+ All Categories
Home > Documents > MEDICINE AND THE LAW

MEDICINE AND THE LAW

Date post: 02-Jan-2017
Category:
Upload: phungquynh
View: 215 times
Download: 2 times
Share this document with a friend
2
452 was lowered below a pressure of 14 to 15 per cent. of an atmosphere that signs of bodily distress for want of oxygen arose. Supposed Presence of Organic Poisons. The facts already mentioned with regard to the atmo- sphere in which certain brewery workers, caisson workers, and divers followed their occupation proved that concentra- tions of carbon dioxide such as occurred in the most crowded and worst ventilated rooms were not directly injurious to health. Forced to admit this, the hygienist has fallen back on the hypothesis that organic chemical poisons were exhaled in the breath, and that the percentage of carbon dioxide was a valuable guide to the concentration of these. It was necessary, said the hygienist, to keep the carbon dioxide below 0.1 part per 1000, so that the organic poisons might not collect to a harmful extent. The supposed existence of organic chemical poison in the expired air was based upon experiments made by Brown-Sequard and d’Arsonval, who injected into guinea-pigs and rabbits either the condensation water obtained from the breath or water which they had used several times over to wash out the trachea of dogs. The water was injected subcutaneously and in large amounts, and produced in their hands signs of illness, collapse, and death. A few confirmatory results have been obtained by some experimenters who used such absurd methods of investigation as to collect condensation water by breathing through a cooled flask and to inject 1 or 2 cubic centimetres of this fluid into a mouse weighing about 13 grammes, a proceeding equivalent to injecting 5 litres of water into a man weighing 65 kilogrammes. Who would not be made ill by the injection of about 9 pints of cold water beneath his skin ? The experiments of Brown-S6quard and d’Arsonval have been repeated by many others, and with negative results by those whose methods of work demand most respect-Dastre and Loye, Van Hofmann, Wellenhof, Lehmann and Jessen, Haldane and Smith, and Weir Mitchell and Borgey. Brown-Sequard and d’Arsonval in their experiments either (1) gave intravenous or subcutaneous injections of condensa- tion water from the breath or washings from the trachea, or (2) they kept animals in cages communicating in series, a current of air being drawn throughout the entire length of the series. Dr. Hill and Dr. Flack suggested that the deaths of injected animals were due either to the excessive amount of the fluid injected or to the inclusion in it of droplets of saliva which produced the well-known phenomena of the anaphylactic shock. Anaphylaxis signified the condition in which an animal became sensitised by the subcutaneous injection of a protein derived from an animal of a different species, and an animal thus sensitised might be poisoned by a subsequent injection of the same protein. When the animals in the last of the series of cages died, the fatal effect was probably due to suffocation from the proportion of carbon dioxide in the air having been allowed to rise to 10 or 12 per cent. Dr. Hill and Dr. Flack, after studying the literature of the subject and making various experiments, have come to the conclusion that there was not at present any trustworthy evidence of the presence of organic chemical poisons in exhaled air. Effects of Electric Fans. They enclosed eight students in a small chamber holding about three cubic metres of air and kept them therein until the carbon dioxide had reached 3 or 4 per cent. and the oxygen had fallen to 17 or 16 per cent. The wet-bulb thermometer rose meanwhile to about 85° F. and the dry- bulb thermometer to one or two degrees higher. The dis- comfort was very great, but this was relieved to an astonishing extent when electric fans placed in the roof were set in motion, whirling the air in the chamber, and so cooling the bodies of the students. In a crowded room the air confined between the bodies and clothes of the people was almost warmed up to body temperature and saturated with moisture, so that cooling of the body by radiation, convection, or evaporation became nearly impossible. This led to sweating, wetness and flushing of the skin, and a rise of skin tempera- ture. The blood was sent to the skin and stagnated there instead of passing through the brain and viscera. Hence arose the feelings of discomfort and fatigue, but the fans whirled away the layer of stationary wet air round the students’ bodies, replacing it by the somewhat cooler and drier air in the rest of the chamber, and so relieved the heat stagnation from which they suffered. Prophylaxis of Catarrhal Infections. Catarrhal infections of bacterial origin were spread by the expulsion of droplets of saliva during the acts of speaking, coughing, or sneezing, and could not be prevented by ventila- tion. The true prophylactic against such infections was the avoidance of whatever might diminish the natural immunising power of the animal organism. Exposure to overheated dry air dried up not only the skin but the membranes of the nose and throat, and so lessened immunity. Exposure to over- heated moist air brought the blood into the skin, lessened the circulation through the viscera, and decreased the evapora- tion from the respiratory tract ; the system also suffered from the absence of the stimulating effect of cold on the cutaneous nerves. Hence arose diminished health and strength together with increased susceptibility to catarrh. Those who habitu- ally exposed themselves to cold rarely took cold. Confine- ment in overheated stagnant air, which too often pervaded places of business and amusement, was one of the chief causes of the depressed physical and mental vigour of town dwellers. Properties of Ozone. Dr. Hill here showed an automatic ventilating fan to be inserted in the window of an"apartment ; at temperatures below 600 F. it remained closed but above 600 it remained open. He also showed some ozone-generating apparatus of the Ozonair Company. Each co-mplete element of this apparatus consisted of a thin sheet of micanite covered on each side by a square of gauze made of an aluminium alloy and having 40 meshes to the inch. Ozone was produced by the silent discharge of a high-tension electric current from one sheet of gauze to the other across the micanite. Mammals exposed to different concentrations of ozone in a closed chamber were killed by prolonged breathing of an atmosphere containing about 20 parts of ozone per 1,000,000 parts of air, the cause of death being an acute irritative inflammation of the respira- tory tract. The ozone in such concentrations made the eyes water and caused coughing. When ozone was employed in ventilation it was arranged so as to produce none of these symptoms of irritation. Ozone could be used in high con- centrations for sterilising water, this being one of its most valuable applications. It also destroyed all disagreeable smells. Ozone itself had a peculiar odour, which could be perceived by the nose in concentrations of far less than 1 part in 1,000,000, and for continuous breathing it should be present in concentrations not greater than that which was scarcely perceptible by the nose. Its powerful deodorising properties made it useful in places where offensive trades were carried on, and in improving the atmosphere of tube railways. MEDICINE AND THE LAW. Thirty 1èars of Unqualified Practice. BEFORE the stipendiary magistrate at Leeds, William Henry Gisburne Bowell, 72 years of age, was recently charged upon five summonses with offences under Section 40 of the Medical Act of 1858, and having been convicted upon one was fined £10, including costs, the other four charges not being proceeded with. Section 40, it will be remembered, is directed against persons who falsely and wilfully pretend to be qualified medical practitioners, the taking or using of titles implying medical qualifications being a manner of committing the offence specially mentioned in the section in the form of an alternative. The career of the defendant has been somewhat remarkable, for he has apparently been generally regarded among his lay neighbours for many years as a qualified medical practitioner, although, presumably, such medical men as were aware of his existence knew that his name was not on the Medical Register. In the case which was gone into before the magistrate the defendant’s lack of qualification and his readi- ness to give certificates in his assumed character of medical practitioner were brought to light by the naval authorities at Sheerness in a manner unfortunate for the patient implicated in the transaction. A young seaman in the Royal Navy had gone to Leeds on furlough, and on the
Transcript

