1
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 1
Mapping of SET-Plan Projects
An Update
2
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 2
Aim of Project Mapping
The Mapping of projects relevant to the SET-Plan was mandated by the Steering Group in October 2010 to:
Prioritise future efforts
Leverage on-going developments and knowledge at EU level
Facilitate joint programming
3
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 3
Current state
– Updated up to 2525thth October October
– Total questionnaires received: 262262 , budget: 5785 M€5785 M€
– Geographical coverage: 18 EU MSs + NO, IS and CH
– Increasing engagement:
• First submissions from FR and NL
• DE submission “Forschungsjahrbuch Erneuerbare Energien 2010”, but information does not contain all questionnaire fields
• DK contributed a large number (62) of (smaller) projects
– Analysis is ongoing
The filled in questionnaires are now online:
http://setis.ec.europa.eu/activities/project-mapping
4
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 4
Number of projectsreceived per EII - total: 262
SOLAR, 16
NUCLEAR, 26GRIDS, 16
WIND, 82
BIOENERGY, 35
CCS, 31
FCH2, 38
BIOENERGY BIOENERGY + FCH2 CCS CCS + BIOENERGY FCH2
GRIDS NUCLEAR SOLAR SOLAR-BIO SOLAR-GRIDS
WIND WIND-BIO WIND-GRIDS WIND-SOLAR-BIO WIND-SOLAR-GRIDS
5
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 5
Budget of projects received per EII – total: 5785 M€
NUCLEAR, 927
SOLAR, 155
WIND, 3211
BIOENERGY 446
CCS, 371
GRIDS, 217
FCH2, 295
BIOENERGY BIOENERGY + FCH2 CCS CCS + BIOENERGY FCH2
GRIDS NUCLEAR SOLAR SOLAR-BIO SOLAR-GRIDS
WIND WIND-BIO WIND-GRIDS WIND-SOLAR-BIO WIND-SOLAR-GRIDS
6
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 6
Number of projects per country
total: 262 projects
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
AT BE CH CZ DE DK EE EL ES FI FR IS IT NL NO PL PT RO SE SK UK
62
7
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 7
Budget per country total: 5785 M€
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
AT BE CH CZ DE DK EE EL ES FI FR IS IT NL NO PL PT RO SE SK UK
3031709
8
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 8
SET-Plan Project MappingResponses – Wind (excl. FP6/7 projects)
Country Number of projects
Budgets
(MEuro)
BE 8 2838.7
DK 44 67.1
EL 1 3.0
ES 5 146.6
FI 3 51.2
IT 1 6.5
NO 2 30.9
PT 2 20.1
SE 14 12.2
SK 1 1.1
UK 1 5.8
TOTAL 82 3183.2
• 1 project (Slovakia) is combined wind, solar & bioenergy.• 2 projects (Greece & Portugal) are combined wind, solar & grids.• The total budgets of these projects are equality divided among the technologies engaged.• 26 out of the 44 Danish projects & 9 out of the 14 Swedish projects are with the budget below the threshold (1M€)• Total budgets in wind is not changed significantly due to the small contribution of the new projects.
Wind Project Grouping (MEuro)
55.4, 2%
74.2, 2%
3053.6, 96% Onshore (18)
Offshore (31)
Other technologies(33)
9
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 9
Wind projects: Split per EII –IP activity
EII activity BE DE DK ES FI FR IT NO PT SE SK UK Ttl1.1 New WT, materials, components 2 2 20 3 6 3 12 1 1 501.2 Testing facilities 3 4 1 2 1 111.3 Mass production 1 2 1 42.1 Offshore - new structures 1 2 3 2 1 92.3 Tech from O&G 1 1 23.1 Grid – HVDC 1 1 23.2 System dynamics 1 2 1 1 53.3.1 Balancing 2 1 33.3.2 Market integration 2 1 2 54.1 Wind resources 1 12 1 1 1 1 174.2 Spatial planning 1 1 24.3 Public acceptance 1 1 2Total 7 4 45 13 10 1 3 11 1 15 1 1 112
10
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 10
SET-Plan Project MappingResponses – Bioenergy (excl. FP6/7 projects)
Country Number of projects
Budgets
(MEuro)
BE 2 14.4
ES 11 65.0
IT 14 16.0
NO 1 0.6
PL 2 34.7
SK 7 22.4
UK 4 304.9
TOTAL 41 458.0
• 4 projects (Spain) are combined bioenergy & CCS.• 1 project (Norway) is combined bioenergy & FCH2.
