Managing Multinational Infrastructure: An analysis of EU Institutional Structures and Best Practices

8/6/2019 Managing Multinational Infrastructure: An analysis of EU Institutional Structures and Best Practices

1/42

KBOL ^fralin Xkxcr Zcrlcz

@kiknlin @sgliklfikgLierkzrsjsrc= Ki Kikg|zlz feCsrfxcki Silfi LizlslfikgZrsjsrcz kib Ocz Xrkjljc

^lggc` uki bcr Nccz kibMfrnc Ic}-Ecrrcr

If) ?


2/42

Rdc ^fralin Xkxcr zcrlcz lz k jfilisklfi fe dc efr`crg| ik`cb Blzjszzlfi Xkxcr zcrlcz1dc is`ocrlin fe dc xkxcrz jfiliscb ~ldfs licrrsxlfi fr jdkinc) KBOLz ~fralinxkxcrz rcegcj lillkg lbckz fi k fxlj kib krc xfzcb figlic efr blzjszzlfi) KBOL cijfsrknczrckbcrz f xfz dclr jf``ciz fi dc `kli xknc efr ckjd ~fralin xkxcr $nluci li dcjlklfi ocgf~,) Zf`c ~fralin xkxcrz `k| bcucgfx lif fdcr efr`z fe xsogljklfi)

Zsnnczcb jlklfi=

Uki bcr Nccz' ^)' kib M) Isic}-Ecrrcr) ?8;;) @kiknlin @sgliklfikg Lierkzrsjsrc= KiKikg|zlz fe Csrfxcki Silfi Lizlslfikg Zrsjsrcz kib Ocz Xrkjljc) KBOL ^fralin Xkxcr?&;3&2523)`kiknlin)`sgliklfikg)lierkzrsjsrc)cs&

Xgckzc jfikj dc ksdfr$z, efr liefr`klfi kofs dlz xkxcr)

C`klg= ~lggc`ukibcrncczH|kdff)jf`1 mfrncisicHn`klg)jf`

^lggc` uki bcr Nccz lz xrczcig| rkbc xfglj| kbulzfr' @lilzr| fe Cjfif`|' _cxsoglj feKr`cilk kib Mfrnc Ic}-Ecrrcr lz ki libcxcibci jfizsgki kib zcilfr kzzfjlkcrczckrjdcr ~ld dc Jcirc efr Csrfxcki Xfglj| Zsblcz) Rdlz lz k rculzcb ucrzlfi fe kokjanrfsib xkxcr xrcxkrcb efr KBO&KBOL.z Egknzdlx zsb| fi Lierkzrsjsrc kib_cnlfikg Jffxcrklfi kib dc offa Lierkzrsjsrc efr k Zck`gczz Kzlk)

Rdc ulc~z ctxrczzcb li dlz xkxcr krc dc ulc~z fe dc ksdfrz kib bf if icjczzkrlg|rcegcj dc ulc~z fr xfgljlcz fe KBOL' dc Kzlki Bcucgfx`ci Okia $KBO,' lz Ofkrb feBlrcjfrz' fr dc nfucri`ciz dc| rcxrczci) KBOL bfcz if nskrkicc dc kjjsrkj| fedc bkk lijgsbcb li dlz xkxcr kib kjjcxz if rczxfizlolgl| efr ki| jfizc{scijcz fedclr szc) Rcr`lifgfn| szcb `k| if icjczzkrlg| oc jfizlzci ~ld KBO feeljlkg cr`z)

Kzlki Bcucgfx`ci Okia LizlscAkzs`lnkzcal Oslgblin 4E:-?-3 Akzs`lnkzcal' Jdl|fbk-asRfa|f ;88-5884' Mkxki

Rcg= !4;-:-:3


3/42

KBOL fralin Xkxcr ?


4/42


5/42

KBOL ^fralin Xkxcr ?


6/42



7/42



8/42

KBOL ^fralin Xkxcr ?3# fe CS kucrknc,1

?, Jfiucrzlfi fe rcnlfiz fr xkrz fe rcnlfiz zcrlfszg| keecjcb o| libszrlkg bcjglic1

:, Jfòklin gfin-cr` sic`xgf|`ci1

2, Mfo kib jkrccr licnrklfi fe |fsin xcfxgc1

3k, Kjjcgcrkcb rcefr` fe knrljsgsrkg zrsjsrcz13o, Bcucgfx`ci fe rsrkg krckz)

^dlgc fomcjlucz ;' ?' kib 3o ~crc crrlfrlkgg| bccr`licb' esibz ckr`kracb efrfomcjlucz :' 2 kib 3k jfsgb zsxxfr xrfnrk`z if gl`lcb f xkrljsgkr krckz)

Rdc Jf``sil| lizlslfiz blb if dkuc ki| xf~crz li dc elcgb fe rkiz-Csrfxckiic~fraz li rkizxfr' cicrn|' fr cgcjf``siljklfiz) Df~cucr' dc CsrfxckiJf``lzzlfi jrckcb k Rrkizxfr Lierkzrsjsrc Jf``lcc kib k jfizsgklfixrfjcbsrc ~ld dc `còcr zkcz li ;4) Rdc rfgc fe dc Csrfxcki lizlslfiz'lijgsblin dc CLO' li kxxrfulin esiblin efr rcnlfikg lierkzrsjsrc jfiecrrcb k jkxkjl|f liegscijc dclr bcucgfx`ci' ~ldfs o|-xkzzlin dc zrfin lizlslfikg jf-

fxcrklfi fe dc Jf``lzzlfi ~ld `còcr zkcz)Li cicrn| kib cgcjf``siljklfiz dc liegscijc fe dc Csrfxcki Jf``lzzlfi ~kzz`kggcr) Rdc xrfxcr esijlfilin fe dc licrikg `krac lz li dc rc`l fe dc CsrfxckiJf``lzzlfi kib l lijrckzcb lz xf~cr kib liegscijc drfsnd lz jf`xcllfi xfglj|kib lz xf~crz li ekjlglklin jrfzz-ofrbcr `crncrz kib kj{slzllfiz' kz ~cgg kzcgl`liklin liblrcj rkbc okrrlcrz)

