+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA...

Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA...

Date post: 16-Jan-2016
Category:
Upload: philip-chandler
View: 216 times
Download: 1 times
Share this document with a friend
Popular Tags:
60
Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA USA http://www.duke.edu/ ~charvey Boston College June 11, 2004
Transcript
Page 1: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation

Campbell R. HarveyDuke University, Durham, NC USA

National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA USA

http://www.duke.edu/~charvey

Boston College June 11, 2004

Page 2: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 2

1. Objectives

• Framework• The importance of higher moments• Rethinking risk• Characteristics of hedge fund returns• Rethinking optimization• Skewness and expected returns• Implementation• Conclusions

Page 3: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 3

2. Framework

Markowitz (1952)

Stage 1:

• “...starts with observation and experience and ends with beliefs about the future performances of available securities”

Page 4: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 4

2. Framework

Markowitz (1952)Stage 2:• “...starts with relevant beliefs and ends with

the selection of a portfolio”

• Markowitz only dealt with Stage 2 in context of the famous mean-variance framework

Page 5: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 5

2. Framework

Markowitz (1952)

Important caveat, p.90-91:

• If preferences depend on mean and variance, an investor “will never accept an actuarially fair bet.”

Page 6: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 6

2. Framework

Markowitz (1952)

Important caveat, p.90-91:

• If preferences also depend skewness, an investor “then there some fair bets which would be accepted.”

Page 7: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 7

3. Motivation

50 years later, we have learned:

• Investors have an obvious preference for skewness

• Returns (or log returns) are non-normal

Page 8: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 8

3. Motivation

Source: Shadwick and Keating (2003)

Page 9: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 9

3. Motivation

Preferences:

1. The $1 lottery ticket. The expected value is $0.45 (hence a -55%) expected return.– Why is price so high? – Lottery delivers positive skew, people like

positive skew and are willing to pay a premium

Page 10: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 10

3. Motivation

Preferences:

2. High implied vol in out of the money OEX put options.– Why is price so high? – Option limits downside (reduces negative

skew).– Investors are willing to pay a premium for

assets that reduce negative skew

Page 11: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 11

3. Motivation

Preferences:2. High implied vol in out of the money S&P index

put options.– This example is particularly interesting because the

volatility skew is found for the index and for some large capitalization stocks that track the index – not in every option

– That is, one can diversify a portfolio of individual stocks – but the market index is harder to hedge.

– Hint of systematic risk

Page 12: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 12

3. Motivation

Preferences:

3. Some stocks that trade with seemingly “too high” P/E multiples– Why is price so high?

– Enormous upside potential (some of which is not well understood)

– Investors are willing to pay a premium for assets that produce positive skew

– [Note: Expected returns could be small or negative!]

Page 13: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 13

3. Motivation

Preferences:

3. Some stocks that trade with seemingly “too high” P/E multiples– Hence, traditional beta may not be that

meaningful. Indeed, the traditional beta may be high and the expected return low if higher moments are important

Page 14: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 14

3. Motivation

Returns:

• Crisis events such as August 1998

• Scholes (AER 2000, p.19) notes:– “This 20-basis point change was a move of 10

standard deviations in the swap spread.”

Page 15: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 15

3. Motivation

Returns:

• 10 standard deviation move has a probability of 10-24 -- under a normal distribution

Page 16: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 16

3. Motivation

Returns:

• 10 standard deviation move has a probability of 10-24 -- under a normal distribution

• Roughly the probability of winning the Powerball Lottery ...

Page 17: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 17

3. Motivation

Returns:• 10 standard deviation move has a

probability of 10-24 -- under a normal distribution

• Roughly the probability of winning the Powerball Lottery ... 3 consecutive times!

