Date post: | 04-Apr-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | tanveer-singh |
View: | 227 times |
Download: | 0 times |
of 81
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
1/81
PREFACE
1
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
2/81
PREFACE
This project report pertains to the making of a project SUMMER TRAININGof
M.B.A. curriculum.
The PURPOSE of this project is to make the students have thorough knowledge
of the topics given to them. I learned a lot from the hard work I put in to collect
information regarding the same, which would be of great use in my near future as a
professional.
Justification cannot be done to whatever I have learnt within a few days but I have
still tried my best to cover as much as possible about Impact of Mechanics on the Sale
of Tractors in Ludhiana Districtin this report.
Being students of Masters in Business Administration, we need to be aware of the
organization internal environment. Summer training helps us to understand these
concepts related to the organization.
2
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
3/81
EXECUTIVE
SUMMARY
3
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
4/81
THE EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
PROJECT UNDERTAKEN BY ME
The project studied by me in MAHINDRA & MAHINDRA LTD., SWARAJ
DIVISION, MOHALI was Impact of Mechanics on the Sale of Tractors in Ludhiana
District It helps to encourages the human problems to be brought out and gives an
opportunity to the employees to understand attendance system. Management can learn
what the workers think about the policies. It is essential for every organization for their
current environment and which will remain in demand in future as it helps in maintaining
good management relations and promoting efficiency through employee attendance.
Positioning is something (perception) that happens in the minds of the target
market. It is the aggregate perception the market has of a particular company, product
or service in relation to their perceptions of the competitors in the same category. It will
happen whether or not a company's management is proactive, reactive or passive about
the on-going process of evolving a position. But a company can positively influence the
perceptions through enlightened strategic actions.
MAIN OBJECTIVE OF THE STUDY
1) To learn about the Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division, Mohali.
2) To know about the effectiveness of mechanics on the sale of tractors.
3) To learn how Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division, Mohali emphasize on
the sale of the tractors.
4
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Target_markethttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Target_markethttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Target_markethttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Target_markethttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Target_market7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
5/81
HOW IT WAS UNDERTAKEN
A survey was conducted by me among the mechanics of tractors in the market.
An appointment or general meeting was fixed with the mechanics, certain questions were
asked regarding the sale of the tractors; what activities are to be included by consumer in
regard to these benefits;; to what extent iteffects the level of satisfaction and how far it is
beneficial for the consumer. There views helped me a lot to practically understand my
project.
5
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
6/81
INTRODUCTION
6
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
7/81
1. INTRODUCTION
An auto mechanic is amechanic who specializes in automobilemaintenance, repair, and
sometimes modification and design. Education is usually post-secondary or secondary
vocational education, although apprenticeship under a master mechanic is also an
accepted method of learning the trade. A good mechanic must be proficient in
mathematics, physics, electronics and computer science as well as logical processes used
for diagnosing problems. Most reputable mechanics are ASE certified, which is a
standardized method of testing skill level. The technology used in automobiles changes
very rapidly and the mechanic must be prepared to learn these new technologies and
systems. The auto mechanic has a physically demanding job, often exposed totemperature extremes and well as lifting heavy objects and staying in uncomfortable
positions for extended periods as well as exposure to gasoline, solvents and other toxic
chemicals. Related jobs include motorcycle repair and small engine repair.
Auto 'mechanics' are today professionally referred to as 'technicians', due to the level of
technological competency now required to diagnose and perform needed repairs. Fading
quickly is the day of the 'shadetree mechanic', who needed little knowledge of today's
computerized systems. Today's technician must have knowledge of these systems, as well
as more basic mechanical principles.
Due to the increasingly labyrinthine nature of the technology that is now incorporated
into automobiles, most automobile dealerships now provide sophisticated diagnostic
computers to each technician, without which they would be unable to diagnose or repair a
multitude of common failures.
1.1 INDIAN TRACTOR INDUSTRY
Tractor industry plays an important part as agriculture sector has a major contribution to
Indias GDP. Tractors are part of agricultural machinery industry. Tractors came to India
through imports and later on were indigenously manufactured with the help of foreign
7
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mechanichttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mechanichttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automobilehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automobilehttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Engine_repair&action=edithttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Engine_repair&action=edithttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Vehicle_modificationhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-secondary_educationhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-secondary_educationhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secondary_educationhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vocational_educationhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automotive_Service_Excellencehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automotive_Service_Excellencehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automotive_Service_Excellencehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motorcyclehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small_engine_repairhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small_engine_repairhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mechanichttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automobilehttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Engine_repair&action=edithttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Vehicle_modificationhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-secondary_educationhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secondary_educationhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vocational_educationhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automotive_Service_Excellencehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motorcyclehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small_engine_repair7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
8/81
collaborations. The manufacturing process started in 1961-62. Indian tractor industry is
relatively young but now has become the largest market worldwide.
Higher productivity and greater output are the two major contributions in farm
mechanization. Tractors form an integral part of farm mechanization and have a crucial
role to play in increasing agricultural productivity. Tractor is a highly versatile piece of
machinery having a multitude of uses, used in agriculture both for land reclamation and
for carrying out various crop cultivation and also employed for carrying out various
operations connected with raising the crops by attaching suitable implements and to
provide the necessary energy for performing various crop production operations involved
in the production of agricultural crops. Tractors are capital intensive, labour displaying
used as a mode of transport, in electricity generation, in construction industry and for
haulage operation. It has now become an integral part of farm structure .The application
of tractor for agricultural activities which swept India during the last twenty years have
erased the problem of farmers. Farm mechanization program in India aims to integrate
the use of available human and animal farm power with mechanical sources of power for
increasing the productivity.
Indian tractor industry, comparatively young by world standards have expanded at a
spectacular pace during last four decades. Consequently it now occupies a place of ride in
India's automobile industry. U.S.A., U.S.S.R. and only a few Western European countriesexceed the current production of tractors in India, but in terms of growth India's growth is
unmatched even with countries of long history of tractor manufacturing.
The spectacular achievement reflects the maturity and dynamism of tractor manufacturers
and also the policies adopted by the government to enable it to effectively meet the
demand. The tractor industry in India has made a significant progress in terms of
production and capacity as well as indigenisation of technology. It is a typical sector
where both imported technology and indigenous developed technology have developed
towards meeting the overall national requirements. The global spotlight on tractors
manufacturers certainly in terms of volume seems to be swinging away from the USA,
UK and Western and Eastern Europe towards India where growth in the number of
producers and the total volume in recent years have been impressive. In India tractor
industry has played a vital role in the development.
8
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
9/81
India's gross cropped area is next only to United States of America and Russia and long
with fragmented land holdings has helped India to become the largest tractor market in
the world.
But it drops to eight position in terms of total tractor in use in the country when compared
to international figures, only 3% of total tractors used all over the world . It is to be noted
that while the overall automobile industry is facing recession the tractor industry is
growing at 9%.About 20% of world tractor production is carried out in our country only.
