+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Measurements and Flow Analysis the of a Radial Turbine › journals › ijrm › 1997 ›...

Measurements and Flow Analysis the of a Radial Turbine › journals › ijrm › 1997 ›...

Date post: 26-Jan-2021
Category:
Upload: others
View: 1 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
15
International Journal of Rotating Machine O’ 1997, Vol. 3, No. 2, pp. 93-105 Reprints available directly from the publisher Photocopying permitted by license only (C) 1997 OPA (Overseas Publishers Association) Amsterdam B.V. Published in The Netherlands under license by Gordon and Breach Science Publishers Printed in Singapore Flow Measurements and Flow Analysis in the Exit Region of a Radial Turbine D. M. MURUGAN*, W. TABAKOFF* and A. HAMED Department of Aerospace Engineering and Engineering Mechanics, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, Ohio, U.S.A (Received April 1996; In final form 2 May 1996) Three-dimensional flow measurements using LDV system were obtained in the exit region of a radial inflow turbine at an off-design operating condition. The measurements reveal a complex flow pattern near the tip region at the rotor exit due to the interaction of the tip clearance flow. The effect of the rotor on the exit flow field is observed in the proximity of the rotor exit. Steady axisymmetric, compressible, turbulent flow computations with a two equation turbulence model were performed using the PARC code for the meridional flow in the radial turbine exit region. The computational results obtained in the meridional plane are compared with the experimental results, which are correlated to the rotor blade rotation in the exit region of the radial turbine. A version of this paper was presented at the 30th AIAA/ASME/SAE/ASEE Joint Propul- sion Conference, Indianapolis, Indiana, Paper no. AIAA-94-3075. Keywords: Turbomachinery, Turbomachinery Flows, Radial Turbomachinery, Radial Turbines, Radial Turbine Exit Flows, Radial Turbine Exit Flow Measurements and Flow Analysis. INTRODUCTION The increasing applications of the radial turbines ne- cessitate better understanding of the flow behavior in order to optimize the design and minimize the losses. As part of an on-going research program on radial inflow turbine at the University of Cincinnati, Malak et al. [1986] measured the detailed flow field in the scroll cross-sections of a radial turbine using LDV system. Eroglu and Tabakoff [1989] investigated the flow field in the nozzle guide vane and Lakshmi- narasimha et al. [1989] reported the flow measure- ments in the vaneless free vortex region. All these investigations were performed without the rotor, which was replaced by an aluminum body of revolu- tion. Recently Pasin and Tabakoff [1992] investigated *Corresponding author. *Currently Project Engineer, EASi Engineering, 30800 Telegraph Road, Suite 3700, Bingham Farms, MI 48025., Graduate Research Assistant. 93
Transcript
  • International Journal of Rotating MachineO’1997, Vol. 3, No. 2, pp. 93-105Reprints available directly from the publisherPhotocopying permitted by license only

    (C) 1997 OPA (Overseas Publishers Association)Amsterdam B.V. Published in The Netherlands

    under license by Gordon and Breach Science PublishersPrinted in Singapore

    Flow Measurements and Flow Analysis in the ExitRegion of a Radial Turbine

    D. M. MURUGAN*, W. TABAKOFF* and A. HAMED

    Department ofAerospace Engineering and Engineering Mechanics, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, Ohio, U.S.A

    (Received April 1996; In final form 2 May 1996)

    Three-dimensional flow measurements using LDV system were obtained in the exit region ofa radial inflow turbine at an off-design operating condition. The measurements reveal acomplex flow pattern near the tip region at the rotor exit due to the interaction of the tipclearance flow. The effect of the rotor on the exit flow field is observed in the proximity ofthe rotor exit. Steady axisymmetric, compressible, turbulent flow computations with a twoequation turbulence model were performed using the PARC code for the meridional flow inthe radial turbine exit region. The computational results obtained in the meridional plane arecompared with the experimental results, which are correlated to the rotor blade rotation inthe exit region of the radial turbine.A version of this paper was presented at the 30th AIAA/ASME/SAE/ASEE Joint Propul-

    sion Conference, Indianapolis, Indiana, Paper no. AIAA-94-3075.

    Keywords: Turbomachinery, Turbomachinery Flows, Radial Turbomachinery, Radial Turbines, RadialTurbine Exit Flows, Radial Turbine Exit Flow Measurements and Flow Analysis.

