Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal: Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
Holly Mawritz
Senior Thesis Project Proposal
Penn State University Department of Architectural Engineering
Mechanical Emphasis Faculty Consultant: Dr. Jim Freihaut
12-10-04
Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
________________________________________________________________________ 1
Table of Contents:
Executive Summary 2
Background: Existing Mechanical Systems 3
Air Systems 3
AHU-3 3
AHU-4 3,4
Water Systems 4
Heat Pumps 4
Heat Pump Cooling Tower 4
Chilled Water Plant 5
Boiler Plant 5
Areas of Focus for Better Design Solutions 6,7
Proposed Design Solutions 8
Removal of Patient Room Heat Pumps 8
The Desiccant Wheel 9,10
Ultraviolet Germicidal Irradiation 10,11
Design Solution Methods 12
Removal of Patient Room Heat Pumps 12
The Desiccant Wheel 12,13
Ultraviolet Germicidal Irradiation 13
Breadth Ideas 14
Project Methods 15
Preliminary Research Resources 16
Calendar Schedule of Tasks 17-20
Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
________________________________________________________________________ 2
Executive Summary:
This report is based on the collaboration of previously written research papers in
preparation for the redesign of the mechanical systems of Calvert Memorial Hospital in
Prince Frederick, Maryland. This proposal will assimilate an analysis of the hospital’s
mechanical, electrical, and structural systems. This project will be finished and presented
in the Penn State University Architectural Engineering Senior Thesis Presentations at the
end of the spring 2005 semester.
The existing mechanical system is explained in basic detail to represent the current
operation of the equipment. The objectives to the mechanical design rely heavily on
indoor air quality and infection control. These issues will increase the building’s first
costs, but eventually the benefits of the proposed systems in this report will eventually
overshadow the first cost expenses. The use of UVGI (Ultraviolet Germicidal
Irradiation) systems for infection control in critical spaces and exhaust ducts will
decrease insurance costs over time. The addition of desiccant wheels to the system
cooling configuration will result in a reduction of some of the mechanical equipment
sizes, which will also lower mechanical equipment costs. Smaller mechanical equipment
creates a reduction in energy used. All of these topics will be discussed in further detain
in this proposal.
The scope of this proposal is to fully explain the mechanical redesign and include areas
of breadth topics such as the electrical and structural systems. The impact of these
proposed ideas will be evaluated in this thesis study.
Lastly, there will be an estimated schedule that gives an outline of the research processes
for this proposal. This timeline will begin in December 2004 with the initial thesis
proposal and end in April 2005 when the Architectural Engineering Senior Thesis
Presentations will begin.
Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
________________________________________________________________________ 3
Background: Existing Mechanical Systems:
Calvert Memorial Hospital contains a plethora of different mechanical systems. Due to
the complexity and size of the hospital, the areas of focus will include the 2nd – 5th floor
patient towers. Below is a summary of the mechanical systems serving these areas of the
hospital. Many of these systems will be replaced or renovated in the proposal section of
this report.
Air Systems:
AHU-3
AHU-3 is a commercial grade, constant volume air handling unit which was
originally installed in 1977. The air handling unit resides in the second floor
mechanical penthouse. The areas served by this unit are the Intensive Care areas
and Isolation rooms on the second and third floors. The unit utilizes a percentage
of outside air and has a rating of 4000 cfm at 3.0 inches of static pressure. The
unit is in poor condition and lacks final filters. Due to these unsatisfactory
conditions, the hospital has begun planning for expansion of the areas served by
this air handling unit. The new air handler, AHU-PT-1 will replace the original
AHU-3 and will remain in the second floor mechanical room and serve the same
areas including the expanded areas. The planned capacity for the new air handler
will be approximately 50,000 cfm.
AHU-4
AHU-4 is a commercial grade, constant volume air handling unit which was also
installed in 1977. This unit is located in the second floor mechanical penthouse
and currently serves the first, second, and third floor corridors. This unit utilizes a
percent of outside air and is rated for 11,000 cfm at 3.5 inches of static pressure.
This unit is also in poor condition, and is also lacking the appropriate final filters.
The hospital renovation plans are to remove the existing AHU-4 and using the
new AHU-PT-1 as the unit to serve the new second floor patient expansion and
Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
________________________________________________________________________ 4
existing second and third floor patient towers. In addition, AHU-PT-1 will serve
the Post-Partum on the first floor that is currently supplied by heat pumps.