The arable land in India is high as 12% of the total arable land in the world. Tractor
market in India is about Rs 6000 crore. On an average around 400000 tractors are
produced and their sale is 260000.Uttar Pradesh is the largest tractor market in our
country. One out of every four tractor is being Purchased here. Indian tractor market has
to be viewed considering its position in the world with respect to key parameters as given
below
FOREIGN COLLABORATION
Tractor industry along with others benefited from this policy which allowed free inflow
of foreign technology .The manufacture of tractors started in India mainly with the help
of foreign collaboration secured from internationally reputed companies from the USA,
UK, USSR, WESTGERMANY, POLAND ,CZECH SLOVAKIA . Most of the models
which were taken up for manufacture in India were developed overseas. Soon after the
decision for the manufacture of tractors was made during second plan, government
approved number of foreign collaboration agreements. The establishment and present
status of tractor industry owes a great deal to the support received by the Indian
entrepreneurs from foreign collaboration during the initial phase of manufacture
9
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
10/81
INDIAN TRACTOR MARKET OVERVIEWThe tractor penetration level in India is very low as compared to the world standards.
Also the penetration levels are also not uniform throughout the country. While the
northern region is now almost saturated in terms of new tractor sales, the southern region
is still under penetrated. The medium horse power category tractors, 31-40 HP are the
most popular in the country and fastest growing segment.
There are currently 14 players in the industry. Mahindra & Mahindra is the leading player
in the industry. Monsoon season is a key driver for sales of tractors. A series of good or
bad monsoon can affect the sales. In recent years the industry has registered a good
growth in sales, both domestic as well as exports. This is also partly because of the
initiative of the government to boost up agriculture and agricultural machinery industry.
Tractor industry has made a steady and satisfactory progress even in drought areas.
10
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
11/81
The tractor industry reported a strong 28.3% growth in sales volumes during 2009-10,
thereby ending the phase of cyclical correction that had pulled down tractor sales during
the preceding two years (2007-09). Significantly, the revival of 2009-10 happened
despite the drought-like conditions in many States during the kharif season dampening
sentiments.
The key factor enabling the demand growth of 2009-10 was strong rural liquidity, which
in turn was sustained by several factors, including: higher minimum support price (MSP)
for crops; greater ability of farmers to make cash purchases (including the usage of Kisan
Credit Card which are increasingly being used to part-finance tractor purchases);
enhanced employment opportunities (with rural employment schemes being implemented
11
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
12/81
by the Government of India); an improved credit environment; and continuance of
replacement demand.
i) INDUSTRY TRENDS BY REGIONS
The biggest markets for the tractor industry include States like Uttar Pradesh (UP),
Andhra Pradesh (AP), Madhya Pradesh (MP), Rajasthan, and Maharashtra, which
together accounted for around 50% of the total tractor sales in India during 2009-10. The
tractor industry witnessed a strong y-o-y growth of 28.3% during 2009-10, with most of
the States reporting positive growth during the year.
Trend in Tractor Sales across regions
The northern region remains the largest tractor market in India with sales of around
1,67,000 units as of 2009-10. This region reported a growth rate of 35.7% in volume
sales in 2009-10 over the previous fiscal, with the key contributors including UP, Punjab,
Haryana and Rajasthan. The northern region benefited from higher MSPs (for crops),
limited availability of labour (forcing higher mechanisation), and increasing non-
agricultural use of tractors.
12
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
13/81
Additionally, increased infrastructure development activities (especially highways) led to
appreciation in land values and use of tractors for non-agricultural purposes. In some
cases, farmers also received compensation for the Governments acquisition of select
land patches (adjoining highways), which increased the availability of cash with them.
Feedback from industry players suggests cash purchases (including purchases using
Kisan Credit Card) in some northern States increased to 35-40% of the total tractor
volumes in 2009-10 from 10- 15% in the past.
Tractor volumes in UP grew by 42.7% during 2009-10, with H2, 2009-10 reporting
particularly strong growth (around 51% y-o-y) mainly on the back of high sugarcane
prices for the kharif crop and improved irrigation facilities. In the case of Punjab, tractor
volumes remained strong for the fifth straight year in 2009-10 (y-o-y growth of 42%). In
Rajasthan however, growth in tractor volumes was relatively subdued in 2009-10 (around
24% y-o-y) as compared with the figure for the northern region as a whole. Tractor salesin Rajasthan were especially low in H2, 2009-10 versus H1, 2009-10, due to lower kharif
output on account of deficient rains and inadequate financing availability.
In the eastern region, tractor volumes continued to report strong growth in 2009-10, albeit
on a small base, and went up by 53.8% over 2008-09, being driven mainly by the higher
MSPs announced for paddy. Within the region however, many financiers remained
13
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
14/81
reluctant to finance tractor purchases in some States like Bihar. Nevertheless, in Bihar,
tractor volumes grew 66% over 2008-09 to around 29,000 units in 2009-10, thereby
accounting for over 50% of the total sales in the eastern region. The Bihar market, where
tractor penetration had been low historically, has shown sustained growth over the last
few years and become one of the important markets for the tractor industry. Overall, in
the eastern region, growth in tractor volumes is expected to moderate, going forward, as
the benefit of a low base get diluted gradually.
The western region reported sales of around 92,000 tractor units during 2009-10a
growth rate of 35.7% over the previous fiscalbenefiting particularly from the strong
performance that Maharashtra, Gujarat and MP posted during H2, 2009-10 (55% y-o-y
growth over H2, 2008-09). The factors contributing to the strong growth in the region
during H2, 2009-10 included a benign base effect, higher crop prices (of sugarcane and
cotton in Maharashtra, and of cereals and soyabean in MP), and greater availability of
retail finance. The performance of the southern region in terms of tractor sales was
relatively modest during 2009-10, with the growth rate being around 11.9% over the
previous fiscal. While most States in the region reported healthy growth, AP, which is the
largest tractor market in the south, de-grew by 10.4% in 2009-10.
ii) INDUSTRY TRENDS BY STATEPunjab, Uttar Pradesh and Haryana were the first States to benefit from the Green
Revolution and hence have traditionally accounted for most of the tractor sales. However,
given the high penetration of tractors in these Northern States, the geographical
concentration of tractor sales is gradually shifting to the Western and Southern States of
the country. States like Gujarat, Andhra Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh have reported
significant increases in tractor volumes over the past three years. This trend is continuing
in the current fiscal also, as the intensity of tractorisation in North India is quite high
already. Table 5 depicts the distribution of tractor sales in the country in the first quarter
of the current fiscal vis-a-vis the like period previous year.
The biggest markets for the tractor industry include States like Uttar Pradesh (UP),
Andhra Pradesh (AP), Madhya Pradesh (MP), Rajasthan, and Maharashtra, which
together accounted for around 50% of the total tractor sales in India during 2009-10. The
14
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
15/81
tractor industry witnessed a strong growth of 28.3% during 2009-10, with most of the
states reporting positive growth during the year.
The performance of the southern region in terms of tractor sales was relatively modest
during 2009-10 with the growth rate being around 11.9% over the previous fiscal. While
most States in the region reported healthy growth, AP, which is the largest tractor market
in the south, de-grew by 10.4% in 2009-10.
The market shares of the top four players in the Indian tractor industry did not change
much during 2009-10 in comparison with 2008-09. M&M remained the market leader
with around 41.1% market share, followed by TAFE with a market share of around 22%,
Escorts with around 12.1% and International Tractors (ITL) with around 8.9%.