    INTRODUCTION

    The increasing applications of the radial turbines ne-cessitate better understanding of the flow behavior inorder to optimize the design and minimize the losses.As part of an on-going research program on radialinflow turbine at the University of Cincinnati, Malaket al. [1986] measured the detailed flow field in the

    scroll cross-sections of a radial turbine using LDVsystem. Eroglu and Tabakoff [1989] investigated theflow field in the nozzle guide vane and Lakshmi-narasimha et al. [1989] reported the flow measure-ments in the vaneless free vortex region. All these

    investigations were performed without the rotor,which was replaced by an aluminum body of revolu-tion. Recently Pasin and Tabakoff [1992] investigated

    *Corresponding author.

    *Currently Project Engineer, EASi Engineering, 30800 Telegraph Road, Suite 3700, Bingham Farms, MI 48025., Graduate ResearchAssistant.

    93

  • 94 D. M. MURUGAN et al.

    the flow field inside the inlet guide vanes of the radialinflow turbine with the rotor. They observed the pe-riodicity of the flow field in the inlet guide vane pas-sages with the rotor revolution. Later, Pasin andTabakoff [1993] performed flow measurements insidethe rotor of the radial turbine.The radial turbine exit flow field has been studied

    by some investigators such as Kof,(key et al. [1972],Mclallin et al. [1980] and Szewczuk [1989]. Re-searchers like Rohlik et al. [1970] and Japikse et al.[1979] have reported in detail the performance of ra-dial turbine exhaust diffusers. Zangeneh et al. [1988]compared the flow measurements and three-dimen-sional viscous computations of the flow field in. a lowspeed radial inflow turbine including the turbine exitregion. Kitson [1992] performed a detailed assess-ment of the various computational methods for theaerodynamic investigation of radial turbines.

    In the present investigation, detailed flow measure-ments were obtained in the region downstream of aradial inflow turbine rotor at off-design condition us-ing a three component Laser Doppler Velocimeter sys-tem and the measured flow velocities are correlated tovarious rotor blade positions. The results are examinedto reveal the influence of swirl and turbulence on theradial inflow turbine exit flow field and associatedlosses. A limited numerical simulation was performedusing the axisymmetric, compressible, turbulent vis-cous code, PARC with k- turbulence model in themeridional plane of the turbine exit region.

    MAIN TEXT

    Test Rig and Instrumentation

    Referring to Fig. 1, the experimental set-up consistsof the test turbine, the 3-dimensional LDV & Dataacquisition systems and the air supply systems.

    Radial Turbine and Laser Window

    The test turbine is shown schematically in Fig. 2. Thescroll has a nearly square cross-section, followed by

    18 slightly cambered inlet guide vanes. Details on thescroll and the guide vanes can be found in the refer-ences by Malak et al. [1986] and Pasin et al. [1992].The rotor has an inlet radius of 81.8 mm (3.22"). Theexit hub and tip radii are 22.1 mm (0.87") and 43.2 mm(1.7") respectively. The rotor has 8 full blades and 8splitter blades. The rotor blade span at the inlet and atthe exit are 12.7 mm (0.50") and 21.1 mm (0.83") re-spectively. The rotor does not incorporate an exducerand so the rotor blades are axially straight at the exit.The exit duct wall has an inner radius of 44.5 mm(1.75"). The rotor hub at the exit of the rotor issmoothly shaped to guide the flow into the exit duct.

    In order to have access for the laser beams, a mea-surement window made out of 1.3 mm (0.05") thickLexan material, was fixed on the turbine exit duct sothat it follows the curvature of the duct wall. Detailed

    descriptions on the selection of this window materialcan be found in the reference by Murugan et al.1994].

    LDV System

    The measurements were accomplished with a threecomponent LDV system as shown in Fig. 1. The op-tics for the three component LDV were arranged inoff-axis backward scatter mode. Blue and Green com-ponents were used to measure the horizontal and ver-tical velocity components respectively, while the pur-ple component was used to measure the non-orthog-onal velocity component that is inclined at 30 to theblue component in the same plane. The focal lengthof the transmitting lenses was 480 mm. Beam ex-panders were used to reduce the measuring volumediameter 3.75 times and to improve the signal-to-noise ratio. Frequency shifters were used to identifythe flow direction and to reduce the fringe bias. Theentire LDV system with the bread-board wasmounted on a milling machine table, which cantraverse 254 mm, 457.2 mm and 558.8 mm in theaxial (longitudinal), transverse and vertical directionsrespectively with an accuracy of 0.025 mm (0.001")in all the three directions. The characteristics of theLDV system used are summarized in Table I. A com-mercial six-jet atomizer, TSI 9306 model was used to

  • FLOW AT EXIT OF A RADIAL TURBINE 95

    CU) T$[ tSg9 Rolry

    CUD inrce Nl-ggO

    (13) ZN PC/48

    (14) St-e=od

    (15) Rd Turbe

    To 14

    FIGURE The LDV system and the test rig.

    seed the flow with propylene glycol particles of 2 ommean diameter. The atomizer is capable of generatingparticle concentrations of l0s particles/cm3. The at-

    omizer was connected to the bottom of the settlingchamber through which the air enters into the turbineas shown in Fig. 1.