452

was lowered below a pressure of 14 to 15 per cent. of anatmosphere that signs of bodily distress for want of oxygenarose.

Supposed Presence of Organic Poisons.The facts already mentioned with regard to the atmo-

sphere in which certain brewery workers, caisson workers,and divers followed their occupation proved that concentra-tions of carbon dioxide such as occurred in the most crowdedand worst ventilated rooms were not directly injurious tohealth. Forced to admit this, the hygienist has fallen backon the hypothesis that organic chemical poisons were exhaled

in the breath, and that the percentage of carbon dioxidewas a valuable guide to the concentration of these. Itwas necessary, said the hygienist, to keep the carbondioxide below 0.1 part per 1000, so that the organicpoisons might not collect to a harmful extent. The supposedexistence of organic chemical poison in the expired airwas based upon experiments made by Brown-Sequard andd’Arsonval, who injected into guinea-pigs and rabbits eitherthe condensation water obtained from the breath or waterwhich they had used several times over to wash out thetrachea of dogs. The water was injected subcutaneously andin large amounts, and produced in their hands signs of illness,collapse, and death. A few confirmatory results have beenobtained by some experimenters who used such absurdmethods of investigation as to collect condensation water bybreathing through a cooled flask and to inject 1 or 2 cubiccentimetres of this fluid into a mouse weighing about13 grammes, a proceeding equivalent to injecting 5 litres ofwater into a man weighing 65 kilogrammes. Who would notbe made ill by the injection of about 9 pints of cold waterbeneath his skin ? The experiments of Brown-S6quard andd’Arsonval have been repeated by many others, and withnegative results by those whose methods of work demandmost respect-Dastre and Loye, Van Hofmann, Wellenhof,Lehmann and Jessen, Haldane and Smith, and Weir Mitchelland Borgey.Brown-Sequard and d’Arsonval in their experiments either