The tractor industry reported a strong 28.3% growth in sales volumes during 2009-10,
thereby ending the phase of cyclical correction that had pulled down tractor sales during
the preceding two years (2007-09). Significantly, the revival of 2009-10 happened
despite the drought-like conditions in many States during the kharif season. The key
factors enabling the demand growth of 2009-10 were,
1. Strong rural liquidity
2. Higher Minimum Support Price (MSP) for crops
15
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
16/81
3. Greater ability of farmers to make cash purchases
4. Enhanced employment opportunities
5. Improved Credit environment
6. Continuance of replacement demand
7. Non-agricultural use of tractors
8. Change in product mix
9. Distribution network
iii) REGION-WISE MARKET SHARE OF MAJOR PLAYERS
The market shares of the top four players in the Indian tractor industry did not change
much during 2009-10 in comparison with 2008-09. M&M remained the market leader
with around 41.1% market share, followed by TAFE with a market share of around 22%,
Escorts with around 12.1%, and International Tractors (ITL) with around 8.9%.
M&M remains particularly strong in the southern region (50.4% market share during
2009- 10). However, L&T John Deere (LT-JD) was able to increase its market share in
the region by around 250 bps in 2009-10, mainly at the expense of M&M (market share
down by 140 bps) and Escorts (down by 140 bps). In the western region too, LT-JD
16
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
17/81
performed well in 2009-10, increasing its market share by 190 bps, even as TAFE lost
market share by around 90 bps there.
In the northern region, where M&M has been traditionally weak, the company increased
its market share by 140 bps during 2009-10, even as ITL and Escorts lost market shares
by around 90 bps and 60 bps respectively, there. In the eastern region, M&M was able to
raise its market share by around 140 bps in 2009-10 at the expense of Escorts and TAFE.
MARKET CONCENTRATION
Market concentration in tractors industry is fairly high with top two players, M&
(including Punjab Tractors) and TAFE accounting for 63 per cent of the market in 2007
Market concentration increased over the past 4 years due to the acquisition of Eicher
tractors by TAFE in 2005-06 and PTLs acquisition by M&M in 2006-07.
i) MARKET CAPITALISATION IN TERMS OF VOLUME
17
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
18/81
As it seen from the above graph of market capitalisation, Mahindra and Mahindra has
become the giant in tractor industry over the last few years and has captured the market
upto 80% of the total segmental industry.
ii) MARKET CAPITALISATION IN TERMS OF SALES
The key success factors for the players will continue to include diversified product
portfolio, nation-wide distribution strength and cost competencies. The relative ranking
18
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
19/81
of players based on market share will remain stable with increasing polarisation of
market position between stronger and marginal players. After the acquisition of Eicher
Motors tractor division, TAFE has emerged a strong number two in the industry with
better product portfolio and distribution network (although overlapping may cause some
loss of share). TAFEs share went up to 28 per cent after its acquisition of Eicher
Escorts and International Tractors, with a market share of 14 per cent and 10 per cent,
respectively, are expected to remain strong competitors in the medium-to-long term.
International Tractors is expected to maintain its share as it would not be able to grow at
higher than industry growth rate.
Global players like John Deere and New Holland India are likely to provide strong
competition to the other well established players in the coming years as they strengthen
their Indian product portfolio and distribution network and remain major exporters.
Smaller players like Force Motors, VST Tillers and HMT are likely to be marginalized
further in the long run due to lack of diversified product portfolio, poor nation-wide
distribution network and weakness in cost structure.
FUTURE GROWTH IN TRACTOR INDUSTRY
Tractor sales are expected to remain healthy in fiscal 2010-11, given the good rabi crop
this time around, the continuing firmness in the prices of agricultural products, and thehealthy monsoons anticipated during the coming kharif season. Moreover, improving
farm mechanisation levels (with labour availability in rural areas declining), increasing
nonagricultural use of tractors, higher credit disbursements for agriculture, and sharper
Governmental focus on the farm sector (larger budgetary allocations) are also expected to
encourage tractor sales. The industrys profitability is however expected to remain
moderate in the medium term, considering the high competitive intensity and low
capacity utilisation levels, although larger players could benefit from scale economics. As
for margins, while they have seen an improvement in 2009-10, they would remain
vulnerable to adverse changes in commodity prices.
While some States in the northern region have achieved high levels of tractor penetration
and farm mechanisation, on an all-India basis, the penetration remains low, which along
with the current shortage of farm labour and consequently rising labour costs, may be
19
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
20/81
expected to lead to greater mechanisation and use of tractors. The long-term prospects for
the Indian tractor industry hinge on agricultural growth and Government support in areas
such as financing availability, tax exemptions, and fiscal stimulus for rural development.
Overall, ICRA expects the long-term growth rate for the Indian tractor industry to trend
around the historical average of 6-8%, supported by increasing tractor penetration.
20
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
21/81
COMPANYPROFILE
21
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
22/81
COMPANY PROFILE
MAHINDRA & MAHINDRA LTD., SWARAJ DIVISION, MOHALI
PROMOTION OF PTL
Punjab Tractors Limited (PTL) a joint sector company of the Punjab Government, whichwent into commercial promotion in the early seventies, is a unique example of
technological self reliance in a high technology area like the automotive sector in the
country. It is promoted by Punjab State Industrial Development Corporation (PSIDC) in
1974 which was set up by Punjab Government for setting up new projects. In 1965 when
the entire industrial growth of India relied upon foreign technology and know-how for
setting up industrial ventures in India, the Central Mechanical Engineering Research
Institute (CMERI, Durgapur), a national Laboratory of the Government of India, took the
bold step of taking up the design and development of totally Indian know how for 26.5
H.P. agricultural tractors.
LOCATION
The plant of Punjab Tractors Limited is located in Mohali Focal Point Estate near
Chandigarh on Chandigarh-Ludhiana Highway (Phase IV, Sahibzada Ajit Singh
Nagar, Mohali (Punjab) on a campus of 17 hectares. The land was allotted by Punjab
Govt. in the developing Mohali to add to the vigorous effects to make it a progressive
Industrial Centre. The location of plant is very suitable because it is quite near to thecapital of Punjab. This fact has been advantageous to the company in its initial stage
of growth. However the inadequacy of railway facilities is a serious drawback to the
location of the plant.
BACKGROUND
Punjab Tractors Limited (PTL) was promoted by PSIDC to commercialize the
indigenous tractor developed by the Central Mechanical Engineering Research Institute(CMERI). The Company's plant is situated at S.A.S. Nagar (Mohali) where production
commenced in the year 1974. Initially, PSIDC contributed 42% equity capital against the
total paid up capital of Rs.140.00 lacs. The facility was initially created to manufacture
5000 nos., tractors and the capital cost at that time was Rs.321 lacs. The company's
product line also includes Combine Harvesters and Forklifts. The production capacity of
22
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
23/81
tractors has increased to 60000 nos., from the level of 5000 nos. The company, over the
years, has also promoted two companies, namely, Swaraj Mazda Limited (manufacture of
Light Commercial Vehicles) & Swaraj Engines Ltd. (manufacture of Diesel Engines in
collaboration with Kirloskar Ltd and it has also promoted Swaraj Automotives. The
present stake of PTL in these is 14% in Swaraj Mazda, 33% in Swaraj Engines and 24%
in Swaraj Automotives.