?): Rdc jrcklfi fe zxcjlelj Rrkiz-Csrfxcki Ic~fraz

Rdc c`crncijc fe k xfglj| f~krbz lirkrcnlfikg kib rkiziklfikg lierkzrsjsrczkrcb xrfxcrg| ~ld dc Bcgfrz LL xkjaknc' ~dljd kggfjkcb ic~ kgocl `fbcz

zxciblin efr dc ;


9/42


Rdlz rkiziklfikg lierkzrsjsrc kgzf lijgsbcb dclr jfiicjlfi f dc Rrkiz-CsrfxckiIc~fraz)

Rdc @kkzrljd Rrck| xrfulbcb dc gcnkg okzlz efr dc Rrkiz-Csrfxcki Ic~fraz$RCIz,) L ~kz ecg dk dc licnrklfi fe dc licrikg `krac ~kz dk`xcrcb o| dcgkja fe ~cgg-licnrkcb rkizxfr' cicrn|' kib cgcjf``siljklfiz lierkzrsjsrc

oc~cci `c`ocr zkcz) Rdc zlingc `krac dkb kz ki kl` f rcbsjc dc jfzz fedkulin bleecrci iklfikg `kracz jdkrkjcrl}cb o| fglnfxfglzlj zrsjsrcz' ~ld kjfizlbcrkogc ifi jf`xclluc zcn`ciklfi fe dc `krac $C`crzfi c kg) ;


10/42

KBOL ^fralin Xkxcr ?3`lgglfi efr dc xcrlfb $?88:?885,) @fz fe dc kl`z krc xsrzscb o| k ic~ xrfnrk`'l?8?8' ~dljd lz if xkr fe dc RCIz)

) Lillkgg| dc `kli drsz fe dc zrkcn|~kz fi rkizxfr' xrl`krlg| ocjkszc efr `c`ocr zkcz dc xfzzlogc cjfif`ljocicelz fe lijrckzcb rkbc kib `folgl| krc jgckr' ~dlgc cicrn| kibcgcjf``siljklfiz krc feci jfirfggcb o| xsoglj jf`xkilcz fr xf~cresg iklfikgjdk`xlfiz) Rdc fxcilin fe dc cgcjf``siljklfiz zcjfr f jf`xcllfi kib dclijrckzc li licrfxcrkolgl| lz zgf~g| oclin kjdlcucb) Efr cicrn|' dc jrcklfi fe rkiz-Csrfxcki ic~fraz kgzf rc{slrcb dc fxcilin fe iklfikg `kracz f jf`xcllfi) Rdcokzlj rc{slrc`ci fe xrlukl}lin kib siosibglin dc cicrn| zcjfr ~kz fig|jf`xgccb ~ld bleeljsg| li ?884' kib `ki| `c`ocr zkcz dfgb zlnileljki zdkrcz fe

f~icrzdlx li dc cicrn| zcjfr' jfizlbcrcb fe iklfikg l`xfrkijc f cizsrc cicrn|zcjsrl|)

:) RCI-R' E_F@ K ZGSNNLZD ZRK_R RF K JCIR_KGXFGLJ\

:); Bcjlzlfi-`kalin kib `kiknc`ci fe Rrkiz-CsrfxckiIc~fraz

Rdc rfgc fe dc CS lizlslfiz li dc bcucgfx`ci fe dc RCIz dkz occi fic feekjlglkfr rkdcr dki bcucgfxcr fr `kikncr) Rdc Csrfxcki Jf``lzzlfi lz if

;? Bcjlzlfi If) ;5


11/42



12/42

KBOL ^fralin Xkxcr ?&?88; fe 4 Fjfocr ?88; fi dc Zksc efr k Csrfxcki jf`xki|

$ZC,;2 Jfsijlg Blrcjluc ?88;&45&CJ fe 4 Fjfocr ?88; zsxxgc`cilin dc Zksc efr k Csrfxcki jf`xki|~ld rcnkrb f dc liufguc`ci fe c`xgf|ccz

Csrfxcki Jf``lzzlfi'BN Cicrn| kib Rrkizxfr

@c`ocr ZkczXrfxfzcz' filfrzRCI' feecrz esibz kibkzzlzkijc Xrfxfzc xrfmcjz'

Knrcc fi RCI glzzCS liegscijc fi dc `kiknc`ci bcxcibz fi zfsrjc fe esibz) Rdc CSicucrdcgczz dkz rsgcz fi xsoglj xrfjsrc`ci' zkibkrbz fe kzzczz`ci' zsjdkz dc Ciulrfi`cikg L`xkj Kzzczz`ci' kib dcrc krc licrfxcrkolgl|bcjlzlfiz dk `c`ocr zkcz dkuc f efggf~) Liblrcjg|' o| kxxflilinCsrfxcki jffrblikfrz ~ld dlnd-rkialin xfglljkg zksrc f efggf~ sx xrfmcjz'dc CS dkz `frc liegscijc)fucr dc xrfjczz)

CS ESIBLIN

Le jfdczlfiesiblin dciBN _cnlfikgXfglj| dkzl`xfrkirfgc likxxrfukg'l`czjkgcz

Le RCIesiblin' BNRrkizxfr kibCicrn| $fr dcRCI-Rkncij|, dkzzf`cliegscijc fucrk rfukgz kib

