UN Economic And Social Commission For Western Asia
WSTA, 11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
MANAGED AQUIFER RECHARGE – AQUIFER STORAGE AND RECOVERY: REGIONAL EXPERIENCES AND NEEDS FOR FURTHER COOPERATION AND KNOWLEDGE EXCHANGES IN THE ARAB REGIONRalf Klingbeil, Regional Advisor Environment and Water
Page 2
Outline
• Managed Aquifer Recharge / Aquifer Storage and Recovery:• Why?• How?
• Examples from the Arab Region• Conclusions and Recommendations
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
Page 3
Managed Aquifer Recharge – Aquifer Storage and Recovery
Reasons forManaged Aquifer Recharge
• Strategic water reserve for emergency situations• Short-term or seasonal peak demands• Reducing runoff losses• Preparation for drought periods / dry years• Vulnerability of desalination to pollution / algae• Constant desalination production vs. variable demands• Recharging / improving brackish groundwater• Preventing / reversing saltwater intrusion /
controlling salinity upconing• Injection / infiltration of excess rain / flood waters• Intermediate storage of Treated Sewage Effluent (TSE)
- mainly for agriculture or industrial uses• Avoiding potential evaporation losses from dams
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
Page 4
Managed Aquifer Recharge – Aquifer Storage and Recovery
Another Attempt for a Definition
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
Human enhanced and managed groundwater recharge
[with the purpose of later abstraction or use either as a fresh groundwater resource or as hydraulic barrier against other threats such as seawater or
saline water intrusion].
Page 5
Managed Aquifer Recharge – Aquifer Storage and Recovery
Using the Groundwater Buffer Wisely: Overview
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
UN
ESC
O, 2
005.
Page 6
Managed Aquifer Recharge – Aquifer Storage and Recovery
What falls underManaged Aquifer Recharge?
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
Inte
rnat
iona
l Gro
undw
ater
Res
ourc
es A
sses
smen
t Cen
tre,
2007
, ww
w.un
-igra
c.or
g
Technology
AS(TR)
ASR
Spreading methods
infiltration ponds & basins
flooding
ditch, furrow, drains
irrigation
sand dams
channel spreading
Induced bank infiltration
Well, shaft and borehole recharge
deep well injection
shallow well/ shaft/ pit infiltration
Sub type
Runoff harvestingbarriers and bunds
trenches
Tech
niqu
es re
ferr
ing
prim
arily
to
getti
ng w
ater
infil
trat
ed
Tech
niqu
es re
ferr
ing
prim
arily
to in
terc
eptin
g th
e w
ater In-channel modifications
recharge dams
sub surface dams
Page 7
Managed Aquifer Recharge – Aquifer Storage and Recovery
What includesManaged Aquifer Recharge?
• Aquifer Storage Recovery (ASR):“well/borehole is used for both injection and recovery, costs are minimised and clogging is removed during the recovery cycle.”
• Aquifer Storage Transfer and Recovery (ASTR):“Water can be injected into a borehole and recovered from another, some distance away, to increase travel time and benefit from water treatment capacity of the aquifer”
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
UN
ESC
O, 2
005.
Page 8
Managed Aquifer Recharge – Aquifer Storage and Recovery
Challenges:Technological, Scientific
• Groundwater level rise:• risk of flooding, esp. in case of unconfined aquifers
• Hydrochemical mixing:• risk of precipitation causing clogging of
well screens or aquifer pore space • risk of mineral dissolution causing mobilization of
harmful substances or development of cavities• System efficiencies:
• injected vs. recovered volumes• Health risks:
• potential risks to human health when injecting / infiltrating treated sewage effluent, mobilizing minerals from the aquifer matrix
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
Page 9
Managed Aquifer Recharge – Aquifer Storage and Recovery
Challenges:Socio-Economic Viability
• Investigation of economic alternatives:• cost of surface vs. groundwater storage• direct use of TSE vs. intermediate storage• infrastructure, access to injection / recovery sites• compromise between deep groundwater table to prevent flooding
and shallow to reduce energy costs for pumping• alternative feasibility studies• environmental costs – environmental impact assessments
• System efficiencies:• injected vs. recovered volumes
• Social acceptance:• health and environmental risk analysis• awareness raising campaigns
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
Page 10
Managed Aquifer Recharge – Aquifer Storage and Recovery
Challenges:Governance, Regulations
• Are all necessary laws, regulations and guidelines in place and officially approved to ensure prevention of negative impacts on the groundwater, ecosystems, water users, the people?