• 2 projects (Slovakia) are combined bioenergy & solar.• 1 project (Slovakia) is combined bioenergy, solar & wind.• The total budgets of these projects are equality divided among the technologies engaged.
Bioenergy Project Grouping (MEuro)
204.2, 44%
199.9, 44%
53.8, 12%Thermochemicalpathways (10 projects)
Biochemical pathways(19 projects)
Complementarymeasures & activities(12 projects)
11
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 11
Bioenergy Project Mapping: Split per EII IP activity
The classification presented here has been slightly changed & adapted from the implementation plan, which only involves activities in demonstration and flagship plants.
The total adds up to more than the total number of projects (41), because several projects are related to multiple activities in the implementation plan, hence these projects are counted more than once.
Country
Bioenergy EII activity BE ES IT NO PL SK UK Total*
Synthetic liquid fuels or hydrocarbons through gasification 1 1
Bio-synthetic gaseous fuels through gasification 1 2 2 5
CHP through thermochemical conversion (efficiency > 45%) 1 1 2 4
Bioenergy carriers through pyrolysis & torrefaction 1 1 2
Ethanol & higher alcohols from ligno-cellulosic feedstock 1 3 1 2 1 8
Hydrocarbons through synthesis from biomass 3 5 2 10
Bioenergy carriers by micro-organisms from CO2 & sunlight 3 3
Biomass feedstock for bioenergy 1 1 2
RD&D on emerging & innovative bioenergy value chains 1 4 1 3 9
Total activities* 2 10 14 1 6 7 4 44
12
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 12
SET-Plan Project MappingResponses – CCS (excl. FP6/7 projects)
Country Number of projects
Budgets
(MEuro)
CH 1 4.2
CZ 1 2.0
DE 6 110.0
ES 6 32.3
FI 1 20.0
IT 1 na
PL 1 4.2
PT 1 0.4
UK 10 58.2
TOTAL 27 231.0
• 4 projects (Spain) are combined CCS & bioenergy. 50% of their total budgets is allocated to CCS
• 1 project (Finland) deals with the whole CO2 chain (capture/transport/storage)
CCS Project Grouping (MEuro)
18.3, 8%
6.7, 3%
206.4, 89%
CO2capture/separation(24.7 projects)CO2 transport (0.7projects)
CO2 storage (1.7projects)
13
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 13
CCS Project Mapping: Split per EII IP activity
*The total adds up to more than the total number of projects (27), because several projects are related to multiple activities in the implementation plan, hence these projects are counted more than once.
Country
CCS EII activity CH CZ DE ES FI IT PL PT UK Total*
CCS Demonstration 1 1 1 3Capture
Pre-combustion 1 3 4Post-combustion 1 3 4 1 1 2 12Oxyfuel 1 2 1 1 5Compression 1 1Capture: generic 1 1
Transport 1 1Storage 1 1 1 1 1 5Policy/Regulatory 1 1 1 3Advanced fossil fuels 1 5 6
Total activities* 3 3 7 9 4 2 1 3 9
14
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 14
SET-Plan Project MappingResponses – FCH2 (excl. FP6/7 projects)
Country Number of projects
Budgets
(MEuro)
AT 1 4.8
BE 1 14.1
CH 1 5.0
DK 17 76.2
EE 1 1.2
FI 9 165.1
IS 1 3.0
IT 1 2.0
NO 3 5.6
PT 1 0.5
RO 2 15.2
TOTAL 38 292.7* 1 projects (Norway) is combined FCH2 & bioenergy. 50% of its total budget is allocated to FCH2.