CLO ESIBLIN

Rdc CLO dkzliegscijc fucrxrfmcjzxcjleljklfizkib`kiknc`ci

IKRLFIKG

CS liegscijc ~cka) Ifliegscijc erf`Csrfxcki lizlslfizfi l`czjkgcz frzxcjleljklfiz'kgdfsnd knrcc`cizfi licrfxcrkolgl|ctlz k CS gcucg)
http://europa.eu/eur-lex/pri/en/oj/dat/2001/l_294/l_29420011110en00010021.pdfhttp://europa.eu/eur-lex/pri/en/oj/dat/2001/l_294/l_29420011110en00010021.pdfhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/October_8http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2001http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2001http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/October_8http://europa.eu/eur-lex/pri/en/oj/dat/2001/l_294/l_29420011110en00010021.pdf


13/42



14/42

KBOL ^fralin Xkxcr ?32 fe ?8Msg| ?883, czkoglzdlin k xrfjcbsrc f kxxfli Csrfxcki Jffrblikfrz li jdkrnc fe

zxcjlelj xrlfrl| xrfmcjz' efr liblulbskg jrfzz-ofrbcr zcjlfiz' efr nrfsxz fe xrfmcjzgfjkcb li dc zk`c xrlfrl| ktlz' fr efr k ~dfgc ktlz) Rdczc kxxfli`ciz krc efr efsr|ckrz) Rdc Csrfxcki Jf``lzzlficr li jdkrnc fe Cicrn| kib Rrkizxfr dsz kxxflizdlnd-gcucg xfglljkg elnsrcz f `cblkc oc~cci jfsirlcz kib xszd efr~krb dc RCIkncibk) Rdc Jf``lzzlfi jfrrcjg| kzzczzcb dk jffrblikfrz ~fsgb lirfbsjc dcicjczzkr| xfglljkg l`xcsz f bckg ~ld bleeljsg jrfzz-ofrbcr fxcrklfiz' dk rc{slrclicriklfikg jfggkofrklfi) Li kbbllfi' dczc jffrblikfrz ~fsgb xrf`fc dc xrfmcjzf xrlukc liuczfrz kib elikijlkg lizlslfiz) Rdc Jffrblikfrz rcnsgkrg| rcxfr f dcCsrfxcki Jf``lzzlfi) Rdc elrz kib zcjfib rcxfrz ~crc xsoglzdcb li Msg| kibZcxc`ocr ?88> kib krc kuklgkogc figlic erf` dc zlc fe dc Rrkiz CsrfxckiRrkizxfr Ic~fraz;5

Jffrblikfrz krc if rc`sicrkcb efr dlz zcruljc= fig| jfzz lijsrrcb efr dcxcrefr`kijc fe dclr bslcz krc rcl`osrzcb) Efr dc RCI-R xrfmcjz' dc efggf~linxfglljkg elnsrcz ~crc kxxflicb=

)

;3 dx=&&cj)csrfxk)cs&ci&rkizxfr&jffrblikfrz&libctVci)d` $kjjczzcb :8 Msg|' ?884,;5 dx=&&cj)csrfxk)cs&ci&rkizxfr&jffrblikfrz&libctVci)d`
http://ec.europa.eu/ten/transport/coordinators/index_en.htmhttp://ec.europa.eu/ten/transport/coordinators/index_en.htm


15/42

KBOL ^fralin Xkxcr ? efsr xrfmcj jffrblikfrz efr dc RCI-C xrfmcjz) Rdc jffrblikfrzdkuc dc `kibkc f ekjlglkc dc bcucgfx`ci fe k dlnd-ufgknc jfiicjlfi oc~cciErkijc kib Zxkli $rkiziklfikg xkr fe xrfmcj CG:,1 feezdfrc ~lib cicrn|jfiicjlfiz li dc Okglj kib Ifrd Zck krckz $rkiziklfikg xkr fe xrfmcj If)CG>,1dc IKOSJJF iksrkg nkz xlxcglic $IN:,' kib k xf~cr jfiicjlfi oc~cciNcr`ki|' Xfgkib kib Gldskilk $CG4,)
http://store.ihs.com/specsstore/controller?event=LINK_SEARCH&search_value=wind%20energy&all_text=true&mid=w092http://store.ihs.com/specsstore/controller?event=LINK_SEARCH&search_value=natural%20gas%20pipeline&all_text=true&mid=w092http://store.ihs.com/specsstore/controller?event=LINK_SEARCH&search_value=natural%20gas%20pipeline&all_text=true&mid=w092http://store.ihs.com/specsstore/controller?event=LINK_SEARCH&search_value=wind%20energy&all_text=true&mid=w092


16/42



17/42



18/42



19/42


Df~cucr' rfkb kib rklg krc if dc fig| jfijcriz fe dc RCI-R xgkiz) @ffr~k|z fedc zck' jffrbliklfi ~ld klr rkizxfr kib dc Nkglgcf xrfmcj efr ki CS zkcgglcikulnklfi z|zc`' kgg krc xkr fe dc xgki)

Rdc DGN rcxfr rc{sczcb dk dc efggf~lin rc{slrc`ciz oc kaci lif kjjfsi lidc bcucgfx`ci fe dc RCI-R ic~fra=

@ffr~k|z fe dc zck zdfsgb jf`xgc`ci `kligkib ktcz1

Iklfikg rklg ic~fraz zdfsgb oc `frc licrfxcrkogc' zxcjleljkgg| ~ld rczxcj fzlnikglin kib cgcjf`z1

