62+./4f"l<B/%"150-$%/-:>"

('6*:"/+"-.*"5''-"'7"/-n"$62"l<B*5"+**":$"90:"-056"+6$F*"r95$++s"7'5"+'(*"+F5/%%$"r('6*:snJ"

[4&'(/69"#'B*(*6-"5*7%*&-"'6".'E"95**2"$62"&'6+0(4-/'6>"&*6-5$%"-'"$2B$6&*2"&$4/-$%/+(>"

$5*"4*56/&/'0+J"K.5'09."-./+"45'&*++"'7"5*7%*C/B*"h0*+-/'6/69"-.*"$5-/+-+"'4*6"04"$"+4$&*"

1*:'62"-.*/5"2:+-'4/$+"7'5"$"('5*"&'6B/B/$%"7'5("'7"%/B/69"-.*:"2'"6'-"2*7/6*J"

"

K.*/5"&5/-/h0*"'7"6*'Q%/1*5$%"&$4/-$%/+("-.*6"*C-*62+"/6-'"$"2/+&0++/'6"'7"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6>"

/(4*5/$%/+("$62"./*5$5&./*+"'7"E*$%-."$62"4'E*5J"`*(4:"$+F+f"lX'B*56(*6-"E$6-":'0-.+"'6"

-.*"E$575'6->"+'"-.*"&'06-5:"&$6"9*-"+'(*"1*--*5"/6&'(*"D"d.:"7/9.-"7'5"-.*"&'06-5:"-.$-"2'6Y-"

E$6-"0+in"K./+"*C$(/6$-/'6"'7"/(4*5/$%"95**2"25$E+"'6"/2*$+"'7"&$66'6"7'22*5J"K./+"$6$%:+/+"'7"

2*$-."$62"/6&'(*>"-.5'09."E$5>"$62"/-+"&'66*&-/'6"-'"%'&$%"($59/6$%/+$-/'6>"/+"-.*6"*C-*62*2"

1:"-.*"$5-/+-+"/6-'"$"+*5/*+"'7"'1+*5B$-/'6+"'6".'E":'069"4*'4%*"%/F*"-.*(>"$5*"-5:/69"-'"9*-"1:>"

/6"+4/-*"'7"-.*"5/&."$62"4'E*570%J"K.*:"-$%F"$1'0-"-.*"6**2"-'"-5:"$62"l('B*"+'(*"E**2n"g"$"

(*$6+"'7"*$56/69"*&'6'(/&$%%:"$62"$&-/69"$9$/6+-"*&'6'(/&"2/+*675$6&./+*(*6->"10-"-.*:"

5*&'96/+*"-.*"&'6+*h0*6&*+"'7"2'/69"+'"$5*"9*--/69"%'&F*2"04J"K./+"/+"6'-"A'11!411!4!>+&Y+"

&*%*15$-/'6"'7"&5/(*>"10-"&5/(*"$+"$"(*$6+"'7"9*--/69"1:J"A6"-./+"E$:>"-.*:"$9$/6"6'-*"-.*"

&/5&0%$5/-:"'7"-.*"2$/%:"95/62"$62".'E"/-"/+"$%E$:+"750+-5$-*2"1:"-.*"45*+*6&*"'7"-.*"4'%/&*"E.'"

E$6-"-'"l%'&F":'0"04"$62"-.5'E"$E$:"-.*"F*:nJ"K./+"+*6+*"'7"750+-5$-/'6"$62"/6H0+-/&*"/+"-.*6"

&'(4'062*2"1:"-.*"F6'E%*29*"-.$-"/6"+4/-*"'7"$%%"-./+>"-.*:".$B*"-'"4$:"-$C"-'"-.*"L0**6"g"-.*"

*4/-'(*"'7"E*$%-.>"4'E*5"$62"&%$++"./*5$5&.:J"

"

K./+"2*-$/%*2"$6$%:+/+"'7"7'5*&%'+*2"70-05*+"/+"45*7/905*2"/6"-.*"&'6-*C-"'7"&'6-/60$%"%'&$%"

2*&%/6*"G2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"KE'IJ"K.*"$5-/+-+"2/+&0++".'E"-.*"9'B*56(*6-".$+"-$F*6"-.*"

lX5*$-n"'0-"'7"^5/-$/6"$62"40-"-.*"l7$F*n"/6-'"^5/-$/6J"K./+"&$6"1*"+**6"$+"$6"*C-*6+/'6"'7"

Page 181: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!V!"

"

$0-'&.-.'6:"$62"4'+-Q('2*56"6'+-$%9/$"$+"2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"KE'>"10-"/-"/+"$%+'"$6"

/62/&-(*6-"'7"-.*"7$/%05*+"'7"9'B*56(*6-"E/-."5*9$52"-'"E'5F/69Q&%$++":'069"4*'4%*J"K.*:"

*C45*++"-.*/5"6'+-$%9/$"7'5"1*--*5"E$:+"'7"%/7*"-.5'09."2/+&0++/69"-.*/5"'E6"&./%2.''2+"$62"

%$(*6-/69"-.*"B/'%*6&*"-.*:"+**"/6"&./%25*6"$5'062"-.*(J"]'5"-.*+*":'069"(*6>"&./%25*6"$%+'"

45'B/2*"5*45'20&-/B*"B*./&%*+"7'5"/($9/6/69"&05-$/%*2"70-05*"4'++/1/%/-/*+"G<2*%($6"?@@\IJ"

_'E*B*5>"E./%*"/-"/+"/(4'5-$6-"-'"5*&$%%"-.*"45*+*6&*"'7"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"/6"-.*+*"6$55$-/B*+>"

/-"/+"$%+'"/(4'5-$6-"-'"6'-*"-.*"7$/%05*"-'"(*6-/'6"-.*"'7-*6"01/h0/-'0+"*C4%$6$-'5:"B$5/$1%*"

W/((/95$-/'6YJ"A6+-*$2>"E./%*"-.*/5"062*5+-$62/69"'7"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"/+"&'62/-/'6*2"-.5'09."$"

%'&$%"./+-'5:"'7".05-"$62"7'5*&%'+*2"70-05*+>"-.*:"45'B/2*2"+'(*-./69"$445'$&./69"$"+'&/$%/+->"

6'-"$"C*6'4.'1/&>"$6$%:+/+"'7"/(4*5/$%"4'E*5"$62"6*'Q%/1*5$%"&'6-5$2/&-/'6J"

"

K.*"$&&'06-"/+"$%+'"4*5+'6$%J"K.*"+-'5/*+"'7"%/(/-*2"4'++/1/%/-/*+"$5*"95'062*2"/6"*B*5:2$:"

*C4*5/*6&*J"K.*:"2/+&0++".'E"4'B*5-:".$+"$77*&-*2"-.*/5"'E6"7$(/%/*+>"$62".'E"-.*/5"('-.*5Y+"

%/*"lr-.$-s"*B*5:-./69"/+"9'/69"-'"1*"$%5/9.-n"45'B/2*+"$"E*$F"$6$*+-.*-/&"-'"-.*/5"062*5+-$62/69"

'7"E.$-"/+"-'"&'(*J"_'E*B*5>"-.*"$6$%:+/+"/+"6'-"'6%:"7'5"-.*/5"'E6"+$F*+J"K.*"45'20&-/'6"

&'6-$/6+"$"E/2*5"+'%/2$5/-:"E/-."4*'4%*"/6"$"+/(/%$5"4'+/-/'6"E.'"2'"6'-".$B*"*6'09."('6*:"-'"

40-"7''2"'6"-.*"-$1%*J"K./+"&0%(/6$-*+"/6"$"4'%/-/&$%"(*++$9*"-'"-.'+*"/6"4'E*5J"8-*B'"2*($62+"

-.$-"-.*"9'B*56(*6-"+.'0%2"$&F6'E%*29*"l-.*"%/7*"-.$-"E*Y5*"%/B/69n"$62"-.*"+-5099%*"-.*:"$5*"

9'/69"-.5'09.J"_*"($F*+"-.*"4'%/-/&$%"$++*5-/'6"-.$-"-./+>"5$-.*5"-.$6":'069"4*'4%*Y+"4'B*5-:"'7"

$+4/5$-/'6>"/+"-.*"5*$+'6"E.:"&5/(*"/+"./9.J"

"

d./%*"-.*+*"45'20&-/'6+"2'"6'-"40-"7'5E$52"$".'5/a'6"'7"75**2'("g"$+"062*5+-''2"/6"$75'Q

70-05/+-"-*C-+"/6-5'20&*2"*$5%/*5eO"g"-.*:"+.'0%2"6'-"1*"2/+&$52*2"$+"$Q70-05$%"'5"$4'%/-/&$%J"

A6+-*$2"-.*:"$5*"$"6*9$-/B*"4'%/-/&+"'7"-.*"70-05*J"K.*+*"7'5(+"'7"70-05/-:"$5*"1$+*2"'6"-.*"

&5/-/h0*"'7"($59/6$%/+*2".'5/a'6+"$62"-.*"&'6-5$2/&-/'6+"'7"6*'Q%/1*5$%"+'&/*-:J"K.*:"45'B/2*"

-.*"1$+/+"75'("E./&."$%-*56$-/B*"70-05*+>"$62"75**2'(+>"$5*"/($9/6$1%*J"A62**2>"-.*5*"/+"

*B/2*6&*"-.$-"-.*"$5-/+-+".$B*"+-$5-*2"E'5F/69"'0-"-.*+*"$%-*56$-/B*+"-.5'09."-.*"+($%%"E$:+"/6"

E./&."-.*:".$B*"('2/7/*2"-.*/5"'E6"%/B*+"+'"$+"6'-"-'"&'67'5("-'"-.*"2'(/6$6-"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:"

'7"&$4/-$%/+-"+'&/*-:"g"5*H*&-/69"45'7/-"$62"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:"$+"E$:+"'7"%/7*J"A(4%/&/-"/6"-./+"/+"$"&$%%"

-'"'-.*5+"-'"2'"-.*"+$(*J"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""eO"8**f"30"^'/+"?@@M>"44JVQPj"<%%/+'6"!PPN>"?@@!j"<+.06"!PPV>"?@@Oj"]$6'6"!PP!j"X/%5':"!PPO>"4J\Mj"X/%5':"

?@@@>"44JO\!QO\Oj"#$:*5"?@@@j"#'-*6"?@@Oj"d5/9.-"!Pe\j"Z$+a*F"?@@eJ"

Page 182: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!V?"

"

"

U'6*"'7"-./+"/+"-'"+$:"-.$-"-.*"B/2*'+"2'"6'-"&'67'5("-'"'-.*5"7'5(+"'7"'445*++/'6J"K.*"B/2*'+"

$5*".*-*5'6'5($-/B*J"K.*:"0+*"-.*"7/905*"'7"-.*"E*$F>"2*7/%*2"$62"+$&5*2"('-.*5"-'"($F*"

-.*/5"&$+*J"K./+".*-*5'6'5($-/B*"/(40%+*"506+"$%'69+/2*"$6"$1+*6&*"'7"$6$%:+/+"'6"-.*"

6'+-$%9/&"4'%/-/&+"'7"%'++"-.*:"*69$9*"E/-.J"U'6*-.*%*++2"B%&+!<%C(!D1%3/!$62"<'&+!'-!"#"$5*"

4$5-"'7"$"5*7%*C/B*"4'%/-/&$%"45'H*&-"*C-*62/69"75'("A'11!411!4!>+&J"A6"-./+"45'H*&-"-.*"$5-/+-+"

h0*+-/'6"-.*"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"'7"-.*/5"70-05*+"$62"-.*"/6H0+-/&*+"E./&."5*+-5/&-"-.*/5"B/+/'6"'7"-.*"

-'Q&'(*J"A6"-./+"E$:>"-.*:"45'B/2*"$%-*56$-/B*".'5/a'6+"6'-"'6%:"7'5"-.*(+*%B*+"10-"/6"+'%/2$5/-:"

E/-."'-.*5+J"d./%*"-.*+*"$5*"6'-"-.*"0-'4/$+"E*".$2".*$52"'7>"-.*:"6'6*-.*%*++"&'6-$/6"-.*"

-5$6+&*62*6-$%"&5:"7'5"75**2'("$%1*/-"('2/7/*2"-'"$"&'6H06&-05*"'7"6*'Q%/1*5$%"1'2:"4'%/-/&+J"

S'6&%0+/'6"

K./+"&.$4-*5".$+"*C4%'5*2".'E":'069"4*'4%*"6*9'-/$-*2"$62"+*%7Q4'%/&*2"-.*/5".'5/a'6+"

-.5'09."2'(/6$6-"2/+&'05+*+"'7"W$+4/5$-/'6Y"$62"W4'B*5-:"'7"$+4/5$-/'6Y>"$62".'E"-.*:"

45'20&*2"$%-*56$-/B*"70-05*+"1*:'62"-./+"1/6$5:J"K.*"&.$4-*5".$+"$590*2"-.$-"U*E";$1'05Y+"

4'%/-/&+"'7"$+4/5$-/'6"&5*$-*2"$"+:+-*("/6"E./&.":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"($2*"4*5+'6$%%:"

5*+4'6+/1%*"7'5"-.*/5"'E6"+0&&*++*+"$62"7$/%05*+J",+4/5$-/'6"E$+"2**(*2"$"6$-05$%"*('-/'6"

$62"-.*5*7'5*"4*'4%*"2*-*5(/6*2"-'".$B*"%'E"$+4/5$-/'6+"E*5*"2**(*2"066$-05$%J"K.*+*"

$+&5/4-/'6+"E*5*"5$&/$%/+*2"$62"&%$++*2J"K.*:"E*5*"2*B*%'4*2"-.5'09."$"<05'&*6-5/&"./+-'5:"'7"

_*9*%/$6"45'95*++"g"$+"E./-*"$62"(/22%*Q&%$++"70-05/-:J"K./+"E$+"+/(0%-$6*'0+%:"&'6+-/-0-*2"

-.5'09."2*7/6/69"_*9*%/$6"70-05*%*++"70-05*+J",-"-.*"%*B*%"'7"-.*"*B*5:2$:>":'069"4*'4%*>"

($59/6$%/+*2"75'("$+4/5$-/'6$%"70-05*+>"+*%7Q4'%/&*2"-.5'09."2'(/6$6-"2/+&'05+*+"'7"-.*/5"'E6"

70-05*"7$/%05*J"K.*+*"7'5(+"'7"+*%7Q4'%/&/69"5*%$-*2"-'"-.*/5"*C4*5/*6&*"'7"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"75'("

-.*"E./-*"(/22%*Q&%$++"*20&$-/'6$%g45'7*++/'6$%g&'6+0(*5"-5$H*&-'5:>"10-"$%+'"-'"$"./+-'5:"'7"

%'++"/6"-.*"%'&$%"$5*$J"R066/69"-.5'09."-.*+*"($59/6$%/+*2"$62"$+4/5$-/'6$%"70-05*+"E*5*"

+4*&/7/&"6*9'-/$-/'6+"'7"5$&*"$62"9*62*5J"K.*"$+4/5$-/'6$%":'069"E'(*6"E'5F*2"'0-"$"B*5+/'6"

'7"4'+-Q7*(/6/6*"7*(/6/6/-:"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"-.$-"-.*:"6*9'-/$-*2",%1$6/$6"9*62*5"5'%*+J"

K.5'09."-./+"45'&*++>"-.*:"7'59*2"$"E./-*6*2"(/22%*Q&%$++"B*5+/'6"'7"-./+"7*(/6/6/-:"1:"2/+Q

/2*6-/7:/69"-.*(+*%B*+"75'("E'5F/69Q&%$++"^5/-/+."$62",%1$6/$6"4'+/-/'6$%/-/*+J"K.*"&'6-*C-"7'5"

-./+"E$+"+*&05/69"$&&*++"-'"*20&$-/'6"$62"70-05*"&'6+0(4-/'6J"K.*":'069"(*6"$62"E'(*6"

($59/6$%/+*2"75'("-.*+*"2/+&'05+*+"$%+'"$++*5-*2"-.*/5"E./-*6*++"-'"+*&05*"-.*/5"'E6"

45*&$5/'0+"70-05*+"10-"2/2"+'"-.5'09."2/+Q/2*6-/7:/69"-.*(+*%B*+"75'("/((/95$6-+J"_'E*B*5>"$-"

Page 183: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!VO"

"

-.*"+$(*"-/(*"-.$-":'069"4*'4%*"6*9'-/$-*2"$+4/5$-/'6$%"$62"7'5*&%'+*2".'5/a'6+>"-.*:"$%+'"

45'20&*2"$%-*56$-/B*"70-05*+J"K.*+*"E*5*"6'-"0-'4/$6"10-"6*9$-/B*"$62"4'%/-/&$%"/6"&.$5$&-*5J"

K.5'09."$"+*5/*+"'7"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+"-.*:"5*7%*&-*2"'6"-.*"/6H0+-/&*"'7"-.*/5"7'5*&%'+*2"

.'5/a'6+>"1*&$(*"4'%/-/&$%%:"&'6+&/'0+>"$62"'4*6*2"04"+4$&*+"7'5"-.*(+*%B*+"E/-."'-.*5+"-'"

/($9/6*"$%-*56$-/B*"-'Q&'(*+J"

"

A6"-.*"&'6&%02/69"&.$4-*5>"A"15/69"-'9*-.*5"-.*"-.*(*+"'7"(0%-/&0%-05*>"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"

4'%/-/&+"&'6-$/6*2"/6"-./+"&.$4-*5"$62"-.*"5*+-"'7"-.*"-.*+/+J"]'%%'E/69"$"+0(($5:"'7"-.*"($/6"

$590(*6-+>"-.*"&'6&%0+/'6"/2*6-/7/*+"-.*"4'%/-/&$%"/(4*5$-/B*"'7"&'6-/60/69"-'"*69$9*"E/-."-.*"

-.*(*+>"$62"5*+-$-*+"/-+"&'((/-(*6-"-'"*-.6'95$4.:"$+"$"(*-.'2"E./&."&$6"$225*++"$62"

*69$9*"4'%/-/&$%%:"E/-."+'&/$%"/6H0+-/&*+J"

Page 184: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!V\"

"

S'6&%0+/'6+"$62"4'%/-/&$%"*626'-*+"

;*$B/69";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01"E$+"$6"*('-/'6$%"*C4*5/*6&*>"2/+-/6&-"75'("-.*"7'5($%/-/*+"$-"-.*"

,7-*5"8&.''%"S%01"$62"-.*"+%'E"25'4Q'77"$-"-.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."X5'04J"A".$2"1*&'(*"&'66*&-*2"

-'"-.*":'069"4*'4%*>":'0-."E'5F*5+"$62"/6+-/-0-/'6"/6"$"E$:"A".$2"6'-"*C4*&-*2J"K./+"E$+"4$5-%:"

$&&'06-*2"7'5"1:"-.*".'05+"A"+4*6-"-.*5*"g"'B*5"-E/&*"$+"($6:"$+"-.*"'-.*5"+/-*+"g"$62"4$5-%:"

1*&$0+*"'7"-.*"5*%$-/'6+./4+"A".$2"10/%->"10-"$%+'"1*&$0+*"'7"-.*"/6Q2*4-.>"%'69Q-*5("

$++'&/$-/'6+"-.*"+-$77"$62":'069"4*'4%*".$2"E/-."*$&."'-.*5>"$62"E/-."-.*"$5*$J"_'E*B*5>"(:"

*('-/B*"2*4$5-05*"E$+"$%+'"$"5*$&-/'6"-'"+4*&/7/&"&.$%%*69*+"7$&/69"-.*":'0-."&%01"/6"E./&."A"

.$2"1*&'(*"*(15'/%*2J"S0-1$&F+"/6"7062/69".$2"45'4*%%*2"+-$77"(*(1*5+"/6-'"$"7/5*7/9.-"

&.$5$&-*5/+*2"1:"/6&5*$+/69"$--*62$6&*"$62"5*20&*2"4*5+'66*%"$62"*h0/4(*6-J"A6"$6".'6*+-"

$--*(4-"-'"F**4"-.*":'0-."&%01"+$7*>"$"+./7-"75'("9'B*56/69"-.5'09."&'6+*6-"-'"9'B*56/69"

-.5'09."7'5&*".$2"-$F*6"4%$&*J"K.*"4'%/&*".$2"1*&'(*"('5*"&%'+*%:"/6B'%B*2>":'069"4*'4%*"

E*5*"$55*+-*2"'0-+/2*"-.*"9$-*+"$62"1:"-.*"-/(*"A"%*7-"$"W1'06&*5Y".$2"1**6"./5*2J"K./+"

*(4%':(*6-"'7"($+&0%/6*"7'5&*"E$+"5*+/+-*2"/6"F/62"1:"-.*":'069"4*'4%*>"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+"

E*5*"-.5*$-*6*2"$62"45'4*5-:"+-'%*6J"8-/%%"6**2/69"-.*/5"*/9.-"4'062+"$6".'05>"+'(*"+*++/'6$%"

:'0-."E'5F*5+"2/+&0++*2"E.*-.*5"-.*:"+.'0%2"E*$5"+-$1QB*+-+"'5"./2*"/6"-.*"F/-&.*6"7'5"-.*"

205$-/'6"'7"-.*"+*++/'6+J",+"-.*"('+-"4.:+/&$%%:"/(4'+/69"(*(1*5"'7"-.*"+-$77"-*$(>"$62"-.*"

'6*"-.$-"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"('+-"5*+4*&-*2>"d/%%"E$+"&$%%*2"04'6"-'"+-*4"04>"$62"/6"+'"2'/69".*"

&$(*"-'"*(1'2:"-.*"6*E"5*9/(*J",+"-.*"2'E6E$52"-056"&'6-/60*2".*"1*&$(*"-.*"-$59*-"'7"

2/5*&-"$62"/62/5*&-"/6-/(/2$-/'6"1:"+'(*"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*J"d.*6"d/%%"2*4$5-*2>"./+"$1+*6&*"

%*7-"-.*"5*+-"'7"0+"+-5099%/69"'5"06E/%%/69"-'"+01+-/-0-*"7'5"./+"%'+-"45*+*6&*J"

"

,+"-.*+*"+/-0$-/'6+"45'95*++*2>"A"+-$5-*2"-'"&'6+/2*5".'E"(0&."%'69*5"A"E'0%2"+-$:J"A".$2"

&'%%*&-*2"$%%"-.*"($-*5/$%"A"E'0%2"*B*5"1*"$1%*"-'"$6$%:+*"/6"(:"5*($/6/69":*$5+"'6"-.*"=.3"

45'95$((*"$62"('+-"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"A".$2"'5/9/6$%%:"9'-"-'"F6'E".$2"%*7->"10-"$-"-.*"

+$(*"-/(*"A"E$+"5*%0&-$6-"-'"9'J"K.*6"'6*"$7-*56''6>"$7-*5"$6'-.*5"+4$-*"'7"-5'01%*>"A"

&'67/5(*2"-'"U*/%"E.$-"A"-./6F".*"$%5*$2:"F6*EJ"A".$2".$2"*6'09.J",-"-./+"4'/6->"A".$2"1**6"$-"

;*:.$("7'5"-E'":*$5+>"$62"E./%*"A".$2"1**6"-.*5*"%'69"*6'09."-'"9*-"*('-/'6$%%:"/6B'%B*2>"

+'&/'%'9/&$%%:"A"E$+"'6%:"+&5$-&./69"-.*"+057$&*J"

"

Page 185: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!VN"

"

]'5"$"-/(*"$7-*5"A"%*7->"A"E$+"06$1%*"-'"*+&$4*"-.*"*('-/'6+"A"7*%-"/6"-.'+*"7/6$%"2$:+J"K.*"90/%-"$-"

%*$B/69>"&'(1/6*2"E/-."-.*"B0%6*5$1/%/-:"A".$2"7*%->"%*2"(*"2'E6"7$-$%/+-/&"$B*60*+J"A"E$+"

'B*5E.*%(*2"1:"-.*"B/'%*6&*>"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:"$62"($+&0%/6/+$-/'6"'7"-.'+*"2*4$5-/69"

('(*6-+J",-"-.*"-/(*>"A"70%%:"062*5+-''2"-.*"2'(/6$6-"&'2/69"'7":'069"4*'4%*Y+"$&-/'6+"$+"

6/./%/+-/&"1*&$0+*"-.'+*"E*5*"-.*"&'6&%0+/'6+"A"E$+"25$E/69"(:+*%7J"A-"E$+"'6%:"$7-*5"9'/69"1$&F"

'B*5"-.5**":*$5+Y"*-.6'95$4./&"($-*5/$%"g"7/*%2"6'-*+>"/6-*5B/*E+"$62"B/2*'+"g"$62"-./6F/69"

('5*"15'$2%:"$1'0-";*:.$("$62"-.*"'-.*5":'0-."&%01+>"-.$-"+'"($6:"('5*"+'062+"5*Q

*(*59*2J"A-"E$+".*5*>"-.5'09."$%%'E/69"-.*"*-.6'95$4.:"-'"+4*$F>"-.$-"(:"/((*2/$-*"

*('-/'6+"E*5*"&'6-*C-0$%/+*2"$62"-.*"($6:"'-.*5"B'/&*+"-.$-"&'(45/+*2"-.*"*-.6'95$4.:"5*Q

+057$&*2J"

"

K.*+*"+%'E%:"*(*59/69"B'/&*+"1*&$(*"95'04*2"/6-'"-.*"7'05"+01+-$6-/B*"&.$4-*5+"A".$B*"

45*+*6-*2J"S.$4-*5"KE'"'6"WE./-*6*++>"%'++"$62"2/$+4'5$"(6*('6/&+Y"2*B*%'4*2"75'(":'069"

4*'4%*Y+"&'66*&-/'6+"-'"2/77*5*6-"4$+-+J"A-"2/+&0++*2".'E":'069"4*'4%*"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+"

-5$&*2"4$+-+"'B*5"'-.*5"4$+-+>"$62"E.$-"E$+"$-"+-$F*"/6"-./+"W95*$-"-/(*Y"'7"(*('5:"45$&-/&*J"

<69$9/69"E/-."$"-.*'5*-/&$%"75$(/69"-.$-"15'09.-"-'9*-.*5"&'%%*&-/B*"G_$%1E$&.+"!PP?j"R/&u05"

?@@\I>"2/$+4'5/&"GX/%5':"!PPOI>"2/$%'9/&"G^$F.-/6"!PVe1I"$62"4*57'5($-/B*"G-5$&/69I"G^*66*--"

?@@Nj"3*55/2$"!PMej"84/B$F"!PMeI"$445'$&.*+"-'"(*('5:>"/-"+.'E*2".'E"-.'+*"(*('5:"

45$&-/&*+"/6"&'6-*(4'5$5:"U*E.$(>"1*/69"7$5"75'("4*5($6*6-"'5"'6%:"1$+*2"'6"$"45'H*&-/'6"

'7"-.*"45*+*6->"E*5*"4$5-"'7"$"%'69"./+-'5:"'7"-5$&/69>"5*6*E/69"$62"+0445*++/69"(*('5/*+J"

"

K.5'09."$"2/+&0++/'6"'7"-.*"(/95$-'5:"$62"&0%-05$%"./+-'5:"'7"U*E.$(>"S.$4-*5"KE'"*C4%'5*2"

.'E"-.*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"'7"U*E.$("E*5*"6'-"'6%:"1$+*2"'6"-.*"(:-.+"'7"$"E./-*".'(*%$62"

10-"$%+'"25*E"'6"E/2*5"2/$+4'5/&"$62"6'+-$%9/&"7'5($-/'6+J"T6"-./+"1$+/+>"/-"$225*++*2"-.*"

+'&/'%'9/&$%>"4'%/-/&$%"$62"4'40%$5Q&0%-05*"/6B*+-(*6-+"/6"E./-*"<$+-"<62"-*55$/6+"G_/%%"!PMej"

_'11+"!PVVj"Z'069"$62"d/%%('--"!PNMI"6'-/69".'E"-.*+*"2/+&'05+*+>"$%'69+/2*"$"%'&$%"$62"

6$-/'6$%"5*Q*(4.$+/+"'6"E./-*6*++"G^%0*";$1'05"?@!?j"X%$+($6"?@!!j"_'29*"?@@MI>".$2"

*6H':*2"$"5*B/B$%"G3*6&."*-"$%J"?@@ej"_'11+"?@@eI>"$62".'E"-./+"5*B/B$%"&'0%2"1*"062*5+-''2"$+"

$"&'(1/6$-/'6"'7"$"(*%$6&.'%/&"&'6H06&-05*"$62"$"%$&F"'7"45'(/6*6-"$%-*56$-/B*"$&&'06-+J"

"

<69$9/69"E/-."W$0-'&.-.'6:Y"GX*+&./*5*"?@@Pj"#''5*"?@@Vj"Z0B$%Q3$B/+"?@!?I"g"-.*"&'6&*4-"'7"

1*%'69/69"-'"-.*"*$5-."g"$+"$"('5*"($%%*$1%*"75$(/69"7'5"45$&-/&*+"'7"4*5($6*6&*"/6"T0-*5"

<$+-";'62'6>"S.$4-*5"KE'"-056*2"-'"-.*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"'7":'0-."E'5F*5+"$62":'069"4*'4%*"

Page 186: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!Ve"

"

-'"$225*++".'E"6'+-$%9/$+"($2*"+*6+*"'7"%'++>"06&*5-$/6-:"$62"($59/6$%/+$-/'6J"A-"2/+&0++*2"

.'E"/6"-.*+*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+>"$+"/6"'-.*5"+-02/*+"G^$6-'6"!PNNj"_0(4.5/*+"!PV!j")'6*+"

!PM!j"R/&.('62"!PN\I>"/((/95$6-+"E*5*"1%$(*2"7'5"2*&%/6*J"#'B/69"2**4*5"/6-'"-.*+*"(:-.+"

/-"*C4%'5*2".'E"-.*+*"2/+&'05+*+"'7"E./-*"$0-'&.-.'6'0+"1*%'69/69"E*5*"6'-"$--$&.*2"-'"

E./-*"1'2/*+"10-"E*5*"7%'$-/69"+/96/7/*5+"G_$%%"!PPeI"-.$-"$--$/6*2"(*$6/69"-.5'09."45'&*++*+"

'7"W1*&'(/69"E./-*Y"G^'66*--"?@@@j"U*E/-a"!PPMj"R'*2/9*5"?@@Mj"d5$:"?@@eIJ"A-"6'-*2".'E"

-.*+*"45'&*++*+"E*5*"-$F*6"04"$62"5*($2*"1:"1%$&F>",+/$6>"A5/+.>"R'($6:"$62"S$6$2/$6"

4*'4%*"A"E'5F*2"E/-.J"K./+"2/2"6'-"/(4%:"-.$-"-.*"(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"'7"1%$&F"$62",+/$6":'0-."

E'5F*5+"E*5*"-.*"+$(*"$+"-.*/5"E./-*"&'06-*54$5-+>"10-"/-"2/2"+.'E"-.$-"E./%*"&'6-*(4'5$5:"

5$&/+("+-/%%"*6+05*2"2/77*5*6-/$-/'6"$%'69"$C*+"'7"4'E*5>"1*%'69/69"$62"C*6'4.'1/$"E*5*"$%+'"

'4*6"-'"$445'45/$-/'6"$62"5*Q0+*"$&5'++"+044'+*2"5$&/$%"1'062$5/*+J"

"

K.*"&.$4-*5"*62*2"E/-."$"2/+&0++/'6"'7".'E"(*('5/*+"'7"4.$6-'("E./-*".'(*+"+/%*6&*2"

G^$F.-/6"!PVe1j"U/*-a+&.*"!PVOI"'5"7'59'-"GS'66*5-'6"?@@PI"'-.*5"2/$+4'5/&"(*('5/*+"/6"

U*E.$(J"A6"F**4/69"E/-."-.*"&'6&*4-0$%/+$-/'6"'7"2/$+4'5$"0+*2"-.5'09.'0-"-.*"-.*+/+>"

2/$+4'5$"(6*('6/&+"E*5*"*C4%'5*2"-.5'09."(/95$-/'6"G^5$."!PPeI"$62"-.5'09."&0%-05$%"7%'E+"

GX/%5':"!PPOIJ"K.*"&.$4-*5"2*('6+-5$-*2".'E"2/$+4'5$"(6*('6/&+"E*5*"&'6+-/-0*6-"7*$-05*+"

'7"-.*"1'5'09.J"A-"$225*++*2".'E"'-.*5"6$-/'6$%"6'+-$%9/$+"*C/+-*2"$%'69+/2*"$0-'&.-.'6:J"

#'B/69"1*:'62"-.*"6$-/'6"$62"*-.6/&"75$(/69"'7"(*('5:"/-"$%+'"+.'E*2".'E":'069"4*'4%*"

%/B*2"$62"+.$5*2"'-.*5"4*'4%*Y+"(*('5/*+"/6"E$:+"-.$-"&'670+*2"%'&$%"$62"6$-/'6$%"./*5$5&./*+"

'7"1*%'69/69"Gd*(:++"?@@VIJ"K.5'09."+'%/2$5/-/*+"E/-."5*709**+"$62"(/95$6-+"-'"-.*"*B*5:2$:"

2/+%'&$-/'6+"'7"2/$+4'5$"+4$&*>"6$-/'6$%"./*5$5&./*+"E*5*"2/+/6B*+-*2J"A6"-./+"E$:>"6$-/'6$%"

(*('5:"45$&-/&*+"1*&$(*"+.$5*2>"4%$:70%"$62"'4*6"5$-.*5"-.$6"&'675'6-$-/'6$%"$62"5$6F*2J"

K.*"&.$4-*5"$%+'"+.'E*2".'E"2/$+4'5$"(6*('6/&+"*B/2*6-"/6"-.*"*B*5:2$:"45$&-/&*+"'7":'069"

4*'4%*"&.$%%*69*2"-.*"(:-.+"'7"-.*"X'%2*6"<5$"$62"45'B/2*2"-.*"1$+/+"-'"*C4%'5*"('5*"

9*60/6*%:"2/$+4'5/&"E$:+"'7"5*(*(1*5/69J"

"

S.$4-*5"K.5**"2*B*%'4*2"-./+"2/+&0++/'6"'7"%'++"$62"E./-*6*++"-.5'09."$6"$6$%:+/+"'7"

&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"-*55/-'5/$%"&'6-5'%"/6"$62"$5'062";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01J"]5$(*2"-.5'09."$"

&'6&*56"7'5":'069"4*'4%*Y+"75**2'("-'"0+*"$62"45'20&*"401%/&"+4$&*"G^*5($6"!PVej"_$5B*:"

?@@Vj"A+/6"?@@@j"`'7($6"$62";*1$+"!PPej";*7*1B5*"!PPej"#$5&0+*"?@@Pj"#*55/7/*%2"?@!!j"

#/-&.*%%"!PPNj"8'H$"?@!@I>"-.*"&.$4-*5"25*E"$--*6-/'6"-'"-.*"(0%-/Q+&$%*"4'%/-/&+"'7"-*55/-'5:"/6"

U*E.$("G_$5B*:"!PVP$>"?@@@j")'6$+"!PP\j";*7*1B5*"!PP!j"8'H$"!PPej"8E:69*2'0E"!PPM>"

Page 187: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!VM"

"

?@@@j"K.5/7-"!PPMIJ"A6"-./+"E$:>"/-"2*('6+-5$-*2".'E"6$-/'6$%>"%'&$%"$62"/6+-/-0-/'6$%"+&$%*+"

/6-*5+*&-*2"-'"($6$9*"-.*".*-*5'9*6*/-:"'7";*:.$("1:"4'%/&/69"$62"&5/(/6$%/+/69":'069"

4*'4%*Y+"0+*"'7"401%/&"+4$&*"G^*5($6"!PVej";*7*1B5*"!PPej"8*66*--"!PPOIJ"

"

K.*"&.$4-*5"./9.%/9.-*2"-.$-"E./%*"-*55/-'5:".$+"1**6"$"5*&055/69"&'6+/2*5$-/'6"/6"-.*"+-02:"'7"

:'069"4*'4%*"G,%*C$62*5"?@@@j"^$&F"!PP\j"R'1/6+"!PP?j"d/%%('--"!PePI>"/-".$+"%*++"'7-*6"GE/-."