  • 96 D. M. MURUGAN et al.

    Cr’05 5eC;OI AA

    FIGURE 2 Sketch of the test turbine configuration.

    Data Acquisition System

    Three counter type signal processors (TSI Model1990) and a rotary encoder (model TS! 1999) wereused in the data acquisition. The signal processorssend the processed data to a TSI MI-990 multi-chan-nel interface, which is housed in one of the proces-sors. Also, the MI-990 receives the rotor blade posi-tion information from the rotary encoder at the timeof each velocity data measurement. The combineddata are then sent from the MI-990 to an IBM P/Cthrough an IBM 6260 DMA card.

    horizontal, vertical and axial (on-axis) components ofthe velocity were then transformed vectorially by theangle of inclination of the test rig to get the tangen-tial, radial and axial components of the velocity in theexit duct. The mean ensemble averaged value of eachcomponent velocity is defined as:

    Nii

    U,/- N;,i(2)

    where N, is the number of velocity data at the mea-surement location ’i’ for the rotor position ’j’ In asimilar way, the variance of the corresponding veloc-ity component for the same rotor position ’j’ at themeasurement location ’i’ is defined as follows"

    Ni,i

    Z (Ui,i,k Ui,i)0

    k=l(3)

    --N:,i-

    where 0",.i is the standard deviation or the turbulencelevel of the corresponding velocity component.

    Measurement Errors

    Measurement Technique

    In the test facility, it was possible to rotate the turbinerig about its inlet duct axis to a convenient angle inorder to gain access into the exit region of the rotor aswell as to synchronize the rotary shaft-angle encoder.From the directly measured velocity components, theorthogonal on-axis component was calculatedthrough the following transformation relation:

    Like other measurement techniques, the LDV mea-surement introduces some fixed bias errors, called

    systematic uncertainties as well as some random er-rors, called statistical uncertainties. The statistical un-certainties in the measured mean velocities were es-timated using the procedures described by Snyder etal. [1981, 1984]. The uncertainty interval of a mea-sured quantity can be related to the sample size asfollows (Snyder et al. [1984]):

    VbCOS 0 gpw ()sin 0

    ZSltAU= + (4)

    where gb and gp are the horizontal (blue) and non-orthogonal (purple) components of velocity respec-tively and 0 is the inclination angle between the twooptical trains. Due to the access constraints into thetest rig, the angle, 0 was set to 30. The measured

    where S is an estimate for the true standard devia-tion and N is the sample size. The value of z is 1.96for 95% confidence level. Based on this statisticalanalysis, the data sample size for each angular posi-tion of the rotor blade was determined to be 400.

  • FLOW AT EXIT OF A RADIAL TURBINE

    TABLE LDV characteristics

    97

    Characteristics Blue Green Purple

    Wavelength inFringe Spacing inDiameter of measuring w)lume at e intensity location in mmLength of measuring w)lume at e -2 intensity location in mmNumber of stationary fl’inges

    0.488 0.5145 0.47652.851 3.0 2.7840.053 0.056 0.0520.617 0.651 0.60319 19 19

    With this sample size, the statistical uncertainty in thetotal velocity was found to be +2.5% and the uncer-tainty in the flow angle (o,.,) was found to be +3close to the rotor exit near blade mid span. The sys-tematic uncertainties were also calculated as de-scribed by Snyder et al. [1981]. A summary of therelative uncertainties associated with the measure-ments are given in Table II.