Xkr fe dc rklg ic~fra zdfsgb oc bcbljkcb f erclnd1

Klr rkeelj `kiknc`ci zdfsgb oc licnrkcb1

K rlucr liefr`klfi z|zc` zdfsgb oc czkoglzdcb1

K uczzcg rkeelj `kiknc`ci kib liefr`klfi jcirc zdfsgb oc jrckcb1

Ctlzlin klrxfrz zdfsgb oc occr `kikncb1

@kli Csrfxcki ktcz zdfsgb oc lbcilelcb1 Kjjcblin jfsirlcz zdfsgb oc licnrkcb1

Jf``sil| klb zdfsgb oc lijrckzcb)

$Csrfxcki Jf``lzzlfi' ?883,

Rdc rcxfr kgzf zsnnczcb k ic~ elikijlin kxxrfkjd' kz dc jfzz fe dc RCI-Rxrfmcjz jkiif oc zdfsgbcrcb o| ifr`kg xsoglj xrfjsrc`ci kgfic) Rdc jfz fe dc~dfgc ic~fra dkz occi czl`kcb k fucr 388 olgglfi) Rdc rcxfr jkggz efr liifuklucz|zc`z fe XXX elikijlin kib dc szc fe `fbcri fgg z|zc`z efr `ffr~k|z frcjfucr liucz`ci kib klicikijc jfzz)

Li kbbllfi dc rcxfr jkggz efr k zkibkrbl}cb kxxrfkjd f dc bcucgfx`ci felierkzrsjsrc' ~ld occr jffrbliklfi' jf``fi l`xkj kzzczz`ciz kib dcjrcklfi fe rkiziklfikg gcnkg cillcz)

Li ?88: dc Csrfxcki Jf``lzzlfi xsoglzdcb ic~ nslbcglicz kib elikijlkg rsgcz kibxcrefr`cb ki ctcibcb l`xkj kzzczz`ci f kzzczz dc l`xkj fe dc ic~ xgkizjf`xkrcb ~ld kalin if kjlfi' dc jf`xgclfi fe dc ?88; xrfxfzcb ~dlc xkxcrxgkiz' kib dc jf`xgclfi fe dc ic~ zrsjsrcz okzcb fi dc DGN rczsgz)

Rdc rczsgz zdf~cb ki l`xfrki l`xrfuc`ci li dc CSz rkizxfr' ciulrfi`cikib nrf~d xcrefr`kijc $Rkogc ;,) Rdc kogc zdf~z dc xfzzlogc l`xkj fe ~fbleecrci zjcikrlfz fe dc RCI-R bcucgfx`ci jf`xkrcb f if bcucgfx`ci) RdcCsrfxcki zjcikrlf zdf~z dc rczsgz fe l`xgc`cilin kgg xrlfrl| xrfmcjz knrccb

ocefrc ?88; kib dkge fe dfzc li kjjczzlfi jfsirlcz) Rdc Csrfxcki! zjcikrlfkzzs`cz dc bcucgfx`ci fe esrdcr lierkzrsjsrc' ~dljd ~crc knrccb li ?88: kibdc jf`xgclfi fe ckzcri Csrfxcki rkizxfr lierkzrsjsrc xrfmcjz)


20/42

KBOL ^fralin Xkxcr ?)> olgglfiJfz ;;: olgglfi ;


21/42



22/42

KBOL ^fralin Xkxcr ?) @ffr~k| ktlz Lnfs`cilzk&XkrkzKdcizZfelkOsbkxcz4) @sgl`fbkg ktlz Xfrsnkg&Zxklircz fe Csrfxc) _klg~k| ktlz XkrlzZrkzofsrnZsnkrUlciikOrklzgkuk;4) _dlic&@cszc@kliBkisoc ligkib ~kcr~k| ktlz;) _klg Okgljk ktlz krzk~Aksikz_lnkRkggliiDcgzlial?4) Csrfjkxrklg fi dc OrszzcgzGstc`ofsrnZrkzofsrn rklg~k| ktlz?


23/42

KBOL ^fralin Xkxcr ? $3, li Bcjlzlfi 442&?882Nluci dc bcgk|z f xrfmcjz' l ~kz bcjlbcb dk dc ?8;8 krnc efr jf`xgclfi ocxs efr~krb f ?8?8) Xrfmcjz dk krc if bcucgfxcb sibcr dc knrccb bckbglicz `k|gfzc dc zsxxfr fe CS esibz)

^fra li rcjci |ckrz dkz occi kjjcgcrklin' kib bczxlc dc Jf``lzzlfiz jfijcridk dc ?8?8 bckbglic ~lgg if oc rckjdcb' `ki| xrfmcjz krc fi rkja) K ?8;8bcklgcb kikg|zlz kib xrfnrczz rcxfr erf` dc Jf``lzzlfiz Blrcjfrkc-Ncicrkg efr@folgl| kib Rrkizxfr fi RCIR ifcz jfizlbcrkogc xrfnrczz)


24/42



25/42

KBOL fralin Xkxcr ? efr dcjfizrsjlfi fe dc fucrkgg ic~fra dkz occi fe ?8;:,' efr fdcr krckz dc fig| esibz kuklgkogc krc dfzc bcbljkcb fRCI-R ~dljd elikijc 38# fe jfz fe zsblcz kib xrlfrl| xrfmcjz $lijgsblin dc zkcgglcxfzllfilin z|zc` Nkglgcf,' :8# efr jrfzz-ofrbcr xrfmcjz kib ;8# efr ifi-xrlfrl| xrfmcjz)Xkrljsgkrg| l`xfrki lz dc jgkszc ~dljd zkcz dk sirckzfikogc bcgk|z ~lgg jkszc xrfmcjzf gfzc CS elikijlkg zsxxfr)


26/42

KBOL fralin Xkxcr ?


