+ All Categories
Home > Documents > May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi...

May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi...

Date post: 05-Jan-2016
Category:
Upload: ralf-summers
View: 213 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
Popular Tags:
37
May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotla nd 1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski, Katarzyna Stankiewicz, Brain Davis, John G. Breslin
Transcript
Page 1: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 1

Trust Models for Community-aware

Identity Management

Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski, Katarzyna Stankiewicz,

Brain Davis, John G. Breslin

Page 2: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 2

Identity

on the Web

Page 3: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 3

Personal Identity

on the Web

Page 4: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 4

Personal Identity

• Account– Blog– Email– Community sites

• Flickr• Orkut

Page 5: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 5

One URI per one thing

Page 6: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 6

One identity per one person

Page 7: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 7

Reason of multiple identities

• Writers want to use a pen name• People like to grumble on the web• Makes feel free to write

People want to use

Page 8: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 8

Reason of multiple identities

• People want to know one subjectnot whole people

People don’t need unique identity

Page 9: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 9

What is the problem?

Page 10: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 10

Identity crisis

*Sorry, I lost the sources of images

Page 11: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 11

To solve personal identity crisis

Objective

Page 12: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 12

What is the important thingto analyze identity?

Page 13: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 13

Link

From: http://www.xarxanet.org/xarxanet/novetatsDetall.xarxanet? xnt_locale=ca&xnt_portal=1&nov_novetatId=26947Page Rank

Page 14: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 14

For the personal identity

Page 15: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 15

Links

In conflict

Father Master

Page 16: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 16

Trust

• Meta-link to make links• Can be propagated

Trust Trust

Trust

Page 17: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 17

Trust

• Meta-link to make links• Can be propagated

Love Love

Love

Trust

Page 18: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 18

Give a better model of trustamong the people

Method

Page 19: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 19

Trust model of FOAF

Trust Level 1

Trust Level 2

Page 20: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 20

Rated relationship model

Trust Value: 0.9 * 0.4 = 0.36Trust Level: 2

Page 21: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 21

FilmTrust (related research)

FilmTrust: http://trust.mindswap.org/FilmTrust

Page 22: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 22

Complex situation

Page 23: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 23

Layered model

Page 24: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 24

Person don’t need to make multiple identities

Page 25: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 25

Layered model

Page 26: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 26

Person need to keep one identity

Page 27: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 27

Benefits

• Solve identity crisis by unique identity

• Improve propagation of information• Massage filtering and ordering

Page 28: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 28

FOAFRealm

• Single-sign-on system• Based on FOAF and RDF storage• P2P/HyperCuP infrastructure• Semantic Social Collaborative

Filtering

Page 29: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 29

Bended model

Page 30: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 30

Multiple dimension

Page 31: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 31

Future work

• Fast calculation algorithm of delegated trust

without privacy problem• How to figure out the layers?• Find meaning of conjunction

among the several layers

Page 32: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 32

Thank [email protected]

Page 33: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 33

Backup slides

Page 34: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 34

Capturing trust on the web

• Machine-driven approaches– PageRank or eBay reputation system– Calculated as an analogy

• User-driven approaches– PGP, FOAFRealm– Needs efforts of user

• Hybrid approaches

Page 35: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 35

My identities on web

Privacy data and life log

For writing

For friends

For research

Page 36: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 36

Free to make a new identity

Page 37: May 23, 2006IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland1 Trust Models for Community-aware Identity Management Choi Hee Chul, Sebastian Ryszard Kruk, Slawomir Grzonkowski,

May 23, 2006 IRW2006 Edinburgh, Scotland 37

Cannot be blocked


Recommended