(1) gave intravenous or subcutaneous injections of condensa-tion water from the breath or washings from the trachea, or(2) they kept animals in cages communicating in series, acurrent of air being drawn throughout the entire length ofthe series. Dr. Hill and Dr. Flack suggested that the deathsof injected animals were due either to the excessive amountof the fluid injected or to the inclusion in it of droplets ofsaliva which produced the well-known phenomena of theanaphylactic shock. Anaphylaxis signified the condition inwhich an animal became sensitised by the subcutaneousinjection of a protein derived from an animal of a differentspecies, and an animal thus sensitised might be poisoned bya subsequent injection of the same protein. When theanimals in the last of the series of cages died, the fatal effectwas probably due to suffocation from the proportion ofcarbon dioxide in the air having been allowed to rise to 10 or12 per cent. Dr. Hill and Dr. Flack, after studying theliterature of the subject and making various experiments,have come to the conclusion that there was not at presentany trustworthy evidence of the presence of organic chemicalpoisons in exhaled air.

Effects of Electric Fans.

They enclosed eight students in a small chamber holdingabout three cubic metres of air and kept them therein untilthe carbon dioxide had reached 3 or 4 per cent. and theoxygen had fallen to 17 or 16 per cent. The wet-bulbthermometer rose meanwhile to about 85° F. and the dry-bulb thermometer to one or two degrees higher. The dis-comfort was very great, but this was relieved to an astonishingextent when electric fans placed in the roof were set inmotion, whirling the air in the chamber, and so cooling thebodies of the students. In a crowded room the air confinedbetween the bodies and clothes of the people was almostwarmed up to body temperature and saturated with moisture,so that cooling of the body by radiation, convection, orevaporation became nearly impossible. This led to sweating,wetness and flushing of the skin, and a rise of skin tempera-ture. The blood was sent to the skin and stagnated thereinstead of passing through the brain and viscera. Hencearose the feelings of discomfort and fatigue, but the fanswhirled away the layer of stationary wet air round thestudents’ bodies, replacing it by the somewhat cooler and

drier air in the rest of the chamber, and so relieved the heatstagnation from which they suffered.

Prophylaxis of Catarrhal Infections.Catarrhal infections of bacterial origin were spread by the

expulsion of droplets of saliva during the acts of speaking,coughing, or sneezing, and could not be prevented by ventila-tion. The true prophylactic against such infections was theavoidance of whatever might diminish the natural immunisingpower of the animal organism. Exposure to overheated dryair dried up not only the skin but the membranes of the noseand throat, and so lessened immunity. Exposure to over-

heated moist air brought the blood into the skin, lessened thecirculation through the viscera, and decreased the evapora-tion from the respiratory tract ; the system also suffered fromthe absence of the stimulating effect of cold on the cutaneousnerves. Hence arose diminished health and strength togetherwith increased susceptibility to catarrh. Those who habitu-

ally exposed themselves to cold rarely took cold. Confine-ment in overheated stagnant air, which too often pervadedplaces of business and amusement, was one of the chiefcauses of the depressed physical and mental vigour of towndwellers.

Properties of Ozone.Dr. Hill here showed an automatic ventilating fan to be

inserted in the window of an"apartment ; at temperaturesbelow 600 F. it remained closed but above 600 it remainedopen. He also showed some ozone-generating apparatus of theOzonair Company. Each co-mplete element of this apparatusconsisted of a thin sheet of micanite covered on each side bya square of gauze made of an aluminium alloy and having40 meshes to the inch. Ozone was produced by the silentdischarge of a high-tension electric current from one sheet ofgauze to the other across the micanite. Mammals exposed todifferent concentrations of ozone in a closed chamber were killedby prolonged breathing of an atmosphere containing about20 parts of ozone per 1,000,000 parts of air, the cause ofdeath being an acute irritative inflammation of the respira-tory tract. The ozone in such concentrations made the eyeswater and caused coughing. When ozone was employed inventilation it was arranged so as to produce none of thesesymptoms of irritation. Ozone could be used in high con-centrations for sterilising water, this being one of its mostvaluable applications. It also destroyed all disagreeablesmells. Ozone itself had a peculiar odour, which could beperceived by the nose in concentrations of far less than

1 part in 1,000,000, and for continuous breathing it shouldbe present in concentrations not greater than that which wasscarcely perceptible by the nose. Its powerful deodorisingproperties made it useful in places where offensive tradeswere carried on, and in improving the atmosphere of tuberailways.

MEDICINE AND THE LAW.