27/42

KBOL fralin Xkxcr ? f ;dr22)

;< Xrfeczzfr Ak~kl bcelicb rkiziklfikg lierkzrsjsrc kz `sgl-jfsir|' jrfzz-ofrbcr lierkzrsjsrc kikncbo| zcucrkg zcxkrkc iklfikg ksdfrllcz fr jf`xkilcz)

?8Rdkg|z szcz ~f `fbcgz fe rkliz' ofd fe ~dljd krc xkr fe dc RNU $rkli nrkibc ulczzc, ek`lg| fe dlnd-zxccb rkliz oslg o| Kgzf` li Erkijc) Rdc elrz |xc' dc XOK $Xkrlz-Orszzcgz-K`zcrbk`, lz k rl-jsrrci cgcjrlj`sglxgc sil bczjcibcb erf` dc RNU _zcks) Rdlz |xc jki fxcrkc fig| oc~cci dc jllcz nluci li lz ik`c)Rdc XOAK $Xkrlz-Orszzcgz-Afgi-K`zcrbk`, lz k |xc bcrlucb erf` dc RNU Bsxgct bfsogc-bcja zcz' kgdfsnddc Rdkg|z rkliz krc fig| zlingc bcja) Rdczc silz krc {skbrl-jsrrci' kib jki fxcrkc f efsr bczliklfiz$K`zcrbk`' Orszzcgz' Jfgfnic kib Xkrlz,) Zfsrjc= ^lalxcblk' dx=&&ci)~lalxcblk)frn&~lal&Rdkg|z $kjjczzcb :8Msg|' ?884,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TGVhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alstomhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SNCF_TGV_R%C3%A9seauhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_multiple_unithttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_multiple_unithttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SNCF_TGV_R%C3%A9seauhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SNCF_TGV_Thalys_PBKAhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SNCF_TGV_Duplexhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thalyshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thalyshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SNCF_TGV_Duplexhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SNCF_TGV_Thalys_PBKAhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SNCF_TGV_R%C3%A9seauhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_multiple_unithttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_multiple_unithttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SNCF_TGV_R%C3%A9seauhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alstomhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TGV


28/42

KBOL fralin Xkxcr ?


29/42

KBOL fralin Xkxcr ?

xcrlfbz ~dljd krc |xljkgg| k ec~ |ckrz kecr kbfxlfi' kjaif~gcbnlin dc iccb efr l`c fkjdlcuc kxxrfxrlkc cjdiljkg kbmsz`ci)

Rdc cjdiljkg zkibkrb efr dc Rdkg|z dlnd-zxccb rklg~k| rkjaz krc bcelicb o| zcucrkgzl`xgc ac| xkrk`ccrz' zsjd kz k `ktl`s` nrkblci kz ~cgg kz k `lil`s` rkblsz fejsruksrc) Li dc jkzc fe Rdkg|z dczc krc rczxcjlucg| 2# kib ::38 `ccrz) Rrkjaz ~dljd

bf if `cc dczc bczlni xkrk`ccrz krc if bcc`cb zslkogc efr dlnd-zxccb szc fe :88 a`xcr dfsr) L lz l`xfrki f ifc dk l`xfrki Ncr`ki rklg~k| glicz' zsjd kz dc ficoc~cci Jfgfnic kib Erkiaesr' bf if `cc dlz xkrljsgkr zkibkrb) Esrdcr`frc' efr cucidlndcr zxccbz' dc nrkblci ~fsgb dkuc f oc cuci gf~cr $l)c) ?#, kib jsruksrc ~fsgb dkucf oc okzcb krfsib k `lil`s` rkblsz fe >888 `ccrz) Rdczc krc dc zxcjleljklfiz szcb efrdc ic~ dlnd-zxccb glia jsrrcig| sibcr bcucgfx`ci li Lkg|)

:)3)? Kxxrfkjdcz f rklg~k| xrlukl}klfi)

Bleecrci `fbcgz fe xrlukl}klfi kib liufguc`ci fe xrlukc zcjfr fxcrkfrz kib c{sl| dkucocci xsrzscb kjrfzz dc CS) Zf`c jfsirlcz' efr ctk`xgc dc Silcb Alinbf`' dkuc fxcbefr k ucrljkg zcxkrklfi ~ld lierkzrsjsrc' rfgglin zfja kib kijlggkr| oszliczzcz zfgb fr

erkijdlzcb f xrlukc zcjfr fxcrkfrz) Esrdcr' dcrc dkz occi dfrl}fikg zcxkrklfi ~ldbleecrci xrlukc zcjfr fxcrkfrz xrfulblin zcruljcz li zcxkrkc rcnlfiz drfsnd k erkijdlzckrrkinc`ci' k~krbcb drfsnd jf`xclluc olbblin) Li zcucrkg CS jfsirlcz' efr ctk`xgcErkijc kib Ncr`ki|' dcrc dkz occi gl`lcb ucrljkg zcxkrklfi' kgdfsnd xrlukc zcjfrliufguc`ci dkz lijrckzcb drfsnd gckzlin kib zsojfirkjlin) Li zf`c fdcr CS jfsirlczdcrc dkz occi ucrljkg zcxkrklfi' os dfrl}fikg licnrklfi dkz occi `kliklicb li xsogljf~icrzdlx $Dsgci Z' E) @l}skil' M) Xrczfi' kib B) Uki bc Ucgbc' ?888,)