Hydrogen & Fuel cells Project Grouping (MEuro)
37.7, 13%
254.9, 87%
Hydrogen (7 projects)
Fuel cells (31 projects)
15
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 15
SET-Plan Project MappingResponses – Solar (excl. FP6/7 projects)
Country Number of projects
Budgets
(MEuro)
BE 7 28.2
EL 1 3.0
ES 1 7.5
PT 4 93.0
SK 4 11.5
TOTAL 17 143.2
• 2 projects (Slovakia) are combined solar & bioenergy.• 1 project (Belgium) is combined solar & grids.• 1 project (Slovakia) is combined solar, bioenergy & wind.• 2 projects (Greece & Portugal) are combined solar, wind & grids.• The total budgets of these projects are equality divided among the technologies engaged.
Solar Project Grouping (MEuro)
49.2, 34%
94.0, 66%
PV (13 projects)
CSP (4 projects)
We have now info on ~ 40 projects from DE
16
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 16
Solar Project Mapping: Split per EII IP activity
Country
Solar energy EII activity BE EL ES PT SK Total*
Solar PVCost reduction
Advanced manufacture for cells & modules 2 2
Performance enhancement & lifetime extension 2 1 1 4
Materials development & sustainability 2 1 3
System integrationEnabling large scale deployment 2 1 1 1 5
Large scale PV power plants 320 20/80Solar resources & monitoring
Preparing for cost & penetration beyond 2020 levelsUltra low cost technologies 50 50-70% 60/40Very high efficiency approaches 50 70-90% 80/20Integration concepts for very high levels of penetration
Solar CSPDemonstration of innovative components 2Demonstration of innovative systems 1Demonstration of innovative configurations of plantsDemonstration of innovative concepts
Total activities* 8 1 1 4 3 17
17
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 17
SET-Plan Project MappingResponses – Grids (excl. FP6/7 projects)
Country Number of projects
Budgets
(MEuro)
BE 3 42.3
CZ 2 18.8
EL 1 3.0
ES 5 42.1
IT 2 93.5
PT 1 11.0
SK 2 7.8
TOTAL 16 221.6
Grids Projects Grouping (MEuro)
6.0, 3%
15.2, 7%
200.4, 90%
Transmission (3 projects)
Distribution (11 projects)
T&D (1 project)
•2 projects (EL + PT) are combined Wind-Solar-Grids. 33% of each budget is allocated to Grids.•1 project (BE) is combined Wind-Grids. 50% of the budget is allocated to Grids.
18
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 18
Number of Grid projects split per activity and country (1)
2.5 Joint task on IT system protocol and standards
113Total Transmission projects per country
1
ES
1RESPO
2.4 Improved defence and restoration plans
1Total T&D projects per country
2.1 Tools for improved system observability and market interactions
12.2 Integration of DSM in TSO
operation
2.3 Ancillary services by DSOs
1. Transmission networks
FREEGI activities BE CZ DE EL IT PT SKTot
projects addressi
ng activity
1.1 Pan EU grid architecture
1.2 Power technologies 41.3 Network management and control 2
1.4 Market rules 1
2. Coordination between T&D
2.5 Joint task on IT system protocol and standards
113Total Transmission projects per country
1
ES
1RESPO
2.4 Improved defence and restoration plans
1Total T&D projects per country
2.1 Tools for improved system observability and market interactions
12.2 Integration of DSM in TSO
operation
2.3 Ancillary services by DSOs
1. Transmission networks
FREEGI activities BE CZ DE EL IT PT SKTot
projects addressi
ng activity
1.1 Pan EU grid architecture
1.2 Power technologies 41.3 Network management and control 2
1.4 Market rules 1
2. Coordination between T&D
TWEN
TIES
PEG
ASE
GRID2025
AN
EMO
S.PL
US
ENERGOZ
FP projectsnational projects
19
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 19
Number of Grid projects split per activity and per country (2)
6SPARC3.6 Integration of EV and PHEV
3.7 Monitoring and control of LV networks
3.8 Automation and control of MV networks
3.9 Integration of methods and system support