    TABLE II Systematic measurement uncertainties

    Longitudinal, transverse & verticaltraverses

    Optical axis or turbine rig angular orientationHorizontal Velocity Component (AUb/UVertical Velocity Component (AUJUg,10On-axis Velocity Component (AW/Wm)

    ___0.025 mm (0.001")

    +_0.5__1.63%___1.63%

    +_ 12.92% (qb 0)+_ 11.87% (4, 45)+_3.86% (qb 90)

    Numerical Analysis

    A limited numerical simulation of the flow field in themeridional plane of the radial turbine exit region hasbeen performed neglecting the tip-clearance flow andthe rotor rotational effect. The flow field simulationsare based on the implicit solution of the compressibleNavier-Stokes equations in the strong conservationform and general curvilinear coordinates. The steady,axisymmetric, compressible, turbulent viscous code,"PARC" [19891 with the two-equation k-e turbulencemodel was used in the computation of the flow field.This code uses the Beam and Warming scheme mod-ified with the diagonalized algorithm for the solutionof the governing equations. The PARC code has been

    extensively used with good success to solve propul-sion inlet and exhaust nozzle problems. Fig. 3 showsthe grid structure for the flow field in the tested radialturbine exit region configuration. Referring to Fig. 3,a total of 7701 grid points were used in the flow fielddiscretization with a 151 51 mesh. A two-dimen-sional poisson grid generation scheme with gridstretching was used to maintain the y+ value of thenear wall grid point less than 2.0, thus ensuring atleast 20 grid points in the boundary layer along allsolid wall boundaries. The measured total pressureand temperature were given as the initial conditionsat inlet to the exit duct. During the simulation, theexit static pressure was controlled to obtain the samemass flow as that of the experiment. The rest of the

    Mesh 151x51

    Exit Duct Wall (Acliabatic Wall-No Slip)

    Rotor Hub(AdiabaticWall-No Slip)

    Exit Duct Centerline (Axis of Symmetry)

    FIGURE 3 Computational mes,h of the exit duct and boundary conditions

    Exit

    (P, .T}

  • 98 D. M. MURUGAN et al.

    FIGURE 4 Sketch showing the radial turbine exit and the mea-surement zone.

    boundary conditions used in the simulation of theflow field are given in Fig. 3. The computations re-quired approximately 20,000 iterations at 0.4 CFLnumber to converge to steady state solution. The cri-teria for convergence were that the order of magni-tude reductions in the averaged root mean square er-ror of the flux be 9 times and the order of magnitudereductions in the percentage local maximum error ofthe density be 4 times.

    Results and Discussion

    Experimental Results

    Referring to Fig. 4, the LDV measurements down-stream of the radial turbine rotor were obtained in thecross-sectional planes (A, B and C) and also in themeridional plane. Fig. 4a shows three-dimensionalsketch of the turbine exit region with the measure-ment cross-sectional planes. All the experimental re-sults reported in this paper were obtained at a con-stant mass flow rate of 0.055 kg/s (0.121 lb/s) and aconstant turbine speed of 1000 rpm. The Reynoldsnumber and the Mach number were 0.564 105 and0.04 respectively based on cold air properties at

    Rotor blade at exit

    Cross-sectlon

    FIGURE 4A Three-dimensional sketch of the measurement cross-sections.

    21.1C (70F), the mean diameter at the rotor exit,and the time and passage averaged absolute velocityat the rotor exit (which was 12.2 m/s for the testedconditions). The results are presented as vector andcontour plots of the measured parameters in thecross-sectional planes A, B and C as well as in themeridional plane. The notations of the measuredmean flow velocity directions and flow angles areshown in Fig. 5. The mean velocity components pre-sented in the plots are the absolute velocity compo-nents in the tangential, radial and axial directionsfrom mid-passage to mid-passage, covering one rotorblade passage.The results obtained in the first cross-section A,

    which is located at 2.54 mm (0.1") downstream of therotor exit are explained in this paragraph. Accordingto the tangential velocity contour plot, shown in Fig.6(a), the tangential velocities of the fluid exitingalong the pressure surface are higher compared tothose along the suction surface. Near the tip region,gross under turning of the flow is observed at the exitof this exducerless radial turbine and hence the de-gree of swirl is very high near the tip region. This

    FIGURE 5 Flow velocity vectors and flow angle notations.

  • FLOW AT EXIT OF A RADIAL TURBINE 99

    Exit Ouct Woll

    Rotor Hub

    FIGURE 6(A) Tangential velocity contours (U, m/s) [cross-section A].

    Exit Duct Woll

    FIGURE 6(B) Radial velocity contours (U,. m/s) [cross-sectionA].

    observation is in good agreement with the results ofKitson [1992]. The work extracted from the fluid asdetermined from the velocity triangles at the rotorinlet and exit leads to the fact that the high degree ofswirl near the tip region drastically reduces the workloading in that region and is hence detrimental to theoverall performance. The radial velocity contours,presented in Fig. 6(b), show that there is a generalradially inward movement (towards the rotor hub) ofthe flow due to the loss of the centrifugal force as theflow leaves the rotor. This phenomenon is also re-ported by Kitson [1992]. The radial velocities aregenerally low throughout the cross-section exceptnear the pressure surface tip corner region, whichmay be due to the possible increased interaction ofthe tip clearance flow with the main flow. It is possi-ble that the mixing of the tip clearance flow with themain flow is enhanced near the pressure surface sincethe streamwise momentum of the flow near the pres-sure surface is low, which is also evidently seen inthe mean velocity vector plot in the meridional planealong pressure surface in Fig. 9(a). The axial velocitycontours are shown in Fig. 6(c) and they are higheralong the suction surface than those along the pres-sure surface.