Water Systems:
Heat Pumps
Water source heat pumps are used to serve numerous portions of the hospital but
serve a majority of the rooms involved in the hospital patient tower (floors two
through five). The patient tower’s heat pump systems serve the second and third
floor patient rooms and the entire fourth and fifth floors of the hospital. The heat
pumps can either cool the air by rejecting heat or heat the air by collecting heat
from the central condenser water loop. The heat pumps are of varying ages and
capacities. Removing the heat pumps and replacing them with an all-air system
configuration has been discussed, but currently no new designs have been
developed.
Heat Pump Cooling Tower
Approximately one-third of Calvert Memorial Hospital is served by water source
heat pumps. These heat pumps reject to two cooling towers: Cooling Tower
No.1 and Cooling Tower No.4. Cooling Tower No.1 is a 378 ton forced-draft
cooling tower was installed in 1977. Cooling Tower No.4 is an induced-draft
cooling tower of unknown capacity. Cooling Tower No. 1 serves the basement,
first, second, and third floor heat pumps while Cooling Tower No.4 serves the
fourth and fifth floor heat pumps. Both of the cooling towers are in poor
condition. For winter operation, Cooling Tower No. 4 utilizes an electric boiler
and a plate and frame heat exchanger for adding required heat to the loop. Also,
the louvers required for optimal winter operation of Cooling Tower No. 1 are
missing. The hospital already has plans of removing these heat pumps, but not for
another 15-20 years.
Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
________________________________________________________________________ 5
Chilled Water Plant
The existing chilled water plant consists of three electric centrifugal chillers.
These chillers are located in the basement mechanical room. Chiller No. 1 has a
rated capacity of 110 tons and was installed in 1996. Chiller No. 2 and Chiller
No. 3 each have a rated capacity of 260 tons and were both installed in 1998.
The chiller plant’s total capacity is 630 tons. Chiller No.1 uses R-22 refrigerant
while Chiller No. 2 and Chiller No. 3 use R-134A refrigerant. The chillers
operate with an entering chilled water temperature of 55oF and a leaving chilled
water temperature of 45oF. All of the chillers are in good condition.
Boiler Plant
The main boiler plant is located in the basement of the hospital. The plant
contains two hot water boilers, each having a rated capacity of 5021 MBH. They
are both forced-draft, gas-fired, fire tube type and are each equipped with a
Cyclonetic burner. They were installed in 1996 are in excellent condition.
Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
________________________________________________________________________ 6
Areas of Focus for Better Design Solutions:
The main emphasis of the mechanical redesign of Calvert Memorial Hospital is to
achieve a more desirable performance of the mechanical systems based on the assignment
requirements. The topics proposed in this redesign report in no way imply that the
current mechanical, electrical, or structural systems of Calvert Memorial Hospital are
dangerous or in error.
One of the primary focuses of health care facilities are indoor air quality, and infection
and disaster control. Through time, these issues have become more critically studied.
Hospitals must follow important design parameters to ensure that the occupants are not
exposed to any harmful contaminants in the air.
A new air distribution system must be designed for the patient tower of Calvert Memorial
Hospital in order to maintain a healthier living environment for the hospital occupants.
The patient tower consists of the second, third, fourth, and fifth floors. The majority of
the spaces on each floor consist of patient rooms that are all conditioned by water-source
heat pumps. The heat pumps contain condensate drip pans that collect moisture
condensing on the evaporator coil in the air conditioning system. These drip pans allow
molds and other particles to grow, eventually exposing bacteria and mold spores to the
breathable air. It is proposed that all of the hospital’s heat pumps located in patient
rooms be removed and replaced with all overhead air systems.
The existing cooling towers serving the heat pumps are presently in poor shape. A new
single cooling tower is suggested to replace the other cooling tower configuration. The
cooling tower capacity will be further calculated once the heat pumps are removed and
the new room loads are calculated. The Chilled Water and Boiler Plants, will most likely
need replacements and modification due to the new system configurations.
In continuing the quest for a healthier indoor air environment, humidity control must also
be taken into consideration. Humid air creates the possibility for molds and bacteria to
Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
________________________________________________________________________ 7
grow, allowing infections to possibly spread from person to person. A drier air
environment is needed; therefore a Desiccant Wheel will be implemented to air system.
Along with the desiccant wheel configuration, UVGI (Ultraviolet Germicidal Irradiation)
systems will be installed in the critical spaces and exhaust ducts.
Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
________________________________________________________________________ 8
Proposed Design Solutions:
The following section describes a summary of the different design solutions to the
mechanical systems being evaluated. In the solution for administering the proper indoor
air quality and infection control of the hospital, the following ideas will be implemented
to the building design: Removal of all patient room heat pumps, use of desiccant wheels
in the building cooling system, and the installation of Ultraviolet Germicidal Irradiation
in the critical care areas and exhaust ducts.
Removal of Patient Room Heat Pumps
The heat pumps serving the patient tower patient rooms contain bacteria and
molds in the condensate drip pans. A drip pan is shaped to collect moisture
condensing on an evaporator coil in an air conditioning of refrigeration system.
Inadequate drainage of ductwork in terminal humidifiers can lead to potential
downstream condensation, which may cause microbial growth in air distribution
systems. These contaminants are emitted into the breathable air space, creating
unsatisfactory breathable air quantities. To eliminate this problem, the heat
pumps will all be removed and replaced with all overhead air systems. By
removing the heat pumps the amount of equipment that needs to be maintained
will be minimized and the system will become more versatile for future
modifications.
The overhead air system replacing the heat pumps will be a variable-air-volume
configuration. There will be two air handling units provided to serve these
spaces. The first of the two units, AHU-PT-1 (old AHU-3) is currently serving
areas of the second and third floor spaces. The second and third floor patient
rooms that were originally conditioned by the heat pumps will be added to the
existing air handling unit, AHU-PT-1. As described in the Existing Mechanical
Systems portion on the proposal, the AHU-PT-1 is located in the second floor
mechanical room. The entire fourth and fifth floors will be served by a new air
handling unit that will be located on fifth floor patient tower roof.
Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
________________________________________________________________________ 9
The Desiccant Wheel
In the cooling system of the building, it is proposed that desiccant wheels are
installed to help control the hospital’s humidity levels. Dehumidification is the
main focus of the desiccant cooling system. It reduces the building’s latent load
by removing excess moisture from the air. Moisture reduction stops or slows
bacteria from growing or traveling through the air. The reduction of the latent
load also decreases the size of the chiller. The air temperature of the sensible load
will be dry but very hot, so sensible coolers such as rotary heat exchangers,
evaporative coolers or coiling coils will be installed and sized accordingly.
The desiccant used can either be solid or liquid. In this analysis a liquid lithium
bromide spray solution will be used. The liquid desiccants work based-on the
principle of chemical absorption of water vapor from the air to be conditioned.
The humid air will pass through the lithium bromide solution spray becoming
dehumidified. This occurs because the desiccant solution has a lower water vapor
pressure than the air passing through it. Over time, the desiccant solution will
become diluted due to the water extracted from the air, so it must be fed to a
regenerator. The regenerator will then heat the lithium bromide, causing moisture
to transfer to the desiccant. The heated desiccant is then sprayed into the air
stream of the outdoor air and the moisture is released and exhausted to the
outside. The regenerated desiccant is then cooled and reused.
The benefits of using the lithium bromide solutions vary.. The performance of the
solution depends on the air temperature. Lower temperature are desired, therefore
it is best to run the solution through a chiller. Also, the lithium bromide kills
bacteria on contact so the liquid desiccant has the ability to deliver biologically
uncontaminated air to the surroundings. There are also no wet surfaces to
promote bacterial growth, so this system is more beneficial than using cooling
coils. If there were any doubts or worries about the spread of the lithium bromide
solution to the surrounding breathable air, the UVGI (Ultraviolet Germicidal
Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
________________________________________________________________________ 10
Irradiation) in the exhaust ducts would kill off any of the proposed particles.
These UVGI systems will be further discussed in the following section of this
proposal.
Ultraviolet Germicidal Irradiation
One of the major aspects of contamination control is ventilation. In Calvert
Memorial Hospital an alternative measure will be taken through the use of UVGI
(Ultraviolet Germicidal Irradiation). Two kinds UVGI will be used to control
contamination; one alternative will be Ultraviolet placed in the exhaust air stream
and the other will be Ultraviolet lamp fixtures placed in the critical space areas.
By adding these two UVGI systems, there will be a significant initial expense to
the hospital. But the systems will create a savings on the hospital’s insurance
issues due to the enhanced infection control configurations. The system will
reduce energy costs due to the decreased outdoor air intake.
