+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root...

Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root...

Date post: 23-Aug-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 3 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
26
Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root Inoculum in Red Raspberry L.W. DeVetter 1 , I. Zasada 2 , J. Weiland 2 , T. Walters 3 , R. Rudolph 4 , S. Watkinson 5 , Mark Mazzola 6, and Suzette Galinato 7 1 Assistant Professor, Small Fruit Horticulture, Washington State University Northwest Research Extension Center (WSU-NWREC) in Mt. Vernon, WA, 2 Research Plant Pathologists, USDA-HCR Unit in Corvallis, OR, 3 Agricultural Researcher, Walters Ag Research, Anacortes, WA, 4 Graduate Student, WSU-NWREC, 5 Scientific Technician, WSU-NWREC, 6 Research Plant Pathologist, USDA-TFR Unit in Wenatchee, WA, and 7 Economist, WSU School of Economic Sciences, Pullman, WA
Transcript
Page 1: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root Inoculum in Red Raspberry

L.W. DeVetter1, I. Zasada2, J. Weiland2, T. Walters3, R. Rudolph4, S. Watkinson5, Mark Mazzola6, and Suzette Galinato7

1Assistant Professor, Small Fruit Horticulture, Washington State University Northwest Research Extension Center (WSU-NWREC) in Mt. Vernon, WA,2Research Plant Pathologists, USDA-HCR Unit in Corvallis, OR,3Agricultural Researcher, Walters Ag Research, Anacortes, WA,

4Graduate Student, WSU-NWREC, 5Scientific Technician, WSU-NWREC,6Research Plant Pathologist, USDA-TFR Unit in Wenatchee, WA, and

7Economist, WSU School of Economic Sciences, Pullman, WA

Page 2: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Red Raspberries in Washington

Washington is the largest national producer of processed red raspberries In 2014, 73 million pounds of fruit

were harvested from 9,700 acres Valued at ~$60.9 million in 2014 Depending on year, 59-88% of total

US red raspberry acreage is in Washington

Source: NASS, 2015 and WRRC, 2015

Page 3: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Industry Challenges Fields that used to remain in

production for 15-20+ years are now being renovated and replanted every 5-8 years Land suitable for red raspberry is

limited, so production is often continuous and crop rotation seldom used Soils are typically fumigated prior to

replanting

Page 4: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Preplant fumigation in fall or spring Fumigants typically applied by commercial applicators Most fumigants are deep-shanked and injected into the soil

at depths of 12-18 inches; untarped Primary fumigant products: Telone® C-35 - 1,3-dichloropropene (63.4%) +

chloropicrin (34.7%) Vapam® - metam sodium (42%)

Soil Fumigation in Red Raspberry

Page 5: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Despite Fumigation, Soilborne Disease Management is Still a Major Challenge

for the Red Raspberry Industry

Changes in land management Loss of traditional soil fumigants Increasing restrictions on fumigant usage Application methods need optimization Concerns over soil quality, especially soil biology Poor understanding of “replant disease”

Page 6: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Phytophthora rubi Oomycete – “water molds” Causal agent of Phytophthora root rot Oospores and mycelia can persist in soils for

years Infection of root tissue damages root systems

Pratylenchus penetrans Root-lesion nematode Migratory endoparasite with broad host

range High populations can cause root dieback,

stunting, and increase the potential for synergistic disease complexes

Soilborne Pathogens and Pests

Image: forestpathology.cfans.umn.edu

Image: apsnet.org

Page 7: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

SFH Research Goals One of the primary goals of the Small Fruit

Horticulture (SFH) program is to develop improved horticultural tools for soilborne disease management in red raspberry Improved soilborne disease management is a shared

goal and offers excellent opportunity for collaboration

Diverse approach: Alternative fumigants and methods of fumigation Application and management of cover crops Improved understanding soil microbial ecology and

“replant disease” Removal of root and crown inoculum

Page 8: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Why Root and Crown Removal? Large amounts of root and

crown material remain in fields prior to fumigation and replanting Soil fumigants are unable to

penetrate undecomposed plant material Remaining plant material could

serve as a source of inoculum for soilborne diseases and pests

Page 9: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Plant Material Remaining in Field Prior to Fumigation

Page 10: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Goals of Root Removal Project

Short Term – Evaluate and demonstrate the efficacy of raspberry root inoculum removal as a pre-plant management technique for reducing soilborne pathogen and pest populations

Long Term – Develop practical tools for the integrated management of soilborne pathogens and pests

Two experiments

Page 11: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Experiment 1 Objective: Compare

three root removal devices for speed and efficacy of root removal in two commercial fields

Economic analysis with Mrs. Galinato

Devices tested includes: Lundby plant lifter Beach cleaner Potato harvester

Page 12: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Evaluated Tools for Raspberry Root Removal

Lundby Plant Lifter

Beach Cleaner Potato HarvesterVideo: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vnN0h8JrOA4

Page 13: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Experiment 1 - Results

Device Speed (mph)Percent of root

and crown material removedz

Plant lifter 0.25 98

Beach cleaner 0.37 91

Potatoharvester 1.0 96ZDetermined by measuring the amount of removed root/crown material within a 4 ft3 (0.1 m3) of soil.