-.*"*C&*4-/'6"'7"R'1/6+"$62"S'.*6"!PMVI"$225*++*2".'E"-.*"&.$69/69"4'%/-/&$%"9*'95$4./*+"/6"

$62"$5'062"-.*":'0-."&%01"5*%$-*"-'"+./7-/69"7'5(+"'7"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"-*55/-'5/$%"9'B*56$6&*"

/6"-.*"%'&$%"$5*$J"<69$9/69"E/-."($+&0%/6*"7'5(+"'7"-*55/-'5/$%"6*9'-/$-/'6"G#$5+-'6"?@@@j"

#&3'E*%%"!PPPj"=*$5+'6"!PVOj"R'+*"!PPOj"K'6F/++"?@@eI"$62"$+"4$5-"'7"$"E/2*5"+:+-*("'7"

-*55/-'5/$%"&'6-5'%>"/-"*C4%'5*2".'E"E./-*6*++"$62"'52*5"G2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"KE'I>"1%$&F6*++"

$62"&.$'+"$62"'-.*5"5$&/$%/+*2"$++'&/$-/'6+"'7"/6+/2*"$62"'0-+/2*"7*2"/6-'"%'&$%"-*55/-'5/$%"

9'B*56$6&*J"

"

A-"$%+'"*C4%'5*2".'E"-.*+*"7'5(+"'7"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"'52*5"2/77*5*2"75'("E.$-".$2"&'(*"

1*7'5*J"K.5'09."$"2/+&0++/'6"'7"4$5-6*5+./4"E'5F/69"$62"-.*"5'%%Q'0-"'7"-.*"E*%7$5*"+-$-*"

G^5*66*5"$62"K.*'2'5*"?@@?j"S/B/%"R*6*E$%"[6/-"?@@\j"_#"X'B*56(*6-"?@@Oj")*++'4"?@@?j"

=*&F"$62"K/&F*%%"?@@?I>"-.*"&.$4-*5"5*B*$%*2".'E"-.*"4'%/&/69"'7"-.*"+-5**-+".$2"*6-*5*2"-.*"

:'0-."&%01>"1%055/69"'%2*5"2/+-/6&-/'6+"1*-E**6"2/+'52*5"$62"'52*5>"$62"2$69*5"$62"+$7*-:J"

3*B*%'4/69"-./+"$6$%:+/+"/-"2*('6+-5$-*2".'E"-.*"&0-+"/6"401%/&"7062/69".$2"*C$&*51$-*2"-.*"

/67%0*6&*"'7"-.*"4'%/&*"/6"-.*":'0-."&%01>"%*$2/69"-'"95*$-*5"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"'7":'069"4*'4%*J"A-"

$%+'"+.'E*2".'E"-.*+*"45'&*++*+"&'/6&/2*2"E/-."-.*"2*B*%'4(*6-"'7";*:.$("$+"$"6*'Q

&'((06/-$5/$6"/6+-/-0-/'6"G=*&F"$62"K/&F*%%"?@@?j"=*&F"?@@?j"=05&*%%"?@@Oj"8E:69*2'0E"

?@@@IJ"

"

^0/%2/69"'6"-.*"2/+&0++/'6"'7"-.*"5'%%Q'0-"'7"-.*"E*%7$5*"+-$-*>"-.*"&.$4-*5"*C4%'5*2".'E"-.*"

:'0-."&%01Y+"6*'Q&'((06/-$5/$6/+("E$+"&'6+-50&-*2"-.5'09."-.*"4'E*5"45'B/2*2"-'"/-"$+"$"

2*&*6-5$%/+*2"('5$%"9'B*56'5"'7"%'&$%"-*55/-'5:J"A-"$225*++*2".'E";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01Y+"6*'Q

&'((06/-$5/$6/+("E$+"7'5(*2"/6"&'6H06&-/'6"E/-."/2*'%'9/*+"'7"2/+'52*5"5*%$-/69"-'"(*('5/*+"

$62"(*2/$"/($9*+"'7"&.$'-/&":'069"4*'4%*"$62"-'"/2*$+"'7"'52*5"5*%$-/69"-'"$0-'&.-.'6'0+"

75$(/69+"'7"1*%'69/69"G*C4%'5*2"/6"S.$4-*5"KE'IJ"A-"705-.*5"$225*++*2".'E"-.*+*"2/+&05+/B*"

7'5($-/'6+"'7"'52*5"$62"2/+'52*5"E*5*"*695$/6*2"-.5'09."+4*&/7/&"+*&05/-:"$62"+05B*/%%$6&*"

45$&-/&*+"1'-."$-"-.*"4*5/(*-*5"$62"/6+/2*"-.*":'0-."&%01J",+"-.*"5*$%"$62"(*-$4.'5/&$%"7*6&*+"

Page 188: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!VV"

"

E*6-"04>";*:.$("$2'4-*2"-.*"(*6-$%/-:"'7"$"7*6&*2"&'((06/-:"&'6+-50&-/69"/-+*%7"-.5'09."/-+"

/6+*&05/-/*+"G,6a$%2t$"?@@Mj"^%$F*%:"$62"86:2*5"!PPPj"^5'E6"?@!@j";'E"?@@Oj"R'+*"$62"#/%%*5"

?@@Vj"8*66*--"!PPOIJ"

"

_'E*B*5>"-.*"&.$4-*5"7'&0+*2"6'-"'6%:"'6"-.*"7'5(+"'7"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6>"+'&/$%"$62"-*55/-'5/$%"

&'6-5'%"*6$&-*2"1:"-.*"4'%/&*"$62":'0-."&%01>"10-"$%+'"*C4%'5*2".'E":'069"4*'4%*"5*+/+-*2"

-.*+*"45$&-/&*+J"K.*"&.$4-*5"2/+&0++*2".'E":'069"4*'4%*"&'675'6-*2"-.*"4'%/&*>"&'670+*2"

+'&/$%"$62"-*55/-'5/$%"'52*5"$62"+.'E*2"+'%/2$5/-:"$9$/6+-"+:+-*(+"'7"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6J"d./%*"

+'(*"'7"-.*+*"7'5(+"'7"5*+/+-$6&*"(*5*%:"&'67/5(*2"-.*"4'E*5"'7"-.*"4'%/&*>"'-.*5+"&'670+*2"

-.*"1/'4'%/-/&+"G]'0&$0%-"?@@OI"$62"-*55/-'5/$%"'52*5"-.*"4'%/&*"0-/%/+*2"-'"9'B*56"-.*"%'&$%"

-*55$/6J"

"

]/6$%%:>"-.*"&.$4-*5"$%+'"-056*2"-'"-.*"(/&5'"-'"$225*++".'E":'069"4*'4%*"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+"

4$5-/&/4$-*2"/6"-.*"6*9'-/$-/'6"$62"9'B*56$6&*"'7"-*55/-'5:"-.5'09."7'5(+"'7"+4**&.>"1$6-*5"

$62"5/2/&0%*"G^$F.-/6"!PV\>"^$F.-/6"!PVe$j"^0-%*5"!PPMj";$1'B"!PM?j"R'1/6+"$62"S'.*6"!PMVj"

8(/-.*5($6"?@@MIJ"T4*6/69"04"-.*"(/&5'"$+"$"%*B*%"'7"$6$%:+/+"5*B*$%*2".'E"-.*"/6+/2*+"$62"

'0-+/2*+"'7"-*55/-'5/$%"'52*5"E*5*"('5*"2/$%'9/&"-.$6"(*+'Q%*B*%"$&&'06-+"5*B*$%*2J",225*++/69"

-.*"$1+*6&*"'7"-.*"(/&5'"/6"2/+&0++/'6+"'7"4'%/-/&$%"9*'95$4./*+>"-.*"&.$4-*5"+.'E*2".'E"-.*"

(/&5'Q+'&/'%'9/&$%"2*7/6/69"$62"5*Q($F/69"'7"75/*62+./4"95'04+>"$1H*&-"1'2/*+"$62"5$&/$%/+*2"

/2*$+"'7"1*%'69/69"$62"*C&%0+/'6"5*%$-*2"-'"%'&$%"$62"6$-/'6$%"+&$%*+"'7"-*55/-'5/$%"4'%/-/&+"10-"

$%+'"-'"45$&-/&*+"'7"+*C0$%/-:"$62"*+-**(J"K.*"2/+&0++/'6"'7"-.*"(/&5'"$%+'"*6$1%*2"-.*"&.$4-*5"

-'"*C4%'5*".'E":'069"4*'4%*"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+"$%/F*"E*5*"/6B'%B*2"/6"&'6+-$6-"45$&-/&*+"'7"

+*--/69"$62"-5$6+95*++/69"5*90%$-/'6+>"$62"-'"+**".'E"-./+"062*5%:/69"B*56$&0%$5"&'0%2"

7$&/%/-$-*".$1/-0$%"*h0/%/15/0("G#*5%*$0Q='6-:"!PVPI"'5"-.*"+%'E"15*$F2'E6"'7"'52*5J"TB*5$%%>"

/6"-.*"&'6-*C-"'7"-.*"401%/&"+4*62/69"&0-+"$62"-.*"5'%%Q'0-"'7"-.*"E*%7$5*"+-$-*>"-.*"&.$4-*5"

+.'E*2"$-"2/77*5*6-"+&$%*+".'E"-*55/-'5/$%"06Q75**2'(+"E*5*"*C$&*51$-*2"$+"7062/69"E$+"

5*20&*2>"4'%/&/69"E$+"/6&5*$+*2"$62"45$&-/&*+"'7"6*'Q&'((06/-$5/$6"45'-*&-/'6/+("$62"

1*%'69/69"E*5*"/6B*+-*2"/6J"K./+"/(4%/*2"$6"/6&5*$+/69"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"'7":'069"4*'4%*"10-"$%+'"

$6"04-056"/6"45$&-/&*+"-.$-"+'09.-"-'"2/+-/690/+."-*55/-'5:"'6"5$&/$%/+*2"95'062+J"

"

S.$4-*5"]'05"*C4%'5*2".'E":'069"4*'4%*Y+"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+"E*5*"&'62*(6*2"/6"2'(/6$6-"

2/+&'05+*"$62"/6"-.*":'0-."&%01"$+"+'%2Q'0-"$62"6/./%/+-/&"G,%*C$62*5"!PPej"^$0($6"?@!!j"X/%5':"

!PVM>"!PPO>"?@@@j"_$%%"*-"$%J"!PMVj"_$6&'C"?@@Pj")$(*+'6"!PV\j")$(*+'6"!PP!j"`/-E$6$"?@@?j"

Page 189: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!VP"

"

;'EF*:"?@!?j"=*$5+*"$62"K$:%'5"?@@Pj"8-$5F*:"?@!!I"$62".'E"-.*+*"2*%*9/-/(/+/69"2/+&'05+*+"

+/%*6&*2":'069"4*'4%*Y+"$&-+"'7"401%/&"&'((06/&$-/'6"GS$%.'06"!PP?j"]5$+*5"?@@Mj"X/%5':"

!PPOj"_$1*5($+"!PVPj"U*9-"$62"`%09*"!PPOIJ"K.5'09."$"2/+&0++/'6"'7"3$B/2"8-$5F*:Y+"5*+4'6+*"

-'"-.*"?@!!"[`"R/'-+"G?@!!I>"/-"2*('6+-5$-*2".'E"2/+&'05+*+"'7"&'62*(6$-/'6"&'67%$-*2"

45*B/'0+"4$6/&+"'7"1%$&F"$62"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"1'2/*+"-'"($F*"+*6+*"'7>"$62"+/%*6&*>"-.*"

4'%/-/&+"'7";'62'6Y+"401%/&"(0%-/&0%-05*J",9$/6+-"-./+"1$&F25'4"/-"+.'E*2".'E":'069"4*'4%*Y+"

0+*"'7"&'((*5&/$%/+*2"./4".'4"$62"1%$&F"&0%-05$%"$*+-.*-/&+"E$+"6'-"'6%:"$"B*./&%*"7'5"B/'%*6&*"

'5"(/(/&5:"10-"(*$6/6970%"$62"4'%/-/&$%"G8.0+-*5($6"!PP!IJ"K./+"E$+"$225*++*2"-.5'09."$6"

$6$%:+/+"'7"-.*"E$:+"-.$-":'069"4*'4%*"0+*2"+'%2Q'0-"./4".'4"$+"+-5$-*9/*+"7'5"%/B/69"GS.$(1*5+"

!PMeI"$62"6/./%/+-"$*+-.*-/&+"$+"B*./&%*+"7'5"5*7%*&-/69"'6"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"/6H0+-/&*J"

"

<C4$62/69"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"+&$%*"/6"S.$4-*5"K.5**"-'"$6"*69$9*(*6-"E/-."-.*"2/$+4'5/&>"/-"

*C4%'5*2".'E":'069"4*'4%*"0+*2"-.*"9%'1$%"$*+-.*-/&+"'7"6/./%/+("/6"&'6H06&-/'6"E/-."%'&$%"

-*55/-'5/$%"$62"5$&/$%"+:(1'%+J"T6"-./+"1$+/+>"/-"$225*++*2"-.*"2/77*5*6-"B/5-0$%"$62"4.:+/&$%"+/-*+"

$-"E./&."-./+"2/$%'90*"'&&055*2>"$62"-.*"-*6+/'6"1*-E**6"4*57'5($6&*"$62"$&-0$%"B/'%*6&*J"

K./+"+.'E*2".'E"6*E"-*&.6'%'9/*+"E*5*"7$&/%/-$-/69"2/77*5*6-"F/62+"'7"&'((06/&$-/'6"$62"

45'B/2/69"2/77*5*6-"+/-*+"'7"2/$%'90*"$-"E./&."-.*"15$B$2'"'5"5*$%/-:"'7"B/'%*6&*"E$+"4*57'5(*2"

$62"/6-*545*-*2J"_'E*B*5>"/-"$%+'"&'6+/2*5*2".'E"-.*+*"'7-*6"$6-$9'6/+-/&"&'((06/&$-/'6+"

E*5*"$%+'"4$5-"'7"-.*"*-./&+"'7"+.$5/69"-.$-"*C-*62*2"1*:'62"-.*"%/6*+"'7"5$&/$%"$62"-*55/-'5/$%"

.'+-/%/-:"-.$-"-.*"/6-*5%'&0-'5+"25*E"/6"-.*"+$62J"K./6F/69"E/-."-.*"*-./&+"'7"&'%%$1'5$-/'6"-.$-"

&.$5$&-*5/+*"1%$&F"2/$+4'5/&"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6"GX/%5':"!PPOI>"$62"-.*"-5$2/-/'6+"'7"5$&/$%"-*55'5"

E/-."E./&."-.*:"&'*C/+-"G^$6*5H*$"$62"^$56"!PPeI>"-.*"&.$4-*5"45*+*6-*2"-.*+*".'+-/%/-/*+"$62"

&'6B/B/$%/-/*+"GX/%5':"?@@\I"$+"&'6-*(4'5$5:"($6/7*+-$-/'6+"'7"-.*"051$6"4$5$2'C"G^$&F"!PP\IJ"

"

S.$4-*5"]'05"$%+'"$225*++*2"-.*"/(4%/&$-/'6"'7"4*57'5($-/B/-:"G^0-%*5"!PPOj"X/%5':"!PPOI"/6"

-.*+*"E'5F+"7'5"$0-.*6-/&/-/*+"$++'&/$-*2"E/-."1%$&F"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6>"$62"1%$&F"$62"E./-*"

&0%-05$%"70+/'6J"K.*"&.$4-*5"+.'E*2".'E"&'6-*(4'5$5:"U*E.$("&'0%2"6'-"1*"70%%:"

062*5+-''2"-.5'09."*$5%/*5"2*+&5/4-/'6+"'7"1%$&F"$62"E./-*"&0%-05$%"+:6&5*-/+("'5"7'5(*5"

$++*++(*6-+"'7"$0-.*6-/&/-:"$62"7$F/69Q/-"G,%*C$62*5"!PPej"^$&F"!PP\j"^*66*--"!PPPj"

S.$(1*5+"!PMej"X/%5':"!PVM>"!PPO>"?@@?j"_*12/9*"!PMPj"_*E/--"!PVej")'6*+"!PVVj"U$:$F"

?@@OIJ"<C4%'5/69"-.*"&.$69/69"7'5($-/'6+"'7"&0%-05$%"+:6&5*-/+("/6"T0-*5"<$+-";'62'6"/-"

$225*++*2":'069"4*'4%*Y+"4*57'5($6&*"'7"2$6&*"('B*+"$++'&/$-*2"E/-."1%$&F"+*C0$%/+*2"

('2*+"'7"1*/69"GX/%5':"?@@@j"_$55/+'6"?@@Pj".''F+"?@@\j"d/%(*5"?@!?IJ"A-"6'-*2".'E"KQ=$/6Y+"

Page 190: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!P@"

"

(/+'9:6:"G?@@PI"E$+"2*-$&.*2"75'("/-+"4%$&*"'7"45'20&-/'6"$62"5*7'5(*2"-.5'09."-.*"9*62*5"

4'%/-/&+"$62"E./-*".$1/-0$%"('5$%/-:"$-";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01j"$62".'E"-.*"&'((*5&/$%/+*2"

*($6&/4$-'5:"4'%/-/&+"GR'1/6+'6"?@@MI"$62"+%$&F6*++"GS''4*5"?@@\j"#/%%*5"!PP!j"U'1%*"?@@@I"

'7"#/++:"<%%/'-"G?@@NI"E*5*"2$6&*2"-'"$%'69+/2*"$"-5$&F"1:"`Q;/6*"G?@!@I"E./&."%$/2"&%$/("-'"$"

%'&$%"E./-*"($+&0%/6*"-*55$/6J"A6"-./+"E$:>"E./%*"'%2*5"7'5(+"'7"$0-.*6-/&/-:"E*5*"15'F*6"2'E6>"

6*E"'6*+"E*5*"5*10/%-J"

"

d.*5*$+"S.$4-*5"KE'"%''F*2"-'"-.*"4$+->"S.$4-*5"]/B*"E$+"'5/*6-*2"-'"-.*"70-05*J"K.*"&.$4-*5"

*C4%'5*2".'E":'069"4*'4%*".$B*"1**6"&*6-5$%"-'"2'(/6$6-"&'6+-50&-/'6+"'7"0-'4/$6"$62"

2:+-'4/$6".'5/a'6+"G<2*%($6"?@@\j"X/5'0C"!PPej"_$55/+"?@@\IJ"_'E*B*5>"-.*"&.$4-*5"6'-*2"

-.$-"$+/2*"75'("5/+F"G^*++$6-"*-"$%J"?@@Oj"S$/56+"$62"S$/56+"!PP\j"`5'6/&F"!PPMj"U*E1056"*-"$%J"

!PPPj"R/&.($6"$62"]5$+*5"?@@!I"$62"%'69/-02/6$%"$6$%:+*+"G_*62*5+'6"?@@Mj"K.'(+'6"?@@PI>"

:'069"4*'4%*Y+"4*5+4*&-/B*+"$62"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+"E*5*"$1+*6-"75'("+'&/'%'9/&$%"

2/+&0++/'6+"'7"-.*"70-05*J"K'"5*+4'62"-'"-./+>"-.*"&.$4-*5"45'4'+*2"&'(1/6*2".*5(*6*0-/&"

G,%&'77"?@@ej"X$2$(*5"!PVPj"_*/2*99*5"!Pe?j"R/&u05"!PV\I"$62"$75'Q70-05/+-"G30"^'/+"?@@M>"

<+.06"!PPV>"?@@Oj"]$6'6"!PP!>"X/%5':"?@!@$>"#'-*6"?@@OI"(*-.'2'%'9/*+"-'"$225*++"

/(($6*6-"$62"-5$6+&*62*6-$%"$+4*&-+"'7"-.*"W-'Q&'(*YJ"

"

S'6-/60/69"-.*"2/+&0++/'6+"'7"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"/6"S.$4-*5+"K.5**"$62"]'05>"/-"+.'E*2".'E"-.*"

4'%/-/&+"'7"$+4/5$-/'6"E$+"4$5-"'7"$"U*E";$1'05"45'H*&-"-.$-"($44*2"'0-"+0&&*++70%"%/7*Q4%$6"

-5$H*&-'5/*+"7'5":'069"4*'4%*"$+"*20&$-*2g45'7*++/'6$%g&'6+0(*5+"G^5'E6"?@@M1j"3$%*"*-"$%J"

?@@?j"_#"X'B*56(*6-"?@@N$j"_#"K5*$+05:"$62"3S8]"?@@Mj"`*%%:"?@@Nj"R$&'"?@@Pj"8'&/$%"

<C&%0+/'6"K$+F"]'5&*"?@@VIJ"A-"2/+&0++*2".'E"-.*+*"0-'4/$6"2/+&'05+*+"E*5*"(/22%*Q&%$++"$62"

E./-*"$62".'E"-.*:"E*5*"+*-"$9$/6+-"2/+&'05+*+"'7"E'5F/69Q&%$++"$62"6'-QE./-*Q*6'09."

062*5$&./*B*(*6-"G_$:%*--"?@@!j"=5*+-'6"?@@Pj"R*$:"*-"$%J"?@@Mj"8/6&%$/5"*-"$%J"?@!@j"

8B*/6++'6"?@@PIJ"]'%%'E/69"$"2/+&0++/'6"'7".'E"-.*+*"2/+&'05+*+"E*5*"&'(4'062*2"/6"

U*E.$("1*&$0+*"'7"-.*"45'C/(/-:"-'"2*45/B$-/'6>"-.*"&.$4-*5"*C4%'5*2".'E":'069"4*'4%*"

062*5+-''2"-.*/5"70-05*+"-.5'09."B/+/'6+"'7"$+4/5$-/'6"'5"4'B*5-:"'7"$+4/5$-/'6J"K.5'09."$"

2/+&0++/'6"'7"-.*+*"2'(/6$6-"$62"7'5*&%'+*2".'5/a'6+>"/-"+.'E*2".'E":'069"4*'4%*"+*%7Q

4'%/&*2J"R*-056/69"-'"$225*++"2*1$-*+"'6"-.*"&'(4%*C/-:"'7"E./-*6*++"/6"U*E.$(>"-.*"&.$4-*5"

+4*&/7/&$%%:"&'6+/2*5*2".'E"$"95'04"'7":'069",%1$6/$6Q+4*$F/69"E'(*6"'5/*6-*2"-.*(+*%B*+"

-'"$"B/+/'6"'7"(/22%*Q&%$++"E./-*"+0&&*++"g"*20&$-*2"$62"/62*4*62*6-":'069"E'(*6"E/-."

E$9*Q*$56/69"&$4$&/-/*+"G#&R'11/*"?@@PI"g"-.5'09."2/+Q/2*6-/7:/69"G8F*99+"!PPMI"E/-."70-05*+"

Page 191: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!P!"

"

-.*:"+$E"$+"6'-"E./-*"'5"(/22%*Q&%$++"*6'09.J",62"/-"*C4%$/6*2".'E"-./+"E$+"2'6*"$%'69+/2*"

6$B/9$-/69"-.*/5"5'%*+"$+",%1$6/$6":'069"E'(*6"G`/69"*-"$%J"?@@ej"`'+-'B/&'B$"$62"=5*+-5*+./"

?@!@j"=.'*6/C"$62"d''%%*--"!PP!j"Z0B$%Q3$B/+"*-"$%J"!PVPIJ"

"

S.$4-*5"]/B*"$%+'"2/+&0++*2".'E":'069"4*'4%*"+*%7Q4'%/&*2"-.5'09."W4'B*5-/*+"'7"$+4/5$-/'6YJ"

R*-056/69"-'"+'(*"'7"-.*"2*1$-*+"&'B*5*2"/6"S.$4-*5"KE'>"-.*"&'%%*&-/B*"(*('5/*+"'7"E'5F/69Q

&%$++"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"E*5*"$225*++*2"GX/%%/*+"?@@Mj"R*$:"?@@Pj"8F*99+"!PPM>"?@@\IJ"K.*"

&.$4-*5"45*+*6-*2".'E"-.*+*"6$55$-/B*+"E*5*"($2*"+*6+*"'7"$%'69"-.*"*20&$-/'6g

*(4%':(*6-g&'6+0(*5"-5$H*&-'5:J",%'69"-./+"-5$H*&-'5:>"-.5'09."/6-*5$&-/'6+"E/-.".'5/a'6+"'7"

(/22%*Q&%$++"4*'4%*"$62"/6+-/-0-/'6+>":'069"4*'4%*"&$(*"-'"1*%/*B*"-.*:"E*5*"*20&$-/'6$%%:"

/6*4->"06*(4%':$1%*"'5"+0/-$1%*"'6%:"7'5"%'EQ4$/2"*(4%':(*6-J"R$-/'6$%/+/69"-.*/5"2/77/&0%-:"/6"

1*/69"+0&&*++70%"'6"-.*+*"-*5(+"+'(*"1%$(*2"5*&*6-"/((/95$6-+"7'5"-.*/5"2/77/&0%-/*+"$62"/6"

-./+"E$:"*+-$1%/+.*2"-.*/5"'E6"+:+-*("'7"2/+Q/2*6-/7/&$-/'6"1$+*2"'6"E./-*6*++"$62"

*6-/-%*(*6-J"K.*+*"7'5(+"'7"+*%7Q4'%/&/69"*C/+-*2"$%'69+/2*"&'6+0(*5"2*+/5*+J"#$6:"'7"-.*+*"

2*+/5*+"E*5*"($/6+-5*$("g"-.*"2*+/5*"-'"10:"$"&$5"'5"$".'0+*"g".'E*B*5>"+'(*"E*5*"

&'6+/2*5*2"l2/+'52*5*2n"/6"&'6-5$+-"-'"-.*"&'6+0(4-/'6"4$--*56+"'7"$+4/5$-/'6$%":'069"E'(*6"

GX5/77/6"!PPMIJ"]'5(+"'7"W2/+'52*5*2Y"&'6+0(4-/'6"/6&%02*2"-.*"405&.$+*"'7"'1H*&-+"-.$-"7/--*2"

E/-."-.*"6/./%/+-"$*+-.*-/&+"*C4%'5*2"/6"S.$4-*5"]'05J"A6"4$5-/&0%$5>"-.*"&.$4-*5"2/+&0++*2"

`5/+-*6Y+"$&h0/+/-/'6"'7"$".''2/*"E/-."$"70%%Q7$&*"a/4J"K./+"2/+'52*5*2"&'6+0(*5"'1H*&-"$62"/-+"

6/./%/+-"$*+-.*-/&+"*6$1%*2"`5/+-*6"-'"$&-"'0-"$"5'11*5:"+&*6$5/'J"K./+"E$+>"/6"4$5->"$"

4*57'5($6&*"'7"6/./%/+(>"$+"/6"S.$4-*5"]'05>"10-"/-"E$+"$%+'"$"45'H*&-/'6"'7"750+-5$-/'6"$-"6'-"

1*/69"$1%*"-'"'E6"-.*"F/62+"'7"9''2+"+.*"E$+"-'%2"-'"2*+/5*J"_/22*6"/6".*5".''2>"+.*".$2"7'062"

$"E$:"-'"($F*"+*6+*"'7".*5"'E6"+.:6*++J"

"

,+"E/-."'-.*5"&.$4-*5+>"-.*"$590(*6-"*62*2"1:"('B/69"$E$:"75'("-.*"1/6$5:"4'+/-/'6+"'7"-.*"

2'(/6$6-"$62"2'(/6$-*2"-'"&'6+/2*5"-.*"$%-*56$-/B*".'5/a'6+"45'20&*2"1:"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"A"

E'5F*2"E/-.J"R*-056/69"-'"-.*"2/+&0++/'6"'7"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6"/6"S.$4-*5"]'05>"-.*"&.$4-*5"

*62*2"1:"+.'E/69".'E":'069"4*'4%*Y+"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+"('B*2"1*:'62"-.*/5"

($59/6$%/+$-/'6"-'"4'%/-/&$%"*B$%0$-/'6+"'7"/6H0+-/&*"$62"$%-*56$-/B*".'5/a'6+J"<69$9/69"E/-."

$590(*6-+"-.$-".$B*"./9.%/9.-*2"-.*"2*(/+*"'7"0-'4/$+"GX/%5':"?@@@I>"-.*"&.$4-*5"45'4'+*2"

-.$-"E./%*"-.*"('B*"-'"-.*"1'2:"/+"*B/2*6-"/6":'069"4*'4%*Y+"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+>"-./+"2/2"6'-"

/(4%:"-.*"*62"'7"$%-*56$-/B*"B/+/'6+"'7"-.*"-'Q&'(*J"K.5'09."$"2/+&0++/'6"'7"[4&'(/69"

#'B*(*6-Y+"7/6$%"-E'"B/2*'+>"S.$4-*5"]/B*"*C4%'5*2".'E":'069"4*'4%*"h0*+-/'6*2"-.*/5"

Page 192: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!P?"

"

($59/6$%/+$-/'6"75'("-.*"70-05*"$62"45'4'+*2"$%-*56$-/B*"E$:+"'7"%/B/69J"d./%*"-./+"2/26Y-"

$('06-"-'"-.*"75**2'("&5/*+"'7"'-.*5"-/(*+"G30"^'/+"?@@M>"44JVgPj"<%%/+'6"!PPN>"?@@!j"<+.06"

!PPV>"?@@Oj"]$6'6"!PP!j"X/%5':"!PPO>"?@@@j"#$:*5"?@@@j"#'-*6"?@@Oj"d5/9.-"!Pe\j"Z$+a*F"

?@@eI>"$62"E./%*"/-"E$+"'5/*6-*2"$+"$"6*9$-/B*"4'%/-/&+>"/-"2/2"F**4"$%/B*"-.*"/2*$"-.$-"$6'-.*5"

E'5%2"/+"4'++/1%*"GX/%5':"?@!@$IJ"

"

K.5'09."+-'5/*+"'7":'069"4*'4%*Y+"%/B*+"/6"T0-*5"<$+-";'62'6"-.*"-.*+/+".$+"*C4%'5*2"

(0%-/&0%-05*>"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"4'%/-/&+"$-"$"+4*&/7/&"&'6H06&-05*J"R*-056/69"-'"2*1$-*+"5$/+*2"

/6"-.*"A6-5'20&-/'6>"/-".$+"2*B*%'4*2"+'&/'%'9/&$%"$&&'06-+"'7"&0%-05$%"+:6&5*-/+("$62"2/$%'90*j"

/-".$+"/6B*+-/9$-*2"7'5(+"'7"'52*5"$62"2/+'52*5>"70-05*+"$62"6'"70-05*+j"$62"/-".$+"$225*++*2"

-.*"+-5$-*9/*+>"5*+/+-$6&*+>"+01B*5+/'6+"$62"5*7%*C/B/-/*+"/6.*5*6-"/6":'069"4*'4%*Y+"45$&-/&*+"

$62"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+J"

"

K.*+*"+-'5/*+"E*5*"$%%"4$5-/&0%$5"-'"-.*"*-.6'95$4./&"&'6-*C-"/6"E./&."-.*:"E*5*"45'20&*2J"

d.*5*"-.*"5*+*$5&."E$+"062*5-$F*6>"E.'"E$+"/6B'%B*2>"$62"E.*6>"45'B/2*2"/-+"06/h0*"

&.$5$&-*5/+-/&+J"K.*":'069"4*'4%*"A"E'5F*2"E/-."95*E"04"/6"$"4%$&*"E/-."$"4$5-/&0%$5"./+-'5:J"

3*Q/620+-5/$%/+$-/'6>"051$6"5*9*6*5$-/'6>"*&'6'(/&"+-$96$-/'6"$62"6$-/'6$%"5'($6&*"&'%'05*2"

-.*/5"%/B*+"/6"2/+-/6&-"E$:+>"$+"2/2"-.*"&'6+*h0*6&*+"'7"&.*$4".'0+/69"$62"!N@":*$5+"'7"

(/95$-/'6J",%%"E*5*"-.*"&'6+*h0*6&*+"'7"-.*"1'5'09.Y+"75/69*"%'&$-/'6J"K.*"6'C/'0+"/620+-5/*+>"

-.*"2'&F+j"-.*"+./7-+"75'("W+%0(+Y"-'"-'E*5"1%'&F+"-'"5*&%$/(*2"($5+.%$62".'0+/69j"-.*"

T%:(4/&+>"-.*"<C&*%"S*6-5*j"d*+-7/*%2"$62"U*E"8-5$-7'52"K'E6>"E*5*"$%%"4$5-"'7"-.*/5"%/B*+J"

K.*+*"/675$+-50&-05$%"$62"4'40%$-/'6"&.$69*+"/6+-/%%*2"-.*"6'5($%&:"'7"4'40%$-/'6"&.056"/6"

-.*/5"&'%%*&-/B*"/($9/6$-/'6+J"^0-"-.*+*"('B*(*6-+"$%+'"*C/+-*2"/6"2/$%'9/&"-*6+/'6"E/-."-.*"

5*&'67/905$-/'6"'7"1*%'69/69>"-*55/-'5:>"5$&*"$62"6$-/'6$%/+(J",%%"'7"-.*+*"5*%$-*2"-'"2/$+4'5/&"

45'20&-/'6+"'7"&0%-05*J"_/4".'4Y+"+'%2Q'0-"9*65*+"E*5*"-$F*6>"5*&'67/905*2"$62"4%$:*2"1$&F"-'"

($F*"+*6+*"'7"%'++>"($59/6$%/+$-/'6>"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:>"5$&/+("$62"&'6+0(*5/+(>"$-"-.*"+$(*"

-/(*"$+"-.*:"5*45'20&*2"*-./&+"'7"+.$5/69>"75/*62+./4"$62"&5*$-/B/-:"$-"9%'1$%"$62"%'&$%"+&$%*+J"

K.*":'069"4*'4%*"A"E'5F*2"E/-."45'20&*2"$62"6$B/9$-*2"-./+"&'6-*+-*2"%$62+&$4*"E/-.'0-"

+%/44/69"/6-'"*C/+-*6-/$%"$69+->"E/-.'0-"7$%%/69"'77"$6:"+'&/$%"45*&/4/&*"$62"E/-.'0-"&'67'5(/69"

-'"+/(4%/+-/&"6$55$-/B*+"'7"&.$'+"$62"&'6B/B/$%/-:J"K./+"E$+"$"4%$&*"E.*5*"*C&%0+/'6"%/B*2"

-'9*-.*5"E/-."$6"*-./&+"'7"&'%%$1'5$-/'6"$62"E.*5*"/6+*&05/-:"*C/+-*2"$%'69+/2*"+'%/2$5/-:J"

"

Page 193: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!PO"

"

K.*"+-'5/*+"&'6-$/6*2"/6"-./+"-.*+/+"E*5*"$%+'"45'20&*2"$-"$"+4*&/7/&"*-.6'95$4./&"('(*6-f"

?@@Mg?@!?"G75'("-.*"7/5+-"/6-*5B/*E+"E/-."+*5B/&*"45'B/2*5+"-'"-.*"%$+-"04%'$2"'7"[4&'(/69"

#'B*(*6-I"E$+"$6"*5$"'7"401%/&"+4*62/69"&0-+"$62"%/(/-*2"*(4%':(*6-"'44'5-06/-/*+J"K./+"

$77*&-*2"-.*"+*5B/&*+"$B$/%$1%*"-'":'069"4*'4%*"$62"-.*/5"$1/%/-:"-'"7/62"E'5FJ"A-"E$+"$%+'"$"-/(*"

'7"/6&5*$+/69"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"-.*"5*4%$&*(*6-"'7":'0-."+*5B/&*"45'B/+/'6"E/-."4'%/&/69J""

K.*+*"/6&5*$+*2".$52+./4+"5*%$-*2"-'"$62"E*5*"&'(4'062*2"1:"$"+*5/*+"'7"('5$%"4$6/&+"

$5'062"051$6":'0-.>"/6&%02/69"-.*"W80((*5"'7"`6/7*"S5/(*Y"/6"?@@V"$62"-.*"?@!!"[`"R/'-+J"

"

K.*+*"+-'5/*+"&'0%2"$%+'"6'-".$B*"1**6"45'20&*2"E/-.'0-"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"A"E'5F*2"E/-.J"

#$6:"$&&'06-+"/6"-./+"-.*+/+"$5*"1$+*2"'6"-.*"%/B*+"'7"E./-*":'069"4*'4%*"$-";*:.$("Z'0-."