– (See Routledge and Zin (2003))

Page 18: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 18

3. Motivation

Returns:

• The most unlikely arena to see normally distributed returns is the hedge fund industry

• Use of derivatives, derivative replicating strategies, and leverage make the returns non-normal

Page 19: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 19

3. Motivation

Returns:

• Consider an excerpt from a presentation of one of the largest endowments in the U.S. from March 2004

Page 20: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 20

The Evolution of Large Endowment Asset Mixes

% of Total Portfolio

1988 1991 1994 1997 2000 2003 US Equity 45.6 45.9 40.1 39.4 32.4 24.8 Non-US Equity 3.1 6.0 13.5 14.8 13.5 13.6 Hedge Funds .7 2.0 6.4 8.8 11.7 24.0 Non-Marketable 3.8 5.3 6.2 7.1 18.7 12.6 Bonds 33.0 32.0 25.5 20.2 16.6 17.2 Real Estate 2.9 3.2 3.3 5.4 4.7 6.2

Page 21: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 21

Asset Mix-Large Endowments Versus the Average FundJune 2003

% of Portfolio

Large Average Endowments Endowment

US Equity 24.8 49.0 Non-US Equity 13.6 8.2 Hedge Funds 24.0 6.1 Non-Marketable 12.6 4.1 Bonds 17.2 25.8 Real Estate 6.2 2.8 Cash 1.6 4.0

“Traditional” 43.6 78.8 (US stocks, bonds, cash)

Page 22: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 22

Selected Endowment Asset MixesJune 2003

% of EndowmentHarvard Yale Virginia

US Equity 18.4 15.1 6.2 Non-US Equity 19.6 14.8 5.8 Hedge Funds 54.7 Private Equity 8.6 15.2 13.1 Equity and Related 46.6 45.1 79.8 Real Estate 5.1 13.1 2.8 Natural Resources 5.8 6.9 2.8 Commodities 3.8 TIPS 6.7 7.7 Inflation hedges 21.4 20.0 13.3 Absolute Return12.2 25.2 6.3 Bonds 24.7 7.5 0 Cash -4.9 2.2 .6 Total Fixed 19.8 9.7 .6

Page 23: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 23

Endowment Returns by Size of FundPeriods ending 6/30/2003

1 year 3 years 5 years 10 years > $1 billion 4.1 -.7 6.9 11.5 $501mm to $1b 2.9 -2.3 3.9 9.3 $101mm to $500mm 2.7 -2.4 3.1 8.8 $51mm to $100mm 2.7 -2.8 2.1 8.1 $26mm to $50mm 3.1 -2.3 2.4 8.1 Less than $25mm 3.5 -2.3 2.2 7.2

Page 24: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 24

3. Motivation

Manager explained the following fact:

• “If I use the same expected returns as in 1994 and add the hedge fund asset class, the optimized portfolio mix tilts to hedge funds. The Sharpe Ratio of my portfolio goes up.”

Page 25: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 25

3. Motivation

Manager’s “optimization” based on traditional Markowitz mean and variance.

• Does this make sense?

Page 26: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 26

3. Motivation

-4-3-2-101234567

1 2 3 4 5

S&P Quintiles

S&P 500Global Macro

Source: Naik (2003)

Page 27: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 27

3. Motivation

-8

-6

-4

-2

0

2

4

6

8

1 2 3 4 5

S&P Quintiles

S&P 500Trend Followers

Source: Naik (2003)

Page 28: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 28

3. Motivation

-2

-1.5

-1

-0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

1 2 3 4 5

Credit spread quintiles

Delta(BAA-10yTBond)x10FI Arb

Source: Naik (2003)

Page 29: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 29

3. Motivation

Event Driven Index: Exposure to Russell 3000 Index (Period: Jan '90 to Dec '91)

-8

-6

-4

-2

0

2

4

6

-15 -10 -5 0 5 10

Russell 3000 Index Returns

Eve

nt D

riven

Inde

x R

etur

ns

LOWESS fit

Source: Naik (2003)

Page 30: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 30

4. Rethinking Risk

• Much interest in downside risk, asymmetric volatility, semi-variance, extreme value analysis, regime-switching, jump processes, ...

Page 31: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 31

4. Rethinking Risk

• …all related to skewness

• Harvey and Siddique, “Conditional Skewness in Asset Pricing Tests” Journal of Finance 2000.

