Date post: | 16-Dec-2015 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | dorothy-bryant |
View: | 216 times |
Download: | 0 times |
Meeting Agenda
Announcements Market Discussions Lecture: Valuation Methods Portfolio Update Pitch: AIG Important Dates
Announcements
Free Wall Street Journal digital access for paid members
Contact [email protected] to receive login information
Announcements
•Build and manage your own virtual portfolio• Compete with other McCombs students
• Top three winners receive prizes in January
Register at usiteam.org/even
ts
Fall Portfolio Challenge
$5entry fee
Market Update
• Credit card debt is down $883M for August (seasonally adjusted)
• Less credit card debt > less spending on stores and restaurants
• Non-revolving debt is up $14.5B for August
• More non-revolving debt means more spending on things like student loans and car loans
Market Update- Twitter
$2.16 per timeline view $.30 per timeline view
Other Key Stats:• 65% revenue from mobile• 2011-2012 Revenue growth of 198%• EBITDA growth of 149%• Net loss decreased 36%
Comps
1. Assemble peer universe2. Spread the comps3. Make ratios
- EV/EBITDA- P/E- Industry specific ratios
4. Benchmark to see if over/undervalued
Relative valuation
Precedent transaction
Look at past deals to see what ratios other similar companies were bought at
Ex: 10x EBITDA
Relative valuation
Problem?
Pros
• Market driven comparison and not subject to assumptions like DCF
Cons
• Market driven so the market environment in which you’re taking comps has direct effect on your result
Problem?
Pros
• Market driven comparison and not subject to assumptions like DCF
Cons
• Market driven so the market environment in which you’re taking comps has direct effect on your result
Fixed by using intrinsic valuation
Portfolio UpdateHistorical Performance
Invested Capital Cash Exposure AUM Weekly Portfolio Return Cumulative Return Since 8/30/13 Exp-Adj Weekly Return Exp-Adj Cum. Return8/30/2013 $4,396.8 $9,716.0 31.2% $14,112.8 - 0.0% 0.0%9/6/2013 $7,739.3 $6,556.9 54.1% $14,296.2 1.3% 1.3% 2.40% 2.4%9/13/2013 $4,328.6 $9,922.9 30.4% $14,251.5 (0.3%) 1.0% (1.03%) 1.3%9/20/2013 $4,381.9 $9,922.9 30.6% $14,304.8 0.4% 1.4% 1.22% 2.6%9/27/2013 $5,911.2 $8,226.2 41.8% $14,137.4 (1.17%) 0.17% (2.80%) (0.3%)10/4/2013 $5,847.4 $8,226.2 41.5% $14,073.6 (0.45%) (0.28%) (1.09%) (1.4%)
Ticker Shares Cost Per Share Total Cost Basis Purchase Date PX_LAST Total Market Value Gain/Loss Gain/Loss % SectorAAPL US Equity 3 $486.11 $1,458.32 8/13/2013 $483.03 $1,449.09 ($9.23) -0.6% Information TechnologyADNC US Equity 50 $10.51 $525.50 8/13/2013 $11.05 $552.50 $27.00 5.1% Information TechnologyCBRX US Equity 125 $6.82 $852.13 8/14/2013 $7.14 $892.50 $40.38 4.7% Health CareENZN US Equity 200 $1.96 $391.00 8/13/2013 $1.68 $336.00 ($55.00) -14.1% Health CareIDT US Equity 55 $17.91 $984.85 8/14/2013 $19.10 $1,050.50 $65.65 6.7% Telecommunication ServicesSWKH US Equity 400 $1.13 $450.00 8/13/2013 $1.13 $452.00 $2.00 0.4% FinancialsU CN Equity 125 $4.64 $579.68 8/28/2013 $4.61 $576.79 ($2.88) -0.5% Basic MaterialsAGX US Equity 25 $21.67 $541.75 9/26/2013 $21.52 $538.00 ($3.75) -0.7% Industrials
Portfolio UpdateSector Exposures Dollar Amount % AllocationInformation Technology $2,001.59 34%Energy $0.00 0%Consumer Services $0.00 0%Consumer Goods $0.00 0%Financials $452.00 8%Industrials $538.00 9%Health Care $1,228.50 21%Utilities $0.00 0%Telecommunication Services $1,050.50 18%Basic Materials $576.79 10%
Sector Exposures + CashInformation Technology $2,001.6 14%Energy $0.0 0%Consumer Services $0.0 0%Consumer Goods $0.0 0%Financials $452.0 3%Industrials $538.0 4%Health Care $1,228.5 9%Utilities $0.0 0%Telecommunication Services $1,050.5 7%Basic Materials $576.8 4%Cash $8,226.2 58%
14% 0%
0%
0%
3%
4%
9%
0%
7%
4%
58%
Information Technology
Energy
Consumer Services
Consumer Goods
Financials
Industrials
Health Care
Utilities
Telecommunication Services
Basic Materials
Cash
INVESTMENT THESIS
Undervalued/Oversold
Well-Established Presence
Rising Interest Rates
Improving Housing Market
Rivalry within
Industry
Threat of New
Entrants
Bargaining Power of Buyers
Threat of Substitute
s
Bargaining Power of Suppliers
Porter’s Five Forces
Insurance services for:◦ Commercial◦ Institutional◦ Independent
Primary Services:◦ Property Casualty◦ Life and Retirement◦ Investment and Banking Services◦ Reinsurance
The Insurance Industry
•Commercial• Largest in the US and Canada
•Focused on Property Casualty• Largest in the US• Largest US based in Europe• Largest foreign insurer in Japan
& China•1st to market in many developing nations
Primary Competitors
• Regularly outperforming industry• Strong industry dominance in key sectorsCompetition
• US monetary policy future is bright• Current rising ratesChanging
Interest Rates
• Conducts enterprise-wide stress tests under a range of different scenarios
• Restructuring away from risky investments
Volatile Market
Risks and Mitigants
Comparables Analysis
AEG DB:ALVENXTPA:CS BRK.A CB SWX:ZURN AIG0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
P/B
AEG DB:ALVENXTPA:CS BRK.A CB SWX:ZURN AIG0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
P/E
AEG
DB:ALV
ENXTP
A:CS
BRK.A CB
SWX:Z
URNAIG
0.0%
2.0%
4.0%
6.0%
8.0%
10.0%
12.0%
14.0%
16.0%
18.0%
ROE
AEG
DB:ALV
ENXTP
A:CS
BRK.A CB
SWX:Z
URNAIG
0.02.04.06.08.0
10.012.014.016.0
Leverage Ratio (Assets/Equity)
Book Valuation
P/B Implied Price Discount
AIG Multiple $ 78.10 64%
Current Share Price $47.70
2012 2013 2014 2015 20160%
2%
4%
6%
8%
10%
12%
ROE
2012 2013 2014 2015 20160
20000
40000
60000
80000
100000
120000
140000
160000
Book Value
Important Dates
• Thursday, October 10, 6-8PM- SCG Workshop #3
• Saturday, October 12: Last day to register for TXSPwww.usiteam.org/events
• Saturday, October 19: Texas Stock Pitch Competition