S%01>"/6"$22/-/'6"-'"-.*"B'/&*+"'7",+/$6>"1%$&F>"(/C*2>";$-/6",(*5/&$6"$62"<$+-*56"<05'4*$6"

:'069"4*'4%*"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+"75'("-.*"+$(*"%'&$-/'6J"K.*5*"$5*"45'(/6*6-"*69$9*(*6-+"

E/-."-.*"B'/&*+"'7":'069"4*'4%*"75'("-.*",%1$6/$6"Z'0-."S%01j"E/-."<$+-*56"$62"8'0-.*56"

<05'4*$6":'069"E'(*6j"$62"S'69'%*+*>"`*6:$6>"X0:$6*+*>"[9$62$6"$62"^%$&F"^5/-/+."

:'069*5"$62"'%2*5"(*6"$-"-.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01J"K.*+*"2/77*5*6-"B'/&*+".$B*"1**6"H0C-$4'+*2"

-'"45'B/2*"/6+/9.-+"/6-'"-.*"*B*5:2$:"(0%-/&0%-05*"'7"U*E.$(J"]'5"*C$(4%*>"2*1$-*+"'6"

E./-*6*++"$62"&%$++".$B*"1**6"2*B*%'4*2"$%'69+/2*"-.*"E./-*6*2"$+4/5$-/'6+"'7"-.*",%1$6/$6Q

+4*$F/69":'069"E'(*6"$62"-.*"2/$+4'5$"(6*('6/&+"'7"-.*",7-*5"8&.''%"S%01J"_'E*B*5>"-.*"

:'069"4*'4%*"E.'".$B*"&'Q45'20&*2"-./+"-.*+/+"$5*"7$5"75'("2*7/6*2"1:"-.*/5"*-.6/&"'5"

(/95$-'5:"./+-'5/*+J"A6"$22/-/'6"-'"-.*"E$:+"/6"E./&."-.*:"$5*"5$&/$%/+*2>"-.*/5"6*9'-/$-/'6+"'7"

&%$++".$B*"1**6"2*B*%'4*2J"#'+-"'7"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"E.'"$5*".*$52"/6"-./+"-.*+/+"$5*"E'5F/69Q

&%$++>"$62"$%-.'09."+'(*"$5*"(/22%*Q&%$++>"('+-"E*5*"%/B/69"/6"7$(/%/*+"E/-."5*%$-/B*%:"%'E"

/6&'(*+J"K.*"-.*+/+".$+"$%+'"*C4%'5*2"6*9'-/$-/'6+"'7"9*62*5"$62"+*C0$%/-:J"_'E*B*5>"/6"$%%"

&.$4-*5+"-.*+*"7'5(+"'7"6*9'-/$-/'6".$B*"1**6"062*5+-''2"/6"-.*"&'6-*C-"'7"+4*&/7/&"

45'20&-/'6+"$62"4'%/-/&+"-.$-"$225*++"$62"('B*"1*:'62"+/(4%/+-/&"/2*6-/-:"%'&$-/'6+J"

"

,6"$--*(4-"-'"F**4"&%'+*"-'"-.*"*B*5:2$:"%/B*+"'7":'069"4*'4%*"/6"T0-*5"<$+-";'62'6>"$62"-'"

062*5+-$62"-.*("/6"-.*"&'6-*C-"'7"(0%-/&0%-05*"$62"2/$+4'5$>".$+"5*h0/5*2"2/77*5*6-"

*-.6'95$4./&"('B*+J"d./%*"-.*"-.*+/+"/+"95'062*2"/6"$6"*C4%'5$-/'6"'7"-.*"*C4*5/*6&*>"

/6-*545*-$-/'6"$62"4*57'5($6&*"'7":'069"4*'4%*"/6"U*E.$(>"/-".$+"6**2*2"-'"('B*"

-*(4'5$%%:"$62"+4$-/$%%:"/6"+&$%*>"$62"-.5'09."2/77*5*6-"B*./&%*+"'7"$6$%:+/+>"-'"5*+4'62"-'"-.*"

5*+*$5&."&'6-*C-J"S.$4-*5+"KE'"$62"]/B*>"/6"2/77*5*6-"E$:+>".$B*"('B*2"$E$:"75'("-.*"6'E"$+"

$"4'/6-"'7"$0-.*6-/&$-/'6>"-'"&'6+/2*5"-.*"95*$-"-/(*>"-*(4'5$%"7'%2+"$62".'5/a'6+"'7"T0-*5Q

Page 194: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!P\"

"

<$+-"<62"%/7*J"K./+".$+"1**6"-$F*6"'6"/6"S.$4-*5"K.5**"-.5'09."$"%'69Q-*5("4*5+4*&-/B*"'6"

&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6>"$62"-.5'09."S.$4-*5"]'05Y+"&'6+/2*5$-/'6"'7"2/$+4'5/&"-5$H*&-'5/*+"$62"&0%-05$%"

7%'E+J"S.$4-*5"K.5**Y+"+./7-"1*-E**6"9*'95$4./&$%"+&$%*+".$+"7$&/%/-$-*2"$"('5*"60$6&*2"

062*5+-$62/69"'7"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"-*55/-'5:"/6"$62"$5'062";*:.$("Z'0-."S%01J"S.$4-*5+"]'05"$62"

]/B*"('B*2"-.*"B*./&%*"'7"$6$%:+/+"75'(":'069"4*'4%*"-'"-.*/5"&0%-05$%"45'20&-/'6+J"_'%2/69"-.*"

-*C-0$%>"-.*"*C4*5/*6-/$%"$62"-.*"4*57'5($-/B*"/6"-*6+/'6"-.*:"'4*6*2"04"$"2/77*5*6-"5$69*"'7"

/(($6*6->"-5$6+&*62*6-"$62"2/$+4'5/&"4'++/1/%/-/*+"7'5"*C4%'5/69"4'%/-/&+>"401%/&"

&'((06/&$-/'6+"$62".'5/a'6+"-.$-"E'0%2"6'-"'-.*5E/+*".$B*"1**6".*$52J"K./+".$+"$%+'"1**6"$"

45$&-/&$%"45'H*&-J",+"$225*++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"T6*>"-.*"(*-.'2'%'9:"*(4%':*2"5*+4'62*2"-'"-.*"

7/*%2E'5F"&'6-*C-J"K.*"5$69*"'7"(*-.'2+"0+*2"/6"-./+"-.*+/+"5*7%*&-*2"-.*"2:6$(/&+"'7":'069"

4*'4%*"$62"-.*":'0-."&%01+J"K.*"-.*+/+"&'6-$/6+"-.*"$6$%:+/+"'7"2$6&*"$62"B/2*'"45'H*&-+"

1*&$0+*"-.$-"/-"E.$-"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"/6-*5*+-*2"/6"2'/69J"

='%/-/&$%"*626'-*+"

_'E*B*5>"-./+"-.*+/+"E'0%2"6'-"1*"&'(4%*-*"E/-.'0-"$"7*E"4'%/-/&$%"*626'-*+J",-"$"&'67*5*6&*"

/6"^/5(/69.$(>"$"7*E"('6-.+"1*7'5*"A"+01(/--*2>"$"5''("'7"$&-/B/+-+"$62"$&$2*(/&+"$+F*2"(*"

7'5"W-.*"4'/6-Y"'7"(:"5*+*$5&.J"S'6&*56*2"7'5"-.*"2*4'%/-/&/+$-/'6"'7"+'&/'%'9:"$62"*-.6'95$4.:"

$+"2/+&/4%/6*+>"-.*:"E*5*"$+F/69"$7-*5"/-+"4'%/-/&$%"(*5/-J",%-.'09."-.*"/6-*55'9$-/'6"E$+"

+-5$/9.-7'5E$52"*6'09.>"-''"(0&."-/(*"/6";'62'6Y+"&0%-05$%"+-02/*+"%'069*"5*+0%-*2"/6"$"%*++"

-.$6"&'6B/6&/69"5*+4'6+*J"K.*"*6&'06-*5"45'B/2*2"(*"E/-."$"-/(*%:"5*(/62*5"-.$-"+'&/$%"

H0+-/&*"E$+"-.*"'5/9/6$%"('-/B$-/'6"'7"-.*"5*+*$5&.J",62"/62**2>"E./%*"5*&'96/-/'6"'7"-./+"

&'((/-(*6-".$2"1*&'(*"-5$44*2"062*5"4/%*+"'7"*-.6'95$4./&"($-*5/$%"$62"+'&/$%"-.*'5:>"*$&."

&.$4-*5"6'6*-.*%*++".$+"$225*++*2"7'5(+"'7"'445*++/'6"$62"/6H0+-/&*J"8'"E./%*"A"($/6-$/6"-.$-"

-./+"-.*+/+"/+"/55*20&/1%*"-'"$"9*6*5$%"$590(*6-"'6":'069"4*'4%*>"/-"/+"/(4'5-$6-"$%%"-.*"+$(*"-'"

+099*+-".'E"-.*"$6$%:+/+"&'6-$/6*2"/6"-.*+*"4$9*+"&$6".*%4"0+"-./6F"$1'0-"E/2*5"/++0*+"-'"2'"

E/-.":'069"4*'4%*>"(0%-/&0%-05*>"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"4'%/-/&+J"K.*"A6-5'20&-/'6"'4*6*2"1:"

+*--/69"'0-".'E"-.*"-.*+/+"7/--*2"/6-'"-.*+*"-.*(*+J"R*+4'62/69"-'"(:"45'B'&$-*05+>"-.*"

S'6&%0+/'6"*62+"E/-."$"2*B*%'4(*6-"'7"-./+"75$(/69"$62>"1$+*2"'6"-.*"2/+&0++/'6+"&'620&-*2"

/6"-./+"-.*+/+>"*%$1'5$-*+"$"+*-"'7"+-$-*(*6-+"'6"E.:"/-"/+"/(4'5-$6-"$62"6*&*++$5:"-'"&'6-/60*"

-./+"&'6B*5+$-/'6J"

Page 195: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!PN"

"

#0%-/&0%-05*"9'6*"(/++/69"

,+"$66'06&*2"/6"-.*"A6-5'20&-/'6>"E./%*"-.*"$6$%:+/+"'7"051$6"(0%-/&0%-05*"/+"6'-"6*E"G,(/6"

?@@?j"^$&F"!PP\j"^*66*--"!PPPj"X/%5':"?@@@j"_$%%"?@@@j"_*++*"?@@@j"_*E/--"!PVej")'6*+"!PVVj"

U$:$F"?@@Oj"8.$5($"*-"$%J"!PPeI>"'B*5"5*&*6-":*$5+"/-".$+"5*&*/B*2"%*++"*-.6'95$4./&"$--*6-/'6"

-.$6"/-"+.'0%2".$B*J",-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"-.*"&'(4'+/-/'6"'7"+'&/*-:".$+"6'-"+-''2"+-/%%J"K.*"7'5(+"

'7"&0%-05$%"+:6&5*-/+("*B/2*6-"/6"45*B/'0+":*$5+"6'E"45'B/2*"'6%:"$"-*(4%$-*"$62"./+-'5/&$%"

1$&F95'062"7'5"-./6F/69"$1'0-"-.*"7'5($-/'6+"'7"051$6"%/7*"-'2$:J"8-5099%/69"1*-E**6"

067$+./'6$1%*"#$5C/$6"4$5$2/9(+>".$44:"&'6B/B/$%/-:"$62"1%$&F>"15'E6"$62"E./-*"&'2/69"'7"

+'&/$%"%/7*>"E*".$B*"*6-*5*2"$"+'&/'%'9/&$%"B'/2"E.*5*"-.*"(*$6/69+"$62"7'5($-/'6+"'7":'069"

4*'4%*Y+"45$&-/&*+>"45'20&-/'6+"$62"4'%/-/&+"$5*"4$++/69"0+"1:J"

"

_'E*B*5>"E./%*"E*"$5*"(/++/69"-.*"-5/&F>"'-.*5+"$5*"7/%%/69"-.*"9$4J"[62*-*55*2"1:"-.*"

06$B$/%$1/%/-:"'7"+'&/'%'9/&$%"75$(*E'5F+"'5"-.*"7$+./'6+"'7"-.*"$&$2*(:>"&'6+*5B$-/B*"$62"

E./-*Q+045*($&/+-"$6$%:+-+"$5*"40--/69"-'9*-.*5"&'(4%*C"(0%-/&0%-05$%"2/+&'05+*+"-'"*C4%$/6"

-.*"('5$%"&'5504-/'6"'7"051$6":'0-."G8-$5F*:"?@!!IJ"T-.*5+"$5*"-056/69"-'"6'+-$%9/&"$&&'06-+"

'7"4'+-QE$5"^5/-$/6"G3*6&."*-"$%J"?@@ej"_'11+"?@@eIj"5*4%/&$-/69"-.*"&'((*5&/$%%:"B/$1%*"

75$(*E'5F+"'7"&'((06/-:"&'.*+/'6"$62"&'6-$&-"-.*'5:"GS$6-%*"?@@!j"S'((/++/'6"'6"

A6-*95$-/'6"$62"S'.*+/'6"?@@Mj"A6+-/-0-*"'7"S'((06/-:"S'.*+/'6"?@@Vj"_*E+-'6*"?@@Oj"

#0(7'52"$62"='E*5"?@@OIj"'5"45'4'+/69"E./-*6*2"6$55$-/B*+"'7"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"5/9.->"

(0%-/&0%-05$%"2*$-."$62"4'+-Q5$&/$%/-:"GX''2.$5-"?@@\j"_'29*"?@@Mj"#/5a$"?@!@j"=./%%/4+"?@@NIJ"

"

,-"$"B*5:"('2*+-"%*B*%>"-./+"-.*+/+".$+"+*-"'0-"-'"$225*++"+'(*"'7"-.*+*"+.'5-&'(/69+"1:"

$--*(4-/69"-'"%/+-*6"-'"-.*"+'062+"$62"5.:-.(+"'7"*B*5:2$:"%/7*"/6"T0-*5"<$+-";'62'6J"K'"2'"

-./+>"/-".$+"*C4%'5*2"2/77*5*6-"4*5+4*&-/B*+"'6"-.*"W051$6"4$5$2'CY"G^$&F"!PP\j"^$6*5H*$"$62"

^$56"!PPej"X/%5':"?@@\I"g"-.*"*C/+-*6&*"'7"/6-*6+*"&'6B/B/$%/-:"$%'69+/2*"&'67%/&-J"K.5'09."

2*B*%'4/69"6'-/'6+"'7"4*57'5($6&*>"&/-$-/'6"$62"2/$+4'5$"+4$&*"GX/%5':"!PPOI>"-.*"-.*+/+".$+"

&'6+/2*5*2".'E"-.*"&'6-*(4'5$5:"($6/7*+-$-/'6+"'7"-.*"051$6"4$5$2'C"$5*"2/77*5*6-"10-"

5*%$-*2"-'"*$5%/*5"2/+&0++/'6+"'7"-./+"&'62/-/'6"G,(/6"?@!@j"^0-%*5"!PPO>"!PPMIJ"A-".$+"

2*('6+-5$-*2".'E"-.*+*"45'&*++*+"25*E"'6"-.*"%$:*5*2"./+-'5/*+"G^$F.-/6"!PVe1j"^*6H$(/6"

!PeVI"'7"2/$+4'5$"-5$H*&-'5/*+"-'"($F*"+*6+*"'7"%'&$%"&'6-*C-+"GX/%5':"!PPOIJ"

"

^:"-.*+*"(*$6+"-.*"-.*+/+".$+"+'09.-"-'"*69$9*"E/-."&'6-*(4'5$5:"(0%-/&0%-05*J"K.5'09."

2/+&0++/'6+"'7"6/./%/+("GS.$4-*5"]'05I>"/-".$+"*C4%'5*2".'E"-.*"5$&/$%"$62"+*C0$%"&'6-*6-"'7"[8"

Page 196: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!Pe"

"

./4".'4"B/2*'+"GX/%5':"?@@@j".''F+"?@@\I"$5*"-5$6+%$-*2"/6-'"%'&$%"75$(/69+"7'5"5$&*"$62"

+*C0$%/-:J"K./+"./9.%/9.-*2"-.*"'4*66*++"$62"+.$5/69"'7"$5-"$&5'++"+044'+*2"6$-/'6$%"$62"5$&/$%"

1'062$5/*+"GX/%5':"?@@@I"10-"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"2*('6+-5$-*2".'E"-.*+*"%'&$%"4*57'5($6&*+"

*6$&-*2"6*E"7'5(+"'7"5$&/$%/+*2"*C&%0+/'6"$62"+*C0$%"('5$%/-/*+>"E./&."'4*6*2"04"-.*"1%$&F"

&0%-05$%"&'2/69+"'7"6/./%/+("-'"$"6*E"(0%-/*-.6/&"$62"(0%-/&0%-05$%"%$62+&$4*J"A-"$225*++*2".'E"

%'&$%"-*55/-'5/*+"E*5*"&'6+-50&-*2"-.5'09."6'-/'6+"'7"1*%'69/69"G+**"S.$4-*5+"KE'>"K.5**"$62"

]'05I"$62".'E"-.*+*"E*5*"+04*5+*2*2"1:"7'5(+"'7"/6-*6+*"%'&$%"&'%%$1'5$-/'6"$62"+.$5/69J"K.*"

'0-&'(*+"'7"-.*+*"&'%%$1'5$-/'6+"E*5*"(0+/&$%"+-$-*(*6-+"'7"-*55/-'5/$%"+*4$5$-/'6"/6"$22/-/'6"

-'"-.*"&'6-/60$-/'6"'7"$5-/+-/&"2/$%'90*J"K.*+*"2/$%'90*+"25*E"'6"-.*"+'%2Q'0-"$*+-.*-/&+"'7"

6/./%/+("G^$0($6"?@!!j"X/%5':"?@@@j")$(*+'6"!PV\j")$(*+'6"!PP!j"`/-E$6$"?@@?I>"10-"$-"-.*"

+$(*"-/(*"5*E'5F*2"-.*+*"45'&%$($-/'6+"'7"1%$&F"&0%-05$%"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:"-'"($F*"+*6+*"'7"

%'&$%"+%/44$9*+"'7"5$&*>"6$-/'6"$62"&0%-05*"4*&0%/$5"-'"-.*"[`"$62"4*&0%/$5"-'"U*E.$(J"A-"

*C4%'5*2".'E"-.*"+/-*+"'7"&'%%$1'5$-/'6"$62"&'67%/&-".$2"+./7-*2"g"75'("-.*";="5*&'52"$62"-.*"

+'062"+:+-*("&%$+."G^$&F"!PP\j"X/%5':"!PVMI>"-'"^%0*-''-.>"('1/%*"4.'6*+"$62"Z'0K01*J"

]/6$%%:>"/-"$225*++*2".'E"-.*+*"&'6B/B/$%"$62"&'67%/&-/B*>"2/$+4'5/&"$62"%'&$%>"-*55/-'5/$%"4'%/-/&+"

E*5*"($2*"+*6+*"'7"-.5'09."-.*"6*'Q%/1*5$%"5*+&$%/69"'7"+4$&*"2/+&0++*2"/6"S.$4-*5"K.5**"

G^5*66*5"$62"K.*'2'5*"?@@?j")*++'4"?@@?j"=*&F"$62"K/&F*%%"?@@?j"8E:69*2'0E"!PPM>"?@@@I"

$62"/-+"$++'&/$-*2"7'5($-/'6+"'7"'52*5"$62"&.$'+>"E/-."E./&."-.*"6/./%/+-/&"$*+-.*-/&+"1*&$(*"

/6-*5-E/6*2J"

"

K.*"9%'1$%/+$-/'6"'7"./4".'4"&0%-05*>"-.*"+./7-/69"'7"5$&/$%"+/96/7/*5+>"-.*"&'6-/60$%"&5*$-/B/-:"'7"

+:6&5*-/&"&0%-05*>"$62"-.*"+./7-+"/6"9%'1$%"$62"%'&$%"6'-/'6+"'7"-*55/-'5/$%/+*2"$62"*(1'2/*2"

&.$'+"$%%"/(4%:"$"5*B/*E"'7"45*B/'0+"062*5+-$62/69+"'7"5$&/$%"$0-.*6-/&/-:>"051$6"&5*$-/B/-:>"

(0%-/&0%-05$%"+'&/*-:"$62"-*55/-'5/$%"*C&%0+/'6J"K.*+*"45'&*++*+"'7"&/-$-/'6"'4*6"04"-.*"

4'-*6-/$%"'7"(0%-/&0%-05*"7'5"2/+($6-%/69"+'&/$%"$62"-*55/-'5/$%"'52*5+"1$+*2"'6"5$&*"$62"6$-/'6>"

$62"&.$%%*69*"&'6+*5B$-/B*"$62"E./-*"+045*($&/+-"$&&'06-+"'7"&'6-*(4'5$5:"051$6"%/7*J"K.*:"

+.'E"-.*"4'-*6-/$%>"$62"-.*"$&-0$%/-:>"'7"-.*"15*$F2'E6"'7"./*5$5&./*+"'7"1*%'69/69>"-.*"

4'++/1/%/-:"'7"%/B/69"7'5"'-.*5+"1*:'62"6$-/'6$%"$62"*-.6/&"1'062$5/*+>"$-"-.*"+$(*"-/(*"$+"

5*B*$%/69"-.*/5"5*Q/6+&5/4-/'6J"

K.*"/6B/+/1/%/-:"$62"5*B/B$%"'7"E./-*6*++"

d/-./6"-./+"$6$%:+/+"-.*"-.*+/+".$+"$225*++*2".'E"2/+&'05+*+"'7"E./-*6*++"$5*"1*/69"5*B/B*2"

-.'09."-.*"&'62*(6$-/'6"'7"(0%-/&0%-05$%/+(>"-.*".*5$%2/69"'7"-.*"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++>"$62"

Page 197: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!PM"

"

-.*"405+0/-"'7"$+4/5$-/'6"G^'--*5'"?@@Pj"X/%%1'56"?@!@j"R$&'"?@@Pj"8B*/6++'6"?@@PIJ"K./+"-.*+/+"

.$+"*C4%'5*2"-.*"/6B*+-(*6-"/6"6'+-$%9/$+"7'5"$"E./-*"<$+-"<62J"A-"$225*++*2".'E"-.*"1'5'09."

E$+"7'5(*2"-.5'09."(/95$-/'6"10-".'E"2/+&'05+*+"'6"-.*"X'%2*6"<5$"E*5*"0+*2>"$-"$"6$-/'6$%"

$62"%'&$%"%*B*%>"-'"*C4%$/6"$E$:"+-50&-05$%"$62"&%$++Q1$+*2"/6*h0$%/-/*+"-.5'09."/((/95$-/'6J"

8**6"/6"-.*"E/2*5"&'6-*C-"'7"$+4/5$-/'6"$62"-.*"(0&."%$02*2"2*$-."'7"(0%-/&0%-05$%/+(>"-.*+*"

6$-/'6$%"5'($6&*+"$62"C*6'4.'1/$+"6**2"-'"1*"E/2*%:"062*5+-''2"/7"-.*:"$5*"-'"1*"&'06-*5*2J"

8'"-''"2'"-.*"/6B/+/1%*"7'5(+"'7"(/22%*Q&%$++"E./-*"4'E*5"-.$-"+0+-$/6"-.*(J"

"

K.*"-.*+/+".$+"&.$%%*69*2"-.*"/6B*+-(*6-"/6"E./-*6*++>"-.5'09."&$%%/69"/6-'"h0*+-/'6"/-+"&%$/(+"

-'"-.*"+'/%"g"$0-'&.-.'6:"GX*+&./*5*"?@@Pj"Z0B$%Q3$B/+"?@!?IJ"S%$/(+"-'"*C&%0+/B*"1*%'69/69"/6"

<$+-";'62'6"&$6"1*"+0+-$/6*2"'6%:"E./%*"$"1*%/*7"/6"$6"$"45/'5/"6'-/'6"'7"E./-*"4*5($6*6&*"

5*($/6+"G#''5*"?@@VIJ"K./+"/+"$6"$590(*6-"-'"('5*"70%%:"5*B*$%"-.*"&'(4%*C/-:"'7"E./-*6*++"

$62"-.*"E$:+"/6"E./&."/-"/+"+'%2"-.5'09."7*-/+./+/69"6$-/'6$%/+-".'(*+"g"+0&."$+"<$+-";'62'6J"A-"

2*($62+"$--*6-/'6"-'".'E"-.*+*"6'+-$%9/&"%'&$-/'6+"E*5*"/6"7$&-"($2*"-.5'09."(/95$-/'6"$62"

6'-"45/('52/$%"'E6*5+./4>"$62".'E"E./-*6*++"/+"6'-"$--$&.*2"-'"E./-*"1'2/*+>"10-"/+"$"7%'$-/69"

+/96/7/*5J",+"E/-."'-.*5"^5/-/+."7'5(+"'7"5$&/+(>"$0-'&.-.'6:"/+"4'E*570%"1*&$0+*"/-"&$6"1*"

&%$/(*2"$62"45$&-/+*2"1:":'069"4*'4%*"E.'>"$"9*6*5$-/'6"*$5%/*5>"(/9.-"6'-".$B*"E./-*"

*6'09.J"

"

A7"E*"$5*"-'"$225*++"-.*"$%%05*"'7"E./-*6*++>"/-"/+"6*&*++$5:"-'"*69$9*"E/-."-.*"45'&*++"'7"

-5$&/69+"G^*66*--"?@@Nj"3*55/2$"!PMej"84/B$F"!PMeI"$62"&/-$-/'6"G^0-%*5"!PPO>"!PPMj"X/%5':"

!PPOI"-.$-"+0+-$/6"/-J"=05+0/69"$6-/Q5$&/+-"&%$/(+"'6"-.*"1$+/+"-.$-"-.*"%3')'(41"E./-*"E'5F/69Q

&%$++"$5*"45*H02/&*2"Gd$5*"?@@VI"/(4%/*+"$6"$"45/'5/"('(*6-"'7"7/C/-:"E./&."/+"$+"45'1%*($-/&"$+"

10:/69"/6-'"-.*"(:-.+"-.$-"E./-*+".$B*"+04*5/'5"5/9.-+"1*&$0+*"-.*:"E*5*"-.*5*"7/5+-"G_'29*"

?@@MIJ"

#$59/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"1*/69"401%/&"

K.*"-.*+/+".$+"$%+'"$225*++*2".'E"&%$++*2"$62"5$&/$%/+*2"7'5(+"'7"+'&/$%"&'6-5'%"$62"401%/&"

($59/6$%/+$-/'6".$B*"1**6"$44%/*2"-'":'069"4*'4%*J"A-".$+"+.'E6".'E"-.*+*"2/+&'05+*+"$62"

45$&-/&*+"E*5*"4$5-"'7"$"%'69*5"./+-'5:"-.5'09."E./&."-.*"(/22%*Q&%$++*+"($/6-$/6*2"-.*/5"

E*$%-."$62"+-$-0+"G,%*C$62*5"!PPejS'55/9$6"!PMPj"X/%5':"!PVMj"_$%%"*-"$%J"!PMVj"_0(4.5/*+"

!PV!j"=*$5+'6"!PVOj"8'%'('+"!PVVIJ"^*:'62"2/+/6B*+-/69"/6"-.*"/2*$"-.$-"-.*+*"$5*"E.'%%:"

6'B*%"4.*6'(*6$>"-.*"-.*+/+".$+"./9.%/9.-*2"+4*&/7/&"&'67/905$-/'6+"'7"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"

Page 198: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!PV"

"

($59/6$%/+$-/'6"-.$-"5*h0/5*"$--*6-/'6"/6"'52*5"-'"&'06-*5"-.*"0675**2'(+"$62"/6H0+-/&*+":'069"

4*'4%*"*C4*5/*6&*J"

"

K.*"-.*+/+".$+"2/+&0++*2"-.*"5*%$-/'6+./4+"1*-E**6"/6&5*$+/69"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"5*20&*2"

7062/69"45'B/+/'6J"K.*"/6&5*$+/69"'5/*6-$-/'6"'7":'0-."45'B/+/'6"-'"-.*"&5/(/6$%"H0+-/&*"$9*62$>"

4$5-6*5+./4"E'5F/69>"-.*"H'/6*2Q04"$&&'06-$6&:"+:+-*(+"'7"-.*"A6-*95$-*2"Z'0-."8044'5-"

8*5B/&*>"&'(1/6*2"E/-."-.*"*C-*62*2"4'%/&/69"'7"-.*"+-5**-+"-.5'09."-*&.6'%'9/*+"'7"

+05B*/%%$6&*>"&05-$/%*2"401%/&"75**2'("$62"($/6+-5*$(*2"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"/6"E$:+"6'-"

45*B/'0+%:"4'++/1%*J",+/2*"75'("-.*/5"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"75'("401%/&"+4$&*>"-.*"-.*+/+".$+"$%+'"

+.'E6".'E":'069"4*'4%*Y+"7'5(+"'7"&'((06/&$-/'6"E*5*"+/%*6&*2"7'5"1*/69"6/./%/+-/&"'5"+'%2Q

'0-"G^$0($6"?@!!j"_$6&'C"?@@Pj";'EF*:"?@!?j"=*$5+*"$62"K$:%'5"?@@Pj"8-$5F*:"?@!!IJ"K.*+*"

&'62*(6$-/'6+"75'("%*7-"$62"5/9.-"(*$6-"*C&%0+/'6"75'("2*('&5$-/&"2*1$-*"$62"2/$%'90*"

GS$%.'06"!PP?j"]5$+*5"!PP?j"X/%5':"!PPOj"_$1*5($+"!PVPI"$62"*6+05*2"-.$-":'069"4*'4%*Y+"

4'%/-/&$%"*C45*++/'6+"$62"4'%/-/&$%"$6$%:+*+"&'0%2"6'-"1*"%/+-*6*2"-'J"

"

,+"4$5-"'7"-.*+*"7'5(+"'7"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"$62"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"-.*"-.*+/+".$+"6'-*2"-.*"5/+*"'7"

6*'Q&'((06/-$5/$6/+("G=*&F"?@@?j"=*&F"$62"K/&F*%%"?@@?j"=05&*%%"?@@Oj"8E:69*2'0E"?@@@IJ"

d./%*"-.*"-.*+/+"/+"6'-"+099*+-/69"-.$-"$%%"7'5(+"'7"6*'Q&'((06/-$5/$6/+("$5*"-.*"+$(*>"'5"$%%"

'7"-.*("45'1%*($-/&>"/-".$+"*C4%'5*2"-.*"*C&%0+/'6+"-.$-"'&&05"E.*6"45'-*&-/B*"7'5(+"'7"

&'((06/-:"7**2"'6"5$&/$%/+*2"6'-/'6+"'7"'52*5"$62"&.$'+"-'"($F*"+*6+*"'7"06&*5-$/6-:"$62"

062*5Q5*+'05&/69J"R*%$-/69"1$&F"-'"-.*"&0-+"$62"-'"/2*$+"'7"E./-*6*++>"-.*"-.*+/+"$590*+"-.$-"

-.*+*"6*'Q&'((06/-$5/$6"7'5($-/'6+"&$6"5*Q*6-5*6&."/2*$+"'7"&'((06/-:"-.$-"5*%:"'6"