SWARAJ: PTLs BRAND NAME SWARAJ
The word SWARAJ in Indian language means freedom from bondage. Since PTL was
the first large scale project in India based totally on Indian know how and technology,
Swaraj was appropriately chosen as its brand name. With more than 5 Lac tractors and
harvest combines operating in Indian farms, now Swaraj is also an internationallyrecognized name in the developing world Viz. East Africa, West Africa, Middle East and
South East Asia, etc.
SWARAJ - STAGES OF GROWTH
A study of PTL history from project stage to its present position of eminence makes a
very interesting reading. It is a fascinating tale of inspiration, dedication, perseverance
and a strong to succeed against all odds and prejudice. All these years could be divided
into different phases:
CONCEPTION STAGE (1970-74)
This project for manufacture of 5000 tractors per year was set up at an outlay of
Rs. 3.70 crores during November 1972- March 1974. Despite all hurdles and constraints,
the project was completed within the estimated costs and well ahead of 24 months time
schedule. The engineers for Swaraj tractors were procured from M/s Kirloskar Oil
Engines Ltd., a pioneer in Indian Engineering Industry. PTL went into commercial
production with the introduction of its first Model Swaraj 724 in April 1974.TEETHING YEARS (1974-78)
In the intensely competitive domestic market conditions prevailing in 1974 when well
known international brands such as Ford, Massey, Ferguson, etc were available, it was
difficult to establish a new tractor. Thus to establish Swaraj against this severe
competition, the following strategy was adopted.
23
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
24/81
Intensive and close marketing.
District - wise distribution.
Limited introduction and slow extension of distribution network.
24
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
25/81
1. PTLs own serving group.
2. Strict uniformity of product performance and quality.
PTLs first launch SWARAJ 724 received quite favorable response and
encouraged by this response and also by taking into account the preference of large
segments of farmers for higher HP tractor, development work on a 35 HP tractor was
started in January 1975. PTL introduced its second model SWARAJ 735 in
November 1975 which is now the most popular tractor. Then a low cost tractor
SWARAJ 720 was introduced in 1978 for small farmers.
1. THE EXPANSIONS (1978-82)
PTL started growing and increased its production capacity to 12,000 tractors at a
capital outlay of Rs. 9.2 crores. During this time PTL became multi-divisional by
installing Swaraj Foundry Division for manufacturing castings at a rate of 5,000
MT/year at a capital outlay of Rs. 1.80 crores. This division started supplying castingto PTL in 1980. In 1983, PTL introduced SWARAJ 855 and became the first
manufacturing organization to have the widest product range.
2. BREAK PERIOD (1982-86)
With encouraging past records Punjab Tractors Ltd. decided to increase its
production to 24000 per annum at an additional capital outlay of Rs. 10 crores. But
the RBIs credit squeeze policy to curb inflation vehemently affected the tractor
industry, as more than 95% of the tractor sales are through banks. PTLs sale dipped
from 10000 tractors to around 5500 tractors in 1982-83. During 1982-86, PTLs
efforts were directed towards training its work force, reducing wastage, cutting down
scrap, inventory control, up gradation of quality, expanding dealer network in new
areas and widening product variants. Thus PTL worked on man rather than
machines
3. STAGE OF GROWTH SINCE 1987.
In contrast to the depressed situation that prevailed during 1982-83, market since
1987 has been showing growth trend. The demand for Swaraj in the last two decades
has increased tremendously. Now consumer prefers to wait and pay the entire amountin advance to buy a Swaraj tractor rather than buying any other tractor. Production
capacity had increased presently to 33000 tractors per year and will further increase
to 36000 tractors per year by 2000.
THE DECADE OF NINETIES - IN RETROSPECT.
25
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
26/81
The decade of 90s has been a rewarding one for all the constituents of Swaraj
enterprise - through generation of wealth for its customers, its business associates, its
employees, its shareholders and the society.
In recognition of this performance and sharing of information, PTL has
been privileged to receive several accolades in this eventful decade, notable amongst
them being:
Nomination by the Economic Times - best company of the year 1998.
Listed by FII in the jewels of Asia category 1999.
Nomination of UTI institute of Capital Markets for excellence in corporate
governance.
Listed by Hong Kong based Asia Money among top 5 best managed
companies in India 1999.
Listed by Business Today among top 3 Economics value generators in
India.
ASSOCIATE UNITS OF PTL
1. SWARAJ FOUNDARY DIVISION:
It was established in 1980 at a capital outlay of Rs. 1.80 crores to provide grey iron
castings to PTL. Initial production was 5000 MT/year. It is situated in village Majari in
Ropar district. In FY 2007-08, production of castings was 9,600 Metric Tonnes,
representing a value of nearly Rs. 50.5 crores.
2. SWARAJ COMBINE DIVISION (SCD):
Recognizing the pioneering role of PTL, Punjab government requested PTL for the
development and manufacture of self propelled Harvester combines to curtail the
harvesting season and save the crops from natural calamities. As a result Swaraj
Combine Division was set up in 1980 at Chappercheri to produce 250 combines per
annum at an initial investment of Rs. 2.65 crores. In 1981, first SWARAJ 8100 rolled out.
In 1985, production of diesel fork lift also started in collaboration with KOMATSU Fork-
Lift Company of Japan. Over last 28 years, the company has sold nearly 3,150 combines
including 65 in 2007-08.
26
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
27/81
3. SWARAJ AUTOMOTIVES LITD.
Earlier it was Punjab Scooters Ltd. But now it has become Swaraj Automotives Ltd. In
1979, PTL took up the rehabilitation of this terminally sick unit and adopted a radically
new technology for it. Now PTL hold 24% of the equity in Swaraj Automotives Ltd.
4. SWARAJ MAZDA LTD.
In 1984 PTL set up Swaraj Mazda Ltd. a US $ 40 million project in collaboration
with the world famous MAZDA MOTORS CORPORATION OF JAPAN for the
manufacture of light commercial vehicles. Mazda and its associate SUMI TOMO
Corporation hold 26% of the equity. The remaining equity was subscribed by the
Indian Public. Now PTL hold 14% of the Equity in Swaraj Mazda Ltd.
5. SWARAJ ENGINES LTD. (SEL).
In 1986, PTL established Swaraj Engines Ltd., a joint venture among PTL, PSIDC
and Kirloskar Oil Engines Ltd (KOEL) for the manufacture of diesel engines per year. PTL
holds 33% of the equity and KOELs share is only 18%.
PUNJAB TRACTORS LTD EQUITY SHAREHOLDING PATTERN
AS ON 31st March, 2010
Mahindra group 64.64%
LIC/GIC/IFCI/Banks 22.75%
Mutual funds 02.37%
F.I.I 00.44%
27
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
28/81
Public & others 09.80%
AN OVERVIEW OF VARIOUS FRONTS OF PTL
I. Manufacturing: Today the product range of PTL consists of:
1. Tractors. Swaraj 722 Swaraj 834
Swaraj 939 Swaraj 733
Swaraj 724 Swaraj 744
Swaraj 735 Swaraj 855
Swaraj 978
2. Forklifts:
Swaraj Komatsu Electrical Forklifts.
(FB-15, FB-20, FB-255)
Swaraj Komatsu Diesel Forklifts.
(FD-30, FD-50)
Swaraj Diesel Forklifts.
(FD-15, FD-20, FD-25)
Swaraj Rough Terrain Diesel Forklifts.
(FS-15, RT, FD-20, RT, Fd-25 RT)
Harvester/ Combine: Swaraj 8100
Light Commercial Vehicles.Diesel Engines.