Determining the amount of equivalent air flow received after installation of the
UV systems and the kill rate of UVGI to that which is realized by adding
ventilation for proper contamination control must be evaluated. The added
ventilation dilutes the contamination as if the bacteria have been killed. The
equivalent air flow for the addition of UV is found by comparing the added
ventilation to the actual kill rate from UV.
Duct irradiation will be used in the exhaust air stream. The duct irradiation
sterilizes the air which flows through a portion of the exhaust air stream. In order
to maintain efficient kill results, duct sizes will need to be sized as large as
possible without being too much of a burden on cost. The reason for the larger
ducts is to slow down the velocity of the air moving through the UV killing zone.
The longer the contaminant particles remain in the UV killing zone, the more
particles will be killed. By slowing down the air velocity of the duct, more
harmful particles will be killed.
Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
________________________________________________________________________ 11
Upper room irradiation will be implemented in the critical areas of the hospital
such as the patient rooms, intensive care units, and operating rooms. The Upper
Room Irradiation involves UVGI lamp fixtures that will be suspended or mounted
on the room’s ceiling or walls. The bottom portion of the light will be shielded to
direct all radiation upward and prevent the lamps from coming in contact with the
direct sight of the occupants. In analyzing the upper room irradiation procedure,
the following factors will be considered: distance from the source, humidity
levels, dust in the air, height of the ceiling, and the mixing factors occurring in the
rooms. These different factors will determine the effectiveness of the upper room
radiation.
Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
________________________________________________________________________ 12
Design Solution Methods:
The following section describes a brief explanation of the different methods that will be
used to redesign the mechanical systems being evaluated. The design solution methods
will decipher the proper indoor air quality and infection control of the hospital.
ASHRAE Standard 62 will be used in evaluating the clean air procedures. The following
methods will be explained: Removal of all patient room heat pumps, the use of desiccant
wheels in the building cooling system, and the installation of Ultraviolet Germicidal
Irradiation in the critical care areas and exhaust ducts.
Removal of Patient Room Heat Pumps
The heat pumps will all be removed and replaced with overhead air systems.
Loads will be calculated for the second, third, fourth, and fifth floor patient tower
rooms by the HAP (Hourly Analysis Program) to determine the appropriate air
distribution to each space. Once these airflows are determined, the air handling
units can be chosen. The existing unit located in the second floor mechanical
room (first floor roof) should be able to handle the additional load requirements
for the second and third floor patient rooms. An appropriate air handling unit will
then be selected for the fourth and fifth floors as well. The first and fifth floor
roof structural systems will be evaluated to determine if the structures will
withstand the weight of the new equipment.
The Desiccant Wheel
Dehumidification is the main focus of the desiccant cooling system. An analysis
of the reduction of the latent load will be administered, thus changing the
capacities of some of the mechanical equipment. Examples of the changed
equipment are: heat exchangers, evaporative coolers, cooling coils, and the
chiller. The loads determined from the HAP analysis will assist in determining a
total loads for rooms in question.
Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
________________________________________________________________________ 13
The liquid lithium bromide spray that will be desiccant material of the cooling
system will then be evaluated in terms of effectiveness, cost and other benefits of
the spray solution. A detailed analysis explaining the desiccant wheel cooling
system configuration will also be implemented into the report. From the HAP
loads as well as the desired operating temperature of the desiccant fluid, a new
chiller will be chosen.
Ultraviolet Germicidal Irradiation
By running a new load analysis on the hospital patient rooms, a new ventilation
requirement will be established. Since contamination control is heavily related to
ventilation in buildings, this will decipher the usages of UVI (Ultraviolet
Germicidal Irradiation) that will be employed in the hospital. The two kinds
UVGI will be used to control contamination; one alternative will be Ultraviolet
placed in the exhaust air stream the other will be Ultraviolet fixtures placed in the
critical space areas. The system ductwork, both supply and exhaust, will be sized
from the load. The equivalent air flow for the addition of UV will be evaluated
by comparing the added ventilation to the actual kill rate from UV and then
setting up the proper equations. This will also affect the sizes of the ducts for the
duct irradiation procedure because the larger the duct size, the slower the air flow.
The slower the air flow is, the more time the lithium bromide spray has to collect
harmful particles to be killed.