E./-*6*++"$62"%'++J"K./+>"-.*6>"*C$&*51$-*+"2/+&'05+*+"'7"5$&*>"6/./%/+("$62"062*5&%$++"$+"/-"

+**F+"-'"&5*$-*"('5$%"/6+/2*5+"$62"'0-+/2*5+J"K./+"/+"-.*"(/62Q+*-"'7"-.*"7*6&*2"&'((06/-:"

G,6a$%2t$"?@@Mj"^%$F*%:"$62"86:2*5"!PPPj"^5'E6"?@!@j";'E"?@@Oj"R'+*"$62"#/%%*5"?@@Vj"

8*66*--"!PPOI>"E.*5*"5$-.*5"-.$6"$225*++"-.*"/6*h0$%/-/*+"'7"+'&/*-:>"4*'4%*"10/%2"5$&/$%/+*2"

$62"('5$%"7'5-5*++*+"-'"45'-*&-"-.*(+*%B*+"75'("-.*"-.5*$-"-.*:"$5*"+/(0%-$6*'0+%:"

&'6+-50&-/69J"K.*+*"7'5(+"'7"-.5*$-"$5*"+/(/%$5%:"7%'$-/69"$62"($%%*$1%*"('5$%"+:+-*(+"-.$-"

2*+*5B*"705-.*5"$--*6-/'6>"&'(45/+/69"/6&5*$+/69%:"&'(4%*C"$62"'B*5%$/2"5$&/$%"&'2*+J"A6"

&'6-*(4'5$5:"U*E.$(>"-.*+*"&'2*+"'7"6/./%/+("$62"062*5&%$++"2'"6'-"1*%'69"-'"1%$&F"'5"

E./-*"1'2/*+J",62"E./%*"-.*:"5*&*/B*"$"+4*&/7/&"5*$2/69"-.'09."/->"-.*:"$5*"($%%*$1%*"$62"

$44%/&$1%*"-'"E/2*5"E'5F/69Q&%$++"&'%%*&-/B*+J"K.*:"$5*"-.*"4%$&*"E.*5*"&.$B"$62"(099*5>"

Page 199: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

!PP"

"

062*5&%$++"$62"6/./%/+-"&'(*"-'9*-.*5"E/-."E./-*Q+045*($&:Y+"7*$5"'7"(0%-/&0%-05$%"W4$-'/+Y"

G8-$5F*:"?@!!IJ",9$/6>"/7"-.*+*"2/+&'05+*+"$5*"6'-"062*5+-''2>"-.*:"&$66'-"1*"$225*++*2J"

"

_'E*B*5>":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"6'-"'6%:"1*/69"*C&%02*2"75'("401%/&"+4$&*"$62"2*1$-*"10-"$%+'"

75'("2'(/6$6-"45'H*&-/'6+"'7"-.*"70-05*J"_*%2"$9$/6+-"E./-*6*2"2/+&'05+*+"'7"$+4/5$-/'6"

G_$:%*--"?@@!j"=5*+-'6"?@@Pj"R*$:"?@@Pj"R*$:"*-"$%J"?@@Mj"8B*/6++'6"?@@PI>"E'5F/69Q&%$++"$62"

6'-QE./-*Q*6'09.":'069"4*'4%*"E*5*"1*/69"&'6+/96*2"-'"70-05*%*++"70-05*+J"K.*"*C&%0+/'6$5:"

2/+&'05+*+"'7"-.*"70-05*%*++"E*5*"%$/2"'0-"$%'69"-.*"*20&$-/'6g*(4%':(*6-g&'6+0(4-/'6"

-5$H*&-'5:"G#&R'11/*"?@@PI"$62"-.*+*"E*5*"+*%7Q4'%/&*2"-.5'09."$"1*%/*7"/6"*20&$-/'6$%"

/6*4-/-02*>"06*(4%':$1/%/-:"$62"&'6+0(*5"750+-5$-/'6+J"K./+"E$+"&'(4'062*2"1:"-.*"+.$54Q

*%1'E*2"*C&%0+/'6+"'7"-.'+*"40+.*2"-'"2*7/6*"-.*"70-05*%*++"/6"'52*5"-'"45'H*&-"-.*/5"'E6"

+0&&*++J"

Z'0-."4'%/-/&+"

^*:'62"-.*+*"&'6&*56+>"-.*"-.*+/+".$+"+'09.-"-'"./9.%/9.-"-.*"45$&-/&*+"$62"45'20&-/'6+"'7"

:'069"4*'4%*"$62"-.*/5"4'-*6-/$%"7'5"5*+/+-$6&*>"+01B*5+/'6"$62"4'%/-/&$%"$&-/'6J",+"E/-."($6:"

*$5%/*5"E'5F+"'6":'069"4*'4%*>"-./+"-.*+/+".$+"5*-056*2"-'"-.*"+01H*&-+"'7"5*+/+-$6&*"$62"

*B*5:2$:"+01B*5+/'6"G,%*C$62*5"?@@@j"_$%%"*-"$%J"!PMej"_*12/9*"!PMPj"_0(4.5/*+"!PV!j")'6*+"

!PVVj"d/%%/+"!PMMIJ"A-".$+"2/+&0++*2"&'6-*+-+"E/-."-.*"4'%/&*>"E/-."-.*":'0-."&%01"$0-.'5/-/*+"

$62"E/-."-.*"5$&/$%/+*2"+:+-*(+"'7"$&&'06-/69>"+'&/$%"&'6-5'%"$62"-*55/-'5/$%"9'B*56$6&*J"A-".$+"

+.'E6".'E"-.*"4'%/&*"E*5*"&.$%%*69*2"$62".'E"&$-*9'5/*+"'7"051$6"&'6-5'%"E*5*"&'670+*2"

-.5'09."-.*"*B*5:2$:"($%%*$1/%/-:"'7"(0%-/Q*-.6/&"1'2:"-:4*+>"75/*62+./4+>"('B*(*6-"$62"

+'%/2$5/-/*+"1*:'62"-.*+*"1'062$5/*+J"K'"-./+"*C-*6-"/-".$+"('B*2"-'"5*Q4'%/-/&/+*"*-.6'95$4./&"

E'5F"-.$-".$+"1*&'(*"-''"/6B*+-*2"/6"%/1*5$%"&*%*15$-/'6+"'7"-.*".$44:"*B*5:2$:>"-.*"

5'($6-/&$%%:"+04*5Q2/B*5+*"$62"-.*"/55*20&/1%:".:15/2J",%-.'09."/-".$+"%$59*%:"5*-056*2"-.*"

&'6&%0+/'6"-.$-"-.*+*"7'5(+"'7"5*+/+-$6&*>"E./%+-"./9.%/9.-/69"/6H0+-/&*+>"'7-*6"5*($/6"E/-./6"

2'(/6$6-"+:+-*(+"'7"+'&/$%"&'6-5'%>"/-".$+"$%+'"+.'E6".'E"7'5(+"'7"&'6&*6-5$-*2"+01B*5+/'6"

'4*6*2"+4$&*+"E.*5*"5$&/$%/+*2"+:+-*(+"'7"+'&/$%"$62"-*55/-'5/$%"&'6-5'%"E*5*"('5*"5$2/&$%%:"

'B*5-056*2J"A6";*:.$("-./+"E$+"*B/2*6-"/6"-.*"7'5(+"'7"+'%/2$5/-:"$62"*B*5:2$:".*-*5'9*6*/-:"

-.$-"-.*":'069"4*'4%*"$62":'0-."E'5F*5+"2*('6+-5$-*2"/6"-.*"7$&*"'7"-.*"4'%/&*J"A6"-.*",7-*5"

8&.''%"S%01"/-"E$+"*B/2*6-"/6".'E"$0-'&.-.'6'0+"6'-/'6+"'7"1*%'69/69"E*5*"15'F*6"2'E6"

E.*6"2/$+4'5$"(6*('6/&+"E*5*"45'(/6*6-J"

"

Page 200: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?@@"

"

U/./%/+-/&"$*+-.*-/&+"'77*5*2"$"2/77*5*6-"E$:"'7"2'/69"4'%/-/&+"7'5":'069"4*'4%*J"Z'069"4*'4%*"

0+*2"-.*"$*+-.*-/&+"'7"6/./%/+("$+"$"B*./&%*"-'"1*&'(*"5*7%*C/B*%:"$E$5*"'7"-.*"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"

-.*:"E*5*"+01H*&-*2"-'J"K.5'09."-.*/5"$5-/+-/&"45'20&-/'6+"-.*:"&'6+/2*5*2"-.*"7'5(+"'7"

/6H0+-/&*"-.*:"E*5*"+01H*&-*2"-'f"-.*"&5/(/6$%/+$-/'6"'7"401%/&"+4$&*>"-.*"%/(/-+"4%$&*2"'6"-.*/5"

.'5/a'6+>"$62"-.*"&'6+-5$/6-+"'7"-.*/5"'E6"$6-/Q+'&/$1/%/-:J",62"E./%*"-.*+*"4'%/-/&+"E*5*"6'-"

0-'4/$6>"$62"/62**2"E*5*"&'((06/&$-*2"$+"$"7'5("'7"6*9$-/B*"4'%/-/&+>"-.*:"2/2"'77*5"$"

&5/-/h0*"'7"/6H0+-/&*"$62"-.*"4'-*6-/$%"7'5"('5*".0($6/+-/&"E$:+"'7"%/B/69J"K'"-./+"*C-*6->"5$-.*5"

-.$6"*62"-.*"75**2'("&5:"-.5'09."$"5*-056"-'"-.*"1'2:"G30"^'/+"?@@Mj"X/%5':"?@@@>"?@!@$j"

#'-*6"?@@OI"-.*:"&5*$-*2"$%-*56$-/B*"+&*6$5/'+"7'5"-.*"-'Q&'(*J"A6"-.*"&'6-*C-"/6"E./&.":'069"

4*'4%*Y+"$&-/'6+"$5*"&'62*(6*2"1:"-.*"%*7-"$62"5/9.-"$+"$4'%/-/&$%>"+'%2Q'0-"$62"6/./%/+-/&"/-"/+"

/6&5*$+/69%:"6*&*++$5:"-'"%/+-*6"-'"-.*/5"4'%/-/&+"$62"$%-*56$-/B*".'5/a'6+>"$62"062*5+-$62"-.*"

$*+-.*-/&"7'5($-/'6"'7"-.*/5"04&'(/69"('B*(*6-+J"

"

,+"-.*"5*+*$5&."4*5/'2"*62*2>"-.*"6*&*++/-:"-'"*69$9*"E/-."-.*+*"-.*(*+"E$+"+.$54*6*2"1:"$6"

*B*6-J"K.*"*B*6-"E$+"-.*"?@!?";'62'6"T%:(4/&+J"S'(/69"$7-*5"-.*"X'%2*6")01/%**"'7"-.*"+$(*"

:*$5>"-.*";'62'6"T%:(4/&+"E$+"?@!?Y+"4/66$&%*"'7"H/69'/+(>"&'((*5&/$%/+("$62"6*'Q%/1*5$%"

1'2:"4'%/-/&+J";'&$-*2"/6"-.*"6'5-.Q*$+-"&'56*5"'7"U*E.$(>"6'-"7$5"75'("E.*5*"A".$2"E'5F*2>"

8-5$-7'52".$2"'6&*"$9$/6"1*&'(*"-.*"&*6-5*"'7"$6"*(4/5*"-./+"-/(*"+4'6+'5*2"1:"S'&$QS'%$"

$62",2/2$+"$62"'5/*6-*2"-'E$52+"-.*"$+4/5$-/'6$%"&'6+0(*5J"=0(4/69"'0-"75'("-.*"+-$-*Q'7Q

-.*Q$5-"(*2/$"&*6-5*"'6"-.*"1$6F"'7"-.*"5/B*5";*$"E*5*"-.*"(*5/-+"'7"/62/B/20$%/+*2"2/+&/4%/6*"

$62"&'54'5*$%"'52*5J"d./%*"-./+"*B*6-"E$+"($6:"-./69+>"/-"E$+"$%+'"$"2*&%$5$-/B*"+-$-*(*6-"'6"

-.*"F/62"'7"T%:(4/&";*9$&:"-.$-"E$+"1*/69"1*h0*$-.*2"-'"U*E.$(Y+",5&"'7"T44'5-06/-:"G;^U>"

?@!@"|MV\IJ"K.*"B/'%*6-"*C&%0+/B/-:"*6-$/%*2"/6"-./+"B/+/'6"E$+"($5F*2"1:"$"&'06-*54'/6-J"K*6"

(/60-*+Y"E$%F"$E$:"/6"d*+-"_$("=$5F"A"+-'44*2"-'"+4*$F"-'"$"95'04"'7":'069"(*6"+/--/69"'6"$"

4$5F"1*6&.J"A-"E$+"-.*"1*9/66/69"'7"-.*"+*&'62"E**F"'7"-.*"T%:(4/&+"$62"A"$+F*2"-.*("E.$-"/-"

E$+"2'/69"7'5"-.*(J"K.*:"&'0%2".$B*"-5'--*2"'0-"-.*"0+0$%"Kc"4%$-/-02*+>"10-"-.*:"2/26Y-J"

_$44:"-'"&'6B*5+*>"$"2/$%'90*"+-$5-*2J"]'5"-.*(>"-./+"B/+/'6"'7"$+4/5$-/'6"(*$6-"1*/69"+-'44*2"

1:"-.*"4'%/&*"04"-'"7'05"-/(*+"$"2$:>".$5$++*2"$62"G/%%*9$%%:I"+-5/4Q+*$5&.*2"/6"-.*"1$&F+"'7"

4'%/&*"B$6+J"#$62$-*2"-'"45'-*&-"-.*"9''2"T%:(4/&"&'((06/-:>"/-"E$+".$52"6'-"-'"-./6F"-.$-"

-.*".0625*2+"'7"4'%/&*"/6"-.*"$5*$"E*5*"+/96$%%/69"-.*"'6+*-"'7"2**4*6/69"5$&/$%/+*2"$62"

&%$++*2"&'6-5$2/&-/'6+"/6"U*E.$(J",695:"$62"$775'6-*2>"-.*":'069"(*6"2/26Y-".$B*"$"+'%0-/'6"

10-"-.*:"E*5*"&%*$5"$1'0-"-.*"/6H0+-/&*+>"$62"-.*"6*&*++/-:"7'5"$6"$%-*56$-/B*"70-05*J"

Page 201: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?@!"

"

R*7*5*6&*+"

,15$.$(+>"R'9*5"3J"!PM?J"z)'F/69f"-.*"-5$/6/69"'7"-.*"($6"'7"E'52+"/6"-$%F/69"15'$2z>"/6"K.'($+"`'&.($6"*2J":4##'(e!4(5!-,/1'(e!%0,.!$%&&0('$4,'%(!'(!03T4(!T14$=![&+3'$4J"[51$6$>"A%%J>"44J?!NQ?\@J"

,9$(1*6>"X/'59/'J"!PPVJ"B%&%!-4$+3.!-%*+3+')(!#%C+3!4(5!T43+!1'F+J"8-$67'52>"S$%/7Jf"8-$67'52"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

,9$(1*6>"X/'59/'J"?@@NJ";,4,+!%F!+M$+#,'%(J"S./&$9'f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"S./&$9'"=5*++J"

,%&'77>";/62$J"?@@eJ"d'-'T1+!'5+(,','+-.!34$+2!)+(5+32!4(5!,9+!-+1FJ"U*E"Z'5Ff"TC7'52"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

,%2*5+'6>"=5/+&/%%$"$62"c/59/6/$"#'55'EJ"?@@\J"7,9'$-2!-%$'41!3+-+43$9!4(5!$%(-01,'()!C',9!$9'153+(!4(5!/%0()!#+%#1+J"?62"*2/-/'6J"A%7'52f"^$56$52'o+J"

,%*C$62*5>"S%$/5*J"!PPeJ"<9+!43,!%F!T+'()!T14$=.!,9+!$3+4,'%(!%F!T14$=!G3','-9!/%0,9!'5+(,','+-J"TC7'52f"S%$5*62'6"=5*++J"

,%*C$62*5>"S%$/5*J"?@@@J"<9+![-'4(!)4().!+,9('$',/2!'5+(,',/2!&4-$01'(',/J"TC7'52f"^*59J"

,%*C$62*5>"S%$/5*J"?@@OJ"zd5/-/69"5$&*f"*-.6'95$4.:"$62"-.*"/($9/6$-/'6"'7"<9+![-'4(!D4()z>"/6"#$5-/6"^0%(*5"$62")'.6"8'%'('+"*2+J":+-+43$9'()!34$+!4(5!34$'-&J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*>"44J!O\Q!\PJ"

,%*C$62*5>"S%$/5*J"?@@eJ"zA6-5'20&-/'6f"($44/69"-.*"/++0*+zJ"7,9('$!4(5!:4$'41!;,05'+->"B'%J?P>"6'JO>"44JOPMQ\!@J"

,%*C$62*5>"S%$/5*J"?@@VJ"H:+J,9'(='()!R)4()-SJ";'62'6f"R066:(*2*"K50+-J"

,%*C$62*5>"S%$/5*J"?@!!J"z#$F/69"^*69$%/"^5/&F";$6*f"&%$/(/69"$62"&'6-*+-/69"+4$&*"/6"<$+-";'62'6zJ"G3','-9!]%03(41!%F!;%$'%1%)/>"B'%Je?>"6'J?>"44J?@!Q??@J"

,%*C$62*5>"S%$/5*J"]'5-.&'(/69J"zS'6-*+-*2"(*('5/*+f"-.*"8.$./2"#/6$5"$62"-.*"+-5099%*"7'5"2/$+4'5/&"+4$&*zJ"7,9('$!4(5!:4$'41!;,05'+-J"

,%*C$62*5>"S%$/5*"<J"?@@NJ"z<(1'2:/69"B/'%*6&*f"W5/'-+Y"2/+D'52*5+"$62"-.*"45/B$-*"%/B*+"'7"W-.*",+/$6"9$69Yz>"/6"S%$/5*"<J",%*C$62*5"$62"S$5'%/6*"`6'E%*+"*2+J"N4='()!34$+!&4,,+3.!T%5'+-2!-#4$+!4(5!'5+(,',/J"^$+/69+-'F*f"=$%95$B*"#$&(/%%$6>"44J!PPQ?!MJ"

,%/>"80F/J"?@@eJ"zR$&/$%/a/69"5*+*$5&.f"($6$9/69"4'%/-/&+"$62"4'E*5izJ"7,9('$!4(5!:4$'41!;,05'+->"B'%J?P>"6'JO>"44J\M!Q\VeJ"

,(/6>",+.J"?@@?J"z<-.6/&/-:"$62"-.*"(0%-/&0%-05$%"&/-:f"%/B/69"E/-."2/B*5+/-:zJ"7(*'3%(&+(,!4(5!Z14(('()>"B'%JO\>""44JPNPQPV@J"

Page 202: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?@?"

"

,(/6>",+.J"?@!@J"zK.*"5*($/62*5+"'7"5$&*zJ"<9+%3/2!_01,03+!4(5!;%$'+,/>"B'%J?M>"6'J!>"44J!Q?OJ"

,(/6>",+.J"[6401%/+.*2J"zK*%*+&'4/&"051$6/+("$62"-.*"4''5zJ"

,62*5+'6>"^*6*2/&-J"!PP!J"L&4)'(+5!$%&&0(','+-.!3+F1+$,'%(-!%(!,9+!%3')'(!4(5!-#3+45!%F!(4,'%(41'-&J"R*BJ"$62"*C-*62*2"*2J";'62'6f"c*5+'J"

,62*5+'6>"<%/H$.J"!PPPJ"_%5+!%F!,9+!-,3++,.!5+$+($/2!*'%1+($+2!4(5!,9+!&%341!1'F+!%F!,9+!'((+3!$',/J"U*E"Z'5F>";'62'6f"dJd"U'5-'6J"

,6a$%2t$>"X%'5/$J"?@@MJ"G%35+314(5-@!84!F3%(,+34.!,9+!(+C!&+-,'b4J"O52"*2/-/'6J"8$6"]5$6&/+&'f",06-";0-*"^''F+J"

,44$205$/>",5H06J"?@@\J"zK.*"&$4$&/-:"-'"$+4/5*f"&0%-05*"$62"-.*"-*5(+"'7"5*&'96/-/'6z>"/6"c/H$:*625$"R$'"$62"#/&.$*%"d$%-'6"*2+J"_01,03+!4(5!#0T1'$!4$,'%(J"8-$67'52>"S$%/7Jf"8-$67'52"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++>"44JNPQV\J"

,5&.*5>";'0/+*"$62"^*&F:"]5$6&/+J"?@@MJ""(5+3-,4(5'()!&'(%3',/!+,9('$!4$9'+*+&+(,.!34$+2!)+(5+32!$14--!4(5!e-0$$+--eJ";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*J"

,+$2>"K$%$%J"!PVeJ"zK.*"&'6&*4-"'7"&0%-05$%"-5$6+%$-/'6"/6"^5/-/+."+'&/$%"$6-.5'4'%'9:z>"/6")$(*+"S%/77'52"$62"X*'59*"<J"#$5&0+"*2+J"^3','()!$01,03+.!,9+!#%+,'$-!4(5!#%1','$-!%F!+,9(%)34#9/.!4!;$9%%1!%F![&+3'$4(!:+-+43$9!45*4($+5!-+&'(43J"^*5F*%*:f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"S$%/7'56/$"=5*++>"44J!\!Q!e\J"

,+-'6"#$6+7/*%2J"U'"2$-*J"z,"15/*7"./+-'5:"'7",+-'6"#$6+7/*%2"zf",+-'6"#$6+7/*%2J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f"EEEJ$+-'6Q($6+7/*%2J'59J0FJ",&&*++*2"!V-."]*150$5:"?@!!J""

^$1:%'6"x''J"!PPNJ";#4$+&4(f"<#AJ"

^$&F>";*+J"!PP\J"I+C!+,9('$','+-!4(5!03T4(!$01,03+.!34$'-&-!4(5!&01,'$01,03+!'(!/%0()!1'*+-J";'62'6f"[S;"=5*++J"

^$&F>";*+J"?@@?J"zX0*++"E.'o+"&'(/69"-'"2/66*5i"K.*"4'%/-/&$%"('5$%/-:"'7"/6B*+-/9$-/69"E./-*6*++"/6"-.*"95$:"a'6*z>"/6"c*5'6/&$"d$5*"$62";*+"^$&F"*2+J"60,!%F!C9',+(+--.!$%1%32!#%1','$-2!4(5!$01,03+J";'62'6f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"S./&$9'"=5*++>"44JOOQNPJ"

^$&F>";*+J"?@@O$J"z8'062+"/6"-.*"&5'E2z>"/6"#/&.$*%"^0%%"$62";*+"^$&F"*2+J"<9+!405',%3/!$01,03+!3+45+3J"TC7'52f"^*59>"44JO!!QO?MJ"

^$&F>";*+J"?@@O1J"zd5/-/69"/6"$62"$9$/6+-"-/(*z>"/6"#$5-/6"^0%(*5"$62")'.6"8'%'('+"*2+J":+-+43$9'()!34$+!4(5!34$'-&J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*>"44J?@OQ?!OJ"

^$&F>";*+J"?@@NJ"zo_'(*"75'(".'(*of":'0-."1*%'69/69"$62"4%$&*z>"/6"S%$/5*"<J",%*C$62*5"$62"S$5'%/6*"`6'E%*+"*2+J"N4='()!34$+!&4,,+3.!T%5'+-2!-#4$+!4(5!'5+(,',/J"^$+/69+-'F*f"=$%95$B*"#$&(/%%$6>"44J!PQ\!J"

^$&F>";*+J"?@@MJ"<9+!43,!%F!1'-,+('()J"TC7'52f"^*59J"

^$F.-/6>"#J"#J"!PV!J"<9+!5'41%)'$!'&4)'(4,'%(.!F%03!+--4/-f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"K*C$+"=5*++J"

Page 203: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?@O"

"

^$F.-/6>"#/F.$/%"#J"!PPOJ"<%C435!4!#9'1%-%#9/!%F!,9+!4$,J",0+-/6f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"K*C$+J"

^$F.-/6>"#/F.$/%J"#J"!PV\J":4T+14'-!4(5!9'-!C%315J"^%''(/69-'6f"A62/$6$"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

^$F.-/6>"#/F.$/%J"#J"!PVe$J"zK.*"45'1%*("'7""+4**&."9*65*+z>"/6"S$5:%"<(*5+'6"$62"#/&.$*%"_'%h0/+-"*2+J";#++$9!)+(3+-!4(5!%,9+3!14,+!+--4/-J",0+-/6f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"K*C$+"=5*++>"44Je@Q!@?J"

^$F.-/6>"#/F.$/%J"#J"J"!PVe1J"zK'E$52"$"(*-.'2'%'9:"'7"-.*".0($6"+&/*6&*+z>"/6"#J"#J"^$F.-/6>"S$5:%"<(*5+'6"$62"#/&.$*%"_'%h0/+-"*2+J";#++$9!)+(3+-!4(5!%,9+3!14,+!+--4/-J",0+-/6f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"K*C$+"=5*++>"44J!NMQ!M@J"

^$%2E/6>"3$B$5/$6";J"?@!@J"z^%$&F"*(4/5*+>"E./-*"2*+/5*+f"-.*"+4$-/$%"4'%/-/&+"'7"/2*6-/-:"/6"-.*"$9*"'7"./4Q.'4z>"/6"#$5F",6-.'6:"U*$%"$62"#055$:"]'5($6"*2+J"<94,e-!,9+!a%'(,f.!,9+!9'#g9%#!-,05'+-!3+45+3J"?62"*2/-/'6J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*>"44J!NPQ!MeJ"

^$6*5H*$>"`'0+./F"$62")$-/62*5"^$56J"!PPeJ"zc*5+/'6/69"-*55'5f")$%%/$6E$%$"^$9."$62"-.*"H069%*z>"/6"8$6H$:"8.$5($>")'.6"_0-6:F"$62",+.E$6/"8.$5($"*2+J">'-g%3'+(,'()!39/,9&-.!,9+!#%1','$-!%F!,9+!(+C![-'4(!54($+!&0-'$J";'62'6f"x*2"^''F+>"44J!POQ?!eJ"

^$6*+>"8$%%:J"?@@\J"z^5*$F/69z>"/6"#$5F",6-.'6:"U*$%"$62"#055$:"]'5($6"*2+J"<94,e-!,9+!a%'(,f.!,9+!9'#g9%#!-,05'+-!3+45+3J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*>"44J!OQ?@J"

^$6-'6>"#/&.$*%J"!PNNJ"<9+!$%1%03+5!c043,+3.!(+)3%!'&&')34(,-!'(!4(!7()1'-9!$',/J";'62'6f")'6$-.$6"S$4*J"

^$5F*5>"#$5-/6J"!PV!J"<9+!(+C!34$'-&.!_%(-+3*4,'*+-!4(5!,9+!'5+%1%)/!%F!,9+!,3'T+J";'62'6f")06&-/'6"^''F+J"

^$0($6>"x:9(06-J"?@!!J"zK.*";'62'6"5/'-+f"'6"&'6+0(*5/+("&'(/69".'(*"-'"5''+-z>",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ+'&/$%Q*05'4*J*0D?@!!D@VD-.*Q%'62'6Q5/'-+Q'6Q&'6+0(*5/+(Q&'(/69Q.'(*Q-'Q5''+-DJ",&&*++*2"O!+-")0%:"?@!?J"

^^SJ"?@@eJ"zS$(*5'6"$--$&F+"R$2/'"!o+"./4Q.'4"zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDD6*E+J11&J&'J0FD!D./D0F}4'%/-/&+DN@NNM?\J+-(J",&&*++*2"O!+-")0%:"?@!?J"

^^SJ"?@@V$J"z)$/%"F6/7*"&$55/*5+>"+$:+"S$(*5'6zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDD6*E+J11&J&'J0FD!D./D0F}4'%/-/&+DM\P?MNVJ+-(J",&&*++*2"M-."8*4-*(1*5"?@!@J"

^^SJ"?@@V1J"z8/+-*5Y+"-5/10-*"-'"-50*"$69*%zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDD6*E+J11&J&'J0FD!D./D0F}4'%/-/&+DM\P?MNVJ+-(J",&&*++*2"?!+-")06*"?@!?J"

^^SJ"?@@V&J"zd./-*"+*$+'6zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ11&J&'J0FDE./-*DJ",&&*++*2"!+-",45/%"?@@PJ"

^^SJ"?@!@J"z=''5*+-";'62'6"1'5'09.+"7$&*"2**4"7062/69"&0-+zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ11&J&'J0FD6*E+D0FQ*69%$62Q%'62'6Q!!PP!PVMJ",&&*++*2"V-."#$5&."?@!!J"

^^SJ"?@!!J"z8*&'62$5:"+&.''%+"$62"&'%%*9*+"/6"U*E.$(zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ11&J&'J0FD6*E+D+4*&/$%D*20&$-/'6D+&.''%}-$1%*+D+*&'62$5:[email protected](%DO!eJ+-(J",&&*++*2"?62"#$5&."?@!!J"

Page 204: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?@\"

"

^*1'J"?@@P$J"z3/+$5(/69"^5/-$/6zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ1*1'J&'(D2/+$5(/6915/-$/6J",&&*++*2"O52"#$5&."?@!!J"

^*1'J"?@@P1J"zA-"2'*+6o-".$B*"-'".$44*6zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ1*1'J&'(D/-2'*+6-.$B*-'.$44*6J",&&*++*2"O52"#$5&."?@!!J"

^*/2*5>"_$55/+J"?@!!J"zS'((06/-:"&'.*+/'6f"-.*"B/*E+"'7"E./-*"E'5F/69Q&%$++"&'((06/-/*+zf")'+*4."R'E6-5**"]'062$-/'6J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJH57J'59J0FD401%/&$-/'6+DE'5F/69Q&%$++QB/*E+Q6*/9.1'05.''2J",&&*++*2"?62"#$:""?@!?J""

^*62*5>"S'05-6*:J"!PPVJ"z^$F.-/6/$6"4*5+4*&-/B*+"/6"W*B*5:2$:"%/7*Y"+'&/'%'9:"z>"/6"#/&.$*%"#$:*57/*%2"^*%%"$62"#/&.$*%"X$52/6*5"*2+J"G4=9,'(!4(5!,9+!90&4(!-$'+($+-.!(%!14-,!C%35-J";'62'6f"8,X<>"44J!V!Q!PNJ"

^*6H$(/6>"d$%-*5J"!PeVJ"zK.*+/+"'6"-.*"4./%'+'4.:"'7"./+-'5:z>"/6"d$%-*5"^*6H$(/6"*2J"L110&'(4,'%(-J"U*E"Z'5Ff"8&.'&F*6"^''F+>"44J?NOQ?e\J"

^*6H$(/6>"d$%-*5J"!PMVJ"z,"^*5%/6"S.5'6/&%*z>"/6"d$%-*5"^*6H$(/6"*2J":+F1+$,'%(-.!+--4/-2!4#9%3'-&-2!40,%T'%)34#9'$41!C3','()J"U*E"Z'5Ff"8&.'&F*6"^''F+>"44JOQe@J"

^*66*-->",62:J"!PPPJ"zR$44/6o"'6"-.*"K:6*f"E./-*"./4".'4"&0%-05*"/6"U'5-.*$+-"<69%$62"Q"$6"*-.6'95$4./&"+-02:zJ"<9+!;%$'%1%)'$41!:+*'+C>"B'%J\M>"6'J!>"44J!Q?\J"

^*66*-->"K'6:J"?@@NJ"z8-'5*2"B/5-0*f"(*('5:>"-.*"1'2:"$62"-.*"*B'%0-/'6$5:"(0+*0(z>"/6"80+$66$."R$2+-'6*"$62"`$-.$5/6*"_'29F/6"*2+J"N+&%3/!$01,03+-.!&+&%3/2!-0Ta+$,'*',/2!4(5!3+$%)(','%(J"U*E"^506+E/&F>"UJ)f"K5$6+$&-/'6"=01%/+.*5+>"44J\@QN\J"

^*5($6>"#$5+.$%%J"!PVeJ"zK$F*"/-"-'"-.*"+-5**-+f"&'67%/&-"$62"&'((06/-:"/6"401%/&"+4$&*zJ">'--+(,6'J]$%%>"44J\M@Q\P\J"

^*++$6->")02/-.>"*-"$%J"?@@OJ"h>'-$%*+3'()h!3'-=.!-%$'41!3+-+43$9!4(5!#%1'$/!&4='()J"U*E"Z'5Ff"=J";$69J"

^.$1.$>"_'(/"`J"!PP\J"<9+!1%$4,'%(!%F!$01,03+J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*J"

^/%%/9>"#/&.$*%J"!PPNJ"G4(41!(4,'%(41'-&J";'62'6f"8,X<J"

^%$F*%:>"<2E$52")J"$62"#$5:"X$/%"86:2*5J"!PPPJ"E%3,3+--![&+3'$4.!)4,+5!$%&&0(','+-!'(!,9+!"(',+5!;,4,+-J"S$(15/29*>"#$++Jf"^5''F/69+"A6+-/-0-/'6"=5*++J"

^%'&.>",%/&*J"?@@?J"<9+!&')34,'%(!4(5!-+,,1+&+(,!%F!3+F0)++-!'(!G3',4'(J"^$+/69+-'F*f"=$%95$B*"#$&(/%%$6J"

^%'&.>"_'E$52"3J"!PPNJ"I+C94&!>%$=14(5J"8-5'02f"S.$%7'52J"

^%'&.>"_'E$52"3J"!PPVJ"_4(('()!<%C(!*%'$+-J"8-5'02f"S.$%7'52J"

^%0*";$1'05J"?@!?J"z^%0*";$1'05f";$1'05o+"5$2/&$%"-5$2/-/'6zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ1%0*%$1'05J'59DJ",&&*++*2"?e-.")0%:"?@!?J"

Page 205: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?@N"

"

^%0(*5>"_*51*5-J"!PePJ";/&T%1'$!'(,+34$,'%('-&.!#+3-#+$,'*+!4(5!&+,9%5J"<69%*E''2"S%/77+>"UJ)Jf"=5*6-/&*Q_$%%J"

^'66*-->",%$+-$/5J"?@@@J"^9',+!'5+(,','+-.!9'-,%3'$41!4(5!'(,+3(4,'%(41!#+3-#+$,'*+-J"_$5%'E>"U*E"Z'5Ff"=5*6-/&*"_$%%J"