Page 32: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 32

0.0%

0.2%

0.4%

0.6%

0.8%

1.0%

1.2%

1.4%

S&P500

Convert

ible

Arb

Distre

ssed

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Total

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Glo

bal

Equity H

edge

Equity M

arke

t Neu

tral

Mar

ket Neu

tral :

Stat

Arb

itrag

e

Equity N

on-H

edge

Event-D

riven

Fixed

Inco

me: Total

Fixed

Inco

me: Arb

itrag

e

Fixed

Inco

me: Con

verti

ble B

onds

Fixed

Inco

me: Dive

rsifie

d

Fixed

Inco

me: High

Yiel

d

Fixed

Inco

me: M

ortgag

e-Bac

ked

Mac

ro

Mer

ger Arb

itrag

e

Relativ

e Valu

e Arb

itrag

e

Fund W

eigted

Compos

ite

Average Returns: January 1995-April 2004

Source: HFR

Page 33: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 33

0.0%

0.5%

1.0%

1.5%

2.0%

2.5%

3.0%

3.5%

4.0%

4.5%

5.0%

S&P500

Convert

ible

Arb

Distre

ssed

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Total

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Glo

bal

Equity H

edge

Equity M

arke

t Neu

tral

Mar

ket Neu

tral :

Stat

Arb

itrag

e

Equity N

on-H

edge

Event-D

riven

Fixed

Inco

me: Total

Fixed

Inco

me: Arb

itrag

e

Fixed

Inco

me: Con

verti

ble B

onds

Fixed

Inco

me: Dive

rsifie

d

Fixed

Inco

me: High

Yiel

d

Fixed

Inco

me: M

ortgag

e-Bac

ked

Mac

ro

Mer

ger Arb

itrag

e

Relativ

e Valu

e Arb

itrag

e

Fund W

eigted

Compos

ite

Volatility: January 1995-April 2004

Source: HFR

Page 34: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 34

-5.0

-4.0

-3.0

-2.0

-1.0

0.0

1.0

S&P500

Convert

ible

Arb

Distre

ssed

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Total

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Glo

bal

Equity H

edge

Equity M

arke

t Neu

tral

Mar

ket Neu

tral :

Stat

Arb

itrag

e

Equity N

on-H

edge

Event-D

riven

Fixed

Inco

me: Total

Fixed

Inco

me: Arb

itrag

e

Fixed

Inco

me: Con

verti

ble B

onds

Fixed

Inco

me: Dive

rsifie

d

Fixed

Inco

me: High

Yiel

d

Fixed

Inco

me: M

ortgag

e-Bac

ked

Mac

ro

Mer

ger Arb

itrag

e

Relativ

e Valu

e Arb

itrag

e

Fund W

eigted

Compos

ite

Skewness: January 1995-April 2004

Source: HFR

Page 35: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 35

0.0

5.0

10.0

15.0

20.0

25.0

30.0

S&P500

Convert

ible

Arb

Distre

ssed

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Total

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Glo

bal

Equity H

edge

Equity M

arke

t Neu

tral

Mar

ket Neu

tral :

Stat

Arb

itrag

e

Equity N

on-H

edge

Event-D

riven

Fixed

Inco

me: Total

Fixed

Inco

me: Arb

itrag

e

Fixed

Inco

me: Con

verti

ble B

onds

Fixed

Inco

me: Dive

rsifie

d

Fixed

Inco

me: High

Yiel

d

Fixed

Inco

me: M

ortgag

e-Bac

ked

Mac

ro

Mer

ger Arb

itrag

e

Relativ

e Valu

e Arb

itrag

e

Fund W

eigted

Compos

ite

Kurtosis: January 1995-April 2004

Source: HFR

Page 36: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 36

-0.030

-0.025

-0.020

-0.015

-0.010

-0.005

0.000

S&P500

Convert

ible

Arb

Distre

ssed

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Total

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Glo

bal

Equity H

edge

Equity M

arke

t Neu

tral

Mar

ket Neu

tral :