• Accountable and transparent decision making… and tendering processes?
• Do we have mechanisms in place to allow for participation and constructive criticism?
• International / national advisory bodies with multi-sectoralexperiences?
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
Page 11
Managed Aquifer Recharge – Aquifer Storage and Recovery
Examples from the Region
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
ww
w.es
cwa.
un.o
rg
Page 12
Bahrain
Isa Town: Storm Water Runoff
• Unique gravity-fed aquifer recharge system:• Gulleys, catch pits, delivery pipes, oil
trap, filter chamber, and recharge well• Direct urban storm water flows from
suitable low points to targeted Khobaraquifer
• Estimated 1,389 m3 recharged• Water level rise 0.6 m• Reduced salinity• Necessity for monitoring potentially
harmful substances (esp. nickel, zinc, copper)
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
Al-N
oaim
i, 20
10
Page 13
Bahrain
Potential Larger Scale ASR / ASTR
• 1986: TSE recharge to Khobar aquifer• 2010: Dammam aquifer regional study• 2010: Feasibility of GW recharge with TSE• 2011: National approach to assessing
reuse of TSE and MAR• Future TSE production:
• 2015: 390,000 m3/day• 2030: 500,000 m3/day
• Alternative uses:• More direct TSE reuse in agriculture• Potential target aquifers: Alat (A) and
Khobar (B), both Dammam formations• Expected total volume of TSE to be
stored: 24 MCM
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
Al-M
anna
i, 20
10, M
oW, 2
011
Page 14
Jordan
MAR: Infiltration of Floodwater
• 2012: Cooperation JOR – GER• Guideline for assessment and implementation
of MAR in (semi-) arid regions• Pre-feasibility study for infiltration of floodwater
• MAR potential map for water availability &site suitability for two surface water basins
• Limitations:• Source water availability in regions
with rainfall of less than 200 mm/a• High sediment load of runoff waters
• Operation and maintenance• Monitoring• Assess actual effectiveness• Involvement of local communities
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
Stei
nel /
BG
R, 2
012
Page 15
Kuwait
Dammam, Kuwait Group
• 1964: Raudhatain, passive infiltration in depression• 1972-1973: Raudhatain, injection of desalinated water• 1992: Sulaibiya, injection in Dammam limestone and
Kuwait Group• 200,000 m3 injected desalinated water in two wells
(18,000 and 180,000) over 30 days• Dammam: Injection possible, system efficiency
initially estimated as rel. low (10-20%)• Kuwait Group: severe clogging of the injection well,
due to suspended solids and dissolved air• 1994: Physical properties of Dammam formation in contact
with fresh water • 1997: Compatibility of desalinated water with Dammam
formation aquifer at pilot recharge site
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
Abde
l-Jaw
ad /
KISR
, 200
8; D
awou
d / E
AD, 2
005;
M
ukho
padh
yay
/ KIS
R, 2
010
and
2013
Page 16
Kuwait
Dammam, Kuwait Group
• 2002: Numerical modeling of artificial recharge options for Dammamformation at pilot recharge site
• 2004: Laboratory investigation compatibility of desalinated water, RO-treated wastewater with the Kuwait Group aquifer
• 2010: Selection of suitable sites for artificial recharge• Kuwait Group: Mutla, Sulaibiya,
Raudhatain areas• Dammam Formation: Kabd area
• 2013: Start of KISR pilot project in Kabd, injecting RO-treated wastewater
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
Abde
l-Jaw
ad /
KISR
, 200
8; D
awou
d / E
AD, 2
005;
Muk
hopa
dhya
y / K
ISR
, 201
0 an
d 20
13
Page 17
Lebanon
ARAK: Aquifer RechargeabilityAssessment in Karst
• Determine ability of karst aquifer to be artificially recharged & managed
• Best sites for implementing artificial recharge from surface
• Multi-criteria indexation analysis modeled on karst vulnerability assessment methods
• Four independent criteria, i.e. Epikarst, Rock, Infiltration and Karst
• Rechargeability index - product of two factors, intrinsic rechargeabilityand feasibility index
• Damour site: salinization and insufficiency of resource
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
Dah
er, 2
011.