    Exit Duct Woll

    Rotor Hub

    FIGURE 6(c) Axial velocity contours (U m/s) [cross-sectionA].

    The next set of results, Fig. 7(a) through Fig. 7(c),were obtained at the cross-section B, which is locatedat 7.62 mm (0.3") downstream of the rotor exit. Thetangential velocity contours, shown in Fig. 7(a) ex-hibit no significant variation from the pressure side tothe suction side. This indicates that the flow behind

  • 100 D. M. MURUGAN et al.

    E:xit Ouct WotlExit Duct

    Rotor Hub

    FIGURE 7(A) Tangential velocity contours (U m/s) [cross-section B]. FIGURE 7()

    B].

    Rotor Hub

    Radial velocity contours (U,. m/s) [cross-section

    Exit Duct Woll

    Rotor Hub

    FIGURE 7(c) Axial velocity contours (U m/s) [Cross-SectionB].

    the trailing edge of the rotor blade is completelymixed at this station. In addition, the tangential ve-locities are reduced compared to their values at cross-section A. The radial velocity contours, shown in Fig.7(b) are generally low in the upper half but higher in

    the lower half of the cross-section, where the flowstarts to turn radially inward near the hub-end (seealso Fig. 4). The axial velocity contours, shown inFig. 7(c), indicate they are mostly uniform except insmall zones near the tip along the suction surface.The results of the cross-section C, which is located

    at 15.24 mm (0.6") downstream of the rotor exit areexplained in this paragraph. The tangential velocitiesfor this cross-sectional plane are shown in Fig. 8(a).They are almost uniform along the tangential direc-tion at each radial location and the levels of the tan-gential velocities are less than those of the cross-sec-tion B. Comparing the tangential velocity contourplots of the three cross-sections, it can be noted thatthe degree of swirl decreases in the downstream di-rection. The radial velocity contours, shown in Fig.8(b), are generally low throughout the cross-section.The radial velocities near the hub along mid-passageare slightly negative due to the wake behind the hub-end. The wake generated behind the hub-end blocksthe flow near the duct centerline and deflects the mainflow slightly in the radially outward direction. Theaxial velocity contours as shown in Fig. 8(c) indicateslightly higher values just above the hub.

  • FLOW AT EXIT OF A RADIAL TURBINE 101

    Exit Ouct Exit Duct Wall

    FIGURE 8(A)section C].

    Rotor Hub

    Tangential velocity contours (U m/s) lcross-

    Exit Duct Woll

    G

    FIGURE 8(c)C].

    Rotor Hub

    Axial velocity contours (U, m/s) [cross-section

    Rotor Hub

    FIGURE 8(u) Radial velocity contours (U,.- m/s) [cross-sectionCl.

    The measured meridional flow velocity vectors forthree different rotor blade positions are presented inFigures 9(a) through 9(c). Fig. 9(a) shows the merid-ional velocity vector plot in a plane aligned with theblade pressure surface. Due to the low meridionalvelocities near the pressure surface, it is possible forthe tip clearance flow to penetrate deep in the radialdirection and mix with main flow near the tip region.The meridional velocity vector plot in a plane alignedwith the rotor mid-passage is shown in Fig. 9(b). Themeridional velocity vectors in a plane aligned withthe blade suction surface are shown in Fig. 9(c).Comparing Figures 9(b) and 9(c) with Fig. 9(a), onecan observe the reduced influence of the tip clearanceflow at the times of passing of the rotor mid-passageand the blade suction surface.From the three Figures 9(a) through 9(c), we can

    conclude that the flow field near the rotor exit ishighly complex due to the interaction of the tip clear-ance flow, the wake region behind the hub-end andthe boundary layer development on the duct wall.The exit flow velocities increase in the mid-region

  • 102 D. M. MURUGAN et al.

    Exit Ducl Wall\\

    Rotor \ul)

    Exit Duct Centerllne

    FIGURE 9(A) Vector plot of mean velocity in the meridionalplane [along pressure surface].