Automotive Castings.
II. TECHNOLOGY
PTL is the first manufacturer of tractors in the country. To have a conveyers assembly
line, PTL has totally indigenous technology unlike other manufacturers who have
technical collaborations with foreign manufacturers.
The relative Advantages of PTL over the other manufacturers are:
All the models can be made on single assembly where the others like M & M like
different lines for different models.
The assembly line is conveyers.
28
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
29/81
Capacity addition will let it tap the current upsurge for the tractors. PTL has been
operating close to 80% utilization levels for the past 4 years. The unutilized capacity
will improve its production capacity to meet the strong demand.
Against the high market share in the 30-40 HP segment capacity constraints
have restricted PTLs share in 40 HP segment, PTL is expected to
gain market share in these segments once the added capacity is in the place.
II. RESEARCH AND DEVELOPENT
Ever since the beginning R & D has been the basic strength of PTL. The long list of
new products which have been introduced and established in the short time span of 34
years of PTLs existence proves the emphasis that is placed in PTL on Research and
Development.
Research, Design and development expenses include:
2008 2007
Rs. (Lacs)Rs. (Lacs)
A) Materials 1, 52.331, 55.81
Salaries &wages 5, 11.13 4, 34.88
29
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
30/81
Contribution to
Provident fund 59.97
69.09
b) Depreciation shown in profit and loss account includes
Rs. 1, 51.45 lacs (2007- Rs. 1, 06.15lacs) in respect of
Assets for research and development activities.
III. QUALITY OF PRODUCTS
Quality is the vital area where the company refuses to compromise. By putting
Dr. Juans total quality management techniques into practice, the company has
not only managed to give the customer value for money but has managed to
reduce wastage as well. To double upon, the company has also been building long
term relationship with its vendors and dealers.
Various Departments of PTL
PRODUCTION DEPARTMENT
This department is concerned with the assembly of all finished goods and bought out
components for combine harvester and testing. There exist the staff and line division in
the production department. The staff department includes the production planning and
control which is in charges of maintaining the inventory status, of arranging a receipt and
dispatch of component and of follow up. The important classification is shown as
follows;
Production department includes following departments:
1) Light Machine Shop (LMS)
2) Heavy Machine Shop (HMS)
3) Paint Shop (PS)
4) Assembly Shop
5) Heat Treatment Shop.
30
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
31/81
FINANCE DEPARTMENT
The vice-president assisted by chief managers, managers and assistant managers,
heads this department. The objective of this department is to meet the statutory
requirement of keeping various books of accounts and records and to exercise to control
over various financial areas through the process of budgetary control, ABC analysis, cash
and fund flow position, profitability planning and compilation of other information for
managerial decision and control. Finance department acts as nerve center for whole of the
organization, almost all other departments are directly or indirectly related to this
department.
Various important routine accounting functions involves:-
a. Sales accounting
b. Purchase accounting
c. Internal Audit
d. Expenses accounting
e. Financial accounting
f. Cost accounting
g. Excise and Sales tax
MARKETING DEPARTMENT
This department is mainly concerned with sales and after sales services, sales
planning, organizing market research, promotion policy etc. It is headed by Senior GM -
Marketing and is assisted by Chief Managers, Managers, Assistant Manager, senior
engineers and technicians.
PTL adopts a cost leadership approach to pricing and promote its product using all
major resources of promotion. Swaraj Tractors are sold through more than 500 dealers
spread all over the country.
During the FY 2007-08, the Company has made special efforts to reduce dealer
outstanding by focusing attention on increasing retain sales and reducing dealer stocks
31
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
32/81
thereby increasing in collection from dealers. This has helped substantial reduction in
pipeline stocks and dealer outstanding.
PERSONNEL MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT (HRD)
This department is headed by the General Manager and is assisted by the managers,
assistant manager and personnel officers. HRD remains in touch with the workers
requirement and tries to fulfill them. This department is divided into:-
1) Recruitment, Training and Placement Department
2) Time Office and Workers Well Fare Department
SWOT ANALYSISSTRENGTHS:
Due to strong consumer preference and the potential for expansion, the industry in
bound to record growth.
Being a cash rich company, PTL should have no obstacle for further expansions.
The management of PTL is very efficient and effective.
The company mainly has medium horse power tractor in its product portfolio,
which hold a good growth potential thereby leading to an increase in the market
share.
The company has an excellent distribution network along with established brand
equity of the company can capitalized upon.
Strong Research and development set up.
WEAKNESSES:
The company has a weak presence in southern and eastern India as compared tonorthern India.
The company is addressing this problem by going in for capacity expansion and
increasing dealer network.
The company has not leveraged its brand and product varies in the exports
market.
32
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
33/81
Being agro-based product , companys fortune depends on the vagaries of the
monsoon.
Major market share in Punjab & Haryana could stagnate as the market mature.
OPPORTUNITIES:
By launching high horse power tractors , the company can enjoy more high
growth rate .
The core rural market is untapped and lots of opportunity exists there any finance
companies, along with banks have gone for innovative schemes to woo buyers.
Largest second market of Gujarat and Madhya Pradesh with low cost economy
tractors.
Good brand name, product quality and cost advantage to increase exports in lowvalue markets of Sri Lanka, Bangladesh and African countries.
THREATS:
The entry of international and new domestic players would intensify
competition significantly. This could put pressure on the sale growth and the
merging of the company.
The contained increase in price of inputs relative to price of final product
could effect badly.
Number of technically superior new models likely to be launched in the
market in the next two years.
The evitable increase in petroleum prices including diesel, will naturally bring
down the spirit of a prospective tractor purchasers.
33
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
34/81
34
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
35/81
RATIONALE
OF
STUDY
35
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
36/81
RATIONALE OF STUDY
Role of Mechanics advantage in sales and distribution channels.
Your sales channels touch potential customers at their most vulnerable moment in
the buying tractors -- the moment when they seek advice at the point-of-purchase. Most
have a good idea of what they need, but are uncertain of which brand will provide it.
Incidentally, tractor mechanics provide the vital information.
Most customers seeking word-of-mouth advice, follow it. If customer is not
satisfied with information provided by sales persons, mechanics fill the important void.
That is how successful brands gain an unfair advantage. Work with strategy to
take advantage of these mechanics for the sale promotion.
36
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
37/81
OBJECTIVES
37
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
38/81
OBJECTIVES
To study the various products of Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division,
Mohali.
To study the market strategy and promotion sales of Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd.,
Swaraj Division, Mohali.
To study the various aspects about the Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj
Division, Mohali.
To study the role of mechanics in the sale of tractors.
To study the comparative analysis of all brands of tractors in relation to the advice
of tractor mechanics.
38
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
39/81
RESEARCH
METHODOLOGY
39
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
40/81
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Research refers to the organized method consisting of enunciating the problem
collecting facts, critically analysis of facts and arriving at conclusion based on them.
Formulation of the problem is the first & vital step in research John says that It is a
familiar & significant saying that problem well put in is half solved.
RESERCH DESIGN
After research objectives the second stage of research calls for developing the
most efficient plan for gathering the needed information. Designing a research plan
includes decisions on data sources, research approaches, research instrument & sampling
plan.
DATA COLLECTION
Collection of data regarding the problem under research is called data collection.