Upper room irradiation will be implemented in the critical areas of the hospital
such as the patient rooms, intensive care units, and operating rooms. Due to the
UVGI lamps being wall or ceiling mounted in the rooms, there will be an intense
analysis of distances from the lamp source to the room occupant. It is important
that the radiation emitted from the UVGI lamps does not come in direct site with
the occupants. Humidity levels, dust in the air, height of the ceiling, and the
mixing factors occurring in the rooms will also be evaluated.
Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
________________________________________________________________________ 14
Breadth Ideas:
The mechanical redesign of Calvert Memorial Hospital will impact the other building
systems in the construction and operational aspects. The breadth areas under analysis for
this proposal are: electrical and structural.
The complicated mechanical redesign requires there to be advanced electrical changes to
the hospital’s electrical systems. New UVGI (Ultraviolet Germicidal Irradiation) lamps,
also known as upper room radiation, will be installed in the existing patient rooms and
critical areas to help increase the building indoor air quality. New electrical loads will be
evaluated for each space thus changing the system feeders, panel boards, and over current
protection devices.
The structural system of the hospital will be evaluated at the first floor roof and at the
fifth floor roof. The existing air handling unit located in the second floor mechanical
room (on the first floor roof) is designated as AHU-PT-1. This portion of the first floor
roof will be analyzed to determine if the new AHU-PT-1 load will affect the existing
structural members. The second and new air handling unit being evaluated will be placed
on the roof of the fifth floor of the building. Here, the framing member sizes will be
analyzed and compared to the existing structure to determine if there is a necessary
increase in load.
Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
________________________________________________________________________ 15
Project Methods:
The research and modeling of the previously proposed design schemes will be
accomplished by using various design tools. The redesign of Calvert Memorial Hospital
will begin with the mechanical systems and continue on with the breadth topics; the
electrical and structural systems.
The first area of analysis will be the new hospital loads. By researching the patient room
and intensive care treatment areas, important data will be accumulated for the load
calculation process. Information on the types of equipment, square footages, and
occupants will be acquired by contacting Calvert Memorial Hospital. Information may
also be attained from Leach Wallace Associates, who have already done previous work
on the hospital. Carrier’s Hourly Analysis Program will them be used to model the
proposed new ventilation and air systems. With these calculations, research from the
UVGI duct systems and desiccant cooling configurations will be evaluated.
After the mechanical depth has been established, the breadth work on the electrical
system will begin. The electrical system will change due to the installation of UVGI
lamps located in the critical patient areas. A lighting compliance will be administered
using the ASHRAE Standard 90.1-2001 to ensure that the proper lighting is being
delivered to each of the spaces. The 2002 National Electric Code will be utilized to make
alterations to the electrical designs.
The addition of air handling units and energy recovery equipment will prompt the
structural analysis. The STAAD program will be used to determine if the loads of the
new equipment meet the structure requirement. These results will be compared to the
existing conditions and will be altered if needed.
Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
________________________________________________________________________ 16
Preliminary Research Resources:
Bahnfleth, W. P., PhD, PE, W. J. Kowalkski,. PhD, PE. “Airborne-Microbe Filtration in
Indoor Environments.” HPAC Engineering. Jan. 2002: pp. 57-69.
Finkelstein, Hal. Contamination Control, Ventilation: A Guide to Engineering, Design,
& Operations. Washington, D.C.: The National Resource Center, 1998.
Hansen, Wayne, PE, REA, CEM. A Guide to Managing Indoor Air Quality in Health
Care Organizations. Oakbrook Terrace: Joint Commissions on Accreditation of
Healthcare Organizations, 1997.
Memarzadeh, Farhad. Handbook on Assessing the Efficacy of Ultraviolet Germicidal
Irradiation and Ventilation in Removing Mycobacterium Tuberculosis. Bethesda:
National Institutes of Health, 2000.
“Natural Gas Desiccant Systems.” Uniongas: A Duke Energy Company. Union Gas
Limited 2000-2004. 7 Dec. 2004 <http://www.uniongas.com/dehumid/systems.asp>
Streifel, Andrew J., MPH, REHS. “Health-Care IAQ: Guidance for Infection Control.”
HPAC Heating/Piping/Air-Conditioning Engineering. Oct. 2000: pp. 28-36.
Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
________________________________________________________________________ 17
Calendar Schedule of Tasks:
Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
________________________________________________________________________ 18
Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
________________________________________________________________________ 19
Mechanical Systems Thesis Proposal Calvert Memorial Hospital
Prince Frederick, MD
________________________________________________________________________ 20