^''-.>"d/%%/$(J"!VP@J"L(!543=+-,!7()14(5.!4(5!,9+!C4/!%0,J";'62'6f"A6-*56$-/'6$%"_*$2h0$5-*5+"'7"-.*"8$%B$-/'6",5(:J"

^'--*5'>"d*62:J"?@@PJ"zS%$++"/6"-.*"?!+-"S*6-05:z>"/6"`H$5-$6"=~%%"8B*/6++'6"*2J"^9%!$43+-!4T%0,!,9+!C9',+!C%3='()!$14--i";'62'6f"R066:(*2*>"44JMQ!NJ"

^':(>"8B*-%$6$J"?@@!J"<9+!F0,03+!%F!(%-,41)'4J"U*E"Z'5Ff"^$+/&"^''F+J"

^5$.>",B-$5J"!PPeJ"_43,%)34#9'+-!%F!5'4-#%34.!$%(,+-,'()!'5+(,','+-J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*J"

^5$.>",B-$5J"!PPPJ"zK.*"+&*6-"'7"(*('5:f"+-5$69*5+>"'05"'E6>"$62"'-.*5+zJ"E+&'('-,!:+*'+C>"B'%Je!"44J\Q?eJ"

^5$/%*:>"`*B/6J"?@@VJ"L(,+)34,+5!/%0,9!-0##%3,!-+3*'$+.!,9+!I+C94&!#'$,03+f"[6401%/+.*2J"

^5$(E*%%>"R/&.$52J"?@!?J"zK.*"$*+-.*-/&+"$62"*-./&+"'7";'62'6"1$+*2"5$4f"$"+'&/'%'9:"'7"[`"./4Q.'4"$62"95/(*z>",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDD*-.*+*+J%+*J$&J0FD!VPDJ",&&*++*2"\-."8*4-*(1*5"?@!?J"

^5*66*5>"U*/%J"?@@!J"zK.*"%/(/-+"-'"+&$%*i"#*-.'2'%'9/&$%"5*7%*&-/'6+"'6"+&$%$5"+-50&-05$-/'6zJ"Z3%)3+--!'(!B0&4(!D+%)34#9/>"B'%J?N>"6'J\>"44JNP!Qe!\J"

^5*66*5>"U*/%J"?@@\J"I+C!-,4,+!-#4$+-.!03T4(!)%*+3(4($+!4(5!,9+!3+-$41'()!%F!-,4,+9%%5J"TC7'52f"TC7'52"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

^5*66*5>"U*/%"$62"U/F"K.*'2'5*J"?@@?J"zS/-/*+"$62"9*'95$4./*+"'7"z$&-0$%%:"*C/+-/69"6*'%/1*5$%/+(ozJ"[(,'#%5+>"B'%JO\>"6'JO>"44JO\PQOMPJ"

^5/&F"$62";$&*J"?@@PJ"G45!,%!5'!T%(+f"='%:2'5J"

^5/-$/6o+"X'-"K$%*6-J"?@@PJ"z]%$E%*++"3$6&*"$&-zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDD-$%*6-J/-BJ&'(D?@@PD7/6$%/+-+D7/6$%/+-Q2*-$/%D/-*(}\@@@@NJ.-(%J",&&*++*2"!e-."#$:"?@!?J"

^5/-/+."_'0+*.'%2"=$6*%"805B*:J"?@@VJ"z^5/-/+."_'0+*.'%2"=$6*%"805B*:zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ/+*5J*++*CJ$&J0FD+05B*:D1.4+DJ",&&*++*2"!!-."#$:"?@!!J"

^5/-/+."8'&/'%'9/&$%",++'&/$-/'6J"?@@?J"z^5/-/+."8'&/'%'9/&$%",++'&/$-/'6f"+-$-*(*6-"'7"*-./&$%"45$&-/&*zJ",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ15/-+'&J&'J0FD0+*5}2'&D8-$-*(*6-�?@'7�?@<-./&$%�?@=5$&-/&*J427J",&&*++*2"O52"#$5&."?@@PJ""

^5'2F/6>"`$5*6J"!PPVJ"B%C!]+C-!T+$4&+!C9',+!F%1=-!4(5!C94,!,94,!-4/-!4T%0,!34$+!'(![&+3'$4i";'62'6f"R0-9*5+"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

Page 206: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?@e"

"

^5'E6>"S.5/+J"?@@N$J"_93'-!G3%C(f")/B*"R*&'52+J"

^5'E6>"S.5/+J"?@@N1J"`%!H+M$0-+!&+!&'--Jf"x'(1$J"

^5'E6>"S.5/+J"?@@M$J"^411!,%!C411f"x'(1$J"

^5'E6>"X$B/6J"?@!!J"z<('-/'6$%"9*'95$4./*+"'7":'069"4*'4%*o+"$+4/5$-/'6+"7'5"$20%-"%/7*zJ"_9'153+(e-!D+%)34#9'+->"B'%JP>"6'J!>"44JMQ??J"

^5'E6>"X'52'6J"?@@M1J"z=#"X'52'6"^5'E6"+*-+"'0-"B/+/'6"7'5"zE'5%2"&%$++"*20&$-/'6z"zJ"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"X5**6E/&.",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDD0F/69*5($6:J7&'J9'BJ0FD*6D6*E+DiB/*EÄ84**&.k/2Ä\e!eNe@J",&&*++*2"?62"8*4-*(1*5"?@!?J"

^5'E6>"d*62:J"?@!@J"^411+5!-,4,+-2!C4('()!-%*+3+')(,/J"U*E"Z'5Ff"x'6*"^''F+J"

^0-%*5>")02/-.J"!PPOJ"G%5'+-!,94,!&4,,+3.!%(!,9+!5'-$03-'*+!1'&',-!%F!h-+MhJ"U*E"Z'5Ff"R'0-%*29*J"

^0-%*5>")02/-.J"!PPMJ"7M$',4T1+!-#++$9.!4!#%1','$-!%F!,9+!#+3F%3&4,'*+J"U*E"Z'5Ff"R'0-%*29*J"

^0-%*5>")02/-.J"!PPPJ"zT6"84**&.>"R$&*"$62"#*%$6&.'%/$f",6"A6-*5B/*E"E/-.")02/-."^0-%*5zJ"<9+%3/2!_01,03+!4(5!;%$'+,/>"B'%J!e>"6'J?>"44J!eOQ!M\J"

^0-%*5>"K/("$62"S.5/+"_$(6*--J"?@!!J"7,9('$',/2!$14--!4(5!4-#'34,'%(.!0(5+3-,4(5'()!8%(5%(e-!(+C!74-,!7(5J"^5/+-'%f"='%/&:J"

S$/56+>"R'1*5-"^J"$62"^*B*5%*:"3J"S$/56+J"!PP\J"8'F+1'(+-!4(5!3'-=-.!#4,9C4/-!%F!/%0,9!'(!%03!,'&+J"S$(15/29*f"S$(15/29*"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

S$%.'06>"S5$/9")J"!PP?J"zA6-5'20&-/'6f"_$1*5($+"$62"-.*"401%/&"+4.*5*z>"/6"S5$/9")J"S$%.'06"*2J"B4T+3&4-!4(5!,9+!#0T1'$!-#9+3+J"S$(15/29*>"#$++Jf"#AK"=5*++>"44J!Q\VJ"

S$(*5'6>"3$B/2J"?@!!J"z=#o+"+4**&."$62"#06/&."+*&05/-:"&'67*5*6&*zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ60(1*5!@J9'BJ0FD6*E+D4(+Q+4**&.Q$-Q(06/&.Q+*&05/-:Q&'67*5*6&*DJ",&&*++*2"?@-.",090+-"?@!?J"

S$66/69"K'E6"S'((06/-:"3*B*%'4(*6-"=5'H*&-J"!PMeJ"_4(('()!<%C(e-!5+$1'('()!$%&&0(',/!'($%&+.!$4-+!-,05/J";'62'6f"K$-*"$62";:%*J"

S$66/69"K'E6"S'((06/-:"3*B*%'4(*6-"=5'H*&-J"!PMMJ"_4(('()!,%C(!,%!I%3,9!^%%1C'$9.!,9+!4'&-!%F!'(50-,3/i![!-,05/!%F!'(50-,3'41!5+$1'(+!'(!%(+!$%&&0(',/J";'62'6f"S$66/69"K'E6"S'((06/-:"3*B*%'4(*6-"=5'H*&-J"

S$6-%*>"K*2J"?@@!J"_%&&0(',/!$%9+-'%(.!4!3+#%3,!%F!,9+!'(5+#+(5+(,!3+*'+C!,+4&!$94'3+5!T/!<+5!_4(,1+J";'62'6f"_'(*"T77/&*J"

S$+.('5*>"<56*+-J"!PMPJ":4-,4&4(.!,9+!:4-,4F43'4(!&%*+&+(,!'(!7()14(5J";'62'6f",%%*6"k"[6E/6J"

S$+-%*+>"8-*4.*6"$62"#$5F")J"#/%%*5J"?@@OJ"<9+!4)+!%F!&')34,'%(J"O52J"U*E"Z'5Ff"X0/%7'52"=5*++J"

Page 207: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?@M"

"

S.$(1*5+>"A$/6J"!PMeJ"z,"+-5$-*9:"7'5"%/B/69z>"/6"8-0$5-"_$%%"$62"K'6:")*77*5+'6"*2+J":+-'-,4($+!,93%0)9!3',041-.!/%0,9!-0T$01,03+-!'(!#%-,gC43!G3',4'(J";'62'6f"_0-&./6+'6>"44J!NMQ!eeJ"

S.$66*%"\J"?@@V$J"z3/+$5(/69"^5/-$/6zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ&.$66*%\J&'(D6*E+D(/&5'+/-*+D3D2/+$5(/69}15/-$/6DJ",&&*++*2"O52"#$5&."?@!!J"

S.$66*%"\J"?@@V1J"zd.:"F/2+"F/%%zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ&.$66*%\J&'(D6*E+D$5-/&%*+D2/+4$-&.*+DE.:ÅF/2+ÅF/%%D!\@@M\MJ",&&*++*2"O52"#$5&."?@!!J"

S/B/%"R*6*E$%"[6/-J"?@@\J"z,&-/B*"%*$56/69>"$&-/B*"&/-/a*6+./4zf"_'(*"T77/&*J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ&'((06/-/*+J9'BJ0FD2'&0(*6-+D&'((06/-/*+D427D!N?NV?J427J",&&*++*2"!P-."U'B*(1*5"?@@VJ""

S%$5F*>")'.6>"*-"$%J"!PMeJ"z801&0%-05*+>"&0%-05*+"$62"&%$++f"$"-.*'5*-/&$%"'B*5B/*Ez>"/6"8-0$5-"_$%%"$62"K'6:")*77*5+'6"*2+J":+-'-,4($+!,93%0)9!3',041-.!/%0,9!-0T$01,03+-!'(!#%-,gC43!G3',4'(J";'62'6f"_0-&./6+'6>"44JPQM\J"

S;XJ"?@@VJ"z#$6$9/69"-.*"/(4$&-+"'7"(/95$-/'6f"$"&5'++Q9'B*56(*6-"$445'$&.zf"S5'E6"S'4:5/9.-J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ&'((06/-/*+J9'BJ0FD2'&0(*6-+D&'((06/-/*+D427DVOVPONJ427J",&&*++*2"?@-."U'B*(1*5"?@@VJ""

S;X"$62";$62"R*9/+-5:J"?@!@J"z_'0+/69zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ6*E.$(J/67'J",&&*++*2"!!-."#$:"?@!!J"

S%/77'52>")$(*+J"!PVOJ"zT6"*-.6'95$4./&"$0-.'5/-:zJ":+#3+-+(,4,'%(->"B'%J!>"6'J?>"44J!!VQ!\eJ"

S%/77'52>")$(*+J"!PVe$J"zA6-5'20&-/'6f"4$5-/$%"-50-.+z>"/6")$(*+"S%/77'52"$62"X*'59*"<J"#$5&0+"*2+J"^3','()!$01,03+.!,9+!#%+,'$-!4(5!#%1','$-!%F!+,9(%)34#9/.!4!;$9%%1!%F![&+3'$4(!:+-+43$9!45*4($+5!-+&'(43J"^*5F*%*:f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"S$%/7'56/$"=5*++>"44J!Q?eJ"

S%/77'52>")$(*+J"!PVe1J"zT6"*-.6'95$4./&"$%%*9'5:z>"/6")$(*+"S%/77'52"$62"X*'59*"<J"#$5&0+"*2+J"^3','()!$01,03+.!,9+!#%+,'$-!4(5!#%1','$-!%F!+,9(%)34#9/.!4!;$9%%1!%F![&+3'$4(!:+-+43$9!45*4($+5!-+&'(43J"^*5F*%*:f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"S$%/7'56/$"=5*++>"44JPVQ!?!J"

S%/77'52>")$(*+J"!PVVJ"<9+!#3+5'$4&+(,!%F!$01,03+.!,C+(,'+,9g$+(,03/!+,9(%)34#9/2!1',+34,03+2!4(5!43,J"S$(15/29*>"#$++Jf"_$5B$52"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

S%/77'52>")$(*+>"*-"$%J"!PVeJ"^3','()!$01,03+.!,9+!#%+,'$-!4(5!#%1','$-!%F!+,9(%)34#9/.!4!;$9%%1!%F![&+3'$4(!:+-+43$9!45*4($+5!-+&'(43J"^*5F*%*:f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"S$%/7'56/$"=5*++J"

S'.*6>"=./%J"!PM?J"z801&0%-05$%"&'67%/&-"$62"E'5F/69Q&%$++"&'((06/-:z>"/6"8-0$5-"_$%%"*2J"_01,03+2!&+5'42!14()04)+!.!C%3='()!#4#+3-!'(!$01,0341!-,05'+-2!?KQOgQKJ";'62'6f"_0-&./6+'6>"44JMVQVMJ"

S'.*6>"8-$6%*:J"?@@?J"E%1=!5+*'1-!4(5!&%341!#4('$-J"O@-."$66/B*5+$5:"*2/-/'6J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*J"

S'((/++/'6"'6"A6-*95$-/'6"$62"S'.*+/'6J"?@@MJ"603!-943+5!F0,03+J";'62'6f"S'((/++/'6"'6"A6-*95$-/'6"k"S'.*+/'6J"

Page 208: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?@V"

"

S'(4'062"8*&05/-:"8:+-*(+J"?@!@J"zS'(4'062"8*&05/-:"8:+-*(+zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ&'(4'062+*&05/-:J&'J0FDJ",&&*++*2"?P-.")$60$5:"?@!@""

S'66*5-'6>"=$0%J"?@@PJ"B%C!&%5+3(',/!F%3)+,-J"S$(15/29*f"S$(15/29*"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

S'66'5>"_*%*6>"*-"$%J"?@@\J"zd.:"-.*"2/77*5*6&*i","&%'+*5"%''F"$-"./9.*5"*20&$-/'6"(/6'5/-:"*-.6/&"+-02*6-+"$62"95$20$-*+zf"A6+-/-0-*"7'5"<(4%':(*6-"8-02/*+J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f"EEEJ15/+-'%J$&J0FD*-.6/&/-:D2'&0(*6-+D*20&$-/'65*4'5-J427J",&&*++*2"?\-."#$:"?@!?J""

S'66'5>"8-*B*6J"?@@OJ"zK.*".*%4"'7":'05"9''2".$62+f"5*4'5-+"'6"&%$44/69z>"/6"#/&.$*%"^0%%"$62";*+"^$&F"*2+J"<9+!405',%3/!$01,03+!3+45+3J"TC7'52f"^*59>"44JeMQMeJ"

S'6+-50&-/69"<C&*%%*6&*J"?@!@J"zK.$(*+"X$-*E$:"&'6+-50&-/69"*C&*%%*6&*"&%01";%06&."zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ&'6+-50&-/69*C&*%%*6&*J'59J0FD6*E+D$5-/&%*JH+4i/2ÄMP@PJ",&&*++*2"?O52"#$5&."?@!?J"

S''F>"K/6$"$62"<%+*"_*++J"?@@MJ"zd.$-"-.*"&$(*5$"+**+"$62"75'("E.'+*"4*5+4*&-/B*f"706"(*-.'2'%'9/*+"7'5"*69$9/69"&./%25*6"/6"*6%/9.-*6/69"$20%-+zJ"_9'159%%5>"B'%J!\>"6'J!>"44J?PQ\NJ"

S''4*5>"S$5'%:6J"?@@\J";%0(5!$14-9.!]4&4'$4(!54($+9411!$01,03+!4,!143)+J"U*E"Z'5F"j"^$+/69+-'F*f"=$%95$B*"#$&(/%%$6J"

S'55/9$6>"=$0%J"!PMPJ";$9%%1'()!,9+!-&4-9!-,3++,!='5-J";'62'6f"#$&(/%%$6J"

3$/%:"#$/%J"?@@e$J"z<$+-*56"<05'4*$6"/((/95$6-+"&$55:"'0-"-*6-."'7"&5/(*zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ2$/%:($/%J&'J0FD6*E+D$5-/&%*Q\!OPVND<$+-*56Q<05'4*$6Q/((/95$6-+Q&$55:Q-*6-.Q&5/(*J.-(%J",&&*++*2"?N-."#$5&."?@@VJ"

3$/%:"#$/%J"?@@e1J"z='%/+."^'5$-o"&%$/(+"95'4/69"E'(*6"/+"6'5($%"/6"<$+-*56"<05'4*zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ2$/%:($/%J&'J0FD6*E+D$5-/&%*Q\!N!?VD='%/+.Q^'5$-Q&%$/(+Q95'4/69QE'(*6Q6'5($%Q<$+-*56Q<05'4*J.-(%|J",&&*++*2"?N-."#$5&."?@@VJ"

3$/%:"#$/%J"?@!@J"zA((/95$6-+"-'"1*"-$09.-"-.*"7/6*"^5/-/+."$5-"'7".'E"-'"h0*0*zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ2$/%:($/%J&'J0FD6*E+D$5-/&%*Q!?N@P\eDK.*:Q.$B*6-Q9'-Qh0*0*QX'B*56(*6-Q-*$&.Q/((/95$6-+Q^5/-/+.Q$5-Q%/6/69Q04J.-(%|/[email protected]{%!8J",&&*++*2"?N-."#$5&."?@!@J"

3$%*>",69*%$>"*-"$%J"?@@?J"zR'0-*+"/6-'"*20&$-/'6"$62"*(4%':(*6-"7'5":'069"=$F/+-$6/"$62"^$69%$2*+./"E'(*6"/6"-.*"[`zJ"7,9('$!4(5!:4$'41!;,05'+->"B'%J?N>"6'Je>"44JP\?QPeVJ"

3$B/*+>"S.$5%'--*",0%%J"!PPPJ":+F1+M'*+!+,9(%)34#9/.!4!)0'5+!,%!3+-+43$9'()!-+1*+-!4(5!%,9+3-J"U*E"Z'5Ff"R'0-%*29*J"

3$B/+>"#/F*J"!PP@J"_',/!%F!c043,b.!+M$4*4,'()!,9+!F0,03+!'(!8%-![()+1+-J";'62'6f"c*5+'J"

2*"S*5-*$0>"#/&.*%J"!PV\J"<9+!#34$,'$+!%F!+*+3/54/!1'F+J"^*5F*%*:f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"S$%/7'56/$"=5*++J"

2*"S*5-*$0>"#/&.*%J"!PVVJ"<9+!C3','()!%F!9'-,%3/J"U*E"Z'5Ff"S'%0(1/$"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

3*6&.>"X*'77>"*-"$%J"?@@eJ"<9+!(+C!74-,!7(5.!='(-9'#2!34$+!4(5!$%(F1'$,J";'62'6f"=5'7/%*J"

Page 209: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?@P"

"

3*6.$(>")'.6J"?@@PJ"zS'66*&-/69"&'((06/-/*+zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDE*1$5&./B*J6$-/'6$%$5&./B*+J9'BJ0FDÅD.--4fDEEEJ&'((06/-/*+J9'BJ0FD6*E+D&'54'5$-*D!ONM?!\J",&&*++*2"!N-.",45/%"?@!!J"

3*66/+")5>"8$(0*%"]J>"*-"$%J"?@@PJ"z=$5-/&/4$-'5:"4.'-'"($44/69"G==#If"<C4%'5/69"$6"/6-*95$-*2"(*-.'2"7'5".*$%-."$62"4%$&*"5*+*$5&."E/-.":'069"4*'4%*z>"B'%J!N>",B$/%$1%*"75'(f"EEEJ*%+*B/*5J&'(D%'&$-*D.*$%-.4%$&*J",&&*++*2"O52"]*150$5:"?@@PJ"

3*55/2$>")$&h0*+J"!PMeJ"6F!)34&&4,%1%)/J"^$%-/('5*f")'.6+"_'4F/6+"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

3*55/2$>")$&h0*+J"?@@@J"6F!9%-#',41',/J"8-$67'52>"S$%/7Jf"8-$67'52"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

3/&F*6+>"S.$5%*+J"!VNMJ"z;'62'6*5+"'B*5"-.*"1'52*5zJ"B%0-+9%15!^%35->"B'%J!e>"6'JOP@>"44J?\!Q?\\J"

3/%-.*:>"d/%.*%(J"!PPeJ";+1+$,+5!C%3=-2!*%10&+!Ld.!9+3&+(+0,'$-!4(5!,9+!-,05/!%F!9'-,%3/J"S./&.*+-*5"=5/6&*-'6"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

3/aa**"R$+&$%J"?@@MJ"z8/5*6+zf"Z'0K01*J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ:'0-01*J&'(DE$-&.iBÄA=4CC5%@C.#J",&&*++*2"!N-.",090+-"?@!?J""

3'%%*5"3$"30+-($6J"?@!!J"z`/%%"$%%"$."2*("G45'2J"1:"3c,I"zf"Z'0K01*J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ:'0-01*J&'(DE$-&.iBÄ&UK{@c!!;0\J",&&*++*2"!N-.",090+-"?@!?J""

3'6$*o'J"?@@MJ">+*'1!'(!G10+!>3+--f"U'"%$1*%J"

3'E6*+>"3$B/2"#J"!PeeJ"<9+!5+1'(c0+(,!-%10,'%(.!4!-,05/!'(!-0T$01,0341!,9+%3/f"R'0-%*29*"k"`J"=$0%J"

35/6FE$-*5>"8-*4.*6"$62"3*5*F";*+%/*J"!PPVJ"z8-$:/69"'6"5$-*+"/6"70%%Q-/(*"*20&$-/'6z>"/6"3*5*F";*+%/*"*2J"[(!'(*+-,')4,'%(!%F!34$'41!5'-45*4(,4)+J"#$6&.*+-*5f"#$6&.*+-*5"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++>"44J!VNQ!PPJ"

30"^'/+>"dJ"<J"^J"?@@MJ"<9+!-%01-!%F!T14$=!F%1=J"TC7'52f"TC7'52"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

3061$5>"R'C$66*J"!PPMJ"z^%''2:"7''-45/6-+f"5*7%*&-/'6+"'6"95'E/69"04"4''5"E./-*z>"/6"#$--"d5$:"$62",66$%**"U*E/-a"*2+J"^9',+!,34-9.!34$+!4(5!$14--!'(![&+3'$4J"U*E"Z'5Ff"R'0-%*29*>"44JMOQVVJ"

306*/*5>"#/-&.*%%"$62";*+"^$&FJ"?@@eJ"zc'/&*+"75'("-.*"+/2*E$%Ff"*-.6'95$4.:"$62"E5/-/69"5$&*zJ"7,9('$!4(5!:4$'41!;,05'+->"B'%J?P>"6'JO>"44JN\OQNeNJ"

306*/*5>"#/-&.*%%"$62"TB/*"S$5-*5J"?@@!J";'5+C41=J"U*E"Z'5Ff"]$55$5>"8-5$0+"$62"X/5'0CJ"

3c,J"?@!@J"z`/%%"$%%"$."2*("G/6+-50(*6-$%I"zf"Z'0K01*J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ:'0-01*J&'(DE$-&.iBÄFeO88]9*!7'J",&&*++*2"!N-.",090+-"?@!?J""

3:*5>"R/&.$52J"!PPMJ"^9',+J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*J"

<2*%($6>";**J"?@@\J"I%!F0,03+.!c0++3!,9+%3/!4(5!,9+!5+4,9!53'*+J"305.$(f"30F*"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

Page 210: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?!@"

"

<%%/+'6>"R$%4.J"!PPNJ"zS.$69*"-.*"H'F*"$62"+%/4"-.*":'F*z>"/6"R$%4."<%%/+'6"$62")'.6"]J"S$%%$.$6"*2+J"<9+!$%11+$,+5!+--4/-!%F!:41#9!711'-%(J"U*E"Z'5Ff"#'2*56";/15$5:>"44J!@@Q!!?J"

<%%/+'6>"R$%4.J"?@@!J"L(*'-'T1+!&4(J";'62'6f"=*690/6J"

<5/&"^"$62"R$F/(J"!PVMJ"Z4'5!'(!F011f"\-."k"^oE$:"R*&'52+J"

<+.06>"`'E2'J"!PPVJ"N%3+!T3'11'4(,!,94(!,9+!-0(.!45*+(,03+-!'(!-%('$!F'$,'%(J";'62'6f"L0$5-*-"^''F+J"

<+.06>"`'E2'J"?@@OJ"z]05-.*5"&'6+/2*5$-/'6+"'6"$75'70-05/+(zJ"_:.!,9+!$+(,+(('41!3+*'+C>"B'%JO>"6'J?>"44J?VMQO@?J"

<-.6/&"$62"R$&/$%"8-02/*+J"?@!?J"zA6+-50&-/'6+"7'5"$0-.'5+zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ-$627'6%/6*J&'(D$&-/'6D$0-.'5801(/++/'6iH'056$%S'2*Ä5*5+?@k4$9*Ä/6+-50&-/'6+J",&&*++*2"?N-."8*4-*(1*5"?@!?J"

]$6'6>"]5$6-aJ"!PP!J"<9+!C3+,$9+5!%F!,9+!+43,9J"U*E"Z'5Ff"X5'B*"d*/2*67*%2J"

]$55$5>"#$CJ"?@@VJ"z,6$%:+/69";'62'6o+"oU*E"<$+-"<62o"Q"_'E"&$6"+'&/$%"+&/*6&*"($F*"$"2/77*5*6&*z>"B'%J!O>"6'JNJ",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ+'&5*+'6%/6*J'59J0FD!ODNDMJ.-(%J",&&*++*2"\-.",45/%"?@!?J"

]/66*:>"U/++$"$62";02/"8/(4+'6J"?@@PJ";1++#C41='()!,%!-+)3+)4,'%(.!$9411+()'()!&/,9-!4T%0,!34$+!4(5!&')34,'%(J"^5/+-'%f"='%/&:J"

]%$E%*++J"?@@PJ"z]%$E%*++"T77/&/$%"d*1+/-*zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ7%$E%*++'77/&/$%J&'(DJ",&&*++*2"O52"T&-'1*5"?@!@J"

]'5($6>"#055$:J"?@@?J"<9+!e9%%5!$%&+-!F'3-,.!34$+2!-#4$+2!4(5!#14$+!'(!34#!4(5!9'#g9%#J"_$6'B*5>"UJ_Jf"d*+%*:$6"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

]'5($6>"#055$:J"?@!@J"zzR*45*+*6-zf"5$&*>"+4$&*"$62"4%$&*"/6"5$4"(0+/&z>"/6"#$5F",6-.'6:"U*$%"$62"#055$:"]'5($6"*2+J"<94,e-!,9+!a%'(,f.!,9+!9'#g9%#!-,05'+-!3+45+3J"?62"*2/-/'6J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*>"44J?@!Q???J"

]'+-*5>")$6*-J"!PPPJ">%$=14(5-.!$01,03+-!'(!$%(F1'$,2!C%315-!'(!$%11'-'%(J";'62'6f"[S;"=5*++J"

]'0&$0%->"#/&.*%J"?@@OJ"h;%$'+,/!&0-,!T+!5+F+(5+5h.!1+$,03+-!4,!,9+!_%11+)+!5+!E34($+2!?KQ\gQYJ";'62'6f",%%*6";$6*J"

]5$+*5>"U$6&:J"!PP?J"zR*-./6F/69"-.*"401%/&"+4.*5*f"$"&'6-5/10-/'6"-'"-.*"&5/-/h0*"'7"$&-0$%%:"*C/+-/69"2*('&5$&:z>"/6"S5$/9")J"S$%.'06"*2J"B4T+3&4-!4(5!,9+!#0T1'$!-#9+3+J"S$(15/29*>"#$++J"j";'62'6f"#AK"=5*++>"44J!@PQ!\!J"

]5$+*5>"U$6&:J"?@@MJ"zK5$6+6$-/'6$%/a/69"-.*"401%/&"+4.*5*f"'6"-.*"%*9/-/($&:"'7"*77/&$&:"'7"401%/&"'4/6/'6"/6"$"4'+-Qd*+-4.$%/$6"E'5%2zJ"<9+%3/2!_01,03+!4(5!;%$'+,/>"B'%J?\>"6'J\>"44JMQO@J"

X$2$(*5>"_$6+QX*'59J"!PVPJ"<30,9!4(5!&+,9%5J"?62"*2/-/'6J";'62'6f"8.**2"$62"d$52J"

Page 211: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?!!"

"

X$6+>"_*51*5-")J"?@!?J"z,9$/6+-"&0%-05*"B*5+0+"+-50&-05*zJ"L5+(,','+-.!)1%T41!-,05'+-!'(!$01,03+!4(5!#%C+3>"B'%J!P>"6'J?>"44J!?NQ!O\J"

X$56*5>"8-*B*J"?@!@J"zK.*"*6-/-%*2"6$-/'6f".'E"4*'4%*"($F*"-.*(+*%B*+"E./-*"/6"&'6-*(4'5$5:"<69%$62z>",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ+*6+Q401%/&J'59D+4/4J4.4i$5-/&%*M?PJ",&&*++*2"!+-")06*"?@!?J"

X**5-a>"S%/77'52J"!PMOJ"<9+!'(,+3#3+,4,'%(!%F!$01,03+-.!-+1+$,+5!+--4/-J";'62'6f"]'6-$6$J"

X*+&./*5*>"=*-*5J"?@@PJ"<9+!#+3'1-!%F!T+1%()'().!40,%$9,9%(/2!$','b+(-9'#2!4(5!+M$10-'%(!'(![F3'$4!4(5!703%#+J"S./&$9'f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"S./&$9'"=5*++J"

X/99+J"?@@PJ"zK$%F/69"-.*".$52*+-zf"Z'0K01*D[`95/(*KcJ",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ:'0-01*J&'(DE$-&.iBÄ[4hLCF%RF_[J",&&*++*2"!N-.",090+-"?@!?J""

X/%%1'56>"3$B/2J"?@!@J"zK.*"E./-*"E'5F/69"&%$++>"5$&/+("$62"5*+4*&-$1/%/-:f"B/&-/(+>"2*9*6*5$-*+"$62"/6-*5*+-Q&'6B*59*6&*zJ"G3','-9!]%03(41!%F!750$4,'%(!;,05'+->"B'%JNV>"6'J!>"44JOQ?NJ"

X/%%/*+>"c$%J"?@@MJ"N43)'(41'-+5!&%,9+3-.!+M#1%3'()!C%3='()!$14--!+M#+3'+($+-!%F!#43+(,'()J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*J"

X/%5':>"=$0%J"!PVMJ"h<9+3+!4'(e,!(%!T14$=!'(!,9+!"('%(!]4$=h.!,9+!$01,0341!#%1','$-!%F!34$+!4(5!(4,'%(J";'62'6f"_0-&./6+'6J"

X/%5':>"=$0%J"!PPOJ"<9+!T14$=![,14(,'$.!&%5+3(',/!4(5!5%0T1+!$%(-$'%0-(+--J";'62'6f"c*5+'J"

X/%5':>"=$0%J"!PP\J"zo,7-*5"-.*"%'B*"$+"9'6*of"1/'Q4'%/-/&+"$62"*-.6'Q4'*-/&+"/6"-.*"1%$&F"401%/&"+4.*5*zJ"Z0T1'$!_01,03+>"B'%JM>""44J\PQMeJ"

X/%5':>"=$0%J"?@@@J"G+,C++(!$4&#-.!34$+2!'5+(,',/!4(5!(4,'%(41'-&!4,!,9+!+(5!%F!,9+!$%1%03!1'(+J";'62'6f",%%*6";$6*J"

X/%5':>"=$0%J"?@@OJ"z^*-E**6"-.*"1%0*+"$62"-.*"1%0*+"2$6&*f"+'(*"+'062+&$4*+"'7"-.*"1%$&F",-%$6-/&z>"/6"#/&.$*%"^0%%"$62";*+"^$&F"*2+J"<9+!405',%3/!$01,03+!3+45+3J"TC7'52f"^*59>"44JOV!QOPNJ"

X/%5':>"=$0%J"?@@\J"[F,+3!+&#'3+.!&+14($9%1'4!%3!$%(*'*'41!$01,03+i";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*J"

X/%5':>"=$0%J"?@@eJ"z#0%-/&0%-05*"/6"-/(*+"'7"E$5zJ";8<"=01%/&";*&-05*J";'62'6"8&.''%"'7"<&'6'(/&+J"

X/%5':>"=$0%J"?@!@$J">43=+3!,94(!T10+.!%(!,9+!&%341!+$%(%&'+-!%F!G14$=![,14(,'$!$01,03+J"S$(15/29*>"#$++Jf"^*%F6$4"=5*++"'7"_$5B$52"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

X/%5':>"=$0%J"?@!@1J"zA-o+"$"7$(/%:"$77$/5z>"/6"#$5F",6-.'6:"U*$%"$62"#055$:"]'5($6"*2+J"<94,e-!,9+!a%'(,f.!,9+!9'#g9%#!-,05'+-!3+45+3J"?62"*2/-/'6J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*>"44JVMQP\J"

X/%5':>"=$0%J"?@!?J"zz#:"^5/-$/6o+"]0&F",%%zf"a'(1/*"(0%-/&0%-05$%/+("$62"-.*"5$&*"4'%/-/&+"'7"&/-/a*6+./4"zJ"3*4$5-(*6-"'7"8'&/'%'9:"$62"A2*6-/-/*+"=01%/&";*&-05*J";'62'6"8&.''%"'7"<&'6'(/&+J"

Page 212: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?!?"