Xrfknfilzz fe ucrljkg zcxkrklfi xfli f dc ocicelz fe kggf~lin ifi-blzjrl`likluc kjjczzf lierkzrsjsrc&rklg-rkja kib dc ocicelz fe jf`xcllfi oc~cci xrfulbcrz) Df~cucr'fxxficiz dkuc occi {slja f xfli fs dk li dc SA xrlukl}klfi kxxrfkjd' rklg~k|fxcrkfrz `k| gkja jf``crjlkg lijcilucz f `kac gfin-cr` liucz`ci li ic~ rfgglin zfjakib rklg-rkja) Rdc xrczzsrc fi erkijdlzcrz f oc ceeljlci ~lgg oc gl`lcb o| dc iccb efrxsoglj zkec|) Rdc SA ctxcrlcijc dkz bc`fizrkcb dk dc f~i jfzz fe SA rklifxcrkfrz dkz rlzci zdkrxg| zlijc dc Dkelcgb kjjlbci li Fjfocr ?888) ?2

Rdkg|z Licriklfikg efggf~z dc Erkijf-Ncr`ki `fbcg fe ucrljkg licnrklfi ~ld dfrl}fikgzcxkrklfi= iklfikg rklg~k|z xrfulbc zcruljcz fi dc zk`c rfsc k gf~cr xrljcz' zgf~crzxccbz kib gczz jf`efr) Rdc gczzfi ~dljd dc Rdkg|z ctxcrlcijc bc`fizrkcz lz dk dcucrljkg zcxkrklfi `fbcg bfcz if gckb f kxxrfxrlkc gcucgz fe liucz`ci)

Rdc rc-c`crncijc fe dc Nrck _klg~k|z li Csrfxc zdfsgb oc xgkjcb li dc orfkbcrjfict kjrfzz dc CS ~dcrc gfnlzlj rcibz efr szlin rklg~k|z efr erclnd krc li xrlijlxgcsiekufrkogc efr dc rklg~k|z dcijc dc xkzzcincr zcn`ci xrfulbcz dc b|ik`ljz fe dczso-zcjfr) Fucrkgg rklg-erclnd kjrfzz dc CS dkz bcjglicb zdkrxg|= ~dlgc li ;8 kz `sjd kz?;# fe kgg nffbz ~crc rkizxfrcb o| rklg' o| dc |ckr ?888 dlz dkb bcjglicb f 4);# fe dcfkg erclnd `krac $Dcizrk c kg)' ?885' x) ;25,)

Rdc `kli rcibz li Csrfxcki erclnd kib gfnlzljz dkuc bcjlzlucg| `fucb knkliz dc szkncfe rklg-erclnd1 dczc rcibz `k| oc zs``krl}cb o| dc efggf~lin=?3

- fszfsrjlin kib ucrljkg blzlicnrklfi' ~dcrc ucrljkg licnrklfi oc~cci xrfbsjcrz kibgfnlzlj xrfulbcrz lz lijrckzling| gl`lcb1 rkdcr zxcjlkgl}klfi lz kalin xgkjc ~dcrc

?2 L dkz occi czl`kcb dk rkli fxcrkfrz f~i jfzz' ctjgsblin rfgglin zfja jfzz kib kjjczz jdkrncz'lijrckzcb o| kg`fz 38# oc~cci ;,?3 Dcizrk B) c kg) $?88>,' x);:4


30/42

KBOL fralin Xkxcr ?

2); Rdc elrz glocrkgl}klfi xkjaknc

) Efggf~lin dczc lillkg' jkslfsz zcxz' dc CS `fucbf~krbz esgg glocrkgl}klfi fe dc cicrn| `krac erf` dc `lb-iliclcz fi~krbz' rczsglin lidc kbfxlfi fe ~f glocrkgl}klfi xkjakncz) _cjcig|' k dlrb glocrkgl}klfi xkjaknc dkz occixrczcicb o| dc Csrfxcki Jf``lzzlfi)

Rdc elrz jfijcri fe dc Csrfxcki Jf``lzzlfi ~kz dc gkja fe ki licrikg `krac li cicrn|'kib k gkja fe licrjfiicjkogl| oc~cci iklfikg nrlbz) R~f blrcjlucz ~crc knrccbjfijcrilin jf``fi rsgcz efr dc licrikg `krac li cgcjrljl| kib nkz $


31/42

KBOL fralin Xkxcr ? :;

Rdc @krjd ?885 Csrfxcki Jfsijlg Jfijgszlfiz $>>>3&;&85' xsoglzdcb ;4 @k| ?885, jkggcbefr esgg' ceecjluc kib rkizxkrci l`xgc`ciklfi fe ctlzlin gcnlzgklfi $x):8,' `kalinrcecrcijc f dc lijf`xgcc l`xgc`ciklfi fe dc zcjfib glocrkgl}klfi xkjaknc) Rdc @krjd

Csrfxcki Jfsijlg srncb `còcr zkcz f bcucgfx rcnlfikg cicrn| jffxcrklfi' ifkog|drfsnd kbc{skc licrjfiicjlfi' ~dljd ~fsgb gckb f dc esrdcr bcucgfx`ci fe dc CSlicrikg `krac) CS gckbcrz rcjfnil}cb dc iccb f zrcindci jffxcrklfi kib jffrbliklfioc~cci rcnsgkfrz kib z|zc` fxcrkfrz o| zrcindcilin dc jffrbliklin rfgc k kJf``sil| gcucg fe dc Csrfxcki Cicrn| _cnsgkfrz Nrfsx efr Cgcjrljl| kib Nkz$C_NCN,)

libljkcb dk dc zcjfib nkz kib cgcjrljl| blrcjlucz dkb if |c occi xrfxcrg|l`xgc`cicb) L`xgc`ciklfi ~kz xkjd| li `ki| `còcr zkcz' f dc ocicel fe zkc-rsilijsòci slgllcz) Rdczc ekjfrz kggf~cb efr dc esrdcr jfilisklfi fe ucrljkgg|-licnrkcbxrfbsjlfi kib blzrloslfi $Kl|kz kib Ic}-Ecrrcr' ?88>,