Stat

Arb

itrag

e

Equity N

on-H

edge

Event-D

riven

Fixed

Inco

me: Total

Fixed

Inco

me: Arb

itrag

e

Fixed

Inco

me: Con

verti

ble B

onds

Fixed

Inco

me: Dive

rsifie

d

Fixed

Inco

me: High

Yiel

d

Fixed

Inco

me: M

ortgag

e-Bac

ked

Mac

ro

Mer

ger Arb

itrag

e

Relativ

e Valu

e Arb

itrag

e

Fund W

eigted

Compos

ite

Coskewness: January 1995-April 2004

Source: HFR

Page 37: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 37

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2.0

S&P500

Convert

ible

Arb

Distre

ssed

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Total

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Glo

bal

Equity H

edge

Equity M

arke

t Neu

tral

Mar

ket Neu

tral :

Stat

Arb

itrag

e

Equity N

on-H

edge

Event-D

riven

Fixed

Inco

me: Total

Fixed

Inco

me: Arb

itrag

e

Fixed

Inco

me: Con

verti

ble B

onds

Fixed

Inco

me: Dive

rsifie

d

Fixed

Inco

me: High

Yiel

d

Fixed

Inco

me: M

ortgag

e-Bac

ked

Mac

ro

Mer

ger Arb

itrag

e

Relativ

e Valu

e Arb

itrag

e

Fund W

eigted

Compos

ite

Beta market: January 1995-April 2004

Source: HFR

Page 38: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 38

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2.0

S&P500

Convert

ible

Arb

Distre

ssed

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Total

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Glo

bal

Equity H

edge

Equity M

arke

t Neu

tral

Mar

ket Neu

tral :

Stat

Arb

itrag

e

Equity N

on-H

edge

Event-D

riven

Fixed

Inco

me: Total

Fixed

Inco

me: Arb

itrag

e

Fixed

Inco

me: Con

verti

ble B

onds

Fixed

Inco

me: Dive

rsifie

d

Fixed

Inco

me: High

Yiel

d

Fixed

Inco

me: M

ortgag

e-Bac

ked

Mac

ro

Mer

ger Arb

itrag

e

Relativ

e Valu

e Arb

itrag

e

Fund W

eigted

Compos

ite

Beta market (August 1998): January 1995-April 2004

Source: HFR

Page 39: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 39

-2.0

-1.0

0.0

1.0

2.0

3.0

4.0

S&P500

Convert

ible

Arb

Distre

ssed

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Total

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Glo

bal

Equity H

edge

Equity M

arke

t Neu

tral

Mar

ket Neu

tral :

Stat

Arb

itrag

e

Equity N

on-H

edge

Event-D

riven

Fixed

Inco

me: Total

Fixed

Inco

me: Arb

itrag

e

Fixed

Inco

me: Con

verti

ble B

onds

Fixed

Inco

me: Dive

rsifie

d

Fixed

Inco

me: High

Yiel

d

Fixed

Inco

me: M

ortgag

e-Bac

ked

Mac

ro

Mer

ger Arb

itrag

e

Relativ

e Valu

e Arb

itrag

e

Fund W

eigted

Compos

ite

Beta chg. 10-yr: January 1995-April 2004

Source: HFR

Page 40: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 40

-1.5

-1.0

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

S&P500

Convert

ible

Arb

Distre

ssed

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Total

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Glo

bal

Equity H

edge

Equity M

arke

t Neu

tral

Mar

ket Neu

tral :

Stat

Arb

itrag

e

Equity N

on-H

edge

Event-D

riven

Fixed

Inco

me: Total

Fixed

Inco

me: Arb

itrag

e

Fixed

Inco

me: Con

verti

ble B

onds

Fixed

Inco

me: Dive

rsifie

d

Fixed

Inco

me: High

Yiel

d

Fixed

Inco

me: M

ortgag

e-Bac

ked

Mac

ro

Mer

ger Arb

itrag

e

Relativ

e Valu

e Arb

itrag

e

Fund W

eigted

Compos

ite

Beta chg. slope: January 1995-April 2004

Source: HFR

Page 41: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 41

-12.0

-10.0

-8.0

-6.0

-4.0

-2.0

0.0

2.0

S&P500

Convert

ible

Arb

Distre

ssed

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Total

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Glo

bal

Equity H

edge

Equity M

arke

t Neu

tral

Mar

ket Neu

tral :