Two types of data can be used in research i.e. primary data & secondary data. I have used
primary data for my project report.
PRIMARY DATA
The primary data is the data gathered for a specific purpose or specific research
report. I have collected primary data with help of questionnaires.
SECONDARY DATA
The secondary data is the data, which already exists & was collected for some
other purpose. The secondary data I have used in my research report is basically collected
from the business magazines, journals & websites of trade organizations.
RESEARCH APPROACH
Primary data can be collected in four ways: Observation. Focus groups, Surveys
& Experiments. My approach to the research is survey based, as it is best suited to know
the role of mechanics in the sale of tractors
40
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
41/81
RESERARCH INSTRUMENT
The instrument used for carrying out the research is questionnaire as it is the most
economical, flexible & easy to understand device used for collection of data. Keeping in
view the research objectives, a questionnaire is prepared which is very easy tounderstand.
SAMPLING DESIGN
The first step in developing any sample design is to clearly define the set of
objects, as my study is exploratory, the sampling design includes three decisions i.e.
sampling unit, Sample size & Sampling procedure.
SAMPLING PROCEDURE
It was a stratified sampling in which Four Strata are made from Ludhiana District
namely Ludhiana, Jagraon, Raikot and Pakhowal. And then random sampling was used
in these strata.
SAMPLING UNIT
In this research report the sampling unit is the tractor mechanics of Ludhiana.
SAMPLING SIZE
The sample size of my research is 30 tractor mechanics , Large samples give more
reliable results that is why I tried my best to cover more tractor mechanics of different
dealers in Ludhiana district.
Sample Size 100
Sample Unit Tractor Mechanics
Area of Survey Ludhiana
41
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
42/81
INTERPRETATION
AND
ANALYSIS
42
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
43/81
INTERPRETATION AND ANALYSIS
Age:
10-15 Years 0
15-20 Years 4
20-30 Years 11
30 or above 85
Agegroup of Mechanics
30 or above
85%
10-15 Years
0%
20-30 Years
11%
15-20 Years
4%
10-15 Years
15-20 Years
20-30 Years
30 or above
43
Mechanics in the market are experienced ones, as only 7 % are of the age group
20-30 Years and rest 93 % are of the age group more than 30 Years.
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
44/81
For how many years, you are in mechanic line?
1-5 Years 3
5-10 Years 17
More than 10 Years 80
Years Experience
5-10 Years17%
1-5 Years
3%
More than
10 Years
80%1-5 Years
5-10 YearsMore than 10 Years
44
13 % of the mechanics have experience of 5-10 years and rest 87 % of the
mechanics have a experience of more than 10 years .
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
45/81
Are you an authorized mechanics?
Yes 3
No 97
Authorised Dealership
No
97%
Yes
3%
Yes
No
45
97 % of the mechanics in the market are not the authorized ones, only 3 % are
having the authorized workshop of tractors.
Authorized Workshops
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
46/81
What is your qualification regarding your work?
Diploma in Mechanical 2
Motor Mechanic Course 11
Work Experience only 87
Qualification Regarding Work
Diploma in
Mechanical
2%
Work
Experience
only87%
Motor
MechanicCourse
11%
Diploma in Mechanical
Motor Mechanic Course
Work Experience only
46
All mechanics working in the market do not have any qualification background
but having a good working experience of their line.
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
47/81
Are you aware of all the models of tractors available in the market?
A. Yes B. No
Awareness Regarding Tractor Models
Yes
100%
No
0%
Yes
No
47
Mechanics in the market have a good knowledge regarding all the models of
the tractors available in the market.
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
48/81
According to you, which group is the main buyer of the tractors?
A. Farmers
B. Commercial Users
Farmers 69
Commercial Users 31
48
Farmers are the main buyers of the tractors thereby 69% responses made by
Consumers are for farmers and the rest 31% for commercial users.
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
49/81
According to you, do they have enough knowledge regarding buying tractor?
A. Yes
B. No
Knowledge Regarding Buying Tractor
Yes
100%
No
0%
Yes
No
49
According to all the mechanics, farmers and Commercial Users have the
knowledge of buying the tractors.
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
50/81
Prioritizes the following aspects when customer looks to buy new tractor.
1. Cost (Price, Resale and maintenance)
2. Distribution Network
3. Brand image
4. Dealer Response
5. Performance
6. After Sale Service
7. Any other
(Please specify): - ___________________________________________________
Customers Priority
Any other, 1After Sale
Service, 11
Performance,
22Distribution
Network, 0
Brand Image,
1
Dealer
Response, 0
Cost, 30
Cost
Distribution Network
Brand Image
Dealer Response
Performance
After Sale Service
Any other
*From the options given respondents have marked more than one option
50
Performance is the main criteria while buying the tractor. Cost & After Sale
Service hold second & third position respectively
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
51/81
Which brand of Tractor comes mostly for repair?
A. HMT B. Mahindra and Mahindra
C. PTL (Swaraj) D. Sonalika
E. Eicher F. New Holland
G. Escorts H. TAFE
I. John Deere J. Bajaj Tempo
K. Standard L. Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj
Division
M. Same
51
Tractor Repair
PTL(Swaraj), 7
Mahindra and
Mahindra, 7
HMT, 0All, 8
Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division, 0
Standarad, 0
Eicher, 3 Sonalika, 3
TAFE, 1
Escorts, 0
Bajaj Tempo, 0
New Holland, 0
John Deere, 1
HMT
Mahindra and Mahindra
PTL(Swaraj)
Sonalika
Eicher
New Holland
Escorts
TAFE
John Deere
Bajaj Tempo
Standarad
Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj D
All
As per mechanics more the selling of tractors and the repair is accordingly
to the selling. Thereby, PTL (Swaraj) and Mahindra and Mahindra come mostly for
repair.
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
52/81
Which brand of Tractor you recommend?
52
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
53/81
A. HMT B. Mahindra and Mahindra
D. PTL (Swaraj) E. Sonalika
F. Eicher G. New Holland
H. Escorts I. TAFE
J. John Deere K. Bajaj Tempo
L. Standard M. Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj
Division
N. Same
*From the options given respondents have marked more than one option
53
Tractor Repair
John Deere, 0
Standard, 0Bajaj Tempo, 0
Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division, 0
Same, 0
New Holland,20
Escorts, 0
TAFE, 1
Eicher, 1
Sonalika, 20
PTL (Swaraj), 18
Mahindra and
Mahindra, 5
HMT, 1HMT
Mahindra and Mahindra
PTL (Swaraj)
Sonalika
Eicher
New Holland
Escorts
TAFE
John Deere
Bajaj Tempo
Standard
Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Div
Same
Tractor Recommendation
In case of recommendation Sonalika is the best amongst all, followed by
PTL(Swaraj) and Mahindra and Mahindra.
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
54/81
Which brand of Tractor do you succeed to sell the most?
A. HMT B. Mahindra and Mahindra
C. PTL(Swaraj) D. Sonalika
E. Eicher F. New Holland
G. Escorts H. TAFE
I. John Deere J. Bajaj Tempo
K. Standard L. Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj
Division
M. Same
*From the options given respondents have marked more than one option
54
As per sale on behalf of tractors mechanics, PTL (Swaraj) having a good share as
13 favoured it, 11 mechanics succeed to sell Sonalika and 5 mechanics favoured
Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division, Mohali.