"

X/5'0C>"_*65:",J"!PPeJ"E0)','*+!$01,03+-.!34$+2!*'%1+($+2!4(5!/%0,9J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*J"

X%$+($6>"#$05/&*J"?@!!J"z#$05/&*"X%$+($6f"(:"^%0*";$1'05"B/+/'6"&$6"2*7*$-"-.*"&'$%/-/'6zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ90$52/$6J&'J0FD4'%/-/&+D?@!!D$45D?\D1%0*Q%$1'05Q($05/&*Q9%$+($6J",&&*++*2"?e-.")0%:"?@!?J"

X''2.$5->"3$B/2J"?@@\J"zK''"2/B*5+*iz>",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ45'+4*&-($9$a/6*J&'J0FD($9$a/6*D-''Q2/B*5+*Q2$B/2Q9''2.$5-Q(0%-/&0%-05$%/+(Q15/-$/6Q/((/95$-/'6Q9%'1$%/+$-/'6DJ",&&*++*2"?M-.")0%:"?@!?J"

X5$.$(>"8-*4.*6J"?@!@J"_','+-!0(5+3!-'+)+.!,9+!(+C!&'1',43/!03T4('-&J";'62'6f"c*5+'J"

X5/77/6>"S.5/+-/6*J"!PPMJ"zK5'01%*2"-**6+f"($6$9/69"2/+'52*5+"'7"-5$6+/-/'6"$62"&'6+0(4-/'6zJ"E+&'('-,!:+*'+C>"B'%JNN>""44J\Q?!J"

X0$52/$6J"?@@VJ"z;$1'05f"/7":'0"E$6-"$"&'06&/%".'0+*>"7/62"$"H'1zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ90$52/$6J&'J0FD4'%/-/&+D?@@VD7*1D@ND0FJ-'4+-'5/*+OJ",&&*++*2"?P-.")06*"?@@VJ"

X029*>"=$-5/&/$J"?@@PJ"N+&%'3-!%F!4(!74-,!7(5!)'31J"KE/&F*6.$(f",-.*6$"=5*++J"

X06$5$-6$(>"Z$+(/6J"?@@OJ":+-+43$9'()!34$+!4(5!+,9('$',/.!&+,9%5-2!=(%C1+5)+!4(5!#%C+3J";'62'6f"8,X<J"

_$1*5($+>")Ç59*6J"!PVPJ"<9+!-,30$,0341!,34(-F%3&4,'%(!%F!,9+!#0T1'$!-#9+3+.!4(!'(c0'3/!'(,%!4!$4,+)%3/!%F!T%03)+%'-!-%$'+,/J"S$(15/29*f"='%/-:J"

_$&F/69>"A$6J"?@@?J"B'-,%3'$41!%(,%1%)/J"S$(15/29*>"#$++Jf"_$5B$52"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

_$%1*5+-$(>")02/-.J"?@@VJ"zK.*"$6-/Q+'&/$%"-056"/6"h0**5"+-02/*+z>"B'%JN>"6'J?J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDD9H++J'59D/($9*+D+-'5/*+DB'%0(*+DND?D@V@NJ?$@V}.$%1*5+-$(J427J",&&*++*2"!?-.")$60$5:"?@!?J"

_$%1E$&.+>"#$05/&*J"!PP?J"6(!$%11+$,'*+!&+&%3/J"S./&$9'f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"S./&$9'"=5*++J"

_$%%>"=*-*5"X*'775*:J"?@@MJ"8%(5%(!*%'$+-2!8%(5%(!1'*+-.!,41+-!F3%&!4!C%3='()!$4#',41J"^5/+-'%f"='%/&:J"

_$%%>"8-0$5-J"!PP?J"zU*E"*-.6/&/-/*+z>"/6")$(*+"3'6$%2"$62",%/"R$--$6+/"*2+J"e:4$+e2!$01,03+!4(5!5'FF+3+($+J";'62'6f"8,X<>"44J?N?Q?NPJ"

_$%%>"8-0$5-J"!PPeJ"zR$&*f"-.*"7%'$-/69"+/96/7/*5"zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDB/2*'J9''9%*J&'(DB/2*'4%$:i2'&/2ÄQV\M!OVONV@?V?P@MVeNJ",&&*++*2"?N-."#$5&."?@@PJ"

_$%%>"8-0$5-J"?@@@J"zS'6&%0+/'6f"-.*"(0%-/&0%-05$%"h0*+-/'6z>"/6"^$56'5"_*++*"*2J""(j-+,,1+5!&01,'$01,0341'-&-.!5'4-#%34-2!+(,4()1+&+(,-2!h,34(-30#,'%(-hJ";'62'6f"x*2"^''F+>"44J?@PQ?\!J"

_$%%>"8-0$5-J"?@@\J"z3/B/2*2"&/-:f"-.*"&5/+/+"'7";'62'6z>",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ'4*62*('&5$&:J6*-D$5-+Q(0%-/&0%-05$%/+(D$5-/&%*}?!P!JH+4J",&&*++*2"!!-."#$:"?@!!J"

Page 213: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?!O"

"

_$%%>"8-0$5->"*-"$%J"!PMVJ"Z%1'$'()!,9+!$3'-'-.!&0))'()2!,9+!-,4,+2!4(5!14C!4(5!%35+3J"^$+/69+-'F*f"#$&(/%%$6J"

_$%%>"8-0$5->"*-"$%J"!PMeJ":+-'-,4($+!,93%0)9!3',041-.!/%0,9!-0T$01,03+-!'(!#%-,gC43!G3',4'(J";'62'6f"_0-&./6+'6J"

_$((*5+%*:>"#$5-:6"$62"=$0%",-F/6+'6J"!PPNJ"7,9(%)34#9/.!#3'($'#1+-!'(!#34$,'$+J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*J"

_$6&'C>"3$6J"?@@PJ"z=01%/&"*6*(:"6'"ePez>",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ90$52/$6J&'J0FD&0%-05*D?@@PDH$6D?!D4'%/&*Q7'5(QePeQ9$5$9*Q(0+/&J",&&*++*2"!N-."#$:"?@!?J"

_$5$E$:>"3'66$J"!PVVJ"z8/-0$-*2"F6'E%*29*+f"-.*"+&/*6&*"h0*+-/'6"/6"7*(/6/+("$62"-.*"45/B/%*9*"'7"4$5-/$%"4*5+4*&-/B*zJ"E+&'('-,!;,05'+->"B'%J!\>"6'JO>"44JNMNQNPPJ"

_$55/+>",6/-$J"?@@\J"E0,03+!)'31.!/%0()!C%&+(!'(!,9+!,C+(,/gF'3-,!$+(,03/J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*J"

_$55/+>"U/&F"$62"_'E$52"^%'&.J"!PPNJ"_4(('()!<%C(J"8-5'02f"S.$%7'52J"

_$55/+>"R'C:J"?@@eJ"I+C!+,9('$','+-!4(5!14()04)+!0-+J"^$+/69+-'F*f"=$%95$B*"#$&(/%%$6J"

_$55/+'6>",6-.'6:"`E$(*J"?@@PJ"B'#!9%#!0(5+3)3%0(5.!,9+!'(,+)3',/!4(5!+,9'$-!%F!34$'41!'5+(,'F'$4,'%(J"=./%$2*%4./$f"K*(4%*"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

_$5B*:>"3$B/2J"!PVP$J"<9+!$%(5','%(!%F!#%-,&%5+3(',/.!4(!+(c0'3/!'(,%!,9+!%3')'(-!%F!$01,0341!$94()+J"TC7'52f"^$+/%"^%$&FE*%%J"

_$5B*:>"3$B/2J"!PVP1J"<9+!03T4(!+M#+3'+($+J"TC7'52f"^$+/%"^%$&FE*%%J"

_$5B*:>"3$B/2J"?@@@J";#4$+-!%F!9%#+J"^*5F*%*:f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"S$%/7'56/$"=5*++J"

_$5B*:>"3$B/2J"?@@VJ"zK.*"5/9.-"-'"-.*"&/-:zJ"I+C!8+F,!:+*'+C>"B'%JNO>"6'J8*4-*(1*5>"44J?OQOPJ"

_$:%*-->"S.5/+J"?@@!J"zA%%*9/-/($-*"+01H*&-+i",1H*&-"E./-*+>"6*'%/1*5$%"('2*56/+$-/'6"$62"(/22%*"&%$++"(0%-/&0%-05$%/+(zJ"7(*'3%(&+(,!4(5!Z14(('()!>.!;%$'+,/!4(5!;#4$+>"B'%J!P>"6'JO>"44JON!QOM@J"

_*12/9*>"3/&FJ"!PMPJ";0T$01,03+.!,9+!&+4('()!%F!-,/1+J";'62'6f"#*-.0*6J"

_*&-'5>")'.6J"?@!@J"Z%#143!&+&%3'+-.!1'F+!'(!,9+!74-,!7(5J"8-5'02f"80--'6"=01%/+./69J"

_<]S<J"?@!?J"z,/(./9.*5zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ$/(./9.*5J$&J0FD+/-*+D45$&-/-/'6*5D.'(*D/62*CJ&7(J",&&*++*2"!O-."]*150$5:"?@!?J"

_*/2*99*5>"#$5-/6J"!Pe?J"G+'()!4(5!,'&+J"TC7'52f"^%$&FE*%%J"

_*62*5+'6>"8.*/%$J"?@@MJ"L(*+(,'()!4501,9%%5-.!4!T'%)34#9'$41!4##3%4$9!,%!/%0,9!,34(-','%(-J"!+-J";'62'6f"8,X<J"

Page 214: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?!\"

"

_*66*++:>",%/+-$/5J"!PVVJ"zd'5F*5+"'7"-.*"6/9.-f"d*+-"A62/$6+"/6"^5/-$/6z>"/6"#$%&'%("S5'++"$62"_$6+"<6-a/69*5"*2+J"8%-,!'110-'%(-.!_43'TT+4(!&'(%3','+-!'(!G3',4'(!4(5!,9+!I+,9+314(5-J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*>"44JOeQNOJ"

_*++*>"^$56'5J"?@@@J""(j-+,,1+5!&01,'$01,0341'-&-.!5'4-#%34-2!+(,4()1+&+(,-2!h,34(-30#,'%(-hJ";'62'6f"x*2"^''F+J"

_*E/-->"R'9*5J"!PVeJ"^9',+!,41=!T14$=!,41=.!'(,+3g34$'41!F3'+(5-9'#!4(5!$%&&0('$4,'%(!4&%()-,!45%1+-$+(,-J"S$(15/29*f"S$(15/29*"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

_*E/-->"R'9*5J"?@@MJ"z8**/69"d./-*6*++"K.5'09."-.*"^%/aa$52f"A++0*+"/6"R*+*$5&."'6"d./-*zJ"^9',+!N4,,+3-@!;#+$'41!L--0+![,94(%32!;+&'%,'$42!E'1%-%F'42![3,+2!8+,,+34,034>"B'%J!@>""44J\!QN!J"

_*E+-'6*>"#/%*+J"?@@OJ"zA6-*595'04"&'6-$&-f"4$6$&*$"7'5"45*H02/&*zJ"<9+!Z-/$9%1%)'-,>"B'%J!e>"6'JM>"44JON?QONNJ"

_/%%>"8-*4.*6J"!PMeJ"<9+!5%$=+3-.!$14--!4(5!,345','%(!'(!8%(5%(J";'62'6f"_*/6*($66"<20&$-/'6$%J"

_#"X'B*56(*6-J"!PPVJ"z_0($6"R/9.-+",&-"!PPVzJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ'4+/J9'BJ0FD,SK8D$&-+!PPVD0F49$}!PPV@@\?}*6}!J",&&*++*2"N-."#$5&."?@@PJ"

_#"X'B*56(*6-J"?@@OJ"z<B*5:"&./%2"($--*5+f"&.$69*"7'5"&./%25*6zJ",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ*B*5:&./%2($--*5+J9'BJ0FD}7/%*+D]P<O]P\!3SV3\NV@NOP<<\SM\O<POM!3J427",&&*++*2"!N-."U'B*(1*5"?@@VJ""

_#"X'B*56(*6-J"?@@N$J"z_/9.*5"+-$62$52+>"1*--*5"+&.''%+"7'5"$%%"('5*"&.'/&*"7'5"4$5*6-+"$62"404/%+zJ",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4+fDDEEEJ*20&$-/'6J9'BJ0FD401%/&$-/'6+D+-$62$52D401%/&$-/'63*-$/%D=$9*!DS(�?@eeMM|2'E6%'$2$1%*4$5-+J",&&*++*2"!O-."]*150$5:"?@!?J""

_#"X'B*56(*6-J"?@@N1J"zZ'0-."($--*5+zf"S5'E6"S'4:5/9.-J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ*B*5:&./%2($--*5+J9'BJ0FD}7/%*+DZ'0-.�?@#$--*5+J427J",&&*++*2"!P-."U'B*(1*5"?@@VJ""

_#"K5*$+05:"$62"3S8]J"?@@MJ"z,/(/69"./9."7'5":'069"4*'4%*f"$"-*6":*$5"+-5$-*9:"7'5"4'+/-/B*"$&-/B/-/*+zf"S5'E6"S'4:5/9.-J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ2&+7J9'BJ0FD401%/&$-/'6+D-*6:*$5:'0-.+-5$-*9:D2'&+D&:4}-*6:*$5+-5$-*9:}?e@M@MJ427J",&&*++*2"!P-."U'B*(1*5"?@@VJ""

_#8TJ"!P!!J"zS*6+0+"'7"<69%$62"$62"d$%*+zf"_#8TJ",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ./+-4'4J'59DJ",&&*++*2"V-."#$5&."?@!!J""

_#8TJ"!PO!J"zS*6+0+"'7"<69%$62"$62"d$%*+zf"_#8TJ",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ./+-4'4J'59J",&&*++*2"#$5&."V-."?@!!J""

_'11+>"3/&FJ"!PVVJ">%'()!,9+!T0-'(+--.!+(,3+#3+(+03-9'#2!,9+!C%3='()!$14--!4(5!5+,+$,'*+-!'(!,9+!74-,!7(5!%F!8%(5%(J"TC7'52f"S%$5*62'6"=5*++J"

Page 215: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?!N"

"

_'11+>"3/&FJ"?@@eJ"z<$+-"*62/69f"2/++'&/$-/'6>"2*Q/620+-5/$%/a$-/'6>"$62"3$B/2"3'E6*+z>"/6"K/("U*E1056"$62"=$0%"<%%/'--"R'&F"*2+J"<9+!#%1','$-!%F!$3'&+!$%(,3%1.!+--4/-!'(!9%(%03!%F!>4*'5!>%C(+-J"TC7'52f"TC7'52"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++>"44J!!MQ!\eJ"

_'29*>"#$59$5*-J"?@@MJ"z,"(*++$9*"-'"(:"7*%%'E"/((/95$6-+zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ90$52/$6J&'J0FD&'((*6-/+75**D?@@MD($:D?@D&'((*6-J4'%/-/&+J",&&*++*2"!N-.",45/%"?@!!J"

_'77($6>"`$5*6J"?@@MJ"z^$6F/69"'6"-.*"70-05*"E/-."X*6*5$-/'6"ZzJ"G4(='()!-,34,+)'+->"B'%JVO>"6'Je>"44J!@P!QeOVNJ"

_'%($6>"#/&.$*%J"?@!@J"z^5*$F/69f"-.*"./+-'5:z>"/6"#$5F",6-.'6:"U*$%"$62"#055$:"]'5($6"*2+J"<94,e-!,9+!a%'(,f.!,9+!9'#g9%#!-,05'+-!3+45+3J"?62"*2/-/'6J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*>"44JO!QOPJ"

_'%h0/+->"#/&.$*%J"!PV!J"zX%'++$5:z>"/6"#J"#J"^$F.-/6"*2J"<9+!5'41%)'$!'&4)'(4,'%(.!F%03!+--4/-J",0+-/6f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"K*C$+"=5*++>""

.''F+>"1*%%J"?@@\J"^+!3+41!$%%1.!T14$=!&+(!4(5!&4-$01'(',/J"U*E"Z'5Ff"R'0-%*29*J"

_'-"8-5*$FJ"!PVOJ"G%5/!C%3=f"<$+:"8-5**-"R*&'52+J"

_0*:J"?@@eJ"Z%#2!1%$=!4(5!53%#!',!x'(1$J"

_0(4.5/*+>"8-*4.*6J"!PV!J"B%%1')4(-!%3!3+T+1-i![(!%341!9'-,%3/!%F!C%3='()g$14--!$9'159%%5!4(5!/%0,9!?WWKg?KVKJ"TC7'52f"^%$&FE*%%J"

_0+1$62+>"S.5/+-'4.*5"KJ"!PVVJ"z<$+-"<62"5$&+/("!P@@Q!PV@zJ"<9+!8%(5%(!]%03(41>"B'%JV>"6'J!>"44JOQ?eJ"

A&*"]/%(+"<6-*5-$/6(*6->"*-"$%J"?@!!$J"z`/%%"$%%"$"2*(zf"#0++$",12$%%$>"A&*"]/%(+"<6-*5-$/6(*6-J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ:'0-01*J&'(DE$-&.iBÄ8+$%/./Z-2+J",&&*++*2"!e-.",090+-"?@!?J""

A&*"]/%(+"<6-*5-$/6(*6->"*-"$%J"?@!!1J"z`/%%"$%%"$"2*("G1*./62"-.*"+&*6*+Izf"#0++$",12$%%$>"A&*"]/%(+"<6-*5-$/6(*6-J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ:'0-01*J&'(DE$-&.iBÄ{\A@;A8*#Z<J",&&*++*2"!e-.",090+-"?@!?J""

A&*"]/%(+"<6-*5-$/6(*6->"*-"$%J"?@!!&J"zK/(*"/+"04zf"#0++$",12$%%$>"A&*"]/%(+"<6-*5-$/6(*6-J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ:'0-01*J&'(DE$-&.iBÄ(1*}Z^T1a&9J",&&*++*2"!e-.",090+-"?@!?J""

A96$-/*B>"U'*%J"?@@PJ"B%C!,9+!L3'-9!T+$4&+!C9',+J"U*E"Z'5Ff"R'0-%*29*J"

A.2*>"3'6J"?@@OJ"z,02/-'5:"/($9/6$-/'6z>"/6"#/&.$*%"^0%%"$62";*+"^$&F"*2+J"<9+!405',%3/!$01,03+!3+45+3J"TC7'52f"^*59>"44Je!QeeJ"

A6+-/-0-*"'7"S'((06/-:"S'.*+/'6J"?@@VJ"z,1'0-"&'((06/-:"&'.*+/'6"Q"$"90/2*"-'"401%/&$-/'6+zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ&'.*+/'6/6+-/-0-*J'59J0FD5*+'05&*+D=$9*+D$1'0-&'((06/-:&'.*+/'6J$+4C|?@@!J",&&*++*2"!e-."#$:"?@@PJ"

Page 216: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?!e"

"

A5B/6*>")02/-."KJ"!PPOJ"zR*+4'6+/1/%/-:"$62"*B/2*6&*"/6"'5$%"2/+&'05+*z>"/6")$6*"_J"_/%%"$62")02/-."KJ"A5B/6*"*2+J";,05'+-!'(!,9+!-%$'41!4(5!$01,0341!F%0(54,'%(-!%F!14()04)+J"S$(15/29*f"S$(15/29*"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++>"44J!@NQ!O\J"

A+$%>"8$5$.J"?@@eJ"z<h0$%"5*+4*&-f",8^T+"$62"5$&*"*h0$%/-:zf"R066:(*2*"K50+-J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ5066:(*2*-50+-J'59D04%'$2+D7/%*D<h0$%�?@R*+4*&-Q�?@,8^T8�?@$62�?@R$&*�?@<h0$%/-:J427J",&&*++*2"!P-."U'B*(1*5"?@@VJ""

A+/6>"<69/6"]J"?@@@J"zA6-5'20&-/'6f"2*('&5$&:>"&/-/a*6+./4"$62"-.*"&/-:z>"/6"<69/6"]J"A+/6"*2J">+&%$34$/2!$','b+(-9'#2!4(5!,9+!)1%T41!$',/J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*>"44J!Q??J"

AKcJ"?@@PJ"z^5/-$/6o+"X'-"K$%*6-zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDD-$%*6-J/-BJ&'(DJ",&&*++*2"?!+-",090+-"?@!?J"

)$&F+'6>"#/&.$*%J"!PV?J"<93'11+3f"<4/&J"

)$(*+'6>"]5*2*5/&J"!PV\J"z='+-('2*56/+(>"'5"-.*"&0%-05$%"%'9/&"'7"%$-*"&$4/-$%/+(z>"6'J!\eJ",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDD6*E%*7-5*B/*EJ'59DiB/*EÄM?eJ",&&*++*2"N-.",45/%"?@!!J"

)$(*+'6>"]5*25/&J"!PP!J"Z%-,&%5+3('-&2!%32!,9+!$01,0341!1%)'$!%F!14,+!$4#',41'-&J";'62'6f"c*5+'J"

)*++'4>"^'1J"?@@?J"z;/1*5$%/+(>"6*'%/1*5$%/+("$62"051$6"9'B*56$6&*f"$"+-$-*Q-.*'5*-/&$%"4*5+4*&-/B*zJ"[(,'#%5+>"B'%JO\>"6'JO>"44J\N?Q\M?J"

)'6$+>",625*E"<JXJ"!PP\J"z<2/-'5/$%zJ"7(*'3%(&+(,!4(5!Z14(('()!>.!;%$'+,/!4(5!;#4$+>"B'%J!?>""44J?NMQ?e\J"

)'6*+>"X$5*-."8-*2($6J"!PM!J"60,$4-,!8%(5%(.!4!-,05/!'(!,9+!3+14,'%(-9'#!T+,C++(!$14--+-!'(!d'$,%3'4(!-%$'+,/J"TC7'52f"S%$5*62'6"=5*++J"

)'6*+>"8/('6J"!PVVJ"G14$=!$01,03+2!C9',+!/%0,9.!,9+!3+))4+!,345','%(!F3%&!][!,%!"AJ"^$+/69+-'F*f"#$&(/%%$6"<20&$-/'6J"

`Q;/6*J"?@!@J""(,',1+5f"[6401%/+.*2J"

`JAJXJ"?@@VJ"B+452!-9%015+3-2!=(++-!(!,%+-f"#/%*"R*&'52+J"

`*/-.>"#/&.$*%J"?@@VJ"z^*-E**6"1*/69"$62"1*&'(/69i"R/9.-+>"5*+4'6+/1/%/-/*+"$62"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"(0%-/&0%-05*"/6"-.*"6*E"<$+-"<62z>"B'%J!O>"6'JNJ",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ+'&5*+'6%/6*J'59J0FD!ODND!!J.-(%J",&&*++*2"\-.",45/%"?@!?J"

`*%%:>"R0-.J"?@@NJ"z]'5E$52Jz"A6"_/9.*5"+-$62$52+>"1*--*5"+&.''%+"7'5"$%%"('5*"&.'/&*"7'5"4$5*6-+"$62"404/%+J";'62'6f"_#"X'B*56(*6-J"

`/69>"X$5:>"*-"$%J"!PP\J">+-')('()!-%$'41!'(c0'3/.!-$'+(,'F'$!'(F+3+($+!'(!c041',4,'*+!3+-+43$9J"=5/6&*-'6>"UJ)f"=5/6&*-'6"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

`/69>"RJ>"*-"$%J"?@@eJ"zX*62*5/69"(/95$-/'6"$62"5*(/--$6&*+f"*B/2*6&*"75'(";'62'6"$62"6'5-.*56",%1$6/$zJ"Z%#014,'%(!;#4$+!4(5!Z14$+>"B'%J!?>"6'Je>"44J\@PQ\O\J"

Page 217: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?!M"

"

`/69>"R0++*%%>"*-"$%J"?@@OJ"7M#1%5'()!,9+!&')34,'%(!&/,9-.!4(41/-'-!4(5!3+$%&&+(54,'%(-!F%3!,9+!703%#+4(!"('%(2!,9+!"A!4(5![1T4('4J";'62'6f"TC7$(J"

`/5F>"80+$6J"?@@MJ"z#*-.'2'%'9/&$%"$62"*-./&$%"/++0*+"/6"&'620&-/69"h0$%/-$-/B*"5*+*$5&."E/-."&./%25*6"$62":'069"4*'4%*f"$"%/-*5$-05*"5*B/*EzJ"L(,+3(4,'%(41!]%03(41!%F!I03-'()!;,05'+-6'J\\>"44J!?N@Q!?e@J"

`/-E$6$>"^$F$5/J"?@@?J"<9+!9'#!9%#!)+(+34,'%(.!/%0()!T14$=-!4(5!,9+!$3'-'-!'(![F3'$4(![&+3'$4(!$01,03+J"U*E"Z'5Ff"^$+/&"S/B/-$+J"

`/-E$6$>"^$F$5/J"?@@NJ"^9/!C9',+!='5-!1%*+!9'#g9%#.!C4(=-,4-2!C'))+3-2!C4((4T+-2!4(5!,9+!(+C!3+41',/!%F!34$+!'(![&+3'$4J"U*E"Z'5Ff"^$+/&"S/B/-$+J"

`6'E%*+>"S$5'%/6*J"?@@PJ"z)'056*:"'7"-.*"+'%*"Q"(:"<05*F$"('(*6-z>",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ-/(*+./9.*5*20&$-/'6J&'J0FD+-'5:J$+4i+*&-/'6&'2*Ä?ek+-'5:&'2*Ä\@PMNOJ",&&*++*2"!?-."T&-'1*5"?@!@J"

`'7($6>"<%*'6'5*"$62"<%/a$1*-.";*1$+J"!PPeJ"z;'+-"/6"-5$6+4'+/-/'6f"-/(*"+4$&*"$62"-.*"&/-:z>"/6"<%*'6'5*"`'7($6"$62"<%/a$1*-.";*1$+"*2+J"^3','()-!%(!$','+-J";'62'6f"^%$&FE*%%>"44JOQe@J"

`'+*5>"`.$%/2"$62"_*%($";0-aJ"!PPMJ"<9+!(+C!&')34,'%(!'(!703%#+.!-%$'41!$%(-,30$,'%(-!4(5!-%$'41!3+41','+-J"U*E"Z'5Ff"8-J"#$5-/6o+"=5*++J"

`'+-'B/&'B$>"3*6/+$"$62",%1*5-"=5*+-5*+./J"?@!@J"z<20&$-/'6>"9*62*5"$62"5*%/9/'6f"/2*6-/-:"-5$6+7'5($-/'6+"$('69"`'+'B'",%1$6/$6+"/6";'62'6zJ"]%03(41!%F!7,9('$!4(5!N')34,'%(!;,05'+->"B'%J?P>"6'Je>"44J!@MPQ!@PeJ"

`5/*9>"^5/9*--*"$62";$62$"R'1*5-+J"?@@MJ"z=.'-'B'/&*f"/6+/9.-+"/6-'"($59/6$%/+$-/'6"-.5'09."$"o&'((06/-:"%*6+o"/6"8$+F$-&.*E$6>"S$6$2$z>"/6"8$5$";'0/+*"`/62'6>"R$&.*%"=$/6"$62"#/F*"`*+1:"*2+J"Z43,'$'#4,%3/!4$,'%(!3+-+43$9!4##3%4$9+-!4(5!&+,9%5-.!$%((+$,'()!#+%#1+2!#43,'$'#4,'%(2!4(5!#14$+J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*>"44J!N@Q!NPJ"

`5'6/&F>"R'1*5-"]J"!PPMJ"[,g3'-=!/%0,9.!,9+%3/2!#34$,'$+2!3+F%3&J"U*E"Z'5Ff"X$5%$62"=01J"

`50(4"`/69+J"?@@VJ"z`50(4/69"E/-."S.5/+"^5'E6zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f"K./+"B/2*'".$+"1**6"5*('B*2J",&&*++*2"#$:"!?-."?@@PJ"

;$1'B>"d/%%/$(J"!PM?J"84()04)+!'(!,9+!'((+3!$',/.!-,05'+-!'(!,9+!T14$=!7()1'-9!*+3(4$0143J"=./%$2*%4./$>J"

;$S.$4*%%*>"3$B/2J"?@@NJ"zR/a*Jz"[8f";/'6+"X$-*"]/%(+J"

;$6&$+-*5>";:66*"SJ"$62"3$B/2"8-/%%($6J"?@!@J"<9+!NgF4$,%3.!9%C!,9+!&'11+(('41!)+(+34,'%(!'-!3%$='()!,9+!C%3=#14$+J"U*E"Z'5Ff"_$54*5^0+/6*++J"

;$E5*6&*>"<55'%J"!PV?$J"zA6"-.*"$1062$6&*"'7"E$-*5"-.*"7''%"/+"-./5+-:f"+'&/'%'9:"$62"1%$&F"o4$-.'%'9:oz>"/6"S*6-5*"7'5"S'6-*(4'5$5:"S0%-05$%"8-02/*+"*2J"<9+!7&#'3+!-,3'=+-!T4$=.!34$+!4(5!34$'-&!'(!QP-!G3',4'(J";'62'6f"_0-&./6+'6>"44JPNQ!\?J"

Page 218: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?!V"

"

;$E5*6&*>"<55'%J"!PV?1J"z)0+-"4%$/6"&'(('6"+*6+*f"-.*"o5''-+o"'7"5$&/+(z>"/6"S*6-5*"7'5"S'6-*(4'5$5:"S0%-05$%"8-02/*+"*2J"<9+!7&#'3+!-,3'=+-!T4$=.!34$+!4(5!34$'-&!'(!QP-!G3',4'(J";'62'6f"_0-&./6+'6>"44J\MQP\J"

;$a$5*B/&>"c/'%*-""$62"8'6H$""=*-5'B/&Q;$a$5*B/&J"?@@MJ"zA6&5*$+/69"15$62"%':$%-:"'7"X*6*5$-/'6"Z"7'5"70-05*"($5F*-*5+zJ"N%(4-9!"('*+3-',/2!>+#43,&+(,!%F!N4(4)+&+(,2!^%3='()!#4#+3!OWjPQ>"44J!Q!@J"

;^UJ"!PMeJ"I+C94&e-!5%$=14(5.!,9+!43+4!,%54/J"U*E.$(f";'62'6"^'5'09."'7"U*E.$(J"

;^UJ"?@@OJ"z;'62'6"'B*5"-.*"1'52*5zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDD$44+J6*E.$(J9'BJ0FD_/+-'5:}&$66/69-'E6D4$9*MJ.-(J",&&*++*2"?!+-"]*150$5:"?@!!J"

;^UJ"?@@e$J"zS./%25*6"$62":'069"4*'4%*Y+"4%$6zf";'62'6"^'5'09."'7"U*E.$(J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ6*E.$(J9'BJ0FDURD52'6%:5*+D,]?!^]OeQ\3MOQ\<NVQ^@MPQN\?^!^^O<<@3D@DSZ=8}=;,U}]AU,;J427J",&&*++*2"!+-",090+-"?@@VJ""

;^UJ"?@@e1J"zK.*"+.$4*"'7"U*E.$(zf";'62'6"^'5'09."'7"U*E.$(J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ6*E.$(J9'BJ0FD<20&$-/'6,62;*$56/69DS'06&/%8-5$-*9:DS./%25*6,62Z'069=*'4%*+=%$6D.*8.$4*'7U*E.$(J.-(J",&&*++*2"!!-."#$:"?@!!J""

;^UJ"?@@MJ"E%$0-!%(!I+C94&.!1%$41!#+%#1+!4(5!1%$41!$%(5','%(-J";'62'6f";'62'6"^'5'09."'7"U*E.$(J"

;^UJ"?@@VJ"zU*E.$(A67'zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ6*E.$(J/67'J",&&*++*2"\-.")06*"?@!?"?@!?J"

;^UJ"?@!@$J"zS*6+0+"2$-$zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ6*E.$(J/67'D5*+*$5&.D&*6+0+2$-$}1'5'09.J.-(J",&&*++*2"!+-"#$5&."?@!!J"

;^UJ"?@!@1J"z<&'6'(/&"2*B*%'4(*6-"+-5$-*9:"?@!@"-'"?@?Mzf";'62'6"^'5'09."'7"U*E.$(J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f"EEEJ6*E.$(J9'BJ0FDJJJDU*E.$(<&'6'(/&3*B*%'4(*6-8-5$-*9:?@!@J427J",&&*++*2"#$:"!!-."?@!!J""

;^UJ"?@!@&J"z)'/6-"8-5$-*9/&"U**2+",++*++(*6->"U*E.$("?@!@zf";'62'6"^'5'09."'7"U*E.$(J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ6*E.$(J9'BJ0FD_*$%-.,628'&/$%S$5*D)'/6-8-5$-*9/&U**2+,++*++(*6-J.-(J",&&*++*2"!!-."#$:"?@!!J""

;^UJ"?@!@2J"z;'&$%"*&'6'(/&"$++*++(*6-"?@!@"-'"?@?Mzf";'62'6"^'5'09."'7"U*E.$(J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f"EEEJ6*E.$(J9'BJ0FJ",&&*++*2"\-.")06*"?@!?J""

;^UJ"?@!@*J"z;'62'6"^'5'09."'7"U*E.$(f"&./%25*6"$62":'069"4*'4%*o+"6**2+"$++*++(*6-"?@@PD!@zf";'62'6"^'5'09."'7"U*E.$(J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ6*E.$(J9'BJ0FD_*$%-.,628'&/$%S$5*DS./%25*6$62Z'069=*'4%*+U**2+,++*++(*6-J.-(J",&&*++*2"#$:"!!-."?@!!J""

;^UJ"?@!@7J"zU*E.$("AU]Tf"'B*5B/*E"*20&$-/'6zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ6*E.$(J/67'DA,8D45'7/%*+D45'7/%*i45'7/%*A2Ä\?k9*'K:4*A2Äek9*'A2+Ä@@^^J",&&*++*2"!!-.""#$:"?@!!J"

Page 219: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?!P"

"

;^UJ"?@!@9J"zU*E.$("4'40%$-/'6zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ6*E.$(J/67'D5*+*$5&.D4'40%$-/'6J.-(J",&&*++*2"!+-"#$5&."?@!!J"

;^UJ"?@!!J"z<(4%':(*6-"+-50&-05*"GU*E.$(IzJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ6*E.$(J/67'D45'7/%*+D45'7/%*i45'7/%*A2ÄePk9*'K:4*A2ÄJ",&&*++*2"?@-.")0%:"?@!?J"

;^UJ"U'"2$-*J"zK.*"U*E.$("+-'5:f"A-$%/$6+zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ6*E.$(+-'5:J&'(D6'2*D?OMMJ",&&*++*2"V-."#$5&."?@!!J"