?4 Cncidfecr kib Nlkgfngfs ?882' x) ;2)?< Lolb):8 Jf``siljklfi erf` dc Jf``lzzlfi f dc Jfsijlg kib dc Csrfxcki Xkrglk`ci' _cxfr fi xrfnrczz li

jrcklin dc licrikg nkz kib cgcjrljl| `krac' Orszzcgz' ;3 Ifucòcr ?883' JF@$?883, 354 elikg):; Jf``siljklfi erf` dc Jf``lzzlfi' Li{slr| xsrzski f Krljgc ;> fe _cnsgklfi $CJ, If ;&?88: lif dcCsrfxcki nkz kib cgcjrljl| zcjfrz $Elikg _cxfr,' JF@&?885&843; elikg)


32/42

KBOL fralin Xkxcr ?

fi ;; Ifucòcr ?88:) L lz ki kbulzfr|nrfsx fe libcxcibci iklfikg rcnsgkfr| ksdfrllcz' ~ld dc kza fe kzzlzlin dcJf``lzzlfi f jfizfglbkc dc licrikg `krac efr cgcjrljl| kib nkz) Lz `còcrz krc dcdckbz fe dc iklfikg cicrn| rcnsgkfr| ksdfrllcz li dc ?> `còcr zkcz)

:: ) Rdc li{slr| kzzczzcb dc xrcuklglinjf`xclluc jfibllfiz kib czkoglzdcb dc jkszcz fe dc xcrjclucb `krac `kgesijlfilin)Rdc Cicrn| Zcjfr Li{slr| lbcilelcb k isòcr fe ac| krckz li ~dljd jf`xcllfi ~kz ifesijlfilin ~cgg= `krac jfijcirklfi&`krac xf~cr1 ucrljkg efrcjgfzsrc $`fz xrf`licig|likbc{skc siosibglin fe ic~fra kib zsxxg|,1 gkja fe `krac licnrklfi $lijgsblin gkja fercnsgkfr| fucrzlnd efr jrfzz-ofrbcr lzzscz,1 gkja fe rkizxkrcij|' xrljc efr`klfi'bf~izrck` `kracz' okgkijlin `kracz' kib gl{scelcb iksrkg nkz $GIN,) L jkggcb efr srncikjlfi li dc efggf~lin efsr krckz= $;, kjdlculin ceecjluc siosibglin fe ic~fra kib zsxxg|kjlullcz1 $?, rc`fulin rcnsgkfr| nkxz $li xkrljsgkr efr jrfzz-ofrbcr lzzscz,1 $:, kbbrczzlin`krac jfijcirklfi kib okrrlcrz f cir|1 kib $2, lijrckzlin rkizxkrcij| li `kracfxcrklfiz):2

Li xkrkggcg ~ld dc li{slr| dc Csrfxcki Jf``lzzlfi kgzf xsoglzdcb k jf``siljklfi fixrfzxcjz efr dc licrikg nkz kib cgcjrljl| `krac

:3

2)2 Lierkzrsjsrc kib cgcjrljl| ctjdkinc `kracz

li ~dljd l zc fs lz licilfizjfijcrilin rcnsgkfr| xrfxfzkgz f oc `kbc li frbcr f kbbrczz dc zdfrjf`linz sijfucrcbo| dc Li{slr| kib xrculfsz rcxfrz) Rdc Csrfxcki Jf``lzzlfi jfizlbcrz l icjczzkr| fkjagc ~f `kli cgc`ciz li dc efrdjf`lin dlrb gcnlzgkluc xkjaknc= $;, zrcindci dcxf~crz kib libcxcibcijc fe dc cicrn| rcnsgkfrz' f kggf~ efr dc xrfxcr kib ceeljlcircnsgklfi fe jrfzz-ofrbcr lzzscz rcgklin f nkz kib cgcjrljl| ic~fra kjjczz1 kib $?, xszdefr f~icrzdlx siosibglin' rcjfnil}lin dk dc gcnkg kib esijlfikg siosibglin fe ic~frafxcrkfrz dk krc ucrljkgg| licnrkcb ~ld xrfbsjlfi kib zsxxg| kjlullcz lz o| lzcge ifzseeljlci f cizsrc c{skg kjjczz f dc ic~fraz efr kgg zsxxglcrz)

Rf cizsrc dk licrjfiicjlul| kib k rckg cicrn| `krac ctlz k zc fe xrlfrl| xrfmcjz li dccicrn| zcjfr ~crc bcjlbcb li ; fe _cnsgklfi $CJ, If ;&?88: lif dc

Csrfxcki nkz kib cgcjrljl| zcjfrz $Elikg _cxfr,' JF@&?885&843; elikg' Orszzcgz' ;8 Mkiskr| ?88>):3 Jf``siljklfi erf` dc Jf``lzzlfi f dc Jfsijlg kib dc Csrfxcki Xkrglk`ci' Xrfzxcjz efr dc licrikgnkz kib cgcjrljl| `krac' JF@$?885, 42; elikg' Orszzcgz' ;8 Mkiskr| ?88>)


33/42

KBOL fralin Xkxcr ?,lz eklrg| jrlljkg fe dc zlsklfi' ~ld `ki| xrfmcjz oclin bcgk|cb sigczz dc lierkzrsjsrc lzli dc iklfikg licrcz) Rdcrc lz if gcnkg rc{slrc`ci f xrlfrll}c CS lierkzrsjsrcbcucgfx`ciz f iklfikg xrfmcjz) Kz k rczsg' l`xgc`ciklfi lz xkjd|) Licrjfiicjlul| lzncicrkgg| fig| bcucgfxcb kz k iklfikg cicrn| zcjsrl| okjasx' os if k rckg `kracctjdkinc) Fig| dc Ifrblj jfsirlcz dkuc zseeljlci jkxkjl| f oc jfizlbcrcb k rckgcgcjrljl| ctjdkinc `krac' li ~dljd cicrn| lz rkbcb erccg| ~ld ercc `krac xrljlin)


34/42

KBOL fralin Xkxcr ?)

dx=&&cj)csrfxk)cs&ci&cicrn|&zsblcz&bfj&?885V8


35/42

KBOL fralin Xkxcr ?

dx=&&cj)csrfxk)cs&ci&cicrn|&zsblcz&bfj&?885V8


36/42

KBOL fralin Xkxcr ?