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
55/81
Rate the following Aspects From 1 to 6 according to priority on the basis of which
you recommend a brand?
A. Cost( Price, Resale and maintenance) B. Distribution Network
C. Brand image D. Performance and looksE. After Sale Service F. Help By dealer or company
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
1 2 3 4 5 6
Ranking
ResponsesofMechanic
Cost
Distribution
Brand Image
Performance and Looks
After Sale Service
Help by delare or company
vera er ormance o spec s
36
151
143
57
88
155
020
406080
100120140160
180
Cost
Distribution
BrandImage
Performance
andLooks
AfterSale
Service
Helpby
Dealeror
Company
Aspects
RatingPoints
As the ranking wise system has been deployed in the survey, the most lower numbers
given, higher the priority. According to that Cost is the most suitable aspect as the
numbers given per rank to the appropriate aspect. Then comes the performance and
looks, similarly after sale service is also valuable.
55
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
56/81
According to you, who influenced buying decision of the user?
A. Friend B. Relative
C. Family Member D. Mechanic
E. OPINION LEADER
Influencing Buying Decision
Relative, 11
Friend, 11
Opinion
Leader, 0
Mechanic,
29Family
Member, 2
Friend
Relative
Family Member
Mechanic
Opinion Leader
*From the options given respondents have marked more than one option
56
It has been clear from the fact that there is good impact of mechanic on the sale of
tractor is more as 29 take the advice from mechanics, 11 from relatives and 2 from
family members.
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
57/81
What %age of people are satisfied with your advice?
A. 0-25% B. 25-50% C. 50-75%. D. 75-100%.
Satisfaction with Advice
25-50 %, 2
0-25 %, 075-100 %, 3
50-75 %, 25
0-25 %
25-50 %
50-75 %
75-100 %
57
As per 25 mechanics, 50 -75 % of the people are satisfied with their advice.
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
58/81
What %age of people do not seek second advice after consulting you to buy a
tractor?
A. 0-25% B. 25-50% C. 50-75%. D. 75-100%.
People not seek second Advice
25-50 %, 2
0-25 %, 26
75-100 %, 050-75 %, 2
0-25 %
25-50 %
50-75 %
75-100 %
58
According to 26 mechanics out of 30, 0-25 % of the people do not seek second
advice.
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
59/81
What %age of people send other people to you for advice to buy a tractor?
A. 0-25% B. 25-50% C. 50-75%. D. 75-100%.
Advice with Reference
25-50 %, 17
0-25 %, 12
75-100 %, 0
50-75 %, 1
0-25 %
25-50 %
50-75 %75-100 %
59
According to 12 mechanics out of 30, 0-25 % of the people sends other people to
them for advice and 17 says 25-50 %.
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
60/81
How many tractors do you help to sell in a month?
A. 10-15 B. 15-30 C. 30-50. D. 50-80
Helping Tractors to Sell
15-30 Tractors,
0 30-50 Tractors,
050-80 Tractors,
0
10-15 Tractors,
30
10-15 Tractors
15-30 Tractors
30-50 Tractors
50-80 Tractors
60
As far as the sale of the tractors is concerned 10-15 tractors are sold with
help of mechanics every month.
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
61/81
Do you Recommend Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division also? If yes, to what
%age of customers who visit you for advice?
A. 0-25% B. 25-50% C. 50-75%. D. 75-100%.
Recommendation for Sonalika
25-50 %, 10
0-25 %, 19
75-100 %, 0
50-75 %, 1
0-25 %
25-50 %
50-75 %
75-100 %
61
19 Mechanics recommend Sonalika to 0-25%of the Customers. 10 Mechanics
recommend Sonalika to 25-50% of the customers & 1 Mechanic says that he
recommends to 50-75% of the customers visiting him for advice.
Recommendations for Mahindra &
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
62/81
What is the %age sale ofMahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division through You?
(%Age of total customers consulting Mechanic)
A. 0-25% B. 25-50% C. 50-75%. D. 75-100%.
62
According to the 23 mechanics, % sale of Sonalika through them is 0-25% & 7 say
that it is 25-50%.
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
63/81
How would you Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division rate on 5-point scale?
1
(poor)
2(Satisfactory) 3(Average) 4(More
thanAverage)
5(Excellent)
a. Price 0 0 8 22 0
b. Fuel Efficiency 1 0 6 23 0
c. Brand Image 0 8 22 0 0
d. Resale Value 0 1 12 16 1
e. Distribution
Network
0 22 8 0 0
f. Spare parts
available
11 19 0 0 0
g. After sale
service
0 18 12 0 0
h. Look style 0 6 19 5 0
i. Performance 0 0 12 18 0
j Customer Care 0 2 25 3 0
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
a.Price
b.FuelE
fficien
cy
c.BrandIma
ge
d.ResaleVa
lue
e.Di
stribu
tionNe
twork
f.Spare
partsa
vailable
g.Aftersa
leservi
ce
h.Looks
tyle
i.Perfo
rmance
jCustome
rCare
Aspect
ResponsesofMechanics
1 (poor)
2(Satisfactory)
3(Average)4(More than A vera
5(Excellent)
63
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
64/81
Summated Rating Of aspects
91108
8972
49
68
102
88
111112
0
20
40
60
80100
120
Price
FuelEfficency
BrandIm
age
Resale
Value
Distribution
Network
SparePa
rtAvailable
AfterSale
Serviec
Look
Style
Performance
Customer
Care
Aspects
Ratingpoin
ts
Rating has been done on 5-point scale, more the points, more the valuability. According
to that Price aspect is highly considerable then the Fuel Efficiency and Performance and
the other aspects respectively.
64
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
65/81
Do you want any type of help from the tractor companies?
A. Yes B. No
If yes, what type?
A. Commission B. Gifts
C. Training. D. Any other type
Help from Tractor Companies
Yes, 19
No, 11
Yes
No
Only Training, 1
Only Commission,
12
Gifts, 0Any Other, 0
Both Commission
& training, 6
Gifts
Only Commission
Only Training
Both Commission &
training
Any Other
65
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
66/81
FINDINGS
66
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
67/81
FINDINGS
The trend has been showing that the impact and the role of mechanics are well in
the sale promotion of the tractors.
It has been clear from the fact that the impact of mechanic on the sale of tractor is
more as 29 responses are for mechanics, 11 for relatives and 2 for family members.
50 -75 % of the people are satisfied with the advice of the mechanics as per 25
mechanics saying. According to 26 mechanics out of 30, 0-25 % of the people do not
seek second advice. According to 12 mechanics out of 30, 0-25 % of the people send
other people on their advice and 17 says 25-50 %. As far as the sale of the tractors are
concern 10-15 tractors have been sold out with the help of mechanics every month.
According to 19 mechanics 0-25 % of the customer visit for their advice to buy Mahindra
& Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division, Mohali and 10 says 25 50 % go for the same cause.
According to the 100 mechanics, 0-25 % of the sale of Mahindra & Mahindra
Ltd., Swaraj Division are through them and 7 says 25 50 % of the Mahindra &
Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division sale through them.
Thereby, for the growth of the sale promotion of Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd.,
Swaraj Division, Mohali, they have to take care of the commission and training in the
benefit of the mechanics so that more and more mechanics recommend Mahindra &
Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division as their favourite brand, that helps the company to make
a good share in the market.