Stat

Arb

itrag

e

Equity N

on-H

edge

Event-D

riven

Fixed

Inco

me: Total

Fixed

Inco

me: Arb

itrag

e

Fixed

Inco

me: Con

verti

ble B

onds

Fixed

Inco

me: Dive

rsifie

d

Fixed

Inco

me: High

Yiel

d

Fixed

Inco

me: M

ortgag

e-Bac

ked

Mac

ro

Mer

ger Arb

itrag

e

Relativ

e Valu

e Arb

itrag

e

Fund W

eigted

Compos

ite

Beta chg. spread: January 1995-April 2004

Source: HFR

Page 42: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 42

-0.1

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

S&P500

Convert

ible

Arb

Distre

ssed

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Total

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Glo

bal

Equity H

edge

Equity M

arke

t Neu

tral

Mar

ket Neu

tral :

Stat

Arb

itrag

e

Equity N

on-H

edge

Event-D

riven

Fixed

Inco

me: Total

Fixed

Inco

me: Arb

itrag

e

Fixed

Inco

me: Con

verti

ble B

onds

Fixed

Inco

me: Dive

rsifie

d

Fixed

Inco

me: High

Yiel

d

Fixed

Inco

me: M

ortgag

e-Bac

ked

Mac

ro

Mer

ger Arb

itrag

e

Relativ

e Valu

e Arb

itrag

e

Fund W

eigted

Compos

ite

Beta SMB: January 1995-April 2004

Source: HFR

Page 43: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 43

-0.4

-0.3

-0.3

-0.2

-0.2

-0.1

-0.1

0.0

0.1

0.1

0.2

S&P500

Convert

ible

Arb

Distre

ssed

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Total

Emer

ging M

arkets

: Glo

bal

Equity H

edge

Equity M

arke

t Neu

tral

Mar

ket Neu

tral :

Stat

Arb

itrag

e

Equity N

on-H

edge

Event-D

riven

Fixed

Inco

me: Total

Fixed

Inco

me: Arb

itrag

e

Fixed

Inco

me: Con

verti

ble B

onds

Fixed

Inco

me: Dive

rsifie

d

Fixed

Inco

me: High

Yiel

d

Fixed

Inco

me: M

ortgag

e-Bac

ked

Mac

ro

Mer

ger Arb

itrag

e

Relativ

e Valu

e Arb

itrag

e

Fund W

eigted

Compos

ite

Beta HML: January 1995-April 2004

Source: HFR

Page 44: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 44

5. Rethinking Optimization

• Move to three dimensions: mean-variance-skewness

• Relatively new idea in equity management but old one in fixed income management

Page 45: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 45

5. Rethinking Optimization

0

5

10

15

Variance

- 2

- 1

0

1

2

Skewness

5

7.5

10

12.5

Expected Return

0

5

10

15

Variance

Page 46: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 46

5. Rethinking Optimization

0

5

10

15

Variance

- 2

- 1

0

1

2

Skewness

5

7.5

10

12.5

Expected Return

RF

0

5

10

15

Variance

Page 47: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 47

5. Rethinking Optimization

0 5 10 15

Variance

- 2

- 1

0

1

2

Skewness

5

7.5

10

12.5

Expected Return

RF

0 5 10 15

Variance

- 2

- 1

0

1

2

Skewness

Page 48: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 48

5. Rethinking Optimization

05 10 15

Variance

- 2- 1012

Skewness

5

7.5

10

12.5

Expected Return

RF

05 10 15

Variance

5

7.5

10

12.5

Expected Return

Page 49: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 49

6. Higher Moments & Expected Returns

• CAPM with skewness invented in 1973 and 1976 by Rubinstein, Kraus and Litzerberger

• Same intuition as usual CAPM: what counts is the systematic (undiversifiable) part of skewness (called coskewness)

Page 50: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 50

6. Higher Moments & Expected Returns

• Covariance is the contribution of the security to the variance of the well diversified portfolio

• Coskewness is the contribution of the security to the skewness of the well diversified portfolio