37/42

KBOL fralin Xkxcr ?


38/42

KBOL fralin Xkxcr ?


39/42

KBOL fralin Xkxcr ?

Csrfxcki Jf``lzzlfi' ?88>) Cicrn| Jfrrlbfrz) Csrfxcki Silfi kib IclndofsrlinJfsirlcz' BN _czckrjd kib Blrcjfrkc Cicrn|' $CS_ ??34;,)

Csrfxcki Jf``lzzlfi) ?884) Ac| lzzscz fi dc l`xgc`ciklfi fe RCI-R xrlfrl| xrfmcjz)Liefr`kg Rrkizxfr Jfsijlg) 5 @k|) Orszzcgz= Csrfxcki Jf``lzzlfi)

Csrfxcki Jf``lzzlfi) ?8;8) RCIR= Xrlfrl| Xrfmcjz ?8;8) K Bcklgcb kikg|zlz' BN efr@folgl| kib Rrkizxfr' :; Bcj ?8;8) Orszzcgz= Csrfxcki Jf``lzzlfi)

Nlgglindk`' M) ;o) CS osbnc kib xfglj| rcefr`z li frbcr f xrf`fc cjfif`lj nrf~d)

LRXZ ~fralin bfjs`ci _?88>=8;3) ~~~)LRXZ)zcXcga`kiz' M) ?885) Csrfxcki Licnrklfi' @cdfbz kib Cjfif`lj Kikg|zlz) Dkrgf~' SA=

Elikijlkg Rl`cz Xrciljc Dkgg)

Z`ld' K)' kib X) ^dck) K {skilkluc zsb| fe rkli fxcrklin jf`xkilcz jfz kibceeljlcij| rcibz ;


40/42

KBOL fralin Xkxcr ?

Zfsrjc= Csrfxcki Jf``lzzlfi $?884o,' x)5

L`xgc`ciklfi fe xrlfrl| ktcz' jf`xgccb kib ctxcjcb

Xrlfrl| ktlz@Zz

liufgucb

Bkc zcefrjf`xgclf

i

Rfkgjfz li@ CS_

Liucz`ci ocefrc?88> li @

CS_

Rfkg

Rfkgjf``lcb ?88>-

?8;: li @

CS_

_c`klilin

liucz`ci li @

CS_ kecr?8;:

XX; _klg~k| ktlzOcrgli-Ucrfik&@lgki-Ofgfnik-Ikxcgz-@czzlik-Xkgcr`f

KR' LR' BC ?8?22>)832'5

;??):>8'3: ;2)?43'5: ;8):'8> :5'::

XX: Dlnd-zxccbrklg~k| ktlz fe zfsd-

~cz Csrfxc

CZ' E_'

XR

?8?838)535'5

4

;8)335'?8 ?5)>4?'53 ;:):;>'4:

XX2 Dlnd-zxccbrklg~k| ktlz ckz E_' BC ?8;: 3)?33'88 2)3?;'58 3>5'28 2):5;'88 2;3'28 8'88XX5 _klg~k| ktlzG|fi-Rrlczc-Blukjk&Afxcr& Blukjk-Gmsogmkik- Osbkxcz-Sarklilki ofrbcr

E_' DS'LR' ZG

?8?358)>2;')4?>'8: ;8)2?>'


41/42

KBOL fralin Xkxcr ?'88 8'88 8'88

XX;8 @kgxcizkKlrxfr $@lgki,$JF@XGCRCB,

LR ?88; ;):22'88 ;):22'88 8'88 8'88

XX;; rczsib eltcbglia $JF@XGCRCB,

BA' Z ?88; 2);34'88 2);34'88 8'88 8'88

XX;? Ifrblj rlkingcrklg~k|-rfkb ktlz

ELI' Z ?8;5;;)>25':

>2):52'28 3)>83':> ;)5>5'58

XX;: SA-Lrcgkib&Ocicgst rfkbktlz

L_G' SA ?8;3 >)3?5'22 :)?43'53 2)83>'48 ;4?' ;)>:?'4> 8'88

XX;5 Erclnd rklg~k|ktlz Zlicz&Kgncjlrkz-@kbrlb-Xkrlz

CZ' XR ?8?8 4)4>8'2

33)?:5':8 ::);4

XX?8 Ecd`kri Ocgrklg~k| ktlz BC' BA ?8;4 >)? ?)548'38 3)?;:'24

XX?? _klg~k| ktlzKdlik-Zfelk-Osbkxcz-Ulciik-Xrknsc-Iriocrn&Brczbci

KR' ON'J]' BC'N_' DS'

_F

?8?8;?)52;'4

8253':5 3)5;4'3? 5)33>'


42/42

KBOL fralin Xkxcr ? _klg Okgljk ktlz^krzk~-Aksikz-_lnk-Rkgglii-Dcgzlial

CC' GR'GU' XG

?8?8 :);

Date post:	07-Apr-2018
Category:	Documents
Upload:	adbi-publications
View:	227 times
Download:	0 times

Managing Multinational Infrastructure: An analysis of EU Institutional Structures and Best Practices

Documents