Standardisation should have to be maintained to avoid change of models
frequently and it will solve the problem of the availability of spare parts.
67
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
68/81
CONCLUSION
68
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
69/81
CONCLUSION
Tractor Mechanics has the vital role in the sale promotion of the Mahindra &
Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division, Mohali. Thereby, for the growth of the sale promotion
of Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division, Mohali, they have to take care of the
commission and training in the benefit of the mechanics so that more and more
mechanics recommend Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division as their favourite
brand, that helps the company to make a good share in the market.
Company must have to enlist all the tractor mechanics of the Ludhiana and
have to make plan sheet in accordance to provide benefits to them. As they help in givingadvices to the farmers, big agriculturists and commercial users regarding the brand and
their performances, cost comparison and also regarding the after sale service.
69
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
70/81
SUGGESTIONS BY THE MECHANICS FOR MAHINDRA &
MAHINDRA LTD., SWARAJ DIVISION, MOHALI
The main problem is with the spare parts of the tractors, company should have to
take care of the availability of the spare parts of tractors in the market so that consumers
do not face problem. Spare parts should be standardized.
Tractor models shouldnt have to change frequently for the improvised
classification of the product. Time to time company is changing the products and making
confusion in the minds of consumer and mechanics as well.
Lift Pump Pipe provided by the company manufacturers is too long and causing
leakage problems time to time. Mechanics have already mentioned these kind of
problems to the sales persons and company officials but no step yet been taken.
Heavy bearing system should be used in steering to make it lighter.
Hydraulic problem of lift is being faced. Dry brakes when used for haulage
purpose not work properly and make noise.
Rear wheel bearings get muddy and as a result, seal leaks. Precautions have to be
taken so that bearings should have to be covered and properly placed to avoid seal
leakage.
70
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
71/81
LIMITATIONS
71
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
72/81
LIMITATIONS
The report may be beneficial to company. But there are some limitations of the study.
1. The size of the research may not be substantial.
2. There was lack of time on the part of mechanics.
3. There may be some bias information provide by tractor mechanics.
4. As only a single city are surveyed or covered. It does not represent the overall
view of Tractor Market.
5. It is very much possible that some of the mechanics may have given the incorrect
information.
6. The last but the most important point to that survey was carried through
Questionnaire and the Questions were based on perception. Most important is
positioning. But there may be certain aspects not taken into consideration.
72
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
73/81
BIBLIOGRAPHY
73
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
74/81
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Library Resources
Drucker, Peter F. (1989), "What Business Can Learn From Nonprofits,"
Harvard Business Review, Vol (July-August), 88-93.
Ensman, Richard (1987), "Market Research: A Valuable Aid To Small
Non-Profits," Fund Raising Management, 18 (September), 108.
Freeman, Laurie (1998), "Corporate Branding Gains B-To-B
Momentum," Advertising Age's Business Marketing, 83 (December), 1-2.
Keller, Kevin Lane, Strategic Brand Management: Building, Measuring,
and Managing Brand Equity, Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall, Inc.
Kotler, Philip and Alan R. Andreason (1996), Strategic Marketing For
Nonprofit Organizations, Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall, Inc.
Internet Resources
www.Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division.com
http://www.naukri.com/gpw/sonalika/index.htm
74
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
75/81
ANNEXURE
75
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
76/81
ANNEXURE: QUESTIONNAIRE
Dear Sir,
I, Pradeep Singh Grewal, MBA 3
rd
Sem. student of LCET, Katani,Chandigarh Highway, Ludhiana,. Conducting a market survey to know the Impact of
mechanics on the sale of tractors in Ludhiana District.
1. Your Name? Please
2. Your Address and contact no.
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
3. Age:
A. 10-15 Yrs B. 15-20Yrs C. 20-30Yrs D. 30 or above
4. For how many years, you are in mechanic line?
A. 1-5 year
B. 5-10 years
C. More than 10 Years
5. Are you an authorized workshop?
A. Yes B. No
6. What is your qualification regarding your work?
A. Diploma in Mechanical
B. Motor Mechanic Course
76
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
77/81
C. Work Experience Only
7. Are you aware of all the models of tractors available in the market?
A. Yes B. No
8. According to you, which group is the main buyer of the tractors?
A. Farmers
B. Commercial Users
9. According to you, do they have enough knowledge regarding buying tractor?
A. Yes
B. No
10. Prioritize the following aspects when customer looks to buy new tractor.
A Cost (Price, Resale and maintenance)
B Distribution Network
C Brand image
D Dealer Response
E Performance
F After Sale Service
G Any other
(Please specify): - ___________________________________________________
11. Which brand of Tractor comes mostly for repair?
A HMT
B Mahindra and Mahindra
C PTL (Swaraj)
D Sonalika
E Eicher
77
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
78/81
F New Holland
G Escorts
H TAFE
I John Deere
J Bajaj Tempo
K Standard
L Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division
M Same
12. Which brand of Tractor you recommend?
A. HMT
B. Mahindra and Mahindra
C. PTL (Swaraj)
D. Sonalika
E Eicher
A. New Holland
B. Escorts
C. TAFE
D. John Deere
E. Bajaj Tempo
F. Standard
G. Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division
H. Same
13. Which brand of Tractor do you succeed to sell the most?
A HMT
78
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
79/81
B Mahindra and Mahindra
C PTL(Swaraj)
D Sonalika
E Eicher
F New Holland
G Escorts
H TAFE
I John Deere
J Bajaj Tempo
K Standard
L Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division
M Same
14. Rate the following Aspects From 1 to 6 according to priority on the basis of which you
recommend a brand?
Cost( Price, Resale and maintenance)
Distribution Network
Brand image
Performance and looks
After Sale Service
Help By dealer or company
15. According to you, who influenced buying decision of the user?
A Friend
B Relative
C Family Member
D Mechanic
E OPINION LEADER
79
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
80/81
16. What %age of people are satisfied with your advice?
A. 0-25% B. 25-50% C. 50-75%. D. 75-100%.
17. What %age of people do not seek second advice after consulting you to buy a tractor?
A. 0-25% B. 25-50% C. 50-75%. D. 75-100%.
18. What %age of people send other people to you for advice to buy a tractor?
A. 0-25% B. 25-50% C. 50-75%. D. 75-100%.
19. How many tractors do you help to sell in a month?
A. 10-15 B. 15-30 C. 30-50. D. 50-80
20. Do you Recommend Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division, Mohali also? If yes, to
what %age of customers who visit you for advice?
A. 0-25% B. 25-50% C. 50-75%. D. 75-100%.
21. What is the %age sale of Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division through You?
(%Age of total customers consulting Mechanic)
A. 0-25% B. 25-50% C. 50-75%. D. 75-100%.
22. How would you Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division rate on 5-point scale?
1
(poor)
2(Satisfactory) 3(Average) 4(More
than
Average)
5(Excellent)
a. Price
b. Fuel Efficiency
c. Brand Image
d. Resale Value
e. Distribution
Network
f. Spare parts
80
7/30/2019 Mechanic Impact
81/81
available
g. After sale service
h. Look style
i. Performance
j Customer Care
23. Do you want any type of help from the tractor companies?
A. Yes B. No
If yes, what type?
A. Commission B. Gifts
C. Training. D. Any other type
If Any Other, Please specify ______________
24. What are your suggestions for the Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Swaraj Division, Mohali?
____________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________.