;*$&.>"<2(062"R'6$%2J"?@@@J"<9+!+--+(,'41!75&0(5!8+4$9J"U*E"_$B*6f"Z$%*"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

;*7*1B5*>"_*65/J"!PP!J"<9+!#3%50$,'%(!%F!-#4$+J"TC7'52f"^%$&FE*%%J"

;*7*1B5*>"_*65/J"!PPeJ"zK.*"5/9.-"-'"-.*"&/-:z>"/6"<%*'6'5*"`'7($6"$62"<%/a$1*-.";*1$+"*2+J"^3','()-!%(!$','+-J";'62'6f"^%$&FE*%%>"44JeOQ!V\J"

;*9($6>"XJ"!PMNJ":4,'%(41+!%F!,9+!5'3,/!a%=+.!4(!4(41/-'-!%F!-+M041!90&%03J"U*E"Z'5Ff"^*%%J"

;*6-/6>",%$6$"$62"X$B$6"K/-%*:J"?@!!J"<9+!$3'-+-!%F!&01,'$01,0341'-&.!34$'-&!'(!4!(+%1'T+341!4)+J";'62'6f"x*2"^''F+J"

;*B/-->"=*99:"$62"^J"U$2:$")$E'5+F:J"?@@MJ"zK5$6+6$-/'6$%"#/95$-/'6"8-02/*+f"=$+-"3*B*%'4(*6-+"$62"]0-05*"K5*62+zJ"[((041!:+*'+C!%F!;%$'%1%)/>"B'%JOO>""44J!?PQ!NeJ"

;/*1'E>"<%%/'-J"!PeMJ"<411/e-!$%3(+3.!4!-,05/!%F!(+)3%!-,3++,$%3(+3!&+(J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*"k"`*9$6"=$0%J"

;/((*5>"#$5FJ"?@@VJ"z,225*++/69":'069"4*'4%*o+"+*C"$62"$%&'.'%"0+*f"/-o+"$1'0-"$+4/5$-/'6"6'-"/67'5($-/'6zJ"750$4,'%(!4(5!B+41,9>"B'%J?e>"6'J?>"44JOVQOPJ"

;/4+/-a>"X*'59*J"!PP\J"zd*"F6'E"E.$-"-/(*"/-"/+f"5$&*>"&%$++"$62":'0-."&0%-05*"/6"-.*"6/6*-/*+z>"/6",625*E"R'++"$62"K5/&/$"R'+*"*2+J"N'$3%#9%(+!F'+(5-.!/%0,9!&0-'$!4(5!/%0,9!$01,03+J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*>"44J!MQ?VJ"

;'$2*5>"A$6J"!PPeJ"`%0,92!#%1'$'()!4(5!5+&%$34$/J"^$+/69+-'F*f"#$&(/%%$6J"

;'E>"8*-.$"#J"?@@OJ"G+9'(5!,9+!)4,+-.!1'F+2!-+$03',/2!4(5!,9+!#03-0',!%F!94##'(+--!'(!F%3,3+--![&+3'$4J"U*E"Z'5Ff"R'0-%*29*J"

;'EF*:J"?@!!J";%0(5,34$=!,%!,9+!-,30))1+f"#*+'4'-$(/$"#0+/&J"

;'EF*:J"?@!?J"zK.*"#*-"4'%/&*"$5*"+-/9($-/+/69"./4Q.'4"E/-."-.*"ePe"7'5(z>",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ90$52/$6J&'J0FD&'((*6-/+75**D?@!?DH$6D!@D4'%/&*Q+-/9($-/+/69Q./4Q.'4QePeQ7'5(J",&&*++*2"!N-."#$:"?@!?J"

;0&$+>"K/(J"!PPVJ"zZ'0-."9$69+"$62"('5$%"4$6/&+"/6"8$6-$"S50a>"S$%/7'56/$z>"/6"K5$&*:"8F*%-'6"$62"X/%%"c$%*6-/6*"*2+J"_%%1!#14$+-.!)+%)34#9'+-!%F!/%0,9!$01,03+-J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*>"44J!\NQ!e@J"

#$&3'6$%2>"R'1*5-"$62")$6*"#$5+.J"?@@NJ">'-$%((+$,+5!/%0,9i!D3%C'()!0#!'(!G3',4'(e-!#%%3!(+')9T%039%%5-J"^$+/69+-'F*"j"U*E"Z'5Ff"=$%95$B*"#$&(/%%$6J"

Page 220: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

??@"

"

#$&A66*+>"K'(>"*-"$%J"?@!@J"z;'62'6Y+"4'B*5-:"45'7/%*f"5*4'5-/69"'6"-.*"5*&*++/'6zf"U*E"='%/&:"A6+-/-0-*J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ%'62'6+4'B*5-:45'7/%*J'59J0FD2'E6%'$2+DS=]Q4'B*5-:5*4'5-?@!@Q;RJ427J",&&*++*2"V-."#$5&."?@!!J""

#$&;*'2>"X'52'6"$62"#$5F"X'2E/6J"!PPPJ"z84$&*>"+&$%*"$62"+-$-*"+-5$-*9:f"5*-./6F/69"051$6"$62"5*9/'6$%"9'B*56$6&*zJ"Z3%)3+--!'(!B0&4(!D+%)34#9/>"B'%J?N>"6'J\>"44JN@OQN?MJ"

#$/%"'6"8062$:J"?@@VJ"zX'52'6"^5'E6"2*7*62+"F6/7*"&5/(*"&%$(42'E6"$+"4'%/&*"&./*7"45'4'+*+"o6$-/'6$%"+*5B/&*o"7'5"H'1%*++zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ($/%'6+062$:J&'J0FD6*E+D$5-/&%*Q!@O\MMPD^5'E6Q2*7*62+QF6/7*Q&5/(*Q&%$(42'E6Q4'%/&*Q&./*7Q45'4'+*+Q6$-/'6$%Q+*5B/&*QH'1%*++J.-(%J",&&*++*2"M-."8*4-*(1*5"?@!!J"

#$%/6'E+F/>"^5'6/+%$EJ"?@@?J"[3)%(40,-!%F!,9+!^+-,+3(!Z4$'F'$.!4(!4$$%0(,!%F!(4,'*+!+(,+3#3'-+!4(5!45*+(,03+!'(!,9+!43$9'#+14)%-!%F!N+14(+-'4(!I+C!D0'(+4J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*J"

#$5&0+>"X*'59*"<""$62"3/&F"S0+.($6J"!PV?J"z<-.6'95$4./*+"$+"-*C-+zJ"[((041!:+*'+C!%F![(,93%#%1%)/>"B'%J!!>""44J?NQePJ"

#$5&0+>"X*'59*"<J"!PVeJ"zS'6-*(4'5$5:"45'1%*(+"'7"*-.6'95$4.:"/6"-.*"('2*56"E'5%2"+:+-*(z>"/6")$(*+"S%/77'52"$62"X*'59*"<J"#$5&0+"*2+J"^3','()!$01,03+.!,9+!#%+,'$-!4(5!#%1','$-!%F!+,9(%)34#9/.!4!;$9%%1!%F![&+3'$4(!:+-+43$9!45*4($+5!-+&'(43J"^*5F*%*:f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"S$%/7'56/$"=5*++>"44J!eNQ!POJ"

#$5&0+>"X*'59*"<J"!PPVJ"7,9(%)34#9/!,93%0)9!,9'$=!4(5!,9'(J"=5/6&*-'6>"UJ)Jf"=5/6&*-'6"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

#$5&0+*>"=*-*5J"?@@PJ"z]5'("&5/-/&$%"051$6"-.*'5:"-'"-.*"5/9.-"-'"-.*"&/-:zJ"_',/.!4(41/-'-!%F!03T4(!,3+(5-2!$01,03+2!,9+%3/2!#%1'$/2!4$,'%(>"B'%J!O>"6'J?QO>"44J!VNQ!PMJ"

#$5+-'6>"8$%%/*",J"J"?@@@J"zK.*"+'&/$%"&'6+-50&-/'6"'7"+&$%*zJ"Z3%)3+--!'(!B0&4(!D+%)34#9/>"B'%J?\>"6'J?>"44J?!PQ?\?J"

#$++'6>")02/-.J"?@@\J"zK.*"%*9$%"&'6-*C-z>"/6"8$62:"]5$+*5"*2J">%'()!3+-+43$9!C',9!$9'153+(!4(5!/%0()!#+%#1+J";'62'6f"8,X<>"44J\OQNVJ"

#$:*5>"R0-.J"?@@@J"zz,75/&$"$+"$6"$%/*6"70-05*zf"-.*"(/22%*"4$++$9*>"$75'70-05/+(>"$62"4'+-&'%'6/$%"B*56$&0%$5zJ"[&+3'=4-,05'+(>"B'%J\N>""44JNNNQNeeJ"

#$:.*E>"_*65:J"!Ve!J"8%(5%(!14T%03!k!,9+!8%(5%(!#%%3J";'62'6f"X5/77/6J"

#&3'6$%2>"=$0%$>"*-"$%J"?@!!J"zZ'069"4*'4%*o+"$+4/5$-/'6+"7'5"*20&-$-/'6>"E'5F>"7$(/%:"$62"%/-*5$-05*zJ"^%3=2!7&#1%/&+(,!4(5!;%$'+,/>"B'%J?N>"6'J!>"44JeVQV\J"

#&3'E*%%>";/62$J"!PPPJ"D+(5+32!'5+(,',/!4(5!#14$+.!0(5+3-,4(5'()!F+&'('-,!)+%)34#9'+-J"#/66*$4'%/+f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"#/66*+'-$"=5*++J"

#&X5$-.>"#*%$6/*J"?@@?J";'1*+3,%C(.!4(!74-,!7(5!F4&'1/!&+&%'3J";'62'6f"]'05-."<+-$-*J"

Page 221: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

??!"

"

#&R'11/*>",69*%$J"!PP?J"z='+-Q#$5C/+("$62"&0%-05$%"+-02/*+f"$"4'+-Q+&5/4-z>"/6";$E5*6&*"X5'++1*59>"S$5:"U*%+'6"$62"=$0%$",J"K5*/&.%*5"*2+J"_01,0341!;,05'+-J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*>"44JM!PQMO@J"

#&R'11/*>",69*%$J"?@@PJ"<9+!4F,+3&4,9!%F!F+&'('-&.!)+(5+32!$01,03+!4(5!-%$'41!$94()+J";'62'6f"8,X<J"

#*2$F>"=*-*5J"!PP@J"zK.*"`5$:+Jz"[`f")J",5-.05"R$6F"]/%("3/+-5/10-'5+J"

#*5%*$0Q='6-:>"#$05/&*J"!PVPJ"Z9+(%&+(%1%)/!%F!#+3$+#,'%(J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*J"

#*5%*$0Q='6-:>"#$05/&*J"?@@?J"Z9+(%&+(%1%)/!%F!#+3$+#,'%(J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*J"

#*55/7/*%2>",62:J"?@!!J"zK.*"5/9.-"-'"-.*"&/-:"$62"1*:'62zJ"_',/.!4(41/-'-!%F!03T4(!,3+(5-2!$01,03+2!,9+%3/2!#%1'$/2!4$,'%(>"B'%J!N>"6'JOQ\>"44J\MOQ\V!J"

#*-5'4'%/-$6"='%/&*J"?@!@J"zS0+-'2:"4'%/&*"Q"('6/-'5/69"5*4'5-z>",B$/%$1%*"75'(f"EEEJ(*-J4'%/&*J0FD7'/D427+D4'%/&/*+D&0+-'2:}('6/-'5/69}5*4'5-J427J",&&*++*2"?O52",090+-"?@!?J"

#/22%*-'6>"80*>"*-"$%J"?@@NJ"zZ'069"4*'4%*"75'("*-.6/&"(/6'5/-:"1$&F95'062+f"*B/2*6&*"75'("-.*"*20&$-/'6"($/6-*6$6&*"$%%'E$6&*"4/%'-+"2$-$1$+*zf";'09.1'5'09."[6/B*5+/-:J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4+fDDEEEJ*20&$-/'6J9'BJ0FD401%/&$-/'6+J",&&*++*2"?\-."#$:"?@!?J""

#/%*+>"8-*B*6J"?@!@J";#4$+-!F%3!$%(-0&#,'%(.!#1+4-03+!4(5!#14$+1+--(+--!'(!,9+!#%-,g'(50-,3'41!$',/J";'62'6f"8,X<J"

#/%%*5>"3$6/*%J"!PP!J"z]5**2'("/6"K5/6/2$2zJ"N4(>"B'%J?e>"6'J?>"44JO?OQO\!J"

#/%%/69-'6>"X$5*-.J"?@!!J"e:4$+e2!$01,03+!4(5!,9+!3')9,!,%!,9+!$',/.!$+(,3+-2!#+3'#9+3'+-2!&43)'(-J"^$+/69+-'F*f"=$%95$B*"#$&(/%%$6J"

#/6-'6>",66$J"?@@PJ"D3%0(5!$%(,3%1.!F+43!4(5!94##'(+--!'(!,9+!,C+(,/gF'3-,g$+(,03/!$',/J";'62'6f"=*690/6J"

#/5a$>"#06/5$J"?@!@J"zR*-./6F/69"5$&*z>",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ45'+4*&-($9$a/6*J&'J0FD($9$a/6*D(06/5$Q(/5a$Q(0%-/&0%-05$%/+(Q5$&/+(DJ",&&*++*2"!e-.",090+-"?@!?J"

#/++:"<%%/'-J"?@@?J"^%3=!',f"X'%2(/62D<%*F-5$J"

#/++:"<%%/'-Y+"7*$-05/69"S/$5$J"?@@NJ"8%-+!$%(,3%1f",-%$6-/&J"

#/-&.*%%>"3'6J"!PPNJ"zK.*"<62"'7"=01%/&"84$&*i"=*'4%*o+"=$5F>"3*7/6/-/'6+"'7"-.*"=01%/&>"$62"3*('&5$&:zJ"[((41-!%F!,9+![--%$'4,'%(!%F![&+3'$4(!D+%)34#9+3->"B'%JVN>"6'J!>"44J!@VQ!OOJ"

#'2''2>"K$5/hJ"!PP?J"I%,!+4-/!T+'()!G3','-9.!$%1%032!$01,03+!4(5!$','b+(-9'#J"8-'F*Q'6QK5*6-f"R066:(*2*"K50+-"$62"K5*6-.$(J"

#'2''2>"K$5/hJ"!PPOJ"zK.*"60(1*5"'7"*-.6/&"(/6'5/-:"+-02*6-+"/6"15/-/+."./9.*5"*20&$-/'6f"+'(*"95'062+"7'5"'4-/(/+(zJ"6MF%35!:+*'+C!%F!750$4,'%(6'J!P>"44J!eMQ!V?J"

Page 222: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

???"

"

#'2''2>"K$5/hJ"!PPMJ"7,9('$!&'(%3','+-!'(!G3',4'(.!5'*+3-',/!4(5!5'-45*4(,4)+J";'62'6f"='%/&:"8-02/*+"A6+-/-0-*J"

#'2''2>"K$5/hJ"!PPVJ"z<-.6/&"(/6'5/-/*+o"25/B*"7'5"h0$%/7/&$-/'6+z>"/6"K$5/h"#'2''2"$62"K'6:",&%$62"*2+J":4$+!4(5!9')9+3!+50$4,'%(!+M#+3'+($+-2!$9411+()+-!4(5!#%1'$/!'&#1'$4,'%(-J";'62'6f"='%/&:"8-02/*+"A6+-/-0-*>"44J?\QOVJ"

#'2''2>"K$5/hJ"?@@?J"z_*%4"'5"./625$6&*i"_/9.*5"*20&$-/'6"$62"-.*"5'0-*"-'"*-.6/&"*h0$%/-:zJ"G3','-9!]%03(41!%F!;%$'%1%)/!%F!750$4,'%(>"B'%J?O>"6'J?>"44J?@PQ?O?J"

#''5*>"R'1*5-J"?@@VJ"zoS$5%*++"-$%Fof"$"&5/-/h0*"'7"3*6&.>"X$B5'6"$62"Z'069o+"K.*"U*E"<$+-"<62zJ"_3','$41!;%$'41!Z%1'$/>"B'%J?V>"6'JO>"44JO\PQOe@J"

#'-*6>"]5*2J"?@@OJ"L(!,9+!T3+4=.!,9+!4+-,9+,'$-!%F!,9+!G14$=!345'$41!,345','%(J"#/66*$4'%/+f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"#/66*+'-$"=5*++J"

#0(7'52>"`$-.$5/6*"$62",66*"='E*5J"?@@OJ"74-,!7(5+3-.!F4&'1/!4(5!$%&&0(',/!'(!74-,!8%(5%(J"^5/+-'%f"='%/&:J"

#055$:>"S.$5%*+J"!PP@J"<9+!+&+3)'()!G3','-9!0(5+3$14--J";'62'6f"A<,"_*$%-."$62"d*%7$5*"[6/-J"

#055$:>"S.$5%*+J"!PP\J""(5+3$14--.!,9+!$3'-'-!5++#+(-f"A6+-/-0-*"'7"<&'6'(/&",77$/5+>"_*$%-."$62"d*%7$5*"[6/-J"

U$:$F>",6''4J"?@@OJ":4$+2!#14$+!4(5!)1%T41'b4,'%(.!/%0,9!$01,03+-!'(!4!$94()'()!C%315J"TC7'52f"^*59J"

U*9->"T+F$5"$62",%*C$62*5"`%09*J"!PPOJ"Z0T1'$!-#9+3+!4(5!+M#+3'+($+.!,%C435!4(!4(41/-'-!%F!,9+!T%03)+%'-!4(5!#3%1+,43'4(!#0T1'$!-#9+3+J";'62'6f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"#/66*+'-$"=5*++J"

U*0>")*5'(*J"?@@MJ"z8-/&F+"$62"+-'6*+"-.*"4./%'+'4.:"'7"/6+0%-+zf"TC7'52"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ'C7'52+&.'%$5+./4J&'(D'+'D401%/&D&'6-*6-D4./%'+'4.:DPMV@!PNO!\O!!D-'&J.-(%J",&&*++*2"!!-.")06*"?@!?J""

U*E1056>"K/(>"*-"$%J"!PPPJ":'-=-!4(5!3+-#%(-+-.!530)!#3+*+(,'%(!4(5!/%0,9!a0-,'$+J";'62'6f"_'(*"T77/&*>"3509+"=5*B*6-/'6",2B/+'5:"8*5B/&*J"

U*E/-a>",66$%**J"!PPMJ"zd./-*"+$B*9*5:"$62".0(/%/$-/'6>"'5"$"6*E"5$&/$%"&'6+&/'0+6*++"/6"-.*"(*2/$z>"/6"#$--"d5$:"$62",66$%**"U*E/-a"*2+J"^9',+!,34-9.!34$+!4(5!$14--!'(![&+3'$4J"U*E"Z'5F>";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*>"44J!O!Q!N\J"

U/*-a+&.*>"]5/*25/&."d/%.*%(J"!PVOJ"zT6"-.*"0+*+"$62"2/+$2B$6-$9*+"'7"./+-'5:"7'5"%/7*z>"/6"]5/*25/&."d/%.*%("U/*-a+&.*"*2J""(,'&+1/!&+5',4,'%(-J"S$(15/29*f"S$(15/29*"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++>"44JNPQ!?OJ"

U/++*6>"X"?@!?J"zU/++*6+zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ6/++*6+J&'J0FD2*7$0%-J.-(J",&&*++*2"!P-.",090+-"?@!?J"

U'";$:J"?@@VJ"z[6'5-.'2'C"3$09.-*5zf"Z'0K01*J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ:'0-01*J&'(DE$-&.iBÄSO=4Oc@[email protected]",&&*++*2"!N-.",090+-"?@!?J""

Page 223: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

??O"

"

U'1%*>"3*6/+*J"?@@@J"zR$99$"(0+/&f"2/+D5*+4*&-/69"1%$&F"E'(*6"$62"2/+D5*40-$1%*"+*C0$%/-/*+z>"/6"^$56'5"_*++*"*2J""(j-+,,1+5!&01,'$01,0341'-&-.!5'4-#%34-2!+(,4()1+&+(,-2!h,34(-30#,'%(-hJ";'62'6f"x*2"^''F+>"44J!\VQ!ePJ"

U'1%*>"#/&.$*%>"*-"$%J"?@@VJ"zK.*"<69%/+."A62/&*+"'7"3*45/B$-/'6"?@@Mzf"S'((06/-/*+"$62";'&$%"X'B*56(*6-J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ&'((06/-/*+J9'BJ0FD2'&0(*6-+D&'((06/-/*+D427DMOON?@J427J",&&*++*2"!O-."U'B*(1*5"?@@VJ""

U'&-056$%J"?@@PJ"z`/%%"$%%"$"2*("G5*(/CI"r/6+-50(*6-$%szf"Z'0K01*J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ:'0-01*J&'(DE$-&.iBÄU;9NeHOh5{#J",&&*++*2"!N-.",090+-"?@!?J""

U'/a:J"?@!@J"zT."(:zf"Z'0K01*J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ:'0-01*J&'(DE$-&.iBÄHZB}*RhN*V9J",&&*++*2"!N-.",090+-"?@!?J""

U'55/69-'6>"8-*4.*6J"!PPVJ"z^%$2*Jz"[8,f"U*E";/6*"S/6*($+J"

ToU*/%%>"S.5/+-/6$"=J"?@@PJ"z#$5F*-/69"-'"X*6*5$-/'6"ZJ"K.*:o5*":'05"1$6Fo+"70-05*zJ"N43/14(5!G4(=+3>"B'%JK./52"h0$5-*5"44J!?Q!NJ"

ToU*/%%>"X/%2$J"!PPPJ"N/!74-,!7(5.!4!9'-,%3/!%F!$%$=(+/!8%(5%(J";'62'6f"c/F/69J"

T77/&*>"_'(*J"?@@VJ"zK$&F%/69"X$69+f"$"45$&-/&$%"90/2*"7'5"%'&$%"$0-.'5/-/*+>"S3R=+"$62"'-.*5"%'&$%"4$5-6*5+zf"_'(*"T77/&*J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ&5/(*5*20&-/'6J.'(*'77/&*J9'BJ0FDB/'%*6-+-5**-DB/'%*6-+-5**-@!?$J427J",&&*++*2"O52"#$5&."?@!@J""

TU8J"?@@!J"z,5*$f"U*E.$("G;'&$%",0-.'5/-:I"Q"5*+/2*6-"4'40%$-/'6"*+-/($-*+"1:"*-.6/&"95'04"G4*5&*6-$9*+IzJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDD6*/9.1'05.''2J+-$-/+-/&+J9'BJ0F",&&*++*2"!!-."#$:"?@!!J"

TU8J"?@!@J";,4(5435!%$$0#4,'%(41!$14--'F'$4,'%(!OP?P.!d%10&+!?!-,30$,03+!4(5!5+-$3'#,'%(-!%F!0(',!)3%0#-J";'62'6f"=$%95$B*"#$&(/%%$6J"

T5E*%%>"X*'59*J"!POMJ"<9+!3%45!,%!^')4(!Z'+3J";'62'6f"K.*"]'%/'"8'&/*-:J"

=$5F*5>"_'E$52")J"!PM\J"d'+C!F3%&!,9+!T%/-.!4!-%$'%1%)/!%F!5%C(g,%C(!45%1+-$+(,-J"U*E-'6",11'-f"3$B/2"$62"S.$5%*+J"

=$+&'*>"SJ)J"?@@MJ"zod.$-"/7"$"90:"./-+"'6":'0iof"/6-*5+*&-/'6+"'7"9*62*5>"+*C0$%/-:>"$62"$9*"/6"7/*%2E'5F"E/-."$2'%*+&*6-+z>"/6",(:";J"^*+-"*2J":+#3+-+(,'()!/%0,9.!&+,9%5%1%)'$41!'--0+-!'(!$3','$41!/%0,9!-,05'+-J"U*E"Z'5Ff"U*E"Z'5F"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++>"44J??eQ?\MJ"

=$--*5+'6>"T5%$62'J"!PPPJ":',041-!%F!T1%%5.!$%(-+c0+($+-!%F!-14*+3/!'(!,%C![&+3'$4(!$+(,03'+-J"d$+./69-'6>"3JSJf"S/B/-$+DS'06-*5='/6-J"

=$--*5+'6>"8.*/%$J"!PeNJ">43=!-,34()+3-.!4!-,05/!%F!^+-,!L(5'4(-!'(!8%(5%(J"_$5('62+E'5-.f"=*690/6J"

=$--'6>"<5/6"TJ"?@@PJ""(5+3!,9+!'(F10+($+.!,34$'()!,9+!9'#g9%#!)+(+34,'%(e-!'&#4$,!%(!T34(5-2!-#%3,-2!4(5!#%#!$01,03+J"A-.$&$>"UZf"=$5$('06-"#$5F*-"=01%/+./69J"

Page 224: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

??\"

"

=$--'6>"#/&.$*%"L0/66J"?@@?J"l041',4,'*+!3+-+43$9!4(5!+*4104,'%(!&+,9%5-J"O52"*2/-/'6J";'62'6f"8,X<J"

=$0%>"8*$6J"?@@PJ";%!F'(+f"c=D,-%$6-/&"R*&'52+J"

=*$5+*>"3$(/*6"$62"#$--.*E"K$:%'5J"?@@PJ"z#*-"4'%/&*"1'E"-'"45*++05*"-'"25'4"h0*+-/'6"'6"o5$&/+-o"7'5("ePez>",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ90$52/$6J&'J0FD+'&/*-:D?@@PD+*4D@MD(*-Q4'%/&*Q7'5(QePeQ&%01+J",&&*++*2"!N-."#$:"?@!?J"

=*$5+'6>"X*'775*:J"!PVOJ"B%%1')4(.!4!9'-,%3/!%F!3+-#+$,4T1+!F+43-J";'62'6f"#$&(/%%$6J"

=*&F>")$(/*J"?@@?J"z='%/-/&$%"*&'6'(/*+"'7"+&$%*f"7$+-"4'%/&:>"/6-*5+&$%$5"5*%$-/'6+>"$62"6*'%/1*5$%"E'5F7$5*zJ"7$%(%&'$!D+%)34#9/>"B'%JMV>"6'JO>"44JOO!QOe@J"

=*&F>")$(/*"$62",2$("K/&F*%%J"?@@?J"zU*'%/1*5$%/a/69"+4$&*zJ"[(,'#%5+>"B'%JO\>"6'JO>"44JOV@Q\@\J"

=<=8ASTJ"?@!?J"z=<=8ASTzJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ4*4+/&'J&'(DJ",&&*++*2"?!+-",090+-"?@!?J"

=./%%/4+>"K5*B'5J"?@@NJ"z8%**4E$%F/69"-'"+*95*9$-/'6zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ-/(*+'6%/6*J&'J0FD-'%D&'((*6-D%*$2/69}$5-/&%*D$5-/&%*NePM@PJ*&*J",&&*++*2"!+-")06*"?@!!J"

=.'*6/C>",66"$62",66*"d''%%*--J"!PP!J"z#'-.*5.''2f"+'&/$%"&'6+-50&-/'6>"4'%/-/&+"$62"4+.:&.'%'9:z>"/6"<B$";%':2>",66"=.'*6/C"$62",66*"d''%%*--"*2+J"N%,9+39%%5.!&+4('()-2!#34$,'$+-!4(5!'5+%1%)'+-J";'62'6f"8,X<>"44J!OQ\NJ"

=/6F>"8$5$.J"?@@MJ">%'()!*'-041!+,9(%)34#9/.!'&4)+-2!&+5'4!4(5!3+#3+-+(,4,'%(!'(!3+-+43$9J"?62"*2J";'62'6f"8,X<J"

=/--+>")'.6J"?@@MJ"zR*%0&-$6-"9$69+-*5+f":'0-."9$69+"/6"d$%-.$("]'5*+-zf"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"^*27'52+./5*J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f"EEEJ./%%/692'6J9'BJ0FD(*2/$D427D1DMD5*%0&-$6-Q9$69+-*5+J427J",&&*++*2"!@-.")0%:"?@!?J""

='E*%%>")J"<6'&."$62")'.6"d''2J"!PePJ"E3++5%&!4(5!3+41',/J";'62'6f"^$-+7'52J"

='E*%%>"dJ"RJ"!PMOJ"[!B'-,%3/!%F!,9+!$%0(,/!%F!7--+M@!d%1@YJ";'62'6"TC7'52f"TC7'52"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++"7'5"-.*"A6+-/-0-*"'7"_/+-'5/&$%"R*+*$5&.J"

=5*+-'6>")'.6J"?@@PJ"z_'E"-.*"E./-*"E'5F/69"&%$++"1*&$(*"W&.$BYf"-.*"($F/69"'7"E./-*6*++"/6"$6"<++*C"]<"S'%%*9*z>"/6")'.6"=5*+-'6"*2J"^9',+(+--!4(5!$14--!'(!+50$4,'%(J"3'525*&.-f"845/69*5>"44JONQ\VJ"

=5'7*++'5"X5**6J"?@@PJ"z[44*5"S%$4-'6"2$6&*"zf"Z'0K01*D45'7*++'595**6-BJ",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ:'0-01*J&'(DE$-&.iBÄAA0L#}h@A[[J",&&*++*2"!N-.",090+-"?@!?J""

=5:&*>"`*6J"!PVeJ"7(51+--!#3+--03+.!4!-,05/!%F!^+-,!L(5'4(!1'F+g-,/1+-!'(!G3'-,%1J"?62"*2/-/'6J"^5/+-'%f"^5/+-'%"S%$++/&$%J"

Page 225: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

??N"

"

=05&*%%>"#$5FJ"?@@OJ"zS/-/a*6+./4"$62"-.*"5/9.-"-'"-.*"9%'1$%"&/-:f"5*/($9/6/69"-.*"&$4/-$%/+-"E'5%2"'52*5zJ"L(,+3(4,'%(41!]%03(41!%F!"3T4(!4(5!:+)'%(41!:+-+43$9>"B'%J?M>"6'JO>"44JNe\QNP@J"

L0/66>"8-*4.*6J"?@@NJ"zZ'0-."401%/&$-/'6+>"X*6*5$-/'6"Z"$62".'4*+"7'5"-.*"70-05*"'7"6*E+4$4*5+zJ"[0-,341'4(!]%03(41'-&!:+*'+C>"B'%J?M>"6'J!>"44J!PNQ?@MJ"

R$&'>"#/F*J"?@@PJ"z]5'("*C4*&-$-/'6+"-'"$+4/5$-/'6+f"+-$-*"('2*56/+$-/'6>"051$6"4'%/&:>"$62"-.*"*C/+-*6-/$%"4'%/-/&+"'7"E*%7$5*"/6"-.*"[`zJ"Z%1','$41!D+%)34#9/>"B'%J?V>""44J\OeQ\\\J"

R$($a$6'9%0>"S$5'%/6*"$62")$6*-"_'%%$62J"?@@?J"E+&'('-,!&+,9%5%1%)/.!$9411+()+-!4(5!$9%'$+-J";'62'6f"8,X<J"

R*$:>"3/$6*J"?@@PJ"z#$F/69"+*6+*"'7"E./-*"E'5F/69"&%$++"*20&$-/'6$%"062*5$&./*B*(*6-z>"/6"`H$5-$6"=$%%""8B*/6++'6"*2J"^9%!$43+-!4T%0,!,9+!C9',+!C%3='()!$14--J";'62'6f"R066:(*2*"K50+->"44J??Q?VJ"

R*$:>"3/$6*>"*-"$%J"?@@MJ"zo,"2$5F*5"+.$2*"'7"4$%*io"d./-*6*++>"-.*"(/22%*"&%$++*+"$62"(0%-/Q*-.6/&"/66*5"&/-:"+&.''%/69zJ";%$'%1%)/>"B'%J\!>"6'Je>"44J!@\!Q!@e@J"

R*:6'%2+>")$&FJ"?@@\J"N+31+40gZ%(,/!4(5!>+33'54.!'(,+3,C'('()!+&T%5'&+(,!4(5!41,+3',/J",-.*6+f"T./'"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

RA,,J"?@!?J"zRA,,zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDD5/$$J&'(DJ",&&*++*2"#$:"!M-."?@!?J"

R/&.($6>")$&F"#J"$62"#$5F"dJ"]5$+*5J"?@@!J"<9+!$%(,+M,!%F!/%0,9!*'%1+($+.!3+-'1'+($+2!3'-=2!4(5!#3%,+$,'%(J"d*+-4'5->"S'66Jf"=5$*9*5J"

R/&.('62>",6-.'6:"_*65:J"!PN\J"_%1%03!#3+a05'$+!'(!G3',4'(.!4!-,05/!%F!^+-,!L(5'4(!C%3=+3-!'(!8'*+3#%%12!?KX?g?K\?J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*"$62"`*9$6"=$0%J"

R/&u05>"=$0%J"!PMOJ"zK.*"('2*%"'7"-.*"-*C-f"(*$6/6970%"$&-/'6"&'6+/2*5*2"$+"$"-*C-zJ"I+C!8',+343/!B'-,%3/>"B'%JN>"6'J!>"44JP!Q!!MJ"

R/&u05>"=$0%J"!PV\J"<'&+!4(5!(4334,'*+@!d%1@!VJ"S./&$9'f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"S./&$9'"=5*++J"

R/&u05>"=$0%J"?@@\J"N+&%3/2!9'-,%3/2!F%3)+,,'()J"S./&$9'>"A%%Jf"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"S./&$9'"=5*++J"

R/-&./*>"X0:J"!PPVJ"z;'&F>"8-'&F"$62"KE'"8('F/69"^$55*%+Jz"[`f"='%:X5$("]/%(*2"<6-*5-$/6(*6-J"

R'1/6+>"3$B/2J"!PP?J"<43('-9+5!*'-'%(.!$3'&+!4(5!$%&&0(',/!4$,'%(!'(!,9+!'((+3!$',/J"TC7'52f"TC7'52"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

R'1/6+>"3$B/2"$62"=./%/4"S'.*6J"!PMVJ"A(0$=1+!-4(5C'$9.!)3%C'()!0#!'(!,9+!C%3='()g$14--!$',/J"_$5('62+E'5-.f"=*690/6J"

R'1/6+'6>"S*25/&")J"?@@MJ"E%3)+3'+-!%F!&+&%3/!4(5!&+4('().!T14$=-!4(5!,9+!3+)'&+-!%F!34$+!'(![&+3'$4(!,9+4,3+!4(5!F'1&!T+F%3+!^%315!^43!LLJ"S.$4*%"_/%%>"UJSJf"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"U'5-."S$5'%/6$"=5*++J"