Thirty 1èars of Unqualified Practice.BEFORE the stipendiary magistrate at Leeds, William

Henry Gisburne Bowell, 72 years of age, was recentlycharged upon five summonses with offences under Section 40of the Medical Act of 1858, and having been convictedupon one was fined £10, including costs, the other fourcharges not being proceeded with. Section 40, it will beremembered, is directed against persons who falsely andwilfully pretend to be qualified medical practitioners, thetaking or using of titles implying medical qualificationsbeing a manner of committing the offence specially mentionedin the section in the form of an alternative. The career ofthe defendant has been somewhat remarkable, for he hasapparently been generally regarded among his lay neighboursfor many years as a qualified medical practitioner, although,presumably, such medical men as were aware of hisexistence knew that his name was not on the MedicalRegister.

In the case which was gone into before the magistratethe defendant’s lack of qualification and his readi-ness to give certificates in his assumed character ofmedical practitioner were brought to light by the navalauthorities at Sheerness in a manner unfortunate for thepatient implicated in the transaction. A young seaman inthe Royal Navy had gone to Leeds on furlough, and on the

453

way there had injured his knee. Desiring to prolonghis leave on account of his injury, he obtained a certi-ficate to that effect from Bowell, paying him a fee ofhalf-a-crown. When it was noticed that the signature uponthe certificate was not that of a registered practitioner theyoung sailor was punished for his action in presentingit by a fine and the loss of a stripe. Apparently thedefendant had described himself in a local directory as

a medical practitioner and surgeon, and had been actingas surgeon to a Friendly Society’s lodge. It was

urged on behalf of Bowell, who admitted his offence, that hebad assisted an uncle, a qualified practitioner, in his

practice from 1859 to 1874, and after that had done thesame for a nephew, who succeeded the uncle, from 1874 to1881, so that he had a lengthy experience. Since 1881 he had

practised on his own account without anyone interferingwith his doing so, but apparently not with any great success,as he was described by his advocate in an appeal for leniencyas being in very poor circumstances. The fine ordered to be

paid is half the maximum penalty allowed by the section,and under the conditions indicated will no doubt provesufficient to prevent the repetition of the illegalities,but the case was not one where mercy was calledfor.The local Friendly Society can hardly be congratulated

upon the care exercised by it in the choice of a medicalattendant for its members ; but bone-setters and herbalistshave been employed, we believe, by some clubs at the directinstance of their members. An interesting part of the case isthe trouble that was brought upon the injured man, whoseplight is a hard one. Bowell seems to have been absolutelyaccepted by the local community as a medical man, and theunlucky seaman went to him in all good faith.

The C7tairnian of the London County Council and the Council’sBy-laws.

Mr. Edward White, J. P., chairman of the London CountyCouncil, was summoned recently at Marylebone police courtby the Marylebone borough council for having constructed athis residence in Upper Berkeley-street soil-pipes of ironinstead of drawn lead with proper wiped plumber’s joints, asrequired by by-laws of the London County Council, madeunder the Metropolis Management Acts of 1855 and 1899, and also for having the work carried out without having I

previously deposited "plans, sections, and particulars" of itwith the borough council. After evidence bad been given, andthe point had been raised by Mr. White that to constitutean infringement of the by-law the soil pipe complained ofmust be inside the house, whereas a very small portion of it

only was so situated, Mr. Plowden held that the by-law didnot contemplate a pipe such as that in question, and that asthe council had not satisfied him that the whole pipe wasinside the house they could not succeed upon that point.With regard to the failure to deposit plans, he decided infavour of the council and against the defendant, whom hefined 10s. with 2s. costs. Mr. Plowden does not appear tohave taken a very serious view of an offence by thechairman of the body responsible for the sanitation ofthe County of London against its sanitary by-laws. Nordoes Mr. White himself appear to have expressed himselfwith any very great respect for the regulations madei.a the interest of the public health by the Council over

which he presides, if Dr. C. Porter, medical officer of health ofthe Borough of Marylebone, is correctly reported to havesaid in evidence that when he called Mr. White’s attentionto the matter of the soil pipe he received the reply fromMr. White, who seemed surprised, that he "had had some-thing to do with the passing of the by-laws and thought thatsome of them were a little silly." It can hardly beencouraging to a borough council in its efforts to secure

proper sanitary conditions within its area to find the chair-man of the Council of the metropolis describing thatCouncil’s own regulations, which it is the duty of the localauthority to enforce, as "silly." Nor is a medical officer ofhealth likely to find his own duties rendered more easy toperform by such a pronouncement. If the chairman of theLondon County Council considers its by-laws silly or notworth attention, his proper course would seem to be toobtain, or to endeavour to obtain, their amendment. Ofcourse, we quite agree that Mr. White’s default was onlytechnical, and sympathise with him in having to pay afine.