    Exit Duet Wall ton,t,

    Exit Duct Centertlne

    FIGURE 9(c) Vector plot of mean velocity in the meridionalplane [along suction surface].

    due to the blockage caused by the wake region be-hind the hub-end and the boundary layer on the ductwall. Figures 9(a) through 9(c) indicate that the rotor

    O’

    Exit Ouct Wall o rn/s

    Hub

    Exit Duet Conterllne

    FIGURE 9() Vector plot of mean velocity in the meridionalplane [along mid-passage].

    blade influence diminishes further downstream of thestraight portion of the hub, alter which the flow fieldis similar for all rotor blade positions.

    Computational Results and Comparison

    The computed axisymmetric flow field vector plot,obtained from the PARC code in the turbine exit re-gion near the rotor exit, is shown in Fig. 10. In thisfigure, the separation behind the rotor hub is clearlycaptured. However, the effects of the tip clearanceflow and the rotor rotation were not simulated in thepredictions.The computational results are compared with the

    experimental measurements obtained in the meridi-onal plane along mid-passage, since it exhibits theleast influence.of the rotor blade. In the figures l(a)and 11 (b), it can be seen that with regard to the pointof separation on the hub end, the agreement betweenthe experiment and the numerical results is poor. Thiscan be due to the fact that the rotation of the rotorhub is neglected in the analysis. The rotation of therotor hub can cause more turbulence in the flow fieldaround it and this increased turbulence could be the

  • FLOW AT EXIT OF A RADIAL TURBINE 103

    1.8

    1.6

    1.4

    1.2

    .0

    O.B

    0.6

    0.4

    0.2

    0.00.0

    Exit Duct Wall

    Rotor Hub

    0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0

    Axial Distance, z (inches)

    FIGURE 10 Vector plot of the flow field in the meridional plane[computational].

    reason for the delayed separation on the hub-end asobtained in the experiment. On the other hand, thepredicted and experimental reattachment points ofseparation behind the hub end are nearly at the samelocation, approximately 1.2" from the rotor bladeexit. Hence, the prediction of the reattachment pointof this separation agrees very well with that of theexperiment. Good agreement between the experiment

    1.8 -- Exit Duct Wall1.6 ;-1.41.20.6

    0,4

    0.2

    0.00.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0

    Axial Di=tance, z (inches]

    FIGURE 11(A) Streamline plot of the flow field in the meridionalplane [computational].

    and the prediction also exists, as far as the accelera-tion of the flow in the mid region just above the endof the straight portion of the rotor hub.

    PRACTICAL IMPORTANCE

    An unresolved problem that is still encountered bythe designers is the relatively high loss region nearthe shroud at the exit plane of the radial turbine rotor.This high loss region, which also corresponds to theregion of high swirl, is further worsened under off-design conditions. The swirl and the turbulence in theexit flow field can significantly contribute to the gen-eration of noise and vibration of the unit. This inves-

    tigation identifies the radial turbine exit loss produc-ing mechanisms, namely the high-swirl flow near therotor tip, the mixing patterns of the tip clearance flowand the wake behind the rotor hub. The results of thisand the preceding (Pasin and Tabakoff [1993]) exper-imental investigations inside and downstream of theradial turbine rotor conducted at an off-design condi-tion provide a database for validating three-dimen-sional turbomachinery CFD codes. The limited com-putational investigation of this work helps us to un-

    I.I

    f.I

    1.4

    0.2

    -_ -_-_-_ -_ -_ Z

    Rotor

    i0.1 ’1.0 .IAxt|I Dl|tene,. (In Inohea)

    FIGURE 11() Vector plot of the flow field in the meridionalplane [experimental] [Along Mid-Passage].

  • 104 D. M. MURUGAN et al.

    derstand the effect of the wake behind the rotor huband its interaction with the turbine exit flow field.However, more detailed, three-dimensional computa-tional studies should be undertaken in order toachieve good prediction of the highly complex flowfield inside and at the exit of a radial turbine.

    CONCLUSIONS

    An experimental investigation and limited analysis ofthe exit flow field of a radial turbine were conductedat off-design condition. The flow field in the immedi-ate vicinity of the rotor tip is influenced by the tipclearance flow. The mixing of the tip clearance flowwith the main flow is revealed at different locationsrelative to the rotor blade position. The degree ofswirl of the flow near the tip region at the rotor exit isvery high due to the gross under turning of the flownear this region. The swirl of the flow near the pres-sure surface was found to be higher than that near thesuction surface at the measurement cross-sectional

    plane nearest to the rotor exit. The degree of swirlreduces as the flow mixes and is guided downstreamin the exit duct. The wake behind the hub and the

    boundary layer development on the exit duct wall arecaptured in this investigation.A limited simulation of the flow field in the merid-

    ional plane of the radial turbine exit flow field hasbeen performed. This limited simulation gives a goodunderstanding of the nature of the wake behind therotor hub and its interaction with the turbine exit flowfield.