Page 14: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Volume of Material Removed

Amount of root material removed (left) and remaining (right) in a 4 ft3 plot.

Page 15: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Experiment 2 Objective: Evaluate the

effects of root removal on:1) Populations of soilborne

pathogens and pests2) Raspberry plant growth,

development, and yields Initiated in a ‘Chemainus’

field replanted to ‘Meeker’ in Aug. 2014 in Whatcom County, WA

Page 16: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Experiment 2 – Approach Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using

Telone ® C-35 at 32 gal/acre Split plot: Root removal (with or without

removal, using a Lundby plant lifter) Replicated six times Main plots were 100 x 30 ft and the split plots

15 x 30 ft in size Data to be collected includes: changes in

soilborne disease (Fusarium and Pythium, proxies for P. rubi) and P. penetrans populations, plant growth, and yield

Page 17: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Experiment 2 – Preliminary Results

Changes in P. penetrans populations over time, 2015.Populations returned to pre-fumigation levels by Aug. 2015.

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

March April May June July Aug. Sept. Oct.

Pp/g

root

Month (2015)

Fum + Roots

Fum - Roots

Nonfum + Roots

Nonfum - Roots

Page 18: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Experiment 2 – Preliminary Results

Changes in Pythium populations as a result of root removal and fumigation treatments, 2015. Results similar for Fusarium.

a

aa

a

a

a

b

aa

a

a

b

Pretreatment PreplantPost treatment (6 weeks)

*Figure courtesy of Dr. Weiland

Page 19: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Experiment 2 – Preliminary Results

Changes in Fusarium populations in root material > 5 mm in diameter over time, 2015. Results similar for Pythium.

Pretreatment PreplantPost

treatment (6 weeks)

aa a

aa

*Figure courtesy of Dr. Weiland

Page 20: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

Fum + roots Fum - roots Nonfum + roots Nonfum - roots

Mea

n he

ight

(cm

)

Treatment

0

5

10

15

20

25

Fum + roots Fum - roots Nonfum + roots Nonfum - roots

Mea

n ca

ne n

o. h

ill

Treatment

Experiment 2 – Preliminary Results

No differences in cane number per hill nor cane height as of June 2015

Re-evaluate in 2016

a aa a

a a a a

Page 21: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Next Steps for Root Removal Projects

Continue monitoring Collect first set of yield data Repeat experiment in a

field site infested with P. rubi

Page 22: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Is composting a viable disposal

method for removed

root/crown material?

Root removal generates a

large amount of waste…

Page 23: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Composting Experiment Tissue culture ‘Meeker’ plants

were grown in compost, with and without roots

Removed roots were composted and screened for P. penetrans, Fusarium, and Pythium via a greenhouse bioassay

Composting reduced pests and pathogens to undetectable levels

Economic viability?

Page 24: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Thoughts Moving Forward…

Conventional fumigation = unsatisfactory results Concerns that overwintering cover crops may serve

as a bridge for P. penetrans Trials with biofumigants (Dominus®) and metam

sodium show promise New research funded by WSDA SCBG address

these timely concerns

Image: www.whatcom.wsu.edu

Page 25: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Acknowledgements Co-PIs: Inga Zasada, Jerry Weiland, Tom Walters,

Suzette Galinato, and Mark Mazzola Sean Watkinson, SFH Technician Chris Benedict, Whatcom County Extension Rachel Rudolph, Graduate Student Rachel Weber and Jack Pinkerton Grower cooperators, especially Jon Maberry and

Randy Honcoop Smit’s Compost Tim Purcell, Trident Agricultural Products Whatcom Farmers Co-op Northwest Center for Small Fruits Research

Page 26: Managing Soilborne Diseases Through Removal of Root ...whatcom.wsu.edu/ag/edu/sfc/documents/sfc2015/De... · Split plot experiment Main plot: Fumigation, with or without using Telone

Thank you for your attention!

Any questions?

Lisa Wasko DeVetter, PhDSmall Fruit Horticulture Program Washington State University NWRECEmail: [email protected]


Recommended