VITAL STATISTICS.

HEALTH OF ENGLISH TOWNS.

IN the 94 largest English towns having an estimatedpopulation of 17,559,219 persons in the middle of this year,8799 births and 7276 deaths were registered during the weekending Feb. 10th, The annual rate of mortality in thesetowns, which had steadily increased from 14.8 8 to 18. 6 per1000 in the three preceding weeks, further rose to 21-6 per1000 in the week under notice. During the first six weeksof the current quarter the mean annual death-rate in theselarge towns averaged 17’ 0 per 1000, while in London duringthe same period the average annual death-rate did notexceed 16’ 3 per 1000. The annual death-rates last week inthe several towns ranged from 10 ’0 in Stockton-on-Tees, 10 1 1in Walthamstow and in Southend-on-Sea, 10. in Ilford,11 . 9 in Devonport, and 12’1 1 in Swindon, to 31’5 in Ply-mouth, 32 - in Gloucester, 32 - 8 in Merthyr Tydfil, 34 - 2 inAberdare, and 40 - 4 in Walsall.The 7276 deaths from all causes in the 94 towns were 998

in excess of the number in the previous week, and included435 which were referred to the principal epidemic diseases,against numbers rising from 297 to 401 in the three precedingweeks. These 435 deaths from the principal epidemicdiseases included 186 from whooping-cough, 98 frommeasles, 64 from diphtheria, 49 from infantile diarrhoeaidiseases, 22 from scarlet fever, and 16 from entericfever, but not one from small-pox. The mean annualdeath-rate from these diseases last week was equal to 1-3per 1000, or 03 per 1000 above the average recordedin the five preceding weeks. The deaths attributed to

whooping-cough, which had been 81, 94, and 166 inthe three preceding weeks, further rose to 186 last

week, and caused the highest annual death-rates of 2 4in Barrow-in-Furness, 2’ 7 in Preston. 3’ 7 in St. Helens, 3 9in Dewsbury, 4. 5 in Walsall, and 5’7 in Merthyr Tydfil.The deaths referred to measles, which had been 64, 72, and63 in the three previous weeks, rose to 98 last week; thehighest annual death-rates from this disease were 1’2 inManchester, l’ 4 in Oldham, l’ 8 in Newport (Mon.), and 7’ 1in Warrington. The fatal cases of diphtheria numbered 64.against 60. 53, and 71 in the three preceding weeks, andincluded 15 in London and its 14 suburban districts, 4 inBolton, and 3 each in Norwich, Plymouth, Nottingham,and Preston. The deaths attributed to infantile diarrhoealdiseases, which had been 55, 47, and 67 in the three

previous weeks, declined to 49 last week ; 19 deaths wererecorded in London and its suburban districts, 3 in Birming-ham, 3 in Liverpool, and 3 in Manchester. The 22 deathsreferred to scarlet fever were equal to the average recordedin the three preceding weeks, and included 4 which wereregistered in Liverpool. The 16 fatal cases of enteric fever,of which 4 occurred in Sheffield, were also equal to theaverage in the three previous weeks.The number of scarlet fever patients under treatment in

the Metropolitan Asylums and in the London Fever Hospital,which had steadily decreased from 2213 to 1500 in the12 preceding weeks, slightly rose to 1512 on Saturday last ;178 new cases of this disease were admitted to these institu-tions during the week, against 162, 158, and 169 in thethree preceding weeks. These hospitals also containedon Saturday last 1172 cases of diphtheria, 369 of whooping-cough, 137 of measles, 50 of enteric fever, and 2 of

small-pox. The 1763 deaths from all causes registered inLondon were 225 in excess of the number in the previousweek, and were equal to an annual death-rate of 20 - 3 per1000. The deaths referred to diseases of the respiratorysystem, which had steadily increased from 290 to 394 inthe four preceding weeks, further rose last week to 545, andwere no fewer than 141 in excess of the number recordedin the corresponding week of last year.

Of the 7276 deaths in the 94 large towns 222 resultedfrom different forms of violence, and 541 were the

subject of coroners’ inquests. The causes of 85, or 1’2

per cent., of the deaths registered in the week under noticewere not certified either by a registered medical practitioneror by a coroner after inquest. All the causes of death wereduly certified in London and in 13 of its 14 suburbandistricts, in Leeds, Bristol, Bradford, Salford, Cardiff,Bolton, and in 44 other smaller towns. The 85 uncertified


Recommended