    Acknowledgment

    This research was supported by NSF Contract No.CTS-9012309 during 1990-1993. The authors alsoexpress their thanks to the Ohio Super ComputerCenter for granting permission to use the OSC supercomputer resources for the flow computations.

    NOMENCLATURE

    IGVLDVNPr

    TU,V

    Ubl

    AU,AV

    Inlet Guide VaneLaser Doppler Velocimeterdata sample sizepressureradial directiontangential directiontemperaturevelocity componentsmean value of velocity componentrotor blade velocityon-axis velocity componentaxial direction

    measurement uncertainty of velocity compo-nent U, Vabsolute flow anglestandard deviation in a velocity data sampleLDV coupling angle between the purple op-tical axis and the blue-green optical axisangle between the in-plane resultant velocityand the blue component velocity

    SUBSCRIPTS

    b

    F

    rzrt

    Z

    zt

    blue componentexit

    green componentmeasurement pointrotor blade positionmean valuetotal condition

    purple componentradial componentradial-axial planeradial-tangential planetangential componentaxial componentaxial-tangential plane

    ReferencesCooper, G.K. and Sirbaugh, J.R. (1989). PARC Code: Theory and

    Usage, AEDC-TR-89-15, December, Arnold Engineering Devel-opment Center, Tennessee.

  • FLOW AT EXIT OF A RADIAL TURBINE 105

    Hassan Eroglu and Widen Tabakoff (1989). LDV Measurementsand Investigation of Flow Field Through Radial Turbine GuideVanes, ASME paper no. 89-GT- 162.

    Japikse, D. and Pampreen, R. (1979). Annular Difl’user Perfofmance tn" an Automotive Gas Turbine, 7?an,s. ASME JournalEngineering.fir Gos 7hrhine oral Pou’er, Vol. 106, pp. 358-372.

    Kitson, S.T. (I 992). Aerodynamic Investigation of Radial TurbinesUsing Computational Methods, VKl Lea’lure Series 1992-()5,April 6-10, pp. 1-44.

    Kofskey, M.G. and Nusbaum, W.J., (1972). Effects of SpecificSpeed on Experimental Performance of a Radial Inflow Turbine,NASA TN-D-6605.

    Lakshminarasimha, A.N., Tabakoff, W. and Metwally, A.M.(1989). LDV Measurements and the Flow Analysis in the Vane-less Region of a Radial Inflow Turbine, ASME paper m. 89-GT-122.

    Malak, M.F., Hamed, A. and Tabakoff, W. (1986). Three Dimen-sional low Field Measurements in a Radial Inflow TurbineScroll using LDV, ASME paper m. 86-GT- 122.

    Mclallin, K.L. and Haas, J.E. (1980). Experimental Performanceand Analysis of 15.04 cm Tip Diameter Radial-Inflow Turbinewith Work Vactor 1.126 and Thick Blading, NASA 7?oh. paperm). 1730.

    Murugan, D.M., Tabakofl’, W. and Hamed, A. (1994). Flow FieldInvestigation in the Exit Region of a Radial Inllow Turbine Us-ing LDV, ASME poper no. 94-GT- 101.

    Pasin, M. and Tabakoff, W. (1992). Laser Measurements of Un-steady Flow Field in a Radial Turbine Guide Vanes, dOth Aero-space Sciences Meeting & Evhihit, Jan., paper no. AIAA 92-0394.

    Pasin, M. and Tabakoff, W. (1993). Laser Measurements of theFlow Field in a Radial Turbine Rotor, 31st Aerospace SciencesMeeling & Evhihit, Jan., paper no. AIAA 93-0156.

    Rohlik, H.E., Kofskey, M.G. and Nusbaum, W.J. (1970). RadialInflow Turbine Performance with an Exit Diffuser Designed forLinear Static Pressure Variation, NASA-TM-X-52890.

    Snyder, EK., Orlofl’, K.L. and Aoyagi, K. (1981). Performance andAnalysis of a Three Dimensional Non-Orthogonal Laser Dop-pler Anemometer, NASA TM-81283.

    Snyder, RK., Orlofl’, K.L. and Reinath, M.S. (1984). Reduction ofFlow Measurement Uncertainties in Laser Velocimeters withNonorthogonal Channels, AIAA Joltrnol, August, Vol. 22, No. 8,pp. 1115-1123.