Page 18
Oman
Groundwater Recharge Dams
• > 30 groundwater recharge dams, intercepting wadi runoff, allowing for controlled recharge downstream of dam
• Managed to hold about 1064 MCM of flood waters until end of 2009
• Substantial experiences in siting and dimensioning of groundwater recharge dams
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
Page 19
Oman
TSE Reuse and MAR, Salalah
• Salalah Sanitary Drainage Services Co.: SSDS• Ownership, management, O&M of current network for
groundwater recharge and future expansions• No legislation in Oman yet on TSE reuse for aquifer recharge• Average quantity of treated water
• to recharge wells: 18,090 m3
• to SSDS clients/consumers: 2,680 m3
• 48 recharge wells
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
AlQ
asm
i, 20
11; S
ham
mas
, 200
7; W
ahai
bi, 2
011.
Groundwater Levels
Page 20
Qatar
Northern Groundwater Basin, ASR
• 1976: “Artificial recharge with desalted sea water to permit additional agricultural development appears technically feasible but its practicability needs to be examined further.” (Vecchioli)
• 1992-1994: Feasibility study for injection of desalinated water in Rus and Umm er-Radhuma with positive results
• 2012: QNFSP/KAHRAMAA: Northern groundwater basin, investigation of four sites to store 136 MCM for emergency (interruption of desalination)
• Tertiary WW Treatment imperative for utilities, i.e. TSE available for non-potable applications such as agricultural irrigation possibly with intermediate aquifer storage
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
Daw
oud
/ EAD
, 200
9; M
EED
, 201
2; S
treet
ly, 1
998;
Ve
cchi
oli /
USG
S, 1
976.
Page 21
• Hydraulic barrier against seawater intrusion• Treated WW better suited for irrigation
due to reduced need for fertilizers• Ongoing: improvement to tertiary WW treatment
Salinity of groundwaterprior to recharge
Groundwater Simulation
Salinity of groundwaterafter 3 years of recharge
Tunisia
KorbaAquifer Recharge
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
Che
rif, S
. et a
l., 2
013,
Gaa
loul
, N.,
2014
.
Page 22
United Arab Emirates - Sharjah
Nizwa:1st Operational ASR
• To replace seasonal peak load capacity• 2001-2002 feasibility study• 2003-2004 pilot project• Site characterization and evaluation,
geophysics, trial boreholes, monitoring• Hydrochemical modeling:
Mixing of injected RO product (250 µS/cm) and native groundwater
• Cycles of injection - storage - recovery• System efficiency: 95% recovery (4th)
24,700 m3 / 26 days injection, 30 days storage, 23,400 m3 / 19 days recovery
• Cost efficiency 10% of surface storage• Planned for 1.8 MCMWater Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
Laba
ky, W
. / S
WS,
201
3; S
EWA,
200
9.
Page 23
United Arab Emirates – Abu Dhabi
Liwa: Strategic Water Storage and Recovery Project (SWSR)
• 2003-2005: Feasibility study• 2006-2009: Pilot project• 2010-2013: Construction• Planned for 23 MCM of surplus
desalinated seawater• Emergency water supply for Abu Dhabi
up to three months at 181,800 m3/d• Extensive site characterisation,
shallow aquifer system, semi-consolidated Aeolian dune sands
• When completed: Benchmark for water management in arid regions
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
Kozi
orow
ski,
2012
; W
olke
, 201
1.
Page 24
Managed Aquifer Recharge – Aquifer Storage and Recovery
Conclusions and Recommendations
1. Technical and scientific issues:• investing into hydrogeological science, research,• open dialogues between scientists from different disciplines,
2. Socio-economic issues:• cost-benefit analysis, assessment of alternative scenarios,• optimize complex multi-faceted challenges,• interaction b/w economists, engineers, social and natural scientists,
3. Legislative and regulatory issues:• understanding legal frameworks, regulatory approaches and needs,
4. Regional knowledge exchanges:• dedicated MAR / ASR research conferences, • joint research programmes,• technical exchange visits,
5. Mutli-sectoral advice to government authorities:• adequate technical, scientific and socio-economic support,• advisory bodies with senior experts from different disciplines.
Water Science and Technology Association (WSTA) ,11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
UN Economic And Social Commission For Western Asia
WSTA 11th Gulf Water Conference, Muscat, Oman, 20-22 Oct 2014
MANAGED AQUIFER RECHARGE – AQUIFER STORAGE AND RECOVERY: REGIONAL EXPERIENCES AND NEEDS FOR FURTHER COOPERATION AND KNOWLEDGE EXCHANGES IN THE ARAB REGIONRalf Klingbeil, Regional Advisor Environment and Water