R'&F>"=$0%J"!PMPJ"<9+!&4='()!%F!-/&T%1'$!'(,+34$,'%('-&J";'62'6f"#$&(/%%$6J"

Page 226: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

??e"

"

R'*2/9*5>"3$B/2"RJ"?@@MJ"<9+!C4)+-!%F!C9',+(+--.!34$+!4(5!,9+!&4='()!%F!,9+![&+3'$4(!C%3='()!$14--J"R*B/+*2"$62"*C4$62*2"*2/-/'6J";'62'6f"c*5+'J"

R'9$%:>"^*6J"?@!!J"zoA62/9*6'0+o"-5$6+6$-/'6$%/+(f"%/7*"9*'95$4./*+"'7"-.*"oE./-*"E'5F/69"&%$++oz>"6'J?!J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ%'62'6(*-J$&J0FD%'62'6(*-D7(+D#R8/-*DR*+*$5&.D/+*-Dd'5F/69�?@=$4*5�?@8*5/*+Dd=�?@?!�?@^�?@R'9$%:J427J",&&*++*2"!+-")06*"?@!?J"

R'9$%:>"^*6"$62"^*&F:"K$:%'5J"?@@PJ"N%*'()!9'-,%3'+-!%F!$14--!4(5!$%&&0(',/.!'5+(,',/2!#14$+!4(5!T+1%()'()!'(!$%(,+&#%343/!7()14(5J"^$+/69+-'F*"j"U*E"Z'5Ff"=$%95$B*"#$&(/%%$6J"

R'+$%2'>"R*6$-'J"!PPOJ"_01,03+!k!,30,9.!,9+!3+&4='()!%F!-%$'41!4(41/-'-J"^'+-'6f"^*$&'6"=5*++J"

R'+*>"X/%%/$6J"!PPOJ"E+&'('-&!4(5!)+%)34#9/.!,9+!1'&',-!%F!)+%)34#9'$41!=(%C1+5)+J"S$(15/29*f"='%/-:"=5*++J"

R'+*>"U/F'%$+"8J"$62"=*-*5"#/%%*5J"?@@VJ"D%*+3('()!,9+!#3+-+(,.!45&'('-,+3'()!+$%(%&'$2!-%$'41!4(5!#+3-%(41!1'F+J"S$(15/29*f"='%/-:J"

R'+*>"K5/&/$J"!PP\J"G14$=!(%'-+.!34#!&0-'$!4(5!T14$=!$01,03+!'(!$%(,+&#%343/![&+3'$4J"#/22%*-'E6>"S'66Jf"d*+%*:$6"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

R01/6>"_*51*5-")J"$62"A5*6*"R01/6J"?@@NJ"l041',4,'*+!'(,+3*'+C'().!,9+!43,!%F!9+43'()!54,4J"?62"*2/-/'6J"K.'0+$62"T$F+>"S$%/7Jf"8,X<J"

R066:(*2*"K50+-J"?@@?J"<9+!F0,03+!%F!&01,'g+,9('$!G3',4'(.!3+#%3,!%F!,9+!_%&&'--'%(!%(!,9+!E0,03+!%F!N01,'g7,9('$!G3',4'(J";'62'6f"=5'7/%*"^''F+J"

R0++*%%>"A$6"#J"?@@NJ"[!F34&+C%3=!F%3!4$,'%(!4(5!+()4)+&+(,J"U'5E/&.f"S5'E6"S'4:5/9.-""

R0--*5>")/%%>"*-"$%J"?@@VJ"G+/%(5!(4,0341'-4,'%(.!$','b+(-9'#!#%1'$/!'(!4(!4)+!%F!-0#+3!&%T'1',/J";'62'6f"A==RJ"

8$/2>"<2E$52"dJ"!PMVJ"63'+(,41'-&J"_$5('62+E'5-.f"=*690/6J"

8$(4+'6>"R'1*5-")J"">"*-"$%J"!PPMJ"zU*/9.1'5.''2+"$62"B/'%*6-"&5/(*f"$"(0%-/%*B*%"+-02:"'7"&'%%*&-/B*"*77/&$&:zJ";$'+($+>"B'%J?MM>""44JP!VQP?\J"

8$(0*%>"R$4.$*%J"!PV!J"74-,!7(5!0(5+3C%315.!$94#,+3-!'(!,9+!1'F+!%F![3,903!B435'()J";'62'6f"R'0-%*9*"k"`*9$6"=$0%J"

8$62*5+'6>"<%*$6'5>"*-"$%J"?@@MJ"z=$5-/&/4$-'5:"&$5-'95$4./*+f"5*7%*&-/'6+"75'("5*+*$5&."4*57'5($6&*+"/6"]/H/"$62"K$6a$6/$z>"/6"8$5$";'0/+*"`/62'6>"R$&.*%"=$/6"$62"#/F*"`*+1:"*2+J"Z43,'$'#4,%3/!4$,'%(!3+-+43$9!4##3%4$9+-!4(5!&+,9%5-.!$%((+$,'()!#+%#1+2!#43,'$'#4,'%(2!4(5!#14$+J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*>"44J!!?Q!?!J"

8$62.0>"80F.2*BJ"?@@MJ"I')9,!940(,-J";'62'6f"c*5+'J"

8$5-5*>")*$6Q=$0%J"!PeVJ";+43$9!F%3!4!&+,9%5J";'62'6f"c/6-$9*J"

Page 227: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

??M"

"

8$5-5*>")*$6Q=$0%J"!PePJ"G+'()!4(5!(%,9'()(+--.!4(!+--4/!%(!#9+(%&+(%1%)'$41!%(,%1%)/J";'62'6f"#*-.0*6J"

8&.$7*5>"RJ"#055$:J"!PP\J"<9+!-%0(5-$4#+.!%03!-%('$!+(*'3%(&+(,!4(5!,9+!,0('()!%F!,9+!C%315J"R'&.*+-*5>"c-Jf"3*+-/6:"^''F+J"

8&.*4*5Q_09.*+>"U$6&:J"!PP?J">+4,9!C',9%0,!C++#'().!,9+!*'%1+($+!%F!+*+3/54/!1'F+!'(!G34b'1J"^*5F*%*:f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"S$%/7'56/$"=5*++J"

8&.(/-->"S$5%J"?@@OJ"<9+!(%&%-!%F!,9+!+43,9!'(!,9+!'(,+3(4,'%(41!14C!%F!,9+!]0-!Z0T1'$0&!703%#4+0&J"U*E"Z'5Ff"K*%'+"=5*++J"

8&.(/-->"S$5%J"?@@VJ"<9+!8+*'4,94(!'(!,9+!-,4,+!,9+%3/!%F!<9%&4-!B%TT+-.!&+4('()!4(5!F4'103+!%F!4!#%1','$41!-/&T%1J"S./&$9'>"A%%Jf"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"S./&$9'"=5*++J"

8*/2%*5>"c/&-'5")J"?@@eJ"`%0()!&+(!4(5!&4-$01'(','+-.!)1%T41!$01,03+-!4(5!'(,'&4,+!1'*+-J";'62'6f"x*2J"

8*66*-->"R/&.$52J"!PPOJ"<9+!F411!%F!#0T1'$!&4(J";'62'6f"]$1*5J"

8.$5($>"8$6H$:>"*-"$%J"!PPeJ">'-g%3'+(,'()!39/,9&-.!,9+!#%1','$-!%F!,9+!(+C![-'4(!54($+!&0-'$J";'62'6f"x*2"^''F+J"

8.0+-*5($6>"R/&.$52J"!PP!J"zK.*"7/6*"$5-"'7"5$4zJ"I+C!8',+343/!B'-,%3/>"B'%J??>""44Je!OQeO?J"

8.:+-/*J"?@!!J"zA($"^'++"7*$-05/69"3c8zf"Z'0K01*DA$(+.:+-/*J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ:'0-01*J&'(DE$-&.iBÄ)dE?$^hNH-[J",&&*++*2"?!+-",090+-"?@!?J""

8/%1*59>")'*%J"!PV\J"z^5*$F/6oJz"[8,f"#X#J"

8/(+>"X*'59*"R'1*5-J"!VVOJ"B%C!,9+!#%%3!1'*+J";'62'6f"S.$--'"k"d/620+J"

8/6&%$/5>"8>"*-"$%J"?@!@J"z]$/%/69":'069"4*'4%*i"<20&$-/'6"$62"$+4/5$-/'6+"/6"$"2*45/B*2"&'((06/-:zJ"750$4,'%(2!_','b+(-9'#!4(5!;%$'41!]0-,'$+>"B'%JN>"6'J!>"44JNQ?@J"

8F*99+>"^*B*5%*:J"!PPMJ"E%3&4,'%(-!%F!$14--!4(5!)+(5+3.!T+$%&'()!3+-#+$,4T1+J";'62'6f"8,X<J"

8F*99+>"^*B*5%*:J"?@@\J"_14--2!-+1F2!$01,03+J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*J"

8(/-.>"U*/%J"?@@!J"z<2/-'5/$%zJ"7(*'3%(&+(,!4(5!Z14(('()!>.!;%$'+,/!4(5!;#4$+>"B'%J!P>""44JeO!QeOMJ"

8(/-.*5($6>"X*6*B$J"?@@MJ"zzA7"Ao("%:/6>"Ao("7%:/6zf"-.*"9$(*"'7"/6+0%-"/6"-.*"1%$&F"%$690$9*z>"/6";*/%$"]5$6&*+"#'6$9.$6"$62")$6*"<J"X''2($6"*2+J"[!$01,0341!4##3%4$9!,%!'(,+3#+3-%(41!$%&&0('$4,'%(.!+--+(,'41!3+45'()-J"#$%2*6>"#,f"^%$&FE*%%>"44JO??QOO@J"

8'&/$%"<C&%0+/'6"K$+F"]'5&*J"?@@VJ"z,+4/5$-/'6"$62"$--$/6(*6-"$('69+-":'069"4*'4%*"/6"2*45/B*2"&'((06/-/*+zf"3S8]J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDE*1$5&./B*J6$-/'6$%$5&./B*+J9'BJ0FDÅD.--4fDDEEEJ&$1/6*-'77/&*J9'BJ0FD(*2/$D!@POOPD$+4/5$-/'6+}*B/2*6&*}4$&FJ427J",&&*++*2"!O-."]*150$5:"?@!?J""

Page 228: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

??V"

"

8'H$>"<2E$52"dJ"!PPeJ"<9'35-#4$+.!a%03(+/-!,%!8%-![()+1+-!4(5!%,9+3!3+41g4(5g'&4)'(+5!#14$+-J"S$(15/29*>"#$++Jf"^%$&FE*%%J"

8'H$>"<2E$52"dJ"?@@NJ"z^'52*5+"061'062f"9%'1$%/a$-/'6>"5*9/'6$%/+(>"$62"-.*"4'+-(*-5'4'%/-$6"-5$6+/-/'6z>"/6"_*6F"c$6"_'0-0(>"T%/B/*5"`5$(+&."$62"d'%79$69"x/*5.'7*5"*2+J"Gj%35+3'()!-#4$+J",%2*5+.'-f",+.9$-*>"44JOOQ\eJ"

8'H$>"<2E$52"dJ"?@!@J";++='()!-#4,'41!a0-,'$+J"#/66*$4'%/+f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"#/66*+'-$"=5*++J"

8'%'('+>")'.6J"!PVeJ"zc$5/*-/*+"'7"#$5C/+-"&'6&*4-/'6+"'7"W5$&*Y>"&%$++"$62"-.*"+-$-*f"$"&5/-/&$%"$6$%:+/+z>"/6")'.6"R*C"$62"3$B/2"#$+'6"*2+J"<9+%3'+-!%F!34$+!4(5!+,9('$!3+14,'%(-J"S$(15/29*f"S$(15/29*"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++>"44JV\Q!@PJ"

8'%'('+>")'.6J"!PVVJ"G14$=!/%0,92!34$'-&!4(5!,9+!-,4,+.!,9+!#%1','$-!%F!'5+%1%)/!4(5!#%1'$/J"S$(15/29*f"S$(15/29*"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

8'%'('+>")'.6J"?@@OJ":4$+!4(5!34$'-&!'(!G3',4'(J"O52"*2/-/'6J"^$+/69+-'F*f"=$%95$B*"#$&(/%%$6J"

8'%'('+>")'.6"$62";*+"^$&FJ"!PPeJ":4$'-&!4(5!-%$'+,/J";'62'6f"#$&(/%%$6J"

84/B$F>"X$:$-5/"S.$F5$B'5-:J"!PMeJ"zK5$6+%$-'5o+"45*7$&*z>"/6")$&h0*+"3*55/2$"*2J"6F!)34&&4,%1%)/J"^$%-/('5*f")'.6+"_'4F/6+"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++>"44J/CQ%CCC/CJ"

8-J")*$6>"=*-*5"`J"^J"?@@MJ"Z%$=+,-!%F!$3'&+.!T3%=+(!C'(5%C-2!$%11+$,'*+!+FF'$4$/2!4(5!,9+!$3'&'(41!#%'(,!%F!*'+CJ"S./&$9'f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"S./&$9'"=5*++J"

8-$5F*:>"3$B/2J"?@!!J"z<69%$62"5/'-+f"oK.*"E./-*+".$B*"1*&'(*"1%$&Fo"+$:+"3$B/2"8-$5F*:zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ11&J&'J0FD6*E+D0FQ!\N!ON!MJ",&&*++*2"!N-."#$:"?@!?J"

8-5$62>"8-*B*"$62")'*"d/6+-'6J"?@@VJ"z<20&$-/'6$%"$+4/5$-/'6+"/6"/66*5"&/-:"+&.''%+z>"B'%JO\>"6'J\J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDD2CJ2'/J'59D!@J!@V@D@O@NNeP@V@?@O\@?!J",&&*++*2"?\-."#$:"?@!?J"

8B*/6++'6>"`H$5-$6"=$%%"?@@PJ"^9%!$43+-!4T%0,!,9+!C9',+!C%3='()!$14--J";'62'6f"R066:(*2*"K50+-J"

8E$:J"?@@eJ"z;/--%*"3*5*Fz>",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ:'0-01*J&'(DE$-&.iBÄ}H!@}x6:d$&J",&&*++*2"!N-.",090+-"?@!?J"

8E:69*2'0E>"<5/FJ"!PPMJ"zU*/-.*5"9%'1$%"6'5"%'&$%f"o9%'&$%/a$-/'6o"$62"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"+&$%*z>"/6"`*B/6"RJ"S'C"*2J";#4$+-!%F!)1%T41'b4,'%(.!3+4--+3,'()!,9+!#%C+3!%F!,9+!1%$41J"U*E"Z'5Ff"X0/%7'52"=5*++>"44J!OMQ!eeJ"

8E:69*2'0E>"<5/FJ"?@@@J"z,0-.'5/-$5/$6"9'B*56$6&*>"4'E*5>"$62"-.*"4'%/-/&+"'7"5*+&$%/69zJ"7(*'3%(&+(,!4(5!Z14(('()!>.!;%$'+,/!4(5!;#4$+>"B'%J!V>""44JeOQMeJ"

KQ=$/6"7*$-05/69"S.5/+"^5'E6J"?@@PJ"E3++b+f"RS,J"

K$4+&'-->"3'6J"?@@PJ"D3%C(!0#!5')',41.!9%C!,9+!(+,!)+(+34,'%(!'-!$94()'()!/%03!C%315J"U*E"Z'5Ff"#&X5$EQ_/%%J"

Page 229: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

??P"

"

K*%*95$4.J"?@@VJ"z3$B/2"S$(*5'6"&'62*(6+"o&0%-05*"'7"B/'%*6&*ozJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ-*%*95$4.J&'J0FD6*E+D6*E+-'4/&+D4'%/-/&+D!NMN!!?D3$B/2QS$(*5'6Q&'62*(6+Q&0%-05*Q'7QB/'%*6&*J.-(%J",&&*++*2"?P-.")0%:"?@@PJ"

K.*"K/(*+J"?@@PJ"zU'5-.*56"A5*%$62".$+"o&0%-05*"'7"/6-'%*5$6&*ozJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ-/(*+'6%/6*J&'J0FD-'%D6*E+D0FD$5-/&%*eN?\!M!J*&*J",&&*++*2"?P-.")0%:"?@@PJ"

K./1$02>")*$6Q=$0%J"?@@OJ"zK.*"+'6/&"&'(4'+/-/'6"'7"-.*"&/-:z>"/6"#/&.$*%"^0%%"$62";*+"^$&F"*2+J"<9+!405',%3/!$01,03+!3+45+3J"TC7'52f"^*59>"44JO?PQO\!J"

K.'(+'6>"=$-J"?@@VJ">%'()!*'-041!3+-+43$9!C',9!$9'153+(!4(5!/%0()!#+%#1+J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*J"

K.'(+'6>"R$&.*%J"?@@PJ""(F%15'()!1'*+-.!/%0,92!)+(5+3!4(5!$94()+J"^5/+-'%f"='%/&:J"

K.'(+'6>"R$&.*%J"?@!@J"zK5$6+/-/'6+"-'"$20%-.''2z>"/6"d$:6*"K$:%'5>"R'2"<$5%*"$62"R/&.$52"_*+-*5"*2+J"`%0,9!a0-,'$+!94(5T%%=.!,9+%3/2!#%1'$/!4(5!#34$,'$+J"S0%%'(4-'6f"d/%%$6>"44J?OQOOJ"

K.5/7->"U/9*%J"!PPMJ"zK.*"+-/%%"4'/6-f"5*+/+-$6&*>"*C45*++/B*"*(1'2/(*6-"$62"2$6&*z>"/6"8-*B*"=/%*"$62"#/&.$*%"`*/-."*2+J"D+%)34#9'+-!%F!3+-'-,4($+J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*>"44J!?\Q!N!J"

K.051*5>"R$E+'6"#$5+.$%%"?@@\J">%5)+T411.![!,30+!0(5+35%)!-,%3/J"[8,f"KE*6-/*-."S*6-05:"]'C"]/%("S'54'5$-/'6J"

K/(*+>"K.*J"?@@VJ"z]$%%"/6"&5/(*"5$-*"2*7/*+"-.*"5/+*"'7"F6/7*"&0%-05*zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ-/(*+'6%/6*J&'J0FD-'%D6*E+D0FD&5/(*D$5-/&%*\O\Me\PJ*&*J",&&*++*2"O52"#$5&."?@!@J"

K/6/*"K*(4$.J"?@!@J"z`/%%"$%%"$o2*("75**+-:%*"r!OD?Vszf"Z'0K01*J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ:'0-01*J&'(DE$-&.iBÄ4NKX43SR(!<J",&&*++*2"!N-.",090+-"?@!?J""

K'6F/++>"]5$6J"?@@OJ"z,05$%"4'+-&$52+f"+'062"(*('5:"$62"-.*"&/-:z>"/6"#/&.$*%"^0%%"$62";*+"^$&F"*2+J"<9+!405',%3/!$01,03+!3+45+3J"TC7'52f"^*59>"44JO@OQO@PJ"

K'6F/++>"]5$6J"?@@eJ";#4$+2!,9+!$',/!4(5!-%$'41!,9+%3/.!-%$'41!3+14,'%(-!4(5!03T4(!F%3&-J"S$(15/29*f"='%/-:J"

K5':6$>"^$55:J"!PMPJ"z3/77*5*6-/$%"&'((/-(*6-"-'"*-.6/&"/2*6-/-:"1:"1%$&F":'0-.+"/6"^5/-$/6zJ"I+C!_%&&0(',/>"B'%JB//>"6'JO>"44J\@eg\?!J"

KE/6*>"]5$6&*"d/622$6&*"?@@eJ"zc/+0$%"*-.6'95$4.:"$62"5$&/$%"-.*'5:f"]$(/%:"4.'-'95$4.+"$+"$5&./B*+"'7"/6-*55$&/$%"/6-/($&/*+zJ"7,9('$!4(5!:4$'41!;,05'+->"B'%J?P>"6'JO>"44J\VMQN!!J"

[6/-*2"U$-/'6+J"!PP@J"zS'6B*6-/'6"'6"-.*"R/9.-+"'7"-.*"S./%2"zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEE?J'.&.5J'59D*69%/+.D%$ED&5&J.-(J",&&*++*2"O52"#$5&."?@@PJ"

[4&'(/69"#'B*(*6-J"?@!?J"z_'(*"-'E6"9%'5:zf"Z'0K01*DA&*]/%(+[`J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ:'0-01*J&'(DE$-&.iBÄ4axS)PK0'6EJ",&&*++*2"!e-.",090+-"?@!?J""

c$%*6-/6*>"X/%%J"?@@\J"Z0T1'$!-#4$+!4(5!,9+!$01,03+!%F!$9'159%%5J",%2*5+.'-f",+.9$-*J"

Page 230: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?O@"

"

c*$%*>",69*%$J"?@@NJ"zS5*$-/B*"(*-.'2'%'9/*+"/6"4$5-/&/4$-'5:"5*+*$5&."E/-."&./%25*6z>"/6"8.*/%$"X5**6*"$62"3/$6*"_'9$6"*2+J":+-+43$9'()!$9'153+(e-!+M#+3'+($+.!4##3%4$9+-!4(5!&+,9%5-J";'62'6f"8,X<>"44J?NOQ?M?J"

c*6F$-*+.>"802./5",%%$2/J"?@@@J"[&+3'$4(!#3%a+$,.!,9+!3'-+!4(5!F411!%F!4!&%5+3(!)9+,,%J"S$(15/29*>"#,f"_$5B$52"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

c*5-'B*&>"8-*B*6J"?@@OJ"z#/95$-/'6"$62"'-.*5"('2*+"'7"-5$6+6$-/'6$%/+(f"-'E$52+"&'6&*4-0$%"&5'++Q7*5-/%/a$-/'6zJ"L(,+3(4,'%(41!N')34,'%(!:+*'+C>"B'%JOM>"6'JO>"44Je\!QeeNJ"

c*5-'B*&>"8-*B*6J"?@@\J"z#/95$6-"-5$6+6$-/'6$%/+("$62"('2*+"'7"-5$6+7'5($-/'6zJ"L(,+3(4,'%(41!N')34,'%(!:+*'+C>"B'%JOV>"6'JO>"44JPM@Q!@@!J"

c*5-'B*&>"8-*B*6J"?@@eJ"zK.*"*(*59*6&*"'7"+04*5"2/B*5+/-:"/6"^5/-$/6z>",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ&'(4$+J'CJ$&J0FD401%/&$-/'6+D4$4*5+D8-*B*6�?@c*5-'B*&�?@d=@e?NJ427",&&*++*2"?P-."U'B*(1*5"?@@eJ"

c*5-'B*&>"8-*B*6J"?@@MJ"zU*E"&'(4%*C/-/*+"'7"&'.*+/'6"/6"^5/-$/6f"+04*5Q2/B*5+/-:>"-5$6+6$-/'6$%/+("$62"&/B/%Q/6-*95$-/'6zf"S'((06/-/*+"$62";'&$%"X'B*56(*6-J",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ&'(4$+J'CJ$&J0FD401%/&$-/'6+Dc*5-'B*&�?@SAS�?@6*E�?@&'(4%*C/-/*+J+.-(%J",&&*++*2"?!+-"T&-'1*5"?@@VJ""

c/+/'6"'7"^5/-$/6J"U'"2$-*J"zd*+-"_$("SJ^f"./+-'5/&$%"4'40%$-/'6"+-$-/+-/&+zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJB/+/'6'715/-$/6J'59J0FD2$-$}&01*}4$9*JH+4i2$-$}-.*(*ÄK}=T=k2$-$}&01*ÄU}KTK}=T=k0}/2Ä!@?\!OVVk&}/2Ä!@@@!@\Ok$22ÄUJ",&&*++*2"V-."#$5&."?@!!J"

c0%%6*-$5/>")0%/*J"?@@MJ"z,%1$6/$6"(/95$-/'6"$62"2*B*%'4(*6-f"+-$-*"'7"-.*"$5-"5*B/*Ez>"6'J!VJ",B$/%$1%*"75'(f"EEEJ2$5*J0B$J6%",&&*++*2"!+-")06*"?@!?J"

d$&h0$6->";'É&J"?@@?J"z8&50-/6/a/69"-.*"+-5**-f"4'B*5-:>"('5$%/-:>"$62"-.*"4/-7$%%+"'7"051$6"*-.6'95$4.:zJ"[&+3'$4(!]%03(41!%F!;%$'%1%)/>"B'%J!@M>"6'Je>"44J!\eVQ!NO?J"

d$&h0$6->";'É&J"?@@VJ"zK.*"(/%/-$5/a$-/'6"'7"051$6"($59/6$%/-:f"%*++'6+"75'("$"^5$a/%/$6"(*-5'4'%/+zJ"L(,+3(4,'%(41!Z%1','$41!;%$'%1%)/6'J?>"44JNeQM\J"

d$F*%/69>"=$0%J"?@@PJ"z,5*"*-.6/&"(/6'5/-/*+"062*55*45*+*6-*2"/6"[`"4'+-95$20$-*"+-02:izJ"B')9+3!750$4,'%(!l043,+31/>"B'%JeO>"6'J!>"44JVeQ!!!J"

d$5*>"c*5'6/&$J"?@@?J"zK.*"4$5$(*-*5+"'7"lE./-*"&5/-/h0*nz>"/6"3$B/2"K.*'"X'%21*59"$62")'.6"8'%'('+"*2+J"[!$%&#4('%(!,%!34$'41!4(5!+,9('$!-,05'+-J"TC7'52f"^%$&FE*%%>"44JC///>"e!@"4J"

d$5*>"c5'6J"?@@VJ"zK'E$52+"$62"+'&/'%'9:"'7"5*+*6-(*6-f"$"2*1$-*"'6"&%$++"$62"E./-*6*++z>"B'%J!O>"6'JNJ",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ+'&5*+'6%/6*J'59J0FD!ODNDPJ.-(%J",&&*++*2"?62"8*4-*(1*5"?@!?J"

d$-->"U/&.'%$+J"?@!@J"z^/6"+&.''%1':"*%*&-/'6"15'$2&$+-"$62"40-"^5''F*"`/6+*%%$"'6"/6+-*$2z>",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ90$52/$6J&'J0FD4'%/-/&+DE/6-'05Q$62QE$--D?@!@D$45D?MD2$B/2Q&$(*5'6Q15''FQF/6+*%%$J",&&*++*2"?M-.",45/%"?@!@J"

d*1+-*5>"S'%/6J"?@@eJ"zoR$&*o>":'0-."&5/(*"$62"H0+-/&*z>"/6"^$55:"X'%2+'6"$62")'.6"#06&/*"*2+J"`%0,92!$3'&+!4(5!a0-,'$+.!$3','$41!'--0+-J";'62'6f"8,X<>"44J!MQ?PJ"

Page 231: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?O!"

"

d*(:++>"X*'59/*J"?@@VJ"zd./-*"(*('5/*+>"E./-*"1*%'69/69f"&'(4*-/69"&'%'6/$%"$66/B*5+$5/*+"/6"o4'+-&'%'6/$%o"<$+-";'62'6z>"B'%J!O>"6'JNJ",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ+'&5*+'6%/6*J'59J0FD!ODNDVJ.-(%J",&&*++*2"\-.",45/%"?@!?J"

d*(:++>"X*'59/*J"?@@PJ"<9+!'(*'-'T1+!+&#'3+.!C9',+!5'-$%03-+2!,%1+34($+!4(5!T+1%()'()J"]$56.$(f",+.9$-*J"

d*+->"S'56*%J"!PP\J":4$+!&4,,+3-J"U*E"Z'5Ff"]/5+-"c/6-$9*"^''F+J"

d./-*>"_$:2*6"cJ"!PMOJ"N+,49'-,%3/.!,9+!9'-,%3'$41!'&4)'(4,'%(!'(!('(+,++(,9g$+(,03/!703%#+J"^$%-/('5*f")'.6+"_'4F/6+"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

d.:-*>"d/%%/$("]''-*J"!P\OJ";,3++,!$%3(+3!-%$'+,/.!,9+!-%$'41!-,30$,03+!%F!4(!L,41'4(!-10&J"S./&$9'f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"S./&$9'"=5*++J"

d/%*:J"?@!@"r?@@!Q?@@esJ"<9+!&4,3'M!'(-,30&+(,41f",B$%$6&.*"#0+/&J"

d/%%/$(+>"R$:('62J"!PMOJ"<9+!$%0(,3/!4(5!,9+!$',/J";'62'6f"_'9$5-.J"

d/%%/$(+>"R$:('62J"?@@?"r!PNVsJ"zS0%-05*"/+"'52/6$5:z>"/6"^*6"_/9.('5*"*2J"<9+!+*+3/54/!1'F+!3+45+3J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*>"44JP!Q!@@J"

d/%%/+>"=$0%"<J"!PMMJ"8+43('()!,%!14T%03.!9%C!C%3='()!$14--!='5-!)+,!C%3='()!$14--!a%T-J"]$561'5'09.>"_$6-+Jf"8$C'6"_'0+*J"

d/%%/+>"=$0%"<J"?@@!J"<9+!+,9(%)34#9'$!'&4)'(4,'%(J"#$%2*6>"#$++Jf"='%/-:"=5*++J"

d/%%/+>"=$0%"$62"#$-+"K5'62($6J"?@@?J"z#$6/7*+-'"7'5"<-.6'95$4.:zJ"_01,0341!;,05'+->"B'%J?>"6'JO>"44JOP\Q\@?J"

d/%%('-->"=*-*5J"!PeOJ"<9+!+*%10,'%(!%F!4!$%&&0(',/.!4!-,05/!%F!>4)+(94&!4F,+3!F%3,/!/+43-J";'62'6f"R'0-%*29*"k"`*9$6"=$0%J"

d/%%('-->"=*-*5J"!PePJ"[5%1+-$+(,!T%/-!%F!+4-,!8%(5%(J"_$5('62+E'5-.f"=*690/6J"

d/%(*5>"c$%J"?@!?J"z,6'-.*5"-/(*>"$6'-.*5"4%$&*zJ"^'3+>"B'%JO\?>""44J?PQO!J"

d''25'E>"#$99/*>"*-"$%J"?@@?J";%$'41!$14--!4(5!#43,'$'#4,'%(.!)%%5!#34$,'$+!'(!C'5+('()!4$$+--!,%!9')9+3!+50$4,'%(m!,9+!F%11%C0#!3+#%3,!,%!eE3%&!+1','-&!,%!'($10-'%(ef"<05'4*$6",&&*++"U*-E'5FJ"

d'51':*+>"8$%%:J"?@@MJ"74-,!7(5!)'31.!)3%C'()!0#!,9+!9435!C4/J";'62'6f"_'22*5J"

d5$:>"#$--J"?@@eJ"I%,!c0',+!C9',+.!C9',+!,34-9!4(5!,9+!T%0(543'+-!%F!C9',+(+--J"305.$(f"30F*"[6/B*5+/-:"=5*++J"

d5/9.->"R/&.$52J"!Pe\J"^9',+!&4(2!1'-,+(f"X$52*6"S/-:f"3'01%*2$:"k"S'J"

Z$55'E>"`/-"$62")$:6*"To3'66*%%J"?@@PJ"D+(!T0`.!9%C!,C++(-2!,++(-2!4(5!,C+(,/g-%&+,9'()-!43+!3+*%10,'%('b'()!3+,4'1J"8$6"]5$6&/+&'f")'++*:Q^$++J"

Page 232: Malcolm James - PhD Thesis - Upcoming movements FINAL ...etheses.lse.ac.uk/550/1/James_Upcoming movements (public...M" " _'E":'0-."E'5F*5+"-5$&*2"E./-*6*++"$62"%'++"JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"eM!

?O?"

"

Z$+a*F>";/+$J"?@@eJ"z,75'70-05/+("+&/*6&*"7/&-/'6"$62"-.*"./+-'5:"'7"-.*"70-05*z>"B'%J?@>"6'JOJ",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDD+2'6%/6*J'59D\?D$75'70-05/+(Q+&/*6&*Q7/&-/'6Q$62Q-.*Q./+-'5:Q'7Q-.*Q70-05*J",&&*++*2"O@-.")$60$5:"?@!?J"

Z'069>"#/&.$*%"306%'4"$62"=*-*5"d/%%('--J"!PNMJ"E4&'1/!4(5!='(-9'#!'(!74-,!8%(5%(J"^*5F*%*:f"[6/B*5+/-:"'7"S$%/7'56/$"=5*++J"

Z'069>"K'1:J"?@@NJ"zK.*"E'52"'6"-.*"+-5**-"/+"4*'4%*"45*7*5"4'+."z>",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ6'+$&5*2&'E+J&'J0FD($/%}'6}+062$:}&'%0(6D\?MD-.*}E'52}'6}-.*}+-5**-}/+}4*'4%*}45*7*5}4'+.J.-(%J",&&*++*2"O!+-")0%:"?@!?J"

Z'069*>"X$5:J"?@!!J"zK.*"(0%-/&0%-05$%/+("-.*"<05'4*$6"5/9.-"7*$5+"+'"(0&."/+"$"7/&-/'6"g"/-"6*B*5"*C/+-*2zJ"",B$/%$1%*"75'(f".--4fDDEEEJ90$52/$6J&'J0FD&'((*6-/+75**D?@!!D($5D!\D(0%-/&0%-05$%/+(Q7*$5+Q7/&-/'6Q*05'4*Q+-$-*J",&&*++*2"?V-.",45/%"?@!!J"

Z0B$%Q3$B/+>"U/5$J"?@@eJ"zA6-*5+*&-/'6$%/-:"$62"7*(/6/+-"4'%/-/&+zJ"703%#+4(!]%03(41!%F!^%&+(e-!;,05'+->"B'%J!O>"6'JO>"44J!POQ?@PJ"

Z0B$%Q3$B/+>"U/5$J"?@!?J"z,6"$0-'&.-.'6/&"+&*6-"'7"(*('5:izJ"E+&'('-,!:+*'+C6'J!@@>"44J!N\Q!e@J"

Z0B$%Q3$B/+>"U/5$>"*-"$%J"!PVPJ"^%&4(!g!(4,'%(!g!-,4,+J"^$+/69+-'F*f"#$&(/%%$6J"

x01*5/>"U$1**%J"?@!@J"zd'55/*+"/6"-.*"2$6&*f"4'+-Q(/%%*66/$%"95''B*+"$62"+01Q1$++"&0%-05*z>"/6",62:"^*66*--"$62")'6"8-5$--'6"*2+J"G3',#%#!4(5!,9+!7()1'-9!&0-'$!,345','%(J"]$56.$(f",+.9$-*>"44J!MPQ!P?J"""


Recommended