    Szewczuk, S. (1989). A Review of their Characteristics and anExperimental Investigation and Analytical Prediction of theAerodynamic Perl)rmance of a 9.6 cm Radial Inflow Turbine,ISABE proceedings ISABE 89-7042, pp. 419-426.

    Zangeneh-Kazemi, M., Dawes, W.N. and Hawthorne, W.R. (1988).Three Dimensional Flow in Radial-Inflow Turbines, ASMEper no. 88-GT- 103.

  • EENNEERRGGYY MMAATTEERRIIAALLSSMaterials Science & Engineering for Energy Systems

    Economic and environmental factors are creating ever greater pressures for theefficient generation, transmission and use of energy. Materials developments arecrucial to progress in all these areas: to innovation in design; to extending lifetimeand maintenance intervals; and to successful operation in more demandingenvironments. Drawing together the broad community with interests in theseareas, Energy Materials addresses materials needs in future energy generation,transmission, utilisation, conservation and storage. The journal covers thermalgeneration and gas turbines; renewable power (wind, wave, tidal, hydro, solar andgeothermal); fuel cells (low and high temperature); materials issues relevant tobiomass and biotechnology; nuclear power generation (fission and fusion);hydrogen generation and storage in the context of the ‘hydrogen economy’; andthe transmission and storage of the energy produced.

    As well as publishing high-quality peer-reviewed research, Energy Materialspromotes discussion of issues common to all sectors, through commissionedreviews and commentaries. The journal includes coverage of energy economicsand policy, and broader social issues, since the political and legislative contextinfluence research and investment decisions.

    SSUUBBSSCCRRIIPPTTIIOONN IINNFFOORRMMAATTIIOONNVolume 1 (2006), 4 issues per year Print ISSN: 1748-9237 Online ISSN: 1748-9245Individual rate: £76.00/US$141.00Institutional rate: £235.00/US$435.00Online-only institutional rate: £199.00/US$367.00For special IOM3 member rates please emailssuubbssccrriippttiioonnss@@mmaanneeyy..ccoo..uukk

    EEDDIITTOORRSSDDrr FFuujjiioo AAbbeeNIMS, Japan

    DDrr JJoohhnn HHaalldd, IPL-MPT,Technical University ofDenmark, Denmark

    DDrr RR VViisswwaannaatthhaann, EPRI, USA

    FFoorr ffuurrtthheerr iinnffoorrmmaattiioonn pplleeaassee ccoonnttaacctt::Maney Publishing UKTel: +44 (0)113 249 7481 Fax: +44 (0)113 248 6983 Email: [email protected] Publishing North AmericaTel (toll free): 866 297 5154 Fax: 617 354 6875 Email: [email protected]

    For further information or to subscribe online please visitwwwwww..mmaanneeyy..ccoo..uukk

    CCAALLLL FFOORR PPAAPPEERRSSContributions to the journal should be submitted online athttp://ema.edmgr.com

    To view the Notes for Contributors please visit:www.maney.co.uk/journals/notes/ema

    Upon publication in 2006, this journal will be available via theIngenta Connect journals service. To view free sample contentonline visit: wwwwww..iinnggeennttaaccoonnnneecctt..ccoomm//ccoonntteenntt//mmaanneeyy

    NNEEWW

    FFOORR 22000066

    Maney Publishing on behalf of the Institute of Materials, Minerals and Mining

  • International Journal of

    AerospaceEngineeringHindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2010

    RoboticsJournal of

    Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

    Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

    Active and Passive Electronic Components

    Control Scienceand Engineering

    Journal of

    Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

    International Journal of

    RotatingMachinery

    Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

    Hindawi Publishing Corporation http://www.hindawi.com

    Journal ofEngineeringVolume 2014

    Submit your manuscripts athttp://www.hindawi.com

    VLSI Design

    Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

    Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

    Shock and Vibration

    Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

    Civil EngineeringAdvances in

    Acoustics and VibrationAdvances in

    Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

    Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

    Electrical and Computer Engineering

    Journal of

    Advances inOptoElectronics

    Hindawi Publishing Corporation http://www.hindawi.com

    Volume 2014

    The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

    SensorsJournal of

    Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

    Modelling & Simulation in EngineeringHindawi Publishing Corporation http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

    Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

    Chemical EngineeringInternational Journal of Antennas and

    Propagation

    International Journal of

    Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

    Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

    Navigation and Observation

    International Journal of

    Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

    DistributedSensor Networks

    International Journal of


Recommended