Page 51: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 51

6. Higher Moments & Expected Returns

-2.5

-2

-1.5

-1

-0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

Australi

a

Austria

Belg

ium

Canad

a

Den

mar

k

Finlan

d

France

Ger

man

y

Hong K

ong

Irelan

d It

aly

Japan

Nether

lands

New

Zea

land

Norway

Portugal

Spain

Swed

en

Switzer

land UK US

World

World

ex-U

S

EAFE

Average Skewness in Developed Markets

Page 52: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 52

6. Higher Moments & Expected Returns

-2.5

-2

-1.5

-1

-0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

Argen

tina

Bahrai

n

Brazil

Chile

China

Colombia

Czech

Rep

ublicEgy

pt

Greece

Hunga

ry

India

Indo

nesia

Israe

l

Jord

an

Korea

Mala

ysia

Mex

ico

Mor

occo

Nigeria

Oman

Pakist

an

Peru

Philipp

ines

Poland

Russia

Saudi

Arabia

Slovak

ia

South

Africa

Sri Lan

ka

Taiw

an

Thaila

nd

Turke

y

Venez

uela

Zimba

bwe

Compo

site

Average Skewness in Emerging Markets

Page 53: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 53

6. Higher Moments & Expected Returns

-1

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

Australi

a

Austria

Belg

ium

Canad

a

Den

mar

k

Finlan

d

France

Ger

man

y

Hong K

ong

Irelan

d It

aly

Japan

Nether

lands

New

Zea

land

Norway

Portugal

Spain

Swed

en

Switzer

land UK US

World

World

ex-U

S

EAFE

Average Excess Kurtosis in Developed Markets

Page 54: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 54

6. Higher Moments & Expected Returns

-1

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

Argen

tina

Bahrai

n

Brazil

Chile

China

Colombia

Czech

Rep

ublicEgy

pt

Greece

Hunga

ry

India

Indo

nesia

Israe

l

Jord

an

Korea

Mala

ysia

Mex

ico

Mor

occo

Nigeria

Oman

Pakist

an

Peru

Philipp

ines

Poland

Russia

Saudi

Arabia

Slovak

ia

South

Africa

Sri Lan

ka

Taiw

an

Thaila

nd

Turke

y

Venez

uela

Zimba

bwe

Compo

site

Average Excess Kurtosis in Emerging Markets

Page 55: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 55

7. New Metrics

• Old Sharpe Ratio= Excess return/vol

• Alternative = Excess return/[vol-adj(skew)]

• Alternative = alpha from 3-moment CAPM

Page 56: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 56

7. New Metrics

• Traditional Markowitz optimization over mean and variance

• New optimization over mean, variance and skewness

Page 57: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 57

8. Implementation

• Harvey, Liechty, Liechty and Müller (2004) “Portfolio Selection with Higher Moments”

Page 58: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 58

9. Conclusions

• Data not normal – especially hedge fund returns

• Investors have clear preference over skewness which needs to be incorporated into our portfolio selection methods – and performance evaluation

• Remember Markowitz’s “two stages”. Ex ante skewness is difficult to measure.

Page 59: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 59

9. Conclusions

• While we have only talked about average risk, it is likely that the risk (including skewness) changes through time

Page 60: Managing Higher Moments in Hedge Fund Allocation Campbell R. Harvey Duke University, Durham, NC USA National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Campbell R. Harvey 60

Readings

• “Distributional Characteristics of Emerging Market Returns and Asset Allocation," with Geert Bekaert, Claude B. Erb and Tadas E. Viskanta, Journal of Portfolio Management (1998), Winter,102-116.

• “Autoregressive Conditional Skewness,” with Akhtar Siddique, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 34, 4, 1999, 465-488.

• “Conditional Skewness in Asset Pricing Tests,” with Akhtar Siddique, Journal of Finance 55, June 2000, 1263-1295.

• “Time-Varying Conditional Skewness and the Market Risk Premium,” with Akhtar Siddique, Research in Banking and Finance 2000, 1, 27-60.

• “The Drivers of Expected Returns in International Markets,” Emerging Markets Quarterly 2000, 32-49.

• “Portfolio Selection with Higher Moments,” with John Liechty, Merrill Liechty, and Peter Müller, Working paper, 2004.


Recommended