3.10 Integration of integrated communication solutions
4
ES FREEGI activities BE CZ DE EL IT PT SKTot
projects addressi
ng activity
3. Distribution networks3.1 Smart Metering infrastructure 4
3.2 Smart metering data processing 4
3.3 DER hosting capacity of LV network 83.4 DER hosting capacity of MV
network 113.5 Integration of storage 7
Total distribution projects per country 3 1 1 3 2 2 2
6SPARC3.6 Integration of EV and PHEV
3.7 Monitoring and control of LV networks
3.8 Automation and control of MV networks
3.9 Integration of methods and system support
3.10 Integration of integrated communication solutions
4
ES FREEGI activities BE CZ DE EL IT PT SKTot
projects addressi
ng activity
3. Distribution networks3.1 Smart Metering infrastructure 4
3.2 Smart metering data processing 4
3.3 DER hosting capacity of LV network 83.4 DER hosting capacity of MV
network 113.5 Integration of storage 7
Total distribution projects per country 3 1 1 3 2 2 2
LIN
EA
RS
MA
RT
E
SM
AR
T R
EG
ION
G4V
MO
REM
ICR
OG
RID
SM
ER
GE S
MA
RT
CIT
Y
DENISE
STORE
PO
I
9 PILOT INO
VG
RID
REI
VE
ITM
SEN
ERG
OZ
S2G
GR
EE
N I
SL
AN
D
FP projects ERDF projectsnational projects
20
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 20
Ongoing efforts in EGII projects mapping
Distribution projects (AIT-Austria Institute of Technology)
•Collection of information on national Distribution projects (240)
Transmission projects (ENTSOE)
•Collection of information on Transmission projects (40)
JRC Smart Grid Pilot Projects Catalogue:•Collection of information on Smart Grid pilot projects (260)
•Projects mapped according to Smart Grid functionalities (EPRI methodology)
21
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 21
SET-Plan Project MappingResponses – Nuclear (excl. FP6/7 projects*)
Country Number of
projects
Allocated Budgets(MEuro)
BE* 1 60.0
CZ 1 na
FR* 1 650.0
IT 2 8.8
SE 1 5.0
TOTAL 6 723.8
* MYRRHA (FR) and ASTRID (BE) projects have been included since FP7 contribution is minor
** SUSEN project has been approved by national government, but approval by EC is pending
Nuclear Projects Grouping (MEuro)
Sodium Fast Reactors(SFR)
(1 project)90%
Lead cooled Fast Reactors
(LFR) (4 projects)
10%
Sodium Fast Reactors(SFR) (1 project)
Lead cooled Fast Reactors (LFR) (4 projects)
22
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 22
ESNII Project Mapping: Split per ESNII IP activity
*The total adds up to more than the total number of projects (8), because several projects are related to multiple activities in the implementation plan, hence these projects are counted more than once.
23
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 23
Mapping of SET-Plan Projects
The way forward
24
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 24
Formalisation of the role of actors
SETIS
Sherpas
distribute questionnaire
NationalPOs
ECPOs
data/ information input
SETIS
data/ information, analysis
Sherpas, SG
EIITeams
25
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 25
Rationale:
A simplified questionnaire was requested by the Steering Group in the last meeting
Better identify synergies & gaps between the EIIs Implementation Plans & National projects
Extract information in a more efficient way Simplify input and reduce workload of reporting
actors Facilitate analysis for purpose by SETIS
Development of a new questionnaire
26
SETIS _STEERING GROUP _27102011_Mapping 26
Online (SETIS website) implementation:
Registration system with username and password
Multiple choices possible
Tick-off related priority activities and KPIs in the relevant
EII implementation plans (via drop-down menus)
User can extract information from the project database
Registered users receive alerts when new projects added
Available by end November 2011
New questionnaire/tool